A green building design evaluation method
By evaluating the spatial configuration and user experience of green buildings, the problem of the existing evaluation system neglecting non-technical factors is solved, and the comprehensive and usability assessment of green building design is achieved, improving user experience and sustainability.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202111078916.5
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-09-15
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-12
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-09-15
AI Technical Summary
The existing green building evaluation system ignores non-technical aspects, especially the integrated evaluation of product availability, teaching ability and spatial configuration, resulting in the inability of users' subjective initiative in the built environment to be effectively reflected.
Using a green building design evaluation method, the measurement of usability and teachingability by obtaining architectural design, evaluating and analyzing the permeability of spatial configurations, including integration, connectivity and comprehensibility, and combining Delphi group surveys and quantitative methods, Use depthmapX software for integration and connectivity calculations, determine penetration, and finally adjust the design to meet usability and teachability requirements.
Achieve quantitative assessment of non-technical aspects of green buildings, ensure the flexibility and comprehensiveness of the design in the early stages, lower the evaluation threshold, quantify teachingability for the first time, improve the usability and understanding of the design, and promote users' Sustainable behavior.
Smart Images

Figure CN113762798B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present application relates to a green building design evaluation method. Background Art
[0002] Currently, green building assessment frameworks focus on quantitative and technical aspects, with less emphasis on non-technical aspects, ignoring the subjective agency of people in the built environment. Quantitative methods are rarely used to assess non-technical aspects, with few exceptions. Unsatisfactory user-design interaction seems to be a major problem in the operational phase of green buildings, due to the following reasons: 1) lack of usability at the product functional level; 2) lack of teachability; and 3) inappropriate spatial design of the building space and / or the products within the building space.
[0003] As for usability, according to the definition of usability in ISO9241-11, usability is "the degree to which a specific user achieves specific goals of effectiveness, efficiency and satisfaction by using a product in a specific use environment". Usability has been widely discussed in industrial design and software development, but it is rarely mentioned in green building environments. At present, existing usability studies include the framework for prospective measurement of design usability proposed by Andrews et al. (2011), which is a "research-level computer simulation modeling framework". Regarding the green building rating system, among the six rating systems widely used worldwide (CaSCo, 2018), "functionality and usability" are only mentioned in the service quality standard of CASBEE, and its indicators (such as the provision of space and storage) are only related to space design, not product usability (CASBEE, 2014).
[0004] Regarding teachability, Merriam-Webster defines teachability as "suitability for use in teaching". In the context of green buildings, we define it as the effectiveness of the building and / or product itself in teaching or educating users about sustainability, and achieving sustainability by promoting active interactions through various stimulating inputs (e.g., visual, auditory) embedded in the building design, which in turn affects one or more senses (e.g., auditory, visual, tactile). Green buildings, together with appropriate preliminary designs, are expected to become a teaching medium to promote sustainable behavior among users. To the best of the author's knowledge, none of the existing green building evaluation system studies have addressed the issue of "teachability" of green buildings or green products. Among the 10 indicators based on the teachability design model proposed by Hsiao et al. (2012), only 5 are related to teachability, namely: prompts, perceptions, symbols, perceptions and feedback.
[0005] For spatial configuration, unlike usability and teachability, the spatial configuration of a design is not considered an independent aspect. Rather, it acts as a potential moderator that can affect usability and teachability through accessibility. “Accessibility” here refers to the degree of connection between the user and the design. It refers to the probability that the design can be accessed (e.g., seen / heard / touched), indicating whether it is appropriately placed within the building. Accessibility should not be confused with external accessibility mentioned in other rating systems (e.g., BRAMHEA06), which promotes ease of entering and exiting a building, or accessibility defined by the U.S. Access Authority and used by the entire building design guide. The accessibility of a design is assumed to be a potential moderator and sometimes a prerequisite for usability / teachability (e.g., first-time users). Spatial configuration research “takes into account the relationship of other relationships,” explores “the elusive ‘pattern aspect’ of things in architecture,” and provides “a quantitative expression of the age-old idea of ‘how things fit together’” (Hillier, 2007).
