Method for eliminating troublesome secondary products in the direct oxidative esterification of methacrolein.

The method addresses the yellowing issue in MMA production by efficiently converting methacrolein-based acetals and hemiacetals, achieving high DMIB reduction and minimal MMA loss, leading to colorless and thermally stable products.

JP2024543443AInactive Publication Date: 2024-11-21ROHM GMBH
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2024527709
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2021-11-12
Filing Date
2022-11-09
Publication Date
2024-11-21
Estimated Expiration
Not applicable · inactive patent

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing methods for preparing methyl methacrylate (MMA) through oxidative esterification of methacrolein result in significant yellowing of secondary products due to the presence of by-products like methacrolein dimethyl acetal (DMIB) and methyl isobutyrate, leading to inefficiencies and yield loss.

Method used

A method involving the hydrolytic conversion of methacrolein-based acetals and hemiacetals using reactive distillation and extraction, with controlled pH and water addition to separate and reduce DMIB and methacrylic acid, ensuring minimal hydrolysis of MMA.

Benefits of technology

Achieves a DMIB hydrolysis of over 90% with less than 3% MMA hydrolysis, resulting in colorless final products and improved polymer yield by reducing by-product accumulation and thermal instability.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 2024543443000001_ABST
    Figure 2024543443000001_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention relates to an optimized process for preparing methyl methacrylate, in which the MMA and the polymers prepared therefrom are characterized by a very low yellowness index, in which the MMA is prepared according to the invention by direct oxidative esterification of methacrolein. In particular, the present invention relates to an optimized workup of the reactor effluent of the oxidative esterification of methacrolein, whereby, inter alia, discoloring by-products are removed or decomposed without significantly impairing the MMA.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to an optimized process for the preparation of methyl methacrylate, whereby the MMA and the polymers prepared therefrom are characterized by a very low yellowness index, where the MMA is prepared according to the invention by direct oxidative esterification of methacrolein.

[0002] In particular, the invention relates to an optimized workup of the reactor effluent of the oxidative esterification of methacrolein, whereby, inter alia, discoloring by-products are removed or decomposed without significant impairment of MMA.

[0003] Background technology Methyl methacrylate is used in large quantities for the preparation of polymers and copolymers with other polymerizable compounds. In addition, methyl methacrylate is an important synthetic unit for a variety of special esters based on methacrylic acid (MAA), which can be prepared by transesterification with suitable alcohols. Therefore, there is great interest in methods for preparing this starting material that are as simple, economical and environmentally friendly as possible. Of particular interest here is the provision of methyl methacrylate (MMA) or other alkyl methacrylates that exhibit low yellowing during polymerization.

[0004] MMA is currently prepared by various methods starting from C2, C3 or C4 synthesis units. In one method, which is said to be particularly efficient, MMA is obtained by the gas phase oxidation of isobutylene or tert-butanol with oxygen from air over a heterogeneous catalyst to form methacrolein, followed by oxidative esterification of methacrolein with methanol. This method, developed by Asahi Chemical Industry Co., Ltd., is described, among others, in publications U.S. Pat. No. 5,969,178 and U.S. Pat. No. 7,012,039. A disadvantage of this method is, in particular, the very high energy requirement. In a further development of this method, methacrolein is obtained in a first step from propanal and formaldehyde. Such a method is described in WO 2014 / 170223.

[0005] US Patent No. 5,969,178 describes a process for the oxidative conversion of isobutene or tert-butanol to methacrolein and subsequent oxidative esterification to MMA. In this second stage, the liquid mixture of methacrolein and methanol with reduced water content is reacted with molecular oxygen and a palladium catalyst, which is usually present on a support as a palladium-lead catalyst. Then, in a first distillation stage, the mixture of methacrolein and methanol is removed from the crude product of the oxidative esterification as a condensate at the top of the rectification column, while low boiling components, containing, for example, acetone, are removed at the top as vapor. The bottom liquid, containing MMA and depleted in methacrolein, is then sent to a second distillation stage, to which the overhead reflux of this second distillation stage is added a saturated hydrocarbon, for example selected from hexane, heptane, octane and their isomers. The saturated hydrocarbons form azeotropes with methanol in the second distillation stage (e.g., a methanol / n-hexane azeotrope with a boiling point of 49.9 ° C.), which allows methanol to be separated from the MMA-containing phase remaining in the bottom liquid. In addition, water also forms azeotropes with the saturated hydrocarbons, e.g., a water / n-hexane azeotrope with a boiling point of 61.6 ° C., which is also separated from the MMA. At the bottom of the distillation column, crude MMA remains, which contains, in addition to MMA, further high-boiling products, such as, for example, methacrylic acid. At the top of the second distillation stage, the two azeotropes of the saturated hydrocarbons with methanol and water, respectively, are condensed and sent to a phase separator. If necessary, fresh saturated hydrocarbons can be added to this condensate stream in the form of "make-ups". The upper phase of the phase separator contains mainly saturated hydrocarbons and is returned to the second distillation stage as reflux. The lower phase of the phase separator is sent to a third distillation stage, where a mixture of methanol and water is obtained as bottom product. This mixture can then be fed to a dehydration between the isobutene or tert-butanol oxidation to obtain methacrolein and the actual direct oxidative esterification, thereby reducing the amount of water in the direct oxidative esterification.

[0006] The overhead product of the third distillation stage, consisting of the two azeotropes of methanol and water, respectively, with the saturated hydrocarbons used, is returned in condensed form to the phase separator.

[0007] Thus, the reactants of the direct oxidative esterification can be recycled directly or indirectly and ultimately the crude MMA can be purified to commercial quality.

