Urban power system toughness evaluation method based on earthquake disasters
By adopting multi-dimensional indicators and CRITIC-entropy weight method in urban power systems, the problems of inaccurate evaluation and insufficient multi-dimensional research in the existing technology are solved, and quantitative evaluation and resilience enhancement of seismic resistance of urban power systems are achieved. Recommendations improve the practicality and generalizability of the evaluation.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411051596.8
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-08-01
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-12
AI Technical Summary
The existing technology lacks specific analysis for different regions and scales when evaluating the seismic resistance of urban power systems, resulting in inaccurate evaluation results and insufficient multi-dimensional research, which makes it impossible to effectively promote resilience enhancement measures.
The urban power system resilience evaluation method is adopted based on earthquake disasters, and the indicators are evaluated through five dimensions: facilities, organization, economic, social and environmental indicator weights are calculated using the CRITIC-entropy weight method to provide quantitative urban power system resilience evaluation, and support Feasibility of actual data analysis and model.
Quantitative evaluation of power system toughness in earthquake scenarios in different regions has been achieved, avoiding the inaccuracy of simulation, providing specific resilience enhancement suggestions, supporting urban-scale policy formulation, and improving the practicality and popularization of the assessment.
Smart Images

Figure CN118940958A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of urban power system resilience evaluation, and in particular to an urban power system resilience evaluation method based on earthquake disasters. Background Art
[0002] In modern society, electricity has penetrated into all fields and has become an important driving force for social progress. The power system is an important support for industries such as industrial production, infrastructure construction and information technology. It has a significant impact on the country's economic development and people's quality of life. It is also an important support for national defense construction. The destruction of the power system will bring serious impacts and losses. One of the important influencing factors is natural disasters. Compared with other factors, the number of households affected by power outages under natural disasters is usually higher. Earthquake disasters are particularly damaging to the power system due to their suddenness, destructive power, wide impact and strong chain reaction. It is particularly important to quantify the response capabilities of the power system under the influence of urban earthquakes and improve the earthquake resistance of the power system.
[0003] At present, scholars' current research methods on power system resilience are still insufficient. First, most methods are to build simulation models to simulate and assess the power system's disasters. This method lacks analysis of real data, and the power system structure and disaster impacts in different regions are different. Based entirely on simulation, the results will be inaccurate, and the relevant assessment methods or resilience enhancement measures will not be effectively promoted to actual areas. Therefore, it is lacking in practicality. Secondly, it is necessary to study the resilience of the power system from different perspectives, dimensions and scales (such as urban scale) so that areas with low resilience of the power system can be found and more specific suggestions can be provided for enhancing the resilience of the power system. Compared with the micro scale, the impact of natural disasters on infrastructure in the regional scope is much greater and the scope is much wider. In other words, improving regional resilience is a prerequisite for improving small-scale resilience. Policies at the urban scale can solve the crisis caused by disasters. Compared with national and provincial policies, the formulation of urban policies can consider regional characteristics more, but current technology rarely considers the urban scale. Except for the micro scale, scholars have studied and constructed provincial and national evaluation indicator systems; for the study of power system resilience under multiple dimensions, there are also problems such as incomplete consideration of dimensions and the use of qualitative methods instead of quantitative calculations. Summary of the invention
[0004] 1. Technical issues to be resolved
[0005] In view of the deficiencies in the prior art, the present invention provides a method for evaluating the resilience of urban power systems based on earthquake disasters, which has the advantages of quantifying the resilience of power systems under earthquake scenarios in different regions, and solves the above-mentioned technical problems.
