A coal-saving method and system based on flue gas recovery system
By establishing a coal-saving method and calculation system suitable for a variety of flue gas recovery systems and large boilers, the inconsistent problem of coal-saving benefit calculation in the flue gas waste heat recovery system is solved, and accurate coal consumption assessment and efficiency improvement are achieved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202310667312.7
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-06-06
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-15
- Estimated Expiration
- 2043-06-06
AI Technical Summary
In the flue gas waste heat recovery system, there is a lack of unified coal-saving efficiency calculation methods and scheme comparison standards, resulting in controversy and problems in application that have not been effectively resolved.
A coal saving method based on flue gas recovery system is proposed. By determining the benefit calculation method suitable for multiple target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers, the coal saving rate of each system is calculated under the situation of generating the same benefits. And choose an optimization plan based on cost differences to establish a flue gas waste heat recovery benefit calculation system.
Accurate coal consumption calculation is achieved, repeated calculations or omissions of coal saving benefits are avoided, and the coal saving calculation level of flue gas waste heat utilization system is improved, and it complies with domestic and foreign boiler specifications.
Smart Images

Figure CN116703086B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of flue gas waste heat recovery, and more specifically, to a coal saving method and system based on a flue gas recovery system. Background Art
[0002] In my country's thermal power industry, the research and application of flue gas waste heat utilization technology can be roughly divided into the following stages:
[0003] (1) Energy-saving low-temperature economizer system: As early as the mid-1990s, a low-temperature economizer waste heat recovery system represented by the 100MW unit of Shandong Longkou Power Plant was put into operation. At that time, the purpose was to reduce the excessively high exhaust temperature and save energy.
[0004] (2) Energy-saving and environmentally friendly low-temperature economizer system: Since the beginning of the 21st century, with the introduction of national energy-saving and emission reduction policies and the promotion of wet flue gas desulfurization systems, flue gas waste heat recovery systems with low-temperature economizers installed at the inlet of the desulfurization tower have emerged. The first million-level full-capacity low-temperature economizer system was built on the 1000MW unit of Waigaoqiao No. 3 Power Plant, achieving good technical and economic benefits; then, with the introduction of low-temperature electrostatic precipitator technology, the energy-saving and environmentally friendly low-temperature economizer system of "low-temperature economizer + low-temperature electrostatic precipitator" before the electrostatic precipitator has become an optimized combination. For example, in 2012, the No. 4 600MW unit of Datang Ningde Power Plant adopted this system, which reduced the inlet flue gas temperature of the electrostatic precipitator by more than 50°C, the unit heat consumption by more than 52kJ / kWh, and the flue gas emission concentration at the outlet of the electrostatic precipitator from 60mg / m3 to 20mg / m3, achieving energy-saving and emission reduction benefits at the same time. At present, energy-saving and environmentally friendly low-temperature economizer systems have been widely promoted and applied in China;
[0005] (3) Low-temperature economizer system combined with air heater: As early as the 1990s, some scholars pointed out that it is more economical to recover flue gas waste heat on the air side than on the condensate side. Around 2010, with the promotion and application of denitrification systems, the phenomenon of ammonium bisulfate deposition and blockage in air preheaters became more common. In order to increase the wall temperature of the cold end of the air preheater and move the ammonium bisulfate deposition point down to the sootblower purgeable area, reduce the ABS blockage risk of denitrification flue gas, and improve the waste heat recovery efficiency, a low-temperature economizer system combined with a heater was born. Representative examples include the engineering practice application on two 600MW units of the Guodian Fujian Jiangyin Power Plant; Fujian Chengxin Green Group, Xi'an Thermal Engineering Research Institute, Guodian Nanjing Electric Power Research Institute and other units have conducted relatively systematic research and performance testing on this technology;
[0006] (4) Flue gas waste heat cascade utilization type medium / low temperature economizer system: Since 2010, inspired by the high-efficiency coal-fired power plants in Europe and drawing on the design experience report of the flue gas waste heat system of the K unit of the Niederaussem Power Plant in Germany, the flue gas waste heat utilization technology with "air preheater bypass flue medium / low temperature economizer" as the core has become a research hotspot in China. Various scientific research institutions and universities have carried out extensive theoretical research on this; and it has been applied in a 600MW unit technical transformation project and a newly built 660MW unit in Pingshan, Anhui. The flue gas waste heat cascade utilization system of the 600MW unit technical transformation project also applied the generalized heat recovery technology, reflecting the latest research results in China;
[0007] At present, in the design of new and rebuilt thermal power units, flue gas waste heat recovery technology with low-temperature economizer as the main body has become a major project of design optimization; in the design of secondary reheat units, low-temperature economizer has also become a measure for boilers to control excessive flue gas temperature, and is included in the scope of boiler design and heat balance assessment. The flue gas waste heat recovery system has developed from a single low-temperature economizer system to a variety of optimization schemes with boiler-machine coupling characteristics. However, at the same time, there is no standardization on basic issues such as coal-saving benefit calculation, assessment methods and scheme comparison of flue gas waste heat recovery systems, and there are still some controversial issues that need to be studied, resolved or clarified. Summary of the invention
[0008] In view of the above problems, the present invention proposes a coal saving method based on a flue gas recovery system, comprising:
[0009] Determine the benefit calculation method applicable to various target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers;
[0010] Using the benefit calculation method, calculate the first amount of coal used when each target flue gas recovery system is used together with a large boiler under the condition of producing the same benefits, and calculate the second amount of coal used in the historical use of the large boiler under the condition of producing the same benefits;
[0011] Based on the first coal amount and the second coal amount, determining a coal saving rate when each target flue gas recovery system is used together with a large boiler relative to a historical use condition of the large boiler;
[0012] Determine the first cost reduced by the coal saving rate, and determine the second cost increased when converting from the historical use of large boilers to the use of the target flue gas recovery system and large boiler together, and select the target flue gas recovery system and large boiler corresponding to the first cost whose first cost is greater than the second cost and the difference is greater than the preset range for use, so as to save coal when the large boiler generates benefits.