[0006] However, how to integrate the above non-technical factors into the quantitative evaluation system of green buildings has not been paid attention to and solved, and there is a lack of unified application. Summary of the invention
[0007] In order to solve the above problems, the present application discloses a green building design evaluation method, comprising the following steps:
[0008] Get architectural designs;
[0009] Assess the spatial configuration of building designs and analyze the permeability of building designs;
[0010] The usability and teachability of the preliminary design are evaluated and modified through permeability, and finally the permeability meets the design requirements.
[0011] Preferably, the permeability includes the following aspects: integration, connectivity and understandability;
[0012] The integration refers to the normalized measure of the distance from any origin to all other origins in the preliminary design. It is a global measure that represents the relationship of a unit to the entire configuration.
[0013] The connectivity measure directly connects the number of spaces in an original space. It is a local measure that describes the permeability of a cell relative to its neighboring cells.
[0014] The comprehensibility measures the correlation between connectivity and integration and can be used to identify the most integrated and connected units in a preliminary design.
[0015] Preferably, the integration is measured using depthmapX software; first, the integration of all spatial units on each floor of the building is calculated; then, for a selected preliminary design, its integration is calculated based on the integration of the specific spatial unit where the product is located, which is based on the integration values of all other units, and the integration values include three levels: above 75%, between 25% and 75%, and below 25%.
[0016] Preferably, the connectivity is calculated using the same steps as the integration, first computing the connectivity via depthmapX, and then computing the connectivity level for the specific preliminary design according to the benchmark process.
[0017] Preferably, the comprehensibility is measured using depthmapX, creating a visibility graph, and plotting connectivity and integration as a scatter plot; first determine whether the overall layout is intelligent, so as to find out whether there are any potential strategic points; if a system R 2 Above 0.8, it is considered an understandable system; methods for finding strategic points include visual search through depthmapX map results, or using numerical analysis methods; if the system is understandable and the studied design is located within the strategic points, the highest score obtained is taken as the final level of permeability.
[0018] Preferably, the usability and teachability are obtained through a Delphi panel survey. In the first round of the Delphi method, a simple "conclusion statement" method is used to screen a pre-validated list of indicators; subsequently, a five-point Likert scale is used to determine the importance level of the indicators using two Delphi methods, followed by generating a confirmed list of indicators after a consistency analysis; finally, in order to obtain a final single score for usability and teachability, the hierarchical analysis method is used to prioritize the questions developed in the Delphi process, and the paired hierarchical analysis method is used to develop weights at the sub-criteria and indicator levels.
[0019] Preferably, the usability is measured by using performance indicators and / or perception indicators using survey-based quantitative methods and qualitative methods; for the quantitative performance indicator option, three sub-criteria are included: effectiveness, efficiency and learnability, through which building users can achieve specific functional goals in green buildings; for the qualitative perception indicator option, a system usability scale is used.
[0020] Preferably, the availability includes determination of the following parameters:
[0021] Task success rate: The success rate measured in binary indicates the efficiency of users in completing a given set of tasks; 0 indicates failure and 1 indicates success, and this indicator is used to measure efficiency;
[0022] The task success rate is measured as follows: Assume that n users test k tasks, k represents how many subtasks a user needs to complete to successfully operate a functional object, and for a simple system k = 1; the final success rate is the average score of all users and all tasks, and Score i,j is the binary success score of user i on task j, that is, Formula 1:
[0023]
[0024] Task time represents the time required for users to complete one and / or all tasks, measured by the percentage of users who can complete the task within a predefined threshold. The task completion time is defined as a binary task, where 0 represents a time above the threshold and 1 represents a time below the threshold. threshold,j ,A simple approach is to have experts double the task completion time;,alternatively, it can be based on competitive data or best guess values;
[0025] The measurement of task time includes the following steps: First, the time taken by each user to complete each task is converted into Time i,j Score, which is the binary task completion score of user i on task j, calculated by Formula 2. The final time rate is the average time of all users and all tasks i,j The score is calculated by formula 3;
[0026]
[0027] Task i,j is the completion time of user i on task j, Task threshold,j is the threshold time on task j;
[0028]
[0029] Efficiency refers to the amount of work required to complete a task. Combining the first two metrics, efficiency is measured by the ratio of effectiveness to task time, which requires further benchmarks to produce meaningful results.
