System and method for automated radiotherapy treatment planning
Through automatic target grouping, clustering and arc beam technology, the complexity and dose distribution problems of multi-transfer treatment plans are solved, and efficient and uniform radiation therapy is achieved, avoiding serrated MLC openings and improving treatment efficiency and quality.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202380037901.5
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2022-05-04
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-03
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-06
AI Technical Summary
In radiation therapy, treatment plans for multiple metastases become complicated and difficult, especially when limited beams are required, prior art is difficult to achieve uniform dose distribution and avoid serrated MLC openings, resulting in therapeutic efficiency Low and quality assurance issues.
Through automatic target grouping and clustering steps, optimize rack and collimator angles, use arc beam and conformal arc plans, combined with dose-controlled barrier methods, to achieve efficient treatment plans for multi-transfer cases, avoiding serrated MLC openings, and ensure the achievement of dose goals.
It improves the efficiency and quality of multi-metastatic treatment, reduces treatment time, optimizes dose distribution, reduces the complexity and cost of treatment plans, and improves the reliability of treatment results.
Smart Images

Figure CN119095649A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to a system and method for radiotherapy treatment planning, and in particular, the present invention relates to a system and method for automatic stereotactic radiosurgery planning for multiple metastases (mets) and a treatment method thereof. Background Art
[0002] It is known to use beams of photons, electrons or protons or other ions and direct them to the treatment area of the patient to treat the area or volume in radiotherapy treatment. The shape of the beam is usually selected so that the area to be treated receives the desired dose while limiting the dose to the surrounding tissue. In particular, sensitive organs known as risk organs should be protected as much as possible. In order to achieve this, a gantry that can rotate around the patient is usually used to provide radiation in beams at different angles so that all beams will reach the target, and each part of the surrounding tissue will only receive a dose from one or several beams, or in the case of arc beams, receive a degree less than the target. The gantry can rotate completely around the patient, or partially along a division of the circumference. When the gantry moves around the patient, the gantry can provide radiation in a continuous arc, or stop delivering static beams at certain angles. The treatment division can be composed of multiple arcs or static beams or a combination thereof. The patient couch on which the patient is arranged and fixed can also be rotated during radiation delivery or between the delivery of static beams or arc beams to modify the radiation direction relative to the patient. There are other means for changing the direction of the beam, for example, the radiation source may be mounted on a movable robotic arm, but for the purposes of this discussion, a gantry is used as an illustrative example. Typically, in radiation therapy such as photon therapy, a collimator placed in the beam plane (i.e., perpendicular to the central axis of the beam) is used to shape the beam so that the deposited dose matches the prescribed dose as accurately as possible. Typically, the collimator is a multi-leaf collimator (MLC), as explained later in this article.
[0003] Planning of radiosurgery becomes exponentially more difficult if there are multiple metastases (multimets) and when the goal is to treat such multiple metastases simultaneously in one treatment or treatment session using a limited number of beams in order to save treatment time. Generally, saving treatment time in radiotherapy has several advantages, such as saving time and its cost, reducing patient discomfort, and reducing the time during which the patient may potentially move the target area as a tumor out of and out of the targeted volume.
[0004] In conventional planning of multi-transfer radiosurgery, the treatment planner usually considers some parameters to manually plan and also groups multiple targets (metastases). This takes time and is quite difficult due to the exponential increase in potential target groups as the number of metastases increases. If the optimal grouping is achieved, uncertainty is also left because the manual grouping of targets is challenging due to many unknown and variable parameters, such as collimator angles, couch angles, and gantry angles. In addition to these parameters, the reduction and avoidance of exposed non-target areas (ENTA) need to be considered during planning. Various transfer shapes or transfer groups may cause ENTA problems, as explained in this article with reference to the accompanying drawings. Therefore, the burden of the optimization plan of the treatment planner is high. In view of these challenges, efforts have been made to automate the planning of multi-transfer cases.
[0005] Some automated tools and solutions do exist, but they only address a limited number of parameters, such as only certain MLC angles and / or gantry angles, and they also examine a limited number of target groups in the complete target set and do not consider all possible groups of a given number or all possible groups in a target.
[0006] Additionally, some of the known tools and solutions strive to deliver equal doses or dose targets on each target of a target set due to the risk of jagged MLC windows or non-exposures and their non-conformal dose delivery. Furthermore, when multiple metastases at different depths are treated simultaneously by a beam, they may receive different doses due to the deep dose curve of the photon beam. In radiotherapy, each target, metastasis or tumor should receive a plannable radiation dose in the target if possible, which in some cases means a uniform dose and in some cases means no uniformly distributed dose on the target, such as a higher dose in the center of the target, whereby the delivered dose should be as close to the dose target as possible. This is not always possible with the methods and solutions of the prior art.
[0007] Another problem with prior art solutions such as, for example, volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) is that they allow for a sawtooth opening of the multi-leaf collimator. This non-compliant opening is not suitable when it is necessary to control and evenly distribute the dose level in the target volume (ref. Figure 7a and 7b) may cause problems. In general, sawtooth MLC openings should be avoided. A sawtooth MLC opening is an MLC opening in which some blades extend further than their neighboring blades. With a sawtooth blade opening and a continuously moving gantry, providing robust treatment is very challenging and providing quality assurance is problematic. By using conformal systems and methods, in particular using conformal arc beams, sawtooth MLC openings can be avoided using the methods presented herein. However, it should be noted that sawtooth MLC openings can be advantageous in some cases because they can facilitate achieving dose goals in the target due to the additional modulation that results in more degrees of freedom.
[0008] Additionally, if the goal is to create a VMAT plan, the process of optimizing such a VMAT plan is greatly simplified by starting the optimization from a high quality conformal arc plan. Starting from a high quality conformal arc plan typically results in a final arc plan of higher quality than would otherwise be obtained. Thus, the present invention also provides a way to improve VMAT plans in stereotactic radiosurgery. Summary of the invention
[0009] In view of the above, it is an object of the present invention to provide a method that allows for automated planning of multi-metastasis cases and also improves the efficiency of multi-metastasis treatment using stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS).
[0010] Another object is to provide a method that allows providing an optimal treatment that can provide dose objectives over the entire target, even if a limited number of beams need to be used to treat a set of targets in the same treatment or treatment phase.
[0011] Another object is to provide a method that allows saving time and optimizing radiation therapy for multiple metastases.
[0012] In a first aspect of the invention, the inventors have recognized that the planning process for radiotherapy of multiple metastases can be improved using automatic target grouping. Thus, by analyzing some or all possible target partitionings of a target set and thus also analyzing some or all possible target group combinations, a target set that should be treated simultaneously is segmented into several target groups taking into account possible gantry angle and collimator angle pairs and constants intended to avoid bridge gap openings and / or avoid exposure of exposed non-target areas (ENTA) to radiation, the term bridge gap opening being referred to later herein. Figure 5a and 5b Briefly, bridge gap opening is the configuration of a multi-leaf collimator (MLC) when the leaves cannot conform to two or more targets without exposing non-target tissue or non-target areas between the targets.
[0013] In a second aspect of the invention, the inventors have realized that if the set of targets exceeds a certain amount N of targets or if the targets are positioned too far from each other, a clustering step may be performed in order to prepare the set of targets into optimal automatic groupings. Such a clustering step may include the steps of selecting a maximum number of clusters M based on the number of targets, limiting the number of targets in a cluster to be less than or equal to N, and selecting the targets in a cluster based on the maximum allowed distance between two targets of the same cluster. The second aspect requires as input a set of targets, including their shape and position relative to each other, and then delivers as output an optimal clustering taking into account the mentioned parameters (such as possible gantry angle and collimator angle pairs) and geometric parameters (such as the maximum allowed distance between two targets of the same cluster).
[0014] In a third aspect, the present invention relates to a solution for dose control blocking when an arc plan with calculated doses and dose level targets for each target is input. Once the dose level targets are calculated or determined for each target, targets with excess dose levels are blocked via MLC on a portion of the arc path or arc beam or at some control points. This means that the blades of the MLC are completely closed above targets with exceeded dose levels at at least some arc beams along the candidate arc path. Optionally, the monitoring unit (MU) level of the beam is changed. Following the method according to the third aspect, the start and stop gantry angles can be modified to avoid the presence of segments or arc beams with completely closed MLCs. The output of the method according to the third aspect delivers a modified preferred conformal arc plan - which improves the achievement of dose level targets for all targets while taking advantage of the effective and convenient MLC opening characteristics of the conformal arc plan.
[0015] A treatment planning method for generating a treatment plan for radiation therapy in which a set of targets is to be treated is disclosed. The method uses a multi-leaf collimator (MLC) for shaping an arc beam, a gantry including the MLC, and a couch, chair, or other structure for positioning a patient, the gantry being capable of rotating at least partially around the patient. The MLC can rotate about a beam axis to define a collimator angle, the gantry can rotate about a gantry axis to define a gantry angle, and the couch can rotate about a z-axis to define a couch angle. The method comprises the following steps:
[0016] - providing a plurality of candidate arc paths for treatment planning with isocenters and a maximum number of arc beams, and depending on the maximum number of arc beams, providing a maximum number of target groups;
[0017] - providing the three-dimensional shape and position of each target in the target set;
[0018] - calculating a target partitioning of at least some possible target partitionings of the target set based on the current candidate arc path, the at least some possible target partitionings comprising a maximum number of target groups, each of the at least some possible target partitionings comprising a target group, whereby in some cases each target is part of at least one target group;
[0019] - for each target group of possible target partitioning, determining a cost taking into account the current candidate arc path, at least one gantry angle and at least one MLC angle;
[0020] - Determine the cost of the possible target partition and the current candidate arc path by summing the cost of each target group of the possible target partition;
[0021] - repeating the calculating and determining steps for each of at least some of the target partitions and candidate arc paths, and
[0022] -Selecting the optimal target partitioning and arc path for the treatment plan with the lowest sum of costs.
