Wiring variation calculation method and wiring variation calculation program
The method separates resistance and capacitance components of wiring variations using multiple ring oscillators, enhancing integrated circuit yield by accurately determining their impact on propagation delay.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023071025
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-04-24
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-06
- Estimated Expiration
- Not applicable · inactive patent
AI Technical Summary
Conventional methods fail to distinguish between resistance and capacitance components of wiring variations, making it difficult to accurately determine their impact on propagation delay in integrated circuits.
A method and program that calculate resistance and capacitance components of wiring variations by using multiple ring oscillators with different driving forces on the same chip, employing equations to separate these components based on measured frequencies under controlled conditions.
Enables precise separation of wiring variations into resistance and capacitance components, allowing for targeted measures to improve integrated circuit yield and quality.
Smart Images

Figure 2024156507000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a wiring variation calculation method and a wiring variation calculation program. [Background technology]
[0002] In recent years, with the miniaturization of transistors, the wiring dimensions have been shrinking and the wiring resistance has been increasing, which has led to a greater effect on wiring propagation delay. The parasitic resistance and parasitic capacitance of wiring vary due to variations in wiring shape caused by the CMP (Chemical Mechanical Polishing) process and variations in the thickness of interlayer insulating films, but due to the increase in wiring resistance, these variations can no longer be ignored.
[0003] Prior art techniques, for example, include solving model equations defined for each embedded test circuit included in an integrated circuit to generate values for various front-end-of-line (FEOL) and back-end-of-line (BEOL) parameters. The embedded test circuits include a ring oscillator coupled to a test load. Each model equation specifies an output delay of the associated embedded test circuit as a function of the FEOL and BEOL parameters. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0004] [Patent Document 1] Special Publication No. 2007-520055 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0005] However, the conventional technology has a problem in that it is not possible to determine whether the propagation delay time of the wiring is influenced by the resistance component of the wiring variation, the capacitance component, or both.
[0006] In one aspect, the present invention aims to separate wiring variations into a resistance component and a capacitance component. [Means for solving the problem]
[0007] In one embodiment, a wiring variation calculation method is provided, which includes obtaining a first equation representing a frequency of a first ring oscillator among a plurality of ring oscillators having different driving forces and arranged on the same chip as a target circuit for estimating wiring variations, using a resistance component and a capacitance component of the wiring variation as variables, and obtaining a second equation representing a frequency of the second ring oscillator among the plurality of ring oscillators, using the resistance component and the capacitance component as variables, and using the first equation and the second equation to calculate the resistance component and the capacitance component based on the frequency of the first ring oscillator actually measured under the predetermined conditions and the frequency of the second ring oscillator actually measured under the predetermined conditions. Effect of the Invention
[0008] Advantageous Effects of Invention According to one aspect of the present invention, an effect is achieved in that wiring variations can be separated into a resistance component and a capacitance component. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0009] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a wiring variation calculation method according to the first embodiment. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the system configuration of the estimation system 200. As shown in FIG. [Diagram 3] FIG. 3 is a block diagram showing an example of the hardware configuration of the wiring variation calculation device 201. As shown in FIG. [Figure 4] FIG. 4 is an explanatory diagram (part 1) showing an example of the circuit configuration of the ROSC. [Diagram 5] FIG. 5 is a block diagram showing an example of a functional configuration of the wiring variation calculation device 201. As shown in FIG. [Figure 6]FIG. 6 is an explanatory diagram showing a specific example of a data set. [Figure 7] FIG. 7 is an explanatory diagram showing a specific example of fitting information. [Figure 8A] FIG. 8A is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a resistance variation table. [Figure 8B] FIG. 8B is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a capacitance variation table. [Figure 9] FIG. 9 is an explanatory diagram showing another example of the system configuration of the estimation system 200. As shown in FIG. [Figure 10] FIG. 10 is a flowchart of an example of a wiring variation calculation process procedure of the wiring variation calculation apparatus 201 according to the first embodiment. [Figure 11] FIG. 11 is a flowchart (part 1) illustrating an example of a specific processing procedure of the fitting equation creation processing. [Figure 12] FIG. 12 is a flowchart (part 2) illustrating an example of a specific processing procedure of the fitting equation creation processing. [Figure 13] FIG. 13 is a flowchart illustrating an example of a specific processing procedure of the data set selection process. [Figure 14] FIG. 14 is a flowchart illustrating an example of a specific processing procedure of the simulation process. [Figure 15] FIG. 15 is a flowchart showing an example of a specific processing procedure of the frequency measurement simulation. [Figure 16] FIG. 16 is a flowchart illustrating an example of a specific processing procedure of the wiring variation estimation processing. [Figure 17] FIG. 17 is a flowchart (part 1) illustrating an example of a specific processing procedure of the selection process. [Figure 18] FIG. 18 is a second flowchart illustrating an example of a specific processing procedure of the selection process. [Figure 19] FIG. 19 is an explanatory diagram (part 2) showing an example of the circuit configuration of the ROSC. [Figure 20] FIG. 20 is an explanatory diagram showing an implementation example of ROSC wiring. [Figure 21]FIG. 21 is a flowchart of an example of a wiring variation calculation process procedure of the wiring variation calculation apparatus 201 according to the second embodiment. [Figure 22] FIG. 22 is a flowchart (part 1) illustrating an example of a specific processing procedure of the second fitting equation creation process. [Diagram 23] FIG. 23 is a flowchart (part 2) illustrating an example of a specific processing procedure of the second fitting equation creation process. [Figure 24] FIG. 24 is a flowchart illustrating an example of a specific processing procedure of the second simulation processing. [Diagram 25] FIG. 25 is a flowchart illustrating an example of a specific processing procedure of the first feedback processing. [Figure 26] FIG. 26 is a flowchart illustrating an example of a specific processing procedure of the second feedback processing. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0010] DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS Hereinafter, with reference to the drawings, embodiments of a wiring variation calculation method and a wiring variation calculation program according to the present invention will be described in detail.
[0011] (Embodiment 1) Fig. 1 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a wiring variation calculation method according to the first embodiment. In Fig. 1, an information processing device 100 is a computer that calculates wiring variations of a target circuit 101. The target circuit 101 is, for example, an integrated circuit such as an IC (Integrated Circuit), an LSI (Large Scale IC), or an SoC (System on Chip).
[0012] Conventionally, in integrated circuits, thick and long wiring is often used for buses and clocks, but the longer the wiring, the greater the effect of variation, making it difficult to ensure yield. If the variation in the wiring of an integrated circuit can be estimated and appropriate measures can be taken according to the variation in the wiring, it can lead to improved yield.
[0013] In the prior art (hereinafter referred to as "Prior Art 1"), multiple ROSCs (ring oscillators), each consisting of a different gate element, are built into an integrated circuit, and the ROSC to be driven can be switched by an EN signal (see, for example, Patent Document 1). A test load of the same structure is connected to each ROSC.
[0014] The test load can be switched between direct short-circuit connection (wiring load disabled, FEOL (Front End Of Line) mode) and wiring load enabled (BEOL (Back End Of Line) mode). In conventional technology 1, for each ROSC, a model formula "Y ij =(1+F i )×(1+a×B j )" is defined.
[0015] Y ij is the propagation delay of ROSC. F i is a FEOL parameter. FEOL parameters, for example, represent the speed of a transistor. B j is a BEOL parameter. The BEOL parameter represents, for example, either the wiring capacitance or the wiring resistance. a is a coefficient that sets the degree of influence of the BEOL parameter.
[0016] For example, in FEOL mode, when the wiring capacitance increases or decreases by 25%, the propagation delay time of ROSC increases or decreases by 6%. In this case, a is 6% / 25%=0.24. In the same way, a can be obtained for BEOL mode. As a result, two linear equations with different values of a are obtained, and Fi and Bi for each ROSC can be obtained by solving the simultaneous linear equations.
[0017] Another conventional technique (hereinafter referred to as "Conventional Technique 2") incorporates two types of ROSC with different wiring lengths into an integrated circuit. In Conventional Technique 2, the propagation delay time T d For example, "T d=R gout ×(a×C int ×L int +a×C gin )+R int ×L int ×(c×C int ×L int +a×C gin )"
[0018] Here, R gout is the output resistance of the gate element. C int is the wiring capacitance. L int is the wire length. C gin is the input capacitance of the gate element. a and c are coefficients for correcting errors with SPICE (Simulation Program with Integrated Circuit Emphasis). R gout , C gin , C int , L int , R int is known.
[0019] In conventional technology 2, ROSCs with different wiring lengths are incorporated, so the wiring capacitance (C int ×L int ) and wiring resistance (R int ×L int ) are different coefficients. C line =C int ×L int , R line =R int ×L int If we rewrite the equation as "T d =R gout ×a×(C line +C gin )+R line ×(c×C line +a×C gin )" which is a linear equation with a and c as variables.
[0020] Propagation delay time T d is obtained from the actual measured ROSC frequency. Also, C line and R lineSince the values of a and c are different, simultaneous linear equations can be solved. This makes it possible to determine the values of coefficients a and c for correcting errors with SPICE. For prior art 2, see, for example, Japanese Patent Application Laid-Open No. 2000-298683.
[0021] However, the propagation delay time of the wiring is determined by the product of the resistance and capacitance components. Therefore, even if the same frequency (propagation delay time) is measured, the ratio of the resistance and capacitance components may differ. With conventional technology, it is not possible to determine the distribution of the resistance and capacitance components of the wiring variation.
[0022] For this reason, in the conventional technology, it is not possible to determine whether the propagation delay time is influenced by the resistance component or the capacitance component, or whether it is both the resistance component and the capacitance component. For example, in conventional technology 2, even if the ratio of the resistance component and the capacitance component can be calculated, the resistance component and the capacitance component of the gate element are included, and it is not possible to estimate only the resistance component and the capacitance component of the wiring. If the wiring variation cannot be separated into the resistance component and the capacitance component, it is difficult to take appropriate measures according to the variation of the wiring.
[0023] Therefore, in the first embodiment, a wiring variation calculation method capable of separating the wiring variation into a resistance component and a capacitance component will be described. Here, a processing example (corresponding to the following (1) to (3)) of the information processing device 100 will be described.
[0024] (1) The information processing device 100 obtains a first equation 120 for a first ROSC 102 among a plurality of ROSCs with different driving powers that are arranged on the same chip 110 as a target circuit 101 that is the subject of wiring variation estimation. The chip 110 is a substrate for forming the target circuit 101.
[0025] A ROSC (ring oscillator) is an oscillator circuit that oscillates by utilizing the propagation delay of a gate element such as an inverter. The multiple ROSCs are, for example, a first ROSC 102 and a second ROSC 103. The driving force of the first ROSC 102 is greater than the driving force of the second ROSC 103. The first ROSC 102 and the second ROSC 103 have different driving forces, and therefore have different propagation delay times.
[0026] The first equation 120 expresses the frequency of the first ROSC 102 under a predetermined condition, with the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation as variables. The frequency corresponds to the propagation delay time. The predetermined condition is, for example, a condition regarding the drive voltage (VDD) and the environmental temperature. The resistance component of the wiring variation is, for example, the wiring resistance per unit length. Also, the capacitance component of the wiring variation is, for example, the wiring capacitance per unit length.
[0027] For example, the first equation 120 defines the natural logarithm of the frequency of the first ROSC 102 as Y, and the resistance component of the wiring variation (R line ) is the inverse of G line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C line Let a1, b1, and d1 be constants, and then Y = a1 × G line +b1×C line +d1'.
[0028] (2) The information processing device 100 obtains a second equation 130 for the second ROSC 103. The second equation 130 expresses the frequency of the second ROSC 103 under a predetermined condition, using the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation as variables.
[0029] For example, the second equation 130 defines the natural logarithm of the frequency of the second ROSC 103 as Y, and the resistance component of the wiring variation (R line ) is the inverse of G line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C line Let a2, b2, and d2 be constants, and then Y = a2 × G line +b2×C line +d2'.