[0008] A further alternative embodiment for recycling the reactants is disclosed in US Pat. No. 5,969,178. There, the reaction product from the direct oxidative esterification is led to a first distillation column, the feed to which is located approximately in the middle of the column. In this distillation column, a mixture of, inter alia, methanol, methacrolein, MMA and water is obtained as overhead condensate. As mentioned above, low-boiling components, which contain, for example, acetone, can be removed as vapor via the top of the column. The overhead condensate results from two azeotropes, one between methacrolein and methanol, with a boiling point of 58.0° C., and one between MMA and methanol, with a boiling point of 64.5° C. As in the previous embodiment, this overhead distillate can then be fed to a dehydration between the isobutene or tert-butyl oxidation to obtain methacrolein and the actual direct oxidative esterification, but in this case the MMA must be recovered separately from the bottom product of the dehydration, since this would possibly result in a decrease in the yield of the methaacrylic product.

[0009] The bottom product of the first distillation column contains, in addition to MMA, further water and high boiling products such as, for example, methacrylic acid. After cooling, this bottom product is phase separated and the organic phase containing MMA is subjected to the usual work-up to remove high and low boiling products in order to obtain commercial quality MMA. The aqueous phase is discarded, which results in a yield loss in the form of MMA and methacrylic acid, respectively, dissolved in water.

[0010] US Patent No. 7,012,039 discloses a slightly different work-up of the oxidative esterification reactor effluent. Here, in a first distillation stage, methacrolein is distilled off at the top via a sieve tray, and the aqueous mixture containing MMA is led to a phase separator at the bottom. In this phase separator, the mixture is adjusted to a pH value of about 2 by adding sulfuric acid. Separation of the sulfuric acid water and the organic / oil phase is then carried out by centrifugation. In a further distillation, this oil phase is separated into high boilers and a phase containing MMA, which is withdrawn at the top of the column. The phase containing MMA is then separated from the low boilers in a third distillation. This is followed by a fourth distillation for final purification.

[0011] The problem with this process is sulfuric acid, which must be added in large quantities and which can have a corrosive effect on the plant components. These components, for example the phase separator, described in particular as a centrifuge, or the second distillation column, must therefore be made from materials suitable for them. Furthermore, US Pat. No. 7,012,039 also makes no mention of the handling of the co-produced methacrylic acid or the methanol remaining in the product. It is assumed, however, that the former is removed together in the distillation stage, while the methanol is only partially obtained and is returned together with methacrolein, while the remainder is probably lost in the third distillation stage. The process itself is problematic, especially with regard to the preparation of colorless MMA on spec by oxidation of isobutene to methacrolein as the first process step, since a significant proportion of diacetyl is produced there in the gas phase. Diacetyl is known as a yellow colorant for MMA and for the PMMA prepared therefrom, and its trace concentrations must be carefully controlled. Moreover, there is no indication in this prior art as to what amounts of acetals of methacrolein, in particular methacrolein dimethyl acetal, are formed and how these are physically or chemically treated and removed in the process. It is noted that the addition of sulfuric acid in this patent serves in particular to remove lead cations in the form of sparingly soluble lead sulfate in order to obtain wastewater that meets the requirements of municipal water purification. The lead cations are dissolved and removed from the catalyst of the second stage, and further lead acetate must be continuously fed to the second stage to maintain the catalytic activity.

[0012] WO 2014 / 170223 describes a similar process to US Pat. No. 7,012,039. The only difference is that in the actual reaction, the pH value is adjusted in the circuit by the addition of methanolic sodium hydroxide solution. This serves, among other things, to protect the catalyst. Furthermore, the removal of the aqueous phase in the phase separation is made easier due to the presence of salt. However, the methacrylic acid produced is present in the form of its sodium salt, which also leads to it being removed and disposed of later together with the aqueous phase. In the variant of adding sulfuric acid in the phase separation, the free acid is indeed recovered. However, instead, sodium (hydrogen)sulfate is generated, which can cause other problems when disposed of.

[0013] Finally, EP 3350153 (WO 2017 / 046110) teaches an optimized work-up of crude MMA obtained from oxidative esterification, in which the crude MMA is first separated from a heavy phase from which an alcohol-containing light phase is subsequently distilled off, which can be recycled again. A further feature of this process is that methacrolein is obtained here on the basis of propanal and formaldehyde, the former being obtained from a C2 synthesis unit, e.g. ethylene and synthesis gas. The patent teaches the work-up of an MMA-containing product mixture from the direct oxidative esterification of methacrolein and methanol to obtain MMA, in which the unconverted reactants methacrolein and methanol are distilled off via the top of a first distillation column and recycled to the reactor of the direct oxidative esterification. The mixture of MMA, water and methanol obtained at the bottom of the column further contains free methacrylic acid and the corresponding alkali metal salts and small amounts of methacrolein dimethyl acetal. The mixture is acidified and additional water is added. Then, phase separation takes place in a phase separator, followed by extraction of the upper organic phase. In this work-up sequence, it is stated that the corresponding acetal is also cleaved. However, no indication is given as to how complete the acetal cleavage is, and it remains open as to how the cleavage products methacrolein and methanol are worked up directly or indirectly. Furthermore, this teaching also leaves open how much acetal remains in the final pure MMA and how this affects the product quality in the application.

[0014] Overall, however, regardless of the methacrolein raw material base used, all of these processes result in MMA or alkyl methacrylates in general, which cause yellowing, especially in the secondary products, such as PMMA moulding compounds, etc. Thus, improvements are needed so that this source of yellowing prior to polymerization can be removed as efficiently as possible from the corresponding alkyl methacrylates, especially MMA.

