Contaminated soil low-carbon leaching remediation decision-making method
Through the decision-making method of low-carbon leaching and repair, combined with the response surface method and subjective empowerment method, the problems of energy consumption and carbon emissions in soil pollution repair are solved, and the coordinated optimization of pollutant removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emissions are achieved, and the improvement of the coordinated optimization of pollutant removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emissions are improved. The comprehensive benefits of the restoration process are suitable for green and low-carbon development.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411368848.X
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-09-29
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-06
- Estimated Expiration
- 2044-09-29
AI Technical Summary
The existing soil pollution restoration technology has shortcomings in reducing energy consumption and carbon emissions. It lacks methods to comprehensively examine pollutant removal rates, energy consumption and carbon emissions, resulting in the risk of failure to meet the standards of repair results and lack of standardization of decision-making procedures.
A low-carbon leaching and repair decision-making method is proposed, and the optimal low-carbon leaching and repair decision is formulated through process parameter analysis, experimental data acquisition, removal rate fitting screening, environmental impact analysis, data standardization processing and comprehensive benefit evaluation model construction. The solution combines the response surface method and the subjective empowerment method to achieve energy-saving and carbon reduction repair of polluted soil.
It realizes low-carbon leaching and repair of contaminated soil, reduces data collection workload, shortens decision-making cycle, provides a closer-to-optimal process parameter combination, is suitable for the needs of green and low-carbon development, and improves the comprehensive benefits of the restoration process.
Smart Images

Figure CN119076599A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention belongs to the field of soil pollution remediation, and in particular relates to a decision-making method for low-carbon leaching remediation of contaminated soil. Background Art
[0002] Green and low-carbon is a new trend in global social and economic development. The country attaches great importance to energy conservation and emission reduction, and has successively issued various energy conservation and carbon reduction guidance documents and action plans. Soil pollution remediation activities require a large amount of energy and resources. Achieving energy conservation and carbon reduction in soil pollution remediation is of great significance to the country's sustainable development.
[0003] In recent years, scholars have conducted research on the energy consumption and carbon emission characteristics of soil pollution remediation processes, and have initially formed some theoretical results and methodological tools. For example, CN 202211318566.X discloses a carbon emission accounting method for ex situ remediation technology of contaminated soil, proposes a formula for calculating carbon emissions during construction, and clarifies the carbon emission accounting process. "Carbon Emission Calculation Method and Case Analysis for Risk Control of Contaminated Sites" and "Carbon Emission Calculation Method and Engineering Case Study for Heavy Metal Contaminated Soil Stabilization Technology" respectively study the process flow of in situ risk control and ex situ stabilization remediation of contaminated sites, propose targeted carbon emission calculation methods, and complete the method application verification based on engineering cases, and explore the carbon emission reduction strategy of the technology. However, existing studies have mainly focused on the distribution law of energy and resource consumption and its carbon footprint in the remediation process. The proposed energy-saving and carbon reduction strategy focuses on reducing environmental impact without considering the change in pollutant removal rate. After the implementation of the strategy, there is a risk that the remediation effect will not meet the standard. At present, there is still a lack of comprehensive benefit evaluation methods for soil remediation that can simultaneously examine pollutant removal rate, energy consumption, and carbon emissions, which affects the decision-making of remediation processes.
[0004] Leaching remediation technology can effectively remove heavy metals and / or organic pollutants from the soil, and is one of the key engineering technologies for soil pollution remediation. The effect of soil pollution remediation is closely related to the process parameters of leaching technology, which is mainly affected by the type and concentration of the eluent, pH, leaching time, solid-liquid ratio, etc. In order to determine the most suitable remediation process parameters for the target soil, the construction party often conducts a large number of cumbersome single-factor small-scale and pilot experiments to compare the removal efficiency of pollutants under different process conditions to provide a basis for the implementation plan of the remediation project. The data collection workload is large, the screening basis is single, and the decision-making process lacks relevant standards. In the technical fields of soil vapor extraction, risk control, extraction-treatment, etc., some decision-making methods based on removal effect monitoring and evaluation have been gradually formed (such as patents CN 202010042282.7, CN 201210313796.7, CN 202311771671.3); however, the decision-making methods for soil leaching remediation process parameters still lack systematic research, especially the lack of research on the comparison method of remediation process parameters based on the comprehensive benefits of remediation. It is urgent to develop a multi-objective decision-making method for soil leaching remediation process that can achieve coordinated promotion of energy conservation, carbon reduction and pollution reduction. Summary of the invention
[0005] In response to the above-mentioned deficiencies, this patent proposes a decision-making method for low-carbon leaching remediation of contaminated soil. This method takes meeting the standards for decontamination, low emissions, and low energy consumption as decision-making goals, constructs a comprehensive benefit evaluation model for remediation, clarifies the operational requirements for data collection, fitting screening, process parameter decision-making, and other links, and provides a methodological tool for the sustainable remediation of contaminated soil.
[0006] The technical solution disclosed in the present invention is:
[0007] A decision-making method for low-carbon leaching remediation of contaminated soil, characterized in that the decision-making method includes seven steps: process parameter analysis (S1), test data collection (S2), removal rate fitting screening (S3), environmental impact analysis (S4), data standardization processing (S5), evaluation model construction (S6), and process parameter decision (S7).
