Quality evaluation method of forage relative feeding value
By measuring the crude protein of forage, the in vitro digestibility of 48-hour neutral detergent fibers and ash correction of neutral detergent fibers, the forage quality index FQI was constructed, which solved the problem of ignoring important nutrient elements and simple calculation assumptions in the existing technology. , realizes simple and accurate forage quality evaluation, suitable for different regions and seasonal changes.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411156102.2
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-08-22
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-12
- Estimated Expiration
- 2044-08-22
AI Technical Summary
Existing forage quality evaluation methods, such as RFV and RFQ, ignore the influence of other important nutrient elements such as proteins and minerals in the feed. The calculation assumption is too simple and cannot reflect the changes in feed quality with seasons and storage conditions. It is directly applied to animal production, and the model calculation is complex and difficult to apply to actual production.
By determining nutritional indicators such as crude protein (CP), 48-hour neutral detergent fiber (NDF) in vitro digestibility and ash correction neutral detergent fiber (aNDF) of forage, FQI was constructed, and FQI = SCP × 0.7153 was used. The formula of +SNDFD48×0.1485+SaNDFom×0.1362 calculates the quality level of forage, and optimizes the quality evaluation model of forage through multiple regression analysis and Pearson correlation analysis.
It realizes simple and accurate quality evaluation of the relative feeding value of forage, can effectively evaluate the production value of forage, is suitable for different regions and seasonal changes, is easy to calculate, is easy to market, and is in line with the quality of forage in the existing technology. The evaluation model is consistent and can provide accurate nutritional data reference.
Smart Images

Figure CN118674176B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention relates to a method for evaluating forage quality, in particular to a method for evaluating the quality of forage relative feeding value, and belongs to the field of forage quality evaluation. Background Art
[0002] In the history of forage quality evaluation research, several forage quality evaluation systems have been developed. Rohweder proposed a roughage relative value evaluation system (RFV) related to forage. Later, Moore optimized RFV by using total digestible nutrients (TDN) and proposed a roughage relative quality evaluation system (RFQ), which has been used as a roughage evaluation index in the United States. In China, Lu Dexun (2004) considered crude protein and energy indicators on the basis of RFV to form a new roughage grading index (GI). Each evaluation system includes the free intake of forage when fed as the only energy and protein source, as well as some measurements of available energy, such as energy digestibility, digestible energy, digestible dry matter (DDM) or total digestible nutrients (TDN). Among them, the intake of available energy is the main factor affecting animal production performance.
[0003] The Roughage Relative Value (RFV) system is a common forage evaluation model in the United States in the early 21st century, and plays a huge role in the forage trading process (Moore JE, Undersander DJ. Relative Forage Quality: An Alternative to Relative Feed Value and Quality Index). At the same time, China is also using this model, mainly for alfalfa marketing. The RFV evaluation is based on animal digestible dry matter (DDM) and free dry matter intake (DMI), while the DDM and DMI values are based on the chemical analysis of acid detergent fiber (ADF) and neutral detergent fiber (NDF), respectively. The final calculation formula is:
[0004] DMI (%BW) = 120 / NDF
[0005] DDM (%DM) = 88.9 - 0.779 ADF (%DM)
[0006] RFV= DMI (%BW) × DDM (%DM) / 1.29
[0007] Among them, 1.29 is the expected DDM intake of alfalfa in full bloom based on a large number of animal experimental data, and divided by 1.29 makes the RFV value of alfalfa in full bloom 100. The higher the value, the higher the forage quality.
[0008] Although RFV is widely used in forage trading, it is still not included in the nutritional model. The above problems are summarized as follows: 1) Single factor influence: RFV mainly relies on the evaluation of neutral detergent fiber (NDF) and acid detergent fiber (ADF), while ignoring the influence of other important nutrients in the feed, such as protein, minerals, etc. 2) Overly simple assumptions: The calculation of RFV is based on the assumption that animals can consume 1% of their body weight in NDF every day, but actual conditions may be different. For example, different animals have lower digestibility of certain types of feed than other species, or under specific feeding conditions, the daily diet consumption of animals may increase or decrease.
