Method for plant operation of optimized components
By modifying the tariff variable value in the factory operation optimization component, meeting the target standards, the limitations of existing components in tariff optimization are solved, and additional optimization dimensions and cost reduction of factory operations are achieved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410607687.9
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-05-26
- Filing Date
- 2024-05-16
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-26
AI Technical Summary
The existing factory operation optimization components are functionally limited and cannot be expanded without hindering the main functions, especially in terms of cost optimization, resulting in the inability to provide additional optimization dimensions.
By receiving current tariffs and technical factory configurations, identifying the optimal operating setpoint and operating cost, and modifying the variable values of candidate tariffs until the target criteria are met, providing new tariff selections and operating setpoints, extending the functionality of the component to support Decision support and optimization.
Without changing the core functionality, the functionality of the factory operation optimization component is expanded, providing additional optimization dimensions, allowing new tariffs to be selected to optimize operational setpoints and reduce operational costs.
Smart Images

Figure CN119024735A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to a computer implemented method, system, computer program product and computer readable medium for a plant operations optimization component. Background Art
[0002] The operation of a plant (particularly its components) is often subject to optimization of plant operation. Special components for such optimization can be used. For example, such components perform optimization to obtain an operating set point at which the plant component is ideally operated under given conditions. For example, such optimization can be for overall cost reduction.
[0003] However, since the optimization component is dedicated to determining setpoints for plant operation, the optimization component is limited in its functionality. It is therefore an object of the present invention to provide a method for a plant operation optimization component that allows the functionality to be expanded without hampering the main functionality. Summary of the invention
[0004] This object is achieved by the present invention. The present invention provides a method, a system, a computer program product and a computer readable medium according to the independent claims. Preferred embodiments are given in the dependent claims.
[0005] The present invention provides a computer implemented method for a plant operations optimization component.
[0006] The method includes determining an optimal operating set point and a corresponding operating cost associated with the current tariff based on the current tariff and the technical plant configuration.
[0007] The method also includes receiving a candidate rate that is different than the current rate.
[0008] The method also includes modifying the candidate tariff to obtain a modified candidate tariff by changing a value of a variable among a plurality of variables characterizing the candidate tariff, and determining an optimal operating set point and a corresponding operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff based on the modified candidate tariff and the technical plant configuration.
[0009] The method also includes determining whether an operating cost associated with the modified candidate rate meets a target criterion.
[0010] The method also includes, in response to determining that the target criteria are not met, repeating the modification of the candidate tariff until the target criteria are met.
[0011] The method also includes providing an output enabling selection of a new current tariff and determination of a corresponding operating set point in response to determining that the target criteria are met.
[0012] The modified candidate tariff for which the target criteria are met is the final modified candidate tariff.
[0013] The output includes at least one of: a final modified candidate tariff, a value of a variable associated with the final modified candidate tariff, one or more tariff selection criteria determined based on the final modified candidate tariff and / or the value of the variable associated with the final modified candidate tariff.
[0014] The target criteria are:
[0015] the operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff is equal to the operating cost associated with the current tariff, or
[0016] the operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff is within a predetermined range relative to the operating cost associated with the current tariff, the range including the cost associated with the current tariff and values less than the cost associated with the current tariff, or the range only includes values less than the cost associated with the current tariff, or
[0017] The operating cost associated with the modified candidate rate is lower than the operating cost associated with the current rate by a predetermined amount.
[0018] In other words, the present invention provides a method that allows the use of components that are specifically used to determine the operating set points of a plant and its constituent components. These components take into account the configuration mode of the plant. For example, the technical configuration of the plant may involve the loads of the plant and their characteristics. For example, each load can be characterized by an operating characteristic, such as a set point range, efficiency at different set points, etc. In addition, the operation of each load can depend on the overall plant operating requirements. For example, according to the overall plant operating requirements, the load may not need to be operated all the time or can be operated at different set points that may be associated with different operating efficiencies. The overall plant operating requirements can be time-related, for example, based on time-related requirements to be met by operating the plant. In addition, some plants may have energy storage, which can have a certain flexibility in consuming external energy (e.g., from the power grid). The use of energy storage is also associated with a certain cost.
[0019] The plant operation optimization component is typically configured to take as input the technical characteristics similar to those described above and, optionally within certain boundary conditions, perform an optimization to obtain an operating set point that produces the minimum operating cost. To obtain the cost, the plant operation optimization component also receives as input a value characterizing the current tariff, as this allows the optimization to also consider the tariff in the cost optimization.
[0020] For otherwise constant demand, technical characteristics and boundary conditions, the tariff type may produce completely different set-point optimization results. For example, in some cases it may depend on the tariff whether energy is consumed from the grid or from energy storage at a given time, where energy prices are time-dependent, or where the tariff involves price increases for peaks in power consumption. This also means that the impact of a changing tariff on overall costs may not be immediately apparent, as even a slightly changing tariff may completely change the optimization results.
[0021] The above-mentioned plant operation optimization components have often been deployed and customized for a given plant. In addition, they are highly specialized for the above-mentioned purposes.
[0022] However, currently these highly specialized components do not help at all with tariff optimization or selection, which essentially also deprives the optimization of additional aspects. That is, currently, the components are configured so that energy tariffs can only be used as input for optimization of operation, which will then output an operating set point.
[0023] The present invention allows the functionality of existing plant operation optimization components to be extended by providing the claimed method. The plant operation optimization itself does not need to be disturbed so that existing plant operation optimization components can be extended, rather than having to replace or modify their core functionality, which avoids degradation of functionality and / or high costs associated with replacing them or modifying core functionality. In addition, the disclosed method is compatible with any existing plant optimization components, so any existing plant optimization components can be retrofitted with extended functionality.
[0024] An extended functionality provided by the invention is decision support for deciding whether to select a new tariff, which, as explained above, is generally not straightforward given the interdependencies of tariff parameters and optimization. In addition, an optimized operating set point can then be provided for operation at the new selected tariff.
[0025] This opens up an additional optimization dimension for the operation of the plant and expands the technical functionality of existing components.
[0026] Hereinafter, the features of the present invention will be explained in more detail.
[0027] As mentioned above, the method of the present disclosure is a method for a plant operation optimization component. In other words, the method will be performed by a plant operation optimization component (e.g., as explained above, in particular an existing plant operation optimization component). The method of the present disclosure allows providing additional functionality to such components without having to replace them or modify their core functionality.