[0030] (3) The information processing device 100 calculates the resistance component and the capacitance component of the wiring variation based on the frequency of the first ROSC 102 actually measured under predetermined conditions and the frequency of the second ROSC 103 actually measured under predetermined conditions using the first equation 120 and the second equation 130. Since the first ROSC 102 and the second ROSC 103 are on the same chip 110 as the target circuit 101, it can be said that the wiring variation is the same as that of the target circuit 101.
[0031] By substituting the actually measured frequency of each ROSC (first ROSC 102, second ROSC 103) into each equation (first equation 120, second equation 130), two equations (for two ROSCs) are generated for two variables (resistance component, capacitance component). The information processing device 100 can obtain the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation by solving the simultaneous linear equations.
[0032] In this way, the wiring variation can be separated into a resistance component and a capacitance component according to the information processing device 100. For example, the information processing device 100 can calculate the wiring variation separated into a resistance component and a capacitance component by using the behavior of the first ROSC 102 and the second ROSC 103 on the same chip 110 as the target circuit 101.
[0033] This allows the information processing device 100 to easily take appropriate measures according to the variation of the wiring. For example, a designer can refer to the resistance component and capacitance component of the variation of the wiring and take measures according to the variation of the wiring, thereby improving the yield of an integrated circuit (for example, the target circuit 101).
[0034] (System configuration example of estimation system 200) Next, a system configuration example of an estimation system 200 including the information processing device 100 shown in Fig. 1 will be described. Here, a case where the information processing device 100 shown in Fig. 1 is applied to a wiring variation calculation device 201 in the estimation system 200 will be described as an example.
[0035] Fig. 2 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a system configuration of an estimation system 200. In Fig. 2, the estimation system 200 includes a wiring variation calculation device 201 and a chip 202. In the estimation system 200, the wiring variation calculation device 201 and the chip 202 are connected via a wired or wireless network.
[0036] Here, the wiring variation calculation device 201 is a computer that calculates the wiring variation of an integrated circuit 203. The integrated circuit 203 is a circuit that is a target for estimating wiring variations. The wiring variation calculation device 201 may be, for example, a server or a PC (Personal Computer).
[0037] The chip 202 includes an integrated circuit 203, a ROSC group 204, and a memory 205. The ROSC group 204 includes a plurality of ROSCs with different driving powers. An example of the circuit configuration of the ROSC will be described later with reference to FIG. 4, for example. The memory 205 is a storage device that stores constants of the fitting equation. The fitting equation corresponds to, for example, the first equation 120 and the second equation 130 shown in FIG. 1.
[0038] In the estimation system 200, the chip 202 is placed in a thermostatic chamber 210. The thermostatic chamber 210 is an apparatus capable of maintaining a constant temperature for a long period of time. By placing the chip 202 in the thermostatic chamber 210, the chip 202 can be kept at the same temperature (environmental temperature) as during a simulation (a frequency measurement simulation to be described later).
[0039] (Example of Hardware Configuration of Wiring Variation Calculation Device 201) Next, an example of the hardware configuration of the wiring variation calculation device 201 will be described.
[0040] Fig. 3 is a block diagram showing an example of a hardware configuration of the wiring variation calculation device 201. In Fig. 3, the wiring variation calculation device 201 has a CPU (Central Processing Unit) 301, a memory 302, a disk drive 303, a disk 304, a communication I / F (Interface) 305, a portable recording medium I / F 306, and a portable recording medium 307. In addition, each component is connected to each other by a bus 300.
[0041] Here, the CPU 301 controls the entire wiring variation calculation device 201. The CPU 301 may have multiple cores. The memory 302 includes, for example, a read only memory (ROM), a random access memory (RAM), and a flash ROM. Specifically, for example, the flash ROM stores an OS program, the ROM stores an application program, and the RAM is used as a work area for the CPU 301. The programs stored in the memory 302 are loaded into the CPU 301 to cause the CPU 301 to execute the coded processing.
[0042] The disk drive 303 controls reading / writing data from / to the disk 304 under the control of the CPU 301. The disk 304 stores data written under the control of the disk drive 303. The disk 304 is, for example, a magnetic disk, an optical disk, or the like.
[0043] The communication I / F 305 is connected to a network through a communication line, and is connected to an external computer through the network. The communication I / F 305 manages the interface between the network and the inside of the device, and controls input and output of data from the external computer. The network is, for example, the Internet, a LAN (Local Area Network), or a WAN (Wide Area Network).
[0044] The portable recording medium I / F 306 controls reading / writing of data from / to the portable recording medium 307 under the control of the CPU 301. The portable recording medium 307 stores data written under the control of the portable recording medium I / F 306. The portable recording medium 307 is, for example, a CD (Compact Disc)-ROM, a DVD (Digital Versatile Disk), or a USB (Universal Serial Bus) memory.
[0045] In addition to the above-mentioned components, the wiring variation calculation device 201 may have, for example, an input device, a display, etc. Also, the wiring variation calculation device 201 may not have, for example, the portable recording medium I / F 306 and the portable recording medium 307 among the above-mentioned components.
[0046] (ROSC circuit configuration example) Next, an example of the circuit configuration of the ROSC will be described with reference to FIG.
[0047] Fig. 4 is an explanatory diagram (part 1) showing an example of the circuit configuration of an ROSC. In Fig. 4, ROSC#A and #B are examples of ROSCs included in the ROSC group 204 shown in Fig. 2. ROSC#A is a ring oscillator with driving force A. ROSC#B is a ring oscillator with driving force B. The magnitude relationship of the driving forces is "driving force A>driving force B".
[0048] The first stage NAND gate of each ROSC#A, #B is for controlling the oscillation of each ROSC#A, #B with the EN signal. However, if oscillation control is not performed, the first stage NAND gate is not necessary. If the oscillation control NAND gate is not used, ROSC will not oscillate, so the gate elements that make up ROSC are set to (2N+1) stages.
[0049] Each ROSC#A,#B is composed of 2N stages of gate elements (N is any natural number). Here, it is composed of INVERTER gates, but it may be composed of any gate element (for example, NOR gates, NAND gates, etc.). When using gate elements with two or more inputs, connect free pins to Lo or Hi so that the signal is propagated inverted.
[0050] The final stage gate element of each ROSC#A,#B is a driver for driving terminal X, which connects a measurement circuit (e.g., an oscilloscope). ROSC#A,#B should be wired long enough so that the propagation delay time of the wiring becomes dominant (e.g., the same length as the clock wiring or bus wiring). When targeting the wiring on upper layers, care should be taken to ensure that the wiring resistance on lower layers is sufficiently small. Also, care should be taken to ensure that the wiring structure of each ROSC#A,#B is as similar as possible (e.g., use the same number of vias).
[0051] (Example of Functional Configuration of Wiring Variation Calculation Device 201) Next, an example of a functional configuration of the wiring variation calculation device 201 according to the first embodiment will be described with reference to FIG.
[0052] Fig. 5 is a block diagram showing an example of a functional configuration of the wiring variation calculation device 201. In Fig. 5, the wiring variation calculation device 201 includes an acquisition unit 501, a creation unit 502, a calculation unit 503, an estimation unit 504, and an output unit 505. The acquisition unit 501 to the output unit 505 are functions of the control unit 500, and specifically, the functions are realized by causing the CPU 301 to execute a program stored in a storage device such as the memory 302, the disk 304, or the portable recording medium 307 shown in Fig. 3, or by the communication I / F 305. The processing results of each functional unit are stored in a storage device such as the memory 302 or the disk 304.
[0053] The acquisition unit 501 acquires first frequency data related to a first ROSC. Here, the first ROSC is one of a plurality of ROSCs with different driving powers arranged on the same chip as a target circuit for estimating wiring variations. The first ROSC is, for example, ROSC#A shown in FIG. 4.
[0054] The first frequency data indicates a frequency of the first ROSC obtained by performing a frequency measurement simulation. The frequency measurement simulation is a simulation for measuring the frequency of the ROSC. The first frequency data indicates a frequency of the first ROSC measured by performing a frequency measurement simulation while changing transistor variations and wiring variations under a predetermined condition.
[0055] The predetermined conditions are, for example, conditions regarding the drive voltage (VDD) and the environmental temperature. The transistor variation is represented, for example, by the variation in the threshold voltage Vth of the transistor. The wiring variation is represented by a resistance component and a capacitance component. The resistance component is, for example, the wiring resistance per unit length. The capacitance component is, for example, the wiring capacitance per unit length. The first frequency data indicates the frequency of the first ROSC under various conditions (drive voltage, environmental temperature, transistor variation, wiring variation).
[0056] The acquiring unit 501 also acquires second frequency data related to a second ROSC. Here, the second ROSC is a ROSC different from the first ROSC among a plurality of ROSCs with different driving powers arranged on the same chip as the target circuit for which the wiring variation is to be estimated. The second ROSC is, for example, ROSC#B shown in FIG. 4.
[0057] The second frequency data indicates the frequency of the second ROSC obtained by performing a frequency measurement simulation. The second frequency data indicates the frequency of the second ROSC measured by performing a frequency measurement simulation while changing the transistor variation and the wiring variation under a predetermined condition. The second frequency data indicates the frequency of the second ROSC under various conditions.
[0058] The first frequency data and the second frequency data are acquired by, for example, executing a frequency measurement simulation by the wiring variation calculation device 201.
[0059] The acquiring unit 501 may acquire the first frequency data and the second frequency data, for example, by a user's operational input using an input device (not shown) or by receiving the data from another computer.
[0060] In the following description, the integrated circuit 203 shown in FIG. 2 may be used as an example of a target circuit for estimating wiring variations. ROSC#A shown in FIG. 4 may be used as an example of the first ROSC. ROSC#B shown in FIG. 4 may be used as an example of the second ROSC. A frequency data group that compiles the frequency measurement results of ROSC#A and #B at the same driving voltage and the same environmental temperature among the frequency measurement results of a frequency measurement simulation executed under various conditions (driving voltage, environmental temperature, transistor variation, wiring variation) may be referred to as a "data set." A specific example of the data set will be described later with reference to FIG. 6.
[0061] The creation unit 502 creates a first fitting equation that expresses the frequency of ROSC#A under a predetermined condition, using the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation as variables. The predetermined condition is, for example, a condition regarding the drive voltage (VDD) and the environmental temperature. The first fitting equation corresponds to, for example, the first equation 120 shown in FIG. 1.
[0062] The first fitting formula is expressed by, for example, the following formula (1). Here, Y is a variable representing the natural logarithm of the frequency of ROSC#A. line is the resistance component of the wiring variation (R line ) is a variable that represents the reciprocal of C line is a variable representing the capacitance component of the wiring variation. a1, b1, and d1 are constants.
[0063] Y=a1×G line +b1×C line +d1 (1)
[0064] Specifically, for example, the creation unit 502 creates a first fitting equation by determining constants a1, b1, and d1 by linear multiple regression analysis based on the acquired first frequency data (data set) so as to satisfy the above formula (1). An example of creating the first fitting equation will be described later with reference to Figs. 6 and 7.
[0065] The constants a1, b1, and d1 of the created first fitting equation are stored in, for example, the memory 205 shown in FIG.
[0066] The creation unit 502 creates a second fitting equation for ROSC#B, which expresses the frequency of ROSC#B under a predetermined condition, using the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation as variables. The predetermined condition is, for example, a condition regarding the drive voltage (VDD) and the environmental temperature. The second fitting equation corresponds to, for example, the second equation 130 shown in FIG. 1.
[0067] The second fitting formula is expressed by, for example, the following formula (2). Here, Y is a variable representing the natural logarithm of the frequency of ROSC#B. line is the resistance component of the wiring variation (R line ) is a variable that represents the reciprocal of C line are variables that represent the capacitance components of the wiring variations. a2, b2, and d2 are constants.
