A method for evaluating the economic feasibility of 5G in the process of distribution network transformation

By optimizing the number and location of 5G base stations in the distribution network, combining with the K-means clustering algorithm, economic evaluation indicators are established, and the problems of low economic and automation level of wireless technology applications in the distribution network are solved, and the problem of low economic and automation level is achieved Efficient wireless communication transformation and smart power consumption requirements.

CN114091926BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-15STATE GRID JIANGXI ELECTRIC POWER CO LTD RES INST +2
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202111408022.8
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2021-11-25
Publication Date
2024-11-15
Estimated Expiration
2041-11-25

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The existing technology has failed to effectively realize the practical remote control of wireless switches in the distribution network, resulting in low automation level, low fault positioning accuracy, and low frequency of electricity consumption information data collection, which cannot meet smart electricity consumption and personalized customers. Service needs affect user satisfaction with electricity use.

Method used

A method of economic evaluation of 5G in the power distribution network transformation process is proposed. The number and location of 5G base stations are optimized and solved through the adaptive particle swarm algorithm, and combined with the K-means clustering algorithm, the cost of 5G transformation of the power distribution network is calculated and Revenue, establish economic evaluation indicators, including reliability, technical and economic indicators, and use the efficiency and cost ratio for evaluation.

Benefits of technology

It has realized the optimization solution for wireless communication transformation of the distribution network, reduced costs, improved automation level and fault positioning accuracy, met the needs of intelligent electricity use and personalized customer service, and improved user power use satisfaction.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN114091926B_ABST
    Figure CN114091926B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

A method for evaluating the economic feasibility of 5G in the process of distribution network transformation is established. The calculation index for solving the number of 5G base stations installed in the distribution network is established. Then the first objective function is constructed and the objective function is optimized and solved by an adaptive particle swarm algorithm to obtain the minimum number of 5G base stations to be installed. n , and then n Set as the K value of the K-means clustering algorithm, and cluster by the K-means clustering algorithm. n The cluster centers are set as the base station installation locations; further, according to the number of cluster centers, the 5G distribution network transformation cost calculation index is established, and the second objective function is established to obtain the construction cost and benefit; finally, the calculation index of the economic evaluation of the 5G distribution network transformation is established, and the third objective function is constructed according to the calculation index, and the fitness value of the third objective function is calculated through the adaptive particle swarm optimization algorithm; the economic evaluation of 5G in the distribution network transformation process is realized through the fitness value of the third objective function.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to a method for evaluating the economic efficiency of 5G in a distribution network transformation process, and belongs to the technical field of power system distribution network construction. Background Art

[0002] Limited by existing communication technology, the distribution network in some regions has the following problems: 1) The distribution network has not realized practical remote control of switches based on wireless technology. Due to the security risks of wireless technologies such as 3G and 4G in physics, connection, data and system, the distribution network has not realized practical remote control of switches based on wireless technology, which limits the automation level of the distribution network: on the one hand, the line maintenance and power outage must be operated by maintenance personnel on site, which is labor-intensive and has certain safety hazards; on the other hand, local protection must be used to isolate the fault, which makes it difficult to complete self-healing control after the fault. 2) The frequency of power consumption information data collection is low and the application level is not high. Power consumption information is collected through the concentrator at a frequency of 15 minutes / time, and the collection time interval is too long. There are problems such as loss of power outage events, inaccurate load change monitoring, and low information value, which cannot meet the needs of smart power consumption and personalized customer service. 3) The accuracy of fault location of distribution network lines is not high. At present, the distribution network uses hierarchical protection configuration technology combined with existing DTU, FTU, fault indicator and other equipment to achieve section location between switches with short-circuit faults, but the fault location accuracy is still at the kilometer level. If the automation equipment is densely installed, the price is relatively expensive and the economic efficiency is poor. In addition, the amount of real-time communication data is large, which cannot be borne by existing wireless communication, and the cost of using optical fiber communication is too high. Fault detection still mainly relies on manual inspection, which consumes a lot of manpower and material resources, and has become one of the main reasons affecting user satisfaction with electricity.

[0003] The fifth generation of mobile communication technology (5G) is much higher than the existing 4G mobile communication technology in terms of transmission rate, delay and bandwidth. 5G mobile communication technology has the characteristics of high speed, high capacity, high reliability, low delay and low power consumption, as well as its unique network slicing function. It can customize the corresponding communication slice business according to the user's different communication requirements such as delay and bandwidth to meet the user's communication needs. These characteristics can meet the relevant business needs under the rapid development of the distribution network in the future. However, since the application of 5G technology in the distribution network is still in a pilot application state, the economic feasibility of 5G technology being widely used in the distribution network is still unclear. As it is an emerging technology, the long-term economic feasibility of the application of 5G technology in the power system still needs further research.

[0004] The evaluation of distribution communication networks at home and abroad is mainly reliability evaluation, and economy is only a part of its reliability indicators. Moreover, most articles on economic evaluation of distribution communication networks ignore the long-term economic research of distribution communication networks and only consider the initial construction costs. Therefore, there are problems such as incomplete consideration. Summary of the invention

[0005] The technical problem to be solved by the present invention is to propose an economic evaluation method for 5G in the process of distribution network transformation in order to solve the economic problem of 5G technology in the process of distribution network transformation.

