Simulation system, operation determination device, operation determination method, and program

The simulation system addresses the challenge of distinguishing between routine and non-routine work times by using a comprehensive approach that includes data acquisition and comparison, enhancing prediction accuracy and efficiency in production line simulations.

WO2024241736A1PCT designated stage expired Publication Date: 2024-11-28MITSUBISHI ELECTRIC CORP
View PDF 2 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/JP2024/014329
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2023-05-23
Filing Date
2024-04-08
Publication Date
2024-11-28

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Current production line simulation systems face challenges in accurately distinguishing between routine and non-routine work times, leading to decreased prediction accuracy due to the difficulty in separating and setting work times for these categories, resulting in errors and inefficiencies.

Method used

A simulation system that includes a first operation input section for generating a production line model, a simulation execution section for simulating the production line behavior, a textbook data generation section for creating time charts of routine work, a measurement data acquisition section for collecting data from tagged resources, a coordinate estimation section for determining resource coordinates, and a comparison calculation section for determining whether work is routine or non-routine by comparing textbook and performance data.

Benefits of technology

The system efficiently determines whether work performed in each process is routine or non-routine by comparing time charts, improving the accuracy of work time settings and enhancing the prediction accuracy of production line simulations.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure JP2024014329_28112024_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure JP2024014329_28112024_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

A simulation system (100) comprises: an operation input unit (12) that generates a model of a production line; a simulation execution unit (13) that simulates the behavior of the production line and generates simulation result information; a handbook data generation unit (24) that generates handbook data on the basis of handbook data generation condition information and the simulation result information; a measurement data acquisition unit (25) that acquires measurement data obtained by measuring a radio wave received from a tag provided to each resource; a coordinate estimation unit (26) that generates coordinate data indicating the coordinates of each resource; a performance data generation unit (27) that generates performance data on the basis of performance data generation condition information and the coordinate data; and a comparison calculation unit (28) that compares the handbook data and the performance data to determine whether an operation indicated by the performance data is a regular operation or an irregular operation, and that outputs determination result information.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Simulation system, work determination device, work determination method, and program

[0001] The present disclosure relates to a simulation system, an operation determination device, an operation determination method, and a program.

[0002] When designing production lines in the manufacturing industry, the behavior of the production line is simulated to calculate output, utilization rate, etc. before the production line is launched. Since it is difficult to anticipate complex manufacturing conditions and branching factors manually, simulators that can register and calculate manufacturing conditions and branching factors have appeared in recent years. The simulator sets the characteristics of the work for the processes that make up the production line and runs a simulation. One of the characteristics of the work is the work time.

[0003] For example, Patent Document 1 discloses a process orchestration device that includes a work sequence candidate generation means that generates work sequence candidates in which tasks are arranged in order in accordance with work constraints related to the order scheduled between specific tasks; a process candidate generation means that generates process candidates made up of process groups in which tasks are divided according to the work sequence candidates and arranged in order so that the required times for the task groups fall within the scheduled takt time; a process evaluation means that calculates an evaluation value for the process candidates using a predetermined index; and a process presentation means that presents process candidates whose evaluation value is within a predetermined range as appropriate process candidates.

[0004] Japanese Patent Application Laid-Open No. 2021-170240

[0005] However, the technology described in Patent Document 1 does not distinguish between the work time of essential routine tasks that occur every time in a process and the non-routine work that occurs under specific conditions when evaluating a process. Failure to set the work time for each routine and non-routine task in a process reduces the prediction accuracy of the production line simulation. Setting the work time for each routine and non-routine task based on work performance requires a human to, for example, watch video footage of the manufacturing site and manually determine whether the work performed in the process is routine or non-routine, which takes an enormous amount of time. This results in a problem of a small parameter set of data used to set work times, resulting in errors relative to the true value.

[0006] The present disclosure has been made to solve the above-mentioned problems, and aims to make it possible to efficiently determine whether work performed in a production line process is routine work or non-routine work.

[0007] To achieve the above object, the simulation system according to the present disclosure includes a first operation input unit, a simulation execution unit, a textbook data generation unit, a measurement data acquisition unit, a coordinate estimation unit, a performance data generation unit, and a comparison calculation unit. The first operation input unit accepts production line modeling operations and generates a production line model. The simulation execution unit simulates the behavior of the production line based on the production line model and generates simulation result information indicating the simulation results. The textbook data generation unit generates textbook data, which is a time chart of each resource present in a zone from the start to the end of one work piece serving as a textbook for the routine work of each process, based on textbook data generation condition information and simulation result information, including information indicating the start and end times of one work piece serving as a textbook for the routine work of each process on the production line and information indicating the zone, which is the area required for the work piece of each process. The measurement data acquisition unit acquires measurement data obtained by measuring radio waves received from tags attached to each resource by a tag reader installed at a production site having the resources. The coordinate estimation unit estimates the coordinates of each resource based on the measurement data and generates coordinate data indicating the coordinates of each resource. The performance data generation unit generates performance data, which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone during the time from the start to the end of work for one workpiece in each process, based on performance data generation condition information indicating conditions that define the work for one workpiece from start to finish in each process and the coordinate data. The comparison calculation unit compares the textbook data with the performance data to determine whether the work indicated by the performance data is regular work or non-regular work, and outputs determination result information indicating the determination result.

[0008] According to the present disclosure, by comparing textbook data, which is a time chart of each resource present in a zone from the start to the end of work for one workpiece that serves as a textbook for routine work in each process on a production line based on simulation results, with actual data, which is a time chart of each resource present in a zone from the start to the end of work for one workpiece in each process at the production site, it is automatically determined whether the work indicated by the actual data is routine work or non-routine work, and judgment result information indicating the judgment result is output, making it possible to efficiently determine whether the work performed in each process is routine work or non-routine work.

[0009] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of the configuration of a simulation system according to the first embodiment. FIG. 2 is a diagram showing an example of work result information according to the first embodiment. FIG. 3 is a diagram showing an example of three-dimensional data according to the first embodiment. FIG. 4 is a diagram showing an example of a manufacturing site in which tags are assigned to resources according to the first embodiment. FIG. 5 is a diagram showing an example of a setting screen for setting the start and end times of work for one workpiece to be used as a textbook for routine work according to the first embodiment. FIG. 6 is a diagram showing an example of a setting screen for setting the area required for work for one workpiece according to the first embodiment. FIG. 7 is a diagram showing an example of textbook data according to the first embodiment. FIG. 8 is a diagram showing an example of a measurement time chart according to the first embodiment. FIG. 9 is a diagram showing an example of performance data according to the first embodiment. Flowchart showing an example of the operation of textbook data generation processing according to the first embodiment. Flowchart showing an example of the operation of work judgment processing according to the first embodiment. FIG. 10 is a diagram showing an example of the configuration of a simulation system according to the second embodiment. FIG. 11 is a diagram showing an example of the hardware configuration of a simulation device and a work judgment device according to the first and second embodiments.