[0030] Efficiency measurement: First, calculate each user’s personal efficiency in each task, i.e., Eff_ind i,j score, calculated by Formula 4; second, the benchmark score Eff is developed using the previously developed threshold time benchmark,j , calculated by formula 5; third, Eff_ind i,j The score is compared with the benchmark to obtain the binary relative efficiency Eff_relative i,j The score is calculated by Formula 6. The final efficiency is the relative value of the average efficiency of all users and all tasks, which is calculated by Formula 7.
[0031] Eff_ind i,j =Score i,j / Time i,j Formula 4
[0032] Eff benchmark,j =Expectedsuccessscore / Thresholdtime=1 / Task threshold,j Formula 5
[0033]
[0034]
[0035] Learnability indicates the degree to which learning is possible; it is measured by comparing the usability of a product for experienced and inexperienced users;
[0036] Measurement of learnability: The original learnability formula is formula 8 written using the above measurable indicators; if the expert task time can be expressed as Task threshold,j In a few cases, the success rate of all users reaches 1 and they are all "super experts", Time i,j <Time expert,j , the final learnability, formula 10, can exceed 100%; check Time expert , j and all other data for accuracy and appropriateness, it can be changed to 100% as the maximum achievable value.
[0037] Learnability i,j =(Usereffectiveness) / (Experttasktime)×100%=Score i,j ×(Time expert,j / Time i,j )×100% Formula 8 Learnability i,j =(Score i,j / 1)×Task threshold,j / (2×Time i,j )×100% Formula 9
[0038]
[0039] Preferably, the teachability includes the following indicators: appearance characteristics and clear information; appearance characteristics indicate the degree to which the design object is presented and exists harmoniously in an environment, so that the user can perceive the beauty of the environment before really paying attention to the design object; clear information indicates the degree to which a design conveys information clearly and fully by using symbols to represent information, so that the user can intuitively make the required response.
[0040] Preferably, the appearance feature indicates the degree of presentation, positioning and harmonious existence of the design object in the environment, so that the user can perceive and appreciate its existence in the environment before actually paying attention to the design object itself; the appearance feature is measured by two binary indicators;
[0041] Each objective is first measured and then weighted to obtain a final score for the appearance characteristics of a specific design object:
[0042] Appearance V app V refers to the aesthetics of an object. It indicates whether the appearance of the object is attractive to a specific user. It is subjective and can be roughly measured by asking users whether they like the design. If user i likes the design, V t,app =1; if not, 0;
[0043] Tip V hnt Indicates that the design itself provides clues to the meaning of sustainability, and the functional components give clues to its operation steps; it can be roughly measured by asking users whether they connect the design to any sustainable meaning or think that the design provides clues to their operation steps. If user i answers yes, V i,hnt =1; if not, it is 0, i.e. formula 11;
[0044] V i,app , V t,hnt =0 or 1(for user i) Formula 11
[0045] The clear information indicates the extent to which the design can intuitively and adequately convey sustainable information without further education or memorization by using necessary symbols to represent the information; four binary indicators are used to measure the clear information, which requires first calculating the individual indicators and then weighting them to calculate the final score of the CI, that is, Formula 12:
[0046]
[0047] Clarity V clr Refers to providing concise but sufficient information to facilitate understanding of a particular green object; it is subjective and subtle, and can be roughly measured by asking users whether they agree that the design itself is clear and not confusing. If the user agrees that all designs are clean, Ciri =1, otherwise 0, that is, formula 13:
[0048]
[0049] Symbol V smb It refers to using enough symbols for the object, and its measurement criteria are: 1) the existence of symbols, S p = 1 if any symbol exists, otherwise 0; and 2) whether the user can correctly interpret the meaning of the symbol smb i =1 if user i recognizes the symbol, then 0, that is, formula 14:
[0050]
[0051] Intuitive itv Refers to the design's use of common sense and the delivery of widely known information, requiring no further education, memorization, or explanation; it is subjective and subtle, and can be roughly measured by asking users; if user i thinks the design is intuitive, then it is intuitive. i =1; if not, then 0, i.e. formula 15;
[0052]
[0053] Responsiveness V res Refers to the user's ability to respond to an object; similar to intuition, it is subjective and subtle, and can be roughly measured by asking users. If users think the design is responsive, Res i =1; if not, it is 0, that is, Formula 16.