[0013] Optionally, by determining the types of the target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers, a benefit calculation method applicable to a variety of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers is determined.
[0014] Optionally, the flue gas recovery system includes at least one of the following: a conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, a heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system, and an air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system;
[0015] Among them, the benefit calculation method used by each of the flue gas recovery systems corresponds to a plurality of benefit calculation systems. Before determining the benefit calculation method applicable to a plurality of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers, the benefit calculation system is determined. After determining the benefit calculation system, the benefit calculation method applicable to a plurality of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers is determined according to the benefit calculation system.
[0016] The benefit calculation system includes:
[0017] For each benefit calculation system, the benefit calculation system is verified using the same input data to determine the accuracy of each benefit calculation system, and the benefit calculation system that best meets the accuracy requirements is used as the benefit calculation system used by the flue gas recovery system;
[0018] The benefit calculation system used as a flue gas recovery system meets the preset selection criteria.
[0019] Optionally, the benefit calculation methods corresponding to the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, the heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system and the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system all include multiple calculation modes, and all include calculation methods for multiple indicators and multiple constraints;
[0020] Among them, the benefit calculation method and the calculation mode used are selected according to the actual sampling data of the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, the heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system and the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system;
[0021] The benefit calculation method corresponding to the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system includes calculation methods for multiple indicators, including: heat consumption change calculation method, auxiliary power consumption calculation method, and plant power consumption rate and power supply coal saving rate calculation method;
[0022] The benefit calculation method corresponding to the cascade utilization system of the heater plus low-temperature economizer includes calculation methods of multiple indicators, including: basic indicator calculation method, boiler side exhaust gas temperature and hot air temperature calculation method, boiler efficiency and coal consumption rate calculation method after the inlet air temperature is increased, practical calculation method of boiler efficiency and auxiliary power consumption and plant power rate calculation method;
[0023] The benefit calculation method corresponding to the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system includes calculation methods for multiple indicators, including: boiler efficiency calculation method, hot air temperature calculation method, air preheater thermal calculation method, air preheater bypass flue high temperature economizer exhaust steam extraction efficiency calculation method and coal saving efficiency calculation method.
[0024] Optionally, the coal saving rate is verified, and if the verification result does not meet the preset requirements, the benefit calculation method corresponding to the verification result that does not meet the preset requirements is adjusted until the verification result meets the preset requirements.
[0025] On the other hand, the present invention also proposes a coal saving system based on a flue gas recovery system, comprising:
[0026] A screening module for determining the benefit calculation methods applicable to various target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers;
[0027] A first calculation module is used to calculate the first amount of coal used when each target flue gas recovery system is used together with a large boiler under the condition of producing the same benefits, and calculate the second amount of coal used in the historical use of the large boiler under the condition of producing the same benefits;
[0028] A second calculation module is used to determine, based on the first coal amount and the second coal amount, a coal saving rate when each target flue gas recovery system is used together with a large boiler relative to a historical use condition of the large boiler;
[0029] The third calculation module is used to determine the first cost reduced by the coal saving rate, and to determine the second cost increased when the target flue gas recovery system and the large boiler are used together after converting from the historical use of the large boiler. The target flue gas recovery system and the large boiler corresponding to the first cost whose first cost is greater than the second cost and whose difference is greater than the preset range are selected for use, so as to save coal when the large boiler generates benefits.
[0030] Optionally, by determining the types of the target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers, a benefit calculation method applicable to a variety of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers is determined.
[0031] Optionally, the flue gas recovery system includes at least one of the following: a conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, a heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system, and an air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system;
[0032] Among them, the benefit calculation method used by each of the flue gas recovery systems corresponds to a plurality of benefit calculation systems. Before determining the benefit calculation method applicable to a plurality of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers, the benefit calculation system is determined. After determining the benefit calculation system, the benefit calculation method applicable to a plurality of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers is determined according to the benefit calculation system.
