Damage Simulation Method

The damage simulation method addresses the challenge of analyzing damage in heterogeneous multiphase materials by creating micro and macro finite element models, linking deformation and damage criteria, enabling accurate prediction of material behavior and quality.

JP7586781B2Active Publication Date: 2024-11-19KOBE STEEL LTD
View PDF 6 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2021107008
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2021-06-28
Publication Date
2024-11-19
Estimated Expiration
2041-06-28

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing methods fail to provide a straightforward, multi-scale simulation that links the occurrence and progression of damage at the microstructural level with the deformation of components at the macrostructural level in heterogeneous multiphase materials, complicating the analysis process.

Method used

A damage simulation method using an arithmetic circuit to create microstructure and macrostructure finite element models, applying deformation history and damage criteria based on equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality to evaluate damage behavior in multiphase materials.

Benefits of technology

Enables accurate analysis of macroscopic mechanical behavior, microstructural behavior, and damage progression in multiphase materials, allowing for the prediction of material characteristics and quality evaluation.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 0007586781000009
    Figure 0007586781000009
  • Figure 0007586781000010
    Figure 0007586781000010
  • Figure 0007586781000011
    Figure 0007586781000011
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To provide a damage simulation method for performing evaluation by considering macroscopic dynamic behavior when deforming a structure composed of a heterogeneous material, such as a diploid material containing a metal material by operating a load to it, dynamic behavior regarding micro organization, and behavior of occurrence and development of damage.SOLUTION: In a damage simulation method for evaluating damage behavior of a diploid material by using an arithmetic circuit, the arithmetic circuit executes the processes of: creating a micro organization finite element model of a diploid material; setting and acquiring strength characteristics and damage criteria for each constituent phase of a diploid material; creating a macro structure finite element model and calculating a deformation history by executing analysis by using the macro structure finite element model assuming a homogeneous material; executing analysis by granting a deformation history to the micro organization finite element model and calculating deformation behavior; performing damage determination by comparing deformation behavior with the damage criteria; and changing a calculation formula of analysis by the damage determination.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 2
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to a damage simulation method for evaluating the damage behavior of multi-phase materials including metallic materials. [Background technology]

[0002] Many metal materials are subject to large loads, for example, during plastic processing in the manufacturing process and when structures formed from the metal materials are used. When a large load is applied and a large strain that exceeds the fracture strain of the metal material occurs, the metal material fractures, resulting in a manufacturing defect during the manufacturing process and a loss of function when used as a structure. Therefore, it is very important to grasp the fracture characteristics of the metal material in advance, for example, to evaluate whether the material will fracture under a certain strain.

[0003] On the other hand, since the above-mentioned metallic materials are heterogeneous at the microstructural level, attempts have been made to develop excellent properties at a macroscopic scale by taking into account the morphology of this microstructural structure. For example, Non-Patent Document 1 shows an example of a multi-scale simulation for analyzing the relationship between the microstructural morphology inside a material and the macroscopic strength properties. In addition, Non-Patent Document 2 proposes a direct evaluation of the microvoid generation behavior of a material by stress analysis using an analytical model of the microstructural structure to which continuum damage mechanics is applied. [Prior art documents] [Non-patent literature]

[0004] [Non-Patent Document 1] Eisuke Kurosawa et al., "Multi-scale strength analysis of Dual-Phase steel", Proceedings of the Academic Conference of the Japan Society for Materials Science, Vol. 67, p. 293-294, May 25, 2018 [Non-Patent Document 2] Shigeru Yonemura et al., "Finite element analysis of deformation and fracture at the mesoscale", Nippon Steel & Sumitomo Metal Technical Report, No. 410 (2018), pages 47-56 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0005] In a multi-phase material including a metal material, heterogeneity in the structure and strength appears inside due to the influence of the component composition and manufacturing conditions. The heterogeneity greatly affects the mechanical properties of the material. Non-Patent Document 1 proposes a multi-scale strength analysis that predicts the mechanical properties of the macrostructure using a microstructure model based on an SEM observation image as the actual structure form of a DP steel sample. However, in order to develop a material with better properties and quality than before, it was necessary to evaluate the damage generation and progression at the microstructure level in a heterogeneous material in association with the deformation of the component at the macrostructure level. Non-Patent Document 2 realizes a damage simulation at the microstructure level, but it is necessary to set a damage model for each damage form, and the analysis is complicated. In other words, a multi-scale simulation that is easy to analyze and associates the damage generation and progression at the microstructure level with the deformation of the component at the macrostructure level has not been realized until now.

[0006] The present invention has been made in consideration of the above circumstances, and has an object to provide a damage simulation method which allows easier analysis than conventional methods and which evaluates by taking into account the macroscopic mechanical behavior of a heterogeneous material, the mechanical behavior of the microstructure, and the behavior of damage initiation and progression. [Means for solving the problem]

[0007] Aspect 1 of the present invention is A damage simulation method for evaluating the damage behavior of a multi-phase material including a metallic material and composed of a plurality of phases having different strength characteristics, using a calculation circuit, the calculation circuit comprising: A step of creating a microstructure finite element model of a microanalysis object based on the structure observation result of the multi-phase material; Obtaining and setting different strength characteristics and damage criteria for each phase constituting the multi-phase material; A step of creating a macro-structure finite element model for analyzing a macro-region of the multi-phase material, performing a finite element analysis using the macro-structure finite element model assuming that the multi-phase material is a homogeneous material, and calculating a deformation history of the evaluation target region; a step of calculating a deformation behavior of the microstructure finite element model by applying the deformation history to each integration point of the microstructure finite element model and performing a finite element analysis based on a homogenization method; performing a damage determination by comparing the deformation behavior with the damage criteria; a step of releasing stress at an integration point where damage has been determined to have occurred in the microstructure finite element model by the damage determination, and reducing element stiffness to zero or a predetermined value; The present invention provides a damage simulation method for evaluating the damage behavior of multi-phase materials, including metallic materials, which are composed of multiple phases with different strength properties.

[0008] Aspect 2 of the present invention is 2. The damage simulation method according to aspect 1, wherein the damage criteria is a function of equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality.

[0009] Aspect 3 of the present invention is The damage judgment is a damage simulation method described in aspect 2, in which if a value calculated based on an equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality calculated as the damage behavior at a specific integration point of the microstructure finite element model is greater than the damage criterion, it is judged that damage has occurred at the specific integration point.

[0010] A fourth aspect of the present invention is A damage simulation method according to any one of aspects 1 to 3, wherein the predetermined value is 1 / 50 or less of an initial value of the element stiffness.

[0011] A fifth aspect of the present invention is The damage simulation method according to any one of the first to fourth aspects, wherein the multi-phase material is a metallic material. Effect of the Invention

[0012] According to the present invention, it is possible to provide a damage simulation method for evaluating, taking into consideration the macroscopic mechanical behavior when a load is applied to a structure made of a heterogeneous material such as a multi-phase material containing a metallic material and the like and the mechanical behavior of the microstructure and the behavior of damage initiation and progression when the structure is deformed by applying a load, the damage simulation method can be provided. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0013] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a block diagram of an evaluation system according to the present embodiment. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a flowchart for evaluating the damage behavior of the metallic material according to this embodiment by numerical analysis. [Diagram 3] FIG. 3 is a diagram showing an example of a procedure for creating an FEM analysis model that simulates the microstructure of the metallic material according to this embodiment. [Figure 4] FIG. 4 is a flow chart for acquiring the macro distortion. [Diagram 5] Figure 5 shows the stress-strain curves of the dual-phase steel obtained by tensile testing. [Figure 6] FIG. 6 is an enlarged view of a portion of the stress-strain curve of FIG. [Figure 7] FIG. 7 is a log-log graph of the stress-strain curve of FIG. [Figure 8] FIG. 8 is a stress-strain curve for explaining the second stress Δσ. [Figure 9] FIG. 9 shows the stress-strain curve of the hard phase, which can be regarded as an elastic-perfectly plastic body. [Figure 10] Figure 10 is a log-log graph showing the relationship between stress and strain for a dual-phase stainless steel, plotted as ln(σ-Δσ) on the vertical axis and ln(1+ε / α) on the horizontal axis. [Figure 11] FIG. 11 is a schematic diagram showing the relationship between the macrostructure finite element model and the microstructure finite element model. [Figure 12A] FIG. 12A shows the stress-strain curve calculated by FEM analysis of the macrostructure finite element model with damage added. [Figure 12B] FIG. 12B is a graph showing the change in the number of integration points determined to be damaged by FEM analysis of the microstructure finite element model. [Figure 13A] FIG. 13A shows a finite element model of a microstructure calculated when a predetermined macroscopic strain is applied in an FEM analysis. [Figure 13B] FIG. 13B is a microstructure finite element model calculated when a macroscopic strain larger than that in FIG. 13A is applied. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0014] The present inventors have conducted intensive research to realize a method for evaluating the damage behavior of multi-phase materials including metallic materials. As a result, the present inventors have found that it is sufficient to create an FE model of a macrostructure based on an FE model of a microstructure created based on the microstructural shape of a material, and perform FEM analysis by associating them with each other. Specifically, the present inventors performed FEM analysis using an FE model of a macrostructure assuming that the material is homogeneous, calculate the deformation history, and perform FEM analysis using an FE model of a microstructure by adding the deformation history. Then, the present inventors determined the presence or absence of damage based on a predetermined criterion in the FEM analysis of the microstructure, and changed the calculation formula of the FEM analysis of the part determined to be damaged. The present inventors have found that by associating the FEM analysis of the macrostructure with the FEM analysis of the microstructure in this way, the decrease in the deformation resistance of the macrostructure side associated with the occurrence and progression of damage on the microstructure side during deformation can be reproduced by simulation. In this specification, unless otherwise specified, "stress" refers to true stress (σ), and "strain" refers to true strain (ε). In the following, a multi-phase material containing the metallic material will be described as an example of a metallic material composed of multiple phases with different strength characteristics. However, the method according to the present embodiment is not limited to this, and can be applied to various multi-phase materials as described below.

