Three-layer energy consumption system impact resistance detection method based on SPH-FEM coupling method

Through the SPH-FEM coupling method and Logistic regression model, the dynamic response and stress state of the composite cushion under the impact of falling rocks was studied, and the problem of insufficient research on the mechanical behavior of the composite cushion in the existing technology was solved, and the selection of protective materials and structural layout were improved. The accuracy of the collision avoidance capability is enhanced.

CN119049620APending Publication Date: 2024-11-29EAST CHINA JIAOTONG UNIVERSITY
View PDF 5 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202411545222.1
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-11-01
Publication Date
2024-11-29

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The mechanical behavior of the composite cushion layer under the impact of falling rocks is rarely studied, and it has not started from the stress state of the concrete material itself, which limits the accuracy of the selection of protective materials and the rationality of structural layout, resulting in the prediction of anti-collision ability. difficulty.

Method used

The numerical model of the three-layer energy-consuming system was established based on the SPH-FEM coupling method, including concrete slabs, sandy soil layer and EPS foam layer. The composite cushion with impact resistance better than sand cushion layer was obtained through dynamic response analysis, and the composite cushion layer was obtained through Logistic regression. The model establishes a stress state recognition model of the RPC plate to determine the optimal thickness and protective structure.

Benefits of technology

A detailed study on the dynamic response and energy dissipation mechanism of the composite cushion under the impact of falling rocks has been achieved, the accuracy of the selection of protective materials and the rationality of structural layout have been improved, and the prediction ability of anti-collision capabilities has been enhanced.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN119049620A_ABST
    Figure CN119049620A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention relates to the technical field of composite cushion layer impact resistance detection, and discloses a three-layer energy consumption system impact resistance detection method based on an SPH-FEM coupling method, and the method comprises the steps: determining composite cushion layer protection structures of multiple groups of shed tunnels and a group of protection structures composed of sand cushion layers; establishing a falling rock impact three-layer energy consumption system numerical model and a sand cushion energy consumption system numerical model based on an SPH-FEM coupling frame according to the determined protection structure; according to the three-layer energy dissipation system impact resistance detection method based on the SPH-FEM coupling method, through a numerical model simulation result established based on SPH-FEM coupling, optimal thickness research on a composite cushion layer impacted by falling rocks is facilitated, and dynamic responses such as a complex impact process and an energy dissipation mechanism are included. Besides, based on the Logistic regression model, an RPC board stress state identification model can be established, the limit impact energy level of the RPC board can be conveniently researched, the protection material can be conveniently and accurately selected, and the rationality of the structural layout of the protection material and the pre-judgment capability of the anti-collision performance can be ensured.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention relates to the technical field of composite cushion layer impact resistance detection, in particular to a three-layer energy consumption system impact resistance detection method based on a SPH-FEM coupling method. Background Art

[0002] At present, the last line of defense near traffic routes often uses a protective shed tunnel structure. The protective shed tunnel generally adopts a reinforced concrete structure and lays a relatively thick sand buffer layer on the top of the structure, which easily leads to problems such as heavy structure and high cost. In addition, it is difficult to construct due to restrictions such as structure height, traffic flow, topography, etc. Therefore, it is particularly important to use new high-strength materials and new protective structure systems to reduce weight and burden while ensuring improved protective toughness.

[0003] Due to site conditions, it is often necessary to combine the bridge structure and the shed-tunnel structure into one to achieve integrated bridge-shed protection. Unlike the traditional protective shed-tunnel structure that uses a thick sand layer for buffering, the bridge-shed integration requires the thickness of the sand paving on the top of the shed-tunnel to be minimized to reduce its own weight. Therefore, the dynamic impact effect of rockfall collapse is more significant, which requires engineers to focus on its impact resistance design. In addition, the shed-tunnel design is thinner, so the analysis and evaluation of its protection performance is more important.

[0004] Polystyrene foam material (EPS for short) has good application prospects in the engineering field due to its low density, corrosion resistance, good shock-proof and buffering performance. EPS foam material is prone to punching and cracking under impact loads, which seriously affects the normal use of the protective pad. The composite cushion system of board + sand + EPS can protect the main structure from the impact of falling rocks.

[0005] Existing literature on composite cushions under rockfall impact mostly focuses on the in-depth exploration and optimization of their buffering performance, and there are few studies on the mechanical behavior of composite cushions under rockfall impact. In addition, the existing technology is still insufficient, that is, it has not systematically explored and defined the rockfall impact energy level of the composite cushion protective structure under various safety stress thresholds based on the stress state of the concrete material itself. This lack of research on the safety threshold of the material layer stress state limits the accuracy of the selection of protective materials, the rationality of the structural layout, and the prediction of anti-collision capabilities. Summary of the invention

[0006] In order to solve the problem that there are few studies on the mechanical behavior of composite cushions under the impact of falling rocks in the above existing literature, and the existing technology does not start from the stress state of the concrete material itself, systematically explore and define the rockfall impact energy level of the composite cushion protection structure under various safety stress thresholds, which limits the accuracy of the selection of protective materials, the rationality of the structural layout and the prediction of the anti-collision capability, the present invention is implemented through the following technical solutions: A three-layer energy dissipation system anti-impact detection method based on the SPH-FEM coupling method, including the following methods, Determine the composite cushion protection structure of multiple groups of shed caves and a group of protection structures composed of sand cushion; According to the determined protective structure, a numerical model of a three-layer energy dissipation system of rockfall impact and a numerical model of a sand cushion energy dissipation system based on an SPH-FEM coupling framework are established; Obtaining a dynamic response of the protective structure during a rockfall impact; The composite cushion layer of the protective structure composed of the sand cushion layer is obtained by analysis and impact resistance is better than that of the protective structure composed of the sand cushion layer; Analyze and obtain the optimal thickness of the composite cushion protection structure; Based on the classification model, a stress state identification model of the RPC plate protected by the composite cushion layer is established.

