High-end numerical control machine tool reliability design method
Through layer-by-layer decomposition and Bayesian fusion method, combining fault data and cost evaluation, the component configuration of CNC machine tools is optimized, and the problem of high-end CNC machine tools is solved, and scientific design guidance and small batches are realized Production adaptability.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410909697.8
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-08
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-03
AI Technical Summary
The lack of effective reliability design methods in the research and development and production process of high-end CNC machine tools has resulted in high cost and slow speed to improve the reliability of the machine tools. The existing methods rely on a large amount of test data and subjective expert scores, making it difficult to adapt to small batch customized production.
By decomposing the CNC machine tool design scheme layer by layer, obtaining the fault data and maintenance information of previous generation machines, using Bayesian fusion method and relative cost evaluation method, a reliability allocation optimization model is built, and component configuration is optimized to improve the reliability of the entire machine.
It has achieved scientific guidance on the reliability design of high-end CNC machine tools, reduced R&D costs, improved the accuracy and practicality of the design, and is suitable for small batch customized production.
Smart Images

Figure CN119066791A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention belongs to the technical field of reliability design of numerical control machine tools, and more specifically relates to a reliability design method suitable for a newly developed or improved model of a high-end numerical control machine tool. Background Art
[0002] The reliability design of CNC machine tools refers to the adoption of comprehensive technologies and measures in the design stage to ensure that the final manufactured machine tool can stably and reliably perform the specified functions under the specified conditions of use and within the specified life span. This design process is crucial to improving the operating efficiency of machine tools and reducing maintenance costs. Common reliability design methods can be divided into reliability allocation, reliability prediction, parameter probability design, interval optimization design, etc. Among them, the iterative combination of reliability allocation and prediction is suitable for the overall design guidance of complex electromechanical systems.
[0003] High-end CNC machine tools refer to CNC machine tools with one or more characteristics such as high speed, high precision, intelligence, compound, and multi-axis linkage. Their typical characteristics are high R&D costs and small production batches. At present, high-end machine tool manufacturers rarely use reliability design methods to ensure product reliability. Instead, they implement design guidelines and management methods in the development process, use technical management and design review, and iterate based on the principle of trial and error to continuously cycle through the three stages of "test-analysis-improvement" to improve the reliability level of machine tools. This improvement process is often costly, blind, and slow to grow.
[0004] This is because the current reliability design technology relies on a large number of long-term operation tests to accumulate reliability data, so as to fully understand the failure mechanism and accurately measure the specific improvement parameters. However, the R&D cost and manufacturing cost of high-end CNC machine tools are relatively high, and they have the characteristics of single-piece small batches or even customized production. In particular, the newly developed or improved models have small model batches and weak market share, making it difficult to carry out large-scale whole machine reliability tests to accumulate reliability data. At this time, the application of existing reliability allocation methods such as fuzzy expert evaluation method, minimum effort method, and proportional allocation method is often too general and fails to fully consider the reliability characteristics of specific models and the improvement needs of enterprises, so their application in actual research and development is limited. At the same time, the commonly used reliability prediction methods are overly dependent on historical data. For newly developed or improved models of high-end CNC machine tools with a small sample size, they can only rely on subjective expert scoring, which lacks practicality and is difficult to guide machine tool companies to scientifically plan product reliability improvement management.
[0005] Therefore, it is necessary to propose a new solution for the reliability design of high-end CNC machine tools. Summary of the invention
[0006] Based on the above-mentioned shortcomings and deficiencies in the prior art, one of the objects of the present invention is to at least solve one or more of the above-mentioned problems in the prior art. In other words, one of the objects of the present invention is to provide a high-end CNC machine tool reliability design method that meets one or more of the above-mentioned needs.
[0007] In order to achieve the above-mentioned object of the invention, the present invention adopts the following technical solutions:
[0008] In a first aspect, the present invention provides a reliability design method for a high-end CNC machine tool, comprising the steps of:
[0009] S1. Obtain an initial design scheme for a CNC machine tool, and decompose the system components in the initial design scheme layer by layer until the level of self-made parts or outsourced parts that have batch test capabilities or batch industry data or are convenient for implementing reliability management, so as to obtain the composition relationship between the total system and subsystems at different levels, and the association relationship between subsystems, and represent them by connecting them layer by layer into a structure tree composed of root nodes and leaf nodes, wherein each layer of the subsystem corresponds to a root node, and each leaf node corresponds to a component, and the component is the self-made part or the outsourced part;
[0010] S2. Obtain the fault data and corresponding maintenance and improvement measures of the corresponding components of each layer leaf node during the service process of the previous generation CNC machine tools and / or similar CNC machine tools, so as to obtain reliability data, reliability improvement plans and various fault impacts respectively;
[0011] S3, based on the reliability data, estimate the initial reliability level of the components corresponding to each leaf node in the initial design of the CNC machine tool, and based on the reliability improvement plan and the impact of various failures, evaluate the improvement cost required to improve the components corresponding to each leaf node on the basis of the initial reliability level, reduce the maintenance benefits saved, and save the user from the potential value of losses;
[0012] S4. Construct a reliability allocation target based on the improvement cost, maintenance benefit and potential value, analyze component parameter improvement constraints in combination with the reliability improvement plan, and construct a reliability allocation optimization model with the whole machine reliability design requirements as design boundary conditions. Based on the reliability allocation optimization model, configure reliability improvement requirements for components corresponding to each leaf node in the initial design plan of the CNC machine tool to form a reliability allocation plan for the CNC machine tool.
