Method for determining degree of damage caused by underground engineering construction to existing masonry building
Through the finite element analysis model and four-stage method, combined with the deterioration index, the problem of inaccurate damage assessment of masonry buildings in the existing technology is solved, and the impact of underground engineering construction on masonry buildings is achieved more accurately and comprehensively evaluated. , ensuring construction safety and construction risk control.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410990221.1
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-23
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-12
AI Technical Summary
When evaluating the damage level of underground construction to masonry buildings, the existing methods are not comprehensive enough, the calculation is difficult and inaccurate, and they fail to effectively consider the importance of the building and the deterioration status of the structure, which affects safety control and engineering cost.
The analysis model of the underground engineering construction process was established using finite element software, and the damage degree of masonry buildings was determined through four stages: the initial determination stage determines the impact domain and deformation threshold, the main tensile strain determination stage calculates the main tensile strain value, and the maximum crack The refinement model calculates the crack width in the width determination stage, and the damage grading stage comprehensively considers the main tensile strain and crack width, and reflects the structural health status with the deterioration index.
It improves the accuracy and comprehensiveness of damage assessment, ensures the safety and construction risk control of important masonry buildings, and reasonably controls the project cost.
Smart Images

Figure CN118940509A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention belongs to the field of building damage, in particular to a method for determining the degree of damage to an existing masonry building induced by underground engineering construction. Background Art
[0002] The construction of underground projects in the old city inevitably requires excavation work to be carried out in close proximity to existing buildings or structures. Construction disturbances will induce changes in stratum stress and strain fields, which will in turn cause stratum displacement, resulting in damage to existing buildings or structures or even obvious cracking. At the same time, underground project excavation will cause obvious horizontal tensile deformation of the stratum, making the building or structure more susceptible to cracking and damage, making the building or structure's ability to withstand deformation worse than the structure's ability to withstand deformation under its own weight. In particular, masonry buildings built in the 1970s and 1980s have relatively low design standards and construction levels. After nearly 40 years of service, their strength and stiffness are often severely deteriorated, and are greatly affected by the construction of adjacent underground projects.
[0003] At present, for masonry buildings, the most widely used method for assessing the degree of building damage is to use the principal tensile strain of the wall structure as the assessment index and to grade the degree of building damage according to the maximum tensile strain value. This method has the following problems:
[0004] 1. The evaluation indicators are not comprehensive enough.
[0005] The impact of factors such as the importance of the building and the deterioration state of the building structure itself were not taken into consideration, which in turn affected the accuracy of the assessment results and reduced the guiding significance of the assessment results for the safety control of underground projects.
[0006] 2. The generation and accuracy of evaluation indicators cannot be guaranteed.
[0007] When the evaluation index adopts the theoretical index of the principal tensile strain of the wall structure, it is not convenient to monitor and verify in practical applications; and when the crack width of the masonry structure is used as the evaluation index, there are prominent problems such as great difficulty in calculation and inconsistency with the evaluation index of the principal tensile strain of the wall structure, i.e. the theoretical index.
[0008] Therefore, there is an urgent need for a damage assessment method that can better solve the problems existing in the above-mentioned assessment methods, and can provide a more reasonable and accurate damage assessment of existing masonry building structures before underground engineering construction, guide risk prevention and control during underground engineering construction, ensure the safety of underground engineering and existing masonry building structures, and reasonably control the project cost. Summary of the invention
[0009] The purpose of the present invention is to provide a method for determining the degree of damage to existing masonry buildings induced by underground engineering construction, in order to solve the technical problems that the existing method for assessing the degree of damage to masonry buildings adopts the principal tensile strain of the wall structure as the assessment index, the assessment index is not comprehensive enough, and the assessment result is not accurate enough; it is also necessary to solve the outstanding problems that when the crack width of the masonry structure is used as the assessment index, the calculation difficulty is large and it is not consistent with the theoretical index.
[0010] To achieve the above object, the present invention adopts the following technical solution:
[0011] A method for determining the extent of damage to existing masonry buildings induced by underground construction, comprising the following steps:
[0012] Step 1, the first stage, the preliminary determination stage:
[0013] Step A, establishing a model: using finite element software to establish a finite element analysis model of the underground engineering construction process when the existing masonry building does not exist, simulating the entire process of underground engineering construction;
[0014] Step B, determine the impact domain:
[0015] Determine the influence area of underground engineering construction based on the free displacement field of the stratum caused by underground engineering construction;
[0016] Step C, determine the maximum settlement and tilt value of the formation:
[0017] According to the free displacement field of the stratum caused by the underground engineering construction, the maximum settlement S and inclination value L of the stratum at the corresponding masonry building foundation position in the influence area are calculated and determined;
[0018] Step D, determine the deformation threshold:
[0019] For the existing masonry buildings in the impact area, the deformation threshold that needs to take into account the damage effect of underground engineering construction on the masonry buildings is determined; the deformation threshold is determined according to the importance of each masonry building;
[0020] Step E: Determine whether the corresponding masonry buildings in the impact area need to undergo the second phase of analysis:
[0021] According to the maximum settlement and inclination values of the formation calculated in step C, and the deformation threshold calculated in step D,
[0022] If the maximum settlement S and the tilt value L are less than the deformation threshold of the masonry building, the impact of underground construction on the masonry building is ignored;
[0023] If the maximum settlement S or tilt value L ≥ the deformation threshold of the masonry building, the next stage of analysis is performed on the masonry building;
[0024] Step 2: Determination of the health status and deterioration index of masonry buildings:
[0025] Step F, definition of deterioration index: used to reflect the current health status of each structural wall of the masonry building and the degree of deterioration of the material;
[0026] The deterioration index is based on the wall segment. By determining the health status of each wall segment in the masonry building under the current service state and the construction quality grade of the masonry building, the determination result of the deterioration index is obtained. Then, according to the determination result of the deterioration index, the strength parameters of the masonry building structural materials in the subsequent second-stage and third-stage finite element models are reduced, and the influence of the health status of the masonry building is reflected in the final result of the damage degree of the masonry building.
