Method for predicting occurrence of spatter in resistance spot welding, resistance spot welding method, and method for manufacturing welded member

By analyzing the increase speed of the molten area and the pressurization state of the non-melting area during welding, using W and dW/dt parameters to predict splash, the problem of splash prediction deviation in resistance spot welding is solved, and high-precision prediction and low-cost and efficient The selection of welding conditions improves the productivity and quality of welded parts.

CN119095686APending Publication Date: 2024-12-06JFE STEEL CORP
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202380035843.2
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2022-06-16
Filing Date
2023-02-22
Publication Date
2024-12-06

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

During the resistance spot welding process, it is difficult to predict the occurrence of splash with high accuracy, resulting in unstable welding quality and high construction costs, and there are many prediction deviations in the prior art.

Method used

By analyzing the increase velocity of the molten region in welding and the change in the pressurization state of the non-melting region over time, the parameters W and dW/dt are used to predict the occurrence of splashing, and the welding conditions are determined to avoid splashing.

Benefits of technology

It realizes high-precision prediction of splash occurrence without prior testing, and selects high-quality welding conditions at low cost, which improves the productivity and quality of welded parts.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN119095686A_ABST
    Figure CN119095686A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention provides a method for predicting the occurrence of spatter in resistance spot welding, which can predict the occurrence of spatter in the whole welding process with high precision without performing a prior test. The occurrence of spatter from the joining surface of the steel sheet is predicted on the basis of the increase rate of the molten region of the material to be joined during welding and the change over time in the pressurized state of the non-molten region of the material to be joined.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention relates to a method for predicting spatter occurrence in resistance spot welding, a resistance spot welding method and a method for manufacturing a welded component. Background Art

[0002] Generally, in the joining of automobile bodies (hereinafter, also referred to as bodies), resistance spot welding, which is a kind of lap resistance welding method, is used. Figure 1 As shown in FIG. 1 , the welding method is a method of joining two or more overlapping steel plates 1 and 2 as the materials to be joined by clamping them, applying pressure from the top and bottom with a pair of electrodes 3 and 4, and passing a welding current between the upper and lower electrodes. In the welding method, the steel plates are melted by the resistance heat generated by the flow of the welding current, and a point-shaped welded portion is obtained. The point-shaped welded portion is called a nugget 5. That is, the nugget 5 is a portion where the steel plates 1 and 2 melt and solidify at the contact position of the steel plates when the current flows through the overlapping steel plates. Through the nugget 5, the steel plates are joined to each other in a point shape.

[0003] In resistance spot welding, the electrodes are kept pressurized on the materials to be joined so that the molten metal does not fly outward from the joining surface of the steel plates during welding. However, when the internal pressure of the molten metal cannot be suppressed by the pressure of the electrodes, a phenomenon called spattering may occur in which the molten metal flies outward. If spattering occurs, the scattered molten metal adheres to the periphery of the weld and deteriorates the appearance. In addition, the nugget diameter and joint strength vary, and the quality of the weld joint is unstable. Therefore, from the perspective of improving the quality of the weld joint and ensuring the strength, it is desirable to obtain a nugget with a large diameter while minimizing spattering.

[0004] In order to obtain a large nugget diameter, it is necessary to increase the heat input during welding. However, if the heat input is increased, the risk of spatter generation increases. Therefore, it is not easy to select welding conditions that can take into account both suppressing the occurrence of spatter and ensuring the diameter of the nugget (hereinafter also referred to as welding conditions that can achieve high-quality welding).

[0005] Generally speaking, when steel plates are joined using resistance spot welding, a large number of preliminary tests are carried out in order to explore welding conditions that can achieve high-quality welding. Then, the results of the nugget diameter and the spatter generation behavior are confirmed, and appropriate conditions are selected. For example, in actual vehicle body joining, it is necessary to carry out preliminary tests on a large variety of plate components assumed in the vehicle body and select appropriate welding conditions. The implementation of such preliminary tests has become an important factor in increasing construction costs. It should be noted that the above-mentioned problems are not limited to the case of resistance spot welding of steel plates for automobiles, but also exist when resistance spot welding is carried out on steel plates for other purposes.

