A route planning method for the Arctic route based on POLARIS
Through the Arctic waterway route planning method based on POLARIS, combined with sea ice and water depth factors, risk levels are evaluated and reclassified, and the lowest cost route is calculated, which solves the problem of lack of comprehensive risk considerations in Arctic route planning and significantly improves navigation safety.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202311692502.0
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-12-11
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-26
- Estimated Expiration
- 2043-12-11
AI Technical Summary
The Arctic route planning lacks comprehensive considerations for ships stranded and sea ice risks in the Arctic waters, which affects navigation safety.
Using the Arctic waterway route planning method based on POLARIS, sea ice risk level map is calculated by evaluating sea ice thickness and sea ice density, combined with ETOPO1 global topographic model to extract safe water depth areas, reclassify risk levels and assign values to costs, calculate the starting point to target The lowest cost route is to determine the lowest risk route.
It effectively improves the safety of navigation in the Arctic region, and reduces navigation risks by taking into account sea ice and water depth factors, especially reducing the possibility of entering high-risk areas, ensuring the safety and reliability of the route.
Smart Images

Figure CN117664140B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of route planning, and in particular to an Arctic waterway route planning method based on POLARIS. Background Art
[0002] As the global climate warms, the navigability of the Arctic route has significantly improved, but the safety of ships still faces many challenges, and safety and navigability need to be further improved. At present, most of the Arctic route planning processes only consider ice collision avoidance and voyage issues, and lack comprehensive consideration of the risks of ship grounding and sea ice in the risks of navigation accidents in Arctic waters. Due to the complexity of the Arctic sea ice and geographical environment, scientific planning of the route with the lowest comprehensive risk in the ice zone is of great significance to ensure navigation safety. Summary of the invention
[0003] The present invention provides an Arctic route planning method based on POLARIS to overcome the technical problem that the Arctic route planning process lacks comprehensive consideration of the risks of ship grounding and sea ice in the risks of navigation accidents in Arctic waters, which affects navigation safety.
[0004] In order to achieve the above object, the technical solution of the present invention is:
[0005] A route planning method for the Arctic route based on POLARIS, the specific steps include:
[0006] S1: The Arctic sea ice risk level map is obtained by calculating the sea ice thickness and sea ice density in the Arctic ice area based on the Polar Operational Restriction Assessment Risk Index System POLARIS;
[0007] S2: obtaining a safe water depth area based on the ETOPO1 global terrain model, and extracting a safe water depth area risk level map from an overlapping portion of the safe water depth area and the Arctic sea ice risk level map;
[0008] S3: Reclassify each risk level in the safe water depth area risk level map to reclassify the risk level into a cost, and calculate the cost distance map of the starting point based on the reclassification result, and obtain the lowest cost route from the starting point to the target point based on the cost distance map, that is, the lowest risk route.
[0009] Specifically, in S1, the Arctic sea ice risk level map obtained by calculating the sea ice thickness and sea ice density in the Arctic ice area based on the Polar Operational Limitation Assessment Risk Index System POLARIS includes:
[0010] The polar operation restriction assessment risk index system POLARIS assesses the navigation risk in the ice area where the ship is located based on the ship's ice class and the ice type classified according to the thickness of the sea ice, and obtains a risk index value table;
[0011] Using the risk index value table, calculate the risk index result RIO, the calculation formula is:
[0012] RIO=(C1×RIV1)…+(C2×RIV2)+(C3×RIV3)+…+(C n ×RIV n )
[0013] In the formula, C1, C2, C3…, C n is the density of each ice type in the ice area; RIV1, RIV2, ···, RIV n is the risk index value for each ice type in the risk index value table;
[0014] Based on the risk index result RIO and in comparison with the risk index result criterion table, the restriction conditions of ships in ice areas are evaluated to obtain an Arctic sea ice risk level map, which includes normal operation areas, high-risk operation areas and operation areas requiring special consideration.
