Risk map design method for operation of light and small urban air traffic unmanned aerial vehicle
By evaluating the operational reliability, safety and public acceptance of drones in urban environments, static and dynamic risk maps are built, and the safety, reliability and acceptance of urban air traffic drones are solved. , improve management efficiency and public acceptance, and promote the development of urban drone applications.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202310622821.8
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-30
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-03
AI Technical Summary
There are problems with safety, reliability and public acceptance in operation in large urban environments, and the existing technology lacks effective risk assessment and management methods.
A risk map method for air traffic drones in light and small cities was designed to build static and dynamic risk maps by evaluating the reliability, safety and public acceptance of drones in urban environments, using ArcGIS The module implements comprehensive risk assessment and visualization.
It provides a scientific basis for formulating flight plans, improves the safety and management efficiency of drone operations, increases the public's acceptance of drone urban operations, and promotes the development of urban drone applications.
Smart Images

Figure BDA0004255920400000036 
Figure BDA0004255920400000051 
Figure BDA0004255920400000052
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention is a risk map design method for the operation of light and small urban air traffic UAVs, and belongs to the field of UAV operation risk assessment. Background Art
[0002] With the rapid development of light and small UAVs, their development potential in civilian commercialization is huge, especially in the field of urban air traffic. However, at this stage, both logistics UAV delivery and manned eVTOL test flights are limited to remote suburbs or smaller cities. The deployment of UAV navigation, communication, and surveillance facilities in large urban scenes needs to be improved. The population and ground buildings are dense, the vehicle traffic is busy, the urban electromagnetic environment is complex, and the noise and operation safety costs are high. There are problems such as operational safety, operational reliability, and public acceptability in the operation of logistics UAVs in low-altitude urban airspace. The advancement of UAVs from remote areas to large cities urgently needs scientific methods to support it. Research on the operational risks of UAVs in urban air traffic has become a hot issue that has attracted widespread attention from the government, aviation industry, industry, and society.
[0003] Existing urban air traffic drone projects abroad mainly study the concepts of urban low-altitude airspace management, airspace structure design, non-isolated airspace operation rules, etc. There are few research results on the risks of urban low-altitude drone operations, but the risks that may be caused by drone operations over cities cannot be ignored. Summary of the invention
[0004] Purpose of the invention: The purpose of the present invention is to provide a risk map design method for the operation of light and small urban air traffic drones, focusing on the risks of urban low-altitude drone operations, comprehensively considering the operational safety, operational reliability, and public acceptability of drones in urban airspace, and constructing static and dynamic risk maps. This map can provide a scientific basis for the formulation of drone urban low-altitude flight plans and ensure flight safety. It has important theoretical value and practical significance.
[0005] Technical solution: A risk map design method for the operation of light and small urban air traffic drones, the design method comprising the following steps:
[0006] Step 1: Evaluate the reliability of drone operation based on the impact of the urban environment on drone operation and draw a reliability layer risk map;
[0007] Step 2: Based on the risk of drone collision in the city, evaluate the safety of drone operation and draw a risk map of operation safety layer. The evaluation of drone operation safety is divided into drone collision risk and third-party risk.
[0008] Step 3: Evaluate the public acceptability of drone operations from the perspective of the impact of drone noise on ground residents and potential privacy violations, and draw an acceptability map;
[0009] Step 4: Use ArcGIS module to draw static risk map, calculate comprehensive operational risk according to the risk assessed in the first three steps, and draw dynamic risk map.
[0010] Furthermore, the step 1 includes the following contents:
[0011] S1.1, refer to the "Interim Regulations on Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Flight Management (Draft for Comments)", set up no-fly zones for light and small drones, and determine whether the airspace is a no-fly zone;
[0012] S1.2, refer to the requirements for the UAV's resistance to wind, high and low temperature, and precipitation in the "Technical Requirements for Electric Multi-rotor Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (Light and Small) for Urban Logistics Systems", and use wind speed, temperature, and precipitation as evaluation indicators for meteorological environment reliability to evaluate the reliability of the meteorological environment in the set area;
[0013] S1.3, considering the distribution of ground broadcast communication base stations and high-voltage lines, evaluate the interference of GPS signals and electromagnetic interference of control links on drones;
[0014] S1.4, determine the communication environment according to the coverage and strength of the mobile communication network signal in the set area;
[0015] S1.5, determine the reliability of the navigation environment based on the number of satellite reception within the set area;
[0016] S1.6, after the indicators in steps 1.1 to 1.5 are determined, the relationship between the indicators is grasped by establishing the explanatory structure model ISM, and the weight of each indicator is calculated by the network analysis method ANP; finally, the operation reliability evaluation results are graded using the fuzzy comprehensive analysis method, and the operation reliability layer risk map is drawn based on the grading results.
