Petrochemical equipment fault strength evaluation method and system
By establishing a petrochemical equipment fault intensity evaluation system, combining the fault impact range, economic losses, number of fault repetitions and causes and other factors, the fault weighting intensity is calculated, and the problem of insufficient comprehensive fault evaluation in the existing technology has been solved, and the failure of petrochemical equipment has been achieved. The comprehensive evaluation and automated judgment have improved the certainty and automation of evaluations.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202310601737.8
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-26
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-26
AI Technical Summary
The existing technology lacks comprehensive considerations on the scope of the failure, economic losses, number of fault repetitions and causes in the evaluation of petrochemical equipment failures, especially when used for warning and assessment after the failure occurs, and most methods focus on faults. Pre-predictions and monitoring of specific devices.
A method for evaluating the fault intensity of petrochemical equipment is proposed. By establishing a fault intensity evaluation system, including the impact range of faults, economic losses, the number of fault repetitions and the weight scores of factors such as factors, the weight scores of factors such as the cause, the fault weighting intensity is calculated, and the fault level is determined based on the weighting intensity. An automated system was designed for evaluation.
It realizes a more comprehensive impact assessment after a petrochemical equipment failure occurs, provides a system that automatically determines the fault intensity score and level, reduces manual interference, fills the gaps in assessment and warning after a failure occurs, and improves the certainty of evaluation.
Smart Images

Figure CN119026895A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention relates to the field of fault evaluation, and in particular to a method and system for evaluating the fault intensity of petrochemical equipment. Background Art
[0002] Equipment is the foundation of an enterprise's production activities. Once a failure occurs, production activities will be interrupted. Severe equipment failures may even lead to casualties and huge property losses. Therefore, equipment managers in all walks of life have always attached great importance to equipment failures. On the one hand, they need to repair, handle and analyze the failures to reduce losses, resume production and prevent similar failures from happening again; on the other hand, they need to conduct performance appraisals on the institutions where the failures occur, guide enterprises to pay attention to failure management and serve as a warning.
[0003] The petrochemical industry is a typical process-based industry. Compared with other industries, it has higher requirements for production continuity. Therefore, when considering the consequence evaluation of equipment failure, it will also focus more on the impact on production continuity.
[0004] At present, the more common fault evaluation methods are usually targeted at a certain type of equipment, and are mainly used to monitor and evaluate the status of the equipment to prevent equipment failures or determine the time and cycle of maintenance. They focus on the time period before the accident and the abnormality of technical parameters, and use this as a basis for qualitative or quantitative evaluation. Some methods also use data-driven AI self-learning model methods, which are essentially just changes in the evaluation mechanism, and usually target the same time period and goals as traditional methods. These methods mainly present several characteristics:
[0005] 1. Emphasis on the urgency of fault handling, that is, the focus should be on completing the evaluation as soon as possible during the duration of the fault to ensure the allocation of resources for maintenance and handling.
[0006] 2. Focus on the impact of the fault on the equipment where the fault occurs, that is, the damage to the equipment after the fault occurs.
[0007] 3. Focus on the various parameters that can be collected by the faulty equipment, and evaluate the fault by the abnormality and degree of the parameters.
[0008] The method of the present invention is mainly used for the period after a fault occurs and is handled, and is mainly used for warning or assessment to prevent similar faults from occurring again. Summary of the invention
[0009] In view of the problems existing in the above-mentioned prior art, the present invention proposes a method and system for evaluating the fault intensity of petrochemical equipment. The method establishes scoring standards for factors such as the fault impact range, economic losses, number of fault repetitions, and fault causes. The quantitative score of the fault is determined by comprehensively analyzing the scores of various factors. The method is reasonably designed, overcomes the shortcomings of the prior art, and has good results.
[0010] In order to achieve the above object, the present invention adopts the following technical solution:
[0011] A method for evaluating the fault intensity of petrochemical equipment comprises the following steps:
[0012] S1. Establish fault determination criteria;
[0013] S2. Establish a fault intensity evaluation system, which includes fault evaluation factors and weights, fault impact range evaluation criteria, fault economic loss evaluation criteria, fault repetition number evaluation criteria, and fault cause evaluation criteria;
[0014] S3. Improve the fault intensity evaluation system;
[0015] S4. Calculate the weighted intensity of faults;
[0016] S5. Establish the criteria for determining the fault intensity level;
[0017] S6. Evaluate the fault intensity.
[0018] Furthermore, in step S1, a criterion for determining equipment failure is determined according to equipment functions, production requirements, and equipment categories.
[0019] Further, in step S2, the fault evaluation factors include the fault impact range, fault economic loss, fault repetition times and fault cause;
[0020] The weight of the fault impact range is 40%;
[0021] The weight of economic loss due to failure is 30%;
[0022] The weight of the number of fault repetitions is 20%;
[0023] The weight of the failure cause is 10%.