[0006] To address such a problem, for example, Patent Document 1 discloses:

[0007] "A method for predicting the occurrence of spatter in resistance spot welding, characterized in that, in resistance spot welding in which two or more materials to be welded are sandwiched and overlapped between two electrodes and energized while pressing the materials to be welded with the electrodes to join the two or more materials to be welded, a method for predicting the occurrence of spatter at a contact interface of any two of the two or more materials to be welded that are in contact with each other is used,

[0008] The occurrence of the above-mentioned sputtering can be predicted based on the electrode pressure and the force acting on the non-melting part.

[0009] The electrode pressure is the force that presses the electrode against the material to be welded.

[0010] The non-melting portion is the interface where any two of the above-mentioned materials to be welded are in contact with each other without melting during the above-mentioned resistance spot welding. "

[0011] Prior art literature

[0012] Patent Literature

[0013] Patent Document 1: Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 2007-283328 Summary of the invention

[0014] here, Figure 2 The figure shows an example of the relationship between the welding time and the diameter of the molten area of ​​the material to be joined when resistance spot welding is performed on two overlapping steel plates as the material to be joined using a common single-pass current pair. It should be noted that the molten area of ​​the material to be joined becomes a nugget after solidification. Figure 2 As shown in the figure, the molten area is rapidly enlarged at the beginning of the power-on. Moreover, in the later stage of the power-on, the diameter change of the molten area becomes slow, approaching the saturation diameter (the final nugget diameter). Such changes in the increase rate of the molten area during power-on (the growth rate of the nugget) are affected by changes in the contact diameter between the electrode and the steel plate and between the steel plate and the steel plate during power-on, changes in resistance caused by temperature changes, etc. In addition, the internal pressure of the molten metal changes with time. Furthermore, as the power-on progresses, the structure of the non-molten area around the nugget pressurized by the electrode also changes. Therefore, it is difficult to predict whether spatter will occur in the entire welding process based only on the electrode pressure and the force acting on the non-molten area.

[0015] In fact, in the technology disclosed in Patent Document 1, there are many cases where the prediction of whether spatter will occur during resistance spot welding deviates depending on the materials to be joined and the welding conditions, and improvement in prediction accuracy is desired.

[0016] The present invention has been developed in view of the above-mentioned current situation, and an object of the present invention is to provide a method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding which can accurately predict whether spatter will be generated in the entire welding process without performing a prior test.

[0017] Another object of the present invention is to provide a resistance spot welding method and a method for manufacturing a welded part, in which resistance spot welding is performed under welding conditions determined based on the above-mentioned method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding.

[0018] Therefore, the inventors have conducted intensive studies to achieve the above-mentioned object and have obtained the following findings.

[0019] (1) As described above, in resistance spot welding, the electrode is pressed against the materials to be joined so that the molten metal does not fly outward from the joining surface of the steel plates during welding. Therefore, the occurrence of spatter is correlated with the pressurization state of the non-molten area around the molten area of ​​the materials to be joined. However, the formation behavior of the nugget during welding changes with time. Therefore, it is impossible to accurately predict the occurrence of spatter based only on the pressurization state of the non-molten area.

[0020] (2) Based on the above points, the inventors have conducted repeated research and obtained the following insights. On the basis of considering the change of the pressurized state of the non-melting area over time, it is effective to further consider the influence of the increase rate of the molten area (the growth rate of the molten nugget). In this way, it is possible to accurately predict whether spatter will occur in the entire welding process.

