Evaluation index system effectiveness clustering verification method based on multi-grey-class task scene

Through the cluster verification method of the evaluation index system effectiveness clustering verification method based on multi-gray task scenarios, the problem of verification of the equipment system combat capability evaluation index system in the existing technology is solved, and a comprehensive, objective and adaptive evaluation of the equipment system combat capability evaluation is achieved. , improves the integrity and correctness of the evaluation index system.

CN118940065AActive Publication Date: 2024-11-12DALIAN UNIV OF TECH
View PDF 2 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202411065207.7
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-08-05
Publication Date
2024-11-12
Estimated Expiration
2044-08-05

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The existing technology is difficult to effectively verify the effectiveness of the equipment system's combat capability evaluation index system, especially the suitability and comprehensiveness issues in multi-task scenarios have not been fully solved.

Method used

A cluster verification method for the effectiveness of the evaluation index system based on multi-gray task scenarios is proposed. By dividing verification of gray classes, determining cluster weights, generating multi-gray task scenarios, selecting gray cluster verification algorithms, and calculating clustering Coefficients and unity evaluation coefficients are used to verify and sort their effectiveness to ensure the suitability of the evaluation index system in different task scenarios.

Benefits of technology

Enhance the integrity and correctness of the evaluation index system, improve the objectivity and comprehensiveness of the evaluation, provide the adaptability and flexibility of the equipment system in different environments, and ensure that the evaluation index system can fully reflect the equipment system. Combat capability.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118940065A_ABST
    Figure CN118940065A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention provides an evaluation index system effectiveness clustering verification method based on a multi-grey-class task scene. The method comprises the following steps: S1, dividing a verification evaluation grey class number S according to verification requirements of effectiveness of an equipment system combat ability evaluation index system; s2, determining a clustering weight of each verification evaluation index; s3, analyzing and generating a multi-grey task scene according to the combat mission of the equipment system; s4, selecting one of all to-be-verified evaluation index system sets to perform gray clustering verification algorithm calculation; s5, judging whether all the to-be-verified evaluation index systems are calculated or not, if so, going to S6 for validity verification result analysis, and otherwise, going to S4; and S6, analyzing the obtained validity verification matrixes of all the evaluation index systems in all the grey task scenes. According to the method, a scientific and systematic solution is provided for establishment and optimization of an evaluation system, and the quality and efficiency of evaluation work are greatly improved.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of equipment system test and identification, and in particular to a clustering verification method for the effectiveness of an evaluation index system based on multi-gray task scenarios. Background Art

[0002] The evaluation of equipment system combat capability is a hot and difficult issue in the current research fields of weapon equipment construction and equipment combat application at home and abroad. The evaluation index system is the basis and necessary condition for realizing equipment system capability evaluation.

[0003] The main task of the effectiveness verification and evaluation of the equipment system combat capability indicator system is to verify the correctness of the design of the evaluation indicator system and whether the indicator system meets the functional and non-functional requirements of the equipment system combat capability evaluation. The effectiveness verification of the equipment system combat capability evaluation indicator system is a relatively long process, because it requires the indicator system builders and verifiers to repeatedly check, analyze, test and inspect the evaluation indicator system. It is necessary to start from the evaluation indicator effectiveness demand mechanism and use as many methods as possible, such as a combination of qualitative and quantitative methods, to verify the effectiveness of the indicator system from multiple angles and aspects.

[0004] At present, most of the literature focuses on the construction of evaluation index systems and various evaluation models. However, issues such as whether the constructed evaluation index system is suitable for the mission scenarios of the combat operation of the equipment system, objectivity and comprehensiveness are rarely involved. Therefore, the effectiveness verification method of the evaluation index system is also an issue that urgently needs to be studied and solved. Summary of the invention

[0005] In view of this, the purpose of the present invention is to propose a clustering verification method for the effectiveness of an evaluation index system based on multi-gray task scenarios, so as to solve the technical problem that the effectiveness of the equipment system combat capability evaluation index system cannot be verified at present.

[0006] The technical means adopted by the present invention are as follows:

[0007] A clustering verification method for the effectiveness of an evaluation index system based on a multi-gray task scenario includes the following steps:

[0008] S1. According to the verification requirements of the effectiveness of the equipment system combat capability evaluation index system, the verification evaluation gray class number S is divided, and the value of each verification evaluation index is also divided into S gray classes accordingly, and the whitening weight function of the j index k gray class is determined;

[0009] S2, determine the clustering weight of each verification evaluation indicator;

[0010] S3. Generate multi-gray mission scenarios based on the equipment system combat mission analysis, which include representative system combat application scenario examples;

[0011] S4, selecting one of all the evaluation index system sets to be verified to perform grey clustering verification algorithm calculation;

[0012] S5, determine whether the calculation of all evaluation indicator systems to be verified has been completed. If so, proceed to S6 to analyze the effectiveness verification results; otherwise, proceed to S4;

[0013] S6. Analyze the effectiveness verification matrix of all evaluation index systems under all gray task scenarios, and rank the effectiveness of the evaluation index systems under different gray task scenarios or rank the suitability of equipment systems under different index systems for gray task scenarios.