[0006] (II) Technical solution
[0007] To achieve the above object, the present invention provides the following technical solution: a method for evaluating the resilience of an urban power system based on earthquake disasters, comprising the following steps:
[0008] S1. Select dimensions and indicators for evaluating the resilience of urban power systems, including facility dimensions, organizational dimensions, economic dimensions, and social dimensions;
[0009] The facility dimension includes the following indicators: power supply reliability, voltage compliance rate, per capita electricity consumption, power generation self-sufficiency rate, installed capacity, annual utilization hours, road network density, village access road hardening rate and observation station density;
[0010] The organizational dimension includes the following indicators: the proportion of correct earthquake warnings, the city's scientific and technological innovation index, the power-related frequency of earthquake emergency plans, the proportion of employees in urban units in the power industry, and the size of employees in urban units in the power industry;
[0011] The economic dimension includes the following indicators: the proportion of secondary industry GDP in total GDP, per capita GDP, per capita disposable income, direct economic losses from earthquakes, year-on-year growth rates of fixed asset investment and electricity GDP supply;
[0012] The social dimension includes the following indicators: Internet penetration rate, user density, urbanization rate, proportion of ethnic minorities, proportion of people with higher education, and average years of education;
[0013] The environmental dimension includes the following indicators: average elevation, topographic relief, average slope, number of days with abnormal temperature per year, number of days with abnormal rainfall per year, and number of earthquakes;
[0014] S2. Calculate the weight of each indicator in step S1 using the CRITIC-entropy weight method, and calculate the comprehensive score of the city;
[0015] S3. Analyze the spatial distribution of earthquake-power system resilience in each city.
[0016] As a preferred technical solution of the present invention, the specific process of step S2 is as follows:
[0017] S2.1, standardize the data in step S1;
[0018] S2.2, use the entropy method to calculate the weight of the jth indicator;
[0019] S2.3, use the critic method to calculate the weight of the jth indicator;
[0020] S2.4, calculate the combined weight for the jth item;
[0021] S2.5. Calculate the comprehensive score of the i-th city.
[0022] As a preferred technical solution of the present invention, the calculation expression of the standardization processing in step S2.1 is as follows:
[0023]
[0024] Among them, x ij represents the jth indicator of the i-th city, Y ij represents the jth index of the ith city after standardization, x j 、min(x j )、max(x j ) represent the j-th index, the minimum value of the j-th index, and the maximum value of the j-th index respectively.
[0025] As a preferred technical solution of the present invention, the specific expression for calculating the weight of the j-th indicator using the entropy method in step S2.2 is as follows:
[0026]
[0027] Where n represents the number of evaluation indicators, W1 represents the weight of the jth indicator calculated using the entropy method, and E j represents the information entropy of the j-th indicator, Indicates the sum of n data, E j The specific expression is as follows:
[0028]
[0029] Among them, Z ij represents the proportion of the i-th city in the j-th indicator, ln* represents the logarithmic function with a natural constant as the base, m represents the number of cities evaluated, and Z ij The expression is as follows:
[0030]
[0031] Among them, Y ij represents the jth index of the i-th city after standardization;
[0032] The specific expression for calculating the index weight using the critic method in step S2.3 is as follows:
[0033]
[0034] Among them, W2 represents the weight of the critic method to calculate the index, C j It represents the information content of the j-th index, and its expression is as follows:
[0035]
[0036] Among them, r ij represents the correlation coefficient between the jth indicator of the i-th city, σ j It represents the standard deviation of the j-th index after dimensionless conversion;
[0037] The combined weight expression of the j-th indicator in step S2.4 is as follows:
[0038] W j =βW1+(1-β)W2
[0039] Among them, W j represents the combined weight of the j-th indicator, W1 represents the weight of the j-th indicator calculated using the entropy method, W2 represents the weight of the j-th indicator calculated using the critic method, and β represents the proportion of the weight calculated by the entropy weight method in the combined weight.
[0040] As a preferred technical solution of the present invention, the expression of the comprehensive score of the i-th city in step S2.5 is as follows:
[0041]
[0042] Among them, R i represents the comprehensive score of the ith city, W j represents the combined weight of the jth indicator, x ij represents the jth index of the i-th city, Indicates the sum of m data.
[0043] As a preferred technical solution of the present invention, the calculation expression for analyzing the spatial distribution of earthquake-power system resilience of each city in step S3 is as follows:
[0044]
[0045] Where I represents the Moran'I index, X a ,X b are the power system resilience indexes in the ath and bth evaluated cities, respectively. represents the average resilience of the power system of all evaluated cities, W ab represents the spatial weight matrix, S represents the sum of the elements of the spatial weight matrix, and N represents the total number of evaluated cities.
