Method for evaluating stability of release amount of smoke components in aerosol generating product

By measuring and calculating the relative average moving extreme difference, factor extreme difference mode and coefficient of variation of flue gas component release, the subjective problem of flue gas stability evaluation in the prior art is solved, and the flue gas of aerosol-generated products is realized The scientific and quantitative evaluation of the amount of ingredients released has improved the stability optimization ability of product development.

CN119064525APending Publication Date: 2024-12-03SHANGHAI TOBACCO GROUP CO LTD +1
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202310652477.7
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-06-02
Publication Date
2024-12-03

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The prior art lacks scientific and objective methods to evaluate the stability of the flue gas component release in aerosol-generated products, which mainly relies on sensory evaluation and have subjective errors, so it is impossible to accurately compare the port-by-mouth stability between different products.

Method used

A method is proposed to capture the flue gas generated by the aerosol-generated product, determine the flue gas component content parameters released by the port by port, calculate the relative average moving extreme difference (MR) and factor extreme difference mode (FMN) and so on. Indicators, the stability of the flue gas component release amount was evaluated, and quantitative evaluation was conducted based on the coefficient of variation (CV) and relative deviation (RD).

Benefits of technology

A scientific and objective evaluation of the stability of flue gas components of aerosol-generated products is achieved, which can accurately compare the stability of different products, and provides a quantitative evaluation method to help product development optimize stability.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN119064525A_ABST
    Figure CN119064525A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The stability evaluation method for the release amount of the smoke components in the aerosol generating product comprises the following steps: capturing smoke generated by puff-by-puff suction, and measuring component content parameters of the smoke released puff-by-puff; and calculating a stability index based on the measured component content parameters of the smoke released puff-by-puff. The stability index in the invention refers to a relative average movement range MR, a factor average movement range FMR or a factor range mode FMN. According to the invention, a standardized test process for the puff-by-puff release amount of the aerosol generating product and the product smoke is established, and the puff-by-puff release amount difference, the overall consistency of the release curve and the puff-by-puff release consistency are comprehensively considered through a mathematical statistical method. A puff-by-puff stability quantitative evaluation scheme suitable for release curves with different characteristics is provided, a breakthrough from qualitative evaluation to quantitative evaluation of the smoke stability of the aerosol generating product is realized, and an objective, scientific and effective evaluation means is provided for the smoke stability of the aerosol generating product.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention belongs to the field of aerosol generating products, and in particular relates to a method for evaluating the stability of smoke component release in an aerosol generating product. Background Art

[0002] With the global tobacco control situation and the demand for safe alternatives to tobacco, new tobacco products are developing at an accelerated pace. By 2021, the total retail sales of new tobacco products worldwide exceeded US$65 billion, and the retail sales of heated cigarettes in aerosol-generating products reached US$28.8 billion, accounting for a proportion of the total retail sales of new tobacco products that has increased for five consecutive years, from 5.7% in 2016 to 39%. Heated cigarettes have become the most potential risk-modified tobacco product.

[0003] In aerosol-generating products, there are large differences in the amount of smoke atomized and the physiological satisfaction of each puff. In the smoke release curve, this is reflected in the different releases from one puff to another of the same product, the large differences in the puff releases between different products, and the different overall trends of the release curves. Therefore, how to evaluate the stability of the smoke release of an aerosol-generating product, and to quantitatively compare the puff-by-puff stability of different products, has become the key to the quality evaluation of aerosol-generating products.

[0004] At present, there is no method for evaluating the puff-by-puff stability of aerosol-generating products in the industry, and it mainly focuses on the evaluation of the release of chemical components puff by puff and sensory evaluation. There are differences in the capture and testing methods of the puff-by-puff release of components in different studies, and there is no standardized smoke capture and testing process; in addition, the evaluation of puff-by-puff stability by sensory evaluation is highly subjective and only reflects the overall consistency of the smoke. For example, patent CN110907591A proposes a method for evaluating the sensory quality of heated cigarettes. First, the sensory quality evaluation index: the score of smoke volume, aroma, fragrance, strength, harmony, irritation and taste is obtained, and then the smoke stability evaluation index: the score of smoke volume, smoke temperature and aroma volume is given, and then the weights of the sensory quality score and smoke stability score are further determined according to the score of the smoke stability index. Finally, the comprehensive score of the sensory quality evaluation of heated cigarettes is finally obtained through weighted calculation. This evaluation method uses the subjective perception evaluation, which is subject to large subjective errors and cannot make accurate quantitative evaluation and comparison of stability. Summary of the invention

[0005] In view of the above problems, the present invention provides a method for evaluating the stability of smoke component release in an aerosol generating product, which can scientifically and objectively evaluate the smoke release stability.

[0006] In the process of puffing aerosol-generating products, it is necessary to pay attention to the difference in component release between two adjacent puffs. If the difference in release between puffs is too large, it will seriously affect the consistency of the sensory quality of the product. Based on this technical problem, the present invention provides a first method for evaluating the stability of smoke component release in aerosol-generating products, including:

[0007] Capturing the smoke generated by the aerosol-generating product when it is puffed, and measuring the content parameters of the smoke components released puff by puff;

[0008] Based on the measured smoke component content parameters released puff by puff, the relative average moving range MR is calculated according to the following formula (1);

[0009] The puff-by-puff release consistency of the aerosol generating product is evaluated based on the obtained relative mean moving range MR, and further the stability of the smoke component release amount in the aerosol generating product is evaluated;

[0010]

[0011] In formula (1), is the average amount of the components released after taking n puffs of the aerosol-generating product, where n is the total number of puffs, and x i is the amount of components released in the i-th puff of smoke from the aerosol generating product, x i+1 It is the amount of components released in the i+1th puff of smoke of the aerosol generating product.

[0012] Through the above technical solution, the relative mean moving range MR takes into account the impact of different puff release amounts and is also well applicable to samples with large differences in release amounts. The smaller the MR, the smaller the difference in puff release amounts, and the higher the consistency of the product's sensory quality.

[0013] Aerosol-generating products are affected by the design parameters of cigarettes and smoking utensils. Different raw materials, heating methods, temperature curves, etc. make the component release curves differ significantly and the trends are different. The evaluation of smoke release stability needs to consider the overall consistency of the puffing process and the relative consistency between two adjacent puffs under the constraint of the puff-by-puff atomization amount, so as to obtain the sensory stability of puff-by-puff. Based on this purpose, the present invention provides a second method for evaluating the stability of smoke component release in aerosol-generating products, including:

[0014] Capturing the smoke generated by the aerosol-generating product when it is puffed, and measuring the content parameters of the smoke components released puff by puff;

[0015] Based on the measured smoke component content parameters released puff by puff, the factor extreme mode FMN is calculated according to the following formula (2);

[0016] evaluating the composite consistency of the aerosol generating product based on the obtained FMN, and further evaluating the stability of the smoke component release in the aerosol generating product;

[0017]

[0018] In formula (2), is the average amount of the components released after taking n puffs of the aerosol-generating product, where n is the total number of puffs, and x i is the amount of components released in the i-th puff of smoke from the aerosol generating product, x i+1 It is the amount of components released in the i+1th puff of smoke of the aerosol generating product.

[0019] Through the above technical solution, FMN's algorithm takes into account the two dimensions of "overall consistency" and "puff-by-puff release consistency", and conducts a comprehensive evaluation of the puff-by-puff release amount of smoke components, the overall consistency of the puff-by-puff release curve, and the consistency of changes between puffs. It is suitable for the evaluation of component release curves of most different types of heated cigarette products, and all factors that affect stability are specifically quantified.

