Usage-demand-oriented fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method for ship airflow field characteristics

Through the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method of ship air flow field for use, combined with expert information and numerical simulation, the problem of systematic insufficient in ship air flow field evaluation is solved, and more reasonable and operational evaluation results are achieved, and the ship air flow is for ship air flow The design of the field scheme provides a basis for decision-making.

CN118965585AActive Publication Date: 2024-11-15RES INST 708 OF CHINA STATE SHIPBUILDING CORP
View PDF 2 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202411150217.0
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-08-21
Publication Date
2024-11-15
Estimated Expiration
2044-08-21

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The prior art lacks systematicity in the evaluation of ship air flow field characteristics, especially ignores the analysis of the use requirements of typical ship-based equipment for air flow field. The ambiguity and cognitive limitations of the expert system lead to the rationality and operability of the evaluation results. Insufficient sex.

Method used

Using the comprehensive fuzzy evaluation method of ship air flow field for use needs, the improvement-based interval two-type fuzzy hierarchical analysis method is established by obtaining expert information, building a comprehensive evaluation index system, performing fuzzy pairwise comparison and defuzzing processing, and combining numerical simulation. and the approximate ideal solution sorting method, the fuzzy envelope body is calculated to quantitatively evaluate the satisfaction of the airflow field characteristics to the usage requirements.

Benefits of technology

Improve the systematicity and rationality of the evaluation of ship's air flow field characteristics, enhance the operability of index weight allocation, scientifically evaluate the satisfaction of the air flow field characteristics to ship's use needs, and provide decisions for ship's air flow field solution design guide.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118965585A_ABST
    Figure CN118965585A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

According to the method, various use requirements of a shipboard aircraft and typical shipboard equipment on a ship airflow field are sorted, the ship airflow field characteristic fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method facing the use requirements is provided, and an analytic hierarchy process and an approximate ideal solution sorting method are expanded to an interval type-2 fuzzy group decision-making situation; therefore, the uncertainty and difference of expert opinions can be effectively dealt with. Aiming at the problem that consistency verification is difficult to pass due to the fact that the number of evaluation indexes is increased, an individual judgment matrix geometric consistency improvement algorithm is provided, a ship airflow field characteristic evaluation index weighting method based on improved IT2FAHP is established, the reasonability and operability of index weight distribution are improved, and the accuracy of the evaluation index weight distribution is improved. Aiming at the problem that the satisfaction degree of ship airflow field characteristics to ship use requirements is difficult to scientifically evaluate under actual atmospheric environment combined working conditions, a ship airflow field index performance evaluation method based on a fuzzy envelope is provided, and a ship airflow field characteristic comprehensive evaluation method based on improved IT2FTOPSIS is established. And a new thought and a new method are provided for solving a ship airflow field evaluation problem.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of ship airflow field characteristic analysis, and in particular to a fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method for ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements. Background Art

[0002] The design of ship airflow field scheme is one of the important contents of ship-equipment adaptability design, and its design quality will have a significant impact on the safe and efficient operation of carrier-based aircraft and typical ship-based equipment. Therefore, it is of great engineering practical significance to evaluate and analyze the characteristics of ship airflow field, accurately identify shortcomings and weaknesses, and provide decision-making guidance and optimization basis for the design of ship airflow field scheme.

[0003] The evaluation of ship airflow field characteristics is usually based on the acquisition of ship airflow field data. For the acquisition of ship airflow field data, two methods, numerical simulation and experimental research, are currently used to study the airflow fields of different types of ships, so as to analyze and master the characteristics of ship airflow fields. Numerical simulation research explores the influence of different grid forms, solution methods, turbulence models, etc. on the simulation results, establishes a numerical calculation strategy for ship airflow fields, and provides method support for the numerical prediction of ship airflow field characteristics. Experimental research measures and analyzes the physical quantities of ship airflow fields by conducting actual ship tests or wind tunnel tests. The measurement data of actual ship tests have small errors and high credibility, but the data acquisition cost is extremely high; while wind tunnel tests can meet the accuracy requirements and save test costs, so they are more widely used than actual ship tests. At present, a research paradigm for numerical prediction of ship airflow field characteristics has been formed that organically combines numerical simulation and experimental verification. It can reveal the influencing factors and mechanisms of ship airflow field characteristics, and propose corresponding control measures for the problems existing in the ship airflow field, thereby improving the quality of the ship airflow field and improving the safety of carrier-based aircraft take-off and landing, while accumulating valuable experience for the design of ship airflow field schemes.

[0004] Compared with the acquisition of ship airflow field data, there are very few studies on the evaluation of ship airflow field characteristics, and they are mainly focused on the safety assessment of carrier-based aircraft take-off and landing. Based on the acquisition of carrier-based aircraft airflow field data, there are currently two main types of carrier-based aircraft take-off and landing safety assessment methods: one is to establish a carrier-based aircraft dynamics model, combined with the carrier-based aircraft safety take-off and landing criteria, and calculate the wind limit diagram for the safe take-off and landing of carrier-based aircraft [1, 2]; the other is to introduce multi-criteria decision analysis technology and use the knowledge and experience of domain experts to establish a carrier-based aircraft take-off and landing safety assessment method based on a multi-criteria decision model [3-6] in view of the technical difficulties of the numerous factors affecting the safety of carrier-based aircraft take-off and landing, the complex influencing relationships, and the unclear influencing mechanisms.

[0005] Although the existing technology has provided a feasible and effective method for obtaining ship airflow field data, in terms of the evaluation of ship airflow field characteristics, only the impact of ship airflow field characteristics on the safety of take-off and landing of carrier-based aircraft is considered, while its impact on the normal operation of typical shipborne equipment is ignored. Due to the lack of analysis of the use requirements of carrier-based aircraft and typical shipborne equipment for ship airflow field, the system of solving the evaluation problem of ship airflow field characteristics is obviously insufficient. In addition, the evaluation problem of ship airflow field characteristics is itself a complex problem with multiple factors coupled. The complex system characteristics of ship equipment bring challenges to the evaluation of the satisfaction of ship airflow field characteristics with various use requirements, especially under the combined working conditions of the actual atmospheric environment at sea. Although the expert system is an acceptable and relatively reasonable solution, due to the fuzziness, diversity and cognitive limitations of expert subjective judgment, targeted improvements are still needed in terms of rationality and operability. In short, solving the evaluation problem of ship airflow field characteristics requires opening up new ideas and establishing new methods.