[0010] A simulation system, an operation determination device, an operation determination method, and a program according to the present embodiment will be described in detail below with reference to the drawings. Note that identical or corresponding parts in the drawings are designated by the same reference numerals. In the following embodiment, an example will be described in which the work time for each process on a product production line is separated into work time for regular work and work time for non-regular work. Hereinafter, workers on a product production line, work-in-progress items that are the subject of work in a process, tools, materials, AGVs (Automatic Guided Vehicles), and the like will be collectively referred to as resources.

[0011] (Embodiment 1) The configuration of a simulation system 100 according to embodiment 1 will be described with reference to Fig. 1. The simulation system 100 includes a simulation device 1 that simulates the behavior of a production line, and an operation determination device 2 that determines whether the operation actually performed at each process on the production line is a regular operation or a non-regular operation, based on textbook data on the regular operation at each process.

[0012] The simulation device 1 includes a storage unit 11 that stores various types of information, an operation input unit 12 that accepts modeling operations for the production line, a simulation execution unit 13 that simulates the behavior of the production line, and a communication unit 14 that transmits and receives information to and from the work judgment device 2. The operation input unit 12 is an example of a first operation input unit.

[0013] The storage unit 11 includes a simulation condition storage unit 111 that stores simulation condition information indicating conditions for executing a simulation, and a simulation result storage unit 112 that stores simulation result information indicating the results of the simulation.

[0014] The operation input unit 12 generates an operation screen for accepting modeling operations for the production line based on a library of objects such as workers, workpieces, tools, components, and AGVs, processes that make up the production line, and tasks in each process, which are included in the simulation condition information stored in the simulation condition storage unit 111. Workpieces are objects to be processed or assembled in a process. Modeling operations for the production line include arranging objects on the production line, setting process routes for workpieces, components, etc., and setting tasks in each process. The operation input unit 12 outputs the generated operation screen. The operation screen may be output by displaying it on the screen or by sending it to a user terminal used by the user. In the latter case, the user terminal outputs the operation screen, and the operation input unit 12 receives information indicating the modeling operations input on the operation screen from the user terminal.

[0015] The operation input unit 12 generates a model of the production line in accordance with the modeling operations input on the operation screen, and sends the generated model of the production line to the simulation execution unit 13.

[0016] The simulation execution unit 13 simulates the behavior of the production line based on the production line model received from the operation input unit 12. Specifically, the simulation execution unit 13 simulates the behavior of the production line based on work time information indicating the work time required for one workpiece in each process, travel time information indicating the travel time between processes, and the like, which are included in the simulation condition information stored in the simulation condition storage unit 111, and outputs the output of each task, the travel routes of people and objects, the operating rate, and the like as simulation results. The simulation execution unit 13 stores simulation result information indicating the simulation results and the production line model in the simulation result storage unit 112.

[0017] The simulation result information includes work result information that indicates the work results for each process. The work result information is, for example, a Gantt chart that indicates the work results for each process, as shown in FIG. 2. The example in FIG. 2 is a Gantt chart that indicates the work results of worker W09 and AGV01 in process A, the work results of worker W10 and AGV02 in process B, the work results of worker W11 and AGV03 in process C, and the work results of worker W12 and AGV04 in process D. The work result information is not limited to information that indicates the work results of workers and AGVs, but may be information that indicates the work results of only workers, or may be information that includes the work results of other resources.

[0018] The production line model includes three-dimensional data that represents the production line in three dimensions. The three-dimensional data is, for example, a three-dimensional model of the production line in which objects are arranged in a digital space, as shown in FIG.

[0019] The communication unit 14 transmits the simulation result information and the production line model stored in the simulation result storage unit 112 to the work determination device 2.

[0020] A manufacturing site where an actual production line exists will now be described with reference to FIG. 4 . At the manufacturing site, each resource is assigned a tag, and a tag reader is installed to receive radio waves emitted by the tag. The tags are, for example, radio frequency (RF) tags. In the example of FIG. 4 , tags are assigned to AGVs, tools, and workers, and a tag reader receives radio waves emitted by each tag. Multiple tag readers may be used. Tags are assigned to all resources at the manufacturing site, not just AGVs, tools, and workers. The tag reader measures the radio waves received from the tags assigned to each resource and transmits measurement data to the work judgment device 2. The measurement data includes, for example, the radio wave reception strength, incident angle, phase, and reception time.

[0021] 1 , the work judgment device 2 includes a memory unit 21 that stores various information, a communication unit 22 that sends and receives information to and from the simulation device 1, an operation input unit 23 that accepts setting operations to set conditions for generating textbook data for one unit of routine work in each process, a textbook data generation unit 24 that generates textbook data, a measurement data acquisition unit 25 that acquires measurement data, a coordinate estimation unit 26 that estimates the coordinates of each resource based on the measurement data and generates coordinate data indicating the coordinates of each resource, a performance data generation unit 27 that generates performance data indicating the performance of work for one unit of work in each process based on the coordinate data, and a comparison calculation unit 28 that compares the textbook data with the performance data to determine whether the work indicated by the performance data is routine work or non-routine work. The operation input unit 23 is an example of a second operation input unit.

[0022] The memory unit 21 includes a data generation condition memory unit 211 that stores textbook data generation condition information indicating the conditions for generating textbook data and performance data generation condition information indicating the conditions for generating performance data, a textbook data memory unit 212 that stores textbook data, a coordinate data memory unit 213 that stores coordinate data, and a performance data memory unit 214 that stores performance data.

[0023] The communication unit 22 stores the simulation result information and the production line model received from the simulation device 1 in the data generation condition storage unit 211 of the storage unit 21 .

[0024] The operation input unit 23 displays the work result information included in the simulation result information stored in the data generation condition storage unit 211 and the three-dimensional data included in the production line model, and generates a setting screen that accepts setting operations for setting conditions for generating textbook data. The operation input unit 23 outputs the generated setting screen. The setting screen may be output by displaying it on the screen or by transmitting it to a user terminal used by the user. In the latter case, the user terminal outputs the setting screen, and the operation input unit 23 receives information indicating the setting operations input on the setting screen from the user terminal.

[0025] The operation input unit 23 generates textbook data generation condition information indicating the conditions for generating textbook data in accordance with the setting operations input on the setting screen. The operation input unit 23 stores the textbook data generation condition information in the data generation condition storage unit 211. The textbook data generation condition information includes information indicating the start and end points of work for one workpiece that serves as a textbook for the routine work of each process, and information indicating the area required for work on one workpiece in each process. Hereinafter, the area required for work on one workpiece will be referred to as a zone.