[0033] The benefit calculation system includes:
[0034] For each benefit calculation system, the benefit calculation system is verified using the same input data to determine the accuracy of each benefit calculation system, and the benefit calculation system that best meets the accuracy requirements is used as the benefit calculation system used by the flue gas recovery system;
[0035] The benefit calculation system used as a flue gas recovery system meets the preset selection criteria.
[0036] Optionally, the benefit calculation methods corresponding to the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, the heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system and the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system all include multiple calculation modes, and all include calculation methods for multiple indicators and multiple constraints;
[0037] Among them, the benefit calculation method and the calculation mode used are selected according to the actual sampling data of the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, the heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system and the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system;
[0038] The benefit calculation method corresponding to the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system includes calculation methods for multiple indicators, including: heat consumption change calculation method, auxiliary power consumption calculation method, and plant power consumption rate and power supply coal saving rate calculation method;
[0039] The benefit calculation method corresponding to the cascade utilization system of the heater plus low-temperature economizer includes calculation methods of multiple indicators, including: basic indicator calculation method, boiler side exhaust gas temperature and hot air temperature calculation method, boiler efficiency and coal consumption rate calculation method after the inlet air temperature is increased, practical calculation method of boiler efficiency and auxiliary power consumption and plant power rate calculation method;
[0040] The benefit calculation method corresponding to the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system includes calculation methods for multiple indicators, including: boiler efficiency calculation method, hot air temperature calculation method, air preheater thermal calculation method, air preheater bypass flue high temperature economizer exhaust steam extraction efficiency calculation method and coal saving efficiency calculation method.
[0041] Optionally, the coal saving rate is verified, and if the verification result does not meet the preset requirements, the benefit calculation method corresponding to the verification result that does not meet the preset requirements is adjusted until the verification result meets the preset requirements.
[0042] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following beneficial effects:
[0043] The present invention provides a coal-saving method based on a flue gas recovery system, comprising: determining a benefit calculation method applicable to a plurality of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers for a plurality of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers; using the benefit calculation method, calculating a first amount of coal used when each target flue gas recovery system and large boiler are used together under the condition of producing the same benefit, and calculating a second amount of coal used when the large boiler is used in history under the condition of producing the same benefit; determining a coal-saving rate when each target flue gas recovery system and large boiler are used together relative to the historical use of the large boiler based on the first amount of coal and the second amount of coal; determining a first cost reduced by the coal-saving rate, and determining a second cost increased when the target flue gas recovery system and large boiler are used together when converted from the historical use of the large boiler, and selecting a target flue gas recovery system and large boiler corresponding to the first cost whose first cost is greater than the second cost and whose difference is greater than a preset range for use, so as to save coal when the large boiler generates benefits. The present invention establishes a flue gas waste heat recovery benefit calculation system, which has practical value for accurately applying domestic and foreign boiler specifications to calculate coal consumption and avoid repeated calculation or omission of coal-saving benefits, and also helps to improve the level of coal-saving calculation of flue gas waste heat utilization systems. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0044] Figure 1 is a flow chart of the method of the present invention;
[0045] Figure 2 It is a structural diagram of the system of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0046] Now, exemplary embodiments of the present invention are described with reference to the accompanying drawings. However, the present invention can be implemented in many different forms and is not limited to the embodiments described herein. These embodiments are provided to disclose the present invention in detail and completely and to fully convey the scope of the present invention to those skilled in the art. The terms used in the exemplary embodiments shown in the accompanying drawings are not intended to limit the present invention. In the accompanying drawings, the same units / elements are marked with the same reference numerals.
[0047] Unless otherwise specified, the terms (including technical terms) used herein have the commonly understood meanings to those skilled in the art. In addition, it is understood that the terms defined in commonly used dictionaries should be understood to have the same meanings as those in the context of the relevant fields, and should not be understood as idealized or overly formal meanings.
[0048] Embodiment 1:
[0049] The present invention proposes a coal saving method based on a flue gas recovery system, such as Figure 1 As shown, including:
[0050] Step 1: Determine the benefit calculation method applicable to various target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers;
[0051] Step 2: using the benefit calculation method, calculate the first amount of coal used when each target flue gas recovery system is used together with a large boiler under the condition of producing the same benefit, and calculate the second amount of coal used in the historical use of the large boiler under the condition of producing the same benefit;
[0052] Step 3: Based on the first coal amount and the second coal amount, determine the coal saving rate when each target flue gas recovery system is used together with a large boiler relative to the historical use of the large boiler;
[0053] Step 4, determine the first cost reduced by the coal saving rate, and determine the second cost increased when converting from the historical use of the large boiler to the use of the target flue gas recovery system and the large boiler together, select the target flue gas recovery system and large boiler corresponding to the first cost whose first cost is greater than the second cost and the difference is greater than the preset range, so as to save coal when the large boiler generates benefits.
[0054] Among them, by determining the types of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers, a benefit calculation method applicable to a variety of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers is determined.