[0015] Specifically, in S2, the safe water depth area is obtained based on the ETOPO1 global terrain model, and the process of extracting the safe water depth area risk level map from the overlapping part of the safe water depth area and the Arctic sea ice risk level map is as follows:
[0016] The reclassification tool in the GIS software was used to reclassify the elevation in the ETOPO1 global model, and the elevation above the safe water depth area in the Arctic risk level map was set to empty data NODATA. The safe water depth area in the ETOPO1 global model was retained, and the Arctic sea ice risk level map was superimposed on the safe water depth area. The mask extraction tool in the GIS software was used to extract the overlapping part of the two maps to obtain the risk level map of the safe water depth area.
[0017] Specifically, in S3, each risk level in the risk level map of the safe water depth area is reclassified so that the risk level is reclassified and assigned a cost, and a cost distance map of the starting point is calculated based on the reclassification result, including: converting the normal operation area and the high-risk operation area in the risk level map of the safe water depth area into the navigation time cost relationship between the normal operation grid and the high-risk operation grid, and converting the high-risk operation area and the operation area requiring special consideration in the risk level map of the safe water depth area into the voyage cost relationship between the high-risk operation grid and the operation grid requiring special consideration, wherein the navigation time cost relationship between the normal operation grid and the high-risk operation grid is:
[0018]
[0019] Where, T a is the time cost in the normal operation area, T bis the time cost of high-risk operation area, V a is the ship’s speed in the normal operating area, V b Speed limits for ships in high-risk operating areas;
[0020] Based on the relationship between the navigation time cost of the normal operation grid and the high-risk operation grid, and the relationship between the voyage cost of the high-risk operation grid and the operation grid requiring special consideration, the risk level is reclassified and assigned to a cost, and the cost distance map of the starting point is calculated using the cost distance tool in the GIS software, wherein the cost distance map includes the cost of each point in the risk level map from the starting point to the safe water depth area.
[0021] Specifically, in S3, the process of obtaining the lowest cost route, i.e., the lowest risk route, from the departure point to the destination point based on the cost distance graph is as follows:
[0022] The cost path polyline tool in the GIS software is used to generate the route with the lowest cumulative cost from the starting point to the target point, taking each grid in the cost distance map as a unit. The calculation formula of the route cost includes:
[0023] The calculation formula for the diagonal cost Road1 is:
[0024]
[0025] The calculation formula for the horizontal and vertical cost Road2 is:
[0026]
[0027] Where cost1 and cost2 are the costs of different grids.
[0028] Beneficial effects: The present invention takes into account the unique polar sea ice and geographical environment, and proposes a method for route planning that comprehensively considers sea ice thickness, sea ice density and water depth factors. The method calculates the comprehensive sea ice risk including sea ice thickness and density based on the Polar Operational Restriction Assessment Risk Index System POLARIS, and simultaneously extracts the safe water depth area. In the safe water depth area, the lowest cost route is planned with the sea ice risk level as the cost, thereby ensuring safety when sailing in the Arctic region. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0029] In order to more clearly illustrate the embodiments of the present invention or the technical solutions in the prior art, the following briefly introduces the drawings required for use in the embodiments or the description of the prior art. Obviously, the drawings described below are some embodiments of the present invention. For ordinary technicians in this field, other drawings can be obtained based on these drawings without paying creative labor.
[0030] Figure 1 This is a flow chart of the Arctic route planning method based on POLARIS in the present invention;
[0031] Figure 2 An Arctic sea ice risk level map in an embodiment of the present invention;
[0032] Figure 3 A risk level map of a safe water depth area in an embodiment of the present invention;
[0033] Figure 4 A schematic diagram of cost distance in an embodiment of the present invention;
[0034] Figure 5 A minimum risk cost route map in an embodiment of the present invention;
[0035] Figure 6 A comparison chart of routes designed considering different risk costs in an embodiment of the present invention;
[0036] Figure 7 A cost route map in an embodiment of the present invention;
[0037] Figure 8 4 is a comparison chart of route costs in an embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0038] In order to make the purpose, technical solution and advantages of the embodiments of the present invention clearer, the technical solution in the embodiments of the present invention will be clearly and completely described below in conjunction with the drawings in the embodiments of the present invention. Obviously, the described embodiments are part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the scope of protection of the present invention.
