A wear assessment method and system for a spray gun used in a coal-fired power plant
By establishing a fly ash flow tracking model and erosion wear model, calculating the total wear amount of the spray gun, the problem of inaccurate wear assessment of spray guns in coal-fired power plants is solved, and more accurate wear assessment and longer service life is achieved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202210751511.1
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2022-06-29
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-05
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-06-29
Smart Images

Figure CN114970284B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention belongs to the technical field of thermal power generation environmental protection, and in particular relates to a wear assessment method and system for a spray gun used in a coal-fired power plant. Background Art
[0002] At present, the wear research of SNCR urea solution spray gun or SCR urea direct injection pyrolysis spray gun in the denitrification flue of coal-fired power plants adopts the method of actual operation data statistics, that is, the spray gun is placed in the flue, and after a period of actual operation, it is taken out to observe the wear parts and wear size of the spray gun, and the wear-prone positions are evaluated by statistics. This method requires months or years of research for each power plant, and with the changes in coal quality, load, air volume and other factors, the results obtained cannot fully match the actual wear rate. At this stage, due to factors such as wear model and gas-solid two-phase flow calculation method, no mature spray gun wear evaluation method has been proposed. Summary of the invention
[0003] In order to solve the problems existing in the prior art, the purpose of the present invention is to provide a wear assessment method and system for a coal-fired power plant spray gun. The present invention is applicable to the wear model of coal-fired power plant spray guns (SNCR urea solution spray guns or SCR urea direct injection pyrolysis spray guns), and improves the gas-solid two-phase flow calculation method, so that the calculation results are consistent with the actual situation.
[0004] The technical solution adopted by the present invention is as follows:
[0005] A method for evaluating the wear of a spray gun used in a coal-fired power plant includes the following steps:
[0006] Calculate fly ash particle information: The fly ash particle information is obtained by numerically calculating the pre-established fly ash flow tracking model of the coal-fired unit and the spray gun surface rebound angle model;
[0007] Establishing erosion wear model: Based on fly ash particle information, establishing erosion wear model for impact angle, velocity and particle shape of fly ash particles in motion;
[0008] Calculate the wear amount of a single fly ash particle: determine the time when a single fly ash particle collides with the spray gun, and use the erosion wear model to calculate the wear amount of the spray gun under the condition of single fly ash wear according to the information of the single fly ash particle at this time; then use the rebound coefficient equation to calculate the velocity direction and position of the single fly ash particle in the next time step until the fly ash particle leaves the area that may participate in the collision;
[0009] Calculate the total wear: Based on the wear of the spray gun under all fly ash particle wear conditions, sum the wear after collision at the same position on the spray gun to obtain the total wear of all positions on the spray gun.
[0010] Preferably, the fly ash flow tracking model of the coal-fired unit is as follows:
[0011]
[0012] Where: m p is the mass of fly ash particles; x p is the position of fly ash particles; ρ p F is the fly ash particle density; sl is the Saffman shear force; F D is the drag force; t is the time, g is the acceleration of gravity, and ρ is the density of the target material for erosion wear.
[0013] Preferably, the fly ash particle information includes fly ash velocity, fly ash particle size, fly ash incident angle and density.
[0014] Preferably, the erosion wear model is as follows:
[0015]
[0016] Where: E(α) is the wear amount, n1 and n2 are specified coefficients, which can be obtained through experimental experience. The value range of n1 is generally 1.1-2.2, and the value range of n2 is generally 0.15-0.85; H v V is the Vickers hardness of the spray gun material; p V is the relative velocity between fly ash particles and the spray gun surface; ref is the reference velocity of fly ash particles; d p is the particle size of fly ash particles; d ref is the reference particle size of fly ash particles, k2 is the velocity reference coefficient, k3 is the particle size reference coefficient, K1 is the set value, k2, k3 and K1 can be obtained through experimental empirical coefficients, and the value range is between 1.2 and 3.5; ρ w is the fly ash particle density; α is the incident angle of the fly ash particles.
