Process for producing ethers using heterogeneous catalysts containing transition metals on zeolite supports - Patent Application 20070123333
A heterogeneous catalyst system with transition metals on zeolite supports enables direct hydrogenation of esters to ethers, addressing the limitations of existing methods by enhancing selectivity and stability for commercial ether production.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2024523396
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2021-11-05
- Filing Date
- 2022-11-02
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-19
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for producing ethers are limited by the use of strongly acidic or basic conditions, which lead to undesirable side reactions, limited structural diversity, and the use of toxic raw materials, making them unsuitable for commercial scale-up.
A process for producing ethers directly from alkyl esters using molecular hydrogen over a heterogeneous catalyst system comprising transition metals supported on zeolite supports, which facilitates a one-step direct hydrogenation reaction.
This process achieves high selectivity and stability for ether production, minimizing side reactions and reducing environmental impact, allowing for cost-effective commercial production of ethers.
Smart Images

Figure 2024542947000001 
Figure 2024542947000002 
Figure 2024542947000003
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a process for producing ether compounds, more specifically, the present invention relates to a process for producing ether compounds directly from alkyl esters using molecular hydrogen over a heterogeneous catalyst. [Background technology]
[0002] Ethers are used in a variety of applications, including as solvents. Ethers are particularly desirable for use as solvents in applications because of their excellent solvency, chemical stability, and compatibility with other organic solvents and formulation products. Known routes to synthesize ethers include three routes: (1) alkyl halides treated with alkoxides (the so-called "Williamson ether synthesis"); (2) alcohol addition to olefins; and (3) acid-catalyzed coupling of alcohols. However, the above three routes have undesirable limitations, including (1) the use of strongly acidic or basic conditions that can lead to competing elimination reactions that produce undesirable olefins; (2) limited options for biologically derived feedstocks due to lack of reactivity with the above reactions that limits the structural diversity of the products; and (3) the use of toxic feedstocks and generation of waste streams in the manufacturing process. It is therefore desirable to provide a viable route to produce ethers that can be successfully scaled up commercially without the limitations of the above known routes.
[0003] For example, previously known methods for producing ethers include: (1) J. Org. Chem., 2007, 72, 5920-5922; Tetrahedron (2) a process for producing thionates (salts or esters of thioic acid), such as thioethers (sulfides, which are compounds in which sulfur and two organic residues are combined), as disclosed in J. Org. Chem., 1981, 46, 831-832; (3) a process for catalytic reduction of α-monoglycerides at about 700 psi (4.8 megapascals [MPa]) and 120 degrees Celsius (°C) using a 5% Pd / C catalyst mixed with an acid promoter, as disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 8,912,365; (4) a process for catalytic reduction of α-monoglycerides at about 700 psi (4.8 megapascals [MPa]) and 120 degrees Celsius (°C), as disclosed in Russian Chemical Bulletin 1988, 37(1), 15-19 and Russian Chemical Bulletin 1990, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2030, 2030, 2040, 2050, 2060, 2070, 2080, 2090, 2100, 2111, 2120, 2130, 2140, 2150, 2160, 2170, 2180, 2190, 2200, 2211, 2220, 223 1986, 35, 280-283, with up to 4.6% conversion and up to 57% selectivity, and (5) processes for hydrogenating lactones to cyclic ethers to produce (for example) tetrahydrofuran with high selectivity, such as greater than 90% (>90%), using a variety of metal catalysts on a variety of supports, as disclosed in U.S. Pat. Nos. 3,370,067, 3,894,054, and 4,973,717. (6) Processes using homogeneous metal complex catalysts (e.g., ruthenium / triphos complexes) that require impractical separation of the catalyst from the product. Angewandte Chemie,International Edition,2015,54,5196-5200;ChemSusChem,2016,9,1442-1448.
[0004] Recently filed U.S. patent application Ser. No. 63 / 107,739 describes a process for the direct conversion of esters to ethers using transition metals supported on metal oxide supports such as Nb2O5 and WO3. Although the invention reported high direct selectivities for ether formation by hydrogenation, the absolute selectivities for ether products from hydrogenation were generally low, typically in the range of 5-10%, with a maximum of 16%. Further improvements in catalyst selectivity are needed to make this process economically viable.
[0005] It would therefore be desirable to have alternative processes for producing ethers that can be commercially produced and that offer advantages over existing processes, including improved absolute and / or direct selectivity. Summary of the Invention
[0006] The present invention relates to a novel process for producing ether products from ester starting materials using a transition metal catalyst on a zeolite support.
[0007] In a broad embodiment, the process of the present invention involves producing ethers by hydrogenating esters in the presence of a heterogeneous catalyst.
[0008] In one embodiment, the process of the invention involves the selective reduction of carboxylic acid derivatives directly to ethers using molecular hydrogen and an appropriate catalyst formulation to achieve high (e.g., >10%) absolute ether selectivity along with high (e.g., >80%) direct ether selectivity. Absolute ether selectivity is the proportion of total products formed in the reaction, and direct ether product selectivity is the proportion of direct ether products to total ether products.
[0009] In another embodiment, the process of the present invention for producing an ether comprises combining (a) at least one ester in the presence of (b) hydrogen and (c) a heterogeneous catalyst to hydrogenate the ester to form the ether.
[0010] In yet another embodiment, the present invention comprises a solvent comprising the above-described ether product produced by the above-described process.