[0006] [1] Huang Bin. CFD simulation of helicopter / ship coupled flow field and calculation of wind limit diagram[D]. Nanjing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, 2017;

[0007] [2] Huang Bin, Hao Tong, Zhao Qibing, et al. Research on theoretical wind limit diagram for shipborne helicopter take-off and landing based on CFD[J]. Naval Architecture and Ship Engineering, 2020, 42(05): 5-10;

[0008] [3] Li Xiang, Huang Sheng, Zhang Xiuyuan. Evaluation of ship airflow field scheme using improved TOPSIS method[J]. Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology, 2016, 48(04): 133-138;

[0009] [4] Li Xiang, Sun Peng, Zhang Jiajia. Quality analysis of ship deck flow field based on numerical simulation and TOPSIS[J]. Ship Science and Technology, 2020, 42(01): 68-74;

[0010] [5] Zhang Xiuyuan, Chang Xin, Li Xiang, et al. Ship airflow field scheme evaluation method based on improved ELECTRE method [J]. Journal of Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, 2016, 42(11): 2507-2515;

[0011] [6] Chen Tianyou, Sun Peng, Ding Xiaojuan, et al. Quality ranking of deck and carrier-based aircraft wing flow fields based on AHP and TOPSIS method [J]. Journal of Dalian Maritime University, 2020, 46(01): 47-56. Summary of the invention

[0012] The purpose of the present invention is to establish a fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method for ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements, thereby improving the systematicity, rationality and operability of solving the evaluation problem of ship airflow field characteristics to a certain extent.

[0013] In order to achieve the above-mentioned purpose of the invention, the technical solution of the present invention is to provide a fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method of ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements, comprising the following steps:

[0014] Obtain expert information of relevant experts for evaluating ship airflow field schemes, and preset expert weights based on the expert information;

[0015] Systematically analyze the impact of the airflow field characteristics of the ship to be tested on the safe take-off and landing of carrier-based aircraft and the normal operation of typical ship-borne equipment, establish various usage requirements for the airflow field of the ship to be tested proposed by the ship to be tested and its typical ship-borne equipment, and construct a comprehensive evaluation index system for the airflow field characteristics of the ship to be tested facing various usage requirements;

[0016] A 9-level language scale is used to compare and judge the relative importance of various indicators in the comprehensive evaluation index system of the ship's airflow field characteristics to be tested, and multiple individual fuzzy pairwise comparison matrices are constructed.

[0017] Defuzzification is performed on multiple individual fuzzy pairwise comparison matrices to construct corresponding multiple defuzzified individual pairwise comparison matrices;

[0018] The row geometric mean method is used to calculate the index weights of multiple defuzzified individual pairwise comparison matrices, and multiple geometric consistency indices corresponding to multiple defuzzified individual pairwise comparison matrices are calculated;

[0019] According to a preset geometric consistency index threshold, determining whether multiple geometric consistency indexes are less than or equal to the geometric consistency index threshold to perform consistency verification;

[0020] When the geometric consistency index is greater than the geometric consistency index threshold, the consistency verification fails, and the corresponding defuzzified individual pairwise comparison matrix that fails the consistency verification is used as the original individual pairwise comparison matrix, which is input into the individual judgment matrix geometric consistency improvement algorithm. By setting a smaller tolerance coefficient, the modified preference value is limited to a smaller neighborhood of the original preference value, and the modified individual fuzzy pairwise comparison matrix and the corresponding modified geometric consistency index are output; the weighted geometric average operator is combined with the preset expert weights, and the corresponding individual fuzzy pairwise comparison matrix is ​​matched according to the corresponding defuzzified individual pairwise comparison matrix that passes the consistency verification, and integrated with the modified individual fuzzy pairwise comparison matrix to construct a group fuzzy pairwise comparison matrix;

[0021] Or when the geometric consistency index is less than or equal to the geometric consistency index threshold, through consistency verification, according to the corresponding multiple defuzzified individual pairwise comparison matrices that pass the consistency verification, the corresponding individual fuzzy pairwise comparison matrices are matched and integrated to obtain the group fuzzy judgment matrix;

[0022] The row geometric mean method is used to calculate the final indicator fuzzy weight and defuzzification weight of the group fuzzy pairwise comparison matrix or group fuzzy judgment matrix;

[0023] The final ship airflow field numerical simulation method is adopted to numerically simulate the airflow field scheme of the ship to be tested under different atmospheric environment combination conditions, and the ship airflow field data under the corresponding conditions are obtained;

[0024] The 7-level language scale is used to quantitatively evaluate the satisfaction of ship use requirements based on the characteristics of ship airflow field under actual atmospheric environment combination conditions, and multiple individual fuzzy decision matrices are constructed.

[0025] Combined with the preset expert weights, the weighted arithmetic average operator is used to integrate multiple individual fuzzy decision matrices to construct a group fuzzy decision matrix.

[0026] Under the combined working conditions of wind speed and direction in the actual atmospheric environment, the performance indicators of each combined working condition are integrated, and the fuzzy envelope of each performance indicator of the ship's airflow field is calculated. The fuzzy envelope is used to describe the satisfaction degree of the ship's airflow field characteristics under the combined working conditions of the actual atmospheric environment for the ship's use requirements;

[0027] The weighted normalized group fuzzy decision matrix is ​​calculated according to the final indicator fuzzy weight and fuzzy envelope, and the defuzzified weighted normalized group decision matrix is ​​constructed by defuzzification.

[0028] The distances between the quantitative evaluation of each performance index of the ship airflow field scheme and the determined fuzzy positive ideal solution and fuzzy negative ideal solution are calculated respectively;

[0029] The relative closeness coefficients of the quantitative evaluation of the performance of each index of the ship airflow field scheme and the fuzzy positive ideal solution are calculated respectively, and the relative closeness coefficients of the solution are obtained by defuzzification.

[0030] The ship airflow field schemes are evaluated and sorted in descending order according to the relative closeness coefficient of the solutions to obtain the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation results of the ship airflow field characteristics.

[0031] Preferably, the comprehensive evaluation index system of the airflow field characteristics of the ship to be tested includes: the take-off and landing safety of the ship to be tested and the operating temperature adaptability of typical shipborne equipment of the ship to be tested, wherein the take-off and landing safety of the ship to be tested includes the forward speed, lateral speed, vertical speed, vertical speed standard deviation, turbulent kinetic energy distribution, streamline distribution and pressure distribution, and the operating temperature adaptability of typical shipborne equipment of the ship to be tested includes the maximum temperature and temperature distribution.

[0032] Preferably, the output of the individual judgment matrix geometric consistency improvement algorithm also includes recommended priority review judgments, recommended priority adjustment directions and recommended correction values.