[0024] Further, in step S2, the fault impact scope evaluation criteria are: when the fault impact scope is unplanned shutdown of more than 2 production units or reduction in production of the entire plant, the fault intensity level is level 1, and the fault intensity evaluation score F1 is 100;
[0025] When the fault impact range is unplanned shutdown of a single unit or abnormal fluctuation of more than two units, the fault intensity level is level 2, and the fault intensity evaluation score F1 is 70;
[0026] When the fault impact range is unplanned shutdown of a single unit or abnormal fluctuation of more than two units, the fault intensity level is level 3, and the fault intensity evaluation score F1 is 40;
[0027] When the fault affects 2 to 4 devices in a single device, the fault intensity level is 4, and the fault intensity evaluation score F1 is 20;
[0028] When the fault affects a single device and causes it to stop operating, the fault intensity level is 5 and the fault intensity evaluation score F1 is 10.
[0029] Further, in step S2, the fault economic loss evaluation criteria are: when the fault economic loss reaches more than 10 million yuan, the fault intensity level is level 1, and the fault intensity evaluation score F2 is 100;
[0030] When the economic loss of the fault is 3 million to 10 million yuan, the fault intensity level is level 2, and the fault intensity evaluation score F2 is 70;
[0031] When the economic loss of the fault is more than 1 million to 3 million yuan, the fault intensity level is level 3, and the fault intensity evaluation score F2 is 40;
[0032] When the economic loss of the fault is more than 300,000 to 1 million yuan, the fault intensity level is 4, and the fault intensity evaluation score F2 is 20;
[0033] When the economic loss caused by the failure is less than RMB 300,000, the failure intensity level is 5 and the failure intensity evaluation score F2 is 10.
[0034] Further, in step S2, the fault repetition number evaluation criteria are: when the fault repetition number is that the fault has occurred in the enterprise within 1 year, the fault intensity level is level 1, and the fault intensity evaluation score F3 is 100;
[0035] When the fault repetition frequency is that the fault has occurred in the enterprise within 5 years, the fault intensity level is level 2, and the fault intensity evaluation score F3 is 70;
[0036] When the fault repetition frequency is that the fault has occurred in the enterprise within 10 years, the fault intensity level is level 3, and the fault intensity evaluation score F3 is 40;
[0037] When the fault is repeated for the number of times that the fault has occurred in the history of the enterprise, the fault intensity level is level 4 and the fault intensity evaluation score F3 is 20;
[0038] When the fault repetition number is the first time that the fault occurs, the fault intensity level is level 5 and the fault intensity evaluation score F3 is 10.
[0039] Further, in step S2, the fault cause evaluation criteria are: when the fault cause is equipment design, the fault intensity level is level 1, and the fault intensity evaluation score F4 is 100;
[0040] When the cause of the fault is loopholes in the management system, guarantee mechanism, and personnel capabilities, the cause of the fault is level 2, and the fault intensity evaluation score F4 is 70;
[0041] When the fault is caused by equipment manufacturing, the fault intensity level is level 3 and the fault intensity evaluation score F4 is 40;
[0042] When the fault is caused by human error, the fault intensity level is level 4, and the fault intensity evaluation score F4 is 20;
[0043] When the fault is caused by equipment installation and construction, the fault intensity level is level 5 and the fault intensity evaluation score F4 is 10.
[0044] Furthermore, step S3 includes the following sub-steps:
[0045] S3.1: Collect or create 500 typical failure cases, compile the failure cases in the form of reports, and form 500 failure reports;
[0046] S3.2: The system automatically captures keywords in the fault report and conducts quantitative evaluation of the fault;
[0047] S3.3: Proofread the completed fault quantitative evaluation, and improve the automatic crawling rules according to the proofreading results to ensure the accuracy of automatic crawling;
[0048] S3.4: Repeat steps S3.3 and S3.4 to ensure that the automatic grasping accuracy exceeds 99%.
[0049] Furthermore, in step S4, the weighted intensity calculation formula of the fault is:
[0050] R f =0.4*F1+0.3*F2+0.2*F3+0.1*F4;
[0051] Among them, R f is the weighted intensity of the fault;
[0052] F1 is the evaluation score of the fault impact range evaluation criterion;
[0053] F1 is the evaluation score of the failure economic loss evaluation criterion;
[0054] F1 is the evaluation score of the fault repetition number evaluation criterion;
[0055] F1 is the evaluation score of the fault cause evaluation criteria;
[0056] Further, in step S5, when the weighted intensity of the fault is ≥80, the final level of the fault intensity is A; when the weighted intensity of the fault is between 60 and 80, the final level of the fault intensity is B; when the weighted intensity of the fault is between 40 and 60, the final level of the fault intensity is C; and when the weighted intensity of the fault is ≤40, the final level of the fault intensity is D.