[0017] Preferably, the rebound coefficient equation is as follows:
[0018] τ N =0.95-0.0127α+8.25×10 -4 α 2 -2.21×10 -6 α 3
[0019] τ T =0.88-0.021α+5.32×10 -4 α 2 -1.16×10 -6 α 3
[0020] Where: τ N , τ T are the normal rebound coefficient and the tangential rebound coefficient respectively; α is the incident angle of the fly ash particles.
[0021] Preferably, the wear time t is calculated using the wear amount:
[0022]
[0023] Where: t is the wear time; ρ is the density of the target material for erosion wear; S is the surface area of the target material wear area; d is the target material thickness; e r is the wear rate of the target material, which is calculated by the wear amount of the target material per unit time.
[0024] Preferably, the spray gun is a SNCR urea solution spray gun or a SCR urea direct injection pyrolysis spray gun of a coal-fired power plant.
[0025] The present invention also provides a wear assessment system for a spray gun used in a coal-fired power plant, comprising:
[0026] Fly ash particle information calculation module: used to obtain fly ash particle information by numerically calculating the pre-established fly ash flow tracking model and the spray gun surface rebound angle model of the coal-fired unit;
[0027] Erosion wear model building module: used to build an erosion wear model for the impact angle, velocity and particle shape of fly ash particles in motion according to fly ash particle information;
[0028] Single fly ash particle wear calculation module: used to determine the time when a single fly ash particle collides with the spray gun, and calculate the wear amount of the spray gun under the condition of single fly ash wear using the erosion wear model according to the single fly ash particle information at this time; and then use the rebound coefficient equation to calculate the velocity direction and position of the single fly ash particle in the next time step until the fly ash particle leaves the area that may participate in the collision;
[0029] Total wear calculation module: used to sum the wear after collision at the same position on the spray gun according to the wear of the spray gun under all fly ash particle wear conditions, and obtain the total wear of all positions on the spray gun.
[0030] Preferably, the wear assessment system for the spray gun for a coal-fired power plant of the present invention further comprises a life calculation module: for calculating the wear time t:
[0031]
[0032] Where: t is the wear time; ρ is the density of the target material for erosion wear; S is the surface area of the target material wear area; d is the target material thickness; e ris the wear rate of the target material, which is calculated by the wear amount of the target material per unit time.
[0033] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following beneficial effects:
[0034] The wear assessment method for the spray gun used in a coal-fired power plant of the present invention is based on the actual operation data of the coal-fired unit, and the impact angle, velocity and particle shape of the fly ash particles colliding with the spray gun when moving in the flue to establish an erosion wear model. The existing erosion wear models are all based on the description of the cold state or a single material, and the actual erosion wear of the spray gun cannot be calculated for the time being. In the present invention, the wear model is corrected by the impact angle, velocity and particle shape. The corrected model is more in line with the erosion wear model of the spray gun in the coal-fired unit, so that the spray gun wear can be studied to achieve a reasonable layout and a longer service life. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0035] Figure 1 This is a wear rate distribution diagram of a urea direct injection gun actually in operation in an embodiment of the present invention;
[0036] FIG. 2( a ) is a layout diagram of a urea direct injection spray gun in actual operation in an embodiment of the present invention; FIG. 2( b ) is a distribution diagram of wear rates of a urea direct injection spray gun in actual operation in an embodiment of the present invention;
[0037] Figure 3 This is a schematic diagram of an actual SCR urea direct injection flue model in an embodiment of the present invention;
[0038] Figure 4 is a fly ash particle size distribution diagram to be simulated in an embodiment of the present invention;
[0039] Figure 5 In the embodiment of the present invention, d and Y d Curve relationship diagram. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0040] The present invention is further described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings and embodiments:
[0041] The present invention proposes a method for evaluating the wear of an SNCR urea solution spray gun or an SCR urea direct injection pyrolysis spray gun caused by the flow of ash-containing flue gas in a denitrification flue of a coal-fired power plant. The method specifically comprises the following steps:
[0042] 1) Establish a tracking model for the fly ash flow of the coal-fired unit and determine the spray gun surface rebound angle model. By numerically calculating the tracking model and the spray gun surface rebound angle model, the fly ash particle information is obtained. The fly ash particle information includes the running trajectory and parameter information of the fly ash particles, and further includes the fly ash velocity, fly ash particle size, fly ash incident angle and density;
[0043] 2) According to the running trajectory and parameter information of fly ash particles, an erosion wear model is established for the impact angle, velocity and particle shape of fly ash particles in motion;
[0044] 3) Determine the time when a single fly ash particle collides with the spray gun, and use the erosion wear model to calculate the wear amount of the spray gun under the condition of single fly ash wear according to the information of the single fly ash particle at this time, and estimate the remaining spray gun life; then use the rebound coefficient equation to calculate the velocity direction and position of the single fly ash particle in the next time step until the fly ash particle leaves the area that may participate in the collision;
[0045] 4) Repeat step 3) for each fly ash particle to obtain the wear amount of each fly ash particle after collision, sum the wear amounts after collision at the same position on the spray gun, and obtain the total wear amount of all positions on the spray gun, thereby realizing the wear assessment of the spray gun used in coal-fired power plants.