[0013] As a preferred solution, step S2 obtains the fault data and corresponding maintenance and improvement measures of the components corresponding to the leaf nodes of each layer during the service of the previous generation of CNC machine tools and / or similar CNC machine tools, so as to obtain reliability data, reliability improvement solutions and various fault impacts, including the steps of:
[0014] Obtain the service data and maintenance records of the corresponding components of each layer of leaf nodes on the previous generation of machine tools and similar machine tools, the service failure data and service degradation trajectory on the independent functional test bench, or relevant industry data or relevant expert knowledge, and classify each component according to the failure mechanism and list the possible failure modes;
[0015] The reliability data types include fault manifestation, maintenance implementation process, failure time distribution, degradation trajectory curve, failure rate, average maintenance mileage, number of cycles or operation time, and 90% failure life;
[0016] Based on the reliability data, statistics and reasoning are used to analyze the failure rate proportion, failure hazards, corresponding maintenance solutions and improvement solutions of each failure mode, so as to provide analysis and evaluation basis for step S3 and step S4.
[0017] As a preferred solution, the step S3 of estimating the initial reliability level of the components corresponding to each leaf node in the initial design scheme of the CNC machine tool based on the reliability data comprises the steps of:
[0018] Obtain the trouble-free operation time distribution, degradation trajectory curve, average maintenance operation mileage, and number of cycles of the corresponding components of each leaf node during the service process of the previous generation of CNC machine tools and similar CNC machine tools, and record the corresponding data for each component;
[0019] Select any component, combine the fault distribution consensus of the component in the industry, and the reliability data conversion formula or Monte Carlo simulation calculation method to uniformly convert the representation of each data collected by the component into the distribution of trouble-free operation time under specific working conditions;
[0020] The similarity comparison method is used to analyze the similarities and differences between the initial solution and the application conditions of the machine tool corresponding to the collected data, and the difference factors are selected to build a correction factor calculation model, and the correction factors of each data of the component are calculated, and then the above data are corrected and uniformly converted into the trouble-free operation time distribution under the working conditions corresponding to the initial solution;
[0021] The failure rate density curve with the correction factor closest to 1 is selected as the base data, and the remaining data are fused one by one using the Bayesian fusion method.
[0022] As a preferred solution, the Bayesian fusion method has the following steps:
[0023] Specify the base data distribution as the prior distribution;
[0024] Select the data to be fused and calculate its likelihood function under the prior distribution;
[0025] Apply the Bayesian formula to calculate the posterior distribution of the two data, and reassign the posterior distribution as the base data;
[0026] Repeat the above process until all data are merged;
[0027] The final fusion prediction result is the initial reliability level of the component;
[0028] The above process is repeated until all components corresponding to leaf nodes have obtained their initial reliability levels.
[0029] As a preferred solution, step S3, based on the reliability improvement scheme and various types of fault impact assessment, the components corresponding to each leaf node are improved based on the initial reliability level, the required improvement cost, the maintenance benefits saved by reducing maintenance, and the potential value brought by users being free from losses, includes the following steps:
[0030] Obtain the failure modes, failure mode proportions, and corresponding improvement measures and improvement costs of the components corresponding to the root nodes of each layer during the service life of the previous generation of CNC machine tools and similar CNC machine tools;
[0031] Based on the failure modes, failure mode proportions, and corresponding improvement measures and improvement costs, a relative cost evaluation method is used to evaluate the improvement costs required to improve the reliability level of the corresponding hierarchical subsystem in the initial plan of the CNC machine tool based on the initial value of the reliability level.
[0032] As a preferred solution, based on the failure mode, failure mode proportion, corresponding improvement measures and improvement costs, a relative cost evaluation method is used to evaluate the improvement cost required for improving the reliability level of the corresponding hierarchical subsystem in the initial solution of the CNC machine tool based on the initial value of the reliability level, including the steps of:
[0033] Obtain the basic improvement cost of each of the components, analyze the basic improvement costs of different components, apply the relative concept, and record it as the basic price K1;
[0034] Based on the failure modes, failure mode proportions, and corresponding improvement measures and improvement costs, estimate the costs required to improve the components at each layer according to various improvement measures and record them as improvement costs K2;
[0035] Obtain the factors affecting the improvement cost K2 of each component corresponding to the subsystem at each layer K2i ;
[0036] Based on the base price K1, improvement cost K2 and their corresponding influencing factors K2i Evaluate the relative cost of reliability improvement required for each layer of subsystem to improve its reliability level based on the initial value of the reliability level.
[0037] As a preferred solution, the base price K1, improvement cost K2 and their corresponding influencing factors are K2i Before evaluating the relative cost of reliability improvement required to improve the reliability level of each layer of subsystem based on the initial value of the reliability level, the steps include:
[0038] Obtain multiple influencing factors affecting the improvement cost K2 of a single component corresponding to the subsystem of a single layer K2i , and multiple influencing factors are analyzed according to their numerical values. K2i Sort.
[0039] As a preferred solution, the base price K1, the maintenance cost K2 and their corresponding influencing factors K2i After evaluating the relative maintenance cost required for improving the reliability level of each layer of subsystem based on the initial value of the reliability level, the OWA operator should also be used to correct the analysis error in the group decision-making process. The OWA operator correction includes the steps of:
[0040] Obtain multiple influencing factors affecting the maintenance cost K2 of a single component corresponding to the subsystem of a single layer K2i , and multiple influencing factors are analyzed according to their numerical values. K2i Sort.
