Failure analysis method for aerospace 3D SIP device

By establishing a failure tree and stress transmission simulation, combined with non-destructive detection, the internal failure analysis problem of aerospace 3D SIP devices is solved, and the positioning and pattern analysis of internal failures is realized, which improves the reliability of the device.

CN118940716APending Publication Date: 2024-11-12Shanghai Institute of Basic Aerospace Technology
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202410933938.2
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-07-12
Publication Date
2024-11-12

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The existing technology is difficult to conduct system-level internal failure analysis on aerospace 3D SIP devices, resulting in difficulty in positioning and unclear failure mechanisms, affecting device reliability.

Method used

By establishing a failure tree, screening possible failure modes, analyzing design parameters and process monitoring parameters, performing stress transfer simulation in graded, combining three-dimensional X-rays and optical microscopes for non-destructive testing, determining the risk point location, and confirming the failure mode.

Benefits of technology

The internal failure positioning and mode analysis of aerospace 3D SIP devices is realized, reducing the analysis complexity and improving the reliability of the devices.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118940716A_ABST
    Figure CN118940716A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention provides a failure analysis method for aerospace SIP components. A failure fault tree simulation method formed by failure modes is provided, internal failure devices can be positioned and analyzed through simulation, and a complete failure analysis fault tree is formed through classification failure mode carding and traversal. And through design parameter margin analysis and process parameter analysis, the number of failure modes is reduced, and the analysis complexity is reduced. Through an internal stress outward and external stress inward analysis path method and a stress superposition method, an internal and external interaction stress analysis effect is obtained, the relation between internal and external stress and defect allowance is comprehensively superposed, a physical section is prepared, and failure positioning and data are obtained to confirm an actual failure mode.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention relates to a failure analysis method for aerospace 3D SIP devices and belongs to the field of semiconductor device reliability assessment. Background Art

[0002] Aerospace 3D SIP devices integrate multiple chips in the form of three-dimensional stacking, using silicon vias and micro solder joints as vertical interconnection structures, forming transitional interconnections between solder joints and silicon vias through redistribution layer RDL routing, stacking multiple layers of memory to form a pyramid or cross structure, stacking FPGA, AD / DA, DSP, FLASH, resistors, and capacitors on the silicon adapter to form a three-dimensional structure, and using high-temperature co-fired ceramics (HTCC) as a sealing and heat dissipation substrate. The signal transmission distance is short, the loss is low, and the bandwidth is large, which can provide stand-alone-like functions and performance, saving space and weight for aerospace models, and integrating more functions to improve the performance of the system's internal indicators.

[0003] However, the aerospace application environment and non-repairability require 3D SIP devices to have high reliability. At the same time, because many pins of 3DSIP devices are embedded inside the system and cannot be brought out for measurement, it is difficult to locate internal defects or application damage. During the development and verification process, when 3D SIP devices fail, there are technical difficulties in failure analysis and location and failure mode definition.

[0004] In the existing technical solutions, CN104112483B TVS wafer-level packaged MEMS chip failure analysis device and analysis method thereof proposes an analysis device combining a probe and a reflector and a corresponding analysis method. This patent is suitable for unpackaged wafer-level analysis. When the SIP device is packaged, most of the interconnection structures are hidden inside, and the pins of the chip cannot be brought out, making it difficult to test it. CN1138713115A tube die failure analysis method and stacked package chip failure analysis method propose a method for obtaining defect information based on backside hot spot positioning and electrical measurement. This method also performs failure analysis on stacked microcomponents. This method cannot be used to solve the failure analysis problem inside the 3D SIP system level in packaged devices.