[0068] Y = a2 × Gline +b2×C line +d2 (2)
[0069] Specifically, for example, the creation unit 502 creates the second fitting equation by determining the constants a2, b2, and d2 by linear multiple regression analysis based on the acquired second frequency data (data set) so as to satisfy the above formula (2). An example of creating the second fitting equation will be described later with reference to Figs. 6 and 7.
[0070] The constants a2, b2, and d2 of the created second fitting equation are stored in, for example, the memory 205 shown in FIG.
[0071] The generating unit 502 may select a data set used to generate the first and second fitting equations from data sets under various conditions (driving voltage, environmental temperature, transistor variation, wiring variation).
[0072] Specifically, for example, the generating unit 502 generates a frequency f TT Based on the frequency of SS and FF (f SS , f FF ) (i.e., f SS / f TT -1, f FF / f TT -1). TT means that the Vth of nMOSFET and pMOSFET is typical. SS means that the Vth of nMOSFET and pMOSFET varies toward the higher side. FF means that the Vth of nMOSFET and pMOSFET varies toward the lower side.
[0073] Then, the creation unit 502 judges whether the maximum absolute value of the frequency ratio is within a predetermined limit value. If the maximum absolute value of the frequency ratio exceeds the limit value, the creation unit 502 selects a data set with a drive voltage (VDD) higher than the current one, and identifies a data set that falls within the limit value. The creation unit 502 then selects the identified data set as a data set to be used in creating the first and second fitting equations.
[0074] In addition, although the first and second fitting equations are created in the wiring variation calculation device 201 here, this is not limiting. For example, the creation unit 502 may obtain the first and second fitting equations that have been created in advance by a user's operation input using an input device (not shown) or by receiving them from another computer.
[0075] The acquisition unit 501 also acquires the frequencies of each of ROSC #A and #B actually measured under predetermined conditions. The predetermined conditions are, for example, conditions regarding the drive voltage (VDD) and the environmental temperature, and are the same as the conditions when a frequency measurement simulation is performed to measure the frequencies of each of ROSC #A and #B.
[0076] 2 at the same temperature as that during the frequency measurement simulation, applies VDD to the chip 202, and measures the frequency of each of ROSC#A and #B. VDD is the same drive voltage as that during the frequency measurement simulation (for example, the drive voltage when the frequency indicated by the first frequency data used to create the first fitting equation is measured).
[0077] In this embodiment, the frequencies of ROSC#A, #B are actually measured in the wiring variation calculation device 201, but this is not limiting. For example, the creation unit 502 may obtain the frequencies of ROSC#A, #B actually measured under a predetermined condition by a user's operation input using an input device (not shown) or by receiving the frequencies from another computer.
[0078] The calculation unit 503 uses the first fitting equation and the second fitting equation to calculate the resistance component and the capacitance component of the wiring variation based on the frequency of ROSC#A actually measured under specified conditions and the frequency of ROSC#B actually measured under specified conditions.
[0079] Specifically, for example, the calculation unit 503 substitutes the actually measured frequency of ROSC#A into Y in the above formula (1) to obtain R line and C line In addition, the calculation unit 503 substitutes the actually measured frequency of ROSC#B for Y in the above formula (2) to create a linear equation with R line and C line Create a linear equation with variables. Note that G included in the above equations (1) and (2) line is R line The calculation unit 503 then solves the created simultaneous linear equations (two linear equations) to obtain R line and C line The value of can be calculated.
[0080] Resistance component R of wiring variation line and the capacitance component C line A calculation example of will be described later with reference to FIG.
[0081] The estimation unit 504 estimates the degree of wiring variation based on the calculated resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation, the standard deviation and average value of the wiring resistance, and the standard deviation and average value of the wiring capacitance. Here, the standard deviation and average value of the wiring resistance and the standard deviation and average value of the wiring capacitance can be obtained from statistical data provided by a foundry (contract manufacturing factory), for example.
[0082] Integrated circuit foundries keep statistical data on the variations in wiring resistance and capacitance, and often publish the maximum, minimum, average, and standard deviation of the wiring resistance and capacitance per unit length for each wiring layer for LSI designers and developers.
[0083] For example, let us assume that the typical (average) wiring resistance per ROSC stage is 2.2 kΩ and the wiring capacitance is 35 fF, which can be obtained from statistical data provided by the foundry. Similarly, let us assume that the standard deviation of the wiring resistance per ROSC stage is 0.4 kΩ and the standard deviation of the wiring capacitance is 2.8 fF.
[0084] Here, wiring resistance and capacitance values that are 1σ larger than typical are calculated by "typical + standard deviation." Wiring resistance and capacitance values that are 2σ larger than typical are calculated by "typical + 2 x standard deviation." Wiring resistance and capacitance values that are 1σ smaller than typical are calculated by "typical - standard deviation." Wiring resistance and capacitance values that are 2σ smaller than typical are calculated by "typical - 2 x standard deviation."
[0085] For example, a value 1σ larger than typical would result in a wiring resistance of 2.6 kΩ and a wiring capacitance of 38 fF. Similarly, a value 1σ smaller than typical would result in a wiring resistance of 1.8 kΩ and a wiring capacitance of 32 fF.
[0086] Let us assume that the wiring resistance per stage is calculated as 4.8 kΩ as the resistance component of the wiring variation, and the wiring capacitance per stage is calculated as 24.3 fF as the capacitance component of the wiring variation. Here, the typical wiring resistance is 2.2 kΩ. The value of 4.8 kΩ is 2.6 kΩ away from the average in the larger direction.
[0087] The standard deviation of the wiring resistance is 0.4 kΩ. Therefore, the estimation unit 504 estimates that the wiring resistance varies from +6.5σtypical to the larger side. Similarly, when the variation of the wiring capacitance is calculated, the estimation unit 504 can estimate that the variation varies from -3.8σtypical to the smaller side.
[0088] The output unit 505 outputs the calculated resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation. Specifically, for example, the output unit 505 outputs R line (resistance component) and C line The output format of the output unit 505 may be, for example, storage in a storage device such as the memory 302 or the disk 304, transmission to another computer via the communication I / F 305, display on a display (not shown), or print output on a printer (not shown).
[0089] The output unit 505 may output the estimated result. Specifically, for example, the output unit 505 may output the estimated result indicating the degree of variation in the wiring variation in association with the product name or serial number of the target circuit (integrated circuit 203).
[0090] (Example of a data set) Next, a specific example of a data set will be described with reference to FIG.
[0091] FIG. 6 is an explanatory diagram showing a specific example of a data set. In FIG. 6, a data set 600 shows the results of a simulation of measuring the frequencies of ROSCs #A and #B. The data set 600 is obtained by setting the drive voltage VDD to "VDD=0.9 [V]" and the environmental temperature T to "T=25 [° C.]" and calculating the variation Tr of the threshold voltage Vth of the transistor. v [σ] and wiring variation (G line [S], C line The figure shows the results of simulating the frequency of each ROSC #A and #B using SPICE while changing the frequency (fF) of the ROSC. The wiring variation is the value per ROSC stage.
[0092] For example, VDD=0.9[V], T=25[℃], Tr v =-2.5[σ], G line =4.53E-04[S], C line=3.48E+01[fF]', the frequency of ROSC#A is '1.04E+09[Hz]' and the frequency of ROSC#B is '9.88E+08[Hz]'.
[0093] The creation unit 502 creates a first fitting equation for the case where "VDD = 0.9 [V], T = 25 [°C]" by, for example, determining the constants a1, b1, and d1 by linear multiple regression analysis based on the data set 600 so as to satisfy the above equation (1).
[0094] In addition, the creation unit 502 creates a second fitting equation for the case where "VDD = 0.9 [V], T = 25 [°C]" by, for example, determining the constants a2, b2, and d2 by linear multiple regression analysis based on the data set 600 so as to satisfy the above equation (2).
[0095] In addition, Tr is also used as a coefficient of the fitting equation. v In this case, it is assumed that the data set 600 has the frequency fluctuation of each of ROSC #A and #B relative to the variation in the threshold voltage Vth of the transistor within the limit value. In this case, Tr v The coefficients corresponding to any pair of Tr can be ignored. v The coefficients of each fitting equation may be obtained by selecting data (for example, 0σ) and performing multiple linear regression analysis.
[0096] Here, the fitting information for specifying the created first and second fitting equations will be described with reference to FIG.
[0097] Fig. 7 is an explanatory diagram showing a specific example of fitting information. In Fig. 7, fitting information 700 indicates the values of the constants (a, b, d) of the fitting equations of each of ROSCs #A and #B. The fitting information 700 is stored, for example, in the memory 205 shown in Fig. 2.
[0098] Here, the constants (a1, b1, d1) in the first fitting equation for ROSC#A are "a1=10221.61, b1=-0.23, d1=24.16", and the constants (a2, b2, d2) in the second fitting equation for ROSC#B are "a2=10862.01, b2=-0.26, d2=24.69".
[0099] The first fitting equation is the following equation (3): Moreover, the second fitting equation is the following equation (4):
[0100] Y=10221.61×G line +(-0.23)×C line +24.16 …(3) Y=10862.01×G line +(-0.26)×C line +24.69 …(4)
[0101] Here, assume that the frequencies of ROSC#A and #B actually measured at a drive voltage of 0.9 [V] and an environmental temperature of 25 [°C] are 965 [MHz] and 903 [MHz], respectively.
[0102] In this case, the calculation unit 503 creates a linear equation such as the following equation (5) by substituting the frequency of ROSC#A "965 [MHz]" into the above equation (3). The calculation unit 503 also creates a linear equation such as the following equation (6) by substituting the frequency of ROSC#B "903 [MHz]" into the above equation (4).
[0103] ln(965×10 6 )=10221.61×G line +(-0.23)×C line +24.16 …(5)
[0104] ln(903×10 6 )=10862.01×G line +(-0.26)×C line +24.69 …(6)
[0105] The calculation unit 503 calculates G by solving the simultaneous linear equations (5) and (6). line (i.e., R line ) and C line Here, we can obtain G line "G line = 2.07 × 10-4 [S]. Therefore, R line "R line = 4.83 [kΩ]. Also, C line "C line =24.3[fF]".
[0106] As a result, the calculation unit 503 calculates the resistance component of the wiring variation (R line =4.83[kΩ]) and capacitance component (C line = 24.3 [fF]).
[0107] (Example of wiring variation estimation) Next, an example of estimating wiring variation (degree) will be described with reference to FIG. 8A and FIG. 8B.
[0108] Fig. 8A is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a resistance variation table. In Fig. 8A, a resistance variation table 801 shows wiring resistance values up to ±2σ of an integrated circuit. Each wiring resistance value is calculated based on statistical data provided by a foundry (a manufacturing contract factory).
[0109] Specifically, for example, the estimation unit 504 estimates the standard deviation σ of the wiring resistance based on statistical data provided by the foundry. R , average value Typ R Then, the estimation unit 504 calculates the calculated standard deviation σ R , average value Typ R For example, the value of +2σ wiring resistance is calculated by "Typ R +2×σ R " Also, the value of the -2σ wiring resistance is "Typ R -2×σ R "
[0110] 8B is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a capacitance variation table. In FIG. 8B, a capacitance variation table 802 shows values of wiring capacitance up to ±2σ of an integrated circuit. Each wiring capacitance value is calculated based on statistical data provided by a foundry.
[0111] Specifically, for example, the estimation unit 504 calculates the standard deviation σ of the wiring capacitance based on statistical data provided by the foundry. C , average value Typ C Then, the estimation unit 504 calculates the calculated standard deviation σ C , average value Typ C For example, the value of the +2σ wiring capacitance is calculated by "Typ C +2×σ C " Also, the value of the wiring capacitance of -2σ is "Typ C -2×σ C "
[0112] For example, the estimation unit 504 refers to the resistance variation table 801 and calculates the calculated resistance component (R line =4.83 [kΩ]), the estimation unit 504 estimates the degree of variation in the wiring resistance. In addition, the estimation unit 504 refers to the capacitance variation table 802 and calculates the calculated capacitance component (C line = 24.3 [fF]), estimate the degree of variation in wiring capacitance.