[0020] The present invention is further configured that the stability evaluation method further includes determining the influence of the overall release fluctuation and the puff-by-puff release fluctuation on the composite consistency:

[0021] The coefficient of variation (CV) used to evaluate the overall release consistency is defined as:

[0022]

[0023] The relative average moving range MR used to evaluate the consistency of each mouthful of release is defined as:

[0024]

[0025] obtaining a first ratio of CV / FMN, and / or obtaining a second ratio of MR / FMN;

[0026] The influence of the overall release fluctuation and the puff-by-puff release fluctuation on the composite consistency is determined based on the first ratio and / or the second ratio.

[0027] Through the above technical solution, only CV / FMN and / or MR / FMN need to be calculated to determine the influence of the overall release fluctuation and the mouthful release fluctuation on the composite consistency. The comparison method is simple, intuitive and clear in meaning.

[0028] The present invention is further configured to determine the coordinates (x, y) of a point R using one of the CV value and the MR value calculated by the aerosol generating article as a horizontal coordinate x and the other as a vertical coordinate y;

[0029] The angle α between the connecting line of point R and the origin and the horizontal coordinate or the vertical coordinate is determined, and the influence of the overall release fluctuation and / or the puff-by-puff release fluctuation on the composite consistency is determined according to the size of the angle α.

[0030] Through the above technical solution, CV and MR that affect the composite consistency are introduced into a two-dimensional coordinate system, and the influencing parameters of the composite consistency are split and projected into a vector diagram, which is very intuitive and easy to analyze and compare.

[0031] The present invention is further configured such that the CV value is the horizontal coordinate x of point R, the MR value is the vertical coordinate y, and the angle α between the connecting line and the horizontal coordinate is such that when cosα is closer to 1, it is judged that the fluctuation of the release of smoke components in the aerosol generating product is obviously affected by the amount represented by the horizontal coordinate; when cosα is closer to 0, it is judged that the fluctuation of the release of smoke components in the aerosol generating product is obviously affected by the amount represented by the vertical coordinate.

[0032] The third method for evaluating the stability of smoke component release in an aerosol generating product provided by the present invention comprises:

[0033] Based on the measured smoke component content parameters released puff by puff, the factor mean moving range FMR is calculated according to the following formula (3);

[0034] The stability of the smoke component release in the aerosol generating product is evaluated based on the obtained factor mean moving range FMR;

[0035]

[0036] In formula (3), is the average amount of the components released after taking n puffs of the aerosol-generating product, where n is the total number of puffs, and x i is the amount of components released in the i-th puff of smoke from the aerosol generating product, x i+1 It is the amount of components released in the i+1th puff of smoke of the aerosol generating product.

[0037] Through the above technical solution, the FMR algorithm also takes into account the two dimensions of "overall consistency" and "puff-by-puff release consistency", and conducts a comprehensive evaluation of the puff-by-puff release amount of smoke components, the overall consistency of the puff-by-puff release curve, and the consistency of changes between puffs.

[0038] The present invention is further configured to include evaluating the degree of differentiation of stability characteristics between different aerosol generating articles:

[0039] The stability index of the two aerosol generating products was obtained, and the relative deviation RD of the stability index was calculated according to the following formula (4):

[0040]

[0041] In the above formula (4), I 1 is the stability index of the aerosol generating product 1, I 2 is a stability index of the aerosol generating product 2, wherein the stability index is selected from one or more of the standard deviation SD, the coefficient of variation CV, the mean of the mouthful difference R, the relative mean moving range MR, the factor mean moving range FMR, and the factor range modulus FMN, wherein:

[0042]

[0043]

[0044]

[0045]

[0046]

[0047]

[0048] The degree of differentiation of stability characterization between different aerosol-generating products is evaluated based on the size of the relative deviation RD value obtained. The greater the degree of differentiation, the more obvious the algorithm's ability to distinguish different puff-by-puff release curves is, and it is easier to distinguish curves with particularly close stability.

[0049] Through the above technical solution, the discrimination between different aerosol generating products can be directly obtained by calculating RD. Through the characterization of discrimination, the stability target value can be set during the product development process, the degree of proximity to the target value during the product development process can be evaluated, and the smoke stability effect of the newly developed product can be quantitatively evaluated.

[0050] The present invention is further configured such that, when RD is closer to 0, the stability indexes of different aerosol generating articles are closer.

[0051] The present invention is further configured such that the method for determining the parameters of the amount of smoke released puff by puff comprises the following steps: heating, inhaling and capturing the aerosol-generating product; when the aerosol-generating product is a reconstituted tobacco leaf or a tobacco raw material, the heating temperature ranges from 100 to 350°C, preferably from 190 to 250°C, and more preferably from 220°C. The number of puffs can be set according to the research purpose, for example, the number of puffs can be set according to the stability of the initial heating stage of the cigarette or the stability of the entire heating process of the cigarette. The number of puffs is generally 6 to 18 puffs. If the stability of the entire heating process of the cigarette is studied, 15 puffs are preferred. Under the preferred heating temperature and number of puffs, reconstituted tobacco leaves of different process types can be fully released, which is conducive to determining the amount of component release puff by puff under the condition of complete release. The reconstituted tobacco leaves or tobacco raw materials of the present invention are substantially unrolled materials.

[0052] When the aerosol generating product is a heated cigarette, the matching smoking device is used as a heating carrier, and the number of puffs of the heated cigarette is 6 to 15. The heating temperature is the temperature set inside the matching smoking device. The heated cigarette of the present invention refers to a rolled cigarette.

[0053] The present invention is further configured such that when the aerosol generating product is reconstituted tobacco leaves or tobacco raw materials, it is heated using a tubular furnace heating platform, the tubular furnace heating platform includes a temperature control module, a heating module and a quartz sample tube, the reconstituted tobacco leaves or tobacco raw materials are loaded into the quartz sample tube and fixed in the heating module area, the smoking machine inhales the reconstituted tobacco leaves or tobacco raw materials in the quartz sample tube, single-mouth inhalation of several quartz sample tubes is captured in a smoke capture device, and the smoke capture device is replaced after each round of inhalation.

[0054] The present invention is further configured such that when the aerosol generating product is reconstituted tobacco leaves or tobacco raw materials, it is heated using a tubular furnace heating platform, the tubular furnace heating platform includes a temperature control module, a heating module and a quartz sample tube, the reconstituted tobacco leaves or tobacco raw materials are loaded into the quartz sample tube and fixed in the heating module area, the smoking machine inhales the reconstituted tobacco leaves or tobacco raw materials in the quartz sample tube, single-mouth inhalation of several quartz sample tubes is captured in a smoke capture device, and the smoke capture device is replaced after each round of inhalation.

[0055] The present invention is further configured as follows: when the aerosol-generating product is reconstituted tobacco leaves or tobacco raw materials, the length of the shredded tobacco of the reconstituted tobacco leaves or the tobacco raw materials is 1.5 to 2.5 cm, preferably 2.0 cm, and 0.2 to 0.4 g of shredded tobacco with a mass deviation of ±0.01 g is loaded into a quartz sample tube, preferably 0.3 g; when the aerosol-generating product is a heated cigarette, the mass deviation of the selected heated cigarette is ≤0.05 g.