[0027] Step G, based on the result of step E, collecting the current usage status of each wall segment in the masonry building that needs to be determined in the next stage, and obtaining the correlation coefficient between the health status and construction quality of each wall segment;
[0028] Step a, determine the health status level of masonry buildings:
[0029] The determination result of the health status of the wall segment sets at least three health status levels, each level sets a wall segment health status feature description item, and a bad index δ2 is set corresponding to each health status level;
[0030] When collecting data, the masonry is first divided into wall sections, and then the health status of each wall section is evaluated by comparing the wall section health status characteristic description items set for each level, and the health status level of each wall section and the corresponding bad index δ2 are determined;
[0031] Step b, determine the construction quality level of each wall section:
[0032] The wall section construction quality is set to at least three construction quality levels, and a construction quality coefficient δ3 is set corresponding to each construction quality level;
[0033] Step H, determine the current deterioration index of each wall segment:
[0034] Deterioration index δ m , δ m =δ2 / δ3;
[0035] Step 3, the second stage, the principal tensile strain determination stage:
[0036] Step I, establishing a model: using finite element software to establish a finite element analysis model of the underground engineering construction process including the complete structure of the existing masonry building with a damage degree to be determined, simulating the entire process of underground engineering construction;
[0037] Step J, determining whether the wall segment needs to be analyzed in the next stage;
[0038] Through the model in step I, the principal tensile strain value ε of the masonry building is calculated, in %;
[0039] If the maximum principal tensile strain value of the wall segment is ε max If it does not exceed 0.05%, the impact of underground construction on the wall section is ignored;
[0040] If the maximum principal tensile strain value of the wall segment is ε max If it is greater than 0.05%, there is a potential risk of damage in the masonry building and the wall section needs to proceed to the next stage;
[0041] Step 4, the third stage, the stage of determining the maximum crack width:
[0042] Step K, build a refined model:
[0043] Based on the principal tensile strain distribution results of each wall section of the masonry building obtained in step J, the maximum principal tensile strain value ε max The wall segments with a rate greater than 0.05% are isolated, and a refined model of the wall including bricks and mortar is established using finite elements. At the same time, the displacement boundary conditions and force boundary conditions obtained from the second stage of wall segment analysis are applied to the refined model; the displacement boundary condition is the basic displacement, and the force boundary condition is the force transmitted by the connecting wall to the left and right boundaries of the wall segment;
[0044] Step L, determine the maximum crack width of each wall segment:
[0045] Through the wall refinement model in step K, the maximum crack width W of each wall segment is calculated. max , unit: mm;
[0046] Step 5, Stage 4, Injury Grading Stage:
[0047] Step M, determine the damage index D of the wall segment a :
[0048] According to the maximum principal tensile strain ε of each wall segment obtained in the second and third stages max and the maximum crack width W max Size, according to formula D a =δ ε γ ε +δ w γ w , determine the damage index D of the wall segment a ,
[0049] in:
[0050] δ ε The principal tensile strain damage index is the principal tensile strain influence coefficient, which is calculated based on the maximum principal tensile strain ε of each wall segment. max , determine the principal tensile strain damage index δ of the wall segment ε;
[0051] δ w is the crack width damage index, i.e. the crack width influence coefficient, according to the maximum crack width W of each wall segment max , determine the crack width damage index δ of the wall segment w ;
[0052] γ ε is the main tensile strain weight coefficient;
[0053] γ w is the crack width weight coefficient;
[0054] γ ε +γ w =1.0;
[0055] γ ε and γ w The value is selected based on the accuracy of the calculation results of the second and third stages.
[0056] Step N, determine the damage level of the masonry building:
[0057] Determine the damage level of each wall segment: According to the damage index D of the wall segment a The damage degree of each wall section is graded, and at least five grades are set to determine the damage degree level of each wall section;
[0058] Determine the damage level of the entire masonry building: The damage level of a masonry building is determined by the highest damage level of its contained wall segments.
[0059] In step B, the influence domain is the area where the vertical displacement of the ground surface is greater than 1 mm in the free displacement field of the stratum caused by the underground engineering construction.
[0060] A monolithic wall is a single wall in masonry construction that runs vertically or horizontally. A wall segment is formed by dividing a monolithic wall by walls that run perpendicular to the direction of the wall.
[0061] The boundary range of the wall segment is determined according to the following principles:
[0062] The left and right boundaries of the wall segment plane are: the midline section of the joint between the two nearest walls perpendicular to the wall where the wall segment is located and the wall segment;
[0063] The upper and lower boundaries of the wall segment plane are: the wall segment includes the foundation and the wall within the entire building height range;
[0064] The deterioration index of each wall segment in the same monolithic wall is the same or different.
[0065] In step D, the deformation threshold of the damage to masonry buildings caused by underground engineering construction in the influence domain needs to be considered as the structural vulnerability deformation threshold;
[0066] The structural vulnerability deformation thresholds include [S] and [L];
[0067] The calculation formula is: [S] = [S]0 / δ1; [L] = [L]0 / δ1;
[0068] Where, [S]0 = 10 mm, [L]0 = 1 / 500;
[0069] δ1 is the importance coefficient of masonry buildings, and the importance coefficient δ1 is determined by the service life of each masonry building;
[0070] When the service life is 50 years or less, the importance coefficient δ1 is 1.00, and the threshold value of structural vulnerability deformation is: [S] = 10.0 mm, [L] = 1 / 500;
[0071] When the service life is 50 to 100 years, the importance coefficient δ1 is 1.10, and the structural vulnerability deformation threshold is: [S] = 9.1 mm, [L] = 1 / 550;
[0072] When the service life is more than 100 years or the building is a historical building, the importance coefficient δ1 is 1.20, and the threshold value of structural vulnerability deformation is: [S] = 8.3 mm, [L] = 1 / 600;
[0073] For masonry buildings within the influence domain, the relative sizes of the maximum ground settlement S and the inclination value L and the corresponding structural vulnerability deformation thresholds are compared, and the following four working conditions can be obtained:
[0074] Working condition 1:
[0075] Working condition 2:
[0076] Working condition three:
[0077] Working condition 4:
[0078] For working condition 1, there is no need to conduct the next stage of analysis, and the impact of underground construction on the masonry building is ignored; for working conditions 2 to 4, the next stage of analysis is carried out on the masonry building.
