Inspection jig and inspection method
The inspection jig with a concave curved portion addresses the challenge of measuring creep damage in heat exchanger tubes by detecting bulges through gap changes, enabling efficient and detailed assessment of tube condition without full diameter measurement.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023080736
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-16
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-28
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for measuring creep damage in heat exchanger tubes installed in parallel at narrow intervals, such as those in a boiler furnace, are hindered by the presence of plate-like members that prevent a caliper-like measuring device from covering a 180° range, and the large number of tubes necessitates a quicker screening process for bulging portions.
An inspection jig with a concave curved portion is used to determine the presence of bulges in heat exchanger tubes by ensuring a predetermined gap between the jig and the tube, allowing for easy detection without measuring the outer diameter over 180°, utilizing a pure carbon steel jig hardened through quenching for wear resistance.
The inspection jig enables quick screening for potentially damaged tubes by detecting bulges based on gap changes, facilitating efficient evaluation of creep damage without full diameter measurement, and allowing for detailed gap measurement and microstructural observation to assess remaining life.
Smart Images

Figure 2024164973000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present disclosure relates to an inspection tool and an inspection method. [Background technology]
[0002] Heat transfer tubes used in boilers and other equipment are exposed to high temperatures and pressures for long periods of time. This type of piping gradually expands (bulges) due to creep damage. As creep damage progresses, creep fracture occurs, leading to fracture. Therefore, it is important to understand the extent of creep damage progression.
[0003] The extent of creep damage can be understood based on the expansion coefficient of the pipe, which is derived from measurements obtained by measuring the circumference of the pipe within a range of 180° using a vernier caliper (see Patent Document 1).
[0004] When assessing the progression of creep damage in a pipe whose unexpanded (undeformed) shape is close to a perfect circle, it is necessary to measure the outside diameter of the bulging part of the pipe in the direction of greatest expansion. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0005] [Patent Document 1] JP 2013-148477 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0006] In a boiler, multiple heat transfer tubes are installed in parallel with a small gap between them. Therefore, even if you try to measure the outer diameter of a heat transfer tube in multiple measurement directions, it may not be possible to rotate the caliper in the circumferential direction of the heat transfer tube.
[0007] In Patent Document 1, the outer diameter of heat transfer tubes arranged in parallel at close intervals is measured by using a caliper-like measuring device with a curved surface that contacts the measurement object.
[0008] However, the measuring device described in Patent Document 1 cannot be used for the heat transfer tubes of the boiler furnace wall. The boiler furnace wall is equipped with a plurality of heat transfer tubes, and the spaces between the heat transfer tubes are blocked with plate-like members (fins) to prevent the combustion gas in the furnace from leaking. Because the heat transfer tubes and the plate-like members are welded together, the caliper-like measuring device cannot accurately measure the 180° range of the heat transfer tubes.
[0009] In addition, since there are a large number of heat transfer tubes, the inspection takes time. It is desirable to carry out a process called screening, which quickly checks for the presence of bulges where the outer diameter has increased.
[0010] The present disclosure has been made in consideration of the above circumstances, and aims to provide an inspection tool and an inspection method that can easily determine the presence or absence of bulging in a heat transfer tube fixed with a plate-shaped member without measuring the diameter of the outer surface of the heat transfer tube within a range of 180°. [Means for solving the problem]
[0011] In order to solve the above problems, the inspection tool and inspection method disclosed herein employ the following measures.
[0012] The present disclosure provides an inspection jig for determining the presence or absence of a bulge in an inspection object, the inspection jig having a heat transfer tube of a component in which multiple heat transfer tubes are arranged in parallel and adjacent heat transfer tubes are joined by a plate-shaped member, the inspection jig having a main body and a concave curved portion that is concave toward the inside of the main body, the concave curved portion being shaped such that, when the concave curved portion is abutted against the outer peripheral surface of an unbulged heat transfer tube, a predetermined gap is secured between the top of the heat transfer tube and the bottom of the concave curved portion.