[0014] Further, S4 includes the following steps:

[0015] S41. Select a typical gray task scenario i and calculate the clustering coefficient σi of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the verified scenario i belonging to the k gray class k ;

[0016] S42. Calculate the unitized evaluation coefficient δ of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the gray task scenario i belonging to the k gray class ik ;

[0017] S43, by Determine the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the verified scenario i belongs to k * Gray category;

[0018] S44, calculate the comprehensive verification measure of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the verified scenario i, which belongs to the k-gray category;

[0019] S45, judging whether the calculation of all gray task scenarios for the selected evaluation index system has been completed, if so, proceed to S5, otherwise proceed to S41.

[0020] Furthermore, the gray category is a characteristic classification of equipment system behavior;

[0021] The representative system combat application scenario examples include expected application scenarios and abnormal application scenarios of different gray categories;

[0022] The expected application scenario is used to describe the behavior environment in which the equipment system's expected combat capability can be exerted, and the abnormal application scenario is used to describe the behavior environment in which the equipment system's combat capability is difficult to exert;

[0023] Use expected application scenarios to verify the completeness of the effectiveness of the evaluation indicator system, and use abnormal application scenarios to verify the correctness of the effectiveness of the evaluation indicator system.

[0024] Furthermore, S3 specifically includes the following steps:

[0025] S31. Combat mission scenario analysis content;

[0026] S311, system mission analysis;

[0027] S312, Operational Concept Analysis;

[0028] S313, Combat Activity Decomposition;

[0029] S314, combat mission generation;

[0030] S32. Grey category analysis of combat mission scenarios.

[0031] Further, S32 specifically includes: based on the combat mission scenario analysis content, according to the percentage of the equipment system completing the specified combat mission, the more combat mission workload is completed, the higher the level of the equipment system's combat capability in the mission scenario, and the levels include unsuitable level, barely suitable level, generally suitable level, relatively suitable level, and fully suitable level;

[0032] Each level constitutes an application scenario layer on the basis of the improvement process of equipment system combat capability enhancement, and is the basis for achieving the next system combat capability level; the unsuitable level and barely suitable level are used to cover abnormal application scenarios; the generally suitable level, relatively suitable level, and completely suitable level are used to cover the expected application scenarios.

[0033] Furthermore, S4 specifically includes the following steps:

[0034] S41. Assume that there are N different gray application scenarios, each of which has M validity verification indicators, d ij For the sample of the jth validity verification indicator for the i-th application scenario, we can get the validity verification sample matrix D = (d ij ) N×M ,Right now:

[0035]

[0036] d in matrix D i1 ,d i2 ,…,d im is the sample row of the validation index j=1, j=2,..., j=M for the validation scenario i, then the i sample row is transformed into the validation evaluation value of each gray class k=1, k=2,..., k=S for the application scenario i, which is called the gray clustering validation evaluation of the gray class to which the validation index system belongs under the application scenario i;

[0037] Calculation of weight coefficient of grey clustering; Let F be the grey clustering map, S grey classes for validity verification and evaluation, OPfjk(d ij ) is sample d ij The operation performed by using the k (1≤k≤S) gray quantity of the j (1≤i≤N, 1≤j≤M)th validity verification evaluation index, f jk is the whitening weight function of the verification gray class k of the jth verification evaluation index, then the weight coefficient σ of the gray clustering is ik The expression is:

[0038] F: OPf jk (d ij )→σ ik ∈[0,1],σ i =σ i1 ,σ i2 ,…,σ iS (2)

[0039] Grey clustering vector calculation; let f jk (d ij ) is the whitening weight function of the jth validity verification evaluation index for the gray class k, η jk is the whitening weight function f jk The conversion value of (·), σ ik is the grey clustering weight coefficient, sample d ij to i It is called grey clustering, σ i is ik The vector is calculated as:

[0040]

[0041] S42, calculation of unitized verification evaluation coefficient; the unitized verification evaluation coefficient expression of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system belonging to the gray class k under the verified scenario i is:

[0042]

[0043] S43, validity verification evaluation gray class; let δ i =(δ i1 ,δ i2 ,…,δ is )(i=1,2,…,N) is the unitized verification evaluation coefficient vector of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the verified scenario i, then Ψ=(δ ik ) N×S is the unitized verification evaluation coefficient matrix; at the same time, if there is

[0044]

[0045] If it holds, then the validity verification evaluation for the verified scenario i can be obtained as gray class k * ;

[0046] S44, adjustment coefficient calculation; Assume S different validity verification evaluation gray categories, and assume η1,η2,…,η S They are the adjustment coefficients of the first gray class, the second gray class, ..., the Sth gray class, and the calculation formula is:

[0047]

[0048] Comprehensive verification measurement calculation; Assume that the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the verified scenario i belongs to the verification evaluation gray category k, then

[0049]

[0050] It is a comprehensive verification measure of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the verified scenario i;

[0051] Furthermore, S6 specifically includes:

[0052] Validity verification comparison: Assume that there are two verified scenarios i and j, and the validity verification evaluations for the two verified scenarios belong to the same gray class, that is, Calculate the comprehensive verification measure respectively, if w i >w j , then the gray class k for validity verification evaluation is called * , the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under verified scenario i is better than that under verified scenario j.

[0053] A storage medium comprising a stored program, wherein when the program is run, any of the above-mentioned clustering verification methods for the effectiveness of an evaluation index system based on a multi-gray task scenario is executed.