[0056] The capture scheme in the determination method of smoke volume parameters can refer to "ISO 20778 Cigarettes—Routine analytical cigarette smoking machine—Definitions and standard conditions with an intense smoking regime", with a puff volume of 55 mL, a puff interval of 30 s, a puff frequency of 2 s, and a bell-shaped puff flow chart.

[0057] The smoke capture device of the present invention can be a Cambridge filter, an absorption bottle, an adsorbent or other devices capable of capturing smoke components.

[0058] As for the calculation of the mass of captured substances, taking ACM as an example, it can be weighed by the built-in balance of the smoking machine to obtain the smoke release per puff of each sample tube / cigarette. For the content of conventional chemical components, CORESTA Recommended Method No. 84 (CRM No.84) can be referred to, and gas chromatography is used to determine the puff-by-puff release of components in the smoke, including but not limited to nicotine, glycerin, propylene glycol, and water. Other components in the smoke, such as aroma components, can also be determined by other chemical analysis methods. Two parallel measurements are performed for each sample, and the measurement results are calculated as the mean, in units of the release per puff of each sample (mg / puff / cig).

[0059] The present invention has the following technical effects:

[0060] (1) In the technical solution of the present invention, the puff-by-puff release consistency of the aerosol generating product is evaluated by calculating the relative mean moving range MR, and then the stability of the smoke component release in the aerosol generating product is evaluated. This evaluation method not only takes into account the influence of different puff-by-puff release amounts, but also has good applicability to samples with large differences in release amounts.

[0061] (2) In the technical solution of the present invention, the composite consistency of the aerosol generating product is evaluated by calculating the factor mean moving range FMR or the factor range modulus FMN. The algorithm takes into account the two dimensions of "overall consistency" and "puff-by-puff release consistency" on the basis of the smoke component release, and comprehensively evaluates the puff-by-puff release of smoke components, the overall consistency of the puff-by-puff release curve, and the consistency of the changes between puffs. It is suitable for the evaluation of component release curves of most different types of heated cigarette products, and all factors affecting stability are specifically quantified.

[0062] (3) In the technical solution of the present invention, the relative deviation RD of the stability index is calculated according to the stability index, and the RD value corresponding to the same stability index can be used to evaluate the degree of stability difference between different products. When the stability index is the standard deviation SD or the coefficient of variation CV, the closer the RD is to 0, the closer the overall consistency of the two aerosol generating products is. When the stability index is the mouthful difference mean R and the relative mean moving range MR, the closer the RD is to 0, the closer the mouthful release consistency of the two aerosol generating products is. When the stability index is the factor mean moving range FMR or the factor range mode FMN, the closer the RD is to 0, the closer the composite consistency of the two aerosol generating products is. Provide an evaluation scale for the degree of stability optimization for product development and optimization.

[0063] The discrimination of different stability characterization methods can also be evaluated based on the size of the RD values ​​calculated from different stability indices. The greater the discrimination, the more obvious the discrimination performance of the corresponding stability index for different puff-by-puff release curves, and it is easier to distinguish curves with particularly close stability.

[0064] In summary, a standardized test process for the puff-by-puff smoke release of aerosol-generating products and products was established, and the concept of "stability index" was proposed for the first time. Through mathematical and statistical methods, a quantitative evaluation scheme for puff-by-puff stability suitable for different characteristic release curves was provided, taking into account the differences in puff-by-puff release, the overall consistency of the release curve and the consistency of release between puffs. This achieved a breakthrough in the evaluation of smoke stability of aerosol-generating products from qualitative (sensory evaluation and comparison of release curves) to quantitative, and provided an objective, scientific and effective evaluation method for the smoke stability of aerosol-generating products. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0065] Figure 1 A vector diagram showing the factor range modulus;

[0066] Figure 2 The puff-by-puff release curve trend diagram of samples AF is shown;

[0067] Figure 3 The trend graph of the puff-by-puff release curve of ACM in the three products is shown;

[0068] Figure 4 The puff-by-puff release curve trend graphs of nicotine in the three products are shown;

[0069] Figure 5 A puff-by-puff release curve trend of ACM in reconstituted tobacco is shown;

[0070] Figure 6 A puff-by-puff release curve trend diagram of nicotine in reconstituted tobacco leaves is shown;

[0071] Figure 7 A puff-by-puff release curve trend of ACM in a typical heated cigarette product is shown;

[0072] Figure 8 The figure shows the puff-by-puff release trend of nicotine in a typical heated cigarette product. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0073] The technical solutions in the embodiments of the present invention are described clearly and completely below. Obviously, the described embodiments are only part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the scope of protection of the present invention.

[0074] The present invention provides a first method for evaluating the stability of smoke component release in an aerosol generating product, comprising: capturing smoke generated by puffing the aerosol generating product, and measuring smoke component content parameters released puff by puff; calculating a relative mean moving range MR based on the measured smoke component content parameters released puff by puff according to the following formula (1); evaluating the puff by puff release consistency of the aerosol generating product based on the obtained relative mean moving range MR, and further evaluating the stability of smoke component release in the aerosol generating product;

[0075]

[0076] In formula (1), is the average amount of the components released after taking n puffs of the aerosol-generating product, where n is the total number of puffs, and x i is the amount of components released in the i-th puff of smoke from the aerosol generating product, x i+1 It is the amount of components released in the i+1th puff of smoke of the aerosol generating product.

[0077] In formula (1) It is the sum of the ranges of the smoke from the first puff to the last puff, which is divided by the mean value of the release amount and the degree of freedom, eliminating the influence of the dimension, thereby accurately reflecting the proportion of the change of each puff of smoke to the overall mean, and also eliminating the influence of the difference in the release amount level of different aerosol-generating products on the degree of data dispersion, making it easier to consider the influence of the release amount of each component on stability. Therefore, the relative mean moving range MR is suitable for characterizing the stability evaluation between each puff of the release curve, and is suitable for different release amount difference magnitudes.

[0078] The second method for evaluating the stability of smoke component release in an aerosol generating product provided by the present invention comprises: capturing smoke generated by puffing the aerosol generating product, and measuring the smoke component content parameters released puff by puff; calculating the factor range mode FMN according to the following formula (2) based on the measured smoke component content parameters released puff by puff; evaluating the composite consistency of the aerosol generating product according to the obtained FMN, and further evaluating the stability of the smoke component release in the aerosol generating product;

[0079]

[0080] In formula (2), is the average amount of the components released after taking n puffs of the aerosol-generating product, where n is the total number of puffs, and x i is the amount of components released in the i-th puff of smoke from the aerosol generating product, x i+1 It is the amount of components released in the i+1th puff of smoke of the aerosol generating product.

[0081] Formula (2) takes into account the two dimensions of "overall consistency" and "puff-by-puff release consistency", and comprehensively evaluates the puff-by-puff release of smoke components, the overall consistency of the puff-by-puff release curve, and the consistency of the changes between puffs. It is applicable to the evaluation of component release curves of most different types of aerosol generating products. When FMN is smaller, the composite consistency is better, which means that the comprehensive effect of "overall consistency" and "puff-by-puff release consistency" is better. FMN is suitable for the comparison of release curves between aerosol generating products affected by different raw materials, different heating methods, different temperatures and other factors.