[0013] The present disclosure provides an inspection method in which an inspection object is a heat transfer tube of a component in which multiple heat transfer tubes are arranged in parallel and adjacent heat transfer tubes are joined by a plate-shaped member, and an inspection tool described in the above disclosure is abutted against the heat transfer tube, and in this state, the presence or absence of a bulge is determined based on the presence or absence of a gap between the top of the heat transfer tube and the bottom of the concave curved portion or the size of the gap. Effect of the Invention
[0014] According to the above disclosure, heat transfer tubes that may be damaged can be easily screened without measuring the diameter of the outer circumferential surface of the heat transfer tube within a range of 180°. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0015] [Figure 1] FIG. 2 is a schematic diagram of an object to be inspected in one embodiment of the present disclosure. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a plan view of an inspection jig according to an embodiment of the present disclosure. [Diagram 3] 11A and 11B are diagrams showing examples of dimensions of a concavely curved portion of an inspection jig; [Figure 4] FIG. 13 is a schematic diagram showing an inspection jig being brought into contact with an unexpanded heat transfer tube. [Diagram 5] FIG. 13 is a schematic diagram showing an inspection jig being brought into contact with a bulging heat transfer tube. [Figure 6] 1A to 1C are schematic diagrams illustrating a method of using the inspection jig. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0016] Hereinafter, the embodiments of the present disclosure will be described with reference to the drawings. Note that the embodiments described below are merely examples, and are not intended to exclude various modifications or application of techniques not explicitly described in the following embodiments. The configurations of the following embodiments can be modified in various ways without departing from the spirit of the embodiments.
[0017] (Subject to inspection) Fig. 1 shows a schematic diagram of an inspection target in this embodiment. Inspection target 1 is a member including a plurality of heat transfer tubes 2 and a plate-like member 3 arranged to close the gaps between adjacent heat transfer tubes 2. More specifically, the outer shape of the heat transfer tubes 2 of inspection target 1 is inspected. The heat transfer tubes 2 are fixed to the plate-like members 3 on both sides of the axis.
[0018] The member to be inspected 1 is, for example, a furnace wall disposed in a boiler furnace. The boiler furnace has a horizontal cross section that is approximately rectangular, and the furnace wall that forms the outer periphery of the furnace is composed of tubes (heat transfer tubes 2) through which boiler water and steam flow, and fins (plate-shaped members 3) that connect the heat transfer tubes together. In such a boiler, the furnace wall may deform due to some factor, such as deterioration of materials due to long-term use or a sudden increase in temperature. The part where the fins are connected is restrained and therefore does not deform easily. The top of the heat transfer tube facing the inside of the furnace is particularly prone to deformation. The "top" refers to the part that protrudes most from the reference plane, which is the plane connecting the two points fixed by the fins.
[0019] (Inspection fixture) The inspection jig according to this embodiment has a main body and a concave curved portion that is concave toward the inside of the main body. The inspection jig is used by abutting the concave curved portion against the outer circumferential surface of the heat transfer tube to be inspected. When the concave curved portion is abutted against an unexpanded heat transfer tube, both ends abut against the heat transfer tube, but a predetermined gap is secured between the bottom of the concave curved portion and the top of the heat transfer tube. The concave curved portion is shaped so that both ends do not contact the plate-like member or the heat transfer tube arranged next to the heat transfer tube to be inspected. The "unexpanded heat transfer tube" may be understood as an unused pipe having the same diameter as the heat transfer tube to be inspected.
[0020] The material of the inspection jig is pure carbon steel. The inspection jig is made by quenching. The quenching process makes the steel harder, which improves its wear resistance.
[0021] 2 shows a plan view of one embodiment of the inspection jig. Inspection jig (bulge gauge) 10 has a flat body 11 and a concave portion 12 formed by cutting out one side of the body. Concave portion 12 is recessed toward the inside of body 11. Body 11 may have a hole 13 for passing a wire or string through to prevent the jig from falling (to prevent loss).
[0022] The main body 11 serves as a gripping portion that is gripped when the inspection jig 10 is used. The main body 11 can be provided with a concavely curved portion 12 on one side, and is of a size and shape that prevents the concavely curved portion 12 from coming into contact with an adjacent heat transfer tube 2 when the concavely curved portion 12 is brought into contact with the adjacent heat transfer tube 2. The thickness of the main body 11 is 2.3 mm or more and 4.0 mm or less. If the main body 11 is too thin, it is prone to deformation, and if it is too thick, it becomes heavy and operability decreases.
[0023] The concavely curved portion 12 is formed of an arc surface with a radius of curvature R. The radius of curvature R is smaller than the radius Ri of the outer peripheral surface of the unexpanded heat transfer tube 2. The curvature of the concavely curved portion 12 is larger than the curvature of the outer peripheral surface of the unexpanded heat transfer tube 2. The arc surface is disposed perpendicular to the upper and lower surfaces of the main body 11.
[0024] An opening distance W from one end to the other end of the concavely curved portion 12 is shorter than a diameter 2Ri of the outer circumferential surface of the unexpanded heat transfer tube 2. The opening distance W is preferably equal to or greater than √2Ri and equal to or less than √3Ri.
