Driving assistance system and operation assistance method
The driving support system calculates and predicts power consumption and driving patterns in real-time, addressing the challenge of mid-journey evaluation and optimization, thereby enhancing energy-saving awareness and operational efficiency for railway operators.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/JP2024/016411
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-05-12
- Filing Date
- 2024-04-26
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-21
AI Technical Summary
Railway operators face challenges in reducing power consumption associated with train operations, as existing systems can only evaluate and present power consumption results after the journey between stations, lacking opportunities for real-time awareness and optimization during the journey.
A driving support system that includes a power consumption calculation unit, a remaining section driving pattern prediction unit, and an evaluation index generation unit, which calculate and predict power consumption and driving patterns in real-time, allowing for mid-journey evaluation and optimization by comparing actual and predicted values with reference data from past operations and simulations.
Enables real-time presentation of power consumption evaluation during the journey, improving energy-saving awareness and operational efficiency by providing drivers with immediate feedback on their energy usage and suggesting optimized driving patterns, leading to reduced energy consumption and improved punctuality.
Smart Images

Figure JP2024016411_21112024_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
Driving assistance system and driving assistance method
[0001] The present invention relates to a train operation support system and a train operation support method, and more particularly to a train operation support system and the like that can evaluate the amount of power consumption of a train.
[0002] To address environmental issues and reduce operating costs, railway operators are facing the challenge of reducing the amount of electricity consumed by train operations. One way to reduce the amount of electricity consumed by train operations is to optimize the speed patterns (hereinafter referred to as "running patterns") used when traveling between stations.
[0003] Patent Document 1 describes a train operation simulator. In this train operation simulator, an energy information calculation unit calculates the power consumption related to train operation and integrates the power consumption amount during execution of the operation simulation. An energy screen display control unit controls the display of a graph showing the running speed for each running position and also controls the display of a graph showing the power consumption for each running position. An individual evaluation unit evaluates the running time based on a timetable and evaluates the power consumption amount based on a standard power consumption amount. An overall evaluation unit performs an overall evaluation of the operation simulation based on the evaluation results by the individual evaluation units.
[0004] Japanese Patent Application Laid-Open No. 2020-134757
[0005] Because on-time operation is important for railways, it is necessary to evaluate power consumption taking into account the running time between stations. Therefore, in order to evaluate power consumption based on the actual running time between stations, the evaluation can only be performed after the running between stations has finished, when the running time is determined, which has led to a problem of limited opportunities to raise drivers' awareness of energy-saving driving. The present invention aims to provide a driving assistance system and driving assistance method for railways that can present the results of power consumption evaluation not only after the running between stations has finished, but also during the running between stations.
[0006] In order to solve the above problems, the present invention provides a driving assistance system that includes: a power consumption calculation unit that calculates actual inter-station power consumption, which is the power consumption associated with train travel; a remaining section travel pattern prediction unit that predicts a predicted remaining section travel pattern, which is the travel pattern for the remaining section between stations on which the train is traveling; a remaining section power consumption prediction unit that predicts a predicted remaining section power consumption value, which is the predicted power consumption for the remaining section, based on the predicted remaining section travel pattern; and an evaluation index generation unit that generates an evaluation result for the train's power consumption before arriving at the next stop station based on the actual inter-station power consumption and the predicted remaining section power consumption value. In this case, the evaluation result for power consumption can be presented on a railway not only after travel between stations has ended but also during travel between stations.
[0007] The evaluation index generation unit can generate the evaluation results by comparing the evaluation reference value of the inter-station power consumption with the sum of the actual inter-station power consumption and the predicted power consumption for the remaining section. In this case, a more appropriate evaluation index can be used for comparison. The evaluation reference value can be generated based on comparative operation data. In this case, the evaluation reference value is more suited to the actual situation. Furthermore, the comparative operation data can be at least one of operation data with the lowest power consumption obtained from past operation data, operation data with average power consumption, and operation data with the lowest power consumption obtained by operation simulation. In this case, more appropriate comparative operation data can be selected. Furthermore, the system can further include an evaluation result presentation unit that presents evaluation results for at least one of the power consumptions obtained from past operation data, operation data with the lowest power consumption, operation data with average power consumption, and operation data with the lowest power consumption obtained by operation simulation, together with the power consumption of the train before arriving at the next stop. In this case, the evaluation results can be presented in an easy-to-understand manner. Furthermore, the evaluation result can be at least one of the difference between the evaluation reference value and the sum, a score based on the difference, and pass / fail. In this case, a more appropriate evaluation result can be selected. Furthermore, the remaining section travel pattern prediction unit can determine the remaining section predicted travel pattern under the condition that the train travels the remaining section at a travel time close to the target remaining travel time between stations. In this case, the travel pattern for the remaining section can be determined more accurately. Furthermore, the remaining section travel pattern prediction unit can determine the remaining section predicted travel pattern by extracting operation data from past operation data that matches the train position, train speed, and target remaining travel time, and further selecting operation data that has similar characteristics of the operating history up to the timing of generating the remaining section predicted travel pattern. In this case, a more appropriate travel pattern for the remaining section can be determined from the past operation data.The remaining section predicted driving pattern is generated by operation simulation, and the driving tendency up to the timing of generating the remaining section predicted driving pattern can be used as the driving pattern if it were continued for the remaining section. In this case, a more appropriate driving pattern for the remaining section can be determined by operation simulation. Furthermore, the remaining section driving pattern prediction unit can determine the remaining section predicted driving pattern at a timing when it is expected that there will be fewer changes in driving operation. In this case, the crew's receptivity to assistance information is improved, contributing to improved energy-saving effects. Furthermore, the timing can be determined based on the driving pattern at the time of planning. In this case, more appropriate timing can be determined in advance. Furthermore, after arriving at the next stop, the evaluation index generation unit can generate an evaluation result for the train's power consumption between stations. In this case, the evaluation result for the determined power consumption after traveling between stations can be presented. The evaluation index generation unit can further generate an evaluation result for the traveling time between stations. In this case, the evaluation result for the traveling time between stations can also be presented.