[0009] Like RFV, the roughage relative quality assessment system (RFQ) is an estimate of the amount of available energy freely consumed when forage is the only source of energy and protein. The intake component is the percentage of dry matter intake (DMI) to body weight (BW), and available energy can be expressed as TDN (DM%). Compared with RFV, the calculation of RFQ is more complicated. In practical application, it is difficult to obtain an accurate reference standard for the nutritional value of roughage through simple chemical analysis and calculation. This is especially true when NDFD is used as a 48-hour in vitro culture, which requires tedious and time-consuming laboratory operations. Secondly, since animal feed intake is affected by many factors (including breed, age, health status, etc.), and the same feed has inconsistent digestion and nutrient intake capabilities for animals at different stages and different physiological states at the same stage, it is necessary to further optimize the roughage assessment system to adapt to the current production model.
[0010] The grading index (GI) is a roughage evaluation system suitable for the development of China's animal husbandry industry proposed by Lu Dexun et al. on the basis of the RFV and other evaluation systems and the current status of China's roughage resource development and utilization (Hong Min, Gao Min, Lu Dexun, Hu Honglian. Establishment of a new generation of grading index for roughage quality evaluation and comparative study with grading index (GI_(2001)) and relative feed value (RFV). Journal of Animal Nutrition, 2011, 23(8): 1296-1302.). GI is a multi-index, comprehensive evaluation model that integrates roughage scoring, forage planting, mowing, and provides recommendations for the use of a variety of roughages. The main evaluation indicators involved are net maintenance energy (ME, MJ / kg), dry matter intake (DMI, kg / d), crude protein (CP, %DM), neutral detergent fiber (NDF, %DM), and acid detergent lignin (ADL, %DM).
[0011] As a static parameter, the GI evaluation index cannot reflect the quality changes of roughage due to changes in seasons, storage conditions and other factors. At the same time, it ignores the impact of specific environmental factors such as soil conditions, climate conditions, dryness and humidity on the quality of roughage. In addition, since the evaluation system uses the forage score as the final result and ignores the unit forage animal production effect, that is to say, no further evaluation is made on the production of animal protein. Therefore, when optimizing the forage evaluation system, it is necessary to consider the ability of unit cut forage to produce animal protein so as to directly apply it to actual production and provide data reference for precise nutrition.
[0012] The food equivalent of forage (FEU) is based on the concept and model of food equivalent. The original model is modified by introducing the energy and protein coefficients of forage food equivalent calculation after forage digestibility. Taking 1kg of alfalfa (standard food part 100%, water content 10%, gross energy (GE) 14.267MJ / kg, protein (CP) content 229g / kg, dry matter digestibility (DDM) 65.48% as standard forage, the food equivalent of grassland resources such as natural grassland, cultivated forage, silage and grain straw is calculated and compared, and the productivity of land resources in different regions, different spatial scales and different utilization methods is compared in a unified dimension.
[0013] In production, dry matter digestibility (DDM) is often measured, which is simple, easy and low-cost, while energy and protein digestibility are less often measured. There is a good quantitative relationship between the two, so food equivalents can also be calculated based on dry matter digestibility.
[0014] The calculation is based on the energy and crude protein content of the forage and its digestible dry matter. The forage food equivalent is corrected according to the digestibility, excluding the energy consumption of gas production and heat production, which intuitively expresses the animal food production value of the forage to a certain extent. However, according to research, although the gas production and heat production energy are corrected in the form of dry matter digestibility, there is no correlation between digestible energy and total energy × digestible dry matter in the calculation process (R2=0.0245). Therefore, the direct multiplication of total energy and digestible dry matter may ignore the synergistic effect and interaction between different nutrients in the digestion process. Although the feeding value of forage can be ranked to a certain extent, the accuracy of evaluating forage quality still needs to further promote the calculation and application of total energy to digestible energy.
