Test method for lossless recovery of explosion-formed bullets with large length-diameter ratio
By calculating the dynamic pressure and resistance of the medium, selecting the appropriate recovery medium and design device size, the problem of deformation and damage of the explosion-forming projectiles in the recycling process is solved, and lossless recycling is achieved, providing for the molding and pneumatic analysis of the projectiles. Data support is provided to improve the success rate and reliability of the trial.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411249489.6
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-09-06
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
AI Technical Summary
The existing technology is difficult to achieve lossless recovery of large-length diameter-bias-bias projectiles. Common recycling media leads to adverse phenomena such as thick pier deformation, wear and damage during the recycling process, especially due to the longer length of the projectile and greater penetration energy. , resulting in a significant increase in recycling difficulty.
By calculating the dynamic pressure and resistance of the medium, selecting the appropriate recycling medium, analyzing the characteristic parameters of the projectile molding, estimating the required length and device size of the recycling medium, using the medium density increment method, designing a lossless recycling plan, and arranging testing equipment for testing to ensure that the projectile is Lossless state during recycling.
The non-destructive recovery of large-length-diameter explosion-formed projectiles is achieved, providing prerequisites for their molding form, microstructure and pneumatic analysis, improving the success rate and reliability of recycling tests, and is suitable for high-speed projectiles of different shapes and sizes. .
Smart Images

Figure CN118913032A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention belongs to the technical field of projectiles, and in particular relates to a test method for non-destructive recovery of explosively formed projectiles with a large aspect ratio. Background Art
[0002] With the continuous improvement of armored target protection capabilities, it is urgent to improve the destructive capability of explosively formed projectiles (EFPs). Large aspect ratios have become the focus of current research on EFP warhead technology. Since detonation-driven EFP forming is a typical high-temperature, high-pressure, high-strain rate and destructive process, the entire action process is a microsecond event, which manifests as multi-media interaction under transient conditions. It is a typical experimental science. Theoretical analysis and numerical simulation are more of a reference and must be based on a large amount of solid factual materials. By non-destructively recovering EFP, the forming morphology, microstructure, and strain of the projectile can be obtained, which provides basic data for the analysis of the plastic deformation mechanism and forming mechanism of the liner under detonation loading, and provides an original model for EFP aerodynamic analysis, which is of great significance to the design of EFP warheads.
[0003] At present, the recovery of high-speed projectiles is mainly carried out by Figure 2 The recovery device is shown as being loaded with one or more soft media. By arranging the recovery device in the direction of the projectile trajectory, the high-speed projectile is decelerated and stopped to complete the recovery of the high-speed projectile. The soft media commonly used for recovery are mainly water, sand, gelatin, vermiculite, sawdust, foamed plastic, perlite powder, flour, soap, etc.
[0004] Unlike rigid projectiles such as high-speed penetrators, armor-piercing shells, and electromagnetic railgun shells, EFP is an ultra-high-speed flexible projectile, which is very prone to adverse phenomena such as roughening and deformation of the projectile body and wear and tear during the recovery process. LIN Jia-Jian et al. used water medium to directly recover EFP in "Numerical and Experimental Study on Explosively Formed Projectile with Fins" (Journal of High Pressure Physics, 2009(03): 215-222), and the head of the EFP was damaged and the whole was roughened and deformed. After adopting a soft recovery device with gradually increasing recovery medium density, Lu Ming et al. conducted a recovery test on EFP with a speed of about 2300 m / s in "Experimental Study on High-Speed EFP Soft Recovery Technology" (Journal of Explosives and Propellants, 2008(05): 38-42), and found that the recovered EFP was severely deformed and broken; the EFP breakage phenomenon that occurred during recovery also appeared in JianFeng Liu et al.'s "Dynamic Response and Microstructure Evolution of Oxygen-Free High-Conductivity Copper Liner in Explosively Formed Projectile" (Latin American Journal of Solids and Structures, 2017(14): 2089-2106) and Jiacheng Peng et al.'s "Explosively Formed Projectile from Stepped Casing Shaped Charge: Formation Mechanism of Canted Fins" (Journal of Energetic Materials, 2022, 2064937). Obviously, the adverse phenomena such as roughening deformation and wear damage during the recovery process are the main factors affecting the lossless recovery of EFP. In addition, due to the longer length and greater penetration energy of the large aspect ratio explosively formed projectile, the probability of adverse phenomena is further increased, and the difficulty of lossless recovery is significantly increased. Summary of the invention
[0005] In order to overcome the shortcomings of the prior art, the present invention provides a test method for non-destructive recovery of explosively formed projectiles with a large aspect ratio. First, the dynamic pressure of the medium is calculated, and then the maximum density of the recovery medium is estimated, and the recovery medium is selected; the forming characteristic parameters of the recovered EFP are analyzed to obtain the motion equation of the EFP in the recovery medium, and the required length of the recovery medium is estimated; the displacement ratio of the lateral offset of the projectile to the axial flight is calculated, and the cross-sectional size of the recovery device is estimated; the EFP recovery position is estimated, and the non-destructive recovery scheme design of the EFP is completed; the EFP warhead, recovery device and test equipment are arranged, and a non-destructive recovery test is carried out. The present invention can realize the non-destructive recovery of the EFP with a large aspect ratio, and creates the prerequisite for the EFP forming morphology, microstructure and strain conditions and aerodynamic analysis.