[0017] Furthermore, the step 2 includes the following contents:
[0018] S2.1, calculate the collision probability between drones and the collision probability between drones and buildings,
[0019] S2.2, calculate the three-level indicators of third-party risk according to the collision probability, including the number of deaths caused by traffic accidents caused by drone crashes, property losses of ground buildings, and safety of ground facilities;
[0020] S2.3, use the fuzzy comprehensive analysis method to calculate and evaluate the third-party risks of ground personnel safety, ground vehicle safety, ground building property loss and ground facility safety, and divide the evaluation results into three risk levels: high, medium and low. Then use ISM and hierarchical analysis method to weighted sum and grade the indicator evaluation results to draw an operation safety layer risk map.
[0021] Furthermore, in step S2.1, when calculating the collision probability between drones, a drone safety envelope is established, and the collision probability is the integral of the probability density function of the drone in the safety envelope. Where p(T) is The probability density function of For in time The probability that the UAV is within the envelope when
[0022] When calculating the collision probability between obstacles, the flight altitude of the drone is assumed to follow a normal distribution. The height of the building is known, so the collision probability between the drone and the obstacle is: Among them, h0 is the obstacle height, h is the UAV flight height, μ is the mean of the UAV flight height, and σ is the standard deviation of the UAV flight height.
[0023] Furthermore, in step S2.2, the population density data D of the set area is obtained, and the drone radius R, maximum take-off weight m, pedestrian radius r, drone fall horizontal displacement d, fall speed v, and shielding factor E are collected; the collision fragment fall range C = π (r + R) is set 2 +2d(r+R), chance of causing fatal damage Collision kinetic energy Using the inter-UAV collision probability p in step S2.1 A (X) Calculate the estimated number of ground casualties in the set area N = P A (X)P F (X)CD, the number of deaths caused by traffic accidents caused by drone crashes P C (X) = P A (X)P M (X)N T , where P M (X) is the probability of a falling drone hitting a vehicle, N T is the average number of deaths caused by car accidents;
[0024] Get the building height h, the mean value μ, and the standard deviation σ of the building height distribution in the set area, and set the building height distribution to conform to the log-normal distribution. Establish building height above the risk cost of property loss C b Relationship Get the cost of property loss risk;
[0025] When calculating the distance of the facility buffer zone for the motion characteristics of the drone, obtain the drone parameters: the larger value of the fuselage length and wingspan length max (L a ,L b ), the flight speed v of the drone, the time t required for the drone to reach the maximum roll angle from the beginning of the turn, and the shortest forward detection line d m , calculate the buffer distance The facility outline is expanded according to the UAV motion characteristics to generate a buffer zone and obtain the safety risk value of the ground facilities.
[0026] Furthermore, the step three includes the following contents:
[0027] S3.1, according to R n =(1-0.8E n )A n ρ n L A Calculate the noise risk index, R, within the drone stereo grid n is the noise risk index of grid n, A n is the area of grid n, ρ n is the population density in grid n, E n is the barrier factor, L A is the resident annoyance index, which is calculated by the following formula:
[0028]
[0029] Among them, L g It is the instantaneous sound level of the drone noise when it reaches the ground;
[0030] S3.2, determine the privacy violation risk according to the degree of privacy protection needs in different regions;
[0031] S3.3, use the fuzzy comprehensive analysis method to classify the noise risk into three categories: high, medium and low. Then use the ISM-ANP method to assign weights to the noise risk index and privacy violation risk within the drone three-dimensional grid, sum them up and grade them, and draw a public acceptability risk map.
