Method and apparatus for reading lateral flow tests

The method and apparatus for reading LFTs using time-gated fluorescence detection and signal normalization address the complexity and interference issues in existing technologies, enhancing sensitivity and specificity, and simplifying data processing for improved LFT reading performance.

WO2024227554A1PCT designated stage expired Publication Date: 2024-11-07AUSTRIAMICROSYSTEMS AG
View PDF 6 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/EP2024/059268
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2023-05-03
Filing Date
2024-04-04
Publication Date
2024-11-07

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Current digital reading methods for lateral flow tests (LFTs) are complex and expensive, requiring sophisticated image processing and equipment, while existing optical reading methods struggle with interference from autofluorescence, leading to reduced sensitivity and specificity.

Method used

A method and apparatus for reading LFTs using a processor to evaluate signals from test and reference line regions with optically active tags, employing time-gated fluorescence detection and signal normalization to improve sensitivity and specificity, and utilizing a simpler microcontroller for data processing.

Benefits of technology

The approach enhances the sensitivity and specificity of LFT readings by reducing autofluorescence interference and simplifying data processing, achieving accurate digital readings with improved performance and reduced device-to-device variation.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure EP2024059268_07112024_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure EP2024059268_07112024_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

An apparatus for reading a lateral flow assay performed on a lateral flow device including a conjugate portion with antibodies labelled with optically active tags, a test line region (41a, 41b) and a reference line region (42a, 42b), to detect presence of an analyte in a sample, wherein the apparatus comprises a first light source (43a, 43b) for emitting a first light towards the test line region (41a, 41b); second light source (44a, 44b) for emitting a second light towards the reference line region (42a, 42b); a photodetector (45a, 46a, 45b, 46b) for receiving a first signal emitted from the test line region (41a, 41b) and / or a second signal emitted from the reference line region (42a, 42b); and a processor for evaluating a result of the reading based on the first signal in a predetermined first signal stable flow phase and the second signal in a predetermined second signal stable flow phase, wherein the first signal stable flow phase begins after a predetermined number of consecutive first derivatives of the first signal-time curve are within a first predetermined threshold, the second signal stable flow phase begins after a predetermined number of consecutive first derivatives of the second signal-time curve are within a second predetermined threshold.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[0001] Description

[0002] METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR READING LATERAL FLOW TESTS

[0003] The present disclosure relates to a method for reading lateral flow tests , in particular, to a method for performing digital reading of lateral flow tests with improved performance . It also relates to an apparatus for reading lateral flow tests .

[0004] BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

[0005] Lateral flow tests ( LFTs ) are widely used in the field of in- vitro diagnostics to detect , for example , infectious diseases or other medically relevant conditions in patients . LFTs can operate as either competitive or sandwich assays . Sandwich assays are generally used for large analytes because they tend to have multiple binding sites . The principle of sandwich assay is shown in Figure 1 ( a ) . The large analyte 13a is coupled to a first antibody 12a which is labelled with an optically active tags I la . Then the analyte-antibody complex is coupled to another speci fic antibody 14a which is immobili zed in the test line area 16a . The labelled antibody which is not coupled to the analyte 13a is not immobili zed in the test line 16a and flows further to a reference line region which contains a further antibody not speci fic to the analyte 13a . The labelled antibody is then bound to the further antibody in the reference line region . Figure 1 (b ) shows the principle of competitive assay used for small analytes 13b which have fewer binding sites . The analyteantibody complexes flow to the test line region 16b which contains target analytes 13b fixed on the surface . When the target analytes 13b are absent from the sample , unbound antibodies will bind to these fixed analytes 13b contend in the test line region 16b. Conversely, when the target analytes 13b are present in the sample, they bind to the antibodies 12b to prevent them from binding to fixed analytes 13b in the test line region 16b.

[0006] Sandwich-immunoassay technique is more often used for LFTs. The optically active tags Ila are made of either gold nanoparticles (GNP) or polystyrene nanoparticles (Latex) that absorb a portion of incident light when immobilized in the test line region 16a. The absorption resulted in a visually colored line (GNP: reddish, latex: bluish) , which confirms the presence of the target analyte 13a.

[0007] As alternative optically active tags, fluorescent dyes, either directly conjugated to an antibody or encapsulated in small nanoparticles, have been becoming increasingly popular over the past few years. Fluorescent dyes theoretically allow better detection sensitivity and can only be read after exciting the dyes with light of a certain wavelength or wavelength range. However, in an LFT, the fluorescence signal from the test line may be interfered by other sources of fluorescence, such as autofluorescence from the nitrocellulose membrane of the LFT, from the surrounding plastic material, or from deposited dust particles.

