Analysis Methods for Two-Stage Compression Refrigeration Systems
By optimizing the design parameters of a two-stage compression refrigeration system using the analytic method, the problem of inaccurate design in existing technologies was solved, and the system performance was improved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202110012241.8
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-01-06
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-05
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-01-06
AI Technical Summary
In existing two-stage compression refrigeration system designs, parameters are mostly selected based on empirical values, resulting in inaccurate designs, a lack of rigorous analysis, and impact on system performance.
Using the calorimetric analysis method and the calorimetric analysis calculation formula, the parameters of each state point are determined, and the COP, total compressor output power, total calorimetric loss and total calorimetric efficiency are calculated to optimize the design parameters of the two-stage compression refrigeration system.
By using analytical methods, the optimal design parameters can be accurately determined, thereby improving the system design quality and operational performance.
Smart Images

Figure CN112651140B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention relates to the field of refrigeration, and in particular to an exergy analysis method for a two-stage compression refrigeration system. Background Art
[0002] The two-stage compression refrigeration system is a refrigeration system that is widely used in the low-temperature field. For the design of this type of refrigeration system, most of the parameters of each state point are selected according to relevant standards, but many parameters are selected based on empirical values, which leads to deviations between the design value and the actual value, resulting in inaccurate system design and equipment selection. Therefore, by analyzing the optimal design parameters through reasonable and effective calculation methods and obtaining accurate equipment selection, the design quality and system operation performance of the two-stage compression refrigeration system can be improved.
[0003] According to the second law of thermodynamics, energy cannot be completely converted into work during the actual conversion process. Energy can be regarded as consisting of a convertible part and an unconvertible part. The convertible part is called exergy, and the unconvertible part is called (i.e. exergy loss). In addition to using COP to evaluate the performance of a refrigeration system, it can also be evaluated through exergy analysis. A refrigeration system with high COP and high exergy efficiency (i.e. the proportion of energy that can be converted) has better performance. At present, when designing a two-stage compression refrigeration system, few researchers will incorporate relevant analysis methods. Most of them only follow the design manual. If exergy analysis can be combined with the design of a two-stage compression refrigeration system, and exergy analysis calculations are performed when the parameters of each state point are determined, the optimal design parameters can be found more accurately. Summary of the invention
[0004] The object of the present invention is to provide an exergy analysis method for a two-stage compression refrigeration system. In the design of the two-stage compression refrigeration system, the exergy analysis calculation formula is combined to calculate the refrigeration system parameters under different working conditions, determine the COP, the total output work of the compressor, the total exergy loss and the total exergy efficiency corresponding to each working condition, and analyze these parameters to determine the optimal design parameters of the two-stage compression refrigeration system.
[0005] In order to achieve the above object, an embodiment of the present invention provides an exergy analysis method for a two-stage compression refrigeration system, wherein the equipment of the refrigeration system includes a compressor, an auxiliary condenser, an oil separator, a gas cooler, an electronic expansion valve, an intercooler, an evaporator and a gas-liquid separator;
[0006] The state points include point a, point b, point c, point d, point e, point f, point g, point h, point i, and point j;
[0007] The compressor comprises a low-pressure stage compressor and a high-pressure stage compressor;
[0008] The electronic expansion valve comprises a first electronic expansion valve and a second electronic expansion valve;
[0009] The steps of exergy analysis are as follows:
[0010] 1) Draw a system diagram of a two-stage compression refrigeration system and mark each state point;
[0011] 2) Determine the cooling capacity, refrigerant type, evaporation temperature, superheat of the evaporator and subcooling of the intercooler of the two-stage compression refrigeration system;
[0012] 3) Determine the temperature, pressure, enthalpy and entropy value of each state point of the gas cooler under different outlet temperature and outlet pressure requirements;
[0013] 4) By changing the gas cooler outlet temperature and outlet pressure parameters, calculate the COP, total compressor output work, total exergy loss and total exergy efficiency of the two-stage compression refrigeration system;
[0014] 5) Analyze the changing trends of COP, total compressor output power, total exergy loss and total exergy efficiency of the two-stage compression refrigeration system as the outlet temperature and outlet pressure of the gas cooler change.