[0021] (3) That is, when the rate of increase of the melting area is fast, the temperature of the melting area changes sharply, and the softening caused by heating of the non-melting area around the melting area cannot be fully carried out. In addition, since the internal pressure caused by the molten metal is also very high, it is a state where splashing is more likely to occur. On the other hand, when the rate of increase of the melting area is slow, the non-melting area around the melting area is fully softened as the melting area expands. In addition, since the internal pressure caused by the molten metal is also low, splashing is less likely to occur compared with the case where the rate of increase of the melting area is fast. Therefore, on the basis of considering the change of the pressurized state of the non-melting area over time, the influence of the rate of increase of the melting area is further considered, thereby being able to accurately predict whether splashing occurs in the entire welding process.

[0022] (4) In addition, as parameters indicating the increase rate of the molten region of the materials to be joined during welding and the temporal change in the pressurized state of the non-molten region of the materials to be joined, for example, W and dW / dt are preferably used.

[0023] here,

[0024] W: The width (mm) of the non-melting area on the joint surface of the steel plate where the compressive stress in the thickness direction of the joined materials less than p (MPa) acts,

[0025] t: welding time (ms),

[0026] dW / dt: Time change of W (mm / ms).

[0027] (5) Figure 3 As shown, W is the width (hereinafter also referred to as the pressurized width) of the non-melting area (hereinafter also referred to as the pressurized area 7) on the joining surface of the steel plate as the joined material, where the compressive stress σz (hereinafter also referred to as the compressive stress σz) in the thickness direction of the joined material less than p (MPa) acts. Figure 4 The figure shows an example of the relationship between the welding time on the joint surface of the steel plates when resistance spot welding is performed on two overlapping steel plates as the joined material, the pressurized width W, the radius a of the molten area, and the radius b of the pressurized area. It should be noted that the pressurized state and the molten state of the joined material during resistance spot welding are basically axially symmetrical about the electrode center on the joint surface of the steel plates as the joined material. In other words, the pressurized width W is the value obtained by subtracting the radius a of the molten area from the radius b of the pressurized area. Figure 4 As shown in the figure, in the initial stage of power-on when the rate of increase of the radius a of the molten region, that is, the growth rate of the nugget, is fast, the softening of the non-molten region cannot be fully performed. Therefore, the rate of increase of the radius b of the pressurized region is smaller than the rate of increase of the radius a of the molten region. On the other hand, in the later stage of power-on when the rate of increase of the radius a of the molten region, that is, the growth rate of the nugget, is slow, the rate of increase of the radius b of the pressurized region is the same as the rate of increase of the radius a of the molten region.

[0028] (6) Therefore, the pressurized width W, which is equivalent to the value obtained by subtracting the radius a of the molten area from the radius b of the pressurized area, and its time variation, dW / dt, are parameters that appropriately represent the pressurized state of the non-molten area of ​​the joined material, further considering the influence of the increase rate of the molten area (growth rate of the nugget). In addition, by using W and dW / dt at various welding times, it is possible to accurately predict whether spatter occurs in the entire welding process.

[0029] The present invention has been completed through further studies based on the above findings.

[0030] That is, the main configuration of the present invention is as follows.

[0031] 1. A method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding, the method comprising: predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding using two or more overlapping steel plates as joining materials;

[0032] The occurrence of spatter from the joining surfaces of the steel plates is predicted based on the increase rate of the molten region of the joined materials during welding and the temporal change in the pressurized state of the non-molten region of the joined materials.

[0033] 2. A method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding according to item 1 above, wherein W and dW / dt are used as parameters representing the change over time in the rate of increase of the molten area of ​​the joined material and the pressurization state of the non-molten area of ​​the joined material in the welding.

[0034] here,

[0035] W: The width (mm) of the non-melting area on the joint surface of the steel plate where the compressive stress in the thickness direction of the joined materials less than p (MPa) acts,

[0036] t: welding time (ms),

[0037] dW / dt: Time change of W (mm / ms).

[0038] 3. The method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding according to 2 above, wherein the p is in the range of -100 to 0 MPa,

[0039] During the period from the start of welding to the end of welding,

[0040] When at least one of the time point satisfying the following formula (1) and the time point satisfying the following formula (2) exists, splashing is predicted to occur.