[0028] For example, a plant operations optimization component may include an optimization engine that takes as input technical plant characteristics and pricing (such as the cost of grid energy, peak power, or energy retrieved from energy storage).
[0029] As mentioned above, the method includes determining an optimal operating set point and a corresponding operating cost associated with the current tariff based on the current tariff and the technical plant configuration.
[0030] According to the present disclosure, a tariff may be characterized by several parameters, such as energy price, peak electricity price, base price, etc. A tariff may be one of a plurality of categories, such as a variable energy price tariff, such as market dependent and / or time dependent, or a fixed energy price tariff. The tariff parameters may also include parameters representing prices associated with emissions associated with plant operations and / or associated with gas, heat, water, etc. consumed and / or output by plant operations.
[0031] According to the present disclosure, the current rate may be the rate at which the plant is currently operating.
[0032] According to the present disclosure, a technical plant configuration may include plant components, such as the plant's loads, energy storage, energy sources, etc., and their characteristics, such as their respective energy consumption at a given set point, output at a given set point, and / or operating efficiency at a given set point. When taking into account current tariffs, operating costs may be derived from these characteristics. That is, with certain set points and current tariffs as input, operating costs may be determined.
[0033] In the present disclosure, the optimal operating set point may be a set point obtained by optimizing operating costs. The corresponding operating costs associated with the current tariff (i.e., corresponding to the optimal operating set point) are those operating costs calculated taking the optimized operating costs and the current tariff (e.g., the rated value) as input.
[0034] Thus, it can be understood that the operating costs are closely related to the technical configuration of the plant, not just to the tariff. Thus, for example, the same tariff may produce completely different costs depending on the plant configuration and / or operation.
[0035] As mentioned above, the method also includes receiving a candidate rate that is different from the current rate.
[0036] Different tariffs may involve that they differ in the value of at least one variable characterizing the tariff. Different tariffs may involve that the tariffs are in different categories, e.g. different types of tariffs, e.g. a fixed energy price tariff as opposed to a variable energy price tariff. Such a scenario may mean that in one case the variable "energy price" has a fixed value. In the case of a variable energy price tariff, the variable "energy price" may be a function of time, which for simplicity will also be referred to hereinafter as having a different value than the fixed energy price, even if the function may have the value of the fixed energy price at a certain moment in time.
[0037] The candidate tariff may be obtained in any manner, which serves as a starting point for an optional iterative method to arrive at a final modified candidate tariff that meets certain criteria. As such, it need not meet any particular requirements. However, for example, where the modified candidate tariff is a fixed energy price tariff and the current tariff is a variable energy price tariff, a value of the fixed energy price derived from the variable energy price may be selected, such as determining a mean energy price based on the historical development of the variable energy price. This may improve the efficiency of arriving at the final modified candidate tariff.
[0038] As mentioned above, the method also includes modifying the candidate tariff to obtain a modified candidate tariff by changing the value of a variable among a plurality of variables characterizing the candidate tariff, and determining an optimal operating set point and a corresponding operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff based on the modified candidate tariff and the technical plant configuration.
[0039] As an example, only one value can be changed. For example, a fixed energy price value can be increased or decreased. The variables to be changed can be automatically selected, for example in a given order or according to any other given rule, or the variables to be changed can be selected based on user input, for example. The direction of change of the value can be automatically determined. For example, the direction change can be determined by determining whether the associated operating cost is higher or lower than the operating cost of the current tariff for a candidate tariff and using the optimal operating set point determined for the candidate tariff. For example, if the operating cost associated with the candidate tariff is lower than the operating cost of the current tariff, the value of the energy price may increase. The direction can also be predetermined or randomly selected. As will be seen below, due to the possibility of iteration, even modifying the candidate tariff in an unfavorable direction will eventually lead to the desired result, even if it may be after more iterations.
[0040] Specifically, modifying the candidate tariff may include changing the value of only one of the variables. As will be seen below, other variables may also be changed subsequently, and the method may be similarly applied to the other variables, optionally while keeping the previously determined (multiple) values for (multiple) other variables fixed. Therefore, the values for the variables may be obtained sequentially, which reduces the complexity of the calculation and may be particularly easily incorporated into the existing optimization components. Alternatively, the values of more than two variables may be changed simultaneously. For example, this allows a trade-off to be made immediately between their values.
[0041] The above steps allow observing changes in the overall cost when changing the values characterizing the candidate tariffs.
[0042] As mentioned above, the method also includes determining whether the operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff meets the target criteria.
[0043] For example, using the optimal set point obtained for the modified candidate tariff and the value characterizing the tariff as input, the operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff may be obtained. Determining whether the target criterion is met may allow determining whether the modified candidate tariff requires further modification. As will be explained in detail below, such a criterion may be that the operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff has a predetermined relationship with the operating cost of the current tariff, such as being equal to or substantially equal to the operating cost associated with the current tariff, or yielding a predetermined saving relative to the current tariff.
[0044] As mentioned above, the method also includes, in response to determining that the target criteria are not met, repeating the modification of the candidate tariff until the target criteria are met.
[0045] For example, when it is determined that the operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff is not equal to the current operating cost or does not provide a predetermined saving, the candidate tariff may be modified again in a manner similar to that described above. Optionally, the method may include determining whether the previous modification was directed toward or away from the target standard, i.e., whether the modified candidate tariff produces better results than the candidate tariff in terms of meeting the target standard. If it is determined that the modified candidate tariff produces better results, the direction of the repeated modification may be the same as the direction of the previous modification, otherwise, the direction of the repeated modification may be opposite to the direction of the previous modification.
[0046] Thus, iteratively, the modified candidate tariff may be further modified until the target criteria are met.
[0047] As mentioned above, the modified candidate tariff for which the target criteria are met is referred to as the final modified candidate tariff. It should be understood that, in the case where the above method is subsequently performed for multiple variables, the final modified candidate tariff may be the candidate tariff obtained after repeating the above steps for all the multiple variables.
[0048] As mentioned above, the method also includes, in response to determining that the target criteria are met, providing an output that allows selection of a new current tariff and determination of a corresponding operating set point.
[0049] The output allowing selection of a new current tariff may involve the output including one or more tariff selection criteria. The output may be provided in a manner allowing automatic selection of a new current tariff, for example in the form of a rule or threshold used in an automatic determination method, and / or as a user output, for example in the form of a visualization of a rule or threshold on a display to allow user selection.
