Strain monitoring and fatigue life evaluation method for high-temperature pressure-bearing equipment
Through the pasted high-temperature strain gauge and finite element simulation model, combined with accelerated deterioration experiments, the accuracy of internal strain monitoring and fatigue life evaluation of high-temperature pressure-bearing equipment is solved, and the structural damage monitoring and life evaluation of high-temperature equipment is realized, and the monitoring is improved. accuracy and durability.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202310601665.7
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-26
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-26
AI Technical Summary
The prior art is difficult to effectively monitor the internal strain conditions of high-temperature pressure-bearing equipment and conduct fatigue life assessment, resulting in insufficient monitoring and insufficient accuracy of the results.
The adhesive high-temperature strain gauge is used, and the stress hazardous parts are calculated through the finite element simulation model, and combined with the accelerated deterioration experimental results of the materials in the service state of the equipment, the high-temperature fatigue life evaluation is achieved. The specific steps include establishing an equal-scale finite element simulation model, pasting a strain gauge, calculating the real strain, conducting high-temperature fatigue performance testing, accurately calculating stress and strain, and finally evaluating fatigue loss and remaining life.
The accuracy of structural damage monitoring and fatigue life evaluation of high-temperature pressure-bearing equipment is achieved, local residual stress caused by welding strain gauge is avoided, and the targetedness and durability of monitoring are improved.
Smart Images

Figure CN119022774A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention belongs to the technical field of pressure vessel monitoring and evaluation, and in particular relates to a method for strain monitoring and fatigue life evaluation of high-temperature pressure-bearing equipment. Background Art
[0002] High temperature pressure equipment is widely used in the petrochemical industry, and its failure often results in huge casualties and property losses. However, the service conditions of high temperature pressure equipment cannot be fully considered during design, resulting in a large deviation between its service life and design life. Therefore, it is necessary to conduct research on monitoring technology for high temperature pressure equipment.
[0003] In view of the high temperature working conditions, patent CN103363919A uses a fixed-focus camera and develops a non-contact pressure vessel creep monitoring method based on white light speckle. However, it cannot effectively monitor the parts with insulation layers.
[0004] For contact monitoring methods, patent CN112344870A invented a high-temperature resistant FBG strain sensor with temperature compensation. Invention patent CN102997041B relates to an online monitoring device for high-temperature pressure pipeline structural damage, which uses a welded high-temperature strain gauge and calculates the damage factor to reflect the equipment status. Invention patent CN114543891A invented a coke tower structural health monitoring system and method based on multiple failure modes, which uses adhesive high-temperature strain gauges to monitor its stress state changes in real time. Invention patent CN114881262A installs a high-temperature strain monitoring device for high-temperature pipelines, measures the stress of the pipeline, analyzes the stress conditions of pipe fittings and connecting equipment, and dynamically monitors pipeline changes.
[0005] In terms of life assessment, patent CN109870295A records and analyzes a large amount of temperature and pressure data, combines size-corrected metal detection data and microstructure detection results, and realizes creep-fatigue life assessment through algorithms pre-made in the computer.
[0006] The strain gauge is attached to the object to be measured, so that it expands and contracts with the strain of the object to be measured, so that the metal foil inside will extend or shorten with the strain, and the strain is measured by measuring the change in resistance. There are many varieties of strain gauges, which can provide customers with perfect strain measurement options in different measurement occasions, mainly including: ordinary, low temperature, high temperature, ultra-high temperature waterproof, composite materials, concrete, welding, welding waterproof, semiconductor, residual stress measurement, etc. The measurement temperature range is wide, from -269℃ to 800℃, and its application is becoming more and more popular.
[0007] The methods used in existing technologies are relatively complex and cannot all be effectively used for continuous monitoring. Even if the damage factor is calculated using high-temperature strain to reflect the equipment status, the result is not very accurate. Therefore, it is difficult to effectively monitor and conduct fatigue life assessment under internal strain conditions of high-temperature pressure-bearing equipment. Summary of the invention
[0008] The technical problem to be solved by the present invention is to provide a method for strain monitoring and fatigue life assessment of high-temperature pressure-bearing equipment, which realizes high-temperature damage monitoring of the structure through adhesive high-temperature strain gauges and a clear adhesive process, and then realizes fatigue life assessment of the equipment under high-temperature conditions through monitoring data of high-temperature strain gauges and combining the results of accelerated degradation experiments of materials under equipment service conditions. The technical solution adopted is:
[0009] A method for strain monitoring and fatigue life assessment of high temperature pressure equipment comprises the following steps:
[0010] (1) Establish a proportional finite element simulation model to calculate stress risk locations;
[0011] (2) Paste strain gauges at stress risk locations;
[0012] (3) Calculation of true material strain;
[0013] (4) Conduct accelerated degradation experiments under laboratory conditions and high-temperature fatigue performance tests according to the service temperature and service load of the material to obtain high-temperature fatigue performance data;
[0014] (5) Accurately calculate strains and stresses at stress-hazardous locations;
[0015] (6) Based on the results of steps (4) and (5), evaluate the fatigue loss and remaining life of the equipment.
[0016] As a further preference, in the step (1), a 1:1 structural model is established using Solidworks, and ABAQUS simulation calculation software is imported to calculate stress risk locations of the equipment.
[0017] As a further optimization, the model uses a thermo-elastoplastic model, uses a grid for refinement analysis, and uses ABAQUS simulation software to obtain the temperature field distribution and stress field distribution results of the equipment. The areas with large stress and strain changes are stress-hazardous areas.
[0018] As a further preference, in the step (2), when pasting the strain gauge, the stress-prone areas need to be surface pretreated.
[0019] As a further preferred embodiment, the surface pretreatment method is to grind the measured surface with a flap grinder to remove the surface rust layer, and then grind with 240-grit sandpaper in a 90° direction until the surface becomes frosted;
[0020] Apply a layer of high-temperature glue to the stress-hazardous area and cure it with a hot air gun;
[0021] Place the strain gauge on the cured high-temperature glue, apply the high-temperature glue to the back and surrounding area of the strain gauge, continue to cure with a hot air gun, and apply high-temperature protective glue after it is completely cured.