[0008] The typical lifetime of the fluorescent electronic state of such interfering autofluorescence is 5 nanoseconds (ns ) . To suppress interfering autofluorescence from any surrounding surface, a fluorescent dye, such as Europium-chelate complex, which features a much longer lifetime, e.g., 500 microseconds (ps ) , can be utilized for optically active tags and the time-gated (TG) technique can also be applied. Figure 2 shows a schematic operational view of the time-gated fluorescence detection. The time-gated detection is initiated by turning a light source, e.g. a LED on. The LED is kept on for a first time period, e.g., 2ms, then it is switched off. Up to now, the photodetector has not yet started to work. After a time interval, e.g. lOOus, from when the LED is turned off, the photodetector is turned on and held for a second time period, e.g. 4ms. In this scheme, any fluorescence with a lifetime shorter than the time interval is completely decayed before the photodetector is activated. Therefore, the photodetector will only detect the fluorescent dye, e.g. Europium / chelate complex immobilized in the test line region.

[0009] In this way, the TG detection approach can improve both the sensitivity and the specificity of an LFT. The sensitivity is hereby defined as number of truly detected positive samples divided by number of total positive samples employed and the specificity is the number of truly detected negative samples divided by number of total negative samples employed. The sensitivity of an LFT is improved due to less interfering autofluorescence, and the specificity of an LFT is improved due to reduction of false signals.

[0010] Result of such TG fluorescence based LFTs cannot be read out visually. Instead, the results are read out digitally, i.e., by optical readers. The prior art US20180356407A1 discloses a reading method used for digital reading of an LFT. However, it uses an expensive camera and conducts a complicated image processing procedure. The digital reading process disclosed in another prior art US20210293793A1 requires to scan the LED and photodetector. Therefore, an object to be achieved is to provide a method to perform simple processing but enable improved optical reading of LFTs. A further object is to provide an apparatus with less complex microcontroller that performs simple calculation but enables better optical reading of LFTs.

[0011] These objects are achieved with the subject-matter of the independent claims. Further developments and embodiments are described in dependent claims.

[0012] SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

[0013] The improved concept is based on the idea of providing an apparatus for reading a lateral flow assay performed on a lateral flow device including a conjugate portion with antibodies labelled with optically active tags, a test line region (41a, 41b) and a reference line region (42a, 42b) , to detect presence of an analyte in a sample, wherein the apparatus comprises a first light source (43a, 43b) for emitting a first light towards the test line region (41a, 41b) ; a second light source (44a, 44b) for emitting a second light towards the reference line region (42a, 42b) ; a photodetector (45a, 46a, 45b, 46b) for receiving a first signal emitted from the test line region (41a, 41b) and / or a second signal emitted from the reference line region (42a, 42b) ; and a processor for evaluating a result of the reading based on the first signal in a predetermined first signal stable flow phase and the second signal in a predetermined second signal stable flow phase. When the sample flows steadily on the lateral flow device, the emitted signal enters the signal stable flow phase. The first signal stable flow phase begins after a predetermined number of consecutive first derivatives of the first signal-time curve are within a first predetermined threshold, the second signal stable flow phase begins after a predetermined number of consecutive first derivatives of the second signal-time curve are within a second predetermined threshold . The predetermined number is at least 3 , and preferably at least 5 . The predetermined percentage is no more than 50% . The apparatus may have two photodetectors . The first photodetector receives a first signal emitted from the test line region ( 41a, 41b ) and the second photodetector receives a second signal emitted from the reference line region ( 42a, 42b ) . The apparatus may have only one photodetector for receiving both the first signal and the second signal , so that the light sources are turned on alternatively . The light sources may be LEDs .

[0014] Preferably, evaluating the result of the reading includes calculating a value v wherein Sltis the first signal , S2iis the second signal , i is the data point , i E [1,N] , i = M is a starting point of the stable flow phase . Although the emitted second signal-time curve is delayed compared to the emitted first signal-time curve , the starting point M may be the same for the first signal stable flow phase and the second signal stable flow phase . Furthermore , evaluating the result comprises also comparing v to a cut-of f value of Negative Control (NC ) of the sample .

[0015] Preferably, before performing the evaluation, the processor performs normali zing the first signal based on an average of the first signal value over a predetermined first signal initial flow phase and normali zing the second signal based on an average of the second signal value over a predetermined second signal initial flow phase , wherein the evaluation is performed on the normali zed first signal in the predetermined first signal stable phase and the normali zed second signal in the predetermined second signal stable phase .

[0016] Preferably, the first signal has a maximum value of a first derivate at a starting point of the predetermined first signal initial flow phase and at an ending point of the predetermined first signal initial flow phase , the first signal is less than a predetermined percentage of a peak of the first signal and a first derivative of the first signal is above a first predetermined threshold, wherein the second signal has a maximum value of a first derivate at a starting point of the predetermined second signal initial flow phase and at an ending point of the predetermined second signal initial flow phase , the second signal is less than the predetermined percentage of a peak of the second signal and a first derivative of the second signal is above a second predetermined threshold .