[0005] In summary, in the above technical fields, it is difficult to use existing technologies to perform failure analysis on the 3D SIP system level. Because the failure location is difficult to determine and the failure mechanism is unclear, the problems of the 3D SIP complex microsystem cannot be completely eliminated, making it difficult to ensure the reliability of SIP devices used in aerospace models. Summary of the invention

[0006] The purpose of the present invention is to provide a method for failure analysis of aerospace SIP devices, which can realize failure analysis of 3DSIP devices for aerospace applications. It includes:

[0007] S1: Establish a failure fault tree and list the failure modes at different levels one by one;

[0008] S2: Simplify the failure fault tree established in step S1 to screen out possible failure modes 1 to n; perform analysis using design parameters, process monitoring parameters PCM and batch monitoring parameters LCM as boundaries; perform margin analysis on the design parameters of the bare chip level, micro-component level, tube and shell level and circuit level of the components, using design parameters and process analysis data as constraints;

[0009] S3: Perform boundary peak analysis on the two groups of parameters PCM and LCM in S2 to determine the failure modes and defect types corresponding to the parameters in the two groups that are close to or exceed the process control baseline, pair the failure modes with the environmental stress and working stress of the 3DSIP components for analysis, obtain the sensitive stress, and divide the sensitive stress into external stress and internal stress;

[0010] S4: Establish the sensitive stress profile and the sensitive stress transmission method and path, simulate the internal and external stress transmission of the failure mode selected in S2 and its corresponding sensitive stress according to the direction of sensitive stress propagation and at the chip level, micro-component level, device level, and board level, and form a sensitive stress distribution profile at each level; superimpose and calculate the internal stress distribution profile and the external stress distribution profile, and calibrate the sensitive stress intensity using the color-value correspondence relationship;

[0011] S5: According to the material failure activation energy, calculate the material failure activation energy and the difference between the defect energy level in the corresponding failure mode in the simplified failure fault tree in S2, record it as the failure margin, compare the failure margin with the sensitive stress intensity calibrated in S4, and determine the risk point position of the SIP device by the position of the peak value of the sensitive stress intensity in the SIP device;

[0012] S6: According to the sensitive stress intensity calibrated in S4 and the risk point position in S5, three-dimensional X-ray and optical microscope are used for non-destructive testing, and then the sample is prepared to form a cross section and the failure mode is confirmed by scanning electron microscope.

[0013] Preferably, in step S1, a failure fault tree of the 3D SIP device is established hierarchically based on previous failure cases and a failure database, and failure faults of different levels and failure faults of interfaces between different levels are divided according to the assembly order of the bare chip level, micro-component level, tube shell level and circuit level. The failure faults of the multi-layer failure fault tree from 1 to n that need to be established are:

[0014] S11: First-level mechanical, electrical, thermal, electromagnetic, and optical failure modes;

[0015] S12: Secondary shock, vibration, voltage / current failure, high temperature, low temperature, high and low temperature cycle, and electromagnetic field failure modes;

[0016] S13: The three-level thermoelectric failure mode, thermoelectric failure mode, interface thermal failure mode, chip and stack structure coupling, electromagnetic field interaction, thermal-vacuum, and space particle effect combined stress mode are used as fault tree branches.

[0017] Preferably, in step S2, the design parameters, process monitoring parameters PCM and batch monitoring parameters LCM are used as boundaries for analysis; the design parameters at the bare chip level, micro-component level, tube shell level and circuit level of the components are subjected to margin analysis, and the design parameters and process analysis data are used as constraints to screen out possible failure modes 1 to n;

[0018] The design parameter changes for each level of bare chip level, micro-component level, tube and shell level and circuit level are ±A1%, ±A2%, ±A3%, ±A4%, and the parameter change rate of SIP components specified in the detailed product specifications and the agreement between the research and user parties is ±B%. The key item of margin analysis is the ratio of the change value of a single item or multiple items among ±A1%, ±A2%, ±A3%, ±A4% and the required value of the research and user parties ±A n / B.

[0019] Preferably, the PCM and LCM parameters in step S2 need to include the structure of the traditional chip-level test, the component daisy chain, and the stacked packaging process components.

[0020] Preferably, in step S3, parameters approaching or exceeding the process control baseline are determined as sensitive parameters of the corresponding failure mode, and the sensitive parameters include at least the static and / or dynamic resistance of the silicon via and / or solder ball daisy chain, the interconnect layer resistance of the ceramic substrate, and the leakage current of the silicon via.

[0021] Preferably, in step S3, the external stress includes direct mechanical stress and corresponding electrothermal stress, direct electrical stress and corresponding electromagnetic stress, microscopic piezoelectric stress, defect process stress and corresponding space radiation effect.