[0032] Furthermore, the step 4 includes the following contents:
[0033] S4.1, the ISM-ANP method is used to assign weights to the operational safety, operational reliability, public acceptability and various risk indicators of urban air traffic drones, and the weighted sum is used to calculate the comprehensive operational risk. Among them, the meteorological environment reliability data uses the annual average data, the traffic volume uses the total road traffic volume, and the population data uses the population density raster data; the comprehensive risk is graded by fuzzy comprehensive analysis method, and ArcGIS is used to draw a fishing net map to achieve the drawing of a static risk map of urban drones;
[0034] S4.2: The dynamic map that takes into account changes in traffic volume draws risk maps in different time periods based on the distribution characteristics of vehicles during peak hours in a day; the risk map that takes into account changes in meteorological data and population density inputs real-time data to draw a real-time dynamic risk map.
[0035] The method of the present invention has the following beneficial effects:
[0036] The risk map design method for urban air traffic drone operation proposed in this invention can conduct a comprehensive and detailed assessment of the risks of drone operation in urban scenes and present it in a visual way. It provides auxiliary decision-making for the formulation of urban drone flight plans, helps operators better plan drone routes to reduce the risks that drones may cause to surrounding residential areas and crowded places when operating, effectively improves operation management efficiency, increases public acceptance of drone urban operations, ensures the safety of drone urban operations, and promotes the development of urban drone applications. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0037] Figure 1 core principles of the design approach for risk mapping;
[0038] Figure 2 The reliability layer risk map provided in the embodiment with Jiangning District of Nanjing as the set area;
[0039] Figure 3 The security layer risk map provided in the embodiment with Jiangning District of Nanjing as the set area;
[0040] Figure 4 The acceptable risk level map provided in the embodiment with Jiangning District of Nanjing as the set area;
[0041] Figure 5 A static comprehensive risk map with Jiangning District, Nanjing City as the set area provided in the embodiment;
[0042] Figure 6 The peak-hour risk map of road vehicles provided in the embodiment with Jiangning District of Nanjing as the set area;
[0043] Figure 7A dynamic risk map of real-time meteorological data with Jiangning District, Nanjing as the set area provided in the embodiment;
[0044] Figure 8 This is a real-time population density dynamic risk map with Jiangning District of Nanjing as the set area provided in the embodiment. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0045] In order to make the purpose, technical solution and advantages of the present invention clearer, the technical solution of the present invention is further described in detail below through specific examples. It should be understood that the examples described here are only used to explain the core principles of the present invention, but are not used to limit the present invention.
[0046] The risk map design method for the operation of small and light urban air traffic drones provided in this embodiment includes the following steps:
[0047] Step 1: Evaluate the reliability of drone operation and draw the reliability layer. The reliability of drone operation mainly considers the impact of the urban environment on drone operation, including the airspace environment, meteorological environment, electromagnetic environment, communication environment, and navigation environment. Among them, the airspace environment is used as a prerequisite for subsequent reliability evaluation to determine whether the airspace belongs to a no-fly zone. For non-no-fly zones, the reliability of the meteorological, electromagnetic, communication, and navigation environments will be further evaluated. Among them, the reliability of the meteorological, electromagnetic, communication, and navigation environments is measured by risk and divided into three orders of magnitude: 2, 1, and 0, representing high risk, medium risk, and low risk, respectively.
[0048] (1.1) Determine whether the airspace is a no-fly zone. Refer to the "Interim Regulations on the Management of Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Flights (Draft for Comments)" issued by the Civil Aviation Administration of China, which set no-fly zones for light and small drones. For details, see Table 1. Drones should strictly avoid no-fly airspace when operating, and non-no-fly airspace requires subsequent evaluation.
[0049] Table 1 Method for assigning reliability of airspace environment operation
[0050]
[0051] (1.2) Comprehensively evaluate the reliability of the meteorological environment in the area based on wind speed, temperature and precipitation. Refer to the requirements for the UAV's resistance to wind, high and low temperature, and precipitation in the "Technical Requirements for Electric Multi-rotor Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (Light and Small) for Urban Logistics" issued by the Civil Aviation Administration of China. Wind speed, temperature, and precipitation are used as evaluation indicators for the reliability of the meteorological environment. The specific assignment method can be found in Table 2.