[0054] An electronic device comprises a memory, a processor and a computer program stored in the memory and executable on the processor, wherein the processor executes any one of the above-mentioned clustering verification methods for the effectiveness of an evaluation index system based on a multi-gray task scenario through the computer program.

[0055] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following advantages:

[0056] Enhance the integrity and correctness of the evaluation index system: By using different gray application scenarios (including expected and abnormal scenarios), this method can comprehensively evaluate and verify the coverage breadth and depth of the evaluation index system. This helps to discover and correct defects in the evaluation system, such as omissions, duplications, or ambiguities in indicators.

[0057] Improve the objectivity and comprehensiveness of the evaluation: The gray clustering method is used, combined with the comprehensive analysis of different combat mission scenarios, to ensure the objectivity and comprehensiveness of the evaluation process. Through detailed scenario analysis, it can be ensured that the evaluation index system can fully reflect the combat capability of the equipment system.

[0058] Enhance the adaptability and flexibility of the evaluation: By conducting gray analysis on different combat environments and mission scenarios, this method provides an evaluation of the adaptability and flexibility of the equipment system in various environments. This method is particularly suitable for the complex and dynamically changing modern battlefield environment.

[0059] In general, this invention provides a scientific and systematic solution for the establishment and optimization of the evaluation system by systematically analyzing and verifying the combat capability of the equipment system in different mission scenarios, greatly improving the quality and efficiency of the evaluation work. This will have a profound impact on the continuous improvement of the equipment system and the combat readiness. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0060] In order to more clearly illustrate the embodiments of the present invention or the technical solutions in the prior art, the drawings required for use in the embodiments or the description of the prior art will be briefly introduced below. Obviously, the drawings described below are some embodiments of the present invention. For ordinary technicians in this field, other drawings can be obtained based on these drawings without paying creative labor.

[0061] Figure 1 This is a grey clustering verification idea diagram for the effectiveness of the present invention based on different grey class application scenarios.

[0062] Figure 2 This is a diagram of the analysis process of multi-gray combat mission scenarios of the present invention.

[0063] Figure 3 This is a gray verification flowchart of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system based on multi-task scenarios in the present invention.

[0064] Figure 4 This is a diagram of the effectiveness verification example of the evaluation index system of the present invention.

[0065] Figure 5 It is a schematic diagram of the center point triangle whitening weight function of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0066] In order to enable those skilled in the art to better understand the scheme of the present invention, the technical scheme in the embodiments of the present invention will be clearly and completely described below in conjunction with the drawings in the embodiments of the present invention. Obviously, the described embodiments are only part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work should fall within the scope of protection of the present invention.

[0067] It should be noted that the terms "first", "second", etc. in the specification and claims of the present invention and the above-mentioned drawings are used to distinguish similar objects, and are not necessarily used to describe a specific order or sequence. It should be understood that the data used in this way can be interchanged where appropriate, so that the embodiments of the present invention described herein can be implemented in an order other than those illustrated or described herein. In addition, the terms "including" and "having" and any variations thereof are intended to cover non-exclusive inclusions, for example, a process, method, system, product or device that includes a series of steps or units is not necessarily limited to those steps or units that are clearly listed, but may include other steps or units that are not clearly listed or inherent to these processes, methods, products or devices.

[0068] The evaluation of equipment system combat capability is a hot and difficult issue in the field of weapon equipment construction and equipment combat application at home and abroad. Formulating a complete evaluation index system that fully reflects the characteristics of the equipment system is the basis and necessary condition for the evaluation of equipment system combat capability. Only by ensuring the effectiveness of the evaluation index system for the evaluation target can we have a comprehensive and objective understanding of the equipment system combat capability and fundamentally guarantee the scientific nature of the evaluation results.

[0069] The equipment system combat capability evaluation index system is generally formed through the decomposition and comprehensive weighing of the equipment system's mission tasks. However, whether the evaluation index system has omissions, duplications, ambiguities, relevance, whether the lower-level performance is a complete description of the upper-level capabilities, whether it can guarantee support for all combat tasks, whether there is overlap between the various capabilities, etc., its effectiveness still needs to be verified.

[0070] Verification is largely an activity based on analytical methods and tools. It is a process of evaluating systems or components to determine whether the product of a given stage meets the conditions imposed at the beginning of that stage. Verification is based on the demand model and verifies that each stage of system development meets the definition of the previous stage through a series of review, analysis and evaluation processes. According to the characteristics and objectives of the equipment system combat capability evaluation project, the effectiveness verification of the system combat capability evaluation index system refers to the orderly process in which system planning and analysis personnel use scientific methods and techniques, based on the evaluation index model, through a series of inspection, comparison, modeling, testing, analysis and adjustment activities, to analyze and determine the integrity, effectiveness and feasibility of the index system, and finally obtain the effectiveness of the evaluation index system.