[0015] In EP 3 450 422 A2, two different substances were identified as being responsible for this yellowing of the secondary products of MMA prepared by direct oxidative esterification. This is, firstly, methacrolein dimethyl acetal (hereinafter also referred to as DMIB). Moreover, methyl isobutyrate formed as a by-product in this process also seems to be responsible for the discoloration. The concept was then proposed of further converting the reactor output of the oxidative esterification in another reactor with reduced alcohol content, increased water content and reduced pH value. However, this process requires an additional reactor. Moreover, this reactor must be designed to be relatively large in order to achieve a sufficient residence time for the associated reduction of the by-products. The patent application teaches the treatment of the product mixture from the direct oxidative esterification, in which the unconverted methacrolein and methanol are first separated by distillation, and the remaining bottoms fraction, which contains MMA, water, methanol, free methacrylic acid, as well as the corresponding alkali metal salts and small amounts of methacrolein dimethyl acetal, is contacted with additional water and acid in an additional reactor, thereby achieving extensive hydrolysis of the acetals. The hydrolysis of the acetals and the hydrolysis of methyl isobutyrate are described in various embodiments, for example in a continuous stirred tank, a plug flow reactor, a phase separator, or at the bottom of the column. Although the hydrolysis of the acetals and methyl isobutyrate proceeds quite efficiently, with an acetal content of less than 20 ppm being achieved, the application also does not explicitly mention that under the described conditions the hydrolysis of MMA and thus of the valuable products of the process is carried out. Thus, the yield of the desired product is reduced and additional products of methacrylic acid and addition of water or methanol to the conjugated double bonds are produced. Among them, the formation of hydroxyisobutyric acid is of great importance, since this component has a strong corrosive effect.

[0016] assignment In view of the prior art, it is therefore an object of the present invention to provide a technically improved process for the oxidative esterification of methacrolein to prepare MMA, which, upon further processing, results in particularly low yellowing of the secondary products.

[0017] In particular, the present invention was based on the problem of efficiently removing from MMA the by-product DMIB, which is formed during the oxidative esterification of methacrolein and which leads, in particular, to yellowing of secondary products.

[0018] Moreover, it is also necessary to solve the problem of keeping the content of the by-product methyl isobutyrate in the final MMA as low as possible.

[0019] Furthermore, it has been a challenge to avoid by-products which lead to yellowing, in particular in the form of MMA hydrolysis, for example to methacrylic acid, so as to minimize as much loss of MMA as possible.

[0020] Furthermore, it was to provide a process which can be carried out with as few disposal efforts as possible, in particular by reducing the generation of organic constituents and acids in the waste stream.

[0021] solution These problems were solved by the development of a new method for preparing alkyl methacrylates, in particular MMA. This method comprises the steps of: a. a process step of preparing methacrolein in a reactor I; b. a process step of oxidatively esterifying methacrolein in at least one reactor II in the presence of an alcohol, oxygen and a heterogeneous noble metal-containing catalyst; c. A process step of distilling the reactor effluent from the reactor II in a distillation column I to separate methacrolein and a portion of the methanol; d. Optionally, a process step of pretreating the bottom effluent from process step c, i. changing the pH value by adding an acid; ii. adding water to obtain a two-phase mixture; iii. Reacting at least a portion of the mixture from ii. and e. a process step of extracting at least one organic phase of the bottom liquid from distillation column I or the bottom effluent from distillation column I with extraction I; has.

[0022] The invention is characterized in particular in that the amount of methacrolein in the organic effluent of extraction I is greater than the amount of methacrolein in the bottom effluent of distillation column I. According to the invention, this is achieved in particular by hydrolytic conversion of methacrolein-based acetals and hemiacetals. This is also preferably achieved by carrying out the reaction by reactive distillation and / or reactive extraction.

[0023] The invention is further characterized in that the amount of methacrylic acid in the organic effluent of extraction I differs from the amount of methacrylic acid in the bottom effluent of distillation column I by less than 10%, preferably less than 5%, based on the amount of methacrylic acid and its salts in the bottom effluent of distillation column I. This is achieved by a combination of acetal cleavage in a reactor provided for that purpose and an extraction apparatus in which hydrolysis also takes place.

[0024] Obtaining MMA from direct oxidative esterification of methacrolein proceeds according to the prior art with a selectivity of MMA of more than 90%. Moreover, depending on the conditions, such as the water content in the direct oxidative esterification, a selectivity of 1% to 5% of methacrylic acid is achieved, and a selectivity of 0.5% to 3% of methyl 3-methoxyisobutyrate is also found. The process according to the invention surprisingly allows the hydrolysis of DMIB of more than 90%, while at the same time the undesired hydrolysis of MMA to methacrylic acid can be reduced to a hydrolysis conversion of less than 3%. Preferably, the undesired hydrolysis can be reduced to a conversion of less than 1%, very preferably to a conversion of less than 0.5%.

[0025] The process according to the invention is preferably characterized in that the distillation column I and the extraction I, respectively, are designed to be acid-resistant and the organic acid and / or mineral acid is introduced into the reactor stream from the reactor II and / or into the bottom liquid of the distillation column I.

[0026] Preferably, the added acid has a pKa value that is 1 less, preferably 2 less, than the pKa value of methacrylic acid.

[0027] In a first embodiment of the invention, the entire bottom discharge from distillation column I is conducted to extraction I, preferably to the bottom of extraction I. In this case, the addition of acid is preferably already carried out in distillation column I or in the bottom stream leaving distillation column I in order to liberate methacrylic acid from the alkaline(earth) metal methacrylate.

[0028] In a second alternative embodiment of the invention, the bottom effluent from the distillation column I is first guided to a phase separator I, where it is separated into an organic phase rich in methacrolein, in particular consisting mainly of MMA, and a polar phase rich in water. The phase separation is promoted by the addition of water and of an acid, the bottom effluent of the distillation column being subjected to a pH change. In this embodiment, the organic phase is then guided to the extraction I, while the polar phase is transferred to a distillation column IV, where the alcohol fraction, in particular the methanol fraction, can be separated from the aqueous phase. The alcohol-containing overhead fraction can then be recycled directly or indirectly to the reactor II, while the aqueous bottom fraction can be discarded. In order to improve the overall raw material consumption, the bottom fraction from the extraction I can also be passed further through this distillation column IV.

[0029] In variant I of the first embodiment, a reactor III is arranged between the distillation column I and the extraction I, in which the bottom discharge from the distillation column I is thermally treated with the addition of water before being led to the extraction I. This reactor III has the role of bringing about the hydrolytic cleavage of methacrolein-containing acetals and hemiacetals.