[0079] In step a of step G, the wall segment health status feature description items include a size status item, a connection and masonry method status item, a crack status item and a corrosion status item, and each item includes at least one feature description;
[0080] The wall segment health status is divided into three levels: intact, poor, and poor; the corresponding poor index δ2 is 1.00, 1.50, and 2.00 respectively;
[0081] Determination of the health status grade of masonry buildings: When evaluating the health status of each wall section, if all the characteristic description items of the health status of each wall section meet the requirements for being rated as intact, the health status grade of the wall section will be rated as intact. As long as there is one characteristic description that is rated as poor or relatively poor, the health status grade of the masonry building of this wall section will be determined as poor or relatively poor accordingly.
[0082] In step b of step G, the construction quality level is divided into three levels, namely, level A, level B and level C, and the corresponding construction quality coefficients δ3 are 1.1, 1.0 and 0.85 respectively.
[0083] In step M, the principal tensile strain damage index is taken as δ ε as follows:
[0084] When ε max When it is 0.05~0.075%, the corresponding δ ε is [3,5);
[0085] When ε max When it is 0.075~0.15%, the corresponding δ ε is [5,10);
[0086] When ε max When it is 0.15~0.30%, the corresponding δ ε is [10,15);
[0087] When ε max When it is >0.30%, the corresponding δ ε is [15,20).
[0088] In step M, the wall crack width damage index δ w The values are as follows:
[0089] When W max When it is <0.1mm, the corresponding δ w is [0,3);
[0090] When W max When it is 0.10~1.0mm, the corresponding δ w is [3,5);
[0091] When W max When it is 1.0~5.0mm, the corresponding δ w is [5,10);
[0092] When W max When it is 5.0~15.0mm, the corresponding δ w is [10,15);
[0093] When W maxWhen it is 15.0~25.0mm, the corresponding δ w is [15,20);
[0094] When W max When it is >25.0mm, the corresponding δ w is [20,30).
[0095] In step N, determine the wall segment damage level and the masonry structure wall segment damage index D a as follows:
[0096] The wall segment damage degree is divided into five levels, namely negligible, slight, moderate, severe and very severe;
[0097] When the level is negligible, the corresponding D a is <3;
[0098] When the level is mild, the corresponding D a is [3,10);
[0099] When the level is medium, the corresponding D a is [10,15);
[0100] When the level is severe, the corresponding D a is [15,20);
[0101] When the level is very serious, the corresponding D a Is ≥20.
[0102] In step K, there are two simulation methods for building a refined model:
[0103] In the first method, the blocks in the wall segment are simulated by solid elements, and the constitutive model adopts elastic or concrete total strain crack model; the mortar between blocks is simulated by interface elements, and the interface elements are simulated by Mohr-Coulomb elastoplastic model;
[0104] In the second method, the masonry blocks in the wall section are simulated by solid elements, and the constitutive model adopts elasticity or concrete total strain crack model; the mortar is simulated by solid elements, and the constitutive model adopts concrete damage model or concrete total strain crack model; the interface between masonry and mortar is simulated by interface elements, and the interface is simulated by Mohr-Coulomb elastoplastic model.
[0105] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following characteristics and beneficial effects:
[0106] The present invention comprises four stages:
[0107] The first stage is the preliminary determination stage. Finite element software is used to establish an analysis model for the underground engineering construction process, solve the stratum free displacement field caused by underground engineering construction when the existing building does not exist, and determine the impact range of underground engineering construction. And determine the maximum settlement and inclination values of the stratum corresponding to the actual masonry building foundation position within the impact range based on the free displacement field. At the same time, for the existing masonry buildings within the impact range of underground engineering construction, the deformation threshold that needs to be considered for damage is determined according to the importance of the building. According to the maximum settlement and inclination values and deformation threshold corresponding to the foundation position of the existing masonry building in the stratum free displacement field calculated, determine whether the masonry buildings within the impact range need to be analyzed in the second stage. If the calculated maximum settlement and inclination values of the stratum at the foundation position of the existing masonry building exceed the deformation threshold of the masonry building, the second stage damage determination is carried out. If the calculated result is less than the threshold, the impact of the underground engineering construction on the masonry building is ignored.
[0108] The second stage is the determination of the principal tensile strain. First, the strength parameters of the masonry building wall sections are reduced according to the deterioration index of each wall of the existing masonry building to prepare for the subsequent stage analysis. Then, an analysis model of the underground engineering construction process including the existing masonry structure is established. The principal tensile strain values of each wall of the masonry structure are obtained by collaborative analysis and calculation of the underground engineering, strata and the existing masonry structure. When the principal tensile strain value is greater than 0.05%, it is considered that there is a potential risk of damage in the masonry building, and the third stage assessment needs to be carried out, otherwise the damage effect of the underground engineering construction on the masonry building is ignored.
[0109] The third stage is to determine the maximum crack width. The masonry walls with a principal tensile strain greater than 0.05% calculated in the second stage are isolated, and a refined model of the masonry wall containing bricks and mortar is established. The force and displacement results obtained in the previous stage are applied as boundary conditions to the refined finite element model. The maximum crack width of each wall is obtained through calculation.
[0110] The fourth stage is the damage classification stage. According to the maximum principal tensile strain and maximum crack width of each wall segment of the masonry, the wall segment damage index is determined, and the damage state of the masonry building is finally classified.
[0111] The present invention proposes a threshold index for the vulnerability deformation of existing masonry buildings that takes into account the importance of the building. The importance coefficient of the building and the corresponding vulnerability deformation control value are determined according to the design service life of the existing masonry structure. This solves the defect that the existing assessment method cannot reflect the influence of the importance of the building, and makes the damage assessment of the existing masonry structure induced by underground engineering construction more accurate, thereby ensuring the safety and normal use of important masonry buildings.
[0112] The present invention proposes the concept and determination method of the deterioration index, which is used to characterize the degradation of the performance of existing masonry structure materials, thereby laying a foundation for considering the influence of the deterioration of existing masonry structure materials on the calculation results in the analysis and calculation of damage induced by underground structure construction to existing masonry structures.