[0006] The technical solution implemented by the present invention is as follows: a method for evaluating the economic efficiency of 5G in the process of distribution network transformation, and the specific evaluation method includes the following steps:

[0007] Step 1: Find the optimal number of 5G base stations to be installed in the distribution network: Set the coverage radius of a single 5G base station to r 5g m, establish the first objective function for solving the number of 5G base stations to be installed, and according to the first objective function and constraints of the number of 5G base stations to be installed, use the adaptive particle swarm algorithm (APSO) to optimize and solve, and obtain the optimal number of base stations n.

[0008] To solve the objective function 1 of the number of 5G base station installations, three indicators need to be considered, namely: 5G installation coverage; 5G capacity indicators, where 5G capacity indicators include bandwidth redundancy and terminal access redundancy; initial construction cost. The corresponding calculation formulas are:

[0009] The calculation formula for 5G installation coverage is as follows:

[0010] S 5g =πr 5g 2 ×n 5g -(a×n 5g +b)

[0011] Where S 5g Indicates the coverage of all 5G base stations; r 5g Indicates the coverage radius of a single 5G base station; n 5g is the value range of the number of installed 5G base stations; the number of installed 5G base stations and the signal coverage overlap area generated during the installation of 5G base stations are fitted; the fitted relationship is a×n 5g +b.

[0012] In the fitted relationship, a and b are the coefficients of the univariate linear equation fitting the number of base stations and the coverage overlap area, a is the proportional coefficient of the coverage overlap area of ​​the fitting equation and the value range n5g of the number of installed 5G base stations, and b is the adjustment coefficient of the coverage overlap area of ​​the fitting equation. Both a and b are constants.

[0013] 5G capacity indicators:

[0014] The bandwidth redundancy calculation formula is as follows:

[0015]

[0016] where η b represents bandwidth redundancy; b user Indicates the amount of data for power business; B 5G Represents the bandwidth of the 5G communication method.

[0017] The terminal access redundancy calculation formula is as follows:

[0018]

[0019] η device Indicates terminal access redundancy; n device Indicates the number of terminals actually connected to the distribution network; N 5G Represents the maximum number of terminals that can access the network simultaneously that 5G communications can allow.

[0020] The initial construction cost is calculated as follows:

[0021] C Struction =c 5g ×n 5g +c state ×n state +c tower ×n tower

[0022] C Struction Represents the initial cost of base station construction; n state Represents the number of computer rooms; c state Represents the construction cost of the computer room; c tower Represents the cost of the communication tower used to mount the 5G active antenna processing unit AAU equipment; n tower Represents the number of towers that need to be built; c 5g Represents the cost of 5G communication equipment; n 5g Represents the required number of 5G devices.

[0023] Solve the first objective function f of the number of 5G base station installations 5G The calculation formula of _num is as follows:

[0024] f 5G_num =ω1S 5g +ω2(η b + / η device ))+ω3c cost

[0025] Among them, ω1 is the weight corresponding to the 5G installation coverage indicator; ω2 is the weight corresponding to the 5G capacity indicator; ω3 is the weight corresponding to the 5G initial construction indicator.

[0026] The constraints for solving the first objective function of the number of 5G base station installations are as follows:

[0027] S 5g ≥S DN

[0028] η b <0.9

[0029] η device <1

[0030] Where S DN Represents the area of ​​the distribution network. After obtaining the first objective function for solving the optimal number of 5G base stations, the adaptive particle swarm algorithm is used to optimize and solve the optimal number n of 5G base stations.

[0031] Step 2. Determine the installation location of the 5G base station site in the distribution network: cluster all nodes of the distribution network using the K-means clustering algorithm, where the K value in the K-means clustering algorithm is the optimal number of base station installations n obtained in step 1. Use the rectangular coordinate system to determine the coordinates of each node in the distribution network, and use the coordinates of each node as the input data of the K-means clustering algorithm. After clustering by the K-means clustering algorithm, set the node coordinates corresponding to the n cluster centers as the installation location of the 5G base station in the distribution network.

[0032] Step 3. Calculate the cost of 5G transformation of the distribution network: The cost of 5G in the distribution network transformation consists of three parts: initial construction cost, later operation and maintenance cost, and the benefits after 5G transformation.

[0033] Among them, the later operation and maintenance costs include: communication slice rental costs, inspection equipment maintenance costs, and the second objective function constructed based on the initial construction cost, later operation and maintenance costs, and the benefits after 5G transformation. The adaptive particle swarm algorithm is used to optimize the second objective function and obtain the cost C of distribution network transformation. cost .

[0034] The calculation formula for the initial construction cost is as follows:

[0035] C Struction =c 5g ×n 5g +c state ×n state +c tower ×n tower

[0036] The calculation formula for communication slice leasing cost is as follows:

[0037] c rent =(c embb +c mmtc +c urllc )×t rent

[0038] Among them, c rent represents the communication slice leasing cost; c embb To enhance the rental cost of mobile bandwidth slices; c mmtc The rental cost of massive machine-type communication slices; c urllc The rental cost of ultra-high reliability and ultra-low latency communication slices; rent The length of the lease.

[0039] The maintenance cost of inspection equipment is calculated as follows:

[0040] c inspection =C Struction ×λ

[0041] Among them, c inspection Inspection and maintenance costs; C Struction is the initial construction cost; λ is the proportional coefficient between maintenance cost and initial construction cost.