[0057] A petrochemical equipment fault intensity evaluation system, using a petrochemical equipment fault intensity evaluation method as described above, including a construction module, an acquisition module and an evaluation module;
[0058] The construction module is used for a fault intensity evaluation system, wherein the fault intensity evaluation system includes fault evaluation factors and weights and four fault evaluation criteria, wherein the fault evaluation criteria include a fault impact range evaluation criterion, a fault economic loss evaluation criterion, a fault repetition number evaluation criterion, and a fault cause evaluation criterion;
[0059] A capture module is used to capture keywords from the input fault report;
[0060] An acquisition module, used to acquire the fault intensity evaluation scores of four fault evaluation criteria of the petrochemical equipment to be evaluated according to the captured keywords;
[0061] The evaluation module is used to determine the final fault intensity level of the petrochemical equipment to be evaluated according to the fault intensity evaluation score.
[0062] Beneficial technical effects brought by the present invention:
[0063] 1. Compared with the common automatic fault evaluation system, the method disclosed in the present invention is not targeted at a specific equipment type. As long as it belongs to the process equipment of a petrochemical enterprise, it can be used to make judgments. If it is non-process equipment, partial judgments can also be made.
[0064] 2. The present invention mainly fills the gap in the assessment and warning of the unit where the fault occurred after the fault occurred. The currently disclosed documents are mainly used for diagnosis and prediction before the fault. For this purpose, they mainly focus on the parametric judgment reflected by technical indicators and equipment status. Since the fault has not occurred or has not occurred completely, the evaluation is often predictive. The present invention is used at the node after the fault occurs, and is mainly used in the petrochemical industry and process industry. Therefore, it focuses more on the overall impact rather than the technical problems of the fault itself, and the evaluation is more certain.
[0065] 3. A system is provided to automatically determine the fault intensity score and level. No manual operation is required during the use phase, which can minimize the experience requirements and interference of personnel. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0066] Figure 1 A flow chart of a method for evaluating the fault intensity of petrochemical equipment in the present invention;
[0067] Figure 2 is a flow chart of the method for using the fault intensity evaluation system of the present invention; DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0068] The embodiments described in the following exemplary embodiments do not represent all embodiments consistent with the present disclosure. Instead, they are merely examples of methods consistent with some aspects of the present disclosure as detailed in the appended claims.
[0069] The terms used in this disclosure are for the purpose of describing characteristic embodiments only and are not intended to limit the disclosure. The singular forms "a", "the" and "the" used in this disclosure and the appended claims are also intended to include plural forms unless the context clearly indicates otherwise. It should also be understood that the term "and / or" used herein refers to and includes any or all possible combinations of one or more associated listed items.
[0070] In order to solve the defects and shortcomings in the prior art, a method and system for evaluating the fault intensity of petrochemical equipment are proposed. The specific implementation of the present invention is further described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and specific embodiments:
[0071] A method for evaluating the fault intensity of petrochemical equipment comprises the following steps:
[0072] S1. Establish fault determination criteria;
[0073] Determine the criteria for determining equipment failure based on equipment functions, production needs, and equipment categories.
[0074] S2. Establish a fault intensity evaluation system, which includes fault evaluation factors and weights, fault impact range evaluation criteria, fault economic loss evaluation criteria, fault repetition number evaluation criteria, and fault cause evaluation criteria;
[0075] (I) Fault evaluation factors and weights
[0076] The present invention focuses on post-fault analysis and assessment, which is usually implemented after a fault occurs. Therefore, it focuses on the evaluation of factors such as the scope of fault impact, economic losses, number of fault repetitions, and fault causes. The factor weights are established as follows:
[0077] Failure impact range: 40%
[0078] Economic loss due to failure: 30%
[0079] Failure repetition rate: 20%
[0080] Cause of failure: 10%
[0081] The above factors can usually only be predicted or speculated based on limited equipment parameters before a fault occurs. However, after a fault occurs, the above factors become relatively clear objective facts and can be scored and evaluated more comprehensively and accurately.