[0026] The setting screen output by the operation input unit 23 will now be described with reference to FIGS. 5 and 6. The example setting screen shown in FIG. 5 displays a Gantt chart showing the work results for each process, which is the example of the work result information shown in FIG. 2. For the work in process A, the start and end times of the work for one workpiece to be used as a textbook for routine work in sections (1) to (4) are set. The start and end times can be set, for example, by clicking once on the Gantt chart displayed on the setting screen to set the start time, or by double-clicking to set the end time. The operation input unit 23 generates textbook data generation condition information indicating the start and end times of the work for one workpiece to be used as a textbook for routine work in accordance with the setting operations entered on the setting screen, and stores the information in the data generation condition storage unit 211. The setting screen is not limited to the example shown in FIG. 5; it may be any screen that allows the user to set the start and end times of the work for one workpiece to be used as a textbook for routine work. Furthermore, the number of sections for which the start and end times of the work for one workpiece to be used as a textbook for routine work are set is not limited to four, and may be one or more.

[0027] The example setting screen shown in FIG. 6 displays a 3D model of a production line, which is the example of 3D data shown in FIG. 3, and zone Z for process A is being set. For example, a method of setting a zone is to click an object on the 3D model of the production line displayed on the setting screen, thereby setting a rectangular parallelepiped zone of a predetermined size centered on the object. Alternatively, the user may set the size of the zone by dragging and deforming the vertices of the rectangular parallelepiped. The operation input unit 23 generates textbook data generation condition information indicating the coordinates of the zone on the 3D model of the production line in accordance with the setting operations input on the setting screen, and stores the information in the data generation condition storage unit 211. The setting screen is not limited to the example shown in FIG. 6; any screen that allows the user to set the zone for each process may be used.

[0028] Returning to Figure 1, the textbook data generator 24 generates textbook data based on the simulation result information and textbook data generation condition information stored in the data generation condition storage unit 211. The textbook data is a time chart of each resource present in a zone from the start to the end of work on one workpiece, which serves as a textbook for routine work in each process. Hereinafter, the time from the start to the end of work on one workpiece will be referred to as the work time for one workpiece.

[0029] The textbook data will be explained using FIG. 7. FIG. 7 shows a time chart of each resource present in the zone of process A during the work time for one workpiece, which serves as a textbook for the routine work set in section (3) of FIG. 5. In the example of FIG. 7, in process A, worker W09, workpiece, tool T1, member P1, and AGV01 are present in the zone during the work time for one workpiece. The textbook data generation unit 24 stores the time chart shown in FIG. 7 in the data generation condition storage unit 211 as textbook data showing the routine work for one workpiece in section (3) of process A.

[0030] 1 , the measurement data acquisition unit 25 acquires the above-mentioned measurement data from a tag reader (not shown) installed at the manufacturing site where the actual production line exists. The measurement data acquisition unit 25 sends the acquired measurement data to the coordinate estimation unit 26.

[0031] The coordinate estimation unit 26 estimates the coordinates of each resource based on the measurement data received from the measurement data acquisition unit 25, and generates coordinate data indicating the coordinates of each resource. The method of estimating the coordinates of each resource involves, for example, inferring the context using the reception strength, incident angle, phase, and reception time of radio waves from tags included in the measurement data. The coordinate data is data indicating the coordinates of each resource from the start of measurement by the tag reader to the end of measurement. The time from the start of measurement by the tag reader to the end of measurement is, for example, the time during which the production line is operating in one day. Hereinafter, the time from the start of measurement to the end of measurement is referred to as the measurement time. The coordinate estimation unit 26 sends the generated coordinate data to the performance data generation unit 27.

[0032] Based on the coordinate data received from the coordinate estimation unit 26, the performance data generation unit 27 determines whether the coordinates of each resource are included in the coordinate space of the zone of each process, and generates a time chart for each resource present in the zone of each process at the time measured by the tag reader. Hereinafter, the time chart for each resource present in the zone of each process at the time measured by the tag reader is referred to as a measured time chart. Based on the performance data generation condition information stored in the data generation condition storage unit 211, the performance data generation unit 27 extracts the work time for one workpiece from the measured time chart and generates performance data indicating the results of work for one workpiece in each process. The conditions for generating performance data indicated by the performance data generation condition information are conditions that specify the work from start to finish for one workpiece in each process, such as determining that work starts when the workpiece enters the zone and ends when the workpiece leaves the zone.

[0033] The measurement time chart and performance data will now be described with reference to FIGS. 8 and 9. FIG. 8 shows the measurement time chart for process A. In the example of FIG. 8, the performance data generation unit 27 extracts the work time for one workpiece in sections (5) to (8) from the measurement time chart for process A based on the performance data generation condition information, and generates performance data indicating the performance of the work for one workpiece in process A. FIG. 9 shows the performance data for process A. The example of FIG. 9 is a time chart of each resource present in the zone of process A during the work time for one workpiece extracted in section (7) of FIG. 8.

[0034] Returning to FIG. 1 , the comparison calculation unit 28 compares the textbook data with the performance data to determine whether the work indicated by the performance data is routine or non-routine. At this time, if there are multiple intervals of the textbook data and multiple intervals of the performance data, the comparison calculation unit 28 may compare the textbook data and performance data for corresponding intervals. The comparison calculation unit 28 compares the time chart of the textbook data with the time chart of the performance data to calculate the similarity. If the similarity exceeds a threshold, the comparison calculation unit 28 determines that the work for one workpiece indicated by the performance data is routine. If the similarity does not exceed the threshold, the comparison calculation unit 28 determines that the work for one workpiece indicated by the performance data is non-routine. The threshold for determining similarity may be set in advance or may be set by the user.

[0035] If the comparison calculation unit 28 determines that the work is steady, it outputs steady-state determination result information, which sets the work time for one workpiece in the time chart of the performance data as the work time for the steady work. The steady-state determination result information may be output by screen display, transmission to a user terminal, or printing. When the steady-state determination result information is output, the user accumulates the steady-state determination result information, and sets information indicating the average value of the work time for one workpiece in the time chart of the performance data included in the steady-state determination result information as the work time information for the steady work, thereby updating the work time information stored in the simulation condition storage unit 111. As a result, the more steady-state determination result information there is, the higher the accuracy of the work time for the steady work used in the simulation. If the comparison calculation unit 28 determines that the work is non-steady, it outputs non-steady-state determination result information, along with the measurement time chart, which sets the work time for one workpiece in the time chart of the performance data as the work time for the non-steady work. The user determines the work time of the non-steady work based on the output measurement time chart and the work time during which the non-steady work was performed, which is indicated by the non-steady work determination result information, and adds the work time information of the non-steady work, which indicates the work time of the non-steady work, to the work time information stored in the simulation condition storage unit 111. The steady work determination result information and the non-steady work determination result information are examples of determination result information.

[0036] For example, when the comparison calculation unit 28 compares the time chart of the textbook data shown in Fig. 7 with the time chart of the textbook data shown in Fig. 9, the degree of similarity does not exceed a threshold, and so the comparison calculation unit 28 determines that the work is non-steady-state work. The comparison calculation unit 28 outputs non-steady-state determination result information, which sets the work time for one workpiece shown in Figs. 7 and 9 as the work time during which the non-steady-state work was performed, together with the measured time chart shown in Fig. 8. Based on the measured time chart shown in Fig. 8 and the work time for one workpiece shown in Figs. 7 and 9 indicated by the non-steady-state determination result information, the user determines that the work time for the non-steady-state work is, for example, the time in section (9) shown in Fig. 8, and adds the work time information for the non-steady-state work indicating the time in section (9) to the work time information stored in the simulation condition storage unit 111.