[0050] The output may also comprise only the final modified tariff and / or one or more values of a variable characterizing the final modified tariff, for example, the value(s) may indicate a break-even point.
[0051] The output allows determining a corresponding operating set point, i.e. an operating set point corresponding to the new current tariff. That is, the output can be configured to allow being input into a plant operation optimization component and being used to determine an optimal operating set point. This allows operating the plant at said optimal operating set point after selecting a given tariff as the new current tariff.
[0052] Selecting a new current tariff may involve determining, for a given tariff, whether one or more tariff selection criteria are met, and if so, confirming the selection and otherwise declining to select the given tariff as the new current tariff.
[0053] As mentioned above, the output comprises at least one of the following: a final modified candidate tariff, values of variables associated with the final modified candidate tariff, one or more tariff selection criteria determined based on the final modified candidate tariff and / or values of variables associated with the final modified candidate tariff.
[0054] It should be understood that, in the case of performing the above steps for multiple variables, the output may include the values of all the multiple variables associated with the final modified candidate tariff and / or the tariff selection criteria associated therewith. The tariff selection criteria may include thresholds and / or selection rules, such as selection rules associated with thresholds. For example, the selection rule may involve confirming the selection of a given tariff only if the threshold is exceeded.
[0055] As mentioned above, the target criterion for determining whether to repeat the modification of the candidate tariff may be that the operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff is equal to the operating cost associated with the current tariff. This means that the method will reach a final modified candidate tariff, which, for the modified (multiple) variables, represents a value at which the cost is the same as the cost of the current tariff (i.e., reaches the break-even point). In this case, the above output may produce a threshold value, which marks from which value of the variable the cost can be reduced.
[0056] For example, this may be particularly advantageous for switching between a fixed energy price tariff and a variable energy price tariff, since the straightforward assumption that the costs would be the same in the case where the mean energy price of the variable energy price tariff is equal to the fixed energy price will generally be incorrect due to the underlying optimization based on the technical plant configuration.
[0057] Alternatively, the target criterion for determining whether to repeat the modification of the candidate tariff may be that the operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff is within a predetermined range relative to the operating cost associated with the current tariff, the range including the cost associated with the current tariff and a value less than the cost associated with the current tariff, or the range only includes values less than the cost associated with the current tariff.
[0058] That is, the target criteria may be that the new cost is approximately the same as the current cost, the approximation being defined by the size of a predetermined range, or that a predetermined savings is approximately produced relative to the current cost, the approximation being defined by the size of a predetermined range.
[0059] Alternatively, the target criterion for determining whether to repeat the modification of the candidate tariff may be that the operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff is lower than the operating cost associated with the current tariff by a predetermined amount. That is, the target criterion may be that a predetermined target cost reduction is met. In this case, the output may generate a threshold value that marks the value of the variable from which at least a predetermined cost reduction is achieved.
[0060] Thus, the present disclosure provides a method to significantly increase the functionality of existing plant operation optimization components, thereby ideally utilizing their core functionality of providing optimal operating set points.
[0061] Optionally, the method may include the step of determining whether the candidate tariff meets the target criteria before modification, and if this is the case, determining that the candidate tariff is the final modified candidate tariff, otherwise continuing to modify the candidate tariff. That is, in the case where the selected candidate tariff already meets the target criteria, for example by chance, modification may not be required. In this case, the method may optionally include automatically or by user prompting setting different (e.g. more ambitious) target criteria and / or modifying the candidate tariff so as to meet other optimization goals, for example to optimize towards a specific cost associated with one of the variables.
[0062] According to the present disclosure, the method may further include determining an optimal operating set point and a corresponding operating cost associated with the candidate tariff based on the candidate tariff and the technical plant configuration. If it is determined that the operating cost associated with the candidate tariff is lower than the operating cost associated with the current tariff by a predetermined amount, the method may only directly continue with the modification of the candidate tariff, otherwise the method only continues with the modification of the candidate tariff after user confirmation and / or continues with the modification of another different candidate tariff and / or the method terminates.
[0063] That is, rules can be established to act as indicators of whether the costs associated with a candidate tariff have a high risk of increasing the overall costs, regardless of the modifications. For example, for the technical configuration of an existing plant, there may be situations where a candidate tariff may be completely unsuitable. An extreme example may be a plant that inevitably has large consumption peaks and does not have its own energy storage. A tariff with a high penalty for consumption peaks may not be suitable for such a plant configuration, regardless of whether the values of other variables are modified.
[0064] The above steps allow handling such a situation. For example, the method may terminate to avoid getting stuck in a loop. Continuing the method by modifying the candidate tariff may require user confirmation, which will allow the user to evaluate whether to risk the method getting stuck. The method may also continue by selecting another different candidate tariff to perform subsequent modifications on it. In the example above, this may be a candidate tariff that does not penalize consumption peaks.
[0065] In particular, in case the method does not comprise the above steps, it may be advantageous to have a termination criterion for interrupting the method when caught in a loop of modifying candidate tariffs and / or a warning criterion for triggering output of a warning to the user when the method is caught in a loop of modifying candidate tariffs.
[0066] According to the present disclosure, the method may further include: performing the modification on exactly one variable of the plurality of variables while keeping the values of the remaining variables of the plurality of variables fixed.
[0067] As briefly mentioned above, this can reduce computational complexity. In addition, in some cases, the selection criteria for the candidate tariff may only be related to one of the variables, in which case it is sufficient to keep the remaining variables fixed. As also mentioned above, these steps can be performed subsequently for different variables individually while keeping the other variables fixed.
[0068] According to the present disclosure, the method may further include: performing modification on two or more variables among the plurality of variables while keeping the values of the remaining variables among the plurality of variables fixed, wherein the same target standard or different target standards are used for the two or more variables among the plurality of variables.
[0069] Such an approach may allow for trade-offs between more than two variables in the method. It may be more computationally complex, but may explore a larger space of potential values for more than two variables than, for example, performing subsequent individual modifications.
[0070] According to the present disclosure, one or more of the tariff selection criteria may include a threshold value corresponding to or determined based on a value of a variable associated with the final modified candidate tariff.