[0015] An evaluation system 1, which is an example for executing a damage simulation method for evaluating the damage behavior of a multi-phase material (metal material composed of multiple phases with different strength properties) according to this embodiment, will be described. FIG. 1 is a block diagram of the evaluation system 1 according to this embodiment. The evaluation system 1 includes an imaging device 10 and a control device 20. The imaging device 10 includes an imaging section 11 and a communication circuit 12. The control device 20 includes an arithmetic circuit 21, a storage device 22, and an interface device (an input / output device 23 and a communication circuit 24).

[0016] The photographing unit 11 is, for example, a scanning electron microscope (SEM) or the like, and can photograph a microstructure image in which at least a part of a metal material is partially enlarged. The photographing unit 11 transmits data of the photographed microstructure image to the control device 20 via the communication circuit 12. As will be described later, the arithmetic circuit 21 of the control device 20 stores the received data of the microstructure image in the storage device 22.

[0017] The arithmetic circuit 21 of the control device 20 executes model creation processing, parameter setting processing, analysis processing, damage determination processing, and the like. The arithmetic circuit 21 includes a general-purpose processor such as a CPU or MPU that realizes a predetermined function by executing a program. The arithmetic circuit 21 can realize model creation processing, parameter setting processing, analysis processing, damage determination processing, and the like, for example, by calling and executing an arithmetic program stored in the storage device 22. The arithmetic circuit 21 is not limited to a circuit that realizes a predetermined function by cooperation between hardware and software, and may be a hardware circuit designed specifically to realize a predetermined function. That is, the arithmetic circuit 21 can be realized by various processors such as a GPU, FPGA, DSP, ASIC, etc., in addition to a CPU or MPU. Such an arithmetic circuit 21 can be configured, for example, by a signal processing circuit that is a semiconductor integrated circuit.

[0018] In the model creation process, a microstructure finite element model (microstructure FE model) is created from the microstructure image of the metal material captured by the photographing device 10, which is an FEM analysis model of the microstructure analysis target to be used in the FEM analysis. Programs, parameters, etc. for creating the microstructure finite element model are stored in, for example, the storage device 22, and the arithmetic circuit 21 reads them out as necessary and uses them for model creation. As described later, the arithmetic circuit 21 can create the microstructure finite element model by, for example, image-based modeling. When performing image-based modeling, the arithmetic circuit 21 applies an arbitrary image processing filter to at least a partial region of the microstructure image, and forms shape data based on the microstructure shape of the corresponding region of the metal material. Then, in a parameter setting process described later, the arithmetic circuit 21 can create a microstructure finite element model simulating the above region based on each parameter (for example, the type of element, the number of elements, the number of nodes, etc. of the model to be created) of the microstructure finite element model that has been set. The created microstructure finite element model is output to the storage device 22 and stored therein.

[0019] The model creation process can also create a macrostructure finite element model (macrostructure FE model) that simulates a larger area than the area simulated by the microstructure finite element model. The macrostructure finite element model may be formed to have any size, and the model is constructed as a homogenous material.

[0020] The parameter setting process sets various parameters. The parameters may include, for example, the type of elements, the number of elements, and the number of nodes of the microstructure finite element model and the macrostructure finite element model created by the calculation circuit 21 in the model creation process. The parameters may also include the properties of the metal material to be analyzed by the FEM analysis (Young's modulus, yield stress and proof stress, work hardening exponent, and crystal orientation of the metal material, etc.), and the boundary conditions when performing the FEM analysis by the analysis process. The parameter setting process can set, as one of the parameters, a damage criterion that is a criterion for determining damage in the damage determination process described later. The damage criterion can be set as a function with variables being the equivalent plastic strain and the stress triaxiality calculated for each integration point in the FEM analysis, as described later. The damage criterion can be set for each phase constituting the metal material. The parameters are output to the storage device 22 and stored therein. Then, as necessary, each component reads out the parameters from the storage device 22 and uses them.

[0021] The analysis process can use the created microstructure finite element model to perform FEM analysis for simulating the shape deformation when stress or strain is applied to the metal material. Also, the analysis process can use the created macrostructure finite element model to perform FEM analysis for simulating the history of stress or strain generated in the metal material when a load is applied to the metal material or a displacement occurs. The microstructure finite element model or macrostructure finite element model used in the analysis, the program for performing the simulation, the boundary conditions, etc. are stored in, for example, the storage device 22 and used for the analysis. The arithmetic circuit 21 of the control device 20 of the evaluation system 1 according to this embodiment can calculate and output the stress triaxiality and the equivalent plastic strain at the integration point of each element of the microstructure finite element model by the analysis process for each stress or strain applied to the microstructure finite element model. Also, the arithmetic circuit 21 can simulate the deformation of the model by each load or displacement applied to the macrostructure finite element model, and calculate and output the deformation history (macrostrain history) of the model by the analysis process. In this embodiment, the macrostrain calculated by the FEM analysis of the macrostructure finite element model is used as input information for the FEM analysis of the microstructure finite element model. The macrostrain, stress triaxiality, and equivalent plastic strain may be output to the input / output device 23 and displayed on the input / output device 23, or may be output to the storage device 22 and stored therein. The macrostrain, stress triaxiality, and equivalent plastic strain may also be output to the communication circuit 24 and transmitted to another control device.

[0022] The damage determination process can determine whether or not an integration point is damaged based on the equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality for each integration point calculated by the FEM analysis and the set damage criteria. When the calculation circuit 21 determines that a certain integration point is damaged, it performs a simulation of the deformation of the microstructure finite element model due to the stress or strain, taking into account the damage of the integration point when performing FEM analysis by further applying stress or strain in the analysis process. More specifically, when performing FEM analysis, the calculation circuit 21 modifies a part of the calculation formula for the integration point and performs a simulation of the deformation of the microstructure finite element model due to the stress or strain (details will be described later).

[0023] The storage device 22 is a storage medium capable of storing various information. The storage device 22 is realized, for example, by a memory such as a DRAM, an SRAM, a flash memory, an HDD, an SSD, or other storage devices, or by an appropriate combination thereof. The storage device 22 can store images captured by the imaging device 10, a microstructure finite element model and a macrostructure finite element model created in a model creation process. The storage device 22 can also store parameters such as material properties and boundary conditions used in the analysis set in a parameter setting process, and data of the analysis results calculated and output in the analysis process. Furthermore, the storage device 22 can transmit the stored information to each component such as the arithmetic circuit 21, the input / output device 23, and the communication circuit 24 as necessary. Each component may transmit and receive information directly between each other without going through the storage device 22.

[0024] The input / output device 23 functions as an input device for inputting information from a user and as an output device for outputting information to a user. The input / output device 23 includes one or more human-machine interfaces. Examples of human-machine interfaces include input devices such as a keyboard, a pointing device (mouse, trackball, etc.), and a touchpad, output devices such as a display and a speaker, and input / output devices such as a touch panel. The input / output device 23 can display any information, such as a microstructure image of a metal material, a microstructure finite element model, a macrostructure finite element model, and parameters such as material properties and boundary conditions used in the analysis.