[0022] As a further preference, the curing temperature of the hot air gun is greater than the temperature when the equipment is in use, and each curing time is 5-6 hours.
[0023] As a further preference, in the step (2), after the strain gauge is pasted, the strain gauge lead and the data line are connected to a data acquisition instrument, and the data acquisition instrument converts the signal resistance change value into a strain value.
[0024] As a further preference, in step (3), according to the material used for the strain gauge, a thermal expansion instrument is used to carry out a thermal output performance test of the strain gauge grid material at different temperatures under laboratory conditions, and the thermal output relationship is:
[0025] ε T =43.16·T-467;
[0026] In the formula, ε T is heat output;
[0027] T is temperature, unit is °C;
[0028] Weld a thermocouple at the point where the strain gauge is attached to record the temperature change of the point to be measured in real time;
[0029] The strain value of the device in a stable state minus the heat output at the corresponding temperature is the true strain value of the device.
[0030] As a further preference, in step (4), the high temperature fatigue performance test is carried out by carrying out an accelerated fatigue test on an MTS fatigue testing machine to obtain fatigue SN curves of materials and strain risk locations, and the formula is:
[0031] S a =159·N -0.07 ;
[0032] Among them, S a is the stress range;
[0033] N is the number of cycles.
[0034] As a further preference, in the step (5), the strain and stress at the stress-hazardous part are accurately calculated, and the total strain measured by the strain gauge is subtracted from the heat output and then the thermal strain, which is the mechanical strain generated by the pressure load of the roasting furnace under high temperature conditions.
[0035] Formula S a =159·N -0.07 In, S a It can be calculated accurately, so the number of cycles can be calculated based on the SN curve. The service life can be obtained through the number of cycles.
[0036] Compared with the prior art, the present invention is beneficial in that:
[0037] When selecting the strain gauge pasting point, the present invention adopts finite element simulation model calculation, and pastes it at the stress and strain risk position, which is more targeted and more economical.
[0038] The present invention realizes high-temperature damage monitoring of the structure by using a bonded strain gauge and clarifying the bonding process. The high-temperature bonding can make the strain gauge better fit the equipment itself and have better durability, thereby avoiding the generation of local residual stress caused by unreasonable welding process of welded strain gauges.
[0039] The present invention realizes fatigue life assessment of equipment under high temperature state by monitoring data through strain gauges and combining the results of accelerated degradation experiments of materials under equipment service state;
[0040] The present invention further ensures the safe operation of the equipment during operation by carrying out status monitoring on high-temperature pressure-bearing equipment. It can be mainly applied to key equipment in large-scale petrochemical industry, and its service condition is high-temperature and pressure operation. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0041] Figure 1 The temperature field distribution and stress field distribution of the roasting furnace barrel in Example 1 of the present invention;
[0042] Figure 2 The strain data obtained by monitoring a certain operation cycle of the roasting furnace in Example 1 of the present invention;
[0043] Figure 3 is a thermal output performance curve of the strain gauge material in Example 1 of the present invention;
[0044] Figure 4 The temperature data obtained by monitoring a certain operation cycle of the roasting furnace in Example 1 of the present invention;
[0045] Figure 5 This is the SN curve of the welded joint of the roasting furnace material N08810 measured at 450°C in Example 1 of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0046] The drawings are for illustrative purposes only. To better illustrate the present embodiment, some parts of the drawings are omitted, enlarged or reduced, and do not represent the size of the actual product. The terms "upper", "lower", "left", "right", "side", "outer", etc. indicate directions or positional relationships based on the directions or positional relationships shown in the drawings, and are only for the convenience of describing the present invention and simplifying the description, and do not indicate or imply that the device or element referred to must have a specific direction, be constructed and operated in a specific direction, and therefore cannot be understood as a limitation on the present invention.
[0047] For those skilled in the art, some well-known structures and their descriptions in the drawings may be omitted, and therefore, they should not be understood as limitations of the present invention.
[0048] In order to make the technical means, creative features, objectives and effects of the present invention easy to understand, the present invention is further described in detail below in conjunction with the embodiments. It should be understood that the specific embodiments described herein are only used to explain the present invention and are not intended to limit the present invention.
[0049] Example 1
[0050] Take the petrochemical equipment roaster as an example. The roaster is one of the key equipment in the catalyst production process. The roaster cylinder is heated by an external heat source and the heat is transferred to the catalyst inside.
[0051] The design temperature of a roasting furnace cylinder is 500℃, and it operates under internal pressure with an operating pressure of about 1MPa.
[0052] One month is an operation cycle. The equipment experiences the following working conditions: heating-pressurization-continuous operation-pressure relief-cooling. The periodic start and stop of the roasting furnace seriously affects the service life of the equipment, so it is necessary to conduct strain monitoring and remaining life assessment for key parts (i.e. dangerous parts).
[0053] The method for strain monitoring and fatigue life assessment of a roasting furnace comprises the following steps:
[0054] (1) Calculation of strain gauge point selection.
[0055] like Figure 1 As shown, firstly, for the roasting furnace cylinder structure, a 1:1 structural model was established using Solidworks, and then imported into ABAQUS simulation calculation software for calculation.
[0056] According to the results of literature research, the density, elastic modulus, Poisson's ratio, yield stress, thermal expansion coefficient, specific heat, and heat conduction parameters of N08810 material from room temperature to 1000°C are obtained. For the transition area from the heating section to the insulation section, a grid transition is performed, and the number of grids in the thickness direction of the cylinder is set to 5.
[0057] A fixed constraint is applied at one end of the cylinder to limit the rigid displacement, while preventing the constraint from being too large and affecting the calculation results of the concerned parts. The heat source, convection, thermal radiation, and changes in internal pressure are taken into account for the calculation.