[0082] (II) Evaluation criteria for fault impact scope:
[0083] When the fault affects more than two production units and causes unplanned shutdowns or a reduction in production of the entire plant, the fault intensity level is level 1, and the fault intensity evaluation score F1 is 100;
[0084] When the fault impact range is unplanned shutdown of a single unit or abnormal fluctuation of more than two units, the fault intensity level is level 2, and the fault intensity evaluation score F1 is 70;
[0085] When the fault impact range is unplanned shutdown of a single unit or abnormal fluctuation of more than two units, the fault intensity level is level 3, and the fault intensity evaluation score F1 is 40;
[0086] When the fault affects 2 to 4 devices in a single device, the fault intensity level is 4, and the fault intensity evaluation score F1 is 20;
[0087] When the fault affects a single device, the fault intensity level is 5, and the fault intensity evaluation score F1 is 10;
[0088] The details are shown in Table 1:
[0089] Table 1 Evaluation criteria for fault impact range
[0090]
[0091]
[0092] (III) Evaluation criteria for economic losses caused by failures:
[0093] When the economic loss of a fault reaches more than 10 million yuan, the fault intensity level is level 1, and the fault intensity evaluation score F2 is 100;
[0094] When the economic loss of the fault is 3 million to 10 million yuan, the fault intensity level is level 2, and the fault intensity evaluation score F2 is 70;
[0095] When the economic loss of the fault is more than 1 million to 3 million yuan, the fault intensity level is level 3, and the fault intensity evaluation score F2 is 40;
[0096] When the economic loss of the fault is more than 300,000 to 1 million yuan, the fault intensity level is 4, and the fault intensity evaluation score F2 is 20;
[0097] When the economic loss of the fault is less than 300,000 yuan, the fault intensity level is 5, and the fault intensity evaluation score F2 is 10;
[0098] The details are shown in Table 2:
[0099] Table 2 Evaluation criteria for economic losses caused by failures
[0100]
[0101] (IV) Evaluation criteria for the number of fault repetitions
[0102] When the fault repetition number is that the fault has occurred in the enterprise within 1 year, the fault intensity level is level 1, and the fault intensity evaluation score F3 is 100;
[0103] When the fault repetition frequency is that the fault has occurred in the enterprise within 5 years, the fault intensity level is level 2, and the fault intensity evaluation score F3 is 70;
[0104] When the fault repetition frequency is that the fault has occurred in the enterprise within 10 years, the fault intensity level is level 3, and the fault intensity evaluation score F3 is 40;
[0105] When the fault is repeated for the number of times that the fault has occurred in the history of the enterprise, the fault intensity level is level 4 and the fault intensity evaluation score F3 is 20;
[0106] When the fault repetition number is the first occurrence of the fault, the fault intensity level is level 5 and the fault intensity evaluation score F3 is 10;
[0107] The details are shown in Table 3:
[0108] Table 3 Evaluation criteria for fault repetition times
[0109]
[0110] (V) Fault cause evaluation criteria:
[0111] When the fault is caused by equipment design, the fault intensity level is level 1 and the fault intensity evaluation score F4 is 100;
[0112] When the cause of the fault is loopholes in the management system, guarantee mechanism, and personnel capabilities, the cause of the fault is level 2, and the fault intensity evaluation score F4 is 70;
[0113] When the fault is caused by equipment manufacturing, the fault intensity level is level 3, and the fault intensity evaluation score F4 is 40; when the fault is caused by human error, the fault intensity level is level 4, and the fault intensity evaluation score F4 is 20;
[0114] When the fault is caused by equipment installation and construction, the fault intensity level is level 5, and the fault intensity evaluation score F4 is 10;
[0115] The details are shown in Table 4:
[0116] Table 4 Fault cause evaluation criteria
[0117]
[0118]
[0119] S3. Improve the fault intensity evaluation system;
[0120] Step S3 includes the following sub-steps:
[0121] S3.1: Collect or create 500 typical failure cases, compile the failure cases in the form of reports, and form 500 failure reports;
[0122] S3.2: The system automatically captures keywords in the fault report and conducts quantitative evaluation of the fault;
[0123] S3.3: Proofread the completed fault quantitative evaluation, and improve the automatic crawling rules according to the proofreading results to ensure the accuracy of automatic crawling;
[0124] S3.4: Repeat steps S3.3 and S3.4 to ensure that the automatic grasping accuracy exceeds 99%.
[0125] The key words of the fault impact range element are set as the device name and equipment name, and the sensitive numbers of the related keywords are captured, and the length is set to 100 characters before and after, so as to complete the determination of the fault impact range;
[0126] The keywords of the economic loss factors of failure are set as economic loss and downtime loss. At the same time, the sensitive numbers of the related keywords are captured and the length is set to 100 characters before and after, so as to complete the determination of the economic loss of failure;
[0127] The key words of the fault repetition times element are set to the same fault or the same fault. The sensitive numbers of the related key words are captured and the length is set to 100 characters before and after to complete the determination of the fault repetition times.
[0128] The keywords of the fault cause factors are set as design, system, mechanism, capability, manufacturing, operation, installation, construction, governance, troubleshooting plan, measures, etc. The fault cause is determined based on the captured keywords;
[0129] When keywords, sensitive numbers cannot be captured or the determination of the fault factor cannot be completed, the fault intensity evaluation of the factor is determined using the highest level of the factor as the default value.
[0130] S3.4: Proofread the completed fault quantitative evaluation, and improve the automatic capture rules according to the proofreading results to ensure the accuracy of automatic capture;
[0131] S3.5: Repeat steps S3.3 and S3.4 to ensure that the automatic grasping accuracy exceeds 99%.