[0082] With respect to the second stability evaluation method of the present invention, the stability evaluation method further includes determining the influence of the overall release fluctuation and the puff-by-puff release fluctuation on the composite consistency:

[0083] The coefficient of variation (CV) used to evaluate the overall release consistency is defined as:

[0084]

[0085] The relative average moving range MR used to evaluate the consistency of each mouthful of release is defined as:

[0086]

[0087] Obtain a first ratio of CV / FMN, and / or obtain a second ratio of MR / FMN; determine the influence of the overall release fluctuation and the mouthful release fluctuation on the composite consistency according to the first ratio and / or the second ratio. For example, it can be seen from the above formula that the obtained CV value or MR value is less than the corresponding obtained FMN. Therefore, the first ratio or the second ratio is a value greater than 0 and less than 1. The larger the first ratio, the greater the proportion of CV, and the greater the influence of CV representing the overall consistency in the composite consistency. Correspondingly, the larger the second ratio, the greater the proportion of MR, and the greater the influence of MR representing the mouthful release consistency in the composite consistency.

[0088] Furthermore, one of the CV value and the MR value calculated by the aerosol generating product is used as the horizontal coordinate x and the other is used as the vertical coordinate y to determine the coordinates (x, y) of a point R. Specifically, for example, it is (CV, MR) or (MR, CV); the angle α between the connecting line of point R and the origin and the horizontal coordinate is determined, or the angle between the connecting line and the vertical coordinate is the angle α, and the influence of the overall release fluctuation on the composite consistency is determined according to the size of the angle α, or the influence of the puff-by-puff release fluctuation on the composite consistency, or the influence of the overall release fluctuation and the puff-by-puff release fluctuation on the composite consistency is determined by the angle α.

[0089] The present invention endows FMN with physical spatial meaning by establishing a vector coordinate system, which is conducive to intuitively reflecting more mathematical meanings of FMN through the positions of points in the coordinate diagram, vector lengths and angles, and is conducive to the visual display of smoke components between overall stability and puff-by-puff consistency, providing intuitive guidance for the improvement direction in the process of product stability optimization.

[0090] Specifically, if the angle α between the connecting line and the horizontal axis is, when cosα is closer to 1 or sinα is closer to 0, it is judged that the fluctuation of the release of smoke components in the aerosol generating product is obviously affected by the amount represented by the horizontal axis; when cosα is closer to 0 or sinα is closer to 1, it is judged that the fluctuation of the release of smoke components in the aerosol generating product is obviously affected by the amount represented by the vertical axis.

[0091] More specifically, if CV is used as the abscissa and MR is used as the ordinate, the angle α between the connecting line and the abscissa is, when cosα is closer to 1 or sinα is closer to 0, the smaller MR is, and / or the larger CV is, the better the consistency of the release from mouth to mouth, and the fluctuation of the release curve is obviously affected by the fluctuation of the overall release; when cosα is closer to 0 or sinα is closer to 1, the smaller CV is, and / or the larger MR is, the better the consistency of the overall release is, and the fluctuation of the release curve is obviously affected by the fluctuation of the release from mouth to mouth.

[0092] Relatively speaking, if the angle α between the connecting line and the ordinate is, when cosα is closer to 1 or sinα is closer to 0, it is judged that the fluctuation of the release of smoke components in the aerosol generating product is obviously affected by the amount represented by the ordinate; when cosα is closer to 0 or sinα is closer to 1, it is judged that the fluctuation of the release of smoke components in the aerosol generating product is obviously affected by the amount represented by the abscissa.

[0093] More specifically, if CV is used as the horizontal coordinate and MR is used as the vertical coordinate, the angle α between the connecting line and the vertical coordinate is, when cosα is closer to 1 or sinα is closer to 0, the smaller the CV is, and / or the larger the MR is, the better the overall release consistency is, and the fluctuation of the release curve is obviously affected by the fluctuation of the release from one puff to another; when cosα is closer to 0 or sinα is closer to 1, the smaller the MR is, and / or the larger the CV is, the better the consistency of the release from one puff to another is, and the fluctuation of the release curve is obviously affected by the fluctuation of the overall release.

[0094] In particular, when both CV and MR are very small, the closer the vector coordinate R is to the origin in the image, the smaller the stability index is, and the release stability of the aerosol-generating product is optimal. Projecting CV and MR as two-dimensional vectors, we obtain the two-dimensional vectors of the two.

[0095] (Overall consistency evaluation, release-by-release consistency evaluation)

[0096] The size of FMN is The modulus of FMN is the line connecting point R and the origin. Figure 1 .

[0097] The third method for evaluating the stability of smoke component release in an aerosol generating product provided by the present invention comprises: calculating the factor mean moving range FMR according to the following formula (3) based on the measured smoke component content parameters released puff by puff; evaluating the stability of the smoke component release in the aerosol generating product according to the obtained FMR;

[0098]

[0099] In formula (3), is the average amount of the components released after taking n puffs of the aerosol-generating product, where n is the total number of puffs, and x i is the amount of components released in the i-th puff of smoke from the aerosol generating product, x i+1 It is the amount of components released in the i+1th puff of smoke of the aerosol generating product.

[0100] Similar to FMN, FMR also takes into account the two dimensions of “overall consistency” and “puff-by-puff release consistency”, and comprehensively evaluates the puff-by-puff release of smoke components, the overall consistency of the puff-by-puff release curve, and the consistency of changes between puffs.

[0101] The aerosol generating product mentioned in the present invention can be a burning cigarette or a heat-not-burn cigarette, can be a tobacco raw material, such as tobacco shreds, tobacco particles, fragments, powder, etc., and can also be a reconstituted tobacco leaf prepared by a thick pulp method, a papermaking method, a rolling method, a dry method, etc. Further, it can be an electrically heated cigarette formed by tobacco, or an electrically heated cigarette made from reconstituted tobacco leaves, and can also be an electronic cigarette, a smokeless gas cigarette, and the smokeless gas cigarette can be, for example, a buccal cigarette, a snuff, etc.

[0102] The smoke component content mentioned in the present invention refers to the amount of a specific component in the smoke, the total amount of several components or the total amount of all components, such as the atomizer content, nicotine content, the content of a specific aroma component, etc.; the total amount of all components, that is, all liquid or solid particles that can be captured in the smoke, is called aerosol captured matter (ACM).

[0103] As a further configuration, the technical solution of the present invention further includes evaluating the degree of differentiation of stability characteristics between different aerosol generating products: obtaining the stability index of the two aerosol generating products, and calculating the relative deviation RD of the stability index according to the following formula (4):

[0104]

[0105] In the above formula (4), I 1is the stability index of the aerosol generating product 1, I 2 is a stability index of the aerosol generating product 2, wherein the stability index is selected from one or more of the standard deviation SD, the coefficient of variation CV, the mean of the mouthful difference R, the relative mean moving range MR, the factor mean moving range FMR, and the factor range modulus FMN, wherein:

[0106] ,

[0108]

[0109]

[0110]

[0111]

[0112]

[0113] The degree of differentiation of stability characteristics between different aerosol generating products is evaluated according to the magnitude of the relative deviation RD value obtained. Any type of aerosol generating product 1 and aerosol generating product 2 are selected to calculate and evaluate RD.

[0114] When I is SD, RD represents the standard deviation difference rate between aerosol generating product 1 and aerosol generating product 2. The overall consistency evaluation is performed with SD, which is suitable for release curve comparison with small difference in puff-by-puff release amount. The smaller the SD, the better the overall consistency of the corresponding aerosol generating product. The smaller the RD, the closer the standard deviation of aerosol generating product 1 and aerosol generating product 2, that is, the closer the overall consistency of the two.

