Comprehensive evaluation method for deep peak regulation transformation scheme of coal-fired boiler
Through the hierarchical analysis method and fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method, a multi-level evaluation index system for deep peak shaving transformation of coal-fired boilers was constructed, which solved the problem of single evaluation indicators in the existing technology, and achieved a comprehensive plan for deep peak shaving transformation of coal-fired boilers. , scientific evaluation provides a more reasonable solution choice.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411076596.3
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-08-07
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-06
AI Technical Summary
The existing technology has single evaluation indicators in the deep peak-shaving transformation of coal-fired boilers, and the failure to fully consider factors such as overall operation stability and coal quality adaptability, resulting in the insensible choice of the plan.
Using a method of combining hierarchical analysis and fuzzy comprehensive evaluation, a multi-level evaluation index system is constructed, including technical adaptability, efficiency feasibility and operational reliability, and the comprehensive evaluation results of each plan are obtained through the judgment matrix and fuzzy operator calculation. .
A comprehensive and scientific evaluation of the deep peak-shaving transformation plan of coal-fired boilers has been achieved, and the evaluation indicators with the greatest impact have been accurately screened out, and the difficulties of qualitative analysis to quantitative analysis have been overcome, and a more reasonable solution choice has been provided.
Smart Images

Figure CN119090331A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of evaluation of deep peak-shaving modification schemes for coal-fired boilers, and in particular to a comprehensive evaluation method for deep peak-shaving modification schemes for coal-fired boilers. Background Art
[0002] At present, my country's peak-shaving power sources are mainly conventional coal-fired thermal power units. The implementation of coal-fired boiler deep peak-shaving projects can reduce the power output of thermal power units and provide space for the grid connection of new energy, which is in line with the current general trend of my country's power development. There are various means to achieve the goal of deep regulation of units, and each technical route has its own advantages and limitations. Due to differences in its own boiler model, coal quality characteristics, deep regulation subsidy policies in the region, etc., each coal-fired power plant needs to choose a deep regulation technology route that combines its own characteristics so that it can be consistent with its own characteristics in terms of reliability, economy, stability, etc.
[0003] At present, most studies have only analyzed the economic costs of deep peak regulation and the benefits of grid subsidies. The evaluation indicators are relatively simple, and the parties have not reached a consensus on the importance of the evaluation indicators. In addition, there is a lack of overall consideration and control of the overall operational stability of the boiler due to deep peak regulation, such as coal quality adaptability, denitrification system commissioning rate and other possible technical problems, so the evaluation of the deep peak regulation transformation plan of the boiler is not comprehensive enough.
[0004] Therefore, it is necessary to establish a complete evaluation index framework and evaluation method for deep peak regulation transformation schemes of coal-fired boilers, to provide a basis for evaluating deep regulation transformation schemes of boilers, and to further provide strong support for improving deep regulation transformation schemes of boilers. The present invention uses a method combining analytic hierarchy process with fuzzy comprehensive evaluation, comprehensively considers various factors, constructs an evaluation index system, obtains the optimal ranking of various schemes based on the evaluation index system, provides guidance for deep regulation transformation of boilers, and provides a scientific basis for scheme selection. Summary of the invention
[0005] The purpose of the present invention is to provide a comprehensive evaluation method for deep peak load regulation transformation schemes of coal-fired boilers, and to provide a scientific basis for selecting the optimal scheme. In order to achieve the above purpose, the present invention adopts the following technical scheme:
[0006] Step 1 S1: Construct an evaluation index system for the scheme. The evaluation index system is divided into the target layer, the criterion layer and the indicator layer. The target layer is the evaluation of the deep adjustment and transformation scheme of coal-fired boilers A, and the criterion layer is divided into technical adaptability B1, benefit feasibility B2 and operation reliability B3, and it is decomposed into different numbers of evaluation indicators according to the characteristics of the criterion layer. Among them, technical adaptability can be decomposed into scheme maturity C1, deep peak regulation capacity C2, and transformation construction difficulty C3; benefit feasibility can be decomposed into net present value C4, internal rate of return C5, investment payback period C6 and related subsidy policies C7; operation reliability B3 can be decomposed into coal quality applicability C8, unit non-stop rate C9 and denitrification system commissioning rate C10.