[0046] In the above scheme of the present invention, the flue gas and fly ash particle information are described by using the Euler and Lagrangian models, wherein the tracking of the fly ash particle flow is described by the following model (i.e., the fly ash flow tracking model):
[0047]
[0048] Where: m p is the particle mass; x p is the particle position; ρ p is the particle density; F sl is the Saffman shear force; F D For drag force.
[0049] In the above solution of the present invention, the erosion wear model is calculated by the following formula:
[0050]
[0051] Where: E(α) is the wear amount, n1 and n2 are specified coefficients, which can be obtained through experimental experience. The value range of n1 is generally 1.1-2.2, and the value range of n2 is generally 0.15-0.85; H v V is the Vickers hardness of the spray gun material; p V is the relative velocity between fly ash particles and the spray gun surface; ref is the reference velocity of fly ash particles; d p is the particle size of fly ash particles; d ref is the reference particle size of fly ash particles, k2 is the velocity reference coefficient, k3 is the particle size reference coefficient, K1 is the set value, k2, k3 and K1 can be obtained through experimental empirical coefficients, and the value range is between 1.2 and 3.5; ρ w is the fly ash particle density; α is the incident angle of the fly ash particles.
[0052] The coefficients in the expression of the erosion wear model need to be determined by data analysis based on the wear data of the actual operation of the power plant. The specific analysis process is: record the wear position and wear size on the spray gun that has been in operation for 6 months or more, substitute the wear amount at each position into the wear model, obtain multiple sets of coefficient values, and substitute their average values as representative values into the wear model for numerical simulation calculations. Taking the SNCR spray gun of a 600MW coal-fired unit as an example, the wear model parameters of the erosion wear model of the spray gun are as follows:
[0053]
[0054] In the above solution of the present invention, the rebound coefficient equation is as follows:
[0055] τ N =0.95-0.0127α+8.25×10 -4 α 2 -2.21×10 -6 α 3
[0056] τ T =0.88-0.021α+5.32×10 -4 α 2 -1.16×10 -6 α 3
[0057] Where: τ N , τ T is the normal rebound coefficient and the tangential rebound coefficient; α is the incident angle of the fly ash particles. The rebound coefficient equation can be obtained by performing a fly ash scouring test on an actual 600MW coal-fired unit and analyzing it through high-speed camera shooting, which is a conventional method.
[0058] The technical solution of the present invention can use numerical calculation software and post-processing software to perform numerical simulation on an SCR denitration system using urea direct injection pyrolysis or an SNCR denitration system. When the actual boiler of the power plant is in operation, the flue where the spray gun operates and the guide plates, mixing devices, catalysts, and grilles inside the upstream and downstream of the spray gun are modeled in 1:1 actual size. And through field tests or operating data, boundary conditions including temperature, composition, ash content, and velocity field that are consistent with the actual operating parameters of the boiler are established to study the flue gas flow field and fly ash distribution upstream and downstream of the spray gun. According to the fly ash distribution, the spray gun wear prediction and evaluation calculation is performed. Through this predictive calculation, the flue structure and the layout of the spray gun can be better designed, so as to extend the service life of the spray gun and reduce the cost of overhauling and replacing the spray gun in the power plant.