[0008] The present invention also provides an operation support method in which a processor executes a program stored in a memory to calculate actual inter-station power consumption, which is the power consumption associated with train travel, predict a predicted remaining section travel pattern, which is the travel pattern for the remaining section between stations along which the train is traveling, predict a predicted remaining section power consumption value, which is the predicted power consumption for the remaining section, based on the predicted remaining section travel pattern, and generate an evaluation result for the train's power consumption before arriving at the next stop based on the actual inter-station power consumption and the predicted remaining section power consumption value.In this case, the evaluation result for power consumption can be presented not only after the train has finished traveling between stations but also during its travel between stations.
[0009] According to the present invention, it is possible to provide a driving assistance system and a driving assistance method that can present the evaluation results of the amount of power consumption not only after the end of the inter-station travel but also during the inter-station travel.
[0010] 1 is a block diagram showing the overall configuration of the driving assistance system of this embodiment. FIG. 1 is a diagram showing the results of a first type of evaluation. FIG. 2 is a diagram showing the results of a first type of evaluation. FIG. 3 is a diagram showing an example of a presentation in which the results of the first type of evaluation are displayed in a graph. FIG. 4 is a diagram showing an example of a method of assigning points to driving time. FIG. 5 is a diagram showing an example of a method of assigning points to power consumption. FIG. 6 is a diagram showing an example of a presentation in which the results of the second type of evaluation are displayed. FIG. 7 is a diagram showing an example of a presentation in which the results of the third type of evaluation are displayed. FIG. 8 is a diagram showing an example of a presentation in which the results of the first type of evaluation are displayed in a graph. FIG. 9 is a diagram showing an example of a presentation in which the results of the second type of evaluation are displayed. FIG. 10 is a diagram showing an example of a presentation in which the results of the third type of evaluation are displayed. FIG. 11 is a diagram showing an example of a timing in which driving operations are not busy. FIG. 12 is a diagram showing an example of a database that defines positions for the timing of executing a prediction process.
[0011] An embodiment of the present invention will be described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings. In this embodiment, the driving assistance system 1 evaluates the amount of power consumption and running time associated with the inter-station running during and after the inter-station running, and presents the evaluation results to the driver. After the inter-station running ends, the actual values of the amount of power consumption and running time for the entire inter-station running are compared with the amount of power consumption and running time that serve as evaluation thresholds. On the other hand, when evaluation is performed during inter-station running, the amount of power consumption compared with the evaluation threshold is the sum of the actual amount of power consumption from the time the train departs from the previous stop until the evaluation timing and the predicted amount of power consumption from the evaluation timing until the time the train arrives at the next stop. Note that, since the entire running time for the inter-station running is not determined during inter-station running, no comparison for evaluation is performed.
[0012] <Overall Description of Driving Assistance System 1> Fig. 1 is a block diagram showing the overall configuration of the driving assistance system 1 of this embodiment. As shown in Fig. 1, the driving assistance system 1 of this embodiment is composed of an operation data recording unit 101, a power consumption calculation unit 102, a driving time calculation unit 103, an evaluation index comparison unit 104, an evaluation result presentation unit 105, a remaining section driving pattern prediction unit 106, and a remaining section power consumption prediction unit 107.
[0013] The operation data recording unit 101 records data related to train operation. A specific example of the operation data recording unit 101 is a driving status recording device. The operation data recording unit 101 can record and output data in chronological order regarding at least power consumption information 151, which is information related to power consumption associated with operation, train position 153, which is the position of the train between stations, train speed 154, which is the speed of the train, target remaining running time between stations 157, and driving operation details 160. The operation data recording unit 101 is not limited to a driving status recording device, and can be any device that can record this information in chronological order.
[0014] As an example of the definition of the target remaining running time 157, it is possible to define it as the time obtained by subtracting the current time from the target arrival time of the train at the next stop station. As another example of the definition of the target remaining running time 157, it is possible to define it as the time obtained by subtracting the elapsed time from the departure timing from the previous stop station to the current time from the target running time for the entire distance between the previous stop station and the next stop station. The target running time is the target time required to run between the previous stop station and the next stop station, and can be determined in advance based on the running pattern at the time of planning, for example. Furthermore, the driving operation content 160 includes at least the operation content of the notch and the operation content of the constant speed running switch.
[0015] The power consumption calculation unit 102 receives the power consumption information 151, the train position 153, and the train speed 154 from the operation data recording unit 101. Then, the power consumption calculation unit 102 calculates the instantaneous power consumption of the train based on this information.
[0016] Examples of the power consumption information 151 include the input voltage and input current of each inverter in the train. Therefore, the power consumption calculation unit 102 can calculate the power consumption of the train by summing the products of the input voltage and input current for all inverters installed in the train. Furthermore, the power consumption calculation unit 102 calculates the actual inter-station power consumption 152 by integrating the power consumption for a time range of the train's travel between stations. That is, the actual inter-station power consumption 152 is the power consumption associated with the train's travel from the departure station between the target stations to the present time. The power consumption calculation unit 102 uses the train position 153 and the train speed 154 to determine the time range of the train's travel between stations. That is, using the train position 153 and the train speed 154, the time range of the train's travel between stations can be calculated from the time when the train's speed changes from zero to positive at the departure station between the target stations to the time when the train's speed changes from positive to zero at the stop station between the target stations. In calculating the power consumption in the power consumption calculation unit 102, the power calculation may be performed only when the input current is positive, i.e., only the traction power excluding the regenerative power. In this way, the influence of the presence of other trains on the track and the braking / driving state of the train can be eliminated, and the power consumption of the train itself can be evaluated.
[0017] The running time calculation unit 103 receives the train position 153 and the train speed 154 from the operation data recording unit 101. Then, the running time calculation unit 103 calculates the actual inter-station running time 155 based on this information. The actual inter-station running time 155 is the time from when the train departs from a departure station to when it stops at a stop station. The running time calculation unit 103 calculates, for example, the actual inter-station running time 155 from the time when the train position 153 is at the departure station position of the target inter-station running and the train speed 154 changes from zero to positive to the time when the train position 153 is at the stop station position and the train speed 154 changes from positive to zero.
[0018] The processes of the operation data recording unit 101, the power consumption calculation unit 102, and the running time calculation unit 103 described above are always executed at a fixed cycle. The processing cycle is determined by simulation or the like, provided that the required accuracy can be ensured from the viewpoint of power consumption calculation and evaluation.