[0037] The flow of the textbook data generation process executed by the task determination device 2 will now be described with reference to Fig. 10. The textbook data generation process shown in Fig. 10 starts when the task determination device 2 is powered on.

[0038] If the communication unit 22 of the work judgment device 2 does not receive the simulation result information and the production line model from the simulation device 1 (step S11; NO), the processing proceeds to step S16. If the communication unit 22 receives the simulation result information and the production line model from the simulation device 1 (step S11; YES), the communication unit 22 stores the simulation result information and the production line model in the data generation condition memory unit 211 of the memory unit 21.

[0039] The operation input unit 23 displays the work result information included in the simulation result information stored in the data generation condition storage unit 211 and the three-dimensional data included in the production line model, and generates a setting screen for accepting setting operations for setting conditions for generating textbook data (step S12). The operation input unit 23 outputs the generated setting screen (step S13). The operation input unit 23 generates textbook data generation condition information indicating conditions for generating textbook data in accordance with the setting operations input on the setting screen (step S14). The operation input unit 23 stores the textbook data generation condition information in the data generation condition storage unit 211. The textbook data generation condition information includes information indicating the start and end points of work for one workpiece serving as a textbook for routine work in each process, and information indicating the zone of each process.

[0040] In the example of the setting screen shown in FIG. 5, a Gantt chart showing the work results for each process, which is an example of the work result information shown in FIG. 2, is displayed, and for the work of process A, the start and end times of work for one workpiece, which will be used as a textbook for the regular work of sections (1) to (4), are set.

[0041] In the example of the setting screen shown in FIG. 6, a three-dimensional model of the production line, which is the example of the three-dimensional data shown in FIG. 3, is displayed, and zone Z of process A is set.

[0042] 10, the textbook data generator 24 generates textbook data (step S15) based on the simulation result information and the textbook data generation condition information stored in the data generation condition storage unit 211. The textbook data is a time chart of each resource present in a zone during the work time for one workpiece, which serves as a textbook for routine work in each process.

[0043] The example of textbook data shown in Fig. 7 is a time chart of each resource present in the zone of process A during the work time for one workpiece, which is the textbook for the routine work set in section (3) in Fig. 5. In the example of Fig. 7, in process A, worker W09, workpiece, tool T1, member P1, and AGV01 are present in the zone during the work time for one workpiece.

[0044] 10, if the power supply of the work determination device 2 is not turned off (step S16; NO), the process returns to step S11 and steps S11 to S16 are repeated. If the power supply is turned off (step S16; YES), the process ends.

[0045] Next, the flow of the work determination process executed by the work determination device 2 will be described using Figure 11. The work determination process shown in Figure 11 starts when the work determination device 2 is powered on. If the measurement data acquisition unit 25 of the work determination device 2 does not acquire measurement data from a tag reader located at the manufacturing site where the actual production line is located (step S21: NO), the process proceeds to step S31. If measurement data has been acquired (step S21: YES), the measurement data acquisition unit 25 sends the acquired measurement data to the coordinate estimation unit 26. The coordinate estimation unit 26 estimates the coordinates of each resource based on the measurement data received from the measurement data acquisition unit 25 and generates coordinate data indicating the coordinates of each resource (step S22). The coordinate estimation unit 26 sends the generated coordinate data to the performance data generation unit 27.

[0046] Based on the coordinate data received from the coordinate estimation unit 26, the performance data generation unit 27 determines whether the coordinates of each resource are included in the coordinate space of the zone for each process, and generates a measured time chart (step S23). Based on the performance data generation condition information, the performance data generation unit 27 extracts the work time for one workpiece from the measured time chart, and generates performance data showing the work results for one workpiece in each process (step S24). The performance data is a time chart of each resource present in the zone during the work time for one workpiece in each process.

[0047] In the example of the measured time chart shown in Fig. 8, the performance data generating unit 27 extracts the work time for one workpiece in sections (5) to (8) from the measured time chart based on the performance data generation condition information, and generates performance data indicating the results of the work for one workpiece in process A. The example of performance data shown in Fig. 9 shows a time chart of each resource present in the zone of process A during the work time for one workpiece extracted in section (7) of Fig. 8.

[0048] 11 , the comparison calculation unit 28 compares the time chart of the textbook data with the time chart of the performance data to calculate the similarity (step S25). If the similarity exceeds the threshold (step S26; YES), the comparison calculation unit 28 determines that the work for one workpiece indicated by the performance data is a regular work (step S27). If the similarity does not exceed the threshold (step S26; NO), the comparison calculation unit 28 determines that the work for one workpiece indicated by the performance data is a non-regular work (step S28).

[0049] If it is determined that the work is steady work, the comparison calculation unit 28 outputs steady-state determination result information in which the work time for one workpiece in the time chart of the performance data is set as the work time for steady work (step S29). The user accumulates the steady-state determination result information, and updates the work time information stored in the simulation condition storage unit 111 by using information indicating the average value of the work time for one workpiece in the time chart of the performance data included in the steady-state determination result information as the work time information for steady work.

[0050] If the comparison calculation unit 28 determines that the work is non-steady-state work, it outputs non-steady-state determination result information, which sets the work time for one workpiece in the time chart of the performance data as the work time for which the non-steady-state work was performed, together with the measured time chart (step S30). The user determines the work time for the non-steady-state work based on the output measured time chart and the work time for which the non-steady-state work was performed indicated by the non-steady-state determination result information, and adds the work time information for the non-steady-state work indicating the work time for the non-steady-state work to the work time information stored in the simulation condition storage unit 111.

[0051] In step S25, the comparison calculation unit 28 calculates the similarity between the time chart of the textbook data shown in Figure 7 and the time chart of the textbook data shown in Figure 9. Since the similarity does not exceed the threshold in step S26, it is determined in step S28 that the work is non-steady-state. In step S30, the comparison calculation unit 28 outputs non-steady-state determination result information, which sets the work time for one workpiece shown in Figures 7 and 9 as the work time for which non-steady-state work was performed, together with the measured time chart shown in Figure 8. Based on the measured time chart shown in Figure 8 and the work time for one workpiece shown in Figures 7 and 9 indicated by the non-steady-state determination result information, the user determines that the work time for the non-steady-state work is, for example, the time of section (9) shown in Figure 8, and adds information indicating the time of section (9) to the work time information stored in the simulation condition storage unit 111 as work time information for the non-steady-state work.

[0052] 11, if the power of the work determination device 2 is not turned off (step S31; NO), the process returns to step S21 and steps S21 to S31 are repeated. If the power is turned off (step S31; YES), the process ends.