[0022] Preferably, in step S4, the stress magnitude after the internal stress is transmitted to the next level is less than 20% of the external stress as non-critical internal stress, and the external stress transmitted to TSV, micro solder joints, and RDL weak points is less than 20% of the internal stress as non-critical external stress; the selected key internal stress and external stress are simulated respectively, and the magnitude of sensitive stress covers at least 50%, 100%, 150% and 200% of the internal stress and external stress, and each internal stress, external stress or their combined stress is statistically analyzed to screen out nonlinear relationships within the range of 50% to 200% as key stresses of concern; the combination of internal stress caused by the application and external stress caused by the environment reaches 80% of the defect tolerance stress, which is selected as the defect-sensitive stress correspondence relationship.

[0023] Preferably, the stress transmission path and method in step S4 is:

[0024] S41: Internal stress paths are at the bare chip level, microcomponent level, device level, and board level.

[0025] S42: External stress pathways are board level, device level, microcomponent level, and bare chip level;

[0026] S43: The sensitive stress propagation paths S41 and S42 contain at least two levels, and the stress profiles at each level and between levels need to use the continuity law to eliminate stress singular points.

[0027] Preferably, in step S5, the method for comparing the failure margin and the sensitive stress intensity is:

[0028] S51: Comparison of failure margin and internal stress intensity;

[0029] S52: Comparison of failure margin and external stress intensity;

[0030] S53: Comparison of failure margin with superimposed internal stress and external stress intensity, i.e., comparison with superimposed vectors of internal and external stresses;

[0031] S54: The value closest to the defect activation energy among S51, S52, and S53 is taken as the trusted value.

[0032] Preferably, in step S6, the nondestructive testing data using X-rays and optical microscopes are inconsistent with the cross-section testing data, and simulation analysis is required; this step is used in S1 to S5 for data calibration between simulation and actual measurement.

[0033] The present invention proposes a failure analysis method for aerospace SIP components. Compared with the prior art, the present invention solves the failure analysis problem of aerospace SIP complex components. The present invention proposes a method for simulating a failure fault tree composed of failure modes. Through simulation, internal failed devices can be located and analyzed. By sorting out the failure modes by classification, a complete failure analysis fault tree is formed. Through design margin analysis and process analysis, the number of failure modes is reduced, and the complexity of analysis is reduced. Through the analysis path method of internal stress outward and external stress inward, and then the stress superposition method, the stress analysis effect of internal and external interaction is obtained, the relationship between internal and external stresses and defect margins is comprehensively superimposed, and a physical profile is prepared to obtain failure location and data. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0034] Figure 1 It is a failure analysis method for complex aerospace 3D SIP components; DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0035] The purpose of the present invention is to provide a method for failure analysis of aerospace SIP devices, which can realize failure analysis of 3DSIP devices for aerospace applications. It includes:

[0036] S1: Establish a failure fault tree and list the failure modes at different levels one by one;

[0037] S2: Simplify the failure fault tree established in step S1 to screen out possible failure modes 1 to n; perform analysis using design parameters, process monitoring parameters PCM and batch monitoring parameters LCM as boundaries; perform margin analysis on the design parameters of the bare chip level, micro-component level, tube and shell level and circuit level of the components, using design parameters and process analysis data as constraints;

[0038] S3: Perform boundary peak analysis on the two groups of parameters PCM and LCM in S2 to determine the failure modes and defect types corresponding to the parameters in the two groups that are close to or exceed the process control baseline, pair the failure modes with the environmental stress and working stress of the 3DSIP components for analysis, obtain the sensitive stress, and divide the sensitive stress into external stress and internal stress;

[0039] S4: Establish the sensitive stress profile and the sensitive stress transmission method and path, simulate the internal and external stress transmission of the failure mode selected in S2 and its corresponding sensitive stress according to the direction of sensitive stress propagation and at the chip level, micro-component level, device level, and board level, and form a sensitive stress distribution profile at each level; superimpose and calculate the internal stress distribution profile and the external stress distribution profile, and calibrate the sensitive stress intensity using the color-value correspondence relationship;

[0040] S5: According to the material failure activation energy, calculate the material failure activation energy and the difference between the defect energy level in the corresponding failure mode in the simplified failure fault tree in S2, record it as the failure margin, compare the failure margin with the sensitive stress intensity calibrated in S4, and determine the risk point position of the SIP device by the position of the peak value of the sensitive stress intensity in the SIP device;

[0041] S6: According to the sensitive stress intensity calibrated in S4 and the risk point position in S5, three-dimensional X-ray and optical microscope are used for non-destructive testing, and then the sample is prepared to form a cross section and the failure mode is confirmed by scanning electron microscope.