[0019] The remaining section running pattern prediction unit 106 receives the train position 153, train speed 154, target remaining running time 157, and operation operation details 160 from the operation data recording unit 101. Then, based on this information, the remaining section running pattern prediction unit 106 generates a remaining section predicted running pattern 158, which is the running pattern for the remaining section during the inter-station running stage. It can also be said that the remaining section running pattern prediction unit 106 predicts the remaining section predicted running pattern 158, which is the running pattern for the remaining section between stations on which the train is running. Here, the running pattern data is time-series data, and data items include time, position, speed, operation details, and input voltage and input current of each inverter. The prediction processing method will be described later. The predicted remaining section predicted running pattern 158 is sent to the remaining section power consumption prediction unit 107 and the operation data recording unit 101. By recording the contents of the remaining section predicted driving pattern 158 together with the actual driving pattern in the operation data recording unit 101, it is possible to improve the prediction processing contents based on a comparative analysis of these two types of driving patterns.
[0020] The remaining section power consumption prediction unit 107 receives the remaining section predicted driving pattern 158 from the remaining section driving pattern prediction unit 106. Then, the remaining section power consumption prediction unit 107 generates a remaining section power consumption predicted value 159, which is a predicted value of power consumption for the section, based on the remaining section predicted driving pattern 158. It can also be said that the remaining section power consumption prediction unit 107 predicts the remaining section power consumption predicted value 159, which is a predicted amount of power consumption for the remaining section, based on the remaining section predicted driving pattern 158. The remaining section power consumption prediction unit 107 calculates the instantaneous power consumption of the train by summing up the products of the input voltages and input currents included in the remaining section predicted driving pattern 158 for all inverters installed in the train, and calculates the remaining section power consumption predicted value 159 by integrating this over the time range to the next station.
[0021] The evaluation index comparison unit 104 is an example of an evaluation index generation unit that generates an evaluation index. The evaluation index comparison unit 104 receives the actual inter-station power consumption 152, the actual inter-station running time 155, and the remaining section power consumption predicted value 159. Then, the evaluation index comparison unit 104 generates an evaluation result 156 based on this information. The method of generating the evaluation result 156, which will be described in detail later, differs between when the train is running between stations and when it has finished running between stations. When the train is running between stations, it can be said that the evaluation index comparison unit 104 generates the evaluation result 156 about the train's power consumption before it arrives at the next stop, based on the actual inter-station power consumption 152 and the remaining section power consumption predicted value 159.
[0022] The evaluation result presentation unit 105 receives the evaluation result 156 from the evaluation index comparison unit 104. Then, the evaluation result presentation unit 105 displays the evaluation result 156 on a display device that can be visually viewed by the driver, such as the driver's cab screen of a vehicle information device.
[0023] <Explanation of Evaluation Result 156 After Running Between Stations and Presentation Examples> Next, specific examples of the evaluation result 156 after running between stations and presentation examples of the evaluation result 156 by the evaluation result presentation unit 105 will be described. First, three types of examples of the evaluation result 156 after running between stations will be shown. The first type is a result of simply comparing the numerical values of running time and power consumption. The second type is a result of scoring based on a comparison of the numerical values of running time and power consumption. The third type is a result of determining whether the evaluation result 156 based on a comparison of the numerical values of running time and power consumption is pass / fail.
[0024] In the first type of simple numerical comparison, the following [A] to [D] are compared and the difference is calculated. [A] Comparison of the evaluation reference value for the inter-station running time (reference running time) with the actual inter-station running time 155 [B] Comparison of the evaluation reference value for the inter-station power consumption amount (result of searching past operation data, energy saving) with the actual inter-station power consumption amount 152 [C] Comparison of the evaluation reference value for the inter-station power consumption amount (result of searching past operation data, average) with the actual inter-station power consumption amount 152 [D] Comparison of the evaluation reference value for the inter-station power consumption amount (result of operation simulation, energy saving) with the actual inter-station power consumption amount 152
[0025] The evaluation result 156 includes the calculated difference along with the numerical value of each comparison target. The difference is the difference from the evaluation reference value. Here, the evaluation reference value is a value that serves as a comparison standard when evaluating the inter-station running time and the amount of power consumption between stations. The evaluation reference values exist as a database inside the evaluation index comparison unit 104, and there are evaluation reference values for the inter-station running time and evaluation reference values for the amount of power consumption between stations. An example of the evaluation reference value for the inter-station running time is the standard running time between each station set by the railway operator. There are variations in the evaluation reference value for the amount of power consumption between stations, and they may be generated by searching past operation data or by operation simulation. The methods for generating these will be described later.
[0026] 2 to 4 are diagrams showing the first type of evaluation results 156. Of these, FIG. 2 is a diagram showing an example of the evaluation results 156 for [A] and [B]. FIG. 3 is a diagram showing an example of the evaluation results 156 for [A] and [C]. Furthermore, FIG. 4 is a diagram showing an example of the evaluation results 156 for [A] and [D]. The evaluation result presentation unit 105, which receives the numerical comparison results, which are the first type of evaluation results 156, displays the information in FIGS. 2 to 4 in numerical form in a table format or displays these numerical values in a graph on a display device that can be visually viewed by the driver, such as the driver's cab screen of the vehicle information device. When displaying these values, it is not necessary to display all of the information in FIGS. 2 to 4; only a portion of the information may be displayed.
[0027] FIG. 5 is a presentation example in which the first type of evaluation result 156 is displayed in a graph. In this example, the operation date and the actual arrival and departure times between the stations are displayed in text in the upper left of the screen, and a scatter plot is displayed from the center to the bottom of the screen. The horizontal axis of the scatter plot represents the running time between the stations, and the vertical axis represents the amount of power consumed. Four data points are plotted on the scatter plot. The four data points are the actual value (shown as "Actual" in the figure), the energy saving of the past actual results (shown as "Energy saving (past actual)" in the figure), the average of the past actual results (shown as "Average (past actual)" in the figure), and the result of the energy saving simulation (shown as "Energy saving (simulation)" in the figure).
[0028] In the second scoring system, the closer the actual value is to the ideal value for both running time and power consumption, the higher the score. The ideal value for running time is the reference value for evaluation of running time between stations, i.e., the standard running time between each station set by the railway operator.
[0029] FIG. 6 is a diagram showing an example of how to assign scores for running time. In FIG. 6, the horizontal axis represents running time, and the vertical axis represents the score. In this example, a time range H1 that provides the highest score is set around the evaluation reference value, and the score is assigned so that the score decreases as the range moves away from this range. The ideal value for power consumption is either an energy-efficient value obtained by searching past operation data from the evaluation reference value for inter-station power consumption, or the result of an operation simulation.
