A method for evaluating the effect of benthic animal enhancement and release

By monitoring the data at the benthic proliferation and release points and calculating the dimensionless comprehensive value F, the problem of inaccurate evaluation effect in the prior art is solved, and an accurate and easy-to-calculate evaluation method is provided, which realizes the proliferation and release of benthic animals. Effective evaluation of the effect.

CN114548740BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-19HUBEI JIANGXIAO ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION TECH CO LTD
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202210151857.8
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2022-02-18
Publication Date
2024-11-19
Estimated Expiration
2042-02-18

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The prior art is difficult to effectively evaluate the effect of benthic proliferation and release, and there is a lack of accurate and comparable evaluation methods.

Method used

By determining the sampling point at the proliferation and release point, monitoring multiple sample data before and after release, using utility function to calculate the quantized value of the evaluation factor, and calculating the dimensionless comprehensive value F in combination with subjective and objective weights, we evaluate the proliferation and release of benthic animals by evaluating the proliferation and release of benthic animals by using the utility function. effect.

Benefits of technology

Accurate quantitative evaluation of the proliferation and release effect of benthic animals is achieved, providing a simple and easy-to-expand evaluation method, which can select factors according to different sites and purposes, and obtain more accurate evaluation results.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN114548740B_ABST
    Figure CN114548740B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention proposes a method for evaluating the effect of benthic animal proliferation and release. The specific evaluation method includes first determining the sampling points of the evaluation factors, and at the sampling points, performing multiple sample sampling and monitoring before and after the release, respectively, performing quantitative calculation of the evaluation factors and weight value calculation on the sampled samples, and finally calculating the quantitative value after the weight value is added, summing and obtaining a dimensionless comprehensive value, and evaluating the effect of benthic animal proliferation and release according to the size of the dimensionless comprehensive value. The present invention provides an evaluation method for benthic animal proliferation and release effect that can perform quantitative calculation, and provides a standardized and feasible method for evaluating the effect of proliferation and release.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention relates to the technical field of enhancement and release assessment, and in particular to a method for assessing the effect of enhancement and release of benthic animals. Background Art

[0002] Benthic animals refer to aquatic animals that spend all or most of their life history at the bottom of the water body. In addition to those that settle and move, most of their life forms are fixed on hard substrates such as rocks and buried in soft substrates such as mud and sand. In addition, there are also benthic species that attach to the surface of plants or other benthic animals, as well as benthic species that live in the intertidal zone. In terms of feeding methods, most of them feed on suspended matter and sediments. Most of them are invertebrates, a complex ecological group. Due to their lifestyle and feeding types, benthic animals play an important role in improving the ecological environment of rivers.

[0003] To restore biological resources, the enhancement and release of benthic animals is a common method, but the effect evaluation after enhancement and release has always been a technical problem that needs to be solved urgently. Summary of the invention

[0004] In view of this, the present invention proposes a method for evaluating the effect of releasing benthic animals for reproduction.

[0005] The technical solution of the present invention is implemented as follows: The present invention provides a method for evaluating the effect of benthic animal proliferation and release, comprising:

[0006] Step 1: Determine the sampling points for the evaluation factors based on the geographical location of the stocking release point;

[0007] Step 2: At the sampling points of the evaluation factors determined in step 1, monitoring is performed before and after the release to obtain multiple samples, each sample including data of several evaluation factors;

[0008] Step 3: Calculate the quantitative values ​​of the evaluation factors and the weight values ​​of the corresponding samples. Sum the quantitative values ​​of all samples according to the weight values ​​to obtain a dimensionless comprehensive value F. The final evaluation of the effect of benthic animal enhancement and release is obtained based on the F value.

[0009] On the basis of the above technical scheme, preferably, in step one, the method for determining the sampling points of the evaluation factors includes taking the interval above the water of the cutoff line of the river where the reproduction and release point is located as the baseline sampling line, and determining at least one sampling line at positions with the same spacing upstream and downstream of the baseline along the direction of river flow, and determining at least three points at equal spacing on each sampling line as sampling points.

[0010] Based on the above technical solutions, preferably, the evaluation factors include: the proportion of released species, the abundance of released species, the biomass of released species, the abundance of community species, the relative abundance of released species, the community biomass, the proportion of released species biomass, the Shannon-Wiener index, the Margalef index and the Pielou index.

[0011] On the basis of the above technical scheme, preferably, in step 2, the number of monitoring before release is once, the number of monitoring after release is not less than once, and the time interval between the first monitoring sample after release and the release is not less than one life cycle of the monitored benthic animals.