[0071] The study of the effectiveness verification method of the equipment system combat capability evaluation index system has strong theoretical guidance and practical application value. The present invention proposes a clustering verification method for the effectiveness of the evaluation index system based on multi-gray task scenarios, which is as follows:

[0072] 1. Grey clustering verification ideas for the effectiveness of the evaluation index system

[0073] The grey clustering comprehensive verification method of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system based on different grey application scenarios refers to using the equipment system combat application scenario as an effective tool to verify the effectiveness of the index system. By selecting a group of different grey categories and representative system combat application scenario examples, the definition of effectiveness is tested and verified to find defects in the definition of effectiveness. Representative system combat application scenario examples usually include a series of expected application scenarios and abnormal application scenarios of different grey categories. The grey category here refers to the characteristic classification of equipment system behavior. The expected application scenario is used to describe the behavioral environment in which the expected combat capability of some equipment systems can be exerted, and the abnormal application scenario is used to describe the behavioral environment in which the combat capability of some equipment systems is difficult to exert. The expected application scenario is usually used to verify the completeness of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system, and the abnormal application scenario is used to verify the correctness of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system. When applying the grey clustering verification method based on application scenarios to verify the effectiveness of the evaluation index system, the message sequence diagram is generally used to formally describe the combat application scenario of the equipment system for different grey application scenarios. Combined with the index system effectiveness verification index system framework, the verification index data sequence of this type of application scenario is obtained, and then the grey clustering verification results of the specific grey system combat application scenario are formed respectively. Finally, the grey clustering comprehensive algorithm is used to calculate the effectiveness comprehensive clustering results based on different grey application scenarios. The whole verification process is as follows: Figure 1 shown.

[0074] 2. Grey verification steps for the effectiveness of the evaluation index system based on multi-grey task scenarios

[0075] In summary, the grey clustering verification method for the effectiveness of the equipment system combat capability evaluation index system can be carried out according to the following steps. Figure 3 shown.

[0076] Step 1: According to the verification requirements of the effectiveness of the equipment system combat capability evaluation index system, the verification and evaluation gray categories S are divided, and the values ​​of each verification and evaluation index are also divided into S gray categories accordingly, and the whitening weight function of the j index k gray category is determined.

[0077] Step 2: Determine the clustering weight of each verification evaluation indicator.

[0078] Step 3: Based on the method in Part 3, generate multi-gray task scenarios according to the equipment system combat mission analysis. It should be noted that the gray category of the task scenario here is not the same as the gray category of effectiveness verification evaluation, and they can have different values.

[0079] Step 4: Select one of all the evaluation indicator system sets to be verified and perform the following verification calculation.

[0080] Step 5: Select a typical gray task scenario i and calculate the clustering coefficient σ of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the verified scenario i belonging to the k gray class ik .

[0081] Step 6: Calculate the unitized evaluation coefficient δ of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the gray task scenario i belonging to the k gray class ik .

[0082] Step 7: It is determined that the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the verified scenario i belongs to the k* gray class.

[0083] Step 8: Calculate the comprehensive verification measure of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the verified scenario i, which belongs to the k-gray class.

[0084] Step 9: Determine whether all gray task scenarios have been calculated for the selected evaluation index system. If so, proceed to the next step; otherwise, proceed to the fifth step.

[0085] Step 10: Determine whether the calculation of all evaluation indicator systems to be verified has been completed. If so, proceed to the next step to analyze the effectiveness verification results; otherwise, proceed to step 4.

[0086] Step 11: Analyze the effectiveness verification matrix of all evaluation index systems under all grey task scenarios. You can rank the effectiveness of the evaluation index systems under different grey task scenarios, or rank the suitability of the equipment systems under different index systems for grey task scenarios.

[0087] 3. Analysis of multi-gray combat mission scenarios

[0088] Combat missions refer to tasks that combat forces accomplish in order to achieve predetermined combat objectives. The multi-gray combat mission analysis of equipment systems is a process of obtaining multi-gray scenario combat missions by further refining the system's combat mission and combat concept, centering on typical combat environments, combat targets, and combat styles. The equipment system combat style is the specific implementation and process of the combat concept on the battlefield, and the system combat mission is the concretization of its combat mission. Combat missions and combat styles are essentially composed of a series of interrelated combat activities, which generally specify the overall goals that need to be achieved to complete the combat concepts and missions, and also implicitly include factors that must be considered, such as combat targets, battlefield environments, and combat resources.

[0089] The equipment system combat concept is the instantiation of the mission, and it is the concretization and visualization of each sub-mission. The equipment system combat task is not only the instantiation of the equipment combat concept, but also a further refinement of the organizational method, specific conditions, implementation process, etc. in the equipment system combat concept. It fully considers the combat application process of the equipment system and its expected combat effect around the combat style analysis, and emphasizes the feasibility and operability of the confrontation process. According to the content of the equipment system task analysis and their mutual relationship, the multi-gray combat task scenario analysis is mainly divided into two aspects: the combat task scenario analysis content and the gray category analysis of the combat task scenario.

[0090] 3.1. Contents of Combat Mission Scenario Analysis

[0091] The analysis of different gray combat mission scenarios mainly includes four steps: system mission analysis, combat concept analysis, combat activity decomposition, and combat mission generation. Figure 2 shown.

[0092] The system mission analysis in the figure refers to the scientific proposal of the overall mission and goals of the weapon and equipment system based on national security strategy, military construction goals, future war forecasts, etc., taking into account the current status of weapons and equipment and the internal and external conditions of systematic development. The overall mission of the weapon and equipment system is decomposed into a series of relatively clear sub-missions according to different combat environments and combat objectives, to provide guidance for the direction of the systematic development of weapons and equipment.

