Method for identifying pneumatic instability in starting process of gas turbine
Through the pneumatic test and data analysis of the single rotor generator of the gas turbine, the pneumatic instability caused by rotation stall during the start of the gas turbine is identified, which solves the difficult problem of identification in the existing technology, and achieves rapid and accurate instability identification and fault analysis support. .
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410967120.2
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-18
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
- Estimated Expiration
- 2044-07-18
AI Technical Summary
The prior art is difficult to quickly and accurately identify aerodynamic instability caused by rotational stall during starting of gas turbines, especially due to the complex relationship between the stall time frequency characteristics of different models of engines and the degree of aerodynamic instability, which leads to difficulty in identification.
By conducting pneumatic tests of single rotor generator of gas turbine, collecting data, calculating similar gas temperature parameters Tt4/Tt2 before gas turbine, establishing working point influence curves, optimizing the speed characteristic lines, and judging the pneumatic process working lines and the parking downward rotation process working lines The difference in the combustion chamber oil and gas ratio is determined to determine the pneumatic instability.
It has achieved rapid and accurate identification of whether the gas turbine stalls and instability levels during starting, and supports timely measures to ensure the safe operation and failure analysis of the gas turbine.
Smart Images

Figure CN118913702A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present application belongs to the field of gas turbine stall identification, and in particular relates to a method for identifying aerodynamic instability during the start-up process of a gas turbine. Background Art
[0002] The process of a gas turbine rapidly transitioning from one stable working state to another is called a transition state, which includes the starting process, acceleration process, deceleration process, loading process, and unloading process. The aerodynamically unstable working state (i.e., aerodynamic instability) of a gas turbine (generally the compressor component is axial flow) usually takes two forms: compressor rotating stall and surge. The aerodynamic instability of a gas turbine can lead to a significant drop in gas turbine performance at the mildest, or serious mechanical damage to the gas turbine at the worst. Therefore, it is very important to accurately, quickly, and conveniently identify the aerodynamic instability of the gas turbine operation, and then take countermeasures as soon as possible to ensure the safe operation of the gas turbine.
[0003] Rotating stall is an unstable phenomenon in which the flow rate and outlet pressure experience high-frequency oscillations when the compressor operating point is close to the surge boundary, which manifests as one or more stall groups propagating circumferentially, resulting in non-axisymmetric pulsation of the airflow. Rotating stall usually occurs in the low speed area, generally during the start-up process of the gas turbine. Generally, a time-frequency characteristic analysis method is used to determine whether the gas turbine is stalled and then to identify whether the gas turbine is aerodynamically unstable. The surge characteristics are obvious and easy to identify. The present invention mainly relates to aerodynamic instability caused by rotating stall.
[0004] At present, the time-frequency characteristic analysis method is generally used to determine whether the gas turbine is stalled. However, since the stall generally gradually changes from the initial stage of stall precursors to the mature stall stage, the corresponding airflow gradually develops from normal flow to the mature stall stage of aerodynamic instability, and the compressor pressure ratio and flow rate are greatly reduced.
[0005] The corresponding relationship between the stall time-frequency characteristics of different models of engines and the degree of aerodynamic instability of gas turbines is complex and changeable, and generally there is no clear rule. Therefore, it is difficult to quickly and accurately determine the degree of aerodynamic instability of gas turbines. For example, it is currently known that many types of gas turbines have stall time-frequency characteristics, but some models of engines are aerodynamically stable, while some models of engines are seriously aerodynamically unstable, causing the engine to fail to work normally.
[0006] Therefore, how to quickly and accurately identify whether a gas turbine is stalled is a problem that needs to be solved. Summary of the invention
[0007] The purpose of this application is to provide a method for identifying aerodynamic instability during the starting process of a gas turbine, so as to solve the problem that the corresponding relationship between the stall time-frequency characteristics of different types of engines and the degree of aerodynamic instability of the gas turbine is complex and changeable, and difficult to accurately identify.