[0042] Therefore, the calculation formula for the later operation and maintenance cost is as follows:

[0043] c maintain =c rent +c inspection

[0044] The revenue after 5G transformation consists of the rental fee of shared poles and towers. rent The benefits obtained by the base station battery group participating in demand response E Battery The rental fee of shared towers is E rent The calculation formula is as follows:

[0045] E rent =e share ×n share ×t share

[0046] E rent The rental fee for shared towers; share The cost of renting a single tower; n share is the number of towers that can be rented out; t share The length of the rental period.

[0047] The profit E obtained by the base station battery group participating in demand response Battery The calculation formula is as follows:

[0048] E Battery =n Battery ×n response ×e response

[0049] E Battery The revenue gained from the base station battery group participating in demand response;Battery is the number of battery groups that can participate in demand response; n response is the number of times the battery group can participate in demand response; e response The profit obtained by a single battery group participating in a demand response operation.

[0050] The profit calculation formula after 5G transformation is as follows:

[0051] E income =E rent +E Battery

[0052] Therefore, the cost of 5G transformation of the distribution network is calculated as follows:

[0053] C cost =(C Struction +c maintain )-E income

[0054] Therefore, the cost of 5G transformation of distribution network is C cost as the second objective function.

[0055] Step 4 establishes an economic evaluation method for 5G in the distribution network transformation process: the economic evaluation method consists of reliability indicators, technical indicators and economic indicators; among them, reliability indicators include data loss rate indicators and signal-to-noise ratio indicators; technical indicators include power business bandwidth satisfaction rate indicators, power business delay satisfaction rate indicators, terminal access redundancy rate indicators and bandwidth redundancy rate indicators. The economic efficiency is expressed by the indicator benefit-cost ratio, and the third objective function is constructed using reliability indicators, technical indicators and economic indicators. Finally, the adaptive particle swarm algorithm is used for optimization. If the constraints of the adaptive particle swarm algorithm are not met, return to step 1, otherwise the final fitness value of the third objective function is obtained. The larger the fitness value, the better the economic evaluation of the distribution network 5G transformation and the more advantageous the 5G transformation.

[0056] The data loss rate indicator is calculated as follows:

[0057]

[0058] Among them, D loss is the data loss rate; d loss is the amount of data lost during data transmission; N data It is the total amount of data transmitted via 5G communication.

[0059] The signal-to-noise ratio is calculated as follows:

[0060]

[0061] Among them, ηp is the signal-to-noise ratio; P noise is the power of the noise during transmission; P DATA The power for transmitting data.

[0062] Thus, the reliability index is obtained, and the calculation formula is as follows:

[0063] η reliable =η p +D loss

[0064] The calculation formula for the power business bandwidth satisfaction rate indicator is as follows:

[0065]

[0066] Among them, η wide is the bandwidth satisfaction rate of power business; n widemeet N is the number of terminals that can meet the bandwidth service requirements of 5G communication mode; device The number of terminal devices connected to the power distribution communication network.

[0067] Electricity business delay satisfaction rate indicators:

[0068]

[0069] Among them, η relay is the delay satisfaction rate of power business; n relay N is the number of terminals that can meet the latency service requirements of the 5G communication mode; device The number of terminal devices connected to the power distribution communication network.

[0070] The terminal access redundancy rate indicator is calculated as follows:

[0071]

[0072] Among them, η device Indicates terminal access redundancy; n device Indicates the number of terminals actually connected to the distribution network; N 5G Represents the maximum number of terminals that can access the network simultaneously that 5G communications can allow.

[0073] The bandwidth redundancy rate index is calculated as follows:

[0074]

[0075] Among them, η b represents bandwidth redundancy; b user Indicates the amount of data for power business; B 5G Represents the bandwidth of the 5G communication method.

[0076] Thus, the technical indicators are obtained, and the calculation formula is as follows:

[0077] η technology =η wide +η relay +η device +η b

[0078] The benefit-cost ratio is used as the economic indicator, and the calculation formula is as follows:

[0079]

[0080] Among them, E earning The benefits brought by 5G transformation of distribution network within a certain period of time; C cost Represents the initial investment cost of 5G transformation.

[0081] Therefore, the third objective function is established, and the calculation formula is as follows:

[0082] f=η technology +η cost -η reliable

[0083] The constraints of the adaptive particle swarm algorithm used for the third objective function are:

[0084] η b <0.9;

[0085] η device <1;

[0086] η relay >0.9;

[0087] η wide >0.9;

[0088] D loss <0.001.

[0089] The working principle of the invention includes the particle swarm optimization algorithm principle and the K-means clustering basic principle.

[0090] Particle swarm optimization algorithm principle:

[0091] Particle swarm optimization (PSO) is an intelligent algorithm first proposed by Kennedy and Eberhart in 1995. The PSO algorithm originated from the study of bird hunting behavior. When birds hunt, the simplest and most effective strategy to find things is to search the area around the bird that is currently closest to the food.

[0092] The PSO algorithm first initializes a group of particles in the feasible solution space. Each particle represents a potential optimal solution to the extreme value optimization problem. The particle characteristics are represented by three indicators: position, speed, and fitness value. The fitness value is obtained by the fitness function, and its value indicates the quality of the particle. The particles move in the solution space and update their individual positions by tracking the individual extreme value Pbest and the group extreme value Gbest. The individual extreme value Pbest refers to the optimal position of the fitness value searched by the individual particle, and the group extreme value Gbest refers to the optimal position of the fitness value searched by all particles in the population. Each time a particle updates its position, the fitness value is calculated once, and the positions of the individual extreme value Pbest and the group extreme value Gbest are updated by comparing the fitness value of the new particle with the fitness values ​​of the individual extreme value and the group extreme value.