[0030] Fig. 7 shows an example of how to assign scores to power consumption. In Fig. 7, the horizontal axis represents power consumption, and the vertical axis represents scores. In this example, a power consumption range H2 that provides the highest score is set around the evaluation reference value, and the scores are assigned so that the score decreases as the power consumption increases beyond this range.
[0031] The evaluation result presentation unit 105, which has received the scores related to the running time and the amount of power consumption, which are the second type of evaluation result 156, displays these scores on a display device that can be seen by the driver, such as the driver's cab screen of the vehicle information device. When displaying the scores, the scores for the running time and the amount of power consumption may be displayed separately, or a value obtained by adding the two scores together with some weighting may be displayed.
[0032] 8 is a diagram showing an example of presentation of the second type of evaluation result 156. In this example, the operation date and the actual arrival and departure times between the stations are displayed in text on the left side of the screen, and the running time, power consumption, and overall evaluation score are displayed as evaluation results 156 on the right side of the screen.
[0033] In the third type of pass / fail judgment, a conceivable method is to compare the score result of the second type evaluation result 156 with a predetermined reference score value, and judge the train to pass if the score exceeds the reference score. Alternatively, regarding the amount of power consumption, a method is possible in which an average value obtained by searching past operation data among the evaluation reference values for the amount of power consumption between stations is compared with the actual amount of power consumption between stations 152, and judge the train to pass if the latter is smaller than the former.
[0034] When the evaluation result 156 is a pass, the evaluation result presenting unit 105, which has received the pass / fail judgment result, which is the third type of evaluation result 156, displays a message indicating that the evaluation result 156 is a pass. For example, the message may be "adequate" for the driving time and "ECO" for the power consumption.
[0035] FIG. 9 is a diagram showing an example of the presentation of the third type of evaluation result 156. In this example, the operation date and the actual departure and arrival times between the stations are displayed in text on the left side of the screen, and the pass / fail judgments for the running time and the amount of power consumption are displayed on the right side of the screen as the evaluation result 156. Possible judgment options for the running time include "appropriate," "early arrival," and "late arrival." Possible judgment options for the amount of power consumption include "eco" and "not eco." As described above, the evaluation index comparison unit 104 generates an evaluation result 156 for the amount of power consumption of the train between stations after the train arrives at the next stop. The evaluation index comparison unit 104 also generates an evaluation result 156 for the running time between stations. The above describes an example of the presentation of the evaluation result 156 by the evaluation result presentation unit 105 after the train has run between stations.
[0036] <Explanation of Evaluation Result 156 During Inter-Station Travel and Presentation Examples> Next, specific examples of the evaluation result 156 during inter-station travel and presentation examples of the evaluation result 156 by the evaluation result presentation unit 105 will be described. First, three types of examples of the evaluation result 156 during inter-station travel will be shown. Note that, since the travel pattern for the remaining section to the next station is not determined during inter-station travel, evaluation of the travel time is not performed, and only evaluation of the amount of power consumption is performed. In other words, no comparison corresponding to the above [A] is performed.
[0037] The first type is a result of simply comparing the numerical values of the power consumption, the second type is a score based on the comparison of the numerical values of the power consumption, and the third type is a pass / fail judgment of the evaluation result 156 based on the comparison of the numerical values of the power consumption.
[0038] In the first type of simple numerical comparison, the following [B'], [D'], and [F'] are compared and the difference is calculated. [B'] Comparison of the reference value for evaluation of the amount of power consumption between stations (results from searching past operation data, energy saving) with the sum of the actual amount of power consumption between stations 152 at the time of evaluation and the predicted value of power consumption for the remaining sections 159 [D'] Comparison of the reference value for evaluation of the amount of power consumption between stations (results from searching past operation data, average) with the sum of the actual amount of power consumption between stations 152 at the time of evaluation and the predicted value of power consumption for the remaining sections 159 [F'] Comparison of the reference value for evaluation of the amount of power consumption between stations (results from operation simulation, energy saving) with the sum of the actual amount of power consumption between stations 152 at the time of evaluation and the predicted value of power consumption for the remaining sections 159
[0039] The evaluation result 156 includes the calculated difference along with the numerical value of each comparison target. The difference is a difference from a reference value for evaluation. The reference value for evaluation here exists as a database inside the evaluation index comparison unit 104, and a reference value for the amount of power consumption between stations is used. The reference value for the amount of power consumption between stations is the same as that used in the evaluation after running between stations described above.
[0040] 10 to 12 are diagrams showing the first type of evaluation results 156. Of these, FIG. 10 is a diagram showing an example of the evaluation result 156 for [B']. FIG. 11 is a diagram showing an example of the evaluation result 156 for [D']. Furthermore, FIG. 12 is a diagram showing an example of the evaluation result 156 for [F']. The evaluation result presenting unit 105, which has received the numerical comparison result, which is the first type of evaluation result 156, displays the information in FIGS. 10 to 12 in numerical form in a table format or displays these numerical values in a graph on a display device that can be visually viewed by the driver, such as the cab screen of the vehicle information device. When displaying these, it is not necessary to display all of the information in FIGS. 10 to 12; only a portion of the information may be displayed.
[0041] FIG. 13 is a presentation example of the first type of evaluation result 156 displayed in a graph. It is desirable that the display in the evaluation result presentation unit 105 clearly indicate that the evaluation is based on estimated values midway between stations. Here, this is indicated by displaying "estimated values midway between stations." In this example, the operation date and the actual departure time between the stations are displayed in text at the top of the screen (with the arrival time being marked as "not collected" because it is not yet determined), and a bar graph is displayed from the center to the bottom of the screen. The vertical axis of the bar graph represents the amount of power consumption. The graph depicts four types of data: estimated values, past energy savings (displayed as "Energy Saving (Past Results)" in the figure), the average of past results (displayed as "Average (Past Results)" in the figure), and the results of an energy saving simulation (displayed as "Energy Saving (Simulation)" in the figure).
[0042] In the second type of scoring, the closer the sum of the actual inter-station power consumption 152 at the time of evaluation and the predicted power consumption value for the remaining section 159 is to the ideal value for the inter-station power consumption, the higher the score is assigned. The ideal value for the power consumption is either an energy-efficient value obtained by searching past operation data or a result of an operation simulation, among the reference values for evaluation of the inter-station power consumption.