[0055] The flue gas recovery system includes at least one of the following: a conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, a heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system, and an air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system;
[0056] Among them, the benefit calculation method used by each of the flue gas recovery systems corresponds to a plurality of benefit calculation systems. Before determining the benefit calculation method applicable to a plurality of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers, the benefit calculation system is determined. After determining the benefit calculation system, the benefit calculation method applicable to a plurality of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers is determined according to the benefit calculation system.
[0057] The benefit calculation system includes:
[0058] For each benefit calculation system, the benefit calculation system is verified using the same input data to determine the accuracy of each benefit calculation system, and the benefit calculation system that best meets the accuracy requirements is used as the benefit calculation system used by the flue gas recovery system;
[0059] The benefit calculation system used as a flue gas recovery system meets the preset selection criteria.
[0060] Among them, the benefit calculation methods corresponding to the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, the heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system and the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system all include multiple calculation modes, and all include calculation methods for multiple indicators and multiple constraints;
[0061] Among them, the benefit calculation method and the calculation mode used are selected according to the actual sampling data of the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, the heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system and the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system;
[0062] The benefit calculation method corresponding to the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system includes calculation methods for multiple indicators, including: heat consumption change calculation method, auxiliary power consumption calculation method, and plant power consumption rate and power supply coal saving rate calculation method;
[0063] The benefit calculation method corresponding to the cascade utilization system of the heater plus low-temperature economizer includes calculation methods of multiple indicators, including: basic indicator calculation method, boiler side exhaust gas temperature and hot air temperature calculation method, boiler efficiency and coal consumption rate calculation method after the inlet air temperature is increased, practical calculation method of boiler efficiency and auxiliary power consumption and plant power rate calculation method;
[0064] The benefit calculation method corresponding to the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system includes calculation methods for multiple indicators, including: boiler efficiency calculation method, hot air temperature calculation method, air preheater thermal calculation method, air preheater bypass flue high temperature economizer exhaust steam extraction efficiency calculation method and coal saving efficiency calculation method.
[0065] The coal saving rate is verified, and if the verification result does not meet the preset requirements, the benefit calculation method corresponding to the verification result that does not meet the preset requirements is adjusted until the verification result meets the preset requirements.
[0066] In the process of implementing the present invention, the selection of the benefit calculation method is a difficult point, so it is necessary to reasonably select the calculation system, which includes: boiler efficiency (improvement) calculation system, 1 There are two calculation definitions according to different thermal balance boundary conditions: the first is to calculate the efficiency according to the exhaust gas temperature at the outlet of the low-temperature economizer. This calculation regards the economizer as a part of the boiler, and the heat caused by the reduction in the exhaust gas temperature is used as the benefit of the effective heat on the boiler side. The second method still calculates the boiler efficiency according to the exhaust gas temperature at the outlet of the air preheater. The heat of the low-temperature economizer is still regarded as a part of the exhaust gas heat loss on the boiler side, and the low-temperature economizer is regarded as a part of the turbine heat recovery cycle, so that the flue gas heat loss is provided to the turbine as waste heat; according to this classification, the boiler efficiency is unchanged whether a low-temperature economizer is installed. 2 In the calculation system with the boiler as the main body of analysis, it is necessary to simultaneously consider the increase in cold end losses caused by the exclusion of the low-pressure extraction steam of the turbine.
[0067] There are also two definitions of the steam turbine heat rate (reduction) calculation system: the first is to regard the low-pressure economizer to increase the condensing water temperature and reduce the heat of the heat recovery extraction steam as the waste heat of the boiler. The steam turbine obtains the "free" low-temperature economizer heat, which reduces the heat rate; the second is that this heat is supplied to the steam turbine as the effective heat of the boiler. In the heat rate calculation, this heat should be added to the total input heat like the superheat and reheat from the boiler; obviously according to this definition, the heat rate of the steam turbine will increase when a low-temperature economizer is used (because the quality of the added heat is too low and the converted electrical power is small).
[0068] In principle, the present invention should be selected according to the nature of the project: 1) For power plants, the steam turbine (heat consumption reduction) calculation system should be selected; 2) For heating projects, only the boiler (efficiency increase) calculation system can be selected.
[0069] (2) Specific selection should be made according to the different characteristics of the waste heat utilization scheme: 1 For the scheme where the flue gas waste heat is used to heat the steam turbine heat recovery system (such as the traditional low-temperature economizer system), the heat absorbed by the low-temperature economizer is not directly returned to the boiler, and the steam turbine heat consumption reduction analysis system should be used; 2 For the scheme where the flue gas waste heat is used to heat the boiler combustion air, the boiler efficiency improvement analysis system should be used; 3 For the scheme where the flue gas waste heat is used to heat both the steam turbine heat recovery system and the boiler combustion air (such as the heater + low-temperature economizer scheme), the boiler efficiency improvement analysis system + steam turbine heat consumption reduction analysis system should be used respectively; 4 For the air preheater bypass flue duct scheme, the flue gas waste heat input-output heat balance calculation system should be used.