[0023] It should be noted that it is not necessary for each target to always be part of at least one target group or at least one target partition. However, in some cases, target partitions that meet this requirement can be used and configured for treatment as in the examples discussed herein.
[0024] The calculations, determinations, and summations described above need not be performed for every possible target partition, even though this may be accomplished. In order to save resources, such as computational resources, only relevant target partitions may be considered. This selection of target partitions may be obtained, for example, by dynamic programming or provided in another manner, whereby it is known that the target partition selections used include the optimal target partitions. For example, if it is known that a particular target group results in a high cost, the target partitions that include that group may be removed from the set of target partitions to be considered.
[0025] The above method allows a target set to be fed into a system such as a computer or a radiotherapy planning system, and then the method automatically calculates at least some possible target partitions for evaluation and finding the optimal target partition for treatment. Therefore, the target partition includes several target groups, and it can be understood that the target set can have many target partitions. The target partitions and target groups can have the following conditions: each target can only be part of one group, or each target can only be part of one group for each candidate arc path, to avoid that some targets are treated more than other targets, which will result in too high a radiation dose level. Automatic target partitioning and its target grouping do not burden the treatment planner with very complex and time-consuming planning. It also improves the results of the treatment because the treatment method takes into account all possible gantry angles, MLC angles, costs and, for example, the sum of ENTA costs as described below or other costs and target partitions and target groups. Certain constraints of the calculation can be fed into the system, such as the maximum number of targets in a target group and the maximum number of target groups in a target partition, and possibly geometric considerations. Geometric considerations can, for example, specify that all targets of a target group must fit into a predetermined volume, so that they are arranged geometrically close to each other, or no targets in the same target group can be closer to each other than a predetermined distance. Alternatively, it may be specified that the projection onto a plane perpendicular to the central axis of the beams of all targets of the target set must fit into a predetermined area.Geometric considerations or conditions may relate to maximum and / or minimum allowed distances and / or volumes.
[0026] All possible target partitions may be considered for the calculation step. Alternatively, only target partitions with less than a specified number of target groups may be considered for the calculation step. Alternatively, target partitions with target groups known to result in poor solutions need not be included in the target partitions considered in the calculation step. Alternatively, up to a specified number of target partitions may be considered.
[0027] All provided candidate arc paths can be used for optimization.
[0028] Alternatively, a static field or static beam may be considered for the candidate arc paths.
[0029] In an embodiment, known non-optimal target partitions, such as target partitions including all targets in one target group or including at least two targets positioned far away from each other or very close to each other, such as more than 5-6 cm away from each other or very close such as a few mm (millimeters), can be directly excluded from the above-mentioned optimization method.
[0030] In an exemplary embodiment, the calculation step may also take into account at least one couch angle.
[0031] Taking into account at least one couch angle can further improve the result of the optimal target division, since the couch angle is an additional parameter that can be adjusted.
[0032] In one embodiment, a maximum number of target groups is provided by the treatment planner or any given number from 1 to 6 per candidate arc beam.
[0033] The maximum number of target groups may be based on the maximum number of arc beams allowed, or vice versa.
[0034] In another embodiment, the calculation step may further include segmenting the arc path into control points spaced at regular gaps, each gap corresponding to a gantry angle segment, wherein at each control point, an optimal MLC angle and / or an optimal couch angle is calculated. Movement constraints, such as a maximum rotation speed of the MLC or a maximum angular rotation of the MLC, may be considered during this calculation step.
[0035] Predetermined control points, typically spaced at regular intervals along the arc path and thus along the gantry path, can be used to further optimize the target partitioning and select the optimal target set. In addition, and at each control point, several MLC angles and couch angles can be considered. The control points can be arranged, for example, at 1°, 2°, or 4° gantry angle intervals along the arc path. The control point distances and the regular interval distances therefrom can be selected based on the available computing power of current computers.
[0036] In another embodiment, the optimal MLC opening is calculated for each control point, whereby the optimal MLC opening is selected based on the lowest cost and the optimal MLC angle relative to previous and subsequent MLC angles at previous and subsequent control points.
[0037] Consistent with the above, if the MLC angle needs to be changed between control points, additional cost is added.
[0038] In some methods, such as in points, a change in the MLC angle from one control point to the next may result in increased cost because adjusting the MLC angle between control points takes time and may be challenging. However, if a bridge gap opens or there is another ENTA in the specific MLC opening at the current control point, the cost of this situation may be higher, and thus the method may choose to rotate the MLC and provide another MLC angle in order to avoid the ENTA cost or another increased cost.
[0039] In view of the above and in accordance with embodiments of the present invention, the calculating step may further include segmenting the arc path into control points spaced at regular gaps, each gap corresponding to a gantry angle segment, wherein the MLC angle is maintained in a fixed position for each control point along the candidate arc path, and wherein a cost for each candidate MLC angle is calculated for each control point to find an optimal fixed MLC angle for each candidate arc path.
[0040] In another embodiment, if the couch angle needs to be changed between adjacent control points, this may increase costs.
[0041] Changing the couch angle may result in delay or uncertainty, and thus may increase costs if such a change is required.
[0042] In another embodiment, the maximum number of arc beams corresponds to the maximum number of target groups.
[0043] The above can help achieve the correct dose level goals for each target and target group. This situation can also improve and reduce the treatment time of patients.
[0044] In another embodiment, the arc beam may be a conformal arc beam.
[0045] The use of conformal arc beams provides a clear and direct distribution of dose levels, as each target receives either radiation using the effective and useful MLC opening characteristics of the conformal arc plan, or no radiation delivery at all when the blades are completely over the target. The conformal MLC openings are intended to be fully open or fully closed across the target, but they may be opened due to accidents, such as when they need to move across the target to be able to reach the desired position of the MLC in the next control point. During such movement, speed limitations may be considered. Sawtooth blade positions where some blades extend further into the opening than their neighboring blades may be avoided. However, according to a third aspect of the present disclosure, complete dose blocking may be allowed, so that in certain control points, some blades of the MLC may be adjusted so that one or more targets receive no radiation at all in order to provide a dose level that matches or is at least very close to the dose level target.
[0046] In another embodiment, the method may further include the steps of retrieving the lowest cost arc beams having the lowest cost MLC angle and gantry angle pair, typically by considering the minimum gantry angle gap for each target group of the optimal target partitioning, and delivering these lowest cost arc beams, whereby each arc beam is conformal to one target group of the optimal target partitioning, so that each target group receives one arc beam for treatment.
[0047] A minimum rack angle clearance may be provided to avoid selecting a rack clearance that is too small.
[0048] Providing a minimum cost arc beam or arc path with a minimum cost MLC angle and gantry angle pair for each target group of the optimal target partitioning may result in a possible treatment for the current multi-metastasis case. Such a minimum cost arc beam may be close to the candidate arc path provided initially, but the angle may vary slightly.
[0049] The described method and / or steps can be used as a starting point for VMAT optimization. Thus, in case the current treatment planner has several transfers and thus multiple transfers, she / he can use the method described herein to optimize the starting point for other treatment methods such as VMAT.
[0050] In another embodiment, a limitation on the maximum number of arc beams (e.g., a maximum number of target groups in total over the maximum number of arc beams) is considered, at least some possible target partitions for various arc paths are considered, and an arc plan including arc beams and arc paths is provided based on the optimal target partition and the lowest cost arc beams.
[0051] Thus, the method may simultaneously consider several arc paths of at least some possible target partitions in order to find the best treatment plan.
[0052] In another embodiment, the method may further include the following steps:
[0053] - receiving the calculated dose for each target in the arc plan and the optimal target partitioning, the arc plan may include several arc paths;
[0054] - Provide a dose level target for each target and adjust the arc plan so that each target at least achieves the dose level target;
[0055] - alternatively, in order to achieve or provide the correct dose level target for each target, the blocking of the targets may be used to achieve the correct relationship between the targets and then in a next step the control point monitor unit MU may be scaled up or optimized;
[0056] - identifying targets that achieve dose levels exceeding dose level objectives; and
[0057] - Calculating the required dose control block where the leaves of the MLC are completely closed for at least a portion of some arc beams of targets having dose levels exceeding the dose level target in order to optimize the delivery of dose and thereby optimize the dose level target for all targets of the optimal target partitioning.
[0058] The above method in the previous paragraph can be used independently of any other method disclosed herein. The above method can be referred to as a dose control blocking method. The dose control blocking method is the third aspect of the present invention disclosed herein as described above, and is independent of other method steps disclosed herein. At the same time, the dose control blocking method can and can be used and combined with any method steps or features disclosed herein independently of other features and method steps.
[0059] Any arc plan that can be calculated or provided by a radiation therapy planning method can be used as an input method for a dose control blocking method as disclosed herein to achieve an optimal target dose level in a target group on an arc beam. Additionally and in particular, a conformal arc plan can be used as an input to a dose control blocking method according to the previous paragraph.