[0093] Assume that in a D-dimensional search space, a population X consisting of n particles is X = (X1, X2...X n ), where the i-th particle is represented by a D-dimensional vector X i =(x i1 ,x i2 ...x in ) T , represents the position of the i-th particle in the D-dimensional search space, and also represents a potential solution to the problem. According to the objective function, the position X of each particle can be calculated. i The corresponding fitness value, the speed of the Ith particle is V i =(V i1 ,V i2 ...V in ) T , whose individual extreme value is P i =(P i1 ,P i2 ...P in ) T , the population extreme value is:

[0094] P g =(P g1 ,P g2 ...P gn ) T

[0095] In each iteration, particles update their own speed and position through individual extrema and group extrema, namely:

[0096]

[0097] Where ω is the inertia weight; d = 1, 2, ..., D; k is the current iteration number; V idis the particle's velocity, c1 and c2 are non-negative constants, called acceleration factors; r1 and r2 are random numbers in the interval [0,1]. To prevent blind searching of particles, it is generally recommended to limit their position and velocity to a certain interval:

[0098] [-X max , X max ]

[0099] [-V max ,V max ]

[0100] The optimization calculation process is as follows: Figure 2 shown.

[0101] The basic principle of K-means clustering:

[0102] In cluster analysis, K-means clustering algorithm is a basic method in unsupervised classification, also known as C-means algorithm. Its basic idea is to update the value of each cluster center through iteration until the best clustering result is obtained. The basis of K-means algorithm is the minimum error square sum criterion. Its cost function is:

[0103]

[0104] In the formula, μ c (i) represents the centroid of the ith cluster. The purpose is to minimize the cost function of the clustering model. Intuitively, the more similar the samples in each cluster are, the smaller the square of the error between them and the centroid of the cluster. By calculating the sum of the squared errors of all clusters, we can verify whether the clustering is optimal when divided into K clusters. The smaller the regression sum of squares, the closer the data points are to their centroids, and the better the clustering effect. Because the errors are squared, more emphasis is placed on points far from the center. One way to definitely reduce the regression sum of squares is to increase the number of clusters, but this goes against the goal of clustering, which is to improve the quality of clusters while keeping the number of families unchanged.

[0105] The K-means clustering algorithm is called K-means because it can find K different clusters, and the center of each cluster is calculated by the mean of the sample features of the sub-dataset contained in the cluster. K-means is an algorithm that finds K clusters of a given data set. The number of clusters K is given by the user, and each cluster is described by its centroid, that is, the center of all the points in the cluster. The K-means clustering algorithm requires numerical data for similarity measurement, and can also map nominal data to binary data for similarity measurement. Its advantage is that it is easy to implement, but its disadvantage is that it may converge to a local minimum and converge slowly on large-scale data sets.

[0106] Algorithm process:

[0107] Suppose we want to divide the sample set into K categories, the algorithm is as follows:

[0108] (1) Appropriately select the initial centers of K clusters;

[0109] (2) In the nth iteration, for any sample, find its distance to the K centers and assign the sample to the class where the center with the shortest distance is located.

[0110] (3) Update the center value of the class using methods such as mean;

[0111] (4) For all K cluster centers, if the value remains unchanged (the objective function converges) after being updated using the iterative method of (2) (3), the iteration ends; otherwise, the iteration continues.

[0112] The present invention provides a method for evaluating the economic efficiency of 5G in the process of power distribution network transformation:

[0113] The first step is to establish calculation indicators for optimizing the number of 5G in distribution network transformation, and use the calculation indicators to construct the objective function, determine the constraints of the objective function, and use the adaptive particle swarm optimization algorithm to optimize the objective function for determining the number of 5G base stations to obtain the optimal number of 5G base stations to be installed.

[0114] In the second step, the K-means clustering algorithm is used to determine the installation location of the 5G base station on the distribution network. The number of installed 5G base stations obtained in the first step is used as the K value in the K-means algorithm for clustering solution, and the cluster centers after clustering are used as the installation locations of the 5G base stations.

[0115] The third step is to establish calculation indicators for solving the 5G distribution network transformation cost and construct the corresponding cost objective function. The number of base station installations solved in the first step is used as a variable in the transformation cost objective function and is substituted into the objective function for solution to obtain the final 5G transformation cost.

[0116] The fourth step is to construct calculation indicators for evaluating the economic feasibility of 5G in distribution network transformation. The calculation indicators include reliability indicators, technical indicators and economic indicators, and establish the final 5G distribution network transformation economic evaluation objective function. The particle swarm algorithm is used to solve the optimal value and obtain the final fitness value. An evaluation is made based on the final fitness value to determine the feasibility of 5G in distribution network transformation.

[0117] The beneficial effect of the present invention is that the present invention provides an optimization calculation method for economic evaluation of wireless communication transformation of distribution network. The present invention automatically calculates the corresponding number of wireless communication base stations and the installation locations of the base stations based on the distribution network parameters, and determines the cost of wireless communication transformation of the distribution network. According to the calculated number of base stations, costs and benefits, an economic evaluation is made for the wireless communication transformation of the distribution network. The calculation process takes into account relatively comprehensive factors, ensures the lowest cost under the conditions of wireless communication coverage, realizes the optimal solution for wireless communication transformation of the distribution network, and provides a decision-making basis for the communication transformation of the distribution network of the power supply department. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0118] Figure 1 This is a flow chart for evaluating the method of the present invention;

[0119] Figure 2 Implement a flow chart for the particle swarm algorithm;

[0120] Figure 3 It is the distribution diagram of distribution network nodes;

[0121] Figure 4 This is the base station distribution map. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0122] like Figure 1 As shown, this embodiment provides an economic evaluation method for 5G in the process of distribution network transformation, and the specific evaluation method includes the following steps:

[0123] Step 1: Find the optimal number of 5G base stations to be installed in the distribution network: Set the coverage radius of a single 5G base station to r 5g m, establish the first objective function for solving the number of 5G base stations to be installed, and according to the first objective function and constraints of the number of 5G base stations to be installed, use the adaptive particle swarm algorithm (APSO) to optimize and solve, and obtain the optimal number of base stations n.