[0058] After finite element calculation, the results Figure 1 It can be found that there is a large stress concentration in the cylinder part from the heating area to the insulation section, and the affected range is about 20mm. This area should be the key monitoring area to obtain the areas with large stress and strain of complex structure pressure vessels for reference in selecting points for structural monitoring.
[0059] This area is a cylinder with a diameter of 1m and a length of 20mm. Considering that the entire cylinder of the roasting furnace is welded and spliced, special attention is paid to the welding parts and the cylinder in this area as stress risk areas.
[0060] (2) High temperature strain gauge pasting.
[0061] Remove the insulation layer to expose the part to be glued. Through finite element calculation, it can be determined that the axial strain of the weld and the part far from the weld is large, which can be used as the monitoring point.
[0062] First, use a lap disc grinder to grind the surface to be tested to remove burrs, rust and uneven pits on the surface. The grinding time is about 1 minute. Since the lap disc grinds too fast, it is easy to cause the surface to overheat. Therefore, after the lap disc is polished, use 240-grit sandpaper to grind in a 90° direction until the surface to be tested appears frosted.
[0063] Then use alcohol cotton balls to clean the surface abrasive particles and air dry them for later use. Then, in the area of about 5×5cm 2 Apply a layer of high-temperature ceramic glue and use a hot air gun for heating and curing. The curing temperature is controlled at about 550°C (greater than the equipment operating temperature of 500°C) and the curing time is 6 hours.
[0064] Use high temperature tape to fix the high temperature strain gauge on the cured high temperature ceramic glue, apply the high temperature ceramic glue on the strain gauge and the surrounding area, and use a hot air gun to cure it at a temperature of 300°C for 2 hours. Then remove the high temperature tape, apply the high temperature ceramic glue on the strain gauge and the surrounding area, and use a hot air gun to cure it at a temperature of 550°C for 6 hours.
[0065] The resistance value of the strain gauge was measured with a multimeter, which was about 133Ω, less than 200Ω, indicating that the grid wire of the strain gauge did not break during the curing process of the high-temperature glue. The strain gauge lead wire was soldered to the data connection line with an electric soldering iron, and the data connection line was connected to the data acquisition instrument using a 1 / 4 bridge method. The data acquisition instrument converted the resistance change of the strain gauge into a strain value and transmitted it to the computer.
[0066] The strain value during the entire start-stop cycle is as follows: Figure 2 As shown, the strain value is large, close to 20,000 microstrain, and includes the heat output of the strain gauge itself, which needs to be removed.
[0067] (3) Calculation of true material strain.
[0068] According to the material NiChromeV used for the strain gauge, a thermal expansion instrument was used to test the thermal output performance of the strain gauge grid material at different temperatures under laboratory conditions, such as Figure 3 At the same time, a K-type thermocouple is welded at the point where the strain gauge is pasted to record the temperature change of the point to be measured in real time.
[0069] like Figure 4 As shown, 450℃ is the thermally stable state. By using the temperature of 450℃ in the thermally stable state of the equipment, find Figure 3 The corresponding heat output. Figure 1 The strain value under steady state minus the heat output at the corresponding temperature is the true strain value of the equipment.
[0070] (4) Carry out accelerated degradation experiments on N08810 materials and welded joints under service conditions to obtain high-temperature fatigue performance data of materials and welded joints.
[0071] The design service temperature of the roasting furnace does not exceed 500 degrees Celsius, and the internal pressure is about 1MPa. According to the thermocouple temperature measurement results, the maximum temperature is about 450℃, so the high temperature fatigue performance test at 450℃ was carried out. According to the processing standards, the base material and welded joints were processed, and accelerated fatigue tests were carried out on the MTS fatigue testing machine with an experimental frequency of 1Hz.
[0072] Considering that this part is a welded joint, the influence of residual stress is inevitable. Usually for large equipment, the amplitude of residual stress is generally near the yield strength (260MPa), so the welding residual stress should be taken into account as the average stress. The SN curve of the material welded joint at 450℃ is obtained, such as Figure 5 As shown, the formula is:
[0073] S a =159·N -0.07 ;
[0074] Among them, S a is the stress range;
[0075] N is the number of cycles.
[0076] (5) Accurately calculate strains and stresses at key points.
[0077] According to the thermocouple temperature collection carried out in the early stage, the results of the finite element simulation model were compared, and it was found that the calculated results and the measured results had a deviation of about 50°C. The temperature deviation may be caused by the influence of thermal convection, thermal radiation coefficient and internal gas flow. Temperature correction was performed to improve the accuracy of thermal strain calculation. The total strain measured by the strain gauge, minus the heat output, and then minus the thermal strain, is the mechanical strain generated by the pressure load of the roasting furnace under high temperature conditions.
[0078] After calculation, the maximum strain of the parent material is 20 microstrain, and the maximum strain at the weld is 40 microstrain. Multiplying with the elastic modulus of 180GPa at 450℃, the stress at the parent material at 450℃ is 36MPa, and the stress at the weld is 72MPa. The error between the stress at the parent material and the finite element calculation result is within 10%, which meets the use requirements.
[0079] (6) Assessment of fatigue damage and remaining life of roasting furnace.
[0080] According to the SN curve of the material and the welded joint at 450°C, the corresponding fluctuating periodic stress range under the pressure load of 1MPa in the roasting furnace is 72MPa in the intact state. Substitute it into the formula S a =159·N -0.07 .
[0081] The corresponding cycle number N is calculated to be 77568.
[0082] Taking the start and stop once a month as an example, it is started 12 times a year, and the maximum calculated stress fluctuation range is estimated to be 72MPa. The cycle number N is divided by 12. The service life of the roasting furnace under extreme working conditions is much longer than 10 years, which meets the requirement of 10-year equipment use, and there is no need to consider anti-fatigue design.
[0083] Comparative Example 1
[0084] By spot welding the high-temperature strain gauge to the base metal of the roasting furnace, as a control group, the microstrain at the base metal was 16 microstrains and the stress was 29MPa, which was 27% more than the calculated result of 39.7MPa. The reason for this is that the spot welding of the high-temperature strain gauge cannot ensure that the strain gauge grid and the cylinder deform at the same time, so the error is large.