[0071] As explained above, the final modified candidate tariff may generate values for one or more variables associated therewith. The values, in particular the values of one or more variables that were changed when modifying the candidate tariff, may be used as (multiple) thresholds or derived therefrom (multiple) thresholds to be used as selection criteria. For example, the selection of a given tariff may depend on whether such a threshold is exceeded.
[0072] According to the present disclosure, the above-mentioned (multiple) thresholds may represent the break-even value of the variable associated with the final modified candidate tariff. That is, the value of the variable (such as price) of the final modified candidate tariff may represent a threshold from which the tariff may generate a lower cost than the current tariff.
[0073] According to the present disclosure, the variables characterizing the tariff may include at least one of the following: a uniform energy price, a peak energy price, a peak electricity price, and an average energy price.
[0074] A flat energy price may refer to an energy price that is not variable, e.g., not time-dependent and / or not market-dependent. A peak energy price may refer to a price associated with a peak in energy consumption, such as when energy consumption exceeds a certain threshold. Similarly, a peak power price may refer to a price associated with a peak in power consumption, such as when power consumption exceeds a certain threshold. A mean energy price may be a statistical mean calculated over a given time period for time-varying energy prices. This may be a suitable starting point when comparing fixed energy price tariffs to variable energy price tariffs.
[0075] According to the present disclosure, a technical plant configuration may include plant component characteristics of plant components, such as loads like EV charging stations, (flexible) loads or sector coupling elements like electric heaters, electrolyzer modules, combined heat and power, etc., and optionally at least one of the following: the presence of energy storage, characteristics of the energy storage, load characteristics of the loads and optionally the presence of hydrogen storage or characteristics of the hydrogen storage.
[0076] Characteristics of components may include set point related efficiency, set point related energy consumption, set point related component wear, availability of energy in energy storage, availability of remaining storage capacity of energy storage, efficiency associated with energy storage, etc.
[0077] According to the present disclosure, determination of the optimal operating set point may be performed with respect to: time series data for a selected time interval, and / or a selected demand curve, in particular a selected demand curve for a selected time interval, and / or historical data, in particular historical data for a selected time interval, and / or forecast data.
[0078] For example, using operational data, the time series data may include, for example, the corresponding inputs and outputs of plant components and their energy consumption throughout a selected time interval. The time series data may be historical data. The optimization may also be run on the basis of a selected demand curve, for example, one may expect a demand curve for the plant, which may be used as an alternative to or in addition to the time series data. Alternatively or additionally, forecast data may be used, for example based on a model modeling the plant operation, for determining the optimal operating set point. The data and tariff data, such as energy and power pricing, may be used using known optimization methods in order to optimize the operating set point in terms of cost.
[0079] According to the present disclosure, the determination of the optimal operating set point may be performed for the current tariff, the modified candidate tariff, and optionally for the modified candidate tariff for the same conditions and the same time interval. That is, the method may rely on keeping other parameters fixed that may affect the optimization, such as the technical configuration of the plant, the time interval over which the optimization is performed, or (other) boundary conditions for the optimization. This allows reliable comparisons between different tariffs and provides meaningful selection criteria.
[0080] According to the present disclosure, the current tariff and the candidate tariff may be different tariff types and / or the candidate tariff and the modified candidate tariff may be the same tariff type, wherein the tariff type may be a fixed energy price or a variable energy price, in particular an energy price that varies over time and / or a market-dependent variable energy price.
[0081] As explained above, different tariff times, such as fixed energy price or variable energy price tariffs, may lead to completely different optimization results, i.e. completely different optimal operating set points. Therefore, the present method has a very important role in the case where the current tariff and the candidate tariff belong to different tariff types, because it is not easy to identify how the operating costs between the two are different. In addition, for the modification of the present disclosure, it may be advantageous not to modify the tariff type itself, i.e. to have candidate tariffs and modified candidate tariffs of the same tariff type. In particular, in the case of iteratively finding the final modified candidate tariff, this will allow faster convergence.
[0082] The method may involve repeating the entire method for candidate tariffs of different tariff types, while keeping the candidate tariff type the same within the modification step. This allows providing selection criteria for different tariff types independently for each type in an efficient manner.
[0083] According to the present disclosure, the current tariff may be a variable energy price type tariff, and the candidate tariff may be a fixed energy price type tariff having a fixed energy price corresponding to a mean energy price of the current tariff.
[0084] As briefly mentioned above, the starting point for the values of the variables of the candidate tariff can in principle be freely chosen. For a current tariff of the variable energy price type and a candidate tariff of the fixed energy price type, if the energy price is the variable to be modified when modifying the candidate tariff, the mean energy price of the current tariff can represent a valid starting point, thereby potentially reducing the number of iterations.
[0085] According to the present disclosure, modification of a candidate rate may include performing an optimization problem to find a value of a variable among a plurality of variables characterizing the candidate rate for which an operating cost associated with the modified candidate rate satisfies a target criterion while minimizing a cost associated with another variable among the plurality of variables characterizing the candidate rate.
[0086] For example, the variable and the further variable may be a fixed energy price and a peak electricity price.
[0087] As an example, it may be desirable to minimize the cost associated with peak power. For example, the cost associated with one variable may be minimized where several value pairs of the variable and another variable may result in meeting a target criterion. For different reasons, it may be desirable to allocate costs among different variables in some manner. For example, it may be desirable to reduce the cost associated with peak power.
[0088] The method of the present disclosure may include receiving a proposed new tariff, determining whether the proposed new tariff meets selection criteria, and if so, approving selection of the proposed new tariff as the current tariff, otherwise not approving selection of the proposed new tariff.
[0089] This may be performed fully automatically. For example, as explained above, the selection criterion may involve whether a threshold derived from the final modified tariff is exceeded. One or more selection criteria may be used.
[0090] The present invention also provides a system including a plant operation optimization component, wherein the system includes a data processing system configured to perform any method of the present disclosure. The plant operation optimization component can be performed by the data processing system, in particular in a centralized manner or in a distributed manner. The system may include a plant component such as a load, which has characteristics that contribute to the configuration of the technical plant. For example, the system may include an electrolyzer module as a load and may optionally include a hydrogen storage system.
[0091] It should be noted that in the present disclosure, the plant operation optimization component can be implemented on one device or multiple devices, such as in a distributed system. That is, the term "component" in this context should not be understood as limited to a physical unit.
[0092] The system may include an energy storage system, such as a BESS (Battery Electric Storage System).
[0093] The present invention also provides a computer program product comprising instructions, which, when executed by a computer, cause the computer to perform any method of the present disclosure.