[0041] When neither the time satisfying the following equation (1) nor the time satisfying the following equation (2) exists, it is predicted that splashing will not occur.

[0042] ·Time range of dW / dt≤-0.010

[0043] W<a×D 0.3 ···(1)

[0044] ·Time range of dW / dt>-0.010

[0045] W<b×D 0.3 ···(2)

[0046] here,

[0047] D: Thickness of the material being joined (mm)

[0048] a: coefficient a

[0049] b: coefficient b, where a>b.

[0050] 4. The method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding according to item 3 above, wherein the coefficient a is in the range of 0.10 to 0.30, and the coefficient b is in the range of 0.01 to 0.25.

[0051] 5. A resistance spot welding method, comprising performing resistance spot welding under welding conditions determined by the method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding according to any one of 1 to 4 above.

[0052] 6. A method for manufacturing a welded component, comprising performing resistance spot welding under welding conditions determined by the method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding according to any one of 1 to 4 above.

[0053] According to the present invention, it is possible to accurately predict whether spatter will occur in the entire welding process without conducting a preliminary test, so that welding conditions that can achieve high-quality welding can be selected at low cost and efficiently. In addition, the productivity of welded parts manufactured by resistance spot welding of car bodies, etc. is greatly improved, which has a special effect in industry. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0054] Figure 1 This is a diagram schematically showing an example of resistance spot welding.

[0055] Figure 2 This is a diagram showing an example of the relationship between the welding time and the diameter of the molten region of the materials to be joined.

[0056] Figure 3 It is a diagram schematically showing the pressurized width W.

[0057] Figure 4 This is a diagram showing an example of the relationship between the welding time, the pressurized width W, the radius a of the molten region, and the radius b of the pressurized region.

[0058] Figure 5 This is a diagram schematically showing an example of the minimum press width when a set of three overlapping plates is used as the materials to be joined.

[0059] Figure 6 This is a diagram showing an example of the minimum pressurized width when the joining surfaces of the steel plates as the materials to be joined are not axially symmetrical about the center of the electrode.

[0060] Figure 7 FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of the relationship between the welding time t and the pressurized width W. FIG.

[0061] Figure 8 FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of the relationship between the welding time t and the pressurized width W. FIG. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0062] The present invention will be described based on the following embodiments. First, a method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding according to one embodiment of the present invention will be described.

[0063] [1] Spatter prediction method for resistance spot welding

[0064] According to a method for predicting spatter occurrence in resistance spot welding according to one embodiment of the present invention,

[0065] This is a method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding using two or more overlapping steel plates as the joining materials.

[0066] The occurrence of spatter from the joining surfaces of the steel plates is predicted based on the increase rate of the molten region of the joined materials during welding and the temporal change in the pressurized state of the non-molten region of the joined materials.

[0067] As described above, by considering the change in the pressurized state of the non-melting area of ​​the joined materials over time, the influence of the increase rate of the molten area is further considered, thereby making it possible to accurately predict whether spatter (splash from the joining surface of the steel plate) will occur during the entire welding process.

[0068] As described above, as parameters indicating the increase rate of the molten region of the materials to be joined during welding and the temporal change in the pressurized state of the non-molten region of the materials to be joined, for example, W and dW / dt are preferably used.

[0069] here,

[0070] W: The width (mm) of the non-melting area on the joint surface of the steel plate where the compressive stress in the thickness direction of the joined materials less than p (MPa) acts,

[0071] t: welding time (ms),

[0072] dW / dt: Time change of W (mm / ms).

[0073] It should be noted that the welding time may be defined as 0 when welding starts (power is supplied).

[0074] Here, W and dW / dt can be calculated by, for example, modeling the plate group of the joined material as the prediction object, and deriving the compressive stress σz at various positions of the joined material, the range of the melting area and the range of the non-melting area according to each welding time through numerical analysis.

