Setting supported devices

By designing and setting the support device, the stability and control performance index values ​​under multiple parameters are calculated and the recommended parameter values ​​are output, which solves the problem that the stability and control performance of the motor control device are difficult to ensure, and the rapid and effective parameter settings are achieved Certainly.

CN112425065BActive Publication Date: 2024-12-03OMRON CORP
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN201980047352.3
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2018-08-21
Filing Date
2019-08-07
Publication Date
2024-12-03
Estimated Expiration
2039-08-07

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The prior art is difficult to ensure the stability and control performance of the motor control device, especially for users who do not have sufficient knowledge of gain adjustment, adjusting parameter values ​​takes time and stability is difficult to ensure.

Method used

A setting support device is designed, including an index value calculation unit, a recommended value calculation unit and a recommended value output unit. By calculating the stability and control performance index values ​​under a combination of multiple parameters, the recommended value of the parameters is output to ensure motor control. Stability and control performance of the device.

Benefits of technology

Even users with insufficient knowledge can effectively set the parameter values ​​of the motor control device, improve the stability and control performance of the motor control device, and reduce adjustment time.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN112425065B_ABST
    Figure CN112425065B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The setting support device includes: an index value calculation unit that calculates a first evaluation index value indicating stability or control performance of motor control performed by the motor control device for each of a plurality of conditions in which the combination of a first parameter value and a second parameter value set for the motor control device is different; a recommended value calculation unit that calculates a recommended value of the first parameter and a recommended value of the second parameter based on the calculated first evaluation index value for each condition; and a recommended value output unit that outputs the calculated recommended value of the first parameter and the recommended value of the second parameter. Thus, even a user who does not have sufficient knowledge about gain adjustment can set the parameter value of the motor control device well.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to a setting support device for supporting the setting of parameter values ​​of a motor control device. Background Art

[0002] Various technologies for supporting parameter value setting for motor control devices are known. For example, Patent Document 1 describes a technology that gradually increases the gain while exploring the gain that satisfies the control performance through trial and error. According to this technology, users with little expertise in gain adjustment can also adjust the gain to satisfy the control performance. However, since only the control performance can be evaluated, the technology described in Patent Document 1 has problems such as not being able to ensure stability and taking time to adjust due to the large number of trial and error. In addition, Patent Document 1 describes a technology that can adjust the gain while achieving a trade-off of various evaluation indicators. According to this technology, the gain can be adjusted in consideration of stability. However, in the technology described in Patent Document 1, the judgment on what values ​​to set various parameter values ​​depends on the user. Therefore, if the user's knowledge about gain adjustment is not sufficient, even if the technology is used, the gain adjustment cannot be performed well.

[0003] Prior art literature

[0004] Patent Literature

[0005] Patent Document 1: Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 2011-244668

[0006] Patent Document 2: Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 2017-167607 Summary of the invention

[0007] Problems to be solved by the invention

[0008] The present invention has been made in view of the above-mentioned problems, and an object of the present invention is to provide a setting support device that allows even a user who does not have sufficient knowledge about gain adjustment to set parameter values ​​for a motor control device that can provide the motor control device with sufficient stability and control performance.

[0009] Technical means of solving problems

[0010] In order to achieve the above-mentioned purpose, a setting support device based on one aspect of the present invention supports setting parameter values ​​for a motor control device that controls a motor, and the setting support device includes: an index value calculation unit, which calculates a first evaluation index value representing the stability or control performance of the motor control performed by the motor control device for each of a plurality of conditions having different combinations of a first parameter value and a second parameter value set for the motor control device; a recommended value calculation unit, which calculates a recommended value of the first parameter and a recommended value of the second parameter based on the first evaluation index value for each condition calculated by the index value calculation unit; and a recommended value output unit, which outputs the recommended value of the first parameter and the recommended value of the second parameter calculated by the recommended value calculation unit.

[0011] That is, the setting support device has a structure for determining (calculating) and outputting the recommended values ​​of the two parameters. Therefore, according to the setting support device, even a user who does not have sufficient knowledge about gain adjustment can set parameter values ​​that can give the motor control device sufficient stability and control performance. In addition, the recommended value output unit of the setting support device can display (output) the recommended value of each parameter on the display, and can also output the recommended value of each parameter as the setting value of each parameter to the motor control device.

[0012] In addition, various methods can be used as a calculation method for the recommended value calculation unit to calculate the two recommended values ​​based on the first evaluation index value for each condition. For example, the recommended value calculation unit may also calculate the first and second parameter values ​​for the condition that obtains the first evaluation index value closest to the expected value as the recommended value of each parameter. Moreover, if there are multiple sets of such first and second parameter values, a set of parameter values ​​as recommended values ​​may be selected from the multiple sets of parameter values ​​based on the first parameter value and / or the second parameter value, or a set of parameter values ​​as recommended values ​​may be selected by other algorithms (e.g., randomly).

[0013] Moreover, in the setting support device, the following structure may also be adopted, namely: "The indicator value calculation unit calculates the first evaluation indicator value and the second evaluation indicator value of the motor control performed by the motor control device, which has a trade-off relationship with the first evaluation indicator value, for each of the multiple conditions, and the recommended value calculation unit calculates the recommended value of the first parameter and the recommended value of the second parameter based on the first evaluation indicator value and the second evaluation indicator value for each condition calculated by the indicator value calculation unit."

[0014] The index value calculation unit may calculate a value representing the stability of the motor control performed by the motor control device as the first evaluation index value. The recommended value calculation unit may also calculate a value that is positively or negatively correlated with the value of the first parameter and the value of the second parameter for each condition as the second evaluation index value for each condition. Furthermore, the index value calculation unit may also calculate a value representing the control performance of the motor control performed by the motor control device as the second evaluation index value.

[0015] The recommended value calculation unit can also determine the condition that meets the required specifications regarding stability and the required specifications regarding control performance and has the lowest achievable performance based on the first evaluation index value and the second evaluation index value of each condition, and calculate the value of the first parameter and the value of the second parameter for the determined condition as the recommended value of the first parameter and the recommended value of the second parameter.

[0016] In the setting support device, the following structure may also be adopted, namely: "The indicator value calculation unit also calculates a third evaluation indicator value for each of the multiple conditions, and the third evaluation indicator value is an evaluation result of the stability of the motor control performed by the motor control device under an evaluation criterion different from the first evaluation indicator value, and the recommended value calculation unit also uses the third evaluation indicator value for each condition calculated by the indicator value calculation unit to calculate the recommended value of the first parameter and the recommended value of the second parameter."

