A method for determining the optimal equivalent length of a DC transmission line physical simulation system
By determining the equivalent length of the π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line and calculating the equivalent input impedance difference, the problem of inaccurate simulation of DC transmission line in the prior art is solved, and the frequency range of 0 Hz to several thousand Hz is realized. Accurate simulation and lowest economic cost effect, meeting the needs of DC transmission line protection algorithm.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202111150621.4
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-09-29
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-09-29
AI Technical Summary
The prior art is difficult to accurately simulate the amplitude and phase response characteristics of DC transmission lines in the frequency range of 0 Hz to thousands of Hz, and cannot meet the high sampling frequency requirements of DC transmission line protection algorithms, and the simulation cost of traditional π equivalent models is relatively high. .
By determining the sample set of equivalent lengths of each DC transmission line, the difference between the equivalent length and the equivalent input impedance of the distribution parameter line at a specific frequency, and the equivalent length under a broadband response is calculated and the equivalent length and the distribution parameter line are calculated. The difference in input impedance is used to finally determine the optimal equal length of the π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line, ensuring that the simulation system meets the protection algorithm verification needs under the premise of the lowest economic cost.
Accurate simulation in the frequency range of 0 Hz to thousands of Hz is realized, which meets the verification requirements of DC transmission line protection algorithms, and reduces the economic cost of physical simulation systems. The response between DC transmission line and distributed parameter lines is quantitatively analyzed. The difference optimizes the technical and economic benefits of the π model.
Smart Images

Figure CN113887039B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of physical simulation of direct current transmission lines, and specifically refers to a method for determining an optimal equivalent length of a direct current transmission line physical simulation system, and in particular to a method for determining an optimal equivalent length of a direct current transmission line physical model that can accurately simulate response characteristics in a frequency range from 0 Hz to several kilohertz. Technical Background
[0002] The DC transmission line itself is a distributed component. In general, the length of the DC transmission line ranges from hundreds to thousands of kilometers. We cannot fully dynamically simulate the distributed components of hundreds to thousands of kilometers. Traditional line dynamic simulation components generally use the π equivalent model, and calculate R, L, and C in the π equivalent model to equivalently simulate the impedance phase response characteristics of the DC transmission line at DC or 50Hz. This fully meets the needs of dynamic simulation in the verification of traditional overcurrent protection, distance protection, and longitudinal protection algorithms based on power frequency quantities.
[0003] Different from the overcurrent protection, distance protection and longitudinal protection based on power frequency quantity commonly used in AC lines, the protection of DC transmission lines often uses low-frequency traveling wave protection and differential undervoltage protection as the main line protection, and the voltage and current frequency used is generally within 10kHz. At the same time, many protection criteria based on transient voltage and current information after a fault have been proposed at home and abroad, and these new protection algorithms also require sampling frequencies of several thousand hertz.
[0004] Therefore, it is necessary to find an optimal equivalent length method for the π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line that can accurately simulate the amplitude and phase response characteristics of the DC transmission line in the frequency range of 0 Hz to several kilohertz. Summary of the invention
[0005] The purpose of the present invention is to overcome the shortcomings of the prior art, with the goal of accurately simulating the broadband response characteristics of a DC transmission line in the frequency range of 0 Hz to several kilohertz, and to propose an optimal equivalent length method for a π-type physical simulation system of a DC transmission line, which can meet the needs of verifying the protection algorithm of the DC transmission line while ensuring the lowest economic cost of the physical simulation system.
[0006] To achieve the above object, the present invention is a method for determining the optimal equivalent length of a DC transmission line physical simulation system, the particularity of which is that the method comprises the steps of:
[0007] 1) Determine the sample set of equivalent length l of each DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system;
[0008] 2) Calculate the difference in equivalent input impedance between the π-type physical simulation system of a DC transmission line with an equivalent length of l and the distributed parameter line at a specific frequency;
[0009] 3) Calculate the difference in equivalent input impedance between the π-type physical simulation system of a DC transmission line with an equivalent length of l and the distributed parameter line under wide frequency response;
[0010] 4) Calculate the optimal equivalent length of the π-type physical simulation system of DC transmission line under wide frequency response.
[0011] Preferably, in step 1), the sample set of equivalent length l of each DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system is:
[0012]
[0013] Where N* represents a set of positive integers, l total Represents the total length of the DC transmission line to be simulated.