[0053] According to the simulation system 100 of the first embodiment, by comparing textbook data, which is a time chart of each resource present in a zone during the work time for one workpiece, which is used as a textbook for routine work in each process on the production line based on the simulation results, with actual data, which is a time chart of each resource present in a zone during the work time for one workpiece in each process at the production site, it is automatically determined whether the work indicated by the actual data is routine work or non-routine work, and judgment result information indicating the judgment result is output, thereby making it possible to efficiently determine whether the work performed in each process is routine work or non-routine work.

[0054] (Embodiment 2) In the simulation system 100 of embodiment 1, if the work for one workpiece indicated by the performance data is determined to be regular work, the user accumulates regular determination result information, and uses information indicating the average value of the work time for one workpiece in the time chart of the performance data included in the regular determination result information as the work time information for the regular work, thereby updating the work time information stored in the simulation condition storage unit 111. On the other hand, if the work for one workpiece indicated by the performance data is determined to be non-regular work, the user determines the work time of the non-regular work based on the output measurement time chart and the work time for the non-regular work indicated by the non-regular determination result information, and adds the non-regular work work time information indicating the work time of the non-regular work to the work time information stored in the simulation condition storage unit 111. In embodiment 2, these processes are performed within the simulation system 100.

[0055] A simulation system 100 according to the second embodiment will be described with reference to Fig. 12. In the simulation system 100 according to the second embodiment, an update unit 15 is added to the simulation device 1, and the functions of the communication unit 14 of the simulation device 1 and the communication unit 22 and comparison calculation unit 28 of the work judgment device 2 are different.

[0056] When the comparison calculation unit 28 of the work determination device 2 determines that the work for one workpiece indicated by the performance data is steady work, it outputs steady-state determination result information, which sets the work time for one workpiece in the time chart of the performance data as the work time for steady work, to the simulation device 1 via the communication unit 22. When the comparison calculation unit 28 determines that the work is non-steady work, it outputs non-steady-state determination result information, which sets the time in the measurement time chart during which the same resources as in the time chart of the performance data exist consecutively as the work time for non-steady work, to the simulation device 1 via the communication unit 22.

[0057] When the communication unit 14 of the simulation device 1 receives steady-state determination result information from the work judgment device 2, it sends the information to the update unit 15. The update unit 15 cumulatively stores the steady-state determination result information received from the communication unit 14, and updates the work time information stored in the simulation condition storage unit 111 with information indicating the average value of the work time for one workpiece in the time chart of the performance data included in the steady-state determination result information as work time information for steady work. When the communication unit 14 receives non-steady-state determination result information from the work judgment device 2, it sends the information to the update unit 15. The update unit 15 adds information indicating the work time of non-steady-state work included in the non-steady-state determination result information to the work time information stored in the simulation condition storage unit 111 as work time information for non-steady-state work. Other functions of the simulation device 1 and the work judgment device 2 are the same as those in the first embodiment.

[0058] According to the simulation system 100 of the second embodiment, the work time information used in the simulation of the production line can be automatically separated into work time information for regular work and work time information for non-regular work, thereby further improving efficiency.

[0059] The hardware configuration of the simulation device 1 and the work judgment device 2 will be described using Fig. 13. As shown in Fig. 13, the simulation device 1 and the work judgment device 2 include a temporary storage unit 101, a storage unit 102, a calculation unit 103, an input unit 104, a transmission / reception unit 105, and a display unit 106. The temporary storage unit 101, the storage unit 102, the input unit 104, the transmission / reception unit 105, and the display unit 106 are all connected to the calculation unit 103 via a BUS.

[0060] Calculation unit 103 is, for example, a CPU (Central Processing Unit). In accordance with a control program stored in storage unit 102, calculation unit 103 executes the processes of operation input unit 12, simulation execution unit 13, and update unit 15 of simulation device 1, and operation input unit 23, textbook data generation unit 24, measurement data acquisition unit 25, coordinate estimation unit 26, performance data generation unit 27, and comparison operation unit 28 of task assessment device 2.

[0061] The temporary storage unit 101 is, for example, a random-access memory (RAM). The temporary storage unit 101 loads the control program stored in the storage unit 102 and is used as a work area for the calculation unit 103.

[0062] The storage unit 102 is a non-volatile memory such as a flash memory, a hard disk, a DVD-RAM (Digital Versatile Disc - Random Access Memory), or a DVD-RW (Digital Versatile Disc - Rewritable). The storage unit 102 pre-stores programs for causing the calculation unit 103 to perform the processing of the simulation device 1 and the work judgment device 2, and also supplies data stored by these programs to the calculation unit 103 in accordance with instructions from the calculation unit 103, and stores data supplied from the calculation unit 103. The storage unit 11 of the simulation device 1 and the storage unit 21 of the work judgment device 2 are configured in the storage unit 102.

[0063] The input unit 104 is an interface device that connects input devices such as a keyboard, pointing device, and voice input device to the BUS. Information input by the user is supplied to the calculation unit 103 via the input unit 104. When the operation input unit 12 of the simulation device 1 and the operation input unit 23 of the work judgment device 2 are configured to accept operation input directly from the user, the input unit 104 functions as the operation input unit 12 of the simulation device 1 and the operation input unit 23 of the work judgment device 2.

[0064] The transmitter / receiver 105 is a network termination device or wireless communication device that connects to the network, and a serial interface or LAN (Local Area Network) interface that connects thereto. The transmitter / receiver 105 functions as the communication unit 14 of the simulation apparatus 1 and the communication unit 22 of the work judgment apparatus 2. If the operation input unit 12 of the simulation apparatus 1 and the operation input unit 23 of the work judgment apparatus 2 are configured to receive information indicating modeling operations and setting operations from a user terminal, respectively, the transmitter / receiver 105 functions as the operation input unit 12 of the simulation apparatus 1 and the operation input unit 23 of the work judgment apparatus 2. Furthermore, if the comparison calculation unit 28 of the work judgment apparatus 2 is configured to transmit steady-state determination result information and non-steady-state determination result information to the user terminal, the transmitter / receiver 105 functions as the comparison calculation unit 28.

[0065] The display unit 106 is a display device such as an LCD (Liquid Crystal Display), an organic EL (Electroluminescence) display, etc. When the operation input unit 12 of the simulation apparatus 1 and the operation input unit 23 of the work judgment device 2 are configured to display an operation screen and a setting screen, respectively, the display unit 106 functions as the operation input unit 12 of the simulation apparatus 1 and the operation input unit 23 of the work judgment device 2. When the comparison calculation unit 28 of the work judgment device 2 is configured to display steady-state judgment result information and non-steady-state judgment result information on a screen, the display unit 106 functions as the comparison calculation unit 28.

[0066] The processing of the memory unit 11, operation input unit 12, simulation execution unit 13, communication unit 14 and update unit 15 of the simulation device 1 shown in Figure 1, and the processing of the memory unit 21, communication unit 22, operation input unit 23, textbook data generation unit 24, measurement data acquisition unit 25, coordinate estimation unit 26, performance data generation unit 27 and comparison calculation unit 28 of the work assessment device 2 are executed by a control program using the temporary memory unit 101, calculation unit 103, memory unit 102, input unit 104, transmission / reception unit 105, display unit 106, etc. as resources.