[0052] Table 2 Meteorological environment operation reliability assignment method
[0053]
[0054] (1.3) The electromagnetic environment is measured by the complexity of the electromagnetic environment. UAVs are subject to electromagnetic interference such as GPS signal interference and control link interference during urban operation. The assessment mainly considers the distribution of facilities that may affect the electromagnetic environment, such as ground broadcast communication base stations and high-voltage lines. The specific assignment method can be found in Table 3.
[0055] Table 3 Method for assigning reliability of electromagnetic environment operation
[0056]
[0057] (1.4) The communication environment is defined based on the mobile communication network signal coverage and strength in the area, as shown in Table 4. The mobile communication 3G / 4G / 5G signal strength coverage and signal congestion caused by dense population must be taken into account.
[0058] Table 4 Communication environment operation reliability assignment method
[0059]
[0060] (1.5) The reliability of the navigation environment is determined by the number of satellites received in the area. Generally, it is best for the UAV to stably obtain more than 12 satellites in the area within 1 minute. For details, please refer to Table 5.
[0061] Table 5 Navigation environment operation reliability assignment method
[0062]
[0063] (1.6) Calculate the comprehensive operational reliability level and draw an operational reliability layer risk map. In terms of determining the weights between the various indicators, the relationship between the various indicators is grasped by establishing an explanatory structural model (ISM), and on this basis, the weights of each indicator are calculated using the analytic network process (ANP). The evaluation results of the meteorological environment, electromagnetic environment, communication environment, and navigation environment are weighted and summed. The summation result is corrected using the airspace environment assessment results. The risk value of the no-fly zone is set to infinity, and the risk value of the non-no-fly zone is based on the weighted summation result. Finally, the fuzzy comprehensive analysis method is used to grade the operational reliability evaluation results, and the operational reliability layer risk map is drawn based on the grading results.
[0064] Step 2: Assess the safety of drone operations and draw safety layers. Based on the risk of drone collisions over cities, the safety assessment of drone operations is divided into drone collision risk and third-party risk. Among them, the collision risk includes the risk of collision between drones and other drones in isolated airspace and the risk of collision between drones and obstacles; the third-party risk is further subdivided into ground personnel safety, ground vehicle safety, ground building property loss, and ground facility safety.
[0065] (2.1) Calculate the collision probability between drones and the collision probability between drones and obstacles. When evaluating the collision probability between drones, establish the drone safety envelope, and the collision probability p A (X) is the integral of the probability density function of the drone in the safety envelope. When evaluating the collision probability between the drone and the obstacle, it is assumed that the flight altitude of the drone follows a normal distribution, the building height is known, and the collision probability between the drone and the obstacle p B (X) can be obtained by integrating the mean and standard deviation of the UAV flight altitude and the building height.
[0066] (2.2) Calculate the three-level indicators of third-party risk based on the collision probability obtained in (2.1). The safety of ground personnel is measured by the number of ground casualties N, which can be calculated based on factors such as population density, drone collision probability, distribution of ground shelters, and drone flight speed and take-off weight. The shielding coefficient of the shelter can be found in Table 6. The safety of ground vehicles is measured by the number of deaths p caused by traffic accidents caused by falling drone debris. C (X) Measurement, which can be calculated based on factors such as vehicle density and road characteristics; Calculation of property loss of ground buildings Property loss caused by drones hitting buildings at different heights C b , the mean and standard deviation of building height distribution can be obtained by statistically analyzing the building heights; for ground facility safety, the facility outline is expanded to generate a buffer zone considering the movement characteristics of drones and the risk value in the area is calculated.
[0067] Table 6 Shielding coefficient of ground facilities
[0068]
[0069] (2.3) Calculate the comprehensive operational safety level and draw an operational safety layer risk map. In terms of determining the weights between the indicators, an explanatory structural model (ISM) can be established to grasp the correlation between the indicators, and then the indicators can be weighted using the analytic network process (ANP). The calculation and evaluation results of ground personnel safety, ground vehicle safety, ground building property loss, and ground facility safety in third-party risks are divided into three risk levels: high, medium, and low using the fuzzy comprehensive analysis method. The weighted sum is then used for grading, and an operational safety layer risk map is drawn based on the grading results.
[0070] Step 3: Evaluate the public acceptability of drone operations and draw acceptability layers. The public acceptability assessment is based on the impact of noise generated by drone operations on ground residents and the potential privacy infringement of drones.