[0094] The present invention also provides a computer-readable medium comprising instructions, which when executed by a computer causes the computer to perform any method of the present disclosure.
[0095] The features and advantages outlined above in the context of the method similarly apply to the system, computer program product, and computer-readable medium described herein.
[0096] Additional features, examples and advantages will become apparent from the detailed description with reference to the accompanying drawings. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0097] In the accompanying drawings,
[0098] Figure 1 illustrates a schematic representation of a system according to the present disclosure;
[0099] Figure 2 is a flow chart illustrating a method according to the present disclosure;
[0100] Figure 3 is a flow chart illustrating a method according to the present disclosure;
[0101] Figures 4 to 6 It is a schematic illustration of power demand, energy price, charging state and energy intake for different scenarios;
[0102] Figure 7 is a flowchart illustrating another method according to the present disclosure DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0103] Figure 1 A system 1 including a plant operation optimization component is illustrated, the system having a data processing system 2 (also referred to as a computing system) configured to perform the method of the present disclosure, as described below in detail in Figures 2 to 7 In particular, the data processing system 2 may be configured to run / execute the plant operation optimization component, for example in a centralized or distributed manner.
[0104] like Figure 1 As shown in the example shown in , the system may optionally include plant components 4 , such as loads to be supplied with energy, and optionally energy storage 5 . Figure 1 An output component 6 is shown in FIG. 1 , which is configured to provide an output allowing selection of a new current tariff and for determining a corresponding operating set point. The output may be formed separate from the data processing system or integrated with the data processing system.
[0105] Note that, at least for some components and some operating modes, the operation of the components will be interdependent and / or dependent upon the use or non-use of energy from the energy storage.
[0106] Reference numeral 3 illustrates a power grid from which power is received. In this example, the power grid is not part of the system.
[0107] Figure 2 A method for optimizing a component of a plant operation according to the present disclosure is illustrated in FIG.
[0108] Known plant operation optimization components may be used, which are typically configured for determining plant operation parameters such as set points based on an optimization procedure that, for example, aims to achieve minimum operating costs given a certain energy tariff. Such plant operation optimization components take into account the technical plant configuration, which may involve the number of components of the plant, their respective characteristics, interdependencies in their operation, etc. In order to take into account the complexity of the plant, especially the complexity of the plant due to interdependencies, very specialized optimization components are usually used. It is worth noting that the optimization will produce significantly different set points depending on the specifics of the energy tariff, such as whether the energy price is fixed or varies over time, and / or whether and how much high peak power consumption is penalized.
[0109] The method comprises, in step S11, determining the optimal operating set point and the corresponding operating cost associated with the current tariff based on the current tariff and the technical plant configuration. As explained above, the technical plant configuration may include, in particular, the number and characteristics of plant components and their interdependencies. The current tariff may include an energy price that may be fixed or variable, and in the case of a variable energy price, may have a predetermined or unpredictable variability. The current tariff may also include a peak electricity price. Based on this information, the optimization component determines the optimal operating set point. The corresponding operating cost associated with the tariff can be retrieved based on simulated or historical operation, based on the determined operating set point and the current tariff. For example, the model can model the plant operation depending on the operating set point, and the resulting operating cost for a given tariff can be determined. The result of step S11 can be considered as a reference operating cost value.
[0110] The method comprises, in step S12, receiving a candidate tariff that is different from the current tariff. For example, the candidate tariff may have a uniform energy price instead of an energy price that varies over time. In principle, the values of the parameters of the candidate tariff may be freely picked. This is because the candidate tariff is only a guess at a starting point for performing a modification step on the candidate tariff. In one embodiment, all values except one remain the same. In the example of switching from a variable energy price to a fixed energy price, only the value of the energy price may be changed from a variable value to a fixed value. This fixed value may be freely chosen. A potential starting point for the fixed value is the mean energy price calculated for the variable energy price.
[0111] The method comprises, in step S13, modifying the candidate tariff so as to obtain a modified candidate tariff by changing the value of a variable among a plurality of variables characterizing the candidate tariff.
[0112] In particular, the value of one or more free parameters, in a preferred embodiment only one free parameter, may be changed. For example, the above-mentioned uniform energy price value used as a starting point in the candidate tariff of step S12 may now be modified. The modification may be selected in different ways. In some cases, the modification may be more direct than in other cases.
[0113] The method comprises, in step S14, determining the optimal operating set points and corresponding operating costs associated with the modified candidate tariff based on the modified candidate tariff and the technical plant configuration. This step may be similar to the above determination step, in particular based on performing an optimization. In more straightforward cases, for example, where the modification merely changes the overall cost structure, it may not be necessary to perform a new optimization, but the optimal operating set points and costs from the unmodified candidate tariff may be used directly to derive the operating costs associated with the modified candidate tariff.
[0114] The method comprises, in step S15, determining whether the operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff meets a target criterion.
[0115] According to the present disclosure, the target criterion may be that the operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff is equal to the operating cost associated with the current tariff. That is, the goal is to keep the overall cost the same when changing the tariff. When setting this target criterion, a break-even value may be determined, indicating that a potential new tariff above or below this value is better or worse than the current tariff in terms of overall cost.
[0116] Alternatively, the target criterion may be that the operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff is within a predetermined range relative to the operating cost associated with the current tariff, the range including the cost associated with the current tariff and a value less than the cost associated with the current tariff or only including a range of values less than the cost associated with the current tariff. That is, it may not be necessary to precisely reach the overall cost of the current tariff or any other target value of the overall cost. There may also be an acceptable cost range. The range may be around and include the current overall cost, or it may include the current overall cost and a lower cost, or may be completely below the current overall cost.
[0117] Still alternatively, the target criterion may be that the operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff is lower than the operating cost associated with the current tariff by a predetermined amount. That is, rather than finding a break-even point relative to the current overall cost, a lower value of the overall cost may be used and the break-even point may be determined with respect to the lower value. This also allows seeking to save costs, rather than just keeping costs the same.
[0118] As mentioned above, in some cases, the modification of the candidate tariff may be more direct than in other cases. Therefore, in some cases, the modification may have been performed in a way that ensures that the target criteria will be met. That is, the modification may directly lead to the target criteria. However, in less direct cases, it may not be possible to identify in advance which modifications may lead to meeting the target criteria. This is also due to the nature of the operation optimizer, which may not inherently support such features. Therefore, in the less direct case, the modification may not necessarily lead to meeting the target criteria.
