Earth and rockfill dam operation safety comprehensive evaluation system based on subjective and objective dynamic weighting-optimization cloud model
Through the comprehensive evaluation system for operation safety of earth and rock dams based on subjective and objective dynamic empowerment-optimized cloud model, the subjectivity and ambiguity of earth and rock dam safety evaluation in the existing technology is solved, and a more accurate and efficient safety status evaluation is achieved. More scientific management of reservoir dams.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410878136.6
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-06-29
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-26
Smart Images

Figure CN119026787A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention belongs to the technical field of earth-rock dam operation safety evaluation, and in particular relates to an earth-rock dam operation safety comprehensive evaluation system based on a subjective and objective dynamic weighting-optimization cloud model. Background Art
[0002] Earth-rock dam refers to a water retaining dam built by dumping, rolling and other methods with local soil, stone or mixed materials. Earth-rock dam has a long history and is the most widely used and fastest-growing dam type in the world's dam construction. At present, earth-rock dam accounts for more than 90% of all existing reservoir dams; however, most of these dams were built in the 1950s and 1970s. Due to the limitations of construction technology and design level at that time, coupled with long-term load and improper management, these dams have suffered varying degrees of damage. In addition, with the intensification of global climate change and the frequent occurrence of extreme weather, the risk of sudden disasters in reservoir dams is increasing, which will not only lead to the destruction and failure of dams, but also further cause serious loss of life and property in downstream areas. Therefore, timely and accurate evaluation of the operational safety status of earth-rock dams is of great significance for preventing and reducing the occurrence of disasters.
[0003] At present, when conducting safety evaluation of earth-rock dams, comprehensive evaluation is mainly carried out based on the "Guidelines for Safety Evaluation of Reservoir Dams" (Sl258-2017) through expert appraisal. However, this method has problems such as strong subjectivity, unclear safety boundaries, and failure to consider the randomness and ambiguity of the evaluation. These problems will lead to inaccuracy and instability in the evaluation results, and cannot fully reflect the actual operational safety status of earth-rock dams. Therefore, a more scientific, objective and accurate comprehensive evaluation method for the operation safety of earth-rock dams is urgently needed to solve the above problems. Summary of the invention
[0004] In view of the defects and problems of existing earth-rock dam safety evaluation methods, such as strong subjectivity, vague safety boundaries, and insufficient consideration of randomness and fuzziness, the present invention provides an earth-rock dam operation safety comprehensive evaluation system based on the subjective and objective dynamic weighting-optimization cloud model, which makes full use of modern scientific and technological means to realize real-time monitoring, data analysis and intelligent evaluation of the operating safety status of earth-rock dams, which can not only improve the accuracy and efficiency of the evaluation, but also reduce the evaluation cost, providing more powerful support for the safety management of reservoir dams.
[0005] The solution adopted by the present invention to solve its technical problems is: a comprehensive evaluation system for the operation safety of earth-rock dams based on a subjective and objective dynamic weighting-optimization cloud model, including an evaluation index selection module, an information collection and processing module, a weight calculation module and a comprehensive evaluation module, wherein the evaluation index weight selection module is used to construct a comprehensive evaluation hierarchical model including a target layer, a criterion layer and an indicator layer based on the engineering structure characteristics and historical disease information of the target earth-rock dam; the information collection and processing module constructs a judgment matrix on the importance of indicators according to the indicator data of the indicator layer in the comprehensive evaluation hierarchical model; at the same time, the module also collects and processes data on the quantitative monitoring indicators and qualitative indicators of the earth-rock dam, and constructs a scoring standard for each indicator for different safety status levels, and calculates the scores of the quantitative monitoring indicators and the qualitative indicators respectively;
[0006] The weight calculation module is used to calculate the subjective weight of each indicator using the judgment matrix, to form an initial data matrix with the indicator scores of each earth-rock dam using the corresponding scores of the quantitative monitoring indicators and the qualitative indicators, to calculate the objective weight of the indicator, and to calculate the subjective and objective fusion weight after fusing the subjective weight with the objective weight; the comprehensive rating module uses the cloud model to establish a comprehensive safety evaluation model for earth-rock dams, including optimizing the cloud droplet number selection problem in the model, and determining the evaluation level based on the combination of cloud similarity and cloud map, thereby realizing the evaluation of the operating safety status of the earth-rock dam.
