Multi-terminal flexible direct current transmission droop control method based on power coordination control

By dynamically correcting the sag coefficient in the VSC-MTDC system and setting the sag coefficient of the converter station based on the power margin, the problem of complex selection of sag coefficients and large DC voltage deviation in sag control is solved, and better power distribution equalization is achieved and DC voltage stability, suitable for systems with frequent power fluctuations.

CN118920557APending Publication Date: 2024-11-08ZHENGZHOU UNIVERSITY OF LIGHT INDUSTRY
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202410880754.4
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-07-02
Publication Date
2024-11-08

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

In the VSC-MTDC system, sag control has the problem of complex selection of sag coefficients and large DC voltage deviation, which affects the stability of the system and the balance of power distribution.

Method used

By determining the power margin within the operation range of the converter station, dynamically correcting the sag coefficient, setting the sag coefficient of the converter station based on the real-time power margin, using power coordination control to achieve reasonable allocation of unbalanced power, and making full use of the converter station Power regulation capability.

Benefits of technology

Effectively improve the quality of DC voltage, reduce the impact of DC voltage on the equipment, avoid problems such as unreasonable unbalanced power distribution and large DC voltage deviation caused by the fixed sag coefficient in traditional sag control, and improve the operating stability of the system. .

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118920557A_ABST
    Figure CN118920557A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention discloses a multi-terminal flexible DC power transmission droop control method based on power coordination control, and aims to solve the technical problems of complex droop coefficient selection and large DC voltage deviation of an existing droop control strategy. According to the control method, the droop coefficient is corrected in real time according to the available power margin of the converter station, the power regulation capability of the converter station is fully utilized, reasonable distribution of unbalanced power is realized based on power coordination control, the DC voltage quality is effectively improved, and the impact of DC voltage on equipment is reduced; the problems that unbalanced power distribution is unreasonable, a converter station is fully loaded, direct-current voltage deviation is large and the like when a droop coefficient is a fixed value in traditional droop control can be effectively solved.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of power control, and in particular to a multi-terminal flexible direct current transmission droop control method based on power coordinated control. Background Art

[0002] In recent years, with the development of renewable energy, voltage source converters ( voltage source converter, VSC) multi-terminal flexible direct current transmission system ( voltage source converter based multi- terminal direct current, VSC-MTDC) has gradually become the best choice for new energy grid connection due to its many advantages such as independent control of active and reactive power, power supply to weak AC system or passive network, power reversal without changing the polarity of DC voltage.

[0003] However, in the VSC-MTDC system, the change of the power of the converter station at the transmitting or receiving end will cause a large deviation of the DC voltage, and even affect the normal operation of the system. Therefore, how to stabilize the DC voltage is crucial for the safe operation of the VSC-MTDC system.

[0004] The existing control strategies of VSC-MTDC systems known to the inventor mainly include master-slave control, voltage margin control and droop control, among which droop control can utilize the power regulation capability of multiple converter stations to achieve rapid absorption of unbalanced power, thereby improving the DC voltage stability capability. Therefore, droop control is widely used in DC voltage control of VSC-MTDC systems.

[0005] However, in the process of implementing the technical solution in the embodiment of the present application, the inventors of the present application found that the droop control had problems such as complex selection of droop coefficient and large DC voltage deviation.

[0006] The information disclosed in this background technology section is only used to deepen the understanding of the background technology of the present disclosure, and should not be regarded as acknowledging or suggesting in any form that the information constitutes the prior art known to those skilled in the art. Summary of the invention

[0007] The inventors have found through research that the droop control system has a decisive influence on the unbalanced power distribution of the DC transmission system, while the change of the DC line resistance has a relatively small influence on the unbalanced power distribution.

[0008] In view of at least one of the above technical problems, the present disclosure provides a multi-terminal flexible direct current transmission droop control method based on power coordinated control, aiming to solve the technical problems of complex droop coefficient selection and large DC voltage deviation in existing droop control strategies.

[0009] According to one aspect of the present disclosure, a multi-terminal flexible direct current transmission droop control method based on power coordinated control is provided, comprising the following steps: (1) Determine the power margin of the converter station within the converter station operation range as R: ; in, P smax is the maximum power point of the converter station, P s is the measured value of active power of the converter station, U dcmin is the minimum DC voltage, U dcmax is the maximum value of DC voltage; U dcref is the DC voltage reference value, U dc is the measured value of DC voltage; (2) Setting the droop coefficient of the i-th converter station in the DC transmission system based on the real-time power margin : ; Where k is the initial droop coefficient, η is a constant, and i≥3.