[0113] Here, let us assume that the typical (average) wiring resistance per ROSC stage is 2.2 [kΩ], the wiring capacitance is 35 [fF], the standard deviation of the wiring resistance per ROSC stage is 0.4 [kΩ], and the standard deviation of the wiring capacitance is 2.8 [fF].
[0114] In this case, the value of the +1σ wiring resistance is 2.6 [kΩ]. The value of the +2σ wiring capacitance is 40.6 [fF]. The calculated resistance component is "R line = 4.83 [kΩ]. For this reason, the estimation unit 504 may estimate that the wiring resistance varies in a direction larger than +2σ, for example.
[0115] The value of the wiring capacitance of -1σ is 32.2 [fF]. The value of the wiring capacitance of -2σ is 29.4 [fF]. The calculated capacitance components are "C line = 24.3 [fF]. For this reason, the estimation unit 504 may estimate that the wiring capacitance varies in a direction smaller than -2σ.
[0116] (Other system configuration examples) Next, another example of the system configuration of the estimation system 200 will be described with reference to FIG.
[0117] 9 is an explanatory diagram showing another example of the system configuration of the estimation system 200. In FIG. 9, the estimation system 200 includes a wiring variation calculation device 201 and a wafer 901. The wafer 901 includes a plurality of chips (e.g., chips 902 and 903). Each chip on the wafer 901 corresponds to, for example, the chip 202 shown in FIG. 2.
[0118] The wafer 901 is placed in a thermostatic chamber 910. The thermostatic chamber 910 is an apparatus capable of keeping the temperature constant for a long period of time, similar to the thermostatic chamber 210 shown in FIG.
[0119] In the estimation system 200, a wiring variation calculation device 201 is connected to each chip on a wafer 901 via a wired or wireless network. Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can calculate the resistance component and the capacitance component of the wiring variation for each chip on the wafer 901, similarly to the chip 202 shown in FIG.
[0120] (Wiring Variation Calculation Processing Procedure of Wiring Variation Calculation Device 201) Next, a wiring variation calculation process procedure of the wiring variation calculation apparatus 201 according to the first embodiment will be described.
[0121] Fig. 10 is a flowchart showing an example of a wiring variation calculation process procedure of the wiring variation calculation device 201 according to the first embodiment. In the flowchart of Fig. 10, first, the wiring variation calculation device 201 executes a fitting equation creation process (step S1001). The fitting equation creation process is a process for creating fitting equations (first fitting equation, second fitting equation) for each ROSC #A, #B. A specific process procedure of the fitting equation creation process will be described later with reference to Figs. 11 and 12.
[0122] Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 actually measures the frequency of each of ROSC #A, #B (step S1002). Specifically, for example, the wiring variation calculation device 201 keeps the thermostatic chamber 210 at the same temperature as during the frequency measurement simulation, applies VDD (a value of a data set selected in a data set selection process shown in FIG. 13 described later) to the chip 202, and measures the frequency of each of ROSC #A, #B.
[0123] Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 creates simultaneous linear equations by substituting the actually measured frequencies of each ROSC #A, #B into the fitting equations for each ROSC #A, #B that have been created (step S1003). Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 solves the created simultaneous linear equations to obtain the resistance component R line and the capacitance component C line The value of is calculated (step S1004).
[0124] Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 executes a wiring variation estimation process to estimate the degree of the wiring variation (step S1005). A specific processing procedure of the wiring variation estimation process will be described later with reference to FIG.
[0125] Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 executes a selection process for determining whether the integrated circuits 203 on the chip 202 are non-defective (step S1006), and ends the series of processes according to this flowchart. A specific processing procedure of the selection process will be described later with reference to FIGS. 17 and 18.
[0126] This enables the wiring variation calculation device 201 to separate the wiring variation into a resistance component and a capacitance component, and estimate the degree of the variation in the wiring of the integrated circuit 203.
[0127] Next, a specific procedure of the fitting equation creation process in step S1001 shown in FIG. 10 will be described with reference to FIG. 11 and FIG.
[0128] 11 and 12 are flowcharts showing an example of a specific processing procedure of the fitting equation creation processing. In the flowchart of Fig. 11, first, the wiring variation calculation device 201 executes a data set selection processing (step S1101). A specific processing procedure of the data set selection processing will be described later with reference to Fig. 13.
[0129] The data set is a group of frequency data that compiles the frequency measurement results of ROSC#A and #B at the same drive voltage and the same environmental temperature from the frequency measurement results of a frequency measurement simulation performed under various conditions (drive voltage, environmental temperature, transistor variation, wiring variation).
[0130] Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 judges whether or not the frequency difference between ROSC#A and #B is sufficient for the selected data set (step S1102). For example, the wiring variation calculation device 201 judges that the frequency difference is sufficient when the frequency difference between ROSC#A and #B is equal to or greater than a threshold value.
[0131] Here, if the frequency difference between ROSC #A and #B is sufficient (step S1102: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 selects the unselected driving force from driving forces A and B (step S1103). Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 calculates the frequency f of the ROSC of the driving force Y selected. ROSC The natural logarithm of is taken (step S1104).
[0132] Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 calculates "Y=a×G line +b×C line +d" is satisfied by calculating the constants a, b, and d by linear multiple regression analysis (step S1105). Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 stores the calculated constants a, b, and d in the memory 205 in association with the ROSC of the selected driving force (step S1106).
[0133] Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 determines whether or not there is an unselected driving force among the driving forces A and B (step S1107). If there is an unselected driving force (step S1107: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 returns to step S1103.
[0134] On the other hand, if there is no unselected driving force (step S1107: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 returns to the step where the fitting equation creation process was called.
[0135] Furthermore, in step S1102, if the frequency difference between ROSC #A and #B is not sufficient (step S1102: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 proceeds to step S1201 shown in FIG.
[0136] 12, first, the wiring variation calculation device 201 adjusts the driving force of ROSC#A or ROSC#B (step S1201). For example, the wiring variation calculation device 201 may increase the driving force of ROSC#A. Also, the wiring variation calculation device 201 may decrease the driving force of ROSC#B.
[0137] Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 executes a data set selection process (step S1202). A specific procedure of the data set selection process will be described later with reference to Fig. 13. Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 determines whether or not the frequency difference between ROSC#A and #B is sufficient for the selected data set (step S1203).
[0138] Here, if the frequency difference between ROSC #A and #B is sufficient (step S1203: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 selects the unselected driving force from driving forces A and B (step S1204). Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 calculates the frequency f of the ROSC of the driving force that selected Y. ROSC The natural logarithm of is taken (step S1205).
[0139] Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 calculates "Y=a×G line +b×C line +d" is satisfied by calculating the constants a, b, and d by linear multiple regression analysis (step S1206). Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 stores the calculated constants a, b, and d in the memory 205 in association with the ROSC of the selected driving force (step S1207).
[0140] Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 determines whether or not there is an unselected driving force among the driving forces A and B (step S1208). If there is an unselected driving force (step S1208: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 returns to step S1204.
[0141] On the other hand, if there is no unselected driving force (step S1208: No), the wiring variation calculating device 201 returns to the step where the fitting equation creation process was called.
[0142] In addition, in step S1203, if the frequency difference between ROSC #A and #B is insufficient (step S1203: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 outputs an impossibility error (step S1209) and ends the series of processes. The impossibility error is an error indicating that estimation of the wiring variation cannot be performed.
[0143] As a result, the wiring variation calculation device 201 calculates the resistance component of the wiring variation (G line ) and capacitance component (C line) as variables to create a fitting equation (constants a, b, d) representing the frequencies of each ROSC#A, #B. Also, when the frequency difference between ROSC#A and #B is small, the coefficients of each fitting equation will be close to each other, which may result in a large error when solving the simultaneous linear equations. When the frequency difference between ROSC#A and #B is small, the wiring variation calculation device 201 adjusts the driving force of ROSC#A or ROSC#B to ensure a sufficient frequency difference and reduce the error when solving the simultaneous linear equations.
[0144] Next, a specific procedure of the data set selection process in step S1101 shown in FIG. 11 and step S1201 shown in FIG. 12 will be described with reference to FIG.
[0145] Fig. 13 is a flowchart showing an example of a specific processing procedure of the data set selection process. In the flowchart of Fig. 13, first, the wiring variation calculation device 201 executes a simulation process (step S1301). A specific processing procedure of the simulation process will be described later with reference to Fig. 14.
[0146] Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 extracts an unextracted data set from the data set obtained by the simulation process (step S1302). Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 calculates a frequency f TT Based on the frequency of SS and FF (f SS , f FF ) is calculated (step S1303).
[0147] Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 judges whether the maximum absolute value of the frequency ratio is within the limit value (step S1304). If it is not within the limit value (step S1304: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 extracts a data set with a higher VDD from the data sets (step S1305) and returns to step S1303.
[0148] When VDD is low, the influence of transistor variations becomes large. Therefore, in step S1305, the wiring variation calculation device 201 extracts a data set with a higher VDD from among the data sets. The wiring variation calculation device 201 may search for a data set with the maximum VDD, in which the maximum absolute value of the frequency ratio is within a limit value.
[0149] Furthermore, in step S1304, if the difference is within the limit value (step S1304: Yes), the wiring variation calculating device 201 selects the extracted data set (step S1306), and returns to the step that called the data set selection process.
[0150] This allows the wiring variation calculation device 201 to select a data set in which the frequency fluctuation of each ROSC#A,#B relative to the variation in the threshold voltage Vth of the transistor falls within the allowable range. Note that, if there is no data set in which the maximum value of the absolute value of the frequency ratio falls within the limit value, the wiring variation calculation device 201 may output an impossibility error.
[0151] Next, a specific procedure of the simulation process in step S1301 shown in FIG. 13 will be described with reference to FIG.
[0152] Fig. 14 is a flowchart showing an example of a specific processing procedure of the simulation process. In the flowchart of Fig. 14, first, the wiring variation calculation device 201 selects an unselected driving force from driving forces A and B (step S1401).
[0153] Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 selects an unselected VDD from among the settable VDDs (step S1402). V Unselected Tr among those not selected V (Step S1403). Vis the transistor variation, which is expressed by the variation in the threshold voltage Vth of the transistor.
[0154] Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 calculates the configurable L V Unselected L that has not been selected V (Step S1404). V is the wiring variation, and G line [S], C line [fF]. Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 executes a frequency measurement simulation (step S1405). A specific processing procedure of the frequency measurement simulation will be described later with reference to FIG.
[0155] Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 calculates the configurable L V Unselected L that has not been selected V It is determined whether there is an unselected L (step S1406). V If there is (step S1406: Yes), the wiring variation calculating apparatus 201 returns to step S1404.
[0156] On the other hand, the unselected L V If there is no Tr that can be set (step S1406: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 V Unselected Tr among those not selected V It is determined whether there is an unselected Tr (step S1407). V If there is (step S1407: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 returns to step S1403. V Select again from scratch.
[0157] On the other hand, unselected Tr VIf there is no VDD (step S1407: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 judges whether there is an unselected VDD among the settable VDDs (step S1408). If there is an unselected VDD (step S1408: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 returns to step S1402. In this case, the wiring variation calculation device 201 determines whether there is a VDD that has not been selected in steps S1403 and S1404. V ,L V Select again from scratch.
[0158] On the other hand, if there is no unselected VDD (step S1408: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 determines whether there is an unselected driving force among the driving forces A and B (step S1409). If there is an unselected driving force (step S1409: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 returns to step S1401. In this case, the wiring variation calculation device 201 does not select VDD, Tr in steps S1402, S1403, and S1404. V ,L V Select again from scratch.
[0159] On the other hand, if there is no unselected driving force (step S1409: No), the wiring variation calculating device 201 returns to the step that called the simulation process.