[0070] (3) For the flue gas waste heat utilization system coupled with the turbine and boiler, the flue gas waste heat cannot be completely analyzed according to the turbine heat consumption reduction analysis system or the boiler efficiency improvement analysis system; it is advisable to calculate the efficiency change on the boiler side and the heat consumption change on the turbine side separately according to the input-output heat balance principle of the flue gas waste heat, that is, to adopt the input-output heat balance calculation system.
[0071] The selection of the calculation system and the calculation method in the present invention are described below in conjunction with the embodiments:
[0072] The calculation system is defined as follows:
[0073] (1) Boiler efficiency (improvement) calculation system:
[0074] There are two calculation definitions according to different heat balance boundary conditions: the first is to calculate the efficiency according to the flue gas temperature at the outlet of the low-temperature economizer. This calculation regards the economizer as a part of the boiler and the heat of the reduced flue gas temperature as the effective heat gain on the boiler side. The second is to calculate the boiler efficiency according to the flue gas temperature at the outlet of the air preheater. The heat of the low-temperature economizer is still regarded as a part of the flue gas heat loss on the boiler side, and the low-temperature economizer is regarded as a part of the turbine heat recovery cycle, so that the flue gas heat loss is provided to the turbine as waste heat; according to this classification, the boiler efficiency is unchanged whether a low-temperature economizer is installed or not.
[0075] In the calculation system with the boiler as the main analysis subject, the increase in cold-end loss caused by the exclusion of the low-pressure extraction steam of the turbine must be considered at the same time.
[0076] (2) There are also two definitions for the calculation system of heat rate (reduction) of steam turbine: the first is to regard the heat of the low-pressure economizer that increases the condensing water temperature and reduces the heat of the heat extraction steam as the waste heat of the boiler. The steam turbine obtains the "free" heat of the low-temperature economizer, which reduces the heat rate; the second is that this heat is supplied to the steam turbine as the effective heat of the boiler. In the heat rate calculation, this heat should be added to the total input heat like the superheat and reheat from the boiler; obviously according to this definition, the heat rate of the steam turbine increases when the low-temperature economizer is used (because the added heat is too low and the converted electric power is small). Taking the low-temperature economizer heat of 33.61MW of the 660MW unit as an example, the heat rates of the steam turbine calculated according to these two definitions are 7032kJ / kWh and 7198kJ / kWh respectively, with a relative difference of +2.35%.
[0077] The calculation system selection criteria are as follows:
[0078] (1) Select by project nature:
[0079] For power plants, it is advisable to use the steam turbine (heat consumption reduction) calculation system;
[0080] For heating projects, only the boiler (efficiency increase) calculation system can be used.
[0081] (2) Specific selection should be made according to the different characteristics of waste heat utilization schemes:
[0082] For the scheme of using flue gas waste heat to heat the steam turbine heat recovery system (such as the traditional low-temperature economizer system), the heat absorbed by the low-temperature economizer is not directly returned to the boiler, and the steam turbine heat consumption reduction analysis system should be used;
[0083] For the scheme where flue gas waste heat is used to heat the boiler combustion air, a boiler efficiency improvement analysis system should be used;
[0084] For the scheme where flue gas waste heat is used to heat both the steam turbine reheat system and the boiler combustion air (such as the heater + low-temperature economizer scheme), the boiler efficiency improvement analysis system + steam turbine heat consumption reduction analysis system should be selected respectively;
[0085] For the air preheater bypass flue solution, the flue gas waste heat input-output heat balance calculation system should be used.
[0086] (3) For the flue gas waste heat utilization system coupled with the turbine and boiler, the flue gas waste heat cannot be completely analyzed according to the turbine heat consumption reduction analysis system or the boiler efficiency improvement analysis system; according to the input-output heat balance principle of flue gas waste heat, the efficiency change on the boiler side and the heat consumption change on the turbine side are calculated separately, that is, the input-output heat balance calculation system is adopted.
[0087] Calculation method of traditional low temperature economizer system:
[0088] The basic calculation methods include the following:
[0089] Computational analysis system selection, including:
[0090] In the two thermal economic analysis systems, the steam turbine heat rate reduction analysis system and the boiler efficiency improvement analysis system, the boiler efficiency improvement analysis system needs to calculate the improvement of the efficiency of the commissioned boiler and the change of the steam turbine heat rate at the same time, which is relatively complicated in both theoretical analysis and field tests. The steam turbine heat rate reduction analysis system belongs to the traditional steam turbine performance calculation method, which can directly reflect the impact of the commissioning of the low-temperature economizer on the thermal economy of the unit. This report analyzes the traditional low-temperature economizer system according to the steam turbine heat rate reduction analysis system.
[0091] Coal saving rate calculation, including:
[0092] (1) Savings in standard coal consumption for power generation △b f Calculate according to the following formula:
[0093]
[0094] Where △q is the reduction value of the heat rate of the steam turbine, kJ / kwh; η g , η p is the boiler efficiency and pipeline efficiency; R h is the thermal equivalent value, according to GB / T2589-2009 "General Rules for Comprehensive Energy Consumption Calculation" take Rh =4.1868, that is, the calorific value of 1kg standard coal is 7000R h =29307kJ / kg.