[0017] Preferably, the first signal and the second signal are normali zed as :

[0018] Wherein Sltis the first signal , S2iis the second signal , i is the data point , i E [1, 7V] , the predetermined first signal initial flow phase and the predetermined second signal initial flow phase are between data points i G [P, Q] , a and p are scaling factors intended to get a final cut-of f value that is not arbitrary . Although the emitted second signaltime curve is delayed compared to the emitted first signaltime curve , the initial flow phase range may be the same for the first signal stable flow phase and the second signal stable flow phase . After the signal normali zation process , the processor will further perform evaluating the result of the reading includes calculating a value v based on the normali zed first signal and second signal : wherein Sltis the first signal , S2iis the second signal , i is the data point , i E [1,N] , i = M is the starting point of the stable flow phase . Furthermore , evaluating the result comprises also comparing v to a cut-of f value of Negative Control (NC ) of the sample .

[0019] Preferably, the optically active tags are fluorescent label or light absorption signal .

[0020] Preferably, the fluorescent is TG fluorescent .

[0021] Preferably, the first signal or the second signal is the number of photons received by the photodetector .

[0022] Preferably, the photodetector is a multispectral photodetector and can accordingly be used for reading multiplex assays to detect multiple targets .

[0023] The improved concept is also based on the idea of providing a method for reading a lateral flow test , comprising : applying a sample to a lateral flow device so that the sample flows on the lateral flow device from a conj ugate portion with antibodies labelled with optically active tags , a test line region ( 41a, 41b ) and a reference line region ( 42a, 42b ) , sequentially; emitting a first light towards the test line region ( 41a, 41b ) and a second light towards the reference line region ( 42a, 42b ) ; receiving a first signal emitted from the test line region ( 41a, 41b ) and a second signal emitted from the reference line region ( 42a, 42b ) ; evaluating a result of the reading based on the first signal in a predetermined first signal stable flow phase and the second signal in a predetermined second signal stable flow phase , wherein the first signal stable flow phase begins after a predetermined number of consecutive first derivatives of the first signal-time curve are within a first predetermined threshold, the second signal stable flow phase begins after a predetermined number of consecutive first derivatives of the second signal-time curve are within a second predetermined threshold .

[0024] Preferably, before performing the evaluation, the method comprises normali zing the first signal based on an average of the first signal value over a predetermined first signal initial flow phase and normali zing the second signal based on an average of the second signal value over a predetermined second signal initial flow phase , wherein the evaluation is performed on the normali zed first signal in the predetermined first signal stable phase and the normali zed second signal in the predetermined second signal stable phase .

[0025] Preferably, the method also comprises emitting the first light towards the test line region ( 41a, 41b ) for a first period of time and then turned of f the first light , receiving the first signal emitted from the test line region ( 41a, 41b ) for a second period of time , and then stopping the receiving, emitting the second light towards the test line region ( 42a, 42b ) for a third period of time and then turning of f the second light , and receiving the second signal emitted from the test line region ( 41a, 41b ) for a fourth period of time , sequentially .

[0026] Preferably, the method further comprises waiting for a fi fth period of time between the turning of f of the first light and the receiving of the first signal .

[0027] Preferably, the method further comprising waiting for a sixth period of time between the turning of f of the second light and the receiving of the second signal .

[0028] Further embodiments of the method become apparent to the skilled reader from the embodiments of method and apparatus for reading lateral flow tests described above , and vice- versa .

[0029] BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0030] The following description of figures may further illustrate and explain aspects of the method and apparatus for reading lateral flow tests . Identical or ef fectively identical components and parts might be described only with respect to the figures where they occur first . Their description is not necessarily repeated in successive figures .

[0031] DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0032] In the figures : Figures 1 ( a ) and 1 (b ) are schematic diagrams of sandwich lateral flow test and competitive lateral flow test , respectively;

[0033] Figure 2 shows a schematic operational view of time-gated fluorescence detection;

[0034] Figure 3 illustrates schematic of a sandwich type lateral flow test device ;

[0035] Figures 4 ( a ) and 4 (b ) illustrate respectively schematic of reflective optical apparatus for reading LFTs and transmissive optical apparatus for reading LFTs , according to the present invention;

[0036] Figure 5 illustrates fluorescence signals from the test line region and reference line region of an LFT ;

[0037] Figure 6 illustrates normali zed fluorescence signals shown in Figure 5 according to the present invention;

[0038] Figure 7 illustrates the result of reading a first LFT by a transmissive reading apparatus according to the present invention with data evaluation process ;

[0039] Figure 8 shows the performance of the reading result corresponding to Figure 7 ;

[0040] Figure 9 illustrates the result of reading a second LFT by a transmissive reading apparatus according to the present invention with data evaluation process ;

[0041] Figure 10 shows the performance of the reading result corresponding to Figure 9 ;

[0042] Figure 11 illustrates the results of reading a first LFT and a second LFT simultaneously by a transmissive reading apparatus according to the present invention;

[0043] Figure 12 shows the performance of the reading results corresponding to Figure 11 ;

[0044] Figure 13 illustrates the results of reading a first LFT and a second LFT by a transmissive reading apparatus according to the present invention but without the data normali zation approach;