[0007] Furthermore, the evaluation index selection module takes the operating safety status of earth-rock dams as the target layer, and six aspects including engineering quality, flood control capacity, seepage safety, structural safety, operation management, and seismic safety as the indicator layer, and uses multi-unit evaluation indicators selected according to the characteristics of the project to be evaluated as the indicator layer to jointly construct a hierarchical model for the comprehensive evaluation of operating safety of earth-rock dams.
[0008] Furthermore, the information collection and processing module divides the indicators in the indicator layer into monitoring indicators and review and inspection indicators, and invites multiple experts to give judgment opinions on the relative importance of the selected indicators, and uses the nine-point scaling method to construct a judgment matrix through pairwise comparison and scoring.
[0009] Furthermore, the weight calculation module is based on the judgment matrix A=[a ij ], the methods for calculating the subjective weight of indicators include:
[0010] Calculate the maximum eigenvalue λ of the judgment matrix A max and its corresponding eigenvector α, and perform consistency check on the matrix to calculate the matrix consistency index and consistency ratio, including the following formula:
[0011]
[0012] In the above formula, n is the number of indicators, and RI is the random consistency index;
[0013] When CR < 0.1, the judgment matrix A passes the consistency test. Otherwise, the judgment matrix needs to be reconstructed to calculate the subjective weight of the indicator.
[0014] in aij is the relative importance of the i-th indicator and the j-th indicator.
[0015] Furthermore, in the weight calculation module, the corresponding scores of the quantitative monitoring indicators and the qualitative indicators are normalized and the indicator scores of each earth-rock dam are used to form an initial data matrix X = [x ij ], where x ij is the score of the jth indicator of the i-th earth-rock dam; calculate the proportion P of the jth indicator in the i-th earth-rock dam ij and the entropy value e of the jth indicator j , the formula is as follows:
[0016]
[0017] Then calculate the objective weight w of the jth indicator j :
[0018]
[0019] Furthermore, the weight calculation module combines the subjective weight and the objective weight to obtain a subjective and objective fusion weight that includes the subjective experience of experts and takes objective reality into consideration, which is calculated as follows:
[0020]
[0021] In the formula, and are the subjective weight and objective weight of the ith indicator respectively.
[0022] Furthermore, the comprehensive rating module includes the following steps:
[0023] Step 1: Generate cloud droplets using the forward cloud generator (CG) and the reverse cloud generator (CG -1 ) Extract cloud characteristic values, including expectation Ex, entropy En and super entropy He;
[0024] Step 2: Calculate the comprehensive cloud characteristic value C(Ex,En,He) according to the following formula:
[0025] Ex=Ex i ω i (8)
[0026]
[0027]
[0028] In the formula, C i =(Ex i ,En i ,He i ) is the digital feature of the evaluation cloud of the i-th indicator; ω i is the corresponding indicator weight;
[0029] Step 3: Calculate the scale cloud eigenvalue
[0030] The golden section method is used to divide the range of evaluation results [0,1] into five security levels, and the corresponding cloud digital features are determined for each level;
[0031] Step 4: Generate cloud droplets n = 5000 using the forward cloud generator, intuitively reflect the safety status of the earth-rock dam through the cloud map, and calculate the membership of the comprehensive cloud to each safety level;
[0032] Step 5: Determine the safety level of the earth-rock dam based on the calculation results of the comprehensive cloud characteristic value and membership degree; if the evaluation cloud is mainly located in a certain safety level range and has the highest membership degree to this level, the operational safety level of the earth-rock dam can be determined.