[0095] (2) Savings in standard coal consumption for power supply △b g Calculate according to the following formula:
[0096]
[0097] in, p e They are the power consumption rate of the plant before and after the flue gas waste heat recovery system is put into operation, %;
[0098] The calculation method of heat rate change includes:
[0099] Calculation standard of equivalent enthalpy drop method:
[0100] Calculation conditions (constraints), including:
[0101] Based on the constant steam inlet volume of the steam turbine;
[0102] The new steam parameters, reheat steam parameters, final parameters and various extraction steam parameters are all known and remain unchanged;
[0103] The exhaust heat recovered from the low-temperature economizer is input into the heat recovery system as pure heat q. Under this premise, all the additional power generated by exhaust steam extraction in the thermal system will improve the efficiency of the steam turbine.
[0104] The additional work generated by all exhaust steam extraction (denoted as ΔH) is called the equivalent enthalpy drop increment;
[0105] The calculation of the equivalent enthalpy drop H of fresh steam includes:
[0106] The total work done by 1 kg of fresh steam in the steam turbine is called the fresh steam equivalent enthalpy drop (denoted as H). Theoretically, it can be calculated according to the equivalent enthalpy drop formula, but in engineering, it can be directly calculated according to the turbine heat balance diagram as follows:
[0107] H=3600N / D0=3600 / d0 kJ / kg; (3)
[0108] Among them, N, D0, and d0 are electric power (kW), new steam consumption (kg / h), and new steam consumption (kg / kWh), respectively.
[0109] Calculation of equivalent enthalpy drop increment ΔH: Calculation is performed based on two systems: series or parallel on the water side:
[0110] (1) The calculation formula for the condensate series system is as follows:
[0111]
[0112] Among them, Q d is the heat load of the low-temperature economizer, kJ / s; q d is the unit heat load of the low-temperature economizer, kJ / kg;
[0113] D C Main condensate flow, kg / s; h d 、h' d is the specific enthalpy of water inlet and outlet of low-pressure economizer, kJ / kg; D0 is the main steam flow rate, kJ / s; η j It is the extraction efficiency of the j-stage low-pressure heater excluded in the series system.
[0114] (2) The calculation formula for the condensate parallel system is as follows:
[0115]
[0116] Among them, β d is the low-temperature economizer flow coefficient, i.e., water separation rate; h' d is the outlet water specific enthalpy of low-pressure economizer, kJ / kg; h m-1 is the outlet water specific enthalpy of No.m-1 heater in the parallel system, kJ / kg; η m is the extraction efficiency of the m-stage low-pressure heater that is excluded in the parallel system; τ r is the enthalpy rise of the low-process mass bypassed at each level in the parallel system, kJ / kg; η r It is the extraction efficiency of each level of low-pressure heater bypassed in the parallel system.
[0117] Calculation of extraction efficiency and extraction equivalent enthalpy drop (steam side), including:
[0118] (1) Extraction efficiency, calculated by the following formula:
[0119]
[0120] Among them, H j is the extraction steam equivalent enthalpy drop, kJ / kg; q j is the heat input of flue gas, kJ / kg;
[0121] (2) The equivalent enthalpy drop of extraction steam is calculated as follows:
[0122]
[0123] Among them, h j is the specific enthalpy of extraction steam at stage j, kJ / kg; h n is the exhaust steam specific enthalpy, kJ / kg; q r is the heat released by the bypassed extraction steam at each stage, kJ / kg; kJ / kg; H ris the enthalpy drop of the bypassed extraction steam at each stage, kJ / kg; H r =h r -h c , kJ / kg; A r It is the enthalpy rise of the bypassed low-pressure heaters (for drain-discharge type LP heaters) or the reduction of drain heat release (for drain-convergence type LP heaters), kJ / kg; the heaters are divided into two types according to the drain system: 1) drain-discharge type heaters and 2) drain-convergence type heaters for calculation;
[0124] The calculation formula used by the drain discharge heater (assuming j is a drain discharge heater) is as follows:
[0125] From j below to (including) the drain collector heater is calculated using the following formula:
[0126]
[0127] Drainage collection heaters are as follows: Whether it is a discharge heater or a collection heater, the following formula is used for calculation:
[0128]
[0129] The calculation formula used for the drain collector heater is as follows:
[0130]
[0131] The general formula for calculating the increase in the equivalent enthalpy drop of new steam, △H, is as follows:
[0132] Low temperature economizer heat load q d , the calculation formula is as follows:
[0133]
[0134] Among them, Q d is the heat load of low-temperature economizer, kJ / s; D is the new steam consumption, kg / s.
[0135] The calculation formula for the increase in the equivalent enthalpy drop of new steam in the condensate series system is as follows:
[0136] △H=q d η j (12)
[0137] Among them, η j is the steam extraction efficiency used for the No.j energy level heater.