[0008] The technical solution of the present application is: a method for identifying aerodynamic instability during the start-up process of a gas turbine, comprising:
[0009] Conduct gas turbine aerodynamic tests on gas turbine single rotor generators and collect aerodynamic test data, including the compressor inlet total temperature T t2 , compressor inlet total pressure p t2 , total temperature at combustion chamber outlet T t4 and compressor inlet air flow mass q ma ;
[0010] Set the similarity parameter T of the gas temperature before the gas turbine t4 / T t2 , the similarity parameter T of the gas temperature before the gas turbine at different working points is calculated and statistically analyzed by aerodynamic test data t4 / T t2 The value of is used to establish the compressor operating point influence curve;
[0011] Establishing constant speed characteristic lines based on aerodynamic test data by and T t4 / T t2 is a variable, discretize the compressor operating point influence curve, obtain a series of discrete operating points, calculate the detailed performance parameters of each discrete operating point, and n is the gas turbine speed;
[0012] Obtain the constraints or given control rules corresponding to the compressor, and The discrete working points that meet the constraints or given control laws are selected in the upper optimization, and the corresponding discrete working points are connected in sequence to obtain the corresponding discrete working lines;
[0013] The starting process working line and the shutdown and reduction process working line in the discrete working line are compared to determine whether the difference between the combustion chamber oil-gas ratio of the aerodynamic process working line and the combustion chamber oil-gas ratio of the shutdown and reduction process working line is greater than the first threshold value. If so, it is determined that when the compressor is working normally, the starting process working line is closer to the surge boundary than the shutdown and reduction process working line; if not, it is determined that the gas turbine is stalled and aerodynamically unstable during the starting and rising process.
[0014] Preferably, when the high-pressure turbine guide vane is in a critical or supercritical state, the gas temperature before the gas turbine is similar to the parameter T t4 T t2 is a constant; when the high-pressure turbine guide vane is in a subcritical state, the similarity parameter T of the gas temperature before the gas turbine t4 T t2 Is not a constant.
[0015] Preferably, the constant speed characteristic line The larger the value of is, the closer the operating points are to the surge boundary.
[0016] Preferably, any operating point on the compressor operating point influence curve of the gas turbine single rotor generator corresponds to a unique (T t4 / T t2 , coordinate.
[0017] Preferably, gas turbine overall performance calculation software is used to calculate the detailed performance parameters of each discrete operating point.
[0018] Preferably, the first threshold is obtained through gas turbine aerodynamic testing and interpolation.
[0019] The method for identifying aerodynamic instability during the gas turbine startup process of the present application uses aerodynamic measurement parameters during the gas turbine operation process to quickly and accurately identify whether the compressor is stalled and aerodynamically unstable during the startup process and the degree of stall, thereby supporting the taking of countermeasures as soon as possible to ensure the safe operation of the gas turbine and analyze the cause of gas turbine failure. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0020] In order to more clearly illustrate the technical solution provided by the present application, the following is a brief introduction to the accompanying drawings. Obviously, the accompanying drawings described below are only some embodiments of the present application.
[0021] Figure 1 This is a schematic diagram of the overall process of this application;
[0022] Figure 2 This is a schematic diagram of the influence curve of the steady-state operating point of the compressor in this application;
[0023] Figure 3 This is a schematic diagram of the discretization of the working point of the single-rotor gas generator for this application;
[0024] Figure 4 This is a schematic diagram of the discrete working line of the transition state of this application;
[0025] Figure 5 This is a schematic diagram comparing the starting working line and the stopping and reducing working line during the normal working process of the gas turbine in this application;
[0026] Figure 6 This is a schematic diagram of the stall identification method during the gas turbine startup process of this application. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0027] The following will be combined with the drawings in the embodiments of the present invention to clearly and completely describe the technical solutions in the embodiments of the present invention. Obviously, the described embodiments are only part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the scope of protection of the present invention.
[0028] A method for identifying aerodynamic instability during the starting process of a gas turbine. The principle and technical solution of the present invention are explained below using a gas turbine with a single-rotor gas generator (composed of an axial flow compressor, a combustion chamber and a gas turbine) as an example. The present invention is also applicable to single-rotor core engines of gas turbines with other structures.
[0029] like Figure 1 As shown, the specific design is as follows:
[0030] Step S100, performing a gas turbine aerodynamic test of a gas turbine single rotor generator, collecting aerodynamic test data, the aerodynamic test data including the compressor inlet total temperature T t2 , compressor inlet total pressure p t2 , total temperature at combustion chamber outlet T t4 and compressor inlet air flow mass q ma wait.
[0031] Step S200, according to the gas turbine aerodynamic performance principle, when the single-rotor gas generator works in a steady state, the various components restrict each other. Through the airflow mass flow balance relationship, pressure balance relationship, and the equal physical speed of the compressor and turbine, it can be deduced that the compressor pressure ratio π of the single-rotor gas generator satisfies formula (1):
[0032]
[0033] Where:
[0034] where σ b is the total pressure recovery coefficient of the combustion chamber, σ t Total pressure recovery coefficient from the gas turbine guide vane inlet to the throat section, A t is the critical cross-sectional area of the gas turbine guide vane, q(λ t ) is the aerodynamic function of the throat section of the gas turbine guide vane;
[0035] T t2 -Compressor inlet total temperature;
[0036] T t4 -Total temperature at combustion chamber outlet;
[0037] q ma - Compressor inlet air mass flow;
[0038] p t2 -Compressor inlet total pressure.