[0006] The technical solution adopted by the present invention to solve the technical problem is as follows:
[0007] Step 1: Calculate the medium dynamic pressure based on the material properties and flight speed of the recovered EFP, and then estimate the maximum density of the recovery medium and select the recovery medium;
[0008] Step 2: Analyze the molding characteristic parameters of the recycled EFP, obtain the motion equation of the EFP in the recycling medium according to Newton's second law, and estimate the required length of the recycling medium;
[0009] Step 3: Based on the flight stability of the recovered EFP, calculate the displacement ratio of the projectile's lateral deflection to the axial flight displacement and estimate the cross-sectional dimensions of the recovery device;
[0010] Step 4: The lossless recovery scheme adopts the method of increasing the density of the recovery medium, repeating steps 1 to 3, clarifying the recovery medium and its size in each section one by one, estimating the EFP recovery position, and completing the design of the EFP lossless recovery scheme;
[0011] Step 5: Arrange the EFP warhead, recovery device and test equipment to ensure that the EFP ballistic line is consistent with the center of the recovery device, and conduct non-destructive recovery tests.
[0012] Furthermore, the step 1 is specifically as follows:
[0013] Step 1-1: When the high-speed penetrator enters the soft medium, the pressure it is subjected to is the dynamic pressure, denoted as P, which satisfies the following formula:
[0014]
[0015] Where v is the instantaneous velocity of the penetrator in the recovery medium, ρ m is the density of the recovery medium;
[0016] Step 1-2: According to formula (1), the velocity v0 of the penetrator entering the recovery medium and the maximum pressure P that the penetrator can withstand without plastic deformation are max Estimate the maximum density of the recovery medium ρ max ,Right now:
[0017]
[0018] Where P max It can be estimated by the compressive strength σ of the projectile;
[0019] Step 1-3: Based on the estimated maximum density of the recovery medium ρ max , select Recovery Media.
[0020] Furthermore, the step 2 is specifically as follows:
[0021] Step 2-1: Assumptions: EFP is an axisymmetric body of revolution with a smooth surface; gravity can be ignored when the speed of EFP exceeds the set value, and the temperature effect of the penetration process is not considered; when the mass loss of EFP in the recovery medium is less than the set value, the mass change can be ignored; the speed of EFP when recovering the medium is higher than the critical speed, and the drag coefficient of the projectile is a constant that is independent of the flight speed;
[0022] Step 2-2: Based on the assumptions in step 2-1, Newton's second law shows that the resistance F encountered by the projectile during the vertical penetration of the EFP into the recovery medium is:
[0023]
[0024] In the formula, C D is the dimensionless drag coefficient of the recovery medium on the projectile, A is the maximum contact area between EFP and the medium;
[0025] Step 2-3: Integrate equation (3) to obtain the recovery medium length L required to recover EFP: m :
[0026]
[0027] Where v0 is the projectile incident velocity;
[0028] Step 2-4: For the recovery medium with unknown resistance coefficient, its resistance coefficient is calculated by the following method:
[0029] By integrating equation (3), the speed-distance and speed-time relationships of EFP are obtained:
[0030]
[0031] Where L is the distance traveled by the projectile, and t is the time traveled by the projectile.
[0032] Furthermore, the step 3 is specifically as follows:
[0033] When the projectile is in stable flight, the displacement ratio of its lateral movement to its axial movement is no more than 0.02, so the side length l of the cross section of the recovery box is greater than 0.04L, that is:
[0034] l≥0.04L (6).
[0035] Furthermore, in step 4, the terminal speed is calculated to 50 m / s.
[0036] The beneficial effects of the present invention are as follows:
[0037] 1. The non-destructive recovery test method of the present invention can realize the non-destructive recovery of EFP with large aspect ratio, and creates the prerequisite for the EFP forming morphology, microstructure and strain as well as aerodynamic analysis.