[0043] The method of assigning points for the amount of power consumption is the same as that shown in Fig. 7. That is, a power consumption range H2 that provides the highest score is set around the evaluation reference value, and points are assigned so that the score decreases as the amount of power consumption increases beyond that range.
[0044] The evaluation result presentation unit 105 receives the score related to the amount of power consumption, which is the second type of evaluation result 156, and displays this score on a display device that can be seen by the driver, such as the driver's cab screen of the vehicle information device.
[0045] FIG. 14 is a diagram showing an example of the presentation of the second type of evaluation result 156. It is desirable that the display in the evaluation result presentation unit 105 clearly indicate that the evaluation is based on estimated values for the distance between stations. Here, this is indicated by displaying "estimated values for the distance between stations." In this example, the operation date and the actual departure time between the stations are displayed in text on the left side of the screen (the arrival time is not yet determined, so it is written as "not collected"), and the power consumption score is displayed as the evaluation result 156 on the right side of the screen. Because the running pattern for the remaining section between stations is not yet determined, the running time and overall evaluation columns are written as "not determined."
[0046] In the third type of pass / fail judgment, a conceivable method is to compare the score result of the second type evaluation result 156 with a predetermined reference score value, and judge the train to pass if the score exceeds the reference score. Alternatively, regarding the amount of power consumption, a method is possible in which an average value obtained by searching past operation data among the evaluation reference values for the amount of power consumption between stations is compared with the actual amount of power consumption between stations 152, and judge the train to pass if the latter is smaller than the former.
[0047] When the evaluation result 156 is a pass, the evaluation result presenting unit 105 that has received the pass / fail judgment result, which is the third type of evaluation result 156, displays a message indicating that the evaluation result 156 is a pass. For example, a message such as "ECO" may be displayed in relation to the amount of power consumption.
[0048] FIG. 15 shows an example of the third type of evaluation result 156. It is desirable for the display in the evaluation result presentation unit 105 to clearly indicate that the evaluation is based on estimated values for the inter-station distance. Here, this is indicated by displaying "estimated values for the inter-station distance." In this example, the operation date and the actual departure time between the stations are displayed in text on the left side of the screen (the arrival time is not determined, so "not collected" is displayed), and the pass / fail judgment for the power consumption is displayed as the evaluation result 156 on the right side of the screen. Because the running pattern for the remaining section between the stations is not determined, the "running time" column is marked "not determined." Note that possible judgment options for the power consumption amount include "Eco" and "Non-Eco." As described above, the evaluation index comparison unit 104 generates the evaluation result 156 by comparing the evaluation reference value for the inter-station power consumption with the sum of the actual inter-station power consumption 152 and the remaining section power consumption predicted value 159. In the above example, the evaluation result 156 is at least one of the difference between the evaluation reference value and the sum thereof, a score based on the difference, and a pass / fail result. The above describes an example of presentation of the evaluation result 156 by the evaluation result presentation unit 105 during running between stations.
[0049] <Description of a method for generating an evaluation reference value for inter-station power consumption> Next, a method for generating an evaluation reference value for inter-station power consumption used in the evaluation index comparison unit 104 will be described. The evaluation reference value for inter-station power consumption is generated based on comparative operation data for comparison with actual operation results. Here, the comparative operation data is operation data that is the subject of comparison when traveling between target stations. The comparative operation data is time-series operation data, and includes information on speed, position, notch operation, and the associated power consumption. Hereinafter, the evaluation reference value for inter-station power consumption will be referred to as the reference inter-station power consumption. The reference inter-station power consumption is calculated by accumulating the power consumption included in the comparative operation data over the entire period of travel between stations.
[0050] Below, we will explain how to create comparative operation data. There are two examples of how to create comparative operation data: searching past operation data and operation simulation. Furthermore, there are two main types of comparative operation data: "operation data for energy-efficient operation" and "operation data for operation with average power consumption" when traveling between target stations.
[0051] <Method of Creating Comparison Operation Data by Searching for Past Operation Data> Searching for past operation data is premised on the existence of a set of past operation data accumulated between target stations. The accumulated operation data is time-series operation data, and includes information on speed, position, notch operation, and power consumption. The accumulation of operation data can be realized by periodically acquiring data from an operation data recording unit 101, such as a driving status recording device (not shown).
[0052] From the accumulated operation data, data within a predetermined range of running time is extracted, and among that, operation data with the most energy-efficient running and operation data with average power consumption are searched for, and the respective power amounts are calculated. Note that when the power consumption calculation unit 102 calculates power consumption based only on power running, it searches for operation data with energy-efficient and average power amounts from the perspective of power running power in order to have a consistent comparison target. The predetermined range of running time is a time range that can be considered as on-time operation. This time range is set near the standard running time between the target stations, and can be set to a width of, for example, 5 to 10 seconds to ensure a sufficient number of samples for statistical processing.
[0053] <Method of Creating Comparative Operation Data Using Operation Simulation> Condition settings required for operation simulation include vehicle conditions (weight, running resistance characteristics, tractive force, braking force, and electric braking force characteristics), route conditions (station distance, route gradient and curvature, presence or absence of tunnels, speed limit), timetable conditions (travel time between stations), and operating method conditions. These conditions are stored in advance in the evaluation index comparison unit 104. Note that the weight, which is included in the vehicle conditions, is affected by fluctuations in occupancy due to the day of the week and time of day. Therefore, by additionally acquiring and using the occupancy value for the inter-station run to be simulated from the operation data recording unit 101, operation simulation with higher accuracy can be performed in terms of speed pattern and power consumption (not shown). Furthermore, the tractive force characteristics, which are included in the vehicle conditions, are affected by the overhead line voltage in electric railways. Therefore, by additionally acquiring and using the overhead line voltage value for the inter-station run to be simulated from the operation data recording unit 101, operation simulation with higher accuracy can be performed in terms of speed pattern and power consumption (not shown). Furthermore, the electric braking force characteristics included in the vehicle conditions are affected by the overhead line voltage in electric railways, so by additionally obtaining and using the overhead line voltage value for the inter-station running to be simulated from the operation data recording unit 101, it is possible to perform a more accurate operation simulation in terms of power consumption (not shown).