[0041] As a preferred solution, step S4 constructs a reliability allocation target based on the improvement cost, maintenance benefit and potential value, analyzes the component parameter improvement constraints in combination with the reliability improvement plan, takes the whole machine reliability design requirements as the design boundary conditions, constructs a reliability allocation optimization model, configures the reliability improvement requirements for the components corresponding to each leaf node in the initial design plan of the CNC machine tool based on the reliability allocation optimization model, and forms a reliability allocation plan for the CNC machine tool, including the steps of:
[0042] The reliability level improvement value of the component corresponding to each leaf node is set as a design variable;
[0043] The above design variables are replaced with improvement measures as intermediate variables, and the analytical formulas of improvement cost, maintenance benefit and potential value of the corresponding components of each leaf node are summed and sorted, and then the improvement benefit of the whole machine is calculated by weighted summation according to the importance weight of the component, and the maximum improvement benefit of the whole machine is taken as the optimization goal; the constraint equation is analyzed with the help of intermediate variables, so that the total value of reliability level improvement is greater than the sum of the reliability requirement of the whole machine and the design margin;
[0044] The optimization algorithm is used to solve the above mathematical optimization problem and find the optimal improvement requirements of the components corresponding to each leaf node;
[0045] Based on the optimal improvement requirements of the components corresponding to each leaf node, a reliability allocation plan is formed.
[0046] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following beneficial effects:
[0047] 1. The reliability design process of the present invention adds a reliability prediction evaluation of the initial design solution, and implements optimal allocation to ensure that the reliability guidance solution designed through this process has better rationality.
[0048] 2. Each analysis indicator of the present invention adopts relative economic value analysis of clear affairs, has corresponding physical meaning or clear and easy-to-understand consensus concept, and establishes communication and cooperation among departments with relative scoring method for the convenience of information collection and protection of cost-related secrets of the enterprise, so that the implementation of the process of the present invention can have better scalability and practicality.
[0049] 3. The present invention proposes to collect and organize multi-source information such as service data, maintenance records, test results of previous generation machine tools and similar machine tools, and industry and expert information of parts and components, and improve the utilization efficiency of existing objective information through unified integration through the Bayesian fusion method, so as to achieve accurate estimation of the initial design scheme, improve the design accuracy of the final reliability allocation scheme, and facilitate the development of high-end CNC machine tools with high development costs and small batch customized production.
[0050] Further or more detailed beneficial effects will be described in detail in conjunction with specific examples in the specific implementation manner. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0051] In order to more clearly illustrate the embodiments of the present invention or the technical solutions in the prior art, the drawings required for use in the embodiments or the description of the prior art will be briefly introduced below. Obviously, the drawings described below are only some embodiments of the present invention. For ordinary technicians in this field, other drawings can be obtained based on these drawings without paying creative work.
[0052] Figure 1 It is a flow chart of a reliability design method for a high-end CNC machine tool provided in an embodiment of the present invention.
[0053] Figure 2 It is a schematic diagram of the principle of system decomposition in the reliability design method for high-end CNC machine tools provided in an embodiment of the present invention.
[0054] Figure 3 It is a schematic diagram of the principle of calculating the relative cost of reliability improvement in the reliability design method for high-end CNC machine tools provided in an embodiment of the present invention.
[0055] Figure 4It is a schematic diagram of the principle of the allocation model in the reliability design method of a high-end CNC machine tool provided in an embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0056] The technical solutions in the embodiments of the present application will be clearly and completely described below in conjunction with the drawings in the embodiments of the present application.
[0057] In the following introduction, multiple embodiments of the present application are provided, and different embodiments can be replaced or combined, so the present application can also be considered to include all possible combinations of the same and / or different embodiments recorded. Therefore, if one embodiment includes features A, B, and C, and another embodiment includes features B and D, then the present application should also be considered to include embodiments containing one or more of A, B, C, and D, all other possible combinations, even though the embodiment may not be clearly recorded in the following text.
[0058] The following description provides examples and does not limit the scope, applicability or examples set forth in the claims. Changes may be made to the functions and arrangements of the elements described without departing from the scope of the present application. Various processes or components may be appropriately omitted, substituted or added to each example. For example, the described method may be performed in an order different from the order described, and various steps may be added, omitted or combined. In addition, features described in some examples may be combined in other examples.
[0059] In order to facilitate a better understanding of the embodiments of the present application, before explaining the specific implementation methods of the present application in detail, its application scenarios are first described.
[0060] The CNC machine tool reliability design method described in the embodiments of this specification is applied to the reliability design process in the production and manufacturing of CNC machine tools. In these scenarios, the application of the CNC machine tool reliability design is intended to improve the reliability of the entire CNC machine tool system, thereby making the performance more stable, improving production quality and efficiency, and providing high-quality user experience and reliable performance.
[0061] Embodiment 1:
[0062] like Figure 1 As shown, this embodiment provides a high-end CNC machine tool reliability design method, including the steps of:
[0063] S1. Obtain an initial design scheme for a CNC machine tool, and decompose the system components in the initial design scheme layer by layer until they reach the level of self-made parts or outsourced components that have batch test capabilities or batch industry data or are convenient for implementing reliability management, thereby obtaining the composition relationship between the overall system and subsystems at different levels, and the association relationship between subsystems, and representing them by connecting them layer by layer into a structure tree composed of root nodes and leaf nodes, wherein each layer of the subsystem corresponds to a root node, and each leaf node corresponds to a component, and the component is the self-made part or the outsourced part;
[0064] S2. Obtain the fault data and corresponding maintenance and improvement measures of the corresponding components of each layer leaf node during the service process of the previous generation CNC machine tools and / or similar CNC machine tools, so as to obtain reliability data, reliability improvement plans and various fault impacts respectively;
[0065] S3, based on the reliability data, estimate the initial reliability level of the components corresponding to each leaf node in the initial design of the CNC machine tool, and based on the reliability improvement plan and the impact of various failures, evaluate the improvement cost required to improve the components corresponding to each leaf node on the basis of the initial reliability level, reduce the maintenance benefits saved, and save the user from the potential value of losses;
[0066] S4. Construct a reliability allocation target based on the improvement cost, maintenance benefit and potential value, analyze component parameter improvement constraints in combination with the reliability improvement plan, and construct a reliability allocation optimization model with the whole machine reliability design requirements as design boundary conditions. Based on the reliability allocation optimization model, configure reliability improvement requirements for components corresponding to each leaf node in the initial design plan of the CNC machine tool to form a reliability allocation plan for the CNC machine tool.