[0119] Steps S14 and S15 evaluate the modification effect of the modification of the candidate tariff by identifying the cost of the modified candidate tariff and by checking whether the target criteria are met.
[0120] For example, the determination may check whether the overall operating cost of the modified candidate tariff is equal to the operating cost identified for the current tariff in step S1 1. Thus, it may be determined whether modifying the candidate tariff results in a break-even value for the modified variable.
[0121] The method includes, in response to determining that the target criterion is not met, repeating the modification of the candidate tariff until the target criterion is met, as indicated by an arrow in the flow chart, which indicates that the method returns to step S13.
[0122] That is, iterations of modifying candidate tariffs may be performed as long as the target criterion is not met. Optionally, abort criteria may be used to terminate the method, for example to resolve situations where iterations do not lead to convergent results, for example, where the target criterion is not met after a predetermined number of iterations or after a predetermined time.
[0123] The method comprises, in step S16, providing an output allowing selection of a new current tariff and determining a corresponding operating set point in response to determining that the target criteria are met. Optionally, steps S13 to S15 may be repeated, each repetition being for a single variable, optionally while keeping unchanged the value obtained from the previous repetition(s). Thus, different variables may be checked individually.
[0124] Step S16 may involve outputting the value of the variable that has been modified when modifying a candidate tariff for which the target criteria are met, such as a break-even value for the variable, wherein the overall cost of the modified tariff is equal to the overall cost of the modified candidate tariff.
[0125] According to the present disclosure, the modified candidate tariff for which the target criteria are met is the final modified candidate tariff. The output may include the final modified candidate tariff, i.e., the values of all variables characterizing the tariff, or only one or some of the values of the variables associated with the final modified candidate tariff, in particular, only the values of the variables that have been changed during the modification process, i.e., free variables. The output may alternatively or additionally include one or more tariff selection criteria determined based on the final modified candidate tariff and / or the values of the variables associated with the final modified candidate tariff. That is, instead of directly outputting the final modified candidate tariff and / or the values of the variables associated with the final modified candidate tariff, the tariff selection criteria may be derived therefrom, and the selection criteria may be output.
[0126] The method may also include the optional step of receiving the proposed new tariff in step S17 and determining in step S18 whether the proposed new tariff meets the selection criteria. The method may include, in step S19, approving the selection of the proposed new tariff as the current tariff (if this is the case), otherwise not approving the selection of the proposed new tariff in step S20. In other words, the output of step S16 can be used to evaluate whether any proposed new tariff should be selected. Since the target criteria (such as maintaining costs or reducing costs) have been reflected in the output due to steps S14 to S16, decision making is direct and does not require running any simulation for the proposed new tariff. Instead, only the selection criteria need to be checked. In the simplest case, for example, the value of a variable that has been modified when modifying a candidate tariff that meets the target criteria, such as a break-even value for a variable. The selection criteria may be to approve the selection of the new tariff if the value of the same variable or corresponding variable of the new tariff is equal to or exceeds or remains below the value obtained in the modification procedure.
[0127] From this, it should be appreciated that complex problems can be solved by existing techniques (ie, operational optimization) resulting in simple selection criteria.
[0128] The method of the present disclosure can be used in Figure 1 The method steps are performed in the system shown in , for example, by the processing system 2 or any other suitable system, in particular a system according to the present disclosure.
[0129] Examples of methods according to the present disclosure
[0130] In the following examples, further aspects of the method of the present disclosure will be outlined. These are only examples, and the present invention is not limited to these examples.
[0131] Figure 3The method according to the present disclosure is shown in . It comprises three steps, which are explained with the aid of a specific example, which, however, should not be considered restrictive. The numerical values are of an exemplary character only and the monetary values are given in an arbitrary currency [CUR].
[0132] The data used in the method are current tariff data, such as energy costs, peaks, connections and / or time series data, and also site information data, such as available assets including generation, loads and storage, flexibility options and time series data, for example, about demand and generation, etc. This data can be used to run operating cost minimization for a certain time period in step 1, so as to produce the minimum total energy cost for a given time period with the current (also referred to as the "old") tariff. As shown in step 2, similar operating cost minimization is run for candidate tariffs (referred to as the "new" tariff here). For example, in a way that the total cost for the new tariff matches the total cost of the old tariff, the results of steps 1 and 2 are used to determine the value of the free tariff parameter. The result can be output, for example, as a break-even value. Step 3 can receive input about which parameter will be used as the free tariff parameter.
[0133] Figures 4 to 6 Two input curves (power demand and energy price) and two optimization curves (energy uptake and state of charge) are shown separately, each for a different scenario.
[0134] Specifically, in Figure 4 In , current tariffs with spot market energy prices are taken into account. The energy uptake and state of charge results are the results of the total cost optimization as described below or obtained, for example, by step S11 above.
[0135] Figure 6 The scenario after switching from the spot market to a flat energy price (i.e. after executing step 2 below) is shown. It is obvious that the curves produced by the optimization are completely different, which also reflects that the optimization produces different set points for different energy tariffs. For example, the optimization here no longer needs to take into account the variability of energy prices and can now more freely reach set points that reduce power peaks, as can be clearly seen from the flat line of energy intake.
[0136] Figure 5 A scenario of the break-even point is shown, i.e. the situation where the total cost matches the cost of the current tariff, i.e. after step 3 below.
[0137] Therefore, the following steps can be performed. The step numbers refer to Figure 3 and Figure 7 .
[0138] Step 1: Get actual / original costs and example timeframe for current tariffs:
[0139] This example site is powered (only) by the grid to meet Figure 4 Given a demand curve shown in , the time interval is 41 time steps in this example. Furthermore, the site also comprises an energy storage (eg BESS) which can have an energy content (SoC = State of Charge) between 0% and 100%.
[0140] For illustration purposes only, assume the following (existing) power tariffs:
[0141] Energy cost: in CUR / MWh el Spot market curve in units (exemplary average is 67.7 CUR / MWh).
[0142] Power cost: 500CUR / kW multiplied by P max , which is the highest grid supply power value [kW] measured during the selected time period.