[0015] Preferably, the state of the refrigerant based on the exergy analysis method of the two-stage compression refrigeration system is T0=298K and the pressure is P0=1atm.
[0016] Preferably, the total exergy loss of the two-stage compression refrigeration system is the sum of the exergy losses of the compressor, auxiliary condenser, oil separator, gas cooler, electronic expansion valve, intercooler, evaporator and gas-liquid separator.
[0017] Preferably, the gas cooler outlet temperature is accurate to the single digit, in units of °C.
[0018] Preferably, the gas cooler outlet pressure is accurate to one decimal place in MPa.
[0019] The present invention provides an exergy analysis method for a two-stage compression refrigeration system, combines exergy analysis to design a two-stage compression refrigeration system, calculates the variation trend and extreme value points of the parameters of the refrigeration system under different working conditions in terms of COP, total compressor output work, total exergy loss and total exergy efficiency, and analyzes and determines the optimal design parameters of the two-stage compression refrigeration system. The present invention provides a new idea for the design of a two-stage compression refrigeration system. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0020] Figure 1It is a schematic diagram of the refrigeration system structure of the exergy analysis method of the two-stage compression refrigeration system of the present invention, and the equipment includes 1.1-low-pressure stage compressor, 1.2-high-pressure stage compressor, 2-auxiliary condenser, 3-oil separator, 4-gas cooler, 5.1-first electronic expansion valve, 5.2-second electronic expansion valve, 6-intermediate cooler, 7-evaporator and 8-gas-liquid separator; the state points include point a, point b, point c, point d, point e, point f, point g, point h, point i, and point j.
[0021] Figure 2 The present invention is a pressure-enthalpy diagram of a refrigeration system of an exergy analysis method for a two-stage compression refrigeration system, wherein the state points include point a, point b, point c, point d, point e, point f, point g, point h, point i, and point j.
[0022] Figure 3 This is a summary diagram of COP parameters of the refrigeration system of the exergy analysis method of the two-stage compression refrigeration system of the present invention.
[0023] Figure 4 This is a summary diagram of the total output work parameters of the compressor of the refrigeration system of the two-stage compression refrigeration system of the present invention.
[0024] Figure 5 It is a summary diagram of total exergy loss parameters of the refrigeration system of the exergy analysis method of the two-stage compression refrigeration system of the present invention.
[0025] Figure 6 It is a summary diagram of the total exergy efficiency parameters of the refrigeration system of the exergy analysis method of the two-stage compression refrigeration system of the present invention.
[0026] Figure 7 A summary diagram of the optimal design parameters of the refrigeration system according to the exergy analysis method of the two-stage compression refrigeration system of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0027] The following describes the implementation of the present invention in detail by taking specific embodiments as examples in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
[0028] like Figure 1 As shown, a refrigeration system structure diagram of an exergy analysis method for a two-stage compression refrigeration system provided by an embodiment of the present invention, the equipment includes a low-pressure stage compressor 1.1, a high-pressure stage compressor 1.2, an auxiliary condenser 2, an oil separator 3, a gas cooler 4, a first electronic expansion valve 5.1, a second electronic expansion valve 5.2, an intermediate cooler 6, an evaporator 7 and a gas-liquid separator 8; the state points include point a, point b, point c, point d, point e, point f, point g, point h, point i, and point j.
[0029] like Figure 2As shown, a pressure-enthalpy diagram of a refrigeration system of an exergy analysis method for a two-stage compression refrigeration system provided by an embodiment of the present invention, wherein the state points include point a, point b, point c, point d, point e, point f, point g, point h, point i, and point j.
[0030] like Figure 3 As shown, a COP parameter summary diagram of an exergy analysis method for a two-stage compression refrigeration system provided by an embodiment of the present invention.