[0030] In variant II of the second embodiment, such a reactor III is arranged between the distillation column I and the phase separator I, in which the bottom discharge from the distillation column I is thermally treated with the addition of water. This reactor III has the role of bringing about the hydrolytic cleavage of methacrolein-containing acetals and hemiacetals.

[0031] In all four embodiments or variants, the acid can already be fed from the distillation column I to the bottom stream before being introduced into the extraction I. In variants I or II, this is done, for example, upstream of reactor III or directly in reactor III. In the second embodiment, it is preferred to pass the acid upstream of phase separator I and / or directly into extraction I. This effectively results in the release of methacrylic acid from the respective alkaline (earth) metal methacrylate and at the same time the formation of the corresponding salt pair. When sulfuric acid and sodium methacrylate are used, for example sodium (hydrogen) sulfate is formed as the corresponding salt pair.

[0032] In the above-mentioned embodiments or variants, the addition of acid is particularly preferably carried out upstream of phase separator I, and optionally upstream of reactor III. Addition of acid at these described positions has the advantage that the alkali(-earth) metal salts from reactor II are preformed and are predominantly present in the polar phase, whereby the subsequent phase separation and extraction I proceed more efficiently. It is also conceivable to add acid at more than one position within these embodiments or variants.

[0033] Furthermore, in the process according to the invention, the reactor effluent of distillation column I preferably has an average residence time of 1 to 30 minutes, in particular 1 to 20 minutes, at a temperature of 30 to 100° C. Moreover, the bottom liquid transferred from distillation column I together with the simultaneously transferred acid resides in extraction I at a temperature of 10 to 100° C., preferably up to 90° C., particularly preferably 20 to 60° C., for 1 to 20 minutes.

[0034] Furthermore, in the process according to the present invention, reactor III preferably has a mean residence time of 10 seconds to 30 minutes, in particular 1 to 5 minutes, at a temperature of 20 to 100°C, and the reaction mixture in reactor III is preferably subjected to turbulent mixing.

[0035] In particular, there are several options for feeding the reactor stream from reactor II, which is mixed with organic and / or mineral acid. Less preferably, it is also possible to pass the acid directly to the distillation column I, which in this embodiment is necessarily designed to be acid-resistant in this case. Alternatively, the mixture can be mixed with another stream upstream of the feed to the distillation column I. Furthermore, this stream can be sent to the extraction I or premixed with another stream upstream of the feed to the extraction I. The acid can alternatively be fed at the feed of reactor III or directly to reactor III. Less preferably, it is also possible to pass the acid and the reactor effluent separately to the distillation column I or to the extraction I.

[0036] It should be noted that the individual process steps do not have to be carried out continuously, one after the other. Further process steps, such as intermediate washings, can also be carried out, in particular between the described steps a and b. Process steps a-e are carried out in a continuous run, following one another in the specified sequence, optionally supplemented with intermediate steps. Generally and preferably, steps b-d are carried out without such intermediate steps, while methacrolein (MAL) from process step a is first purified and dehydrated before being used in process step b.

[0037] Preferably, the reaction in reactor II is carried out at a water content of 0.1-10% by weight and a pH value of 5-8.

[0038] In principle, methacrolein of process step a. in reactor I can be prepared based on a C2 or C4 synthesis unit. Preferably, process step a is the reaction of propanal with formaldehyde in the presence of at least one acid and optionally an amine, i.e. a process step starting from a C2 synthesis unit. In particular, the process according to the invention can be applied to the combination of such a C2-based process for preparing methacrolein with a subsequent oxidative esterification to obtain alkyl methacrylates in process step b. This particularly relates to the description of such combinations of process steps a and b, as described, for example, in DE-A-3213681, US-A-4,408,079, CN-A-103846104 or EP-A-3194355.

[0039] Preferably, process step a in reactor I is the reaction of propanal with formaldehyde in the presence of at least one acid and optionally an amine. Particularly preferably, propanal is obtained from a C2 process. According to the present invention, a C2 process refers to a process that starts from a C2 synthesis unit in the synthesis of alkyl methacrylates. Particularly preferably, in the context of the present invention, the propanal for process step a) is obtained on the basis of ethylene and synthesis gas.

[0040] More preferably, the alcohol in process step b is methanol and the alkyl methacrylate is MMA.

[0041] By adding acid, methacrolein dimethyl acetal (dimethoxyisobutene, DMIB) is cleaved in process steps d and e or in variants I or II and process steps d and e of reactor III together with water into methacrolein and methanol. These cleavage products correspond to the reactants used in process step b and together with these remaining reactants are separated in large part via the top of distillation column I and / or extraction I and / or optionally distillation column IV or in a side stream and optionally returned directly or indirectly to reactor II. The expression "large part" here generally includes at least 70% of MAL and methanol. If a recycle rate is subtracted from the output of reactor II, it is preferably even more than 98% for MAL and methanol.

[0042] Alternatively, the overhead product of extraction I can be separated by distillation into a phase containing MMA and a low-boiling phase, the reactant from process step b being in the low-boiling phase. This low-boiling phase also separates into an organic phase and an aqueous phase. The aqueous and / or organic phase fractions contain components that are difficult to separate from MMA, such as, for example, methyl isobutyrate or methyl propionate, and therefore can optionally be discharged from the process instead of being fully recycled to the process.

[0043] The addition of the acid can take place in process step d such that it is introduced directly into the bottoms of the distillation column I. Alternatively, or less preferably, the acid can also be fed, for example, into the feed from the reactor II. It is also possible to feed the crude product from the reactor II first with the acid in a mixing chamber and then feed this mixture into the distillation column I.

[0044] When adding an acid to the bottoms, a combination of the design of the column and the choice of acid must be considered. In particular, if the column is packed to an appropriate degree with distillation packing, the acid should not be selected to form poorly soluble salts with potentially present ions such as sodium ions. To prevent the associated clogging or plugging of the column over time, methanesulfonic acid can be used instead of sulfuric acid when adding an acid to the bottoms.