[0115] When I is CV, RD represents the difference rate of the coefficient of variation between aerosol generating product 1 and aerosol generating product 2. The overall consistency evaluation is performed using CV, which is applicable to different magnitudes of release difference. The smaller the CV, the better the overall consistency of the corresponding aerosol generating product; and the smaller the RD, the closer the coefficient of variation of aerosol generating product 1 and aerosol generating product 2, that is, the overall consistency of the two is close.

[0116] When I is R, RD represents the difference rate of the mean puff-by-puff difference between aerosol generating product 1 and aerosol generating product 2. The puff-by-puff release consistency evaluation based on R is only applicable to curves with small differences in release amounts. The smaller R is, the better the puff-by-puff release consistency of the corresponding aerosol generating product is; and the smaller RD is, the closer the mean puff-by-puff difference between aerosol generating product 1 and aerosol generating product 2 is, that is, the puff-by-puff release consistency of the two is close.

[0117] When I is MR, RD represents the relative average moving range difference rate between aerosol generating product 1 and aerosol generating product 2. MR is used to evaluate the puff-by-puff release consistency, which is applicable to different magnitudes of release difference. The smaller MR is, the better the puff-by-puff release consistency of the corresponding aerosol generating product is; and the smaller RD is, the closer the relative average moving range of aerosol generating product 1 and aerosol generating product 2 is, that is, the puff-by-puff release consistency of the two is close.

[0118] When I is FMR, RD represents the FMR difference rate between aerosol generating product 1 and aerosol generating product 2. FMR is used to comprehensively evaluate volume consistency and puff-by-puff release consistency. It is applicable to different levels of release difference. The smaller the FMR, the better the composite consistency of the corresponding aerosol generating product. The smaller the RD, the closer the relative average moving range of aerosol generating product 1 and aerosol generating product 2, that is, the composite consistency of the two is close. In fact, FMR = CV*MR. More intuitively, FMR represents the determination of the coordinates of a point R as (CV, MR) or (MR, CV) with one of the CV value and the MR value as the horizontal coordinate x and the other as the vertical coordinate y; the line connecting point R with the horizontal coordinate and the vertical coordinate, the area of ​​the rectangle enclosed by the line and the two coordinate axes is the FMR. For example Figure 1 The area of ​​the rectangular surface is the geometric meaning of FMR. Furthermore, RD is the difference rate of the areas corresponding to aerosol generating product 1 and aerosol generating product 2. The difference rate of the area can be used to intuitively judge the discrimination degree of different aerosol generating products relative to the same aerosol generating product. The larger the RD, the greater the corresponding discrimination degree.

[0119] When I is FMN, RD represents the composite consistency difference rate between aerosol generating product 1 and aerosol generating product 2. FMN is used to comprehensively evaluate the overall consistency and the consistency of each puff of release. It is applicable to different magnitudes of release difference. The smaller the FMN, the better the composite consistency of the corresponding aerosol generating product; and the smaller the RD, the closer the composite consistency of aerosol generating product 1 and aerosol generating product 2.

[0120] The difference in the use of the above standard deviation SD and coefficient of variation CV: Taking the data in Table 1 as an example, combined with Figure 2 Although the standard deviations SD of the two sets of release data are the same, their coefficients of variation CV are significantly different. From the data, we can see that the release trends of the two are consistent, but the puff-by-puff release of sample B is higher than that of sample A. In actual products, it is generally believed that under the same release trend, the higher the puff-by-puff release, the better the smoke atomization volume. Therefore, the puff-by-puff release should be considered as a constraint condition for stability.

[0121] Therefore, the standard deviation method is mainly applicable to the case where the difference in release amount from mouthful to mouthful is not large, and to compare the overall dispersion of the release curve. The coefficient of variation method is mainly applicable to the case where the overall difference in the release curve is large, and it is also suitable for samples with the same release trend but different release amounts.

[0122] Table 1 ACM release per mouthful with the same standard deviation (1-8 in Table 1 is the mouthful order)

[0123] 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 SD value CV value Sample A 2.70 3.90 4.10 3.90 3.50 3.10 2.90 2.80 0.558 0.169 Sample B 4.70 5.90 6.10 5.90 5.50 5.10 4.90 4.80 0.558 0.106

[0124] The difference between the use of the above relative mean moving range MR and the coefficient of variation CV is that the coefficient of variation CV mainly considers the overall mean deviation of the data points and cannot reflect the difference in changes between two consecutive data points. In the process of puffing aerosol-generating products, in addition to paying attention to the overall differences in the puffing process, it is also necessary to pay attention to the difference in component release between two adjacent puffs. The difference in release between puffs is too large, which seriously affects the consistency of the sensory quality of the product. As shown in the data in Table 2, with the same coefficient of variation, the release curve ( Figure 2 ) are not consistent with the curve trend and stability performance. The release curve of sample D is more in line with the requirement of relatively balanced differences between each puff, and the MR value is more accurate by comparison.

[0125] Table 2 ACM release per mouthful with the same coefficient of variation (1-8 in Table 1 is the mouthful order)

[0126] 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 CV value MR value Sample C 2.70 3.92 4.12 3.90 3.46 3.30 3.05 2.88 0.154 0.111 Sample D 2.30 3.00 3.65 3.80 3.80 3.75 3.65 3.40 0.154 0.079

[0127] Heated cigarette products are affected by the design parameters of cigarettes and smoking utensils. Different raw materials, heating methods, temperature curves, etc. make the component release curves differ significantly from one another, and the trends are different. Therefore, there may be two release curves with similar or identical deviations and moving ranges, but the actual release curve trends and puff-by-puff stability are quite different. As shown in Table 3, although the relative average moving ranges of samples E and F are the same, the release curve trends are significantly different. See Table 3. Figure 2 Although it is possible to Figure 2 It can be seen that the puff fluctuations or overall fluctuations of sample E and sample F are different, but the specific differences and the magnitude of the fluctuations cannot be clearly and intuitively obtained from the figure.

[0128] Table 3 ACM release amount for each mouthful of the same relative average moving range (1-8 in Table 1 is the mouthful order)

[0129] 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 MR Sample E 2.70 2.60 2.30 2.10 1.70 1.50 1.20 1.04 0.126 Sample F 1.20 1.70 2.05 1.70 1.50 1.50 1.50 1.50 0.126

[0130] The coefficient of variation CV mainly represents the overall and averaged discreteness of the data, while the relative average moving range MR mainly represents the changing trend between consecutive data points. The evaluation of smoke release stability needs to consider the overall consistency of the puffing process and the relative consistency between two adjacent puffs under the constraint of the puff-by-puff atomization amount, so as to obtain the sensory stability of puff-by-puff puffing. The two-dimensional coupled stability indexes FNR and FMN are just suitable for this.

[0131] Five evaluation methods based on two dimensions under the constraint of puff-by-puff atomization volume were used to calculate the puff-by-puff release stability of six sample ACMs (Table 4). Different calculation methods focus on different dimensions, resulting in different scopes of application. Under their applicable conditions, they can all be used as quantitative evaluation methods for smoke stability.

[0132] Table 4 Comparison of stability index under different ACM release curves

[0133]

[0134]

[0135] In summary, if you only need to make an overall stability evaluation on the release curves of samples with small differences in release amount from mouth to mouth, use SD evaluation. If you only need to make a mouthful release stability evaluation on the release curves of samples with small differences in release amount from mouth to mouth, use R evaluation. If you need to make an overall stability evaluation on the release curves of samples with different magnitudes of release amount differences, use CV evaluation. If you need to make a mouthful stability evaluation on the release curves of samples with different magnitudes of release amount differences, use MR evaluation. If you need to make a comprehensive stability evaluation on different types of release curves with different release amount differences, different overall and different mouthful fluctuation ranges, use FMN or FMR evaluation. The evaluation of FMN is similar to that of FMR, among which FMN can better clarify the degree of overall and mouthful influence.