[0007] Furthermore, the composite cushion layer is composed of a concrete slab, a sand layer and an EPS foam layer, and the concrete slab, the sand layer and the EPS foam layer are sequentially distributed from top to bottom; The overall dimensions of the plurality of groups of composite cushion layers are the same, the thickness of the concrete slabs are the same, and the overall dimensions of the sand cushion layers are the same as the overall dimensions of the composite cushion layers.

[0008] Furthermore, a three-layer energy dissipation system numerical model based on SPH-FEM coupling was established using LS-DYNA software. The three-layer energy dissipation system numerical model consists of a concrete pier, an RPC slab, a composite cushion and falling rocks. Specifically: The concrete pier is modeled by solid elements. The physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 2650 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 32.5 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.2; the RPC plate is modeled by solid elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 2650 kg / m 3 , the shear modulus is 16.8 GPa; the steel bars in the RPC slab are modeled using beam elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 7850 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 200 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3, yield stress is 500 MPa, secant modulus is 200 MPa, and unit failure strain is 0.2; the steel bars are coupled to the RPC plate through the solid constraint Lagrangian method; The concrete slab is modeled by solid elements, and the material model physical parameters include a mass density of 2650 kg / m 3 The damage mode adopts the maximum brittle and ductile damage, the unit failure strain is set to 1.06, the concrete strength is 30MPa, and the maximum aggregate size is set to 19mm; the steel bars in the concrete slab are modeled using beam elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 7850kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 200 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3, yield stress is 500 MPa, secant modulus is 200 MPa, and unit failure strain is 0.2; the steel bars are coupled to the concrete slab through the solid constraint Lagrangian method; The impact surface and non-impact surface of the sand layer are modeled using SPH particles and FEM units respectively. The physical parameters of the material model include mass density of 1628 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 40MPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3; The EPS foam layer is modeled by solid elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 20 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 3.7MPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.4; The rockfall is modeled by solid elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 2735 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 20 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3; The interaction contact between SPH particles and falling rocks, EPS foam layer and FEM elements was defined as automatic point-to-surface contact, and the contact type between the concrete slab, FEM elements, EPS foam layer, RPC slab, concrete pier and ground was set to automatic surface-to-surface contact.

[0009] Furthermore, the numerical model of the sand cushion energy dissipation system based on SPH-FEM coupling was established using LS-DYNA software. The numerical model of the sand cushion energy dissipation system consists of concrete piers, RPC slabs, sand cushions and fallen rocks. Specifically: The concrete pier is modeled by solid elements. The physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 2650 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 32.5 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.2; the RPC plate is modeled by solid elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 2650 kg / m 3 , the shear modulus is 16.8 GPa; the steel bars in the RPC slab are modeled using beam elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 7850 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 200 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3, yield stress is 500 MPa, secant modulus is 200 MPa, and unit failure strain is 0.2; the steel bars are coupled to the RPC plate through the solid constraint Lagrangian method; The impact surface and non-impact surface of the sand cushion layer are modeled using SPH particles and FEM units respectively. The physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 1628 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 40MPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3; The rockfall is modeled by solid elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 2735 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 20 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3; The interaction contact between SPH particles and rockfall was defined as automatic point-to-surface contact, and the contact type between FEM elements, RPC slabs, concrete piers, and the ground was set to automatic surface-to-surface contact.

[0010] Furthermore, in the method based on SPH-FEM coupling, the contact condition at the interface between the SPH particle and the FEM unit contact surface follows the Runge-Kutta method: ; in, represents the gap function, The contact force is represented. The interaction between SPH particles and FEM units is realized by a penalty function based on automatic point-to-surface contact. The SPH particles are set as slave nodes and the FEM units are set as master surfaces.

[0011] Furthermore, the dynamic response includes an energy dissipation mechanism and a stress response, wherein the energy dissipation mechanism includes an energy dissipation mechanism of the composite cushion layer, and the stress response includes a stress response in a three-layer energy dissipation system and a stress response in a sand cushion layer energy dissipation system; The energy dissipation mechanism of the composite cushion layer includes the dissipated energy and erosion energy of the concrete slab, the dissipated energy of the sand layer and the dissipated energy of the ESP foam layer in the three-layer energy dissipation system numerical model, and also includes the energy dissipation proportion of each layer in the composite cushion layer; The stress response in the three-layer energy dissipation system includes the maximum contact force of the RPC plate in the three-layer energy dissipation system numerical model, the maximum stress of the steel bars in the RPC plate and the minimum principal stress of the RPC plate; The stress response in the sand cushion energy dissipation system includes the maximum contact force of the RPC plate in the numerical model of the sand cushion energy dissipation system, the maximum stress of the steel bars in the RPC plate and the minimum principal stress of the RPC plate.

[0012] Furthermore, according to the stress response obtained after the rockfall impacts the composite cushion layer and the sand cushion layer, it is judged whether the impact resistance of the composite cushion layer is better than that of the sand cushion layer.

[0013] Furthermore, the composite cushion protective structure with the best thickness is obtained by combining the energy consumption mechanism, cost and overall weight density of the composite cushion.

[0014] Furthermore, the RPC plate includes three stress states: Elastic state: ; Elastic-plastic state: ; Plastic damage state: ; in, is the stress of the RPC plate when it is impacted, For compressive strength.

[0015] Furthermore, the classification model is a Logistic regression model, which uses a linear decision boundary in the feature space for binary classification and extends it to a nonlinear boundary to establish the stress state recognition model, specifically: Randomly generate several samples of falling rocks with different impact velocities and masses, and calculate the RPC plate stress value corresponding to each sample; The nonlinear decision boundaries of the elastic state and elastoplastic state of the RPC plate under the set strength and determined composite cushion protection structure are obtained through the logistic regression algorithm in Python, and then the stress state identification model of the RPC plate is obtained.