[0012] More preferably, in step 3, the quantitative value of the evaluation factor is Y j (j=1, 2, ..., n), the Y j =f j (D j ), where D j is the jth evaluation factor, f j The evaluation factor D j The utility function of , n is the total number of evaluation factors.

[0013] Based on the above technical solution, preferably, the method for calculating the weight value of the sampling sample includes:

[0014] First, quantify each evaluation factor and calculate the i-th measurement value x of the j-th evaluation factor. ij The weight P ij ,

[0015] Calculate the entropy value e of the jth evaluation factor j ,

[0016] Calculate the difference coefficient g of the jth evaluation factor j , g j =1-e j ;

[0017] Calculate the objective weight W 2j ,

[0018] Calculate the combined weight W j ,

[0019] Where W 1j is the subjective weight of the evaluation factor, W 1j It is the ratio of the subjective score of each evaluation factor to the sum of the subjective scores of all evaluation factors (i=1,2,…,m), where m is the total number of samples.

[0020] On the basis of the above technical solution, preferably, the (j=1,2,...,n), where:

[0021]

[0022]

[0023] Where A is the change rate of each evaluation factor z j The maximum value of B is the change rate of each evaluation factor z j The minimum value of each evaluation factor, where the change rate Where X1 is the x before release ij The average Where X2 is the x after discharge ij The average

[0024] On the basis of the above technical scheme, preferably, in step three, the method for obtaining the final evaluation of the effect of benthic animal proliferation and release according to the size of the F value includes dividing 0-1 into four interval ranges, each range being: poor effect, F<0.25; general effect 0.25≤F<0.5; good effect, 0.5≤F<0.75; excellent effect, F>0.75.

[0025] The method for evaluating the effect of benthic animal proliferation and release of the present invention has the following beneficial effects compared with the prior art:

[0026] (1) The present invention proposes a new evaluation method, which calculates the evaluation items using utility functions to obtain accurate values, and uses objective evaluation combined with subjective judgment to conduct a specific quantitative evaluation of the final release effect, so that the final evaluation results are accurate and comparable;

[0027] (2) The evaluation method of the present invention is reasonably designed. The abstract and difficult-to-understand concept of the reproduction and release effect of benthic animals is concretely transformed into an evaluation method that can be accurately calculated and has low calculation difficulty. The combination of subjective and objective methods enables each part of the evaluation project to be reasonably calculated. The algorithm has high scalability. According to the actual release site and the purpose of the release, the evaluation factors can also be selected to obtain a simpler and more accurate evaluation result. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0028] In order to more clearly illustrate the embodiments of the present invention or the technical solutions in the prior art, the drawings required for use in the embodiments or the description of the prior art will be briefly introduced below. Obviously, the drawings described below are only some embodiments of the present invention. For ordinary technicians in this field, other drawings can be obtained based on these drawings without paying creative work.

[0029] Figure 1 This is a geographical location map of the sampling points and the release points in the embodiment of the present invention.

[0030] In the figure, the black dots are sampling points. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0031] The following will be combined with the embodiments of the present invention to clearly and completely describe the technical solutions in the embodiments of the present invention. Obviously, the described embodiments are only part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the scope of protection of the present invention.

[0032] The method for evaluating the effect of benthic animal proliferation and release of the present invention, in this embodiment, takes the effect of the proliferation and release of mollusks released by the benthic animals in Jingjiang Nature Reserve as the evaluation object, and the specific evaluation method is as follows:

[0033] First, the sampling points for the evaluation factors are determined according to the geographical location of the stocking release point, as follows: Figure 1 As shown, the arrow position is the release point, the black dot position is the sampling point, and 5 points are sampled at equal intervals on the river cutoff line where the reproduction and release point is located. Then, another four sampling cutoff lines are taken at equal intervals upstream of the river cutoff line parallel to the reproduction and release point. Another two sampling cutoff lines are taken at equal intervals downstream of the river cutoff line parallel to the reproduction and release point, and 5 points are sampled at equal intervals on the corresponding sampling cutoff lines.

[0034] After the sampling points are determined, samples are taken once before release and twice after release. For the same evaluation factor, samples are taken multiple times at different locations each time, and the evaluation factors are monitored and calculated for the samples. The specific evaluation factors are shown in the following table:

[0035]

[0036] According to the utility function of the evaluation factor, the quantitative value of each sample of the evaluation factor is calculated. Specifically, the quantitative value of the evaluation factor is Y j (j=1, 2, ..., n), the Y j =f j (D j), where D j is the jth evaluation factor, f j The evaluation factor D j The utility function is used, n is the total number of evaluation factors, and then the weight values ​​of the corresponding sampling samples are calculated. The quantified values ​​are weighted according to the weight values ​​and then summed to obtain a dimensionless comprehensive value F. The final evaluation of the effect of the benthic animal proliferation room is judged based on the dimensionless comprehensive value F. N samplings were taken after the release, so each sampling corresponds to an F value. The stable F value is the effective comprehensive value. If the number of samplings after the release is limited, the F value of the last sampling is used as the basis, and the F value generated in the middle can be used as a reference value for trend judgment.