[0017] When the motor control device includes a notch filter or a torque filter, the gain of the servo system including the motor control device at a frequency corresponding to the center frequency of the notch filter or the blocking frequency of the torque filter can also be calculated as the first evaluation index value or the third evaluation index value.

[0018] Moreover, in the case where the motor control device includes a notch filter or a torque filter, a filter parameter recommended value output unit may be added to the setting support device, wherein the filter parameter recommended value output unit is respectively based on a plurality of parameter setting information that specifies the values ​​of one or more parameters that specify the frequency characteristics of the notch filter or the torque filter, and for each of the plurality of parameter setting information, the first evaluation index value is calculated for each of the plurality of conditions when the value specified by the parameter setting information is set as the value of the one or more parameters of the notch filter or the torque filter, and based on the calculated first evaluation index value for each condition, it is determined whether each condition meets the required specifications for stability, and the values ​​of the one or more parameters specified by the parameter setting information for the condition that is determined to meet the required specifications for stability is the widest range is output as recommended values ​​of the one or more parameters of the notch filter or the torque filter.

[0019] The setting support device may further include a user interface unit configured to change the plurality of parameter setting information to be processed by the filter parameter recommendation value output unit in accordance with an instruction from a user.

[0020] When the motor control device includes a notch filter, a recommended value determination unit may be added to the setting support device, which determines recommended values ​​of one or more parameters that specify the frequency characteristics of the notch filter based on the measurement results of the gain characteristics of the motor control performed by the motor control device.

[0021] The index value calculation unit may also obtain a frequency transfer function including a predetermined portion of the motor based on a measurement result of a gain characteristic of the motor control performed by the motor control device, and calculate the first evaluation index value for each of the plurality of conditions using the obtained frequency transfer function. Furthermore, the index value calculation unit may also calculate the second evaluation index value for each of the plurality of conditions using the frequency transfer function.

[0022] The index value calculation unit may calculate the second evaluation index value for each of the plurality of conditions based on the frequency transfer function without performing an integral operation such as a convolution operation. Furthermore, the index value calculation unit may have a function of determining the value of at least one parameter other than the first parameter and the second parameter in each condition based on the value of the first parameter or the second parameter.

[0023] A setting support device based on one aspect of the present invention supports parameter value setting for multiple motor control devices used to synchronously control motors with more than two axes, and the setting support device includes: a first evaluation index value calculation unit, which calculates, for each motor control device that is an object of parameter value setting support, a first evaluation index value representing the stability of motor control performed by the motor control device for each of a plurality of conditions in which different combinations of a first parameter value and a second parameter value set for the motor control device are present; a determination unit, which determines a worst value of the first evaluation index value calculated by the first evaluation index value calculation unit according to the condition; and a recommended value output unit, which determines and outputs a recommended value of the first parameter and a recommended value of the second parameter based on the worst value for each condition determined by the determination unit.

[0024] According to the setting support device (hereinafter also referred to as the second setting support device), even a user who does not have sufficient knowledge related to gain adjustment can set parameter values ​​that can provide sufficient stability and control performance to each motor control device for multiple motor control devices used to synchronously control motors with more than two axes.

[0025] The method of calculating the two recommended values ​​according to the worst value for each condition by the recommended value calculation component as the second setting support device can adopt various methods. For example, the recommended value calculation component can also calculate the first and second parameter values ​​of the condition that obtains the worst value closest to the expected value as the recommended values ​​of each parameter. Moreover, if there are multiple sets of such first and second parameter values, a set of parameter values ​​as recommended values ​​can be selected from the multiple sets of parameter values ​​based on the first parameter value and / or the second parameter value, or a set of parameter values ​​as recommended values ​​can be selected by other algorithms (for example, randomly).

[0026] Moreover, in the second setting support device, the following structure can also be adopted, namely: "The recommended value calculation component determines whether each condition meets the required specifications regarding stability based on the determination result according to the worst value of the condition, and for each of the conditions determined to meet the required specifications, calculates a second evaluation index value regarding the motor control performed by the motor control device that has a trade-off relationship with the first evaluation index value, and calculates the recommended value of the first parameter and the recommended value of the second parameter based on the calculated second evaluation index value for each condition."

[0027] Effects of the Invention

[0028] According to the present invention, it is possible to provide a setting support device that allows even a user who does not have sufficient knowledge about gain adjustment to set parameter values ​​for a motor control device that can provide the motor control device with sufficient stability and control performance. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0029] Figure 1 It is an explanatory diagram of an example of usage of the setting support device 10 according to one embodiment of the present invention.

[0030] Figure 2 This is a block diagram for explaining parameters of the motor control device.

[0031] Figure 3 2 is a functional block diagram of the setting support device 10 .

[0032] Figure 4 This is a diagram to explain the closed-loop gain peak amount and resonance peak margin.

[0033] Figure 5 This is an illustration of the stability map.

[0034] Figure 6 This is an illustration of the stability map.

[0035] Figure 7 Flowchart of stability index value calculation process.

[0036] Figure 8 It is an explanatory diagram of the position closed-loop characteristic Gp_closed, the position open-loop characteristic Gp_open, the speed closed-loop characteristic Gv_closed, and the speed open-loop characteristic Gv_open.

[0037] Fig. 9 4 is a flowchart of the second notch filter parameter calculation process.

[0038] Fig.10 This is a diagram for explaining the items for setting the optimization level.

[0039] Fig.11 It is an explanatory diagram of the effect of the second notch filter parameter calculation process.

[0040] Fig.12 It is an explanatory diagram of the effect of the second notch filter parameter calculation process.

[0041] Fig.13 4 is a flowchart of the third notch filter parameter calculation process.

[0042] Fig.14 It is a diagram for explaining the content of the third notch filter parameter calculation process.

[0043] Fig.15 This is a diagram to explain an example of a system that operates multiple axes in coordination.

[0044] Fig.16 is Fig.15 Illustration of possible phenomena that may occur in the system shown.

[0045] Fig.17 This is a diagram for explaining the contents of the parameter value setting support process for multiple axes.

[0046] Explanation of symbols

[0047] 10: Set supported devices

[0048] 11: Input device

[0049] 12: Display device

[0050] 13: Main body

[0051] 14: Calculation processing unit

[0052] 15: UI Department

[0053] 16: Display control unit

[0054] 30: Motor control device

[0055] 31: Position controller

[0056] 32: Speed ​​controller

[0057] 34: Current controller

[0058] 35: Position detector

[0059] 40: Control Object

[0060] 41: Motor

[0061] 42: Load device DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0062] Hereinafter, embodiments of the present invention will be described based on the drawings.