[0016] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following beneficial effects: The three-layer energy dissipation system impact resistance detection method based on the SPH-FEM coupling method is convenient for studying the optimal thickness of the composite cushion impacted by falling rocks, including dynamic responses such as complex impact processes and energy dissipation mechanisms, through the simulation results of the numerical model established based on the SPH-FEM coupling. In addition, based on the Logistic regression algorithm, a stress state identification model of the RPC plate can be established to facilitate the study of the ultimate impact energy level of the RPC plate, facilitate the accurate selection of protective materials, and ensure the rationality of the structural layout of the protective materials and the ability to predict the anti-collision performance. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0017] Figure 1 This is a numerical model diagram of a three-layer energy consumption system in an embodiment of the present invention; Figure 2 Schematic diagram of SPH-FEM coupling contact at its interface in an embodiment of the present invention; Figure 3 It is a schematic diagram of the impact process of the numerical model of the composite cushion under the impact of falling rocks in an embodiment of the present invention; Figure 4 Schematic diagram of energy dissipation of the composite cushion layer in an embodiment of the present invention; Figure 5 Schematic diagram of dissipated energy and erosion energy of a concrete slab in an embodiment of the present invention; Figure 6 Schematic diagram of vertical displacement response of the composite cushion layer at different moments after being impacted in an embodiment of the present invention; Figure 7 It is a comparative schematic diagram of the contact force of the RPC plate in the three-layer energy dissipation system and the sand cushion layer energy dissipation system in the embodiment of the present invention; Figure 8 Schematic diagram of the stress response of the RPC plate in the sand cushion energy dissipation system in the embodiment of the present invention; Fig. 9 Schematic diagram of the stress response of the RPC board in the three-layer energy dissipation system in the embodiment of the present invention; Fig.10 Schematic diagram of the stress state identification model of the RPC plate subjected to rockfall impact load in an embodiment of the present invention; Fig.11 Schematic diagram of stress state identification model comparison of elastic states of C120 and C50 RPC plates in an embodiment of the present invention; Fig.12 Schematic diagram of stress state identification model comparison of elastic-plastic states of C120 and C50 RPC plates in an embodiment of the present invention; Fig.13 Schematic diagram of stress state identification model comparison of RPC plate elastic state corresponding to RSE1, RSE2 and RSE4 in the embodiment of the present invention; Fig.14 Schematic diagram for comparing stress state identification models of the elastic-plastic state of RPC plates corresponding to RSE1, RSE2, and RSE4 in an embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0018] The following will be combined with the drawings in the embodiments of the present invention to clearly and completely describe the technical solutions in the embodiments of the present invention. Obviously, the described embodiments are only part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the scope of protection of the present invention.

[0019] The embodiment of the three-layer energy consumption system anti-shock detection method based on the SPH-FEM coupling method is as follows: See also Figure 1-Figure 14 , the impact resistance detection method of the three-layer energy consumption system based on the SPH-FEM coupling method includes the following methods, The first step is to determine the composite cushion protection structure of multiple groups of shed caves and a group of protection structures composed of sand cushion layers.

[0020] Among them, the composite cushion layer is composed of a concrete slab, a sand layer and an EPS foam layer, and the concrete slab, the sand layer and the EPS foam layer are distributed in sequence from top to bottom; the overall dimensions of multiple groups of composite cushion layers are the same, the thickness of the concrete slab is the same, and the overall dimension of the sand cushion layer is the same as the overall dimension of the composite cushion layer.

[0021] In the second step, according to the determined protection structure, a numerical model of the three-layer energy dissipation system of rockfall impact and a numerical model of the sand cushion energy dissipation system based on the SPH-FEM coupling framework were established.

[0022] The third step is to obtain the dynamic response of the protective structure during the rockfall impact process, where the dynamic response includes energy dissipation mechanism and stress response. The energy dissipation mechanism includes the energy dissipation mechanism of the composite cushion layer, and the stress response includes the stress response in the three-layer energy dissipation system and the stress response in the sand cushion layer energy dissipation system. The RPC board is a reactive powder concrete shed hole board. The energy dissipation mechanism of the composite cushion layer includes the dissipated energy and erosion energy of the concrete slab, the dissipated energy of the sand layer, and the dissipated energy of the ESP foam layer in the three-layer energy dissipation system numerical model. The dissipated energy of the concrete slab includes internal energy and kinetic energy, the dissipated energy of the sand layer includes internal energy and kinetic energy, and the dissipated energy of the EPS foam layer includes internal energy and kinetic energy. The energy dissipation mechanism also includes the energy consumption proportion of each layer in the composite cushion layer.

[0023] The stress response in the three-layer energy dissipation system includes the maximum contact force of the RPC plate in the numerical model of the three-layer energy dissipation system, the maximum stress of the steel bars in the RPC plate, and the minimum principal stress of the RPC plate; the stress response in the sand cushion energy dissipation system includes the maximum contact force of the RPC plate in the numerical model of the sand cushion energy dissipation system, the maximum stress of the steel bars in the RPC plate, and the minimum principal stress of the RPC plate.

[0024] The fourth step is to analyze and obtain a composite cushion layer whose impact resistance is better than that of the protective structure composed of a sand cushion layer, and judge whether the impact resistance of the composite cushion layer is better than that of the sand cushion layer based on the stress response obtained after the falling rocks impact the composite cushion layer and the sand cushion layer.

[0025] The fifth step is to analyze and obtain the optimal thickness of the composite cushion protection structure, and combine the energy consumption mechanism, cost and overall weight density of the composite cushion to obtain the optimal thickness of the composite cushion protection structure.

[0026] The sixth step is to establish a stress state identification model of the RPC plate under the protection of the composite cushion based on the classification model.

[0027] The classification model is a Logistic regression model. A linear decision boundary is used in the feature space for binary classification and extended to a nonlinear boundary to establish a stress state recognition model. Specifically: Several samples of falling rocks with different impact velocities and masses are randomly generated, and the corresponding RPC plate stress value of each sample is calculated. The nonlinear decision boundary related to the elastic state and elastoplastic state behavior of the RPC plate under the set strength and the determined composite cushion protection structure is obtained through the logistic regression algorithm in Python, and then the stress state identification model of the RPC plate is obtained.