[0011] Some of the advantageous features that may be provided by one or more embodiments of the processes of the present invention include, for example: (1) An active catalyst is used in a one-step process: the catalyst is active for reducing esters to form ethers by direct hydrogenation of the ester rather than via the known two-step ether-forming process, such as (i) ester hydrogenolysis to form alcohols followed by (ii) alcohol dehydration. (2) Use of a relatively inexpensive route. The process uses inexpensive molecular hydrogen as the reducing agent, rather than expensive hydrosilanes, metal hydrides, or metal hydride / Lewis acid complexes as hydride donors. The highly reactive hydrosilanes or metal hydrides used in the prior art processes also require complex and expensive process designs to ensure the safety of operators running the prior art processes. (3) Using a heterogeneous catalyst The fact that the catalyst is heterogeneous rather than homogeneous can contribute to reducing production costs due to the reusability and separability of the catalyst. (4) Use efficient processes. (5) Use of a flexible process: The process is applicable to general ester compounds (cyclic or non-cyclic) as raw materials, and the process is not limited to a specific ester compound. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0012] In one embodiment, the present invention comprises a distinct and novel method for the synthesis of ethers from esters using heterogeneous catalysts. Reactions of esters over heterogeneous catalysts include a variety of chemical reaction routes or pathways, such as hydrogenolysis, hydrolysis, dehydration, hydrogenation, and transesterification. In a general embodiment, the process of the present invention comprises the production of ethers by hydrogenation of esters, such as propyl acetate, in the presence of a heterogeneous catalyst. The novel hydrogenation reaction pathway or scheme of the present invention, such as the hydrogenation of propyl acetate reduction reaction scheme where R1 is -CH3 and R2 is -CH2CH3, is generally shown below as reaction scheme (I).
[0013] [ka]
[0014] In the above reaction scheme (I), water is produced by the reduction process, and the produced water can be separated by conventional processes such as distillation or other procedures known in the art. The functional groups R1, R2 can be alkyl functional groups, including linear or branched alkyl groups, cyclic or non-cyclic alkyl groups, and mixtures thereof. Examples of esters herein include, but are not limited to, ethyl acetate, propyl acetate, butyl acetate, ethyl propionate, butyl propionate, and mixtures thereof. The desired ether product obtained from the above reaction scheme (I) can be a symmetrical ether when R1 is equivalent to R2, or an asymmetrical ether when R1 is not equivalent to R2, for example, the asymmetrical ether can be ethyl propyl ether.
[0015] By "symmetric ether" herein is meant an ether containing two identical functional groups, where R1 is equal to R2. By "asymmetric ether" herein is meant an ether containing two different functional groups, where R1 is not equal to R2.
[0016] In the present invention, the desired reaction scheme, reaction scheme (I), is a direct hydrogenation route to obtain the desired ether product. "Direct hydrogenation" or "direct selective reduction" refers to the removal of the carbonyl oxygen from an ester (R1COOCH2R2) by hydrogenation to form an ether (R1CH2OCH2R2) while keeping the alkoxy group intact. The present process differs from known processes because the present process does not go through the typical route of ester (R1COOCH2R2) hydrogenation, where the ester is first decomposed into two alcohols (R1CH2OH+R2CH2OH molecules) via hydrogenolysis, and then the mixture of ethers (R1CH2OCH2R1+R1CH2OCH2R2) is decomposed into two alcohols (R1CH2OCH2R1+R1CH2OCH2R2) via dehydration. 2+ R2CH2OCH2R2). Direct hydrogenation can maintain the structure of the ether from the ester by only removing the carbonyl oxygen. Thus, the asymmetric ester provided in this process advantageously leads to the direct production of the asymmetric ether since this process does not decompose the ester into two alcohol molecules by hydrogenolysis. The selectivity of ethyl propyl ether in the reaction example is listed in Tables III and V described in the following examples.
[0017] The term "direct ether product" as used herein means an ether formed by a one-step reduction process of an ether from an ester.
[0018] The term "indirect ether product" as used herein means an ether formed by a two-step reduction process of an ether from an ester, the two-step reduction process including the steps of (i) hydrogenolysis and (ii) dehydration.
[0019] The term "direct ether product selectivity" herein means the ratio of direct ether products to total ether products. For example, for the reduction of propyl acetate, ethyl propyl ether is the direct ether product, and the direct ether product selectivity is the ratio of ethyl propyl ether to total ether products (ethyl propyl ether + dipropyl ether + diethyl ether).
[0020] The term "absolute ether product selectivity" herein means the proportion of ether product among all products (eg, ethers, alcohols, and alkanes) formed in a reaction.
[0021] Advantageously, one unique factor of the present invention involves increased direct ether selectivity using the one-step process of the present invention versus the known two-step process.
[0022] In one embodiment, the process of the invention for producing an ether comprises treating (a) an ester with (b) hydrogen, (c) in the presence of a heterogeneous catalyst to hydrogenatively reduce the ester to form an ether.
[0023] In one desirable embodiment, as shown in the above reaction scheme (I), the process of the present invention for producing ethers includes the steps of (A) feeding an ester compound, such as propyl acetate, component (a) to a reactor, (B) feeding hydrogen, component (b), to the reactor to form a hydrogen atmosphere in the reactor, (C) charging the reactor with a heterogeneous catalyst system, component (c), comprising a transition metal on a zeolite support sufficient to cause a hydrogenation reaction in the reactor, and (D) heating the reactor contents, components (a)-(c), at a temperature sufficient to reduce the ester compound to form an ether compound. For example, the heating step (D) can be carried out at a temperature between 350 Kelvin (K) and 650 K. It will also be readily understood by those skilled in the art that the order of the recited steps may be changed in certain circumstances or the steps may be carried out simultaneously.