[0008] Among them, S1 determines the key process parameters for decision-making on the leaching and remediation process of contaminated soil, collects auxiliary factor data, and establishes energy consumption and carbon emission evaluation formulas for remediation activities; S2 designs response surface experiments based on the key process parameters proposed by S1 and collects pollutant removal rate data; S3 fits the pollutant removal rate data through the response surface method to obtain alternative combinations of process parameters that can meet the decontamination standards; S4 calculates the energy consumption and carbon emission data corresponding to the alternative combinations of process parameters, and completes the forward conversion of energy consumption and carbon emission index data; S5 standardizes the removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emission data of S3 and S4 to achieve dimensionless processing; S6 determines the weight coefficients of removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emission, and constructs a comprehensive benefit evaluation model for remediation; S7 calculates the comprehensive benefit value of remediation based on the standardized data of S5 and the evaluation model of S6, selects the optimal process parameter combination from the alternative combinations of process parameters of S3, and forms a low-carbon leaching and remediation decision-making plan. (1) The specific implementation content of the process parameter analysis (S1) step is to construct a generalized model of the contaminated soil leaching remediation process, determine the key process parameters, collect auxiliary factor data, and establish an evaluation formula for the energy consumption and carbon emissions of the remediation activities.
[0009] The system boundaries of the energy consumption and carbon emission assessment of the remediation activities include but are not limited to the production, procurement and application of reagents, water input, and energy input for the operation of leaching and remediation equipment. The leaching and remediation equipment includes but is not limited to pulping and leaching equipment, vibrating screening equipment, solid-liquid separation equipment, and wastewater treatment equipment.
[0010] The key process parameters include the concentration of the elution agent (C f ), pH e ), elution time (T f ), liquid-to-solid ratio (R f ), Temperature (Tem f ) or more indicators.
[0011] The auxiliary factor data include: the operating power (P f ); the initial pH of the elution solution (pH i ); the amount of acid-base regulator input per unit pH change in the elution agent (W a ); heating input per unit temperature change in pulping and washing equipment (P tem ); the number of stages of vibration screening equipment (K z ) and operating power (P z ); operating power of solid-liquid separation equipment (P s ); Equipment operation time of wastewater treatment (T w ), operating power (P w ) and the amount of capture agent (C w); Purchasing distance of washing agent, acid-base regulator and capture agent (L f , L a , L w ); Carbon emission factors of elution agents, pH regulators, water, capture agents, diesel and electricity (F f 、F a 、F w 、F b 、F g 、F e ); fuel consumption per kilometer of transport vehicles (N l ) and single transport volume (K); standard coal coefficient for diesel and electricity (E g 、E e ).
[0012] The above key process parameters and auxiliary factor types can be adjusted and increased or decreased according to actual process investigations.
[0013] The energy consumption evaluation formula for the repair activity is: Energy consumption value E sum =Energy consumption of reagent transportation +Energy consumption of leaching and repair equipment operation = N l ×(L f +L a +L w )×E g +(T f ×(P f +P z ×K z +P s )+(Tem f -RT)×P tem ×T f +T w ×P w ×R f ×1))×E e .
[0014] Among them, E sum The unit is kgce / t soil. RT is room temperature, the default value is 25℃, which can be adjusted according to needs.
[0015] The carbon emission assessment formula for the restoration activity is: Carbon emission C sum = Carbon emissions from reagent resource input + Carbon emissions from reagent transportation + Carbon emissions from energy consumption of leaching and repair equipment = Carbon emissions from leaching reagent input + Carbon emissions from water input + Carbon emissions from acid-base regulator input + Carbon emissions from capture agent input + Carbon emissions from reagent transportation + Carbon emissions from energy consumption of leaching and repair equipment = C f ×R f ×1×F f +R f ×1×F w+|pH e -pH i |×W a ×F a +(T f ×(P f +P tem +P z ×K z +P s )+N l ×(L f ×((C f ×(R f ×1)) / K)+L a ×((|pH e -pH i |×W a ) / K)+L w ×((R f ×1)×(C w1 +C w2 +C w3 )) / K))×F g +(Tem f -RT)×P w ×T f +T w ×P w ×R f ×1)×F e +R f ×1×C w ×F b .
[0016] Among them, C sum The unit is kg CO2eq / t soil;|pH e -pH i | represents the absolute value of the difference in acidity of the eluent before and after adjustment; RT is room temperature, the default value is 25℃, and can be adjusted according to needs.
[0017] The above energy consumption and carbon emission assessment formulas for remediation activities can be adjusted according to the type of key process parameters.
[0018] (2) The specific implementation content of the experimental data collection (S2) step is as follows: based on the response surface method (RSM) principle, design the experimental gradient of key process parameters; take the target remediation soil as the pilot test object, carry out response surface experiments, and collect pollutant removal rate data corresponding to the process parameter test combination; according to the S1 remediation activity energy consumption and carbon emission evaluation formula, calculate the energy consumption and carbon emission data corresponding to the process parameter test combination.
[0019] The pollutant removal rate calculation formula is: pollutant removal rate R = (C i -Ce ) / C i ×100%
[0020] Among them, C i is the initial concentration of soil pollutants, C e is the soil pollutant concentration after remediation.