[0025] The communication circuit 24 is an interface device for connecting to a device or a system via a communication line, either wired or wirelessly. The interface device is capable of performing communication in accordance with a wired communication standard, such as USB (registered trademark) or Ethernet (registered trademark). The interface device is also capable of performing communication in accordance with a wireless communication standard, such as Wi-Fi (registered trademark), Bluetooth (registered trademark), or a mobile phone line.

[0026] The evaluation system 1 may include at least the control device 20. For example, the arithmetic circuit 21 may receive a microstructure image captured separately via an interface device (the input / output device 23 and the communication circuit 24) and execute various processes.

[0027] The method for evaluating the damage behavior of a multi-phase material according to this embodiment will be described with reference to the flowchart for evaluating the damage behavior of a metallic material in Fig. 2. Fig. 2 is a flowchart for numerically analyzing and evaluating the damage behavior of a metallic material.

[0028] [Step 100: Acquiring microstructural images of multi-phase materials] First, as shown in step 100 (S100) of Fig. 2, the arithmetic circuit 21 acquires a microstructure image of the multi-phase material. The arithmetic circuit 21 may acquire the microstructure image by reading it out from the storage device 22, for example, or may acquire the image from another device or system via the communication circuit 24.

[0029] The microstructure image may be, for example, an image observed by a scanning electron microscope (SEM), an optical microscope (OM), electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD), computed tomography (CT), ultrasonic testing (UT), or the like. For the above observation, pretreatment such as etching may be performed in advance depending on the type of constituent phase that constitutes the microstructure. The size, magnification, and the like of the above microstructure image may be appropriately set depending on the evaluation area, evaluation position, and the like.

[0030] In the above, a method for obtaining a microstructure image of a metallic material has been described in which the microstructure of the metallic structure is observed to obtain an image. However, the present invention is not limited to this method. A simulated shape model may be formed without observing the microstructure of the metallic structure, and a microstructure finite element model may be created based on this simulated shape model.

[0031] The multi-phase material to be targeted may be any material that includes a metal material. The type and strength level of the metal material to be targeted are not limited. The metal material is not limited to steel, but may be aluminum-based, titanium-based, copper-based, or magnesium-based pure metal or alloy. When the metal material is steel, the type, structure shape, and phase fraction of the microstructure are not limited. The constituent phases that constitute the microstructure may include, for example, one or more of ferrite, martensite, bainite, pearlite, retained austenite, and MA (Martensite-Austenite constituent, also called "island martensite"), and may also include precipitates such as cementite. The structure shape refers to the shape of the crystal, and may be, for example, branch-like, granular, or needle-like. The composition of the steel is not limited. The manufacturing method of the metal material is also not limited, and manufacturing conditions such as hot rolling conditions and heat treatment conditions can be appropriately set so as to obtain a desired microstructure. When evaluating multiple metallic materials, for example when comparing multiple metallic materials, it is possible to prepare multiple metallic materials that differ in one or more of the types of constituent phases in the microstructure, the structure shape, and the phase fraction.

[0032] The multi-phase material may contain ceramics in addition to metal materials, such as metal oxides such as silica, alumina, zirconia, titania, magnesia, cerium oxide, zinc oxide, barium titanate, hexaferrite, and mullite, and non-oxide ceramics such as silicon nitride, titanium nitride, aluminum nitride, silicon carbide, titanium carbide, tungsten carbide, boron carbide, and titanium boride.

[0033] The target multi-phase materials include, for example, materials composed of multiple steels that are made of metallic materials and differ in one or more of the types of constituent phases that make up the microstructure, the microstructural shape, and the phase fraction; materials composed of steel and non-ferrous metals other than steel, such as aluminum-based materials; materials composed of different types of non-ferrous metals; and materials composed of metallic materials and ceramics.

[0034] For the sake of simplicity, the damage simulation method described below is intended to evaluate the microstructural damage behavior of a metallic material having different types of constituent phases that make up the microstructure as a multi-phase material, specifically, a dual-phase steel that is composed of ferrite as a soft phase and martensite as a hard phase.

[0035] [Step 110: Creating a finite element model of the microanalysis target] As shown in step 110 (S110) of FIG. 2, the arithmetic circuit 21 executes a model creation process to create a mesh model as a microstructure finite element model, which is an FEM analysis model of a microstructure analysis target to be used in FEM analysis. The analysis model can be created by image-based modeling using an acquired microstructure image of a metal material, for example. An example of a model creation method is shown in FIG. 3. FIG. 3A shows an acquired microstructure image. The arithmetic circuit 21 creates a binary image by setting a predetermined threshold value for the density or brightness of pixels in such a microstructure image, and performing a binarization process to set a value for the pixel depending on whether the density or the like at an arbitrary pixel position exceeds the threshold value. FIG. 3B is a binary image created from the microstructure image of FIG. 3A. This allows the martensite phase to be extracted and separated from other phases.

[0036] Next, the arithmetic circuit 21 acquires the contour of the region corresponding to the martensite phase from the binary image. The contour can be acquired, for example, by using an image processing filter (for example, a Sobel filter, a Laplacian filter, etc.) that detects edges. Fig. 3C shows the contour of the region corresponding to the martensite phase (hard phase) acquired from the binary image.

[0037] Next, the arithmetic circuit 21 creates shape data of the region corresponding to the martensite phase and shape data of the region corresponding to the ferrite phase (soft phase) from the above outline. FIG. 3D shows shape data created for the region M corresponding to the martensite layer and the region F corresponding to the ferrite phase. After that, the arithmetic circuit 21 creates a two-dimensional mesh model by dividing the shape data into meshes set based on a predetermined condition. The mesh model according to this embodiment is divided into a mesh of quadrilateral elements. FIG. 3E shows an example of a mesh shape by partially enlarging a part of the region in the upper right. The quadrilateral elements do not need to be rectangular. In addition, it is not essential that they be quadrilaterals, and they may be polygons having three or more sides.

[0038] As the FEM analysis model in this embodiment, the above mesh model is created as a 2D model with a total number of elements of 40,279 and a total number of nodes of 40,507 by setting 4-node isoparametric elements. Then, the 2D model is expanded by one layer in the depth direction of the image, and a 3D model with a total number of elements of 40,279 and a total number of nodes of 81,014 is created by using 8-node isoparametric elements, and FEM analysis is performed using the 3D model. The model conditions are not limited to the above, and for example, elements with different numbers of constituent nodes may be used for the type of element. In addition, 3D models with different total numbers of elements and nodes may be created to perform FEM analysis. In addition, a 2D model may be created instead of a 3D model and used as an FEM analysis model.

[0039] [Step 120: Obtaining material properties and determining damage criteria] As shown in step 120 (S120) of FIG. 2, the calculation circuit 21 acquires the properties of each material related to each phase constituting the metallic material by parameter setting processing to perform FEM analysis, and sets them as parameters. Here, the acquired material properties are, for example, the Young's modulus, yield stress and proof stress, work hardening exponent, and crystal orientation of each of the ferrite phase and the martensite phase. The calculation circuit 21 also acquires the stress-strain curves of each material of each phase constituting the metallic material (in this embodiment, the stress-strain curves of ferrite and the stress-strain curves of martensite) as material properties. As a result, when the calculation circuit 21 performs the FEM analysis described later in the analysis processing, the stress or strain applied to each integration point is calculated based on the shape and properties of each phase constituting the microstructure finite element model in response to the stress or strain applied to the model.

[0040] The arithmetic circuit 21 can set boundary conditions for performing FEM analysis using the microstructure finite element model by parameter setting processing. In this embodiment, the arithmetic circuit 21 imposes periodic boundary conditions on disturbance displacement components, assuming that the microstructure finite element model is periodically arranged. As a result, as described later, the arithmetic circuit 21 can perform FEM analysis on the microstructure finite element model using, as input information, the history of macroscopic strain calculated by performing FEM analysis on the macrostructure finite element model based on the so-called homogenization method.

