Method for achieving a reliable soldered connection, and master alloys therefor
Patent Information
- Application Number
- EP2023701050
- Authority / Receiving Office
- EP · EP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2022-01-18
- Filing Date
- 2023-01-17
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-27
AI Technical Summary
Microalloyed soft solders are ineffective for components pre-soldered with standard solder, such as Ball Grid Arrays (BGAs), as they get diluted, failing to enhance the reliability of solder joints under high temperature stress.
A method involving the creation and application of a solder master alloy with increased microalloying elements, which mixes with the pre-soldered standard alloy during soldering to achieve a desired microalloyed target alloy composition, ensuring a reliable solder connection between electronic components and printed circuit boards.
The method results in a solder joint with a composition matching the desired microalloyed target alloy, enhancing mechanical strength and reliability, even for pre-soldered components like BGAs, by ensuring complete or predominant mixing of the standard and applied solders.
Smart Images

Figure IMGF000007_0001
Abstract
Description
[0001] Process for achieving a reliable solder joint and master alloys therefor
[0002] The invention relates to a method for achieving a reliable soldered connection between two electronic components and master alloys based on tin-silver-copper alloys therefor.
[0003] Micro-alloyed soft solders for solder connections between electronic components are known from EP 1 617 968 B l and have proven themselves. These soft solders can significantly improve the reliability of solder connections, particularly under high-temperature stress conditions, e.g., at operating temperatures above 120°C. Soft solders are usually applied in the form of solder pastes for the solder connection of a surface-mounted device (SMD). However, the effect of the microalloys is ineffective for components that are already pre-soldered with a standard solder, such as ball grid arrays (BGA). This is a package type for integrated circuits in which the connections for the SMD assembly are located compactly on the underside of the component.When using such BGAs, the micro-alloyed solder of the solder paste is strongly diluted in the standard solder of the BGAs, so that the micro-alloying elements are not sufficiently effective in forming the solder joint.
[0004] The article "Optimizing Solder Paste Volume for Low-temperature Reflow of BGA Packages" (Keith S. et al., in SMT007 Magazine, Volume 34, July 2019, Number 7, pages 14-16, available at: http: / / iconnect007.uberflip.com / smt007-magazine / smt007-july2019) describes how solder joints can be made more mechanically robust by partially mixing a standard BGA solder with a solder paste during the soldering process. Part of the standard solder remains unmixed after the soldering process, while only another part of the standard solder forms a new alloy with the solder paste. This has advantages for the mechanical strength of the new solder joint. Solder pastes made of an Sn-Bi alloy are recommended. Their component concentration is close to the eutectic region, which has a melting point of approximately 139°C.The document describes methods for calculating the final composition of the solder joint. However, it does not provide for determining a final composition of the target alloy or calculating the composition of a solder master alloy based on the desired target alloy and the volume of solder to be applied to achieve this target alloy. Nor does it provide for completely melting the standard solder of a BGA and achieving a predominantly to complete mixing of the standard solder and the solder paste.
[0005] The object of the present invention is to obtain a reliable micro-alloyed solder joint with a fixed alloy even when using components with pre-soldered connection points (BGA).
[0006] This object is achieved by a method having the features of claim 1. For this purpose, a solder master alloy having the features of claim 6 is used, which has an increased concentration of microalloying elements. The solder master alloy mixes with the pre-soldered standard alloy during soldering, and after soldering, a desired microalloyed target alloy is finally formed in the soldered joint.