[0038] 2. Compared with recycling based on experience or reference to relevant tests, the present invention forms a theoretical basis for material selection and size design of the recycling medium, which can obtain key parameters of the test design more economically and quickly, and improve the success rate and reliability of the recycling test.
[0039] 3. Since the calculation method and test arrangement of the present invention are universal, they can be applied to the recovery of EFP and other high-speed projectiles of different shapes and sizes, and have a wide range of applications. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0040] Figure 1 is a flow chart of the method of the present invention;
[0041] Figure 2 It is a common soft recovery device used for high-speed projectile recovery;
[0042] Figure 3 It is a schematic diagram of the test arrangement of non-destructive recovery of explosively formed projectiles with large aspect ratio according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0043] Figure 4 Comparison diagram of EFP and X-ray imaging test for lossless recovery according to an embodiment of the present invention, (a) actual soft recovery, (b) X-ray imaging test. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0044] The present invention is further described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and embodiments.
[0045] The purpose of the present invention is to solve the technical problem that the existing test technology is difficult to avoid the adverse phenomena such as roughening deformation, wear and tear of EFP during recovery, and realize the non-destructive recovery of large aspect ratio explosively formed projectiles.
[0046] Combination Figure 1, a test method for non-destructive recovery of explosively formed projectiles with a large aspect ratio, specifically comprising the following steps:
[0047] Step 1: Calculate the medium dynamic pressure according to the material properties and flight speed of the recovered EFP, and then estimate the maximum density of the recovered medium and select the recovered medium.
[0048] When a high-speed penetrator penetrates a soft medium with a very low compressive strength, the pressure is dynamic pressure, denoted as P, and the pressure along the axial direction is denoted as P, which satisfies the following formula:
[0049]
[0050] Where v is the instantaneous velocity of the penetrator in the recovery medium, ρ m is the density of the recovery medium.
[0051] According to formula (1), the velocity v0 of the penetrator entering the recovery medium and the maximum pressure P that the penetrator can withstand without plastic deformation are: max The maximum density of the recovery medium can be estimated max ,Right now:
[0052]
[0053] Where P max It can be estimated by the compressive strength σ of the projectile. Due to the tensile strain and detonation effect during the EFP forming process, the strain rate of the projectile material increases, the temperature rises, and the yield strength σ changes. To improve accuracy, the compressive strength σ of the projectile can be calculated based on the corresponding strain rate and temperature.
[0054] According to the estimated maximum density of the recovery medium ρ max , select Recovery Media.
[0055] According to relevant data, the density of pure water at room temperature is 1g / cm 3 , the density of tap water is about 0.997g / cm 3 ; Wood is about 0.35~0.95g / cm 3 , sawdust is about 0.4~0.6g / cm 3 ; Fine sand is about 1.6g / cm 3 , coarse sand is about 1.65g / cm 3 , water-containing sand is about 1.65~1.7g / cm 3 ; Polystyrene foam is about 0.02~0.06g / cm 3 ; Vermiculite is about 0.056g / cm 3 ; Glass fiber is about 0.256g / cm 3 ; Pearlite powder is about 0.09g / cm3 ; Foamed plastic is about 0.01~0.03g / cm 3 In addition, when selecting the recovery medium, full consideration should be given to: impact absorption (strong ability to absorb external impact during compression), process and processing (easy to cut and process), and economy (low price and easy to obtain).
[0056] Step 2: Analyze the molding characteristic parameters of the recovered EFP, obtain the motion equation of the EFP in the recovery medium according to Newton's second law, and estimate the required length of the recovery medium.
[0057] Assumptions: EFP is an axisymmetric body of revolution with a smooth surface; the speed of EFP is so high that the gravity effect can be ignored, and the temperature effect of the penetration process is not considered; the mass loss of EFP in the recovery medium is small and the mass change can be ignored; the speed of EFP passing through the main part of the recovery medium is higher than the critical speed, and the drag coefficient of the projectile is a constant that is independent of the flight speed. Based on the above assumptions, it is easy to obtain from Newton's second law that the drag F of the projectile during the vertical penetration of the EFP into the recovery medium is:
[0058]
[0059] Where v is the projectile velocity, C D is the dimensionless resistance coefficient of the recovery medium to the projectile, and A is the maximum contact area between EFP and the medium.
[0060] Integrate equation (2) and make a slight transformation to obtain the recovery medium length L required to recover EFP: m :
[0061]
[0062] Where v0 is the projectile incident velocity.