[0060] The output of the dose control blocking method may be a modified conformal arc plan whereby in some locations or control points, some targets are blocked from radiation via the MLC. Typically, the MLC will be open for at least one target in each control point. In some cases, the MLC may be completely closed in some control points. By modifying the start and stop gantry angles and potentially the MLC angles, control points or beams with completely closed collimators may be avoided, as such closed segments waste time during treatment. Another option is to ignore the completely blocked collimator or MLC segments and proceed on these segments without applying any radiation in these segments.
[0061] As explained, the control points and / or starting and stopping gantry angles may be selected so that there are no completely closed control points or sectors where all targets are blocked.
[0062] The modified start and stop gantry angles may be adapted and / or additionally include segments that are ignored due to fully closed MLC openings in these segments. Alternatively, the start and stop gantry angles may not be modified, but segments with fully closed MLC configurations or openings may be ignored.
[0063] In another embodiment according to the disclosure herein and according to the second aspect, if the distance between two targets exceeds a certain threshold or if the number of targets exceeds N targets, a clustering step is performed before the step disclosed in the first aspect. The clustering step may include the steps of selecting a maximum number of clusters M based on the number of targets present, limiting the number of targets in a cluster to be less than or equal to N, and selecting targets in a cluster based on a maximum allowed distance between two targets of the same cluster or geometric considerations or conditions.
[0064] As input the position and three-dimensional shape of the target may be provided.
[0065] In another embodiment, if the total number of target groups in the current target partition exceeds a certain threshold, such as 15 to 20 target groups, additional costs may be added.
[0066] This may lead to improved target segmentation and an optimized planning process.
[0067] In another embodiment, the clustering step may directly take geometrical considerations as initial conditions. Thus, if it is detected or determined that two targets are too far from each other and thus exceed a threshold value for distance, whereby the threshold value may be 6 cm, the clustering step may be directly initiated without being limited to the current number of targets N. The clustering step may be initiated using any combination of a maximum number of targets N and a maximum number of clusters M and geometrical considerations or conditions.
[0068] If there are more than three (3) targets, more than four (4) targets and / or more than five (5) targets, preferably more than ten (10) to fifteen (15) targets, a clustering step may be used. The clustering step reduces complexity because the number of targets treated with one arc set or method is reduced and because they are arranged geometrically close to each other. Alternatively, for the maximum allowed distance between any two targets of the same cluster, the volume may be, for example, in cm, as described above. 3 Given that all targets of a cluster need to fit in this volume so as to facilitate treatment and targeting, these geometric conditions (such as maximum volume or maximum allowed distance) are called geometric conditions or geometric considerations.
[0069] The clustering step as described above is according to the second aspect disclosed herein and can be used independently of any other method or feature disclosed herein. The clustering step or clustering method is not connected to the first aspect or the third aspect of the invention disclosed herein. The clustering step or method can be used before conventional radiation therapy such as IMRT or VMAT to prepare and reduce the number of targets to be treated in one and the same treatment to a manageable level.
[0070] As an example and to better illustrate the clustering method and steps, an example is provided. A patient with brain cancer has seven (7) metastases on his head, some of which are close to the right ear and others close to the left eye. The maximum allowed distance between the targets (metastases) is 6 cm. Therefore, it is required that all targets in a cluster must be spaced closer than or equal to 6 cm from each other. The maximum number of targets in a cluster is set to four (4), which corresponds to N, and thus the total number of targets, seven (7), exceeds the number of targets allowed in a cluster, four (4). In this case, the maximum number of clusters M is three (3). As long as the criterion of the maximum distance of 6 cm is met, the first cluster, for example, close to the right ear, will contain 4 targets and the second cluster, for example, close to the left eye, will contain the remaining 3 targets. Although a third cluster is theoretically allowed, it is not required because the maximum number N of four targets per cluster is not exceeded and because the 6 cm maximum allowed distance condition is not violated. Once the clusters are defined, the method according to the first and third aspects or any other known radiation therapy plan can be performed.
[0071] Note that in the above example, alternatively there could be a cluster with only one (1) target, while the other two clusters include the remaining targets. The method will evaluate which cluster is the optimal cluster given the constraints provided, such as the maximum number of targets in one cluster and the maximum number of clusters. The constraints may depend on the available arc beams specified, for example, by the treatment planner, or other circumstances such as treatment time constraints.
[0072] Also disclosed herein is a computer program product comprising computer readable means, which when executed in a computer will cause the computer to perform any aspect or method step disclosed herein.
[0073] Also disclosed herein is a non-transitory computer-readable medium encoded with computer-executable instructions, which when executed in a computer device will cause the device to perform the method steps or aspects of the present disclosure.
[0074] In addition to what is further disclosed above, this document further discloses a computer system, including a processor and a memory, wherein the memory includes the computer program product according to the above or the non-transitory computer-readable medium according to the above.
[0075] In the present disclosure, certain terms and technical specifications will be used, some of which are explained with reference to the accompanying drawings, and some of which are explained and specified here:
[0076] Cost function or cost
[0077] The term cost function or cost related to radiotherapy describes a measure of the distance or difference between the quality of the plan obtained and the desired quality of the plan. The cost function may include the clinical goals of the radiotherapy plan and represents a critical point of the optimization process during the plan. Various variables may be added to the cost or cost function, such as exposure of non-target tissue, exposed non-target tissue area (ENTA), bridge gap opening in the MLC, and / or MLC or couch angle changes between segmented or arc beams. Such variables may lead to additional costs. The value delivered by the cost or cost function can be regarded as a quality indicator of the treatment plan. Typically, the cost function of the radiotherapy plan undergoes an optimization process. The cost or cost function may be based on a dose level criterion as a physical cost function, or may be based on a biological criterion as a biological cost function. The purpose of the cost function is usually to provide a treatment plan with a highly conformal dose distribution without irradiating exposed non-target tissues or organs at risk. In many solutions, the cost function or cost is optimized by finding the minimum value of such a cost function. The cost, cost function or ENTA cost may be highly complex, but since the core of the present invention is not in the cost or cost function determination, the explanation provided is sufficient to understand the aspects disclosed herein.
[0078] The cost function may include the number of arc paths used to treat a target set. In general, the more arc paths used for treatment, the higher the cost, because arc paths increase the time of treatment. Thus, if a certain cost level A can be achieved with seven (7) arc paths and a first treatment plan, and the same cost level A can also be achieved with only six (6) arc paths and a second treatment plan, then the second treatment plan with six (6) arc paths is advantageous and should therefore receive a lower total cost than A. A cost function that depends on the number of arc paths with a single output value may be designed in the following manner:
[0079] Let T be a threshold such that all ENTA costs below T are considered equal. Let the cost be defined as
[0080]
[0081] where P is the target partition, N is the number of arc paths (up to 99) and means round x to 3 decimal places after the integer part. In other words, the function can be expressed by the formula as follows:
[0082] An example of a cost is calculated as follows: First, calculate the value of the ENTA portion of the cost. If the resulting value is below a threshold T, where T is greater than or equal to 0, then set the value to exactly T. Round the value to a maximum of three decimal places, and then multiply the result by 100000. This ensures that we have an integer with two ending zeros. Finally, add the number of arc paths in the treatment plan (less than 100) to obtain the total cost. The target partition with the lowest total cost is selected as the optimal target partition.
[0083] Alternatively, the cost function considering the number of arc paths can also be designed in the following manner: First, if the cost of a partition is below a threshold T, where T is greater than or equal to 0, the cost is set to exactly T. After the step, the target partition with the lowest cost is selected. If multiple target partitions have the same cost, such as cost T, the target partitions are sorted according to the number of arc paths in the final treatment plan, and the treatment plan with the lowest number of arc paths in the final treatment plan is selected as the optimal target partition.
[0084] Multi-leaf collimator
[0085] A multi-leaf collimator (MLC) comprises a frame having a rectangular opening and a plurality of leaf pairs placed adjacent to each other along opposite sides of the opening. The two leaves in the leaf pair are placed opposite to each other and can be moved so that they can completely close a portion of the opening or expose all or a portion of that portion of the opening. Each leaf pair defines a linear portion of the MLC. There are various techniques for calculating the movement pattern of the MLC during beam delivery. For example, in sliding window delivery, the leaves move unidirectionally across the field, where the distance between opposing leaves is selected so that radiation will pass through the area that should be exposed to radiation within the amount of time determined by the fluence map, while being blocked in other areas. Multiple sliding window leaf sweeps can be delivered sequentially without cutting off the irradiation, thereby producing a movement pattern in which the leaves move back and forth over the treatment area.
[0086] Another example of radiation delivery is step and shoot delivery, during which the leaves of the MLC are static while the radiation beam or beams are turned on.
[0087] For arc beams, the blades of the MLC can usually move in any direction when the beam is on.
[0088] The MLC can be rotated to different angles around the central axis of the beam to limit the beam in the most appropriate way given the patient geometry. A given rotation of the MLC relative to the central axis of the beam is called the collimator angle. It is also feasible to rotate the MLC to different collimator angles at different gantry angles, since the patient geometry will change depending on the beam direction and / or gantry angle. The MLC can also be rotated during the delivery of a static beam, i.e., the collimator angle can be a function of the delivery time of the beam, the gantry angle, or the cumulative monitoring units (MU). In today's conventional practice, the collimator angle is manually selected and remains constant over the entire arc or static beam.