[0010] In some embodiments of the present disclosure, in step (2), the UP initial droop coefficient k of the DC power transmission system converter station based on power control is determined by the following formula: ; in, ΔU dc is the DC voltage change, ΔP is the unbalanced power of the DC system, U dcref is the DC voltage reference value, U dc is the measured value of DC voltage, P s is the measured value of active power of the converter station, P sref It is the reference value of active power of converter station.

[0011] In some embodiments of the present disclosure, in step (2), η takes a value of [0.5, 1.5].

[0012] One or more technical solutions provided in the embodiments of the present application have at least the following technical effects or advantages: the control method corrects the droop coefficient in real time according to the available power margin of the converter station, makes full use of the power regulation capability of the converter station, realizes the reasonable distribution of unbalanced power based on power coordination control, effectively improves the quality of DC voltage, reduces the impact of DC voltage on equipment, and can effectively avoid the problems of unreasonable unbalanced power distribution, full load of converter station, large DC voltage deviation, etc. that are easy to occur when the droop coefficient is a fixed value in traditional droop control. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0013] Figure 1 Schematic diagram of the structure of a typical ring-shaped five-terminal VSC-MTDC system in one embodiment of the present application.

[0014] Figure 2 Schematic diagram of the structure of the VSC in one embodiment of the present application.

[0015] Figure 3 This is a conventional UP and UI droop control curve diagram in one embodiment of the present application.

[0016] Figure 4 Schematic diagram of a simplified equivalent circuit of a five-terminal VSC-MTDC system in an embodiment of the present application.

[0017] Figure 5 This is a simulation diagram of unbalanced power distribution between VSC1 and VSC2 in an embodiment of the present application.

[0018] Figure 6 This is another simulation diagram of unbalanced power distribution between VSC1 and VSC2 in an embodiment of the present application.

[0019] Figure 7 This is a schematic diagram of the converter station operation range in one embodiment of the present application.

[0020] Figure 8 1 is a control characteristic curve of an adaptive droop coefficient and a fixed droop coefficient in an embodiment of the present application.

[0021] Fig. 9 This is a simulation curve when a DC network has a power surplus in an embodiment of the present application.

[0022] Fig.10 This is a simulation curve when a power loss occurs in a DC network in an embodiment of the present application.

[0023] In the above figures, 1 is a DC network. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0024] In order to better understand the technical solution of the present application, the above technical solution will be described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and specific implementation methods.

[0025] The existing multi-terminal flexible direct current transmission system based on voltage source converter (VSC-MTDC) is shown in Figure 1 As shown, this example takes a typical ring-shaped five-terminal VSC-MTDC system as an example, where VSC1~VSC5 are five voltage source converter stations, and the DC sides of each voltage source converter station VSC1~VSC5 are connected in parallel through a DC network 1, and the AC sides are electrically connected to their respective AC grids S1~S5. In this example, the structures of VSC1~VSC5 are the same, see Figure 2 The VSC structure shown in the figure is in a three-phase coordinate system. U sa , U sb , U sc are the phase voltages of the AC power grid respectively; U a , U b , U c are the voltage vectors of each phase voltage of the AC power grid; R and X are the equivalent resistance and reactance of the VSC AC side; C is the capacitance of the DC side; U dc is the DC side voltage.

[0026] The traditional droop control strategies in VSC-MTDC systems can be divided into two types, namely UP droop based on power control and UI droop based on current control. Figure 3 The UP droop control curve and UI droop control curve are shown in FIG. P s and P sref Respectively represent the measured value and reference value of active power of converter station VSC, U dc and U dcref Respectively represent the measured value and reference value of DC voltage, i dc and i dcref Respectively represent the measured value and reference value of DC current; ΔU dc is the DC voltage change, Δ i dc is the DC current change, ΔP is the unbalanced power of the DC system. Figure 3 The control equations of UP droop control and UI droop control can be obtained: .

[0027] Among them, k is the UP droop coefficient and r is the UI droop coefficient.