[0046] Compared with the prior art, the present invention provides a method for evaluating the resilience of urban power systems based on earthquake disasters, which has the following beneficial effects:
[0047] The present invention considers the earthquake-power system resilience assessment in five dimensions: facilities, organization, society, economy, and environment. It adopts objective real data, and all data are quantifiable and easy to obtain. The CRITIC-entropy weight method is used to calculate the indicator weights and results to avoid the unreliability caused by subjective judgment. Actual data and cases are used for analysis, which supports the feasibility of the assessment model and provides a method for the calculation of future power system resilience assessment. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0048] Figure 1 It is a schematic diagram of the overall structure of the present invention;
[0049] Figure 2 It is a schematic diagram of the indicator pointing framework of the present invention;
[0050] Figure 3 This is a schematic diagram of the resilience of the power systems in various dimensions of 45 cities in the present invention;
[0051] Figure 4 This is a schematic diagram of the spatial distribution of the facility dimension resilience of the present invention;
[0052] Figure 5 This is a schematic diagram of the spatial distribution of toughness in the organizational dimension of the present invention;
[0053] Figure 6 This is a schematic diagram of the spatial distribution of resilience in the economic dimension of the present invention;
[0054] Figure 7 This is a schematic diagram of the spatial distribution of resilience in the social dimension of the present invention;
[0055] Figure 8 This is a schematic diagram of the spatial distribution of toughness in the environmental dimension of the present invention;
[0056] Fig. 9 This is a schematic diagram of the spatial distribution of comprehensive toughness of the present invention;
[0057] Fig.10 This is a schematic diagram of the earthquake-power system resilience aggregation of the present invention;
[0058] Fig.11 It is a schematic diagram of the process of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0059] The following will be combined with the drawings in the embodiments of the present invention to clearly and completely describe the technical solutions in the embodiments of the present invention. Obviously, the described embodiments are only part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the scope of protection of the present invention.
[0060] See also Figure 1 - Fig.11 , a method for evaluating the resilience of an urban power system based on earthquake disasters, comprising the following steps:
[0061] S1. Select dimensions and indicators for evaluating the resilience of urban power systems, including facility dimensions, organizational dimensions, economic dimensions, and social dimensions;
[0062] The facility dimension includes the following indicators: power supply reliability, voltage compliance rate, per capita electricity consumption, power generation self-sufficiency rate, installed capacity, annual utilization hours, road network density, village access road hardening rate and observation station density;
[0063] The organizational dimension includes the following indicators: the proportion of correct earthquake warnings, the city's scientific and technological innovation index, the power-related frequency of earthquake emergency plans, the proportion of employees in urban units in the power industry, and the size of employees in urban units in the power industry;
[0064] The economic dimension includes the following indicators: the proportion of secondary industry GDP in total GDP, per capita GDP, per capita disposable income, direct economic losses from earthquakes, year-on-year growth rates of fixed asset investment and electricity GDP supply;
[0065] The social dimension includes the following indicators: Internet penetration rate, user density, urbanization rate, proportion of ethnic minorities, proportion of people with higher education, and average years of education;
[0066] The environmental dimension includes the following indicators: average elevation, topographic relief, average slope, number of days with abnormal temperature per year, number of days with abnormal rainfall per year, and number of earthquakes;
[0067] The relevant data of earthquakes with a magnitude of 5 or above on the Richter scale during the period of rapid urbanization expansion in China from 2018 to 2023 were collected, and 45 Chinese cities where the earthquakes occurred were selected as implementation cases of the present invention. According to the E-PRI framework (Table 1) designed by this technology, data were collected from the "Statistical Communiqué of National Economic and Social Development" of each city, the "National Power Supply Reliability Index Report of Prefectural-level Administrative Regions", the statistical yearbooks of various provinces over the years, the China Earthquake Networks Center, the China Earthquake Early Warning Network, the Weather Network, the seventh census of each city, the official website of each city government, and the ASTERGlobalDigitalElevationModelV003 data;
[0068] Table 1 Power system resilience assessment index framework based on earthquake scenarios
[0069]
[0070]
[0071] In the table, “+” indicates a positive indicator and “-” indicates a negative indicator;
[0072] S2. Calculate the weight of each indicator in step S1 using the CRITIC-entropy weight method, and calculate the comprehensive score of the city;
[0073] S2.1, standardize the data in step S1;
[0074] The calculation expression for standardization is as follows:
[0075]
[0076] Among them, x ij represents the jth indicator of the i-th city, Y ij represents the jth index of the ith city after standardization, x j 、min(x j )、max(x j ) represent the j-th index, the minimum value of the j-th index, and the maximum value of the j-th index respectively.