[0113] The present invention proposes a method for reducing the strength calculation parameters of masonry structures according to the deterioration index of existing masonry structures, thereby realizing the consideration of the influence of the structural health status in the finite element analysis of damage to existing masonry structures induced by underground structure construction, and solving the defect that the calculation results of existing evaluation methods cannot take into account the deterioration of masonry structure materials.
[0114] The present invention comprehensively considers the influence of two indicators, principal tensile strain and crack width of masonry structure wall and their weights in the damage classification stage, realizes the effective unification of two types of evaluation indicators, principal tensile strain and crack width, and improves the accuracy and rationality of the evaluation results. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0115] The present invention will be further described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
[0116] Figure 1 It is a flow chart of the determination method of the present invention.
[0117] Figure 2 It is the finite element model of the free displacement field of the stratum caused by the underground engineering construction established in step A of step one of the present invention.
[0118] Figure 3 yes Figure 2 Model reference diagram.
[0119] Figure 4 It is a vertical displacement cloud diagram of the free displacement field of the stratum caused by the underground engineering construction in step B of step one of the present invention.
[0120] Figure 5 It is a coordinate diagram of the influence domain of the underground engineering construction in step B of step one of the present invention.
[0121] Figure 6 It is a schematic diagram of the division and definition of wall segments and single-piece walls in step F of step 2 of the present invention.
[0122] Figure 7 yes Figure 6 Model reference diagram.
[0123] Figure 8 It is the finite element model of the underground engineering construction process established in step I of step three of the present invention, which includes the complete structure of the masonry building whose damage degree is to be determined.
[0124] Fig. 9 yes Figure 8 Model reference diagram.
[0125] Fig.10 It is the refined finite element model of the wall including displacement boundary conditions and force boundary conditions established in step K of step four of the present invention.
[0126] Figure numerals: 1 - existing masonry building, 2 - underground project, 3 - wall segment, 4 - single wall, 5 - influence domain, 6 - displacement boundary condition, 7 - force boundary condition. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0127] See Example Figure 1 As shown, a method for determining the degree of damage to existing masonry buildings induced by underground engineering construction is applicable to the assessment of the impact of underground engineering construction such as tunnels and foundation pits on the degree of damage to surrounding existing masonry structures. The underground engineering 2 in this embodiment is a tunnel engineering, which includes four stages, see Figure 2-3 As shown, the underground project 2 passes under the existing masonry building 1, and the specific steps are as follows:
[0128] Step 1, the first stage, the preliminary determination stage:
[0129] Step A, establishing a model: using finite elements to establish a finite element analysis model of the underground engineering construction process when the existing masonry building does not exist, simulating the entire process of underground engineering construction;
[0130] The first stage is the preliminary determination stage. Finite element software is used to establish a finite element analysis model of the underground engineering construction process without considering the existence of existing masonry buildings, simulating the entire process of underground engineering construction. Figure 2-3 In the first stage finite element model, the soil body adopts the small strain hardening model, and the soil material parameters include gravity γ, Poisson's ratio μ, cohesion c, internal friction angle φ, reference secant stiffness Reference tangent stiffness Reference unloading modulus Initial shear modulus The shear strain γ corresponding to the shear modulus decaying to 70% of the initial shear modulus 0.7 And the static side pressure coefficient K 0nc Etc. The elastic model is adopted for underground structure and supporting structure materials, and the model parameters include gravity γ, elastic modulus E and Poisson's ratio μ.
[0131] Step B, determine the impact domain:
[0132] The whole process of underground engineering construction is numerically simulated by finite element numerical simulation, and the free displacement field of the stratum caused by underground engineering construction is calculated. Figure 4According to the ground free displacement field caused by the underground engineering construction, the influence domain 5 of the underground engineering construction is determined. In this embodiment, the influence domain 5 is the area where the vertical displacement of the ground free displacement field caused by the underground engineering construction is greater than 1 mm, see Figure 5 shown.
[0133] Step C, determine the maximum settlement and tilt value of the formation:
[0134] According to the free displacement field of the stratum caused by the underground engineering construction, the maximum settlement S and inclination value L of the stratum at the corresponding masonry building foundation position in the influence area are calculated and determined.
[0135] Step D, determine the deformation threshold:
[0136] For the existing masonry buildings in the impact area, the deformation threshold for considering the damage caused by underground engineering construction to the masonry buildings is determined; the deformation threshold is determined according to the importance of each masonry building;
[0137] In step D, the deformation threshold that needs to be considered in the influence domain for the damage of masonry buildings caused by underground engineering construction is the structural vulnerability deformation threshold;
[0138] The structural vulnerability deformation thresholds include [S] and [L];
[0139] The calculation formula is: [S] = [S]0 / δ1; [L] = [L]0 / δ1;
[0140] Where, [S]0 = 10 mm, [L]0 = 1 / 500;
[0141] δ1 is the importance coefficient of masonry buildings, and the importance coefficient δ1 is determined by the service life of each masonry building;
[0142] When the service life is 50 years or less, the importance coefficient δ1 is 1.00, and the threshold value of structural vulnerability deformation is: [S] = 10.0 mm, [L] = 1 / 500;
[0143] When the service life is 50 to 100 years, the importance coefficient δ1 is 1.10, and the structural vulnerability deformation threshold is: [S] = 9.1 mm, [L] = 1 / 550;
[0144] When the service life is more than 100 years or it is a historical building, the importance coefficient δ1 is 1.20, and the structural vulnerability deformation threshold is: [S] = 8.3mm, [L] = 1 / 600.
[0145] Step E: Determine whether the corresponding masonry buildings in the impact area need to undergo the second phase of analysis:
[0146] According to the maximum settlement and inclination values of the formation calculated in step C, and the deformation threshold calculated in step D,
[0147] If the maximum settlement and tilt value L is less than the deformation threshold of the masonry building, the impact of underground construction on the masonry building is ignored;
[0148] If the maximum settlement S or tilt value L ≥ the deformation threshold of the masonry building, the next stage of analysis is performed on the masonry building;
[0149] Specifically, for masonry buildings within the influence domain, the relative sizes of the maximum ground settlement S and the inclination value L and the corresponding structural vulnerability deformation threshold are compared, and the following four working conditions can be obtained:
[0150] Working condition 1:
[0151] Working condition 2:
[0152] Working condition three:
[0153] Working condition 4:
[0154] For working condition 1, there is no need to conduct the next stage of analysis, and the impact of underground construction on the masonry building is ignored; for working conditions 2 to 4, the next stage of analysis is carried out on the masonry building.