[0067] It can be understood that the reliability design method described in this embodiment is mainly aimed at high-end CNC machine tools with high development costs and small-batch customized production. By systematically collecting, organizing and analyzing the service data, maintenance records, test results and industry and expert information of parts and components of previous generation machine tools and similar machine tools, a comprehensive evaluation is conducted on the cost-effectiveness, maintainability and improvement tendency of the subsystem reliability improvement. Then, a mathematical optimization method is used to allocate the reliability indicators of the whole machine from top to bottom to the self-made parts and purchased and outsourced parts with controllable reliability levels, and convert them into reliability control and production requirements for specific components, so as to scientifically guide the design and test verification of the company's newly developed machine models, and solve the problem that the current research and development process of high-end CNC machine tools ignores the top-level design of the reliability of the whole machine, and has only the reliability requirements of the whole machine but no detailed design methods.
[0068] More specifically, if Figure 2As shown, the layer-by-layer decomposition of the CNC machine tool system in the initial design of the CNC machine tool may include at least the following steps: First, according to the overall structure of the high-end CNC machine tool, the implementation process of the main functions and auxiliary functions of the system is analyzed, and the overall system and the decomposed subsystems are decomposed layer by layer according to the functional integrity and structural independence to form a product structure tree and a corresponding system fault tree model. The nodes of the product structure tree are decomposed to the level of self-made parts or outsourced parts with batch testing capabilities, or batch industry data, or convenient for implementing reliability management. The reliability modeling of the whole machine is carried out according to the system fault tree model, and the mapping relationship between the reliability index of the whole machine and the commonly used reliability index of the components is established to realize the conversion of the total reliability requirements of the high-end CNC machine tool system and the reliability design requirements of the analyzed component nodes.
[0069] Specifically, this embodiment provides a preferred implementation method, in which the step S2 obtains the fault conditions and corresponding maintenance measures and improvement measures of the components corresponding to the leaf nodes of each layer during the service process of the previous generation of CNC machine tools and / or similar CNC machine tools, so as to obtain reliability data, reliability improvement solutions and various fault impacts, including the steps of:
[0070] Obtain the service data and maintenance records of the corresponding components of each layer of leaf nodes on the previous generation of machine tools and similar machine tools, the service failure data and service degradation trajectory on the independent functional test bench, or relevant industry data or relevant expert knowledge, and classify each component according to the failure mechanism and list the possible failure modes;
[0071] The reliability data types include fault manifestation, maintenance implementation process, failure time distribution, degradation trajectory curve, failure rate, average maintenance mileage, number of cycles or operation time, and 90% failure life;
[0072] Based on the reliability data, statistics and reasoning are used to analyze the failure rate proportion, failure hazards, corresponding maintenance solutions and improvement solutions of each failure mode, so as to provide analysis and evaluation basis for step S3 and step S4.
[0073] It is understandable that for the similar products collected, each product and the research object will have some differences. The differences here refer to the product's composition structure, performance, design, raw materials, use environment, component level, manufacturing process level, organizational management and other aspects. Therefore, each difference factor will have a certain impact on the reliability performance of the product, so all of them should be taken into account as much as possible in the prediction process. In summary, for different similar products, the differences with the object to be developed should be comprehensively analyzed, and then the corresponding correction factors can be obtained, which can represent the differences in the reliability prediction process of different similarities.
[0074] More specifically, this embodiment provides a preferred implementation method for correcting the estimated failure rate of the components corresponding to the root nodes of each layer in the future service process of the initial solution of the CNC machine tool based on the actual failure rate value of the components corresponding to the root nodes of each layer in the service process of similar CNC machine tools. Taking the vth subsystem of the product to be estimated as an example, assuming that a total of m subsystems of similar products are selected (here only means that their subsystems v are very similar), the average failure rate model of the subsystem v of the product to be estimated is shown in the following formula (1):
[0075]
[0076] In formula (1): represents the average failure rate of the h-th similar subsystem, C h Represents the reliability correction factor of subsystem h.
[0077] Specifically, this embodiment provides a preferred implementation method, in which the step S3 estimates the initial reliability level of the components corresponding to each leaf node in the initial design scheme of the CNC machine tool based on the reliability data, including the steps of:
[0078] Obtain the trouble-free operation time distribution, degradation trajectory curve, average maintenance operation mileage, and number of cycles of the corresponding components of each leaf node during the service process of the previous generation of CNC machine tools and similar CNC machine tools, and record the corresponding data for each component;
[0079] Select any component, combine the fault distribution consensus of the component in the industry, and the reliability data conversion formula or Monte Carlo simulation calculation method to uniformly convert the representation of each data collected by the component into the distribution of trouble-free operation time under specific working conditions;
[0080] The similarity comparison method is used to analyze the similarities and differences between the initial solution and the application conditions of the machine tool corresponding to the collected data, and the difference factors are selected to build a correction factor calculation model, and the correction factors of each data of the component are calculated, and then the above data are corrected and uniformly converted into the trouble-free operation time distribution under the working conditions corresponding to the initial solution;
[0081] The failure rate density curve with the correction factor closest to 1 is selected as the base data, and the remaining data are fused one by one using the Bayesian fusion method.