[0077] S2.2, use the entropy method to calculate the weight of the jth indicator;
[0078] The specific expression for calculating the weight of the jth indicator using the entropy method is as follows:
[0079]
[0080] Where n represents the number of evaluation indicators, W1 represents the weight of the jth indicator calculated using the entropy method, and E j represents the information entropy of the j-th indicator, Indicates the sum of n data, E j The specific expression is as follows:
[0081]
[0082] Among them, Z ij represents the proportion of the i-th city under the j-th indicator, ln* represents the logarithmic function with natural constant as the base, and calculates the information entropy value E of each indicator j The smaller the information entropy, the greater the discreteness of the indicator, the more information it contains, and the greater the weight it is given. m represents the number of cities evaluated, and Z ij The expression is as follows:
[0083]
[0084] Among them, Y ij represents the jth index of the i-th city after standardization;
[0085] S2.3, use the critic method to calculate the weight of the jth indicator;
[0086] The specific expression for calculating the indicator weight using the critic method is as follows:
[0087]
[0088] Among them, W2 represents the weight of the critic method to calculate the index, C j It represents the information content of the j-th index, and its expression is as follows:
[0089]
[0090] Among them, σ j represents the standard deviation of the jth index after dimensionless conversion, r ij The correlation coefficient between the jth indicators of the i-th city is expressed. The more positive the correlation is, the less information it contains and the smaller the weight is. This step can effectively eliminate the influence of the strong correlation between the indicators of the E-PRI model.
[0091] S2.4, calculate the combined weight for the jth item;
[0092] The combined weight expression of the j-th indicator is as follows:
[0093] W j =βW1+(1-β)W2
[0094] Among them, W j represents the combined weight of the jth indicator, W1 represents the weight of the jth indicator calculated using the entropy method, W2 represents the weight of the jth indicator calculated using the critic method, and β represents the proportion of the weight calculated by the entropy weight method in the combined weight. Assuming that the entropy weight method and the critic method are equally important, β = 0.5;
[0095] S2.5. Calculate the comprehensive score of the i-th city;
[0096] The expression of the comprehensive score of the i-th city is as follows:
[0097]
[0098] Among them, R i represents the comprehensive score of the ith city, W j represents the combined weight of the jth indicator, x ij represents the jth index of the i-th city, Indicates the sum of m data;
[0099] S3. Analyze the spatial distribution of earthquake-power system resilience in each city;
[0100] The local autocorrelation index is used to reveal the degree of spatial correlation between different cities, thereby clarifying the spatial distribution pattern of earthquake-power system resilience in each city. The calculation expression for analyzing the spatial distribution of earthquake-power system resilience in each city is as follows:
[0101]
[0102] Where I represents the Moran'I index, X a ,X b are the power system resilience indexes in the ath and bth evaluated cities, respectively. represents the average resilience of the power system of all evaluated cities, W ab represents the spatial weight matrix, S represents the sum of the elements of the spatial weight matrix, and N represents the total number of evaluated cities. Indicates the sum of N data.
[0103] Using the method proposed in this invention, the power system resilience of 45 cities can be successfully calculated, and the resilience can be divided into sub-resilience under five dimensions, making it easier to analyze the performance of different cities in different dimensions. At the same time, the power system resilience can also be compared between cities;
[0104] The proposed method can be successfully used in 45 cities in China, and can also be used in cities with high earthquake incidence in other countries or regions. In addition, the method can be decomposed into five dimensions of sub-resilience calculation ( Figure 3 ), the quantitative data can be clearly obtained, which is conducive to comparative analysis; the calculation results can also be linked to the spatial distribution, sub-dimension or overall to obtain the toughness weak area ( Figure 4-Figure 9 ); After obtaining the calculation results and spatial distribution, the local spatial autocorrelation method can be used for further analysis ( Fig.10 ). In general, after carrying out example calculations, the urban power system resilience evaluation model based on earthquake disasters proposed in the present invention demonstrates its practicability and scalability.
[0105] Although embodiments of the present invention have been shown and described, it will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that various changes, modifications, substitutions and variations may be made to the embodiments without departing from the principles and spirit of the present invention, and that the scope of the present invention is defined by the appended claims and their equivalents.