[0033] Preferably, the establishment of the final ship airflow field numerical simulation method comprises the following steps:

[0034] Obtaining a three-dimensional model of the ship to be tested and performing a quality check on the model;

[0035] The blocking rate is calculated according to the blocking rate formula, and the calculation domain is divided under the premise that the blocking rate is less than 3%;

[0036] Divide the computational grid according to the computational conditions and model size, and encrypt the grids on the model surface and key areas according to the Reynolds number of the flow field and the areas of focus;

[0037] Select appropriate turbulence model and incompressible air physical model, and set boundary conditions according to working conditions to define the model;

[0038] Different grid schemes are obtained by adjusting the grid size, grid convergence is verified by trial calculation, and the initial numerical calculation strategy of the ship airflow field is established;

[0039] The initial numerical calculation strategy of the ship airflow field is adopted to calculate the similar ship airflow field schemes with existing test data. The calculation results are compared with the test results to verify the accuracy of the initial numerical calculation strategy of the ship airflow field and establish the final numerical simulation method of the ship airflow field.

[0040] Preferably, the turbulence model uses a k-ε model, adopts a pressure-based coupling solution to control equations, discretizes the convection term using a second-order upwind format, and discretizes the dissipation term using a second-order central difference format.

[0041] Preferably, the calculation formula of the geometric consistency index is:

[0042]

[0043]

[0044] In the formula, is the individual in the original individual pairwise comparison matrix, and is the original indicator weight corresponding to the individual.

[0045] Preferably, the calculation formula of the group fuzzy decision matrix is:

[0046]

[0047] In the formula, To preset expert weights, Indicates expert P k The ship airflow field scheme F is given i About indicator D j At wind speed V p Wind direction q Evaluation value under combined working conditions.

[0048] Preferably, the calculation formula of the fuzzy positive ideal solution is:

[0049]

[0050] In the formula, B is the benefit indicator set, C is the cost indicator set, is the weighted normalized group fuzzy decision matrix, v ij Normalize the group decision matrix for defuzzification weights.

[0051] Preferably, the calculation formula of the fuzzy negative ideal solution is:

[0052]

[0053] Preferably, the calculation formula of the relative closeness coefficient is:

[0054]

[0055] In the formula, is the distance between the ship airflow field solution and the fuzzy positive ideal solution, is the distance between the ship airflow field solution and the fuzzy negative ideal solution.

[0056] The technical solution of the present invention sorts out the various use requirements of carrier-based aircraft, typical ship-borne equipment, etc. on the ship airflow field, and proposes a fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method for ship airflow field characteristics oriented to the use requirements. The analytic hierarchy process (AHP) and the technique for order preference by similarity to an ideal solution (TOPSIS) are extended to the interval type-II fuzzy group decision-making scenario, which effectively copes with the uncertainty and diversity of expert opinions. Aiming at the problem that the consistency verification is difficult to pass due to the increase in the number of evaluation indicators after the ship use requirements, an improved algorithm for the geometric consistency of the individual judgment matrix is ​​proposed, and a weighting method for the evaluation index of the ship airflow field characteristics based on the improved IT2FAHP is established to improve the rationality and operability of the index weight allocation. Aiming at the problem that it is difficult to scientifically evaluate the satisfaction of the ship airflow field characteristics with the ship use requirements under the actual atmospheric environment combination working conditions, a ship airflow field index performance evaluation method based on fuzzy envelope is proposed, and a comprehensive evaluation method for the ship airflow field characteristics based on the improved IT2FTOPSIS is established, which provides new ideas and methods for solving the ship airflow field evaluation problem. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0057] Figure 1 A comprehensive evaluation index system for ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements provided by an embodiment of the present invention;

[0058] Figure 2 A flow chart of an improved IT2FAHP method provided by an embodiment of the present invention;

[0059] Figure 3 A schematic diagram of the language evaluation of index performance under combined working conditions provided by an embodiment of the present invention;

[0060] Figure 4 The geometric model and area of ​​interest diagram of the "USA" class amphibious assault ship provided by the embodiment of the present invention;

[0061] Figure 5 A computational domain grid division diagram provided by an embodiment of the present invention;

[0062] Figure 6 Comparison of PIV test data and CFD calculation results provided by the embodiments of the present invention;

[0063] Figure 7 The vorticity distribution under the working condition of wind speed 10m / s and direction 30° provided by the embodiment of the present invention;

[0064] Figure 8 A global weight ranking diagram provided by an embodiment of the present invention;

[0065] Fig. 9 D1 forward velocity diagram provided by an embodiment of the present invention;

[0066] Fig.10 A D2 lateral velocity diagram provided by an embodiment of the present invention;

[0067] Fig.11 A D3 vertical velocity diagram provided by an embodiment of the present invention;

[0068] Fig.12 A maximum temperature diagram of D8 provided in an embodiment of the present invention;

[0069] Fig.13 The D9 temperature distribution diagram provided by the embodiment of the present invention;

[0070] Fig.14 The airflow field index performance and positive ideal solution of the "USA" class amphibious assault ship provided by the embodiment of the present invention The distance map of

[0071] Fig.15 Airflow field index performance and negative ideal solution of the "USA" class amphibious assault ship provided by the embodiment of the present invention The distance diagram. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0072] The present invention will be further described below in conjunction with specific embodiments. It should be understood that these embodiments are only used to illustrate the present invention and are not intended to limit the scope of the present invention. In addition, it should be understood that after reading the content taught by the present invention, those skilled in the art can make various changes or modifications to the present invention, and these equivalent forms fall within the scope limited by the appended claims of the application equally.

[0073] like Figure 1-Figure 3 As shown, a fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method of ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements is proposed in an embodiment of the present invention, comprising the following steps:

[0074] By systematically analyzing the impact of the ship's airflow field on the safe take-off and landing of carrier-based aircraft and the normal operation of typical ship-borne equipment, the various usage requirements of carrier-based aircraft and typical ship-borne equipment on the ship's airflow field are fully captured (see Table 1), and then a comprehensive evaluation index system for ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements is constructed (see Table 2). Figure 1 ).

[0075] Table 1 Various requirements for the ship's airflow field put forward by carrier-based aircraft and typical ship-based equipment

[0076]

[0077] The influence range of the ship's airflow field on the safe take-off and landing of carrier-based aircraft is mainly located above and around the take-off and landing position of carrier-based aircraft, and the influencing factors are mainly the relevant physical quantities of the flow field velocity; while the influence range of the ship's airflow field on the normal operation of typical shipborne equipment is mainly located in the superstructure, and the influencing factors are mainly the relevant physical quantities of the flow field temperature.