[0007] Step 2 S2: Construct a judgment matrix. The judgment matrix is used to compare the indicators in the indicator layer of a certain criterion layer, and obtain the relative importance, that is, the weight. The element cij in the matrix is a scale, representing the importance of element Ci to element Cj; the main diagonal of the matrix is always 1, and cij = 1 / cji. The judgment matrix is shown in Table 1:
[0008] Table 1 Judgment matrix example
[0009] <![CDATA[B m ]]> <![CDATA[C1]]> <![CDATA[C2]]> ... <![CDATA[C n ]]> <![CDATA[C1]]> <![CDATA[c 11 ]]> <![CDATA[c 12 ]]> ... <![CDATA[c 1n <!-- 1 -->]]> <![CDATA[C2]]> <![CDATA[c 21 ]]> <![CDATA[c 22 ]]> … <![CDATA[c 2n ]]> … … … … <![CDATA[C n ]]> <![CDATA[c n1 ]]> <![CDATA[c n2 ]]> … <![CDATA[c nn ]]>
[0010] The 1-9 scale is generally used to judge the relative importance of two elements. The specific judgment rules are shown in Table 2:
[0011] Table 2 Scales and judgment rules for each level
[0012]
[0013] Step 3 S3: Sort the hierarchy through the judgment matrix and calculate the weights of the importance order of the factors in the indicator layer for a certain criterion layer. For the judgment matrix Bm, use the sum-product method to calculate the characteristic roots and characteristic vectors that satisfy BmW = λmaxW. Each component Wi of W is the weight of the single ranking of the corresponding factor. The calculation formula of the maximum characteristic root λmax of the judgment matrix is shown in Formula 1:
[0014]
[0015] Step 4 S4: Perform consistency check on the judgment matrix to ensure that there is no deviation in the judgment matrix after expert scoring. In order to check the consistency of the judgment matrix, the consistency index CI needs to be calculated, and its calculation formula is shown in Formula 2:
[0016]
[0017] Compare CI with the average random consistency index RI of the judgment matrix found in Table 3. When the consistency ratio CR of the judgment matrix is less than 0.1, it is considered that the judgment matrix has satisfactory consistency. The calculation formula of CR is shown in Formula 3:
[0018]
[0019] Table 3 Random consistency index of judgment matrix
[0020]
[0021] Step 5 S5: Continue to calculate the ranking vector of the criterion layer (B) relative to the target layer (A) and the weights of other indicator layers (C) relative to the criterion layer (B) and calculate the consistency.
[0022] The total ranking results of C1, C2, ...Cn relative to A are shown in Table 4 below:
[0023] Table 4 Total ranking index weight table
[0024]
[0025] Step 6 S6: Establish the comment set and index set of fuzzy comprehensive evaluation. The index set is to select the evaluation indexes Ci (i = 1, 2, ..., n) mentioned above, which can be represented by C, that is:
[0026] C={C1,C2,…Cn}
[0027] Then determine the comment set, represented by V. Considering the classification level of each indicator of the coal-fired power plant and the operation status of the transformation project, the comment level is determined to be 4. Define the comment set V = {V1, V2, V3, V4}, where V1, V2, V3, V4 represent excellent, good, medium, and poor, respectively, as shown in Table 5.
[0028] Table 5 Fuzzy comprehensive evaluation review set
[0029] Rating excellent good middle Difference Points 90∽100 75∽90 60∽75 0∽60
[0030] Step 7 S7: Construct a fuzzy evaluation matrix. First, evaluate according to a single indicator, and then conduct a comprehensive evaluation under all indicator systems. Single indicator evaluation is to evaluate from the perspective of one indicator to determine the degree of membership of the project to the above evaluation set. After evaluating all indicators, the membership matrix R of the evaluation results of the project under the indicator can be obtained.
[0031]
[0032] Step 8 S8: Obtain the evaluation result K through fuzzy compound operation. Obtain the first-level fuzzy evaluation result of each criterion layer through fuzzy operator calculation, and its calculation formula is as described in Formula 4. Then, the second-level fuzzy evaluation result of the target layer is finally determined according to the weight vector result of the criterion layer.
[0033]
[0034] Through the above calculations, we can get the comprehensive evaluation results of the project under various evaluation indicators, which represents the degree of membership of the project to each evaluation result.