[0075] As an example of numerical analysis, single-point welding analysis using resistance welding simulation software SORPAS (registered trademark) can be cited. As analysis conditions, for example, the grid near the weld is a quadrilateral with a side of 0.01 to 0.5 mm, and the time interval for outputting the pressurization width W is 1 to 100 ms. Other conditions can be in accordance with conventional methods. It should be noted that the setting of welding conditions (type of steel plate as the material to be joined, plate thickness, pressure applied by the electric power, current value and welding time) can be carried out according to the welding conditions that predict whether spatter will occur.

[0076] It should be explained, such as Figure 5 As shown, when there are three or more steel plates as the joined materials, the minimum value of the press width (hereinafter referred to as the minimum press width) can be used as W on the joining surface of each steel plate ( Figure 5 Symbol 1-1 in the figure is steel plate (medium steel plate). In addition, Figure 6 As shown, when the joining surfaces of the steel plates serving as the joined materials are not axially symmetrical about the electrode center, the minimum pressurizing width (the pressurizing width in the direction in which the value obtained by subtracting the distance from the electrode center to the end of the pressurizing area from the distance from the electrode center to the end of the molten area is the smallest) can also be used as W.

[0077] In addition, p is preferably set in the range of -100 to 0 MPa. It should be noted that, with respect to p, + represents tensile stress and - represents compressive stress. That is, since p is an indicator for setting the width of the pressurized area where the electrode bears the compressive stress in the thickness direction of the joined material, the stress less than p must be in the range showing the compressive stress, that is, p needs to be set to less than 0 MPa. On the other hand, if p is less than -100 MPa, the area of ​​the pressurized width becomes extremely small, and the prediction accuracy of whether or not splashing occurs based on the pressurized width sometimes decreases. Therefore, p is preferably set in the range of -100 to 0 MPa. p is more preferably above -70 MPa. In addition, p is more preferably below -10 MPa.

[0078] And, preferably, on the basis of setting p within the above range, for example,

[0079] During the period from the start of welding to the end of welding,

[0080] When at least one of the time point satisfying the following formula (1) and the time point satisfying the following formula (2) exists, splashing is predicted to occur.

[0081] When neither the time point satisfying the following formula (1) nor the time point satisfying the following formula (2) exists, it is predicted that splashing will not occur.

[0082] ·Time range of dW / dt≤-0.010

[0083] W<a×D 0.3 ···(1)

[0084] ·Time range of dW / dt>-0.010

[0085] W<b×D 0.3 ···(2)

[0086] here,

[0087] D: Thickness of the material being joined (mm)

[0088] a: coefficient a

[0089] b: coefficient b.

[0090] It should be noted that when the thickness of the material to be joined is large, the volume of the molten metal increases and the internal pressure increases, so splashing is likely to occur even if the same pressurization width is ensured. Therefore, the above formulas (1) and (2) are further specified by considering the influence of the thickness of the material to be joined.

[0091] The coefficient a and the coefficient b are not particularly limited. For example, it is preferred that the coefficient a is set in the range of 0.10 to 0.30, and the coefficient b is set in the range of 0.01 to 0.25. In addition, in the time range of dW / dt≤-0.010, splashing is likely to occur due to the sharp decrease in the pressurized width. In order to suppress splashing, a wider pressurized width is required. On the other hand, in the time range of dW / dt>-0.010, the change in the pressurized width is small. Therefore, compared with the time range of dW / dt≤-0.010, splashing is less likely to occur, and such a wide pressurized width is not required to suppress splashing. Therefore, a>b is preferred. A>1.3×b is more preferred, and a>2×b is further preferred. It should be noted that the coefficient a and the coefficient b can be appropriately set within the above range according to the numerical analysis conditions used to determine W.