[0041] Furthermore, the arithmetic circuit 21 sets a damage criterion, which is a criterion for determining whether or not damage has occurred in each element of the microstructure finite element model when stress or strain is applied in an FEM analysis using the microstructure finite element model, by parameter setting processing. By setting the damage criterion, the arithmetic circuit 21 can determine whether or not damage has occurred in each element of the microstructure finite element model based on the damage criterion and the equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality calculated by the FEM analysis described below. This allows the arithmetic circuit 21 to perform an FEM analysis that takes into account local damage to the metal material that occurs when a certain amount of stress or strain or more is applied to the metal material. The damage criterion can be expressed, for example, by equations (1) and (2). f i =ε p (η+A) (1) f i >f cr (2)

[0042] where f i is a parameter for determining damage. cr is a criterion for determining damage and is an arbitrary constant. p is the equivalent plastic strain. η is the stress triaxiality. A is an arbitrary constant. f cr and A can be set to different values ​​for each phase that constitutes the metal material. By setting them for each constituent phase, the calculation circuit does not need to create an FEM analysis model for each constituent phase, and the FEM analysis model can be simplified. cr and A may be empirically determined or based on experimental data.

[0043] The damage criteria is ε p and η can be expressed as a function expressed by equation (3) with variables: f cr =ε p (η+A) (3) The function is expressed as the stress triaxiality η on the horizontal axis and the equivalent plastic strain ε on the vertical axis. p On a graph where p =f crTherefore, the calculation circuit 21 can express the stress triaxiality η and the equivalent plastic strain ε at a certain integration point as p When plotted on the graph, the η and ε represented by the curve p η or ε rather than combinations with p If at least one of the above has a large value, it may be determined that the corresponding integral point is damaged. The damage criteria is not limited to the above-described inversely proportional function, and may be set as, for example, any linear function.

[0044] When the damage criteria are determined based on experimental data, for example, the damage criteria can be determined as follows. An FEM analysis model is created based on a structural image of an arbitrary test piece, a tensile test is performed on the test piece, and the arithmetic circuit 21 performs FEM analysis by imparting a history of stress or strain equivalent to that of the tensile test to the FEM analysis model. During the tensile test, the arithmetic circuit 21 acquires a structural image of the test piece at an arbitrary timing and associates it with the strain occurring in the test piece at that timing. Then, when microvoids are generated by checking the structural image, the arithmetic circuit 21 calculates the equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality of the integration point corresponding to the position where the microvoids are generated in the structural image from the FEM analysis result when the strain associated with the structural image is imparted to the FEM analysis model. When the arithmetic circuit 21 acquires the equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality, it plots them on a graph. The calculation circuit 21 plots combinations of equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality for a plurality of microvoids on a graph, and determines whether the plotted points satisfy the formulas (1) and (2). cr and A are defined, and the damage criteria can be determined accordingly.

[0045] The calculation circuit 21 calculates a parameter f based on the equivalent plastic strain, the stress triaxiality, and an arbitrary constant as shown in the formula (2). i There is a reference value f crIf the equivalent plastic strain and the stress triaxiality are greater than the threshold value, it can be determined that damage has occurred. The equivalent plastic strain and the stress triaxiality are calculated in the analysis process described below. The details of obtaining the material properties and setting the damage criteria for setting the parameters in the parameter setting process will be described later.

[0046] [Step 130: Obtaining macro strain] 2, the arithmetic circuit 21 acquires the macro-strain to be applied when performing FEM analysis on the microstructure finite element model. For example, the arithmetic circuit 21 performs steps 131 to 133 described below to create a macro-structure finite element model, perform FEM analysis on the model, and calculate and acquire the macro-strain. 4 is a flowchart for acquiring the macro distortion. The arithmetic circuit 21 may acquire the macro distortion by reading out the macro distortion that has been calculated in advance and stored in the storage device 22, or may acquire the macro distortion via the communication circuit 24.

[0047] [Step 131: Creating a macro-structural finite element model] 4, the arithmetic circuit 21 executes a model creation process to create a mesh model as a macro-structure finite element model, which is an FEM analysis model of an object to be analyzed of a macro-structure, for use in FEM analysis. The mesh model may have any size.

[0048] [Step 132: Obtaining strength properties as homogeneous material] As shown in step 132 (S132) of FIG. 4, the arithmetic circuit 21 executes a parameter setting process to acquire the characteristics of the metallic material related to the macro-structure finite element model in order to perform FEM analysis, and sets them as parameters. Here, the acquired material characteristics are, for example, the Young's modulus, Poisson's ratio, stress-strain curve, yield stress and proof stress, work hardening exponent, and crystal orientation of the metallic material. The parameters can be acquired by experiment. For example, the stress-strain curve and yield stress of the metallic material can be acquired by performing a tensile test on a test piece made of the material. The Young's modulus and Poisson's ratio can be acquired by a tensile test, a resonance method, an ultrasonic method, or the like. Since the metallic material can be separated into each phase constituting the metallic material in the micro-structure, the arithmetic circuit 21 sets parameters related to each phase in the micro-structure, but sets parameters for a uniform material regardless of the phase structure in the macro-structure.

[0049] [Step 133: Execute FEM analysis using macro-structural finite element model (strain calculation)] As shown in step 133 (S133) of FIG. 4, the arithmetic circuit 21 executes FEM analysis using the created macrostructure finite element model by the analysis process. In the FEM analysis, a predetermined load or displacement is applied to the created macrostructure finite element model, and the history of stress or strain occurring in the metal material can be analyzed by simulation. For example, the analysis process applies a load or displacement condition equivalent to uniaxial tension to the macrostructure finite element model, simulates the deformation of the macrostructure finite element model, and calculates the deformation history (macrostrain history) of the macrostructure finite element model. The calculated deformation history is output to, for example, the storage device 22 and stored. Note that the deformation field applied to the macrostructure finite element model is not limited to uniaxial tension, and may be a composite deformation field in which tension, compression, and shear deformation occur simultaneously.

[0050] In this way, the calculation circuit 21 can create a macro-structure finite element model and calculate and acquire the macro-strain using the model. In this embodiment, the calculation circuit 21 calculates the macro-strain after acquiring the material properties of the microstructure finite element model and determining the damage criteria (i.e., step 120), but this is not limited to this. For example, the calculation circuit 21 may calculate the macro-strain before acquiring a microstructure image (i.e., step 100). Also, as described later, the calculation circuit 21 performs FEM analysis in the microstructure finite element model for each macro-strain by providing a history of the macro-strain. Therefore, it is sufficient that the macro-strain is calculated when performing the FEM analysis of the microstructure finite element model. For example, the calculation circuit 21 may first execute steps 131 and 132, and then execute step 133 as necessary. That is, the calculation circuit 21 may execute step 133 after executing step 160 described later and before executing step 140 described later, and calculate the macro-strain to be used in step 140 at that timing.

[0051] [Step 140: Execute FEM analysis using the microstructure finite element model (calculate equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality)] As shown in step 140 (S140) of FIG. 2, the calculation circuit 21 executes FEM analysis using the created microstructure finite element model by the analysis process. As described above, as boundary conditions for the FEM analysis of the microstructure finite element model, the periodic boundary conditions are applied to the disturbance displacement components, assuming that the model is periodically arranged. Therefore, in the FEM analysis, the calculation circuit 21 applies the history of the macrostrain acquired in step 130 to the created microstructure finite element model as a macrostrain increment. Thereby, the calculation circuit 21 can perform a simulation of how the metal material behaves when a macrostrain increment is applied based on the so-called homogenization method. The calculation circuit 21 can calculate the equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality in each element as the deformation behavior of the microstructure finite element model for each macrostrain applied to each element of the microstructure finite element model by the analysis process. The calculated equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality can be output to the storage device 22 and stored. An integration point is preset for each element of the microstructure finite element model for integration during analysis. The equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality are calculated for each strain applied to the integration point. In addition to the integration points of each element of the microstructure finite element model, the equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality may be calculated using an element solution or a nodal solution calculated from a solution calculated for the integration point.

[0052] [Step 150: Damage assessment at each integration point of the microstructure finite element model] As shown in step 150 (S150) of Fig. 2, the arithmetic circuit 21 determines whether damage (i.e., microvoids) has occurred at each integration point of the microstructure finite element model through damage determination processing. The damage determination processing determines the presence or absence of damage based on the damage criteria set in step 120 and the equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality calculated by the FEM analysis executed in step 140. The damage determination processing determines the presence or absence of damage each time the equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality are calculated in step 140. The damage determination processing will be described in detail later.