[0078] Based on the improved Interval Type-2 Fuzzy AHP (IT2FAHP), the weighting method of ship airflow field characteristic evaluation index is proposed. The classic AHP method is extended to the interval type-2 fuzzy group decision-making situation to effectively deal with the ambiguity and differences of expert opinions. At the same time, an improved algorithm for the geometric consistency of the individual judgment matrix is ​​proposed. When the individual judgment matrix fails to pass the consistency verification, it provides key information support for experts to correct their original opinions. Figure 2 As shown, the specific steps are as follows:

[0079] Step 0: Clarify the evaluation object and decision-making purpose, and invite experts in the field of ship airflow field scheme to form an expert group, denoted as P = {p1, p2, …, p l}, P k represents the kth expert, k = 1, 2, ..., l; the expert weight is set according to the expert information such as professional knowledge, work experience, and education level, and is recorded as have and

[0080] Step 1: Use the 9-level language scale of “EMI-VE-VSMI-SV-SMI-MS-MMI-EM-EI” as shown in Table 2 to compare and judge the relative importance of the evaluation indicators, and construct an individual fuzzy pairwise comparison matrix (FPCM), denoted as

[0081]

[0082]

[0083] Table 2 9-level language scale of relative importance of evaluation indicators

[0084]

[0085] Step 2: Verify the individual consistency.

[0086] Step 2.1: Use the area centroid method to Perform defuzzification and construct the individual pairwise comparison matrix (PCM), denoted as

[0087]

[0088]

[0089] Step 2.2: Use the row geometric mean (RGM) method to calculate the indicator weights.

[0090]

[0091] Step 2.3: Calculate individual PCMA k The geometric consistency index (GCI) of

[0092]

[0093] Step 2.4: According to the GCI threshold (denoted as ) for individual PCMA k Perform consistency verification. If It is believed that individual PCM A k If the individual PCM A k With acceptable consistency, it is believed that individuals Also with acceptable consistency.

[0094] Table 3 Thresholds for consistency verification based on GCI

[0095]

[0096] Step 2.5: When the individual judgment matrix fails to pass the consistency verification, it is necessary to organize experts to review and revise the original opinions. To this end, an individual judgment matrix geometric consistency improvement algorithm is established to provide experts with key information support such as the judgment of the recommended priority review, the recommended priority adjustment direction, and the specific value of the recommended revision.

[0097] Specifically, the individual judgment matrix geometric consistency improvement algorithm has the following inputs: original individual PCMA, tolerance coefficient ρ, and output is the modified individual The corresponding geometric consistency index GCI(A′). The following are the specific algorithm steps, including:

[0098] Step 0: Let J = {(r, s)}, where r < s, r and s are the row and column subscripts of the individual judgment matrix respectively;

[0099] Step 1: If a rs <1, let (r,s) = (s,r); otherwise, remain unchanged;

[0100] Step 2: For all (r,s)∈J, calculate

[0101] Step 3: Find out The following is marked as (r', s'), let (r, s) = (r', s');

[0102] Step 4: Calculation

[0103] a) If loge rs <0,

[0104] b) If loge rs >0,

[0105] Let a' rs =a rs t rs , a' sr =1 / a' rs , update the individual judgment matrix A, record it as A′, and update J=J\(r',s');

[0106] Step 5: Calculate GCI(A′)

[0107] a) If calculate And update the individual

[0108] Get corrected individual

[0109] Output correction individual and the corresponding geometric consistency index GCI(A′);

[0110] b) If and Repeat steps 1-5.

[0111] The individual judgment matrix geometric consistency improvement algorithm is set to a smaller tolerance coefficient. ρ , the preference value a' will be modified rs Restricted to the original preference value a rs The smaller neighborhood In this way, more original expert preference information is retained as much as possible, which is conducive to the expert's recognition of the weighting results. In addition, the individual judgment matrix geometric consistency improvement algorithm can iteratively provide key information support for experts to correct preference information, including the judgment of priority review. Suggested priority adjustment directionloge rs And the specific value of the proposed correction a' rs =a rs t rs , thus realizing the automatic correction of expert judgment. Compared with the traditional method, it not only avoids the blindness of expert self-correction, reduces the mental burden of experts, improves the operability of the weighting process, but also reduces the secondary error that may be caused by it, and further ensures the rationality of the weighting result.

[0112] Step 3: Use weighted geometric averaging (WGA) to integrate individual Construct group FPCM, denoted as

[0113]

[0114] When the group fuzzy pairwise comparison matrix is ​​used to describe the failure of consistency verification, the individual judgment matrix is ​​corrected by the improved algorithm of geometric consistency. According to the corresponding defuzzified individual pairwise comparison matrix that passes the consistency verification, the corresponding individual fuzzy pairwise comparison matrix is ​​matched, and the set formed by integrating with the corrected individual fuzzy pairwise comparison matrix is ​​formed. At this time, the group FPCM is the group fuzzy pairwise comparison matrix; when the group fuzzy judgment matrix is ​​used to describe the failure of consistency verification, according to the corresponding multiple defuzzified individual pairwise comparison matrices that pass the consistency verification, the corresponding individual fuzzy pairwise comparison matrices are matched to form an integrated set. At this time, the group FPCM is the group fuzzy judgment matrix.

[0115] Previous studies have shown that the consistency of the group PCMB integrated using the WGA operator is better than or equal to the individual PCMB with the worst consistency. k , so if all individual PCM A k All pass the consistency verification, then the group PCMB integrated by WGA operator must have acceptable consistency. k With individuals is approximately equivalent, so if all individuals All pass the consistency verification, then it can be considered that the group using the WGA operator integration There must be acceptable consistency.

[0116]

[0117] Step 4: Calculate the fuzzy weight of the indicator, denoted as

[0118]

[0119]

[0120] The numerical simulation method of ship airflow field based on CFD (Computational Fluid Dynamics) uses computational fluid dynamics method to numerically simulate the ship airflow field scheme to obtain ship airflow field data and provide input for the evaluation of ship airflow field characteristics.

[0121] The specific steps of the CFD-based numerical simulation method for ship airflow field are as follows:

[0122] Step 1: Use engineering modeling software to perform three-dimensional modeling of the ship's airflow field scheme, and ensure the closedness of the model during the modeling process.

[0123] Step 2: Import the 3D model into the fluid calculation software and check the model quality to ensure that the triangular faces of the model are not repeated or intersected.

[0124] Step 3: Divide the computational domain to ensure that the computational blocking rate is less than 3%.

[0125]

[0126] Step 4: Divide the computational grid according to the computational conditions and model size, and appropriately encrypt the grids on the model surface and key locations based on the flow field Reynolds number and key areas of concern.

[0127] Step 5: Define the calculation model, select the appropriate turbulence model and incompressible air physical model, and set boundary conditions according to working conditions.

[0128] Step 6: Obtain different grid schemes by adjusting the grid size, verify the grid convergence through trial calculations, and preliminarily establish the numerical calculation strategy for the ship airflow field.

[0129] Step 7: Using the initially established numerical calculation strategy for the ship airflow field, calculate similar ship airflow field schemes with existing test data, compare the calculation results with the test results, verify the accuracy of the initially established numerical calculation strategy for the ship airflow field, and establish the final numerical simulation method for the ship airflow field.