[0132] S4. Calculate the weighted intensity of faults;
[0133] The weighted intensity calculation formula of the fault is:
[0134] R f =0.4*F1+0.3*F2+0.2*F3+0.1*F4;
[0135] Among them, R f is the weighted intensity of the fault;
[0136] F1 is the evaluation score of the fault impact range evaluation criterion;
[0137] F1 is the evaluation score of the failure economic loss evaluation criterion;
[0138] F1 is the evaluation score of the fault repetition number evaluation criterion;
[0139] F1 is the evaluation score of the fault cause evaluation criteria;
[0140] S5. Establish the criteria for determining the fault intensity level;
[0141] When the weighted intensity of the fault is ≥80, the final level of the fault intensity is A; when the weighted intensity of the fault is between 60 and 80, the final level of the fault intensity is B; when the weighted intensity of the fault is between 40 and 60, the final level of the fault intensity is C; when the weighted intensity of the fault is ≤40, the final level of the fault intensity is D.
[0142] S6. Evaluate the fault intensity;
[0143] Automatically capture keywords from the complete fault report and conduct fault evaluation, and finally give the fault score and grade.
[0144] A petrochemical equipment fault intensity evaluation system, using a petrochemical equipment fault intensity evaluation method as described above, including a construction module, a capture module, an acquisition module and an evaluation module;
[0145] A construction module is used for a fault intensity evaluation system, wherein the fault intensity evaluation system includes fault evaluation factors and weights and four fault evaluation criteria, wherein the fault evaluation criteria include a fault impact range evaluation criterion, a fault economic loss evaluation criterion, a fault repetition number evaluation criterion, and a fault cause evaluation criterion;
[0146] A capture module is used to capture keywords from the input fault report;
[0147] An acquisition module, used to acquire the fault intensity evaluation scores of four fault evaluation criteria of the petrochemical equipment to be evaluated according to the captured keywords;
[0148] The evaluation module is used to determine the final fault intensity level of the petrochemical equipment to be evaluated according to the fault intensity evaluation score.
[0149] The present invention is further described below by several embodiments and comparative examples:
[0150] Example 1
[0151] A petrochemical enterprise A implements fault intensity level evaluation according to the above fault intensity evaluation system, such as Figure 2 As shown;
[0152] Step 1: Fault determination:
[0153] When an event occurs, it should first be determined whether the event is a fault, based on the fault determination criteria established by the enterprise. When the event is determined not to be a fault, the process ends; when the event is determined to be a fault, proceed to step 2.
[0154] Step 2: Prepare a fault report:
[0155] Due to the characteristics of high safety requirements of petrochemical enterprises, when a fault occurs, a fault report is usually prepared. This action is not directly related to the present invention, but if the enterprise wants to apply the present invention, it must use the fault report. In this embodiment, the fault report is prepared as follows:
[0156] "At 14:08 on January 1, 2021, the equipment operator of the AAA workshop of XXX plant heard an abnormal sound during the on-site inspection and immediately rushed to the scene to check. He smelled a heavy liquefied hydrocarbon smell on the northwest side of the primary distillation tower bottom pump P-1 and immediately evacuated the scene. At the same time, the indoor operator of the AAA workshop found that the DCS combustible gas alarm EIA-1 (P-1 West) alarmed and immediately notified the outdoor operator to confirm on the spot. When the outdoor operator rushed to the scene, he found that the fire was near the first-line pump P-2, and immediately used the intercom to inform the indoor operator of the situation on the scene. At 14:09, the indoor operator called the fire alarm and reported to the factory dispatcher and the workshop on-duty personnel at the same time. The workshop-level on-site disposal plan and the factory-level emergency plan were successively launched to prepare for the initial emergency disposal on the scene.
[0157] After receiving the accident report, managers at the workshop and factory levels immediately rushed to the scene. At 14:09, after receiving the alarm, the 119 Command Center of the Fire Brigade mobilized a team of 6 fire and gas defense vehicles, a total of 31 officers and soldiers to go to the scene of the accident for disposal. The workshop adjusted the process of the accident device, closed the stabilization tower reflux control valve FIC-1, closed the liquefied hydrocarbon delivery control valve FIC-2, closed the stabilization tower bottom heat source control valve FIC-3, and compressed the dry gas tank D-2 through the dry gas line on the top of the liquefied hydrocarbon tank D-1 to release the torch and relieve the pressure, and cut off the pipeline connecting the device to the outside world. At 14:22, the device stopped feeding and stopped working. At 14:25, the open fire was controlled. In order to prevent secondary accidents caused by leaking gas after the fire is extinguished, a place for controlled burning of open fire is retained. At 6:26, the flame was completely extinguished.