[0015] As the main feed source for ruminants, roughage not only plays a vital role in stimulating rumination, but also, with the current development of roughage resources and the continuous progress in processing and storage, the quality of forage can be effectively improved to achieve soybean meal reduction and low-protein diet mode, reduce breeding costs, and improve economic benefits. However, in the early stage of processing and storage, such as controlling the harvest time and identifying the quality, it will have a multiplier effect on the later processing. At present, there are still deficiencies in the assessment of forage quality, such as defects in the use of indicators and overly complex model calculations that cannot be applied to actual production. Summary of the invention
[0016] The main purpose of the present invention is to provide a simple and accurate method for evaluating the quality of forage relative feeding value;
[0017] To achieve the above purpose, the main technical solutions adopted by the present invention include:
[0018] A method for evaluating the quality of forage relative feeding value, comprising:
[0019] (1) Determine the nutritional indexes of crude protein (CP), 48-hour neutral detergent fiber (NDF) in vitro digestibility (NDFD48) and ash-corrected neutral detergent fiber (aNDFom) of the forage to be evaluated;
[0020] (2) The forage quality index (FQI) score is calculated using the following formula:
[0021] FQI = S CP ×0.7153+S NDFD48 ×0.1485+S aNDFom ×0.1362
[0022] Among them, S CP The calculation method of S value is as follows: Determine the crude protein (CP) nutritional index of the forage to be evaluated; if the crude protein nutritional index is less than or equal to 4, then S CP The value is 0.1; if the crude protein nutrition index is greater than or equal to 28, then S CP The value is 1.0; if the crude protein nutritional index is greater than 4 and less than 28, calculate S according to the following formula CP value:
[0023] S CP=
[0024] Where Xi is the nutritional index of the CP corresponding to the tested forage, L is 4, and U is 28;
[0025] S NDFD48The calculation method of S value is as follows: Determine the 48-hour neutral detergent fiber (NDF) in vitro digestibility nutrient index of the forage to be evaluated; if the 48-hour NDF in vitro digestibility nutrient index is less than or equal to 27, then S NDFD48 The value is 0.1; if the 48-hour NDF in vitro digestibility nutrient index is greater than or equal to 68, then S NDFD48 The value is 1.0; if the 48-hour NDF in vitro digestibility nutrient index is greater than 27 and less than 68, calculate S according to the following formula NDFD48 value:
[0026] S NDFD48=
[0027] Where Xi is the nutritional index of NDFD48 corresponding to the tested forage, L is 27, and U is 68;
[0028] S aNDFom The calculation method of the value is as follows: determine the ash-corrected neutral detergent fiber nutritional index of the forage to be evaluated; if the ash-corrected neutral detergent fiber nutritional index is less than or equal to 28, then S aNDFom The value is 0.1; if the ash-corrected neutral detergent fiber nutrition index is greater than or equal to 78, then S aNDFom The value is 1.0; if the ash-corrected neutral detergent fiber nutrition index is greater than 28 and less than 78, calculate S according to the following formula aNDFom value:
[0029] S aNDFom=
[0030] Where Xi is the nutritional index of aNDFom corresponding to the tested forage, L is 28, and U is 78;
[0031] (3) When the FQI score is greater than 0.8, the quality grade of the forage to be evaluated is special grade (the best quality); when the FQI score is between 0.75-0.8, the quality grade of the forage to be evaluated is first grade; when the FQI score is between 0.67-0.75, the quality grade of the forage to be evaluated is second grade; when the FQI score is between 0.54-0.67, the quality grade of the forage to be evaluated is third grade; when the FQI score is less than 0.54, the quality grade of the forage to be evaluated is fourth grade or above.
[0032] In order to build a forage quality evaluation system, 215 samples of grass, legume and mixed grass and legume forage were collected in Heilongjiang, Yunnan, Ningxia, Inner Mongolia and other places, and a total of 2160 nutritional indicators were tested, including dry matter (DM), crude protein (CP), crude fat (EE), crude ash (Ash), neutral detergent fiber (NDF), acid detergent fiber (ADF), gross energy (GE), ash-corrected NDF (aNDFom), in vitro 48-hour NDF digestibility (NDFD48), and dry matter digestibility (DDM). A total of 216 groups of agronomic traits such as plant height and fresh weight were measured to optimize the forage quality evaluation model. The model construction starts with crude protein, crude fiber and energy value, the main nutritional indicators of forage, and uses Pearson correlation analysis, principal component analysis and multiple regression analysis to obtain the main indicators that affect the feeding value of roughage, including the three major nutrients; the analysis results show that crude protein (CP), 48-hour neutral detergent fiber (NDF) in vitro digestibility nutrition (NDFD48), and ash-corrected neutral detergent fiber (aNDFom) can be used as important indicators for evaluating forage quality, among which CP and NDFD48 are positively correlated with forage quality, and aNDFom is negatively correlated with forage quality. Using the weights of the four indicators in the overall forage and the standard scoring function, the forage quality index (FQI) [FQI = S CP ×0.7153+S NDFD48 ×0.1485+S aNDFom ×0.1362】.