[0085] Example 2
[0086] For a certain roasting furnace, the cylinder design temperature is 500℃, the internal pressure is operated, and strain monitoring and remaining life assessment are carried out under the operating pressure of 1.5MPa.
[0087] (1) Calculation of strain gauge point selection.
[0088] Firstly, for the roasting furnace cylinder structure, a 1:1 structural model was established using Solidworks and then imported into ABAQUS simulation software for calculation.
[0089] According to the results of literature research, the density, elastic modulus, Poisson's ratio, yield stress, thermal expansion coefficient, specific heat, and heat conduction parameters of N08810 material from room temperature to 1000°C are obtained. For the transition area from the heating section to the insulation section, a grid transition is performed, and the number of grids in the thickness direction of the cylinder is 5.
[0090] A fixed constraint is applied at one end of the cylinder to limit the rigid displacement, while preventing the constraint from being too large and affecting the calculation results of the concerned parts. The heat source, convection, thermal radiation, and changes in internal pressure are taken into account for the calculation. After the finite element calculation, it can be found in the result cloud map that there is a large stress concentration in the cylinder part from the heating area to the insulation section, with an impact range of about 20mm. This area should be the focus of monitoring.
[0091] (2) High temperature strain gauge pasting.
[0092] Remove the insulation layer to expose the part to be pasted. Through finite element calculation, it can be determined that the axial strain of the weld and the part far from the weld is large, which is used as the monitoring point. First, use a thousand-blade grinder to grind the measured surface to remove surface burrs, rust layers and uneven pits. The grinding time is about 1 minute.
[0093] Since the lap disc grinding speed is too fast, it is easy to cause the surface to overheat. Therefore, after the lap disc is ground, use 240-grit sandpaper to grind at 90° until the surface to be tested appears frosted.
[0094] Then use alcohol cotton balls to clean the surface abrasive particles and air dry them for later use. Then, in the area of about 5×5cm 2 Apply a layer of high-temperature ceramic glue and use a hot air gun for heating and curing. The curing temperature is controlled at about 550°C (greater than the equipment operating temperature of 500°C) and the curing time is 6 hours.
[0095] The high-temperature strain gauge is fixed on the cured high-temperature ceramic adhesive with a high-temperature tape, and the high-temperature ceramic adhesive is coated on the strain gauge and the surrounding area. A hot air gun is used for curing. The curing temperature is 300°C and the curing time is 2 hours.
[0096] Then remove the high temperature tape, apply the high temperature ceramic glue to the strain gauge and the surrounding area, and use a hot air gun to cure it. The curing temperature is 550℃ and the curing time is 6 hours. Use a multimeter to measure the resistance value of the strain gauge. The resistance value is about 133Ω, which is less than 200Ω, indicating that the strain gauge grid wire did not break during the curing process of the high temperature glue. Use an electric soldering iron to solder the strain gauge lead wire to the data connection line, and the data connection line is connected to the data acquisition instrument. Using a 1 / 4 bridge method, the data acquisition instrument converts the resistance change of the strain gauge into a strain value and transmits it to the computer.
[0097] During the equipment shutdown period, the equipment was tested and the entire strain value of the equipment under normal temperature and pressure to high temperature and pressure was obtained through monitoring.
[0098] (3) Calculation of true material strain.
[0099] According to the material NiChromeV used for the strain gauge, a thermal expansion instrument was used to test the thermal output performance of the strain gauge grid material at different temperatures under laboratory conditions. The thermal output relationship is:
[0100] ε T =43.16·T-467;
[0101] In the formula, ε T is heat output;
[0102] T is temperature, unit is °C.
[0103] K-type thermocouples are welded at the points where the strain gauges are attached, and the temperature changes of the points to be measured are recorded in real time. The temperature of the equipment in the thermally stable state is 450°C. The strain value when the equipment is started from normal temperature and pressure to the stable state minus the heat output at the corresponding temperature is the true strain value of the equipment.
[0104] (4) Carry out accelerated degradation experiments on N08810 materials and welded joints under service conditions to obtain high-temperature fatigue performance data of materials and welded joints.
[0105] The design service temperature of the roasting furnace does not exceed 500 degrees Celsius, and the internal pressure is about 1MPa. According to the thermocouple temperature measurement results, the maximum temperature is about 450℃, so the high temperature fatigue performance test at 450℃ was carried out. According to the processing standards, the base material and welded joints were processed, and accelerated fatigue tests were carried out on the MTS fatigue testing machine with an experimental frequency of 1Hz.
[0106] Considering that this part is a welded joint, the influence of residual stress is inevitable. Usually for large equipment, the amplitude of residual stress is generally near the yield strength (260MPa), so welding residual stress should be taken into account as an average stress. The SN curve of the material and welded joint at 450℃ is obtained as follows:
[0107] S a =159·N -0.07 ;
[0108] Among them, S a is the stress range;
[0109] N is the number of cycles.
[0110] (5) Accurately calculate strains and stresses at key points.
[0111] The total strain measured by the strain gauge, minus the heat output, and then minus the thermal strain, is the mechanical strain generated by the pressure load of the roasting furnace under high temperature conditions. After calculation, the maximum strain of the parent material is 31 microstrains, and the maximum strain at the weld is 59 microstrains. Multiplying with the elastic modulus of 180GPa at 450℃, the stress at the parent material at 450℃ is 56MPa, and the stress at the weld is 106MPa. The error between the stress at the parent material and the finite element calculation result is within 10%, which meets the use requirements.
[0112] (6) Evaluation of fatigue damage and remaining life of the roasting furnace. In the intact state, the corresponding fluctuation periodic stress range of 106MPa under the pressure load of 1.5MPa of the roasting furnace corresponds to 251 cycles.
[0113] Taking the example of starting and stopping once a month, the number of starts and stops in a year is 12 times, and the maximum calculated stress fluctuation range is estimated to be 106MPa. The cycle number is 251 divided by 12. Under extreme working conditions, the roasting furnace can be used for 21 years, which meets the 10-year use requirement of the equipment.