[0025] The distance B from the opening to the bottom of the concave curved portion 12 (depth of the concave curved portion) is shorter than the radius Ri of the outer peripheral surface of the unexpanded heat transfer tube 2. The depth B of the concave curved portion is a value obtained by subtracting A (the distance from the center of curvature to the opening of the concave curved portion 12) from R (the radius of curvature of the concave curved portion 12).
[0026] The "bottom" is the deepest recessed part of the concave curved portion. The "bottom" is located on the center line (center line of the concave curved portion) in the width direction of the opening of the concave curved portion 12. The concave curved portion 12 has a shape symmetrical with respect to the center line of the concave curved portion.
[0027] The radius of curvature R and depth B of the concave curved portion 12 are appropriately set so that the distance (gap) between the bottom of the concave curved portion 12 and the top of the unexpanded heat transfer tube 2 is a predetermined value. The gap is 0.2 mm or more and 1 mm or less. By setting the gap within the above numerical range, a replacement standard value can be selected in combination with the remaining life evaluation results obtained by microstructural observation.
[0028] 3 shows an example of the dimensions of the concave curved portion 12 of an inspection jig for inspecting a heat transfer tube 2 with an outer diameter of φ45 mm before expansion. R is the radius of curvature of the concave curved portion 12, A is the distance from the center of curvature to the opening of the concave curved portion 12, and B is the depth of the concave curved portion.
[0029] As shown in Nos. 1 to 4, when the radius of curvature R is increased, the gap becomes smaller. When the distance A from the center of curvature to the opening of the concave curved portion 12 is increased, the gap becomes smaller. When the depth B of the concave curved portion is decreased, the gap becomes smaller. By adjusting the radius of curvature R and the depth B of the concave curved portion, an inspection jig 10 having a concave curved portion 12 that forms a gap of the desired size can be obtained.
[0030] (Testing method) In the inspection method according to this embodiment, the concave curved portion of the inspection jig is abutted against the outer peripheral surface of the heat transfer tube to be inspected, and the presence or absence of a bulge is determined based on the presence or absence of a gap between the heat transfer tube and the concave curved portion and the size of the gap.
[0031] The inspection jig to be used is selected based on the information on the outer diameter (initial outer diameter) of the heat transfer tube to be inspected before expansion. It is recommended to use an inspection jig that, when the concave curved portion is abutted against the heat transfer tube with the initial outer diameter, the gap between the top of the heat transfer tube and the bottom of the concave curved portion is equal to or larger than the JIS outer diameter tolerance.
[0032] The concave curved portion of the inspection jig is brought into contact with the outer circumferential surface of the heat transfer tube to be inspected. Here, the upper and lower surfaces of the main body 11 of the inspection jig are arranged perpendicular to the axial direction of the heat transfer tube, and the thickness direction of the main body is arranged to coincide with the axial direction of the heat transfer tube.
[0033] With the inspection jig in contact, it is checked whether there is a gap between the top of the heat transfer tube and the bottom of the concave curve of the inspection jig. If there is no gap, it is determined that there is a bulge. If there is a gap, the gap distance is measured using a gap gauge.
[0034] The inspection jig is designed so that when the concave curved portion is brought into contact with an unexpanded heat transfer tube, a predetermined gap (initial gap) is generated between the top of the heat transfer tube and the bottom of the concave curved portion. The gap gauge is, for example, thin plate-like, and gap gauges of different thicknesses may be used. The presence or absence of bulging may be determined based on whether or not the gap gauge can be inserted into the gap between the top of the heat transfer tube and the bottom of the concave curved portion. Also, the gap may be measured by inserting the gap gauge, and if the measured value is smaller than the initial gap, it may be determined that there is bulging. The smaller the measured value of the gap gauge, the more the heat transfer tube bulges. Therefore, it can be determined that the degree of bulging is smaller compared to when there is no gap.
[0035] If the measurement value using the gap gauge is equal to the initial gap, it is determined that there is no bulging.
[0036] 4 is a schematic diagram of an inspection jig being placed against an unexpanded heat transfer tube. When the inspection jig 10 is placed against a portion of the heat transfer tube 2 that is not expanded (deformed), the presence of a gap G between the bottom of the concave bend 12 and the top of the heat transfer tube 2 is confirmed.
[0037] 5 is a schematic diagram of an inspection jig being placed in contact with an expanded heat transfer tube. When the inspection jig 10 is placed in contact with the expanded (deformed) portion of the heat transfer tube, the gap G' between the bottom of the concave curved portion and the top of the heat transfer tube 2' disappears or becomes smaller than the initial gap (gap G).