[0067] Furthermore, the above hardware configuration and flowchart are merely examples and can be changed and modified as desired.

[0068] The core components that perform the processing of the simulation device 1 and the work judgment device 2, such as the calculation unit 103, temporary storage unit 101, storage unit 102, input unit 104, transmission / reception unit 105, and display unit 106, can be realized using an ordinary computer system rather than a dedicated system. For example, the computer program for executing the above operations may be stored and distributed on a computer-readable recording medium such as a flexible disk, CD-ROM (Compact Disc - Read Only Memory), or DVD-ROM (Digital Versatile Disc - Read Only Memory), and the simulation device 1 and the work judgment device 2 that perform the above processing may be configured by installing the computer program on a computer. Alternatively, the computer program may be stored in a storage device of a server device on a communication network, such as the Internet, and downloaded by an ordinary computer system to configure the simulation device 1 and the work judgment device 2.

[0069] Furthermore, when the functions of the simulation device 1 and the work judgment device 2 are realized by sharing the functions between an OS (Operating System) and an application program, or by collaboration between an OS and an application program, only the application program portion may be stored in a recording medium or storage device.

[0070] It is also possible to superimpose a computer program on a carrier wave and provide it via a communication network. For example, the computer program may be posted on a bulletin board system (BBS) on the communication network and provided via the communication network. The computer program may then be started and executed under the control of an OS in the same way as other application programs, thereby enabling the above-mentioned processing to be performed.

[0071] In the first and second embodiments described above, the simulation system 100 includes the simulation device 1 and the work judgment device 2 separately, but this is not limiting, and the simulation device 1 and the work judgment device 2 may be realized by a single device.

[0072] In the above-described first embodiment, when the comparison calculation unit 28 of the work judgment device 2 determines that the work for one workpiece indicated by the performance data is non-steady work, it outputs non-steady-state judgment result information, which sets the work time for one workpiece on the time chart of the performance data as the work time during which the non-steady-state work was performed, together with the measured time chart. However, this is not limited to this. For example, when the comparison calculation unit 28 determines that the work for one workpiece indicated by the performance data is non-steady-state work, it may output non-steady-state judgment result information, which sets the work time for one workpiece on the time chart of the performance data as the work time during which the non-steady-state work was performed, together with video data capturing a zone of the work time for one workpiece on the time chart of the performance data and the measured time chart.

[0073] In this case, a camera is placed at the manufacturing site, and video data capturing each process zone is sent to the work assessment device 2. The user checks the video data output by the comparison calculation unit 28 to determine whether the work is routine or non-routine. If the work is determined to be routine, the user updates the work time information stored in the simulation condition storage unit 111 with information indicating the average value of the work time for one workpiece in the time chart of the performance data included in the routine assessment result information as work time information for the routine work. If the work is determined to be non-routine, the user determines the work time for the non-routine work based on the measurement time chart output by the comparison calculation unit 28 and the work time for one workpiece in the time chart of the performance data, and adds the work time information for the non-routine work to the work time information stored in the simulation condition storage unit 111.

[0074] In the first and second embodiments described above, the simulation device 1 includes the storage unit 11, but this is not limiting and the storage unit 11 may be provided by an external device or system. The work determination device 2 includes the storage unit 21, but this is not limiting and the storage unit 21 may be provided by an external device or system.

[0075] In the first and second embodiments described above, the work judgment device 2 includes the operation input unit 23, but this is not limiting, and if the data generation condition storage unit 211 stores textbook data generation condition information in advance, the work judgment device 2 does not need to include the operation input unit 23. In this case, the textbook data generation condition information includes, for example, information indicating the conditions that define the start and end times of work for one workpiece that serves as a textbook for the routine work of each process, and information indicating the conditions that define the zone for each process.

[0076] In the above-described first and second embodiments, the measurement data acquisition unit 25 of the work judgment device 2 acquires measurement data from a tag reader installed at the manufacturing site where the actual production line is located, but this is not limited to this. Positioning data may be acquired from a device or system other than a tag reader, or positioning data may be input from a user.

[0077] In the above first and second embodiments, an example has been described in which the working time of each process in a product production line is separated into working time for regular work and working time for non-regular work. However, this is not limited to this. In any production line that has a process for producing goods at a production site with multiple resources, the working time of the process can be separated into working time for regular work and working time for non-regular work.

[0078] Although the preferred embodiments have been described in detail above, the present invention is not limited to the above-described embodiments, and various modifications and substitutions can be made to the above-described embodiments without departing from the scope of the claims.

[0079] Various aspects of the present disclosure are summarized below as appendices.