[0155] Step 2: Determination of the health status and deterioration index of masonry buildings:
[0156] Step F, definition of degradation index: the degree of damage that underground construction may cause to existing masonry buildings in the affected area is closely related to the health status of the masonry buildings themselves and the degree of degradation of the building materials. However, the various assessment methods for the damage impact of underground construction on existing masonry buildings cannot consider the impact of the health status of existing masonry buildings on the assessment results. For this reason, the present invention proposes the concept of masonry building degradation index, which is jointly determined by the health status and construction quality of each structural wall in the masonry building, and is used to reflect the current health status of each structural wall of the masonry building and the degree of degradation of the material.
[0157] The deterioration index is based on the wall segment. The health status of each wall segment in the masonry building under the current service state and the construction quality grade of the masonry building are determined to obtain the determination result of the deterioration index. Then, according to the determination result of the deterioration index, the strength parameters of the masonry building structural materials in the subsequent second-stage and third-stage finite element models are reduced, and the influence of the health status of the masonry building is reflected in the final result of the damage degree of the masonry building. In this embodiment, in order to reflect the influence of the building deterioration index on the damage, the shear, tension, compression and other strength parameters of the masonry materials of each wall segment are divided by the deterioration index in the second-stage and third-stage finite element calculations to reduce the strength.
[0158] The monolithic wall 4 is a whole wall in the longitudinal or transverse direction of a masonry building; the wall segment 3 is formed by the monolithic wall 4 being separated by walls perpendicular to the direction of the wall. The monolithic wall 4 itself is a special wall segment, which is separated by walls perpendicular to the monolithic wall on both sides.
[0159] The boundary range of wall segment 3 is determined according to the following principles, see Figure 6-7 As shown:
[0160] The left and right boundaries of wall segment 3 in the plane are: the midline section of the joint between the two nearest walls perpendicular to the wall where the wall segment is located and the wall segment;
[0161] The upper and lower boundaries of the wall segment 3 plane are: the wall segment includes the foundation and the wall within the entire building height range;
[0162] Figure 6 In the embodiment, the longitudinal single wall 4 is divided into two wall segments 3.
[0163] The deterioration index of each wall segment in the same monolithic wall is the same or different.
[0164] Step G, based on the results of step E, collect the current usage status of each wall segment in the masonry building that needs to be analyzed in the next stage, and obtain the correlation coefficient between the health status and construction quality of each wall segment:
[0165] Step a, determine the health status level of masonry buildings:
[0166] The determination result of the health status of the wall segment sets at least three health status levels, each level sets a wall segment health status feature description item, and a bad index δ2 is set corresponding to each health status level;
[0167] When collecting data, the masonry is first delineated into wall sections, and then the health status of each wall section is assessed according to the wall section health status characteristic description items set for each level, and the health status level of each wall section and the corresponding adverse index δ2 are determined.
[0168] The wall segment health status feature description items include size status items, connection and masonry method status items, crack status items and corrosion status items, each of which includes at least one feature description;
[0169] The wall segment health status is divided into three levels: intact, poor, and poor; the corresponding poor index δ2 is 1.00, 1.50, and 2.00 respectively;
[0170] Determination of the health status grade of masonry buildings: When evaluating the health status of each wall section, if all the characteristic description items of the health status of each wall section meet the requirements for being rated as intact, the health status grade of the wall section will be rated as intact. As long as there is one characteristic description that is rated as poor or relatively poor, the health status grade of the masonry building of this wall section will be determined as poor or relatively poor accordingly.
[0171] In this embodiment, the wall segment health status feature description items are as follows:
[0172] Characteristics of the grade "Good" include:
[0173] Dimension status items: The height-to-thickness ratio of the wall in the masonry structural component complies with the provisions of the specification;
[0174] Connection and masonry status items: The connection and masonry methods are reasonable, the structure complies with the provisions of the specification, there are no defects or only local surface defects, and there are no abnormalities in the work;
[0175] Crack status item: There are no cracks visible to the naked eye on the wall;
[0176] Corrosion status items: There is no corrosion on the brick body and mortar layer.
[0177] Characteristics that are rated as poor include:
[0178] Dimension status item: The height-to-thickness ratio of the wall does not meet the requirements of the specification, but does not exceed 10% of the specified limit; the specification in this embodiment is the Code for Design of Masonry Structures GB50003;
[0179] Connection and masonry status items: The connection and masonry methods are correct, the structure complies with the provisions of the specification, there are no defects or only local surface defects, and there are no abnormalities in the work;
[0180] Crack status items: non-stress crack width of wall and wall with pilasters ≤ 1.5mm;
[0181] Corrosion status items:
[0182] The masonry has corrosion in a small area, with the maximum corrosion depth not exceeding 6mm and no development trend;
[0183] Corrosion occurs in a small area of the mortar layer, with the maximum corrosion depth not exceeding 10 mm and no development trend.
[0184] Characteristics that are rated as poor include:
[0185] Dimension status item: The height-to-thickness ratio of the wall does not meet the requirements of the specification and has exceeded 10% of the limit specified in the standard; the specification in this embodiment is the "Code for Design of Masonry Structures" GB50003;
[0186] Connection and masonry status items: Improper connection and masonry methods, serious structural defects, which have caused cracks, deformation, displacement, loosening of components or connection parts, or other damage;
[0187] Crack status items:
[0188] Long vertical cracks appeared at the junctions of the vertical and horizontal walls;
[0189] The load-bearing wall has serious cracks, and the maximum crack width is greater than 5mm;
[0190] The width of non-stress cracks in walls and walls with pilasters is >1.5mm;
[0191] Corrosion status items:
[0192] The masonry is corroded over a large area, with the maximum corrosion depth no more than 6mm, and there is a trend of development;
[0193] Corrosion occurs in a large area of the mortar layer, with the maximum corrosion depth not exceeding 10 mm, and there is a trend of development.