[0082] Specifically, this embodiment provides a preferred implementation method, and the steps of the Bayesian fusion method are as follows:
[0083] Specify the base data distribution as the prior distribution;
[0084] Select the data to be fused and calculate its likelihood function under the prior distribution;
[0085] Apply the Bayesian formula to calculate the posterior distribution of the two data, and reassign the posterior distribution as the base data;
[0086] Repeat the above process until all data are merged;
[0087] The final fusion prediction result is the initial reliability level of the component;
[0088] The above process is repeated until all components corresponding to leaf nodes have obtained their initial reliability levels.
[0089] More specifically, all the failure data such as failure rate, trouble-free operation time distribution, degradation trajectory curve, average maintenance operation mileage, and number of cycles can be converted into the trouble-free operation time distribution π(θ) of the product by the product reliability concept formula. By specifying any product reliability information as the initial distribution, the remaining observation data can be used in turn to calculate the corresponding likelihood function L(y|θ), and then the two information can be fused using the Bayesian fusion method to obtain the posterior distribution p(θ|y) of the trouble-free operation time of the product obtained by the two information, as shown in formula (2). By looping the above method until all information is fused, the failure rate density curve of its failure time distribution is obtained, which can then be converted and calculated to obtain the commonly used reliability index description.
[0090]
[0091] In formula (2), p(θ|y) represents the posterior distribution of the subsystem's trouble-free operation time, L(y|θ) represents the likelihood function of a new observation, and π(θ) represents the current prior distribution of the subsystem's trouble-free operation time.
[0092] Specifically, this embodiment provides a preferred implementation method, in step S3, based on the reliability improvement scheme and various types of fault impact assessment, the components corresponding to each leaf node are improved based on the initial reliability level, the required improvement cost, the maintenance benefits saved by reducing maintenance, and the potential value brought by preventing users from losses, including the steps of:
[0093] Obtain the failure modes, failure mode proportions, and corresponding improvement measures and improvement costs of the components corresponding to the root nodes of each layer during the service life of the previous generation of CNC machine tools and similar CNC machine tools;
[0094] Based on the failure modes, failure mode proportions, and corresponding improvement measures and improvement costs, a relative cost evaluation method is used to evaluate the improvement costs required to improve the reliability level of the corresponding hierarchical subsystem in the initial plan of the CNC machine tool based on the initial value of the reliability level.
[0095] Specifically, this embodiment provides a preferred implementation method, which uses a relative cost evaluation method to evaluate the improvement cost required for improving the reliability level of the corresponding hierarchical subsystem in the initial solution of the CNC machine tool based on the initial value of the reliability level based on the failure mode, the failure mode ratio, and the corresponding improvement measures and improvement costs, including the steps of:
[0096] Obtain the basic improvement cost of each of the components, analyze the basic improvement costs of different components, apply the relative concept, and record it as the basic price K1;
[0097] Based on the failure modes, failure mode proportions, and corresponding improvement measures and improvement costs, estimate the costs required to improve the components at each layer according to various improvement measures and record them as improvement costs K2; obtain the influencing factors K affecting the improvement costs K2 of each component corresponding to the subsystem at each layer 2i ;
[0098] Based on the base price K1, improvement cost K2 and its corresponding influencing factor K 2i Evaluate the relative cost of reliability improvement required for each layer of subsystem to improve its reliability level based on the initial value of the reliability level.
[0099] Specifically, this embodiment provides a preferred implementation method, based on the basic price K1, maintenance cost K2 and their corresponding influencing factors K2i After evaluating the relative maintenance cost required for improving the reliability level of each layer of subsystem based on the initial value of the reliability level, the OWA operator should also be used to correct the analysis error in the group decision-making process. The OWA operator correction includes the steps of:
[0100] Obtain multiple influencing factors affecting the improvement cost K2 of a single component corresponding to the subsystem of a single layer K2i , and multiple influencing factors are analyzed according to their numerical values. K2i Sort.
[0101] It is understandable that in order to protect business secrets such as corporate cost data and integrate the differences in the cognition of different people on the same thing, the relative scoring method is used to conduct relative cost analysis of improvement plans. The principle is to let multiple personnel in the company who are responsible for design improvement or outsourced supply chain management use the sorted failure modes, failure mode proportions and corresponding improvement methods of each subsystem as a reference, and use specific matters such as specific design costs, manufacturing costs, and procurement negotiated prices as anchor concepts to establish a hypothetical relationship between specific improvement measures and the reliability improvement value of each subsystem, and conduct a relative multiple evaluation of the specific improvement measures and the improvement cost of implementing specific improvement plans for newly developed machine tools. Subsequently, through standardization of evaluation values, OWA group decision correction and weighted summation, a reliability improvement cost function for each subsystem is established to achieve modeling of the mapping relationship between the reliability improvement requirements of each subsystem and the improvement cost of the enterprise.