[0028] The specific implementation is as follows: like Figure 1 As shown in the figure, in the numerical model of the three-layer energy dissipation system, the size of the RPC slab is 3.5m×2.2m×0.3m, the size of the composite cushion is 2m×2m×0.9m, the thickness of the concrete slab is 10cm, and a steel bar layer consisting of two layers of steel bars is arranged in the RPC slab, and the spacing of the steel bars in two directions in the steel bar layer is 100mm. Among them, the diameters of the longitudinal and transverse steel bars are 20mm and 14mm respectively, and the yield strength is 335MPa. In addition, the diameter of the stirrups is 12mm, and the yield strength is 330MPa. A single layer of steel bars is arranged in the concrete slab, the distance between the steel bars in two directions is 100mm, the diameter of the steel bars is 16mm, and the yield strength is 500MPa.

[0029] The physical parameters of the concrete pier, composite cushion and rockfall are shown in Table 1: Table 1 ; The material properties of the RPC board are shown in Table 2: Table 2 ; In Table 2: R 0 is the material density; G is the material shear modulus; FC is the quasi-static uniaxial compressive strength ; T is the maximum tensile hydrostatic pressure (uniaxial tensile strength); A is the normalized cohesive strength coefficient; B is the normalized pressure hardening coefficient; C is the strain rate coefficient; N is the pressure hardening exponent; SFMAX is the normalized maximum strength value; PC is the crushing pressure; UC is the crushing volume strain; PL is the compaction pressure; UL is the compaction volume strain; K1, K2, K3 are pressure coefficients; D1 and D2 are damage parameters; EFMIN is the plastic strain before fracture (the minimum crushing strain of the material); EPS0 is the reference strain rate.

[0030] In order to study the optimal composition of the three-layer energy dissipation system, three composite cushions with different thicknesses were designed: a composite cushion system consisting of an upper 10 cm concrete slab, a middle 30 cm sand layer, and a lower 50 cm EPS foam layer, denoted as RSE1; a composite cushion system consisting of an upper 10 cm concrete slab, a middle 40 cm sand layer, and a lower 40 cm EPS foam layer, denoted as RSE2; and a composite cushion system consisting of an upper 10 cm concrete slab, a middle 50 cm sand layer, and a lower 30 cm EPS foam layer, denoted as RSE3. Among them, the strength of the concrete slab is 30 MPa (C30).

[0031] In the sand cushion energy dissipation system, the size of the sand cushion is 2m×2m×0.9m, and the other structural dimensions are the same as those in the three-layer energy dissipation system.

[0032] The LS-DYNA software was used to establish a three-layer energy dissipation system numerical model based on SPH-FEM coupling. The three-layer energy dissipation system numerical model consists of concrete piers, RPC slabs, composite cushions and fallen rocks. Specifically: The concrete pier is modeled by solid elements. The physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 2650 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 32.5 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.2; the RPC plate is modeled by solid elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 2650 kg / m 3 , the shear modulus is 16.8 GPa, see Table 2 for details; the steel bars in the RPC slab are modeled using beam elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 7850 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 200 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3, yield stress is 500 MPa, secant modulus is 200 MPa, and unit failure strain is 0.2; the steel bars are coupled to the RPC plate through the solid constraint Lagrangian method; The concrete slab is modeled by solid elements, and the material model physical parameters include a mass density of 2650 kg / m 3 The damage mode adopts the maximum brittle and ductile damage, the unit failure strain is set to 1.06, the concrete strength is 30MPa, and the maximum aggregate size is set to 19mm; the steel bars in the concrete slab are modeled using beam elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 7850kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 200 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3, yield stress is 500 MPa, secant modulus is 200 MPa, and unit failure strain is 0.2; the steel bars are coupled to the concrete slab through the solid constraint Lagrangian method; The impact surface and non-impact surface of the sand layer are modeled using SPH particles and FEM units respectively. The physical parameters of the material model include mass density of 1628 kg / m 3, Young's modulus is 40MPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3; The EPS foam layer is modeled by solid elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 20 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 3.7MPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.4; The rockfall is modeled by solid elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 2735 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 20 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3; The interaction contact between SPH particles and falling rocks, EPS foam layer and FEM elements was defined as automatic point-to-surface contact, and the contact type between the concrete slab, FEM elements, EPS foam layer, RPC slab, concrete pier and ground was set to automatic surface-to-surface contact.

[0033] The numerical model of the sand cushion energy dissipation system based on SPH-FEM coupling was established using LS-DYNA software. The numerical model of the sand cushion energy dissipation system consists of concrete piers, RPC slabs, sand cushions and fallen rocks. Specifically: The concrete pier is modeled by solid elements. The physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 2650 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 32.5 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.2; the RPC plate is modeled by solid elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 2650 kg / m 3 , the shear modulus is 16.8 GPa; the steel bars in the RPC slab are modeled using beam elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 7850 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 200 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3, yield stress is 500 MPa, secant modulus is 200 MPa, and unit failure strain is 0.2; the steel bars are coupled to the RPC plate through the solid constraint Lagrangian method; The impact surface and non-impact surface of the sand cushion layer are modeled using SPH particles and FEM units respectively. The physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 1628 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 40MPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3; The rockfall is modeled by solid elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 2735 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 20 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3; The interaction contact between SPH particles and rockfall was defined as automatic point-to-surface contact, and the contact type between FEM elements, RPC slabs, concrete piers, and the ground was set to automatic surface-to-surface contact.