[0021] The pollutant removal rate data may be the removal rate data of a single pollutant, or may be the weighted average of multiple pollutant removal rates. The pollutants may be one or more of heavy metal pollutants or organic pollutants.
[0022] The design of the key process parameter test gradient adopts the Box-Behnken Designs (BBD) method in RSM and is implemented through professional response surface analysis software such as Design Expert. In the BBD test plan, the number of center point treatments is not less than 3, that is, the center point treatment requires 3 or more parallel tests using the same process parameter combination, and the data of each parallel test group are used separately; non-center point treatments all use 3 parallel tests and take the average value. According to needs, the test gradient design can be adjusted to the Central Composite Designs (CCD) method to increase the amount of test data collected.
[0023] The investigation range of the above-mentioned process parameter test gradient is provided by the construction party based on the previous engineering experience, and can also be determined through single factor experiments.
[0024] (3) The specific implementation content of the removal rate fitting and screening (S3) step is as follows: based on the pollutant removal rate data obtained in S2, the pollutant removal rate equation is obtained by fitting through the response surface method; with the remediation target value as the critical point, the removal rate tends to be large, and the energy consumption value and carbon emission tend to be small, 50 sets of process parameter alternative combinations for environmental impact analysis are fitted and screened. The number of the process parameter alternative combinations can be adjusted according to demand.
[0025] The pollutant removal rate equation is a multivariate quadratic equation based on a combination of process parameters.
[0026] The response surface method fitting process is implemented by professional response surface analysis software such as Design Expert. The P1 value of the significance test result of the model fitting in the response surface method fitting result should be less than 0.05, and the P2 value of the significance test result of the lack of fit item should be greater than 0.05. When the P1 value and P2 value do not meet the requirements, step 2 should be carried out again to optimize the experimental gradient design of key process parameters and collect data again.
[0027] (4) The specific implementation content of the environmental impact analysis (S4) step is as follows: according to the alternative combinations of process parameters obtained in S3, the energy consumption and carbon emission data corresponding to each alternative combination of process parameters are calculated through the energy consumption and carbon emission evaluation formula of the remediation activity in S1; the remediation energy consumption and carbon emission data are forward processed through the maximum value method, and the conversion formula is Item ki =Item max –Item ks , where Item ki The energy consumption value or carbon emission value is standardized data. max The maximum value of energy consumption or carbon emission among 50 alternative combinations of process parameters. ks It is the raw data of energy consumption or carbon emissions.
[0028] (5) The specific implementation content of the data standardization processing step (S5) is: using the Z-score method to perform dimensionless standardization on the removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emission data of S3 and S4.
[0029] The data conversion formula of the Z-score method is: std =(Item i -Item ave ) / δ
[0030] Among them, Item std The data is the removal rate, energy consumption value or carbon emission standardized data. i The original data of removal rate or the data of energy consumption value and carbon emission after positive processing, Item ave and δ are the mean and standard deviation of removal rate, energy consumption or carbon emission in 50 combinations of process parameters, respectively.
[0031] (6) The specific implementation content of the evaluation model construction step (S6) is: determining the evaluation weights of pollutant removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emissions, and constructing a comprehensive restoration benefit evaluation model that takes into account energy conservation, pollution reduction and carbon reduction.
[0032] The specific formula of the restoration comprehensive benefit evaluation model is: Restoration comprehensive benefit value F sum =(K R ×R i +K E ×E i +K C ×C i )×100.
[0033] Among them, F sum K is the comprehensive benefit value of restoration; R , K E , K Care the evaluation weight coefficients of removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emission respectively; R i 、E i , C i are the normalized values of removal rate, energy consumption or carbon emission of the i-th alternative combination of process parameters respectively.
[0034] The comprehensive benefit evaluation model of restoration adopts subjective weighting method. The evaluation weight coefficient K of pollutant removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emission is R , K E , K C The numerical interval of is required to be [0,1], and the initial values are set to 1, 1, and 1. The specific weight coefficient can be adjusted according to the preference of the decision maker.
[0035] (7) The specific implementation content of the process parameter decision (S7) step is: input the removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emission standardized data corresponding to the alternative process parameter combinations in S5 into the S6 remediation comprehensive benefit evaluation model, calculate the remediation comprehensive benefit value, and select the alternative process parameter combination with the highest remediation comprehensive benefit value as the final low-carbon leaching remediation decision plan.
[0036] The invention patent proposes a soil pollution low-carbon leaching remediation decision-making method, which is applicable to soil pollution ex situ leaching remediation projects and can assist construction parties in quickly screening and determining the optimal low-carbon remediation process parameters. The soil pollution includes heavy metal pollution, organic pollution, and heavy metal-organic composite pollution.