[0033] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following beneficial effects:
[0034] The present invention provides a comprehensive evaluation system for the operation safety of earth-rock dams based on the subjective and objective dynamic weighting-optimization cloud model. First, by constructing a hierarchical model for the comprehensive evaluation of the operation safety of earth-rock dams, the indicators can be modified according to the actual engineering conditions of the earth-rock dam to be evaluated, and the system has strong applicability. Secondly, the system integrates the objective data of the indicators under the premise of considering the subjective preferences of experts, obtains the subjective and objective fusion weights of the indicators, and avoids the limitations of the single weighting method. And based on the variable weight theory, the weights are dynamically adjusted according to the measured data of the indicators to prevent the adverse effects caused by the superior indicators covering the inferior indicators, and evaluate the operation safety status of the earth-rock dam from a safer perspective. Finally, the characteristic values of the index cloud were extracted based on the cloud model, and the mutual conversion between qualitative concepts and quantitative indicators was realized based on the cloud generator. The impact of data uncertainty on the evaluation results was fully considered, and the evaluation level was determined from qualitative and quantitative perspectives based on the combination of cloud similarity and cloud map, which can more accurately and comprehensively reflect the operating safety status of the earth-rock dam. The analytical solution of cloud similarity was derived based on the probability density function of the normal distribution, and it was compared with the model solution. It was found that when the engineering error of 5% was used as the boundary, it could meet the coordination and unity of accuracy and computational efficiency, so the number of cloud droplets in the cloud model was optimized. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0035] Figure 1 This is a schematic diagram of the architecture of the comprehensive evaluation system for earth-rock dam operation safety;
[0036] Figure 2 This is a hierarchical model diagram for comprehensive evaluation of earth-rock dam operation safety;
[0037] Figure 3 It is a weight curve diagram of different indicators of the present invention;
[0038] Figure 4 This is a schematic diagram of a forward and reverse cloud generator;
[0039] Figure 5 This is the error variation diagram under different cloud droplet numbers;
[0040] Figure 6 This is a cloud diagram of comprehensive evaluation results. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0041] The present invention is further described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and embodiments.
[0042] See also Figure 1-6 The present invention provides a technical solution for a comprehensive evaluation system for the operation safety of earth-rock dams based on a subjective and objective dynamic weighting-optimization cloud model. The target project is located in Baiyun District, Guangdong Province. The present invention combines the characteristics of the earth-rock dam body itself, evaluates and analyzes a variety of monitoring indicators, establishes a comprehensive evaluation system, and improves the accuracy of the evaluation.
[0043] Embodiment 1:
[0044] The present embodiment provides an earth-rock dam operation safety comprehensive evaluation system based on the subjective and objective dynamic weighting-optimization cloud model, including an evaluation index selection module, an information collection and processing module, a weight calculation module and a comprehensive evaluation module. First, an evaluation index system is established according to the working and structural characteristics of the target earth-rock dam, and the objective data of the index are integrated to obtain the subjective and objective fusion weights of the index. Then, based on the variable weight theory, the weight is dynamically adjusted according to the measured data of the index to make the evaluation angle safer. Finally, the evaluation level is determined from qualitative and quantitative perspectives by combining cloud similarity and cloud map, so as to more accurately and comprehensively reflect the operation safety status of the earth-rock dam. Specifically, the following contents are included.
[0045] like Figure 1 and Figure 2As shown, the evaluation index selection module is mainly used to construct a hierarchical model for comprehensive evaluation of the operation safety of earth-rock dams. Specifically, it selects representative indicators from six aspects, namely, engineering quality, flood control capacity, seepage safety, structural safety, operation management, and seismic safety, based on the working characteristics and structural characteristics of the target earth-rock dam and the historical damage of the dam, in accordance with the Guidelines for Safety Evaluation of Reservoir Dams (SL258-2017), to construct a comprehensive evaluation index system for the operation safety of earth-rock dams. This module takes the operational safety status of earth-rock dams as the target layer, and the above-mentioned six aspects, namely, structural safety, flood control capacity, and engineering quality, as the criterion layer. Evaluation indicators are selected according to the characteristics of the project to be evaluated, such as construction quality, filling conditions, connection conditions, etc. Figure 2 The evaluation indicators of each unit shown in the figure are used as the indicator layer to jointly construct a hierarchical model for comprehensive evaluation of earth-rock dam operation safety.