[0093] Operational concept analysis refers to the analysis of the integrated organization, integrated use and coordinated interaction of weapons and equipment of various services and arms based on the mission set of the weapons and equipment system, in accordance with the army's construction goals and operational theory, and in accordance with the basic requirements and characteristics of all-round system confrontation, and the proposal of system confrontation combat concepts for specific missions. The weapons and equipment system combat concept is a macro and general description of the combat mode or style with the goal of integrated joint operations.

[0094] The decomposition of combat activities refers to further refining the implementation process of system confrontation based on the combat concept in accordance with the specific battlefield conditions, the composition of the weapon and equipment system, and the actual combat requirements of combat operations. The main combat activities of system confrontation under specific combat concepts and their mutual relationships are proposed according to the objects, intentions, deployments, actions and their interaction methods of system confrontation operations, forming a specific combat style, and testing the rationality and scientific nature of system confrontation activities through the combat effectiveness of the weapon and equipment system.

[0095] The last step in the figure is the generation of combat missions. The combat concept is realized by the implementation of combat activities. Different combat concepts will inevitably lead to different combat activities and their capability sets. The combat activities contained in different combat concepts may have similar or identical combat activities. In the process of implementing system confrontation, it is usually necessary to organize the combat activities of various equipment and personnel into a process model that can complete one or more sub-missions or combat concepts. By organically integrating related combat activities and their overall processes, combat tasks that are mapped to combat missions and combat concepts are formed. This is the fundamental basis for guiding the construction and development of the weapon and equipment system composition system.

[0096] 3.2 Grey Class Analysis of Combat Mission Scenarios

[0097] Based on the above-mentioned task generation mechanism, according to the percentage of the equipment system completing the prescribed combat tasks (i.e., the degree of completion of the prescribed combat tasks), the more combat task workload (including task types) is completed, the higher the level of the equipment system's combat capability in the task scenario. This patent proposes a gray level model for the combat application of the equipment system, including "unsuitable level", "barely suitable level", "generally suitable level", "relatively suitable level", and "completely suitable level", as shown in Table 1. Each level constitutes an application scenario level on the basis of the equipment system combat capability improvement process, and is the basis for achieving the next system combat capability level; and "unsuitable level" and "barely suitable level" are used to cover abnormal application scenarios, and "generally suitable level", "relatively suitable level", and "completely suitable level" are used to cover expected application scenarios.

[0098] Table 1 Grey categories and performance characteristics of combat mission scenarios

[0099]

[0100]

[0101] Table 1 Among them, the "unsuitable level" corresponds to the abnormal application scenario of the equipment system, indicating that the equipment system cannot achieve normal operation and use in this mission scenario, resulting in the inability to complete any combat mission or combat activity; the "barely suitable level" corresponds to the abnormal application scenario of the equipment system, indicating that the equipment system can achieve normal operation and use in a single combat activity and can complete some combat activities, but basically cannot complete other specified combat activities or combat tasks, and can only complete 1% to 50% of the specified combat tasks in a statistical sense; the "generally suitable level" corresponds to the expected application scenario of the equipment system, indicating that the equipment system can complete the specified combat tasks in this gray scenario so-so, and can complete 51% to 70% of the specified combat tasks or all combat tasks in a statistical sense; the "relatively suitable level" corresponds to the expected application scenario of the equipment system, indicating that the equipment system can complete the specified combat tasks well in this gray scenario, and can complete 71% to 99% of the specified combat tasks in a statistical sense; the "completely suitable level" corresponds to the expected application scenario of the equipment system, indicating that the equipment system can complete all specified combat tasks in all periods and in all directions in this gray scenario.

[0102] for Figure 1 The formation mechanism of the gray mission scenarios shown in Table 1 is combined with the capability requirement mechanism of the equipment system to complete combat missions. Table 1 constructs the performance characteristics of the equipment system in four aspects: physical domain action, information domain utilization, cognitive domain understanding, and social domain management under different gray mission scenarios. The physical domain refers to the land, sea, air and space environments that support the deployment of equipment systems and combat infrastructure. The action characteristics of the physical domain express the traditional combat effects of the equipment system, such as reconnaissance, interference, defense, mobility and interoperability. The information domain is the field or space where the combat information of the equipment system is generated, processed, value-added and shared. The utilization characteristics of the information domain express the quality of information exchange and sharing, information cognition and information coordination of the equipment system. The cognitive domain is the place where commanders and operators of the equipment system form feelings, beliefs, values ​​and make decisions. The understanding characteristics of the cognitive domain express the perception and understanding of the combat situation of the troops, the understanding and comprehension of the commander's combat intentions, and the decision-making and synchronization of coordinated combat activities. The social domain is the field where economic, cultural, political and even religious factors affect the cognition and decision-making of troop personnel and organizations. The management characteristics of the social domain express the information interaction, awareness formation, cognition sharing and collaborative decision-making capabilities of the troops under the influence of cultural differences, organizational structure, regulations, and combat technical procedures.

[0103] 4. Grey clustering verification algorithm for evaluating the effectiveness of the index system

[0104] The grey clustering comprehensive verification method of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system based on different grey application scenarios is based on the basic idea of ​​firstly coarsely clustering the effectiveness of the equipment system combat capability evaluation index system under different grey application scenarios, and then realizing the precise clustering verification of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system based on comprehensive different grey application scenarios through the category adjustment coefficient.