[0053] [Step 160: Determine whether to continue FEM analysis] As shown in step 160 (S160) of FIG. 2, the calculation circuit 21 judges whether or not to continue the FEM analysis. Specifically, the calculation circuit 21 judges whether or not the deformation of the microstructure finite element model has reached a predetermined deformation ratio by the damage judgment process. If the deformation of the microstructure finite element model has not reached the predetermined deformation ratio, the calculation circuit 21 changes the macro strain to be applied to the microstructure finite element model and further executes the FEM analysis (S140) (S160: Yes). Then, the calculation circuit 21 calculates the equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality in the microstructure finite element model when the macro strain is applied. If the deformation of the microstructure finite element model has reached the predetermined deformation ratio, the calculation circuit 21 ends the FEM analysis by the analysis process (S160: No). In addition, an element judged to be damaged in the microstructure finite element model reduces the element rigidity of the element, and therefore, as the number of elements judged to be damaged increases, the damage caused by microvoids progresses and the deformation resistance of the microstructure finite element model decreases. The arithmetic circuit 21 may terminate the FEM analysis by the analysis process when the deformation resistance falls to a predetermined value or less.

[0054] As described above, the damage simulation method according to this embodiment can perform FEM analysis using a finite element model simulating the macrostructure of a metallic material and calculate the history of macrostrain. In addition, the damage simulation method can perform FEM analysis using a finite element model simulating the microstructure of a metallic material and the history of the calculated macrostrain and calculate the equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality. The damage simulation method can reproduce the occurrence of damage in the microstructure due to tensile deformation and the decrease in deformation resistance in the macrostructure in the tensile direction associated with the progress of the damage by judging the presence or absence of damage based on the calculated equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality. In addition, the damage simulation method can simultaneously analyze the behavior in which damage occurs in the microstructure and the damage in the microstructure is linked and progresses as the macroscopic deformation of the metallic material progresses on the microstructure side.

[0055] (Obtaining stress-strain curves for each constituent phase, etc.) The setting process of the material properties for performing the FEM analysis, which are set in the parameter setting process, will be described. The stress-strain curve for each material related to each phase constituting the metal material can be obtained, for example, by performing a tensile test on a test piece made of the material. The stress-strain curve and the yield stress for each material can be obtained, for example, by an analysis method as described below. The method of obtaining the stress-strain curve and the yield stress for each material is not limited to the above method, and may be determined and obtained based on a predetermined formula such as the Swift's law formula, or a curve previously stored in the storage device 22 may be used.

[0056] First, the calculation circuit 21 obtains the area fraction of each phase (ferrite phase and martensite phase in FIG. 3A) constituting the metallic material from a microstructure image as shown in FIG. 3A. The calculation circuit 21 can separate the microstructure image of the metallic material into each phase, for example, by the method described in step 110, and can obtain the area fraction of each phase. Next, the calculation circuit 21 calculates the volume fraction of each phase based on the area fraction. For example, assuming that the constituent phase (constituent phase A) having a smaller area fraction of the two constituent phases is uniformly dispersed in the dual-phase steel, the calculation circuit 21 can convert the area fraction SA of the constituent phase A to the 3 / 2 power and convert it into the volume fraction VA of the constituent phase A. The volume fraction VB of the other constituent phase (constituent phase B) can be obtained by subtracting the volume fraction VA of the constituent phase A from 100%.

[0057] In the example of FIG. 3A, the arithmetic circuit 21 can obtain that the area fraction of the ferrite phase is 85% and the area fraction of the martensite phase is 15%. The arithmetic circuit 21 multiplies the area fraction of the martensite phase (15%), which has a smaller area fraction, by the power of 3 / 2 (i.e., 0.15 3 / 2 ) to obtain the volume fraction of the martensite phase (approximately 6%). The arithmetic circuit 21 can calculate the volume fraction of the ferrite phase by subtracting the volume fraction of the martensite phase (6%) from the total (100%). For example, if the volume fraction of the martensite phase is 6%, the volume fraction of the ferrite phase is 100%-6%=94%.

[0058] Next, the arithmetic circuit 21 obtains a stress-strain curve for the target dual-phase steel. The stress-strain curve can be obtained, for example, by preparing a specimen for a tensile test from the dual-phase steel and performing a uniaxial tensile test. The test method for the uniaxial tensile test and the shape of the specimen are not particularly limited, but for example, JIS Z2241:2011 can be referred to. Figure 5 shows an example of measured data of a stress-strain curve for dual-phase steel.

[0059] Next, the calculation circuit 21 calculates the yield stress σ of the dual-phase steel from the obtained measured data of the stress-strain curve. yDP Figure 6 is an enlarged view of the stress-strain curve in Figure 5 near the boundary between the elastic and plastic regions. The stress-strain curve is linear in the elastic region, but when the dual-phase steel starts to undergo plastic deformation (i.e., when it enters the plastic region), the stress-strain curve loses linearity. The stress value at which the curve loses linearity is called the yield stress σ of dual-phase steel. yDP In the example of Figure 6, σ yDP = 220MPa.

[0060] In dual-phase steels composed of a soft phase and a hard phase, it is believed that the soft phase, i.e., the ferrite phase in this embodiment, begins to plastically deform first, and then the hard phase, i.e., the martensite phase in this embodiment, begins to plastically deform. In other words, the yield stress σ yDP is the yield stress σ of the ferrite phase ySP Therefore, the yield stress of the ferrite phase depends only on the yield stress σ of the dual-phase steel. yDP and the volume fraction of the ferrite phase, it can be calculated using the following formula (4). σ ySP = σ yDP ÷{(volume fraction of ferrite phase (%)) / 100} (4)

[0061] For example, the yield stress σ of dual-phase stainless steel yDP When the volume fraction of the ferrite phase is 94% (0.94), the yield stress of the ferrite phase σ ySPis 220÷(94(%) / 100)=234MPa. Thus, the yield stress σ of the ferrite phase is ySP Calculate.

[0062] Next, the arithmetic circuit 21 creates a graph showing the relationship between stress and strain (for example, a log-log graph with the natural logarithm of stress on the vertical axis and the natural logarithm of strain on the horizontal axis) from the measured data of the stress-strain curve. FIG. 7 is a log-log graph of the stress-strain curve shown in FIG. 5. The arithmetic circuit 21 then determines the portion of the log-log graph that is a straight line within the plastic region of the stress-strain curve. The range that includes the straight line portion is defined as the "range LA." The range LA is the range that follows the multiplier (nth power) on the right side of Swift's law (5) that shows the stress-strain curve of the ferrite phase. σ 1 = σ ySP (1+ε / α) n (5)

[0063] Here, σ 1 is the primary stress borne by the ferrite phase. σ ySP is the yield stress of the ferrite phase. ε is the strain of the ferrite phase. α is the characteristic constant of the ferrite phase. n is the work-hardening exponent of the ferrite phase. In Figure 7, the solid line shows a log-log graph of the stress-strain curve. If an approximation line (dashed line) is drawn along the straight line portion of the solid line (the portion within the range of region LA), the slope of the approximation line correlates with the work-hardening exponent n of the ferrite phase.

[0064] In this specification, the "straight line portion" refers to a part or all of the part that can be regarded as a straight line in a double logarithmic graph of a stress-strain curve. The range LA may be any range that includes "a part or all of the part that can be regarded as a straight line." In this specification, the "part that can be regarded as a straight line" also includes a part that is not completely straight but is almost straight. Specifically, when an approximation line is drawn on a double logarithmic graph of a stress-strain curve by the least squares method, if the "deviation" in the vertical axis direction (natural logarithm direction of stress) between the double logarithmic graph and the approximation line is equal to or less than a value equivalent to 1 MPa on the double logarithmic graph, it is regarded as a "part that can be regarded as a straight line."

[0065] The stress σ experienced by dual-phase stainless steel is the first stress σ borne by the ferrite phase. 1 and the second stress Δσ borne by the martensite phase. Figure 8 is a stress-strain curve to explain the second stress Δσ. In the stress-strain curve shown in Figure 8, the solid line is the measured data of the stress-strain curve of the dual-phase steel, and the dashed line is an image of the stress-strain curve of the ferrite phase. From the stress-strain curve of the ferrite phase, it can be seen that the first stress σ borne by the ferrite phase 1 The distance between the solid and dashed lines in the vertical direction corresponds to the second stress Δσ borne by the martensite phase.

[0066] Based on this, a range C-LA (see Fig. 8) corresponding to the range LA specified on the log-log graph is defined on the stress-strain curve, and the stress σ of the dual-phase stainless steel in that range is defined as the first stress σ 1 and the second stress Δσ. The corresponding range on the stress-strain curve may be simply referred to as the "range C-LA."