[0059] Example
[0060] Specifically, taking an actual power plant as an example, the wear assessment method for a spray gun used in a coal-fired power plant in this embodiment includes the following steps:
[0061] 1) After the ultra-low emission transformation of the denitrification system of an actual power plant, a urea direct injection pyrolysis scheme was adopted. In order to avoid the rapid wear of the direct injection pyrolysis spray gun, it is now necessary to evaluate the safe operation time of its spray gun equipment. The urea direct injection spray gun is arranged in the vertical flue of the SCR denitrification system, with an elevation of 36.5m. A total of 11 spray guns are arranged, divided into two groups and staggered in the depth direction. According to the layout plan, first collect the historical operation and field test data of the power plant SCR denitrification system, and then obtain the boiler tail flue drawings, as well as related boundary conditions and initial conditions, such as Figure 3 As shown, a 1:1 actual size model is performed. Then, industrial analysis and elemental analysis of the actual coal sample entering the furnace need to be performed, and the analysis results are shown in Table 1. At the same time, the physical properties of the fly ash after the combustion of the coal entering the furnace need to be tested and studied, and the analysis results are shown in Table 2.
[0062] Table 1
[0063]
[0064] Table 2
[0065]
[0066] See also Figure 1 , that is, the differential volume particle size distribution diagram of the ash particle size of the power plant from 0.375μm to 2000μm, the average diameter of the particle size distribution is 285μm, the median diameter is 240.9μm, and the peak value is 356.1μm.
[0067] The ash particle size of this power plant is large and has strong abrasive properties.
[0068] The density of fly ash is 1130 kg·m -3 . Use the Rosin-Rammler distribution model to Figure 4 To simulate the fly ash particle size, the model needs to know the particle size d and mass fraction Y d The corresponding relationship is shown in Table 3.
[0069] Table 3
[0070]
[0071]
[0072] The Rosin-Rammler distribution function assumes that the particle size d is related to the mass fraction Y d There is an exponential relationship as follows:
[0073]
[0074] Among them, d m is the mean particle size (Mean Diameter); n is the spread coefficient (Spread Parameter).
[0075] In order to obtain the above particle size d and mass fraction Yd, it is necessary to find the particle size d and mass fraction Y d The relationship between d and Y d The curve relationship is as follows Figure 5 shown.
[0076] Y d =e -1 The particle size d value corresponding to ≈0.368 is the average particle size d m =310μm.
[0077] The average particle size d m Afterwards, according to the formula The following formula can be obtained;
[0078] n=ln(-lnY d ) / ln(d / d m )
[0079] According to the above formula, the propagation coefficient n values obtained are 1.45, 1.19, 1.29, 1.34, 1.50, 1.38, and 1.39, respectively. The average value of these 7 propagation coefficient n values is n=1.36.
[0080] The density of fly ash is used as the simulation condition, that is, the density is 1330 kg·m -3 .
[0081] 3) Through the fly ash scouring test, the fly ash collision angle and fly ash wear model are obtained, and the wear amount is obtained according to the fly ash wear model. Since the shape of fly ash particles is irregular and the surface of each metal wall is not smooth, the collision is uneven, and the actual rebound angle of fly ash particles needs to be described. By using a high-speed camera to study the particle collision, the rebound coefficient equation is obtained, as follows:
[0082] τ N =0.95-0.0127α+8.25×10 -4 α 2 -2.21×10 -6 α 3
[0083] τ T =0.88-0.021α+5.32×10 -4 α 2 -1.16×10-6 α 3
[0084] Where: τ N , τ T are the normal rebound coefficient and the tangential rebound coefficient; α is the incident angle of the fly ash particles.