[0042] According to an embodiment of the present invention, in step S1, a failure fault tree of a 3D SIP device is established hierarchically based on past failure cases and a failure database. Failure faults at different levels and failure faults at interfaces between different levels are divided according to the assembly order of the bare chip level, micro-component level, tube shell level and circuit level. The failure faults of the multi-layer failure fault tree from 1 to n that need to be established are:

[0043] S11: First-level mechanical, electrical, thermal, electromagnetic, and optical failure modes;

[0044] S12: Secondary shock, vibration, voltage / current failure, high temperature, low temperature, high and low temperature cycle, and electromagnetic field failure modes;

[0045] S13: The three-level thermoelectric failure mode, thermoelectric failure mode, interface thermal failure mode, chip and stack structure coupling, electromagnetic field interaction, thermal-vacuum, and space particle effect combined stress mode are used as fault tree branches.

[0046] According to one embodiment of the present invention, in step S2, the design parameters, process monitoring parameters PCM and batch monitoring parameters LCM are used as boundaries for analysis; the design parameters at the bare chip level, micro-component level, tube shell level and circuit level of the components are subjected to margin analysis, and the design parameters and process analysis data are used as constraints to screen out possible failure modes 1 to n;

[0047] The design parameter changes for each level of bare chip level, micro-component level, tube and shell level and circuit level are ±A1%, ±A2%, ±A3%, ±A4%, and the parameter change rate of SIP components specified in the detailed product specifications and the agreement between the research and user parties is ±B%. The key item of margin analysis is the ratio of the change value of a single item or multiple items among ±A1%, ±A2%, ±A3%, ±A4% and the required value of the research and user parties ±A n / B.

[0048] According to an embodiment of the present invention, the PCM and LCM parameters in step S2 need to include the structure of the traditional chip-level test, the component daisy chain, and the stacked packaging process.

[0049] According to one embodiment of the present invention, in step S3, parameters approaching or exceeding the process control baseline are determined as sensitive parameters of the corresponding failure mode, and the sensitive parameters include at least the static and / or dynamic resistance of the silicon via and / or the solder ball daisy chain, the interconnect layer resistance of the ceramic substrate, and the leakage current of the silicon via.

[0050] According to an embodiment of the present invention, in step S3, the external stress includes direct mechanical stress and corresponding electrothermal stress, direct electrical stress and corresponding electromagnetic stress, microscopic piezoelectric stress, defect process stress and corresponding space radiation effect.

[0051] According to one embodiment of the present invention, in step S4, the stress magnitude after the internal stress is transmitted to the next level is less than 20% of the external stress as non-critical internal stress, and the external stress transmitted to TSV, micro solder joints, and RDL weak points is less than 20% of the internal stress as non-critical external stress; the selected key internal stress and external stress are simulated respectively, and the magnitude of sensitive stress covers at least 50%, 100%, 150% and 200% of the internal stress and external stress, and each internal stress, external stress or their combined stress is statistically analyzed to screen out nonlinear relationships within the range of 50% to 200% as key focus stress; the combination of internal stress caused by application and external stress caused by environment reaches 80% of the defect tolerance stress, which is selected as the defect-sensitive stress correspondence relationship.

[0052] According to one embodiment of the present invention, the stress transmission path and method in step S4 is:

[0053] S41: Internal stress paths are at the bare chip level, microcomponent level, device level, and board level.

[0054] S42: External stress pathways are board level, device level, microcomponent level, and bare chip level;

[0055] S43: The sensitive stress propagation paths S41 and S42 contain at least two levels, and the stress profiles at each level and between levels need to use the continuity law to eliminate stress singular points.