[0071] (3.1) Calculate the UAV noise risk. The noise risk index model R in the UAV three-dimensional grid can be established nConduct risk assessment. The drone noise risk is mainly affected by three factors: noise source, sound barrier and exposure. The noise source refers to the description of the acoustic energy generated by the drone propeller; the sound barrier refers to the sound blocking ability between the drone and the sound receiving object.
[0072] (3.2) Privacy infringement risks are divided according to the degree of privacy protection needs in different regions. Areas with strong privacy protection needs, such as government units and residential areas, are distinguished from potential privacy infringement risks in public places. For details, please refer to Table 7.
[0073] Table 7 Privacy public acceptability evaluation method
[0074]
[0075] (3.3) Calculate the comprehensive operation public acceptability and draw a public acceptability risk map. The noise risk can be divided into three categories: high, medium and low using the fuzzy comprehensive analysis method. Then, the two indicators are weighted and summed and graded using the ISM-ANP method. The public acceptability risk map can be drawn based on the grading results.
[0076] Step 4: Consider the temporal and spatial variation characteristics of data and draw static and dynamic risk maps. When drawing static risk maps, ignore the temporal and spatial variations of population, vehicle and meteorological data. After completing the above three parts of the evaluation, the comprehensive risk of drone urban operation can be calculated, and the computer software ArcGIS can be used to draw static risk maps. When drawing dynamic risk maps, draw dynamic risk maps based on the temporal and spatial variation characteristics and laws of population density, vehicle flow, and meteorological elements.
[0077] (4.1) Calculate the comprehensive operational risk and draw a static risk map of urban drones. The operational safety, operational reliability, public acceptability and the various risk indicators contained in urban air traffic drones are weighted according to the ANP network hierarchical analysis method to calculate the comprehensive operational risk. Among them, the meteorological environment reliability data uses the annual average data, the traffic volume uses the total road traffic volume, and the population data uses the population density raster data. The comprehensive operational risk is graded by the fuzzy comprehensive analysis method, and the fishing net map is drawn through ArcGIS based on the classification results to realize the drawing of the static risk map of urban drones.
[0078] (4.2) Dynamic risk maps are drawn based on the temporal and spatial changes of traffic volume, meteorological data, and population density. The dynamic map that takes into account the changes in traffic volume draws the risk map in different time periods based on the distribution characteristics of vehicles during peak hours in a day. The risk map that takes into account the changes in meteorological data and population density can input real-time data to draw a dynamic risk map.
[0079] The following will take Jiangning District of Nanjing as an example to further introduce the above plan:
[0080] Step 1: Evaluate the reliability of drone operation and draw the reliability layer. Taking Jiangning District of Nanjing as an example, the urban area is processed in a grid-like manner. The reliability of drone operation mainly considers the impact of the urban environment on drone operation, including airspace environment, meteorological environment, electromagnetic environment, communication environment, and navigation environment. (1.1) Determine whether the airspace is a no-fly zone. Refer to the provisions on the flight area of light and small drones in the "Interim Regulations on Flight Management of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (Draft for Comments)" issued by the Civil Aviation Administration of China and the no-fly zone set by the DJI GEO system for subsequent evaluation. (1.2) Obtain interpolation data of wind speed, temperature, and precipitation in Jiangning District. For the processed data, refer to Table 2 to assign reliability. (1.3) The electromagnetic environment is measured by the complexity of the electromagnetic environment. Refer to Table 3 to assign reliability to areas with dense broadcast communication base stations, areas with complex electromagnetic environments such as those near ultra-high voltage lines, areas around towers, areas around general-level high-voltage lines, and areas with relatively simple electromagnetic environments. (1.4) The communication environment is defined according to the coverage and strength of the mobile communication network signal in the area. Refer to Table 4 to assign reliability to different communication environments. (1.5) The reliability of the navigation environment is determined by the number of satellites received in the area. Please refer to Table 5 to assign reliability values based on the number of satellites that can be stably obtained in 1 minute and whether there is a satellite loss phenomenon. Except for the no-fly zone in the airspace environment, the reliability scores of the other environments represent the risk level. (1.6) Calculate the comprehensive operational reliability level, and use the ISM-ANP-fuzzy comprehensive analysis method to weighted sum and grade the assessment results of the meteorological environment, electromagnetic environment, communication environment, and navigation environment. Use the airspace environment assessment results to correct the summation result. The risk value of the no-fly zone is set to infinity, and the risk value of the non-no-fly zone is based on the weighted summation result. Draw an operational reliability layer risk map, such as Figure 2 .