[0130] Step 8: Using the established ship airflow field numerical simulation method, numerically simulate the airflow field scheme of the target ship according to different working conditions to obtain the ship airflow field data and provide input for the evaluation of the ship airflow field characteristics.

[0131] A comprehensive evaluation method for ship airflow field characteristics is proposed based on the improved interval type-2 fuzzy analytic hierarchy process. The classic TOPSIS method is extended to the interval type-2 fuzzy group decision-making scenario to effectively deal with the ambiguity and differences of expert opinions. At the same time, a ship airflow field index performance evaluation method based on fuzzy envelope is proposed to quantitatively evaluate the satisfaction of ship airflow field characteristics with ship use requirements under actual atmospheric environment combination conditions.

[0132] The specific steps to improve the IT2FTOPSIS method are as follows:

[0133] Step 1: Use the fuzzy envelope-based ship airflow field index performance evaluation method to quantitatively evaluate the satisfaction of ship airflow field characteristics with ship use requirements under actual atmospheric environment conditions.

[0134] Step 1.1: Organize experts to use the 7-level language scale of "VL-L-ML-M-MH-H-VH" as shown in Table 4 to quantitatively evaluate the satisfaction of the ship's airflow field characteristics under the actual atmospheric environment combination conditions with the ship's use requirements, such as Figure 3 As shown, construct the individual fuzzy decision matrix, denoted as

[0135]

[0136] In the formula, Indicates expert P k Given about the indicator D j Plan F i The evaluation value of Indicates expert P k The proposed solution F i About indicator D j At wind speed V p Wind direction q Evaluation value under combined working conditions.

[0137] Table 4 7-level language scale for evaluating indicator performance

[0138]

[0139] Step 1.2: Use weighted arithmetic mean (WAM) to integrate individual fuzzy decision matrices Construct a group fuzzy decision matrix, denoted as

[0140]

[0141] Step 1.3: In the actual atmospheric environment wind speed and wind direction combination conditions, integrate the index performance of each combination condition, and calculate the fuzzy envelope of each index performance of the ship airflow field, which is recorded as

[0142]

[0143] The fuzzy envelope reflects the satisfaction degree of the ship's airflow field characteristics under the actual atmospheric environment combination conditions for the ship's use requirements.

[0144] Step 2: Use the WAM operator to calculate the weighted normalized group fuzzy decision matrix, denoted as

[0145]

[0146] Step 3: Use the area centroid method to defuzzify the weighted normalized group fuzzy decision matrix and construct a defuzzified weighted normalized group decision matrix, denoted as V = [v ij ] m×n .

[0147] Step 4: Determine the fuzzy positive ideal solution (FPIS), denoted as Determine the fuzzy negative ideal solution (FNIS), denoted as

[0148]

[0149] In the formula, B represents the benefit-based indicator set, and C represents the cost-based indicator set.

[0150] Step 5: Calculate F for each solution separately i and fuzzy positive ideal solution and fuzzy negative ideal solution The distance between and

[0151]

[0152] Step 6: Calculate F for each solution i and fuzzy positive ideal solution The relative closeness coefficient is denoted as

[0153]

[0154] Step 7: Right Perform defuzzification processing to obtain the relative closeness coefficient of defuzzification, recorded as CC i .

[0155] Step 8: According to the relative closeness coefficient CC i Descending order for ship airflow field scheme F i Evaluate and rank.

[0156] Example

[0157] The comprehensive evaluation of the airflow field characteristics of the "America" ​​class amphibious assault ship is used as an example to verify the feasibility and effectiveness of the proposed method. In this example, three experts in the field of ship and sea are invited to perform the index weight allocation and index performance evaluation work, and the expert weight is set to W P =(0.4,0.3,0.3).

[0158] This paper systematically analyzes the impact of the airflow field characteristics of the "America" ​​class amphibious assault ship on the safe take-off and landing of carrier-based aircraft and the normal operation of typical shipborne equipment, establishes a table of various usage requirements for the airflow field of the "America" ​​class amphibious assault ship and its typical shipborne equipment, and constructs a comprehensive evaluation index system for the airflow field characteristics of the "America" ​​class amphibious assault ship based on usage requirements.

[0159] The weighting method for evaluation indexes of ship airflow field characteristics based on improved IT2FAHP was adopted, and the weighting node of carrier-based aircraft take-off and landing safety was taken as an example to verify its feasibility and effectiveness.

[0160] The three experts used the 9-level language scale of “EMI-VE-VSMI-SV-SMI-MS-MMI-EM-EI” as shown in Table 2 to compare and judge the relative importance of the evaluation indicators and give the initial individual As shown below:

[0161]

[0162]

[0163]

[0164] Calculate the corresponding consistency index GCI (A k ) As shown in Table 5, it can be seen from the table that experts P1, P2, and P3 all failed to pass the consistency verification. Therefore, the tolerance coefficient ρ=0.1 is set, and the individual judgment matrix geometric consistency improvement algorithm is called to perform the individual PCM A 1 , A 2 , A 3 Make corrections to obtain the corrected individual judgment matrix A 1 '、A 2 '、A 3 ' and the corresponding consistency index GCI (A 1'), GCI(A 2 '), GCI(A 3 '), see Table 5. The results show that by slightly modifying the expert judgment, experts P1, P2, and P3 all passed the individual consistency verification.

[0165] Table 5 Individual weighting results of weighted node 2

[0166]

[0167] The following gives the individual PCM A before and after the expert P1's opinion is revised 1 and A 1 ', where the italic matrix elements have been modified by the algorithm. It can be seen that by setting a smaller tolerance coefficient ρ, the modified preference value Limit to original preference value The smaller neighborhood , thereby retaining as much original expert preference information as possible, which is more conducive to the expert's recognition of the weighting results. Under this condition, the proposed individual judgment matrix geometric consistency improvement algorithm can iteratively provide key information support for experts to correct preference information, including the judgments that need to be corrected first. Direction to be corrected rs and the recommended correction value a' rs =a rs t rs , thus realizing the automatic correction of expert judgment. Compared with the traditional method, it not only avoids the blindness of expert self-correction, reduces the mental burden of experts, improves the operability of the weighting process, but also reduces the secondary error that may be caused by it, and further ensures the rationality of the weighting result.

[0168]

[0169] Then calculate a ij k ' / a ij k and feeds this ratio back to the individual FPCM A k Then, the modified individual k FPCMA' is obtained. Then, the WGA operator is used to integrate the individual Get the group Because each individual All have passed the consistency verification, so the group It must have an acceptable level of consistency. Therefore, the RGM method is used to calculate the fuzzy weights and defuzzified weights of the indicators, see Table 6.