[0037] Then, a weight is calculated for each measurement value of each evaluation factor. Specifically, the ith measurement value x of the jth evaluation factor is ij The weight P ij ,

[0038] Calculate the entropy value e of the jth evaluation factor j ,

[0039] Calculate the difference coefficient g of the jth evaluation factor j , g j =1-e j ;

[0040] Calculate the objective weight W 2j ,

[0041] Calculate the combined weight W j ,

[0042] Where W 1j is the subjective weight of the evaluation factor, W 1j It is the ratio of the subjective score of each evaluation factor to the sum of the subjective scores of all evaluation factors (i=1,2,…,m), where m is the total number of samples.

[0043] Specifically, (j=1,2,...,n), where:

[0044]

[0045]

[0046] Where A is the change rate of each evaluation factor z j The maximum value of B is the change rate of each evaluation factor z j The minimum value of each evaluation factor, where the change rate Where X1 Before release x ij The average Where X 2 After the release ij The average

[0047] The final calculated F value is within the range of 0-1. The method for obtaining the final evaluation of the effect of benthic animal enhancement and release based on the F value includes dividing 0-1 into four intervals, each range being: poor effect, F < 0.25; general effect, 0.25 ≤ F < 0.5; good effect, 0.5 ≤ F < 0.75; excellent effect, F > 0.75.

[0048] Specifically, in this embodiment, the released species include round field snails, ring-rimmed snails and river clams.

[0049] A total of 35 sampling points were collected in this survey, among which no benthic animals were collected at 9 sampling points near both sides of the waterway.

[0050] The species composition of benthic animals at each stage is shown in the following table:

[0051]

[0052] The top three dominant species of benthic animals at each stage (density: ind / m 2 Advantage: %), the specific results are as follows:

[0053]

[0054] The community biomass is as follows:

[0055] According to quantitative data, the average biomass of benthic animals in Jingjiang before the proliferation and release was 1.22 g / m 2 The average biomass of the first survey after release was 50.0g / m 2 The average biomass of the second release was 23.8 g / m 2 It can be seen that stocking and reproduction significantly increased the biomass in the assessment area.

[0056] Distribution of species released for stock enhancement:

[0057] In this survey, three species of released species were collected, including two species of river snails and one species of river clams, but no river clams were found. Before the proliferation and release, river snails did not appear in the historical research of Jingjiang Nature Reserve, and the number of distribution points after the proliferation and release accounted for about 39.1%; before the proliferation and release, river clams were distributed in Jingjiang Nature Reserve, and the number of distribution points doubled after the proliferation and release.

[0058] Effect evaluation results:

[0059] The subjective weight is determined by the hierarchical analysis method. First, the weight is divided in proportion to the importance of the evaluation category, among which the population, community and diversity index account for 0.5000, 0.3332 and 0.1668 respectively, and then it is evenly divided into factors under each category. According to the benthic animal survey data, the calculation results are shown in the following table:

[0060] Evaluation Factor Subjective weight Objective weight Comprehensive weight Proportion of released species 0.1667 0.0457 0.1018 Abundance of released species 0.1667 0.1208 0.1909 Biomass of released species 0.1667 0.2145 0.2256 Community species abundance 0.0833 0.0576 0.0807 Relative abundance of released species 0.0833 0.0826 0.0967 Community biomass 0.0833 0.3834 0.2083 Proportion of released species biomass 0.0833 0.0501 0.0034 Shannon-Wiener Index 0.0556 0.0152 0.0339 Margalef Index 0.0556 0.0280 0.0460 Pielou Index 0.0556 0.0021 0.0127

[0061] The combined weight of released species biomass and community biomass is above 0.2, the abundance of released species and the proportion of released species are above 0.1, and the four factors account for more than 70% of the combined weight.

[0062] First review:

[0063] Based on the first monitoring data before and after the stocking, the single evaluation value Y of the benthic animals in the Jingjiang Nature Reserve during the stocking period can be calculated. j The results of the change rate, the change rate of the enhancement and release effect evaluation, the comprehensive weights of the enhancement and release effect evaluation factors and the evaluation values ​​are shown in the following table. Then calculate the individual evaluation values ​​Y j And the comprehensive value F.