[0045] Figure 14 shows the performance of the reading results corresponding to Figure 13 ;

[0046] Figure 15 illustrates the result of reading a LFT by prior art reflective reading apparatuses without the data normali zation and data evaluation approach according to the present invention;

[0047] Figure 16 shows the performance of the reading results corresponding to Figure 15 ;

[0048] Figure 17 illustrates the result of reading a LFT by using the method according to the present invention including the data normali zation and data evaluation approach;

[0049] Figure 18 shows the performance of the reading results corresponding to Figure 17 ;

[0050] Figure 19 illustrates the result of reading a LFT by a prior art reflective LFT reading apparatus using the dry-white algorithm for normali zation;

[0051] Figure 20 shows the performance of the reading results corresponding to Figure 19 ; Figure 21 illustrates the result of reading a LFT by using a reflective LFT reading apparatus according to the present invention including data normali zation and data evaluation approach; and Figure 22 shows the performance of the reading results corresponding to Figure 21 .

[0052] A typical sandwich type lateral flow assay device is illustrated in Figure 3 . A drop of liquid sample comprising analytes 33 is applied to the LFT device . Once applied, the fluid sample flows to the conj ugate portion which comprises antibodies 32 labelled with optically active tags 31 , e . g . fluorescent label . At the conj ugate portion, the analytes 33 from the applied sample get bound to the labelled antibodies to form analyte-antibody complexes . At the same time , the remaining labelled antibodies continue to flow through a nitrocellulose membrane to reach the test line region 36 and the reference line region 37 . The analyte-antibody complexes will then also flow through the nitrocellulose membrane to reach the test line region 36 . As shown in Figure 3 , speci fic antibodies 34 ( the second antibodies ) are contained in the test line region 36 , which can bind to the analyte-antibody complexes , and hence the latter will be immobili zed in the test line region 36 . The antibodies 32 alone cannot be bound to the speci fic antibodies 34 , so they do not stop at the test line region 36 but flow further to the reference line region 37 which comprises a third antibodies 35 di f ferent from the speci fic antibodies 34 . Some of labelled antibodies can be bound to the antibodies 35 and immobili zed in the reference line region 37 . The rest liquid flows further to an end of the LFT assay . Such LFT cannot be read out visually but by an optical reading apparatus shown in Figure 4 ( a ) or 4 (b ) . A reflective optical reading apparatus schematically illustrated in Figure 4 ( a ) comprises two light sources , e . g . two LEDs 43a and 44a, two photodetectors 45a and 46a, and a processor (not shown) . The first LED 43a emits light with a speci fic wavelength or wavelength range towards the test line region 41a . Then the optically active tags / fluorescent labels in the test line region 41a area absorbs the incident light from the first LED 43a, and emits the first outgoing light / fluorescence signal . The mentioned optically active tags / fluorescent labels in the test line region 41a area may be the optically active tags / fluorescent labels contained in analyte / antibody complexes , the optically active tags / fluorescent labels contained in the labelled antibodies which are not bound to any analyte , or both, depending on the flow of the sample across the assay device at the time of light incidence . The reflective optical reading apparatus works in the reflection mode , so the first outgoing light / fluorescence signal is reflected towards the first photodetector 45a which is arranged on the same side of the first LED 43a . The first photodetector 45a is arranged to receive the first outgoing light / fluorescence signal . It is already explained that , for TG based fluorescence detection, the LED 43a is first hold on for a first period, and then turned of f . After a certain time interval , the first photodetector is turned on for detection . Similarly, the second LED 44a emits light with a speci fic wavelength or wavelength range towards the reference line region 42a, so that the optically active tag / fluorescent label in the reference line region 42a area enters an excited state after absorbing the light energy, and emits the second outgoing light / fluorescence signal , which is then reflected towards and detected by the second photodetector 46a . The reflective apparatus for reading LFTs shown in Figure 4 ( a ) comprises two photo detectors to receive light / fluorescence signals from test line region 41a and reference line region 42a, respectively . It is also possible to comprise only one photodetector which receives the light / fluorescence signals alternatively from the test line region 41a and the reference line region 42a . This arrangement works only in reflection mode , and the photodetector is placed in the middle while the first LED 45a and the second LED 46a are placed above the test line region 41a and reference line region 42a, respectively . The light / signals are distinguished by turning the first LED 45a and the second LED 46a on and of f at well controlled time points . The photodetector ( s ) convert the light / fluorescence signals to electrical signals which will then be sent to a processor for assessing the data and determine the result of an LET .

[0053] A transmissive optical apparatus for reading LFTs , which comprises two LEDs 43b and 44b, two photodetectors 45b and 46b, and a processor (not shown) , is schematically illustrated in Figure 4 (b ) . The working principle of the transmissive apparatus is similar to that of the reflective apparatus shown in Figure 4 ( a ) . The optically active tag / fluorescent labels in the test line region 41b and reference line region 42b absorb incident light from the LED 43b and 44b, respectively , when the incident light reaches the test and reference line regions , the optically active tags / fluorescent labels , which are in the two lines at this moment , enter an excited state after absorbing light energy and emits outgoing light / fluorescent signals , which pass through the LET device and are received by the photodetectors 45b and 46b, respectively . In the transmissive arrangement , the first LED 43b and the second LED 44b are arranged on one side of the test line region 41b and reference line region 42b, while the first photodetector 45b and the second photodetector 46b are arranged on other side.