[0046] The information collection and processing module includes the collection of judgment matrix and the collection and processing of index data information, wherein the collection of judgment matrix refers to the various indicators selected in the criterion layer of the evaluation index selection module, and each indicator is divided into monitoring indicators and review and inspection indicators according to its characteristics, and a number of experts and professors in the water conservancy industry who have in-depth research on earth-rock dam construction, design, management, scientific research and other fields are invited to give judgment opinions on the relative importance of the selected indicators, and the nine-point scale method is used to construct the judgment matrix through pairwise comparison and scoring, as shown in Table 1 below:
[0047] Table 1 Nine-point scale method discrimination table
[0048]
[0049] And because the earth-rock dam is a complex integrated system, in order to be able to more systematically and accurately reflect the safety status of the dam, the information collection and processing module also selects various quantitative monitoring indicators and qualitative indicators, and calculates the scores of indicators of different levels accordingly. For quantitative monitoring indicators, the indicator scores can be calculated according to the following Table 2:
[0050] Table 2 Quantitative monitoring indicators classification and scoring table
[0051]
[0052]
[0053] For qualitative indicators, quantitative scoring was performed based on the following Table 3 after field visits by the above-mentioned experts.
[0054] Table 3 Qualitative indicator classification and scoring table
[0055]
[0056] The weight calculation module mainly includes the subjective weight calculation of indicators based on the hierarchical analysis method, the objective weight calculation based on the entropy weight method, and the subjective and objective variable weight weights combined with the variable weight theory. Through the weight calculation of the three aspects, the limitations of the single weighting method are effectively avoided, and the weights are dynamically adjusted according to the measured data of the indicators based on the variable weight theory to prevent the adverse effects caused by the superior indicators covering the inferior indicators, and evaluate the operational safety status of the earth-rock dam from a safer perspective. Specifically:
[0057] (1) Subjective weight calculation
[0058] The importance judgment matrix A constructed based on the expert opinions collected by the above information collection and processing module is A=[a ij ], calculate the subjective weight of the indicator, where a ij is the relative importance of the i-th indicator and the j-th indicator, and
[0059] Calculate the maximum eigenvalue λ of the judgment matrix A max and its corresponding eigenvector α, and perform consistency check on the matrix to calculate the matrix consistency index and consistency ratio, including the following formula:
[0060]
[0061] In the above formula, n is the number of indicators and RI is the random consistency index.
[0062] When CR < 0.1, the judgment matrix A passes the consistency test. Otherwise, the judgment matrix needs to be reconstructed to calculate the subjective weight of the indicator.
[0063] This embodiment takes the judgment matrix A constructed by a certain expert on the criterion layer as an example to introduce the calculation process of the subjective weight, where
[0064]
[0065] According to Matlab, the maximum eigenvalue λ of the matrix is calculated max =6.245, calculate the consistency index and consistency ratio. The value of the random consistency index RI is referenced in Table 4 below:
[0066] Table 4 Random consistency index value table
[0067]
[0068] Calculated The consistency check passed.
[0069] λ max The corresponding eigenvector is normalized into the criterion layer weight
[0070] w 1 =(0.151, 0.096, 0.427, 0.255, 0.045, 0.026). Similarly, all indicator weights are calculated, and the indicator weights corresponding to the 10 experts selected in this embodiment are averaged to obtain the subjective weight of the indicator.
[0071] (2) Objective weight calculation
[0072] According to the corresponding scores of the above quantitative monitoring indicators and qualitative indicators, the indicator scores of each earth-rock dam are normalized to form the initial data matrix X = [x ij ], where x ij is the score of the jth indicator of the i-th earth-rock dam. Calculate the weight P of the jth indicator in the i-th earth-rock dam ij and the entropy value e of the jth indicator j .