[0143] Basic cost: None
[0144] Step 1 now uses plant operation optimization to determine the best operating strategy, including grid supply and use of energy storage, to minimize overall power costs. Figure 4 , and produces the following exemplary figures:
[0145] Current tariff examples unit Spot Market Optimized E-cost CUR / MWh 59.3 E-Cost CUR 112302 Optimizing power peaks kW 64.2 Peak power cost CUR 32107 Total Cost CUR 144409
[0146] The following can be observed:
[0147] Energy: Energy uptake from the grid is low, spot market prices are high, and BESS is unloaded and refilled at low prices. Optimal utilization of energy storage (BESS) results in an average energy price of 59.3 CUR / MWh instead of 67.7 CUR / MWh.
[0148] • Power: The goal of minimizing power peaks was also considered, as reflected here, with the maximum power value being 64.2 kW.
[0149] Cost: The total cost for the time interval is 144409 CUR, which is the sum of energy cost (78%) and power cost (22%).
[0150] Step 2: Optimize hypothetical cost of the same example, but with candidate tariffs (changed from current tariffs)
[0151] For simplicity, it is assumed that the overall goal is to move to a fixed energy cost tariff, with the same power cost (500CUR / kW) in this example. All assets and parameters are also kept the same as in step 1, except for the energy cost, which is now fixed to a constant value. This constant value can be chosen arbitrarily, but in this example it is set to 59.3CUR / MWh, which is the average energy cost of the current tariff in step 1.
[0152] Using these parameters, optimization operations involving, for example, grid intake and energy storage operations can be run to find the minimum total cost. Figure 6 and as shown in the following table.
[0153]
[0154] The following can be observed:
[0155] Energy: Energy costs are constant because the uniform energy price is chosen to be the same as the average value from step 1.
[0156] Power: Since the degrees of freedom are no longer used to minimize the average cost of energy on the volatile spot market, they can be used to minimize the peak power value, thereby minimizing the power cost. The result is a reduced peak of 46.4kW (previously 64.2kW), resulting in a reduced power cost.
[0157] • Cost: The total cost for the time interval is reduced to 135496, which in this example reflects the reduction in power cost.
[0158] Step 3: Modify the candidate tariffs, especially the flexible tariff parameters, to match the original total energy cost
[0159] Since the total energy cost after step 2 is reduced, the flexible tariff parameters (here as an example of energy price) can be adjusted to match the total cost determined for the current tariff. In this example, this can be achieved by increasing the energy cost from 59.3 CUR / MWh to 64.0 CUR / MWh.
[0160] The results are as follows Figure 5 and as shown in the following table.
[0161] Modified tariff examples unit Unified price (optimized) Optimized E-cost CUR / MWh 64.0 E-Cost CUR 121214 Optimized P kW 46.4 P Cost CUR 23194 Total Cost CUR 144409
[0162] The result is an optimized operating strategy that minimizes the power peak (here 46.4) and maximizes the constant energy cost parameter (here 64.0) so as to exactly match the original total cost 144409CUR in step 1. Thus, a break-even value is obtained for the constant energy cost parameter in this example.
[0163] This allows determining that tariffs with energy cost parameters below 64.0 will result in reduced total energy costs. This can be used to make tariff selection decisions.
[0164] In the above example, the calculation in step 3 is very simple. This may not always be the case. The following provides alternatives to the calculation in step 3 (e.g. Figure 7 Indicated by the dotted line in ):
[0165] Iterate steps 2 and 3: Start the next iteration by taking a uniform energy price of 64.0 CUR / MWh and minimize the total cost again, as described in step 2. This iteration can be continued until the parameters no longer change. This approach is beneficial if the setpoint selection between step 2 and step 3 is different. This is determined by Figure 7 Indicated by the dotted circle on the right.
[0166] Joint Optimization: In some cases, steps 2 and 3 can be formulated in a closed optimization problem that finds a parameter (e.g., uniform energy price) that matches the original total cost (as opposed to minimizing the total cost) while minimizing the power peak parameter. This is done by Figure 7 are indicated by the boxes around steps 2 and 3 in the
[0167] This mechanism is described for finding a constant breakeven energy price, it can be used in the same way to determine other parameters, the most common ones are:
[0168] Energy costs: spot market, time of use, constant / flat rates
[0169] Peak cost: None, Exceeding a limit, Maximum peak value within a specific time interval (e.g., month, year)
[0170] • Basic price: fixed amount (e.g. for connection and / or metering) or flexible price depending on consumption.
[0171] The method of the present disclosure may also be applied to various other parameters, such as CO 2 content correlated with power.
[0172] As seen above, according to one aspect of the present disclosure relates to a method allowing determination of a breakeven parameter value for a new tariff compared to an existing tariff. As an alternative or in addition to breakeven, the method may be performed with the goal of achieving a given saving (eg 5% of total energy costs).
[0173] The methods of the present disclosure may involve running optimized operational calculations on time series data.
[0174] The method of the present disclosure may involve running the method on an arbitrary time interval in the past (historical data) or in the future (forecast time series).
[0175] As will be appreciated from the above, a method is provided which allows at least one parameter value of a new energy tariff to be obtained which results in a "break-even total cost" compared to the current / existing tariff. This is done by performing an operational optimization calculation on the time series data, by varying one parameter to arrive at a break-even total cost.
[0176] Facilities, parks or industrial sites are large complexes of multiple energy flows (power, natural gas, heat), with energy consumers, grid connections and potentially different energy generation options. Total energy costs can account for a large portion of annual operating costs. There are two options for reducing energy costs: one is to change consumption patterns, and the other is to change energy tariffs. However, consumption patterns and energy tariffs are closely related, and tariffs may have multiple components that affect overall costs in different ways, which are closely related to consumption patterns. Changing energy tariffs may completely change the optimized consumption pattern obtained through operational optimization. Therefore, optimizing operating costs is challenging, and the present disclosure allows solving this challenge.
[0177] As an example, as seen above, the present disclosure can calculate a tariff parameter value that results in a breakeven or cost reduction. The method can determine a set of tariff parameters that will result in the same energy cost as the current tariff or result in a target cost reduction based on historical or predicted patterns. Thus, based on only one parameter value, the breakeven value, it can be determined whether a candidate tariff is more favorable than the current tariff in terms of overall cost. This can be done, for example, using a predictive estimate, over arbitrary time intervals in the past and / or in the future.
[0178] As mentioned above, an iterative approach may be performed. An example of such an iterative approach is provided below for arriving at a breakeven value.