[0092] In addition, as parameters indicating the change in the speed of increase of the molten area of ​​the joined material during welding and the pressurized state of the non-molten area of ​​the joined material over time, in addition to the stress in the thickness direction of the joined material, for example, an index using equivalent stress and maximum principal stress can also be cited. When these indexes are used to predict the occurrence of spatter, the same evaluation can be performed as when the stress in the thickness direction of the joined material is used. For example, when the maximum principal stress is used to judge the occurrence of spatter, when the width of the non-molten area on the joint surface of the steel plate as the joined material, which is the maximum principal stress σmax of the joined material less than p′ (MPa), is set to W′ (mm), the occurrence of spatter can be judged by evaluating dW′ / dt. The calculation method of W′ and dW′ / dt and the judgment method of the occurrence of spatter using W′ and dW′ / dt can be the same as the above-mentioned case of using W and dW / dt as parameters indicating the change in the speed of increase of the molten area of ​​the joined material during welding and the pressurized state of the non-molten area of ​​the joined material over time. For example, W and dW / dt in the above formulas (1) and (2) are replaced by W' and dW' / dt, respectively. Furthermore, when there is at least one of the moment satisfying the replaced formula (1) and the moment satisfying the replaced formula (2), splashing is predicted to occur. On the other hand, when neither the moment satisfying the replaced formula (1) nor the moment satisfying the replaced formula (2) does not exist, splashing is predicted not to occur. It should be noted that the preferred ranges of coefficient a and coefficient b are the same as above. In addition, p' is preferably set in the range of -100 to 0 MPa. p' is more preferably above -70 MPa. In addition, p' is more preferably below -10 MPa.

[0093] It should be noted that the welding conditions for predicting the presence or absence of spatter generation by the method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding according to one embodiment of the present invention are not particularly limited.

[0094] For example, the thickness of the steel plate used as the material to be joined is not limited, and in particular, when a steel plate with a thickness of 0.5 mm to 3.0 mm, which is generally used as an automobile component, is used as the material to be joined, it is preferably applied.

[0095] In addition, the type of steel plate used as the material to be joined is not particularly limited, and it can be applied not only to steel plates without plating on the surface (hereinafter, also referred to as unplated steel plates), but also to steel plates with plating on the surface (hereinafter, also referred to as plated steel plates) as the material to be joined. As plating, for example, Zn-based plating (plating with a Zn content of 50% by mass or more) and Al-based plating (plating with an Al content of 50% by mass or more) can be cited. As Zn-based plating, hot-dip galvanizing (GI), Zn-Ni-based plating, Zn-Al-based plating, etc. can be cited. In addition, as Al-based plating, Al-Si-based plating (for example, Al-Si-based plating containing 10 to 20% by mass of Si) can be exemplified. Hot-dip plating can also be alloyed hot-dip plating after alloying. As alloyed hot-dip plating, for example, alloyed hot-dip galvanizing (GA) can be cited.

[0096] Furthermore, the number of steel plates used as the joined material is not particularly limited, and two or more are sufficient. The steel type and shape of the steel plates may be the same or different. That is, the steel plates may be of the same steel type and the same shape, or of different steel types and shapes. The thickness D of the joined material is also not limited, and in particular, 1.0 to 5.0 mm is preferably applicable.

[0097] In addition, the power-on mode is not particularly limited, and not only the usual single power-on, but also uphill power-on, downhill power-on, multi-stage power-on and other conditions can be used. In addition, it can also be applied to either direct current or alternating current. Furthermore, the pressurization mode is not particularly limited, and it can be applied not only to single-stage pressurization but also to multi-stage pressurization and other conditions.

[0098] In addition, the form of the tip of the electrode is not particularly limited, and for example, the DR type (dome spherical type), R type (spherical shape) and D type (dome type) described in JIS C 9304: 1999 can be applied. In addition, the tip diameter of the electrode is not particularly limited, and for example, it can be preferably applied to the case of 4 mm to 16 mm.

[0099] [2] Resistance spot welding method

[0100] A resistance spot welding method according to one embodiment of the present invention is a method of performing resistance spot welding under welding conditions determined according to the above-mentioned method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding.