[0045] Particularly preferably, the acid used is sulfuric acid. Sulfuric acid here includes concentrated sulfuric acid, but also aqueous solutions of sulfuric acid. Preference is given to using aqueous sulfuric acid with a sulfuric acid proportion of at least 10% by weight. More preferably, the distillation in the distillation column I is carried out at a bottom temperature of 50 to 100 ° C. This internal temperature, measured in the liquid phase, depends in particular on the internal pressure and on the exact configuration of the distillation column used. Columns with intermediate trays, packing materials or relatively large internal volumes can generally be operated at different temperatures than columns without the respective configuration.

[0046] Optionally, additional water can be introduced into the bottoms of distillation column I to improve results.

[0047] Especially preferably, the acid is added to the effluent stream from the bottoms of distillation column I.

[0048] In an optional embodiment of the present invention, an acid, preferably sulfuric acid, can be additionally passed into the extraction in process step e, the sulfuric acid can be concentrated, but an aqueous solution of sulfuric acid can also be used, preferably an aqueous sulfuric acid solution with a sulfuric acid proportion of at least 10% by weight is used. Depending on the overall process configuration, this additional acid in the extraction can further reduce the by-product content, in particular the content of DMIB. Those skilled in the art can easily check with minor modifications whether in selected embodiments additional addition of acid to extraction I has a positive effect or whether the acid transferred from process step d is sufficient in extraction I. The cleavage of methacrolein-containing acetals with water in an acidic medium is carried out by the method according to the present invention in such a way that a commercial quality MMA with a DMIB content of less than 90 ppm is achieved after isolation.

[0049] Preferably, extraction I of process step d is a mixer-settler. Alternatively, however, other devices can be used, such as, for example, centrifugal or stirred cell extraction. The combination of a plug flow reactor as reactor III and a settler as phase separator I upstream of extraction I has also proven to be very advantageous. Optionally, in one of these variants, additional water can also be supplied.

[0050] The medium used as the extractant is preferably water, aqueous sulfuric acid or at least a portion of the bottoms stream from distillation column IV.

[0051] Generally, process step e is followed by isolation and purification stages, which may be phase separators, distillation columns such as high / low boiler columns or crystallization chambers. Preferably, they are optionally at least one phase separator, at least one high boiler column and at least one low boiler column.

[0052] In process step e, in extraction I, the bottom discharge from distillation column I is separated into a phase containing alkyl methacrylates, in particular a phase containing MMA, and a polar phase containing the acid used and its salts. The methacrylic acid or other light organic acids formed, in contrast, may remain mainly in the phase containing MMA. Preferably, the phase containing MMA is subsequently led to distillation column II. Preferably, this distillation column II is a distillation column for separating high-boiling components from the MMA phase.

[0053] Particularly preferably, this distillation column II is designed to be acid-resistant.

[0054] In an alternative embodiment, distillation column II is a distillation column for separating low boiling components from the MMA phase. In this case, an acid, preferably sulfuric acid, in particular aqueous sulfuric acid, can be introduced into the bottoms and / or feed of the column. In this embodiment, the bottoms of this distillation column II are then led to an acid-resistant designed distillation column III for separating high boiling components from the MMA phase, so that in this particular embodiment, the MMA-containing stream is contacted with acid at relatively high temperatures in a total of four different process steps, with the proportion of by-products being further reduced in each case.

[0055] However, highly preferred is another embodiment, which has the opposite concept compared to the preceding embodiment, in which distillation column II is the high boiler column and distillation column III is the low boiler column, in which generally no acid addition is made to distillation column III.

[0056] According to the invention, the invention is particularly characterized in that in process step c in the bottom liquid of distillation column I the water content is at least 2% by weight, preferably at least 3% by weight, particularly preferably at least 4% by weight, higher in absolute terms than in reactor II. In some embodiments of the invention, in particular when the acid is fed directly to the bottom of extraction I, the difference in water content can also only be 20% by weight, or even 30% by weight or more, higher in absolute terms than in reactor II.

[0057] Furthermore, the alcohol concentration of process step c in the bottoms of distillation column I is lower than in reactor II, in which process step b is carried out. This is already the result of the distillation alone. However, it also seems to play a decisive role with regard to the decomposition of DMIB.

[0058] Finally, the novel process is characterized in that the pH value in the bottom discharge from distillation column I after the addition of acid is generally between 0.5 and 7, preferably between 0.5 and 4, in particular between 0.5 and 3, being at least 0.5 lower than that established in reactor II.

[0059] The pH value of extraction I, after the addition of acid, is generally 0.5 to 7. The addition of acid here can be carried out according to embodiments 1 and 2 and their variants I and II. Preferably, the pH value is 0.5 to 4, in particular 0.5 to 3, preferably at least 0.5 lower than in reactor II.

[0060] Surprisingly, it has been found that the alkyl methacrylates prepared according to the invention, in particular the MMA prepared according to the invention, result in a particularly colorless final product. This is the case, for example, in polymerization processes in which the product is often subjected to degassing and the recycle liquid obtained by this degassing is returned to the polymerization for use in further polymerization steps. In this case, by-products, in particular by-products with a relatively low vapor pressure, can accumulate during the process. The accumulation of these by-products, in particular dimethoxyisobutene (DMIB) and methyl isobutyrate, further increases the yellowing of the polymer in subsequent batches. Therefore, after several recyclings, a part of the recycle liquid must be discarded in order to reduce the circulation of the recycle liquid for these by-products. This also leads to a decrease in the overall polymer yield. The method according to the invention surprisingly makes it possible to carry out significantly more batches with return and reuse of the recycle liquid, which can thus significantly improve the overall polymer yield.

[0061] Moreover, it has surprisingly been found that the process according to the invention not only reduces the DMIB content, but also reduces the proportion of undesirable methyl isobutyrate in the final product.

[0062] A surprising and identified negative effect of DMIB on alkyl methacrylate resins and secondary products prepared therefrom is, in addition to yellowing, a decrease in the thermal stability of polymers prepared therefrom. This is due to a more severe polymer chain degradation during thermal treatment, which affects especially during processing to obtain molded articles and during the work-up of polymer syrups. Therefore, a further advantage of the present invention is that the alkyl methacrylates prepared according to the present invention do not have these disadvantages with respect to the polymers prepared therefrom.