[0063] Figure 1 2 shows an example of usage of the setting support device 10 according to one embodiment of the present invention.

[0064] The setting support device 10 of this embodiment is to support the parameter value setting of the motor control device 30, and is connected to one or more ( Figure 1 ) A device connected to a motor control device 30 for use.

[0065] The motor control device 30 is a device that controls a motor 41 connected to a load device 42 according to a command (position command, torque command, or speed command) input from a host device (not shown) such as a programmable logic controller (PLC). Hereinafter, the portion including the motor 41 and the load device 42 is referred to as a control object 40, and the portion including the motor control device 30 and the control object 40 is referred to as a servo system.

[0066] When the motor control device 30 receives a position command from the host device, Figure 2 As shown, it operates as a position controller 31, a speed controller 32, a current controller 34, a position detector 35, etc.

[0067] The position detector 35 is a unit that outputs the position of the controlled object 40 (hereinafter referred to as the detected position) by integrating the speed of the controlled object 40 (hereinafter referred to as the detected speed) detected by an encoder (not shown) attached to the motor 41 or the load device 42 .

[0068] The position controller 31 is a unit having a position proportional gain Kpp as a parameter. As shown in the figure, the position controller 31 receives a position deviation, which is a deviation between a position command and a detected position. The position controller 31 calculates and outputs a value obtained by multiplying the position deviation by the position proportional gain Kpp, which is a speed command.

[0069] The speed controller 32 is a unit that performs proportional integral (PI) control using the speed deviation, which is the deviation between the speed command and the detected speed, as an operation variable and the torque command as a control variable. The speed controller 32 has a speed proportional gain Kvp and an integral gain Ki as parameters.

[0070] Furthermore, the speed controller 32 includes a torque filter (low pass filter) and a notch filter that can be set to enable / disable (ON / OFF) (whether to function). The torque filter in the speed controller 32 has a cutoff frequency as a parameter, and the notch filter in the speed controller 32 has a center frequency, a notch depth, and a Q value (= center frequency / notch width) as parameters.

[0071] The current controller 34 is a unit that generates a driving current according to a torque command from the speed controller 32 and supplies the driving current to the motor.

[0072] Based on the above contents, the structure and operation of the setting support device 10 will be described in detail below.

[0073] Figure 3A functional block diagram of the setting support device 10 is shown.

[0074] The configuration support device 10 of this embodiment is a device in which a configuration support program is installed in a personal computer (PC). Figure 3 As shown, the setting support program installed in the PC enables the main body of the PC (including the central processing unit (CPU) and its peripheral components) 13 to operate as a calculation processing unit 14, a user interface (UI) unit 15 and a display control unit 16.

[0075] The display control unit 16 is a functional block that displays an image of the content instructed by the calculation processing unit 14 or the UI unit 15 on the screen of the display device 12 .

[0076] The calculation processing unit 14 is a functional block that can execute notch filter parameter calculation processing, recommended value calculation processing, display / setting processing, setting / display processing, and the like.

[0077] The notch filter parameter calculation process is a process of calculating recommended values ​​of parameters of the notch filter in the speed controller 32 and setting the recommended values ​​in the motor control device 30. The notch filter parameter calculation process includes first to third notch filter parameter calculation processes.

[0078] The recommended value calculation process is a process including a stability index value calculation process and a control performance index value / recommended value calculation process.

[0079] The stability index value calculation process is a process for calculating a stability index value indicating the stability of the motor control performed by the motor control device for each of a plurality of situations in which the combination of the first parameter value and the second parameter value set for the motor control device 30 is different. The stability index value calculation process is a process in which a user can specify which parameter is to be set as the first and second parameters, and is a process in which one or more values ​​of the gain margin, phase margin, closed-loop gain peak amount, and resonance peak margin can be specified as the stability index value to be calculated. In addition, the closed-loop gain peak amount and resonance peak margin, such as Figure 4 As schematically shown, they refer to the peak on the low-frequency side in the gain characteristics and the gain margin at the resonance frequency, respectively.

[0080] Furthermore, the stability index value calculation process is a process that can specify whether the values ​​of each parameter other than the first and second parameters are set to a fixed value (a value specified by the user) or to a value corresponding to the first or second parameter value. Furthermore, the stability index value calculation process is a process that can also specify whether the values ​​of one of the first and second parameters are set to a fixed value (a value specified by the user).

[0081] The control performance index value / recommended value calculation process is a process of calculating a control performance index value indicating the control performance of the motor control performed by the motor control device 30 for at least each situation in which the stability index value calculated by the stability index value calculation process satisfies the stability requirement specification, and calculating the values ​​of the first and second parameters satisfying the stability requirement specification and the control performance requirement specification as recommended values ​​of each parameter based on the calculation result. The control performance index value / recommended value calculation process is a process in which one or more values ​​of the track following delay time, the steady-state deviation, the settling time, the track following performance substitute characteristic value, the steady-state deviation substitute characteristic value, the settling time substitute characteristic value, and the ramp response followability substitute characteristic value are specified as the control performance index value to be calculated.

[0082] Here, the so-called stability requirement specification refers to information that specifies the conditions that should be judged as satisfying the stability requirement by using the values ​​of one or more stability index values ​​set as the calculation object (for example, "the closed-loop gain peak amount is less than 1dB", "the closed-loop gain peak amount is less than 1dB and the resonance peak margin (gain margin at the resonance frequency) is more than 5dB"). Moreover, the so-called control performance requirement specification refers to information that specifies the conditions that should be judged as satisfying the control performance requirement by using the values ​​of the control performance index values. The control performance requirement specification is information set for each control performance index value (according to the control performance index value), and in the control performance index value / recommended value calculation process, the recommended value is calculated for each control performance requirement specification.

[0083] The display / setting process is a process of displaying each recommended value calculated by the control performance index value / recommended value calculation process together with the stability index value of each condition as a processing result on the screen of the display device 12, and setting each calculated recommended value to the motor control device 30 when the user performs a confirmation operation. The setting / display process is a process of setting each recommended value calculated by the control performance index value / recommended value calculation process to the motor control device 30, and then displaying each recommended value together with the stability index value of each condition as a processing result on the screen of the display device 12.

[0084] Figure 5An example of an image (hereinafter referred to as a stability map) displayed on the screen of the display device 12 as a result of the display / setting process or the setting / display process is shown. As shown in the figure, the stability map is basically a graph showing a graph (☆) indicating recommended values ​​on a contour graph indicating stability index values ​​in colors for each combination of the value of the first parameter (in the figure, the velocity proportional gain Kvp) and the value of the second parameter (in the figure, the integral gain Ki). In addition, the ○ displayed in the stability map is a graph indicating the setting values ​​of the first and second parameters when measuring the position closed loop characteristic Gp_closed described later.