[0064]

[0065]

[0066] The top three factors with higher change rates are the biomass of released species, the biomass of communities, and the abundance of released species. The single evaluation values ​​were calculated according to the formula, and the top three single evaluation values ​​were the biomass of released species, the biomass of communities, and the abundance of released species. The comprehensive value of the enhancement and release effect F = 0.3407, and the overall restoration effect level is medium.

[0067] Second evaluation:

[0068] Based on the second monitoring data before and after the stocking, the single evaluation value Y of the benthic animals in the Jingjiang Nature Reserve during the stocking period can be calculated. j The results of the change rate, the change rate of the enhancement and release effect evaluation, the comprehensive weights of the enhancement and release effect evaluation factors and the evaluation values ​​are shown in the following table. Then calculate the individual evaluation values ​​Y j And the comprehensive value F.

[0069]

[0070]

[0071] The top three factors with higher change rates are biomass of released species, biomass of communities and abundance of released species. The single evaluation values ​​are calculated according to the formula. The top three single evaluation values ​​are biomass of released species, biomass of communities and abundance of released species. The comprehensive value of the enhancement and release effect is F = 0.2903, and the overall restoration effect level is medium.

[0072] From the above data, we can see that the comprehensive values ​​of the two evaluations are close and the evaluation results are consistent, which has a good quantitative evaluation effect.

[0073] The above description is only a preferred embodiment of the present invention and is not intended to limit the present invention. Any modifications, equivalent substitutions, improvements, etc. made within the spirit and principles of the present invention should be included in the protection scope of the present invention.

Claims

1. A method for evaluating the effect of benthic animal proliferation and release, characterized in that: include: Step 1: Determine the sampling points for the evaluation factors based on the geographical location of the stocking release point; Step 2: At the sampling points of the evaluation factors determined in step 1, monitoring is performed before and after the release to obtain multiple samples, each sample including data of several evaluation factors; Step 3: Calculate the quantitative value of the evaluation factor for the sampled samples, as well as the weight value of the corresponding sampled samples, and sum the quantitative values ​​of all samples according to the weight value to obtain a dimensionless comprehensive value F. The final evaluation of the effect of the release of benthic animals is obtained according to the value of F. In step 3, the quantitative value of the evaluation factor is Y j (j=1, 2, ..., n), the Y j =f j (D j ), where D j is the jth evaluation factor, f j The evaluation factor D j The utility function of , n is the total number of evaluation factors; The weight value calculation method of the sample includes: First, quantify each evaluation factor and calculate the i-th measurement value x of the j-th evaluation factor. ij The weight P ij , Calculate the entropy value e of the jth evaluation factor j , Calculate the difference coefficient g of the jth evaluation factor j , g j =1-e j ; Calculate the objective weight W 2j , Calculate the combined weight W j , Where W 1j is the subjective weight of the evaluation factor, W 1j It is the ratio of the subjective score of each evaluation factor to the sum of the subjective scores of all evaluation factors, (i = 1, 2, ..., m), where m is the total number of samples; Said in: Where A is the change rate of each evaluation factor z j The maximum value of B is the change rate of each evaluation factor z j The minimum value of each evaluation factor, where the change rate Where X1 is the x before release ij The average Where X2 is the x after discharge ij The average 2. The method for evaluating the effect of benthic animal proliferation and release according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step one, the method for determining the sampling points of the evaluation factors includes taking the interval where the cutoff line of the river where the reproduction and release point is located above the water as the baseline sampling line, determining at least one sampling line at the same interval upstream and downstream of the baseline along the direction of river flow, and determining at least three points at equal intervals on each sampling line as sampling points.

3. The method for evaluating the effect of benthic animal proliferation and release according to claim 1, characterized in that: The evaluation factors include: the proportion of released species, the abundance of released species, the biomass of released species, the species abundance of benthic animal communities, the relative abundance of released species, the biomass of benthic animal communities, the proportion of released species biomass, the Shannon-Wiener index, the Margalef index and the Pielou index.

4. The method for evaluating the effect of benthic animal proliferation and release according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step 2, the number of monitoring before release is one, and the number of monitoring after release is no less than one, and the time interval between the first monitoring sample after release and the release is no less than one life cycle of the monitored benthic animals.

5. The method for evaluating the effect of benthic animal proliferation and release according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step three, the method for obtaining the final evaluation of the effect of benthic animal enhancement and release according to the size of the F value includes dividing 0-1 into four interval ranges, each range is: poor effect, F<0.25; general effect 0.25≤F<0.5; good effect, 0.5≤F<0.75; excellent effect, F>0.75.