[0080] (Supplementary Note 1) A first operation input unit that receives a modeling operation for a production line and generates a model of the production line; a simulation execution unit that simulates the behavior of the production line based on the model of the production line and generates simulation result information that indicates the simulation results; a textbook data generation unit that generates textbook data that is a time chart of each resource present in a zone from the start to the end of one piece of work that is to be used as a textbook for the routine work of each process, based on textbook data generation condition information including information indicating the start and end times of work for one piece of work that is to be used as a textbook for the routine work of each process on the production line and information indicating the zone that is the area required for the work for one piece of work of each process, and the simulation result information; a measurement data acquisition unit that acquires measurement data that measures radio waves received from tags attached to each resource by a tag reader arranged at a production site having the resources; and a coordinate estimation unit that estimates the coordinates of each resource based on the measurement data and generates coordinate data that indicates the coordinates of each resource. a comparison calculation unit that compares the textbook data with the performance data to determine whether the work indicated by the performance data is regular or non-regular, and outputs determination result information that indicates the determination result. (Appendix 2) A simulation system comprising: a performance data generation unit that generates performance data that is a time chart of each resource present in the zone for the time from the start to the end of work for one work in each process, based on the coordinate data and performance data generation condition information that indicates the conditions that define the start to end of work for one work in each process, and a comparison calculation unit that compares the textbook data with the performance data to determine whether the work indicated by the performance data is regular or non-regular, and outputs determination result information that indicates the determination result. (Appendix 2) The simulation system according to Appendices 1, further comprising a second operation input unit that receives a setting operation to set the start and end times of work for one work as a textbook for regular work in each process of the production line and the zone for each process, and generates the textbook data generation condition information.(Supplementary Note 3) The simulation system described in Supplementary Note 1 or 2, wherein the comparison calculation unit calculates a similarity by comparing the time chart of the textbook data with the time chart of the performance data, and if the similarity exceeds a threshold, determines that the work indicated by the performance data is regular work, and if the similarity does not exceed the threshold, determines that the work indicated by the performance data is non-regular work. (Supplementary Note 4) The simulation system described in any of Supplementary Notes 1 to 3, wherein the performance data generation unit generates a measurement time chart, which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone of each process at the measurement time of the tag reader, based on the coordinate data, and generates the performance data by extracting the work time for one work from the measurement time chart based on the textbook data generation condition information; and the comparison calculation unit, when determining that the work indicated by the performance data is regular work, outputs regular determination result information which sets the work time for one work in the time chart of the performance data as the work time for regular work, and when determining that the work indicated by the performance data is non-regular work, outputs non-regular determination result information, together with the measurement time chart, which sets the work time for one work in the time chart of the performance data as the work time for non-regular work.(Supplementary Note 5) The performance data generation unit generates a measurement time chart, which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone of each process at the measurement time of the tag reader, based on the coordinate data, and generates the performance data by extracting the work time for one work from the measurement time chart based on the textbook data generation condition information; the simulation execution unit simulates the behavior of the production line based on simulation condition information including work time information indicating the work time for one work in each process of the production line model; the comparison operation unit, when determining that one work indicated by the performance data is a regular work, outputs regular determination result information that sets the work time for one work in the time chart of the performance data as the work time of the regular work, and when determining that one work indicated by the performance data is a non-regular work, outputs non-regular determination result information that sets the time in the measurement time chart during which the same resource as in the time chart of the performance data is continuously present as the work time of the non-regular work; The simulation system according to any one of appendices 1 to 3, further comprising an update unit that, when the steady-state determination result information is output, cumulatively stores the steady-state determination result information, updates the work time information with information indicating an average value of work times for one time chart of actual data included in the steady-state determination result information as work time information for steady work, and, when the non-steady-state determination result information is output, adds information indicating the work time of non-steady-state work included in the non-steady-state determination result information to the work time information as work time information for non-steady work.(Supplementary Note 6) The simulation system described in any of Supplementary Notes 1 to 3, wherein the performance data generation unit generates a measurement time chart, which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone of each process at the measurement time of the tag reader, based on the coordinate data, and generates the performance data by extracting the work time for one work from the measurement time chart based on the textbook data generation condition information; and the comparison operation unit, when determining that the work indicated by the performance data is regular work, outputs regular determination result information which sets the work time for one work in the time chart of the performance data to the work time of regular work, and when determining that the work indicated by the performance data is non-regular work, outputs non-regular determination result information which sets the work time for one work in the time chart of the performance data to the work time for non-regular work, together with the measurement time chart and video data of the zone during the work time for one work in the time chart of the performance data.(Supplementary Note 7) A textbook data generation unit generates textbook data, which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone from the start to the end of one piece of work to be used as a textbook for routine work in each process, based on textbook data generation condition information including information indicating the start and end times of work for one work piece to be used as a textbook for routine work in each process of the production line and information indicating the zone which is the area required for work for one work piece in each process, and simulation result information indicating the results of a simulation of the behavior of the production line based on a model of the production line; a measurement data acquisition unit acquires measurement data obtained by measuring radio waves received from tags attached to each resource by a tag reader installed at a production site having the resources; a coordinate estimation unit estimates the coordinates of each resource based on the measurement data and generates coordinate data indicating the coordinates of each resource; and a performance data generation unit generates performance data, which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone from the start to the end of work for one work piece in each process, based on performance data generation condition information indicating the conditions that define the start to end of work for one work piece in each process and the coordinate data. a comparison calculation unit that compares the textbook data with the performance data to determine whether the work indicated by the performance data is regular work or non-regular work, and outputs determination result information that indicates the determination result.(Supplementary Note 8) A simulation system executes the steps of: accepting a modeling operation for a production line and generating a model of the production line; simulating the behavior of the production line based on the model of the production line and generating simulation result information showing the simulation results; generating textbook data, which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone from the start to the end of one work piece, which is used as a textbook for the routine work of each process, based on the simulation result information and textbook data generation condition information, which includes information showing the start and end times of work for one work piece, which is used as a textbook for the routine work of each process on the production line, and information showing the zone, which is the area required for work for one work piece of each process; estimating the coordinates of each resource based on measurement data obtained by measuring radio waves received from tags attached to each resource by a tag reader arranged at a production site having the resources, and generating coordinate data showing the coordinates of each resource; generating performance data, which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone from the start to the end of work for one work piece of each process, based on the coordinate data and performance data generation condition information showing the conditions that define the start to end of work for one work piece in each process; comparing the textbook data with the performance data to determine whether the work indicated by the performance data is regular work or non-regular work, and outputting determination result information indicating the determination result.(Supplementary Note 9) A computer includes: a textbook data generation unit that generates textbook data, which is a time chart of each resource present in a zone from the start to the end of one piece of work that is to be used as a textbook for the routine work of each process on the production line, based on textbook data generation condition information including information indicating the start and end times of work for one piece of work that is to be used as a textbook for the routine work of each process and information indicating a zone that is an area required for work for one piece of work in each process, and simulation result information indicating the results of a simulation of the behavior of the production line based on a model of the production line; a coordinate estimation unit that generates coordinate data indicating the coordinates of each resource by estimating the coordinates of each resource based on measurement data obtained by measuring radio waves received from tags attached to each resource by a tag reader arranged at a production site having the resources; a performance data generation unit that generates performance data, which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone from the start to the end of work for one piece of work in each process, based on performance data generation condition information indicating conditions that define the start to end of work for one piece of work in each process and the coordinate data; a comparison calculation unit that compares the textbook data with the performance data to determine whether the work indicated by the performance data is regular work or non-regular work, and outputs determination result information indicating the determination result.

[0081] It should be noted that the present disclosure allows various embodiments and modifications without departing from the broad spirit and scope of the present disclosure. Furthermore, the above-described embodiments are intended to explain the disclosure and do not limit the scope of the present disclosure. That is, the scope of the present disclosure is defined by the claims, not the embodiments. Various modifications made within the scope of the claims and within the meaning of the disclosure equivalent thereto are considered to be within the scope of the present disclosure.

[0082] This application is based on Japanese Patent Application No. 2023-84501, filed on May 20, 2023. The entire specification, claims, and drawings of Japanese Patent Application No. 2023-84501 are incorporated herein by reference.

[0083] 1 Simulation device, 2 Work judgment device, 11 Memory unit, 12 Operation input unit, 13 Simulation execution unit, 14 Communication unit, 15 Update unit, 21 Memory unit, 22 Communication unit, 23 Operation input unit, 24 Textbook data generation unit, 25 Measurement data acquisition unit, 26 Coordinate estimation unit, 27 Performance data generation unit, 28 Comparison calculation unit, 100 Simulation system, 101 Temporary storage unit, 102 Memory unit, 103 Calculation unit, 104 Input unit, 105 Transmission / reception unit, 106 Display unit, 111 Simulation condition storage unit, 112 Simulation result storage unit, 211 Textbook data generation condition storage unit, 212 Textbook data storage unit, 213 Coordinate data storage unit, 214 Performance data storage unit, Z Zone.