[0028] Further, based on Figure 1 The five-terminal VSC-MTDC system shown in the figure is further simplified. Figure 4 The simplified equivalent circuit shown in FIG. Among them, the voltage source converter stations VSC1 and VSC2 respectively adopt the traditional droop control, the voltage source converter stations VSC3 and VSC4 respectively adopt the fixed active power control, and the voltage source converter station VSC5 adopts the fixed AC voltage control. Among them, U dciref (i=1~5) is the DC voltage reference value of the converter station; U dc0 is the common DC bus voltage of the converter station; R i (i=1~5) is the DC line resistance of the converter station. Since the droop control is achieved by controlling the output current of the converter station, its droop coefficient is equivalent to adding a virtual resistor to the DC line. The DC current generates a voltage drop through the virtual resistor, which leads to a change in the DC voltage of the converter station. Figure 4 In the equivalent circuit shown in r 1 and r 2 They respectively represent the virtual resistance equivalently generated when VSC1 and VSC2 adopt droop control.

[0029] Depend on Figure 4 The equivalent circuit shown is analyzed to obtain: ; .

[0030] Since the voltage source converter stations VSC1 and VSC2 respectively adopt traditional droop control, when they dynamically absorb unbalanced power, the DC voltage deviation generated by the system is: .

[0031] Considering that the DC voltage reference values ​​of converter stations VSC1 and VSC2 are equal, that is: ; Therefore, we can get: ;thereby ; It can be seen from this formula that for the converter station using droop control, its DC current is inversely proportional to the sum of the line resistance and the virtual resistance.

[0032] Furthermore, the active power of the converter station using droop control can be expressed as: .

[0033] When the DC system is subject to power disturbance, the unbalanced power borne by VSC1 and VSC2 is ΔP1 and ΔP2 respectively. After the system dynamic adjustment is completed, the actual active power values ​​of VSC1 and VSC2 are P1′ and P2′ respectively, then: .

[0034] Under droop control, the difference in unbalanced power borne by VSC1 and VSC2 is: ; When and only when R1=R2, r1=r2, (ΔP1-ΔP2) is 0, at which time the unbalanced power in the system is evenly divided by the droop-controlled VSC1 and VSC2. In actual projects, since the distances of DC transmission lines are usually different, the DC resistance is also different. At the same time, the resistance value is easily affected by the ambient temperature rise, which is not conducive to power distribution.

[0035] Under the actual power grid operation conditions, the converter stations interconnected by DC lines must have transmission line resistance, and the resistance is correlated with the transmission line distance. However, the inventors have found through research that the DC transmission line resistance has little impact on the converter stations.

[0036] For more information, see Figure 5 First, VSC1 and VSC2 are set as droop control converter stations with the same droop coefficient. The resistance of the DC transmission line of converter station VSC1 is set to 0.05Ω, and the resistance of the DC transmission line of VSC2 is set to 0.25Ω. Figure 5 As shown in the simulation diagram, at 3s, the system has an unbalanced power of 40.2MW, of which the unbalanced power shared by VSC1 is -19.5MW and the unbalanced power shared by VSC2 is -20.7MW. Then change the setting of the DC transmission line resistance of VSC1 to 0.15Ω and the DC transmission line resistance of VSC2 to 0.25Ω, and perform simulation analysis on the system again, see Figure 6 At 3s, the system has an unbalanced power of 40.2MW, of which VSC1 receives -19.9MW and VSC2 receives -20.3MW. It can be seen that when the DC transmission line resistance of converter station VSC1 is changed and the DC transmission line resistance of converter station VSC2 remains unchanged, the change of DC line resistance has little effect on the unbalanced power distribution, so the droop coefficient is the decisive factor affecting the unbalanced power distribution.

[0037] Based on this, the DC transmission line loss is ignored, and it is assumed that there are n converter stations in the DC transmission system that use droop control. When the line loss is ignored, the DC voltage of each converter station remains consistent. If the DC system is disturbed by the load, the converter station absorbs the unbalanced power through droop control to stabilize the DC voltage. When the system enters a steady state again, the unbalanced power borne by the i-th (1≤i≤n) converter station is: .