[0124] To solve the first objective function of the number of 5G base station installations, three indicators need to be considered: 5G installation coverage; 5G capacity indicators, including bandwidth redundancy and terminal access redundancy; and initial construction costs. The corresponding calculation formulas are:

[0125] The calculation formula for 5G installation coverage is as follows:

[0126] S 5g =πr 5g 2 ×n 5g -(a×n 5g +b)

[0127] Where S 5g Indicates the coverage of all 5G base stations; r 5gIndicates the coverage radius of a single 5G base station; n 5g is the value range of the number of installed 5G base stations. The number of installed 5G base stations and the signal coverage overlap area generated during the installation of 5G base stations are fitted. The fitted relationship is a×n 5g +b.

[0128] 5G capacity indicators:

[0129] The bandwidth redundancy calculation formula is as follows:

[0130]

[0131] where η b represents bandwidth redundancy; b user Indicates the amount of data for power business; B 5G Represents the bandwidth of the 5G communication method.

[0132] The terminal access redundancy calculation formula is as follows:

[0133]

[0134] η device Indicates terminal access redundancy; n device Indicates the number of terminals actually connected to the distribution network; N 5G Represents the maximum number of terminals that can access the network simultaneously that 5G communications can allow.

[0135] The initial construction cost is calculated as follows:

[0136] C Struction =c 5g ×n 5g +c state ×n state +c tower ×n tower

[0137] C Struction Represents the initial cost of base station construction; n state Represents the number of computer rooms; c state Represents the construction cost of the computer room; c tower Represents the cost of the communication tower used to mount the 5G active antenna processing unit AAU equipment; n tower Represents the number of towers that need to be built; c 5g Represents the cost of 5G communication equipment; n 5g Represents the required number of 5G devices.

[0138] The first objective function formula for solving the number of 5G base station installations is as follows:

[0139] f=ω1S 5g +ω2(ηb +η device )+ω3c cost

[0140] Among them, ω1 is the weight corresponding to the 5G installation coverage indicator; ω2 is the weight corresponding to the 5G capacity indicator; ω3 is the weight corresponding to the 5G initial construction indicator.

[0141] The constraints for solving the first objective function of the number of 5G base station installations are as follows:

[0142] S 5g ≥S DN

[0143] η b <0.9

[0144] η device <1

[0145] Where S DN Represents the area of ​​the distribution network. After obtaining the first objective function for solving the optimal number of 5G base stations, the adaptive particle swarm algorithm is used to optimize and solve the optimal number n of 5G base stations.

[0146] Step 2. Determine the installation location of the 5G base station site in the distribution network: cluster all nodes of the distribution network using the K-means clustering algorithm, where the K value in the K-means clustering algorithm is the optimal number of base station installations n obtained in step 1. Use the rectangular coordinate system to determine the coordinates of each node in the distribution network, and use the coordinates of each node as the input data of the K-means clustering algorithm. After clustering by the K-means clustering algorithm, set the node coordinates corresponding to the n cluster centers as the installation location of the 5G base station in the distribution network.

[0147] Step 3: Calculate the cost of 5G transformation of distribution network: The cost of 5G in distribution network transformation consists of three parts: initial construction cost, later operation and maintenance cost, and the income after 5G transformation. The later operation and maintenance cost includes: communication slice rental cost, inspection equipment maintenance fee. The second objective function is constructed based on the initial construction cost, later operation and maintenance cost, and the income after 5G transformation. The adaptive particle swarm algorithm is used to optimize the second objective function and obtain the cost C of distribution network transformation. cost .

[0148] The calculation formula for the initial construction cost is as follows:

[0149] C Struction =c 5g ×n 5g +c state ×n state +c tower ×n tower

[0150] The calculation formula for communication slice leasing cost is as follows:

[0151] c rent =(c embb +c mmtc +c urllc )×t rent

[0152] Among them, c rent represents the communication slice leasing cost; c embb To enhance the rental cost of mobile bandwidth slices; c mmtc The rental cost of massive machine-type communication slices; c urllc The rental cost of ultra-high reliability and ultra-low latency communication slices; rent The length of the lease.

[0153] The maintenance cost of inspection equipment is calculated as follows:

[0154] c inspection =C Struction ×λ

[0155] Among them, c inspection Inspection and maintenance costs; C Struction is the initial construction cost; λ is the proportional coefficient between maintenance cost and initial construction cost.

[0156] Therefore, the calculation formula for the later operation and maintenance cost is as follows:

[0157] c maintain =c rent +c inspection

[0158] The revenue after 5G transformation consists of the rental fee of shared poles and towers. rent The benefits obtained by the base station battery group participating in demand response E Battery The rental fee of shared towers is E rent The calculation formula is as follows:

[0159] E rent =e share ×n share ×t share

[0160] E rent The rental fee for shared towers; share The cost of renting a single tower; n share is the number of towers that can be rented out; t share The length of the rental period.