[0073]
[0074] Then calculate the weight w of the jth indicator j :
[0075]
[0076] In this example, five earth-rock dams of medium-sized reservoirs were selected, and the index scores of each earth-rock dam were used to form an initial matrix X to calculate the objective weight of the index. Specifically, the weight P of the jth index in the i-th earth-rock dam is calculated according to the above formulas (3) and (4): ij and the entropy value e of the jth indicator j . Calculate the weight w of the jth indicator according to formula (5): j .
[0077] (3) Calculation of subjective and objective fusion weights and variable weights
[0078] See also Figure 3 The subjective weight, objective weight, fusion weight and variable weight curve of each indicator are shown in the figure. Due to the limitations of single subjective and objective weighting methods, in order to calculate the indicator weight more scientifically and comprehensively, the above two weights are fused to obtain a subjective and objective fusion weight that includes the subjective experience of experts and takes into account objective reality. It can be calculated according to the following formula.
[0079]
[0080] In the formula, and are the subjective weight and objective weight of the ith indicator respectively.
[0081] Furthermore, in order to make up for the insufficiency of the constant weight in the comprehensive evaluation of earth-rock dam operation safety, the variable weight theory is used to modify the constant weight. The exponential state variable weight vector has the advantages of flexible parameter setting, clear decision requirements, and strong fitting ability. The larger the status value of each evaluation index in the comprehensive evaluation of earth-rock dam operation safety, the safer the status of the earth-rock dam. In order to highlight the unfavorable factors generated in the comprehensive evaluation of disadvantageous indicators, the safety status of the earth-rock dam is evaluated from a more conservative and safer perspective, and ε=-1 is selected to construct a penalty variable weight vector ω.
[0082]
[0083] In the formula, ω i is the variable weight of the indicator, x is the indicator score, and the weight calculation result is as follows Figure 3 shown.
[0084] The comprehensive rating module uses the cloud model to establish a comprehensive safety evaluation model for earth-rock dams, including optimizing the cloud droplet number selection problem in the model and determining the evaluation level based on the combination of cloud similarity and cloud map, so as to evaluate the operational safety status of earth-rock dams. Specifically:
[0085] Since the dam is a complex nonlinear system with obvious uncertainty in both time and space domains under the coupling of factors, the uncertainty of dam monitoring information directly determines the uncertainty of the dam's safety status. The fuzzy mathematics, set pair theory, and DS evidence theory commonly used in dam safety evaluation only consider randomness or models. In order to consider randomness while taking into account fuzziness and realize the mutual transformation of qualitative concepts and quantitative indicators, the comprehensive evaluation module in this embodiment uses a cloud model to establish a comprehensive safety evaluation model for earth-rock dams, and optimizes the problem of selecting cloud droplets in the cloud model, which mainly includes the following contents:
[0086] 1) If Figure 4 As shown in the figure, the forward cloud generator (CG) is used to generate cloud droplets and the reverse cloud generator (CG -1 ) extracts cloud feature values, Figure 4 Ex, En and He are the expectation, entropy and super entropy of the indicator respectively, x i The measured data of the indicator, n is the total number of data, S 2 For example, the scoring result of the construction quality of indicator C11 is (0.930, 0.870, 0.850, 0.950, 0.890, 0.850, 0.870, 0.930, 0.850, 0.880, 0.870, 0.950, 0.930, 0.920, 0.950). It can be calculated by inputting it into the reverse cloud generator to get Ex = 0.893, En = 0.044, He = 0.021.
[0087] 2) Based on the indicator cloud characteristic value and the indicator weight calculated by the above weight calculation module, the comprehensive cloud characteristic value C (Ex, En, He) is calculated according to the following formula:
[0088] Ex=Ex i ω i (8)
[0089]
[0090] In the formula, C i =(Ex i ,En i ,He i ) is the digital feature of the evaluation cloud of the i-th indicator; ω i For the corresponding indicator weights, the comprehensive cloud of this embodiment is calculated to be (0.857, 0.054, 0.016).