[0037] Compared with the existing technology, the technical solution proposed by this patent has the following advantages and benefits: (2) This patent proposes a three-objective collaborative decision-making method, which is significantly different from the conventional method of formulating remediation process parameters based on pollutant removal rate. It can simultaneously examine the impact of process parameter changes on pollutant removal, energy consumption and carbon emissions, which is in line with the current green and low-carbon development needs. According to the needs, the benefit evaluation indicators of the comprehensive benefit evaluation model of remediation in the decision-making method can be expanded to other environmental, social and economic impact indicators to form a multi-dimensional evaluation decision-making tool for remediation process parameters, providing strong support for the development of green and sustainable remediation technologies. (3) In view of the shortcomings of traditional single-factor experiments or orthogonal experiments, such as small amount of data collected and weak decision-making support, this technical solution adopts the response surface experimental method to collect data, reduce the workload of data collection, and shorten the decision-making cycle of repair process parameters. Furthermore, the response surface method is used to complete the pollutant removal rate fitting of different process parameter combinations, and quickly provide alternative process parameter combinations that are closer to the optimal solution. Compared with traditional numerical simulation methods, the response surface fitting method proposed in this technical solution is convenient to operate and easy to implement; compared with emerging machine learning or deep learning methods, this fitting method requires less basic data and can provide a clear and unambiguous removal rate fitting equation, which is convenient for subsequent calculations. (4) The weight coefficient of the comprehensive benefit evaluation model for remediation in this technical solution is determined by the subjective weighting method. The weight values of removal rate, energy consumption, and carbon emissions can be adjusted according to the needs of the owner and the preferences of the decision-makers, and are suitable for different decision-making scenarios. This method can also be used to compare the comprehensive benefits of remediation with different process parameter combinations, providing an intuitive benefit value reference for decision-makers to select remediation strategies, and helping to achieve efficient, low-carbon, and low-consumption leaching remediation of contaminated soil. After adjusting the process parameter indicators, this method can also be used in the decision-making process of other soil and groundwater pollution remediation processes such as solidification / stabilization and chemical oxidation. It has a wide range of applications and good prospects for promotion. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0038] Figure 1 A flowchart of a decision-making method for low-carbon leaching remediation of contaminated soil;
[0039] Figure 2 To show the correlation between each step in the decision-making method;
[0040] Figure 3 This is the generalized model of the contaminated soil leaching and remediation process in Example 1;
[0041] Figure 4 This is the response surface fitting result of the pollutant removal rate based on the process parameters in Example 1. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0042] The present invention is further described in detail below in conjunction with specific implementation methods to better reflect the advantages of the present invention.
[0043] Example 1 Decision making on process parameters for ex situ leaching and remediation of lead-contaminated soil at a site
[0044] A lead-contaminated site in Fujian was selected as the research object of the embodiment. The target pollutant in the soil of the site was heavy metal lead (Pb), and its average content was 15267 mg / kg. Based on the technical solution proposed in the patent of this invention, the decision on the process parameters of soil pollution leaching and remediation was carried out. The flowchart of the decision-making method is shown in Figure 1 The correlation of each step is shown in Figure 2 shown.
[0045] (1) Process parameter analysis (S1) step:
[0046] Collect basic information on the target site, and master the restoration technology, restoration equipment, process route and input information that the construction party intends to adopt. The research data are summarized as follows: The site selects the ex situ leaching restoration process, uses a domestic leaching restoration equipment as the restoration equipment, and EDTA as the leaching agent. The contaminated soil is excavated and sent to the leaching restoration equipment, and is processed through pulping leaching, one or more stages of vibration screening, and solid-liquid separation. The soil samples after screening are collected for testing and analysis to determine the restoration effect; the contaminated liquid after screening is treated by adding capture agents PAC, PAM and Na2S, and discharged after meeting the standards.
[0047] Based on the above data, a generalized model of the contaminated soil leaching and remediation process was constructed. The contaminated soil leaching and remediation process was divided into four stages: pulping and leaching, vibration screening, solid-liquid separation, and wastewater treatment; the input equipment included pulping and leaching equipment (including chemical pumps and pulping equipment), vibration screening equipment, solid-liquid separation equipment, and wastewater treatment equipment; the input resources included leaching chemicals, water, acid-base regulators, and capture agents; and the input energy included diesel and electricity.
[0048] Determine the concentration of the elution agent (C f ), elution time (T f ), liquid-to-solid ratio (R f ) are the three key process parameter investigation objects of this embodiment.
[0049] The equipment and reagent input parameters of each process link related to the concentration of leaching reagent, leaching time, and liquid-to-solid ratio are collected and sorted. The parameter information summary results are as follows: The operating power of the reagent pump and the pulping equipment in the pulping leaching equipment are P f1 =6.6kW, P f2 =25kW; the level of the vibration screening equipment is 1, and the operating power is P z =71kW; operating power of solid-liquid separation equipment P s =93.5kW; Wastewater treatment equipment operation time T w =0.03h / m 3 , operating power P w =28.2kW, capture agent PAC, PAM, Na2S dosage C w1 =1.90kg / m 3 soil, C w2 =0.19kg, C w3 =0.19kg; Purchasing distance of washing agent L f = 50km, the purchasing distance of the capture agent is L w = 50km; carbon emission factors of elution agent, water, capture agent (PAC, PAM, Na2S), diesel and electricity (F f =4.3859kg CO2eq / kg, Fw =0.21kg CO2eq / m 3 、F b1 =1.6879kg CO2eq / kg, F b2 =3.2546kg CO2eq / kg, F b3 =2.9396kg CO2eq / kg, F g =3.7659kg CO2eq / kg, F e =0.5703kg CO2eq / kWh; fuel consumption per kilometer of transport vehicles (N l =35L / 100km), single transport volume (K=60t); standard coal coefficient for diesel and electricity (E g =1.4571kgce / kg, E e =0.1229 kgce / kWh). Since this embodiment does not involve the investigation of pH and temperature parameters, the pH value of the elution agent solution was not collected. i and pH e Data, and the amount of acid-base regulator input per unit pH change in the elution reagent W a , Heating power P per unit temperature change in pulping and washing equipment tem , Acid purchasing distance L a , Carbon emission factor F of acid-base regulator a The values of are all assigned 0.