[0024] As is commonly known in the art, a "heterogeneous catalyst" refers to a catalyst whose phase (e.g., solid, liquid, or gas) is different from the phase of the reactants. For example, the reactants (esters and hydrogen) and products (e.g., ethers) may be in the liquid or gas phase, but the catalyst is a solid.
[0025] In the present invention, the heterogeneous catalyst system of the present invention is a combination of a transition metal and a zeolite support. For example, the catalyst used in some embodiments of the present invention can include 0.1 weight percent (wt%) to 20 wt% of a transition metal supported on a zeolite support element.
[0026] As generally known in the art, zeolites are crystalline aluminosilicate materials composed of corner-sharing AlO4 and SiO4 tetrahedra bound into a three-dimensional framework with pores of molecular dimensions. The presence of aluminum in the zeolite framework results in a negative charge that is balanced by cations. The zeolite of the present invention advantageously has a framework type that may be selected from the group consisting of the following framework types FAU, MOR, BEA, CHA, FER, MFI, and combinations thereof, which framework type corresponds to the naming convention of the International Zeolite Association.
[0027] The atomic Si / Al ratio is often used in catalysis practice to characterize zeolites and refers to the number of silicon-containing sites (typically SiO2) present per alumina-containing site (typically HAlO2). Zeolites for use in the present invention may have a Si:Al ratio ranging from 1 to 300. In some embodiments, the ratio may be from 2 to 250, or even from 10 to 50.
[0028] The synergistic effect from both the transition metal component and the zeolite support component promotes the direct ether reduction route as depicted in the reaction pathway reaction scheme (I). Without the combination of the transition metal and zeolite support elements as disclosed herein, the undesirable two-step ether formation route would occur. Steady-state rates and product selectivities for competing reaction pathways of model ester compounds are obtained as a function of reactant pressure, temperature and ester conversion controlled by superficial residence time, for example, in packed bed and / or trickle bed reactors.
[0029] The ester compound to be reduced to ether, component (a), can include one or more ester compounds, such as carboxylic acid derivatives, esters containing linear or branched alkyl groups, and cyclic or non-cyclic alkyl groups, and mixtures thereof. In some embodiments, the asymmetric ether includes reaction scheme (I) in which the R1 group is not equal to the R2 group. In some embodiments, the esters useful in the present invention can be, for example, propyl acetate (available from Sigma-Aldrich), butyl acetate (available from Sigma-Aldrich), butyl propionate, glycerol esters; and mixtures thereof.
[0030] The concentration of the ester, component (a), is not particularly critical. However, in some embodiments, it may be advantageous for the ester to be present in an amount of at least 1 wt. % to provide a desired production rate and / or avoid increased separation costs. In some embodiments, the concentration of the ester is from 1 wt. % to 100 wt. %. The concentration of the ester is based on the total weight of the ester compound in the liquid feedstock.
[0031] The concentration of hydrogen, component (b), useful in the process of the present invention, is, for example, 3% to 100% by weight in one embodiment, 10% to 100% by weight in another embodiment, and 50% to 100% by weight in yet another embodiment. Low concentrations of hydrogen, for example less than 3% by weight (<3%), may reduce reactivity or ether selectivity and thus, in such cases, would require an undesirable increase in reaction pressure. The concentration of hydrogen is based on the total weight of hydrogen in the gaseous feed.
[0032] In a broad embodiment, the catalyst, component (c), used in the process of the present invention may comprise one or more heterogeneous catalyst compounds. The catalyst used in the process of the present invention may, for example, comprise a combination of transition metals (ci) supported on a zeolite support (carrier) element (cii). For example, the transition metals (component (ci)) may include palladium (Pd), platinum (Pt), ruthenium (Ru), cobalt (Co), copper (Cu), rhodium (Rh), rhenium (Re), nickel (Ni), and mixtures thereof. The acidic zeolite support element (component (cii)) may be derived from any zeolite or mixture of zeolites including, for example, faujasite zeolite ("FAU"); sodium Y zeolite (NaY) (sodium ion exchanged Y zeolite); mordenite zeolite ("MOR"); beta zeolite ("BEA"); chabazite zeolite ("CHA"); ferrierite zeolite ("FER"); Mobil-five zeolite ("MFI") and mixtures thereof. These zeolites may preferably have a Si to Al ratio in the range of 2 to 250. In one preferred embodiment, the heterogeneous catalyst useful in the present invention can be Pd supported on a FAU support, Pt supported on a FAU, MOR, FER or CHA support; Rh supported on a FAU3 support, and mixtures thereof.
[0033] The heterogeneous catalysts of the present invention exhibit several advantageous properties. For example, the heterogeneous catalysts useful in the present invention provide a synergistic effect between the metal compound (e.g., Pd or Pt) of the catalyst and the zeolite support of the catalyst to catalyze direct ester hydrogenation, which may otherwise result in reduced ether selectivity.
[0034] The heterogeneous catalyst as component (c) may, for example, in one embodiment, contain 0.01 wt % to 20 wt % of a metal compound based on the total weight of the heterogeneous catalyst, in another embodiment, contain 0.1 wt % to 10 wt % of a metal compound based on the total weight of the heterogeneous catalyst, and in yet another embodiment, contain 1 wt % to 5 wt % of a metal compound based on the total weight of the heterogeneous catalyst.
[0035] The process equipment used to carry out the reduction process can be any conventional reactor, such as a packed bed reactor or a trickle bed reactor, and the ester conversion and ether selectivity can be controlled by reactor pressure, temperature and superficial residence time.