[0054] The operating method conditions are how the running speed pattern while traveling between stations is determined, and ultimately the notch handling strategy. The running time and power consumption amount change depending on the operating method conditions. In the operation simulation to create the comparative operation data, first a running speed pattern that allows the train to travel between stations in the shortest time is generated. Hereafter, this running speed pattern will be referred to as the fastest pattern. The fastest pattern is a speed pattern that utilizes the maximum acceleration and maximum deceleration allowed in consideration of safety and ride comfort, and travels at a high speed that does not exceed the speed limit. If the running time when traveling between stations using the fastest pattern is equal to or longer than the running time specified in the timetable, then the fastest pattern will be used as the comparative operation data.
[0055] If the running time of the fastest pattern is shorter than the running time specified in the timetable, then by utilizing the extra running time, flexibility in the running speed pattern can be created. In other words, by running at the running time specified in the timetable, and then reducing the maximum speed from the fastest pattern or increasing coasting, it is possible to run between stations more energy-efficiently than with the fastest pattern. In such cases, a mathematically generated energy-efficient running pattern (hereinafter referred to as an energy-efficient pattern) that runs at the running time specified in the timetable is used as the operation data for comparison. There is a lot of existing research on methods for mathematically generating energy-efficient patterns, such as methods using dynamic programming and hill-climbing methods, so these methods can be utilized.
[0056] The inter-station power consumption of the generated comparative operation data can be calculated by accumulating the instantaneous power consumption estimated from the magnitude of tractive force and electric control force required to run along the running pattern, taking into account equipment efficiency, etc., over the course of running between stations. Note that when the power consumption calculation unit 102 calculates the power consumption based only on power running, the power running between stations is also calculated by accumulating only positive power consumption.
[0057] Since it is difficult to represent the variations in driving patterns in actual driving using operation simulation methods, only "operation data for energy-efficient driving" is generated as comparative operation data, and "operation data for driving with average power consumption" is not generated.
[0058] The above is an explanation of the methods for creating comparative operation data. Using these creation methods, two types of "operation data for energy-efficient driving" (a method based on searching past operation data and a method based on operation simulation) and one type of "operation data for driving with average power consumption" (a method based on searching past operation data) are created as comparative operation data, and reference inter-station power consumption amounts are calculated for each type. In this case, the comparative operation data can be said to be at least one of the operation data for driving with the lowest power consumption (energy-efficient) obtained from past operation data, the operation data for driving with average power consumption, and the operation data for driving with the lowest power consumption (energy-efficient) obtained by operation simulation.
[0059] In addition, the forms of Figures 10 to 13 can also be said to be such that the evaluation result presentation unit 105 presents, side by side, evaluation results 156 for at least one of the power consumption amounts obtained from the operation data with the lowest power consumption (energy-efficient) running, which is determined from past operation data, the operation data with the average power consumption, and the operation data with the lowest power consumption (energy-efficient) running, which is determined by operation simulation, and the power consumption amount of the train before arriving at the next stop.
[0060] <Description of Method for Generating Remaining Section Predicted Driving Pattern 158> Next, an example of a method for generating the remaining section predicted driving pattern 158 in the remaining section driving pattern prediction unit 106 will be described in detail. First, the timing of the process for generating the remaining section predicted driving pattern 158 in the remaining section driving pattern prediction unit 106 will be described. The process for generating the remaining section predicted driving pattern 158 is not executed continuously. Specifically, the process is performed at discrete timings so that the evaluation result presentation unit 105 can present information based on the generation results at a timing that is easily acceptable to the driver. Here, a timing that is easily acceptable to the driver refers to a timing when driving operations are not busy or when the vehicle is not entering a section where a speed limit is imposed by a branch or curve, etc. Providing information at such timings improves the driver's receptivity to the support information, contributing to improved energy-saving effects.
[0061] An example of a timing when driving operations are not busy is a timing when the vehicle is coasting or cruising at a constant speed after accelerating. In this case, it can be said that the remaining section driving pattern prediction unit 106 determines the remaining section predicted driving pattern 158 at a timing when it is expected that there will be few changes in driving operations. FIG. 16 is a diagram showing an example of a timing when driving operations are not busy. The driving pattern shown in FIG. 16 is not an actual driving pattern, but a driving pattern at the time of planning, represented by a driving curve diagram. A section where coasting or cruising at a constant speed continues is extracted in advance from the driving pattern at the time of planning, and the remaining section driving pattern prediction unit 106 is controlled to execute the prediction process while traveling through that section. In FIG. 16, this section is indicated by an arrow. In addition to a method of referring to the driving pattern at the time of planning, a method of statistically extracting sections where coasting or cruising at a constant speed is often performed based on past driving records can be considered as a method of selecting a timing when driving operations are not busy.
[0062] An example of a determination regarding the timing of the prediction process in the remaining section driving pattern prediction unit 106 is a method in which the determination is made based on the train position 153 by referring to a database provided inside the remaining section driving pattern prediction unit 106 that defines positions for the timing of executing the prediction process.
[0063] FIG. 17 is a diagram showing an example of a database that defines positions for the timing of executing prediction processing. The illustrated database is composed of three types of data: "Inter-station," "Prediction number within inter-station," and "Inter-station running position." "Inter-station" has a value that indicates a combination of a departure station and a destination station. "Prediction number within inter-station" indicates a number that distinguishes between multiple prediction timings for the same inter-station period. "Inter-station running position" contains a value that indicates the position where prediction processing will be performed, and when the train position 153 reaches that position, the processing of the remaining section running pattern prediction unit 106 is executed.
[0064] Next, we will describe the process of generating the remaining section predicted driving pattern 158 in the remaining section driving pattern prediction unit 106. There are two methods for generating the remaining section predicted driving pattern 158, namely, searching past driving data and driving simulation.
[0065] <Method of generating remaining section predicted travel pattern 158 by searching past operation data> Searching past operation data is premised on the existence of a group of past operation data accumulated between target stations. The accumulated operation data is time-series operation data, and includes information on speed, position, notch operation, and power consumption. The accumulation of operation data can be realized by periodically acquiring data from an operation data recording unit 101, such as a driving status recording device (not shown).
[0066] First, at the timing of generating the remaining section predicted running pattern 158, operation data that matches the train position 153, train speed 154, and target remaining running time 157 is extracted from the accumulated past operation data. Here, the matching of each element does not need to be strictly the same value, and a method of determining whether the values are close to each other by setting a predetermined judgment criterion may be used.