[0039] From formula (1), we can see that:
[0040] 1) When the high-pressure turbine guide vane is in a critical or supercritical state, q(λ t )=1, K value can be approximately considered as a constant. In this case, when the gas temperature before the gas turbine is similar to the parameter T t4 T t2 When the air flow through the gas turbine is constant, the similarity parameter It is proportional to the compressor pressure ratio π. On the compressor characteristic diagram, a slope of Take a series of similar parameters T of gas temperature before gas turbine t4 T t2 By using the value of , we can get a series of straight lines on the compressor characteristic diagram, which are the compressor operating point influence curves, such as Figure 2 . With T t4 T t2 =const value increases, the working point along the constant speed characteristic line Move closer to the surge boundary, n is the gas turbine speed.
[0041] 2) When the gas turbine is in the low speed area, the compressor pressure ratio π is low, and the gas turbine guide vane is in the subcritical state, q(λ t )<1, the K value in formula (1) is no longer a constant, and the compressor pressure ratio π is similar to the flow rate parameter It is no longer a proportional relationship, but a curve relationship passing through the point π=1 on the ordinate axis, see Figure 2 .
[0042] When a single-rotor gas generator is working in a transient state, the performance parameters of the engine working state change with time, there may be accumulation and release of energy and mass between each section, the flow of each section is no longer continuous (i.e., volume effect), and there is unsteady heat exchange between the airflow and the blades and casing walls. In fact, in transient operation, the volume of each component is small, and the change of aerodynamic thermodynamic process parameters is much faster than the change of speed, so the volume effect of these components and the unsteady heat exchange between the airflow and the blades and casing walls can be ignored.
[0043] It can be approximately considered that the flow rate of each section is still continuous at any time, and each component is in an instantaneous stable state, that is, the quasi-steady state assumption. After ignoring the volume effect of the components and the unsteady heat exchange, the overall performance mathematical model of the transition state operating point of the single-spool gas generator is the same except that it no longer satisfies the compressor and turbine power balance equation in the steady-state operating point joint working equation. Therefore, the transition state operating point, like the steady-state operating point, also satisfies formula (1). Therefore, any operating point on the single-spool compressor operating point influence curve corresponds to a unique (T t4 / T t2 , coordinate.
[0044] Through the above design, the compressor operating point influence curve diagram can be simplified to facilitate subsequent processing.
[0045] Step S300, with parameters and T t4 / T t2 As a variable, the compressor operating point influence curve is discretized to obtain a series of discrete operating points (such as Figure 3 ), and the gas turbine overall performance calculation software can be used to calculate the detailed performance parameters of each discrete operating point.
[0046] Step S400: According to the constraints of the corresponding compressor or the given control law, Optimize the selection of discrete working points that meet the constraints or given control laws from the discrete points on the constant speed characteristic line. The corresponding discrete working points are connected in sequence to form discrete working lines that meet the conditions. The discrete working lines include the starting process working line, the transition state working line, and the parking and downshifting working line.
[0047] When the engine is working normally, the T of the selected discrete working point t4 T t2 The larger the value, the closer the transition state working line is to the surge boundary line. Figure 4 Medium T t4 T t2 The transition working line 1 with a larger value is closer to the surge boundary line than the transition working line 2. For the same gas turbine with the same technical status, the combustion chamber oil-gas ratio and T t4 / T t2 There is a basic linear positive correlation and one-to-one correspondence. Therefore, if the oil-gas ratio in the gas turbine transition process is larger, the corresponding discrete working line is closer to the surge boundary.
[0048] Step S500, comparing the working lines of the gas turbine startup process and the shutdown and reduction process to identify whether the compressor is unstable: whether the difference between the combustion chamber oil-gas ratio of the startup process working line and the combustion chamber oil-gas ratio of the shutdown and reduction process working line is greater than the first threshold value, if so, it is judged that when the compressor is working normally, the startup process working line is closer to the surge boundary than the shutdown and reduction process working line, and the pressure ratio is higher at the same gas generator conversion speed (such as Figure 5 ); if not, it can be determined that the gas turbine stalls during the startup and ramp-up process and is aerodynamically unstable. The first threshold is set according to the actual gas turbine type and can be obtained through gas turbine aerodynamic testing and interpolation.