[0063] According to relevant data, for the deceleration process of high-speed projectiles such as EFP, the resistance coefficient of polystyrene foam is about 0.77-0.84, vermiculite is about 0.88, glass fiber is about 0.94, perlite powder is about 0.87, and foam plastic is about 0.70-0.73. In addition, for the recovery medium with unknown resistance coefficient, its resistance coefficient can be calculated by the following method:
[0064] By integrating equation (2), we can obtain the speed-distance and speed-time relationships of EFP:
[0065]
[0066] Where L is the distance traveled by the projectile, and t is the time traveled by the projectile.
[0067] EFP initial velocity v0, mass m, contact area A, medium density ρ m It is known that the travel L of the recovery medium can be measured, and the projectile flight time t and instantaneous velocity v can be measured by the velocity target. From this, the resistance coefficient C of this recovery medium on the penetrator can be obtained. D .
[0068] Step 3, based on the flight stability of the recovered EFP, calculate the displacement ratio of the projectile's lateral deflection to the axial flight and estimate the cross-sectional dimensions of the recovery device.
[0069] According to relevant data, when an ordinary projectile flies stably (without flipping in flight), the displacement ratio of its lateral movement to its axial movement is no more than 0.02, so the side length l (or diameter D) of the cross section of the recovery box should be greater than 0.04L, that is:
[0070] l≥0.04L (6)
[0071] Step 4: The lossless recovery scheme adopts the method of increasing the recovery medium density, repeating steps 1 to 3, clarifying each section of recovery medium and its size one by one, estimating the EFP recovery position, and completing the design of the EFP lossless recovery scheme.
[0072] To facilitate the arrangement of non-destructive recovery test, the recovery stroke should be reduced as much as possible while ensuring the quality of projectile recovery. Considering that the lower the projectile speed, the lower the requirement for the recovery medium density, when the speed is lower than a certain level, the recovery medium density can be appropriately increased to enhance the recovery effect, and a recovery medium density increasing scheme should be adopted. By calculating the speed drop and flight length of each EFP section, the recovery medium and its size at the corresponding position can be determined. Among them, the terminal speed can be calculated to 50m / s.
[0073] Step 5, follow Figure 3 The schematic diagram of the test layout is shown, which arranges the EFP warhead, recovery device and test equipment to ensure that the EFP ballistic line is consistent with the center of the recovery device and carry out non-destructive recovery tests.
[0074] Example:
[0075] The EFP used in the embodiment has an aspect ratio of 3.39, is formed by explosion of pure tantalum liner, has a flight speed of 1220 m / s, a material yield strength of 270-340 MPa, and a mass of 136 g. Combined with the simulation calculation data, it can be obtained that its frontal area is about 8.44 cm 2 .
[0076] Step 1: Calculate the maximum pressure that the EFP can withstand without plastic deformation based on the speed of the projectile entering the recovery medium. Take the minimum yield strength of the projectile (270 MPa) to calculate the density of the recovery medium ρ. max 0.36g / cm 3, that is, the incident recovery medium density shall not exceed 0.36g / cm 3 Accordingly, if the projectile speed is reduced to 900m / s, the recovery medium density shall not exceed 0.67g / cm 3 ; If the projectile speed is reduced to 600m / s, the recovery medium density shall not exceed 1.5g / cm 3 On this basis, the recovery medium is selected according to the difficulty of obtaining it.
[0077] Step 2: Select polystyrene foam (0.02 g / cm 3 ) is the first recovery medium, and the resistance coefficient is calculated as 0.77. Through the EFP motion equation in the recovery medium, it is obtained that the required distance for the EFP to slow down by about 1 / 3 is 10m.
[0078] Step 3. According to relevant data, the displacement ratio of the projectile's lateral offset to its axial flight is approximately 0.02, so the side length L of the recovery box cross section should be greater than 0.04z, and the side length of the recovery box in the first 10m should not be less than 0.4m.
[0079] Step 4: The non-destructive recycling scheme adopts the recycling medium density increasing method, repeating steps 1 to 3, and specifying the recycling medium and its size in each section one by one. The recycling scheme is specified as "polystyrene foam + polyurethane foam + sawdust + water tank". The EFP enters the recycling process after flying 5m, in which polystyrene foam (0.02g / cm 3 ) section is 3m, polyurethane foam (0.04g / cm 3 ) section is 1.5m + polyurethane foam (0.06g / cm 3 ) section is 1.5m, sawdust (0.04g / cm 3 ) section is 4m, water tank (0.997g / cm 3 ) is 1m, a total of 16m. According to calculations, EFP should be recovered at a position of 13m to 15m.