[0033] In order to clearly determine whether the three indicators are correlated, the variance inflation factor (VIF) of the three was calculated. When the VIF is less than 10, it proves that the three have the conditions for model combination and construction. The VIF values of CP, NDFD48 and aNDFom were calculated to be 3.01, 5.58 and 2.67, respectively, so they can be used as nutritional indicators for evaluating forage quality. Based on the selected principal components, multiple regression analysis was further performed to obtain the Beta coefficient for calculating the weight of forage nutritional indicators in forage quality, and finally a comprehensive forage quality index FQI based on CP, NDFD48 and aNDFom was constructed.
[0034] The present invention uses forage food equivalent (FEU), relative feeding value (RFV), and relative forage quality (RFQ) to verify the consistency correlation coefficient (CCC) of FQI; among them, FQI and FEU have a very strong fit, and the correlation reaches more than 98%, indicating that FQI has a reference value for evaluating forage quality; RFV has the lowest fit with FQI compared with RFQ and FEU (R 2 =0.79); correlation coefficient between RFQ and FQI R 2It is 0.83, which is better than the correlation between RFV and FQI. According to these verification test results, constructing the forage quality comprehensive index FQI with CP, NDFD48 and aNDFom as the main nutritional indicators can effectively evaluate the forage quality, and it is simple to calculate and easy to promote in the market.
[0035] The present invention further utilizes different forage quality evaluation models in the prior art and performs quality evaluation based on the commonly used feed raw materials provided in NASEM (2021), and obtains that the quality rankings of different forages by each model are consistent, further proving that the FQI constructed by the present invention can be promoted and applied as a forage evaluation model.
[0036] The present invention mainly studies the comprehensive evaluation method of relative feeding value of forage by evaluating the biological mass yield change law of Gramineae forage, Leguminosae forage and mixed legume and grass forage at different growth stages, obtains the minimum data set for evaluating forage quality and representative biological significance, establishes a comprehensive forage quality index, verifies the seasonal growth change law of forage, constructs a grass-livestock conversion rate evaluation model, and at the same time, based on the annual quality and yield prediction model of mowed grassland forage and the animal protein yield that unit grassland forage can provide according to animal nutritional needs, finally establishes a set of roughage feeding value evaluation system related to ruminant nutrition, and provides data reference and technical support for the evaluation of mowed grassland forage quality and grass-livestock conversion efficiency in the industry.
[0037] In summary, the present invention measures seasonal yields of different forages in different regions, and analyzes the seasonal dynamic changes of plant nutrients and biological yields by detecting data such as chemical indicators. The present invention adopts multiple regression statistics, principal component analysis, standard scoring function and weight calculation and other analysis methods, and combines the theory of animal nutritional requirements to analyze the weights of various nutrients in plant nutrition to construct a model for evaluating forage quality and apply it to forage quality evaluation; the present invention uses forage food equivalent (FEU), relative feeding value (RFV), and relative forage quality (RFQ) to verify the consistency correlation coefficient (CCC) of FQI; the verification test results show that the forage quality comprehensive index FQI constructed by the present invention can accurately and effectively evaluate forage quality, and is simple to calculate and easy to market. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0038] Figure 1 This is a sample distribution diagram among the five forage quality grades determined by the present invention.
[0039] Figure 2 This is the correlation analysis result between FQI and FEU.
[0040] Figure 3 This is the result of correlation analysis between RFV and FQI.
[0041] Figure 4 This is the correlation analysis result between RFQ and FQI.
[0042] Figure 5 This is the verification result of the correlation between FQI and unit grassland forage organic matter yield (OM-yield). DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0043] The present invention will be further described below in conjunction with specific embodiments, and the advantages and features of the present invention will become clearer as the description proceeds. However, it should be understood that the embodiments are exemplary only and do not constitute any limitation to the scope of the present invention. It should be understood by those skilled in the art that the details and forms of the technical solution of the present invention may be modified or replaced without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention, but these modifications or replacements all fall within the protection scope of the present invention.