[0031] like Figure 4 As shown, a summary diagram of the total output work parameters of the compressor of the exergy analysis method of the two-stage compression refrigeration system provided by one embodiment of the present invention.
[0032] like Figure 5 As shown, a summary diagram of total exergy loss parameters of an exergy analysis method for a two-stage compression refrigeration system provided by an embodiment of the present invention.
[0033] like Figure 6 As shown, a summary diagram of total exergy efficiency parameters of an exergy analysis method for a two-stage compression refrigeration system provided by an embodiment of the present invention.
[0034] like Figure 7 As shown, a summary diagram of optimal design parameters of an exergy analysis method for a two-stage compression refrigeration system provided by an embodiment of the present invention.
[0035] The two-stage compression refrigeration system provided in this embodiment is a carbon dioxide transcritical two-stage compression refrigeration system, which is used in a refrigerated container. The refrigerant is carbon dioxide. The design working conditions are 40°C outdoors (calculated based on the worst condition, the refrigeration capacity is the largest under this condition) and -18°C inside the refrigerated container.
[0036] The connection mode of the refrigeration system of this embodiment is as follows: the outlet of the low-pressure compressor 1.1 is connected to the auxiliary condenser 2; the outlet of the auxiliary condenser 2 is connected to the high-pressure compressor 1.2; the outlet of the high-pressure compressor 1.2 is connected to the oil separator 3; the outlet of the oil separator 3 is connected to the gas cooler 4; the outlet of the gas cooler 3 is split, one branch is connected to the first electronic expansion valve 5.1, and the other branch is connected to the intermediate cooler 6; the outlet of the first electronic expansion valve 5.1 is connected to the intermediate cooler 5; the two outlets of the intermediate cooler 6, one is connected to the pipeline of the outlet of the auxiliary condenser 2, and the other is connected to the second electronic expansion valve 5.2; the second electronic expansion valve 5.2 is connected to the evaporator 7; the evaporator 7 is connected to the gas-liquid separator 8; the gas-liquid separator 8 is connected to the low-pressure compressor 1.1.
[0037] The flow process of refrigerant is:
[0038] 1) The carbon dioxide at state point a enters the low-pressure compressor 1.1 and undergoes the first compression to become state point b;
[0039] 2) The carbon dioxide at state point b enters auxiliary condenser 2 and is cooled at isobaric pressure to become state point j. In this process, auxiliary condenser 2 only serves as a cooling device;
[0040] 3) The carbon dioxide at state point j and the carbon dioxide at state point i at the outlet of the intercooler 5 are mixed at the intersection of the two pipelines to form state point c;
[0041] 4) The carbon dioxide at state point c enters the high-pressure compressor 1.2 and undergoes a second compression to become state point d;
[0042] 5) The carbon dioxide at state point d passes through the oil separator 3 for de-oiling treatment, and the oil separator 3 will not affect the physical properties of the carbon dioxide;
[0043] 6) The de-oiled carbon dioxide at state point d enters the gas cooler 4 and is cooled at isobaric pressure to state point e;
[0044] 7) The carbon dioxide at state point e is split, one branch is throttled by the first electronic expansion valve 5.1, and after reaching state point f, it flows into the intercooler 6, and the other branch directly enters the intercooler 6;
[0045] 8) The intercooler 6 has two outlets. The carbon dioxide at state point f passes through the intercooler to become state point i, and mixes with the carbon dioxide at state point j to become state point c. The carbon dioxide at state point E is cooled by the intercooler to become state point g.
[0046] 9) The carbon dioxide at state point g is throttled by the second electronic expansion valve 5.2 and becomes state point h;
[0047] 10) The carbon dioxide at state point h enters the evaporator 7, absorbs heat and evaporates to become state point a;
[0048] 11) The carbon dioxide at state point a passes through the gas-liquid separator 8 for dehydration treatment, and the gaseous carbon dioxide is sent to the inlet of the low-pressure compressor 1.1. The gas-liquid separator 8 will not affect the physical properties of the carbon dioxide.