[0056] According to an embodiment of the present invention, in step S5, the method for comparing the failure margin and the sensitive stress intensity is:

[0057] S51: Comparison of failure margin and internal stress intensity;

[0058] S52: Comparison of failure margin and external stress intensity;

[0059] S53: Comparison of failure margin with superimposed internal stress and external stress intensity, i.e., comparison with superimposed vectors of internal and external stresses;

[0060] S54: The value closest to the defect activation energy among S51, S52, and S53 is taken as the trusted value.

[0061] According to one embodiment of the present invention, in step S6, the nondestructive testing data using X-rays and optical microscopes are inconsistent with the cross-sectional testing data and simulation analysis is required; this step is used in S1 to S5 for data calibration between simulation and actual measurement.

[0062] The present invention proposes a failure analysis method for aerospace SIP components. Compared with the prior art, the present invention solves the failure analysis problem of aerospace SIP complex components. The present invention proposes a method for simulating a failure fault tree composed of failure modes. Through simulation, internal failed devices can be located and analyzed. By sorting out the failure modes by classification, a complete failure analysis fault tree is formed. Through design margin analysis and process analysis, the number of failure modes is reduced, and the complexity of analysis is reduced. Through the analysis path method of internal stress outward and external stress inward, and then the stress superposition method, the stress analysis effect of internal and external interaction is obtained, the relationship between internal and external stresses and defect margins is comprehensively superimposed, and a physical profile is prepared to obtain failure location and data.

[0063] The various embodiments in this specification are described in a progressive manner. Professionals may further realize that the steps described in conjunction with the embodiments disclosed herein can be implemented in hardware, program methods, or a combination of the two. In order to clearly illustrate the interchangeability of hardware and software, the composition and steps of each example have been generally described in the above description according to function. Whether these functions are performed by hardware or software methods depends on the specific application and design constraints of the technical solution. Professionals and technicians may use different methods to implement the described functions for each specific application, but such implementation should not be considered to be beyond the scope of the present invention.

[0064] Obviously, those skilled in the art can make various changes and modifications to the invention without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention. Thus, if these modifications and variations of the invention fall within the scope of the claims of the invention and their equivalents, the invention is also intended to include these modifications and variations.

Claims

1. A 3D SIP component failure analysis method, characterized in that: Includes steps: S1: Establish a failure fault tree and list the failure modes at different levels one by one; S2: Simplify the failure fault tree established in step S1 to screen out possible failure modes 1 to n; perform analysis using design parameters, process monitoring parameters PCM and batch monitoring parameters LCM as boundaries; Conduct margin analysis on the design parameters of components at the bare chip level, micro-assembly level, tube and shell level, and circuit level, using design parameters and process analysis data as constraints; S3: Perform boundary peak analysis on the two groups of parameters PCM and LCM in S2 to determine the failure modes and defect types corresponding to the parameters in the two groups that are close to or exceed the process control baseline, pair the failure modes with the environmental stress and working stress of the 3DSIP components for analysis, obtain the sensitive stress, and divide the sensitive stress into external stress and internal stress; S4: Establish the sensitive stress profile and the sensitive stress transmission method and path, simulate the internal and external stress transmission of the failure mode selected in S2 and its corresponding sensitive stress according to the direction of sensitive stress propagation and at the chip level, micro-component level, device level, and board level, and form a sensitive stress distribution profile at each level; superimpose and calculate the internal stress distribution profile and the external stress distribution profile, and calibrate the sensitive stress intensity using the color-value correspondence relationship; S5: According to the material failure activation energy, calculate the material failure activation energy and the difference between the defect energy level in the corresponding failure mode in the simplified failure fault tree in S2, record it as the failure margin, compare the failure margin with the sensitive stress intensity calibrated in S4, and determine the risk point position of the SIP device by the position of the peak value of the sensitive stress intensity in the SIP device; S6: According to the sensitive stress intensity calibrated in S4 and the risk point position in S5, three-dimensional X-ray and optical microscope are used for non-destructive testing, and then the sample is prepared to form a cross section and the failure mode is confirmed by scanning electron microscope.