[0034] It should be noted that regarding the SPH-FEM coupling method, the FEM (finite element) method can intuitively simulate the change process of the internal force of the structure under the influence of external forces. It has a strong dependence on the unit grid, and the main problem inherent in the FEM method is related to the grid deformation in large deformation simulation. The meshless characteristics of the SPH method can properly solve the grid deformation problem. Compared with the FEM method, the SPH method can better demonstrate the splash and shrinkage phenomenon of rockfall impact on the sand layer or sand cushion layer. However, compared with the FEM method, the computational cost of the SPH method is very high, so the SPH-FEM coupling method can make full use of the advantages of the SPH method in dealing with large deformation problems, while improving the accuracy and stability of the simulation calculation.

[0035] like Figure 2 As shown in the figure, in the method based on SPH-FEM coupling, the contact condition at the interface between the SPH particle and the FEM unit contact surface follows the Runge-Kutta method: ; in, represents the gap function, The contact force is represented. The interaction between SPH particles and FEM units is realized by a penalty function based on automatic point-to-surface contact. The SPH particles are set as slave nodes and the FEM units are set as master surfaces.

[0036] In the SPH-FEM coupling framework, the SPH and FEM methods use leapfrog explicit integration and central difference method for time integration, respectively. Coupling these two methods requires synchronous integration and using the same time step in each step in the same computational framework context. The time step is: ; in: , ; in, is the speed of sound, is the smoothing length, is the time scale factor, is the minimum element length, is the time step of the SPH method, is the time step of the FEM method, is the time step of SPH-FEM coupling.

[0037] The dynamic responses of the composite cushions of three different thicknesses under different rockfall impact energy levels are shown in Table 3 below, where the rockfall is 760 kg, the free fall height is 6.68-20.03 m, and the impact load is 50-150 kJ.

[0038] Table 3 ; In Table 3, Q is the impact energy, σ1 is the maximum principal stress of the RPC board, σ3 is the minimum principal stress of the RPC board, σs is the effective stress of the steel bar, and Fp is the peak contact force between the EPS foam layer and the RPC board.

[0039] The dynamic response of rockfall impact on composite cushion protective shed tunnel structure is analyzed based on LS-DYNA dynamics software. The mechanical properties of composite cushion under impact are investigated from three aspects: impact process (mechanism), energy dissipation mechanism, and displacement response.

[0040] The impact energy level of the rockfall is 250 kJ, the mass is 1410 kg, and the impact velocity is 18.83 m / s. Figure 3 As shown in the figure, the dissipated energy of the composite cushion and the concrete slab are respectively Figure 4 and Figure 5 As shown in Figure 2, the displacement response of the composite cushion is Figure 6 shown.

[0041] The contact start between the rockfall and the composite cushion surface is set to 0s. Figure 3 As shown, the impact process exhibits a high degree of transientness, and the composite cushion layer undergoes significant deformation under the impact of falling rocks, demonstrating its effectiveness in absorbing impact energy.

[0042] The instant when the rockfall begins to contact the composite cushion surface is set to 0s. Figure 4 It can be seen that the entire impact process lasts for a very short time, and the deformation of the composite cushion under the impact is more obvious.

[0043] When t=0s, the rockfall contacts the concrete slab, and the impact kinetic energy of the rockfall is quickly transferred to the concrete slab, causing the concrete in the contact area of ​​the concrete slab to break and fail. At this time, part of the kinetic energy of the rockfall is converted into the kinetic energy, internal energy and erosion energy of the concrete slab, which are 11.63kJ, 63.49kJ and 61kJ respectively. Figure 5 As shown in the figure, the three account for about 54.5% of the total energy. It can be seen that concrete slabs consume energy in various ways and account for a large proportion of energy consumption.

[0044] As the collision process progresses, the rockfall begins to contact the surface of the sand layer. In addition, the surface particles of the sand layer are deformed by the impact load, which absorbs and dissipates the impact energy through displacement and friction between particles. Figure 4 The results plotted in Figure 2 show that the energy absorbed and dissipated by the sand layer is about 80 kJ, accounting for 32% of the total energy. At t = 0.01 s, the EPS foam layer consumes energy through deformation, reaching a peak energy consumption of about 33.75 kJ at t = 0.04 s, accounting for about 13.5% of the total energy.

[0045] According to the above results, the composite cushion has a good energy dissipation effect, which mainly relies on the crushing and rebound of the concrete slab and the friction between the sand particles in the sand layer. The energy consumption of the EPS foam layer accounts for only a small part, which takes advantage of the light weight of the EPS material and avoids the disadvantage of the EPS material being easy to break under impact load.

[0046] The displacement process is Figure 6 As shown, the rockfall collided with the concrete slab, subsequently causing a rapid increase in vertical displacement within the concrete slab, leading to failure and spalling of the concrete slab in the impact zone of the composite cushion, as shown in Figure 6 At t = 0.003s, the vertical displacement of the concrete slab triggers the sand particles in the sand layer to start falling, as shown in (a). Figure 6 As shown in (b), this process is accompanied by friction, squeezing and energy dissipation in the sand layer. As the impact process continues, the displacement of the sand layer gradually propagates from the impact contact area to the adjacent area. At t = 0.009s, the displacement of the EPS foam layer shows a rapid increase in the direction of the rockfall path, initially concentrated in the center of the cushion layer, and then gradually diffuses to its periphery. As the contact area between the rockfall and the composite cushion layer gradually increases, the displacement stripes in the central area of ​​the cushion layer show a clear pattern, characterized by low displacement values ​​in the core and gradually increasing displacement values ​​radiating from the center to the outside, as shown in Figure 2. Figure 6 This phenomenon occurs because the EPS foam layer in the central area of ​​the contact surface is mainly subjected to triaxial compression, while the EPS foam layer and sand layer in the peripheral area mainly experience shear deformation.

[0047] In order to highlight the performance advantages of composite cushions over traditional sand cushions, a comparative analysis was conducted on the impact resistance of composite cushions and sand cushions under impact loads. In the impact experiment, a 90 cm thick sand cushion was taken as an example, and the significant advantages of the composite cushion in terms of protection efficiency and structural stability were analyzed based on multi-dimensional indicators (i.e., contact force, RPC plate principal stress and steel bar stress). Figure 7 A comparison of the contact forces of the main structure is provided, Table 4 and Figure 8 and Fig. 9 The stresses generated in the RPC plate are provided.