[0105] Gray clustering is a method of dividing some effectiveness evaluation indicators or the effectiveness of an indicator system into several definable categories based on the whitening weight function of the gray number. For the present invention, it is assumed that there are N different gray application scenarios, each of which has M effectiveness verification indicators, d ij For the sample of the jth validity verification indicator for the i-th application scenario, we can get the validity verification sample matrix D = (d ij ) N×M ,Right now

[0106]

[0107] d in matrix D i1 ,d i2 ,…,d im For the sample row of validity verification index j=1, j=2,..., j=M for the verified scenario i, the i sample row is converted into the verification evaluation value of each gray class k=1, k=2,..., k=S for the application scenario i (the present invention assumes S gray class levels for validity verification evaluation), which is called the gray clustering verification evaluation of the gray class to which the validity of the evaluation index system belongs under the application scenario i.

[0108] Calculation of weight coefficients of grey clustering. Let F be the grey clustering map, S grey classes for validity verification and evaluation, OPf jk (d ij ) is sample d ij The operation performed by using the k (1≤k≤S) gray quantity of the j (1≤i≤N, 1≤j≤M)th validity verification evaluation index, f jk is the whitening weight function of the verification gray class k of the jth verification evaluation index, then the weight coefficient σ of the gray clustering is ik The expression is

[0109] F:OP jk (d ij )→σ ik ∈[0,1],σ i =σ i1 ,σ i2 ,…,σ iS (2)

[0110] Grey clustering vector calculation. Let f jk (d ij) is the whitening weight function of the jth validity verification evaluation index for the gray class k, η jk is the whitening weight function f jk The conversion value of (·), σ ik is the grey clustering weight coefficient, sample d ij to i It is called grey clustering, σ i is ik The vector is calculated as

[0111]

[0112] Unitized verification evaluation coefficient calculation. The unitized verification evaluation coefficient expression of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system belonging to the gray class k under the verified scenario i is:

[0113]

[0114] Validity verification and evaluation of gray class. Let δ i =(δ i1 ,δ i2 ,…,δ is )(i=1,2,…,N) is the unitized verification evaluation coefficient vector of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the verified scenario i, then Ψ=(δ ik ) N×S is the unitized verification evaluation coefficient matrix. At the same time, if there is

[0115]

[0116] If it holds, then the validity verification evaluation for the verified scenario i can be obtained as gray class k * .

[0117] In order to more effectively distinguish the effectiveness of the equipment system combat capability evaluation index system for different verification scenarios, the following comprehensive verification algorithm is continued.

[0118] Adjustment coefficient calculation. Assume S different validity verification evaluation gray categories, and assume η1,η2,…,η S are the adjustment coefficients of the first gray class, the second gray class, ..., the Sth gray class, and the calculation formula is:

[0119]

[0120] Comprehensive verification measurement calculation. Assume that the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the verified scenario i belongs to the verification evaluation gray category k, then

[0121]

[0122] It is a comprehensive verification measure of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the verified scenario i.

[0123] Validity Verification Comparison. Assume that there are two verified scenarios i and j, and the validity verification evaluations for the two verified scenarios belong to the same gray class, that is, Calculate the comprehensive verification measure respectively, if w i >w j , then the gray class k for validity verification evaluation is called * , the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under verified scenario i is better than that under verified scenario j.

[0124] 5. Grey clustering verification example of the effectiveness of a certain evaluation index system

[0125] From the above process, it can be seen that the clustering verification method for the effectiveness of the evaluation index system based on multiple gray task scenarios proposed in the present invention is essentially a qualitative and quantitative combination method. In order to verify the rationality and feasibility of the method of the present invention, based on the effectiveness verification framework of the given evaluation index system, a simple gray clustering example for two typical gray task scenarios is given.

[0126] 5.1 Case Study Background and Related Data

[0127] The example establishes a validity verification framework that reflects the completeness and correctness of the equipment system combat capability evaluation index system from three aspects: effectiveness based on the pragmatic layer, completeness and correctness based on the grammatical semantic layer, and non-functional indicators. Figure 4 shown.

[0128] Depend on Figure 4 It can be seen that the underlying indicators have uncertain characteristics such as incomplete description information and difficulty in obtaining a large amount of data information, and the meanings and dimensions of the indicators are different. These lay a good foundation for the application of the gray evaluation method to aggregate the information of each indicator. Usually, an expert group is organized to score the underlying indicators of the above validity verification architecture. For two typical gray task scenarios, the final score of the underlying indicator is described by the following matrix A, that is,

[0129]

[0130] The rows of matrix A represent the validity verification data of the indicator system for gray task scenarios I and II, and the columns of A correspond to Figure 4 12 underlying indicator data.

[0131] 5.2. Construction of center point whitening weight function

[0132] This patent uses five gray-class levels, such as "very effective", "effective", "generally effective", "basically effective", and "basically ineffective", to measure the effectiveness of the evaluation index system. The central point triangular whitening weight function is used, and the triangular whitening weight functions of the gray class starting point and the gray class end point are respectively taken as the lower limit measurement whitening weight function and the upper limit measurement whitening weight function. Figure 4 All clustering indicators in , assuming that their value range is [0,1]. For the five clustering gray classes, λ1=30, λ2=45, λ3=60, λ4=75, λ5=90 are respectively used as the center points of the gray classes, then the center point triangle whitening weight function is as follows Figure 5 shown.