[0136] Embodiment 1:

[0137] 1) Sample preparation

[0138] Three different price ranges of heated cigarettes of a certain brand were selected. All three cigarettes used the same inner core electric heating device as the atomization medium. The differences in the stability of releases between the flagship product (product-1) and the other two non-flagship products (product-2 and product-3) were compared. The smoking machine was equipped with a Cambridge filter holder, the cigarette was inserted into the filter holder, and the inner core electric heating device was used as the heating device for smoking.

[0139] 2) Flue gas capture

[0140] The smoking plan refers to "ISO 20778 Cigarettes—Routine analytical cigarette smoking machine—Definitions and standard conditions with an intense smoking regime", with a smoking volume of 55 mL, a puff interval of 30 s, a puff frequency of 2 s, and puffing using a bell-shaped flow chart.

[0141] Each time the test is performed, 4 cigarettes are smoked, each with 1 puff, and a total of 4 puffs are captured on a 44mm Cambridge filter. The Cambridge filter is replaced between different puffs. Similarly, the measured mean of the 4 cigarettes represents the component release per puff of each cigarette. Each sample is tested in parallel, and the mean of the two parallels is taken as the component release per puff.

[0142] 3) Component analysis

[0143] The built-in balance of the smoking machine weighs the mass of aerosol capture material (ACM) released puff by puff (mg / puff / cig, the weight of each cigarette puffed), and the nicotine release per puff in the smoke (mg / puff / cig) is determined with reference to CORESTA Recommended Method No. 84 (CRM No.84 Determination of Glycerin, Propylene Glycol, Water, and Nicotine in the Aerosol of E-Cigarettes by Gas Chromatographic Analysis). The smoke ACM and nicotine release per puff data are shown in Table 5.

[0144] The trends of the release curves of the three heated cigarettes seem similar, but there are differences in the actual product performance and stability, so it is difficult to intuitively see the puff-by-puff release stability of different products from the curves. Among them, in the smoke of aerosol-generating products, aerosol capture matter (ACM) is one of the important indicators to characterize the amount of smoke atomization, and nicotine is mainly related to the physiological satisfaction during smoking. ACM and nicotine are the two most important parameters for evaluating the sensory quality of heated cigarettes. The stability of the above two parameters during the smoking process will affect the stability of the overall quality of the heated cigarette product. Therefore, the specific embodiment of the present invention chooses to use these two parameters for experimental verification.

[0145] Table 5 ACM and nicotine release per puff of three HCI cigarettes of the same brand at different prices

[0146]

[0147]

[0148] 4) Stability index evaluation

[0149] Taking the flagship product-1 as the standard, Figures 3-4 Intuitively, the release trends of Product-2 and Product-3 are basically the same, but only the general rules can be seen, and more accurate information cannot be obtained. Therefore, the evaluation method of the present invention is needed to quantify and compare to evaluate which product, Product-2 or Product-3, has a stability closer to the flagship product-1.

[0150] The “stability index” of the puff-by-puff release of ACM and nicotine in the smoke of the three heated cigarettes was calculated using the stability index algorithm under three dimensions, and the RD values ​​between product-2 and product-3 and flagship product-1 were calculated respectively. The results are shown in Table 6.

[0151] Table 6 Stability index and relative deviation of ACM and nicotine puff release of three different heated cigarette products of the same brand

[0152]

[0153]

[0154] In Table 6, RD(2 / 1) is |I 1 -I 2 | / I 1 , RD(3 / 1) is |I 1 -I 3 | / I 1 , where I 1 is the stability index of product-1, I 2 is the stability index of product-2, I 3 is the stability index of product-3, and the stability index is selected from one of the standard deviation SD, the coefficient of variation CV, the mean of the mouthful difference R, the relative mean moving range MR, the factor mean moving range FMR, and the factor range modulus FMN.

[0155] For the same stability index, whether it is ACM or nicotine, RD(3 / 1) is smaller than RD(2 / 1), indicating that the ACM and nicotine release stability of product-3 is closer to that of flagship product-1, thus achieving the stability evaluation during product development and optimization.

[0156] Different stability index algorithms have different degrees of differentiation for the same product. The larger the RD value, the greater the differentiation between products. It can better highlight the stability differences between different products, which is more conducive to analyzing the pros and cons of products. On the other hand, it is also conducive to finding products with consistent composite stability.

[0157] It can be seen from the RD(2 / 1) and RD(3 / 1) in the above table that the six algorithms can distinguish the stability differences between product-2, product-3 and flagship product-1, and the resolution is good. By calculating the RD values ​​of different stability parameters, it is possible to compare which stability parameter has a greater degree of differentiation. Among them, the FMR algorithm has a relatively large degree of differentiation (RD(2 / 1) calculated by ACM is 311.76%, RD(3 / 1) calculated by ACM is 143.50%, RD(2 / 1) calculated by nicotine is 106.36%, and RD(3 / 1) calculated by nicotine is 19.02%), which can better highlight the stability differences between different products. FMN depends on the combination of the coefficient of variation and the relative average moving range. Generally, the RD value is between the RD values ​​of the two dimensions (i.e., CV and MR). The larger the RD value, the larger the RD values ​​of the coefficient of variation and the relative average moving range, and the greater the overall differentiation between samples. The smaller the RD value, the smaller the RD value of the coefficient of variation and the relative average moving range, and the smaller the degree of differentiation in one dimension. Therefore, by comparing the RD value calculated using CV as the stability index with the RD value calculated using MR as the stability index, it can also reflect the impact of "overall consistency" and "consistency between bites" on the stability index.

[0158] The results show that ACM and nicotine of different heated cigarette products can be quantitatively evaluated. According to the stability index ranking, ACM and nicotine show certain differences, indicating that different components in the smoke have different release patterns from puff to puff. The stability of flagship product-1 is better than the other two products, and is closer to product-3.

[0159] Embodiment 2:

[0160] 1) Sample preparation

[0161] Four typical processes (roller pressing, dry method, papermaking method, thick pulp method) of reconstituted tobacco leaves for heating cigarettes were selected for mechanical shredding, and the shredded length was about 2.0 cm. 0.2g±0.01g of shredded samples were randomly loaded into a fixed position in a quartz sample tube, and the filling height of Party B's sample was about 2.0 cm. A small amount of high-temperature resistant glass wool was used to fix the two ends of the sample to prevent the reconstituted tobacco shreds from shifting under the airflow.

[0162] The smoking machine is equipped with a Cambridge filter holder, and the tube furnace heating platform is connected to the standard port of the filter holder. The quartz sample tube filled with the sample is inserted into the tube furnace heating device, and the front end is connected to the filter holder.

[0163] 2) Flue gas capture

[0164] The smoking scheme refers to "ISO 20778 Cigarettes—Routine analytical cigarette smoking machine—Definitions and standard conditions with an intense smoking regime", with a smoking volume of 55 mL, a puff interval of 30 seconds, a puff frequency of 2 seconds, and a bell-shaped flow chart. The heating temperature is 220°C, and the number of puffs is 15.