[0050] Construct an evaluation formula for the energy consumption of restoration activities. The specific formula is:
[0051] Energy consumption value E sum =Energy consumption of reagent transportation + Energy consumption of leaching and repair equipment operation = Fuel consumption per kilometer of transportation vehicle × (Purchase distance of leaching reagent + Purchase distance of acid-base regulator + Purchase distance of capture agent) × (Amount of reagent input / Single transportation volume) × Standard coal coefficient of diesel + ((Leaching time × (Slurry leaching equipment operating power + Heating power + Vibration screening equipment operating power × Number of stages + Solid-liquid separation equipment operating power) + Temperature change × Heating power × Leaching time + Wastewater treatment equipment operating time × Operating power × Liquid-solid ratio × Unit soil repair volume) × Standard coal coefficient of electricity = N l ×(L f ×((C f ×(R f ×1)) / K)+L a ×((|pH e -pH i |×W a ) / K)+L w×((R f ×1)×(C w1 +C w2 +C w3 )) / K))×E g +(T f ×(P f +P z ×K z +P s )+(Tem f -RT)×P tem ×T f +T w ×P w ×R f ×1))×E e =-0.96+10.23×C f +0.47×R f +0.0007×T f
[0052] Among them, E sum The unit is kgce / t soil, which is the amount of standard coal consumed to repair 1 ton of soil; C f is the concentration of eluent EDTA, in mol / L, T f is the elution time, in min, R f is the liquid-to-solid ratio (volume of eluent: volume of soil).
[0053] The carbon emission assessment formula for restoration activities is established. The specific formula is:
[0054] Carbon emissions sum = Carbon emissions from leaching agent input + Carbon emissions from water resources input + Carbon emissions from acid-base regulating agent input + Carbon emissions from capture agent input + Carbon emissions from agent transportation + Carbon emissions from energy consumption of leaching remediation equipment = leaching agent concentration × (liquid-solid ratio × unit soil remediation volume) × Carbon emission factor of leaching agent + (liquid-solid ratio × unit soil remediation volume) × Carbon emission factor of water + pH change of leaching solution × Acid-base regulating agent input per unit pH change × Carbon emission factor of acid-base regulating agent + (liquid-solid ratio × unit soil remediation volume) × capture agent Concentration of capture agent × carbon emission factor of capture agent + unit kilometer fuel consumption of transport vehicle × (transport distance of leaching agent + transportation distance of acid-base regulator + transportation distance of capture agent) × (amount of agent input / single transport volume) × carbon emission factor of diesel + ((leaching time × (operating power of pulping leaching equipment + heating power + operating power of vibration screening equipment × number of stages + operating power of solid-liquid separation equipment) + temperature change × heating power × leaching time + operating time of wastewater treatment equipment × operating power × liquid-solid ratio × unit soil remediation amount) × carbon emission factor of electricity =C f ×(R f ×1)×F f +(R f ×1)×F w +|pH e -pH i |×W a ×F a +(R f ×1)×(C w1 ×F b1 +C w2 ×F b2 +C w3 ×F b3 )+N l ×(L f ×((C f ×(R f ×1)) / K)+L a ×((|pH e -pH i |×W a ) / K)+L w ×((R f ×1)×(C w1 +C w2 +C w3 )) / K))×F g + (T f ×(P f +P z ×K z +P s )+(Tem f -RT)×P tem ×T f +T w ×P w ×(R f ×1))×F e =-1171+7839×C f +197×R f +0.003×T f
[0055] Among them, C sum The unit is kg CO2eq / t soil, that is, the carbon dioxide equivalent emitted when repairing 1 ton of soil.
[0056] (2) Test data collection (S2) steps:
[0057] EDTA concentration, elution time, and liquid-solid ratio were selected as the parameters for investigation, and the response surface experimental treatment groups were designed by the Box-Behnken Designs (BBD) method of the Design Expert software, with a total of 17 groups (see Table 1). Among them, the number of center point treatments was 5, that is, the center point treatment required 5 parallel tests with the same process parameter combination, and the data results were used separately; all non-center point treatments used 3 parallel tests and took the average value.
[0058] Table 1 Treatment group design of response surface experiment
[0059] The soil samples of the site were used as test materials to carry out batch leaching experiments. EDTA solutions of different concentrations were prepared, mixed with the contaminated soil samples, and leached by oscillation; the setting gradients of EDTA concentration, liquid-solid ratio, and leaching time are shown in Table 1. Solid-liquid separation, liquid samples were taken to determine the Pb concentration, and the removal rate of pollutant Pb was calculated. The calculation formula for the removal rate of pollutant Pb is: Pollutant removal rate R = (C i -C e ) / C i × 100%. C i is the initial Pb concentration in soil, C e is the Pb concentration in the soil after restoration. At the same time, the energy consumption and carbon emission data corresponding to each treatment group were calculated according to the energy consumption and carbon emission evaluation formula for restoration activities provided by S1. The experimental data are shown in Table 2.