[0160] This allows the wiring variation calculation device 201 to execute a frequency measurement simulation for each of ROSCs #A and #B under various conditions (drive voltage, environmental temperature, transistor variation, wiring variation).
[0161] Next, a specific processing procedure of the frequency measurement simulation in step S1405 shown in FIG. 14 will be described with reference to FIG.
[0162] 15 is a flowchart showing an example of a specific processing procedure of a frequency measurement simulation. In the flowchart of FIG. 15, first, the wiring variation calculation device 201 sets various conditions (step S1501). The various conditions are an environmental temperature: T [° C.], a driving voltage VDD [V], a transistor (threshold voltage Vth) variation Tr, V , wiring variation L V , EN:L[V].
[0163] The environmental temperature T is a predetermined condition. VDD, Tr V and L V is the value selected in steps S1402 to S1403 shown in FIG. V represents the variation in the threshold voltage Vth of the transistor. V is G line [S], C line [fF]. L [V] is the potential at which the logic circuit goes Low.
[0164] Next, the wiring variation calculating device 201 applies a voltage of the terminal EN from L (Low) to H (Hi) (step S1502). As a result, the ROSC of the driving force selected in step S1401 shown in Fig. 14 starts oscillating. Then, the wiring variation calculating device 201 simulates the frequency of the periodic square wave output from the terminal X by SPICE (step S1503), and returns to the step that called the frequency measurement simulation.
[0165] This allows the wiring variation calculation device 201 to obtain the frequency measurement results of each of ROSCs #A and #B (for example, the data set 600 shown in FIG. 6).
[0166] Next, a specific processing procedure of the wiring variation estimation processing in step S1005 shown in FIG. 10 will be described with reference to FIG.
[0167] 16 is a flowchart showing an example of a specific processing procedure of a wiring variation estimation process. In the flowchart of FIG. 16, first, the wiring variation calculation device 201 calculates the standard deviation σ of the wiring variations (wiring resistance, wiring capacitance) based on statistical data provided by a foundry. R ,σ C , average value Typ R ,Typ C is calculated (step S1601).
[0168] Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 calculates the standard deviation σ R ,σ C , average value Typ R ,Typ C Based on this, values up to ±2σ are calculated to create a resistance variation table and a capacitance variation table (step S1602). The resistance variation table is, for example, the resistance variation table 801 shown in Fig. 8A. The capacitance variation table is, for example, the capacitance variation table 802 shown in Fig. 8B.
[0169] Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 refers to the created resistance variation table and capacitance variation table to calculate the resistance component R line and the capacitance component C line Based on the value of , the degree of wiring variation is estimated (step S1603), and the process returns to the step that called the wiring variation estimation process.
[0170] This allows the wiring variation calculation device 201 to estimate the degree of variation in the wiring resistance and wiring capacitance of the integrated circuit 203 .
[0171] Next, a specific processing procedure of the selection processing in step S1006 shown in FIG. 10 will be described with reference to FIG. 17 and FIG.
[0172] 17 and 18 are flowcharts showing an example of a specific processing procedure of the selection process. In the flowchart of Fig. 17, first, the wiring variation calculation device 201 judges whether the variation of C (wiring capacitance) is deviated to the plus side (in the larger direction) from the allowable range based on the estimation result of step S1603 shown in Fig. 16 (step S1701).
[0173] The allowable range can be set arbitrarily, for example, to 2σ, etc. If there is a deviation on the positive side (step S1701: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 determines whether the variation in R (wiring resistance) is deviated on the positive side from the allowable range based on the estimation result (step S1702).
[0174] If there is a deviation on the positive side (step S1702: Yes), the wiring variation calculating device 201 judges the integrated circuit 203 to be defective (step S1703), and the process returns to the step that called the screening process.
[0175] Furthermore, in step S1701, if the variation in C (wiring capacitance) is not greater than the allowable range on the positive side (step S1701: No), the wiring variation calculating device 201 determines whether the variation in R (wiring resistance) is greater than the allowable range on the positive side (step S1704).
[0176] If there is a deviation on the positive side (step S1704: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 judges the integrated circuit 203 to be defective (step S1705) and returns to the step where the selection process was called. On the other hand, if there is no deviation on the positive side (step S1704: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 judges the integrated circuit 203 to be non-defective (step S1706) and returns to the step where the selection process was called.
[0177] Moreover, in step S1702, if the variation in R (wiring resistance) is not deviated from the allowable range to the positive side (step S1702: No), the wiring variation calculating device 201 proceeds to step S1801 shown in FIG.
[0178] 18, first, the wiring variation calculation device 201 checks whether the integrated circuit 203 works (step S1801). If the integrated circuit 203 works (step S1801: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 judges the integrated circuit 203 to be a non-defective product (step S1802) and returns to the step that called the selection process.
[0179] On the other hand, if the integrated circuit 203 does not operate (step S1801: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 boosts the drive voltage VDD (step S1803). It is confirmed whether the integrated circuit 203 operates (step S1804). If the integrated circuit 203 operates (step S1804: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 determines that the integrated circuit 203 is a non-defective product (step S1805) and returns to the step that called the selection process.
[0180] On the other hand, if the integrated circuit 203 does not operate (step S1804: No), the wiring variation calculating device 201 determines that the integrated circuit 203 is defective (step S1806), and returns to the step that called the screening process.
[0181] Thus, the wiring variation calculating device 201 can evaluate the quality of the integrated circuit 203 from the estimation result of the degree of variation in the wiring resistance and wiring capacitance of the integrated circuit 203. Furthermore, even if the variation in C (wiring capacitance) is outside the allowable range, when the variation in R (wiring resistance) is within the allowable range, the wiring variation calculating device 201 can boost VDD and check the operation, thereby preventing the integrated circuit 203 from being erroneously determined to be defective.
[0182] As described above, the wiring variation calculation device 201 according to the first embodiment can obtain the first and second fitting equations for the first and second ROSCs among the multiple ROSCs with different driving powers arranged on the same chip as the target circuit for estimating wiring variations. The first fitting equation expresses the frequency of the first ROSC under a predetermined condition (e.g., power supply voltage, environmental temperature) with the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation as variables for the first ROSC. The second fitting equation expresses the frequency of the second ROSC under a predetermined condition with the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation as variables for the second ROSC. Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can calculate the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation based on the frequency of the first ROSC actually measured under the predetermined condition and the frequency of the second ROSC actually measured under the predetermined condition using the first and second fitting equations. Moreover, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can output the resistance component and capacitance component of the calculated wiring variation.
[0183] This allows the wiring variation calculation device 201 to separate the wiring variation into a resistance component and a capacitance component. For example, a designer can easily take appropriate measures according to the wiring variation by referring to the resistance component and the capacitance component of the wiring variation.
[0184] Moreover, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can estimate the degree of wiring variation based on the calculated resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation, the standard deviation and average value of the wiring resistance, and the standard deviation and average value of the wiring capacitance. Moreover, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can output the estimated degree of wiring variation.
[0185] This allows the wiring variation calculation device 201 to estimate the degree of variation in wiring resistance and wiring capacitance based on statistical values obtained from statistical data provided by a foundry (contract manufacturing factory). For example, a designer can easily determine the quality (whether it is a good product or a defective product) of a target circuit (for example, the integrated circuit 203) from the estimated result of wiring variation.
[0186] Moreover, according to the wiring variation calculation device 201, the fitting formulas (first and second fitting formulas) are calculated by taking the natural logarithm of the frequency of each ROSC (first and second ROSC) as Y, and taking the inverse of the resistance component of the wiring variation as G. line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C line Let a, b, and d be constants. Y=a×G line +b×C line It can be expressed as +d.
[0187] As a result, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can accurately calculate the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation by using a fitting equation constructed taking into account the dependency of the propagation delay time of the wiring on the wiring resistance and wiring capacitance.
[0188] Moreover, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can acquire a data set (first and second frequency data) indicating the frequency obtained by performing a frequency measurement simulation in which the frequency of each ROSC (first and second ROSC) is measured while changing the transistor variation and the wiring variation under predetermined conditions (ambient temperature, driving voltage). Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can calculate Y=a×G based on the acquired data set. line +b×C line Each fitting equation (first and second fitting equations) can be created by determining the constants a, b, and d by linear multiple regression analysis so as to satisfy +d.
[0189] This allows the wiring variation calculation device 201 to create a fitting equation that accurately represents the frequency of each ROSC (first and second ROSC) using the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation as variables.
[0190] (Embodiment 2) Next, a wiring variation calculation device 201 according to a second embodiment will be described. In the second embodiment, a case will be described in which the number of ROSCs is increased to three to expand the variables of the fitting formula. Note that illustrations and descriptions of the same parts as those of the wiring variation calculation device 201 according to the first embodiment will be omitted.
[0191] (ROSC circuit configuration example) First, an example of the circuit configuration of ROSC will be described with reference to FIG.
[0192] Fig. 19 is an explanatory diagram (part 2) showing an example of the circuit configuration of an ROSC. In Fig. 19, ROSC#A, #B, and #C are examples of ROSCs included in the ROSC group 204 shown in Fig. 2. ROSC#A is a ring oscillator with driving force A. ROSC#B is a ring oscillator with driving force B. ROSC#C is a ring oscillator with driving force C. The magnitude relationship of the driving forces is "driving force A>driving force B>driving force C".
[0193] In the following description, the first ROSC of the three ROSCs (first ROSC, second ROSC, and third ROSC) may be described by taking ROSC#A shown in Fig. 19 as an example. The second ROSC may be described by taking ROSC#B shown in Fig. 19 as an example. The third ROSC may be described by taking ROSC#C shown in Fig. 19 as an example.
[0194] Here, the wiring structure of each of ROSCs #A, #B, and #C will be described with reference to FIG.
[0195] Fig. 20 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of ROSC wiring implementation. In Fig. 20, a wiring structure 2000 shows an example of the wiring structure of ROSC (ROSC #A, #B, #C). In the wiring structure 2000, wiring adjacent to the signal wiring that propagates a signal is surrounded by wiring fixed to the GND potential. The upper and lower layers of the signal wiring are also covered by wiring fixed to the GND potential.
[0196] The assumed wiring (the wiring for which the variation is estimated) is a wiring with a high density like a bus wiring and capable of transmitting signals over a long distance. By making the wiring structure of the ROSC into such a structure (wiring structure 2000), the assumed wiring (for example, the wiring in the integrated circuit 203) is reproduced in a pseudo manner.
[0197] (Example of Functional Configuration of Wiring Variation Calculation Device 201) Next, a functional configuration example of the wiring variation calculation device 201 according to the second embodiment will be described. However, since the functional configuration example of the wiring variation calculation device 201 according to the second embodiment is similar to that of the wiring variation calculation device 201 according to the first embodiment, illustration thereof will be omitted. Here, processing contents different from those of the wiring variation calculation device 201 according to the first embodiment will be described.
[0198] The acquisition unit 501 acquires frequency data (first frequency data, second frequency data, third frequency data) of each of ROSCs #A, #B, #C. The frequency data of each of ROSCs #A, #B, #C is obtained by performing a frequency measurement simulation.
[0199] The creation unit 502 creates a third fitting equation expressing the frequency of ROSC#A under a predetermined condition, using the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation and the transistor variation as variables. The predetermined condition is, for example, a condition regarding the drive voltage (VDD) and the environmental temperature. The transistor variation is expressed, for example, by the variation of the threshold voltage Vth of the transistor.
[0200] Tr Vis a real number that takes a positive value for a variation in which Vth (threshold voltage) is higher than the typical value, and a negative value for a variation in which Vth is lower than the typical value, assuming that the typical Vth is 0. For example, if Vth is estimated to be 1.5σ higher than the typical value, Tr v Similarly, if Vth is estimated to be 1σ smaller than typical, Tr v will have the value -1.