[0039] This embodiment provides a method for planning an Arctic route based on POLARIS. Figure 1 As shown, the specific steps include:
[0040] S1: The Arctic sea ice risk level map is obtained by calculating the sea ice thickness and sea ice density in the Arctic ice area based on the Polar Operational Restriction Assessment Risk Index System POLARIS;
[0041] S2: obtaining a safe water depth area based on the ETOPO1 global terrain model, and extracting a safe water depth area risk level map from an overlapping portion of the safe water depth area and the Arctic sea ice risk level map;
[0042] S3: Reclassify each risk level in the safe water depth area risk level map to reclassify the risk level into a cost, and calculate the cost distance map of the starting point based on the reclassification result, and obtain the lowest cost route from the starting point to the target point based on the cost distance map, that is, the lowest risk route.
[0043] In a specific embodiment, in S1, the thickness and density of sea ice in the Arctic ice zone are calculated based on the polar operation restriction assessment risk index system POLARIS as follows: Figure 2 The Arctic Sea Ice Risk Level map shown includes:
[0044] The polar operation restriction assessment risk index system POLARIS assesses the navigation risk in the ice area where the ship is located based on the ship's ice class and the ice type classified according to the thickness of the sea ice, and obtains a risk index value table, as shown in Table 1;
[0045] Table 1
[0046]
[0047] The risk index value table is used to calculate the risk index result RIO. For polar ships, RIO is the sum of the risk index value corresponding to each ice type multiplied by its corresponding density (expressed in tenths). The specific calculation formula is:
[0048] RIO=(C1×RIV1)…+(C2×RIV2)+(C3×RIV3)+…+(C n ×RIV n )
[0049] In the formula, C1, C2, C3…, C n is the density of each ice type in the ice area (expressed in tenths); RIV1, RIV2, ···, RIV n is the risk index value for each ice type in the risk index value table;
[0050] Based on the risk index result RIO and in comparison with the risk index result criterion table, as shown in Table 2, the navigation risk of the ship in the ice area is assessed, thereby obtaining the Arctic sea ice risk level map, which includes normal operation areas, high-risk operation areas and operation areas that require special consideration. Under the condition of reducing the speed without damaging the maneuverability of the ship, the ship sailing in the high-risk area should limit the speed, and generally avoid entering the area when making navigation plans. If entering, an emergency plan should be formulated; when the ship sails to the operation area that requires special consideration, the captain and senior crew members on navigation duty should operate with extra caution, and should also avoid entering the area when making navigation plans.
[0051] Table 2
[0052]
[0053] In a specific embodiment, in S2, a safe water depth area is obtained based on the ETOPO1 global terrain model, and the following is extracted from the overlapping part of the safe water depth area and the Arctic sea ice risk level map: Figure 3 The process of the safe water depth area risk level map shown is:
[0054] The reclassification tool in the GIS software was used to reclassify the elevations in the ETOPO1 global model, and the elevations above the safe water depth area in the Arctic risk level map were set to empty data NODATA. The safe water depth area in the ETOPO1 global model was retained, and the Arctic sea ice risk level map was imported into the software. The mask extraction tool in the GIS software was used to extract the overlapping part of the Arctic sea ice risk level map and the safe water depth area, so as to obtain the risk level map of the safe water depth area.
[0055] In a specific embodiment, in S3, each risk level in the risk level map of the safe water depth area is reclassified so that the risk level is reclassified and assigned a cost, and a cost distance map of the starting point is calculated based on the reclassification result, including: converting the normal operation area and the high-risk operation area in the risk level map of the safe water depth area into the navigation time cost relationship between the normal operation grid and the high-risk operation grid, and converting the high-risk operation area and the operation area requiring special consideration in the risk level map of the safe water depth area into the voyage cost relationship between the high-risk operation grid and the operation grid requiring special consideration, wherein the navigation time cost relationship between the normal operation grid and the high-risk operation grid is:
[0056]
[0057] Where, T a is the time cost in the normal operation area, T b is the time cost of high-risk operation area, V a is the ship’s speed in the normal operating area, V b Speed limits for ships in high-risk operating areas;
[0058] Based on the relationship between the normal operation grid and the high-risk operation grid in terms of navigation time cost, and the relationship between the high-risk operation grid and the operation grid that needs special consideration in terms of voyage cost, the risk level is reclassified and assigned to cost, and the cost distance map of the starting point is calculated using the cost distance tool in the GIS software, as shown in Figure 4 As shown, the cost distance map includes the cost from the starting point to each point in the safe water depth area risk level map.