[0036] For example, the pressure of the process of the present invention is, in one embodiment, 0.1 MPa to 10 MPa, in another embodiment, 2 MPa to 6 MPa, and in yet another embodiment, 6 MPa to 10 MPa. Pressures below the aforementioned ranges may result in lower reactivity or lower ether selectivity than disclosed herein. Pressures higher than the aforementioned ranges may be sufficient for use in the present invention, but may require higher costs in reactor construction and operation.
[0037] For example, the temperature of the process of the present invention is from 350K to 650K in one embodiment, from 400K to 500K in another embodiment, and from 500K to 650K in yet another embodiment. Temperatures below the aforementioned ranges may result in lower reactivity than that disclosed herein. Temperatures above the aforementioned ranges may result in undesirable alkane and alcohol by-products, and therefore, in such cases, ether selectivity may be reduced.
[0038] For example, the ester conversion of the process of the present invention is from 1% to 100% in one embodiment, from 1% to 50% in another embodiment, and from 50% to 100% in yet another embodiment. In some embodiments, ester conversions higher than the aforementioned conversion ranges may result in side reaction products.
[0039] The process of the invention can be carried out as a batch process or a continuous process. In some embodiments, when a batch process is used, the residence time of the process of the invention is, for example, from 0.1 hour (hr) to 24 hours in one embodiment, from 0.1 hr to 8 hr in another embodiment, and from 1 hr to 24 hr in yet another embodiment. In some embodiments, residence times below the aforementioned residence time ranges may result in lower ester conversion, and in some embodiments, residence times above the aforementioned residence time ranges may result in undesirable side reaction products.
[0040] In some embodiments, when a continuous process is used, the residence time of the process of the invention is, for example, from 0.1 seconds to 100 seconds in one embodiment, from 1 second to 10 seconds in another embodiment, and from 10 seconds to 100 seconds in yet another embodiment. Residence times below the aforementioned residence time ranges may result in lower ester conversions, and in some embodiments, residence times above the aforementioned residence time ranges may result in undesirable side reaction products.
[0041] Some advantageous properties and / or benefits of using the reduction process of the present invention include, for example, that the process of the present invention can achieve a steady state rate and that the process can provide better selectivity of products for competing reaction pathways of ester compounds, even better than other heterogeneous catalysts that do not feature a zeolite support. Also, the process of the present invention does not produce salts, whereas conventional processes for producing ethers also produce salts.
[0042] After the ester compound undergoes a reduction process, the resulting ether product is formed. The turnover rate from ester to ether product is typically 10 -8 moles of ether / grams of catalyst / second (moles / g cat s)~10 -5 moles / g cat s, 5×10 -8 moles / g cat s~5×10 -6 moles / g cat Ester turnover rates below the aforementioned rate ranges may result in lower ether production rates, and in some embodiments, ester turnover rates above the aforementioned residence time ranges may result in undesirable side reaction products.
[0043] The selectivity of the ether product may depend on whether a vapor or liquid process is used to form the ether, and whether a batch or continuous process is used. Generally, the selectivity of the direct ether product is greater than 10% in one embodiment, between 10% and 25% in another embodiment, and between 25% and 60% in yet another embodiment.
[0044] The ether product produced by the process of the present invention can be a symmetrical or asymmetrical ether, but as an example of the present invention and not limited thereby, the process of the present invention is described with reference to an asymmetrical ether.Surprisingly, it has been discovered that the process of the present invention is selective for asymmetrical ethers, since in the process of the present invention, esters are directly converted to ethers without undergoing ester hydrogenolysis and alcohol dehydration.Ester hydrogenolysis and alcohol dehydration are two processes that are known to be unselective for certain ethers.
[0045] When an asymmetric ether is desired for a particular process or end use, use of the process of the present invention has advantages over conventional processes for the following reasons. (1) The ether products are more stable than the corresponding ester products under basic and acidic conditions, and the ether products of the present invention are typically not subject to hydrolysis that can occur at high humidity and / or high temperature. (2) The hydrogen reaction chemistry of the process of the present invention is believed to keep the backbone of the ester product intact. During hydrogenation, only the oxygen molecules are detached from the backbone, leaving the carbon molecules and backbone oxygens intact. In conventional reaction processes, the reaction breaks the backbone and recombines parts together under different reaction conditions. Therefore, direct hydrogenation / reduction of esters to ethers does not occur. (3) The process of the present invention minimizes undesirable side reactions that can adversely affect the selectivity of the desired ether product.
[0046] Since the ether products of the present invention are derived from organic and renewable sources, the ether products of the present invention have minimal impact on the environment. For example, the ether products can be advantageously used as global green and bio-based solvents to address the stringent regulations imposed on chemical industrial solvents regarding toxicity, non-biodegradability, volatile organic compound (VOC) emissions, etc. Green and bio-based solvents are typically used in paint and coating applications. Other applications include adhesives, pharmaceuticals, and printing inks. In some embodiments, the ether products can be used as foam control agents and flavor additives. In other embodiments, the ether products can be used in cosmetics and personal care applications.
[0047] The present invention provides bio-based solvents with cost and performance advantages over solvents known in industry. In addition, the chemical transformations provided by the process of the present invention may be useful for producing, for example, bio-based surfactants, antifoams and lubricants in an economical and environmentally friendly process.
[0048] The ether production process of the present invention can also be used to develop (1) a more robust capping process to overcome the problem of limited reactant alkyl chloride type and final product impurities, (2) novel capped low viscosity-low volatility lubricants, and (3) novel surfactants and novel bio-based defoamers for food and pharmaceutical applications, metalworking fluid applications, and other applications utilizing ether solvents. EXAMPLES
[0049] The following Inventive Examples (Inv. Ex.) and Comparative Examples (Comp. Ex.) (collectively "Examples") are presented herein to further illustrate the present invention, but should not be construed as limiting the scope of the claims. Unless otherwise indicated, all parts and percentages are by weight.