[0091] 3) Calculation of scale cloud eigenvalues
[0092] In this embodiment, the operation safety level of the earth-rock dam is divided into five levels according to the golden section method, that is, [0, 1] is divided into five intervals, which correspond to the five safety levels of the operation safety of the earth-rock dam, as shown in the following Table 5.
[0093] Table 5 Characteristic values of clouds at different levels
[0094]
[0095] 4) Determination of evaluation results
[0096] The cloud map can directly reflect the state of the object and reveal the ambiguity of the evaluation results. The cloud similarity can quantify the overlap between the evaluation cloud and the scale cloud, while avoiding the influence of subjective factors on the evaluation results. At the same time, in order to quantitatively determine the membership of the security level in this embodiment, the comprehensive similarity of the comprehensive cloud to each level is calculated. The membership of different evaluation levels is shown in Table 6 below:
[0097] Table 6 Reference table of membership degree of each level
[0098]
[0099] The specific calculation method is as follows:
[0100] a. Input the comprehensive cloud C (Ex, En, He) into the forward cloud generator (CG) to obtain n cloud droplets (x i ,μ i );
[0101] b. Calculate x i CVi Membership
[0102]
[0103] In the formula, En Vi ′~N(En vi ,He Vi ), Ex Vi ,En Vi ,He Vi are the expectation, entropy and super entropy of the i-th evaluation level respectively.
[0104] c. Calculate the comprehensive similarity
[0105]
[0106] Finally, the comprehensive cloud characteristic value and the five levels are input into the forward cloud generator to generate 5000 cloud droplets, which are plotted in the same coordinate system to form an evaluation cloud map. The safety level of the earth-rock dam is determined based on the comprehensive cloud characteristic value and the membership calculation results. If the evaluation cloud is mainly located in a certain safety level interval and has the highest membership to this level, the operational safety level of the earth-rock dam can be determined. Figure 6 As shown in Figure 2, the cloud map can intuitively reflect the state of the object while revealing the ambiguity of the evaluation results. The cloud similarity can quantify the overlap between the evaluation cloud and the scale cloud while avoiding the influence of subjective factors on the evaluation results. Figure 6 It can be seen that the comprehensive evaluation clouds in this embodiment are all between "basic safety" and "safety", and are more inclined to "safety". Combined with the calculation results of cloud similarity, it is found that the membership of this embodiment to "safety" reaches 57.5%, which is much larger than the membership of the other four levels. Therefore, it can be judged that the operation safety level of this embodiment is "safety".
[0107] 5) Determination of the optimal number of cloud droplets
[0108] Considering that too few cloud droplets may lead to incorrect evaluation results and too many cloud droplets will affect the calculation efficiency, the value of the cloud droplet number is optimized in consideration of the coordination between calculation efficiency and evaluation accuracy. 2 ) and Envi~N(Env,Hev 2 The probability density functions of ) are:
[0109]
[0110] Since x~N(Ex,Eni 2 ), then the cumulative distribution function of x is
[0111]
[0112] According to formula (12), the expected membership can be obtained:
[0113]
[0114] in According to the 3σ criterion of normal distribution, the above formula can be simplified as:
[0115]
[0116] E μ The error Δ of each cloud droplet number is calculated as the theoretical solution (i.e., the comprehensive similarity when the cloud droplet number is infinite). Δ is calculated according to formula (18). After 100 random experiments, the error variation of each cloud droplet number is shown in the figure below: Figure 5 shown.