[0063] In addition to the described methods, novel alkyl methacrylates, which can be obtained as products, for example, from the process steps a to e according to the invention, form part of the subject matter of the present invention. These novel alkyl methacrylates are therefore characterized in that they necessarily have DMIB as a constituent. Moreover, the alkyl methacrylates also generally have methyl isobutyrate.

[0064] In particular, these alkyl methacrylates can be prepared by a very advantageous method starting from a C2 base instead of a C3 or C4 base as the basic synthesis unit of the methacrylate synthesis.What is particularly novel about this alkyl methacrylate, compared to the materials described in the prior art, is that it does have DMIB, but in a hitherto unknown content of less than 90 ppm, preferably less than 50 ppm, and very preferably less than 20 ppm.In particular, a content of less than 90 ppm is particularly suitable for the preparation of methacrylate resins without visible yellowing.

[0065] Further preferably, the alkyl methacrylate according to the invention additionally comprises a methyl isobutyrate content of less than 250 ppm, particularly preferably less than 200 ppm, particularly preferably less than 170 ppm. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0066] [Figure 1] A method for preparing alkyl methacrylates is provided.

[0067] Explanation of symbols Reactor for the direct oxidative esterification of 1-MAL and methanol to MMA II 2- Optional supply of fresh MAL; MAL can also be optionally supplied directly to 1 3- Possible supplies of sulfuric acid 4- Feed stream to distillation column I Distillation column I for returning 5-MAL and methanol 5 to 1 recycle stream / distillate stream with 6-MAL and methanol (Reactor II) 7- Possible supplies of sulfuric acid and water Bottoms stream from 8-5 Optional Reactor III for Cleavage of 9-Acetals 10- Possible supplies of sulfuric acid and water 11-Flow from reactor III to phase separator I 12-Optional Phase Separator I 13-Outlet from Phase Separator I - Aqueous phase (salt-rich) 14 - Bottoms stream of distillation column IV 15 - Distillation column IV for further methanol recovery 16—Distillate stream of distillation column IV—optionally may be returned to reactor II or 5 or 6 17 - Aqueous bottoms stream from extraction column I for feeding distillation column IV 18-Outlet from Phase Separator I - Organic Phase (rich in MMA) 19 - Extraction column for cleaving DMIB (methacrolein dimethyl acetal) 20-Addition of extraction water to the top of extraction column I 21- The overhead stream, which is crude MMA leaving extraction column I, is sent to distillation column II.

[0068] Working Example Example 1 - Cleavage of Acetals Direct oxidative esterification of methacrolein and methanol to give MMA was carried out in a stirred tank using a gold-cobalt oxide@SiO2-Al2O3-MgO catalyst (see WO2017084969) at 80 °C, 5 bar (absolute pressure), pH = 7 and a molar ratio of methanol to methacrolein of 4:1 at the reactor inlet.

[0069] The resulting reaction mixture was sent together with fresh methacrolein to a distillation column (distillation column I); the column pressure was 1000 mbar (absolute), the reflux ratio was 1.00 and the column bottom temperature averaged 73° C. The feed to the column averaged approximately 2800 g / h and the column bottom discharge was about 1180 g / h.

[0070] The concentrations of relevant components in the reaction product (RKP) and the bottoms of distillation column I were as follows: [Table 1] All values ​​are in mass %.

[0071] Aqueous sulfuric acid was added continuously to the bottom effluent in a small acid-resistant stirred tank, so that a pH value of 2 and a bottom liquid to feed water ratio of 0.77 (by weight) were obtained. The two-phase mixture was subjected to turbulent mixing in the stirred tank at 40° C. with an average residence time of 5 minutes. The two-phase mixture was then subjected to phase separation at 40° C. and both phases were analyzed. The flow rate of the organic phase was on average 773 g / h and the flow rate of the aqueous phase was on average 1622 g / h.

[0072] The relevant component concentrations in the phases were as follows: [Table 2] All values ​​are mass %. |nd = not detected. Detection limit is <5 ppm by GC-FID.

[0073] Furthermore, the MMA content in the organic phase of the phase separator was analyzed, showing a decrease of 0.4% (absolute), whereas the methacrylic acid content increased in total by 0.3% (absolute). "In total" means an increase in methacrylic acid in the organic phase of the phase separator and also an increase in methacrylic acid in the aqueous phase, the contents being measured by HPLC to exclude lower results due to residual methacrylic acid.

[0074] The organic phase was then sent to the bottom of the extraction column, where the extraction was carried out as a stirred cell extraction in countercurrent mode. The extraction parameters were the same as in the previous reactor: 40° C., pH value 2. The ratio of organics to extraction water was 3.9 (by mass). The flow rate of the crude MMA, which corresponds to the organics at the top of the extraction column, was on average 770 g / h.

[0075] The relevant component concentrations in the organic matter (also called crude MMA) at the top of the extraction column were as follows: [Table 3] All values ​​are mass %. |nd = not detected. Detection limit is <5 ppm by GC-FID.

[0076] The extraction water used was distilled water. It should be noted that the aqueous phase of the phase separator and the aqueous phase of the extraction can be sent together to a second distillation column, optionally to remove the organic matter remaining therein by distillation. The sulfuric acid-containing bottom product obtained in this distillation column can be used at least in part as the acidification and extraction water in the stirred tank, thereby reducing the need for fresh water and fresh sulfuric acid in the process.

[0077] Based on the analysis and flow rates, the following conversions can be calculated: Conversion rate of acetal cleavage in a stirred tank = 96.5% Conversion rate of acetal cleavage in the extraction column = 3.5% Overall conversion of acetal cleavage =>99.99%.

[0078] Based on the analytical results and the flow rate, the methacrolein emissions can also be determined: [Table 4]

[0079] It is therefore seen that the proportion and amount of methacrolein increases upon acetal cleavage and that at least a portion can be recycled directly to oxidative esterification.