[0161] The profit E obtained by the base station battery group participating in demand response BatteryThe calculation formula is as follows:

[0162] E Battery =n Battery ×n response ×e response

[0163] E Battery The revenue gained from the base station battery group participating in demand response; Battery is the number of battery groups that can participate in demand response; n response is the number of times the battery group can participate in demand response; e response The profit obtained by a single battery group participating in a demand response operation.

[0164] The profit calculation formula after 5G transformation is as follows:

[0165] E income =E rent +E Battery

[0166] Therefore, the cost of 5G transformation of the distribution network is calculated as follows:

[0167] C cost =(C Struction +c maintain )-E income

[0168] Therefore, the cost of 5G transformation of distribution network is C cost as the second objective function.

[0169] Step 4: Establish an economic evaluation method for 5G in the distribution network transformation process: This economic evaluation method consists of reliability indicators, technical indicators and economic indicators; among which, reliability indicators include data loss rate indicators and signal-to-noise ratio indicators; technical indicators include power business bandwidth satisfaction rate indicators, power business delay satisfaction rate indicators, terminal access redundancy rate indicators and bandwidth redundancy rate indicators. The economic efficiency is expressed by the indicator benefit-cost ratio, and the third objective function is constructed using reliability indicators, technical indicators and economic indicators. Finally, the adaptive particle swarm algorithm is used for optimization. If the constraints of the adaptive particle swarm algorithm are not met, return to step 1, otherwise the final fitness value of the third objective function is obtained. The larger the fitness value, the better the economic evaluation of the distribution network 5G transformation and the more advantageous the 5G transformation.

[0170] The data loss rate indicator is calculated as follows:

[0171]

[0172] Among them, D loss is the data loss rate; d lossis the amount of data lost during data transmission; N data It is the total amount of data transmitted via 5G communication.

[0173] The signal-to-noise ratio is calculated as follows:

[0174]

[0175] Among them, η p is the signal-to-noise ratio; P noise is the power of the noise during transmission; P DATA The power for transmitting data.

[0176] Thus, the reliability index is obtained, and the calculation formula is as follows:

[0177] η reliable =η p +D loss

[0178] The calculation formula for the power business bandwidth satisfaction rate index is as follows:

[0179]

[0180] Among them, η wide is the bandwidth satisfaction rate of power business; n widemeet N is the number of terminals that can meet the bandwidth service requirements of 5G communication mode; device The number of terminal devices connected to the power distribution communication network.

[0181] Electricity business delay satisfaction rate indicators:

[0182]

[0183] Among them, η relay is the delay satisfaction rate of power business; n relay N is the number of terminals that can meet the latency service requirements of the 5G communication mode; device The number of terminal devices connected to the power distribution communication network.

[0184] The terminal access redundancy rate indicator is calculated as follows:

[0185]

[0186] Among them, η device Indicates terminal access redundancy; n device Indicates the number of terminals actually connected to the distribution network; N 5G Represents the maximum number of terminals that can access the network simultaneously that 5G communications can allow.

[0187] The bandwidth redundancy rate index is calculated as follows:

[0188]

[0189] Among them, η b represents bandwidth redundancy; b user Indicates the amount of data for power business; B 5G Represents the bandwidth of the 5G communication method.

[0190] Thus, the technical indicators are obtained, and the calculation formula is as follows:

[0191] η technology =η wide +η relay +η device +η b

[0192] The benefit-cost ratio is used as the economic indicator, and the calculation formula is as follows:

[0193]

[0194] Among them, E earning The benefits brought by 5G transformation of distribution network within a certain period of time; C cost Represents the initial investment cost of 5G transformation.

[0195] Therefore, the third objective function is established, and the calculation formula is as follows:

[0196] f=η technology +η cost -η reliable

[0197] The constraints of the adaptive particle swarm algorithm used for the third objective function are:

[0198] η b <0.9;

[0199] η device <1;

[0200] η relay >0.9;

[0201] η wide >0.9;

[0202] D loss <0.001.

[0203] Example

[0204] As Figure 3 The distribution network model of is taken as an example to conduct experimental verification:

[0205] Table 1 shows the 5G communication base station parameters set when performing calculations in this embodiment.

[0206] Table 1 5G communication setting parameters for distribution network

[0207]

[0208] The communication equipment costs include the costs of the 5G communication equipment baseband processing unit BBU and the active antenna processing unit AAU. The 5G base station includes a BBU and a set of AAU, and adopts a distributed base station setting method, that is, each set of AAU equipment is installed at the base station installation location, and the BBUs are installed in the computer room. In this embodiment, the installation location of the AAU is used instead of the installation location of the base station. The site rental fee includes the computer room rental fee, computer room construction fee, power supply, monitoring, battery pack fee and the cost of the optical fiber used to connect the BBU and AAU.