[0138] The calculation formula for the increase in the equivalent enthalpy drop of new steam in the condensate parallel system is as follows:
[0139] △H=q d η jp(13)
[0140] Among them, η jp is the average steam extraction efficiency of heat utilization of low-temperature economizer.
[0141] The reduction of steam turbine heat rate △q is calculated as follows:
[0142] △q=ΔH·q / H kJ / kwh (14)
[0143] Where q is the unit heat rate, kJ / kwh.
[0144] Thermal system device efficiency improvement rate δη i , the calculation formula is as follows:
[0145]
[0146] Savings in standard coal consumption for power generation △b f Calculate according to the following formula (boiler efficiency remains unchanged):
[0147] △b f =b f ×δη i g / kwh (16)
[0148] Among them, b f is the original power generation coal consumption rate, g / kwh.
[0149] The application criteria of the equivalent enthalpy drop method in the present invention: the use conditions of the equivalent enthalpy drop method cannot be deviated from and the alienated equivalent enthalpy drop formula cannot be adopted;
[0150] The equivalent enthalpy drop method provides a simple and feasible calculation method for the energy-saving evaluation of waste heat utilization. However, it can be seen from the derivation process that the calculation of the equivalent enthalpy drop is based on the premise that the new steam flow rate remains unchanged. In addition, when there is pure heat input to the heat recovery system, the amount of steam to be squeezed out is limited to the steam that bypasses the heaters of these stages. There is no squeezing effect on the steam of the lower pressure level downstream. The steam extraction volume is slightly increased due to the loss of the hydrophobic heat returned by the squeezing steam extraction stage. The use of the equivalent enthalpy drop calculation method in some literature deviates from the above law, which is bound to cause deviations in the calculation data.
[0151] Corrections for the application of the equivalent enthalpy drop method:
[0152] Correction of the effect of turbine back pressure on unit heat rate:
[0153] (1) The equivalent heat drop method is a local calculation method for constant flow. This method assumes that the enthalpy value of each point in the thermal system remains unchanged, that is, the exhaust steam enthalpy value remains unchanged. Therefore, when using the equivalent heat drop method to calculate the thermal economy of the flue gas waste heat system, the changes in exhaust steam pressure and enthalpy value are generally not considered. However, after the low-temperature economizer or medium-temperature economizer is put into operation, the exhaust steam flow rate increases due to the exhaust steam entering the condenser, which is an objective fact. It is still necessary to make corrections for this.
[0154] (2) Calculation method: The effect of increased turbine back pressure on the work done by the unit can be considered from two aspects. First, the exhaust enthalpy increases, causing the effective enthalpy drop of the unit to decrease. Second, the condensate temperature increases, which squeezes out the last stage of low-pressure heater extraction steam and increases the work done by the turbine.
[0155] Steam turbine extraction port pressure correction:
[0156] (1) The introduction of waste heat into the thermal system puts the steam turbine in a variable operating state: The equivalent enthalpy drop method provides a simple and easy calculation method for the energy-saving evaluation of waste heat utilization, but its premise is that the mass flow rate of new steam remains unchanged; in fact, when external pure heat is introduced into the heat recovery system, it will inevitably squeeze out the mass flow rate of the heat recovery extraction steam, causing the mass flow rate of the unit condensing steam to increase; if it is desired to maintain the exhaust pressure, while the parameters and mass flow rate of the new steam remain unchanged, according to the Flugel formula, the steam extraction port pressure will increase with the increase of the subsequent condensing steam mass flow rate, resulting in insufficient steam expansion of each stage of the upstream steam turbine, indicating that the waste heat entering the thermal system puts the steam turbine in a variable operating state. Therefore, simply calculating the increased electric power of waste heat utilization through the formula of the equivalent enthalpy drop method will deviate from reality. That is, the equivalent enthalpy drop method should be improved according to the variable operating condition characteristic analysis method.
[0157] Calculation method of heat balance diagram of steam turbine under variable operating conditions:
[0158] The traditional thermal system analysis method is the calculation method of the variable operating condition heat balance diagram of the steam turbine. After the installation of the low-temperature economizer, not only the steam extraction share of the steam turbine will change, but also the pressure, temperature and flow rate of the steam extraction point will change with the flow rate of each stage of the steam turbine, and then the corresponding parameters of the heat recovery system will also change, so it is necessary to calculate the variable operating condition of the steam turbine; the main changes considered at this time are as follows:
[0159] (1) Calculation of steam turbine extraction port pressure:
[0160] The flow capacity of each stage group depends on the relevant parameters before and after the stage group, and the specific relationship can be obtained according to the Flugel formula.
[0161] (2) Calculation of regenerative heater:
[0162] Based on the calculation method of the drain discharge heater and the collecting heater, after the extraction pressure is obtained, the saturated pressure and saturated temperature of the heater are obtained according to the extraction pressure loss from each extraction port to the heater, and then the inlet and outlet condensate temperature of the heater and the corresponding drain temperature are calculated according to the difference between the upper and lower ends of the heater.