[0170] Table 6 Weighting results of carrier-based aircraft take-off and landing safety indicators

[0171]

[0172] Figure 8 The global weights of the ship airflow field evaluation indicators are given. For ease of analysis, the evaluation indicators are rearranged in descending order according to the indicator weights. Figure 8 It can be seen that the D3 vertical speed index has the largest weight, with a single index weight of 32.5%, and its impact on the safety of carrier-based aircraft take-off and landing is as high as 39.9%; followed by the maximum temperature at the D8 superstructure position, with a single index weight of 20.2%, and its impact on the operating temperature adaptability of typical shipborne equipment is as high as 82.3%; the sum of the global weights of these two indicators even exceeds 50%, so subsequent designers need to focus on these two indicators when carrying out scheme design.

[0173] The numerical simulation method of the ship airflow field based on CFD is used to establish the numerical calculation strategy of the airflow field of the "America" ​​class amphibious assault ship. The CATIA software is used to carry out three-dimensional modeling of the "America" ​​class amphibious assault ship, and the closedness of the model is ensured, such as Figure 4 As shown. Import the CATIA 3D model into the STAR-CCM+ software, and ensure that the triangular faces of the model are not repeated or intersected. Use real-scale calculation, comprehensively consider the calculation accuracy and the number of grids, set the main scale of the calculation domain to 7L×10D×6H, and ensure that the calculation blockage rate is less than 3%. According to the calculation conditions and model size, the "America" ​​class amphibious assault ship is divided into real-scale grids, and the grids of the model surface and key parts are appropriately encrypted, such as Figure 5 As shown. The k-ε model is used as the turbulence model, and the control equation is solved by coupling based on pressure. The convection term is discretized by the second-order upwind format, the dissipation term is discretized by the second-order central difference format, and the gas model is the Peng-Robinson model, thus defining the calculation model. According to the number of grids Different grid schemes are generated in an incremental manner. After comprehensive analysis of data convergence and computational efficiency, the optimal number of grids is confirmed to be 30 million, thereby preliminarily establishing the numerical calculation strategy for the airflow field of the "USA" class amphibious assault ship, as shown in Table 7. The preliminarily established numerical calculation strategy for the airflow field of the "USA" class amphibious assault ship is further adopted to perform numerical calculations on the airflow field of the "USA" class amphibious assault ship. Combined with the PIV experimental data of a large 1:48 scale model, the accuracy of the preliminarily established numerical calculation strategy for the airflow field of the ship is verified, as shown in Table 7. Figure 6 By comparing the cloud chart, we can see that the CFD calculation results are consistent with the PIV experimental results, with little deviation. It can be considered that the initially established numerical calculation strategy for the airflow field of the "America" ​​class amphibious assault ship can provide reliable flow field data for the comprehensive evaluation of the airflow field characteristics of the "America" ​​class amphibious assault ship.

[0174] Table 7 Numerical calculation strategy of ship airflow field

[0175]

[0176] On this basis, the established numerical simulation method of the airflow field of the "America" ​​class amphibious assault ship is used to perform numerical simulation of the airflow field scheme of the "America" ​​class amphibious assault ship according to different working conditions. In the working condition setting, a working condition is set every 5m / s at a wind speed of 0-25m / s and every 30° at a wind direction of 360°, for a total of 61 working conditions. Some CFD calculation results are shown in the figure below. Figure 7 According to the constructed ship airflow field evaluation index system for use requirements, considering the operational characteristics of the "America" ​​class amphibious assault ship, three carrier-based aircraft take-off and landing positions and three areas in front, middle and back of the superstructure are identified as focus areas (see Figure 4 The CFD calculation results at these locations are extracted and used together with the safe take-off and landing operation criteria of carrier-based aircraft and the normal operation criteria of typical ship-based equipment as the input for the performance evaluation of the ship's airflow field indicators.

[0177] The established improved IT2FTOPSIS method is used to conduct a comprehensive evaluation of the airflow field of the "America" ​​class amphibious assault ship to verify the feasibility and effectiveness of the proposed method.

[0178] The ship airflow field index performance evaluation method based on fuzzy envelope is used to quantitatively evaluate the satisfaction degree of ship airflow field characteristics with ship use requirements under actual atmospheric environment conditions.

[0179] Experts were organized to use the “VL-L-ML-M-MH-H-VH” 7-level language scale as shown in Table 4 to give a linguistic evaluation of the performance of the indicators under each combination of working conditions. The WAM operator was then used to fuse the expert opinions to obtain the linguistic evaluation of the expert group on the performance of the indicators under each combination of working conditions, and an envelope diagram was drawn based on this.

[0180] The embodiment of the present invention innovatively uses a fuzzy envelope to evaluate the overall performance of the index. By integrating the envelope diagram at all wind speeds and all wind directions, the fuzzy envelope volume of each index performance of the "America" ​​class amphibious assault ship airflow field solution is obtained as shown in the table. It can be seen from the table that the index with the largest fuzzy envelope volume under the safety of carrier-based aircraft take-off and landing is the D2 lateral speed #2 position, while the smallest index is the D1 forward speed #1 position, which is also the worst performance among all indicators; the fuzzy envelope volume under the adaptability of the working temperature of typical shipborne equipment is the D9 temperature distribution #4 position, which is also the best performance among all indicators, and the smallest index is the D8 highest temperature #6 position.

[0181] Table 8 Fuzzy envelope volume of index performance

[0182]

[0183] Figure 9-13 The envelope diagrams of three positions of D1 forward speed, D2 lateral speed, D8 maximum temperature and D9 temperature distribution are further given. The lower the gray value in the diagram, the better the index performance is, which is more beneficial to the safety of carrier-based aircraft take-off and landing and the adaptability of typical ship-based equipment to the operating temperature.

[0184] Among them, from Fig. 9 It can be seen that the #1 position basically meets the forward speed requirement for safe take-off and landing of carrier-based aircraft only within the wind speed range of 300° to 60° and less than 10m / s, but cannot meet the requirements under other wind speed and direction combinations. The #2 and #3 positions are relatively better.

[0185] from Fig.10 It can be seen that the #2 position can basically meet the lateral speed requirements for safe take-off and landing of carrier-based aircraft within the wind speed range of 10m / s and 180° to 360°, and the wind speed range of 0° and 180° near 25m / s, while the #1 and #3 positions are slightly worse, which is caused by the blocking effect of the superstructure on the starboard lateral speed of the #2 position.

[0186] from Fig.12 It can be seen that the #6 position cannot meet the maximum temperature requirements for the normal operation of typical shipborne equipment on the superstructure within the wind speed range of 0 to 25 m / s and the wind direction range of 240° to 90°. The #5 position is relatively better, while the #4 position is obviously better. This is because the #4 position is located on a small platform in front of the superstructure and is least affected by the smoke emitted by the chimney.