[0179] - The candidate tariff (new possible tariff) is a time-of-use (ToU) tariff with a certain cost (e.g. 70 € / MWh) during the day (e.g. 7:00-19:00) and a certain cost (e.g. 50 € / MWh) during the night (e.g. 19:00-7:00).
[0180] - The first step simulates the new (operation-optimized) annual costs with these values. In this example, the costs now may be 20% higher than before.
[0181] - In a second step, the candidate tariff is modified, for example, both tariff components (daytime and nighttime) are reduced by 20%, and another (operation-optimizing) simulation is run.
[0182] – In the third step, the simulation may now generate a different operating point, so that the cost is now 5% lower than before. In this example, a different operating point may be generated, for example, because energy storage may no longer be profitable, because the price difference in step 1) decreased from 70-50=20 to 56-40=16.
[0183] - In a fourth step, the candidate tariff is modified again, for example now both tariff components (daytime and nighttime) may be increased by 5%, and another (operation-optimizing) simulation is run.
[0184] -Candidate tariffs can be modified repeatedly until a break-even value is found.
[0185] Here, iteration is necessary because the modifications lead to the selection of different operating points, making the exact results after the modifications unpredictable.
[0186] Although the present invention has been illustrated and described in detail in the drawings and the foregoing description, such illustration and description should be considered as illustrative rather than restrictive. The present invention is not limited to the disclosed embodiments. In view of the foregoing description and drawings, it will be apparent to those skilled in the art that various modifications may be made within the scope of the present invention as defined by the claims.
Claims
1. A method for optimizing a plant operation component, the method include: Based on current tariffs and technical plant configurations, determining (S11) optimal operating set points and corresponding operating costs associated with said current tariffs; receiving (S12) a candidate tariff different from the current tariff; modifying (S13) the candidate tariff so as to obtain a modified candidate tariff by changing the value of a variable among a plurality of variables characterizing the candidate tariff, and determining (S14) an optimal operating set point and a corresponding operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff based on the modified candidate tariff and the technical plant configuration; determining (S15) whether the operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff meets a target criterion; In response to determining that the target criterion is not met, repeating the modification of the candidate tariff until the target criterion is met; In response to determining that the target criteria are met, providing (S16) an output allowing selection of a new current tariff and determination of a corresponding operating set point, The modified candidate tariff that meets the target standard is the final modified candidate tariff, wherein the output comprises at least one of: the final modified candidate tariff, the value of the variable associated with the final modified candidate tariff, one or more tariff selection criteria determined based on the final modified candidate tariff and / or the value of the variable associated with the final modified candidate tariff, and The target criteria are the operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff is equal to the operating cost associated with the current tariff, or the operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff is within a predetermined range relative to the operating cost associated with the current tariff, the range including the cost associated with the current tariff and values less than the cost associated with the current tariff, or the range only including values less than the cost associated with the current tariff, or The operating cost associated with the modified candidate rate is lower than the operating cost associated with the current rate by a predetermined amount.
2. The method according to claim 1, wherein the method further include: determining an optimal operating set point and a corresponding operating cost associated with the candidate tariff based on the candidate tariff and the technical plant configuration, Wherein if it is determined that the operating cost associated with the candidate tariff is lower than the operating cost associated with the current tariff by a predetermined amount, the method only directly continues to modify the candidate tariff, otherwise the method only continues to modify the candidate tariff after user confirmation, and / or continues to modify a different candidate tariff, and / or terminates.
3. The method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the method include: The modifying is performed for exactly one variable of the plurality of variables while keeping values of the remaining variables of the plurality of variables fixed.
4. The method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the method comprises performing the modification on two or more variables among the plurality of variables while keeping the values of the remaining variables among the plurality of variables fixed, wherein the same target standard or different target standards are used for the two or more variables among the plurality of variables.
5. The method according to any one of the preceding claims, the one or more tariff selection criteria comprising a threshold value corresponding to or determined based on the value of the variable associated with the final modified candidate tariff.
6. A method according to any preceding claim, wherein the threshold value represents a break-even value of the variable associated with the final modified candidate tariff.
7. The method according to any of the preceding claims, wherein the variables characterizing the tariff include at least one of the following: a fixed energy price, a peak energy price, a peak electricity price, an average energy price.
8. A method according to any of the preceding claims, wherein the technical plant configuration comprises plant component characteristics of components of the plant and / or at least one of the following: the presence of energy storage, characteristics of energy storage, load characteristics of loads and optionally the presence of hydrogen storage or characteristics of hydrogen storage.
9. A method according to any of the preceding claims, wherein the determination of the optimal operating set point is performed on: time series data for a selected time interval, and / or a selected demand curve, in particular a selected demand curve for a selected time interval, and / or historical data, in particular historical data for a selected time interval, and / or forecast data.
10. A method according to any preceding claim, wherein determination of an optimum operating set point is performed for the current tariff, the modified candidate tariff, and optionally the modified candidate tariff is performed for the same conditions and time interval.
11. A method according to any of the preceding claims, wherein the current tariff and the candidate tariff are different tariff types and / or wherein the candidate tariff and the modified candidate tariff are the same tariff type, wherein the tariff type can be a fixed energy price or a variable energy price, in particular an energy price that varies over time and / or a market-dependent variable energy price.
12. The method of claim 11, wherein the current tariff is a variable energy price type tariff and the candidate tariff is a fixed energy price type tariff having a fixed energy price corresponding to the mean energy price of the current tariff.
13. A method according to any of the preceding claims, wherein the modification of the candidate tariff may include performing an optimization problem to find a value of the variable of the plurality of variables characterizing the candidate tariff for which the operating cost associated with the modified candidate tariff satisfies the target criterion while minimizing a cost associated with another variable of the plurality of variables characterizing the candidate tariff.
14. A method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the method comprises receiving (S17) a proposed new tariff, determining (S18) whether the proposed new tariff meets the selection criteria, and if so, approving (S19) selection of the proposed new tariff as the current tariff, otherwise not approving (S20) selection of the proposed new tariff.
15. A system (1) comprising a plant operation optimization component, the system having a data processing system (2) configured to perform the method according to any one of the preceding claims.
16. A computer program product comprising instructions which, when the program is executed by a computer, cause the computer to perform the method according to any one of claims 1 to 14.
17. A computer-readable medium comprising instructions, which, when the program is executed by a computer, cause the computer to perform the method according to any one of claims 1 to 14.