[0050] catalyst The catalyst ("Catalyst") formulations used in the examples are set forth in Tables I and II. Examples using Catalyst 1 through Catalyst 14 below (Table I) were tested in a vapor phase reactor, while examples using Catalyst 15 through Catalyst 28 (Table II) were tested in a liquid phase reactor.
[0051] Transition metal particles (Pd, Pt, Ru, Co, Ni, Cu, Rh) were deposited on zeolites (FAU, Tosoh; NaY, ACS Materials; MOR, ACS Materials and Tosoh; BEA, Tosoh; MFI, Tosoh and Zeolyst; CHA, ACS Materials; FER, Zeolyst) using incipient wetness impregnation (IWI), weakly capping growth approach (WCGA), ion exchange (IE) or by a modified NaBH4 reduction method, as shown.
[0052] The IWI method involves preparing aqueous solutions with precursor concentrations adjusted to the indicated weight loading. An equal volume of the support pore volume was added dropwise to the support to achieve incipient wetness. For the Pd-deposited zeolite catalysts prepared by the IWI method, catalyst 4 used Pd(NH3)4Cl2·H2O as the precursor, whereas catalyst 5, catalyst 22-catalyst 25 used Pd(NH3)4(NO3)2 as the precursor. For the Pt, Rh, Ru, Ni, and Co-deposited zeolite catalysts (catalyst 9-catalyst 14, catalyst 16-catalyst 26), the precursors used were [Pt(NH3)4](NO3)2, Rh(NO3)3·xH2O, Ru(NO)(NO3)3, Ni(NO3)2·6H2O, Cu(NO3)2·2.5H2O, and Co(NO3)2·6H2O, respectively.
[0053] The WCGA method involves the synthesis procedures as published in Journal of the American Chemical Society 2015, 137(36), 11743-11748 and Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research 2021, 60, 2326-2336. First, palladium acetate (Pd(OAc)2) is dissolved in methanol and stirred to obtain 170 mg Pd L -1 After the precursor is dissolved, the zeolite support is added to the solution and left stirring for at least 18 h. The initial yellow solution turns dark during the synthesis. The Pd-zeolite solid is collected by centrifugation and washed with methanol. After centrifugation, the solid has a dark gray to black color and the filtrate is clear. Catalyst 1-Catalyst 3, Catalyst 6, Catalyst 8, Catalyst 15 were prepared by the WCGA method.
[0054] The IE method involves the synthesis procedure published in the Journal of Catalysis 1989,118(1),266-274). Briefly, the catalyst is synthesized by preparing an aqueous solution of the metal precursors and adding the support while stirring. The sample is left stirring for at least 18 hours and then separated by centrifugation. Catalyst 7 was prepared by the IE method.
[0055] The modified NaBH4 reduction method is as described in JJournal of Molecular Catalysis A:Chemical 2013,376,63-70. Briefly, 5 grams of zeolite and 483 mg of ruthenium chloride hydrate (RuCl3·xH2O) were mixed with 150 mL of ethanol at 250 cm 3 The mixture is stirred vigorously under Ar for at least 24 h. Then, ethanol (40 cm 3 A 0.3 M solution of NaBH4 in 100 mL of 1000 mM NaBH2O is added dropwise to the mixture and the resulting mixture is stirred for at least an additional 24 hours. The catalyst is collected by filtration and washed with ethanol.
[0056] Regardless of the method used to prepare them, the resulting wet solids are dried in a static oven at 353 K for >12 h. The samples are then heated to the oxidation treatment temperature in flowing air (Ultra Zero Grade Air) and held for 2-12 h. The samples are then cooled to ambient temperature. The samples are then heated to the reduction temperature in flowing 20% H2 / He (H2, Ultra High Purity 5.0) and (He, Ultra High Purity 5.0) and held for 0.5-4 h. The samples are cooled to ambient temperature and heated in flowing air / He (Ultra Zero Grade Air, 2 cm 3 min -1 ) and (He, Ultra High Purity 5.0, 250cm 3 min -1 ) for 1 hour to allow passivation and then expose to ambient air.
[0057] Elemental analysis by energy dispersive X-ray fluorescence (EDXRF) and inductively coupled plasma (ICP) analysis revealed that H + The ratio of Pd to (Al) and the total weight loading are given.
[0058] [Table 1]
[0059] [Table 2]
[0060] The examples using Catalyst 1 through Catalyst 28 are representative examples of the invention (Inv. Ex.), while the examples using Catalyst 29 through Catalyst 33 are comparative examples (Comp. Ex.). Catalysts 29 through 32 in Tables III and IV were prepared using the incipient wetness impregnation method described in recently filed U.S. patent application Ser. No. 63 / 107,739 using the materials listed in Tables III and IV. Catalyst 33 in Table IV was prepared by the incipient wetness impregnation method using aluminum silicate (Al2O3-SiO2) purchased from Sigma Aldrich as the support.
[0061] [Table 3]
[0062] [Table 4]
[0063] Test Measurements The processes of the invention include those which (1) use molecular hydrogen (H2) as the reducing agent, (2) are carried out in the vapor or liquid phase, and (3) use a heterogeneous catalyst for the reduction of esters to ethers, where the heterogeneous catalyst comprises a transition metal, e.g., a Pd-based catalyst, and the catalyst support (support) is a zeolite in the inventive embodiment or an acid support, e.g., a WO3-based catalyst support or a Nb2O5-based catalyst support in the comparative embodiment.