[0089] Target division
[0090] Target partitioning in this document may mean dividing the targets into groups independently of the candidate arc paths. Target partitioning typically includes several target groups. Given that the target partitioning may therefore vary for target sets and various target groups. Therefore, the target set can be divided into various target groups, and thereby also into various target partitions. In addition, target partitioning may also mean the partitioning of the targets for each candidate arc path. Target partitioning typically includes target groups, whereby each target is part of at least one target group, but in some cases and especially if this results in a lower overall cost or ENTA, it may also be allowed that not every target is part of at least one target group. Typically, each candidate arc path checks at least one target partition; however, it may be more than one target partition, and this may be specified using the method disclosed herein.
[0091] Candidate Arc Path
[0092] The candidate arc path of the specification of this article describes and means the path that the MLC travels on the patient, which is usually in the form of an arc due to the configuration and / or design of the radiotherapy system. The candidate arc path also affects or determines the potential gantry angle, couch angle and / or even collimator angle in some way. When treating a target group, it is important to select the relevant candidate arc path for treatment in order to reduce the ENTA cost of the patient and to provide an effective plan for radiotherapy. The MLC opening and the associated cost of ENTA associated with the candidate arc path are related to the selected candidate arc path, and iterating the grouping and target division of the target while being related to the candidate arc path greatly improves the results for the patient and treatment efficiency. Selecting the target division or grouping depends on the candidate arc path provided. The quality of a particular target division can depend on the candidate arc path. The candidate arc path can be provided via a treatment planning system or via a physical person such as a medical staff. Generally, it is also allowed that the candidate arc path that is or is considered to be the method disclosed herein deviates from one or more candidate arc paths provided to a certain extent. In some cases, the candidate arc path can correspond to the couch angle. The current candidate arc path in this article also means the candidate arc path currently being examined and / or calculated and / or analyzed.
[0093] Arc Beam
[0094] An arc beam in this article is considered to be a radiation beam that is allowed to pass through the MLC at a specific position along the trajectory of the arc path. The arc beam can be a beam that is temporarily generated at a fixed point along the trajectory, or it can be a continuous arc beam that moves along the trajectory when the collimator blades or collimator openings are adapted depending on the target. In some cases, the arc beam is a static beam generated at certain fixed gaps along the trajectory of the MLC and the arc path or candidate arc path. The arc beam is also illustrated in the drawings of this article.
[0095] The method according to the invention according to the first aspect, the second aspect or the third aspect can be incorporated into any known treatment planning system for improving treatment planning and reducing the burden on the treatment planner. The method according to the first aspect, the second aspect or the third aspect can be used and applied independently of each other in radiotherapy planning, but they can also be used in combination with each other. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0096] The present invention is described in more detail below by way of examples and with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
[0097] Figure 1 A setup for radiation therapy is schematically illustrated;
[0098] Figure 2Schematically illustrates a target and an arc path along which the MLC moves on a gantry for radiation treatment of the target;
[0099] Figure 3a to Figure 3d Schematically illustrates the principle of target partitioning or grouping via a patient's head with seven targets;
[0100] Figure 4a and Figure 4b The principle of target clustering is schematically illustrated;
[0101] Figure 5a to Figure 5c Schematically illustrates the principle of using a target group to avoid the bridge gap opening in a multi-leaf collimator (MLC);
[0102] Figure 6a and Figure 6b The principle of avoiding exposure of non-target areas (ENTA) is schematically illustrated;
[0103] Figure 7a and Figure 7b Schematically illustrates the principle of the sawtooth blade opening that the present invention seeks to avoid;
[0104] Figure 8 schematically illustrates another embodiment according to the invention, which relates to a dose control barrier;
[0105] Fig. 9 schematically illustrates an embodiment of a method according to a second aspect of the invention;
[0106] Fig.10 schematically illustrates another embodiment of the method according to the first aspect of the present invention;
[0107] Fig.11 Schematically illustrates a similar approach using all candidate arc paths Fig.10 Another embodiment of the method;
[0108] Fig.12 schematically illustrates a further embodiment of the method according to the third aspect of the present invention; and
[0109] Fig.13 A radiation therapy planning system is schematically illustrated. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0110] Turning now to the accompanying drawings which illustrate various aspects and concepts of the present invention, Figure 1A radiation therapy treatment system 1 is schematically illustrated that includes a gantry 2 with a multi-leaf collimator (MLC) 4. The radiation therapy treatment system 1 can be used for stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS). The radiation therapy treatment planning system 1 can also include a patient couch or couch 6 for positioning the patient while the patient is being treated with radiation. For illustrative purposes, the radiation therapy treatment system 1 is shown without a patient. The treatment couch 6 can be rotated about an axis to optimally position the patient during or for treatment. Figure 1 In the example shown, the couch angle 8 can be adjusted by rotating the couch 6 about the z-axis. Other movements of the couch 6 are also possible. The MLC 4 can be rotated about a collimator axis c to adjust the collimator angle 12. The collimator axis c depends on the position and thereby on the gantry angle 10, since the gantry 2 can be rotated about a rotation center 13. When a radiation beam or arc beam 15 is allowed to extend from the MLC 4 toward a body part 17 including a target or target volume 18, then the radiation beam 15 travels along the collimator axis c, while its shape in cross section is perpendicular to the collimator axis c, depending on the MLC opening, as explained later herein (refer to Figures 5a to 7b The gantry may be able to rotate a full 360° about the center of rotation 13 to illuminate the target from different gantry angles 10 ( Figure 1 ). Figure 1 As shown, the gantry 2 can rotate about the y-axis. In order to better reach the target, the MLC 4 can be mounted on an extension arm 14 or the like, which is connected to and is a part of the gantry 2.
[0111] It should be noted that the angle can be defined in different ways. For the purposes of illustration herein, the couch angle 8 is defined as Figure 1 The positions shown are measured counterclockwise, which means that Figure 1 In the illustration shown, the couch angle 8 is 0°. The gantry angle 10 can be measured from the horizontal plane defined by the x-axis and the y-axis (also in the counterclockwise direction), which means Figure 1 The gantry angle 10 in is about 110°. The collimator angle 12 can be measured starting from a line defined by the longitudinal axis d of the extension arm 14 .
[0112] During the path along various gantry angles 10, the MLC takes different positions along the arc path. Figure 2 Shown and described in.
[0113] Figure 2 Illustrated is a configuration in which a patient's head 16 having three metastases 18' or targets 18' is to be treated via radiation therapy treatment.For illustrative purposes, only the patient's head 16 is shown. Figure 2 Several arc paths 20, 20', 20'' are shown. In addition, Figure 2Another arc path 22 is shown in FIG. Arc path 22 corresponds to a gantry angle from 0º to 360º and a couch angle of 0º. Arc path 20 corresponds to a gantry angle from 0º to 180º and a couch angle of approximately 45º. Arc path 20' corresponds to a gantry angle from 0º to 180º and a couch angle of approximately 90º. Finally, arc path 20'' corresponds to a gantry angle from 0º to 180º and a couch angle of approximately 120º or 240º (360º-120º), depending on the definition of the couch angle.
[0114] To further illustrate the radiation process, an arc path 20 is used herein, which, as described above, corresponds to a gantry angle from 0° to 180° and a couch angle of approximately 45°. The arc path 20 is used to treat one of the targets 18′ via an arc beam 24. For illustrative purposes, only one arc beam 24 along the arc path 20 is shown. In addition, and also for illustrative purposes, only one of the targets 18′ is irradiated via an MLC opening 26a. The MLC 4 and the MLC opening 26a are located at a collimator angle 12 of approximately 15° to 20°. Figure 2 In the example shown in , the gantry angle 10 of the arc beam 24 is about 30º. The arc beam can be delivered to the target 18' from various positions along the arc path 20 with gaps. These gaps can be regular gaps along the arc path. In conformal radiotherapy, the arc beam 24 is delivered from at least some positions 28. Between two adjacent positions 28, the arc beam is usually in an open state and the leaves 40 of the MLC 4 are not closed. However, in some radiotherapy methods, the arc beam is closed on at least a portion of the arc path 20, in particular during the movement of the MLC 4, but the MLC opening is not closed. The invention described herein is applicable to various solutions, including continuous arc beam delivery along the arc path 20, especially using conformal arc therapy, but also to VMAT, and more generally to intensity modulated radiotherapy (IMRT), including IMRT using static fields or static beams.
[0115] The blade 40 typically moves linearly between its designated positions / MLC openings between two adjacent positions 28 or control points 28. In some cases, the movement of the blade 40 may be non-linear due to accelerations in the MLC 4, such as during rotation.
[0116] Figure 2The locations 28 shown in can also be referred to as segments, and alternatively they can be used as control points 28 when simulating and planning treatment. Each control point 28 can be used to determine the optimal collimator angle 12, the optimal MLC opening 26a, and even optimize the couch angle 8 by plus or minus a few degrees to optimize radiation delivery. In addition, even the arc path 20 can be optimized by a few degrees during the calculation process in order to find the optimal arc beam, arc path, and arc plan for radiation delivery. The control points 28 can be spaced at regular intervals along the entire arc path 20. In Figure 2 In the example of FIG. 1 , the control points 28 are spaced 5° to 7° from the gantry angle 10. Any other spacing interval from 1° to 25°, preferably 2° to 8°, is possible and feasible. For ease of illustration, Figure 2 Only four control points 28 are shown in FIG. 1 , but the reader will understand the concept of distributing control points 28 along the arc path 20 when calculating and determining the treatment plan. The control points 28 can also be used to determine whether any of the following concepts and aspects can be optimized.