Claims

1. A first operation input unit that receives a modeling operation of a production line and generates a model of the production line; a simulation execution unit that simulates the behavior of the production line based on the model of the production line and generates simulation result information indicative of the simulation result; a textbook data generation unit that generates textbook data, which is a time chart of each resource present in a zone from the start to the end of one piece of work to be used as a textbook for routine work of each process, based on textbook data generation condition information including information indicating the start and end times of work for one work to be used as a textbook for routine work of each process of the production line and information indicating a zone which is an area required for work for one work of each process, and the simulation result information; a measurement data acquisition unit that acquires measurement data obtained by measuring radio waves received from tags attached to each resource by a tag reader arranged at a production site having resources; and a coordinate estimation unit that estimates the coordinates of each resource based on the measurement data and generates coordinate data indicating the coordinates of each resource. a performance data generation unit that generates performance data, which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone for the time from the start to the end of work on one work in each process, based on the coordinate data and performance data generation condition information that indicates conditions that dictate the start to end of work on one work in each process; and a comparison operation unit that compares the textbook data with the performance data to determine whether the work indicated by the performance data is regular or non-regular, and outputs determination result information that indicates the determination result.

2. The simulation system of claim 1, further comprising a second operation input unit that accepts setting operations for setting the start and end times of work for one workpiece that serves as a textbook for routine work in each process of the production line and the zone for each process, and generates the textbook data generation condition information.

3. The simulation system according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the comparison calculation unit calculates a similarity between the time chart of the textbook data and the time chart of the performance data, and if the similarity exceeds a threshold, determines that the work indicated by the performance data is routine work, and if the similarity does not exceed the threshold, determines that the work indicated by the performance data is non-routine work.

4. The simulation system described in any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein the performance data generation unit generates a measurement time chart, which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone of each process at the measurement time of the tag reader, based on the coordinate data, and generates the performance data by extracting the work time of one work from the measurement time chart based on the textbook data generation condition information; and when the comparison calculation unit determines that the work indicated by the performance data is regular work, it outputs regular judgment result information which sets the work time of one work in the time chart of the performance data to the work time of regular work, and when the comparison calculation unit determines that the work indicated by the performance data is non-regular work, it outputs non-regular judgment result information together with the measurement time chart, which sets the work time of one work in the time chart of the performance data to the work time during which non-regular work was performed.

5. The performance data generation unit generates a measurement time chart, which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone of each process at the measurement time of the tag reader, based on the coordinate data, and generates the performance data by extracting the work time of one work from the measurement time chart based on the textbook data generation condition information; the simulation execution unit simulates the behavior of the production line based on simulation condition information including work time information indicating the work time of one work in each process of the production line model; the comparison operation unit, when it determines that one work indicated by the performance data is regular work, outputs regular judgment result information which sets the work time of one work in the time chart of the performance data as the work time of regular work, and when it determines that one work indicated by the performance data is non-regular work, outputs non-regular judgment result information which sets the time of the measurement time chart during which the same resource as in the time chart of the performance data is continuously present as the work time of non-regular work; 4. The simulation system according to claim 1, further comprising an update unit that, when the steady-state judgment result information is output, cumulatively stores the steady-state judgment result information, updates the work time information with information indicating an average value of work times for one time chart of the performance data included in the steady-state judgment result information as work time information for steady work, and, when the non-steady-state judgment result information is output, adds information indicating the work time of non-steady work included in the non-steady-state judgment result information to the work time information as work time information for non-steady work.

6. The simulation system according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein the performance data generation unit generates a measurement time chart, which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone of each process at the measurement time of the tag reader, based on the coordinate data, and generates the performance data by extracting the work time of one work from the measurement time chart based on the textbook data generation condition information; and the comparison operation unit, when it determines that the work indicated by the performance data is routine work, outputs routine determination result information which sets the work time of one work in the time chart of the performance data to the work time of routine work, and when it determines that the work indicated by the performance data is non-routine work, outputs non-routine determination result information which sets the work time of one work in the time chart of the performance data to the work time during which non-routine work was performed, together with the measurement time chart and video data capturing the zone of the work time of one work in the time chart of the performance data.

7. A textbook data generation unit that generates textbook data which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone from the start to the end of one piece of work to be used as a textbook for routine work in each process of the production line, based on textbook data generation condition information including information indicating the start and end times of work for one work piece to be used as a textbook for routine work in each process and information indicating the zone which is the area required for work for one work piece in each process, and simulation result information indicating the results of a simulation of the behavior of the production line based on a model of the production line; a measurement data acquisition unit that acquires measurement data which measures radio waves received from tags attached to each resource by a tag reader installed at a production site having the resources; a coordinate estimation unit that estimates the coordinates of each resource based on the measurement data and generates coordinate data indicating the coordinates of each resource; and a performance data generation unit that generates performance data which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone from the start to the end of work for one work piece in each process, based on performance data generation condition information indicating the conditions that define the start to end of work for one work piece in each process and the coordinate data. a comparison calculation unit that compares the textbook data with the performance data to determine whether the work indicated by the performance data is regular work or non-regular work, and outputs determination result information indicative of the determination result.

8. A simulation system executes the steps of: accepting a modeling operation for a production line and generating a model of the production line; simulating the behavior of the production line based on the model of the production line and generating simulation result information indicating the simulation result; generating textbook data which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone from the start to the end of one piece of work to be used as a textbook for routine work of each process on the production line, based on textbook data generation condition information including information indicating the start and end times of work for one work as a textbook for routine work of each process and information indicating a zone which is an area required for work for one work in each process, and the simulation result information; estimating the coordinates of each resource based on measurement data obtained by measuring radio waves received from tags attached to each resource by a tag reader disposed at a production site having the resources, and generating coordinate data indicating the coordinates of each resource; generating performance data which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone from the start to the end of work for one work in each process, based on performance data generation condition information indicating the conditions defining the start to the end of work for one work in each process and the coordinate data; comparing the textbook data with the performance data to determine whether the work indicated by the performance data is regular or non-regular work, and outputting determination result information indicating a determination result.

9. A computer comprising: a textbook data generation unit that generates textbook data which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone from the start to the end of one piece of work to be used as a textbook for routine work in each process on a production line, based on textbook data generation condition information including information indicating the start and end times of work for one work piece to be used as a textbook for routine work in each process and information indicating a zone which is an area required for work for one work piece in each process, and simulation result information indicating a simulation result of simulating the behavior of the production line based on a model of the production line; a coordinate estimation unit that estimates the coordinates of each resource based on measurement data that measures radio waves received from tags attached to each resource by a tag reader disposed at a production site having the resources, and generates coordinate data indicating the coordinates of each resource; a performance data generation unit that generates performance data which is a time chart of each resource present in the zone from the start to the end of work for one work piece in each process, based on performance data generation condition information indicating the conditions that define the start to end of work for one work piece in each process and the coordinate data; a comparison calculation unit that compares the textbook data with the performance data to determine whether the work indicated by the performance data is regular or non-regular work, and outputs determination result information indicating the determination result.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Work analysis device, work analysis method, and program

    JP2020184250A

  • Work management device, work management method, and work management program

    JP2022113099A