[0187] from Fig.13 It can be seen that, except for the temperature distribution requirements for the normal operation of typical shipborne equipment on the superstructure in the wind speed range of 10-25m / s and the wind direction range of 180°-240°, the #4 position can fully meet the requirements under other wind speed and wind direction combination conditions, while the #5 and #6 positions are relatively worse. This is also because the #4 position is located on a small platform in front of the superstructure and is least affected by the smoke emitted by the chimney, while the #5 position is located in front of the chimney. When the wind comes from the rear or side, the high-temperature airflow and soot particles discharged from the chimney will be blown directly to the special equipment, which will have an adverse effect on the shipborne equipment. The situation at the #6 position is the opposite to that at the #5 position.

[0188] Taking the obtained global index fuzzy weight and the envelope volume of index performance as input, the WAM operator is further used to calculate the weighted normalized fuzzy decision matrix The ideal solution and negative ideal solution The settings are as follows to evaluate the satisfaction of the typical ship airflow field with the ship's use requirements.

[0189] D1D2D3D4…D9

[0190]

[0191]

[0192] For each index, calculate the typical ship airflow field index performance and the positive ideal solution and negative ideal solution The distances are shown in Table 9 and Table 10 respectively. The typical ship airflow field scheme and the positive ideal solution are calculated again. The relative closeness coefficient is calculated, and finally the defuzzification is performed, and the results are shown in Table 11. As can be seen from Table 11, the comprehensive evaluation result of the airflow field characteristics of the "America" ​​class amphibious assault ship is 0.2192, which is basically consistent with the evaluation result obtained by calculating the area by drawing the traditional wind limit diagram.

[0193] Table 9 Performance of each index and positive ideal solution Distance

[0194]

[0195] Table 10 Performance of each index and negative ideal solution Distance

[0196]

[0197]

[0198] Table 11 Typical ship airflow field and positive ideal solution and negative ideal solution Distance

[0199]

[0200] Fig.14 The performance index and positive ideal solution of typical ship airflow field are given. From the figure, we can see that the performance of the D3 vertical velocity at position #1, position #2, and position #3 is similar to the ideal solution. The distance is the largest, and the performance is poor, especially at position #1 and position #2, which reaches 0.106. The performance of the D2 lateral velocity at position #1, position #2, and position #3, and the performance of the D9 temperature distribution at position #4, position #5, and position #6 are consistent with the positive ideal solution. The distance is the smallest, and the performance is better, especially the temperature distribution of D9 at position #4, which is only 0.007; in horizontal comparison, the maximum value is 15 times the minimum value (15.143). It can be seen that the performance of each indicator is unbalanced and the difference is large.

[0201] Fig.15 The performance index and negative ideal solution of typical ship airflow field are given. From the figure, we can see that the performance of the D6 flow distribution and D7 pressure distribution at positions #1, #2, and #3 is similar to that of the negative ideal solution. The distance is the smallest, and the performance is poor, close to 0 (0.0004); while the performance of #4 position D8 at the highest temperature is similar to the negative ideal solution The distance is the largest, and the performance is better, reaching 0.034; in horizontal comparison, the maximum value is 85 times the minimum value. It can be seen that the performance of each indicator is extremely unbalanced and the differences are huge.

[0202] In addition, from Fig.14 and Fig.15 It can also be seen that the performance of D3 vertical speed at position #1, position #2, and position #3 is poor, and it is necessary to improve these performances in a targeted manner. According to the fuzzy envelope volume of D3 vertical speed in the table, it is found that the performance of the index at position #3 is worse than that at position #1 and position #2. Fig.11 From the performance envelope diagram of the D3 vertical speed, it can be seen that the #3 position cannot meet the vertical speed requirements for safe take-off and landing of carrier-based aircraft in the wind direction range of 270° to 90° above a wind speed of 5 m / s, while the #1 and #2 positions perform relatively better under these conditions, allowing the wind speed for safe take-off and landing of carrier-based aircraft to reach about 10 m / s.

[0203] The embodiment of the present invention proposes a fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method for ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements, which can provide decision-making guidance and optimization basis for the design of ship airflow field schemes, and has important engineering practical significance. Specifically, it includes the following beneficial effects:

[0204] 1. The comprehensive evaluation index system of ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements is constructed, which fully reflects the various usage requirements of carrier-based aircraft and typical ship-based equipment on the ship airflow field, and effectively improves the systematic solution of the evaluation problem of ship airflow field characteristics;

[0205] 2. The established ship airflow field characteristic evaluation index weighting method based on improved IT2FAHP extends the classic AHP method to the interval type II fuzzy group decision-making situation, which can effectively deal with the ambiguity and differences of expert opinions and effectively improve the rationality of the index weighting results;

[0206] 3. The established algorithm for improving the geometric consistency of the individual judgment matrix can provide key information support such as the judgments that need to be corrected first, the directions that need to be corrected, and the recommended correction values ​​for experts to correct their preference information, while retaining the original expert preference information as much as possible. This can realize the automatic correction of individual expert judgments, avoid the blindness of experts' independent corrections, reduce the mental burden of experts, and reduce the secondary errors that may be caused by this, thus ensuring the rationality of the weighting results and the operability of the weighting process;

[0207] 4. The established comprehensive evaluation method of ship airflow field characteristics based on improved IT2FTOPSIS extends the classic TOPSIS method to the interval type-II fuzzy group decision-making scenario, which can effectively deal with the ambiguity and differences of expert opinions and effectively improve the rationality of the comprehensive evaluation results;

[0208] 5. The established ship airflow field index performance evaluation method based on fuzzy envelope can scientifically evaluate the satisfaction of ship airflow field characteristics with ship use requirements under actual atmospheric environment combination conditions, and provides new ideas and methods for solving ship airflow field evaluation problems.