[0060] Table 2 Response surface experimental data Serial number Removal rate % <![CDATA[Carbon emissions kg CO2eq / t soil]]> Energy consumption kgce / t soil 1 79.22 1583 4.50 2 77.60 1060 3.76 3 73.48 1583 4.39 4 64.36 796 2.93 5 66.64 794 2.50 6 77.84 1580 3.95 7 73.10 1188 3.50 8 81.76 2105 5.13 9 73.77 1188 3.50 10 73.66 1188 3.50 11 77.12 797 3.04 12 73.19 1188 3.50 13 85.10 1581 4.07 14 70.07 1188 3.50 15 73.45 533 2.21 16 84.07 1055 2.89 17 81.73 794 2.61
[0061] (3) Removal rate fitting screening (S3) step:
[0062] Using the pollutant removal rate data obtained by S2, the pollutant removal rate equation based on the process parameter combination was obtained by fitting with the Design Expert software.
[0063] The fitting results show that the pollutant removal rate equation is a multivariate quadratic equation based on the combination of process parameters. The specific formula is:
[0064] Removal rate R = 72.57-204.65 × C f +0.19×T f -3.68R f -0.31×C f ×T f -16.16×C f ×R f -0.013×T f×R f +1460×C f 2 -0.000037×T f 2 +0.70×R f 2
[0065] The significance test results of the model fit are P1=0.0002<0.05, P2=0.5019>0.05. The significance test results meet the requirements and can proceed to the next step of fitting and screening of alternative combinations of process parameters.
[0066] According to the site remediation needs, with 80% removal rate as the remediation target, the principle of increasing removal rate and decreasing energy consumption and carbon emissions was adopted, and 50 sets of process parameter alternative combinations were selected through the Design Expert software as the data source of S4. The fitting data are shown in Table 3.
[0067] (4) Environmental impact analysis (S4) steps:
[0068] Using the alternative combinations of process parameters obtained in S3, we substituted them into the energy consumption and carbon emission evaluation formula of the remediation activity in S1, and calculated the energy consumption and carbon emission data corresponding to 50 sets of alternative combinations of process parameters using Excel software. Subsequently, because the construction party's demand for energy consumption and carbon emissions is opposite to the removal rate, that is, it hopes that the removal rate will be larger and the energy consumption value and carbon emissions will be smaller, the maximum value method is selected to perform positive processing on the remediation energy consumption and carbon emission data, and the conversion formula is Item ki =Item max – Item ks Among them, Item ki This is the standardized data of carbon emissions. max is the maximum carbon emission value among the 50 alternative combinations of process parameters, Item ks This is the raw data of carbon emissions.
[0069] The processed data are shown in Table 3.
[0070] Table 3 Alternative combinations of process parameters and their values
[0071] (5) Data standardization processing step (S5):
[0072] The Z-score method was used to perform dimensionless standardization on the removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emission data of S3 and S4. The data conversion formula of the Z-score method is: std =(Itemi -Item ave ) / δ. Among them, Item std The removal rate, energy consumption value, and carbon emission are standardized data. i The original data of removal rate or the data of energy consumption value and carbon emission after positive processing, Item ave and δ are the mean and standard deviation of the removal rate, energy consumption or carbon emission values in the 50 alternative combinations of process parameters, respectively.
[0073] Based on this method, the removal rate conversion formula in this experiment is obtained after substituting the data: R std =(R i -R ave ) / δ R =(R i -81.53%) / 0.02; the conversion formula for carbon emission data is: C std =(C i -C ave ) / δ C =(C i -897) / 213; the conversion formula for energy consumption data is: E std =(E i -E ave ) / δ E =(E i -3.25) / 0.27.
[0074] The data normalization values are shown in Table 2.
[0075] (6) Evaluation model building step (S6):
[0076] Determine the assessment weights of pollutant removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emissions, and construct a comprehensive restoration benefit assessment model that takes into account energy conservation, pollution reduction and carbon reduction. The specific formula of the comprehensive restoration benefit assessment model is:
[0077] Restoration comprehensive benefit value F sum =(K R ×R i +K E ×E i +K C ×C i )×100
[0078] Among them, F sum K is the comprehensive benefit value of restoration; R , K E , K C are the evaluation weight coefficients of removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emission respectively; R i 、E i , C iare the standardized values of removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emission of the i-th alternative combination of process parameters respectively.
[0079] Three weight coefficients are set according to the decision-maker's preferences to complete the construction of the comprehensive benefit evaluation model of restoration:
[0080] a emphasizes decontamination: set the removal rate weight to 1, the energy consumption weight to 0, and the carbon emission weight to 0. The final comprehensive benefit evaluation model of restoration under this scenario is F sum =R i ×100;
[0081] b Focus on restoration: Set the removal rate weight to 1, the energy consumption weight to 0.2, and the carbon emission weight to 0.2. The final restoration comprehensive benefit evaluation model under this scenario is F sum =(R i +0.2×E i +0.2×C i )×100;
[0082] c. Synergistic energy saving, carbon reduction and pollution reduction: Set the removal rate weight to 1, the energy consumption weight to 1, and the carbon emission weight to 1. The final comprehensive benefit evaluation model of restoration under this scenario is F sum =(R i +E i +C i )×100.