[0080] The obtained crude MMA was purified by a high boiler distillation column and a low boiler distillation column, and stabilized to commercial quality in a final purification distillation column. The quality of the obtained MMA is shown in Table 1.

[0081] Example 2 - Change in pH value for acetal cleavage Example 2a - pH=3 The experiment was carried out as in Example 1, but the pH value for the acetal cleavage was 3. The following conversions were achieved: Conversion rate of acetal cleavage in a stirred tank = 73.2% Conversion rate of acetal cleavage in the extraction column = 24.7% Overall conversion of acetal cleavage = 97.9%.

[0082] Example 2b - pH=4 The experiment was carried out as in Example 1, but the pH value for the acetal cleavage was 4. The following conversions were achieved: Conversion rate of acetal cleavage in a stirred tank = 31.0% Conversion rate of acetal cleavage in the extraction column = 59.4% Overall conversion of acetal cleavage = 90.4%.

[0083] Example 2c - pH=5 The experiment was carried out as in Example 1, but the pH value for the acetal cleavage was 5: the following conversions were achieved: Conversion rate of acetal cleavage in a stirred tank = 9.7% Conversion rate of acetal cleavage in the extraction column = 32.5% Overall conversion of acetal cleavage = 42.2%.

[0084] Examples 1 and 2 show that at low pH values, most of the acetal cleavage occurs in the stirred tank, thus resulting in an acetal content below 20 ppm. As the pH value increases, the conversion rate shifts towards extraction and, overall, it is no longer possible to achieve the conversion rate of more than 97%, which is required for pure MMA with an acetal content below 20 ppm.

[0085] Further MMA workup was performed as in Example 1 and the results are summarized in Table 1: Table 1 - Pure MMA Quality Overview [Table 5]

[0086] It is found that increasing the pH value and therefore decreasing the conversion in the acetal cleavage leads to accumulation of acetals and methyl isobutyrate in pure MMA, which in subsequent processing increases the yellowness of the polymer and thus reduces its optical quality.

[0087] Example 3 - Addition of Acid to Bottoms of Distillation Column I Aqueous sulfuric acid was fed into the bottoms of distillation column I at the same mass flow rate as in Example 1, thereby giving a pH value of 2. Mixing occurred due to thermally induced circulation of the bottoms. The residence time in the bottoms was about 10 min. The stirred tank was omitted and the bottoms were sent directly to the phase separation. The conversion of acetal cleavage achieved in the bottoms was more than 99%. However, due to the long residence time and relatively high temperature, secondary reactions / polymerization formation occurred, which led to the formation of a brown lag phase (Mulm-Phase) between the organic and aqueous phases in the phase separation, which disturbed the fill level control of the phase separation and caused fluctuations in the mass flow rate to the extraction. This resulted in fluctuations in the crude MMA of the extraction and in the MMA content in the aqueous product, which made the general plant operation more sensitive and the final pure MMA quality fluctuated.

[0088] Thus, although it is in principle possible to carry out the acetal cleavage with sulfuric acid in the bottoms, this means that for long-term operation the following phase separation / extraction must be equipped with technical means for lag phase removal to allow stable operation, resulting in further additional costs.

[0089] Example 4 - Tubular reactor instead of stirred tank for acetal cleavage A tubular reactor with a length of 60 m and an internal diameter of 4 mm, equipped with three static mixers evenly distributed on the reactor, was fed with the bottom effluent of the first distillation column (for composition see Example 1) and an aqueous sulfuric acid solution, so that the residence time in the reactor was 83 seconds. The organic to aqueous sulfuric acid ratio was 0.71 (by weight) and the pH value was 3. The tubular reactor was operated at 80° C. by preheating the feed stream and jacket heating.

[0090] Downstream of the tubular reactor, the reaction mixture was cooled to 40° C. and phase separated as in Example 1. The conversion of the acetal cleavage was determined by GC analysis to be 96.1%, and therefore higher than in the stirred tank case. This example shows that improved mixing and higher reaction temperatures increase the space-time yield of the acetal cleavage with a concomitant decrease in sulfuric acid consumption (tubular reactor=1.37 mol DMIB / kg H2SO4×hr (hr) vs. stirred tank=1.2 mol DMIB / kg H2SO4×hr (hr)).

[0091] Example 5 - Acetal cleavage in a stirred vessel at elevated temperatures The experiment was carried out as in Example 1, but the temperature was increased from 40° C. to 80° C. The following conversions were achieved: Conversion rate of acetal cleavage in a stirred tank = 98.9% Conversion rate of acetal cleavage in the extraction column = 1.0% Overall conversion of acetal cleavage =>99.99%.

[0092] However, the MMA content in the organic phase of the phase separator decreased by 2.8%. At the same time, the content of methacrylic acid in the aqueous and organic phases of the phase separator increased by 2.3% in total. "In total" means the increase in methacrylic acid in the organic phase of the phase separator and also the increase in methacrylic acid in the aqueous phase, the contents were measured by HPLC to exclude low results due to residual methacrylic acid.

[0093] This suggests that MMA is hydrolyzed to methacrylic acid by increasing the temperature.

[0094] Example 6 - Acetal cleavage in a stirred tank at elevated temperature and extended residence time The experiment was carried out similarly to Example 1, except that the temperature was increased from 40° C. to 80° C. and the residence time was doubled from approximately 5 minutes to approximately 10 minutes. The following conversions were achieved: Conversion rate of acetal cleavage in a stirred tank = 99.8% Conversion rate of acetal cleavage in the extraction column = 0.1% Overall conversion of acetal cleavage =>99.99%.

[0095] However, the MMA content in the organic phase of the phase separator decreased by 5.4%. At the same time, the methacrylic acid content in the aqueous and organic phases of the phase separator increased by 4.5% in total. "In total" means an increase in methacrylic acid in the organic phase of the phase separator and also an increase in methacrylic acid in the aqueous phase, the contents were measured by HPLC to exclude low results due to residual methacrylic acid. This suggests that the increase in temperature hydrolyzes MMA to methacrylic acid.