[0117]
[0118] This example takes the evaluation cloud of (0.8, 0.2, 0.02) as an example. According to the basic principle of the forward cloud generator, MATLAB is used to generate 500, 1,000, 2,000, 5,000, 10,000, 20,000 and 100,000 cloud droplets. 100 sets of experiments are repeated for each number of cloud droplets, and the corresponding membership degree δ is calculated as the model solution. The theoretical solution E is calculated according to (13)-(17). μ , calculate the error Δ according to formula (18), the result is as follows Figure 5 As shown. Figure 5 It can be seen that in 100 random experiments, as the number of cloud droplets increases, Δ gradually tends to be stable, and the corresponding variance decreases from 38.2 to 0.17. When the number of cloud droplets is 2000, 6 experiments exceed the 5% error. When the number of cloud droplets is 5000, 100 experiments meet the engineering accuracy requirement of 95%. The error does not change much when the number of cloud droplets continues to increase. In order to ensure the calculation accuracy and efficiency, the number of cloud droplets n is taken as 5000.
[0119] The comprehensive evaluation system for the operation safety of earth-rock dams based on the subjective and objective dynamic weighting-optimization cloud model provided by the present invention combines the dam body characteristics of the earth-rock dam and a variety of monitoring indicators to provide a comprehensive safety status assessment; through subjective and objective dynamic weighting, the system integrates the subjective experience and objective data of experts, and improves the accuracy and reliability of the evaluation; the variable weight theory is used to dynamically adjust the weights, which can reflect the changes in the indicator status values and prevent the superior indicators from covering up the influence of the inferior indicators.
[0120] The present invention uses cloud models to process data uncertainty, realizes the mutual conversion between qualitative concepts and quantitative indicators, and more accurately evaluates the safety status of the dam; by optimizing the selection of cloud droplet numbers, the system not only ensures evaluation accuracy, but also takes into account computational efficiency. Through the quantitative evaluation of cloud similarity, the influence of subjective factors on the evaluation results is reduced; the application of the system helps to improve the scientificity and systematicness of dam safety management, helps to prevent and reduce the occurrence of dam safety accidents, and provides quantitative and visual evaluation results for dam managers and decision makers, supporting more reasonable management and decision-making, thereby significantly improving the quality and efficiency of earth-rock dam operation safety management.
[0121] The above description is only a preferred embodiment of the present invention and does not limit the present invention. Any modifications, equivalent substitutions and improvements made within the spirit and principle of the present invention should be included in the protection scope of the present invention.
Claims
1. A comprehensive evaluation system for earth-rock dam operation safety based on subjective and objective dynamic weighting-optimization cloud model, characterized by: It includes an evaluation index selection module, an information collection and processing module, a weight calculation module and a comprehensive evaluation module. The evaluation index weight selection module is used to construct a comprehensive evaluation hierarchical model including a target layer, a criterion layer and an indicator layer based on the engineering structure characteristics and historical disease information of the target earth-rock dam; the information collection and processing module constructs a judgment matrix on the importance of indicators according to the indicator data of the indicator layer in the comprehensive evaluation hierarchical model; at the same time, the module also collects and processes data on the quantitative monitoring indicators and qualitative indicators of the earth-rock dam, and constructs a scoring standard for each indicator for different safety status levels, and calculates the scores of the quantitative monitoring indicators and qualitative indicators respectively; the weight calculation module is used to calculate the subjective weight of each indicator using the judgment matrix, use the corresponding scores of the quantitative monitoring indicators and qualitative indicators to form an initial data matrix with the indicator scores of each earth-rock dam, calculate the objective weight of the indicator, and calculate the subjective and objective fusion weight after fusing the subjective weight with the objective weight, and then calculate the variable weight based on the monitoring data calculation combined with the variable weight theory; The comprehensive rating module uses a cloud model to establish a comprehensive safety evaluation model for earth-rock dams, including optimizing the cloud droplet number selection problem in the model and determining the evaluation level based on a combination of cloud similarity and cloud maps, thereby achieving an evaluation of the operating safety status of the earth-rock dam.
2. The comprehensive evaluation system for earth-rock dam operation safety based on subjective and objective dynamic weighting-optimization cloud model according to claim 1 is characterized by: The evaluation index selection module takes the operating safety status of earth-rock dams as the target layer, and six aspects including engineering quality, flood control capacity, seepage safety, structural safety, operation management, and seismic safety as the indicator layer. It also takes multi-unit evaluation indicators selected according to the characteristics of the project to be evaluated as the indicator layer to jointly construct a hierarchical model for the comprehensive evaluation of operating safety of earth-rock dams.