[0133] In the figure, f1(x), ..., f5(x) are the weight functions of the central points of gray class 1, ..., gray class 5, respectively. The membership of the observed value to the gray class can be calculated based on the function. Assuming x is an observed value of the maturity clustering index, the expressions of f1(x), f2(x), and f5(x) are

[0134]

[0135] 5.3 Grey clustering calculation process

[0136] The calculation process is explained by grey clustering of the three underlying indicators of grey task scenario I, “indicator system performance”, “indicator system effectiveness”, and “comprehensive satisfaction of needs”, to the upper-level indicator “validation of utility based on pragmatic layer”.

[0137] Determine the weights η corresponding to the three indicators j Here we assume that the corresponding weight is

[0138] eta1=0.3, eta2=0.3, eta3=0.4.

[0139] Determine the clustering coefficient σ ik .Depend on have to

[0140]

[0141]

[0142] Thus, the clustering row vector of the gray task scenario I "validation of utility based on pragmatic layer" is obtained: for

[0143]

[0144] Similarly, the clustering row vectors of gray task scenario I “Completeness and correctness verification based on grammatical semantic layer” and “Non-functional indicator verification of indicator system” are calculated as

[0145]

[0146] Assuming that the weight coefficients of “validity verification based on pragmatic layer”, “completeness and correctness verification based on grammatical semantic layer” and “non-functional indicator verification of indicator system” are (0.4, 0.4, 0.2) respectively, the validity verification vector σ of the evaluation indicator system for gray task scenario I is 1 for

[0147]

[0148] Similarly, the clustering row vectors of the gray task scenario II, namely, “validation of utility based on pragmatic layer”, “validation of completeness and correctness based on grammatical semantic layer”, and “validation of non-functional index of index system”, are obtained as follows:

[0149]

[0150] The validity verification vector σ of the evaluation index system for gray task scenario II 2 for

[0151]

[0152] 5.4. Clustering result analysis and judgment

[0153] Depend on It is found that the effectiveness of the evaluation index system for the grey task scenario I belongs to the grey category k=5, and the effectiveness of the evaluation index system for the grey task scenario II belongs to the grey category k=4.

[0154] It can be seen that the effectiveness of the evaluation index system for gray task scenario I is better than that for gray task scenario II. Of course, if the effectiveness of the evaluation index system for gray task scenarios I and II above belongs to the same gray category, their comprehensive decision-making measures can be further calculated.

[0155] Furthermore, based on the above algorithm, the effectiveness verification vector σ of the evaluation index system for L different gray task scenarios is obtained: 1 ,σ 2 ,…,σ L , assuming that the weight vectors of L different gray task scenarios are (w1,w2,…,w L ), the validity verification vector of the evaluation index system based on multi-gray task scenarios is calculated by the following formula:

[0156]

[0157] Depend on The effectiveness of the evaluation index system based on multi-gray task scenarios can be determined as gray class k * .

[0158] Finally, it should be noted that the above embodiments are only used to illustrate the technical solutions of the present invention, rather than to limit it. Although the present invention has been described in detail with reference to the aforementioned embodiments, those skilled in the art should understand that they can still modify the technical solutions described in the aforementioned embodiments, or replace some or all of the technical features therein by equivalents. However, these modifications or replacements do not cause the essence of the corresponding technical solutions to deviate from the scope of the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present invention.

Claims

1. A clustering verification method for the effectiveness of an evaluation index system based on multi-gray task scenarios, characterized in that: The steps include: S1. According to the verification requirements of the effectiveness of the equipment system combat capability evaluation index system, the verification evaluation gray class number S is divided, and the value of each verification evaluation index is also divided into S gray classes accordingly, and the whitening weight function of the j index k gray class is determined; S2, determine the clustering weight of each verification evaluation indicator; S3. Generate multi-gray mission scenarios based on the equipment system combat mission analysis, which include representative system combat application scenario examples; S4, selecting one of all the evaluation index system sets to be verified to perform grey clustering verification algorithm calculation; S5, determine whether the calculation of all evaluation indicator systems to be verified has been completed. If so, proceed to S6 to analyze the effectiveness verification results; otherwise, proceed to S4; S6. Analyze the effectiveness verification matrix of all evaluation index systems under all gray task scenarios, and rank the effectiveness of the evaluation index systems under different gray task scenarios or rank the suitability of equipment systems under different index systems for gray task scenarios.

2. The effectiveness clustering verification method of the evaluation index system based on multi-gray task scenarios according to claim 1 is characterized in that: S4 includes the following steps: S41. Select a typical gray task scenario i and calculate the clustering coefficient σ of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system belonging to the k gray class under the verified scenario i. ik ; S42. Calculate the unitized evaluation coefficient δ of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the gray task scenario i belonging to the k gray class ik ; S43, by Determine the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the verified scenario i belongs to k * Gray category; S44, calculate the comprehensive verification measure of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the verified scenario i, which belongs to the k-gray category; S45, judging whether the calculation of all gray task scenarios for the selected evaluation index system has been completed, if so, proceed to S5, otherwise proceed to S41.