[0085] However, when the user specifies multiple control performance requirement specifications, an image showing recommended values ​​according to the control performance requirement specifications is displayed on the contour map as a stability map. Furthermore, when the user specifies the display of contour lines related to a certain control performance index value, Figure 6 As shown, the control performance evaluation value is displayed in color by connecting the points with the same control performance evaluation value on the contour map.

[0086] UI section 15( Figure 3 ) is a functional block that allows the processing unit 14 to execute the processing specified by the user by operating the input device 11 such as a mouse or keyboard to specify the content of the processing to be executed by the processing unit 14.

[0087] The UI unit 15 is configured so that a user can cause the calculation processing unit 14 to execute a series of processes exemplified below.

[0088] ·Processing Example 1

[0089] Execute a notch filter parameter calculation process (any of the first to third notch filter parameter calculation processes),

[0090] The first parameter and the second parameter are set to Kvp and Ki respectively, the stability index value is set to the closed-loop gain peak value, and the stability index value is set to the recommended value calculation processing of the alternative characteristic value of the steady-state deviation.

[0091] The setting / display processing (or the display / setting processing) is executed.

[0092] ·Processing Example 2

[0093] Perform notch filter parameter calculation processing,

[0094] The first parameter and the second parameter are set to Kvp and Ki respectively, the stability index value is set to the closed-loop gain peak value, and the stability index value is set to the recommended value calculation processing of the alternative characteristic value of the steady-state deviation.

[0095] executing a recommended value calculation process in which the first parameter and the second parameter are set to Kpp and Ki respectively and Ki is fixed to the recommended value obtained by the completed recommended value calculation process,

[0096] The setting / display processing (or the display / setting processing) is executed.

[0097] ·Processing Example 3

[0098] Perform notch filter parameter calculation processing,

[0099] The first parameter and the second parameter are set to Kvp and Kpp respectively, Ki is set to Kvp·4, the stability index value is set to the closed-loop gain peak value, and the stability index value is set to the recommended value calculation processing of the alternative characteristic value of the steady-state deviation.

[0100] The setting / display processing (or the display / setting processing) is executed.

[0101] The following further describes in detail various processes that can be performed by the operation processing unit 14. In addition, when the present setting support device 10 is used, the notch filter parameter calculation process is usually performed first, but for the sake of convenience, the notch filter parameter calculation process will be described below after the description of the recommended value calculation process (stability index value calculation process and control performance index value calculation process).

[0102] 《Calculation and processing of stability index values》

[0103] Figure 7 The flowchart of the stability index value calculation process is shown. In this flowchart and the following description, the position closed-loop characteristic Gp_closed, the position open-loop characteristic Gp_open, the speed closed-loop characteristic Gv_closed, and the speed open-loop characteristic Gv_open refer to the servo system, respectively. Figure 8 The frequency transfer function of the portion shown in the dashed boxes 51 to 54.

[0104] like Figure 7 As shown, in the stability index value calculation process, the operation processing unit 14 first performs a process of measuring the position closed-loop characteristic Gp_closed (plural arrangement) by controlling the motor control device 30 (step S101). The process of this step can be "while inputting a position command that changes with time in a manner including a plurality of frequency components to the motor control device 30, periodically collecting the detection positions, performing Fourier transform on the input position command and the collected detection positions, and taking a ratio, thereby calculating the position closed-loop characteristic Gp_closed", or "relying on the motor control device 30 to measure the position closed-loop characteristic Gp_closed, and obtaining the measurement result from the motor control device 30".

[0105] The calculation processing unit 14 that has completed the processing of step S101 calculates the controlled object characteristic P (frequency transfer function P of the controlled object 40 ) based on the measured position closed loop characteristic Gp_closed and various parameter values ​​set to each part of the motor control device 30 at that time (step S102 ).

[0106] More specifically, in the step S102, the operation processing unit 14 first determines the characteristic Cp (frequency transfer function, the same below) of the position controller 31 and the characteristic Cv of the speed controller 32 based on the set values ​​of various parameters (Kpp, Kvp, Ki, filter parameters) at this time point (the measurement time point of Gv_closed).

[0107] Next, the calculation processing unit 14 sequentially performs the following calculations based on the determined characteristics Cp, Cv, etc., thereby calculating the controlled object characteristic P. In the following equation (2), Ci is the characteristic (frequency transfer function) of the position detector 35 .

[0108] Gp_open=Gp_closed / (1-Gp_closed)…(1)

[0109] Gv_closed=Gp_open / (Cp·Ci)…(2)

[0110] Gv_open=Gv_closed / (1-Gv_closed)…(3)

[0111] P = Gv_open / Cv...(4)

[0112] That is, the calculation processing unit 14 first obtains the position open-loop characteristic Gp_open based on the position closed-loop characteristic Gp_closed (Formula (1)). Next, the calculation processing unit 14 removes the characteristics Cp and Ci from the position open-loop characteristic Gp_open, thereby obtaining the speed closed-loop characteristic Gv_closed (Formula (2)). Furthermore, the calculation processing unit 14 obtains the speed open-loop characteristic Gv_oepn based on the speed closed-loop characteristic Gv_closed (Formula (3)). Next, the calculation processing unit 14 removes Cv from the speed open-loop characteristic Gv_open, thereby calculating the control object characteristic P (Formula (4)).

[0113] The operation processing unit 14 that has completed the processing of step S102 starts the processing loop of steps S103 to S106. First, the processing object status is stored as the first evaluation object status among multiple evaluation object statuses (step S103). Here, the so-called multiple evaluation object statuses refer to situations in which the combinations of values ​​of two parameters (Ki and Kvp, Kpp and Kvp, etc.) specified by the user as setting object parameters are different from each other. In addition, the number of evaluation object statuses and the specific content of each evaluation object status are automatically determined by the operation processing unit 14 based on the combination of two setting object parameters. At this time, the operation processing unit 14 sets the parameter values ​​other than the setting object parameters for each evaluation object status to fixed values ​​(values ​​specified by the user) or values ​​calculated based on the first or second parameters according to the user's designation.

[0114] After completing the processing of step S103, the calculation processing unit 14 determines the characteristics of each component under the processing target condition (characteristic Cp of the position controller 31 and characteristic Cv of the speed controller 32) (step S104). Then, the calculation processing unit 14 calculates Gp_closed under the processing target condition based on the determined characteristics of each component and the control target characteristic P (step S104). The processing of step 104 is a processing to calculate Gp_closed by performing the following operations in sequence (refer to Figure 8 ).