[0044] Experimental Example 1 Construction and Methodological Validation of the Quality Evaluation Method for Relative Feeding Value of Forage
[0045] In order to construct a forage quality assessment system, 216 samples of grass, legume and mixed grass and legume forage were collected in Heilongjiang Province, Yunnan Province, Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region, Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region, etc., and a total of 2160 nutritional indicators were tested, including dry matter (DM), crude protein (CP), crude fat (EE), crude ash (Ash), neutral detergent fiber (NDF), acid detergent fiber (ADF), gross energy (GE), ash-corrected neutral detergent fiber (aNDFom), in vitro 48-hour NDF digestibility (NDFD48), and dry matter digestibility (DDM). The detection indicators and detection methods of these nutritional indicators are well known to those skilled in the art, and are specifically referred to Table 1.
[0046] Table 1 Detection indicators and methods
[0047]
[0048] A total of 216 groups of agronomic traits such as plant height and fresh weight were measured to optimize the forage quality evaluation model. The model construction took crude protein, crude fiber and energy value, the main nutritional indicators of forage, as the entry point, and used analysis methods such as Pearson correlation analysis, principal component analysis and multiple regression analysis to obtain the main indicators that affect the feeding value of roughage, including the three major nutrients. The analysis results showed that crude protein (CP), non-fibrous carbohydrates (NFC), crude fat (EE), and ash-corrected neutral detergent fiber (aNDFom) can be used as important indicators for evaluating forage quality. Among them, CP and NDFD48 are positively correlated with forage quality, and aNDFom is negatively correlated with forage quality. Using the weights of the three indicators in the overall forage and the standard scoring function, the forage quality index (FQI) [FQI = S CP ×0.7153+SNDFD48 ×0.1485+S aNDFom ×0.1362】. The consistency correlation coefficient (CCC) of FQI was verified by forage food equivalent (FEU), relative feeding value (RFV), and relative forage quality (RFQ), and the advantages of the optimized FQI as a forage evaluation were analyzed.
[0049] The specific analysis is as follows:
[0050] 1. Principal Component Analysis
[0051] According to the results of principal component analysis, it can be concluded that the first three principal components account for 95% of the total contribution (Table 2).
[0052] Table 2 Principal component analysis results scores
[0053]
[0054] The maximum load value and quality index within 10% of the maximum load value in the first two principal components were selected as the main nutritional indexes affecting the quality of roughage for further analysis (Table 3). Among them, the quality indexes with load values and maximum load values within 10% in PC1 were aNDFom, NDF and CP. Since aNDFom is the NDF corrected by ash, it can better reflect the original crude fiber value than NDF. At the same time, NDF and aNDFom have a significant correlation, so NDF is eliminated. CP is an index within 10% of the maximum load value in the first principal component, and protein is the main component affecting forage quality, so it is included in the formula. ADF and NDFD48 have the largest load values in PC2 and PC3, but ADF and NDF have a strong correlation, so NDFD48 is selected as the evaluation model index and can reflect the digestion of roughage. Therefore, CP, NDFD48 and aNDFom were finally selected for further model construction and analysis.
[0055] Table 3 Loading values of each index in the principal component
[0056]
[0057] 2. FQI model construction
[0058] In order to clearly determine whether the three indicators are correlated, the variance inflation factor (VIF) was calculated for the three. When the VIF is less than 10, it proves that the three have the conditions for model combination and construction. The VIF values of CP, NDFD48 and aNDFom were calculated to be 3.01, 5.58 and 2.67, respectively, so they can be used as nutritional indicators for evaluating forage quality at the same time (Table 4). Based on the selected principal components, multiple regression analysis was further performed to obtain the Beta coefficient used to calculate the weight of forage nutritional indicators in forage quality, and finally a comprehensive forage quality index FQI based on CP, NDFD48 and aNDFom was constructed. The model formula is as follows:
[0059] FQI = S CP ×0.7153+S NDFD48 ×0.1485+S aNDFom ×0.1362
[0060] Where: S represents the score of each nutritional index under the calculation condition of the standard scoring function, see Table 4 for details.