[0038] in, (1≤i≤n) is the droop coefficient of the i-th converter station. It can be seen from this formula that in the process of absorbing unbalanced power, the converter station with a smaller droop coefficient bears more power distribution, and the converter station with a larger droop coefficient bears less power distribution. Since the traditional droop control sets the droop coefficient according to the capacity of the converter station, the droop coefficient usually remains unchanged. If the droop coefficient is large, the power distribution characteristics are better and power fluctuations are not likely to occur, but the DC voltage deviation caused is large; if the droop coefficient is small, the DC voltage fluctuation is small, but the power distribution characteristics are poor.

[0039] Considering that the droop coefficient of traditional droop control is usually determined by the rated capacity of each converter station. However, when the DC system dynamically absorbs unbalanced power, not all droop control converter stations reach full load at the same time. Therefore, this example performs adaptive droop control based on the real-time power margin of the converter station, so that the selection of the droop coefficient is no longer affected by the rated capacity of the converter station, but is determined by the real-time power margin of the converter station.

[0040] Specifically, the multi-terminal flexible direct current transmission droop control method based on power coordinated control disclosed in this example includes the following steps: (1) The power margin of the converter station is determined as R within the operating range of the converter station.

[0041] See also Figure 7 , the power margin R of the converter station is expressed as: ; in, P smax is the maximum power point of the converter station, P s is the measured value of active power of the converter station, U dcmin is the minimum DC voltage, U dcmax is the maximum value of DC voltage; U dcref is the DC voltage reference value, U dc is the measured value of DC voltage.

[0042] (2) Set the droop coefficient of the i-th (i≥3) converter station of the DC transmission system based on the real-time power margin .

[0043] See also Figure 7 ,when P s When it is greater than 0 and moves to the right, P smargin1 gradually decreases, and P smargin2 Gradually increases, at this time the converter station moves towards the maximum power point, so there is a problem of power margin. Therefore, in this embodiment, when dynamically correcting the droop coefficient, the power margin is mainly considered. P smargin1 On the contrary, when P s When it is less than or equal to 0 and moving to the left, P smargin1 Gradually decreases, and P smargin2 Gradually decreases, at this time the converter station moves against the maximum power point, and there is also a problem of power margin, so the power margin needs to be considered. P smargin2 .

[0044] Therefore, according to the above analysis, in this embodiment, the converter station droop coefficient Set to: ; Where k is the initial droop coefficient and η is a constant. In this example, η is in the range of [0.5, 1.5]. UP initial droop coefficient based on power control of the DC transmission system converter station ;in, ΔU dc is the DC voltage change, ΔP is the unbalanced power of the DC system, U dcref is the DC voltage reference value, U dc is the measured value of DC voltage, P s is the measured value of active power of the converter station, P sref It is the reference value of active power of converter station.

[0045] Therefore, for P s The positive and negative values ​​and the moving direction can be divided into the following four working conditions: (1) When P s Greater than and towards P smax When the converter station moves in the direction ofP smargin1 The droop coefficient gradually decreases and increases, which equivalently reduces the unbalanced power borne by the converter station during the dynamic adjustment process.

[0046] (2) When P s When it is greater than 0 and moves toward 0, the available power margin of the converter station P smargin1 The droop coefficient gradually increases, and the droop coefficient gradually decreases, which equivalently increases the unbalanced power borne by the converter station during the dynamic adjustment process.

[0047] (3) When P s Less than 0 and -P smax When the converter station moves in the direction of P smargin2 The droop coefficient gradually decreases and increases, which equivalently reduces the unbalanced power borne by the converter station during the dynamic adjustment process.

[0048] (4) When P s When it is less than 0 and moves toward 0, the available power margin of the converter station P smargin2 The droop coefficient gradually increases, and the droop coefficient gradually decreases, which equivalently increases the unbalanced power borne by the converter station during the dynamic adjustment process.

[0049] Hence, see Figure 8 The selection of the droop coefficient is no longer affected by the rated capacity of the converter station, but is determined by the real-time power margin of the converter station itself. The droop coefficient is corrected in real time according to the available power margin of the converter station, which can make full use of the power regulation capability of the converter station.

[0050] In order to verify the effectiveness of the multi-terminal flexible DC transmission droop control method based on power coordinated control disclosed in this example, PSCAD / EMTDC The simulation platform is built as Figure 1 The simulation parameters of the five-terminal flexible DC grid shown in FIG. 1 are shown in Table 1.

[0051] Table 1 System simulation parameters .