[0014] Preferably, in step 2), when the frequency is equal to f, the difference ΔZ between the equivalent input impedance of the π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line and the distributed parameter line under the equivalent length l is input The calculation method of (f,l) is:
[0015]
[0016] In the above formula, l represents the equivalent length of the line, R p1 , L p1 , C p1 They represent the positive-sequence series resistance, positive-sequence series inductance, and positive-sequence shunt capacitance in the π equivalent model, respectively. p0 , L p0 , C p0 They represent the zero-sequence series resistance, zero-sequence series inductance, and zero-sequence shunt capacitance in the π equivalent model, respectively. c1 and γ1 represent the positive sequence characteristic impedance and positive sequence propagation coefficient of distributed parameter DC transmission line respectively, Z c0 and γ0 represent the zero-sequence characteristic impedance and zero-sequence propagation coefficient of distributed parameter DC transmission line, respectively; λ1 and λ0 represent the positive-sequence and zero-sequence equivalent calculation coefficients in the π equivalent model, respectively; j represents a pure imaginary unit.
[0017] Preferably, in step 3), the comprehensive difference ΔZ between the equivalent input impedance of the π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line with an average length of l and the distributed parameter line input (l), the calculation method is:
[0018]
[0019] In the above formula, α m is the weight of the component parameter corresponding to the mth frequency, and f mRepresents the mth frequency of the selected N frequency points.
[0020] Preferably, in step 4), the optimal equivalent length l of the π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line under the broadband response is r The calculation method is:
[0021]
[0022] In the above formula, l r The unit of measurement is kilometer, and ρ is the maximum allowable maximum value of the comprehensive difference between the π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line and the equivalent input impedance of the distributed parameter line.
[0023] Preferably, the positive sequence characteristic impedance Z of the distributed parameter DC transmission line c1 and positive sequence propagation coefficient γ1, distributed parameter DC transmission line zero sequence characteristic impedance Z c0 and zero-sequence propagation coefficient γ0, π in the positive sequence and zero-sequence equivalent calculation coefficient λ1 and λ0, π in the positive sequence series resistance R in the equivalent model p1 , positive sequence series inductance L p1 , positive sequence parallel capacitor C p1 Zero-sequence series resistance R in the π equivalent model p0 , zero-sequence series inductance L p0 , zero-sequence parallel capacitance C p0 The calculation methods are:
[0024]
[0025]
[0026]
[0027]
[0028]
[0029]
[0030] R p1 =real(Z c1 sinh(γ1l)) (9)
[0031] L p1 =imag(Z c1 sinh(γ1l)) / (2πf) (10)
[0032]
[0033] R p0 =real(Zc0 sinh(γ0l)) (12)
[0034] L p0 =imag(Z c0 sinh(γ0l)) / (2πf) (13)
[0035]
[0036] In the above formula, R u1 , L u1 , C u1 They represent the positive-sequence series resistance, positive-sequence series inductance and positive-sequence shunt capacitance of the distributed parameter DC transmission line per unit length, R u0 , L u0 , C u0 They represent the zero-sequence series resistance, zero-sequence series inductance and zero-sequence shunt capacitance of the distributed parameter DC transmission line per unit length respectively. ω represents the angular frequency and is equal to 2πf. real() and imag() are MATLAB functions.
[0037] Compared with the prior art, the parameter optimization method for constructing a physical simulation system of a DC transmission line proposed in the present invention has the following technical effects:
[0038] 1. The method for determining the optimal equivalent length of the physical simulation system of a DC transmission line provided by the present invention is based on accurately simulating the amplitude and phase response of the DC transmission line in the frequency range of 0 Hz to several kilohertz. By determining the equivalent length l sample set of each DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system, calculating the difference in equivalent input impedance between the DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system with an equivalent length of l and the distributed parameter line at a specific frequency, calculating the difference in equivalent input impedance between the DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system with an equivalent length of l and the distributed parameter line under a wide-frequency response, and calculating the optimal equivalent length of the DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system under a wide-frequency response, the optimal equivalent length of the DC transmission line physical simulation system is finally determined, which can meet the needs of DC transmission line protection algorithm verification while ensuring the lowest economic cost of the physical simulation system.
[0039] 2. The method for determining the sample set of equivalent length l of the π-type physical simulation system of each DC transmission line provided by the present invention can preliminarily determine the value samples of the equivalent length of the π-type physical simulation system of each DC transmission line with high comprehensive technical and economic benefits.
[0040] 3. The method for calculating the difference in equivalent input impedance between a π-type physical simulation system of a DC transmission line with an equivalent length of l and a distributed parameter line at a specific frequency provided by the present invention can quantitatively analyze the response difference between the physical simulation system of a DC transmission line and a distributed parameter line.