[0158] The direct economic loss of the accident was approximately 230,000 yuan, including the loss of fire pipelines and accessories, consumption of fire-fighting foam, and loss of oil products.
[0159] Life archives have not been established for long-term pressure pipelines; annual and monthly inspections of industrial pipelines and hidden danger investigation and treatment are not in place; special equipment accident emergency plans are not perfect and emergency protection measures are insufficient. "
[0160] Step 3: Enter the fault report:
[0161] Enter the above fault report into the system and obtain the following information through keyword crawling:
[0162] (1) The device stops feeding and shuts down for processing;
[0163] (2) The direct economic loss of the accident was approximately RMB 230,000;
[0164] (3) The factor of the number of fault repetitions is missing;
[0165] (4) Annual inspections, monthly inspections, and hidden danger investigation and management of industrial pipelines are not in place; special emergency plans for special equipment accidents are not perfect, and emergency protection measures are insufficient;
[0166] Step 4: Fault classification:
[0167] The score of each factor is determined based on the captured keywords.
[0168] (1) Stop feeding the device and shut down the plant for processing. 70 minutes
[0169] (2) The direct economic loss of the accident was approximately RMB 230,000. 10 points
[0170] (3) The fault repetition factor is default. 100 points
[0171] (4) Annual inspection, monthly inspection, and hidden danger investigation and treatment of industrial pipelines are not in place; special equipment accident emergency plans are not perfect, and emergency protection measures are insufficient. 70 points
[0172] According to the weighted coefficients of each factor, the final score is determined as follows:
[0173] 70*0.4+10*0.3+100*0.2+70*0.1=58
[0174] Therefore, the fault is rated as C.
[0175] Additional note: Since the number of fault repetitions is not mentioned in the fault report, the default value is triggered, affecting part of the fault score. If you want to correct the score, you need to clearly state the number of repetitions.
[0176] Comparative Example 1
[0177] While implementing the method of the present invention, Company A also established other fault evaluation methods, but they were mainly used for fault prediction and preventive maintenance.
[0178] Also used in the above-mentioned fault case, the fault evaluation method should be used before the fault occurs, focusing on the operating status of the equipment, such as medium flow, corrosive medium content, temperature, wall thickness, etc., and predicting the fault through the parameters of these states. Since the state parameters are fully collected, the fault prediction is very accurate, and it is handled in a timely and effective manner before the fault occurs, so the fault can be avoided. At this time, the method provided by the present invention will not be triggered.
[0179] Comparative Example 2
[0180] While implementing the method of the present invention, Company A also established other fault evaluation methods, but they were mainly used for fault prediction and preventive maintenance.
[0181] Also used in the above fault case, this fault evaluation method should be used before the fault occurs, focusing on the operating status of the equipment, such as medium flow, corrosive medium content, temperature, wall thickness, etc., and predicting the fault through the parameters of these states. Due to insufficient collection of state parameters, the relevant personnel's evaluation and judgment of the fault are inaccurate, the fault occurs earlier than predicted, and the consequences of the fault are roughly similar to the prediction. This method does not effectively predict the fault before it occurs.
[0182] Therefore, the fault still occurs, the method provided by the present invention is triggered, and the fault classification is performed.
[0183] Example 2
[0184] A petrochemical enterprise B implemented fault intensity level evaluation according to the above fault intensity evaluation system.
[0185] Step 1: Fault determination:
[0186] When an event occurs, it should first be determined whether the event is a fault, based on the fault determination criteria established by the enterprise. When the event is determined not to be a fault, the process ends; when the event is determined to be a fault, proceed to step 2.
[0187] Step 2: Prepare a fault report:
[0188] Due to the characteristics of high safety requirements of petrochemical enterprises, when a fault occurs, a fault report is usually prepared. This action is not directly related to the present invention, but if the enterprise wants to apply the present invention, it must use the fault report. In this embodiment, the fault report is prepared as follows:
[0189] "At 8:32 on X / X / XXXX, the vibration probe y-1 of the smoke machine-1 of unit 4 suddenly fluctuated, and the fluctuation exceeded the alarm value (60um). The workshop director and technicians rushed to the scene at 37 minutes and quickly arranged to reduce the smoke machine load. When closing the smoke machine inlet butterfly valve, the smoke machine shaft displacement suddenly changed and exceeded the interlock value (0.5mm), and the unit was interlocked and shut down. At 8:55 on the same day, the standby machine was turned on, at 10:20, the main air entered the regenerator, and at 14:46 the catalytic device resumed feeding.