[0117] Figure 3a to Figure 3d The diagram illustrates aspects of the present disclosure related to target partitioning (or targetpartition). Figure 3a to Figure 3d A patient's head 16' is shown with an ear 30 for illustrative purposes. The patient has a total of five (5) metastases or targets 18a-18e in the head 16'. For illustrative purposes, the metastases or targets 18a-18e are shown only in FIG. Figure 3a However, Figure 3b to Figure 3d The same head 16' is disclosed with the same transfer or target 18a-18e, but these Figure 3b to Figure 3d The concepts of target divisions 36 , 36 ′, 36 ″ and target groups 34 , 34 ′, 34 ″ are explained.
[0118] Now turn to Figure 3b As can be appreciated, when grouping the five targets 18a-18e into target groups 34, 34', 34", some conditions may apply. In the example, the condition is that each target partition 36 may include a maximum number of three (3) target groups 34, 34', 34", thereby allowing less than three (3) target groups 34, 34', 34" (see Figure 3c ).However, Figure 3b , Figure 3c and Figure 3d Another condition not shown in the figure is the physical distance. It can be specified that the targets 18a-18e arranged farthest from each other in a target group 34, 34', 34'' can only be separated by a certain distance. This distance can be specified as a condition before the target grouping and target division steps. The distance can be from 0.5 cm to 8 cm, 9 cm or 10 cm. Figure 3b, the first target group 34 includes targets 18a and 18b, the second target group 34' includes target 18c, and the third target group 34' includes targets 18d and 18e. Therefore, it is allowed to position only one target 18c in the target group 34'. Figure 3b It will be appreciated that the target partition 36 may be selected in another manner, e.g. Figure 3c and Figure 3d Thus, a target partition or target partitioning is a segmentation of a target by target group, whereby each target partition represents another target group partition or segmentation. Figure 3c The target partition 36' shown in FIG. 1 includes two (2) target groups, while Figure 3d The target partitioning 36'' shown in includes three (3) target groups. Those skilled in the art will appreciate that there are many more possible target partitions than 36, 36', 36'', many of which may be excluded (not shown) simply because they are impractical or impossible to treat. The method disclosed herein considers all or at least some of the possible target partitions using given conditions, such as the maximum number of target groups 34, 34', 34'' allowed in the target partitioning 36, 36', 36'' and the maximum distance between two targets that are farthest from each other but still in the same group. The maximum distance may alternatively be specified or given as a maximum volume. When optimizing the treatment of multiple metastases, the target partitioning also takes into account other parameters, such as reference Figures 5a to 6b The concept of not exposing the so-called non-target area (ENTA) to radiation was explained. Figure 3a to Figure 3d It relates to the first aspect of the present invention.
[0119] Now turn to Figure 4a and Figure 4b , another aspect of the invention is disclosed and explained herein with reference to target clustering.The concept or second aspect of the present disclosure is now explained using a different head 16" of a patient having seven (7) metastases 18f-18l or targets 18f-18l.
[0120] It is worth noting that seven (7) targets 18f-18l is a fairly high number, but cases with up to fifteen (15) metastases have been treated. This means that multiple metastatic cases with several targets up to fifteen (15) or even more targets may occur, and the concept of clustering is explained here based on seven targets 18f-18l. Seven targets 18f-18l are difficult to treat with one and the same arc and therefore the same isocenter. Figure 4a and Figure 4bIn the exemplary case shown, due to rotational uncertainty, the targets 18f-18l are too far apart to be safely treated with the same arc / isocenter, which means that the targets 18f-18l need to be segmented into clusters 38, 38' so that each cluster 38, 38' can be treated separately, for example by using a separate or independent isocenter / arc. The clustering step of segmenting the targets 18f to 18l into clusters 38, 38' can therefore be used with the radiation therapy methods disclosed herein (such as conformal therapy or IMRT), or it can be used with other radiation therapy treatment methods (such as VMAT). The clusters 38, 38' can be selected based on the maximum volume allowed for the targets, or can be selected based on geometric constraints. Another parameter that can be considered when selecting the clusters 38, 38' of targets may be the maximum number of target divisions and target groupings allowed for the targets. This limit can be selected to be four (4), five (5), or six (6) targets. Figure 4a and Figure 4b The clustering steps or methods disclosed in can be used in conjunction with the present invention, or can be used as an independent method in other radiation therapy planning methods or treatments to improve the results of radiation therapy planning.
[0121] Figure 5a The MLC opening 26b is disclosed, which includes a blade pair 40 designed to block radiation from the radiation source in the MLC 4 ( Figure 5a radiation (not shown). Figure 5a Five (5) targets 18m-18q are shown, here in the form of spherical targets. Figure 5a In this embodiment, all targets 18m-18q are irradiated as simulations rather than actually. Analysis of the resulting irradiated area yields ENTA 42, which is referred to as the bridge gap opening 42. This area between targets 18p and 18o is not irradiated during treatment, but if one were to use Figure 5a By grouping the targets 18m-18q into a target partition 36''' including two groups 34''', 34'''', wherein the first group 34''' includes the targets 18n and 18o, and the second group 34'''' includes the targets 18m, 18p and 18q, as shown in FIG. Figure 5b As shown, it is possible to avoid bridging gap openings 42 and thus ENTAs 42. Such ENTAs 42 are taken into account when finding the best possible target partition 36''' according to the method of the appendix, as shown in FIG. Figure 5b As shown. Figure 5b The treatment or radiation treatment of the second group 34''' or MLC opening 26c is shown or at least simulated. Figure 5c Shown in FIG. 1 is a radiation treatment or at least a simulation of a first set 34 ′″ of MLC openings 26 d including targets 18 n , 18 o .
[0122] Figure 5b and Figure 5c The diagram illustrates how the blade pairs 40 can be closed over target groups 34''', 34'''' that do not need to be treated, and open over targets or target groups 34''', 34'''' that need to be treated. Note also that Figure 5a to Figure 5c Variations in the collimator angle 12 are not shown for ease of illustration, but it is contemplated and within the scope of the present invention that the target partitioning step may include examining and taking into account various collimator angles 12 at the control point 28 (see Figure 2 ).exist Figure 5b In the second target group, 34'''' were treated, while in Figure 5c In the first target group 34'''' was treated, and thus exposure or ENTA 42 was avoided (see Figure 5a ).
[0123] Figure 6a and Figure 6b As another example of avoiding the ENTA 42 region, these figures illustrate another MLC opening 26e, which may illustrate a simulated or real treatment, wherein a target 18r or tumor 18r having a banana shape is illustrated. Figure 6a As shown, the leaf pair 40 is open above the target 18r, and the collimator angle (not shown) is 0°. For ease of explanation, we assume here that this angle is 0°, but it can be any other angle, depending on how the collimator angle is defined. Figure 6a The diagram shows how ENTA 42' will expose (simulation) or be exposed (real treatment) to radiation with the current collimator angle. By rotating the MLC approximately 90º, as Figure 6b As shown, another MLC opening 26f may be used to avoid ENTA 42' due to the blade pair configuration and the MLC configuration.
[0124] exist Figure 6b The MLC opening 26f is treated with Figure 6a The same target 18r shown in FIG. 1 is used with the MLC rotated approximately 90°. As described above, this avoids radiation exposure to the ENTA 42′. Such issues are also considered when evaluating the MLC angle 12 and optimizing the treatment plan according to the methods disclosed herein.
[0125] like Figures 5a to 6b As shown, exposures ENTA 42, 42' may be represented in the optimization of the treatment plan by adding the ENTA cost to the optimization of each exposure of ENTA when analyzing the target partitions 36, 36', 36", 36''' and the various target groups 34, 34', 34", 34''' therein to find the optimal target partitions 36, 36', 36", 36'''.
[0126] Figure 7a and Figure 7b The diagram illustrates additional costs that may be added to the optimization process. Figure 7a An MLC opening 26g is illustrated for a target 18s having a particular shape. Figure 7a The MLC opening 26g shown in FIG. 1 is a conformal MLC opening 26g in which the blade pair 40 opens across the target 18s, while Figure 7b The blade pair 40 of the MLC opening 26h in the target 18s is not open over the entire target 18s, which means that Figure 7b The MLC opening 26h is not conformal, but a so-called sawtooth opening. The sawtooth MLC opening 26h is avoided in the method according to the present disclosure. If the sawtooth MLC opening 26h appears even after the optimization is run, the cost of the sawtooth MLC opening 26h can be increased at one or some control points 28 (see Figure 2 ) This sawtooth MLC opening 26h is taken into account in the optimization process. The reason why the use of a sawtooth MLC opening 26h should be avoided is that this sawtooth MLC opening 26h has a negative impact on the robustness of dose delivery. Since it may not be certain that the position of the patient is exactly as assumed when calculating the dose, it becomes uncertain whether the dose calculation is correct.
[0127] The challenge of conformal arc planning is that in some cases, the dose levels of different targets of the same arc beam become highly correlated, making it difficult to simultaneously obtain the desired dose levels of multiple targets and therefore targets in one target group. Some solutions suggest VMAT to optimize the dose levels, but VMAT results in sawtooth leaf positions, which need to be avoided in conformal arc planning or conformal radiotherapy. Figure 8 The diagram shows Figure 5b A similar view, but with a different MLC opening 26e. A second target set 34'''' including targets 18m, 18p, and 18q is now exposed to radiation, but only targets 18m and 18p are present without target 18q. Target 18q is at this particular control point 28 or arc beam 24 (see Figure 2 ) is blocked because the optimization process has shown that otherwise the target 18q will receive a dose level that exceeds the desired dose level. This process is called dose control blocking and is disclosed herein as a third aspect of the present invention. It will be understood by those skilled in the art that other targets of the second group 34'''' in other arc beams 24 along the arc path 20 can be blocked to achieve the desired dose level in the targets of the target groups 34, 34', 34''', 34''''.