[0054]
[0055] This application can bring the following beneficial effects:
[0056] 1. This application is the first discussion of quantitative non-technical aspects in the development and assessment of green buildings. Due to different interpretations in different contexts and cultural backgrounds, some believe that these factors should be considered and ranked on a qualitative basis; although a combination of qualitative and quantitative measures are used to evaluate the proposed aspects, the final presentation is made through a quantitative measurement scheme (0-1 percentile scale), which is necessary for potential integration with current green building rating systems.
[0057] 2. To ensure flexibility in design in practice, this application developed the framework so that it can be deployed in the early design stage as much as possible. In the early design stage, even survey questions involving measuring usability and teachability can be evaluated using design prototypes or other technologies (such as virtual environments) as long as the floor plan is provided.
[0058] 3. The indicators and measurement methods proposed in this application were developed with comprehensiveness and simplicity of use in mind, with a low threshold for implementation, which is a prerequisite for further adoption or inclusion in current green building rating systems.
[0059] 4. Quantification of teachability is a topic that has not been explored before. The participatory approach used in this application is a relatively better approach because it can more actively engage users in the early design stage.
[0060] 5. A major practical problem addressed by this application is the correct identification of product designs that require usability and / or teachability metrics and configuration analysis. Obviously, not every green building is designed to promote sustainability. Deliberately including trivial designs and / or excluding key green designs in the analysis to manipulate the final results (e.g., to obtain a higher percentage ratio by including only well-designed objects) is certainly undesirable. In practice, we leave this issue to the designers and evaluators to identify the key designs that require further analysis. A possible solution is to select those that have already been assigned credits under the rating system. For example, a heat recovery ventilation system may have been assigned credits, so its usability is worth analyzing to avoid poor operational results. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0061] The drawings described herein are used to provide a further understanding of the present application and constitute a part of the present application. The illustrative embodiments of the present application and their descriptions are used to explain the present application and do not constitute an improper limitation on the present application. In the drawings:
[0062] Figure 1 This is an analysis diagram for a hypothetical floor plan;
[0063] Figure 2 An analysis diagram of strategic points for a hypothetical floor plan;
[0064] Figure 3 Plan possible locations for green building signage for a hypothetical floor plan;
[0065] Figure 4 For permeability analysis. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0066] In order to clearly illustrate the technical features of the present solution, the present application is described in detail below through specific implementation methods and in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
[0067] In a first embodiment, a green building design evaluation method includes the following steps:
[0068] S101. Obtain architectural design;
[0069] S102 evaluates the spatial configuration of the building design and analyzes the permeability of the building design;
[0070] The permeability includes the following aspects: integration, connectivity and understandability;
[0071] The integration refers to the normalized measure of the distance from any origin to all other origins in the preliminary design. It is a global measure that represents the relationship of a unit to the entire configuration.
[0072] The connectivity measure directly connects the number of spaces in an original space. It is a local measure that describes the permeability of a cell relative to its neighboring cells.
[0073] The comprehensibility measures the correlation between connectivity and integration and can be used to identify the most integrated and connected units in a preliminary design.
[0074] The integration is measured using depthmapX software; first, the integration of all spatial units on each floor of the building is calculated; then, for a selected preliminary design, its integration is calculated based on the integration of the specific spatial unit where the product is located, which is based on the integration values of all other units, and the integration values include three levels: above 75%, between 25% and 75%, and below 25%.
[0075] The connectivity is calculated using the same steps as integration, first computing connectivity via depthmapX, then computing the connectivity level for a specific preliminary design according to the benchmark process.