[0194] Step b, determine the construction quality level of each wall section:
[0195] At least three construction quality levels are set for the wall section construction quality, and a construction quality coefficient δ3 is set for each construction quality level. The division of construction quality levels needs to comply with the regulations, and in this embodiment, it is determined according to the "Code for Acceptance of Construction Quality of Masonry Structure Engineering" GB50203. In this embodiment, the construction quality level is divided into three levels, namely, A, B and C, and the corresponding construction quality coefficients δ3 are 1.1, 1.0 and 0.85 respectively.
[0196] Step H, determine the current deterioration index of each wall segment:
[0197] Deterioration index δ m , δ m =δ2 / δ3.
[0198] Step 3, the second stage, the principal tensile strain determination stage:
[0199] Step I, establishing a model: using finite elements to establish a finite element analysis model of the underground engineering construction process including the complete structure of the existing masonry building with a damage degree to be determined, to simulate the entire process of underground engineering construction.
[0200] Step J, determining whether the wall segment needs to be analyzed in the next stage;
[0201] Through the model in step I, the principal tensile strain value ε of the masonry building is calculated, in %;
[0202] If the maximum principal tensile strain value of the wall segment is ε max If it does not exceed 0.05%, the impact of underground construction on the wall section is ignored;
[0203] If the maximum principal tensile strain value of the wall segment is ε max If it is greater than 0.05%, there is a potential risk of damage in the masonry building and the wall section needs to be analyzed in the next stage.
[0204] The second stage is the main tensile strain determination stage. Finite element analysis models of underground engineering construction process including the complete structure of the existing masonry building with the degree of damage to be determined are established by finite element method to simulate the whole process of underground engineering construction. Figure 8-9 As shown. In the finite element analysis, the soil adopts a small strain hardening constitutive model, and the masonry structure adopts a constitutive model that can reflect the compressive, tensile and shear strength characteristics of the masonry material, such as the engineering masonry model, the jointed masonry model and the concrete damage model. By simulating the entire process of underground engineering construction, the principal tensile strain value ε of the masonry structure is calculated. Areas in each wall of the masonry structure where the principal tensile strain value is greater than 0.05% are considered to be likely to produce cracks visible to the naked eye, that is, potential damage has occurred. Based on the calculation and analysis of this stage, the distribution characteristics of the principal tensile strain of the masonry structure wall are obtained. For the maximum principal tensile strain value ε of the wall section max Wall sections with a maximum principal tensile strain exceeding 0.05% need to be analyzed in the next stage, and wall sections with a maximum principal tensile strain not exceeding 0.05% are considered to have negligible effects of underground structure construction on the wall section.
[0205] Step 4, the third stage, the stage of determining the maximum crack width:
[0206] Step K: Establish a detailed wall model:
[0207] Based on the principal tensile strain distribution results of each wall section of the masonry building obtained in step J, the maximum principal tensile strain value ε max The wall segments with a value greater than 0.05% are isolated, and a refined model of the wall including bricks and mortar is established using finite elements. At the same time, the displacement boundary conditions and force boundary conditions obtained in the second stage of wall segment analysis are applied to the refined model; the displacement boundary condition 6 is the basic displacement, and the force boundary condition 7 is the force transmitted by the connecting wall to the left and right boundaries of the wall segment. For details, see Fig.10 shown.
[0208] There are two simulation methods to build a detailed wall model:
[0209] In the first method, the blocks in the wall segment are simulated by solid elements, and the constitutive model adopts elastic or concrete total strain crack model; the mortar between blocks is simulated by interface elements, and the interface elements are simulated by Mohr-Coulomb elastoplastic model;
[0210] In the second method, the masonry blocks in the wall section are simulated by solid elements, and the constitutive model adopts elasticity or concrete total strain crack model; the mortar is simulated by solid elements, and the constitutive model adopts concrete damage model or concrete total strain crack model; the interface between masonry and mortar is simulated by interface elements, and the interface is simulated by Mohr-Coulomb elastoplastic model.
[0211] Step L, determine the maximum crack width of each wall segment:
[0212] Through the wall refinement model in step K, the maximum crack width W of each wall segment is calculated. max , unit: mm.
[0213] Step 5, Stage 4, Injury Grading Stage:
[0214] Step M, determine the damage index D of the wall segment a :
[0215] According to the maximum principal tensile strain ε of each wall segment obtained in the second and third stages max and the maximum crack width W max Size, according to formula D a =δ ε γ ε +δ w γ w , determine the damage index D of the wall segment a ,
[0216] Where: ε The principal tensile strain damage index is the principal tensile strain influence coefficient, which is calculated based on the maximum principal tensile strain ε of each wall segment. max , determine the principal tensile strain damage index δ of the wall segment ε ;
[0217] The value of the principal tensile strain damage index δ ε as follows:
[0218] When ε max When it is 0.05~0.075%, the corresponding δ ε is [3,5);
[0219] When ε max When it is 0.075~0.15%, the corresponding δ ε is [5,10);
[0220] When ε maxWhen it is 0.15~0.30%, the corresponding δ ε is [10,15);
[0221] When ε max When it is >0.30%, the corresponding δ ε is [15,20).
[0222] δ w is the crack width damage index, i.e. the crack width influence coefficient, according to the maximum crack width W of each wall segment max , determine the crack width damage index δ of the wall segment w ;
[0223] Wall crack width damage index δ w The values are as follows:
[0224] When W max When it is <0.1mm, the corresponding δ w is [0,3);
[0225] When W max When it is 0.10~1.0mm, the corresponding δ w is [3,5);
[0226] When W max When it is 1.0~5.0mm, the corresponding δ w is [5,10);
[0227] When W max When it is 5.0~15.0mm, the corresponding δ w is [10,15);
[0228] When W max When it is 15.0~25.0mm, the corresponding δ w is [15,20);
[0229] When W max When it is >25.0mm, the corresponding δ w is [20,30).
[0230] γ ε is the main tensile strain weight coefficient;
[0231] γ w is the crack width weight coefficient;
[0232] γ ε +γ w =1.0;
[0233] γ ε and γ w The value is selected based on the accuracy of the calculation results of the second and third stages.