[0114] Comparative Example 2
[0115] By spot welding the high temperature strain gauge to the base metal of the roasting furnace, as a control group, the micro strain at the base metal was 20 micro strains and the stress was 36 MPa, which was 39% more than the calculated result of 59.5 MPa. Therefore, the result has a large error.
[0116] Example 3
[0117] For a certain roasting furnace, the cylinder design temperature is 500℃, the internal pressure is operated, and strain monitoring and remaining life assessment are carried out under the operating pressure of 2.0MPa.
[0118] (1) Calculation of strain gauge point selection.
[0119] Firstly, for the roasting furnace cylinder structure, a 1:1 structural model was established using Solidworks and then imported into ABAQUS simulation software for calculation.
[0120] According to the results of literature research, the density, elastic modulus, Poisson's ratio, yield stress, thermal expansion coefficient, specific heat, and heat conduction parameters of N08810 material from room temperature to 1000°C are obtained. For the transition area from the heating section to the insulation section, a grid transition is performed, and the number of grids in the thickness direction of the cylinder is 5.
[0121] A fixed constraint is applied at one end of the cylinder to limit the rigid displacement, while preventing the constraint from being too large and affecting the calculation results of the concerned parts. The heat source, convection, thermal radiation, and changes in internal pressure are taken into account for the calculation. After the finite element calculation, it can be found in the result cloud map that there is a large stress concentration in the cylinder part from the heating area to the insulation section, with an impact range of about 20mm. This area should be the focus of monitoring.
[0122] (2) High temperature strain gauge pasting.
[0123] Remove the insulation layer to expose the part to be pasted. Through finite element calculation, it can be determined that the axial strain of the weld and the part far from the weld is large, which is used as the monitoring point. First, use a thousand-blade grinder to grind the measured surface to remove surface burrs, rust layers and uneven pits. The grinding time is about 2 minutes.
[0124] Since the lap disc grinding speed is too fast, it is easy to cause the surface to overheat. Therefore, after the lap disc is ground, use 240-grit sandpaper to grind at 90° until the surface to be tested appears frosted.
[0125] Then use alcohol cotton balls to clean the surface abrasive particles and air dry them for later use. Then, in the area of about 5×5cm 2 Apply a layer of high-temperature ceramic glue and use a hot air gun for heating and curing. The curing temperature is controlled at about 550°C (greater than the equipment operating temperature of 500°C) and the curing time is 6 hours.
[0126] The high-temperature strain gauge is fixed on the cured high-temperature ceramic adhesive with a high-temperature tape, and the high-temperature ceramic adhesive is coated on the strain gauge and the surrounding area. A hot air gun is used for curing. The curing temperature is 300°C and the curing time is 2 hours.
[0127] Then remove the high temperature tape, apply the high temperature ceramic glue to the strain gauge and the surrounding area, and use a hot air gun to cure it. The curing temperature is 550℃ and the curing time is 6 hours. Use a multimeter to measure the resistance value of the strain gauge. The resistance value is about 133Ω, which is less than 200Ω, indicating that the strain gauge grid wire did not break during the curing process of the high temperature glue. Use an electric soldering iron to solder the strain gauge lead wire to the data connection line, and the data connection line is connected to the data acquisition instrument. Using a 1 / 4 bridge method, the data acquisition instrument converts the resistance change of the strain gauge into a strain value and transmits it to the computer.
[0128] During the equipment shutdown period, the equipment was tested and the entire strain value of the equipment under normal temperature and pressure to high temperature and pressure was obtained through monitoring.
[0129] (3) Calculation of true material strain.
[0130] According to the material NiChromeV used for the strain gauge, a thermal expansion instrument was used to test the thermal output performance of the strain gauge grid material at different temperatures under laboratory conditions. The thermal output relationship is:
[0131] ε T =43.16·T-467;
[0132] In the formula, ε T is heat output;
[0133] T is temperature, unit is °C.
[0134] K-type thermocouples are welded at the points where the strain gauges are attached, and the temperature changes of the points to be measured are recorded in real time. The temperature of the equipment in the thermally stable state is 450°C. The strain value when the equipment is started from normal temperature and pressure to the stable state minus the heat output at the corresponding temperature is the true strain value of the equipment.
[0135] (4) Carry out accelerated degradation experiments on N08810 materials and welded joints under service conditions to obtain high-temperature fatigue performance data of materials and welded joints.
[0136] The design service temperature of the roasting furnace does not exceed 500 degrees Celsius, and the internal pressure is about 1MPa. According to the thermocouple temperature measurement results, the maximum temperature is about 450℃, so the high temperature fatigue performance test at 450℃ was carried out. According to the processing standards, the base material and welded joints were processed, and accelerated fatigue tests were carried out on the MTS fatigue testing machine with an experimental frequency of 1Hz.
[0137] Considering that this part is a welded joint, the influence of residual stress is inevitable. Usually for large equipment, the amplitude of residual stress is generally near the yield strength (260MPa), so welding residual stress should be taken into account as an average stress. The SN curve of the material and welded joint at 450℃ is obtained as follows:
[0138] S a =159·N -0.07 ;
[0139] Among them, S a is the stress range;
[0140] N is the number of cycles.
[0141] (5) Accurately calculate strains and stresses at key points.
[0142] The total strain measured by the strain gauge, minus the heat output, and then minus the thermal strain, is the mechanical strain generated by the pressure load of the roasting furnace under high temperature conditions. After calculation, the maximum strain of the parent material is 36 microstrains, and the maximum strain at the weld is 70 microstrains. Multiplying with the elastic modulus of 180GPa at 450℃, the stress at the parent material at 450℃ is 65MPa, and the stress at the weld is 126MPa. The error between the stress at the parent material and the finite element calculation result is within 10%, which meets the use requirements.
[0143] (6) Evaluation of fatigue damage and remaining life of the roasting furnace. In the intact state, the corresponding fluctuation periodic stress range of the roasting furnace under the pressure load of 2.0MPa is 126MPa, and the number of cycles is 28.