[0209] First, according to the coverage radius of a single 5G base station, the range of the number of 5G base stations installed in the distribution network node model used in this example is determined, and the determined range of the number of 5G base stations is used as part of the parameters of the particle swarm algorithm. The first objective function of the number of 5G base stations established in step 1 is optimized. After optimization by the adaptive particle swarm optimization algorithm, the optimal number of base stations that meets the constraints is obtained, as shown in Table 2:

[0210] Table 2 Number of base stations

[0211] Scenario Communication Number of computer rooms AAU quantity (sets) 10kV distribution network 5G 21 93

[0212] It can be seen from Table 2 that the optimal number of 5G base stations after optimization is 93. The number of 5G base stations 93 is used as the K value of the K-means clustering algorithm in step 2. After K-means clustering, the clustered classes and cluster centers are obtained. The cluster centers are set as the installation locations of the 5G base stations. The distribution of the installation locations of the 5G base stations in the distribution network node diagram is shown in the figure. Figure 4 As shown, the 5G base station obtained according to step 1

[0213] After the optimal number of installations is obtained, through step 3, the number is used as a parameter of the second objective function of the 5G transformation cost, and the transformation cost is calculated using the adaptive particle swarm algorithm based on the obtained 5G transformation cost objective function. Since there is a later operation and maintenance cost in the 5G transformation cost objective function, for the later operation and maintenance time, ten years is used as the operation and maintenance time in this example to set relevant parameters and calculate the initial construction investment cost and the benefits obtained within ten years as shown in Table 3:

[0214] Table 3 Renovation cost

[0215] Scenario Investment cost (ten thousand) Revenue (10,000) 10kV distribution network 5629 2102

[0216] After the investment cost and benefit are obtained in step 3, they are used as part of the data for the economic evaluation of 5G in the distribution network transformation in step 4. They are brought into step 4. The economic evaluation index of 5G in the distribution network transformation and the third objective function established in step 4 are used to optimize and calculate the fitness value of the final objective function using the adaptive particle swarm optimization algorithm. The economic situation of 5G in the distribution network transformation is determined according to the numerical value of the third objective function, so as to determine whether to carry out 5G transformation of the distribution network in the end.

[0217] The final fitness value obtained by the adaptive particle swarm optimization algorithm is 4.33, which is a high value, indicating that 5G has good economy in the transformation of distribution networks. At the same time, the reliability and technicality of 5G transformation are taken into consideration. Therefore, it is feasible to carry out 5G transformation for distribution networks.

[0218] In summary, the above are only preferred embodiments of the present invention and are not intended to limit the scope of the present invention. Any modifications, equivalent substitutions, improvements, etc. made within the spirit and principles of the present invention should be included in the protection scope of the present invention.