[0054] In the present invention, both reflective and transmissive optical devices may be used.

[0055] An LFT typically takes between 10 and 20 minutes, and the optical or digital reading of the assay can be taken throughout the assay time or just at the endpoint. Obviously, optical or digital reading performed for the entire assay time ("on-the-f ly" reading) requires more control and processing of the data readout but can result in more accurate reading performance due to the greater amount of information collected.

[0056] Figure 5 shows typical kinetic signals from the test line region and reference line (control line) region of an LFT. The x-axis (horizontal) of the graph represents the LFT reading time. The y-axis (vertical) of the graph represents the number of photons detected by a photodetector. The initial point "0" on the x-axis represents the time point when photodetectors are turned on. Preferably, to avoid crosstalk between the signals of the two lines, both LEDs are switched on / off not exactly at the same time and the two photodetectors are turned on / off correspondingly. For example, the first LED is switched on for 2ms and switched off, then the first sensor is switched on lOOus after the first LED is switched off, and the first sensor is switched off after another 4ms. Then, the second LED is switched on for 2ms and switched off. The second sensor is switched on after a delay of lOOus, and the second sensor is switched off after another 4ms. In this case, the complete cycle takes 12.2ms and can be repeated up to ~80 times per second if necessary. Preferably, the number of complete cycles per second are in the range between 1 and 10. Preferably, there is also a little time delay between the two cycles (e.g., 1ms, or 10ms, or 100ms) . The reference line region curve (control line) shows the number of detected photons absorption signal emitted from the reference line region as a function of the assay reading time, which is the assay running time from the time photodetectors are first turned on. Similarly, the test line region curve (test line) shows the number of detected photons absorption signal emitted from the test line region as a function of the assay reading time. Since the two lines are arranged quite close on the LFT device, the fluorescence signals emitted from the two lines started at almost the same time. The kinetic curves of the test line region and reference line region are matched temporally by the first time point when the count is > a threshold (i.e. 3 counts) . So, the dry signal is 0.

[0057] Figure 5 shows a result of on-the-fly reading, which means that processor processing the data from the photodetector during the entire LFT reading time. The LFT reading time is defined as LFT running time or the assay running time from the time the photodetectors are turned on. For analysis purpose, the x-axis is divided into two phases: the initial flow phase and the stable flow phase. In the initial flow phase, which is the beginning of the sample flow, the unbound optically active tag / fluorescent label-labeled antibodies flow faster than the optically active tag / fluorescent label- labeled antibodies that are bound with analytes (analyteantibody complexes) . Thus, a large amount of the unbound antibodies flow to the measurement area including the test line region and the reference line region. As a result, as shown in figure 5, a peak in the reference line region curve (control line) and a peak in the test line region curve occur during the initial phase. During the entire assay process, the measure should be at a sampling rate as high as possible, especially to capture the initial phase, i.e. every 30s, 10s, or Is. After a while, ca. 5 minutes, the kinetic signals or the two curves enter the stable flow phase. The flow of the unbound optically active tag / fluorescent label-labeled antibodies gets stable, and in case of a positive sample, the analyte-antibody complexes reach the test line region and are bound to the antibodies in the test line region. The result is that the test line region curve increases and exceeds the reference line region curve (control line) . In practice, the first signal has a maximum value of a first derivate at a starting point of the predetermined initial first signal initial flow phase and at an ending point of the predetermined first signal initial phase, the first signal is less than a predetermined percentage of a peak of the first signal and a first derivative of the first signal is above a predetermined threshold.

[0058] The invention requires prior knowledge of the flow behavior over time, particularly the distinction between initial flow and later stable flow. Therefore, pre-measurements in LFT devices should be done.

[0059] The photodetectors acquire photons during the whole assay reading time (e.g., 15-20min) with enough time resolution to distinguish an initial flow phase from a later stable flow phase and to provide a sufficient number of data points (e.g., 20) for each phase. In the on-the-fly detection approach, during the first phase of the reading time when the liquid flow just passes through the test line region and the reference line region, the emitted photons or fluorescence signals are mostly not yet affected by the potential target proteins / analytes in the flow sample. In the following second phase, when the liquid flow gets stable, the presence of target proteins / analytes in the flow sample will lead to accumulation of optically active tags / fluorescent labels in the test line region and a corresponding increase in the optical signal output there.

[0060] The present invention adopts the "on-the-fly" detection approach and takes advantage of these two phases. In the initial flow phase, the test line region curve and the reference line region curve (control line) shown in the figure 5 are normalized and then in the stable flow phase, the difference values between the two curves at the same time point over a longer time rather than just the endpoints of the detection or assay, are calculated to provide assay result .