[0048] from Figure 7 It can be seen that after the rockfall contacts the 90cm sand cushion, the contact force of the RPC plate increases rapidly and reaches a maximum value of 1070kN within the time interval of [0.03s, 0.04s]. In addition, under the protection of the composite cushion, the maximum contact force of the main structure is about 711.7kN, a decrease of 33.49%, which shows that the three-layer energy dissipation system absorbs most of the impact energy.

[0049] Table 4 ; As shown in Table 4, the maximum stress of the steel bar reached 48.94 MPa, while the minimum principal stress of the RPC slab protected by the 90 cm thick sand cushion was 11.5 MPa. In contrast, the implementation of the composite cushion resulted in a significant reduction in stress levels. The peak stress of the steel bar was reduced to 21.5 MPa, a 56% reduction, while the minimum principal stress on the RPC slab dropped to 1.95 MPa, a 83% reduction. In contrast, the effectiveness and reliability of the proposed composite cushion in protecting the main structure from rockfall impact damage have been well demonstrated.

[0050] As can be seen from Table 3, with the decrease of the thickness of the EPS foam layer and the increase of the impact energy of the rockfall, the maximum principal stress of the RPC board, the effective stress of the steel bar, and the contact force between the EPS foam layer and the RPC board all show an increasing trend. In the three-layer energy dissipation system, the static load of the main structure of RSE3 significantly exceeds that of the system RSE2 by 12.2% and that of RSE1 by 27.8%. Compared with RES2, RES1 shows slightly better buffering performance; however, the growth trend of the main structure stress and the steel bar stress is relatively mild. In addition, the use of a relatively thin sand layer may damage the overall stability of the protection system, causing the EPS foam layer to break when the rockfall hits, which will have an adverse effect on the safety and stability of the structure. Considering the economic impact, RES2 has a lower application cost, which can save 15.6% compared with RES1. Among the three different three-layer energy dissipation systems mentioned above, RES2 is the best choice.

[0051] According to the prior art, when the stress is applied to the normal strength less than 0.3 When the stress is close to 0.7, the stress-strain relationship can be approximated by a straight line, which indicates that the concrete specimen is in the elastic stage. -0.8 The stress-strain curve of the concrete specimen gradually deviates from linearity and exhibits plastic properties characterized by cracks inside the concrete specimen, which do not affect the overall structural integrity. When the concrete specimen is subjected to the stress test, longitudinal cracks appear on the surface of the concrete specimen, indicating that the concrete specimen gradually loses its bearing capacity and enters the plastic damage stage, at which time obvious plastic deformation and internal damage accumulation occur. To ensure safety, three different stress states of the RPC plate are described here: Elastic state: ; Elastic-plastic state: ; Plastic damage state: ; in, δ is the stress of the RPC plate when it is impacted, f c For compressive strength.

[0052] Based on 100 randomly generated rockfall samples with different impact velocities and masses, the stress value of the RPC plate corresponding to each sample is calculated; the nonlinear decision boundary related to the elastic state and elastoplastic state behavior of the RPC plate under the set strength and the determined composite cushion protection structure is obtained by the logistic regression algorithm in Python, and then the stress state identification model of the RPC plate is obtained; for the logistic regression algorithm, the binary variable y is used, where y=0 means that the RPC plate is in the elastic state (i.e., δ<0.3 ), y=1 means it exceeds the threshold value of 0.3 stress state.

[0053] Based on the composite cushion protection structure of RSE2, the stress state change of the RPC plate with a strength of 120MPa (C120) is analyzed: like Fig.10 As shown in Figure 1, the nonlinear decision boundaries associated with the elastic and elastoplastic behavior of the RPC plate are mathematically represented in order as follows: (1); (2); in, v is the impact velocity of the falling rock, m is the mass of the falling rock.

[0054] The plane coordinates are divided into three regions by two precisely defined nonlinear decision boundary curves. Each of these regions corresponds to a different stress state of the RPC plate, so that its stress state can be classified under different impact conditions. Plotting the Cartesian coordinates, the rockfall mass and velocity in plane region 1 indicate that the RPC plate maintains an elastic state under the corresponding impact conditions. Regions 2 and 3 indicate that under the corresponding impact conditions, the mechanical behavior of the RPC plate is in an elastic-plastic state and a plastic damage state, respectively. The decision boundary curve between region 1 and region 2 corresponds to a stress of 25.2 MPa, and the decision boundary curve between region 2 and region 3 corresponds to a stress of 58.8 MPa. Therefore, the decision boundary curve can accurately capture the stress state of the RPC plate under the impact of rockfall of a certain mass and velocity, which is convenient for application in practical engineering.

[0055] Based on the two decision boundaries described in equations (1) and (2), the impact energy of the rockfall in the elastic state and the elastoplastic state is calculated, as shown in Table 5. It is obvious from Table 5 that the energy required to reach the critical state for a rockfall with a larger mass is much less, so active protection measures should be adopted to deal with the threat posed by these large mass rockfalls. In addition, it is recorded in the prior art that 90% of the rockfalls have a mass of less than 1360 kg, and the maximum mass is 4500 kg. Therefore, when a three-layer energy dissipation system is used to reduce the impact effect of the rockfall with a mass of 4.5 tons or less, the limit energy of the RPC plate in the elastic state remains at 1000 kJ, while the upper limit of the elastoplastic state where some permanent deformation may occur is 2400 kJ.

[0056] Table 5 ; In Table 5, m is the mass of the falling rock, v is the velocity of the falling rock, and E is the impact energy of the falling rock.