[0076] The comprehensibility is measured using depthmapX, visibility graphs are created, and connectivity and integration are plotted as scatter plots; first determine whether the overall layout is intelligent, thereby discovering whether there are any potential strategic points; if a system is R 2 Above 0.8, it is considered an understandable system; methods for finding strategic points include visual search through depthmapX map results, or using numerical analysis methods; if the system is understandable and the studied design is located within the strategic points, the highest score obtained is taken as the final level of permeability.
[0077] S103 evaluates and modifies the usability and teachability of the preliminary design through permeability, and ultimately makes the permeability meet the design requirements.
[0078] The usability and teachability were obtained through a Delphi panel survey. In the first round of Delphi, a simple "conclusion statement" method was used to screen a pre-validated list of indicators; subsequently, a five-point Likert scale was used to determine the importance level of the indicators using two Delphi methods, in order to generate a confirmed list of indicators after a consistency analysis; finally, in order to obtain the final single score of usability and teachability, the hierarchical analysis method was used to prioritize the questions developed in the delphi process, and the paired hierarchical analysis method was used to develop weights at the sub-criteria and indicator levels.
[0079] The usability is measured by using performance indicators and / or perception indicators using a quantitative survey-based approach as well as a qualitative approach; for the quantitative performance indicator option, three sub-criteria are included: effectiveness, efficiency, and learnability, through which building users can achieve specific functional goals in green buildings; for the qualitative perception indicator option, a system usability scale is used.
[0080] The availability includes the determination of the following parameters:
[0081] Task success rate: The success rate measured in binary indicates the efficiency of users in completing a given set of tasks; 0 indicates failure and 1 indicates success, and this indicator is used to measure efficiency;
[0082] The task success rate is measured as follows: Assume that n users test k tasks, k represents how many subtasks a user needs to complete to successfully operate a functional object, and for a simple system k = 1; the final success rate is the average score of all users and all tasks, and Score i,j is the binary success score of user i on task j, that is, Formula 1:
[0083]
[0084] Task time represents the time required for users to complete one and / or all tasks, measured by the percentage of users who can complete the task within a predefined threshold. The task completion time is defined as a binary task, where 0 represents a time above the threshold and 1 represents a time below the threshold. threshold,j ,A simple approach is to have experts double the task completion time;,alternatively, it can be based on competitive data or best guess values;
[0085] The measurement of task time includes the following steps: First, the time taken by each user to complete each task is converted into Time i,j Score, which is the binary task completion score of user i on task j, calculated by Formula 2. The final time rate is the average time of all users and all tasks i,j The score is calculated by formula 3;
[0086]
[0087] Task i,j is the completion time of user i on task j, Task threshold,j is the threshold time on task j;
[0088]
[0089] Efficiency refers to the amount of work required to complete a task. Combining the first two metrics, efficiency is measured by the ratio of effectiveness to task time, which requires further benchmarks to produce meaningful results.
[0090] Efficiency measurement: First, calculate each user’s personal efficiency in each task, i.e., Eff_ind i,j score, calculated by Formula 4; second, the benchmark score Eff is developed using the previously developed threshold time benchmark,j , calculated by formula 5; third, Eff_ind i,j The score is compared with the benchmark to obtain the binary relative efficiency Eff_relative i,j The score is calculated by Formula 6. The final efficiency is the relative value of the average efficiency of all users and all tasks, which is calculated by Formula 7.
[0091] Eff_ind i,j =Score i,j / Time i,j Formula 4
[0092] Eff benchmark,j =Expectedsuccessscore / Thresholdtime=1 / Task threshold,j Formula 5
[0093]
[0094]
[0095] Learnability indicates the degree to which learning is possible; it is measured by comparing the usability of a product for experienced and inexperienced users;
[0096] Measurement of learnability: The original learnability formula is formula 8 written using the above measurable indicators; if the expert task time can be expressed as Task threshold,j In a few cases, the success rate of all users reaches 1 and they are all "super experts", Time i,j <Time expert,j , the final learnability can exceed 100%; check Time againexpert,j and all other data for accuracy and appropriateness, it can be changed to 100% as the maximum achievable value.