[0101] Specifically, based on the prediction results of the spatter generation prediction method of the above-mentioned resistance spot welding, welding conditions (power-on mode, pressurization mode, current value and pressure) that can obtain the desired weld nugget diameter without spattering during the entire welding process are selected, and resistance spot welding is performed according to the welding conditions.

[0102] In addition, the configuration of the welding device that supplies current and controls the current value when energized is not particularly limited, and a conventionally known device can be used.

[0103] [3] Method for manufacturing welded parts

[0104] A method for manufacturing a welded component according to an embodiment of the present invention is a method for manufacturing a welded component by performing resistance spot welding under welding conditions determined according to the above-mentioned method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding. It should be noted that the construction method of resistance spot welding is as described in [2] above. In addition, examples of welded components include automobile components, etc.

[0105] Example

[0106] The various plate groups shown in Table 1 are modeled, and the occurrence of spatter when resistance spot welding is performed under the conditions shown in Table 1 is predicted according to the various prediction conditions shown in Table 2. It should be noted that W and dW / dt are used as parameters representing the increase rate of the molten area of ​​the joined material during welding and the change in the pressurized state of the non-molten area of ​​the joined material over time. In addition, W and dW / dt are calculated by numerical analysis according to the above-mentioned principles. The numerical analysis is performed by two-dimensional axisymmetric analysis of single-spot welding using resistance welding simulation software SORPAS (registered trademark) 2D. The analysis conditions are set to a grid near the weld: a quadrilateral with a side of 0.1 mm, a time interval of 20 ms for output of the pressurized width W, and other conditions are performed according to conventional methods. In addition, regarding the occurrence of spatter, if at least one of the moments satisfying the above formula (1) and the moments satisfying the above formula (2) exists from the start time of welding to the end time of welding, it is predicted that spatter will occur, and if neither the moments satisfying the above formula (1) nor the moments satisfying the above formula (2) exist, it is predicted that spatter will not occur. The prediction results are shown in Table 3.

[0107] For reference, Figure 7 The relationship between the welding time t and the pressurized width W under the welding condition e and the predicted condition A is shown. In this case, in the time range of dW / dt≤-0.010, there is a moment that satisfies the above formula (1), so it is predicted that spatter will occur. In addition, Figure 8 The relationship between the welding time t and the pressurized width W under the welding condition c and the prediction condition A is shown. In this case, in the time range of dW / dt>-0.010, there is a time point satisfying the above formula (2), so it is predicted that spatter will occur.

[0108] For comparison, in the prediction condition F, regardless of dW / dt, there is a period from the welding start time to the welding end time that satisfies W < 0.03 × D 0.3At the time of , splashing is predicted to occur, and there is no situation that satisfies W<0.03×D 0.3 At the moment of time, splashing is predicted not to occur.

[0109] Furthermore, in the prediction condition G, regardless of dW / dt, there exists a period from the welding start time to the welding end time that satisfies W<0.13×D 0.3 At the time of , splashing is predicted to occur, and there is no situation that satisfies W<0.13×D 0.3 At the moment of time, splashing is predicted not to occur.

[0110] In addition, as the prediction condition H, a prediction of the occurrence of spatter using the maximum principal stress is performed. W′ and dW′ / dt are used as parameters that represent the increase rate of the molten area of ​​the joined materials during welding and the change in the pressurized state of the non-molten area of ​​the joined materials over time. Here, W′ is the width (mm) of the non-molten area where the maximum principal stress of the joined materials less than -50 MPa acts on the joining surface of the steel plate. In addition, W′ and dW′ / dt are calculated by numerical analysis in the same manner as the calculation of W and dW / dt described above. For the prediction of spatter occurrence, spatter is predicted to occur when at least one of the moments satisfying the following formula (1)′ and the moments satisfying the following formula (2)′ exists, and spatter is predicted not to occur when neither the moments satisfying the following formula (1)′ nor the moments satisfying the following formula (2)′ exists. The prediction results are collectively noted in Table 3.