[0128] The optimization process according to the third aspect may include segment weight optimization, also known as control point MU optimization, to calculate and optimize the dose levels as much as possible. The difference between the actual dose levels in the targets 18a-18q and the desired dose levels or dose level targets is calculated. The segment weights or arc beam MUs are then increased so that all actual dose levels of the targets 18a-18q are at or above their dose targets. Then, according to Figure 8 The concept shown in , blocks the targets 18q or targets whose dose levels are now above the dose level target in the last part of the arc path 20 and therefore in some of the arc beams 24 or segments. This is achieved by analyzing the arc beams 24 along the arc path 20 and modifying the arc beams 24 so that the configuration of the MLCs 4 at some control points 28 is modified by shutting down the blades 40 of the MLCs 4 on the relevant targets 18q, thereby achieving the desired dose level in the corresponding targets 18q. This process allows the actual delivered dose level of each target to be reduced to the desired dose level.
[0129] The process related to the dose control block according to the third aspect of the present invention may be performed according to Figure 4a and Figure 4b After clustering and taking into account the avoidance of bridging gap openings 42 or ENTA 42' is completed according to Figure 3a and Figure 3d However, according to Figure 8 Dose control blocking may also be accomplished using other treatment planning methods and is not limited to use with only the first and second aspects disclosed herein.
[0130] Since now with Figures 1 to 8 Various aspects and concepts of the present invention are described in relation to each other, and therefore reference is made here to Figures 9 to 11 To explain the method according to aspects of the present invention.
[0131] Fig. 9A method related to target clustering is illustrated. The clustering method can be performed before the target division. As input S01 to the method, the maximum allowed distance between two targets of the same cluster is given. This maximum allowed distance can be a threshold. In addition, a specific number of targets N can be given as another input. N can be an integer, such as four (4), five (5) or six (6) targets. Preferably, the maximum allowed distance is the main criterion for selecting a cluster. In addition, the input S01 can be given as the maximum number M of clusters 38, 38' of the clustering step or method. Another potential input is the maximum distance between two targets in a cluster so that a cluster can be determined and selected based on geometric conditions. Alternatively, a maximum volume can be used as input to the method. Once the method receives these conditions, it determines S02 the number of targets to be treated, including their positions relative to each other, and then checks S03 whether the number of targets exceeds the specific number of targets N. If a certain number N of targets is exceeded, the targets are divided S04a into clusters based on geometric parameters, such as the maximum distance between two targets of the same cluster 38, 38', the volume required to accommodate all targets of a cluster 38, 38'. In the case where the number of targets does not exceed a certain number N, the division S04a of the targets into clusters based on geometric parameters, such as the maximum distance between two targets of the same cluster 38, 38', the volume required to accommodate all targets of a cluster 38, 38' may be performed. Fig.10 method.
[0132] Also refer to Figure 4a and Figure 4b Explained based on Fig. 9 method.
[0133] Fig.10 The target partitioning optimization method is illustrated when multiple targets 18, 18', 18a-18q need to be treated during one radiation treatment. A treatment planning method for generating a treatment plan for radiation therapy, wherein a set of targets 18a-18q need to be treated, the method uses a multi-leaf collimator (MLC) 4 to shape an arc beam 24 or a radiation beam 15, a gantry 2 includes the MLC 4, the gantry 2 can be rotated at least partially around a patient, a couch 6 is used to position the patient, the MLC 4 defines a collimator angle 12, the gantry 4 is movable around a gantry angle 10, and the couch 6 is movable around a couch angle 8. The target partitioning optimization method comprises the following steps:
[0134] - providing a plurality of candidate arc paths with isocenters and a maximum number of arc beams for treatment planning S05 and, depending on the maximum number of arc beams, providing a maximum number of target groups 34, 34', 34", 34''', 34'''' allowed for treatment;
[0135] - Provide S06 the shape and position of each target 18a-18q in the target set;
[0136] - optionally, calculating S07 at least some possible target partitions 36, 36', 36" of the target set, each of the possible target partitions 36, 36', 36" comprising target groups 34, 34', 34", 34'", 34'",'', wherein each target 18a-18q is part of at least one target group 34, 34', 34", 34'", 34'"'; additionally and as an option, target partitions comprising target groups that have been determined to be non-optimal may be directly omitted from the possible target partitions, which means which target groups add high costs to the current target partition;
[0137] - calculating S08 target partitioning 36, 36', 36" of at least some possible target partitioning 36, 36', 36" of at least one possible target partitioning 36, 36', 36" of the target set based on the current candidate arc paths 20, 20', 20", 22, at least some target partitioning 36, 36', 36" comprising a maximum number of target groups 34, 34', 34", 34'", 34'"', optionally depending on a constraint of a maximum number of target groups for all arc beams / number of arc beams;
[0138] - determining S09 a cost for each target group 34, 34', 34", 34'", 34''' in the possible target partitioning, taking into account the current candidate arc path, the at least one gantry angle 10 and the at least one MLC angle 12 for each target group 34, 34', 34", 34''', 34''' in the possible target partitioning 36, 36', 36'';
[0139] - determining S10 the cost of the possible target partitioning 36, 36', 36" and the current candidate arc path by adding the costs of the target groups 34, 34', 34", 34'", 34'''' in the possible target partitioning 36, 36', 36";
[0140] - determining S11 whether all of at least some of the target partitions 36 , 36 ′, 36 ″ have been considered;
[0141] - repeat the S12 calculation, determination and summing steps for each possible target partition and each candidate arc path, and
[0142] - Select S13 the optimal target partitioning 36, 36', 36", arc path 20 and arc beam 24 of the treatment plan with the lowest sum of costs, taking into account the maximum number of target groups in all arc beams.
[0143] Fig.10 The methods shown in and explained in the previous paragraphs are connected and used in reference Figure 2 The concepts, references to the arc paths 20, 20', 20" and control points 28 shown and explained in Figure 3a to Figure 3dThe concept of target partitioning shown and explained in and reference Figures 5a to 6b The concept of avoiding such ENTA 42, 42' by defining the cost of ENTA 42, 42' is shown and explained in FIG. Fig.10 The method is not explicitly described in the literature, but the method is designed for conformal treatment and thus avoids jagged MLC openings, as described in reference Figure 7a and Figure 7b As shown and explained in.
[0144] A limitation of the above approach may be the total number of target groups that provide all arc beams. It may be helpful to consider all potential arc beams at once.
[0145] Each arc beam 24 along the arc path 20 takes into account the collimator angle 12 along the arc path 20 and / or at each control point 28 .
[0146] In an embodiment, the calculation step S08 may take into account all possible target partitions.
[0147] From the basis Fig.10 According to the method, an arc plan can be provided based on the optimal target partitioning 36, 36', 36". Such an arc plan can include a series of arc paths 20, 20', 20" for the treatment of the target groups 34, 34', 34", 34'", 34''', 34'''', the arc paths including information about the collimator angle 12, the couch angle 8 and the MLC opening 26a-26i and other parameters of each arc beam 24 or control point 28. Fig.10 The arc plan provided by the method may include a minimum cost arc path or a minimum arc beam based on the optimal target segmentation 36, 36', 36". The arc plan may also include a calculated dose or an expected dose for each target.
[0148] Fig.11 The diagram shows Fig.10 A similar method scheme is used for a target partitioning optimization method when multiple targets 18, 18', 18a-18q need to be treated during a radiotherapy treatment. A treatment planning method for generating a treatment plan for radiotherapy, wherein a set of targets 18a-18q need to be treated, the method uses a multi-leaf collimator (MLC) 4 to shape an arc beam 24 or a radiation beam 15, a gantry 2 includes the MLC 4, the gantry 2 can be rotated at least partially around a patient, a couch 6 is used to position the patient, the MLC 4 defines a collimator angle 12, the gantry 4 can be moved around a gantry angle 10, and the couch 6 can be moved around a couch angle 8. The target partitioning optimization method includes the following steps:
[0149] - providing S05 a plurality of candidate arc paths with isocenters and a maximum number of arc beams for treatment planning and, depending on the maximum number of arc beams, providing a maximum number of target groups 34, 34', 34", 34''', 34'''' allowed for treatment;
[0150] - providing S06 the shape and position of each target 18a-18q in the target set;
[0151] - optionally, calculating S07 at least some possible target partitions 36, 36', 36" of the target set, each of the possible target partitions 36, 36', 36" comprising target groups 34, 34', 34", 34'", 34'",'', wherein each target 18a-18q is part of at least one target group 34, 34', 34", 34'", 34'"'; additionally and as an option, target partitions comprising target groups that have been determined to be non-optimal may be directly omitted from the possible target partitions, which means which target groups add high costs to the current target partition;
[0152] - calculating S08 a target partitioning 36, 36', 36" of at least some possible target partitionings 36, 36', 36" of the target set based on the current candidate arc path 20, 20', 20", 22, the at least some possible target partitionings 36, 36', 36" comprising a maximum number of target groups 34, 34', 34", 34'", 34'"', 34'"', taking into account the current candidate arc path, at least one gantry angle 10 and at least one MLC angle 12 for each target group 34, 34', 34", 34'", 34'"' of the possible target partitionings 36, 36', 36";
[0153] - determining S09 a cost for each target group 34, 34', 34", 34'", 34''', 34'''' in the possible target partitioning 36, 36', 36'', taking into account the current candidate arc path, the at least one gantry angle 10 and the at least one MLC angle 12 for each target group 34, 34', 34'', 34'''' in the possible target partitioning 36, 36', 36'';
[0154] - determining S10 the cost of the possible target partitioning 36, 36', 36" and the current candidate arc path by adding the costs of the target groups 34, 34', 34", 34'", 34'''' in the possible target partitioning 36, 36', 36";
[0155] - determining S11 whether all at least some possible target partitions 36, 36', 36" and candidate arc paths have been considered;
[0156] - repeating S14 providing candidate arc paths, providing shapes and positions, and optionally calculating, determining and summing steps for each possible target partition and each or at least some candidate arc paths, and
[0157] - Selecting S13 the optimal target partitioning 36, 36', 36", arc path 20 and arc beam 24 of the treatment plan with the lowest sum of costs, and optionally taking into account limitations and constraints related to the maximum number of total target groups when summing over at least some of the target partitions.