[0144] Taking the start and stop once a month as an example, the number of start and stop times a year is 12 times, and the maximum calculated stress fluctuation range is estimated to be 126MPa. The cycle times are divided by 12. Under extreme working conditions, the roasting furnace can be used for 2.3 years, which does not meet the 10-year service requirement of the equipment. Therefore, it is recommended to change the structural design of the roasting furnace or modify the catalyst roasting process.
[0145] Example 4
[0146] For a certain roasting furnace, the cylinder design temperature is 500℃, the internal pressure is operated, and strain monitoring and remaining life assessment are carried out under the operating pressure of 0.5MPa.
[0147] (1) Calculation of strain gauge point selection.
[0148] Firstly, for the roasting furnace cylinder structure, a 1:1 structural model was established using Solidworks and then imported into ABAQUS simulation software for calculation.
[0149] According to the results of literature research, the density, elastic modulus, Poisson's ratio, yield stress, thermal expansion coefficient, specific heat, and heat conduction parameters of N08810 material from room temperature to 1000°C are obtained. For the transition area from the heating section to the insulation section, a grid transition is performed, and the number of grids in the thickness direction of the cylinder is 5.
[0150] A fixed constraint is applied at one end of the cylinder to limit the rigid displacement, while preventing the constraint from being too large and affecting the calculation results of the concerned parts. The heat source, convection, thermal radiation, and changes in internal pressure are taken into account for the calculation. After the finite element calculation, it can be found in the result cloud map that there is a large stress concentration in the cylinder part from the heating area to the insulation section, with an impact range of about 20mm. This area should be the focus of monitoring.
[0151] (2) High temperature strain gauge pasting.
[0152] Remove the insulation layer to expose the part to be pasted. Through finite element calculation, it can be determined that the axial strain of the weld and the part far from the weld is large, which is used as the monitoring point. First, use a thousand-blade grinder to grind the measured surface to remove surface burrs, rust layers and uneven pits. The grinding time is about 1.5 minutes.
[0153] Since the lap disc grinding speed is too fast, it is easy to cause the surface to overheat. Therefore, after the lap disc is ground, use 240-grit sandpaper to grind at 90° until the surface to be tested appears frosted.
[0154] Then use alcohol cotton balls to clean the surface abrasive particles and air dry them for later use. Then, in the area of about 5×5cm 2 Apply a layer of high-temperature ceramic glue and use a hot air gun for heating and curing. The curing temperature is controlled at about 550°C (greater than the equipment operating temperature of 500°C) and the curing time is 5 hours.
[0155] The high-temperature strain gauge is fixed on the cured high-temperature ceramic adhesive with a high-temperature tape, and the high-temperature ceramic adhesive is coated on the strain gauge and the surrounding area. A hot air gun is used for curing. The curing temperature is 300°C and the curing time is 2 hours.
[0156] Then the high temperature tape was removed, and the high temperature ceramic glue was applied to the strain gauge and the surrounding area. A hot air gun was used to cure the strain gauge at a temperature of 550°C for 5 hours. The resistance value of the strain gauge was measured with a multimeter, which was about 125Ω, less than 200Ω, indicating that the strain gauge grid wire did not break during the curing process of the high temperature glue.
[0157] The strain gauge lead wire is connected to the data connection line by soldering with an electric soldering iron, and the data connection line is connected to the data acquisition instrument using a 1 / 4 bridge method. The data acquisition instrument converts the resistance change of the strain gauge into a strain value and transmits it to the computer.
[0158] During the equipment shutdown period, the equipment was tested and the entire strain value of the equipment under normal temperature and pressure to high temperature and pressure was obtained through monitoring.
[0159] (3) Calculation of true material strain.
[0160] According to the material NiChromeV used for the strain gauge, a thermal expansion instrument was used to test the thermal output performance of the strain gauge grid material at different temperatures under laboratory conditions. The thermal output relationship is:
[0161] ε T =43.16·T-467;
[0162] In the formula, ε T is heat output;
[0163] T is temperature, unit is °C.
[0164] K-type thermocouples are welded at the points where the strain gauges are attached, and the temperature changes of the points to be measured are recorded in real time. The temperature of the equipment in the thermally stable state is 450°C. The strain value when the equipment is started from normal temperature and pressure to the stable state minus the heat output at the corresponding temperature is the true strain value of the equipment.
[0165] (4) Carry out accelerated degradation experiments on N08810 materials and welded joints under service conditions to obtain high-temperature fatigue performance data of materials and welded joints.
[0166] The design service temperature of the roasting furnace does not exceed 500 degrees Celsius, and the internal pressure is about 1MPa. According to the thermocouple temperature measurement results, the maximum temperature is about 450℃, so the high temperature fatigue performance test at 450℃ was carried out. According to the processing standards, the base material and welded joints were processed, and accelerated fatigue tests were carried out on the MTS fatigue testing machine with an experimental frequency of 1Hz.
[0167] Considering that this part is a welded joint, the influence of residual stress is inevitable. Usually for large equipment, the amplitude of residual stress is generally near the yield strength (260MPa), so welding residual stress should be taken into account as an average stress. The SN curve of the material and welded joint at 450℃ is obtained as follows:
[0168] S a =159·N -0.07 ;
[0169] Among them, S a is the stress range;
[0170] N is the number of cycles.
[0171] (5) Accurately calculate strains and stresses at key points.
[0172] The total strain measured by the strain gauge, minus the heat output, and then minus the thermal strain, is the mechanical strain generated by the pressure load of the roasting furnace under high temperature conditions. After calculation, the maximum strain of the parent material is 11 microstrains, and the maximum strain at the weld is 21 microstrains. Multiplying with the elastic modulus of 180GPa at 450℃, the stress at the parent material at 450℃ is 20MPa, and the stress at the weld is 38MPa. The error between the stress at the parent material and the finite element calculation result is within 10%, which meets the use requirements.