[0097] Learnability i,j =(Usereffectiveness) / (Experttasktime)×100%=Score i,j ×(Time expert,j / Time i,j )×100% Formula 8
[0098] Learnability i,j =(Score i,j / 1)×Task threshold,j / (2×Time i,j )×100% Formula 9
[0099]
[0100] The teachability includes the following indicators: appearance characteristics and clear information; appearance characteristics indicate the degree to which the design object is presented and exists harmoniously in an environment, allowing users to perceive the beauty of the environment before really paying attention to the design object; clear information indicates the degree to which a design conveys information clearly and fully by using symbols to represent information, allowing users to intuitively make the required response.
[0101] The appearance feature indicates the degree of presentation, positioning and harmonious existence of the design object in the environment, so that the user can perceive and appreciate its existence in the environment before actually paying attention to the design object itself; the appearance feature is measured by two binary indicators;
[0102] Each objective is first measured and then weighted to obtain a final score for the appearance characteristics of a specific design object:
[0103] Appearance V app V refers to the aesthetics of an object. It indicates whether the appearance of the object is attractive to a specific user. It is subjective and can be roughly measured by asking users whether they like the design. If user i likes the design, V i,app =1; if not, 0;
[0104] Tip V hnt Indicates that the design itself provides clues to the meaning of sustainability, and the functional components give clues to its operation steps; it can be roughly measured by asking users whether they connect the design to any sustainable meaning or think that the design provides clues to their operation steps. If user i answers yes, V i,hnt =1; if not, it is 0, i.e. formula 11;
[0105] V i,app , V thnt =0 or 1(for user i) Formula 11
[0106] The clear information indicates the extent to which the design can intuitively and adequately convey sustainable information without further education or memorization by using necessary symbols to represent the information; four binary indicators are used to measure the clear information, which requires first calculating the individual indicators and then weighting them to calculate the final score of Cl, that is, Formula 12:
[0107]
[0108] Clarity V clr Refers to providing concise but sufficient information to facilitate understanding of a particular green object; it is subjective and subtle, and can be roughly measured by asking users whether they agree that the design itself is clear and not confusing. If the user agrees that all designs are clean, Cir i =1, otherwise 0, that is, formula 13:
[0109]
[0110] Symbol V smb It refers to using enough symbols for the object, and its measurement criteria are: 1) the existence of symbols, S p = 1 if any symbol exists, otherwise 0; and 2) whether the user can correctly interpret the meaning of the symbol smb i =1 if user i recognizes the symbol, then 0, that is, formula 14:
[0111]
[0112] Intuitive itv Refers to the design's use of common sense and the delivery of widely known information, requiring no further education, memorization, or explanation; it is subjective and subtle, and can be roughly measured by asking users; if user i thinks the design is intuitive, then it is intuitive. i =1; if not, then 0, i.e. formula 15;
[0113]
[0114] Responsiveness V res Refers to the user's ability to respond to an object; similar to intuition, it is subjective and subtle, and can be roughly measured by asking users. If users think the design is responsive, Res i =1; if not, it is 0, that is, Formula 16.
[0115]
[0116] The following example illustrates finding the best location for a green building signage plan, using ThedepthmapX-0.7.0 to process a hypothetical floor plan.
[0117] Smart analysis shows the relationship between integration and connectivity ( Figure 1 Left), indicating that the whole system is "intelligent", R 2 =0.78 (rounded to 0.8). The most “strategic points” are the red points in the integrated connectivity scatter plot, which correspond to the yellow points in the floor plan, numbered 1, 2, 3, and 4, which (in theory) seem to be good places to place green building designation projects. The VGA graphic is a hypothetical floor plan, with the floor plan showing high integration points (e.g., warmer colors) on the right and the smart analysis on the left. The red points represent “strategic points” - corresponding to the yellow dashed areas (numbered 1, 2, 3, 4 in the right figure).