[0190] Preliminary inspection found that manual cranking of Unit 4 was laborious, and the coupling between the smoke exhaust fan and the axial flow fan was seriously damaged; cranking of Unit 3 was normal. The smoke exhaust fan was disassembled and inspected overnight, and the damage to the smoke exhaust fan was confirmed. Metal foreign matter entered between the guide cone and the impeller of the smoke exhaust fan, and continuously contacted and rubbed the joint part of the smoke exhaust fan impeller and the root of the moving blades when the unit was in operation. The heat generated by the contact and friction caused the temperature of the impeller and the root of the moving blades to rise, and the strength of the blades to decrease. When the temperature exceeded the temperature limit of the blade root material (GH864), the blade root mortise and tenon and the blade root exceeded the strength limit, causing the moving blades to break one after another in a very short time, and generating a huge impact force, while tearing the coupling laminations, cutting off the connecting bolts, and disintegrating the unit shaft system. Preliminary analysis showed that the metal foreign matter may be caused by defective fracture of the stationary blades.
[0191] The direct economic loss of the accident was 73,428.4 yuan."
[0192] Step 3: Enter the fault report:
[0193] Enter the above fault report into the system and obtain the following information through keyword crawling:
[0194] (1) The unit was shut down by interlock. At 8:55 a.m. on the same day, the standby unit was turned on, at 10:20 a.m., the main air entered the regenerator, and at 14:46 p.m., the catalytic unit resumed feeding.
[0195] (2) Direct economic losses amounted to RMB 73,428.4.
[0196] (3) The fault repetition factor is default.
[0197] (4) The strength of the blade decreases. When the temperature exceeds the temperature limit of the blade root material (GH864), the blade root groove and the blade root exceed the strength limit, causing the moving blades to break one after another in a very short time and generate a huge impact force. At the same time, the coupling stack is torn, the connecting bolts are cut off, and the unit shaft system disintegrates.
[0198] Step 4: Fault classification:
[0199] The score of each factor is determined based on the captured keywords.
[0200] (1) The unit was shut down by interlock. At 8:55 on the same day, the standby unit was turned on, at 10:20 the main air flow entered the regenerator, and at 14:46 the catalytic unit resumed feeding. 10 minutes
[0201] (2) Direct economic loss: RMB 73,428.4. 10 points
[0202] (3) The fault repetition factor is default. 100 points
[0203] (4) The blade strength decreases. When the temperature exceeds the temperature limit of the blade root material (GH864), the blade root groove and the blade root exceed the strength limit, causing the moving blades to break in a very short time and generate a huge impact force. At the same time, the coupling laminations are torn, the connecting bolts are cut off, and the unit shaft system disintegrates. 100 points
[0204] According to the weighted coefficients of each factor, the final score is determined as follows:
[0205] 10*0.4+10*0.3+100*0.2+100*0.1=37
[0206] Therefore, the fault is graded as D.
[0207] Since the fault repetition factor is not mentioned in the fault report, the default value is triggered, which affects part of the fault score. If you want to correct the score, you need to clearly state the number of repetitions.
[0208] The above describes the preferred embodiments of the present invention. It should be understood that the present invention is not limited to the above-mentioned specific embodiments, and the devices and structures that are not described in detail should be understood to be implemented in a common manner in the art; any technician familiar with the art can use the above-disclosed methods and technical contents to make many possible changes and modifications to the technical solutions of the present invention without departing from the scope of the technical solutions of the present invention, or modify them into equivalent embodiments of equivalent changes, which does not affect the essential content of the present invention. Therefore, any simple modifications, equivalent changes and modifications made to the above embodiments based on the technical essence of the present invention without departing from the content of the technical solutions of the present invention are still within the scope of protection of the technical solutions of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for evaluating the fault intensity of petrochemical equipment, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: S1. Establish fault determination criteria; S2. Establish a fault intensity evaluation system, which includes fault evaluation factors and weights, fault impact range evaluation criteria, fault economic loss evaluation criteria, fault repetition number evaluation criteria, and fault cause evaluation criteria; S3. Improve the fault intensity evaluation system; S4. Calculate the weighted intensity of faults; S5. Establish the criteria for determining the fault intensity level; S6. Evaluate the fault intensity.
2. A petrochemical equipment failure intensity evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S1, the judgment criteria for equipment failure are determined according to equipment functions, production requirements and equipment categories.
3. A petrochemical equipment failure intensity evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S2, the fault evaluation factors include fault impact scope, fault economic loss, fault repetition times and fault cause, the weight of fault impact scope is 40%, the weight of fault economic loss is 30%, the weight of fault repetition times is 20%, and the weight of fault cause is 10%.
4. A petrochemical equipment failure intensity evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S2, the fault impact scope evaluation criteria are: when the fault impact scope is unplanned shutdown of more than two production units or a reduction in production of the entire plant, the fault intensity level is level 1, and the fault intensity evaluation score F1 is 100; when the fault impact scope is unplanned shutdown of a single unit or abnormal fluctuations of more than two units, the fault intensity level is level 2, and the fault intensity evaluation score F1 is 70; when the fault impact scope is unplanned shutdown of a single unit or abnormal fluctuations of more than two units, the fault intensity level is level 3, and the fault intensity evaluation score F1 is 40; when the fault impact scope is a single unit with 2 to 4 equipment outages, the fault intensity level is level 4, and the fault intensity evaluation score F1 is 20; when the fault impact scope is a single equipment outage, the fault intensity level is level 5, and the fault intensity evaluation score F1 is 10.