[0067] Figure 9 is a schematic diagram of the stress-strain curve of the martensite phase, which can be considered as an elastic perfectly plastic body. Since the martensite phase can be considered as an elastic perfectly plastic body, the stress-strain curve in the case of only the martensite phase will be as shown in Figure 9. Therefore, the stress σ within the range C-LA HP is constant and the yield stress σ yHP The second stress Δσ borne by the martensite phase is equal to the stress σ HP This corresponds to a value obtained by multiplying the volume fraction by the second stress Δσ. From these facts, the second stress Δσ is constant within the range C-LA (i.e., in FIG. 8, the distance in the vertical axis direction between the solid line and the broken line is constant within the range C-LA). Also, the second stress Δσ is calculated by multiplying the yield stress σ of the martensite phase by the yHP The first stress σ borne by the ferrite phase is equal to the volume fraction of the 1 is the stress σ when there is only ferrite phaseSP This corresponds to the value obtained by multiplying by the volume fraction.

[0068] The above contents can be expressed by the following formulas (6) to (9): The volume fraction of the ferrite phase is, for example, 94% (0.94), and the volume fraction of the martensite phase is, for example, 6% (0.06). σ=σ 1 +Δσ (6) σ HP = σ yHP (7) Δσ=σ HP × (volume fraction of martensite phase) = σ yHP ×(volume fraction of martensite phase) (8) σ 1 = σ SP ×(volume fraction of ferrite phase) (9)

[0069] As described above, the Swift's law represented by the formula (5) can be applied to the ferrite phase. The relationship between the ferrite phase and the martensite phase can be expressed by one formula by transforming the formula (5) in the following steps (i) to (ii). Step (i) Take the natural logarithm of both sides and transform the equation. lnσ 1 = lnσ ySP (1+ε / α) n =ln(1+ε / α) n +lnσ ySP =n ln(1+ε / α)+lnσ ySP (5-1) Step (ii) Transform equation (6) into equation (10) and substitute it into equation (5-1). σ 1 =σ-Δσ (10) ln(σ-Δσ)=n·ln(1+ε / α)+lnσ ySP (5-2)

[0070] If we plot equation (5-2) with ln(σ-Δσ) on the vertical axis and ln(1+ε / α) on the horizontal axis, we can create a graph of a linear function. The graph has a slope of n and an intercept of lnσ.ySP Figure 10 is a log-log graph of the stress-strain relationship for dual-phase stainless steel, plotted as ln(σ-Δσ) on the vertical axis and ln(1+ε / α) on the horizontal axis. Here, the yield stress of the ferrite phase, σ ySP Since it can be obtained as above (for example, 234 MPa), the intercept lnσ ySP The value of α is determined so that = ln234 = 5.45. Once the value of α is determined, the slope n is also uniquely determined. In FIG. 10, the slope n = 0.23.

[0071] Substituting the obtained values ​​of α and n into formula (5-2), the variables in the formula are the stress σ and strain ε of the dual-phase steel, and the second stress Δσ. Since the stress σ and strain ε of the dual-phase steel can be determined from the measured data of the tensile test of the dual-phase steel, the only variable is essentially the second stress Δσ. Therefore, the calculation circuit 21 can determine Δσ by setting an appropriate initial value (e.g., 200 MPa) for the second stress Δσ and performing inverse analysis of the finite element method from the measured data of the tensile test of the dual-phase steel. Note that the value of Δσ finally obtained does not depend on the initial value, so any value may be set for the initial value.

[0072] The arithmetic circuit 21 substitutes the obtained second stress Δσ into the formula (10) to obtain the first stress σ 1 As a result, the calculation circuit 21 calculates the stress σ in the stress-strain curve as the first stress σ borne by the ferrite phase. 1 and a second stress Δσ borne by the martensite phase.

[0073] In this way, by processing so that the variable is one of the second stresses Δσ, the calculation circuit 21 can reduce the calculation load required for the inverse analysis of the finite element method. The calculation circuit 21 can also perform the inverse analysis of the finite element method while treating, for example, the characteristic constant α of the ferrite phase and the work hardening exponent n in the Swift's law formula (5) as variables similar to the second stress Δσ. However, it is not easy to uniquely determine a combination from among a plurality of combinations of variables. Therefore, by treating only the second stress Δσ as a variable, the calculation circuit 21 can relatively easily identify Δσ by inverse analysis.

[0074] The calculation circuit 21 transforms the formula (8) into the following formula (11) and substitutes the second stress Δσ obtained as described above to obtain the yield stress σ of the martensite phase: yHP As described above, the value of the volume fraction of the martensite phase of 6% is merely an example and is not limited to this. σ yHP = Δσ / (volume fraction of martensite phase) =Δσ / 0.06 (11)

[0075] Next, the calculation circuit 21 calculates the yield stress σ of the ferrite phase obtained as described above. ySP The stress-strain curve of the ferrite phase is calculated using σ, the work hardening exponent n, and the characteristic constant α of the ferrite phase. The stress-strain curve of the ferrite phase is calculated using σ in Swift's law (5). ySP , α, and n, the above-obtained values ​​can be substituted for the above.

[0076] Next, the calculation circuit 21 calculates the yield stress σ of the martensite phase obtained as described above. yHP The stress-strain curve of the martensite phase is calculated using the formula (12). Since the martensite phase can be regarded as an elastic perfectly plastic body, the stress-strain curve takes the form shown in Figure 9. In the elastic region, the stress σ is proportional to the strain ε, and in the plastic region, the stress σ is constant regardless of the value of strain ε. The stress and strain in the elastic region satisfy the relationship shown in the following formula (12). Stress = Young's modulus × strain (12)

[0077] Therefore, in the martensite phase, the stress at the boundary between the elastic region and the composition region (yield point YP) (yield stress σ yHP ) and strain (yield strain ε yHP ) can be calculated by the following formula (13). As the Young's modulus of the martensite phase, a known value can be used, and it is, for example, about 200 GPa. σ yHP = Young's modulus of martensite phase × ε yHP (13)

[0078] Based on these, if a stress-strain curve of the martensite phase is created, the curve will be a straight line with a slope of "Young's modulus of the martensite phase" up to the yield point YP, and once the yield point YP is exceeded, the stress will be "yield stress σ yHP ", the graph shown in Figure 9 is obtained.

[0079] As described above, the arithmetic circuit 21 can obtain the stress-strain curve of the ferrite phase and the stress-strain curve of the martensite phase. As described above, the method is not limited to dual-phase steels composed of ferrite and martensite phases, but can be used for any dual-phase steels composed of soft and hard phases.

[0080] (Processing by FEM analysis and damage assessment) The following describes the FEM analysis and damage assessment performed by the damage assessment process and the process in the damage assessment. The microelement stiffness equation used in the FEM analysis is expressed by the following equation (14). Here, x (x has a dot symbol above x) represents the characteristic displacement at each node, and F (F has a dot symbol above F) represents the nodal load for each node.

[0081]

number

[0082] Regarding formula (14), [K], {x}, and {F} are respectively expressed by the following formulas (15) to (17).

[0083]

number

[0084]

number

[0085]

number

[0086] Here, [B D ] is the matrix relating displacement velocity to deformation velocity. [B L ] is the matrix relating displacement velocity to velocity gradient. [C ep ] is the microelastic-plastic constitutive law matrix, [σ L ] is the stress matrix caused by geometric nonlinearity. In three-dimensional problems, these are specifically expressed by the following equations (18) to (21).

[0087]

number

[0088]

number

[0089]

number

[0090]

number

[0091] Here, N iindicates the shape function for node i. {j} in the right-hand side of equation (17) is a column vector with only the j component being 1 and the other components being zero. I in the right-hand side of equation (21) is a 3×3 unit matrix. Equation (15) is an elastic-plastic stiffness matrix. If the load velocity vectors corresponding to the six deformation modes given by equation (17) can be calculated separately, it is possible to calculate the characteristic displacement velocity of the microstructure using a normal FEM solver (i.e., software). Note that, as the geometric boundary condition when solving equation (14), it is necessary to give a periodic boundary condition, and an MPC (multipoint constraint) function is required. When calculating the elastic-plastic stiffness matrix expressed by equation (15) and the load velocity vector expressed by equation (17), the characteristic displacement velocity is calculated by the static explicit method using all known quantities (quantities at time t).