[0102] More specifically, if Figure 3 As shown, the reliability design method described in this embodiment provides a preferred calculation method for the relative cost of reliability improvement: the purchasing department personnel or supply chain management personnel can simultaneously score the basic price K1 and improvement cost K2 of m different parts to determine the weight of the basic price and improvement cost in the overall relative price of the feed system. 2i Score and determine the weight of different specification parameters on the improvement cost. The specification parameters of different parts are used as input, and the relative cost of parts (RCP) is formed based on the hierarchical analysis method. The larger the RCP value, the higher the cost, and the number of influencing factors involved is unlimited. The calculation formula is as follows:
[0103]
[0104] In formula (3): K1 (v) The first round of scoring for the base price of the vth part; K2 (v) The first round of scoring for the improvement cost of the vth part; k 2j (v ) is the weight of the jth specification parameter of the vth part affecting the improvement cost; p j (v) is the jth specification parameter of the vth part; P (v) is the intermediate variable calculated based on the specification parameters and weights of the vth part; 2j (v) is the unit specification change of the jth specification parameter of the vth part.
[0105] Specifically, this embodiment provides a preferred implementation method, based on the basic price K1, the improvement cost K2 and the corresponding influencing factor K 2iBefore evaluating the relative cost of reliability improvement required to improve the reliability level of each layer of subsystem based on the initial value of the reliability level, the steps include:
[0106] A plurality of influencing factors K2i that influence the improvement cost K2 of a single component corresponding to the single-layer subsystem are obtained, and the plurality of influencing factors K2i are sorted according to numerical values.
[0107] More specifically, in the analysis process, there are many group decision-making processes, which will inevitably introduce analysis errors caused by unfair or inaccurate subjective evaluations of individual decision makers. This paper introduces the (OWA) operator that obeys the normal distribution to correct this error and avoid the irrationality of the decision results.
[0108] For the position weight ω i , Xu
[25] Starting from the normal distribution, a method of allocating position weights using a discrete normal distribution function is proposed. Assuming that a experts participate in the evaluation, the calculation formula for each position weight is shown in formula (4):
[0109]
[0110] According to the calculation method of RCP in formula (43), Arrange them in descending order to get (b1, b2, ..., b n ), where b1≥b2≥…≥b n The equation (3) can be used to calculate the discrete normal distribution function to determine each b i The position weight ω i . In this way, the evaluation results of the experts can be weighted in an orderly manner. Assuming that the evaluation results of a experts need to be processed, we can get:
[0111]
[0112] After applying the OWA operator to correct the evaluation, the total relative cost of the feeding system based on the OWA algorithm can be obtained as follows:
[0113]
[0114] In addition, in order to make the application of the reliability design method described in this embodiment more in line with actual needs, the improvement cost, improvement benefit, and potential value obtained can be evaluated by experts through multiple senior managers of the enterprise management level, and the economic benefits of the reference objects of the relative evaluation in the above steps can be evaluated relatively, and the values between different relative quantities can be unified. In this process, a group decision fusion algorithm is used to eliminate individual subjective cognitive biases and form a consistent group cognitive weight. The group decision fusion algorithm is to let the evaluators score the evaluation trust of other participants based on their own cognition without viewing the evaluation opinions of other participants in addition to drawing an evaluation.
[0115] Collect all trust and calculate the weight using the Pagerank formula:
[0116]
[0117] In the formula, PR(a) represents the trust weight of the current participant a; PR(Ti) represents the trust weight of other participants (who can point to a); L(T) represents the number of non-zero weights obtained by other participants (who can point to a); i represents the current moment or the number of iterations. Initially, the average trust weight of all participants is set to 1 as the initial value, and the above weight calculation iterative formula is used to iterate until the calculation result converges. The convergence value is the sum of the evaluation results of each participant. According to the improvement cost of the specific maintenance plan, the improvement benefit of the specific operation and maintenance requirements, and the potential benefit of the specific customer stop loss, the relative scalar of the above analysis is obtained, so as to facilitate the weighted summation of the improvement cost, improvement benefit, and potential value of each subsystem obtained in the above steps.
[0118] This process also takes the specific implementation of economic value on affairs as its concrete conceptual object.
[0119] Furthermore, taking the enterprise's technological development trends and the importance of subsystem R&D as analysis objects, the development importance of each subsystem is evaluated, and the importance of each subsystem as an enterprise technology improvement and content enhancement is identified. In this process, a group decision fusion algorithm is used to eliminate individual subjective cognitive biases, form consistent group cognitive weights, and form an importance analysis of technological improvement needs, which is used as the sum of the relative cost-effectiveness weights of each subsystem.
[0120] This process is based on the enterprise's decision on the direction of system development, and is only to facilitate the enterprise to select appropriate subsystems with technological advantages and future investment plans for development and upgrading based on actual conditions and technical levels.
[0121] Specifically, this embodiment provides a preferred implementation method, in step S4, a reliability allocation target is constructed based on the improvement cost, maintenance benefit and potential value, and component parameter improvement constraints are analyzed in combination with the reliability improvement plan, and a reliability allocation optimization model is constructed with the reliability design requirements of the whole machine as the design boundary conditions. Based on the reliability allocation optimization model, the reliability improvement requirements of the components corresponding to each leaf node in the initial design plan of the CNC machine tool are configured to form a reliability allocation plan for the CNC machine tool, including the steps of:
[0122] The reliability level improvement value of the component corresponding to each leaf node is set as a design variable;
[0123] The above design variables are replaced with improvement measures as intermediate variables, and the analytical formulas of improvement cost, maintenance benefit and potential value of the corresponding components of each leaf node are summed and sorted, and then the improvement benefit of the whole machine is calculated by weighted summation according to the importance weight of the component, and the maximum improvement benefit of the whole machine is taken as the optimization goal; the constraint equation is analyzed with the help of intermediate variables, so that the total value of reliability level improvement is greater than the sum of the reliability requirement of the whole machine and the design margin;
[0124] The optimization algorithm is used to solve the above mathematical optimization problem and find the optimal improvement requirements of the components corresponding to each leaf node;
[0125] Based on the optimal improvement requirements of the components corresponding to each leaf node, a reliability allocation plan is formed.