[0059] In this embodiment, the high-risk operation area and the operation area that needs special consideration in the risk level map of the safe water depth area are converted into the voyage cost relationship between the high-risk operation grid and the operation grid that needs special consideration, that is, the cost of the special consideration operation grid is assigned to N times the cost of the high-risk operation grid, N ≥ 2, so that when planning the lowest cost route, the ship is allowed to avoid the operation area that needs special consideration as much as possible during navigation, so as to choose a detour route to reduce costs. Specifically, taking the data of the Yongsheng ship of COSCO Shipping Special Transport Company sailing in the Northeast Passage of the Arctic in 2015 as an example, the Yongsheng ship is IA ice class and has a maximum draft of 8.41m. In order to ensure the safety of the ship's navigation, this embodiment takes the waters with a depth of more than 10m as its safe water depth, according to the speed limit comparison table, as shown in Table 3;
[0060] Table 3
[0061]
[0062] When an IA ice-class ship sails to a high-risk operation area, its recommended speed limit is 3 kn; the average speed of the Yongsheng is 12.5 kn. Due to the strong wind slowing down when sailing to the north of Novaya Zemlya, this embodiment will use 12 kn as its speed for research. According to the relationship between sailing time and cost, it is calculated that the high-risk operation grid time cost is 4 times the normal operation grid time cost; for the operation area that needs special consideration, the detour route is used as its cost. In this embodiment, preferably, the operation grid cost that needs special consideration is assigned to 2 times the high-risk operation grid cost. At this time, if Figure 8 As shown in the figure, when the cost of the original route in the left grid is 4.242, the cost of the collision avoidance route after adopting the detour route is 4; when the cost of the original route in the right grid is 3, the cost of the collision avoidance route is 2.828. The ships all adopted the collision avoidance route when sailing. Therefore, considering the sailing time cost and the voyage cost, the risk costs of the normal operation, high-risk operation and operation requiring special consideration grids are assigned 1, 4 and 8 respectively.
[0063] In a specific embodiment, in S3, based on the cost distance, a GIS minimum cost path analysis method is used to plan the distance from the starting point to the target point. Figure 5 The process for the least cost route shown is:
[0064] The cost path polyline tool in the GIS software is used to generate the route with the lowest cumulative cost from the starting point to the target point, taking each grid in the cost distance map as a unit. The calculation formula of the route cost includes:
[0065] The calculation formula for the diagonal cost Road1 is:
[0066]
[0067] The calculation formula for the horizontal and vertical cost Road2 is:
[0068]
[0069] In the formula, Figure 7 As shown, cost1 and cost2 are the costs of different grids.
[0070] This embodiment uses the cost path polyline tool in the GIS software and adopts the minimum cost path analysis method to plan routes in Arctic waters, which effectively solves the problem that traditional route planning takes less risk factors of grounding and sea ice into account in the risk of navigation accidents in Arctic waters. Figure 6 As shown in Table 4, Route 3, which was planned by considering multiple risk factors, is a route designed based on safe water depth. It is farther away from islands and reefs and land, and the shallowest water depth of the route is greater than 10m. Compared with the traditional shortest distance route 2, Route 3, with a total length of only 23 nautical miles different, can reduce the area that needs special consideration along the way by 21.44%, which can effectively reduce risks.
[0071] Table 4
[0072]
[0073] Finally, it should be noted that the above embodiments are only used to illustrate the technical solutions of the present invention, rather than to limit it. Although the present invention has been described in detail with reference to the aforementioned embodiments, those skilled in the art should understand that they can still modify the technical solutions described in the aforementioned embodiments, or replace some or all of the technical features therein with equivalents. However, these modifications or replacements do not cause the essence of the corresponding technical solutions to deviate from the scope of the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present invention.