[0115] Gv_open=Cv·P

[0116] Gv_closed=(Gv_open) / (1+Gv_open)

[0117] Gp_open=Cp·Ci·Gv_closed

[0118] Gp_closed=Gp_open / (1+Gp_open)

[0119] The arithmetic processing unit that has completed the calculation of Gp_closed in the processing target state calculates and stores the number and type of stability index values ​​specified by the user (for example, only the gain margin, or the closed-loop gain peak amount and the resonance peak margin) using Gp_closed (step S105).

[0120] After completing the process of step S105, the calculation processing unit 14 determines whether an unprocessed evaluation target state remains (step S106). If an unprocessed evaluation target state remains (step S106; Yes), the calculation processing unit 14 returns to step S103 and executes the process for the next evaluation target state.

[0121] Then, when the processing for all the evaluation target conditions is completed (step S106 ; No), the calculation processing unit 14 ends the stability index value calculation processing.

[0122] 《Control performance index value / recommended value calculation and processing》

[0123] The control performance index value / recommended value calculation process is a process as described below, that is, based on the stability index value calculation process ( Figure 7 ), the stability requirement specification and one or more control performance requirement specifications, and for each control performance requirement specification, two setting object parameter values ​​that meet the stability requirement specification and the control performance requirement specification and have the worst control performance are calculated as recommended values ​​of the two setting object parameters. In addition, instead of calculating the two setting object parameter values ​​with the best control performance, the two setting object parameter values ​​with the worst control performance are calculated as the recommended values ​​of the two setting object parameters because: if stability is ensured, even if the stability is deteriorated due to changes in the control object 40 over time, the state of satisfying the stability requirement specification can be maintained.

[0124] As described, the setting support device 10 is configured as a device that is capable of specifying one or more values ​​of track following delay time, steady-state deviation, stabilization time, alternative characteristic value of track following performance, alternative characteristic value of steady-state deviation, alternative characteristic value of stabilization time, and alternative characteristic value of slope response tracking as control performance indicator values ​​for determining control performance.

[0125] In the control performance index value / recommended value calculation process, the operation processing unit 14 performs convolution operation based on Gv_close in each evaluation object condition obtained in the stability index value calculation process, thereby calculating the track following delay time, steady-state deviation, and stabilization time in each evaluation object condition. In addition, the operation processing unit 14 calculates two setting object parameter values ​​with the worst control performance that meet the stability requirement specification and the control performance requirement specification based on the control performance index value (track following delay time, etc.) calculated for each evaluation object condition and the stability index value for each evaluation object condition calculated by the stability index value calculation process, as the recommended values ​​of the two setting object parameters.

[0126] Furthermore, during the recommended value calculation process, the calculation processing unit 14 calculates other control performance index values ​​without performing a convolution operation.

[0127] Specifically, the calculation processing unit 14 calculates the following L value as a substitute characteristic value of the track following performance.

[0128] L = SQR (the first parameter value 2 +α·Second parameter value 2 )

[0129] In addition, α is a value (>0) predetermined according to a combination of the first parameter and the second parameter.

[0130] Furthermore, the calculation processing unit 14 calculates the first permutation value (permutation value on the lowest frequency side) Gv_closed[1] and the k-th permutation value Gv_closed[k] of Gv_closed under each evaluation object condition obtained during the stability index value calculation process as a substitute characteristic value of the steady-state deviation and a substitute characteristic value of the stabilization time, respectively. In addition, the so-called Gv_closed[k] refers to the frequency component of Gv_closed that is equivalent to the inverse of the following time, which is the time specified by the user as the evaluation time of the substitute characteristic value of the stabilization time.

[0131] Furthermore, the calculation processing unit 14 calculates a value obtained by further multiplying Gv_closed in each evaluation target situation by 1 / (jω) (ω is a designated frequency) as a substitute characteristic value of the ramp response followability.

[0132] In addition, the operation processing unit 14 calculates two setting object parameter values ​​with the worst control performance that meet the stability requirement specifications and the control performance requirement specifications based on the control performance index value (alternative characteristic value) calculated for each evaluation object condition and the stability index value for each evaluation object condition calculated through the stability index value calculation processing, as recommended values ​​of the two setting object parameters.

[0133] Here, several matters are supplemented in advance regarding each of the above-mentioned alternative characteristic values.

[0134] In the stable region of the Bode diagram where no gain peak appears, there is a roughly positive correlation between the track following performance and each gain value (Kpp value, Kvp value, Ki value). Therefore, the L value can be used as a substitute characteristic value of the track following performance. In addition, there is a roughly positive correlation between the steady-state deviation and Gv_closed[1], between the stabilization time and Gv_closed[k], and between the slope response tracking and Gv_closed / (jω). Therefore, the steady-state deviation, the stabilization time slope, and the substitute characteristic values ​​of the response tracking can also be used as index values ​​of the control performance.

[0135] Furthermore, the above-mentioned alternative characteristic values ​​are obtained by simple calculations, and thus can be calculated in a shorter time than the track following delay time etc. which requires convolution calculations. Therefore, as long as the above-mentioned alternative characteristic values ​​are designated for the determination of control performance, the recommended values ​​of the various setting object parameters can be obtained in a very short time.

[0136] 《Notch filter parameter calculation and processing》

[0137] As described above, the notch filter parameter calculation process includes first to third notch filter parameter calculation processes. The contents of the first to third notch filter parameter calculation processes will be described in order below.

[0138] · First notch filter parameter calculation process

[0139] The arithmetic processing unit 14 , to which the execution of the first notch filter parameter calculation process is instructed, calculates recommended values ​​of the parameters of the notch filter in the speed controller 32 and sets the recommended values ​​in the motor control device 30 according to the following flow.

[0140] The operation processing unit 14 that has started the first notch filter parameter calculation process first sets the notch filter to off. Next, the operation processing unit 14 measures the position closed-loop characteristic Gp_closed by controlling the motor control device 30. Here, the so-called position closed-loop characteristic Gp_closed refers to the frequency transfer function (complex arrangement) of the servo system. The measurement process of Gp_closed can be "while inputting a position instruction that changes with time in a manner that includes multiple frequency components into the motor control device 30, while periodically collecting the detection position, performing Fourier transform on the input position instruction and the collected detection position to obtain a ratio, thereby calculating the position closed-loop characteristic Gp_closed" or "relying on the motor control device 30 to measure the position closed-loop characteristic Gp_closed, and obtaining the measurement result from the motor control device 30".