[0049] For example, Figure 6 The working lines of the start-up process and the flameout process in the same test of a gas turbine with a single-rotor gas generator are compared. After the gas turbine is successfully pneumatically ignited, the oil and gas in the combustion chamber is higher than that in the shutdown process, and the pressure ratio increases, indicating that the compressor is working normally. After that, after the compressor begins to stall, the pressure ratio decreases, and the start-up working line gradually decreases. When the start-up working line is very close to or lower than the working line of the shutdown process, it can be judged that the compressor has entered the mature stall stage, the gas turbine has been aerodynamically unstable, and the compressor cannot work normally.
[0050] Through the above design, aerodynamic measurement parameters of the gas turbine operation process are used to quickly and accurately identify whether the compressor is stalled and aerodynamically unstable during the startup process and the degree of stall, so as to support the rapid adoption of countermeasures to ensure the safe operation of the gas turbine and analyze the causes of gas turbine failures.
[0051] Finally, it should be noted that: the drawings of the embodiments disclosed in the present invention only involve structures related to the embodiments disclosed in the present invention, and other structures can refer to the general design. In the absence of conflict, the same embodiment and different embodiments of the present invention can be combined with each other;
[0052] Finally: The above description is only a preferred embodiment of the present invention and is not intended to limit the present invention. Any modifications, equivalent substitutions, improvements, etc. made within the spirit and principles of the present invention should be included in the protection scope of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for identifying aerodynamic instability during the start-up process of a gas turbine, characterized in that: include: Conduct gas turbine aerodynamic tests on gas turbine single rotor generators and collect aerodynamic test data, including the compressor inlet total temperature T t2 , compressor inlet total pressure p t2 , total temperature at combustion chamber outlet T t4 and compressor inlet air flow mass q ma ; Set the similarity parameter T of the gas temperature before the gas turbine t4 T t2 , the similarity parameter T of the gas temperature before the gas turbine at different working points is calculated and statistically analyzed by aerodynamic test data t4 T t2 The value of is used to establish the compressor operating point influence curve; Establishing constant speed characteristic lines based on aerodynamic test data by and T t4 T t2 is a variable, discretize the compressor operating point influence curve, obtain a series of discrete operating points, calculate the detailed performance parameters of each discrete operating point, and n is the gas turbine speed; Obtain the constraints or given control rules corresponding to the compressor, and The discrete working points that meet the constraints or given control laws are selected in the upper optimization, and the corresponding discrete working points are connected in sequence to obtain the corresponding discrete working lines; The starting process working line and the shutdown and reduction process working line in the discrete working line are compared to determine whether the difference between the combustion chamber oil-gas ratio of the aerodynamic process working line and the combustion chamber oil-gas ratio of the shutdown and reduction process working line is greater than the first threshold value. If so, it is determined that when the compressor is working normally, the starting process working line is closer to the surge boundary than the shutdown and reduction process working line; if not, it is determined that the gas turbine is stalled and aerodynamically unstable during the starting and rising process.
2. The method for identifying aerodynamic instability during the gas turbine startup process according to claim 1, characterized in that: When the high-pressure turbine guide vane is in a critical or supercritical state, the similarity parameter T of the gas temperature before the gas turbine t4 T t2 is a constant; when the high-pressure turbine guide vane is in a subcritical state, the similarity parameter T of the gas temperature before the gas turbine t4 T t2 Is not a constant.
3. The method for identifying aerodynamic instability during the gas turbine startup process according to claim 1, characterized in that: The constant speed characteristic line The larger the value of is, the closer the operating points are to the surge boundary.
4. The method for identifying aerodynamic instability during the gas turbine startup process according to claim 1, characterized in that: Any working point on the compressor working point influence curve of the gas turbine single rotor generator corresponds to a unique coordinate.
5. The method for identifying aerodynamic instability during gas turbine startup according to claim 1, characterized in that: The gas turbine overall performance calculation software is used to calculate the detailed performance parameters of each discrete operating point.
6. The method for identifying aerodynamic instability during the gas turbine startup process according to claim 1, characterized in that: The first threshold is obtained through gas turbine aerodynamic testing and interpolation.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Fuel control method and system for starting process of aero-engine
CN106321252A
Method and device for judging rotating stall of aero-gas turbine engine
CN110735669A
Gas turbine engine transition state working line design method
CN114676530A
Fuel cell system
JP2019145338A