[0064] Part A: Catalytic rate measurements in vapor phase reactors Catalysts 1-14 and comparative catalysts 29 and 30 were tested in a vapor phase reactor. The vapor phase reactor is a tubular packed bed reactor held in a stainless steel tube (outer diameter, OD 9.5 millimeters [mm]) containing 10 milligrams (mg) to 200 mg of catalyst. The catalyst is held in the center of the reactor using a glass rod and packed glass wool. The tubular reactor is placed in a three-zone furnace (Applied Test Systems, available from 3210) controlled by an electronic temperature controller (Watlow, available from EZ-Zone). The catalyst temperature is measured by a K-type thermocouple contained in a 1.6 mm stainless steel sheath (available from Omega) that is aligned coaxially within the reactor and submerged in the catalyst bed. A 1.4 cubic centimeter (cm 3 ) of catalyst was prepared by mixing an excess of silicon carbide (SiC) (available from Washington Mills, Carborex green 36) with the desired amount of catalyst. 3 The catalyst bed volume is kept constant with a pressure regulator (EPR, Equilibar LF Series, available from Equilibar Precision Pressure Control) controlled by an electronic pressure regulator (EPR, Equilibar GP1, available from Equilibar Precision Pressure). The reactor pressure is monitored upstream and downstream of the catalyst bed using a digital pressure gauge (available from Omega) and an EPR, respectively.
[0065] The gases used in the examples are H2 (available from Airgas Inc. as "Ultra High Purity 5.0") and He (available from Airgas Inc. as "Ultra High Purity 5.0"). Gas flow rates are controlled using mass flow controllers (available from Bronkhorst as "EL-FLOW High Pressure"). Liquid propyl acetate (CH 10O2, supplied by Sigma Aldrich, 537438, at 99.5% or higher [≥99.5%]) was 10 A stainless steel syringe pump with a Hastelloy cylinder (100DX with D-series controller, available from Teledyne Isco) is used to control as O2 is fed through a polyether ether ketone (PEEK) polymer tube (1.6 mm OD and 0.25 mm inner diameter, ID) whose outlet is placed within a small bed of non-porous sand (SiO2 50-70 mesh particle size, supplied by Sigma Aldrich, 274739) in a cross-flow of H2. To avoid condensation, the transfer lines surrounding the liquid inlet are maintained at 373 K using heating tape (available from Omega). All transfer lines downstream of the liquid inlet are heated above 373 K using heating tape, and the line temperature is monitored with a K-type thermocouple (available from Omega) displayed on a digital reader (available from Omega).
[0066] The catalyst was heated to the desired temperature at 0.08 Kelvin / s (K s) prior to all catalytic measurements. -1 ) and the catalyst is heated to 100 cubic centimeters per minute (cm 3 ) of H2 at that temperature for the desired time. 3 min -1The reactor is pretreated in situ by flowing at 100 psi (0.4 psi) and holding at 101 kilopascals (kPa). The reactor effluent is characterized using an on-line gas chromatograph (HP6890, available from Agilent). The gas chromatograph (GC) is equipped with a capillary column (DB-624 UI, 30 meters (m) long, 0.25 mm ID, 1.40 micrometers [μm]) connected to a flame ionization detector to quantify the concentration of combustible species. Sensitivity factors and retention times for all components are determined using gas and liquid standards. Control of reactor pressure and temperature, reactant flow rates, and GC sampling are automated to allow continuous measurements. Conversion is calculated on a carbon basis based on the amount of carbon appearing in the product. Carbon and oxygen balances are within ±20%. Reactor conditions during rate and selectivity measurements were varied by successively decreasing and then increasing the reactant pressure over the entire range of 1 MPa to 10 MPa, with one or more conditions being measured at least twice throughout the experiment to ensure that any trends measured were not the result of systematic deactivation.
[0067] Part B: Measurement of catalytic rates in liquid-phase reactors Catalysts 15-28 and comparative catalysts 31 and 32 are tested in a liquid phase reactor. Rate and selectivity measurements are performed in a trickle bed reactor containing a stainless steel tube (1.6 mm OD) containing 1,000 mg-4,000 mg of catalyst (30 mesh-60 mesh), which is held in the center of the reactor using a Pyrex glass rod and packed glass wool. The reactor is heated in an aluminum clamshell containing two heating cartridges controlled by an electronic temperature controller (EZ-Zone available from Watlow). The reaction temperature is measured by a K-type thermocouple contained within a 3.2 mm stainless steel sheath (available from Omega) that is coaxially aligned within the reactor and submerged within the aluminum clamshell. The system is pressurized up to 6.6 MPa using a dome type back pressure regulator (BPR) (Equilibar LF Series available from Equilibar Precision Pressure Control) controlled by an electronic pressure regulator (EPR) (Equilibar GP1 available from Equilibar Precision Pressure Control). Reactor pressure is monitored using a digital pressure gauge (available from Omega) and the EPR.
[0068] The gas flows of H2 (available from Airgas) and He (available from Airgas) are controlled using mass flow controllers (EL-FLOW High Pressure controllers available from Bronkhorst). Liquid propyl acetate (CH) supplied by Sigma Aldrich, 537438. 10 O2) flow rate is ≧99.5%, C5H 10 O2 is controlled using a high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) pump (P-LST40B available from Chromtech) while being fed through stainless steel tubing (1.6 mm OD and 0.15 mm ID) in a cross-flow of H2 and He.