[0111] ·Time range of dW′ / dt≤-0.010

[0112] W′<0.32×D 0.3 ···(1)′

[0113] ·Time range of dW′ / dt>-0.010

[0114] W′<0.08×D 0.3 ···(2)′

[0115] In addition, various plate groups shown in Table 1 were prepared to confirm whether spatter occurred when resistance spot welding was actually performed under the conditions shown in Table 1. In the actual welding, a DR-type electrode made of chromium copper with a front end diameter (front end diameter): 6 mm and a curvature radius: 40 mm was used. In addition, the pressure was controlled by driving the upper electrode with a servo motor, and a DC power supply was used when power was turned on. The confirmation results are marked in Tables 1 and 3. It should be noted that no spatter was confirmed under all conditions, and the desired nugget diameter was obtained.

[0116] Then, based on the above prediction results and the confirmation results of whether spatter occurs during actual welding, the prediction hit rate of each prediction condition was calculated, and the prediction accuracy was evaluated according to the following criteria. The evaluation results are recorded in Table 3.

[0117] Qualified (excellent): prediction accuracy is above 90%

[0118] Pass (good): prediction accuracy is 70% or more (except ◎)

[0119] Failure: Prediction hit rate is less than 70%

[0120]

[0121] [Table 2]

[0122]

[0123]

[0124] According to Table 3, the occurrence of splashing can be predicted with high accuracy in all the inventive examples. On the other hand, the occurrence of splashing cannot be predicted with sufficient accuracy in the comparative examples.

[0125] Explanation of symbols

[0126] 1 steel plate (upper steel plate)

[0127] 1-1 Steel Plate (Medium Steel Plate)

[0128] 2 steel plate (lower steel plate)

[0129] 3 electrodes (upper electrode)

[0130] 4 electrodes (lower electrode)

[0131] 5Nugget

[0132] 6 Melting area

[0133] 7 Pressurized Area

Claims

1. A method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding, the method comprising: predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding using two or more overlapping steel plates as joining materials; The presence or absence of spatter from the joining surfaces of the steel plates is predicted based on the increase rate of the molten region of the joined materials during welding and the temporal change in the pressurized state of the non-molten region of the joined materials.

2. The method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding according to claim 1, wherein: As parameters representing the increase rate of the molten region of the materials to be joined and the temporal change in the pressurized state of the non-molten region of the materials to be joined during the welding, W and dW / dt are used. here, W: The width of the non-melting area on the joint surface of the steel plate where the compressive stress in the thickness direction of the joined materials less than p acts. The unit of p is MPa and the unit of width is mm. t: welding time, unit is ms, dW / dt: The time change of W, in mm / ms.

3. The method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding according to claim 2, wherein: The p is in the range of -100 to 0 MPa, During the period from the start of welding to the end of welding, When at least one of the time point satisfying the following formula (1) and the time point satisfying the following formula (2) exists, splashing is predicted to occur. When neither the time point satisfying the following formula (1) nor the time point satisfying the following formula (2) exists, it is predicted that splashing will not occur. ·Time range of dW / dt≤-0.010 W<a×D 0.3 ···(1) ·Time range of dW / dt>-0.010 W<b×D 0.3 ···(2) here, D: The thickness of the material being joined, in mm a: coefficient a b: coefficient b, where a>b.

4. The method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding according to claim 3, wherein: The coefficient a is in the range of 0.10 to 0.30, and the coefficient b is in the range of 0.01 to 0.

25.

5. A resistance spot welding method, comprising performing resistance spot welding under welding conditions determined according to the method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding according to any one of claims 1 to 4. 6 . A method for manufacturing a welded component, comprising performing resistance spot welding under welding conditions determined according to the method for predicting spatter generation in resistance spot welding according to claim 1 .