[0049] The parameters involved in this embodiment are marked as follows:
[0050] t——temperature, °C;
[0051] h——enthalpy value, kJ / kg;
[0052] S——entropy value, kJ / (kg·K);
[0053] P——pressure, MPa;
[0054] Q——cooling load, kW;
[0055] Q E ——heat exchange capacity, kW;
[0056] m——mass flow rate, kg / s;
[0057] W——output power, kW;
[0058] COP – coefficient of performance;
[0059] T——temperature, K;
[0060] e——unit exergy value, kJ / kg;
[0061] E——exergy value, kW;
[0062] η——exergy efficiency;
[0063] If the symbols or letters written in the same way as above appear in the subscript position, they are state point labels, not parameter marks.
[0064] Flow calculation formula:
[0065] Flow rate at 1.1 of low pressure compressor: m L =Q / (h h -h a );
[0066] High pressure compressor 1.2 flow rate: m H =m L (h i -h g ) / (h i -h e );
[0067] Flow rate at state point i: m ZL =m H -m L .
[0068] Performance parameter calculation formula:
[0069] Output power of low pressure compressor 1.1: W L =m L (h b -h a );
[0070] Output power of high pressure compressor 1.2: W H =m H (h d -h c );
[0071] Total output power of the compressor: W = W L +W H ;
[0072] Coefficient of performance: COP=Q / W.
[0073] Exergy analysis calculation formula:
[0074] Exergy balance expression: E in -E out =E dest ;
[0075] Unit exergy: e=(h-T0·S)-(h0-T0·S0);
[0076] Exergy efficiency: η=1-E dest / W;
[0077] Exergy loss of low pressure compressor 1.1: E dest,1.1 =m L ·T0(S b -S a );
[0078] Exergy loss of high pressure compressor 1.2: E dest,1.2 =m H ·T0(S d -S c );
[0079] Heat exchange capacity of auxiliary condenser 2: Q E,2 =m L (h b -h j );
[0080] Exergy loss of auxiliary condenser 2: E dest,1.3 = m L (e j -e b ) - Q E,2 (1-T0 / T b,ac,2 );
[0081] Heat exchange capacity of gas cooler 4: Q E,4 =m L (h d -h e );
[0082] Exergy loss of gas cooler 4: E dest,4 = m H (e d -e e )-Q E,4 (1-T0 / T b,ac,4 );
[0083] Exergy loss of the first electronic expansion valve 5.1: E dest,5.1 = m ZL (S e -Sf );
[0084] Exergy loss of the second electronic expansion valve 5.2: E dest,5.2 = m L (S g -S h );
[0085] Exergy loss of intercooler 6: E dest,6 = m L (S e -S g )+ m ZL (S f -S j );
[0086] Exergy loss of evaporator 7: E dest,7 = m H (e h -e a )+Q(1-T0 / T b,evap );
[0087] The reference state conditions of the refrigerant are T0=298K, pressure P0=1atm, enthalpy h0= 496.64kJ / kg, and entropy S0=2.2759kJ / (kg·K);
[0088] T b,ac,4 is the heat transfer boundary temperature of the gas cooler 4, taking the outdoor ambient temperature (40°C), i.e. 313K;
[0089] T b,ac,2 is the heat transfer boundary temperature of auxiliary condenser 2, taking the middle temperature;
[0090] T b,evap is the heat transfer boundary temperature of the evaporator 7, taking the temperature inside the refrigerated container (-18°C), that is, 255K.
[0091] The system diagram of the two-stage compression refrigeration system of this embodiment is as follows: Figure 1 The pressure-enthalpy diagram of this system is as follows: Figure 2 As shown, the cooling capacity is 1.23 kW, carbon dioxide is selected as the refrigerant, the evaporation temperature is -23°C, and the superheat of the evaporator 7 and the subcooling of the intercooler 6 are both 3°C.