[0007] The new process for achieving a reliable solder connection between at least one electronic component with pre-soldered connection points (BGA) and a printed circuit board in surface mounting includes the following steps:
[0008] • Determination of the volume and composition of the pre-soldered connection points of the electronic component as the volume and composition of the standard solder alloy, • Determination of the desired composition of a micro-alloyed target alloy for the solder connection to be achieved between the component and the printed circuit board,
[0009] • Determination of the volume of solder to be applied per intended connection (pad) on the circuit board, if necessary taking into account a proportion of flux,
[0010] • Determining the composition of a solder master alloy for the solder to be applied during surface mounting, namely from the determined or specified compositions of the standard solder alloy and the desired target alloy, taking into account the volume of the standard solder alloy and the volume of solder to be applied,
[0011] • Producing a solder master alloy with the predetermined composition,
[0012] • Production of a solder from the solder alloy and, if necessary, the proportion of flux,
[0013] • Applying the specified volume of solder to the designated connections (pads) of the circuit board,
[0014] • Placing at least one component on the circuit board,
[0015] • Connecting the component to the circuit board by soldering, o where the flux used surrounds the connection point of the electronic component and removes an oxide layer at the pre-soldered connection point of the electronic component and o where the process temperature used melts the standard solder alloy and solder master alloy and a predominant mixing of the standard solder alloy of the pre-soldered connection point of the electronic component and the master alloy of the applied solder takes place before the solder connection between the electronic component and the circuit board is created,
[0016] • Preferably, a soldered connection is created between the electronic component and the circuit board with a composition that corresponds to the desired microalloyed target alloy. Predominant mixing means that the standard solder of the pre-soldered connection point is completely or almost completely melted during the soldering process, as is the pre-alloy of the applied solder, and that both solders are predominantly or completely mixed during the soldering process to form the target alloy.
[0017] To determine the volume of the pre-soldered connection points of the electronic component (BGA), the volume of the solder balls is measured. For example, solder balls with a diameter of 0.6 mm have a volume of 0.113 mm 3Common standard solder alloys for pre-soldered connection points of electronic components (BGAs) are based on tin, silver, and copper. A SnAg3.0Cu0.5 alloy or an SnAg3.0Cu0.7 alloy is preferred, with melting points of approximately 217–221 °C.
[0018] To determine the desired composition of a microalloyed target alloy for the desired solder joint between the component and the circuit board, proven alloys can be used. An example of such a microalloyed target alloy is the Innolot alloy SnAg3.8Cu0.7Bi3.0Sbl.5Ni0.15.
[0019] The determination of the volume of solder to be applied for each intended connection (pad) on the circuit board takes into account a proportion of flux. If the solder is, for example, a solder paste and contains a flux in addition to the solder master alloy, this must be taken into account when determining the volume. With a volume proportion of, for example, 50 vol% flux, then only 50 vol% solder master alloy is contained in the solder that is printed onto the circuit board. For a known solder paste print with a solder paste stencil that has, for example, a thickness of 100 μm and a round opening diameter of 0.6 mm, which corresponds to the printed paste thickness and the printed area, a printed circular area of 0.28 mm 2 with a thickness of 0.1 mm, ie a volume of printed solder paste per connection of 0.028 mm 3, which at a volume fraction of 50 vol% solder pre-alloy, then a volume of 0.014 mm 3 In this example, the ratio of the volume fraction of the solder master alloy in a pad to the volume of the solder ball present on the component is 1:8.
[0020] The master alloy can also be used as a solid preform, e.g., as a stamped part or wire. Such preforms can contain a proportion of flux or consist solely of the solder master alloy. If the preform consists solely of the solder master alloy, flux is added separately during soldering. This can also be a fluid flux, such as a gas with a reducing effect on the oxide layer of a solder. Easily reducible gas mixtures include forming gases.
[0021] To determine the composition of the solder master alloy for the solder to be applied during surface mounting, the determined or specified compositions of the standard solder alloy and the desired target alloy are used, for example, SnAg3.0Cu0.5 alloy for the standard solder alloy of the solder balls and SnAg3.8Cu0.7Bi3.0Sbl.5Ni0.15 for the target alloy of the solder joint. Taking into account the volume of the standard solder alloy and the volume of solder to be applied, the individual alloy proportions for the master alloy are calculated. For example, the solder paste of the master alloy and the solder balls are mixed in a volume ratio of 1:8 for a pad with a diameter of 0.6 mm, a 0.1 mm thick stencil, and a solder ball with a diameter of 0.6 mm. The calculation of the master alloy is based on the following assumptions.To calculate the mixture, the alloy composition, which is given as mass percent, must first be converted into volume percent using the density. From the volume fractions of the target alloy and the standard alloy of the solder ball, the volume fractions of all elements in the master alloy can be calculated as unknowns. These must then be converted back into mass percent. The results of the described method produce values that would be exact if all elements were completely soluble in the solid state and no phase change occurred. In a complex 6-component alloy, however, the densities and proportions of the various possible phases cannot be determined precisely, so that only an estimated average density of the overall alloy can be assumed. In the following calculation formula, VI is the volume of the solder balls and V2 is the volume of the master alloy pads:.