[0096] Examples 5 and 6 show that at higher temperatures and / or extended residence times, not only does the conversion of acetal cleavage increase, but significant hydrolysis of MMA occurs, thereby resulting in loss of valuable materials.

[0097] Example 7 - Acetal cleavage in a stirred tank at varying pH values The experiment was carried out as in Example 1, but the pH value for the acetal cleavage was 1. The following conversions were achieved: Conversion rate of acetal cleavage in a stirred tank = 99.8% Conversion rate of acetal cleavage in the extraction column = 0.1% Overall conversion of acetal cleavage =>99.99%.

[0098] However, the MMA content in the organic phase of the phase separator decreased by 2.5%. At the same time, the methacrylic acid content in the aqueous and organic phases of the phase separator increased by 2.1% in total. "In total" means an increase in methacrylic acid in the organic phase and also in the aqueous phase of the phase separator, the contents were measured by HPLC to exclude low results due to residual methacrylic acid. This suggests that the increase in temperature hydrolyzes MMA to methacrylic acid.

[0099] Example 7 shows that a sufficiently high conversion in the acetal cleavage can also be achieved without extraction, but at the cost of loss of MMA and thus of a valuable substance or product of the process.

[0100] Nevertheless, Examples 5 to 7 are examples according to the invention, since in each case the proportion of hydrolyzed MMA is still lower compared to the prior art, while at the same time the acetal is efficiently cleaved.

Claims

1. 1. A process for preparing an alkyl methacrylate comprising the steps of: a. a process step of preparing methacrolein in reactor I; b. a process step of oxidatively esterifying said methacrolein in at least one reactor II in the presence of an alcohol, oxygen and a heterogeneous noble metal-containing catalyst; c. A process step of distilling the reactor effluent from the reactor II in a distillation column I to separate methacrolein and a portion of the methanol; d. Optionally, a process step of pre-treating the bottom effluent from process step c, comprising: i. adding an acid to change the pH value; ii. adding water to obtain a two-phase mixture; iii. reacting at least a portion of the mixture from ii.; and e. A process step of extracting the organic phase of the bottom liquid from distillation column I or the bottom effluent from distillation column I with extraction I; 20. The method of claim 19, further comprising: The method according to claim 1, wherein the amount of methacrolein in the organic effluent of extraction I is greater than the amount of methacrolein in the bottom effluent of distillation column I.

2. 2. The process for preparing alkyl methacrylates according to claim 1, comprising a process step e., which is the extraction of the bottoms from distillation column I with extraction I, Extraction I and optionally distillation column I are designed to be acid-resistant; an organic acid and / or a mineral acid is mixed with the reactor stream from reactor II and introduced into said distillation column I and / or into said extraction column I; the reactor effluent has an average residence time in distillation column I of 1 to 30 minutes at a temperature of 30 to 100° C., In extraction I, the bottom liquid transferred from the distillation column I is retained for 1 to 20 minutes at a temperature of 10 to 100° C. in the presence of the additionally transferred acid.

2. The method according to claim 1 , characterized in that

3. 3. The process according to claim 1, wherein the reaction in reactor II is carried out at a water content of 0.1 to 10% by weight and a pH value of 5 to 8.

4. 4. The process according to claim 1, characterized in that process step a in reactor I is the reaction of propanal with formaldehyde in the presence of at least one acid and optionally an amine, and in process step b the alcohol is methanol and the alkyl methacrylate is MMA.

5. 5. The process according to claim 1, characterized in that in process step c, methacrolein dimethyl acetal is split with water into methacrolein and methanol, the majority of which is separated in the distillation column I together with the remaining reactants of process step b. via the top of the distillation column I or in a side stream and recycled to reactor II.

6. 6. The process according to claim 1, wherein in process step c, sulfuric acid is conducted as the acid to the distillation column I and, optionally, in process step e, further to the extraction.

7. 7. The process according to claim 1, characterized in that additional water is introduced into the bottoms of the distillation column I and the distillation is carried out at a bottom temperature of 50 to 100°C.

8. 8. The process according to claim 1, characterized in that the extraction I is a mixer-settler and that as extractant water, aqueous sulfuric acid or the bottom stream from distillation column IV is used.

9. 9. The process according to claim 1, wherein the acid is added to the effluent from the bottoms of the distillation column I.

10. 10. The process according to claim 1, characterized in that process step e. is followed by isolation and purification stages, which are at least one optional phase separator, at least one high boiler column and at least one low boiler column.

11. 11. The process according to claim 10, characterized in that in process step e., in the extraction I, the bottom discharge from the distillation column I is separated into a phase containing MMA and a polar phase containing the acid used and its salts, the MMA-containing phase being subsequently conducted to a distillation column II, which is preferably a distillation column for separating high-boiling components from the MMA phase.

12. 12. The process according to claim 11, characterized in that the distillation column II is designed to be acid-resistant and an acid, preferably sulfuric acid, is introduced into the bottoms and / or into the feed of the distillation column II.

13. 12. The process according to claim 11, characterized in that the distillation column II is a distillation column for separating low boiling components from the MMA phase, an acid, preferably sulfuric acid, is introduced into its bottoms and / or feed, and the bottoms of the distillation column II are led to a distillation column III designed to be acid-resistant for separating high boiling components from the MMA phase.

14. 14. The process according to claim 1, wherein the acid added has a pKa value that is 1 less than the pKa value of methacrylic acid.

15. MMA which can be prepared by process steps a to d of the process according to any one of claims 1 to 11, The MMA comprises methacrolein dimethyl acetal (DMIB) and methyl isobutyrate, characterized in that the MMA has a DMIB content of less than 90 ppm and a methyl isobutyrate content of less than 200 ppm.

16. 16. The MMA of claim 15, characterized in that the MMA has a DMIB content of less than 50 ppm and a methyl isobutyrate content of less than 250 ppm.