[0234] Step N, determine the damage level of the masonry building:
[0235] Determine the damage level of each wall segment: According to the damage index D of the wall segment a The damage degree of each wall section is graded, and at least five grades are set to determine the damage degree level of each wall section;
[0236] Determine the damage level of the entire masonry building: The damage level of a masonry building is determined by the highest damage level of the wall segments it contains.
[0237] Determine the wall damage level and the masonry wall damage index D a as follows:
[0238] The wall segment damage degree is divided into five levels, namely negligible, slight, moderate, severe and very severe;
[0239] When the level is negligible, the corresponding D a is <3;
[0240] When the level is mild, the corresponding D a is [3,10);
[0241] When the level is medium, the corresponding D a is [10,15);
[0242] When the level is severe, the corresponding D a is [15,20);
[0243] When the level is very serious, the corresponding D a Is ≥20.
Claims
1. A method for determining the extent of damage to existing masonry buildings induced by underground engineering construction, characterized in that: Here are the steps: Step 1, the first stage, the preliminary determination stage: Step A, establishing a model: using finite element software to establish a finite element analysis model of the underground engineering construction process when the existing masonry building does not exist, simulating the entire process of underground engineering construction; Step B, determine the impact domain: Determine the influence area of underground engineering construction based on the free displacement field of the stratum caused by underground engineering construction; Step C, determine the maximum settlement and tilt value of the formation: According to the free displacement field of the stratum caused by the underground engineering construction, the maximum settlement S and inclination value L of the stratum at the corresponding masonry building foundation position in the influence area are determined; Step D, determine the deformation threshold: For the existing masonry buildings in the affected area, determine the deformation threshold that needs to take into account the damage effect of underground engineering construction on masonry buildings; The deformation threshold is determined according to the importance of each masonry building; Step E: Determine whether the corresponding masonry buildings in the impact area need to undergo the second phase of analysis: According to the maximum settlement and inclination values of the formation calculated in step C, and the deformation threshold calculated in step D, If the maximum settlement S and the tilt value L are less than the deformation threshold of the masonry building, the impact of underground construction on the masonry building is ignored; If the maximum settlement S or tilt value L ≥ the deformation threshold of the masonry building, the next stage of analysis is performed on the masonry building; Step 2: Determination of the health status and deterioration index of masonry buildings: Step F, definition of deterioration index: used to reflect the current health status of each structural wall of the masonry building and the degree of deterioration of the material; The deterioration index is based on the wall segment. By determining the health status of each wall segment in the masonry building under the current service state and the construction quality grade of the masonry building, the determination result of the deterioration index is obtained. Then, according to the determination result of the deterioration index, the strength parameters of the masonry building structural materials in the subsequent second-stage and third-stage finite element models are reduced, and the influence of the health status of the masonry building is reflected in the final result of the damage degree of the masonry building. Step G, based on the result of step E, collecting the current usage status of each wall segment in the masonry building that needs to be analyzed in the next stage, and obtaining the correlation coefficient between the health status and construction quality of each wall segment; Step a, determine the health status level of masonry buildings: The determination result of the health status of the wall segment sets at least three health status levels, each level sets a wall segment health status feature description item, and a bad index δ2 is set corresponding to each health status level; When collecting data, the masonry is first divided into wall sections, and then the health status of each wall section is evaluated by comparing the wall section health status characteristic description items set for each level, and the health status level of each wall section and the corresponding bad index δ2 are determined; Step b, determine the construction quality level of each wall section: The wall section construction quality is set to at least three construction quality levels, and a construction quality coefficient δ3 is set corresponding to each construction quality level; Step H, determine the current deterioration index of each wall segment: Deterioration index δ m , δ m =δ2 / δ3; Step 3, the second stage, the principal tensile strain determination stage: Step I, establishing a model: using finite element software to establish a finite element analysis model of the underground engineering construction process including the complete structure of the existing masonry building with a damage degree to be determined, simulating the entire process of underground engineering construction; Step J, determine whether the wall segment needs to be analyzed in the next stage; Through the model in step I, the principal tensile strain value ε of the masonry building is calculated, in %; If the maximum principal tensile strain value of the wall segment is ε max If it does not exceed 0.05%, the impact of underground construction on the wall section is ignored; If the maximum principal tensile strain value of the wall segment is ε max If it is greater than 0.05%, there is a potential risk of damage in the masonry building, and the wall section needs to be analyzed in the next stage; Step 4, the third stage, the stage of determining the maximum crack width: Step K, build a refined model: Based on the principal tensile strain distribution results of each wall section of the masonry building obtained in step J, the maximum principal tensile strain value ε max The wall segments with a rate greater than 0.05% are isolated, and the finite element software is used to establish a refined model of the wall including bricks and mortar. At the same time, the displacement boundary conditions and force boundary conditions obtained from the second stage of wall segment analysis are applied to the refined model; the displacement boundary condition is the basic displacement, and the force boundary condition is the force transmitted by the connecting wall to the left and right boundaries of the wall segment; Step L, determine the maximum crack width of each wall segment: Through the wall refinement model in step K, the maximum crack width W of each wall segment is calculated. max , unit: mm; Step 5, Stage 4, Injury Grading Stage: Step M, determine the damage index D of the wall segment a : According to the maximum principal tensile strain ε of each wall segment obtained in the second and third stages max and the maximum crack width W max Size, according to formula D a =δ ε γ ε +δ w γ w , determine the damage index D of the wall segment a , in: δ ε The principal tensile strain damage index is the principal tensile strain influence coefficient, which is calculated based on the maximum principal tensile strain ε of each wall segment. max , determine the principal tensile strain damage index δ of the wall segment ε ; δ w is the crack width damage index, i.e. the crack width influence coefficient, according to the maximum crack width W of each wall segment max , determine the crack width damage index δ of the wall segment w ; γ ε is the main tensile strain weight coefficient; γ w is the crack width weight coefficient; c ε +g w =1.0; γ ε and γ w The value is selected based on the accuracy of the calculation results of the second and third stages. Step N, determine the damage level of the masonry building: Determine the damage level of each wall segment: According to the damage index D of the wall segment a The damage degree of each wall section is graded, and at least five grades are set to determine the damage degree level of each wall section; Determine the damage level of the entire masonry building: The damage level of a masonry building is determined by the highest damage level of the wall segments it contains.