[0201] The third fitting formula is expressed by, for example, the following formula (7). Here, Y is a variable representing the natural logarithm of the frequency of ROSC#A. line is the resistance component of the wiring variation (R line ) is a variable that represents the reciprocal of C line is a variable that represents the capacitance component of the wiring variation. V are variables that represent transistor variations. a1, b1, d1, and e1 are constants.
[0202] Y=a1×G line +b1×C line +d1×Tr V +e1...(7)
[0203] Specifically, for example, the creation unit 502 creates a third fitting equation by determining the constants a1, b1, d1, and e1 by linear multiple regression analysis based on the acquired first frequency data (data set) so as to satisfy the above equation (7). The constants a1, b1, d1, and e1 of the created third fitting equation are stored in, for example, the memory 205 shown in FIG.
[0204] Furthermore, the creation unit 502 creates a fourth fitting equation for ROSC#B that expresses the frequency of ROSC#B under predetermined conditions, using the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation and the transistor variation as variables.
[0205] The fourth fitting formula is expressed by, for example, the following formula (8). Here, Y is a variable representing the natural logarithm of the frequency of ROSC#B. line is the resistance component of the wiring variation (R line ) is a variable that represents the reciprocal of C line is a variable that represents the capacitance component of the wiring variation. V are variables that represent transistor variations. a2, b2, d2, and e2 are constants.
[0206] Y = a2 × G line +b2×C line +d2×Tr V +e2...(8)
[0207] Specifically, for example, the creation unit 502 creates a fourth fitting equation by determining the constants a2, b2, d2, and e2 by linear multiple regression analysis based on the acquired second frequency data (data set) so as to satisfy the above equation (8). The constants a2, b2, d2, and e2 of the created fourth fitting equation are stored in the memory 205, for example.
[0208] Furthermore, the creation unit 502 creates a fifth fitting equation for ROSC#C that expresses the frequency of ROSC#B under predetermined conditions, using the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation and the transistor variation as variables.
[0209] The fifth fitting formula is expressed by, for example, the following formula (9). Here, Y is a variable representing the natural logarithm of the frequency of ROSC#B. line is the resistance component of the wiring variation (R line ) is a variable that represents the reciprocal of C line is a variable that represents the capacitance component of the wiring variation. V are variables that represent transistor variations. a3, b3, d3, and e3 are constants.
[0210] Y = a3 × G line +b3×C line +d3×Tr V+e3...(9)
[0211] Specifically, for example, the creation unit 502 creates a fifth fitting equation by determining the constants a3, b3, d3, and e3 by linear multiple regression analysis based on the acquired third frequency data (data set) so as to satisfy the above equation (9). The constants a3, b3, d3, and e3 of the created fifth fitting equation are stored in the memory 205, for example.
[0212] The acquisition unit 501 also acquires the frequencies of each of ROSC #A, #B, and #C that are actually measured under predetermined conditions. The predetermined conditions are, for example, conditions regarding the drive voltage (VDD) and the environmental temperature, and are the same as the conditions when a frequency measurement simulation is performed to measure the frequencies of each of ROSC #A, #B, and #C.
[0213] 2 at the same temperature as that during the frequency measurement simulation, applies VDD to the chip 202, and measures the frequency of each of ROSC#A, #B, and #C. VDD is the same drive voltage as that during the frequency measurement simulation (for example, the drive voltage when the frequency indicated by the first frequency data used to create the third fitting equation is measured).
[0214] The calculation unit 503 uses the third, fourth and fifth fitting equations to calculate the resistance component and the capacitance component of the wiring variation based on the frequency of each of ROSCs #A, #B, #C actually measured under predetermined conditions.
[0215] Specifically, for example, the calculation unit 503 substitutes the actually measured frequency of ROSC#A into Y in the above formula (7) to obtain R line , C line and Tr V In addition, the calculation unit 503 substitutes the actually measured frequency of ROSC#B for Y in the above formula (8) to create a linear equation with R line , C line and Tr V Create a linear equation with variables.
[0216] In addition, the calculation unit 503 substitutes the actually measured frequency of ROSC#C into Y in the above formula (9) to obtain R line , C line and Tr V Then, the calculation unit 503 calculates R by solving the created simultaneous linear equations (three linear equations). line , C line and Tr V The value of can be calculated.
[0217] The output unit 505 outputs the calculated resistance component, capacitance component, and transistor variation of the wiring variation. Specifically, for example, the output unit 505 outputs R line (resistance component), C line (capacitive component) and Tr V (Transistor threshold voltage variation) value may be output.
[0218] In the above description, the variable of the fitting equation to be expanded is the transistor variation, but this is not limited to this. Transistors are affected by the environmental temperature. Therefore, the variable of the fitting equation to be expanded may be the environmental temperature. Also, the variable of the fitting equation to be expanded may be the power supply voltage VDD.
[0219] (Wiring Variation Calculation Processing Procedure of Wiring Variation Calculation Device 201) Next, a wiring variation calculation process procedure of the wiring variation calculation apparatus 201 according to the second embodiment will be described.
[0220] Fig. 21 is a flowchart showing an example of a wiring variation calculation process procedure of the wiring variation calculation device 201 according to the second embodiment. In the flowchart of Fig. 21, first, the wiring variation calculation device 201 executes a second fitting equation creation process (step S2101). The fitting equation creation process is a process for creating fitting equations (third, fourth, and fifth fitting equations) for each ROSC #A, #B, and #C. A specific processing procedure of the second fitting equation creation process will be described later with reference to Figs. 22 and 23.
[0221] Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 actually measures the frequency of each of ROSC#A, #B, and #C (step S2102). Specifically, for example, the wiring variation calculation device 201 keeps the thermostatic chamber 210 at the same temperature as that during the frequency measurement simulation, applies VDD (value of the data set) to the chip 202, and measures the frequency of each of ROSC#A, #B, and #C.
[0222] Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 creates simultaneous linear equations by substituting the actually measured frequencies of each ROSC #A, #B, #C into the fitting equations for each ROSC #A, #B, #C that have been created (step S2103). Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 solves the created simultaneous linear equations to obtain the resistance component R line and the capacitance component C line and transistor variation Tr V The value of is calculated (step S2104).
[0223] Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 executes a wiring variation estimation process to estimate the degree of wiring variation (step S2105). The specific processing procedure of the wiring variation estimation process is similar to the processing procedure shown in FIG. 16, so illustration and description thereof will be omitted.
[0224] Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 executes a feedback process (step S2106) and ends a series of processes according to this flowchart. The feedback process is a process of feeding back the estimation result of the wiring variation to the design process or the manufacturing process. A specific processing procedure of the feedback process will be described later with reference to FIGS. 25 and 26.
[0225] This allows the wiring variation calculation device 201 to separate the wiring variation into a resistance component and a capacitance component, and to estimate the degree of variation in the wiring of the integrated circuit 203. line , C line Not only Tr V By creating a fitting equation with the variables, it is possible to omit the process of selecting a data set in which the frequency fluctuation of each ROSC with respect to the variation in the threshold voltage Vth of the transistor falls within the allowable range, as shown in FIG. 13.
[0226] Next, a specific processing procedure of the second fitting equation creating process in step S2101 shown in FIG. 21 will be described with reference to FIG. 22 and FIG.
[0227] 22 and 23 are flowcharts showing an example of a specific processing procedure of the second fitting equation creation processing. In the flowchart of FIG. 22, first, the wiring variation calculation device 201 executes the second simulation processing (step S2201). The specific processing procedure of the second simulation processing will be described later with reference to FIG. 24.
[0228] Next, the wiring variation calculating device 201 selects a data set obtained by the second simulation process (step S2202). Here, any data set can be selected as the data set. Then, the wiring variation calculating device 201 judges whether or not the frequency difference between ROSCs #A, #B, and #C is sufficient for the selected data set (step S2203). For example, the wiring variation calculating device 201 judges that the frequency difference is sufficient when the frequency difference between the ROSCs is equal to or greater than a threshold value.
[0229] Here, if the frequency difference between ROSC #A, #B, and #C is sufficient (step S2203: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 selects an unselected driving force from among driving forces A, B, and C (step S2204). Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 calculates the frequency f of the ROSC of the driving force that selected Y. ROSC The natural logarithm of is taken (step S2205).
[0230] Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 calculates "Y=a×G line +b×C line +d×Tr V +e" is satisfied by linear multiple regression analysis (step S2206). Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 stores the calculated constants a, b, d, and e in the memory 205 in association with the ROSC of the selected driving force (step S2207).
[0231] Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 determines whether or not there is an unselected driving force among the driving forces A, B, and C (step S2208). If there is an unselected driving force (step S2208: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 returns to step S2204.
[0232] On the other hand, if there is no unselected driving force (step S2208: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 returns to the step where the second fitting equation creation process was called.
[0233] Furthermore, in step S2203, if the frequency difference between ROSC #A, #B, #C is not sufficient (step S2203: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 proceeds to step S2301 shown in FIG.
[0234] In the flowchart of Fig. 23, first, the wiring variation calculation device 201 adjusts the driving force of ROSC#A, ROSC#B, or ROSC#C (step S2301). For example, the wiring variation calculation device 201 may increase the driving force of ROSC#A. Also, the wiring variation calculation device 201 may decrease the driving force of ROSC#B (where driving force B>driving force C). Also, the wiring variation calculation device 201 may decrease the driving force of ROSC#C.
[0235] Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 executes a second simulation process (step S2302). A specific procedure of the second simulation process will be described later with reference to FIG. 24. Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 selects a data set obtained by the second simulation process (step S2303). Here, any data set can be selected as the data set.
[0236] Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 judges whether or not the frequency difference between ROSC#A, #B, and #C is sufficient for the selected data set (step S2304). If the frequency difference between ROSC#A, #B, and #C is sufficient (step S2304: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 selects an unselected driving force from among driving forces A, B, and C (step S2305).
[0237] Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 calculates the frequency f of the ROSC for the driving force selected by Y. ROSC Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 calculates, based on the selected data set, "Y=a×G line +b×C line +d×Tr V+e" is satisfied by multiple linear regression analysis (step S2307).
[0238] Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 stores the calculated constants a, b, d, and e in the memory 205 in association with the ROSC of the selected driving force (step S2308). Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 determines whether or not there is an unselected driving force among the driving forces A, B, and C (step S2309).
[0239] If there is an unselected driving force (step S2309: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 returns to step S2305. On the other hand, if there is no unselected driving force (step S2309: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 returns to the step where the second fitting equation creation process was called.
[0240] Furthermore, in step S2304, if the frequency difference between ROSC #A, #B, and #C is insufficient (step S2304: No), the wiring variation calculating device 201 outputs an impossibility error (step S2310) and ends the series of processes.
[0241] As a result, the wiring variation calculation device 201 calculates the resistance component of the wiring variation (G line ) and capacitance component (C line ) and transistor variation (Tr V ) as variables to create fitting equations (constants a, b, d, e) expressing the frequencies of each ROSC #A, #B, #C. Also, when the frequency difference between ROSC #A, #B, #C is small, the coefficients of each fitting equation will be close to each other, and there is a risk of a large error occurring when solving the simultaneous linear equations. When the frequency difference between ROSC #A, #B, #C is small, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can ensure a sufficient frequency difference by adjusting the driving force of the ROSC, thereby reducing the error occurring when solving the simultaneous linear equations.
[0242] Next, a specific procedure of the second simulation process in step S2302 shown in FIG. 23 will be described with reference to FIG.
[0243] Fig. 24 is a flowchart showing an example of a specific processing procedure of the second simulation process. In the flowchart of Fig. 24, first, the wiring variation calculation device 201 selects an unselected driving force from among driving forces A, B, and C (step S2401).
[0244] Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 selects an unselected VDD from among the settable VDDs (step S2402). V Unselected Tr among those not selected V (Step S2403). V is the transistor variation, which is expressed by the variation in the threshold voltage Vth of the transistor.
[0245] Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 calculates the configurable L V Unselected L that has not been selected V (Step S2404). V is the wiring variation, and G line [S], C line [fF]. Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 executes a frequency measurement simulation (step S2405). The specific processing procedure of the frequency measurement simulation is similar to the processing procedure shown in FIG. 15, and therefore illustration and description thereof will be omitted.