[0165] Each time the test is performed, 10 sample tubes are sucked, and each sample tube is sucked 1 time, and a total of 10 times are captured on a 44mm Cambridge filter. The Cambridge filter is replaced between different times. Similarly, the average value of the 10 sample tubes represents the component release amount of each sample tube per time. Each sample is measured in two parallels, and the average of the two parallels is taken as the component release amount of the reconstituted tobacco leaf per time.

[0166] 3) Component analysis

[0167] The built-in balance of the smoking machine is used to weigh the puff-by-puff mass (mg / puff / cig) of the aerosol capture material (ACM), and the puff-by-puff nicotine release (mg / puff / cig) in the smoke is determined with reference to CORESTA recommended method No. 84 (CRM No. 84 Determination of Glycerin, Propylene Glycol, Water, and Nicotine in the Aerosol of E-Cigarettes by Gas Chromatographic Analysis).

[0168] The ACM and nicotine content of the smoke are shown in Table 7, and the release trend of the curve is shown in Figures 5-6 ACM and glycerol both showed a trend of first rising and then falling, and the release amount was mainly concentrated in a few mouthfuls in the middle. Intuitively, the more concentrated the release, the worse the stability of the mouthful release. Figures 5-6 Judging from the volatility and variation of the release curves, the puff-by-puff release stability of ACM and nicotine is in the order of roller pressing method > dry method > papermaking method > thick pulp method.

[0169] Table 7 ACM and nicotine release per puff of reconstituted tobacco leaves

[0170]

[0171]

[0172] 4) Stability index calculation

[0173] The "stability index" of the puff-by-puff release of ACM and nicotine in the smoke of four types of reconstituted tobacco leaves was calculated using the composite consistency algorithm "FMR" and "FMN" methods. The results are shown in Table 8. The results show that the puff-by-puff release stability of ACM and nicotine is roller pressing method > dry method > papermaking method > thick pulp method, and the two judgments are consistent. In practical applications, it is also generally believed that due to process reasons, the components of the papermaking method are released faster and the puff-by-puff stability is poor. Therefore, the stability index can accurately reflect the stability of the puff-by-puff release of different components.

[0174] Table 8 Stability index of puff-by-puff release of ACM and nicotine in reconstituted tobacco leaves

[0175]

[0176] Embodiment 3:

[0177] 1) Sample preparation

[0178] Select 5 different types of heated cigarette products, including typical peripheral heated cigarettes and internal heated cigarettes. Peripheral heated cigarettes refer to cigarettes that, when smoked, insert the end of the shaped cigarette rod into the peripheral heating device to heat and release smoke. Internal heated cigarettes refer to cigarettes that, when smoked, insert the heating device into the shaped cigarette rod to heat and release smoke.

[0179] The smoking machine is equipped with a Cambridge filter holder, a cigarette is inserted into the filter holder, and an electric heating cigarette smoking device is used as a heating device for smoking.

[0180] 2) Flue gas capture

[0181] The smoking plan refers to "ISO 20778 Cigarettes—Routine analytical cigarette smoking machine—Definitions and standard conditions with an intense smoking regime", with a smoking volume of 55 mL, a puff interval of 30 s, a puff frequency of 2 s, and puffing using a bell-shaped flow chart.

[0182] Each time the test is performed, 4 cigarettes are smoked, each with 1 puff, and a total of 4 puffs are captured on a 44mm Cambridge filter. The Cambridge filter is replaced between different puffs. Similarly, the measured mean of the 4 cigarettes represents the component release per puff of each cigarette. Each sample is tested in parallel, and the mean of the two parallels is taken as the component release per puff.

[0183] 3) Component analysis

[0184] The built-in balance of the smoking machine is used to weigh the puff-by-puff mass (mg / puff / cig) of the aerosol capture material (ACM), and the puff-by-puff nicotine release (mg / puff / cig) in the smoke is determined with reference to CORESTA recommended method No. 84 (CRM No. 84 Determination of Glycerin, Propylene Glycol, Water, and Nicotine in the Aerosol of E-Cigarettes by Gas Chromatographic Analysis).

[0185] Due to the different heating methods (including inner core heating and outer heating) and the design of the number of puffs (8 to 12 puffs) of different products, see Table 9 for details. The component release curves not only differ in the puff-by-puff release amount and the number of puffs, but also in the release curve trends. Therefore, it is difficult to intuitively see the puff-by-puff release stability of different products from the curves. The smoke ACM puff-by-puff release curve measured in this example is shown in Table 9. Figure 7 ,Depend on Figure 7 It can be seen from the figure that the release curve of the inner core heating-2 is the most stable, and the release curve of the outer heating-1 is the most tortuous. The nicotine puff-by-puff release curve measured in this example is shown in Figure 8 It can be seen intuitively from the figure that the release curve of inner core heating-4 is relatively stable, but the release amount is low, which will lead to insufficient satisfaction in the actual experience. It is difficult to judge the composite stability of the two sensoryly. The change trends of the other curves are different, and it is difficult to see the difference in release amount. Therefore, it is necessary to calculate its composite stability with "FMR" and "FMN".

[0186] 4) Stability index calculation

[0187] The “stability index” of the puff-by-puff release of ACM and nicotine in the smoke of the five heated cigarettes was calculated using “FMR” and “FMN” respectively. The results are shown in Table 9.

[0188] Table 9 Stability index of ACM and nicotine puff-by-puff release of heated cigarettes

[0189]

[0190] The results showed that in the evaluation of ACM and nicotine stability of the five products, the rankings of FMR and FMN were consistent. The two methods took into account the different types of release curves, the number of puffs and the difference in release amount, and were a comprehensive method for evaluating the stability index of smoke component release of heated cigarettes. The ACM and nicotine of different heated cigarette products can be quantitatively evaluated.

[0191] Among the above five products, the ranking of ACM release stability is: inner core heating-2>inner core heating-1>inner core heating-4>inner core heating-3>peripheral heating-1, and the ranking of nicotine release stability is: inner core heating-1>inner core heating-4>inner core heating-2>inner core heating-3>peripheral heating-1. For the stability of ACM release, according to the ranking, inner core heating-2 is closest to inner core heating-1, and peripheral heating-1 is closest to inner core heating-3. It is not yet known whether the stability of inner core heating-4, which is in the middle ranking, is closest to inner core heating-1 or inner core heating-3. RD can solve this problem well.

[0192] The FMR calculated with the ACM of the inner core heating -1 is taken as I 1 , then the FMR calculated by the ACM of the inner core heating -2 is I 2 , RD=|I 1 -I 2 | / I 1 = 0.087; FMR calculated by ACM for core heating -3 as I 3 , RD=|I 1 -I 3 | / I 1 =1.652; FMR calculated by ACM for core heating -4 as I 4 , RD=|I 1 -I 4 | / I 1 =0.522; FMR calculated by ACM with peripheral heating -1 as I 5 , RD=|I 1 -I 5 | / I 1 =2.435. It can be seen that, taking inner core heating-1 as the reference, inner core heating-2 is closest to the composite consistency of inner core heating-1 compared with other heating methods, while outer heating-1 is the most different from inner core heating-1 compared with other heating methods.

[0193] Further, the FMR calculated with the ACM of the inner core heating -3 is taken as I 1 , then the FMR calculated by the ACM for the inner core heating -1 is I 2 , RD=|I 1 -I 2 | / I 1 = 0.623; FMR calculated by ACM for core heating -2 as I 3 , RD=|I 1 -I 3 | / I 1 =0.656; FMR calculated by ACM for core heating -4 as I 4, RD=|I 1 -I 4 | / I 1 =0.426; FMR calculated by ACM with peripheral heating -1 as I 5 , RD=|I 1 -I 5 | / I 1 = 0.295. It can be seen that the composite consistency of inner core heating-3 is closest to that of outer core heating-1, while the difference with inner core heating-2 is the largest.