[0085] The fly ash erosion wear model is as follows:
[0086]
[0087] The relevant parameters applicable to this power plant are obtained through the physical characteristics of ash particles and field test data, and substituted into the erosion wear model as follows:
[0088]
[0089] Where: E(α) is the wear amount; V p is the relative speed between the particles and the spray gun surface; d p is the particle size; α is the particle incident angle.
[0090] In the present invention, a numerical model of the SCR flue spray gun arrangement system is established, and the model is meshed by finite element processing, and boundary conditions for particles entering the SCR flue spray gun arrangement system, namely, fly ash velocity, fly ash particle size, fly ash incident angle and density, are set.
[0091] The calculation process is as follows: ① Read the information in each finite element before the spray gun in the numerical calculation software; ② Analyze and calculate the fly ash particle information of each spray gun area, including the position, velocity, particle size, density and mass flow rate of each fly ash particle; ③ Calculate the position of the fly ash particle in the next time step through the fly ash particle information of the previous time step; ④ Determine whether the position of the fly ash particle contacts and collides with the spray gun; ⑤ If it collides, use Calculate the location and mass of gun wear and use the rebound coefficient equation τ N =0.95-0.0127α+8.25×10 -4 α 2 -2.21×10 -6 α 3 , τ T =0.88-0.021α+5.32×10 -4 α 2 -1.16×10 -6 α 3 Recalculate the velocity and position of the fly ash particle in the next time step until the fly ash particle passes through the height layer where the spray gun is arranged; ⑥ If there is no collision, return to step ③ and continue calculating until the fly ash particle passes through the height layer where the spray gun is arranged; ⑦ Complete the calculation process of steps ③ to ⑥ for each fly ash particle.
[0092] 5) See Figure 1 As shown in Figure 2(b), the predicted wear rate distribution is compared with the actual wear area size after the spray gun has been running for a period of time. It is found that the correspondence is good and the relevant parameters are selected correctly. If it is found that the correspondence is poor, it is necessary to replace the wear model or model parameters and recalculate until the prediction is consistent with the actual situation.
[0093] 6) Evaluate the spray gun wear. If the wear is serious, the tail flue needs to be modified. By changing the layout of the spray gun and adding appropriate guide plates, the wear can be reduced, and the wear rate distribution after the modification can be evaluated again. The spray gun wear of the power plant is mainly concentrated at the root of the spray gun. The wear rate is within a reasonable range and does not require major changes.
[0094] 7) By using the wear time calculation formula, the use time of the spray gun before and after the transformation is calculated to predict the service life of the spray gun, thereby improving or solving the wear problem.
[0095] The calculation formula of wear time is as follows:
[0096]
[0097] Where: t is the wear time, s; ρ is the density of the target material for erosion wear, kg / m 3 ; S is the surface area of the target material wear area, m 2 ; d is the target material thickness, m; e r is the wear rate of the target material, kg / (m 2 ·s).
[0098] According to calculations, the spray gun wear time of this power plant is about 4 years, that is, the spray gun will wear to the point of leaking after 4 years of operation.
[0099] The present invention samples actual fly ash, conducts testing and analysis, models the actual flue structure, uses gas-solid two-phase flow, simulates and studies the entire flow process of fly ash, reflects the actual flow process to the greatest extent, and makes the simulated wear results consistent with the actual situation.
[0100] From the above, it can be seen that the wear assessment method for spray guns used in coal-fired power plants of the present invention can evaluate the wear rate of spray guns with different layouts, and by changing the layout, find the layout with the lowest wear rate, thereby extending the service life of the spray gun and reducing the uneven spraying and the number of equipment maintenance caused by spray gun wear. In addition, the method is easy to use and takes a short time. The results of long-term operation of the spray gun can be studied through numerical calculations, and the spray gun can be arranged from the beginning to avoid large wear of the spray gun. The method conducts an in-depth study of the wear model and confirms the key parameters of the gas-solid two-phase flow calculation in detail to ensure that the results of the numerical simulation are completely consistent with the actual situation, thereby achieving the accuracy of the calculation and providing accurate guidance for actual operation.