[0173] (6) Evaluation of fatigue damage and remaining life of the roasting furnace. In the intact state, the corresponding fluctuation period stress range under the pressure load of 0.5MPa of the roasting furnace is 38MPa, and the number of cycles is 7.5×10 8 Weekly.
[0174] Taking starting and stopping twice a month as an example, there are 24 starts and stops in a year. The maximum calculated stress fluctuation range is estimated to be 38MPa. The number of cycles is divided by 24. The service life is much greater than the design life requirement of 10 years, and fatigue analysis design is not required.
[0175] Example 5
[0176] For a certain roasting furnace, the cylinder design temperature is 500℃, the internal pressure is operated, and strain monitoring and remaining life assessment are carried out under the operating pressure of 1.2MPa.
[0177] (1) Calculation of strain gauge point selection.
[0178] Firstly, for the roasting furnace cylinder structure, a 1:1 structural model was established using Solidworks, and then the ABAQUS simulation software was imported for calculation, solid modeling and meshing.
[0179] According to the results of literature research, the density, elastic modulus, Poisson's ratio, yield stress, thermal expansion coefficient, specific heat, and heat conduction parameters of N08810 material from room temperature to 1000°C were obtained.
[0180] For the transition area from the heating section to the insulation section, a grid transition is performed, and the number of grids in the thickness direction of the cylinder is not greater than 6, and is set to 5 in this embodiment.
[0181] A fixed constraint is applied at one end of the cylinder to limit the rigid displacement, while preventing the constraint from being too large and affecting the calculation results of the concerned parts. The heat source, convection, thermal radiation, and changes in internal pressure are taken into account for the calculation.
[0182] After finite element calculation, the results are as follows Figure 1 It can be found that there is a large stress concentration in the cylinder part from the heating area to the insulation section, and the affected range is about 20mm. This area should be the key monitoring area to obtain the areas with larger stress and strain of the complex structure pressure vessel for reference in selecting points for structural monitoring.
[0183] This area is a cylinder with a diameter of 1m and a length of 20mm. Considering that the entire cylinder of the roasting furnace is welded and spliced, special attention is paid to the welding parts and the cylinder in this area, which are stress-hazardous parts (large strain).
[0184] (2) High temperature strain gauge pasting.
[0185] Remove the insulation layer to expose the part to be glued. Through finite element calculation, it can be determined that the axial strain of the weld and the part far away from the weld is large, which is used as the monitoring point (i.e. the stress danger part).
[0186] Pre-treat the monitoring points.
[0187] First, use a thousand-blade grinder to grind the measured surface to remove surface burrs, rust layers and uneven pits. The grinding time is about 1 minute.
[0188] Since the lapis lathe is polished too fast, it is easy to cause the surface to overheat. Therefore, after the lapis lathe is polished, use 240-grit sandpaper to polish at 90 degrees until the surface to be tested appears frosted. Then use an alcohol cotton ball to clean the surface abrasive particles and air dry for later use. Then, in the area of about 5×5cm at the point to be tested, 2 Apply a layer of high-temperature ceramic glue and use a hot air gun for heating and curing. The curing temperature is controlled at about 550°C (greater than the equipment operating temperature of 500°C) and the curing time is 6 hours.
[0189] Use high temperature tape to fix the high temperature strain gauge on the cured high temperature ceramic glue, apply the high temperature ceramic glue on the strain gauge and the surrounding area, and use a hot air gun to cure it at a temperature of 300°C for 2 hours. Then remove the high temperature tape, apply the high temperature ceramic glue on the strain gauge and the surrounding area, and use a hot air gun to cure it at a temperature of 550°C for 6 hours.
[0190] The resistance value of the strain gauge was measured with a multimeter and the resistance value was about 145Ω, which was less than 200Ω, indicating that the grid wire of the strain gauge did not break during the curing process of the high-temperature glue.
[0191] The strain gauge lead wire is connected to the data connection line by soldering with an electric soldering iron, and the data connection line is connected to the data acquisition instrument using a 1 / 4 bridge method. The data acquisition instrument converts the resistance change of the strain gauge into a strain value and transmits it to the computer.
[0192] During the equipment shutdown period, the equipment was tested and the entire strain value of the equipment under normal temperature and pressure to high temperature and pressure was obtained through monitoring.
[0193] (3) Calculation of true material strain.
[0194] According to the material NiChromeV used for the strain gauge, a thermal expansion instrument was used to test the thermal output performance of the strain gauge grid material at different temperatures under laboratory conditions. The thermal output relationship is:
[0195] ε T =43.16·T-467;
[0196] In the formula, ε T is heat output;
[0197] T is temperature, unit is °C.
[0198] K-type thermocouples are welded at the points where the strain gauges are attached, and the temperature changes of the points to be measured are recorded in real time. The temperature of the equipment in the thermally stable state is 450°C. The strain value when the equipment is started from normal temperature and pressure to the stable state minus the heat output at the corresponding temperature is the true strain value of the equipment.
[0199] (4) Carry out accelerated degradation experiments on N08810 materials and welded joints under service conditions to obtain high-temperature fatigue performance data of materials and welded joints.
[0200] The design service temperature of the roasting furnace does not exceed 500 degrees Celsius, and the internal pressure is about 1MPa. According to the thermocouple temperature measurement results, the maximum temperature is about 450℃, so the high temperature fatigue performance test at 450℃ was carried out. According to the processing standards, the base material and welded joints were processed, and accelerated fatigue tests were carried out on the MTS fatigue testing machine with an experimental frequency of 1Hz.
[0201] Considering that this part is a welded joint, the influence of residual stress is inevitable. Usually for large equipment, the amplitude of residual stress is generally near the yield strength (260MPa), so welding residual stress should be taken into account as an average stress. The SN curve of the material and welded joint at 450℃ is obtained as follows:
[0202] S a =159·N -0.07 ;
[0203] Among them, S a is the stress range;
[0204] N is the number of cycles.
[0205] (5) Accurately calculate strains and stresses at key points.