[0083] (7) Process parameter decision (S7) step:
[0084] The standardized data of removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emission in S5 are input into the comprehensive remediation benefit evaluation model of S6 to calculate the comprehensive remediation benefit value corresponding to each alternative combination of process parameters; the combination with the highest comprehensive remediation benefit value is selected as the final decision plan.
[0085] The evaluation score distribution and final process parameter decision plan for this site remediation case under three preference scenarios are as follows:
[0086] (1) Emphasis on decontamination (removal rate weight is 1, energy consumption weight is 0, carbon emission weight is 0)
[0087] Table 4 Benefit value evaluation scores of alternative combinations of process parameters under the decontamination scenario
[0088] The benefit value evaluation scores of 50 alternative combinations of process parameters are shown in Table 4. According to the above calculation results, the best process parameter combination under this decision demand scenario was finally selected as K44 combination, with EDTA concentration of 0.18 mol / L, liquid-solid ratio of 4.34 L / kg, and elution time of 240 min.
[0089] (2) Emphasis on restoration (removal rate weight is 1, energy consumption weight is 0.2, and carbon emission weight is 0.2)
[0090] Table 5 Benefit value evaluation scores of alternative combinations of process parameters in the repair scenario
[0091] The benefit value evaluation scores of 50 alternative combinations of process parameters are shown in Table 5. According to the above calculation results, the best process parameter combination under this decision demand scenario was finally selected as K28 combination, with EDTA concentration of 0.17 mol / L, liquid-solid ratio of 4.01 L / kg, and elution time of 240 min.
[0092] Collaborative energy conservation, carbon reduction and pollution reduction (removal rate weight is 1, energy consumption weight is 1, carbon emission weight is 1)
[0093] Table 6 Benefit value evaluation scores of alternative combinations of process parameters under the scenario of synergistic energy conservation, carbon reduction and pollution reduction
[0094] The benefit value evaluation scores of 50 alternative combinations of process parameters are shown in Table 6. According to the above calculation results, the optimal process parameter combination under this decision demand scenario was finally selected as K2 combination, with EDTA concentration of 0.10 mol / L, liquid-solid ratio of 4.05 L / kg, and elution time of 235 min.
[0095] The above technical solutions of the present invention are only preferred embodiments of the present invention, and the patent scope of the present invention is not limited thereto. All equivalent structural changes made by using the contents of the present invention specification and drawings under the technical concept of the present invention, or directly / indirectly applied in other related technical fields are included in the patent protection scope of the present invention.
Claims
1. A decision-making method for low-carbon leaching and remediation of contaminated soil, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: Process parameter analysis (S1): construct a generalized model of the contaminated soil leaching remediation process, determine key process parameters, collect auxiliary factor data, and establish an evaluation formula for energy consumption and carbon emissions of remediation activities; Experimental data collection (S2): Design experimental gradients of key process parameters and collect pollutant removal rate data through response surface modeling (RSM); According to the energy consumption and carbon emission assessment formula of the repair activity in S1, calculate the energy consumption and carbon emission data corresponding to each process parameter combination; Removal rate fitting screening (S3): using the pollutant removal rate data obtained in S2, the pollutant removal rate equation based on the process parameter combination is obtained by fitting through the response surface method; Taking the restoration target value as the critical point, and adopting the principle of increasing the removal rate and decreasing the energy consumption and carbon emissions, 50 sets of process parameter alternative combinations for environmental impact analysis were obtained by fitting. Environmental impact analysis (S4): Based on the alternative combinations of process parameters obtained in S3, the energy consumption and carbon emission data corresponding to each alternative combination of process parameters are calculated using the energy consumption and carbon emission assessment formula for the remediation activities in S1; The restoration energy consumption and carbon emission data are processed positively by the maximum value method. The formula for the positive processing is Item ki =Item max –Item ks , where Item ki The energy consumption value or carbon emission value is standardized data. max The maximum value of energy consumption or carbon emission among 50 alternative combinations of process parameters. ks The raw data of energy consumption or carbon emissions; Data standardization (S5): The removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emission data of S3 and S4 were dimensionlessly standardized using the Z-score method; the data conversion formula of the Z-score method is Item std =(Item i -Item ave ) / δ, where Item std The data is the removal rate, energy consumption value or carbon emission standardized data. i It is the original data of removal rate, energy consumption value or carbon emission. ave and δ are the mean and standard deviation of the removal rate, energy consumption or carbon emission values in the 50 alternative combinations of process parameters, respectively; Evaluation model construction (S6): Determine the evaluation weights of pollutant removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emissions, and construct a comprehensive benefit evaluation model for restoration that takes into account the needs of energy conservation, pollution reduction and carbon reduction; Process parameter decision (S7): input the removal rate, energy consumption value or carbon emission standardized data corresponding to the alternative combinations of process parameters in S5 into the comprehensive benefit evaluation model of restoration in S6 to calculate the comprehensive benefit value of restoration; The alternative combination of process parameters with the highest comprehensive repair benefit value is selected as the final decision plan.