[0022] Taking into account the different densities of the alloying elements (Sn, Ag, Cu, Bi, Sb, Ni), the following alloy composition results for the solder master alloy of the solder paste: Sn49.2Ag9.7Cu2.2Bi25.1Sbl2.5Nil.3
[0023] A solder paste with this composition
[0024] The master alloy (Sn49.2Ag9.7Cu2.2Bi25.1Sb12.5Ni1.3) has a lower melting point than the standard solder due to its high bismuth content. After the soldering process, mixing with the standard solder (SnAg3.0Cu0.5) from the BGA solder ball in a ratio of 1:8 produces the desired target alloy SnAg3.8Cu0.7Bi3.0Sb1.5Ni0.15 with the desired properties for the resulting solder joint.
[0025] For other microalloyed target alloys of the solder joint, different compositions for the solder master alloys result from the calculation method described above. These are, in particular, tin-silver-copper-based solder master alloys, which contain at least one or more of the following additional elements, such as bismuth (Bi), antimony (Sb), and nickel (Ni). The proportions of the additional elements are higher than those of the target alloy. The solder master alloys contain, in particular: - 0 to 10 wt% Ag
[0026] - 0 to 10 wt% Cu
[0027] - 0 to 30 wt% Bi
[0028] - O to 15 wt% Sb
[0029] - 0 to 2 wt% Ni
[0030] - Rest Sn.
[0031] Commercially available soft solder powders can be used to advantageously produce the solder master alloys. These include, in particular: SnSb5, SnSb10, SnBi58, SnCu07, SnNi5, Ni, Ag, and Cu.
[0032] By mixing soft solder powder, for example 50% SnSb5 and 50% SnBi58, a Sn66Bi3 lSb2 master alloy is obtained.
[0033] By mixing soft solder powder of, for example, 30% SnSblO and 40% SnBi58 and 20% SnCuO,7 and 10% SnNi5, a Sn71, lCu0, lBi25,5Sb2,8Ni0, 5 master alloy is obtained.
[0034] By mixing soft solder powder of, for example, 65% SnSblO and 25% SnBi58 and 1% Ni and 7% Ag and 2% Cu, a Sn65,4 Ag9,4Cu2,3Bil5,8Sb6,0Ni 1,1 master alloy is obtained.
[0035] All three of the latter powder compositions result in solder master alloys for micro-alloyed solder joints, whereby the latter Sn65.4Ag9.4Cu2.3Bil5.8Sb6.0NiIl,l master alloy leads approximately to a target alloy SnAg3.8Cu0.7Bi3.0Sbl,5Ni0.15 in the solder joint, which corresponds to the Innolot alloy.
[0036] Before soldering, the solder is applied to the designated pads of the circuit board, e.g., by printing solder paste with a predetermined volume of solder. The use of solid solder preforms is also possible. Subsequently, at least one component with the pre-soldered connection points is placed on the circuit board.