[0092] As described above, the analysis process simulates the deformation behavior of the metallic material by providing the microstructure finite element model with the macrostrain history obtained by performing FEM analysis on the macrostructure finite element model as a macrostrain increment. For example, the analysis process provides the microstructure finite element model with six components of the macrostrain increment equivalent to uniaxial tension. If the tensile direction is the 11 direction, and the directions perpendicular to the 11 direction are the 22 direction and the 33 direction, the analysis process may provide all integration points with strain increments in a ratio such that 11 component: 22 component: 33 component: 12 component: 23 component: 31 component = 1: -0.5: -0.5: 0: 0: 0. Note that the 12 component, 23 component, and 31 component mean shear components. The ratio is not limited to the above. For example, when the deformation field provided to the macrostructure finite element model is a multiaxial strain field instead of a uniaxial tension field, the analysis process can provide all integration points with strain increments in a ratio different from the above ratio to perform FEM analysis.

[0093] As described above, when it is determined that damage has occurred at a certain integration point in the damage determination process, the analysis process changes the calculation formula for element stiffness and performs FEM analysis. For example, the analysis process changes [σ L ] to zero, and [C ep] to 1 / 100 of the initial value. This allows the analysis process to release stress for integration points where damage has been determined to have occurred, and perform FEM analysis with element stiffness reduced to 1 / 100. This allows the analysis process to perform FEM analysis that takes into account the occurrence of damage at each integration point. After the change, [C ep The value of [C] is not limited to the above values ​​and can be any value, for example, 1 / 50 or less of the initial value. More specifically, ep The value of ] can be changed to 1 / 50, 1 / 200, 1 / 500, 1 / 1000, zero, etc.

[0094] [Example] The present invention will be described in more detail below with reference to examples. The present invention is not limited to the following examples, and can be modified as appropriate within the scope of the above and below-mentioned aims, and all of these are included in the technical scope of the present invention. That is, the following examples show examples using dual-phase steel composed of two phases, a ferrite phase which is a soft phase and a martensite phase which is a hard phase, but the present invention is not limited to this. In addition, the deformation field given to the macro-structure finite element model is given by uniaxial tension, but the present invention is not limited to this. In addition, the following damage criteria expressed by a certain function are given as a criterion for determining the presence or absence of damage, but the present invention is not limited to this.

[0095] In this example, the multi-phase material targeted was a dual-phase steel composed of two phases, ferrite and martensite, and damage to the metal material was evaluated as follows based on a finite element model created based on this dual-phase steel.

[0096] 1. Preparation of multi-phase materials (metallic materials) As the dual-phase steel, steel containing 0.063 mass% C, 0.50 mass% Si, and 1.46 mass% Mn (actual results) was melted, an ingot was obtained, forged, and heat-treated to prepare a dual-phase steel of martensite and ferrite. Using the above dual-phase steel, a FEM analysis model simulating the microstructure was created using the following procedure.

[0097] 2. Acquiring Microstructure Images of Metallic Materials The above material was cut into a size of approximately 10 mm x 10 mm for microscopic observation, etched with nital, and then a micrograph was taken at a magnification of 1000 times using a scanning electron microscope to obtain an image of the microstructure. The micrograph of the above material is shown in FIG. 3A. In FIG. 3A, the white parts indicate the martensite phase, which is a hard phase, and the gray parts indicate the ferrite phase, which is a soft phase. In FIG. 3A, when the micrograph was analyzed, the area fraction of the martensite, which is a hard phase, was about 15%.

[0098] 3. Creation of Microstructure Finite Element Model Next, the calculation circuit 21 of the evaluation system 1 was made to execute a model creation process to create a mesh model simulating an image of the microstructure of the above material in order to create a microstructure finite element model to be used in FEM analysis. The mesh model can be created in the same manner as in step 110 described above. In this embodiment, as in the model described in step 110, the mesh model is created as a 2D model with a total number of elements of 40,279 and a total number of nodes of 40,507 by setting four-node isoparametric elements. By making the calculation circuit 21 execute the model creation process, the 2D model is expanded by one layer in the depth direction of the image, and a 3D model with a total number of elements of 40,279 and a total number of nodes of 81,014 is created using eight-node isoparametric elements.

[0099] The 2D mesh model was created so that the area fraction of the region corresponding to the hard phase martensite was about 15%. Similarly, the 3D mesh model was created so that the volume fraction of the region corresponding to the hard phase martensite was about 15%.

[0100] 4. Obtaining material properties and setting damage criteria Next, the calculation circuit 21 of the evaluation system 1 was made to execute a parameter setting process to obtain each material property related to each phase constituting the metal material. Known values ​​were used for the Young's modulus and Poisson's ratio of each phase, with the Young's modulus of the ferrite phase set to 206 GPa, the Poisson's ratio to 0.3, and the Young's modulus of the martensite phase set to 206 GPa, and the Poisson's ratio to 0.3. In addition, curve data expressed by Swift's law (22) was provided as a stress-strain curve. The relationship between stress and strain related to the ferrite phase and the martensite phase can be expressed by the following formula (22). Here, σ y is the equivalent plastic strain of ε p is the yield stress (subsequent yield stress) of each phase when 0 is the initial yield stress of each phase (the yield stress when the equivalent plastic strain is zero). ε p is the equivalent plastic strain. a is a constant specific to each phase. n is the work hardening exponent of each phase. The parameters for each phase were calculated using the above method and input as material properties by parameter setting processing. In this embodiment, the parameters for the ferrite phase are σ 0 = 230MPa, a = 7 × 10 -3 , n = 0.23. The parameters related to the martensite phase are σ 0 = 2100MPa, a = 1 × 10 -5 , which was calculated to be n=0.015. σ y = σ 0 (1+ε p / a) n (twenty two)

[0101] In addition, the calculation circuit 21 was made to execute a parameter setting process to set damage criteria for each phase constituting the metal material. Based on formulas (1) and (2), the damage criteria were set so that the structure at the integration point is determined to be damaged when formula (23) is satisfied for the ferrite phase, and formula (24) is satisfied for the martensite phase. Here, ε p is the equivalent plastic strain. η is the stress triaxiality. ε pFor η, the equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality for each integration point calculated by the FEM analysis described later are input. ε p (η+4.5)>5 (23) ε p (η+1.4)>2.2 (24)

[0102] 5. Creating a Macro-Structure Finite Element Model Next, the calculation circuit 21 was made to execute a model creation process to create a macrostructure finite element model. FIG. 11 is a schematic diagram showing the relationship between the macrostructure finite element model and the microstructure finite element model. FIG. 11(a) is a schematic diagram of the macrostructure finite element model. FIG. 11(b) is a schematic diagram of the microstructure finite element model periodically arranged. FIG. 11(c) is an example of the microstructure finite element model. The schematic diagram shown in FIG. 11(b) shows how the microstructure finite element model shown in FIG. 11(c) is periodically arranged and configured. FIG. 11(b) corresponds to a part of the region of FIG. 11(a), and shows that a part of the region of the macrostructure finite element model corresponds to the region where the microstructure finite element model is periodically arranged.

[0103] 6. Acquisition of material properties as homogeneous material Next, the calculation circuit 21 was made to execute a parameter setting process to obtain material properties for performing FEM analysis on the macro-structure finite element model, and the parameters were set as uniform material properties. As described above, a uniaxial tensile test was performed on a test piece made of a metal material to obtain a stress-strain curve for the metal material. In addition, the yield stress of the metal material was obtained by the uniaxial tensile test.

[0104] 7. Executing FEM analysis on macro-structural finite element model (calculating macro-strain history) Next, the arithmetic circuit was made to execute the analysis process, and the FEM analysis was performed using the macro-structure finite element model. In the FEM analysis, the macro-structure finite element model was given a load or displacement condition equivalent to a uniaxial tensile test, the deformation behavior of the macro-structure finite element model was simulated, and the deformation history of the macro-structure finite element model was calculated. The tensile direction in the uniaxial tensile test corresponds to the direction indicated by the arrow in FIG. 11(a). Hereinafter, the tensile direction is appropriately referred to as "11 directions". In this embodiment, as shown in FIG. 11(a), the left and right directions of the macro-structure finite element model are set as the 11 directions, and the directions perpendicular to the tensile direction are set as the 22 directions and the 33 directions. In this embodiment, the boundary conditions were set as shown in FIG. 11(a). Specifically, the lower left end of the macro-structure finite element model was completely constrained, and the right end and the left end of the model except for the lower left end were constrained in the 11 directions. Under the boundary conditions, a forced displacement was applied to the macro-structure finite element model to pull the right end in 11 directions, and a FEM analysis equivalent to a uniaxial tensile test was performed to calculate a predetermined macro-strain in an arbitrary evaluation region. In this embodiment, the macro-strain was calculated in a ratio of 11 components: 22 components: 33 components: 12 components: 23 components: 31 components = 1: -0.5: -0.5: 0: 0: 0. Then, the macro-strain calculated for each load set in the uniaxial tension was output as a macro-strain history. In the following, "macro-strain" means the strain in the above 11 directions, unless otherwise specified. In addition, the 12 components, 23 components, and 31 components mean shear components.