[0069] The catalyst was heated at 0.08 K s before all catalytic measurements.-1 Heat to 423K or 573K at 50cm 3 min -1 The reactor is pretreated in situ by holding it in He (20 kPa) and H2 (81 kPa) flowing at 37°C for 2 h. The reactor effluent passes through a stainless steel cooling chamber containing cold water (temperature of about 377 K), and then the gaseous and liquid products are separated in a gas-liquid separator (GLS). The liquid products collected in the GLS are pumped by an HPLC pump to a high-pressure liquid sampling valve (LSV, Transcendent Enterprise Inc., PLIS-6890, 1 μL injection volume) attached to an online gas chromatograph (Agilent, HP 7890B). At the outlet of the LSV, a manual BPR (Swagelok) is installed to maintain the liquid pressure at 1,380 kPa to prevent the products from evaporating in the sampling system. The gaseous and liquid products are characterized using online gas chromatograph (Agilent, HP 7890B). The GC is equipped with two capillary columns for the liquid products (DB-Wax UI, 60 m long, 0.25 mm ID, 0.25 μm, available from Agilent) and a GS-GASPRO (GC column, 60 m long, 0.32 mm ID, available from Agilent) connected to a flame ionization detector to quantify the species concentrations. Sensitivity factors and retention times for all gaseous and liquid products are determined using gas standards and methanizers (Polyarc System, PA-SYC-411, available from Activated Research Company), respectively. Control of reaction pressure and temperature, reactant and product flow rates, and GC sampling are automated to allow continuous measurements. Conversion is calculated on a carbon basis based on the amount of carbon appearing in the products. Carbon balances are within ±10%.
[0070] Test results Reaction pathway using propyl acetate as the ester starting compound A kinetic study of the catalysts (Catalyst 1-Catalyst 28) used in the examples for the direct selective reduction of propyl acetate (an example of a representative ester) with molecular hydrogen is performed to determine the reaction pathways for converting propyl acetate to ethers. By GC analysis, several products are observed in the product stream exiting the fixed-bed reactor. The various products include, for example, C2-C3 alkanes and alkenes, ethanol, propanol, dipropyl ether, diethyl ether, ethyl propyl ether, acetic acid, and light hydrocarbons such as ethyl acetate. Based on this observation, it can be concluded that the reaction occurred via several routes in the reactor, including: For example, (1) hydrogenolysis of propyl acetate to one ethanol and one propanol, (2) hydrolysis of propyl acetate to form propanol and acetic acid, (3) the alcohols can then be dehydrated to form light hydrocarbons and can be dehydrated to form ether products such as dipropyl ether, diethyl ether and ethyl propyl ether, (4) transesterification of propyl acetate with ethanol to form ethyl acetate and propanol, and (5) reaction scheme (I), which is the route of the present invention, i.e., direct hydrogenation of propyl acetate with hydrogen to form ethyl propyl ether. Since the desired product is ethyl propyl ether by direct hydrogenation of propyl acetate, the route of reaction scheme (I) of the present invention is the desired reaction route. It should be noted that ethyl propyl ether can also be formed from route (3) above. However, route (3) above is not desirable because it involves an alcohol dehydration reaction, and such alcohol dehydration reaction is not selective for the formation of asymmetric ethers over symmetric ethers such as dipropyl ether or diethyl ether. The process of the present invention is not limited to the production of either symmetric or asymmetric ethers. Advantageously, the process of the present invention provides asymmetric ethers where desired or necessary in a selective and straightforward route.
[0071] Part A: Results of the above phase ester reduction Examples 1 to 5 and Comparative Examples A to M The ether selectivity results using inventive Examples 1-14 and comparative Examples 29 and 30, catalyst 1-catalyst 14, and 29 and 30 in the vapor phase are listed in Table V. The hydrogenation was carried out under the following reaction conditions: temperature 356-503 K, H2 pressure 6.2 MPa, propyl acetate pressure 10 kPa.
[0072] [Table 5-1]
[0073] [Table 5-2]
[0074] Part B: Results of solution-phase ester reduction Examples 15 to 28 and Comparative Examples 31 to 33 In inventive Examples 14-28 and comparative Examples 31-33, hydrogenation is carried out in a liquid phase reactor using the indicated catalyst. The reactions for the inventive examples are carried out at 6293 kPa H2 pressure and 119 kPa ester pressure. The reactions for the comparative examples are carried out at 4977 kPa H2 pressure and 1573 kPa ester pressure. In a liquid phase reactor, the molar concentration of the ester is higher in the feed stream compared to the vapor phase reactor, and the ester is maintained in a liquid state. Ether product selectivities are listed in Table VI.
[0075] [Table 6]
[0076] Part A: Vapor phase ester reduction In the present invention, in Examples 1-9, the selectivity for the formation of dipropyl ether and diethyl ether from propyl acetate is less than 3% in most cases, while the relative selectivity for ethyl propyl ether among all three ether products is more than 80% in most cases. Since alcohol dehydration has no preference in selectivity for symmetric or asymmetric ethers, such performance indicates that substantially all of the ethyl propyl ether is formed based on the direct hydrogenation reaction pathway of propyl acetate.
[0077] The results of Inventive Example 1 to Inventive Example 3 show that Pd deposited on FAU with a Si / Al ratio of 50 provides direct hydrogenation of esters to ethers. Pd metal loading has only a small effect on ether selectivity. Pd loading on FAU with Si / Al ratios of 0.5 to 4 wt% can be effective for direct ester reduction.