Claims
1. A method for evaluating the resilience of urban power systems based on earthquake disasters, characterized by: The following steps are involved: S1. Select dimensions and indicators for evaluating the resilience of urban power systems, including facility dimensions, organizational dimensions, economic dimensions, and social dimensions; The facility dimension includes the following indicators: power supply reliability, voltage compliance rate, per capita electricity consumption, power generation self-sufficiency rate, installed capacity, annual utilization hours, road network density, village access road hardening rate and observation station density; The organizational dimension includes the following indicators: the proportion of correct earthquake warnings, the city's scientific and technological innovation index, the power-related frequency of earthquake emergency plans, the proportion of employees in urban units in the power industry, and the size of employees in urban units in the power industry; The economic dimension includes the following indicators: the proportion of secondary industry GDP in total GDP, per capita GDP, per capita disposable income, direct economic losses from earthquakes, year-on-year growth rates of fixed asset investment and electricity GDP supply; The social dimension includes the following indicators: Internet penetration rate, user density, urbanization rate, proportion of ethnic minorities, proportion of people with higher education, and average years of education; The environmental dimension includes the following indicators: average elevation, topographic relief, average slope, number of days with abnormal temperature per year, number of days with abnormal rainfall per year, and number of earthquakes; S2. Calculate the weight of each indicator in step S1 using the CRITIC-entropy weight method, and calculate the comprehensive score of the city; S3. Analyze the spatial distribution of earthquake-power system resilience in each city.
2. The urban power system resilience evaluation method based on earthquake disasters according to claim 1 is characterized by: The specific process of step S2 is as follows: S2.1, standardize the data in step S1; S2.2, use the entropy method to calculate the weight of the jth indicator; S2.3, use the critic method to calculate the weight of the jth indicator; S2.4, calculate the combined weight for the jth item; S2.
5. Calculate the comprehensive score of the i-th city.
3. The urban power system resilience evaluation method based on earthquake disasters according to claim 2 is characterized by: The calculation expression of the normalization process in step S2.1 is as follows: Among them, x ij represents the jth index of the i-th city, Yij represents the jth index of the i-th city after standardization, and x j 、min(x j )、max(x j ) represent the j-th index, the minimum value of the j-th index, and the maximum value of the j-th index respectively.
4. The urban power system resilience evaluation method based on earthquake disasters according to claim 3 is characterized by: The specific expression for calculating the weight of the j-th indicator using the entropy method in step S2.2 is as follows: Where n represents the number of evaluation indicators, W1 represents the weight of the jth indicator calculated using the entropy method, and E j represents the information entropy of the j-th indicator, Indicates the sum of n data, E j The specific expression is as follows: Among them, Z ij represents the proportion of the i-th city in the j-th indicator, ln* represents the logarithmic function with a natural constant as the base, m represents the number of cities evaluated, and Z ij The expression is as follows: Among them, Y ij represents the jth index of the i-th city after standardization; The specific expression for calculating the index weight using the critic method in step S2.3 is as follows: Among them, W2 represents the weight of the critic method to calculate the index, C j It represents the information content of the j-th index, and its expression is as follows: Among them, r ij represents the correlation coefficient between the jth indicator of the i-th city, σ j It represents the standard deviation of the j-th index after dimensionless conversion; The combined weight expression of the j-th indicator in step S2.4 is as follows: W j =βW1+(1-β)W2 Among them, W j represents the combined weight of the j-th indicator, W1 represents the weight of the j-th indicator calculated using the entropy method, W2 represents the weight of the j-th indicator calculated using the critic method, and β represents the proportion of the weight calculated by the entropy weight method in the combined weight.
5. The urban power system resilience evaluation method based on earthquake disasters according to claim 4 is characterized by: The expression of the comprehensive score of the i-th city in step S2.5 is as follows: Among them, R i represents the comprehensive score of the ith city, W j represents the combined weight of the jth indicator, x ij represents the jth index of the i-th city, Indicates the sum of m data.
6. The urban power system resilience evaluation method based on earthquake disasters according to claim 1 is characterized by: The calculation expression for analyzing the spatial distribution of earthquake-power system resilience in each city in step S3 is as follows: Where I represents the Moran'I index, X a ,X b are the power system resilience indexes in the ath and bth evaluated cities, respectively. represents the average resilience of the power system of all evaluated cities, W ab represents the spatial weight matrix, S represents the sum of the elements of the spatial weight matrix, and N represents the total number of evaluated cities.
Citation Information
Cited By
Method and system for determining earthquake damage toughness of commercial power system based on multi-dimensional data analysis
CN120875287A
Urban power grid toughness evaluation method fusing public safety influence
CN121332459A