[0038] In the furnace wall, the heat transfer tubes 2 are fixed by fins 3. The heat transfer tubes 2 restrained by the fins 3 are less likely to deform (expand) near the fin joints, but are more likely to deform at points away from the fin joints. In addition, the range of the curvature central angle of ±45° around the center of the concave curved portion on the side of the heat transfer tube 2 facing the furnace interior, particularly the apex, becomes the hottest and is therefore more likely to deform. Therefore, in the heat transfer tubes 2 of the furnace wall restrained by the fins 3, by checking the bulging near the apex of the heat transfer tube on the furnace inside, it is possible to screen for heat transfer tubes with a high possibility of creep damage, without measuring the outer diameter of the perfect circle of the heat transfer tube 2.
[0039] Heat transfer tubes 2' that are determined to have bulges should also be inspected by microstructural observation. Areas likely to have large bulges may be selected for microstructural observation. The replica method can be used for microstructural observation. The replica method is a method in which irregularities corresponding to the metal structure of the surface of the measurement area, which have been revealed by a specified process, are transferred onto a film, and the transferred irregularities are then used for microstructural observation using an optical microscope or a scanning electron microscope. For example, by measuring the observed creep voids as the number of voids per specified area, the extent of damage to the heat transfer tube can be identified and the remaining life of the heat transfer tube can be evaluated.
[0040] Note that multiple inspection jigs with different initial gap sizes (for example, initial gaps of 1 mm, 0.5 mm, etc.) may be used to determine the presence or absence of bulging in stages. In this case, the inspection jigs with the largest initial gaps are used in ascending order. This makes it possible to determine the presence or absence of bulging and to grasp the degree of bulging without using a gap gauge.
[0041] The inspection jig 10 may be applied intermittently to a plurality of positions on the heat transfer tube, or may be slid in the longitudinal direction L of the heat transfer tube 2 while being in contact with the heat transfer tube 2 as shown in FIG.
[0042] <Additional Notes> The inspection tool and the inspection method described in the above-described embodiment can be understood, for example, as follows.
[0043] An inspection jig (10) according to a first aspect of the present disclosure is an inspection jig for determining the presence or absence of a bulge in an inspection object (1), the inspection object being a heat transfer tube of a component in which a plurality of heat transfer tubes (2) are arranged in parallel and adjacent heat transfer tubes are joined by a plate-shaped member (3), the inspection jig having a main body portion (11) and a concave curved portion (12) that is concave toward the inside of the main body portion, and the concave curved portion has a shape such that, when the concave curved portion is abutted against the outer peripheral surface of the unbulged heat transfer tube, a predetermined gap (G) is secured between the top of the heat transfer tube and the bottom of the concave curved portion.
[0044] The heat transfer tube in the above-mentioned inspection object is fixed by a plate-like member. In such a heat transfer tube, the top of the heat transfer tube, which is the furthest from the fixing point, is the part most likely to bulge. By providing a predetermined gap in advance at the part that is likely to bulge when the heat transfer tube abuts in an unbulged state, it is possible to determine the presence or absence of bulging based on the change in the size of the gap. If there is bulging, the gap changes in a smaller direction. If there is thinning, the gap changes in a larger direction. If the shape of the heat transfer tube does not change, the size of the gap does not change either. By observing the change in the size of the gap, the amount of physical change in the top of the heat transfer tube can be easily confirmed.
[0045] According to the above aspect, since attention is focused on the top of the heat transfer tube, it is possible to screen for heat transfer tubes that may be damaged without measuring the diameter of the outer circumferential surface of the heat transfer tube within a range of 180°.
[0046] In the inspection jig according to the second aspect of the present disclosure, in the first aspect, the concave curved portion consists of an arcuate surface with a radius of curvature R, and the curvature of the concave curved portion is greater than the curvature of the outer peripheral surface of the heat transfer tube in an unexpanded state.
[0047] The arc surface of the concave curved portion is symmetrical, and the bottom of the concave curved portion is located at the center of the arc surface. The curvature of the concave curved portion is greater than the curvature of the outer peripheral surface of the heat transfer tube in an unexpanded state. When such an inspection jig is brought into contact with the heat transfer tube in an unexpanded state, a gap is formed between the top of the heat transfer tube and the bottom of the concave curved portion.
[0048] According to a third aspect of the present disclosure, in the inspection jig of the second aspect, a depth (B) of the concave curved portion is smaller than a radius (Ri) of an outer circumferential surface of the heat transfer tube in an unexpanded state.