2. The 3D SIP component failure analysis method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S1, based on previous failure cases and failure database, a failure fault tree of 3D SIP device is established hierarchically. The failure faults of different levels and the failure faults of interfaces between different levels are divided according to the assembly order of bare chip level, micro-component level, tube shell level and circuit level. The failure faults of 1 to n multi-layer failure fault trees need to be established: S11: First-level mechanical, electrical, thermal, electromagnetic, and optical failure modes; S12: Secondary shock, vibration, voltage / current failure, high temperature, low temperature, high and low temperature cycle, and electromagnetic field failure modes; S13: The three-level thermoelectric failure mode, thermoelectric failure mode, interface thermal failure mode, chip and stack structure coupling, electromagnetic field interaction, thermal-vacuum, and space particle effect combined stress mode are used as fault tree branches.

3. The 3D SIP component failure analysis method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S2, design parameters, process monitoring parameters PCM and batch monitoring parameters LCM are used as boundaries for analysis; Conduct margin analysis on the design parameters of components at the bare chip level, micro-assembly level, tube and shell level, and circuit level, and use the design parameters and process analysis data as constraints to screen out possible failure modes 1 to n; The design parameter changes for each level of bare chip level, micro-component level, tube and shell level and circuit level are ±A1%, ±A2%, ±A3%, ±A4%, and the parameter change rate of SIP components specified in the detailed product specifications and the agreement between the research and user parties is ±B%. The key item of margin analysis is the ratio of the change value of a single item or multiple items among ±A1%, ±A2%, ±A3%, ±A4% and the required value of the research and user parties ±A n / B.

4. The 3D SIP component failure analysis method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The PCM and LCM parameters in step S2 need to include the traditional chip-level test structure, the component daisy chain, and the structure of the stacked packaging process parts.

5. The 3D SIP component failure analysis method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S3, parameters approaching or exceeding the process control baseline are determined as sensitive parameters of the corresponding failure mode, and the sensitive parameters at least include static and / or dynamic resistance of the silicon via and / or solder ball daisy chain, interconnect layer resistance of the ceramic substrate, and leakage current of the silicon via.

6. The 3D SIP component failure analysis method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S3, the external stress includes direct mechanical stress and corresponding electrothermal stress, direct electrical stress and corresponding electromagnetic stress, microscopic piezoelectric stress, defect process stress and corresponding space radiation effect.

7. The 3D SIP component failure analysis method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S4, the stress level after the internal stress is transferred to the next level is less than 20% of the external stress, which is a non-critical internal stress, and the external stress transferred to the TSV, micro solder joints, and RDL weak points is less than 20% of the internal stress, which is a non-critical external stress; The selected key internal stresses and external stresses are simulated respectively, and the magnitude of sensitive stresses covers at least 50%, 100%, 150% and 200% of the internal stresses and external stresses. Statistical analysis is performed on each internal stress, external stress or their combined stresses, and nonlinear relationships in the range of 50% to 200% are screened out as key focus stresses; the combination of internal stress caused by application and external stress caused by environment reaches 80% of the defect tolerance stress and is selected as the defect-sensitive stress correspondence relationship.

8. The 3D SIP component failure analysis method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The stress transmission path and method in step S4 are: S41: Internal stress paths are at the bare chip level, microcomponent level, device level, and board level. S42: External stress pathways are board level, device level, microcomponent level, and bare chip level; S43: The sensitive stress propagation paths S41 and S42 contain at least two levels, and the stress profiles at each level and between levels need to use the continuity law to eliminate stress singular points.

9. The 3D SIP component failure analysis method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S5, the method for comparing the failure margin and the sensitive stress intensity is: S51: Comparison of failure margin and internal stress intensity; S52: Comparison of failure margin and external stress intensity; S53: Comparison of failure margin with superimposed internal stress and external stress intensity, i.e., comparison with superimposed vectors of internal and external stresses; S54: The value closest to the defect activation energy among S51, S52, and S53 is taken as the trusted value.

10. The 3D SIP component failure analysis method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S6, the nondestructive testing data obtained by using X-rays and optical microscopes are inconsistent with the cross-section testing data, and simulation analysis is required; this step is used in S1 to S5 for data calibration between simulation and actual measurement.