[0246] Next, the wiring variation calculation device 201 calculates the configurable L V Unselected L that has not been selected V It is determined whether there is an unselected L (step S2406). V If there is (step S2406: Yes), the wiring variation calculation apparatus 201 returns to step S2404.
[0247] On the other hand, the unselected L V If there is no Tr that can be set (step S2406: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 V Unselected Tr among those not selected V It is determined whether there is an unselected Tr (step S2407). V If there is (step S2407: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 returns to step S2403. V Select again from scratch.
[0248] On the other hand, unselected Tr V If there is no VDD (step S2407: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 judges whether there is an unselected VDD among the settable VDDs (step S2408). If there is an unselected VDD (step S2408: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 returns to step S2402. In this case, the wiring variation calculation device 201 determines whether there is a VDD that has not been selected in steps S2403 and S2404. V ,L V Select again from scratch.
[0249] On the other hand, if there is no unselected VDD (step S2408: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 determines whether there is an unselected driving force among the driving forces A, B, and C (step S2409). If there is an unselected driving force (step S2409: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 returns to step S2401. In this case, the wiring variation calculation device 201 does not select VDD, Tr in steps S2402, S2403, and S2404. V ,L V Select again from scratch.
[0250] On the other hand, if there is no unselected driving force (step S2409: No), the wiring variation calculating device 201 returns to the step where the second simulation process was called.
[0251] This allows the wiring variation calculation device 201 to execute a frequency measurement simulation for each of ROSCs #A, #B, and #C under various conditions (drive voltage, environmental temperature, transistor variation, wiring variation).
[0252] Next, a specific procedure of the feedback process in step S2106 shown in Fig. 21 will be described. First, a case where the estimation result of the wiring variation is fed back to the BEOL process will be described with reference to Fig. 25.
[0253] Fig. 25 is a flowchart showing an example of a specific processing procedure of the first feedback process. In the flowchart of Fig. 25, first, the wiring variation calculation device 201 determines whether the variation of C (wiring capacitance) deviates from the allowable range to the plus side (in the direction of increasing) based on the estimation result of the wiring variation (step S2501).
[0254] If the deviation is not on the positive side (step S2501: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 judges whether the deviation of R (wiring resistance) is on the positive side of the allowable range based on the estimation result (step S2502). If the deviation is not on the positive side (step S2502: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 does not perform feedback and returns to the step that called the first feedback process.
[0255] On the other hand, if there is a deviation on the positive side (step S2502: Yes), the wiring variation calculation device 201 performs feedback for adjusting the film thickness of the barrier metal to the BEOL process (step S2503), and returns to the step that called the first feedback process.
[0256] A barrier metal is a metal film (e.g., Ta) that surrounds the wiring material to prevent the metal (e.g., Cu) from diffusing into the insulating film. Barrier metals generally have a higher resistance than the metal wiring material. This feedback aims to reduce the wiring resistance by reducing the barrier metal film thickness and increasing the filling rate of the wiring material.
[0257] Furthermore, in step S2501, if there is a deviation on the positive side (step S2501: Yes), the wiring variation calculating device 201 determines whether the variation in R (wiring resistance) is deviated on the positive side from the allowable range (step S2504).
[0258] If there is a deviation on the positive side (step S2504: Yes), the wiring variation calculating device 201 performs feedback of the barrier metal film thickness adjustment and the interlayer insulating film thickness adjustment to the BEOL process (step S2505), and returns to the step that called the first feedback process.
[0259] An interlayer insulating film (e.g., SiN) is a film that insulates lower and upper wiring. If the film is thin, the distance between the upper and lower wiring becomes closer, and the capacitance between the wiring increases. This feedback loop aims to reduce the capacitance between the wiring by thickening the interlayer insulating film.
[0260] Also, in step S2504, if there is no deviation on the positive side (step S2504: No), the wiring variation calculating device 201 performs feedback of the interlayer insulating film thickness adjustment to the BEOL process (step S2506), and returns to the step that called the first feedback process.
[0261] Note that this does not take into account the variation in C (wiring capacitance) caused by the variation in the distance between wiring lines resulting from the accuracy of double patterning alignment in the photolithography process, or the variation in R (wiring resistance) caused by the variation in wiring width resulting from a decrease in pattern contrast due to the optical proximity effect.
[0262] This allows the wiring variation calculation device 201 to provide appropriate feedback to the BEOL process, thereby improving the yield of the integrated circuits 203.
[0263] Next, a case where the estimation result of the wiring variation is fed back to the layout design process will be described with reference to FIG.
[0264] Fig. 26 is a flowchart showing an example of a specific processing procedure of the second feedback process. In the flowchart of Fig. 26, first, the wiring variation calculation device 201 determines whether the variation of C (wiring capacitance) deviates from the allowable range to the plus side (in the direction of increasing) based on the estimation result of the wiring variation (step S2601).
[0265] If there is no deviation on the positive side (step S2601: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 judges whether or not the variation in R (wiring resistance) is more positive than the allowable range based on the estimation result (step S2602). If there is no deviation on the positive side (step S2602: No), the wiring variation calculation device 201 does not perform feedback and returns to the step that called the second feedback process.
[0266] On the other hand, if there is a deviation on the positive side (step S2602: Yes), the wiring variation calculating device 201 performs feedback to reduce the placement interval (implementation interval) of the repeaters that propagate signals to the layout design process (step S2603), and returns to the step that called the second feedback process.
[0267] The repeater is, for example, an INVERTER. In this feedback, the aim is to reduce the wiring resistance by shortening the wiring length per repeater. When shortening the wiring length per repeater, the wiring capacitance C also becomes smaller as a result, so adjustments may be made to reduce the driving force of the repeater in order to reduce the through current during signal transitions. Adjustments may also be made to increase the threshold voltage Vth of the transistor.
[0268] Furthermore, in step S2601, if there is a deviation on the positive side (step S2601: Yes), the wiring variation calculating device 201 determines whether the variation in R (wiring resistance) is deviated on the positive side from the allowable range (step S2604).
[0269] If the deviation is on the positive side (step S2604: Yes), the wiring variation calculating device 201 performs feedback to the layout design process to increase the driving force of the repeater and reduce the placement interval (mounting interval) (step S2605), and returns to the step that called the second feedback process. When increasing the driving force of the repeater, an adjustment to reduce the threshold voltage Vth of the transistor may also be performed.
[0270] In addition, in step S2604, if the deviation is not on the positive side (step S2604: No), the wiring variation calculating device 201 performs feedback to increase the driving power of the repeater to the layout design process (step S2606), and returns to the step that called the second feedback process. When increasing the driving power of the repeater, an adjustment to reduce the threshold voltage Vth of the transistor may also be performed.
[0271] As a result, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can provide appropriate feedback to the layout process, thereby remanufacturing the reticle and improving the yield.
[0272] As described above, according to the wiring variation calculation device 201 of the second embodiment, the third, fourth, and fifth fitting formulas can be obtained for the first, second, and third ROSCs among the ROSCs with different driving powers arranged on the same chip as the target circuit to be estimated for the wiring variation. The third fitting formula expresses the frequency of the first ROSC under a predetermined condition (for example, power supply voltage, environmental temperature) for the first ROSC, using the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation and the transistor variation as variables. The transistor variation is expressed, for example, by the variation of the threshold voltage Vth of the transistor. The fourth fitting formula expresses the frequency of the second ROSC under a predetermined condition, using the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation and the transistor variation as variables for the second ROSC. The fifth fitting formula expresses the frequency of the third ROSC under a predetermined condition, using the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation and the transistor variation as variables for the third ROSC. Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can use the third, fourth, and fifth fitting equations to calculate the resistance component, capacitance component, and transistor variation of the wiring variation based on the first ROSC frequency actually measured under predetermined conditions, the second ROSC frequency actually measured under predetermined conditions, and the third ROSC frequency actually measured under predetermined conditions. Also, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can output the calculated resistance component, capacitance component, and transistor variation of the wiring variation.
[0273] This allows the wiring variation calculation device 201 to separate the wiring variation into a resistance component and a capacitance component. For example, a designer can easily take appropriate measures according to the variation of the wiring or the variation of the transistor by referring to the resistance component, capacitance component, and transistor variation of the wiring variation.
[0274] According to the wiring variation calculation device 201, each fitting equation (third, fourth, and fifth fitting equations) is calculated by taking the natural logarithm of the frequency of each ROSC (first, second, and third ROSC) as Y, and taking the inverse of the resistance component of the wiring variation as G.line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C line The transistor variation is Tr V Let a, b, d, and e be constants. Y=a×G line +b×C line +d×Tr V It can be expressed by +e.
[0275] As a result, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can accurately calculate the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation by using a fitting formula constructed taking into account the dependence of the wiring propagation delay time on the wiring resistance, wiring capacitance, and transistor variations.
[0276] Moreover, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can acquire data sets (first, second and third frequency data) indicating the frequencies obtained by performing a frequency measurement simulation to measure the frequencies of the ROSCs (first, second and third ROSCs) while changing the transistor variation and the wiring variation under predetermined conditions (ambient temperature, driving voltage). Then, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can calculate Y=a×G based on the acquired data sets. line +b×C line +d×Tr V Each fitting equation (third, fourth and fifth fitting equations) can be created by determining the constants a, b, d and e by linear multiple regression analysis so as to satisfy +e.
[0277] This allows the wiring variation calculation device 201 to create a fitting equation that accurately represents the frequency of each ROSC (first, second, and third ROSC) using the resistance component and capacitance component of the wiring variation and the transistor variation as variables.
[0278] From these facts, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can separate the wiring variation into a resistance component and a capacitance component, and can easily take appropriate measures according to the wiring variation. Also, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can estimate only the wiring capacitance and wiring resistance by removing the parameters (output resistance, input capacitance) of the gate element (transistor) from the resistance component and capacitance component that affect the propagation delay time. Also, when a poorly made chip is found, the wiring variation calculation device 201 can easily narrow down the cause to determine whether the problem is the transistor, the wiring, or both, based on the degree of the wiring variation (resistance component, capacitance component) and the transistor variation (variation in threshold voltage Vth).
[0279] The wiring variation calculation method described in this embodiment can be realized by executing a prepared program on a computer such as a personal computer or a workstation. The wiring variation calculation program is recorded on a computer-readable recording medium such as a hard disk, a flexible disk, a CD-ROM, a DVD, or a USB memory, and is executed by being read from the recording medium by the computer. The wiring variation calculation program may also be distributed via a network such as the Internet.
[0280] In addition, the information processing device 100 (wiring variation calculation device 201) described in this embodiment can also be realized by an application-specific IC such as a standard cell or a structured ASIC (Application Specific Integrated Circuit) or a PLD (Programmable Logic Device) such as an FPGA.
[0281] The following supplementary notes are further disclosed regarding the above-described embodiment.
[0282] (Note 1) For a first ring oscillator among a plurality of ring oscillators having different driving powers arranged on the same chip as a target circuit for which wiring variations are to be estimated, a first equation expressing a frequency of the first ring oscillator under predetermined conditions is obtained using a resistance component and a capacitance component of the wiring variations as variables; obtaining a second equation expressing a frequency of a second ring oscillator of the plurality of ring oscillators under the predetermined conditions, using the resistance component and the capacitance component as variables; calculating the resistance component and the capacitance component based on a frequency of the first ring oscillator actually measured under the predetermined conditions and a frequency of the second ring oscillator actually measured under the predetermined conditions, using the first equation and the second equation; A wiring variation calculation method, the processing of which is executed by a computer.
[0283] (Appendix 2) Estimating the degree of the wiring variation based on the calculated resistance component and capacitance component, the standard deviation and average value of the wiring resistance, and the standard deviation and average value of the wiring capacitance. 2. The wiring variation calculation method according to claim 1, wherein the processing is executed by the computer.