[0057] Based on the composite cushion protection structure of RSE2, the stress state change of RPC panels with a strength of 50MPa (C50) is analyzed, and RPC panels with concrete strengths of 50MPa (C50) and 120MPa (C120) are selected for comparative analysis. Fig.11 and Fig.12 A comparison of stress states for different concrete strengths can be obtained, where Fig.11 The upper limit stress threshold of the elastic state corresponding to the RPC plate of medium C50 is 10.05MPa. Fig.12 The upper limit stress threshold of the elastic-plastic state corresponding to the RPC plate with medium C50 is 24.5MPa, and the nonlinear decision boundaries of the nonlinear elastic state and the elastic-plastic state of the RPC plate with strength C50 are: ; ; When the strength of the RPC plate increases from 50 MPa to 120 MPa, the number of specimens showing elastic and elastoplastic behavior increases by 16 and 22, respectively, as shown in Tables 6 and Fig.11 , Fig.12As shown. In addition, when the concrete strength is 120MPa, the ultimate energy level under the elastic state condition rises to 1001.35kJ, which is a significant increase of 73.63% compared with the corresponding level when the RPC board strength is 50MPa. Similarly, under the elastic-plastic state, the ultimate energy level increases to 2352.13kJ, a significant increase of 32.4% compared with the 50MPa level. It can be seen that increasing the strength of the RPC board has a significant effect on the protective performance of the shed hole board. Specifically, when evaluated based on the stress-strain behavior, the impact resistance of the RPC board with C120 strength is approximately 1.3 to 1.7 times that of the RPC with C50 strength. Table 6 shows the ultimate energy level parameters of RPC boards with different strengths: Table 6 ; The analysis is based on the stress state changes of the RPC slab with a strength of 120 MPa (C120) and protected by different composite cushion protection structures, where the strength of the concrete slab in the composite cushion is 30 MPa (C30): While keeping the total thickness of the composite cushion the same, different thicknesses of composite cushions were selected. The composite cushion system consisted of an upper 10 cm concrete slab, a middle 60 cm sand layer and a lower 20 cm EPS foam layer, recorded as RSE4; three different EPS foam layer thicknesses were selected: RSE1, RSE2 and RSE4. Fig.13 and Fig.14 The comparative analysis of the stress state in the RPC plate is shown. The specific nonlinear elastic state and elastoplastic state decision boundaries of the RPC plate corresponding to RSE1 and RSE4 are shown below: ; ; ; .

[0058] Table 7 shows the limit energy level parameters of RPC plates corresponding to composite cushion layers of different thicknesses: Table 7 ; in, Fig.13 The upper limit stress threshold of the elastic state of the RPC plate corresponding to RSE2 is 25.2MPa. Fig.14 The upper limit stress threshold of the RPC plate in the elastic-plastic state corresponding to RSE2 is 58.8MPa.

[0059] like Fig.13 , Fig.14As shown in Table 7, the number of samples showing elastic and elastoplastic behaviors gradually increases with the increase of the EPS foam layer. In addition, the decision boundary of each stress state gradually moves to the upper right of the coordinate system. This is mainly because increasing the thickness of the EPS foam layer can improve the impact resistance of the composite cushion. Specifically, the ultimate energy level of the RPC board corresponding to RSE4 in the elastic state is 463.4 kJ, which is significantly reduced by 53.72% compared with the RPC board corresponding to RSE2. On the contrary, in the elastoplastic state, the ultimate energy level is 1679.51 kJ, which is a decrease of 28.6%. It can be seen that the thickness factor has a significant impact on the protective ability of the composite cushion. When the total thickness remains unchanged, within a certain range, increasing the thickness of the EPS foam layer will enhance the impact resistance of the system.

[0060] While the embodiments of the present invention have been shown and described, it will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that many changes, modifications, substitutions and variations can be made to the embodiments without departing from the principles and spirit of the invention.

Claims

1. Three-layer energy consumption system anti-shock detection method based on SPH-FEM coupling method, Features: Including the following methods, Determine the composite cushion protection structure of multiple groups of shed caves and a group of protection structures composed of sand cushion; According to the determined protective structure, a numerical model of a three-layer energy dissipation system of rockfall impact and a numerical model of a sand cushion energy dissipation system based on an SPH-FEM coupling framework are established; Obtaining a dynamic response of the protective structure during a rockfall impact; The composite cushion layer of the protective structure composed of the sand cushion layer is obtained by analysis and impact resistance is better than that of the protective structure composed of the sand cushion layer; Analyze and obtain the optimal thickness of the composite cushion protection structure; Based on the classification model, a stress state identification model of the RPC plate protected by the composite cushion layer is established.

2. According to the three-layer energy consumption system anti-shock detection method based on the SPH-FEM coupling method according to claim 1, Features: The composite cushion layer is composed of a concrete slab, a sand layer and an EPS foam layer, and the concrete slab, the sand layer and the EPS foam layer are arranged in sequence from top to bottom; The overall dimensions of the plurality of groups of composite cushion layers are the same, the thickness of the concrete slabs are the same, and the overall dimensions of the sand cushion layers are the same as the overall dimensions of the composite cushion layers.