[0037] Then the actual soldering process begins. The pre-soldered connection points of the components, e.g. solder balls, are surrounded by an oxide layer which does not melt at the soldering temperature of approximately 260°C. This oxide layer must be broken down chemically. The flux is used for this purpose; it reduces the oxide layer and thus exposes the standard solder alloy. In order for the applied solder master alloy of the solder to mix with the standard solder alloy of the pre-soldered connection points, it must be ensured that there is sufficient flux to keep the solder balls free of oxides until the initially melted solder master alloy has gradually mixed with the standard solder alloy of the solder ball. If, for example, the solder ball is surrounded by a sufficient amount of flux, the solder master alloy has sufficient time to diffuse into the standard solder alloy.It has been shown that it is advantageous to use 10 times the amount of flux required, for example, to remove the oxide layer from the solder balls. This ensures that no cold solder joints, i.e., unconnected areas, are created. If, for example, a solder paste with a flux is used as the solder, fluxes containing a multimeric resin are preferred. Such a resin remains at the solder joint for a long time and essentially holds the solder master alloy melt to the solder ball, allowing for extensive mixing of the solder ball and the solder master alloy.
[0038] A solder connection is created between the electronic component and the circuit board with a composition that corresponds to the desired microalloyed target alloy.
Claims
Claims Method for achieving a reliable soldered connection between at least one electronic component with pre-soldered terminals (BGA) and a printed circuit board during surface mounting • Determination of the volume and composition of the pre-soldered connection points of the electronic component as volume and composition of the standard solder alloy, • Determining the desired composition of a micro-alloyed target alloy for the solder joint to be achieved between the component and the printed circuit board, • Determining the volume of solder to be applied to each intended connection (pad) on the printed circuit board, possibly taking into account a proportion of flux, • Determining the composition of a brazing alloy for the brazing compound to be applied during surface assembly, namely from the determined or specified compositions of the standard brazing alloy and the desired target alloy, taking into account the volume of the standard brazing alloy and the volume of brazing compound to be applied. • Producing a solder pre-alloy with the predetermined composition, • Production of a soldering compound from the soldering pre-alloy and, if applicable, the proportion of flux, • Applying the specified volume of solder to the designated terminals (pads) of the printed circuit board, • Placing at least one component on the circuit board, • Connecting the component to the printed circuit board by soldering, o wherein the flux used surrounds the connection point of the electronic component and removes an oxide layer at the pre-soldered connection point of the electronic component andwherein the standard solder alloy and solder pre-alloy melt due to the process temperature used, and a predominant mixing of the standard solder alloy of the pre-soldered connection point of the electronic component and the solder pre-alloy of the applied soldering medium occurs before the solder joint between the electronic component and the printed circuit board is formed. Method according to claim 1, characterized in that solder balls of a standard tin-silver-copper-based solder alloy are present on the component, preferably a SnAg3.0Cu0.5 alloy or a SnAg3.0Cu0.7 alloy, the melting points of which are approximately 217–221 °C. Method according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that the soldering medium is a solder paste with a volume fraction of 30 to 70 vol% solder pre-alloy, preferably 50 vol% solder pre-alloy, wherein the solder paste is preferably printed onto the printed circuit board.A method according to claim 3, characterized in that an excess of flux is supplied during soldering, preferably 10 times the amount necessary to break up the oxide layer of the pre-soldered connection points. A method according to any one of claims 1 to 4, characterized in that the solder master alloy is a tin alloy, preferably a tin-silver-copper alloy or tin-copper alloy, which contains as additive elements at least one element selected from bismuth (Bi), antimony (Sb), and nickel (Ni), wherein the alloy proportions are adjusted such that, when soldering with solder balls of a standard solder alloy, a solder joint of a micro-alloyed alloy is obtained. A solder master alloy, in particular for a method according to any one of claims 1 to 5, consisting of SnSblO, SnBi58, Ag, Cu, and Ni, containing approximately... - 9.4 wt% Ag - 2.3 wt% Cu - 15.8 wt% Bi - 6.0 wt% Sb - 1.1 wt% Ni - Residual Sn. Soldering master alloy according to claim 6, comprising at least one further alloying element, namely germanium and / or rare earth elements. Method for producing a soldering master alloy, in particular for use in a method according to any one of claims 1 to 5, • Determining the desired composition of the brazing alloy, • Provision of soft solder powders containing the alloying elements of the desired solder master alloy, • Determining the mass fractions of the selected soft solder powders, • Mixing the specified mass fractions of the selected soft solder powders to form a solder pre-alloy.