Claims

1. A fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method for ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: Obtain expert information of relevant experts for evaluating ship airflow field schemes, and preset expert weights based on the expert information; Systematically analyze the impact of the airflow field characteristics of the ship to be tested on the safe take-off and landing of carrier-based aircraft and the normal operation of typical ship-borne equipment, establish various usage requirements for the airflow field of the ship to be tested proposed by the ship to be tested and its typical ship-borne equipment, and construct a comprehensive evaluation index system for the airflow field characteristics of the ship to be tested facing various usage requirements; A 9-level language scale is used to compare and judge the relative importance of various indicators in the comprehensive evaluation index system of the ship's airflow field characteristics to be tested, and multiple individual fuzzy pairwise comparison matrices are constructed. Defuzzification is performed on multiple individual fuzzy pairwise comparison matrices to construct corresponding multiple defuzzified individual pairwise comparison matrices; The row geometric mean method is used to calculate the index weights of multiple defuzzified individual pairwise comparison matrices, and multiple geometric consistency indices corresponding to multiple defuzzified individual pairwise comparison matrices are calculated; According to a preset geometric consistency index threshold, determining whether multiple geometric consistency indexes are less than or equal to the geometric consistency index threshold to perform consistency verification; When the geometric consistency index is greater than the geometric consistency index threshold, the consistency verification fails, and the defuzzified individual pairwise comparison matrix corresponding to the one that fails the consistency verification is used as the original individual pairwise comparison matrix and input into the individual judgment matrix geometric consistency improvement algorithm. By setting a smaller tolerance coefficient, the modified preference value is limited to a smaller neighborhood of the original preference value, and the modified individual fuzzy pairwise comparison matrix and the corresponding modified geometric consistency index are output; The weighted geometric mean operator is combined with the preset expert weights. According to the corresponding defuzzified individual pairwise comparison matrix that has passed the consistency verification, the corresponding individual fuzzy pairwise comparison matrix is ​​matched and integrated with the corrected individual fuzzy pairwise comparison matrix to construct the group fuzzy pairwise comparison matrix. Or when the geometric consistency index is less than or equal to the geometric consistency index threshold, through consistency verification, according to the corresponding multiple defuzzified individual pairwise comparison matrices that pass the consistency verification, the corresponding individual fuzzy pairwise comparison matrices are matched and integrated to obtain the group fuzzy judgment matrix; The row geometric mean method is used to calculate the final indicator fuzzy weight and defuzzification weight of the group fuzzy pairwise comparison matrix or group fuzzy judgment matrix; The final ship airflow field numerical simulation method is adopted to numerically simulate the airflow field scheme of the ship to be tested under different atmospheric environment combination conditions, and the ship airflow field data under the corresponding conditions are obtained; The 7-level language scale is used to quantitatively evaluate the satisfaction of ship use requirements based on the characteristics of ship airflow field under actual atmospheric environment combination conditions, and multiple individual fuzzy decision matrices are constructed. Combined with the preset expert weights, the weighted arithmetic average operator is used to integrate multiple individual fuzzy decision matrices to construct a group fuzzy decision matrix. Under the combined working conditions of wind speed and direction in the actual atmospheric environment, the performance indicators of each combined working condition are integrated, and the fuzzy envelope of each performance indicator of the ship's airflow field is calculated. The fuzzy envelope is used to describe the satisfaction degree of the ship's airflow field characteristics under the combined working conditions of the actual atmospheric environment for the ship's use requirements; The weighted normalized group fuzzy decision matrix is ​​calculated according to the final indicator fuzzy weight and fuzzy envelope, and the defuzzified weighted normalized group decision matrix is ​​constructed by defuzzification. The distances between the quantitative evaluation of each performance index of the ship airflow field scheme and the determined fuzzy positive ideal solution and fuzzy negative ideal solution are calculated respectively; The relative closeness coefficients of the quantitative evaluation of the performance of each index of the ship airflow field scheme and the fuzzy positive ideal solution are calculated respectively, and the relative closeness coefficients of the solution are obtained by defuzzification. The ship airflow field schemes are evaluated and sorted in descending order according to the relative closeness coefficient of the solutions to obtain the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation results of the ship airflow field characteristics.

2. The fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method for ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements as claimed in claim 1 is characterized in that: The comprehensive evaluation index system of the airflow field characteristics of the ship to be tested includes: the take-off and landing safety of the ship to be tested and the working temperature adaptability of the typical shipborne equipment of the ship to be tested, wherein the take-off and landing safety of the ship to be tested includes the forward speed, lateral speed, vertical speed, vertical speed standard deviation, turbulent kinetic energy distribution, streamline distribution and pressure distribution, and the working temperature adaptability of the typical shipborne equipment of the ship to be tested includes the maximum temperature and temperature distribution.

3. The fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method for ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements as claimed in claim 1 is characterized in that: The output of the individual judgment matrix geometric consistency improvement algorithm also includes recommended priority review judgments, recommended priority adjustment directions and recommended correction values.

4. The fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method for ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements as claimed in claim 1 is characterized in that: The establishment of the final ship airflow field numerical simulation method includes the following steps: Obtaining a three-dimensional model of the ship to be tested and performing a quality check on the model; The blocking rate is calculated according to the blocking rate formula, and the calculation domain is divided under the premise that the blocking rate is less than 3%; Divide the computational grid according to the computational conditions and model size, and encrypt the grids on the model surface and key areas according to the Reynolds number of the flow field and the areas of focus; Select the turbulence model and the incompressible air physics model, and set the boundary conditions according to the working conditions to define the model; Different grid schemes are obtained by adjusting the grid size, grid convergence is verified by trial calculation, and the initial numerical calculation strategy of the ship airflow field is established; The initial numerical calculation strategy of the ship airflow field is adopted to calculate the similar ship airflow field schemes with existing test data. The calculation results are compared with the test results to verify the accuracy of the initial numerical calculation strategy of the ship airflow field and establish the final numerical simulation method of the ship airflow field.

5. The fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method of ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements as claimed in claim 4 is characterized in that: The turbulence model adopts the k-ε model, adopts the pressure-based coupling solution to control equations, discretizes the convection term using the second-order upwind format, and discretizes the dissipation term using the second-order central difference format.

6. The fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method for ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements as claimed in claim 4 is characterized in that: The calculation formula of the geometric consistency index is: In the formula, is the individual in the original individual pairwise comparison matrix, and is the original indicator weight corresponding to the individual.

7. The fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method for ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements as claimed in claim 1 is characterized in that: The calculation formula of the group fuzzy decision matrix is: In the formula, To preset expert weights, Indicates expert P k The expert solution F i About indicator D j At wind speed V p Wind direction q Evaluation value under combined working conditions.

8. The fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method for ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements as claimed in claim 1 is characterized in that: The calculation formula of the fuzzy positive ideal solution is: In the formula, B is the benefit indicator set, C is the cost indicator set, is the weighted normalized group fuzzy decision matrix, v ij Normalize the group decision matrix for defuzzification weights.

9. The fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method for ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements as claimed in claim 8, characterized in that: The calculation formula of the fuzzy negative ideal solution is:

10. The fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method of ship airflow field characteristics oriented to usage requirements as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: The calculation formula of the relative closeness coefficient is: In the formula, is the distance between the expert solution and the fuzzy positive ideal solution, is the distance between the expert solution and the fuzzy negative ideal solution.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Ship equipment maintenance support capability assessment method and system

    CN110119904A

  • Unmanned aerial vehicle low-altitude monitoring method

    CN118504925A