[0035] Step 9 S9: Calculate the final score and determine the evaluation level of the scheme. Determine the weight vector F of the evaluation set, calculate the final score X of each level of the scheme indicators, and determine the evaluation level of the scheme based on the comment set. The calculation formula of X is shown in Formula 5:
[0036] X=K·FT (Formula 5)
[0037] Compared with the prior art, the beneficial effects of the present invention are as follows: the method of the present invention is convenient and simple, easy to implement, and is used to evaluate the deep peak regulation transformation plan of coal-fired boilers. It proposes technical adaptability, benefit feasibility, and operational reliability as criteria, and establishes secondary evaluation indicators in combination with the actual production and operation of the power plant, and establishes a comprehensive evaluation index system. Compared with the prior art, this evaluation system comprehensively and reasonably demonstrates the advantages and disadvantages of the deep regulation transformation plan of coal-fired boilers. By using the hierarchical analysis method, the target is decomposed into a multi-level and multi-factor decision-making method, so that the weight assignment of each indicator is more accurate, and at the same time, the evaluation indicators with the greatest impact can be screened out and focused on; then, the judgment criteria for the advantages and disadvantages of each indicator are defined based on expert experience, and the evaluation value of each indicator is obtained. The weight of each indicator is used in the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation calculation, which overcomes the difficulty of some indicators from qualitative analysis to quantitative analysis, making the evaluation and comparison of the scheme more scientific and reasonable. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0038] Figure 1 The figure is a flow chart of the method of the present invention.
[0039] Figure 2 This is a diagram of the evaluation index system for the deep peak-shaving transformation plan of coal-fired boilers established in the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0040] The following will be combined with the drawings in the embodiments of the present invention to clearly and completely describe the technical solutions in the embodiments of the present invention. Obviously, the described embodiments are only part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the scope of protection of the present invention.
[0041] The present invention will be further described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and embodiments.
[0042] The evaluation method of the present invention is as follows Figure 1 As shown in the figure, the evaluation of a deep peak load regulation transformation plan for a coal-fired boiler includes the following steps:
[0043] Step 1: Construct the evaluation index system of the program. In the specific implementation, the evaluation system is defined as a three-level evaluation system according to the actual situation, such as Figure 2 As shown. The evaluation index system is divided into the target layer, the criterion layer and the indicator layer. The target layer is the evaluation of the deep adjustment and transformation plan of coal-fired boilers A, and the criterion layer is divided into technical adaptability B1, benefit feasibility B2 and operation reliability B3, and it is decomposed into different numbers of evaluation indicators according to the characteristics of the criterion layer. Among them, technical adaptability can be decomposed into program maturity C1, deep peak regulation capacity C2, and transformation construction difficulty C3; benefit feasibility can be decomposed into net present value C4, internal rate of return C5, investment payback period C6 and related subsidy policies C7; operation reliability B3 can be decomposed into coal quality applicability C8, unit non-stop rate C9 and denitrification system commissioning rate C10.
[0044] Step 2: Use the 1-9 scaling method to construct a judgment matrix. See Table 1, Table 2, Table 3, and Table 4 below.
[0045] Table 1A Judgment Matrix
[0046] A B1 B2 B3 B1 1 1 / 5 1 / 2 B2 5 1 3 B3 2 1 / 3 1
[0047] Table 2B1 Judgment Matrix
[0048] <![CDATA[B1]]> C1 C2 C3 C1 1 1 / 2 3 C2 2 1 5 C3 1 / 3 1 / 5 1
[0049] Table 3B2 Judgment Matrix
[0050] <![CDATA[B2]]> C4 C5 C6 C7 C4 1 1 / 3 1 / 2 1 / 5 C5 3 1 2 1 / 2 C6 2 1 / 2 1 1 / 3 C7 5 2 3 1
[0051] Table 4B3 Judgment Matrix
[0052] <![CDATA[B3]]> C8 C9 C10 C8 1 1 / 5 3 C9 5 1 7 C10 1 / 3 1 / 7 1
[0053] Step 3: Calculate the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the judgment matrix, sort the judgment matrix hierarchically, and calculate the weights of the importance order of the relevant factors of this indicator layer for a certain criterion layer.