[0092] The outlet temperatures of the gas cooler 4 are selected as 32°C, 33°C, 35°C, 37°C, 39°C and 41°C, and the outlet pressures of the gas cooler 4 are selected as 8.9MPa, 9.1MPa, 9.2MPa, 9.3MPa, 9.5MPa and 9.7MPa. According to the combinations of the above 6 outlet temperatures and outlet pressures of the gas cooler 4, the temperature, pressure, enthalpy and entropy values of each state point of the 36 control groups are determined.
[0093] According to the flow calculation formula, performance parameter calculation formula and exergy analysis calculation formula, the COP, total compressor output work, exergy loss and exergy efficiency corresponding to each state point of the 36 control groups were calculated.
[0094] In terms of COP value, COP increases with the decrease of the outlet temperature of gas cooler 4 and with the decrease of the outlet pressure of gas cooler 4. However, in the control group with the outlet temperature of gas cooler 4 being 39°C and 41°C, the trend is completely opposite. After verification, many state points of this control group are on the right side of the critical point in the pressure-enthalpy diagram, which cannot be achieved in reality. Therefore, this abnormal phenomenon can be ignored. The maximum COP value appears when the outlet temperature of gas cooler 4 is 32°C and the outlet pressure of gas cooler 4 is 8.9MPa, which is 2.4400.
[0095] In terms of the total output work of the compressor, the total output work of the compressor increases with the increase of the outlet temperature of the gas cooler 4 and the outlet pressure of the gas cooler 4, but in the control group with the outlet temperature of the gas cooler 4 being 39°C and 41°C, the trend is completely opposite. After verification, many state points of this part of the control group are on the right side of the critical point in the pressure-enthalpy diagram, which cannot be realized in reality, so this abnormal phenomenon can be ignored. Theoretically, the greater the total output work of the compressor, the better, but the greater the total output work of the compressor, the greater the energy conversion loss generated, so it needs to be analyzed in combination with the total exergy loss and the total exergy efficiency.
[0096] In terms of total exergy loss, the total exergy loss generally increases with the increase of the outlet temperature of gas cooler 4 and the outlet pressure of gas cooler 4, but in the control group with the outlet temperature of gas cooler 4 being 39℃ and 41℃, the trend is completely opposite. After verification, many state points of this part of the control group are on the right side of the critical point in the pressure-enthalpy diagram, which cannot be realized in reality, so this abnormal phenomenon can be ignored. The total exergy loss is the sum of the exergy loss of all equipment in the two-stage compression refrigeration system. There are many influencing factors, so it is reasonable to have small fluctuations sometimes, as long as there is no excessive change in the overall trend.
[0097] In terms of total exergy efficiency, the total exergy efficiency increases with the increase of the outlet temperature of gas cooler 4, but it first increases and then decreases with the increase of the outlet pressure of gas cooler 4. In the control group with the outlet temperature of gas cooler 4 being 39℃ and 41℃, the total exergy efficiency increases with the increase of the outlet pressure of gas cooler 4. After verification, many state points of this part of the control group are on the right side of the critical point in the pressure-enthalpy diagram, which cannot be realized in reality, so this abnormal phenomenon can be ignored. In the control group with the outlet temperature of gas cooler 4 being 32℃, 33℃, 35℃ and 37℃, the total exergy efficiency of gas cooler 4 with an outlet pressure of 9.2MPa is an extreme value, and these four extreme values are 50.10%, 49.37%, 47.69% and 45.47% respectively. It can be seen that the total exergy efficiency of the control group with the outlet temperature of gas cooler 4 being 32℃ and the outlet pressure of gas cooler 4 being 9.2MPa is the highest.
[0098] Combining the data of total compressor output power, total exergy loss and total exergy efficiency, it is found that the control group with larger total compressor output power also has larger total exergy loss. Using total exergy efficiency to evaluate the performance of the refrigeration system is the most objective and accurate.