[0067] Next, from the extracted group of operation data, the operation data is further narrowed down and extracted, taking into account the characteristics of the operation history up to the timing of generating the remaining section predicted operation pattern 158, and the operation data with the most similar operation history characteristics is selected. The portion of the operation data selected in this manner from the train position 153 onwards is set as the remaining section predicted operation pattern 158. Here, examples of the characteristics of the operation history include characteristics of the running speed pattern shape and characteristics of the driving operation. The characteristics of the driving operation are characteristics related to the driver's operations related to braking and driving of the vehicle, such as notch operation and constant speed running switches. An example of a method for extracting operation data based on the characteristics of the running speed pattern shape and the driving history is pattern matching using time series data of parameters related to the characteristics of the driving history (speed, notch, switch, etc.). This makes it possible to generate from past operation data a driving pattern that would occur if the driving tendency up to the timing of generating the remaining section predicted operation pattern 158 were continued in the remaining section.
[0068] <Method for generating remaining section predicted running pattern 158 by operation simulation> Condition settings required for the operation simulation include vehicle conditions (weight, running resistance characteristics, tractive force, braking force, and electric braking force characteristics), route conditions (station distance, route gradient and curvature, presence or absence of tunnels, speed limit), timetable conditions (running time between stations), and operating method conditions. These conditions are stored in advance in the remaining section running pattern prediction unit 106. Note that the weight included in the vehicle conditions is affected by fluctuations in occupancy rate depending on the day of the week and time of day. Therefore, by additionally acquiring and using the occupancy rate value for the running between stations to be simulated from the operation data recording unit 101, a more accurate operation simulation can be achieved in terms of speed pattern and power consumption (not shown). Furthermore, the tractive force characteristics included in the vehicle conditions are affected by the overhead line voltage in electric railways. Therefore, by additionally acquiring and using the overhead line voltage value for the running between stations to be simulated from the operation data recording unit 101, a more accurate operation simulation can be achieved in terms of speed pattern and power consumption (not shown). Furthermore, the electric braking force characteristics included in the vehicle conditions are affected by the overhead line voltage in electric railways, so by additionally obtaining and using the overhead line voltage value for the inter-station running to be simulated from the operation data recording unit 101, it is possible to perform a more accurate operation simulation in terms of power consumption (not shown).
[0069] The operation method conditions are how to determine the running speed pattern while running between stations, and ultimately the notch handling strategy. The running time and power consumption amount change depending on the operating method conditions. The premise for generating the remaining section predicted running pattern 158 is that the crew will aim for on-time operation, and will run the remaining section at a running time as close as possible to the target remaining running time 157.
[0070] In the operation simulation for generating the remaining section predicted running pattern 158, first, starting from the train position 153 and train speed 154 at the timing of generating the remaining section predicted running pattern 158, a running speed pattern is generated that will allow the train to run the remaining section to the next stop in the shortest time. Hereinafter, this running speed pattern will be referred to as the fastest pattern. The fastest pattern is a speed pattern that utilizes the maximum acceleration and maximum deceleration allowed in consideration of safety and ride comfort, and runs at a high speed within a range that does not exceed the speed limit. If the running time when running the remaining section using the fastest pattern is equal to or greater than the target remaining running time 157, the fastest pattern is used as comparison operation data.
[0071] When the running time of the fastest pattern is shorter than the target remaining running time 157, the extra running time can be utilized to create a degree of freedom in the running speed pattern. That is, by running at the target remaining running time 157, and then reducing the maximum speed from the fastest pattern or increasing coasting, it is possible to run between stations more energy-efficiently than with the fastest pattern.
[0072] In such a case, one possible method is to generate a driving pattern for driving the remaining section at the target remaining driving time 157 by simulation, taking into account the characteristics of the driving history up to the timing of generating the remaining section predicted driving pattern 158. Here, the characteristics of the driving history include characteristics related to driving operations when braking and driving the vehicle, such as notch operation and the constant speed driving switch. More specifically, these characteristics related to driving operations are determined from the driving history up to the timing of generating the remaining section predicted driving pattern 158, and incorporated into a driver model when performing an operation simulation for the remaining section. In this way, a driving pattern that would occur if the driving tendencies up to the timing of generating the remaining section predicted driving pattern 158 were continued for the remaining section can be generated by the operation simulation.
[0073] As another example of a method for generating, by simulation, a driving pattern for driving the remaining section within the target remaining driving time 157, a driving pattern can be generated by assuming that the remaining section will be driven in a mathematically optimal energy-saving pattern. There are many existing studies on mathematically generating energy-saving patterns, such as methods using dynamic programming and hill-climbing methods, and these methods can be utilized.
[0074] In the above example, it can be said that the remaining section travel pattern prediction unit 106 determines the remaining section predicted travel pattern 158 under the condition that the train travels the remaining section in a travel time close to the target remaining travel time between stations. This concludes the description of an example of the method for generating the remaining section predicted travel pattern 158 in the remaining section travel pattern prediction unit 106.
[0075] Regarding the installation locations of each processing unit described above, the power consumption calculation unit 102, running time calculation unit 103, evaluation index comparison unit 104, remaining section running pattern prediction unit 106, and remaining section power consumption prediction unit 107 can be installed either on the ground or on the train, and data is exchanged between the ground and trains as needed. In particular, the remaining section running pattern prediction unit 106 requires a lot of processing and uses a database of past operation data, so processing it on a high-performance ground server leads to cost reduction and compactness of the on-board equipment. The evaluation result presentation unit 105 is implemented on a driver's cab screen on the train and is assumed to be checked by the driver immediately after the end of the inter-station run. However, it may also be implemented on a tablet device carried by the driver or a computer terminal used on the ground.
[0076] There is variation in the driving patterns when the driver manually drives the train, which causes variations in running time and power consumption. By reducing the variation in driving patterns and operating in an energy-efficient manner within the range of running time that allows punctuality to be maintained, it is possible to reduce the amount of power consumed by train operations. In addition to adopting automatic train driving systems that automate driving, other effective ways to reduce the variation in driving patterns include educating drivers on energy-efficient driving methods and introducing driving assistance systems that provide driving advice, assuming manual driving. Methods that assume manual driving have lower implementation costs than adopting automatic train driving systems, so until automatic driving becomes mainstream in the future, reducing the variation in driving patterns by assuming manual driving is effective.