[0049] According to the above aspect, the inspection jig does not cover the radius of the outer circumferential surface of the heat transfer tube, and therefore can have a shape that does not contact the plate-like member.
[0050] An inspection method according to a fourth aspect of the present disclosure inspects a heat transfer tube of a component in which multiple heat transfer tubes are arranged in parallel and adjacent heat transfer tubes are joined by a plate-shaped member, and an inspection tool described in any of the first to third aspects is brought into contact with the heat transfer tube. In this state, the presence or absence of a bulge is determined based on the presence or absence of a gap between the top of the heat transfer tube and the bottom of the concave curved portion or the size of the gap.
[0051] According to the above aspect, as in the first aspect, attention is focused on the top of the heat transfer tube, so that heat transfer tubes that may be damaged can be easily screened without measuring the diameter of the outer circumferential surface of the heat transfer tube within a range of 180°.
[0052] An inspection method according to a fifth aspect of the present disclosure involves, in the fourth aspect, inserting a gap gauge (not shown) into the gap between the top of the heat transfer tube and the bottom of the concave curved portion while they are in abutting contact, measuring the size of the gap, and determining whether the gap can be inserted or not or the presence or absence of the bulge based on the measurement value.
[0053] According to the above aspect, by measuring the size of the gap using a gap gauge, the degree of bulging can be confirmed in more detail.
[0054] An inspection method according to a sixth aspect of the present disclosure is the same as that of the fourth aspect, in which a plurality of inspection jigs with different gaps are prepared for a heat transfer tube to be inspected that has not bulged, and the presence or absence of the bulge is determined in stages by using the inspection jigs in order starting with the inspection jig with the largest gap.
[0055] According to the above aspect, the degree of bulging can be checked in more detail without using a gap gauge.
[0056] In the inspection method according to a seventh aspect of the present disclosure, a structure observation is carried out on a heat transfer tube determined to have a bulge in any one of the fourth to sixth aspects.
[0057] In addition to checking for the presence or absence of bulges, by also observing the structure, it is possible to confirm the location of damage and also evaluate the remaining life of the heat transfer tube. [Explanation of symbols]
[0058] 1. Test subjects 2 Heat transfer tube (non-expanded heat transfer tube) 3. Plate-shaped components (fins) 10 Inspection fixture 11 Main body 12 Concave section 13 Hole
Claims
1. An inspection tool for determining the presence or absence of a bulge in an inspection object, the inspection object being a heat transfer tube of a member in which a plurality of heat transfer tubes are arranged in parallel and adjacent heat transfer tubes are joined by a plate-shaped member, the inspection tool comprising: A main body portion and a concave curved portion that is concave toward the inside of the main body portion, The inspection jig has a shape such that, when the concave curved portion is abutted against the outer peripheral surface of the unexpanded heat transfer tube, a predetermined gap is secured between the top of the heat transfer tube and the bottom of the concave curved portion.
2. The concave curved portion is formed of an arcuate surface having a radius of curvature R, The inspection jig according to claim 1 , wherein the curvature of the concavely curved portion is greater than the curvature of the outer circumferential surface of the heat transfer tube in an unexpanded state.
3. 3. The inspection jig according to claim 2, wherein a depth of the concave curved portion is smaller than a radius of an outer circumferential surface of the heat transfer tube in an unexpanded state.
4. The heat transfer tubes in a member in which a plurality of heat transfer tubes are arranged in parallel and adjacent heat transfer tubes are joined by a plate-shaped member are inspected, The inspection jig according to any one of claims 1 to 3 is brought into contact with the heat transfer tube, An inspection method for determining the presence or absence of a bulge based on the presence or absence of a gap between the top of the heat transfer tube and the bottom of the concave curved portion when they are in abutting contact, or the size of the gap.
5. 5. The inspection method according to claim 4, wherein, while the heat transfer tube is in abutted state, a gap gauge is inserted into the gap between the top of the heat transfer tube and the bottom of the concave curved portion, the size of the gap is measured, and whether the gap can be inserted or the presence or absence of the bulge is determined based on the measurement value.
6. preparing a plurality of the inspection jigs having different gaps for the heat transfer tubes to be inspected that are not expanded; The inspection method according to claim 4 , wherein the presence or absence of the bulge is determined in stages by using the inspection jigs in order from the inspection jig with the largest gap.
7. The inspection method according to claim 4, further comprising the step of: observing the structure of the heat transfer tube determined to have a bulge.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Pipe diameter measuring instrument and pipe diameter inspection method
JP2013148477A