Claims
1. A route planning method for the Arctic route based on POLARIS, It is characterized in that The specific steps include: S1: The Arctic sea ice risk level map is obtained by calculating the sea ice thickness and sea ice density in the Arctic ice area based on the Polar Operational Restriction Assessment Risk Index System POLARIS; In S1, the Arctic sea ice risk level map is obtained based on the calculation of sea ice thickness and sea ice density in the Arctic ice area by the Polar Operational Limitation Assessment Risk Index System POLARIS, including: The polar operation restriction assessment risk index system POLARIS assesses the navigation risk in the ice area where the ship is located based on the ship's ice class and the ice type classified according to the thickness of the sea ice, and obtains a risk index value table; Using the risk index value table, calculate the risk index result RIO, the calculation formula is: RIO=(C 1 ×RIV 1 )…+(C 2 ×RIV 2 )+(C 3 ×RIV 3 )+…+(C n ×RIV n ) In the formula, C 1 ,C 2 ,C 3 …,C n is the density of each ice type in the ice area; RIV 1 ,RIV 2 ,…,RIV n is the risk index value for each ice type in the risk index value table; Based on the risk index result RIO and in comparison with the risk index result criterion table, the limiting conditions of ships in the ice area are evaluated to obtain the Arctic sea ice risk level map, which includes normal operation areas, high-risk operation areas and operation areas requiring special consideration; S2: obtaining a safe water depth area based on the ETOPO1 global terrain model, and extracting a safe water depth area risk level map from an overlapping portion of the safe water depth area and the Arctic sea ice risk level map; In S2, the safe water depth area is obtained based on the ETOPO1 global terrain model, and the process of extracting the safe water depth area risk level map from the overlapping part of the safe water depth area and the Arctic sea ice risk level map is as follows: The elevation in the ETOPO1 global terrain model was reclassified using the reclassification tool in the GIS software, and the elevation above the safe water depth area in the Arctic risk level map was set to null data NODATA, and the safe water depth area in the ETOPO1 global terrain model was retained. The Arctic sea ice risk level map was superimposed on the safe water depth area, and the mask extraction tool in the GIS software was used to extract the overlapping part of the two maps, thereby obtaining the risk level map of the safe water depth area. S3: Reclassify each risk level in the safe water depth area risk level map to reclassify the risk level into a cost, and calculate the cost distance map of the starting point based on the reclassification result, and obtain the lowest cost route from the starting point to the target point based on the cost distance map, that is, the lowest risk route.
2. The Arctic route planning method based on POLARIS according to claim 1, It is characterized in that In S3, each risk level in the risk level map of the safe water depth area is reclassified to assign the risk level to a cost, and a cost distance map of the starting point is calculated based on the reclassification result, including: converting the normal operation area and the high-risk operation area in the risk level map of the safe water depth area into the navigation time cost relationship between the normal operation grid and the high-risk operation grid, and converting the high-risk operation area and the operation area requiring special consideration in the risk level map of the safe water depth area into the voyage cost relationship between the high-risk operation grid and the operation grid requiring special consideration, wherein the navigation time cost relationship between the normal operation grid and the high-risk operation grid is: Where, T a is the time cost in the normal operation area, T b is the time cost of high-risk operation area, V a is the ship’s speed in the normal operating area, V b Speed limits for ships in high-risk operating areas; Based on the relationship between the navigation time cost of the normal operation grid and the high-risk operation grid, and the relationship between the voyage cost of the high-risk operation grid and the operation grid requiring special consideration, the risk level is reclassified and assigned to a cost, and the cost distance map of the starting point is calculated using the cost distance tool in the GIS software, wherein the cost distance map includes the cost of each point in the risk level map from the starting point to the safe water depth area.
3. The Arctic route planning method based on POLARIS according to claim 2, It is characterized in that In S3, the process of obtaining the lowest cost route from the departure point to the destination point, i.e., the lowest risk route, based on the cost distance graph is as follows: The cost path polyline tool in the GIS software is used to generate the route with the lowest cumulative cost from the starting point to the target point, taking each grid in the cost distance map as a unit. The calculation formula of the route cost includes: Diagonal CostRoad 1 The calculation formula is: Horizontal and vertical costsRoad 2 The calculation formula is: In the formula, cost 1 and cost 2 are the costs of different grids.