2. The method for determining the degree of damage to existing masonry buildings induced by underground engineering construction according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step B, the influence domain is the area where the vertical displacement of the ground surface is greater than 1 mm in the free displacement field of the stratum caused by the underground engineering construction.
3. The method for determining the degree of damage to existing masonry buildings induced by underground engineering construction according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that: A monolithic wall is a single wall in masonry construction that runs vertically or horizontally. A wall segment is formed by dividing a monolithic wall by walls running perpendicular to the direction of the wall. The boundary range of the wall segment is determined according to the following principles: The left and right boundaries of the wall segment plane are: the midline section of the joint between the two nearest walls perpendicular to the wall where the wall segment is located and the wall segment; The upper and lower boundaries of the wall segment plane are: the wall segment includes the foundation and the wall within the entire building height range; The deterioration index of each wall segment in the same monolithic wall is the same or different.
4. The method for determining the degree of damage to existing masonry buildings induced by underground engineering construction according to claim 3 is characterized in that: In step D, the deformation threshold of the damage to masonry buildings caused by underground engineering construction in the influence domain needs to be considered as the structural vulnerability deformation threshold; The structural vulnerability deformation thresholds include [S] and [L]; The calculation formula is: [S] = [S]0 / δ1; [L] = [L]0 / δ1; Where, [S]0 = 10 mm, [L]0 = 1 / 500; δ1 is the importance coefficient of masonry buildings, and the importance coefficient δ1 is determined by the service life of each masonry building; When the service life is 50 years or less, the importance coefficient δ1 is 1.00, and the structural vulnerability deformation threshold is: [S] = 10.0 mm, [L] = 1 / 500; When the service life is 50 to 100 years, the importance coefficient δ1 is 1.10, and the structural vulnerability deformation threshold is: [S] = 9.1 mm, [L] = 1 / 550; When the service life is more than 100 years or the building is a historical building, the importance coefficient δ1 is 1.20, and the threshold value of structural vulnerability deformation is: [S] = 8.3 mm, [L] = 1 / 600; For masonry buildings within the influence domain, the relative sizes of the maximum ground settlement S and the inclination value L and the corresponding structural vulnerability deformation thresholds are compared, and the following four working conditions can be obtained: Working condition 1: Working condition 2: Working condition three: Working condition 4: For working condition 1, there is no need to conduct the next stage of analysis, and the impact of underground construction on the masonry building is ignored; for working conditions 2 to 4, the next stage of analysis is carried out on the masonry building.
5. The method for determining the degree of damage to existing masonry buildings induced by underground engineering construction according to claim 3, characterized in that: In step a of step G, the wall segment health status feature description items include a size status item, a connection and masonry method status item, a crack status item and a corrosion status item, and each item includes at least one feature description; The wall segment health status is divided into three levels: intact, poor, and poor; the corresponding poor index δ2 is 1.00, 1.50, and 2.00 respectively; Determination of the health status grade of masonry buildings: When evaluating the health status of each wall section, if all the characteristic description items of the health status of each wall section meet the requirements for being rated as intact, the health status grade of the wall section will be rated as intact. As long as there is one characteristic description that is rated as poor or relatively poor, the health status grade of the masonry building of this wall section will be determined as poor or relatively poor accordingly.
6. The method for determining the degree of damage to existing masonry buildings induced by underground engineering construction according to claim 3 or 5, characterized in that: In step b of step G, the construction quality level is divided into three levels, namely, level A, level B and level C, and the corresponding construction quality coefficients δ3 are 1.1, 1.0 and 0.85 respectively.
7. The method for determining the degree of damage to existing masonry buildings induced by underground engineering construction according to claim 6, characterized in that: In step M, the principal tensile strain damage index is taken as δ ε as follows: When ε max When it is 0.05~0.075%, the corresponding δ ε is [3,5); When ε max When it is 0.075~0.15%, the corresponding δ ε is [5,10); When ε max When it is 0.15~0.30%, the corresponding δ ε is [10,15); When ε max When it is >0.30%, the corresponding δ ε is [15,20).
8. The method for determining the degree of damage to existing masonry buildings induced by underground engineering construction according to claim 7, characterized in that: In step M, the wall crack width damage index δ w The values are as follows: When W max When it is <0.1mm, the corresponding δ w is [0,3); When W max When it is 0.10~1.0mm, the corresponding δ w is [3,5); When W max When it is 1.0~5.0mm, the corresponding δ w is [5,10); When W max When it is 5.0~15.0mm, the corresponding δ w is [10,15); When W max When it is 15.0~25.0mm, the corresponding δ w is [15,20); When W max When it is >25.0mm, the corresponding δ w is [20,30).
9. The method for determining the degree of damage to existing masonry buildings induced by underground engineering construction according to claim 8, characterized in that: In step N, determine the wall segment damage level and the masonry structure wall segment damage index D a as follows: The wall segment damage degree is divided into five levels, namely negligible, slight, moderate, severe and very severe; When the level is negligible, the corresponding D a is <3; When the level is mild, the corresponding D a is [3,10); When the level is medium, the corresponding D a is [10,15); When the level is severe, the corresponding D a is [15,20); When the level is very serious, the corresponding D a Is ≥20.
10. The method for determining the degree of damage to existing masonry buildings induced by underground engineering construction according to claim 3, characterized in that: In step K, there are two simulation methods for building a refined model: In the first method, the blocks in the wall segment are simulated by solid elements, and the constitutive model adopts elastic or concrete total strain crack model; the mortar between blocks is simulated by interface elements, and the interface elements are simulated by Mohr-Coulomb elastoplastic model; In the second method, the masonry blocks in the wall section are simulated by solid elements, and the constitutive model adopts elasticity or concrete total strain crack model; the mortar is simulated by solid elements, and the constitutive model adopts concrete damage model or concrete total strain crack model; the interface between masonry and mortar is simulated by interface elements, and the interface is simulated by Mohr-Coulomb elastoplastic model.
Citation Information
Cited By
Multi-mode Internet of Things monitoring and early warning system for old building structure cracks
CN120521655A