[0061] The test line region curve and the reference line region curve (control line) are normalized based on the average of the fluorescent photon counts or light absorption signal over time of the initial phase.

[0062] Denote kinetic data (fluorescent photon counts or light absorption signal) of the test line region as: Slifi is the data point on the test line region curve, i E [17V] , and similarly S2ifor the reference line region. The initial flow happens between data points i G [P,Q], (P is e.g. 3) the kinetic data of the test and reference line regions are normalized as: where a and p are scaling factors intended to get a final cut-off value that is not arbitrary (e.g., 1, 100 or 1000) .

[0063] The two curves shown in Figure 5 are normalized according to the above formulas and the result is shown in Figure 6. The two kinetic signal curves are not normalized to a single data point, e.g. the peak value or a value after the peak (i.e. between 30s and 5 mins after the peak) , but normalized to the average of the value over the initial phase time. The invention yields significantly better results than another possible "on-the-fly" algorithm, where the signal ratios of the initially dray and clean (white) strip are used to normalize the later signals from the wetted strip.

[0064] The normalized data will then be used for data evaluation to determine if the assay result is positive or negative. The normalized kinetic data (fluorescent photon counts or light absorption signal) of the test line region, Slt(i E [1,7V]) , contains signal from the test line region and also control signal and noise, while the normalized kinetic data of the reference line region, S2l(i E [1, TV] ) , contains the control signal and noise. Assuming the control signal is homogeneous, by taking the difference between the test and reference line regions, Slt— S2l, the control signal can be omitted and so $ll ~ $2l now represents signal and noise. Thus averaging Slt— S2lover time (when the flow is stable) will reduce the impact of the noise. Denote i = M when the flow is stable. The value that algorithm will calculate for the measurement is: Hereby the sum in the numerator represents the integral of the area between the two single photodetector curves in the stable flow region.

[0065] Figure 7 illustrates the result of reading the first LFT by a transmissive reading apparatus according to the present invention. Here, the data evaluation process has been performed, but the signal normalization process is not performed. The x-axis (horizontal) of the graph shown in Figure 7 represents dilution of a fluid sample, i.e. 4M means a positive sample that is diluted 4 million times from a raw positive sample, 512k means 512000 times. The higher the dilution is, the lower the concentration is, or the weaker the positive sample is. The y-axis (vertical) of the graph shown in Figure 7 is the data evaluation result or the readout value. Each circle shown in the graph represents a result of reading of an LFT. It is obvious from the graph that, the higher the concentration of the positive fluid sample is, the larger the read-out value is, which means easier to perform the reading.

[0066] The dashed line shown in the graph is a cut-off value of Negative Control (NC) of the fluid sample. So, any read-out value below the dashed line is determined as negative according to the present reading method. Figure 7 shows that the reading method according to the present data evaluation process provides accurate and good reading results even for highly diluted samples.

[0067] Figure 8 shows the performance of the reading result corresponding to Figure 7. More specifically, it shows the curves of the sensitivity and specificity of the reading results shown in Figure 7 as a function of the cut-off value of the NC (X-axis) . It can be seen that the performance of the reading method varies according to the different cut-off values of the NC . However, the above performed LFT reading method can achieve 100% sensitivity and specificity, which indicates the good performance of the method including data evaluation .

[0068] Figure 9 illustrates the result of reading a second LFT by a transmissive reading apparatus according to the present invention. Here again, the data evaluation process has been performed, but the signal normalization process is not performed. The curve represented in this figure is different from the one shown in Figure 7, which shows a device-to- device variation.

[0069] Figure 10 shows the performance of the reading result corresponding to Figure 9. It shows that the 100% of sensitivity and specificity can also be achieved, which indicates a good performance. Compared with the performance shown in Figure 8, the two devices have a different cut-off value of NC to achieve the 100% of sensitivity and specificity (1.5 for the first device and -0.5 for the second device) .

[0070] Fig. 8 and 10 show the sensitivity-specificity curves for the first LFT and the second LFT. It can be seen that both the first LFT and the second LFT can achieve 100% of sensitivity and specificity, which indicates a good performance of the present LFT reading method with data evaluation. Note that the two LFTs have different cut-off values to achieve 100% of sensitivity and specificity (1.5 for Devi and -0.5 for Dev2 ) due to device-to-device variation.

[0071] The LFT reading apparatus according to the present invention allows combination with a multispectral photodetector and can accordingly be used for reading multiplex assays to detect multiple targets.

[0072] Figure 11 illustrates the results of reading the first LFT and the second LFT simultaneously by a transmissive reading apparatus according to the present invention. Here, both data evaluation and data normalization are performed. In the same graph of Figure 11, two curves formed by circles are presented. The two curves represent the results of reading the first LFT and the second LFT, respectively. By applying the present reading method, and more specifically the normalization approach according to the present method, the two curves are close, i.e. the difference between the two apparatus is not significant. The overall sensitivity and specificity of the above reading results are 96% and 100%, respectively, as seen in figure 12.