[0081] Step 2: Evaluate the safety of drone operations and draw a safety layer. Calculate the drone collision risk and third-party risk over Jiangning District, Nanjing. The collision risk includes the risk of collision between drones and other drones in isolated airspace and the risk of collision between drones and obstacles; the third-party risk is further subdivided into ground personnel safety, ground vehicle safety, ground building property loss, and ground facility safety. (2.1) Calculate the probability of collision between drones and the probability of collision between drones and buildings. When calculating the probability of collision between drones, establish a drone safety envelope, and the collision probability is the integral of the probability density function of the drone in the safety envelope. Where p(T) is The probability density function of For in time When calculating the collision probability between obstacles, it is assumed that the flight altitude of the drone follows a normal distribution and the building height is known, then the collision probability between the drone and the obstacle is Among them, h0 is the obstacle height, h is the drone flight height, μ is the mean drone flight height, and σ is the standard deviation of the drone flight height. (2.2) Calculate the three-level indicators within the third-party risk according to the collision probability. Obtain the population density data D of Jiangning District, collect the drone radius R, maximum take-off weight m, pedestrian radius r, drone fall horizontal displacement d, fall speed v, and shielding factor E, and use the drone collision probability p calculated in (2.1) A (X). Collision debris falling range C = π (r + R) 2 +2d(r+R), chance of causing fatal damage Collision kinetic energy Correction Factor α represents the energy level that may cause fatal injury to a person, and β represents the impact energy threshold required to cause death, which can be taken as a constant of 34 J. Calculate the estimated number of ground casualties in each area of Jiangning District, Nanjing City N = P A (X)P F (X)CD. Number of deaths caused by traffic accidents caused by drone crashes P C (X) = P A (X)P M (X)N T , where P A (X) UAV collision probability, P M (X) The probability of a falling drone hitting a vehicle, N T The average number of deaths caused by traffic accidents. Obtain the building height h, the average value μ, and the standard deviation σ of the building height distribution in Jiangning District. Generally, the building height is a non-negative value and the distribution is asymmetric. The building height distribution does not conform to the standard normal distribution, but conforms to the logarithmic normal distribution. Based on this, the relationship between building height and property loss risk cost C can be established. b Relationship The cost of property loss risk can be obtained. Ground facility safety considers the movement characteristics of drones to expand the facility outline to generate a buffer zone and calculate the risk value in the area. The risk within the facility outline can refer to the provisions on the intervals between various types of building areas for light and small drones in the "Interim Regulations on the Management of Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Flights (Draft for Comments)". When calculating the buffer zone distance for a specific drone, the drone parameters can be entered: the larger value of the fuselage length and wingspan length max (L a ,L b ), the flight speed v of the drone, the time t required for the drone to reach the maximum roll angle from the beginning of the turn, and the shortest forward detection line d m, calculate the buffer distance (2.3) To calculate the comprehensive operational safety level, the fuzzy comprehensive analysis method can be used to divide the calculation and evaluation results of ground personnel safety, ground vehicle safety, ground building property loss and ground facility safety in third-party risks into three risk levels: high, medium and low. Then, the ISM and hierarchical analysis method are used to weight the index evaluation results and classify them to draw an operational safety layer risk map, such as Figure 3 .
[0082] Step 3: Evaluate the public acceptability of drone operations and draw an acceptability layer. The public acceptability assessment was conducted in Jiangning District based on the impact of drone noise on ground residents and the potential privacy infringement of drones. (3.1) Formula R n =(1-0.8E n )A n ρ n L A Calculate the noise risk index, R, within the drone stereo grid n is the noise risk index of grid n; A n is the area of grid n; ρ n is the population density in grid n, E n is the barrier factor, L A is the resident annoyance index, where the resident annoyance index can be expressed as follows: Calculate, L g is the instantaneous sound level when the drone noise is broadcast to the ground. (3.2) The privacy violation risk is divided according to the degree of privacy protection needs in different regions. Please refer to Table 7 for the classification according to the privacy needs of different regions. (3.3) To calculate the public acceptability of comprehensive operation, the fuzzy comprehensive analysis method can be used to divide the noise risk into three categories of high, medium and low. Then, the ISM-ANP method is used to assign weights to the two indicators, and then the weighted sum and classification are performed to draw a public acceptability layer risk map, such as Figure 4 .