[0206] The total strain measured by the strain gauge, minus the heat output, and then minus the thermal strain, is the mechanical strain generated by the pressure load of the roasting furnace under high temperature conditions. After calculation, the maximum strain of the parent material is 25 microstrain, and the maximum strain at the weld is 56 microstrain. Multiplying it with the elastic modulus of 180GPa at 450℃, the stress at the parent material at 450℃ is 45MPa, and the stress at the weld is 101MPa. The error between the stress at the parent material and the finite element calculation result is within 10%, which meets the use requirements.
[0207] (6) Evaluation of fatigue damage and remaining life of the roasting furnace. In the intact state, the corresponding fluctuation periodic stress range of 101MPa under the pressure load of 1.2MPa of the roasting furnace corresponds to 653 cycles.
[0208] Taking the start and stop once a month as an example, there are 12 starts and stops a year, and the maximum calculated stress fluctuation range is estimated to be 101MPa. The number of cycles is divided by 12. Under extreme working conditions, the roasting furnace can be used for 54 years, which meets the 10-year service requirement of the equipment.
[0209] It can be seen from the above Examples 1-5 that the high temperature pressure bearing equipment (roasting furnace) has a low operating pressure and a long service life. Therefore, the operating pressure of the equipment should not exceed 1.5 MPa as much as possible.
[0210] Furthermore, it should be understood that when the terms “include” and / or “comprise” are used in the present specification, they specify the presence of features, steps, operations, devices, components and / or their combinations.
[0211] Unless otherwise specifically stated, the relative arrangement of the parts and steps described in these embodiments, numerical expressions and numerical values do not limit the scope of the present application. At the same time, it should be understood that, for ease of description, the sizes of the various parts shown in the accompanying drawings are not drawn according to the actual proportional relationship. The technology, methods and equipment known to ordinary technicians in the relevant field may not be discussed in detail, but in appropriate cases, the technology, methods and equipment should be regarded as a part of the authorization specification. In all examples shown and discussed here, any specific value should be interpreted as merely exemplary, rather than as a limitation. Therefore, other examples of exemplary embodiments may have different values.
[0212] Of course, the above description is not a limitation of the present invention, and the present invention is not limited to the above examples. Changes, modifications, additions or substitutions made by technicians in this technical field within the essential scope of the present invention should also fall within the protection scope of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for strain monitoring and fatigue life assessment of high temperature pressure equipment, characterized in that: The following steps are included: (1) Establish a proportional finite element simulation model to calculate stress risk locations; (2) Paste strain gauges at stress-hazardous locations; (3) Calculation of true material strain; (4) Conduct accelerated degradation experiments under laboratory conditions and high-temperature fatigue performance tests according to the service temperature and service load of the material to obtain high-temperature fatigue performance data; (5) Accurately calculate strains and stresses at stress-hazardous locations; (6) Based on the results of steps (4) and (5), evaluate the fatigue loss and remaining life of the equipment.
2. A method for strain monitoring and fatigue life assessment of high temperature pressure equipment according to claim 1, characterized in that: In the step (1), a 1:1 structural model is established using Solidworks, and ABAQUS simulation software is imported to calculate stress risk locations of the equipment.
3. A method for strain monitoring and fatigue life assessment of high temperature pressure equipment according to claim 2, characterized in that: The model uses a thermo-elastoplastic model, uses the grid for refinement analysis, and uses ABAQUS simulation software to obtain the temperature field distribution and stress field distribution results of the equipment. The parts with large stress and strain changes are stress-hazardous parts.
4. A method for strain monitoring and fatigue life assessment of high temperature pressure equipment according to claim 1, characterized in that: In the step (2), when the strain gauge is pasted, the surface of the stress-prone area needs to be pre-treated.
5. A method for strain monitoring and fatigue life assessment of high temperature pressure equipment according to claim 4, characterized in that: The surface pretreatment method is to grind the measured surface with a flap grinder to remove the surface rust layer, and then grind with 240-grit sandpaper in a 90° direction until the surface becomes frosted; Apply a layer of high-temperature glue to the stress-hazardous area and cure it with a hot air gun; Place the strain gauge on the cured high-temperature glue, apply the high-temperature glue to the back and surrounding area of the strain gauge, continue to cure with a hot air gun, and apply high-temperature protective glue after it is completely cured.
6. A method for strain monitoring and fatigue life assessment of high temperature pressure equipment according to claim 5, characterized in that: The curing temperature of the hot air gun is higher than the temperature when the equipment is in use, and each curing time is 5-6 hours.
7. A method for strain monitoring and fatigue life assessment of high temperature pressure equipment according to claim 1, characterized in that: In the step (2), after the strain gauge is pasted, the strain gauge lead and the data line are connected to a data acquisition instrument, and the data acquisition instrument converts the signal resistance change value into a strain value.
8. A method for strain monitoring and fatigue life assessment of high temperature pressure equipment according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step (3), the method for calculating the true strain is: According to the material used for the strain gauge, a thermal expansion instrument is used to test the thermal output performance of the strain gauge grid material at different temperatures under laboratory conditions. The thermal output relationship is: e T =43.16·T-467; In the formula, ε T is the heat output, T is the temperature, unit is ℃; A thermocouple is welded at the point where the strain gauge is pasted to record the temperature change of the measured point in real time; the strain value of the equipment in a stable state minus the heat output at the corresponding temperature is the actual strain value of the equipment.
9. A method for strain monitoring and fatigue life assessment of high temperature pressure equipment according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step (4), the high temperature fatigue performance test is carried out by conducting an accelerated fatigue test on an MTS fatigue testing machine to obtain the fatigue SN curve of the material and the strain risk position, and the formula is: S a =159·N -0.07 ; Among them, S a is the stress range and N is the number of cycles.
10. A method for strain monitoring and fatigue life assessment of high temperature pressure equipment according to claim 1, characterized in that: In the step (5), the strain and stress at the stress-hazardous part are accurately calculated. The total strain measured by the strain gauge is subtracted from the heat output and then the thermal strain, which is the mechanical strain generated by the pressure load of the roasting furnace under high temperature conditions.