[0158] The above method and Fig.11 The illustration allows considering each candidate arc path and at least some of the target partitions all for the optimization step, at least more or less simultaneously, to seek the best possible treatment plan.
[0159] Fig.12 A method for controlling the dose according to the third aspect of the present invention is further illustrated. The method for controlling the dose comprises the following steps:
[0160] - determining S14 an arc plan based on the least-cost arc beam 24 or least-cost arc path 20 , 20 ′, 20 ″, the arc plan comprising a calculated dose for the treatment;
[0161] - providing S15 a dose level target for each target in the target group 34, 34', 34'', 34''', 34'''' of the optimal target partition 36, 36', 36'', and determining an exposure time and a monitoring unit for each target so that each target in the optimal target partition 36, 36', 36'' obtains at least a desired dose level;
[0162] - identifying S16 a target for achieving a dose level exceeding a dose level target; and
[0163] The required dose control block is calculated S17, wherein for targets exceeding the dose level target at certain arc beams 24 or portions of arc beams 24, the leaves of the MLC opening are fully closed in order to control the delivery of dose and thereby the dose level in these targets.
[0164] according to Fig.11 The method may be used with the invention disclosed herein, or may be used with another treatment planning method. Advantageously, the dose control blocking method is used for conformal arc beam therapy or arc planning.
[0165] Fig.13A radiation therapy treatment planning system 42 is further illustrated, which includes a processor 44, a memory 46 connected to the processor 44, an optional additional memory 50 also connected to the processor 44 and / or the memory 46, and an input / output interface 48 having a display and / or a keyboard for user interaction. The processor 44 can be any combination of a central treatment unit (CPU), a multiprocessor, a digital signal processor (DSP), an ASIC (application-specific integrated circuit) capable of executing software instructions stored on the memory and capable of performing the methods described according to the embodiments of this document. The memory 46 and / or the additional memory 50 may include software code in the form of a computer program product 52, which includes the computer software 54 or includes instructions for any method according to the present disclosure. The computer software 54 can be executed by the processor 44.
[0166] The memory 46 and the additional memory 50 may be any one of random access memory (RAM) or read only memory (ROM) or any combination thereof.
[0167] Example
[0168] Example 1
[0169] Assume that four (4) candidate arc paths are provided to treat a set of targets. We assume in this example that each target is to be treated from all four (4) couch angles corresponding to the provided candidate arc paths. Furthermore, it is assumed in this example 1 that each target is to be treated only once from each such couch angle / candidate arc path.
[0170] The goal is to find the best possible plan using at most ten (10) arcs in the final plan, which means that the total number of target groups among all candidate arc paths is at most 10. If we can reduce the number of arcs, for example to nine (9) or eight (8), while still keeping the ENTA of the optimal partitioning at a satisfactory level, for example at or below some low threshold, such as 0.5 cm 2 , this optimization must also be considered. In other words, according to, for example, clinic guidelines, we are allowed to use ten (10) arcs, but we would prefer to use fewer arcs if using fewer arcs does not significantly increase the dose of radiation to non-target tissues.
[0171] The optimization of this problem must be performed on all candidate arc paths. at the same timeDone. The reason for this is that if we try this for one arc at a time, then we may find an optimal partition for the first candidate arc path, for example into two (2), three (3), or four (4) target groups. As we increase the number of target groups, ENTA decreases (if it is still not satisfactory), so we might try splitting the target set into four (4) target groups for the first candidate arc path. On the other hand, this leaves only six (6) target groups for the remaining 3 candidate arc paths. Splitting into only two (2) target groups leaves eight (8) target groups, but results in a higher ENTA contribution. However, it is not yet clear what the optimal configuration of candidate arc paths and target partitions is, which means it is impossible to know what the optimal choice is.
[0172] On the other hand, if we optimize simultaneously, we first compute the optimal partitioning for each of the four (4) candidate arc paths, such as into two (2), three (3), and four (4) target groups, thus saving the cost of the optimal partitioning and number of target groups for each candidate arc path. From this, we loop through all ways to combine the four numbers (one for each candidate arc path) - two (2), three (3), or four (4) - so that their sum is ten (10). Some examples are: 2+2+2+4; 2+3+2+3; 3+3+2+2. These options are then evaluated by summing the ENTA contributions of each candidate arc path; in the case of 2+2+2+4, we add the ENTA of the optimal way to partition each of the first three candidate arc paths into two (2) target groups to the ENTA of the optimal way to partition the fourth into four (4) target groups. Doing this for all possible combinations and choosing the lowest sum gives us the optimal way to optimally partition the targets for all candidate arc paths. We then compare the total ENTA of this optimal value to a threshold. If it is low enough, i.e., if the ENTA is at or below the threshold, we can hope that it will still be low enough even for a total of nine (9) beams; to find out, we repeat the same process as above, but with the total number of target groups limited to nine (9) instead of ten (10). If the total ENTA is low enough for nine (9), we can do it again for eight (8), and so on. In this way, we end up with an optimal treatment plan that uses at most ten (10) candidate arc paths, minimizing the number of final arc paths as much as possible without significantly affecting the ENTA.
[0173] Example 2
[0174] Assume again that we have four (4) candidate arc paths, but this time we do not need every target to be treated by every candidate arc path, but rather by at least three (3) candidate arc paths. However, the set of arc paths that treat target A does not have to be the same as the set of arc paths that treat another target B. Note that this example is equally valid, and useful in practice, in other cases, for example, if we have at most five (5) candidate arc paths and want to treat each target from at least four (4) or at least three (3) candidate arc paths.
[0175] Assume that we want to treat six (6) targets with as few arc beams as possible while keeping the total ENTA below a threshold. The fact that we allow each target to be treated with only three (3) of the four (4) available candidate arc paths allows the possibility of using fewer beams while obtaining a better plan than manually selecting three (3) of the four (4) candidate arc paths and treating all targets with only these candidate arc paths, or in the worst case, the possibility of obtaining an equally good plan.
[0176] To do this, we proceed in a similar way to the previous example, computing for each candidate arc path the cost of the optimal way of partitioning into two (2), three (3) and four (4) parts (we could also have partitioned into one (1) or five (5) parts). However, this time we add another level of optimization: selecting at least three (3) of the four (4) candidate arc paths to treat each target.
[0177] In the aforementioned Example 1, when calculating the cost of the optimal way to partition into two (2), three (3), and four (4) target groups, we assumed that all targets were included in one of the partitioned target groups. Now, we perform these calculations not only for all sets of targets, but also for each subset of targets. In other words, for each subset of targets, we find the optimal way to partition that subset into two (2), three (3), and four (4) target groups, given the constraint that there are enough targets in the subset.
[0178] Suppose we have 6 targets: A, B, C, D, E, F. Each To find candidate arc paths, we do the following:
[0179] Enumerate all subsets of the set S = {A, B, C, D, E, F} of all targets. One such subset is S1 = {A, B, D, F}, where C and E are missing; another subset is S2 = {B, C}; and yet another subset is the set S3 = {A, B, C, D, E, F}, which is equal to S itself.
[0180] For each subset, find the best partitioning into two (2), three (3), and four (4) target groups. For S1, this may result in:
[0181] o Two (2) target sets: {{A, D}, {B, F}}, total cost 2.1
[0182] o Three (3) target sets: {{A, D}, {B}, {F}}, total cost 0.3
[0183] o Four (4) target sets: {{A}, {D}, {B}, {F}}, total cost 0.0.
[0184] For S2, which contains only two (2) targets, it does not make sense to split it into three (3) or four (4) target groups, so we only find the best way to split it into two target groups.
[0185] After completing the above operations for each candidate arc path, it is time to combine the results into an optimal treatment plan. We do this by solving multiple choices for the total number of arc paths, similar to Example 1 above, where the choices are ten (10) arc paths, nine (9) arc paths, and eight (8) arc paths. We then minimize the number of arc paths under the constraint that the total cost must be below a threshold.
[0186] However, in this setting, the problem is more complex. Suppose that for the case of Example 1, we only look for cases where the total number of arcs in the final plan should be ten (10). Then, for each of the possible ways of choosing the partition size for each candidate arc path, summing up to ten (10), e.g., 2+2+2+4, we need to consider all ways of choosing different subsets for each partition. That is, we need to compute a cost for each combination of ways in which subsets can be chosen for different candidate arc paths. For example, if the selected subsets are S3, S3, S3, S3, we need to compute one cost sum; one cost sum for S2, S3, S3, S3; one cost sum for S1, S3, S3, S3; and so on. In doing so, we only consider combinations that satisfy the requirement of at least three (3) initial arc paths per target: thus, S1, S2, S3, S3 are not considered because target E is not included in S1 or S2, and is therefore treated by only two candidate arc paths, namely the third and fourth candidate arc paths, which both treat S3.