[0054] The judgment matrix B1 is normalized, and its eigenvector W1=[0.309 0.5810.11] is obtained by using the sum-product method. T
[0055]
[0056] The largest characteristic root:
[0057]
[0058] Step 4: Perform consistency check on the judgment matrix to ensure that there is no deviation in the judgment matrix after expert scoring. In order to check the consistency of the judgment matrix, calculate the consistency index CI
[0059]
[0060] When n=3, the average random consistency index RI of the judgment matrix obtained from Table 5 is 0.58. Then the consistency ratio CR of the judgment matrix is
[0061]
[0062] Satisfy the consistency test of the judgment matrix.
[0063] Table 5 Random consistency index of judgment matrix
[0064]
[0065] Step 5: Continue to calculate the ranking vector of the criterion layer (B) relative to the target layer (A) and the weights of other indicator layers (C) relative to the criterion layer (B) and calculate the consistency. The eigenvectors and maximum eigenroots of each judgment matrix obtained according to the above calculation method are shown in Tables 6 to 8 below:
[0066] Table 6 Judgment matrix B2 eigenvectors and consistency
[0067]
[0068] Table 7 Eigenvectors and consistency of judgment matrix B3
[0069]
[0070] Table 8 Eigenvectors and consistency of judgment matrix A
[0071]
[0072] The composite weight is calculated based on the weight value of each indicator, and the importance is ranked. It can be seen that the most important indicators for evaluating the deep peak regulation plan of coal-fired boilers are the relevant subsidy policy C7, the internal rate of return on investment C5, and the non-stop rate of the unit C9.
[0073] Table 9 Total ranking index weight table
[0074]
[0075] Step 6: Establish the comment set and indicator set for fuzzy comprehensive evaluation. The evaluation indicator set is to select the evaluation indicators Ci (i = 1, 2, ..., 10) mentioned above. Considering the classification level of each indicator of the coal-fired power plant and the operation status of the transformation project, the comment level is determined to be 4. Define the comment set V = {V1, V2, V3, V4}, where V1, V2, V3, V4 represent excellent, good, medium, and poor, respectively, as shown in Table 10.
[0076] Table 10 Fuzzy comprehensive evaluation review set
[0077] Rating excellent good middle Difference Points 90∽100 75∽90 60∽75 0∽60
[0078] Step 7: Construct a fuzzy evaluation matrix. The evaluation matrix of each indicator based on expert scoring is as follows:
[0079] Fuzzy evaluation matrix of technical adaptability B1
[0080] Fuzzy evaluation matrix of benefit feasibility B2
[0081] Fuzzy evaluation matrix of operation reliability B3
[0082] Step 8: Obtain the evaluation results Ki of each criterion layer through fuzzy composite operation, and finally determine the fuzzy evaluation results of the target layer according to the weight vector results of the criterion layer.
[0083] Fuzzy evaluation of technical adaptability B1
[0084]
[0085] Fuzzy Evaluation of Benefit Feasibility B2
[0086]
[0087] Fuzzy Evaluation of Operation Reliability B3
[0088]
[0089] Get the fuzzy evaluation matrix of the criterion layer
[0090]
[0091] Finally, the fuzzy evaluation of target layer A is obtained
[0092]
[0093] Step 9: Calculate the final score and determine the evaluation level of the solution. According to the evaluation criteria in Table 10, determine the weight vector F of the evaluation set = (95, 82.5, 67.5, 30). The final score of the solution is:
[0094]
[0095] It can be concluded that the comprehensive evaluation score of the deep peak-shaving scheme for coal-fired boilers is between 75 and 90, and the comprehensive evaluation grade of this scheme is “good”.
[0096] The contents not described in detail in this specification belong to the prior art known to professional and technical personnel in the field. Although the present invention has been described in detail with reference to the aforementioned embodiments, it is still possible for those skilled in the art to modify the technical solutions described in the aforementioned embodiments, or to make equivalent substitutions for some of the technical features therein. Any modifications, equivalent substitutions, improvements, etc. made within the spirit and principles of the present invention should be included in the protection scope of the present invention.