[0083] Step 4: Consider the temporal and spatial variation characteristics of the data and draw static and dynamic risk maps for Jiangning District. When drawing a static map, you can select representative data values according to the actual application scenario, ignore the temporal and spatial variations of population, vehicle and meteorological data, calculate the comprehensive risk of urban drone operations, and use ArcGIS to draw a static risk map. When drawing a dynamic risk map, you can consider the temporal and spatial variation patterns of population density, traffic flow, and meteorological elements respectively. (4.1) The ISM-ANP method can be used to assign weights to the operational safety, operational reliability, public acceptability, and various risk indicators of urban air traffic drones and calculate the comprehensive operational risk by weighted summation. Among them, the meteorological environment reliability data selects the annual average data, the traffic flow selects the total road traffic flow, and the population data uses the population density raster data. The comprehensive risk is graded using the fuzzy comprehensive analysis method, and a fishing net map is drawn using ArcGIS to achieve the drawing of a static risk map for urban drones, such as Figure 5 (4.2) Dynamic map considering traffic flow changes Draw risk maps according to the distribution characteristics of vehicles during peak hours in a day, such as Figure 6 The risk map that considers the changes in meteorological data and population density inputs real-time data and draws a real-time dynamic risk map, such as Figure 7 , 8 shown.
[0084] The above is only a preferred embodiment of the present invention. It should be pointed out that for ordinary technicians in this technical field, several improvements and modifications can be made without departing from the principle of the present invention. These improvements and modifications should also be regarded as the scope of protection of the present invention.
Claims
1. A risk map design method for small and light urban air traffic drone operations, characterized by: The design method comprises the following steps: Step 1: Evaluate the reliability of drone operation based on the impact of the urban environment on drone operation and draw a reliability layer risk map; Step 2: Based on the risk of drone collision in the city, evaluate the safety of drone operation and draw a risk map of operation safety layer. The evaluation of drone operation safety is divided into drone collision risk and third-party risk. Step 3: Evaluate the public acceptability of drone operations from the perspective of the impact of drone noise on ground residents and potential privacy violations, and draw an acceptability map; Step 4: Use ArcGIS module to draw static risk map, calculate comprehensive operational risk based on the risks assessed in the first three steps, and draw dynamic risk map.
2. The design method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The step 1 includes the following contents: S1.1, refer to the "Interim Regulations on Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Flight Management (Draft for Comments)", set up no-fly zones for light and small drones, and determine whether the airspace is a no-fly zone; S1.2, refer to the requirements for the UAV's resistance to wind, high and low temperature, and precipitation in the "Technical Requirements for Electric Multi-rotor Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (Light and Small) for Urban Logistics Systems", and use wind speed, temperature, and precipitation as evaluation indicators for meteorological environment reliability to evaluate the reliability of the meteorological environment in the set area; S1.3, considering the distribution of ground broadcast communication base stations and high-voltage lines, evaluate the interference of GPS signals and electromagnetic interference of control links on drones; S1.4, determine the communication environment based on the coverage and strength of the mobile communication network signal in the set area; S1.5, determine the reliability of the navigation environment based on the number of satellite reception within the set area; S1.6, after the indicators in steps 1.1 to 1.5 are determined, the relationship between the indicators is grasped by establishing the explanatory structure model ISM, and the weight of each indicator is calculated by the network analysis method ANP; finally, the operation reliability evaluation results are graded using the fuzzy comprehensive analysis method, and the operation reliability layer risk map is drawn based on the grading results.
3. The design method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The step 2 includes the following contents: S2.1, calculate the collision probability between drones and the collision probability between drones and buildings, S2.2, calculate the three-level indicators of third-party risk according to the collision probability, including the number of deaths caused by traffic accidents caused by drone crashes, property losses of ground buildings, and safety of ground facilities; S2.3, use the fuzzy comprehensive analysis method to calculate and evaluate the third-party risks of ground personnel safety, ground vehicle safety, ground building property loss and ground facility safety, and divide the evaluation results into three risk levels: high, medium and low. Then use ISM and hierarchical analysis method to weighted sum and grade the indicator evaluation results to draw an operation safety layer risk map.