[0041] 4. The method for calculating the difference in equivalent input impedance between a π-type physical simulation system of a DC transmission line with an equivalent length of l and a distributed parameter line under a wide-frequency response provided by the present invention can quantitatively give the response difference between the physical simulation system of a DC transmission line under a wide-frequency response and a distributed parameter line under the signal frequency band used by the DC transmission line protection algorithm.
[0042] 5. The method for determining the optimal equivalent length of the π-type physical simulation system of a DC transmission line under a wide frequency response provided by the present invention can optimize the technical and economic performance of the equivalent "π" model of the physical simulation of a DC transmission line. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0043] Figure 1 is the distributed parameter line model diagram;
[0044] Figure 2 This is the traditional "π" equivalent circuit model diagram;
[0045] Figure 3 This is the equivalent “π” model diagram of the DC transmission line. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0046] The present invention is further described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and examples, but the examples should not be construed as limiting the present invention.
[0047] The invention relates to a method for determining an optimal equivalent length of a physical simulation system of a direct current transmission line, in particular to a method for determining an optimal equivalent length of a physical model of a direct current transmission line which can accurately simulate response characteristics in a frequency range from 0 Hz to several kilohertz.
[0048] In fact, when a fault occurs in a DC transmission line, the protection algorithm of the DC transmission line generally uses low-frequency traveling wave protection and differential undervoltage protection formed by voltage and current sampling values in the range of 0 Hz to several kilohertz to form the main line protection. Therefore, the present invention focuses on a method for determining the optimal equivalent length of a DC transmission line physical model that can accurately simulate the response characteristics in the frequency range of 0 Hz to several kilohertz, so as to meet the needs of DC transmission line protection algorithm verification while ensuring the lowest economic cost of the physical simulation system; it mainly includes four parts: first, determining the equivalent length l sample set of each DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system; second, calculating the difference between the equivalent input impedance of the DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system with an equivalent length of l and the distributed parameter line at a specific frequency; third, calculating the difference between the equivalent input impedance of the DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system with an equivalent length of l and the distributed parameter line under a wide frequency response; fourth, calculating the optimal equivalent length of the DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system under a wide frequency response to finally determine the optimal equivalent length of the DC transmission line physical simulation system.
[0049] The present invention is described in more detail below with the help of examples, but the following examples are only illustrative, and the protection scope of the present invention is not limited by these examples.
[0050] The DC transmission line is actually a distributed parameter model, and its unit length impedance Z u =r u +jωl u , its admittance per unit length to the ground is Y u =G u +jωC u , the end load is Z load . Distributed parameter transmission lines such as Figure 1 As shown, the corresponding traditional equivalent "π" model is as follows Figure 2 To simulate the positive and negative lines of DC transmission at the same time, the “π” model of the DC transmission line is as follows: Figure 3 As shown, it is assumed that the total length of the DC transmission line to be equivalent is l total , the equivalent length of each DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system is l.
[0051] Step 1: Determine the sample set of equivalent length l for each DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system.
[0052] In order to ensure that an integer number of π-type physical simulation systems of DC transmission lines are connected in series to form a complete physical simulation platform of DC transmission lines, total The response characteristics of the DC transmission line to be equivalent, the sample set of equivalent length l of each DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system is
[0053]
[0054] Where N* represents the set of positive integers.
[0055] Step 2: Calculate the difference in equivalent input impedance between the π-type physical simulation system of a DC transmission line with an equivalent length of l and the distributed parameter line at a specific frequency.
[0056] In order to ensure that the amplitude and phase response of the "π" model of the DC transmission line in the frequency range of 0 Hz to several kilohertz are closest to the distributed parameter line, it is necessary to calculate the difference △Z between the equivalent input impedance of the DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system and the distributed parameter line at the equivalent length l when the frequency is equal to f input (f,l), the calculation formula is
[0057]
[0058] In the above formula, l represents the equivalent length of the line, R p1 , L p1 , C p1The π equivalent model represents the positive sequence series resistance, positive sequence series inductance, and positive sequence parallel capacitance R p0 , L p0 , C p0 They represent the zero-sequence series resistance, zero-sequence series inductance, and zero-sequence parallel capacitance in the π equivalent model. c1 and γ1 represent the positive sequence characteristic impedance and positive sequence propagation coefficient of distributed parameter DC transmission line respectively, Z c0 and γ0 represent the zero-sequence characteristic impedance and zero-sequence propagation coefficient of distributed parameter DC transmission line respectively, and λ1 and λ0 represent the positive-sequence and zero-sequence equivalent calculation coefficients in the π equivalent model respectively.