[0073] Similarly, Figure 13 shows, in the same graph, two curves representing the results of reading a first LFT and a second LFT by a transmissive reading apparatus according to the present invention. However, data normalization is not performed. Compared to the two curves shown in Figure 11, the two curves without the current normalization process are farther apart from each other. The device-to-device variation brings down the overall performance. The overall sensitivity and specificity without the present normalization are both 90% as shown in Figure 14, which are significantly lower than the sensitivity and speci ficity got based on the present normali zation .

[0074] The comparison shows that the invented normali zation process can strongly reduce the device-to-device variation in terms of performance . The signals of the two photodetectors are normali zed to compensate for di f ferences in their optical detection pathway by using the signal during the initial phase of the assay' s liquid flow . The normali zation approach can reduce the device-to-device variation without requiring LED / photodetector calibration .

[0075] Similarly, Figure 15 illustrates the result of reading a LET by prior art reflective reading apparatuses without the data normali zation and data evaluation approach according to the present invention, and 16 shows the performance of the corresponding reading results . Figure 17 illustrates the result of reading a LET by using the method according to the present invention including the data normali zation and data evaluation approach, and Figure 18 shows the performance of the corresponding reading results . By comparing these four figures , it is concluded that using the reflective reading apparatus according to the present invention can also strongly outperform a LET reading using a prior art reflective reading apparatus . It also confirms that the invented normali zation approach can strongly reduce the device-to-device variation .

[0076] Fig . 21 and 22 show the results of reading a LET by using a reflective LET reading apparatus according to the present invention including data normali zation and data evaluation approach . This result strongly outperforms the result obtained by using the dry-white algorithm for normali zation, as shown in Fig . 19 and 20 . It is confirmed that the invented normali zation algorithm can strongly reduce the device-to- device variation . In addition, the dry-white calibration approach can only be used for colorimetric assays , but not for fluorescence-based assays since the excitation wavelength is typically not visible to the photodetector . The present invention is applicable to both colorimetric and fluorescence-based assays .

[0077] Intra-device and inter-device calibration of the optical detection pathway is typically required to keep the result variation of LFT measurements as low as possible . I f the result variations between devices are low, the cut-of f value to discriminate between positive and negative samples can be set more precisely and the performance of the technology ( as measured by sensitivity and speci ficity) increases . The LFT reading method disclosed here enables inter- and intra-device calibration "on the fly" , which means during each measurement and without the need for initial calibration ef forts at the end of LFT device production as well as without the need for re-calibration after certain time intervals .

[0078] The present reading method can be executed "on-the- fly" during the measurements , which saves the costs and ef forts by omitting the need for initial device calibration after production as well as later re-calibration during the use cycle . There is no initial calibration required for corresponding devices to compensate , for example , di f ferences in the light source intensity or the photodetector sensitivity . The algorithm is highly robust over time , while classical calibration typically requires repetition after a certain time period to compensate for changes ( e . g . , from component aging) . The acquired data is stored in the device and be trans ferred to a processor contained in a mobile / PC / cloud via USB connection or Bluetooth to be processed .

[0079] It will be appreciated that the disclosure is not limited to the disclosed embodiments and to what has been particularly shown and described hereinabove . Rather, features recited in separate dependent claims or in the description may advantageously be combined . Furthermore , the scope of the disclosure includes those variations and modi fications , which will be apparent to those skilled in the art and fall within the scope of the appended claims .

[0080] The term " comprising" , insofar it was used in the claims or in the description, does not exclude other elements or steps of a corresponding feature or procedure . In case that the terms " a" or " an" were used in conj unction with features , they do not exclude a plurality of such features . Moreover, any reference signs in the claims should not be construed as limiting the scope .

[0081] References

[0082] I la, 31 optically active tag

[0083] 12a, 12b, 32 the first antibody 13a large analyte

[0084] 13b small analyte

[0085] 33 analytes

[0086] 14a, 34 speci fic antibody

[0087] 15a, 35 the third antibody 16a, 16b, 36 , 41a, 41b test line region

[0088] 37 , 42a, 42b reference line region

[0089] 43a, 43b the first LED

[0090] 44a, 44b the second LED

[0091] 45a, 45b the first photodetector 46a, 46b the second photodetector

Claims

Claims1. An apparatus for reading a lateral flow assay performed on a lateral flow device including a conjugate portion with antibodies labelled with optically active tags, a test line region (41a, 41b) and a reference line region (42a, 42b) , to detect presence of an analyte in a sample, wherein the apparatus comprises: a first light source (43a, 43b) for emitting a first light towards the test line region (41a, 41b) ; a second light source (44a, 44b) for emitting a second light towards the reference line region (42a, 42b) ; a photodetector (45a, 46a, 45b, 46b) for receiving a first signal emitted from the test line region (41a, 41b) and / or a second signal emitted from the reference line region (42a, 42b) ; and a processor for evaluating a result of the reading based on the first signal in a predetermined first signal stable flow phase and the second signal in a predetermined second signal stable flow phase, wherein the first signal stable flow phase begins after a predetermined number of consecutive first derivatives of the first signal-time curve are within a first predetermined threshold, the second signal stable flow phase begins after a predetermined number of consecutive first derivatives of the second signal-time curve are within a second predetermined threshold .