[0061] Table 4 Weights and VIF values of main nutritional indicators for evaluating forage quality
[0062]
[0063] 3. Threshold selection and standard scoring function calculation
[0064] According to the forage nutrient database, the thresholds of CP, NDFD48 and aNDFom were determined, and the standard scoring function was calculated using the given thresholds and the correlation of each nutrient index with the forage quality. MB represents a positive correlation, and LB represents a negative correlation. Finally, a standard score of 0.1-1 was obtained for different forage quality scores. The specific thresholds and calculations are shown in Table 5.
[0065] Table 5 Weights and VIF values of main nutritional indicators for evaluating forage quality
[0066]
[0067] 4. Forage quality evaluation level corresponding to FQI score
[0068] The FQI was used to score the quality of different alfalfas and compared with RFV and RFQ to obtain the FQI scores corresponding to different alfalfa grades. See Table 6 for details.
[0069] Table 6 Comparison of FQI, RFQ and RFV scores of different grades of alfalfa
[0070]
[0071] The FQS developed based on the MRA method ranged from 21 to 66, with an average of 49 and a coefficient of variation of 21%. The distribution of feed samples among the five feed quality grades is shown in Figure 2. Figure 1 According to the FQS calculated based on the FQI, the first and second grade forages account for about 13% and 20% of the total evaluated forages, followed by grade 3 (27%), grade 4 feed accounts for 36%, and the remaining 4% of forages are grade 5.
[0072] 5. Model Validation
[0073] The consistency correlation coefficient (CCC) of FQI was verified using forage food equivalent (FEU), relative feeding value (RFV), and relative forage quality (RFQ). Among them, FEU = DDM,% × (0.042 × GE,MJ / kg + 0.0033 × CP,g / kg) / 100; RFV = DMI,%BW×DDM,% / 1.29 (DMI = 120 / NDF; DDM = 88.9 - (0.779× ADF)); RFQ = DMI × TDN / 1.23. The specific verification results are shown in Figure 2-Figure 4 .
[0074] from Figure 2 It can be seen that FQI and FEU have a very strong fit, and the correlation reaches more than 98%, indicating that FQI has a reference value for evaluating forage quality. FQI covers crude protein, fiber and energy value when evaluating forage. Compared with the method of estimating only energy value and protein in the FEU model, it is more convincing. Although FEU considers energy value as a key indicator for evaluating forage quality, due to the small difference in total energy provided by different forages, using it as an evaluation for forage may overestimate the total digestible nutrients of low-quality forage. Total energy is mainly evaluated by the sum of the energy values of starch, fatty acids, NDF, CP, and ROM, among which NDF occupies the largest share of total energy. Although fat provides a higher energy value, it accounts for a small proportion in forage, so it is significantly lower than the impact of NDF on energy value. In addition to providing digestible energy for ruminants, NDF is also one of the sources of physically effective fiber, and has the ability to stimulate rumination, saliva secretion and rumen reticulum peristalsis. Therefore, considering replacing GE with NDF can not only be a response to energy value, but also strengthen the role of NDF in forage. Make model evaluation more valuable for reference.
[0075] from Figure 3 It can be seen that the fit between RFV and FQI is better than that of RFQ ( Figure 3 ) and FEU ( Figure 1 )Minimum (R 2=0.79). The main reason is that RFV only considers NDF and ADF as the evaluation criteria for dry matter intake (DMI) and digestible dry matter (DDM), ignoring the important role of crude protein in forage. Since RFV has few detection indicators and is easy to calculate, it is mostly used to evaluate the quality of alfalfa in the current market. However, due to the lack of consideration of the main nutrients of forage, there is an inaccurate evaluation. At the same time, only using NDF as the standard for evaluating DMI ignores the impact of different animal breeds and growth stages on feed intake, so RFV needs to be optimized more systematically.
[0076] from Figure 4 It can be seen that the correlation coefficient R between RFQ and FQI 2 It is 0.83, which is better than the correlation between RFV and FQI. RFQ changes digestible dry matter into total digestible nutrients (TDN) on the basis of RFV, and systematically and comprehensively evaluates the proportion of different nutrients in the total digestible nutrients in forage. However, TDN is actually used for the evaluation of the overall diet, and it may be different when evaluating a single forage compared to the evaluation of the overall diet. When considering the overall diet, the digestibility of crude protein, crude fat, nitrogen-free extract, starch, and neutral detergent fiber cannot be consistently quantified for a single forage or feed raw material. At the same time, as an empirical regression value, TDN's quantitative indicators cannot be included in the nutritional indicators, which can easily cause indirect calculation errors and affect the accuracy of the evaluation of forage quality.