[0059] When the frequency of the DC transmission line is equal to f, the positive sequence impedance per unit length Z u1 (f) = R u1 (f)+jωL u1 (f), its positive sequence admittance per unit length to ground is Y u1 (f) = G u1 (f)+jωC u1 (f), zero-sequence impedance per unit length Z when the frequency is equal to f u0 (f) = R u0 (f)+jωL u0 (f), its positive sequence admittance per unit length to ground is Y u0 =G u0 +jωC u0 , then Z in formula (1) c1 ,γ1,λ1,Z c0 ,γ0,λ0,R p1 , L p1 , C p1 , R p0 , L p0 , C p0 The calculation formula is as follows
[0060]
[0061]
[0062]
[0063]
[0064]
[0065]
[0066] R p1 =real(Z c1 sinh(γ1l)) (9)
[0067] L p1 =imag(Z c1 sinh(γ1l)) / (2πf) (10)
[0068]
[0069] R p0 =real(Z c0 sinh(γ0l)) (12)
[0070] L p0 =imag(Z c0 sinh(γ0l)) / (2πf) (13)
[0071]
[0072] In the above formula, R u1 , L u1 , C u1 They represent the positive-sequence series resistance, positive-sequence series inductance and positive-sequence shunt capacitance of the distributed parameter DC transmission line per unit length, R u0 , L u0 , C u0 They represent the zero-sequence series resistance, zero-sequence series inductance and zero-sequence shunt capacitance of the distributed parameter DC transmission line per unit length respectively. ω represents the angular frequency and is equal to 2πf. real() and imag() are MATLAB functions.
[0073] Step 3: Calculate the difference in equivalent input impedance between the π-type physical simulation system of a DC transmission line with an equivalent length of l and the distributed parameter line under wide frequency response.
[0074] The DC transmission line protection uses voltage and current signals in a wide frequency band of 0-10kHz. By selecting N frequency points and using the weighted average value, the comprehensive difference △Z between the equivalent input impedance of the π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line with an equivalent length of l and the distributed parameter line is determined. input (l), calculated as follows
[0075]
[0076] In the above formula, α m is the weight of the component parameter corresponding to the mth frequency, and f m Represents the mth frequency of the selected N frequency points.
[0077] Step 4: Calculate the optimal equivalent length of the π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line under wide frequency response.
[0078] The comprehensive difference △Z between the equivalent input impedance of the π-type physical simulation system of DC transmission line and the distributed parameter line input (l), which meets the requirements of DC transmission line protection algorithm verification. However, if l is too small, the cost of the DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system will rise rapidly. Therefore, the optimal equivalent length l of the DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system is determined r , it should be ensured that at the selected N frequency points, △Z input (l) is just within the range required for protection algorithm verification. When the DC transmission line protection algorithm verification is required, the maximum value of the comprehensive difference between the DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system and the distributed parameter line equivalent input impedance is ρ. Then the optimal equivalent length l of the DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system is r Calculated from the following formula
[0079]
[0080] In the above formula, l r The unit of measurement is kilometer, l total Represents the total length of the DC transmission line to be simulated.
[0081] The following is to illustrate the effectiveness of the parameter optimization method of the DC transmission line physical simulation system, combined with a typical DC transmission line parameter, as shown in Table 1:
[0082] Table 1 Parameters of a ±800kV DC transmission line
[0083]
[0084] Step 1: Given the total length of the DC transmission line l total =932km. According to formula (1), the sample set of equivalent length l of the π-type physical simulation system of each DC transmission line is determined to be 93.2km, 84.7km, 77.7km, 71.7km, 66.6km, 62.1km, 58.2km, …, 20.7km.
[0085] Step 2: Calculate the difference in equivalent input impedance between the π-type physical simulation system of a DC transmission line with an equivalent length of l and the distributed parameter line at a specific frequency. Take the difference in equivalent input impedance between the π-type physical simulation system of a DC transmission line and the distributed parameter line when the equivalent length is 77.7 km at 50 Hz as △Z input (f,l) is 242.0801.
[0086] Step 3: Calculate the difference between the equivalent input impedance of the π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line with an equivalent length of l and the distributed parameter line under broadband response. When the weights are 0.4, 0.4 and 0.2 respectively, and the physical equivalent length of each π-type DC transmission line is 77.7 km, the total difference between the equivalent input impedance of the π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line and the distributed parameter line is △Z input (l)=0.4×242.0801+0.4×154.5805+0.2×1276.2=413.9.