[0194] Further, the FMR calculated with the ACM of the inner core heating -4 is taken as I 1 , then the FMR calculated by the ACM for the inner core heating -1 is I 2 , RD=|I 1 -I 2 | / I 1 = 0.343; FMR calculated by ACM for core heating -2 as I 3 , RD=|I 1 -I 3 | / I 1 = 0.4; FMR calculated by ACM with inner core heating -3 as I 4 , RD=|I 1 -I 4 | / I 1 =0.743; FMR calculated by ACM with peripheral heating -1 as I 5 , RD=|I 1 -I 5 | / I 1 =1.257. It can be seen that the composite consistency of inner core heating-4 is closest to that of inner core heating-1, while the difference with outer core heating-1 is the largest.

[0195] This example shows that FMR or FMN can be used to evaluate the release stability of different aerosol-generating products, so as to select the product with the best stability. Further use of RD can identify the product that is closest to a specific stability standard, thus providing a quantitative standard for product development, upgrading and stability control.

[0196] The above are only preferred embodiments of the present invention and are not intended to limit the present invention. Any modifications, equivalent substitutions, improvements, etc. made within the spirit and principles of the present invention should be included in the protection scope of the present invention.

Claims

1. A method for evaluating the stability of smoke component release in an aerosol generating product, characterized in that: include: Capturing the smoke generated by the aerosol-generating product when it is puffed, and measuring the content parameters of the smoke components released puff by puff; Based on the measured smoke component content parameters released puff by puff, the relative average moving range MR is calculated according to the following formula (1); The puff-by-puff release consistency of the aerosol generating product is evaluated based on the obtained relative mean moving range MR, and further the stability of the smoke component release amount in the aerosol generating product is evaluated; In formula (1), is the average amount of the components released after taking n puffs of the aerosol-generating product, where n is the total number of puffs, and x i is the amount of components released in the i-th puff of smoke from the aerosol generating product, x i+1 It is the amount of components released in the i+1th puff of smoke of the aerosol generating product.

2. A method for evaluating the stability of smoke component release in an aerosol generating product, characterized in that: include: Capturing the smoke generated by the aerosol-generating product when it is puffed, and measuring the content parameters of the smoke components released puff by puff; Based on the measured smoke component content parameters released puff by puff, the factor extreme mode FMN is calculated according to the following formula (2); The composite consistency of the aerosol generating product is evaluated according to the obtained factor range mode FMN, and then the stability of the smoke component release in the aerosol generating product is evaluated; In formula (2), is the average amount of the components released after taking n puffs of the aerosol-generating product, where n is the total number of puffs, and x i is the amount of components released in the i-th puff of smoke from the aerosol generating product, x i+1 It is the amount of components released in the i+1th puff of smoke of the aerosol generating product.

3. The stability evaluation method according to claim 2, characterized in that: The stability evaluation method also includes determining the effect of overall release fluctuation and puff-by-puff release fluctuation on the composite consistency: The coefficient of variation (CV) used to evaluate the overall release consistency is defined as: The relative average moving range MR used to evaluate the consistency of each mouthful of release is defined as: obtaining a first ratio of CV / FMN, and / or obtaining a second ratio of MR / FMN; The influence of the overall release fluctuation and the puff-by-puff release fluctuation on the composite consistency is determined based on the first ratio and / or the second ratio.

4. The stability evaluation method according to claim 3, characterized in that: One of the CV value and the MR value calculated by the aerosol generating article is used as a horizontal coordinate x, and the other is used as a vertical coordinate y, and the coordinates (x, y) of a point R are determined; The angle α between the connecting line of point R and the origin and the horizontal coordinate or the vertical coordinate is determined, and the influence of the overall release fluctuation and / or the puff-by-puff release fluctuation on the composite consistency is determined according to the size of the angle α.

5. The evaluation method according to claim 4, characterized in that: The CV value is the abscissa x of point R, the MR value is the ordinate y, and the angle α between the connecting line and one of the coordinate axes is such that when cosα is closer to 1 or sinα is closer to 0, it is judged that the fluctuation of the smoke component release in the aerosol generating product is significantly affected by the amount represented by the coordinate axis; When cosα is closer to 0 or sinα is closer to 1, it is judged that the fluctuation of the smoke component release in the aerosol generating product is significantly affected by the amount represented by the other coordinate axis.

6. A method for evaluating the stability of smoke component release in an aerosol generating product, characterized in that: include: Based on the measured smoke component content parameters released puff by puff, the factor mean moving range FMR is calculated according to the following formula (3); The stability of the smoke component release in the aerosol generating product is evaluated based on the obtained factor mean moving range FMR; In formula (3), is the average amount of the components released after taking n puffs of the aerosol-generating product, where n is the total number of puffs, and x i is the amount of components released in the i-th puff of smoke from the aerosol generating product, x i+1 It is the amount of components released in the i+1th puff of smoke of the aerosol generating product.

7. The stability evaluation method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, characterized in that: It also includes the evaluation of the degree of differentiation of stability characteristics between different aerosol-generating products: The stability index of the two aerosol generating products was obtained, and the relative deviation RD of the stability index was calculated according to the following formula (4): In the above formula (4), I1 is the stability index of the aerosol generating product 1, I2 is the stability index of the aerosol generating product 2, and the stability index is selected from one or more of the standard deviation SD, the coefficient of variation CV, the mean of the mouthful difference R, the relative mean moving range MR, the factor mean moving range FMR, and the factor range modulus FMN, wherein, The degree of differentiation of stability characterization between different aerosol generating products was evaluated based on the relative deviation RD value obtained.

8. The evaluation method according to claim 7, characterized in that: As RD approaches 0, the stability indices of different aerosol generating products are closer.

9. The evaluation method according to claim 7, characterized in that: The method for determining the parameters of the amount of smoke released puff by puff comprises the following steps: heating, inhaling and capturing an aerosol-generating product; when the aerosol-generating product is reconstituted tobacco leaves or tobacco raw materials, the heating temperature ranges from 100 to 350°C, and the number of puffs is 6 to 18; when the aerosol-generating product is a heated cigarette, the number of puffs of the heated cigarette is 6 to 15.

10. The evaluation method according to claim 9, characterized in that: When the aerosol generating product is reconstituted tobacco leaves or tobacco raw materials, it is heated by a tubular furnace heating platform, which includes a temperature control module, a heating module and a quartz sample tube. The reconstituted tobacco leaves or tobacco raw materials are loaded into the quartz sample tube and fixed in the heating module area. The smoking machine inhales the reconstituted tobacco leaves or tobacco raw materials in the quartz sample tube. Single-mouth inhalation of several quartz sample tubes is captured in a smoke capture device, and the smoke capture device is replaced after each round of inhalation.

11. The evaluation method according to claim 10, characterized in that: When the aerosol generating product is reconstituted tobacco leaves or tobacco raw materials, the length of the shredded tobacco of the reconstituted tobacco leaves or the tobacco raw materials is 1.5 to 2.5 cm, and 0.2 to 0.4 g of shredded tobacco with a mass deviation of ±0.01 g is loaded into a quartz sample tube; when the aerosol generating product is a heated cigarette, the mass deviation of the selected heated cigarette is ≤0.05 g.