Claims
1. A comprehensive evaluation method for deep peak load regulation transformation scheme of coal-fired boilers, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: Step 1: Construct an evaluation index system for the scheme. The evaluation index system is divided into target layer, criterion layer and indicator layer. The target layer is the evaluation of the deep adjustment and transformation scheme of coal-fired boilers A. The criterion layer is divided into technical adaptability B1, benefit feasibility B2 and operation reliability B3. According to the characteristics of the criterion layer, it is decomposed into different numbers of evaluation indicators. Among them, technical adaptability B1 can be decomposed into scheme maturity C1, deep peak regulation capability C2, and transformation construction difficulty C3; benefit feasibility B2 can be decomposed into net present value C4, internal rate of return C5, investment payback period C6 and related subsidy policies C7; operation reliability B3 can be decomposed into coal quality applicability C8, unit non-stop rate C9 and denitrification system commissioning rate C10; Step 2: Use the 1-9 scaling method to construct a judgment matrix. The judgment matrix is used to compare the indicators in the indicator layer of a certain criterion layer, and obtain the relative importance, that is, the weight. The element cij in the matrix is a scale, which represents the importance of element Ci to element Cj. The main diagonal of the matrix is always 1, and cij = 1 / cji; Step 3: Sort the hierarchy through the judgment matrix, calculate the weight of the importance order of the factors in the indicator layer for a certain criterion layer, and use the sum-product method to calculate the characteristic roots and characteristic vectors that satisfy BmW = λmaxW for the judgment matrix Bm. Each component Wi of W is the weight of the single ranking of the corresponding factor; Step 4: Conduct consistency test on the judgment matrix to ensure that there is no deviation in the judgment matrix after expert scoring. In order to test the consistency of the judgment matrix, it is necessary to calculate the consistency index CI and compare CI with the average random consistency index RI of the judgment matrix. When the consistency ratio CR of the judgment matrix is less than 0.1, it is considered that the judgment matrix has satisfactory consistency. Step 5: Continue to calculate the ranking vector of the criterion layer B relative to the target layer A and the weights of other indicator layers C relative to the criterion layer B and calculate the consistency. After the judgment matrix is constructed, use the results of the single ranking within the layer to comprehensively calculate the combined weight value of the importance order of the lowest layer (indicator layer) relative to the highest layer (target layer); Step 6: Establish the comment set and index set of fuzzy comprehensive evaluation. The index set is to select the evaluation indexes Ci (i = 1, 2, ..., n) mentioned above, which can be represented by C, that is: C={C1,C2,…Cn} Then determine the comment set, represented by V, comprehensively consider the classification level of each index of the coal-fired power plant and the operation status of the transformation project, determine the comment level as 4, and define the comment set V = {V1, V2, V3, V4}, where V1, V2, V3, V4 represent excellent, good, medium, and poor respectively; Step 7: Construct a fuzzy evaluation matrix. First, evaluate according to a single indicator, and then conduct a comprehensive evaluation under all indicator systems. Single indicator evaluation is to evaluate from the perspective of one indicator to determine the degree of membership of the project to the above evaluation set. After evaluating all indicators, the membership matrix R of the evaluation results of the project under the indicator can be obtained; Step 8: Obtain the evaluation result K through fuzzy compound operation, calculate through fuzzy operator, obtain the first-level fuzzy evaluation result of each criterion layer, and finally determine the second-level fuzzy evaluation result of the target layer according to the weight vector result of the criterion layer; Through the above calculations, we can get the comprehensive evaluation results of the project under each evaluation index, which represents the degree of membership of the project to each evaluation result; Step 9: Calculate the final score and determine the evaluation level of the scheme, determine the weight vector F of the evaluation set, calculate the final score X of the indicators at all levels of the scheme, and determine the evaluation level of the scheme based on the comment set.
2. A comprehensive evaluation method for deep peak load regulation of coal-fired boilers according to claim 1, characterized in that: The analytic hierarchy process is used to calculate the weight of each indicator.
3. The comprehensive evaluation method for deep peak load regulation of coal-fired boilers according to claim 1 is characterized in that: The comprehensive evaluation results are calculated through fuzzy calculation.
Citation Information
Cited By
Energy efficiency evaluation method for ammonia-coal co-combustion power station boiler
CN119599531A
Coal-fired unit peak regulation optimization method, device and equipment and storage medium
CN119918715A
Factory site evaluation method and device for changing thermal power plant into nuclear power plant
CN121526377A