[0141] In addition, the calculation processing unit 14 determines the recommended values ​​of the parameters of the notch filter (center frequency ωn, notch depth d, notch width Δω) in a manner that suppresses the resonance peak in the measured Gp_closed, and sets the determined recommended values ​​to the motor control device 30, thereby completing the first notch filter parameter calculation processing.

[0142] Second notch filter parameter calculation process

[0143] Fig. 9 A flowchart showing the second notch filter parameter calculation process.

[0144] As shown in the figure, the calculation processing unit 14 that starts the second notch filter parameter calculation process first measures the position closed loop characteristic Gp_closed by controlling the motor control device 30 (step S201). The measurement process and the stability index value calculation process ( Figure 7) is the same as the processing of step S101. Furthermore, in step S201, the arithmetic processing unit 14 further performs the following processing, that is, determining the frequency of the resonance peak as the recommended value of the center frequency of the notch filter based on the position closed loop characteristic Gp_closed.

[0145] Next, the calculation processing unit 14 performs, in step S202 , processing similar to that in step S102 of the stability index value calculation process.

[0146] Subsequently, the calculation processing unit 14 stores the fact that the combination of the depth d and the Q value of the notch filter evaluated by the processing cycle of steps S204 to S207 executed this time is the first evaluation object value pair among the plurality of evaluation object value pairs (step S203). Here, the plurality of evaluation object value pairs refers to information that specifies the total number or the content of each evaluation object value pair according to the optimization level of the notch filter specified by the user. More specifically, the UI unit 15 of the present embodiment causes the display control unit 16 to display on the screen of the display device 12 Fig.10 Then, for example, when the highest level is designated as the optimization level, the UI unit 15 notifies the calculation processing unit 14 that a total of 25 pairs of depth d and Q value, including a value of [0, 5, 10, 15, 20] and a value of [0.8, 1.0, 1.2, 1.4, 1.6], are "a plurality of evaluation target value pairs".

[0147] Step S203 ( Fig. 9 ) starts the processing loop of steps S204 to S207. The processing loop is similar to the stability index value calculation processing ( Figure 7 ) has the same processing loop of steps S103 to S107.

[0148] If there are no unprocessed evaluation target conditions (step S207; No), the calculation processing unit 14 exits the processing loop of steps S204 to S207. If there are unprocessed evaluation target value pairs remaining (step S208; Yes), the calculation processing unit 14 returns to step S203 to process the next evaluation target value pair.

[0149] When there are no unprocessed evaluation target value pairs (step S208; No), the calculation processing unit 14 determines the evaluation target value pair with the widest range that can ensure stability based on the processing results of each evaluation target value pair (step S209). As this processing, for example, when a contour map is displayed, a process is performed to determine the evaluation target value pair with the widest range of stability index values ​​that meet the prescribed conditions.

[0150] Then, the arithmetic processing unit 14 sets the determined evaluation target value pair together with the center frequency determined in step S201 in the motor control device 30 (step S209 ), and then ends the second notch filter parameter calculation process.

[0151] According to the second notch filter parameter calculation process, for example like Fig.11 (A) Fig.11 As shown in (B), the stable region of the servo system can be expanded. Fig.11 (A) is the stability map of the servo system when the notch filter is turned off (the depth of the notch filter is "0"). Fig.11 (B) is a stability map of the servo system after the second notch filter parameter calculation process is completed.

[0152] Furthermore, after the second notch filter parameter calculation process, the recommended value calculation process of the content is performed. Therefore, according to the setting support device 10 of this embodiment, as shown in FIG. Fig.12 (A) Fig.12 As shown in (B), the control band can be improved.

[0153] ·Third notch filter parameter calculation process

[0154] Fig.13 A flowchart showing the third notch filter parameter calculation process.

[0155] The third notch filter parameter calculation process is a process in which the second notch filter parameter calculation process is modified so that the recommended value of each parameter of the notch filter can be calculated at a higher speed.

[0156] As shown in the figure, the arithmetic processing unit 14 that has started the third notch filter parameter calculation process first performs the third notch filter parameter calculation process ( Fig. 9 ) performs the same processing as steps S201 and S202.

[0157] Next, the calculation processing unit 14 stores the case where the combination of the depth d and Q value of the notch filter evaluated by the processing cycle of steps S304 to S307 executed this time is the first evaluation object value pair among the multiple evaluation object value pairs (step S303). In addition, in the step S303, the calculation processing unit 14 also stores the case where the Kvp value evaluated by the processing cycle of steps S304 to S307 executed this time is the initial value of Kvp (for example, 1 [Hz]).

[0158] After completing the processing of step S303, the operation processing unit 14 starts the processing loop of steps S304 to S307. First, Ki=Kvp / 4 is set to calculate the stability index value (step S304). More specifically, the operation processing unit 14 assumes that the motor control device 30 is in a state where the center frequency of the notch filter is the frequency determined in step S301, the combination of the depth d and Q value of the notch filter is the current evaluation object pair, the Kvp value is the value set in step S303 or S306, and the Ki value is 1 / 4 of the Kvp value, and uses the control object characteristic P to obtain the position closed loop characteristic Gp_closed under the above condition. Then, the operation processing unit 14 calculates the stability index value based on the obtained Gp_closed.

[0159] After completing the process of step S304 , the calculation processing unit 14 determines whether the calculated stability index value satisfies the stability requirement specification (step S305 ).

[0160] If the calculated stability index value meets the stability requirement specification (step S305; yes), the calculation processing unit 14 stores the current Kvp value as the maximum Kvp value for the current evaluation object value pair (step S306). In addition, this process is a process of rewriting the existing maximum Kvp value. Next, the calculation processing unit 14 performs a process of increasing the Kvp value by a predetermined amount (step S307), and then starts the process after step S304 again.

[0161] Furthermore, if the calculated stability index value does not satisfy the stability requirement specification (step S305; No), the calculation processing unit 14 determines whether there is an unprocessed evaluation object value pair remaining (step S308). Next, if there is an unprocessed evaluation object value pair remaining (step S308; Yes), the calculation processing unit 14 returns to step S303 and starts processing the next evaluation object value pair.

[0162] If there are no unprocessed evaluation object value pairs (step S308; No), the calculation processing unit 14 determines the evaluation object value pair with the largest maximum Kvp value based on the maximum Kvp value for each evaluation object value pair (step S309). Fig.14In the case shown in FIG. 1 , the operation processing unit 14 determines the evaluation object value pair (notch depth "10", Q value "1.6") with a maximum Kvp value of "107". Next, the operation processing unit 14 sets the determined evaluation object value pair together with the center frequency determined in step S301 to the motor control device 30 (step S309), and then ends the third notch filter parameter calculation process.