3. The comprehensive evaluation system for earth-rock dam operation safety based on subjective and objective dynamic weighting-optimization cloud model according to claim 1 is characterized by: The information collection and processing module divides the indicators in the indicator layer into monitoring indicators and review and inspection indicators, and invites multiple experts to give judgment opinions on the relative importance of the selected indicators, and uses the nine-point scale method to construct a judgment matrix through pairwise comparison and scoring.
4. The comprehensive evaluation system for earth-rock dam operation safety based on subjective and objective dynamic weighting-optimization cloud model according to claim 1 is characterized by: The weight calculation module is based on the judgment matrix A=[a ij ], the methods for calculating the subjective weight of indicators include: Calculate the maximum eigenvalue λ of the judgment matrix A max and its corresponding eigenvector α, and perform consistency check on the matrix to calculate the matrix consistency index and consistency ratio, including the following formula: In the above formula, n is the number of indicators, and RI is the random consistency index; When CR < 0.1, the judgment matrix A passes the consistency test. Otherwise, the judgment matrix needs to be reconstructed to calculate the subjective weight of the indicator. where a ij is the relative importance of the i-th indicator and the j-th indicator.
5. The comprehensive evaluation system for earth-rock dam operation safety based on subjective and objective dynamic weighting-optimization cloud model according to claim 1 is characterized by: In the weight calculation module, the corresponding scores of the quantitative monitoring indicators and the qualitative indicators are normalized and the indicator scores of each earth-rock dam are used to form an initial data matrix X = [x ij ], where x ij is the score of the jth indicator of the i-th earth-rock dam; Calculate the weight P of the jth index in the i-th earth-rock dam ij and the entropy value e of the jth indicator j , the formula is as follows: Then calculate the subjective weight w of the jth indicator j :
6. The comprehensive evaluation system for earth-rock dam operation safety based on subjective and objective dynamic weighting-optimization cloud model according to claim 1 is characterized by: The weight calculation module combines the subjective weight and the objective weight to obtain a subjective and objective fusion weight that includes the subjective experience of experts and takes objective reality into consideration, which is calculated as follows: In the formula, and are the subjective weight and objective weight of the i-th indicator respectively.
7. The comprehensive evaluation system for earth-rock dam operation safety based on subjective and objective dynamic weighting-optimization cloud model according to claim 1 is characterized by: The comprehensive rating module includes the following steps: Step 1: Generate cloud droplets using the forward cloud generator (CG) and the reverse cloud generator (CG -1 ) Extract cloud characteristic values, including expectation Ex, entropy En and super entropy He; Step 2: Calculate the comprehensive cloud characteristic value C(Ex,En,He) according to the following formula: Ex=Ex i ω i (8) In the formula, C i =(Ex i ,En i ,He i ) is the digital feature of the evaluation cloud of the i-th indicator; ω i is the corresponding indicator weight; Step 3: Calculate the scale cloud eigenvalue The golden section method is used to divide the range of evaluation results [0,1] into five security levels, and the corresponding cloud digital features are determined for each level; Step 4: Generate cloud droplets n = 5000 using the forward cloud generator, intuitively reflect the safety status of the earth-rock dam through the cloud map, and calculate the membership of the comprehensive cloud to each safety level; Step 5: Determine the safety level of the earth-rock dam based on the calculation results of the comprehensive cloud characteristic value and membership degree; if the evaluation cloud is mainly located in a certain safety level range and has the highest membership degree to this level, the operational safety level of the earth-rock dam can be determined.
Citation Information
Cited By
Low-carbon city subjective and objective mixed planning interval entropy weighting evaluation method
CN120106402A
Earth and rockfill dam intelligent monitoring risk early warning system
CN120430623A
Power generation dispatching method and device based on comprehensive capability evaluation of power generation enterprises
CN120875312A
Evaluation method for safe operation state of dam structure
CN122594948A