[0052] (1) Simulate the situation of power surplus in DC network. The simulation results are shown in Fig. 9At t=3s, the active power command value of VSC3 increases from 115MW to 175MW. At this time, the DC transmission system has a power surplus and the DC voltage begins to drop. Under the traditional droop control strategy, since the droop coefficient remains unchanged, the unbalanced power shared by VSC1 and VSC2 also remains unchanged, 19.7MW and 40.3MW respectively. That is, the traditional droop control distributes the unbalanced power according to the droop coefficients of VSC1 and VSC2. The droop coefficient of VSC1 is greater than that of VSC2, so the unbalanced power shared by VSC1 is less than that of VSC1.

[0053] As for the adaptive droop control strategy disclosed in this example, when the system has a power surplus, the droop coefficients of VSC1 and VSC2 are corrected in real time according to their own power margins, so that VSC2 with a larger power margin bears more unbalanced power, avoiding the VSC1 with a smaller power margin from switching to fixed active power operation at full load and losing the ability to control the DC voltage. When the system reaches a steady state again, the unbalanced power shared by VSC1 and VSC2 is 10.6MW and 50.4MW respectively. At the same time, the DC voltage deviation is reduced by 3.06kV compared with the traditional droop control, and the operating stability of the system has been significantly improved.

[0054] (2) Simulate the situation of power loss in the DC network. The simulation results are shown in Fig.10 At t=3s, the active power command value of VSC4 dropped from 85MW to 25MW. At this time, the DC transmission system experienced power shortage and the DC voltage began to rise. Under the traditional droop control strategy, the unbalanced power shared by VSC1 and VSC2 was 19.9MW and 40.1MW respectively, and the DC voltage deviation was 5.95kV. Since the droop coefficient remains unchanged, when the DC system has power surplus or shortage, the ratio of unbalanced power shared by VSC1 and VSC2 is 1:2, which makes it difficult to flexibly cope with systems with frequent power fluctuations.

[0055] As for the adaptive droop control strategy disclosed in this example, when the system has power deficiency, the droop coefficients of VSC1 and VSC2 are corrected in real time according to their own power margins. At this time, the power margin of VSC1 is greater than that of VSC2, so the unbalanced power allocated to VSC1 is greater than that of VSC2, which are 38.1MW and 22.9MW respectively, and the DC voltage deviation is 5.22kV. Compared with the traditional droop control, the droop coefficient considering the real-time power margin of the converter station disclosed in this example can be flexibly corrected in real time according to the system status, and the power regulation capability of the converter station can be fully utilized to achieve the reasonable distribution of unbalanced power, effectively improve the quality of DC voltage, reduce the impact of DC voltage on equipment, and is more suitable for systems with frequent power fluctuations.

[0056] Although some preferred embodiments of the present invention have been described, those skilled in the art may make other changes and modifications to these embodiments once they have learned the basic creative concept. Therefore, the appended claims are intended to be interpreted as including the preferred embodiments and all changes and modifications that fall within the scope of the present invention.

[0057] Obviously, those skilled in the art can make various changes and modifications to the present invention without departing from the spirit and scope of the inventive concept of the present application. Thus, if these modifications and variations of the present invention fall within the scope of the claims of the present application and their equivalents, the present invention is also intended to include these modifications and variations.

Claims

1. A multi-terminal flexible direct current transmission droop control method based on power coordinated control, characterized in that: The steps include: (1) Determine the power margin of the converter station within the converter station operation range as R: ; in, P smax is the maximum power point of the converter station, P s is the measured value of active power of the converter station, U dcmin is the minimum DC voltage, U dcmax is the maximum value of DC voltage; U dcref is the DC voltage reference value, U dc is the measured value of DC voltage; (2) Setting the droop coefficient of the i-th converter station in the DC transmission system based on the real-time power margin : ; Where k is the initial droop coefficient, η is a constant, and i≥3.

2. The multi-terminal flexible direct current transmission droop control method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step (2), the UP initial droop coefficient k of the DC transmission system converter station based on power control is determined by the following formula: ; in, ΔU dc is the DC voltage change, ΔP is the unbalanced power of the DC system, U dcref is the DC voltage reference value, U dc is the measured value of DC voltage, P s is the measured value of active power of the converter station, P sref It is the reference value of active power of converter station.

3. The multi-terminal flexible direct current transmission droop control method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step (2), η takes the value of [0.5, 1.5].