[0163] The setting support device 10 (the calculation processing unit 14 ) is configured to be able to perform a multi-axis parameter value setting support process in addition to the various processes described above.

[0164] The multi-axis parameter value setting support process is a process for supporting parameter value setting for the dual motor control device 30. Fig.15 The X1 axis and X2 axis of the system that coordinates the operation of multiple axes (X1 axis and X2 axis) like a gantry of the structure shown are controlled.

[0165] Fig.15 In the system shown, if the frequency characteristics of each axis are different, undesirable behaviors such as yaw may occur. Therefore, the same value is often set as the gain of each axis, but the frequency characteristics of each axis will change according to the mechanical structure, gantry position, load position, etc. For example, when the load is biased toward the X2 axis, the speed closed loop frequency characteristics related to the X1 axis and the speed closed loop frequency characteristics related to the X2 axis are as follows: Fig.16 It becomes different as shown.

[0166] Therefore, setting the same value as the gain of each axis may not ensure the stability of the control of the two axes.

[0167] In order to ensure the stability of the two-axis control, in the multi-axis parameter value setting support process, first, in a state where the load is biased toward the X2 axis (or the X1 axis), the motor control device 30 for X1 axis control and the motor control device 30 for X2 axis control perform stability index value calculation processing (for example, setting the target parameters as the position proportional gain Kpp and the speed proportional gain Kvp) on each motor control device. Figure 7 ).

[0168] Next, based on the processing result of the stability index value calculation processing for the X1-axis control motor control device 30 (the stability index value for each of the plurality of conditions) and the processing result of the stability index value calculation processing for the X2-axis control motor control device 30, a worst value determination processing is performed to determine the worst value of the stability index value for each condition. That is, a processing equivalent to the following processing is performed: Fig.17The X1-axis stability map and the X2-axis stability map shown in the figure are used to generate the synthetic stability map shown in this figure.

[0169] Then, using the processing result of the worst value determination processing (each worst value obtained by the worst value determination processing is processed as a stability index value), the control performance index value / recommended value calculation processing is performed on the X1-axis or X2-axis control motor control device 30. And, after confirmation by the user (or without confirmation by the user), the calculated two recommended values ​​are set to the X1-axis control motor control device 30 and the X2-axis control motor control device 30, and the multi-axis parameter value setting support processing is ended.

[0170] As described above, the setting support device 10 of the present embodiment can determine and output the recommended values ​​of the two parameters in consideration of both stability and control performance. Therefore, according to the setting support device 10, even a user who does not have sufficient knowledge about gain adjustment can set parameter values ​​that can give the motor control device 30 sufficient stability and control performance.

[0171] 《Variation Example》

[0172] The setting support device 10 can be modified in various ways. For example, the first to third notch filter parameter calculation processes can be modified to the following process, that is, the calculated recommended values ​​are presented to the user, and after confirmation, the recommended values ​​are set to the motor control device 30. The second and third notch filter parameter calculation processes can also be modified to processes for calculating recommended values ​​of parameters of filters other than notch filters (position filters, torque filters). The setting support device 10 can also be modified to a device that displays a three-dimensional graph as a stability map.

[0173] Furthermore, as an alternative characteristic value of the track following performance (or other performance), the value corresponding to SQR (the first parameter value) may also be used. 2 +α·Second parameter value 2 ) different values, for example, you can also use the "first parameter value 2 +k 1 Second parameter value 2 ", or |first parameter value|+k 2 |First parameter value|(k 1 , k 2 is a pre-specified value).

[0174] The setting support device 10 may also be transformed into a device for calculating (determining) the recommended values ​​of the first and second parameters based on the first evaluation index value for each condition. As a calculation method for calculating two recommended values ​​based on the first evaluation index value for each condition, the following method can be exemplified, that is, the first and second parameter values ​​of the condition for which the first evaluation index value closest to the expected value is calculated as the recommended values ​​of each parameter. In addition, if there are multiple sets of such first and second parameter values, a set of parameter values ​​as recommended values ​​may also be selected from the multiple sets of parameter values ​​based on the first parameter value and / or the second parameter value. More specifically, the maximum or minimum parameter value of the first parameter value, or the parameter value for which the value obtained based on the first parameter value and the second parameter value (the L value, etc.) is the maximum or minimum, may also be retrieved from the multiple sets of parameter values, and the retrieval result may be used as the recommended values ​​of the first and second parameters. Moreover, a set of parameter values ​​as recommended values ​​may also be selected from the multiple sets of parameter values ​​by other algorithms (for example, randomly).

[0175] Similarly, the multi-axis parameter value setting support process can also be transformed into a process for calculating (determining) the recommended values ​​of the first and second parameters based on the worst values ​​for each condition. In addition, the setting support device can also be transformed into a device that calculates an evaluation index value representing control performance as the first evaluation index value and calculates an evaluation index value representing stability as the second evaluation index value. However, if the setting support device is transformed in this way, it usually takes a longer time until the recommended value is obtained, so it is preferable to adopt the structure of the above embodiment.

[0176] Notes

[0177] A setting support device supports setting of parameter values ​​of a motor control device 30 for controlling a motor 41, the setting support device 10 comprising:

[0178] an index value calculation unit 14 for calculating a first evaluation index value indicating stability or control performance of motor control performed by the motor control device 30 for each of a plurality of conditions in which a combination of a first parameter value and a second parameter value set for the motor control device 30 is different;

[0179] a recommended value calculation unit 14 that calculates a recommended value of the first parameter and a recommended value of the second parameter based on the first evaluation index value for each situation calculated by the index value calculation unit 14; and

[0180] The recommended value output unit 14 outputs the recommended value of the first parameter and the recommended value of the second parameter calculated by the recommended value calculation unit 14 .

[0181] A setting support device 10 supports parameter value setting for a plurality of motor control devices 30 used to synchronously control motors 41 with two or more axes, the setting support device 10 comprising:

[0182] a first evaluation index value calculation unit 14 for calculating, for each motor control device index value that is a parameter value setting support object, a first evaluation index value indicating stability of motor control performed by the motor control device 30 in each of a plurality of situations in which a combination of a first parameter value and a second parameter value set for the motor control device index value is different;

[0183] a determining unit that determines the worst value of the first evaluation index value calculated by the first evaluation index value calculating unit 14 according to the situation; and

[0184] The recommended value output unit 14 determines and outputs the recommended value of the first parameter and the recommended value of the second parameter based on the worst value for each condition determined by the determination unit 14 .