Claims

1. A method for evaluating the economic efficiency of 5G in the process of distribution network transformation, characterized in that: The method steps are as follows: (1) Solve for the optimal number of 5G base stations to be installed in the distribution network: Set the coverage radius of a single 5G base station to r 5g m, establish the first objective function for solving the number of 5G base stations to be installed, and according to the first objective function and constraint conditions of the number of 5G base stations to be installed, use the APSO adaptive particle swarm algorithm to optimize and solve, and obtain the optimal number of base stations n; The first objective function for solving the number of 5G base station installations needs to consider three indicators: 5G installation coverage; 5G capacity indicators, including bandwidth redundancy and terminal access redundancy; initial construction cost; the corresponding calculation formulas are: The calculation formula for 5G installation coverage is as follows: S 5g =πr 5g 2 ×n 5g -(a×n 5g +b) Where S 5g Indicates the coverage of all 5G base stations; r 5g Indicates the coverage radius of a single 5G base station; n 5g is the value range of the number of installed 5G base stations; a×n 5g +b is the linear fitting function of the number of installed 5G base stations and the signal coverage overlap area generated during the installation of 5G base stations; a is the value range of the fitting equation coverage overlap area and the number of installed 5G base stations n 5g The proportional coefficient is , b is the adjustment coefficient of the overlapping area covered by the fitting equation, and both a and b are constants; 5G capacity indicators: The bandwidth redundancy calculation formula is as follows: where η b represents bandwidth redundancy, b user Indicates the amount of data for power business, B 5G Represents the bandwidth of 5G communication method; The terminal access redundancy calculation formula is as follows: η device Indicates the terminal access redundancy, n device Indicates the number of terminals actually connected to the distribution network, N 5G Represents the maximum number of terminals that can be connected simultaneously in 5G communication; The calculation formula for the initial construction cost of 5G base stations is as follows: C Struction =c 5g ×n 5g +c state ×n state +c tower ×n tower C Struction represents the initial cost of base station construction, n state Represents the number of computer rooms, c state represents the construction cost of the computer room, c tower Represents the cost of the communication tower used to mount the 5G active antenna processing unit AAU equipment, n tower represents the number of towers that need to be built, c 5g Represents the cost of 5G communication equipment, n 5g Represents the required number of 5G devices; Solve the first objective function f of the number of 5G base station installations 5G_num The calculation formula is as follows: f 5G_mum =ω1S 5g +ω2(η b +n device )+ω3c cost Where: f 5G_num is the first objective function of the number of 5G base station installations, ω1 is the weight corresponding to the 5G installation coverage index; ω2 is the weight corresponding to the 5G capacity index; ω3 is the weight corresponding to the 5G initial construction index, c cost The cost of remodeling 5G base stations; The constraints for solving the first objective function of the number of 5G base station installations are as follows: S 5g ≥S DN or b <0.9 or device <1 Where S DN represents the area of ​​the distribution network; after obtaining the first objective function for solving the optimal number of 5G base stations, the adaptive particle swarm algorithm is used to optimize and solve, and the optimal number n of 5G base stations is obtained; (2) Calculate the cost of 5G transformation of distribution networks: The cost of 5G in distribution network transformation consists of three parts: initial construction cost, later operation and maintenance cost, and the benefits after 5G transformation; Among them, the later operation and maintenance costs include: communication slice rental costs, inspection equipment maintenance costs, and the second objective function constructed based on the initial construction cost, later operation and maintenance costs, and the benefits after 5G transformation. The adaptive particle swarm algorithm is used to optimize the second objective function and obtain the transformation cost c of the distribution network 5G base station cost ; The calculation formula for communication slice leasing cost is as follows: c rent =(c embb +c mmtc +c urllc )×t rent Among them, c rent represents the communication slice leasing cost; c embb To enhance the rental cost of mobile bandwidth slices; c mmtc The rental cost of massive machine-type communication slices; c urllc The rental cost of ultra-high reliability and ultra-low latency communication slices; rent is the length of the lease; The maintenance cost of inspection equipment is calculated as follows: c inspection =C Struction ×λ Among them, c inspection Inspection and maintenance costs; C Struction is the initial construction cost; λ is the proportional coefficient between maintenance cost and initial construction cost; Therefore, the calculation formula for the later operation and maintenance cost is as follows: c maintain =c rent +c inspection In the formula, c maintain is the later operation and maintenance cost of 5G base stations, c rent represents the communication slice leasing cost, c inspection Inspection and maintenance costs; The revenue after 5G transformation consists of the rental fee of shared poles and towers. rent The benefits obtained by the base station battery group participating in demand response E Battery The rental fee of shared towers is E rent The calculation formula is as follows: AND rent =and share ×n share ×t share E rent The rental fee for shared towers; share The cost of renting a single tower; n share is the number of towers that can be rented out; t share The duration of the lease; The profit E obtained by the base station battery group participating in demand response Battery The calculation formula is as follows: E Battery =n Battery ×n response ×e response E Battery The revenue gained from the base station battery group participating in demand response; Battery is the number of battery groups that can participate in demand response; n response is the number of times the battery group can participate in demand response; e response The revenue gained from a single battery group participating in a demand response; The profit calculation formula after 5G transformation is as follows: AND income =And rent +E Battery In the formula, E income The profit from the later operation of 5G base stations, E rent is the rental fee of the shared tower, E Battery The revenue gained from base station battery groups participating in demand response; Therefore, the cost of 5G transformation of the distribution network is calculated as follows: C cost =(C Struction +c maintain )-E income Therefore, the cost of 5G transformation of distribution network is C cost As the second objective function; (3) Establish an economic evaluation method for 5G in the distribution network transformation process: This economic evaluation method consists of reliability indicators, technical indicators and economic indicators; Among them, the reliability index includes the data loss rate index and the signal-to-noise ratio index; the technical index includes the power business bandwidth satisfaction rate index, the power business delay satisfaction rate index, the terminal access redundancy rate index and the bandwidth redundancy rate index; the economic efficiency is represented by the benefit-cost ratio of the index, and the third objective function is constructed using the reliability index, the technical index and the economic index. Finally, the adaptive particle swarm algorithm is used for optimization. If the constraint condition of the adaptive particle swarm algorithm is not satisfied, then return to step (1), otherwise the final fitness value of the third objective function is obtained. The larger the fitness value, the better the economic evaluation of the 5G transformation of the distribution network, and the more advantageous the 5G transformation is. The data loss rate indicator is calculated as follows: Among them, D loss is the data loss rate; d loss is the amount of data lost during data transmission; N data is the total amount of data transmitted via 5G communication; The signal-to-noise ratio is calculated as follows: Among them, η p is the signal-to-noise ratio; P noise is the power of the noise during transmission; P DATA The power for transmitting data; Thus, the reliability evaluation index is obtained, and the calculation formula is as follows: or reliable =the p +D loss Where η reliable is the reliability evaluation index, η p is the signal-to-noise ratio, D loss is the data loss rate; The calculation formula for the power business bandwidth satisfaction rate indicator is as follows: Among them, η wide is the bandwidth satisfaction rate of power business; n widemeet N is the number of terminals that can meet the bandwidth service requirements of 5G communication mode; device The number of terminal devices connected to the power distribution communication network; Electricity business delay satisfaction rate indicators: Among them, η relay is the delay satisfaction rate of power business; n relay N is the number of terminals that can meet the latency service requirements of the 5G communication mode; device The number of terminal devices connected to the power distribution communication network; The terminal access redundancy rate indicator is calculated as follows: Among them, η device Indicates terminal access redundancy; n device Indicates the number of terminals actually connected to the distribution network; N 5G Represents the maximum number of terminals that can be connected simultaneously in 5G communication; The bandwidth redundancy rate index is calculated as follows: Among them, η b represents bandwidth redundancy; b user Indicates the amount of data for power business; B 5G Represents the bandwidth of 5G communication method; Thus, the technical indicator η is obtained technology , the calculation formula is as follows: or technology =the wide +n relay +n device +n b The benefit-cost ratio is used as the economic indicator, and the calculation formula is as follows: Among them, η cost is the economic index, E earning The benefits brought by 5G transformation of distribution network within a certain period of time; C cost Represents the initial investment cost of 5G transformation; Thus, the third objective function f is established _ecom , the calculation formula is as follows: f_ ecom =η technology +η cost -η reliable In the formula, f _ecom To evaluate the economic evaluation objective function of 5G application in distribution network, η technology is a technical indicator, η cost is the economic index, η reliable It is a reliability evaluation index; The constraints of the adaptive particle swarm algorithm used for the third objective function are: or b <0.9; or device <1; or relay >0.9; or wide >0.9; D loss <0.001。