Claims
1. A method for evaluating the wear of a spray gun used in a coal-fired power plant, characterized in that: The process includes the following: Calculate fly ash particle information: The fly ash particle information is obtained by numerically calculating the pre-established fly ash flow tracking model of the coal-fired unit and the spray gun surface rebound angle model; Establishing an erosion wear model: Based on the fly ash particle information, an erosion wear model is established for the impact angle, velocity and particle shape of the fly ash particles in motion; the erosion wear model is as follows: Where: is the amount of wear, , is the specified coefficient; is the Vickers hardness of the spray gun material; is the relative velocity between the fly ash particles and the spray gun surface; is the reference velocity of fly ash particles; is the particle size of fly ash particles; is the reference particle size of fly ash particles, is the speed reference coefficient, is the particle size reference coefficient, K1 is the setting value, is the fly ash particle density; is the incident angle of fly ash particles; Calculate the wear amount of a single fly ash particle: determine the time when a single fly ash particle collides with the spray gun, and use the erosion wear model to calculate the wear amount of the spray gun under the condition of single fly ash wear according to the information of the single fly ash particle at this time; then use the rebound coefficient equation to calculate the velocity direction and position of the single fly ash particle in the next time step until the fly ash particle leaves the area that may participate in the collision; Calculate the total wear: Based on the wear of the spray gun under all fly ash particle wear conditions, sum the wear after collision at the same position on the spray gun to obtain the total wear of all positions on the spray gun.
2. The wear assessment method for a spray gun for a coal-fired power plant according to claim 1, characterized in that: The fly ash flow tracking model of the coal-fired unit is as follows: Where: is the mass of fly ash particles; is the fly ash particle position; is the fly ash particle density; is the Saffman shear force; is the drag force; t For time, g is the acceleration due to gravity, The target material density for erosive wear.
3. The wear assessment method for a spray gun for a coal-fired power plant according to claim 1, characterized in that: The fly ash particle information includes fly ash velocity, fly ash particle size, fly ash incident angle and density.
4. The wear assessment method for a spray gun for a coal-fired power plant according to claim 1, characterized in that: The coefficient of rebound equation is as follows: Where: , are the normal rebound coefficient and the tangential rebound coefficient respectively; is the incident angle of fly ash particles.
5. The wear assessment method for a spray gun for a coal-fired power plant according to claim 1, characterized in that: Calculating wear time using wear volume t : Where: t For wear time; The target material density for erosive wear; is the surface area of the target material wear region; is the target material thickness; is the wear rate of the target material, which is calculated by the wear amount of the target material per unit time.
6. The wear assessment method for a spray gun for a coal-fired power plant according to claim 1, characterized in that: The spray gun is a SNCR urea solution spray gun or an SCR urea direct injection pyrolysis spray gun of a coal-fired power plant.
7. A wear assessment system for a spray gun used in a coal-fired power plant, characterized in that: A method for evaluating the wear of a spray gun for a coal-fired power plant according to any one of claims 1 to 6, comprising: Fly ash particle information calculation module: used to obtain fly ash particle information by numerically calculating the pre-established fly ash flow tracking model and the spray gun surface rebound angle model of the coal-fired unit; Erosion wear model building module: used to build an erosion wear model for the impact angle, velocity and particle shape of fly ash particles in motion according to fly ash particle information; Single fly ash particle wear calculation module: used to determine the time when a single fly ash particle collides with the spray gun, and calculate the wear amount of the spray gun under the condition of single fly ash wear using the erosion wear model according to the single fly ash particle information at this time; and then use the rebound coefficient equation to calculate the velocity direction and position of the single fly ash particle in the next time step until the fly ash particle leaves the area that may participate in the collision; Total wear calculation module: used to sum the wear after collision at the same position on the spray gun according to the wear of the spray gun under all fly ash particle wear conditions, and obtain the total wear of all positions on the spray gun.
8. The wear assessment system for a spray gun for a coal-fired power plant according to claim 7, characterized in that: Also includes life calculation module: for calculating wear time t : Where: t For wear time; The target material density for erosive wear; is the surface area of the target material wear region; is the target material thickness; is the wear rate of the target material, which is calculated by the wear amount of the target material per unit time.