[0078] The results of Inventive Example 4 to Inventive Example 5 show that the preparation method via IWI and the use of different precursors have only a small effect on the direction of hydrogenation of esters to ethers. Pd deposited on FAU50 prepared by IWI using either Pd(NH3)4Cl2·H2O or Pd(NH3)4(NO3)2 precursors can be effective for direct ester reduction.
[0079] The results of Inventive Example 6 to Inventive Example 7 show that Pd deposited on FAU with a Si / Al ratio of 250 and on Y zeolite with a Si / Al ratio of 2 can be effective for direct ester reduction.
[0080] The results of Inventive Example 8 show that Pd deposited on BEA250 works to some extent, but is not very effective in performing direct ester hydrogenation.
[0081] The results of Inventive Example 8 to Inventive Example 9 show that Pt and Rh deposited FAU50 catalysts can be effective for direct ester hydrogenation.
[0082] The results of Inventive Example 11 to Inventive Example 14 show that transition metals such as Ru, Ni, Cu and Co on FAU50 supports function to some extent, but they are not very effective for direct ester hydrogenation.
[0083] The best direct ester reduction performance observed in the vapor phase reaction was observed in inventive Example 2 using Catalyst 2 (4.00 wt. % Pd deposited on FAU with a Si / Al ratio of 50), giving an absolute ethyl propyl ether selectivity of 48.4% with a direct ether selectivity of 90.0%.
[0084] Part B: Solution-phase ester reduction In Examples 15-19 of the present invention, the absolute selectivity for ethyl propyl ether and the obtained direct ether selectivity indicate that the metal-deposited zeolite catalysts (Pd deposited on FAU50, Pt deposited on MOR10, Pt deposited on MOR120, Pt deposited on FER10 and Pt deposited on CHA10) can be applied to direct ester reduction in liquid phase reaction.
[0085] The results of Examples 20-28 of the present invention show that Pt deposited on zeolite supports such as MFI11.5 and BEA14, as well as Pd-deposited zeolite supports such as BEA14, MOR10, MFI11.5 and CHA10, and Ru-deposited zeolite supports such as MOR10, BEA250 and MFI180 all function to some extent but are less effective in performing direct ester hydrogenation.
[0086] The results of Comparative Examples 31, 32, and 33 show that catalysts on Al2O3, SiO2, or Al2O3-SiO2 supports are not effective in direct ester hydrogenation, indicating that the microstructure of the zeolite support is important in catalyzing direct ester hydrogenation.
[0087] The best direct ester reduction performance observed in the liquid phase reaction comes from Example 19 of the present invention using catalyst 19 (2.46 wt. % Pt deposited on FER with a Si / Al ratio of 10), giving an absolute ethyl propyl ether selectivity of 58.0% with a direct ether selectivity of 93.7%.
[0088] conclusion The present invention discloses a series of metal-deposited zeolite catalysts (e.g., Pd-deposited FAU, Pt-deposited FAU, Rh-deposited FAU, Pt-deposited MOR, Pt-deposited CHA, Pt-deposited FER) that are highly effective for the direct hydrogenation of esters to ethers in both vapor and liquid phases. The best performances obtained are 48.4% absolute ethyl propyl ether selectivity and 90.0% direct ether selectivity in vapor phase reactions, and 58.0% absolute ethyl propyl ether selectivity and 93.7% direct ether selectivity in liquid phase reactions. Such results significantly exceed the performance of the prior art for transition metal / metal oxide catalysts (Processes for Producing an Ether, 63 / 107, 739), which claims an absolute ethyl propyl ether selectivity of >5% and a direct ether selectivity of >85%.
Claims
1. 1. A process for producing an ether product by the direct selective reduction of an ester, comprising: (a) treating at least one ester with (b) hydrogen in the presence of (c) a heterogeneous catalyst to directly and selectively reduce said at least one ester by hydrogenation to form at least one ether, said heterogeneous catalyst comprising a transition metal deposited on a zeolite support.
2. 2. The process of claim 1, wherein the ester is an ester containing a straight or branched chain alkyl group, a cyclic or acyclic alkyl group, and mixtures thereof.
3. 2. The process of claim 1, wherein the transition metal comprises at least one of palladium, platinum, nickel, ruthenium, cobalt, rhodium, rhenium, copper, and mixtures thereof.
4. 2. The process of claim 1, wherein the transition metal is deposited on the zeolite support in an amount of 0.01 to 20 wt. % of the metal compound, based on the total weight of the heterogeneous catalyst.
5. 2. The process of claim 1, wherein the zeolite comprises at least one of FAU, sodium Y zeolite, MOR, BEA, CHA, FER, MFI, and mixtures thereof.
6. 2. The process of claim 1, wherein the zeolite has a Si to Al ratio in the range of 1-300.
7. 2. The process of claim 1, wherein the process temperature is from 350K to 650K and the process pressure is from 0.1 MPa to 10 MPa.
8. The process of claim 1 , wherein the ether is an asymmetric ether.
9. 10. The process of claim 1, wherein the process is a vapor phase reduction process conducted under vapor phase process conditions.
10. 2. The process of claim 1, wherein the process is a liquid phase reduction process carried out under liquid phase process conditions.
11. 2. The process of claim 1, wherein the heterogeneous catalyst is selected from the group consisting of palladium on FAU, platinum on FAU, platinum on FER, rhodium on FAU, platinum on MOR, platinum on CHA, or mixtures thereof.
12. 13. A solvent comprising an ether produced from the process of claim 1.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
JP1973030633A
Production of glycol ethers
JP1989242541A
Carboxylic acid hydrogenation catalyst and hydrogenating method
JP1996057325A