[0099] Through the analysis of the above data, it can be seen that the lower the outlet temperature of the gas cooler 4, the higher the COP and the greater the total exergy loss. However, since the carbon dioxide selected in this embodiment is used for transcriticality, it cannot be lower than the critical temperature of carbon dioxide (31.06°C). Therefore, the temperature should be close to the critical temperature of carbon dioxide (31.06°C) and greater than this temperature. The temperature is accurate to the unit, so 32°C is taken; the total exergy efficiency will have an extreme value in the process of increasing the outlet pressure of the gas cooler 4. If the pressure is accurate to the first decimal place, when the outlet temperature of the gas cooler 4 is low, the extreme point will appear at 9.2MPa.
[0100] The best design parameters are determined as follows: the outlet temperature of gas cooler 4 is 32°C, and the outlet pressure of gas cooler 4 is 9.2MPa. Under this condition, the state point parameters of the two-stage compression refrigeration system are as follows: Figure 7 shown.
[0101] The exergy analysis only calculates the part passing through the refrigeration components, and the flow of carbon dioxide in the pipeline is considered to be lossless flow.
[0102] The optimal design parameters that can be determined by the present invention are for design purposes only.
[0103] The above embodiments are merely illustrative of the design principles and uses of the present invention, and are not intended to limit the present invention. Anyone familiar with the technology may modify or change the above embodiments without violating the spirit and scope of the present invention. Therefore, all equivalent modifications or changes made by those with ordinary knowledge in the technical field without departing from the spirit and technical ideas disclosed by the present invention should still be covered by the claims of the present invention.
Claims
1. Exergy analysis method for two-stage compression refrigeration system, Features: The exergy analysis method of the two-stage compression refrigeration system, the equipment of the refrigeration system includes a compressor, an auxiliary condenser (2), an oil separator (3), a gas cooler (4), an electronic expansion valve, an intermediate cooler (6), an evaporator (7) and a gas-liquid separator (8); The state points include point a, point b, point c, point d, point e, point f, point g, point h, point i, and point j; The compressor comprises a low-pressure stage compressor (1.1) and a high-pressure stage compressor (1.2); The electronic expansion valve comprises a first electronic expansion valve (5.1) and a second electronic expansion valve (5.2); The steps of exergy analysis are as follows: 1) Draw a system diagram of a two-stage compression refrigeration system and mark each state point; 2) Determine the refrigeration capacity, refrigerant type, evaporation temperature, superheat of the evaporator (7) and subcooling of the intercooler (6) of the two-stage compression refrigeration system; 3) Gas cooler (4) Determine the temperature, pressure, enthalpy and entropy of each state point under different outlet temperature and outlet pressure requirements; 4) By changing the outlet temperature and outlet pressure parameters of the gas cooler (4), calculate the COP, total compressor output power, total exergy loss and total exergy efficiency of the two-stage compression refrigeration system; 5) Analyze the changing trends of COP, total compressor output power, total exergy loss and total exergy efficiency of the two-stage compression refrigeration system as the outlet temperature and outlet pressure of the gas cooler (4) change.
2. The exergy analysis method for a two-stage compression refrigeration system according to claim 1, Features: The state of the refrigerant in the exergy analysis method of the two-stage compression refrigeration system is T 0 =298K, pressure is P 0 =1atm.
3. The exergy analysis method for a two-stage compression refrigeration system according to claim 1, Features: The total exergy loss of the two-stage compression refrigeration system is the sum of the exergy losses of the compressor, the auxiliary condenser (2), the oil separator (3), the gas cooler (4), the electronic expansion valve, the intercooler (6), the evaporator (7) and the gas-liquid separator (8).
4. The exergy analysis method for a two-stage compression refrigeration system according to claim 1, Features: The outlet temperature of the gas cooler (4) is accurate to the last digit and is expressed in °C.
5. The exergy analysis method for a two-stage compression refrigeration system according to claim 1, Features: The outlet pressure of the gas cooler (4) is accurate to one decimal place and is expressed in MPa.