[0105] 8. Setting Boundary Conditions Next, the boundary conditions to be given to the microstructure finite element model were set by executing a parameter setting process in the arithmetic circuit 21. More specifically, assuming that the microstructure finite element model is periodically arranged, periodic boundary conditions were given to the disturbance displacement components.

[0106] 9. Executing FEM analysis on microstructural finite element model (calculating equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality) Next, the calculation circuit 21 was made to execute an analysis process, and an FEM analysis was performed using the created microstructure finite element model. In the FEM analysis, the history of the obtained macrostrain was given to all integration points of the microstructure finite element model as input information for the boundary value problem. Then, when the macrostrain increment based on the history of the macrostrain was given to the microstructure finite element model, the deformation behavior of the model was analyzed by simulation to see how the model would deform under the periodic boundary condition for the disturbance displacement component. As a result, the equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality at each position were calculated and output as the deformation behavior of the model for each macrostrain. In this embodiment, the values ​​at the integration points of each element of the microstructure finite element model were used as each position.

[0107] 10. Damage determination at each integration point of the microstructure finite element model and continue FEM analysis Next, the calculation circuit 21 was made to execute a damage determination process to determine whether damage had occurred at each integration point based on the equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality calculated when FEM analysis was performed at a certain macroscopic strain increment. The damage criteria for determining damage are given by equations (1) and (2) as described above. In this embodiment, as shown in equations (23) and (24), A=4.5, f cr = 5, A = 1.4 for the martensite phase, f cr = 2.2, and the presence or absence of damage was judged based on the phases that compose each integral point. In other words, the equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality calculated at a certain integral point were substituted into equations (1) and (2), and f i ≦f cr If f, it is determined that no damage has occurred at the integration point. i >f cr In this embodiment, if f i =f cr For the integral points where f i =f crIt may be determined that damage has occurred for an integration point where the stress is greater than the initial value. If it is determined that damage has occurred for an integration point, the calculation circuit 21 releases the stress at the integration point and reduces the element stiffness to 1 / 100 of the initial value. Then, the macro strain increment is increased and the FEM analysis is further performed.

[0108] The FEM analysis was terminated when the strain in the microstructure finite element model reached a predetermined deformation rate or when the number of integration points where damage was determined to have occurred increased to such an extent that it became impossible to calculate the equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality using FEM analysis.

[0109] Fig. 12A shows stress-strain curves of 11 directional components obtained by calculating the volume average at all integration points for the stress and strain calculated by the above-mentioned FEM analysis of the microstructure finite element model. Fig. 12B shows the transition of the number of integration points of the microstructure finite element model determined to be damaged based on the damage criteria according to the applied strain in the FEM analysis of the microstructure finite element model.

[0110] Figure 12B shows that the number of integral points determined to be damaged increases sharply from the point where the macrostrain in the tensile direction component exceeds approximately 27%. Similarly, Figure 12A shows that the stress required for deformation decreases from the point where the macrostrain in the tensile direction component exceeds approximately 27%, causing a decrease in deformation resistance. Figure 12A reproduces the same tendency as the measured data of the stress-strain curve obtained from a uniaxial tensile test performed on a test piece made of a metal material.

[0111] FIG. 13A shows a microstructure finite element model calculated by simulation when a macrostrain of 30% tensile direction component is applied in the FEM analysis. FIG. 13B shows a microstructure finite element model calculated by simulation when a macrostrain of 35% tensile direction component is applied in the FEM analysis. In each of FIG. 13A and FIG. 13B, the area surrounded by a solid line circle shows microvoids generated in each microstructure finite element model. In addition, in FIG. 13B, the area surrounded by a dashed line circle shows that microvoids generated when a macrostrain of 30% is applied have grown by increasing the macrostrain, and multiple microvoids have become connected.

[0112] As shown in Figs. 12A to 13B, the analysis results obtained by this simulation method can reproduce the data obtained by the experiment, and the analysis can be performed with high accuracy. In this way, according to the present invention, it is possible to reproduce by simulation the decrease in deformation resistance in the tensile direction on the macrostructure side accompanying the occurrence and progression of damage on the microstructure side during tensile deformation. In addition, on the microstructure side, damage occurs in the microstructure as the macrodeformation progresses, and it is possible to simultaneously analyze the behavior of the damage linking and progressing. Therefore, it is possible to realize a multi-scale simulation that takes into account and evaluates the mechanical behavior of the macrostructure, the mechanical behavior of the microstructure, and the behavior of damage occurrence and damage progression.

[0113] By executing such a simulation, a person skilled in the art can predict the material properties associated with the progression of deformation, taking into account the occurrence and progression of damage in the microstructure, and compare and judge multiple materials. This allows a person skilled in the art to predict through analysis which material can satisfy the required quality and material properties. In addition, a person skilled in the art can analytically judge which of multiple materials is superior.

[0114] In recent years, as the component composition and manufacturing process of metallic materials become more complex, distribution (inhomogeneity) of structure and strength is unavoidably likely to occur at the scale of the microstructure of metallic materials, and the inhomogeneity of the structure etc. greatly affects the macroscopic strength characteristics. Furthermore, the strength characteristics required for structures formed from the above metallic materials have become increasingly strict in recent years. However, according to the method of this embodiment, the influence of the inhomogeneity of the structure etc. can be accurately taken into account, and the macroscopic strength characteristics of a practical-scale structure (component) can be evaluated with high accuracy.

[0115] The damage simulation method for evaluating the damage behavior of multi-phase materials including metallic materials of the present disclosure is realized by cooperation between hardware resources, such as a processor and memory, and software resources (computer programs). [Industrial Applicability]

[0116] The method according to this embodiment can be effectively used in the development of metal materials for constructing structures such as buildings, ships, marine structures, bridges, and tanks, which require more stringent strength characteristics. [Explanation of symbols]

[0117] 1. Rating System 10. Imaging Device 11. Photography Department 12 Communication Circuits 20 Control device 21 Arithmetic circuit 22 Storage device 23 Input / Output Devices 24 Communication Circuits

Claims

1. A damage simulation method for evaluating the damage behavior of a multi-phase material including a metallic material and composed of a plurality of phases having different strength characteristics, using a calculation circuit, the calculation circuit comprising: A step of creating a microstructure finite element model of a microanalysis object based on the structure observation result of the multi-phase material; A step of setting and acquiring different strength characteristics and damage criteria for each phase constituting the multi-phase material; A step of creating a macro-structure finite element model for analyzing a macro-region of the multi-phase material, performing a finite element analysis using the macro-structure finite element model assuming that the multi-phase material is a homogeneous material, and calculating a deformation history of the evaluation target region; a step of calculating a deformation behavior of the microstructure finite element model by applying the deformation history to each integration point of the microstructure finite element model and performing a finite element analysis based on a homogenization method; A step of performing damage determination by comparing the deformation behavior with the damage criteria; a step of releasing stress at an integration point where damage has been determined to have occurred in the microstructure finite element model by the damage determination, and reducing element stiffness to zero or a predetermined value; A damage simulation method is performed.

2. The damage simulation method of claim 1 , wherein the damage criteria is a function of equivalent plastic strain and stress triaxiality.

3. 3. The damage simulation method according to claim 2, wherein the damage judgment is performed by judging that damage has occurred at a specific integration point when a value calculated based on an equivalent plastic strain and a stress triaxiality calculated as the damage behavior at the specific integration point of the microstructure finite element model is greater than the damage criterion.

4. The damage simulation method according to claim 1 , wherein the predetermined value is equal to or smaller than 1 / 50 of an initial value of the element stiffness.

5. The damage simulation method according to claim 1 , wherein the multi-phase material is a metallic material.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • FEAP-based construction method of three-dimensional polycrystalline microstructure material model

    CN109063275A

  • Simulation method of heterogeneous material

    JP2006015866A

  • Prediction method of uniform extension and prediction program for uniform extension

    JP2012104042A

  • Method of pre-treating composite finite element, method of analyzing composite material, analysis service system and computer readable recording medium

    JP2018055509A

  • Integrated process-structure-property modeling frameworks and methods for design optimization and / or performance prediction of material systems and applications of same

    US20200089826A1