[0126] More specifically, this embodiment provides a preferred method of the allocation model:
[0127] Design variables of the allocation model: subsystem MTBF improvement value, x1, x2, …
[0128] Intermediate variables in allocation models: specific improvements.
[0129] Optimization objective: min∑each subsystem (improvement cost*cost relative scalar+improvement benefit*benefit relative scalar+potential value*value relative scalar)*subsystem weight.
[0130] Constraint equation of the allocation model: Total MTBF > (specific reliability requirements of the whole machine * 1 + design margin of 15% to 20%) parameter accessibility of improvement measures.
[0131] More specifically, if Figure 4 The entire optimization process shown uses a genetic algorithm. The objective function and the constraint equation are combined in the form of a penalty function as a comprehensive fitness function. Secondly, a population is established based on the design variables of the feed system for algorithm iteration. Finally, the optimal individual output is the optimization design result.
[0132] It should be noted that, for the aforementioned method embodiments, for the sake of simplicity, they are all expressed as a series of action combinations, but those skilled in the art should be aware that the present application is not limited by the described order of actions, because according to the present application, certain steps can be performed in other orders or simultaneously. Secondly, those skilled in the art should also be aware that the embodiments described in the specification are all preferred embodiments, and the actions and modules involved are not necessarily required by the present application.
[0133] In the above embodiments, the description of each embodiment has its own emphasis. For parts that are not described in detail in a certain embodiment, reference can be made to the relevant descriptions of other embodiments.
[0134] The above is only an exemplary embodiment of the present disclosure, and the scope of the present disclosure cannot be limited thereto. That is, any equivalent changes and modifications made according to the teachings of the present disclosure are still within the scope of the present disclosure. After considering the specification and practicing the disclosure here, those skilled in the art will easily think of the implementation scheme of the present disclosure. This application is intended to cover any modification, use or adaptation of the present disclosure, which follows the general principles of the present disclosure and includes common knowledge or customary technical means in the technical field not recorded in the present disclosure. The description and examples are regarded as exemplary only, and the scope and spirit of the present disclosure are defined by the claims.
Claims
1. A reliability design method for high-end CNC machine tools, characterized in that: Includes steps: S1. Obtain an initial design scheme for a CNC machine tool, and decompose the system components in the initial design scheme layer by layer until they reach the level of self-made parts or outsourced components that have batch test capabilities or batch industry data or are convenient for implementing reliability management, thereby obtaining the composition relationship between the overall system and subsystems at different levels, and the association relationship between subsystems, and representing them by connecting them layer by layer into a structure tree composed of root nodes and leaf nodes, wherein each layer of the subsystem corresponds to a root node, and each leaf node corresponds to a component, and the component is the self-made part or the outsourced part; S2. Obtain the fault data and corresponding maintenance and improvement measures of the corresponding components of each layer leaf node during the service process of the previous generation CNC machine tools and / or similar CNC machine tools, so as to obtain reliability data, reliability improvement plans and various fault impacts respectively; S3, based on the reliability data, estimate the initial reliability level of the components corresponding to each leaf node in the initial design of the CNC machine tool, and based on the reliability improvement plan and the impact of various failures, evaluate the improvement cost required to improve the components corresponding to each leaf node on the basis of the initial reliability level, reduce the maintenance benefits saved, and save the user from the potential value of losses; S4. Construct a reliability allocation target based on the improvement cost, maintenance benefit and potential value, analyze component parameter improvement constraints in combination with the reliability improvement plan, and construct a reliability allocation optimization model with the whole machine reliability design requirements as design boundary conditions. Based on the reliability allocation optimization model, configure reliability improvement requirements for components corresponding to each leaf node in the initial design plan of the CNC machine tool to form a reliability allocation plan for the CNC machine tool.
2. A high-end CNC machine tool reliability design method according to claim 1, characterized in that: Step S2 is to obtain the failure conditions and corresponding maintenance measures and improvement measures of the components corresponding to the leaf nodes of each layer during the service process of the previous generation of CNC machine tools and / or similar CNC machine tools, so as to obtain reliability data, reliability improvement plans and various failure impacts, including the following steps: Obtain the service data and maintenance records of the corresponding components of each layer of leaf nodes on the previous generation of machine tools and similar machine tools, the service failure data and service degradation trajectory on the independent functional test bench, or relevant industry data or relevant expert knowledge, and classify each component according to the failure mechanism and list the possible failure modes; The reliability data types include fault manifestation, maintenance implementation process, failure time distribution, degradation trajectory curve, failure rate, average maintenance mileage, number of cycles or operation time, and 90% failure life; Based on the reliability data, statistics and reasoning are used to analyze the failure rate proportion, failure hazards, corresponding maintenance solutions and improvement solutions of each failure mode, so as to provide analysis and evaluation basis for step S3 and step S4.