5. A petrochemical equipment failure intensity evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S2, the fault economic loss evaluation criteria are as follows: when the fault economic loss reaches more than 10 million yuan, the fault intensity level is level 1, and the fault intensity evaluation score F2 is 100; when the fault economic loss is between 3 million and 10 million yuan, the fault intensity level is level 2, and the fault intensity evaluation score F2 is 70; when the fault economic loss is between 1 million and 3 million yuan, the fault intensity level is level 3, and the fault intensity evaluation score F2 is 40; when the fault economic loss is between 300,000 and 1 million yuan, the fault intensity level is level 4, and the fault intensity evaluation score F2 is 20; when the fault economic loss is less than 300,000 yuan, the fault intensity level is level 5, and the fault intensity evaluation score F2 is 10.
6. A petrochemical equipment failure intensity evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S2, the evaluation criteria for the number of fault repetitions are: when the number of fault repetitions is that the fault has occurred in the enterprise within 1 year, the fault intensity level is level 1, and the fault intensity evaluation score F3 is 100; when the number of fault repetitions is that the fault has occurred in the enterprise within 5 years, the fault intensity level is level 2, and the fault intensity evaluation score F3 is 70; when the number of fault repetitions is that the fault has occurred in the enterprise within 10 years, the fault intensity level is level 3, and the fault intensity evaluation score F3 is 40; when the number of fault repetitions is that the fault has occurred in the history of the enterprise, the fault intensity level is level 4, and the fault intensity evaluation score F3 is 20; when the number of fault repetitions is the first time that the fault has occurred, the fault intensity level is level 5, and the fault intensity evaluation score F3 is 10.
7. A petrochemical equipment failure intensity evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S2, the fault cause evaluation criteria are: when the fault cause is equipment design, the fault intensity level is level 1, and the fault intensity evaluation score F4 is 100; when the fault cause is loopholes in management system, guarantee mechanism, and personnel ability, the fault cause is level 2, and the fault intensity evaluation score F4 is 70; when the fault cause is equipment manufacturing, the fault intensity level is level 3, and the fault intensity evaluation score F4 is 40; when the fault cause is human error, the fault intensity level is level 4, and the fault intensity evaluation score F4 is 20; when the fault cause is equipment installation and construction, the fault intensity level is level 5, and the fault intensity evaluation score F4 is 10.
8. A petrochemical equipment failure intensity evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: Step S3 includes the following sub-steps: S3.1: Collect or create 500 typical failure cases, compile the failure cases in the form of reports, and form 500 failure reports; S3.2: The system automatically captures keywords in the fault report and conducts quantitative evaluation of the fault; S3.3: Proofread the completed fault quantitative evaluation, and improve the automatic crawling rules according to the proofreading results to ensure the accuracy of automatic crawling; S3.4: Repeat steps S3.3 and S3.4 to ensure that the automatic grasping accuracy exceeds 99%.
9. A petrochemical equipment failure intensity evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S4, the weighted intensity calculation formula of the fault is: R f =0.4*F1+0.3*F2+0.2*F3+0.1*F4。 10. A petrochemical equipment failure intensity evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S5, when the weighted intensity of the fault is ≥80, the final level of the fault intensity is A; when the weighted intensity of the fault is between 60 and 80, the final level of the fault intensity is B; when the weighted intensity of the fault is between 40 and 60, the final level of the fault intensity is C; when the weighted intensity of the fault is ≤40, the final level of the fault intensity is D.
11. A petrochemical equipment fault intensity evaluation system, characterized in that: A petrochemical equipment fault intensity evaluation method as described in any one of claims 1 to 10 is adopted, comprising a construction module, an acquisition module and an evaluation module; The construction module is used for a fault intensity evaluation system, wherein the fault intensity evaluation system includes fault evaluation factors and weights and four fault evaluation criteria, wherein the fault evaluation criteria include a fault impact range evaluation criterion, a fault economic loss evaluation criterion, a fault repetition number evaluation criterion, and a fault cause evaluation criterion; A capture module is used to capture keywords from the input fault report; An acquisition module, used to acquire the fault intensity evaluation scores of four fault evaluation criteria of the petrochemical equipment to be evaluated according to the captured keywords; The evaluation module is used to determine the final fault intensity level of the petrochemical equipment to be evaluated according to the fault intensity evaluation score.
Citation Information
Cited By
Fault alarm method and system, storage medium and electronic equipment
CN119863105A