[0284] (Note 3) In the first equation, the natural logarithm of the frequency of the first ring oscillator is defined as Y, and the inverse of the resistance component of the wiring variation is defined as G. line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C line Let a1, b1, and d1 be constants, and Y = a1 × G line +b1×C line +d1, In the second equation, the natural logarithm of the frequency of the second ring oscillator is Y, and the inverse of the resistance component of the wiring variation is G. line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C line Let a2, b2, and d2 be constants, and Y = a2 × G line +b2×C line +d2, 3. The wiring variation calculation method according to claim 1 or 2,
[0285] (Note 4) The predetermined conditions are conditions related to an environmental temperature and a driving voltage, The process of obtaining the first formula includes: acquiring first frequency data indicating a frequency obtained by performing a simulation to measure a frequency of the first ring oscillator while changing a transistor variation and a wiring variation under the predetermined condition; Based on the acquired first frequency data, the natural logarithm of the frequency of the first ring oscillator is defined as Y, and the inverse of the resistance component of the wiring variation is defined as G line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C line Then, Y=a1×G line +b1×C line The first formula is created by determining the constants a1, b1, and d1 by linear multiple regression analysis so as to satisfy +d1, The process of obtaining the second formula includes: acquiring second frequency data indicating a frequency obtained by performing a simulation to measure a frequency of the second ring oscillator while changing a transistor variation and a wiring variation under the predetermined condition; Based on the acquired second frequency data, the natural logarithm of the frequency of the second ring oscillator is defined as Y, and the inverse of the resistance component of the wiring variation is defined as G. line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C line Then, Y=a2×G line +b2×C line The constants a2, b2, and d2 are determined by linear multiple regression analysis so as to satisfy +d2, thereby creating the second equation. 4. The wiring variation calculation method according to claim 3,
[0286] (Note 5) A third equation is obtained for the first ring oscillator, expressing a frequency of the first ring oscillator under a predetermined condition, using a resistance component and a capacitance component of the wiring variation and a transistor variation as variables; obtaining a fourth equation expressing a frequency of the second ring oscillator under the predetermined conditions, using the resistance component, the capacitance component, and the transistor variation as variables for the second ring oscillator; obtaining a fifth equation expressing a frequency of a third ring oscillator of the plurality of ring oscillators under the predetermined conditions, using the resistance component, the capacitance component, and the transistor variation as variables; calculating the resistance component, the capacitance component, and the transistor variations based on the frequency of the first ring oscillator actually measured under the predetermined conditions, the frequency of the second ring oscillator actually measured under the predetermined conditions, and the frequency of the third ring oscillator actually measured under the predetermined conditions, using the third equation, the fourth equation, and the fifth equation; 5. The wiring variation calculation method according to claim 1, wherein the processing is executed by the computer.
[0287] (Note 6) In the third equation, the natural logarithm of the frequency of the first ring oscillator is defined as Y, and the inverse of the resistance component of the wiring variation is defined as G. line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C line The transistor variation is Tr V Let a1, b1, d1, and e1 be constants, and then Y=a1×G line +b1×C line +d1×Tr V +e1, In the fourth equation, the natural logarithm of the frequency of the second ring oscillator is defined as Y, and the inverse of the resistance component of the wiring variation is defined as G. line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C line The transistor variation is Tr V Let a2, b2, d2, and e2 be constants, and then Y=a2×G line +b2×C line +d2×Tr V +e2, In the fifth equation, the natural logarithm of the frequency of the third ring oscillator is defined as Y, and the inverse of the resistance component of the wiring variation is defined as G. line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C line The transistor variation is Tr V Let a3, b3, d3, and e3 be constants, and then Y=a3×G line +b3×C line +d3×Tr V +e3, 6. The wiring variation calculation method according to claim 5,
[0288] (Note 7) The predetermined conditions are conditions related to an environmental temperature and a driving voltage, The process of obtaining the third formula includes the steps of: acquiring first frequency data indicating a frequency obtained by performing a simulation to measure a frequency of the first ring oscillator while changing a transistor variation and a wiring variation under the predetermined condition; Based on the acquired first frequency data, the natural logarithm of the frequency of the first ring oscillator is defined as Y, and the inverse of the resistance component of the wiring variation is defined as G. line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C line The transistor variation is Tr V Then, Y=a1×G line +b1×C line +d1×Tr V The third formula is created by determining the constants a1, b1, d1, and e1 by linear multiple regression analysis so as to satisfy +e1, The process of obtaining the fourth equation includes the steps of: acquiring second frequency data indicating a frequency obtained by performing a simulation to measure a frequency of the second ring oscillator while changing a transistor variation and a wiring variation under the predetermined condition; Based on the acquired second frequency data, the natural logarithm of the frequency of the second ring oscillator is defined as Y, and the inverse of the resistance component of the wiring variation is defined as G. line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C lineThe transistor variation is Tr V Then, Y=a2×G line +b2×C line +d2×Tr V The fourth formula is created by determining the constants a2, b2, d2, and e2 by linear multiple regression analysis so as to satisfy +e2, The process of obtaining the fifth equation includes the steps of: acquiring third frequency data indicating a frequency obtained by performing a simulation to measure a frequency of the third ring oscillator while changing a transistor variation and a wiring variation under the predetermined condition; Based on the acquired third frequency data, the natural logarithm of the frequency of the third ring oscillator is defined as Y, and the inverse of the resistance component of the wiring variation is defined as G. line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C line The transistor variation is Tr V Then, Y=a3×G line +b3×C line +d3×Tr V The constants a3, b3, d3, and e3 are determined by linear multiple regression analysis so as to satisfy +e3, thereby creating the fifth formula. 7. The wiring variation calculation method according to claim 6,
[0289] (Appendix 8) Outputting the calculated resistance component and capacitance component. 8. The wiring variation calculation method according to claim 1, wherein the processing is executed by the computer.
[0290] (Appendix 9) Outputting the estimated degree of wiring variation. 3. The wiring variation calculation method according to claim 2, wherein the processing is executed by the computer.
[0291] (Appendix 10) For a first ring oscillator among a plurality of ring oscillators having different driving powers arranged on the same chip as a target circuit for which wiring variations are to be estimated, a first equation expressing a frequency of the first ring oscillator under a predetermined condition is obtained using a resistance component and a capacitance component of the wiring variations as variables; obtaining a second equation expressing a frequency of a second ring oscillator of the plurality of ring oscillators under the predetermined conditions, using the resistance component and the capacitance component as variables; calculating the resistance component and the capacitance component based on a frequency of the first ring oscillator actually measured under the predetermined conditions and a frequency of the second ring oscillator actually measured under the predetermined conditions, using the first equation and the second equation; A wiring variation calculation program for causing a computer to execute a process. [Explanation of symbols]
[0292] 100 Information processing device 101 Target circuit 102 First ROSC 103 Second ROSC 110,202,902,903 chips 120,130 expressions 200 Estimation System 201 Wiring Variation Calculation Device 203 Integrated Circuits 204 ROSC group 205,302 Memory 210,910 Constant temperature chamber 300 Bus 301 CPU 303 Disk Drive 304 Disk 305 Communication I / F 306 Portable Recording Media I / F 307 Portable recording media 500 Control section 501 Acquisition Department 502 Creation Department 503 Calculation Department 504 Estimation Department 505 Output section 600 Datasets 700 Fitting Information 801 Resistance Variation Table 802 Capacity Variation Table 901 Wafer
Claims
1. obtaining a first equation expressing a frequency of a first ring oscillator among a plurality of ring oscillators having different driving forces and arranged on the same chip as a target circuit for estimating wiring variations, under a predetermined condition, using a resistance component and a capacitance component of the wiring variations as variables; obtaining a second equation expressing a frequency of a second ring oscillator of the plurality of ring oscillators under the predetermined conditions, using the resistance component and the capacitance component as variables; calculating the resistance component and the capacitance component based on a frequency of the first ring oscillator actually measured under the predetermined conditions and a frequency of the second ring oscillator actually measured under the predetermined conditions, using the first equation and the second equation; A wiring variation calculation method, the processing of which is executed by a computer.
2. estimating a degree of the wiring variation based on the calculated resistance component and capacitance component, a standard deviation and an average value of the wiring resistance, and a standard deviation and an average value of the wiring capacitance; 2. The wiring variation calculation method according to claim 1, wherein the processing is executed by the computer.
3. In the first equation, the natural logarithm of the frequency of the first ring oscillator is Y, and the inverse of the resistance component of the wiring variation is G. line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C line Let a1, b1, and d1 be constants, and Y = a1 x G line + b1 × C line +d1, In the second equation, the natural logarithm of the frequency of the second ring oscillator is Y, and the inverse of the resistance component of the wiring variation is G. line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C line Let a2, b2, and d2 be constants, and Y = a2 × G line + b2 × C line +d2, 2. The wiring variation calculation method according to claim 1,
4. the predetermined conditions are conditions related to an environmental temperature and a driving voltage, The process of obtaining the first equation includes the steps of: acquiring first frequency data indicating a frequency obtained by performing a simulation to measure a frequency of the first ring oscillator while changing a transistor variation and a wiring variation under the predetermined condition; Based on the acquired first frequency data, a value obtained by taking the natural logarithm of the frequency of the first ring oscillator is defined as Y, and the inverse of the resistance component of the wiring variation is defined as G line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C line Then, Y = a1 × G line + b1 × C line The first equation is created by determining constants a1, b1, and d1 by linear multiple regression analysis so as to satisfy +d1, The process of obtaining the second equation includes the steps of: acquiring second frequency data indicating a frequency obtained by performing a simulation to measure a frequency of the second ring oscillator while changing a transistor variation and a wiring variation under the predetermined condition; Based on the acquired second frequency data, a value obtained by taking the natural logarithm of the frequency of the second ring oscillator is defined as Y, and the inverse of the resistance component of the wiring variation is defined as G line The capacitance component of the wiring variation is C line Then, Y = a2 × G line + b2 × C line The second equation is created by determining the constants a2, b2, and d2 by linear multiple regression analysis so as to satisfy the above-mentioned equation.
4. The wiring variation calculation method according to claim 3.
5. obtaining a third equation expressing a frequency of the first ring oscillator under a predetermined condition, using a resistance component and a capacitance component of the wiring variation and a transistor variation as variables for the first ring oscillator; obtaining a fourth equation expressing a frequency of the second ring oscillator under the predetermined conditions, using the resistance component, the capacitance component, and the transistor variation as variables for the second ring oscillator; obtaining a fifth equation expressing a frequency of a third ring oscillator of the plurality of ring oscillators under the predetermined conditions, using the resistance component, the capacitance component, and the transistor variation as variables; calculating the resistance component, the capacitance component, and the transistor variations based on a frequency of the first ring oscillator actually measured under the predetermined conditions, a frequency of the second ring oscillator actually measured under the predetermined conditions, and a frequency of the third ring oscillator actually measured under the predetermined conditions, using the third equation, the fourth equation, and the fifth equation; 2. The wiring variation calculation method according to claim 1, wherein the processing is executed by the computer.
6. outputting the calculated resistance component and capacitance component; 6. The wiring variation calculation method according to claim 1, wherein the processing is executed by the computer.
7. obtaining a first equation expressing a frequency of a first ring oscillator among a plurality of ring oscillators having different driving forces and arranged on the same chip as a target circuit for estimating wiring variations, under a predetermined condition, using a resistance component and a capacitance component of the wiring variations as variables; obtaining a second equation expressing a frequency of a second ring oscillator of the plurality of ring oscillators under the predetermined conditions, using the resistance component and the capacitance component as variables; calculating the resistance component and the capacitance component based on a frequency of the first ring oscillator actually measured under the predetermined conditions and a frequency of the second ring oscillator actually measured under the predetermined conditions, using the first equation and the second equation; A wiring variation calculation program for causing a computer to execute a process.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Characterization of circuit performance
JP2007520055A