3. A high-end CNC machine tool reliability design method according to claim 2, characterized in that: Step S3, based on the reliability data, estimating the initial reliability level of the components corresponding to each leaf node in the initial design scheme of the CNC machine tool, comprises the following steps: Obtain the trouble-free operation time distribution, degradation trajectory curve, average maintenance operation mileage, and number of cycles of the corresponding components of each leaf node during the service process of the previous generation of CNC machine tools and similar CNC machine tools, and record the corresponding data for each component; Select any component, combine the fault distribution consensus of the component in the industry, and the reliability data conversion formula or Monte Carlo simulation calculation method to uniformly convert the representation of each data collected by the component into the distribution of trouble-free operation time under specific working conditions; The similarity comparison method is used to analyze the similarities and differences between the initial solution and the application conditions of the machine tool corresponding to the collected data, and the difference factors are selected to build a correction factor calculation model, and the correction factors of each data of the component are calculated, and then the above data are corrected and uniformly converted into the trouble-free operation time distribution under the working conditions corresponding to the initial solution; The failure rate density curve with the correction factor closest to 1 is selected as the base data, and the remaining data are fused one by one using the Bayesian fusion method.
4. A high-end CNC machine tool reliability design method according to claim 3, characterized in that: The steps of the Bayesian fusion method are as follows: Specify the base data distribution as the prior distribution; Select the data to be fused and calculate its likelihood function under the prior distribution; Apply the Bayesian formula to calculate the posterior distribution of the two data, and reassign the posterior distribution as the base data; repeat the above process until all data are merged; The final fusion prediction result is the initial reliability level of the component; The above process is repeated until all components corresponding to leaf nodes have obtained their initial reliability levels.
5. A high-end CNC machine tool reliability design method according to claim 4, characterized in that: Step S3, based on the reliability improvement scheme and various types of fault impact assessment, the components corresponding to each leaf node are improved based on the initial reliability level, the required improvement cost, the maintenance benefits saved by reducing maintenance, and the potential value brought by users being free from losses, including the steps of: Obtain the failure modes, failure mode proportions, and corresponding improvement measures and improvement costs of the components corresponding to the root nodes of each layer during the service life of the previous generation of CNC machine tools and similar CNC machine tools; Based on the failure modes, failure mode proportions, and corresponding improvement measures and improvement costs, a relative cost evaluation method is used to evaluate the improvement costs required to improve the reliability level of the corresponding hierarchical subsystem in the initial plan of the CNC machine tool based on the initial value of the reliability level.
6. A high-end CNC machine tool reliability design method according to claim 5, characterized in that: Based on the failure mode, failure mode proportion, corresponding improvement measures and improvement costs, the relative cost evaluation method is used to evaluate the improvement cost required to improve the reliability level of the corresponding hierarchical subsystem in the initial plan of the CNC machine tool based on the initial value of the reliability level, including the steps of: Obtain the basic improvement cost of each of the components, analyze the basic improvement costs of different components, apply the relative concept, and record it as the basic price K1; Based on the failure modes, failure mode proportions, and corresponding improvement measures and improvement costs, estimate the costs required to improve the components at each layer according to various improvement measures and record them as improvement costs K2; Obtain the influencing factors K affecting the improvement cost K2 of each component corresponding to the subsystem of each layer 2i ; Based on the base price K1, improvement cost K2 and its corresponding influencing factor K 2i Evaluate the relative cost of reliability improvement required for each layer of subsystem to improve its reliability level based on the initial value of the reliability level.
7. A high-end CNC machine tool reliability design method according to claim 6, characterized in that: Based on the base price K1, improvement cost K2 and its corresponding influencing factors K 2i Before evaluating the relative cost of reliability improvement required to improve the reliability level of each layer of subsystem based on the initial value of the reliability level, the steps include: A plurality of influencing factors K2i that influence the improvement cost K2 of a single component corresponding to the single-layer subsystem are obtained, and the plurality of influencing factors K2i are sorted according to numerical values.
8. A high-end CNC machine tool reliability design method according to claim 7, characterized in that: Based on the base price K1, maintenance cost K2 and their corresponding influencing factors K2i After evaluating the relative maintenance cost required for improving the reliability level of each layer of subsystem based on the initial value of the reliability level, the OWNA operator should also be used to correct the analysis error in the group decision-making process. The OWNA operator correction includes the steps of: Obtain multiple influencing factors affecting the improvement cost K2 of a single component corresponding to the subsystem of a single layer K2i , and multiple influencing factors are analyzed according to their numerical values. K2i Sort.
9. A high-end CNC machine tool reliability design method according to claim 8, characterized in that: In step S4, a reliability allocation target is constructed based on the improvement cost, maintenance benefit and potential value, and component parameter improvement constraints are analyzed in combination with the reliability improvement plan. The reliability design requirements of the whole machine are used as design boundary conditions to construct a reliability allocation optimization model. Based on the reliability allocation optimization model, the reliability improvement requirements of the components corresponding to each leaf node in the initial design plan of the CNC machine tool are configured to form a reliability allocation plan for the CNC machine tool, including the steps of: The reliability level improvement value of the component corresponding to each leaf node is set as a design variable; The above design variables are replaced with improvement measures as intermediate variables, and the analytical formulas of improvement cost, maintenance benefit and potential value of the corresponding components of each leaf node are summed and sorted. Then, according to the importance weight of the component, the improvement benefit of the whole machine is calculated by weighted summation, and the maximum improvement benefit of the whole machine is taken as the optimization goal; By using intermediate variables to analyze the constraint equation, the total value of reliability improvement is greater than the sum of the reliability requirement of the whole machine and the design margin; The above mathematical optimization problem is solved by using an optimization algorithm to find the optimal improvement requirements of the components corresponding to each leaf node; based on the optimal improvement requirements of the components corresponding to each leaf node, a reliability allocation plan is formed.
Citation Information
Cited By
Evaluation method for numerical control part machining process capability index
CN119758873A
A method for evaluating the process capability index of CNC machining parts
CN119758873B