[0077] Maintaining driver motivation is a major challenge in reducing the variability of driving patterns based on manual driving. Many drivers experience some psychological resistance to modifying their familiar driving methods. Therefore, to establish energy-saving driving methods, the energy-saving effects must be visible and tangible. One way to address this issue is to introduce a driving assistance system that displays the energy consumption and running time associated with inter-station driving, as well as the evaluation results of driving skills, on a screen in the driver's cab. Checking the driver's own driving results and evaluation results after each inter-station driving session can maintain motivation to improve driving methods. The driving assistance system 1 described above can display the evaluation results of energy consumption not only after the inter-station driving session has ended but also during the inter-station driving session. Therefore, the driver's own driving results and evaluation results can be checked even while driving between stations. This can strengthen the driver's awareness of energy-saving driving, leading to energy savings in train operation.
[0078] <Explanation of Operation Assistance Method> The processing performed by the driving assistance system 1 described above is realized by the cooperation of software and hardware resources. That is, a processor within a computer provided in the driving assistance system 1 loads software that realizes each of the above-mentioned functions into memory and executes it to realize each of these functions. Therefore, the processing performed by the driving assistance system 1 can be considered as a driving assistance method in which the processor executes a program recorded in memory to calculate actual inter-station energy consumption 152, which is the energy consumption associated with train travel, predict a remaining section predicted travel pattern 158, which is the travel pattern for the remaining section between stations along which the train is traveling, predict a remaining section energy consumption predicted value 159, which is the predicted energy consumption for the remaining section, based on the remaining section predicted travel pattern 158, and generate an evaluation result 156 of the train's energy consumption before arriving at the next stop based on the actual inter-station energy consumption 152 and the remaining section energy consumption predicted value 159.
[0079] Although the present embodiment has been described above, the technical scope of the present invention is not limited to the scope described in the above embodiment. It is clear from the claims that various modifications and improvements to the above embodiment are also included in the technical scope of the present invention.
[0080] 1... Driving assistance system, 101... Operation data recording unit, 102... Power consumption calculation unit, 103... Running time calculation unit, 104... Evaluation index comparison unit, 105... Evaluation result presentation unit, 106... Remaining section running pattern prediction unit, 107... Remaining section power consumption prediction unit, 151... Power consumption information, 152... Actual inter-station power consumption, 153... Train position, 154... Train speed, 155... Actual inter-station running time, 156... Evaluation result, 157... Target remaining running time, 158... Remaining section predicted running pattern, 159... Remaining section power consumption prediction value, 160... Driving operation content, H1... Time range, H2... Power amount range
Claims
1. A driving assistance system comprising: a power consumption calculation unit that calculates actual inter-station power consumption, which is the power consumption associated with the running of a train; a remaining section running pattern prediction unit that predicts a remaining section predicted running pattern, which is the running pattern for the remaining section between stations along which the train is running; a remaining section power consumption prediction unit that predicts a remaining section power consumption predicted value, which is the predicted power consumption for the remaining section, based on the remaining section predicted running pattern; and an evaluation index generation unit that generates an evaluation result for the power consumption of the train before arriving at the next station, based on the actual inter-station power consumption and the remaining section power consumption predicted value.
2. A driving assistance system as described in claim 1, wherein the evaluation index generation unit generates the evaluation result by comparing an evaluation reference value of the amount of power consumption between stations with the sum of the actual amount of power consumption between stations and the predicted amount of power consumption for the remaining sections.
3. A driving assistance system according to claim 2, wherein the evaluation reference value is generated based on comparative driving data.
4. A driving assistance system as described in claim 3, wherein the comparative driving data is at least one of driving data obtained from past driving data, driving data obtained from driving with average power consumption, and driving data obtained by driving simulation, which shows the least power consumption.
5. A driving assistance system as described in claim 4, further comprising an evaluation result presentation unit that presents, in a side-by-side manner, evaluation results for at least one of the amounts of power consumed by the train, obtained from past operation data, the amount of power consumed by the train, the average amount of power consumed, and the amount of power consumed by the train, obtained by operation simulation, and the amount of power consumed by the train before arriving at the next stop.
6. A driving assistance system according to claim 2, wherein the evaluation result is at least one of a difference between the evaluation reference value and the sum, a score based on the difference, and pass / fail.
7. A driving assistance system as described in claim 1, wherein the remaining section driving pattern prediction unit determines the remaining section predicted driving pattern under the condition that the train travels through the remaining section in a driving time close to a target remaining traveling time between stations.
8. The driving assistance system of claim 7, wherein the remaining section driving pattern prediction unit determines the remaining section predicted driving pattern by extracting from past operation data operation data in which the train position, train speed and target remaining driving time match, and further selecting operation data in which the characteristics of the driving history up to the timing of generating the remaining section predicted driving pattern are similar.
9. A driving assistance system as described in claim 7, wherein the remaining section predicted driving pattern is generated by operation simulation and is a driving pattern that occurs when the driving tendency up to the timing of generation of the remaining section predicted driving pattern is continued in the remaining section.
10. A driving assistance system according to claim 1, wherein the remaining section driving pattern prediction unit determines the remaining section predicted driving pattern at a timing when fewer changes in driving operation are expected.
11. A driving assistance system according to claim 10, wherein the timing is determined based on a driving pattern at the time of planning.
12. A driving assistance system as described in claim 1, wherein the evaluation index generating unit generates an evaluation result regarding the amount of power consumed by the train between stations after the train arrives at the next station.
13. A driving assistance system according to claim 12, wherein the evaluation index generating unit further generates an evaluation result regarding a travel time between stations.
14. An operation support method in which a processor executes a program recorded in a memory to calculate actual inter-station power consumption, which is the power consumption associated with train operation, predict a remaining section predicted running pattern, which is the running pattern for the remaining section between stations along which the train is running, predict a remaining section power consumption predicted value, which is the predicted power consumption for the remaining section, based on the remaining section predicted running pattern, and generate an evaluation result for the power consumption of the train before arriving at the next station based on the actual inter-station power consumption and the remaining section predicted power consumption value.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Operation assist system
JP2014148277A
Travel pattern generation device, automatic train operation system equipped with travel pattern generation device and automatic train operation device, and operation assisting system equipped with travel pattern generation device and operation assisting device
JP2017063556A
Program and train operation simulator
JP2020134757A
Train operations management system, method for managing train operations, and train operations management program
WO2016139709A1