3. According to the three-layer energy consumption system anti-shock detection method based on the SPH-FEM coupling method according to claim 2, Features: The LS-DYNA software was used to establish a three-layer energy dissipation system numerical model based on SPH-FEM coupling. The three-layer energy dissipation system numerical model consists of concrete piers, RPC slabs, composite cushions and fallen rocks. Specifically: The concrete pier is modeled by solid elements. The physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 2650 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 32.5 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.2; The RPC plate is modeled by solid elements, and the material model physical parameters include a mass density of 2650 kg / m 3 , the shear modulus is 16.8 GPa; the steel bars in the RPC slab are modeled using beam elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 7850 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 200 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3, yield stress is 500 MPa, secant modulus is 200 MPa, and unit failure strain is 0.2; the steel bars are coupled to the RPC plate through the solid constraint Lagrangian method; The concrete slab is modeled by solid elements, and the material model physical parameters include a mass density of 2650 kg / m 3 The damage mode adopts the maximum brittle and ductile damage, the unit failure strain is set to 1.06, the concrete strength is 30MPa, and the maximum aggregate size is set to 19mm; the steel bars in the concrete slab are modeled using beam elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 7850kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 200 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3, yield stress is 500 MPa, secant modulus is 200 MPa, and unit failure strain is 0.2; the steel bars are coupled to the concrete slab through the solid constraint Lagrangian method; The impact surface and non-impact surface of the sand layer are modeled using SPH particles and FEM units respectively. The physical parameters of the material model include mass density of 1628 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 40MPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3; The EPS foam layer is modeled by solid elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 20 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 3.7MPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.4; The rockfall is modeled by solid elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 2735 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 20 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3; The interaction contact between SPH particles and falling rocks, EPS foam layer and FEM elements was defined as automatic point-to-surface contact, and the contact type between the concrete slab, FEM elements, EPS foam layer, RPC slab, concrete pier and ground was set to automatic surface-to-surface contact.

4. According to claim 3, the three-layer energy consumption system anti-shock detection method based on the SPH-FEM coupling method, Features: The numerical model of the sand cushion energy dissipation system based on SPH-FEM coupling was established using LS-DYNA software. The numerical model of the sand cushion energy dissipation system consists of concrete piers, RPC slabs, sand cushions and fallen rocks. Specifically: The concrete pier is modeled by solid elements. The physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 2650 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 32.5 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.2; The RPC plate is modeled by solid elements, and the material model physical parameters include a mass density of 2650 kg / m 3 , the shear modulus is 16.8 GPa; the steel bars in the RPC slab are modeled using beam elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 7850 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 200 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3, yield stress is 500 MPa, secant modulus is 200 MPa, and unit failure strain is 0.2; the steel bars are coupled to the RPC plate through the solid constraint Lagrangian method; The impact surface and non-impact surface of the sand cushion layer are modeled using SPH particles and FEM units respectively. The physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 1628 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 40MPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3; The rockfall is modeled by solid elements, and the physical parameters of the material model include a mass density of 2735 kg / m 3 , Young's modulus is 20 GPa, Poisson's ratio is 0.3; The interaction contact between SPH particles and rockfall was defined as automatic point-to-surface contact, and the contact type between FEM elements, RPC slabs, concrete piers, and the ground was set to automatic surface-to-surface contact.

5. According to claim 4, the three-layer energy consumption system anti-shock detection method based on the SPH-FEM coupling method, Features: In the SPH-FEM coupling-based method, the contact condition at the interface between the SPH particle and the FEM unit contact surface follows the Runge-Kutta method: ; in, represents the gap function, The contact force is represented. The interaction between SPH particles and FEM units is realized by a penalty function based on automatic point-to-surface contact. The SPH particles are set as slave nodes and the FEM units are set as master surfaces.

6. According to claim 4, the three-layer energy consumption system anti-shock detection method based on the SPH-FEM coupling method, Features: The dynamic response includes energy dissipation mechanism and stress response. The energy dissipation mechanism includes the energy dissipation mechanism of the composite cushion layer. The stress response includes the stress response in the three-layer energy dissipation system and the stress response in the sand cushion layer energy dissipation system. The energy dissipation mechanism of the composite cushion layer includes the dissipated energy and erosion energy of the concrete slab, the dissipated energy of the sand layer and the dissipated energy of the ESP foam layer in the three-layer energy dissipation system numerical model, and also includes the energy dissipation proportion of each layer in the composite cushion layer; The stress response in the three-layer energy dissipation system includes the maximum contact force of the RPC plate in the three-layer energy dissipation system numerical model, the maximum stress of the steel bars in the RPC plate and the minimum principal stress of the RPC plate; The stress response in the sand cushion energy dissipation system includes the maximum contact force of the RPC plate in the numerical model of the sand cushion energy dissipation system, the maximum stress of the steel bars in the RPC plate and the minimum principal stress of the RPC plate.

7. According to claim 6, the three-layer energy consumption system anti-shock detection method based on the SPH-FEM coupling method, Features: Based on the stress response obtained after the falling rocks impact the composite cushion layer and the sand cushion layer, it is judged whether the impact resistance of the composite cushion layer is better than that of the sand cushion layer.

8. According to claim 6, the three-layer energy consumption system anti-shock detection method based on the SPH-FEM coupling method, Features: The composite cushion protective structure with the best thickness is obtained by combining the energy consumption mechanism, cost and overall weight density of the composite cushion.

9. The three-layer energy consumption system anti-shock detection method based on the SPH-FEM coupling method according to claim 8, It is characterized in that The RPC plate includes three stress states: Elastic state: ; Elastic-plastic state: ; Plastic damage state: ; in, is the stress of the RPC plate when it is impacted, For compressive strength.

10. The three-layer energy consumption system anti-shock detection method based on the SPH-FEM coupling method according to claim 9, Features: The classification model is a Logistic regression model, which uses a linear decision boundary in the feature space for binary classification and extends it to a nonlinear boundary to establish the stress state recognition model, specifically: Randomly generate several samples of falling rocks with different impact velocities and masses, and calculate the RPC plate stress value corresponding to each sample; The nonlinear decision boundaries of the elastic state and elastoplastic state of the RPC plate under the set strength and determined composite cushion protection structure are obtained through the logistic regression algorithm in Python, and then the stress state identification model of the RPC plate is obtained.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Impact response modeling method for composite laminated plate

    CN111353228A

  • Method for predicting damage engineering protection effect after high-position remote landslide

    CN111475978A

  • Corrosion-resistant ocean underwater concrete column and preparation method thereof

    CN114477921A

  • Calculation method for correction coefficient of young's modulus due to temperature stress of concrete, and calculation kit

    JP2024022057A

  • Method for detecting defects of concrete pipe using ultrasonic testing techiques

    KR102279142B1