[0080] Step 5: Arrange the EFP warhead, recovery device and test equipment to ensure that the EFP trajectory is consistent with the center of the recovery device, and conduct a non-destructive recovery test. According to the test results, a complete EFP was recovered from the fourth wooden box of sawdust. The recovered EFP was weighed to 133.69g, with a mass recovery rate of more than 98%. Figure 4 As shown in the figure, the recovered EFP was compared with the X-ray results. The recovered EFP had good consistency with the X-ray test, and the non-destructive recovery of the EFP with a large aspect ratio of more than 3 was achieved.
Claims
1. A test method for non-destructive recovery of explosively formed projectiles with large aspect ratio, characterized in that: The steps include: Step 1: Calculate the medium dynamic pressure based on the material properties and flight speed of the recovered EFP, and then estimate the maximum density of the recovery medium and select the recovery medium; Step 2: Analyze the molding characteristic parameters of the recycled EFP, obtain the motion equation of the EFP in the recycling medium according to Newton's second law, and estimate the required length of the recycling medium; Step 3: Based on the flight stability of the recovered EFP, calculate the displacement ratio of the projectile's lateral deflection to the axial flight displacement and estimate the cross-sectional dimensions of the recovery device; Step 4: The lossless recovery scheme adopts the method of increasing the density of the recovery medium, repeating steps 1 to 3, clarifying the recovery medium and its size in each section one by one, estimating the EFP recovery position, and completing the design of the EFP lossless recovery scheme; Step 5: Arrange the EFP warhead, recovery device and test equipment to ensure that the EFP ballistic line is consistent with the center of the recovery device, and conduct non-destructive recovery tests.
2. A test method for non-destructive recovery of explosively formed projectiles with large aspect ratio according to claim 1, characterized in that: The step 1 is specifically as follows: Step 1-1: When the high-speed penetrator enters the soft medium, the pressure it is subjected to is the dynamic pressure, denoted as P, which satisfies the following formula: Where v is the instantaneous velocity of the penetrator in the recovery medium, ρ m is the density of the recovery medium; Step 1-2: According to formula (1), the velocity v0 of the penetrator entering the recovery medium and the maximum pressure P that the penetrator can withstand without plastic deformation are max Estimate the maximum density of the recovery medium ρ max ,Right now: Where P max It can be estimated by the compressive strength σ of the projectile; Step 1-3: Based on the estimated maximum density of the recovery medium ρ max , select Recovery Media.
3. A test method for non-destructive recovery of explosively formed projectiles with large aspect ratio according to claim 2, characterized in that: The step 2 is specifically as follows: Step 2-1: Assumptions: EFP is an axisymmetric body of revolution with a smooth surface; gravity can be ignored when the speed of EFP exceeds the set value, and the temperature effect of the penetration process is not considered; when the mass loss of EFP in the recovery medium is less than the set value, the mass change can be ignored; the speed of EFP when recovering the medium is higher than the critical speed, and the drag coefficient of the projectile is a constant that is independent of the flight speed; Step 2-2: Based on the assumptions in step 2-1, Newton's second law shows that the resistance F encountered by the projectile during the vertical penetration of the EFP into the recovery medium is: In the formula, C D is the dimensionless drag coefficient of the recovery medium on the projectile, A is the maximum contact area between EFP and the medium; Step 2-3: Integrate equation (3) to obtain the recovery medium length L required to recover EFP: m : Where v0 is the projectile incident velocity; Step 2-4: For the recovery medium with unknown resistance coefficient, its resistance coefficient is calculated by the following method: By integrating equation (3), the speed-distance and speed-time relationships of EFP are obtained: Where L is the distance traveled by the projectile, and t is the time traveled by the projectile.
4. A test method for non-destructive recovery of explosively formed projectiles with large aspect ratio according to claim 3, characterized in that: The step 3 is specifically as follows: When the projectile is in stable flight, the displacement ratio of its lateral movement to its axial movement is no more than 0.02, so the side length l of the cross section of the recovery box is greater than 0.04L, that is: l≥0.04L (6)。 5. A test method for non-destructive recovery of explosively formed projectiles with large aspect ratio according to claim 4, characterized in that: In step 4, the terminal speed is calculated to 50 m / s.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Soft recovery method of storage testing device embedded in high-speed flying body
CN103604321A
Lossless shot recovery device
CN110595301A
Multi-stage soft recovery method for high-speed test projectiles and auxiliary device thereof
CN112781451A
Systems and methods for projectile recovery
US20030200800A1
Bullet test tube and method
US7421893B1