[0087] Step 4, calculate the optimal equivalent length of the π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line under wide-frequency response. Take 50Hz, 500Hz and 5000Hz as examples for analysis, and the weights are 0.4, 0.4 and 0.2 respectively. Generally speaking, the maximum allowable value ρ of the comprehensive difference is set to 400. After calculation, when the physical equivalent length of each π-type DC transmission line is 77.7km, 71.7km, 66.6km and 62.1km respectively, the total difference between the equivalent input impedance of the π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line and the distributed parameter line is 413.9, 612.8, 386.55 and 1289.8 respectively. Therefore, in this example, the optimal equivalent length of each π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line is 66.6km. The DC transmission line physical simulation platform is composed of 14 DC transmission line π-type physical simulation systems, and the total length l total =Complete simulation of a 932km DC transmission line.
[0088] Although the preferred embodiments of the present invention have been described above in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, the present invention is not limited to the above-mentioned specific implementation methods. The above-mentioned specific implementation methods are merely illustrative and not restrictive. Under the guidance of the present invention, ordinary technicians in this field can also make many forms of specific changes without departing from the scope of protection of the purpose of the present invention and the claims, which all fall within the scope of protection of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for determining the optimal equivalent length of a DC transmission line physical simulation system, characterized in that: The method comprises the steps of: 1) Determine the sample set of equivalent length l of each DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system; 2) Calculate the difference in equivalent input impedance between the π-type physical simulation system of a DC transmission line with an equivalent length of l and the distributed parameter line at a specific frequency; 3) Calculate the difference in equivalent input impedance between the π-type physical simulation system of a DC transmission line with an equivalent length of l and the distributed parameter line under wide frequency response; 4) Calculate the optimal equivalent length of the π-type physical simulation system of DC transmission line under wide frequency response; In the step 1), the sample set of equivalent length l of each DC transmission line π-type physical simulation system is: Where N* represents a set of positive integers, l total represents the total length of the DC transmission line to be simulated; In the step 2), when the frequency is equal to f, the difference △Z between the equivalent input impedance of the π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line and the distributed parameter line under the equivalent length l is input The calculation method of (f,l) is: In the above formula, l represents the equivalent length of the line, R p1 , L p1 , C p1 They represent the positive-sequence series resistance, positive-sequence series inductance, and positive-sequence shunt capacitance in the π equivalent model, respectively. p0 , L p0 , C p0 They represent the zero-sequence series resistance, zero-sequence series inductance, and zero-sequence shunt capacitance in the π equivalent model, respectively. c1 and γ1 represent the positive sequence characteristic impedance and positive sequence propagation coefficient of distributed parameter DC transmission line respectively, Z c0 and γ0 represent the zero-sequence characteristic impedance and zero-sequence propagation coefficient of distributed parameter DC transmission line, respectively; λ1 and λ0 represent the positive-sequence and zero-sequence equivalent calculation coefficients in the π equivalent model, respectively; j represents a pure imaginary unit. In the step 3), the comprehensive difference △Z between the equivalent input impedance of the π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line with an average length of l and the distributed parameter line input (l), the calculation method is: In the above formula, α m is the weight of the component parameter corresponding to the mth frequency, and f m Represents the mth frequency of the selected N frequency points; The optimal equivalent length l of the π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line under the broadband response in step 4) r The calculation method is: In the above formula, l r The unit of measurement is kilometer, ρ is the maximum allowable value of the comprehensive difference between the π-type physical simulation system of the DC transmission line and the equivalent input impedance of the distributed parameter line; the positive sequence characteristic impedance Z of the distributed parameter DC transmission line c1 and positive sequence propagation coefficient γ1, distributed parameter DC transmission line zero sequence characteristic impedance Z c0 and zero-sequence propagation coefficient γ0, π in the positive sequence and zero-sequence equivalent calculation coefficient λ1 and λ0, π in the positive sequence series resistance R in the equivalent model p1 , positive sequence series inductance L p1 , positive sequence parallel capacitor C p1 Zero-sequence series resistance R in the π equivalent model p0 , zero-sequence series inductance L p0 , zero-sequence shunt capacitor C p0 The calculation methods are: R p1 =real(Z c1 birth(γ1l)) (9) L p1 =imag(Z c1 sinh(γ1l)) / (2πf)(10) R p0 =real(Z c0 birth(γ0l))(12) L p0 =imag(Z c0 sinh(γ0l)) / (2πf)(13) In the above formula, R u1 , L u1 , C u1 They represent the positive-sequence series resistance, positive-sequence series inductance and positive-sequence shunt capacitance of the distributed parameter DC transmission line per unit length, R u0 , L u0 , C u0 They represent the zero-sequence series resistance, zero-sequence series inductance and zero-sequence shunt capacitance of the distributed parameter DC transmission line per unit length respectively. ω represents the angular frequency and is equal to 2πf. real() and imag() are MATLAB functions.