2. The apparatus according to claim 1, wherein evaluating the result of the reading includes calculating a valuer:wherein S-^ is the first signal , S2iis the second signal , i is the data point , i E [1,N] , i = M is a starting point of the stable flow phase ; and comparing v to a cut-of f value of Negative Control (NC ) of the sample .3 . The apparatus according to claim 1 or 2 , the predetermined number is at least 5 .4 . The apparatus according to any of claims 1 to 3 , before performing the evaluation, the processor performs normali zing the first signal based on an average of the first signal value over a predetermined first signal initial flow phase and normali zing the second signal based on an average of the second signal value over a predetermined second signal initial flow phase , wherein the evaluation is performed on the normali zed first signal in the predetermined first signal stable phase and the normali zed second signal in the predetermined second signal stable phase .5 . The apparatus according to claim 4 , wherein the first signal has a maximum value of a first derivate at a starting point of the predetermined first signal initial flow phase and at an ending point of the predetermined first signal initial flow phase , the first signal is less than a predetermined percentage of a peak of the first signal and a first derivative of the first signal is above a first predetermined threshold, wherein the second signal has a maximum value of a first derivate at a starting point of the predetermined second signal initial flow phase and at an ending point of the predetermined second signal initial flow phase , the secondsignal is less than the predetermined percentage of a peak of the second signal and a first derivative of the second signal is above a second predetermined threshold.

6. The apparatus according to claim 4 or 5, the first signal and the second signal are normalized as:Wherein Sltis the first signal, S2iis the second signal, i is the data point, i E [1,7V], the predetermined first signal initial flow phase and the predetermined second signal initial flow phase are between data points i G [P,Q], a and p are scaling factors intended to get a final cut-off value that is not arbitrary.

7. The apparatus according to claim 6, wherein evaluating the result of the reading includes calculating a value vwherein Sltis the first signal, S2iis the second signal, i is the data point, i E [1,7V], i = M is the starting point of the stable flow phase; and comparing v to a cut-off value of Negative Control (NC) of the liquid sample.

8. The apparatus according to any of the preceding claims, wherein the optically active tags are fluorescent label or light absorption signal.9 . The apparatus according to claim 9 , wherein the fluorescent is TG fluorescent .10 . The apparatus according to any of the preceding claims , the first signal or the second signal is the number of photons received by the photodetector .11 . A method for reading a lateral flow test , comprising : applying a sample to a lateral flow device so that the sample flows on the lateral flow device from a conj ugate portion with antibodies labelled with optically active tags , a test line region ( 41a, 41b ) and a reference line region ( 42a,42b ) , sequentially; emitting a first light towards the test line region ( 41a, 41b ) and a second light towards the reference line region ( 42a, 42b ) ; receiving a first signal emitted from the test line region ( 41a, 41b ) and a second signal emitted from the reference line region ( 42a, 42b ) ; evaluating a result of the reading based on the first signal in a predetermined first signal stable flow phase and the second signal in a predetermined second signal stable flow phase , wherein the first signal stable flow phase begins after a predetermined number of consecutive first derivatives of the first signal-time curve are within a first predetermined threshold, the second signal stable flow phase begins after a predetermined number of consecutive first derivatives of the second signal-time curve are within a second predetermined threshold .12 . The method according to claim 11 , wherein before performing the evaluation, the method comprises normali zingthe first signal based on an average of the first signal value over a predetermined first signal initial flow phase and normalizing the second signal based on an average of the second signal value over a predetermined second signal initial flow phase, wherein the evaluation is performed on the normalized first signal in the predetermined first signal stable phase and the normalized second signal in the predetermined second signal stable phase.

13. The method according to claim 12, comprising: emitting the first light towards the test line region (41a, 41b) for a first period of time and then turned off the first light, receiving the first signal emitted from the test line region (41a, 41b) for a second period of time, and then stopping the receiving, emitting the second light towards the test line region (42a, 42b) for a third period of time and then turning off the second light, and receiving the second signal emitted from the test line region (41a, 41b) for a fourth period of time, sequentially.

14. The method according to claim 13, further comprising waiting for a fifth period of time between the turning off of the first light and the receiving of the first signal.

15. The method according to claim 13 or 14, further comprising waiting for a sixth period of time between the turning off of the second light and the receiving of the second signal.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Device and method for performing a diagnostic test

    US20180356407A1

  • Interactive test device and apparatus with timing mechanism

    US20210293793A1

  • Assay devices and methods

    US20080213875A1

  • Integrated point-of-care cartridge assay system

    US20190317115A1

  • Methods and apparatus for sample analysis using lateral flow

    US20210156855A1