2. A decision-making method for low-carbon leaching and remediation of contaminated soil according to claim 1, characterized in that: The key process parameters in step S1 include the concentration of the elution agent (C f ), pH e ), elution time (T f ), liquid-to-solid ratio (R f ), Temperature (Tem f ) or more than three indicators; auxiliary factors include the operating power of pulping and washing equipment (P f ), the initial pH of the elution solution (pH i ), the amount of acid-base regulator input per unit pH change in the elution agent (W a ), heating input per unit temperature change in pulping and washing equipment (P tem ), the number of vibration screening equipment (K z ) and operating power (P z ), operating power of solid-liquid separation equipment (P s ), equipment operation time of wastewater treatment (T w ), operating power (P w ) and the amount of capture agent (C w ), the purchasing distance of the washing agent (L f ), the purchasing distance of acid-base regulator (L a ) and the sourcing distance of the capture agent (L w ), leaching agent, pH regulator, water, capture agent, diesel and electricity carbon emission factors (F f 、F a 、F w 、F b 、F g 、F e ), fuel consumption per kilometer of transport vehicles (N l ) and single transport volume (K), standard coal coefficient for diesel and electricity (E g 、E e ).
3. A decision-making method for low-carbon leaching and remediation of contaminated soil according to claim 1, characterized in that: The energy consumption evaluation formula for the repair activity in step S1 is: Energy consumption value E sum =N l ×(L f ×((C f ×(R f ×1)) / K)+L a ×((|pH e -pH i |×W a ) / K)+L w ×((R f ×1)×(C w1 +C w2 +C w3 )) / K))×E g +(T f ×(P f +P z ×K z +P s )+(Tem f -RT)×P tem ×T f +T w ×P w ×R f ×1))×E e Where: E sum The unit is kgce / t soil, RT is room temperature; The carbon emission assessment formula for the restoration activities is: Carbon emissions sum =C f ×R f ×1×F f +R f ×1×F w +|pH e -pH i |×W a ×F a +(T f ×(P f +P tem +P z ×K z +P s )+N l ×(L f ×((C f ×(R f ×1)) / K)+L a ×((|pH e -pH i |×W a ) / K)+L w ×((R f ×1)×(C w1 +C w2 +C w3 )) / K))×F g +(Tem f -RT)×P w ×T f +T w ×P w ×R f ×1)×F e +R f ×1×C w ×F b Where: C sum The unit is kg CO2eq / t soil, RT is room temperature.
4. A decision-making method for low-carbon leaching and remediation of contaminated soil according to claim 1, characterized in that: The experimental gradient design of the response surface experiment in step S2 adopts the Box-Behnken Designs method, and the number of center point treatments is not less than 3; the calculation formula of the pollutant removal rate is: pollutant removal rate R = (C i -C e ) / C i ×100%, where C i is the initial concentration of soil pollutants, C e is the soil pollutant concentration after remediation.
5. The low-carbon leaching and remediation decision-making method for contaminated soil according to claim 1 is characterized in that: The pollutant removal rate equation described in step S3 is a multivariate quadratic equation based on a combination of process parameters; the significance test result P1 value of the model fitting in the response surface method fitting result should be less than 0.05, and the significance test result P2 value of the lack of fit term should be greater than 0.
05.
6. A decision-making method for low-carbon leaching and remediation of contaminated soil according to claim 1, characterized in that: The formula of the comprehensive benefit evaluation model for restoration in step S6 is: sum =(K R ×R i +K E ×E i +K C ×C i )×100 where F sum is the comprehensive benefit value of restoration, K R , K E , K C are the evaluation weight coefficients of removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emission, R i 、E i , C i are the standardized values of removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emission of the i-th alternative combination of process parameters respectively.
7. The low-carbon leaching and remediation decision-making method for contaminated soil according to claim 1 is characterized in that: The comprehensive benefit evaluation model of restoration adopts subjective weighting method, and the evaluation weight coefficient K of pollutant removal rate, energy consumption and carbon emission is R , K E , K C The numerical range is [0,1], and the initial values are 1, 1 and 1 respectively.
8. The low-carbon leaching and remediation decision-making method for contaminated soil according to claim 1 is characterized in that: The decision-making method is used to determine the process parameters for ex situ leaching remediation of soil pollution; the soil pollution includes soil heavy metal pollution, organic pollution and heavy metal-organic composite pollution.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Decision-making method for in-situ remediation of oil-contaminated underground water
CN102992417A
Method for designing SVE process parameters in petroleum contaminated site
CN111259543A
Carbon emission accounting method and system for polluted soil ex-situ remediation technology
CN115660279A
Polluted site risk management and control process parameter determining and monitoring method
CN117973839A
Eluting agent for soil heavily contaminated by composite heavy metals and method thereof
CN107309266A
Cited By
Method for calculating carbon emission in full life cycle of heavy metal polluted site remediation and method for determining low-carbon remediation technology
CN120094959A
Polluted site soil remediation evaluation method and system
CN120409975A
Wastewater heavy metal recovery intelligent decision-making method for metal processing
CN120998330A