Claims

1. A setting support device for supporting parameter value setting of a motor control device for controlling a motor, the setting support device comprising: an index value calculation unit that calculates a first evaluation index value indicating stability or control performance of motor control performed by the motor control device for each of a plurality of conditions in which a combination of a first parameter value and a second parameter value set for the motor control device is different; a recommended value calculation unit that calculates a recommended value of the first parameter and a recommended value of the second parameter based on the first evaluation index value for each situation calculated by the index value calculation unit; as well as a recommended value output unit that outputs the recommended value of the first parameter and the recommended value of the second parameter calculated by the recommended value calculation unit, The motor control device includes a notch filter or a torque filter, The setting support device also includes a filter parameter recommended value output unit, which is respectively based on a plurality of parameter setting information that specifies the values ​​of one or more parameters that specify the frequency characteristics of the notch filter or the torque filter. For each of the plurality of parameter setting information, the first evaluation index value is calculated for each of the plurality of conditions when the value specified by the parameter setting information is set as the value of the one or more parameters of the notch filter or the torque filter, and based on the first evaluation index value calculated for each condition, it is determined whether each condition meets the required specifications for stability, and the values ​​of the one or more parameters specified by the parameter setting information for the condition that is determined to meet the required specifications for stability is the widest range is output as recommended values ​​of the one or more parameters of the notch filter or the torque filter.

2. The setting support device according to claim 1, characterized in that: The index value calculation unit calculates the first evaluation index value and a second evaluation index value of the motor control performed by the motor control device and having a trade-off relationship with the first evaluation index value for each of the plurality of conditions, The recommended value calculation unit calculates a recommended value of the first parameter and a recommended value of the second parameter based on the first evaluation index value and the second evaluation index value for each situation calculated by the index value calculation unit.

3. The setting support device according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that: The index value calculation unit calculates a value indicating stability of motor control performed by the motor control device as the first evaluation index value.

4. The setting support device according to claim 2, characterized in that: The index value calculation unit calculates, as the second evaluation index value for each situation, a value that is positively correlated or negatively correlated with each of the value of the first parameter and the value of the second parameter for each situation.

5. The setting support device according to claim 2, characterized in that: The index value calculation unit calculates a value indicating control performance of the motor control performed by the motor control device as the second evaluation index value.

6. The setting support device according to claim 5, characterized in that: The recommended value calculation unit determines a condition that satisfies the required specifications regarding stability and the required specifications regarding control performance and has the lowest achievable performance based on the first evaluation index value and the second evaluation index value of each condition, and calculates the value of the first parameter and the value of the second parameter for the determined condition as the recommended value of the first parameter and the recommended value of the second parameter.

7. The setting support device according to claim 1, characterized in that: The index value calculation unit further calculates a third evaluation index value for each of the plurality of conditions, the third evaluation index value being an evaluation result of the stability of the motor control performed by the motor control device under an evaluation criterion different from that of the first evaluation index value, The recommended value calculation unit further calculates a recommended value of the first parameter and a recommended value of the second parameter using the third evaluation index value for each situation calculated by the index value calculation unit.

8. The setting support device according to claim 7, characterized in that: The index value calculation unit calculates a gain of a servo system including the motor control device at a frequency corresponding to a center frequency of the notch filter or a cutoff frequency of the torque filter as the first evaluation index value or the third evaluation index value.

9. The setting support device according to claim 1, characterized in that Also includes: The user interface unit changes the plurality of parameter setting information to be processed by the filter parameter recommendation value output unit according to an instruction from a user.

10. The setting support device according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that: The setting support device further includes a recommended value determination unit that determines recommended values ​​of one or more parameters that define frequency characteristics of the notch filter based on a measurement result of a gain characteristic of the motor control performed by the motor control device.

11. The setting support device according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that: The index value calculation unit obtains a frequency transfer function including a specified portion of the motor based on a measurement result of a gain characteristic of the motor control performed by the motor control device, and calculates the first evaluation index value for each of the plurality of conditions using the obtained frequency transfer function.

12. The setting support device according to claim 2, characterized in that: The index value calculation unit obtains a frequency transfer function including a specified part of the motor based on a measurement result of a gain characteristic of the motor control performed by the motor control device, and uses the obtained frequency transfer function to calculate the first evaluation index value and the second evaluation index value for each of the multiple conditions.

13. The setting support device according to claim 12, characterized in that: The index value calculation unit calculates the second evaluation index value for each of the plurality of situations based on the frequency transfer function without performing an integral operation.

14. The setting support device according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that: The index value calculation unit has a function of determining a value of at least one parameter other than the first parameter and the second parameter in each situation, based on the value of the first parameter or the second parameter.

15. A setting support device for supporting parameter value setting for a plurality of motor control devices used for synchronously controlling motors of two or more axes, the setting support device comprising: a first evaluation index value calculation means for calculating, for each motor control device that is a parameter value setting support object, a first evaluation index value indicating stability of motor control performed by the motor control device in each of a plurality of situations in which a combination of a first parameter value and a second parameter value set for the motor control device is different; a determining component, which determines, according to the condition, the worst value of the first evaluation index value calculated by the first evaluation index value calculating component; as well as a recommended value outputting means for determining and outputting a recommended value of the first parameter and a recommended value of the second parameter based on the worst value for each condition determined by the determining means, The motor control device includes a notch filter or a torque filter, The setting support device also includes a filter parameter recommended value output unit, which is respectively based on a plurality of parameter setting information that specifies the values ​​of one or more parameters that specify the frequency characteristics of the notch filter or the torque filter. For each of the plurality of parameter setting information, the first evaluation index value is calculated for each of the plurality of conditions when the value specified by the parameter setting information is set as the value of the one or more parameters of the notch filter or the torque filter, and based on the first evaluation index value calculated for each condition, it is determined whether each condition meets the required specifications for stability, and the values ​​of the one or more parameters specified by the parameter setting information for the condition that is determined to meet the required specifications for stability is the widest range is output as recommended values ​​of the one or more parameters of the notch filter or the torque filter.

16. The setting support device according to claim 15, characterized in that: The recommended value output component determines whether each condition meets the required specifications regarding stability based on the determination result of the worst value according to the condition, and for each of the conditions determined to meet the required specifications, calculates a second evaluation index value regarding the motor control performed by the motor control device that has a trade-off relationship with the first evaluation index value, and calculates the recommended value of the first parameter and the recommended value of the second parameter based on the calculated second evaluation index value for each condition.