[0077] According to the above test results, it can be seen that the forage quality comprehensive index FQI constructed with CP, NFC, EE and aNDFom as the main nutritional indicators can effectively evaluate the forage quality, and the calculation is simple and easy to promote in the market. Commonly used roughage nutritional indicators are shown in Table 8.
[0078] This experiment further utilized different forage quality evaluation models in the prior art and performed quality evaluation based on the commonly used feed raw materials provided in NASEM (Nutrient Requirements of Dairy Cattle: Seventh Revised Edition, 2021. Washington, DC: National Academies Press, 2021). The results showed that the quality rankings of different forages by each model were consistent, further proving that the FQI constructed by the present invention can be promoted and applied as a forage evaluation model. See Table 7 for details.
[0079] Table 7 Evaluation and ranking of commonly used roughage by different forage quality evaluation models
[0080]
[0081] Table 8 Commonly used roughage nutritional indicators in NRC
[0082]
[0083] Experimental Example 2 Correlation analysis test between the FQI constructed by the present invention and the organic matter yield per unit grassland forage (OM-yield)
[0084] Based on the current FQI comprehensive index, the correlation between FQI and unit grassland forage organic matter yield (OM-yield) was verified, and it was found that forage quality and forage organic matter yield were negatively correlated (R 2 =0.7786)( Figure 5 ). Therefore, the FQI constructed by the present invention can be used to control the quality and yield of forage and provide a reference for the forage harvest time.
Claims
1. A method for evaluating the relative feeding value of forage, characterized in that: include: (1) Determine the crude protein, 48-hour in vitro digestibility of neutral detergent fiber, and ash-corrected neutral detergent fiber nutritional indexes of the forage to be evaluated; (2) The FQI score is calculated using the following formula: FQI = S CP ×0.7153+S NDFD48 ×0.1485+S aNDFom ×0.1362; The S CP The calculation method of the score is as follows: Determine the crude protein nutritional index of the forage to be evaluated; if the crude protein nutritional index is less than or equal to 4, then S CP The value is 0.1; if the crude protein nutrition index is greater than or equal to 28, then S CP The value is 1.0; if the crude protein nutritional index is greater than 4 and less than 28, calculate S according to the following formula CP value: S CP= Where Xi is the crude protein nutritional index corresponding to the tested forage, L is 4, and U is 28; The S NDFD48 The calculation method of the score is as follows: determine the 48-hour neutral detergent fiber in vitro digestibility nutritional index of the forage to be evaluated; if the 48-hour neutral detergent fiber in vitro digestibility nutritional index is less than or equal to 27, then S NDFD48 The value is 0.1; if the 48-hour neutral detergent fiber in vitro digestibility nutritional index is greater than or equal to 68, then S NDFD48 The value is 1.0; if the 48-hour neutral detergent fiber in vitro digestibility nutritional index is greater than 27 and less than 68, calculate S according to the following formula NDFD48 value: S NDFD48= Where Xi is the 48-hour in vitro digestibility of neutral detergent fiber corresponding to the tested forage, L is 27, and U is 68; The S aNDFom The calculation method of the score is as follows: determine the ash-corrected neutral detergent fiber nutritional index of the forage to be evaluated; if the ash-corrected neutral detergent fiber nutritional index is less than or equal to 28, then S aNDFom The value is 0.1; if the ash-corrected neutral detergent fiber nutrition index is greater than or equal to 78, then S aNDFom The value is 1.0; if the ash-corrected neutral detergent fiber nutrition index is greater than 28 and less than 78, calculate S according to the following formula aNDFom value: S aNDFom= Where Xi is the ash-corrected neutral detergent fiber nutritional index corresponding to the tested forage, L is 28, and U is 78; (3) When the FQI score is greater than 0.8, the quality grade of the forage to be evaluated is special grade; when the FQI score is between 0.75-0.8, the quality grade of the forage to be evaluated is first grade; when the FQI score is between 0.67-0.75, the quality grade of the forage to be evaluated is second grade; when the FQI score is between 0.54-0.67, the quality grade of the forage to be evaluated is third grade; when the FQI score is less than 0.54, the quality grade of the forage to be evaluated is fourth grade or above.