[0118] The most strategically important point Figure 2 The red dot in the left image and the corresponding yellow dashed area and red circle in the right image) is located in the center of a spatial unit, which may not be a viable location for a green building signage program. The most “strategic point” is the red dot in the left image and the corresponding yellow dashed area and red circle. There are other “strategic points” that, despite having lower integration and connectivity scores, may still provide viable options for locating a green building signage program.
[0119] like Figure 3 As shown, some “strategic points” (yellow dashed areas within yellow circles) can provide viable locations for green building signage programs. To demonstrate the permeability scoring procedure, several short functions were written in R. After importing the VGA results (exported from the depthmap software) into R, these functions can calculate the connectivity and integration scores and the permeability score for any selected spatial unit (reference unit), as shown in Figure 2. Figure 4 Reference number 2228235 (above) is located near the entrance and has a permeability score of only 0.2. Reference number 5767272 (below left) appears to be a better location with a permeability of 0.8, while reference number 2555964 (below right) is the theoretical best choice with a permeability of 1.
[0120] Each embodiment in this specification is described in a progressive manner, and the same or similar parts between the embodiments can be referred to each other, and each embodiment focuses on the differences from other embodiments. In particular, for the system embodiment, since it is basically similar to the method embodiment, the description is relatively simple, and the relevant parts can be referred to the partial description of the method embodiment.
[0121] The above are only embodiments of the present application and are not intended to limit the present application. For those skilled in the art, the present application may have various changes and variations. Any modification, equivalent replacement, improvement, etc. made within the spirit and principle of the present application should be included within the scope of the claims of the present application.
Claims
1. A green building design evaluation method, Features: The steps include: Get architectural designs; Assess the spatial configuration of building designs and analyze the permeability of building designs; Evaluate and modify the usability and teachability of architectural design through permeability, and ultimately make the permeability meet the design requirements; The permeability includes the following aspects: integration, connectivity and understandability; Integration refers to the standardized measure of the distance from any origin to all other origins in a building design. It is a global measure that represents the relationship of a unit to the entire configuration. The connectivity measure directly connects the number of spaces in an original space. It is a local measure that describes the permeability of a cell relative to its neighboring cells. The described comprehensibility measures the correlation between connectivity and integration and can be used to identify the most integrated and connected elements in a building design; The integration is measured using depthmapX software; first, the integration of all spatial units on each floor of the building is calculated; then, for a selected building design, its integration is calculated based on the integration of the specific spatial unit where the product is located, which is based on the integration value of all spatial units, and the integration value includes three levels: above 75%, between 25% and 75%, and below 25%; The connectivity is calculated using the same steps as integration, first calculating connectivity through depthmapX, and then calculating the connectivity level of the specific building design according to the benchmark process; The comprehensibility is measured using depthmapX, creating visibility graphs, and plotting connectivity and integration as scatter plots; first determine whether the overall layout is intelligent, thereby discovering whether there are any potential strategic points; if the R of a system scatter plot is 2 Above 0.8, it is considered an understandable system. Methods for finding strategic points include visual search through depthmapX map results, or using numerical analysis methods. If the system is understandable and the studied design is located within the strategic points, the highest score obtained is taken as the final level of permeability; The usability and teachability were obtained through a Delphi panel survey. In the first round of the Delphi panel survey, a simple "conclusion statement" method was used to screen a pre-validated list of indicators. Subsequently, a five-point Likert scale and two Delphi panel surveys were used to determine the importance level of the indicators. After a consistency analysis, a confirmed list of indicators was generated. Finally, in order to obtain the final single score of usability and teachability, the hierarchical analysis method was used to prioritize the questions developed during the Delphi panel survey, and the paired hierarchical analysis method was used to develop weights at the sub-criteria and indicator levels. The usability is measured by using performance indicators and / or perception indicators using a quantitative survey-based approach as well as a qualitative approach; for the quantitative performance indicator option, three sub-criteria are included: effectiveness, efficiency, and learnability, through which building users can achieve specific functional goals in green buildings; for the qualitative perception indicator option, a system usability scale is used.