3. The effectiveness clustering verification method of the evaluation index system based on multi-gray task scenarios according to claim 1 is characterized in that: The gray category is a characteristic classification of equipment system behavior; The representative system combat application scenario examples include expected application scenarios and abnormal application scenarios of different gray categories; The expected application scenario is used to describe the behavior environment in which the equipment system's expected combat capability can be exerted, and the abnormal application scenario is used to describe the behavior environment in which the equipment system's combat capability is difficult to exert; Use expected application scenarios to verify the completeness of the effectiveness of the evaluation indicator system, and use abnormal application scenarios to verify the correctness of the effectiveness of the evaluation indicator system.

4. The effectiveness clustering verification method of the evaluation index system based on multi-gray task scenarios according to claim 1 is characterized in that: S3 specifically includes the following steps: S31. Combat mission scenario analysis content; S311, system mission analysis; S312, Operational Concept Analysis; S313, Combat Activity Decomposition; S314, combat mission generation; S32. Grey category analysis of combat mission scenarios.

5. The effectiveness clustering verification method of the evaluation index system based on multi-gray task scenarios according to claim 4 is characterized in that: S32 specifically includes: based on the content of the combat mission scenario analysis, according to the percentage of the equipment system completing the specified combat mission, the more combat mission workload is completed, the higher the level of the equipment system's combat capability in the mission scenario, and the levels include unsuitable level, barely suitable level, generally suitable level, relatively suitable level, and fully suitable level; Each level constitutes an application scenario layer on the basis of the improvement process of equipment system combat capability enhancement, and is the basis for achieving the next system combat capability level; the unsuitable level and barely suitable level are used to cover abnormal application scenarios; the generally suitable level, relatively suitable level, and completely suitable level are used to cover the expected application scenarios.

6. The effectiveness clustering verification method of the evaluation index system based on multi-gray task scenarios according to claim 2 is characterized by: S4 specifically includes the following steps: S41. Assume that there are N different gray application scenarios, each of which has M validity verification indicators, d ij For the sample of the jth validity verification indicator for the i-th application scenario, we can get the validity verification sample matrix D = (d ij ) N×M ,Right now: d in matrix D i1 ,d i2 ,…,d im is the sample row of the validation index j=1, j=2,..., j=M for the validation scenario i, then the i sample row is transformed into the validation evaluation value of each gray class k=1, k=2,..., k=S for the application scenario i, which is called the gray clustering validation evaluation of the gray class to which the validation index system belongs under the application scenario i; Calculation of weight coefficients of grey clustering; Let F be the grey clustering mapping, S grey classes for validity verification and evaluation, OPf jk (d ij ) is sample d ij The operation performed by using the k (1≤k≤S) gray quantity of the j (1≤i≤N, 1≤j≤M)th validity verification evaluation index, f jk is the whitening weight function of the verification gray class k of the jth verification evaluation index, then the weight coefficient σ of the gray clustering is ik The expression is: F:OPf jk (d ij )→s ik ∈[0,1],σ i =s i1 ,s i2 ,…,s iS (2) Grey clustering vector calculation; let f jk (d ij ) is the whitening weight function of the jth validity verification evaluation index for the gray class k, η jk is the whitening weight function f jk The conversion value of (·), σ ik is the grey clustering weight coefficient, sample d ij to i It is called grey clustering, σ i is ik The vector is calculated as: S42, calculation of unitized verification evaluation coefficient; the unitized verification evaluation coefficient expression of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system belonging to the gray class k under the verified scenario i is: S43, validity verification evaluation gray class; let δ i =(δ i1 ,δ i2 ,…,δ is )(i=1,2,…,N) is the unitized verification evaluation coefficient vector of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the verified scenario i, then Ψ=(δ ik ) N×S is the unitized verification evaluation coefficient matrix; at the same time, if there is If it holds, then the validity verification evaluation for the verified scenario i can be obtained as gray class k * ; S44, adjustment coefficient calculation; Assume S different validity verification evaluation gray categories, and assume η1,η2,…,η S They are the adjustment coefficients of the first gray class, the second gray class, ..., the Sth gray class, and the calculation formula is: Comprehensive verification measurement calculation; Assume that the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the verified scenario i belongs to the verification evaluation gray category k, then It is a comprehensive verification measure of the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under the verified scenario i.

7. The clustering verification method for the effectiveness of the evaluation index system based on multi-gray task scenarios according to claim 1 is characterized in that S6 include: Validity verification comparison; Assume that there are two verified scenarios i and j, and the validity verification evaluation of the two verified scenarios belongs to the same gray class, that is, Calculate their comprehensive verification measures respectively, if w i >w j , then the gray class k for validity verification evaluation is called * , the effectiveness of the evaluation index system under verified scenario i is better than that under verified scenario j.

8. A storage medium, characterized in that: The storage medium includes a stored program, wherein when the program is run, the effectiveness clustering verification method of the evaluation index system based on multi-gray task scenarios described in any one of claims 1 to 7 is executed.

9. An electronic device comprising a memory, a processor, and a computer program stored in the memory and executable on the processor, wherein: The processor executes the effectiveness clustering verification method of the evaluation index system based on multi-gray task scenarios as described in any one of claims 1 to 7 through the computer program.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Reduction method and system for reliability evaluation indexes of power communication network

    CN104463704A

  • Urban agglomeration rail transit network planning evaluation method based on grey fuzziness

    CN113988692A