4. The design method according to claim 3, characterized in that: In step S2.1, when calculating the collision probability between drones, a drone safety envelope is established, and the collision probability is the integral of the probability density function of the drone in the safety envelope. Where p(T) is The probability density function of For in time The probability that the UAV is within the envelope when When calculating the collision probability between obstacles, the flight altitude of the drone is assumed to follow a normal distribution. The height of the building is known, so the collision probability between the drone and the obstacle is: Among them, h0 is the obstacle height, h is the UAV flight height, μ is the mean of the UAV flight height, and σ is the standard deviation of the UAV flight height.
5. The design method according to claim 3, characterized in that: In step S2.2, the population density data D of the set area is obtained, and the UAV radius R, the maximum take-off weight m, the pedestrian radius r, the UAV falling horizontal displacement d, the falling speed v, and the shielding factor E are collected; and the collision fragment falling range C=π(r+R) is set. 2 +2d(r+R), chance of causing fatal damage Collision kinetic energy Using the inter-UAV collision probability p in step S2.1 A (X) Calculate the estimated number of ground casualties in the set area N = P A (X)P F (X)CD, the number of deaths caused by traffic accidents caused by drone crashes P C (X) = P A (X)P M (X)N T , where P M (X) is the probability of a falling drone hitting a vehicle, N T is the average number of deaths caused by car accidents; Get the building height h, the mean value μ, and the standard deviation σ of the building height distribution in the set area, and set the building height distribution to conform to the log-normal distribution. Establish building height above the risk cost of property loss C b Relationship Get the cost of property loss risk; When calculating the distance of the facility buffer zone for the motion characteristics of the drone, obtain the drone parameters: the larger value of the fuselage length and wingspan length max (L a ,L b ), the flight speed v of the drone, the time t required for the drone to reach the maximum roll angle from the beginning of the turn, and the shortest forward detection line d m , calculate the buffer distance The facility outline is expanded according to the UAV motion characteristics to generate a buffer zone and obtain the safety risk value of the ground facilities.
6. The design method according to claim 3, characterized in that: The step three includes the following contents: S3.1, according to R n =(1-0.8E n )A n ρ n L A Calculate the noise risk index, R, within the drone stereo grid n is the noise risk index of grid n, A n is the area of grid n, ρ n is the population density in grid n, E n is the barrier factor, L A is the resident annoyance index, which is calculated by the following formula: Among them, L g It is the instantaneous sound level of the drone noise when it reaches the ground; S3.2, determine the privacy violation risk according to the degree of privacy protection needs in different regions; S3.3, use the fuzzy comprehensive analysis method to classify the noise risk into three categories: high, medium and low. Then use the ISM-ANP method to assign weights to the noise risk index and privacy violation risk within the drone three-dimensional grid, sum them up and grade them, and draw a public acceptability risk map.
7. The design method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The step 4 includes the following contents: S4.1, the ISM-ANP method is used to assign weights to the operational safety, operational reliability, public acceptability and various risk indicators of urban air traffic drones, and the weighted sum is used to calculate the comprehensive operational risk. Among them, the meteorological environment reliability data uses the annual average data, the traffic volume uses the total road traffic volume, and the population data uses the population density raster data; the comprehensive risk is graded by fuzzy comprehensive analysis method, and ArcGIS is used to draw a fishing net map to achieve the drawing of a static risk map of urban drones; S4.2: The dynamic map that takes into account changes in traffic volume draws risk maps in different time periods based on the distribution characteristics of vehicles during peak hours in a day; the risk map that takes into account changes in meteorological data and population density inputs real-time data to draw a real-time dynamic risk map.
Citation Information
Cited By
Regional unmanned aerial vehicle safety risk assessment method
CN119849941A
Urban unmanned aerial vehicle operation comprehensive risk assessment method and system
CN120106584A
Transportation route evaluation method and system for urban low-altitude unmanned aerial vehicle logistics
CN120450485A
Visualization method based on multi-source heterogeneous data
CN120745020A