[0187] After doing this for all valid subset combinations, the cost of partitioning into 2+2+2+4 target groups is taken as the allocation with the lowest cost among the valid subsets. After doing this for all possible partition sizes for each candidate arc path up to ten (10) arc paths, we have found the optimal way to treat each target using ten (10) arc paths and with at least three (3) candidate arc paths. Repeating this for different numbers of total arc paths, as in Example 1 above, gives the result we are looking for.
[0188] For example, the outcome of this situation may be that we end up treating with subsets S3, S1, S3, S4, where S4 = {B, C, E}, split into 3, 2, 2, 2 target groups, respectively, giving a total of 9 arc paths with a cost of 0. Doing so while requiring each candidate arc path to treat each target as in Example 1 is equivalent to treating with subsets S3, S3, S3, S3. Replacing S1 and S4 with instances of S3 will increase the cost of treating these target partitions when each is split into 2 target groups. Therefore, and in order to achieve 0 cost in this case, the number of target groups in these partitions is increased, and therefore the total number of arc paths in the plan is also increased to 10 or 11 in order to achieve 0 cost.
[0189] The present invention has been described with reference to the embodiments disclosed above and in the accompanying drawings. However, and as will be appreciated by those skilled in the art, other embodiments besides those disclosed herein may be readily conceived and are equally possible within the scope of the present invention, as defined by the appended patent claims.
Claims
1. A treatment planning method for generating a treatment plan for radiotherapy, wherein a set of targets (18a-18q) is to be treated, the method using a multi-leaf collimator (MLC) (4) for shaping an arc beam (24), a gantry (2) for holding the MLC, a couch (6) for positioning the patient, the gantry (2) being at least partially rotatable around the patient, the MLC (4) being movable and defining a collimator angle (12), the gantry (2) being movable and defining a gantry angle (10), and the couch (6) being optionally movable so as to define a couch angle (8), the method The following steps are involved: - providing (S05) a plurality of candidate arc paths (20, 20', 20", 22) with isocenters and a maximum number of arc beams (24) for the treatment plan, and depending on the maximum number of arc beams, providing a maximum number of target groups (34, 34', 34", 34'", 34''''); - providing (S06) the shape and position of each target (18a-18q) in the target set; - based on the current candidate arc path (20, 20', 20'', 22), calculating (S08) a target partitioning (36, 36', 36'') of at least some possible target partitionings of the target set, the at least some possible target partitionings (36, 36', 36'') comprising a maximum number of target groups (34, 34', 34'', 34''', 34'''), each of the at least some possible target partitionings (36, 36', 36'') comprising a target group (34, 34', 34'', 34''', 34'''), - determining (S09) a cost for each target group (34, 34', 34'', 34''', 34''') of the possible target partitioning (36, 36', 36''), taking into account the current candidate arc path (20, 20', 20'', 22), at least one gantry angle (10) and at least one MLC angle (12); - determining (S10) the cost of the possible target partition (36, 36', 36'') and the current candidate arc path (20, 20', 20'', 22) by summing the costs of the target group (34, 34', 34'', 34''', 34'''') of the possible target partition (36, 36', 36''); - repeating (S12) said calculating (S08), said determining (S09) and said summing (S10) steps for each of said at least some possible target partitions (36, 36', 36") and at least some of said candidate arc paths (20, 20', 20", 22), and - selecting ( S13 ) the optimal target partition ( 36 , 36 ′, 36 ″) and the candidate arc path ( 20 , 20 ′, 20 ″, 22 ) of the treatment plan with the lowest sum of costs.
2. The treatment planning method according to claim 1, in, The calculation step (S08) also takes into account at least one couch angle (8).
3. The treatment planning method according to claim 1 or 2, in, The maximum number of target groups (34, 34', 34", 34''', 34'''') is provided by the treatment planner, or is any given number between 2 and 30, preferably 8 to 20 for all arc beams (24), alternatively 1 to 6 target groups per arc beam.
4. A treatment planning method according to any one of claims 1 to 3, in, The calculation step (S08) further comprises dividing the candidate arc paths (20, 20', 20", 22) into control points (28) spaced at regular intervals, each gap corresponding to a gantry angle segment, wherein an optimal MLC angle (12) and / or an optimal couch angle (8) is calculated at each control point (28).
5. A treatment planning method according to any one of claims 1 to 3, in, For each control point (28), an optimal MLC opening (26a-26i) is calculated, wherein the optimal MLC opening is selected based on the lowest cost and the optimal MLC angle (12) and the previous and subsequent MLC angles (12) at the previous and subsequent control points (28).
6. A treatment planning method according to any one of claims 1 to 3, in, The calculating step (S08) further comprises segmenting the candidate arc paths (20, 20', 20", 22) into control points (28) spaced at regular gaps, each gap corresponding to a gantry angle segment, wherein for each control point (28), the MLC angle (12) is maintained in a fixed position, and wherein the cost of each candidate MLC angle (12) is calculated for each control point (28) to find an optimal fixed MLC angle (12) for each candidate arc path (20, 20', 20", 22).
7. The treatment planning method according to claim 4, in, If the MLC angle (12) needs to be changed between adjacent control points (28), additional costs are added.
8. The treatment planning method according to claim 2, in, If the couch angle (8) needs to be changed between adjacent control points (28), additional costs are incurred.
9. A treatment planning method according to any one of the preceding claims, in, If the total number of target groups ( 34 , 34 ′, 34 ″, 34 ′″, 34 ″″) in the current target partition ( 36 , 36 ′, 36 ″) exceeds a certain threshold, such as 15 to 20 target groups, an additional cost is added.
10. A treatment planning method according to any one of the preceding claims, in, The maximum number of the arc beams (24) corresponds to the maximum number of the target groups (34, 34', 34", 34'", 34'''').
11. A treatment planning method according to any one of the preceding claims, in, The arc beam (24) is a conformal arc beam.
12. A treatment planning method according to any one of the preceding claims, further comprising: The following steps are involved: The method further comprises retrieving the lowest cost arc beam (4) having the lowest cost MLC angle (12) and gantry angle (10) pair for each target group (34, 34', 34'', 34''', 34''') of the optimal target partitioning (36, 36', 36'') and delivering the lowest cost arc beam (24), whereby each arc beam (24) corresponds to one target group (34, 34', 34'', 34''', 34''') of the optimal target partitioning (36, 36', 36''), so that each target group (34, 34', 34'', 34''', 34'''') receives one arc beam (24) for treatment.
13. The treatment planning method according to any of the preceding claims, further comprising the step of using the treatment planning method according to any of the preceding claims as a starting point for volumetric modulated arc therapy optimization.
14. A treatment planning method according to any one of the preceding claims, in, At least some possible target partitions (36, 36', 36") are considered for various candidate arc paths (20, 20', 20", 22), and an arc plan including arc beams (24) and arc paths (20, 20', 20", 22) is provided based on the optimal target partitions (36, 36', 36") and the lowest cost arc beam (24), while considering a limit on the maximum number of arc beams (24), such as a maximum number of target groups (34, 34', 34", 34'", 34''") in total over the maximum number of arc beams (24).
15. A treatment planning method according to any one of the preceding claims, further comprising: The following steps are involved: - receiving (S14) an arc plan and a calculated dose for each target (18a-18q) in said optimal target partitioning (36, 36', 36''); - providing (S15) a dose level target for each target (18a-18q) and adjusting the arc plan so that each target obtains at least the dose level target; - identifying (S16) said targets (18a-18q) that achieve a dose level exceeding said dose level target; and - calculating (S17) the required dose control blockage, wherein at least some blades (40) of the MLC (4) are completely closed for at least a portion of some arc beams (24) of the targets (18a-18q) having a dose level exceeding the dose level target, so as to optimize the delivery of the dose and thereby optimize the dose level target for all targets of the optimal target partition (36, 36', 36'').
16. The treatment planning method according to claim 11, in, The control points (28) and / or the starting gantry angle (10) and the stopping gantry angle (10) are modified so as to avoid any completely closed MLC openings (26a-26i) at the control points (28) or segments, wherein all targets (18a-18q) are blocked.
17. A treatment planning method according to any one of the preceding claims, in, If the distance (S01) between two targets (18a-18q) exceeds a certain threshold or if the number of said targets exceeds (S03) N targets, where N is an integer, a clustering step (S04a) is performed before the step disclosed in claim 1, said clustering step comprising the following steps: selecting a maximum number M of clusters (38, 38') based on the number of said targets (18a-18q), where M is an integer, limiting the number of said targets in a cluster (38, 38') to be less than or equal to N and selecting the targets in a cluster based on the maximum allowed distance between two targets of the same cluster.
18. The treatment planning method according to claim 17, in, The position and three-dimensional shape of each target (18a-18q) in the target set relative to other targets in the target set are provided as input, and wherein integers N and M are specified by an operator.
19. A computer program product (52) comprising computer readable means which, when executed in a computer, will cause the computer to perform the method according to any one of the preceding claims.
20. A radiation therapy planning system comprising a processor (44), a memory, in, The memory (46) comprises a computer program product according to claim 20, the radiation therapy planning system being designed to perform the method according to any of the preceding claims 1 to 18.