[0163] Finally, other thermal parameters are obtained based on the conservation of flow and heat.
[0164] (3) Calculation of condenser variable operating conditions:
[0165] Since the low-temperature economizer system is a low-grade waste heat power recovery and utilization system, the waste heat has poor work capacity, and most of the recovered waste heat is discharged into the condenser cooling water as cold source loss. Therefore, it is necessary to calculate the condenser variable operating conditions. Based on the main structural parameters and design operating parameters of the condenser, the condenser variable operating condition calculation software 1461 established by the HEI standard can be used to calculate the impact of the condenser heat load change on the unit exhaust pressure and unit output, etc. The specific calculation formula is as follows:
[0166] Q=K×S×△T (17)
[0167] K=K S ×F W ×F M ×F C (18)
[0168] Where, Q is the heat load of the condenser, kW; S is the heat exchange area of the condenser, m 2 ; ΔT is the logarithmic heat transfer temperature difference of the condenser, ℃; K, K W are the condenser heat transfer coefficient and the condenser basic heat transfer coefficient, kW / (m 2 ℃); F W ,F M ,F C are the inlet water temperature correction factor, pipe correction factor and cleanliness factor respectively.
[0169] (4) Calculation of auxiliary steam and water loss:
[0170] The auxiliary steam-water loss such as valve stem leakage and shaft seal leakage of high, medium and low pressure cylinders in the steam turbine system accounts for a very small proportion of the main steam flow. In the variable operating condition calculation, according to the corresponding data in the heat balance diagram under different operating conditions, the corresponding parameters at the steam source or the change value of the main steam flow are fitted and obtained. If the change is not large, it can also be taken as a fixed value.
[0171] (5) Iterative calculation of thermal system:
[0172] Calculation is performed sequentially according to the steam process. First, the extraction steam pressure and the corresponding heater condensate inlet temperature are assumed. Then, the corresponding extraction steam flow rate is calculated based on the mass conservation and heat conservation of the heater. Finally, the new extraction steam pressure is calculated based on the flow fitting formula and compared with the assumed value. After multiple iterations, the error requirements are met.
[0173] The same calculation method is used to iterate the calculation of the next stage of steam extraction. The corresponding heater condensate outlet temperature is obtained according to the fixed heater end difference, that is, the inlet temperature of the previous stage heater, and compared with the assumed value of the previous stage. After multiple iterations, the error requirements are met. Note that when calculating the last stage heater, it is necessary to reversely calculate the condensate temperature from the condenser to the last stage heater.
[0174] Heat rate test method:
[0175] In order to verify the actual coal-saving benefits of the low-temperature economizer system, on-site performance tests can be conducted to determine the unit heat rate and coal-saving rate under different load conditions when the system is in operation and shut down, and directly compare the economic efficiency of the unit's thermal system.
[0176] In the present invention, the low temperature economizer system connection is optimized, including:
[0177] Optimization of connection methods in condensate water system:
[0178] 1) Two connection methods: There are two connection methods for low-temperature economizers in the condensate system: series connection and parallel connection. Different connection methods lead to different analysis and calculation methods and different operating safety and economy.
[0179] 2) Low-temperature economizer series system: All condensate enters the low-pressure economizer from the outlet of the low-pressure heater No.7, and the heat absorbed by the low-pressure economizer is all returned to the No.6 low-pressure heater inlet. From the perspective of the condensate system, it is equivalent to connecting a heater in series between two low-pressure heaters. The advantage of the series system is that the amount of condensate flowing through the low-pressure economizer is the largest. Under the condition that the water intake position, water intake parameters and heat exchange area remain unchanged, the heat exchange capacity of the low-pressure economizer is large, and the utilization rate of the boiler exhaust waste heat is high; the disadvantage is that a heater is added to the condensate system, the flow resistance on the water side increases, and the condensate pump pressure head increases; and because all the condensate flows through the low-pressure economizer, its adjustability is not strong. Under the condition of variable load or change in coal quality, the condensate flow cannot be effectively adjusted to adapt to the change in boiler exhaust temperature and prevent low-temperature corrosion.
[0180] 3) Low-pressure economizer parallel system: Part of the condensate enters the low-pressure economizer from the outlet of the low-pressure heater No. 7. After absorbing heat, it returns to the inlet of the low-pressure heater No. 6 or other high-level return water points to merge with the main condensate according to the temperature of the heated condensate. From the perspective of the condensate system, it is equivalent to connecting a heater in parallel to the bypassed low-pressure heater. There can also be multiple heaters in parallel. Advantages of the parallel system (1) The water side flow resistance of the entire condensate system is small; (2) The condensate volume can be adjusted, which increases the adjustability of the low-pressure economizer system; (3) It is convenient to realize the cascade development and utilization of waste heat; (4) The low-pressure economizer parallel system is an independent bypass, which is convenient for maintenance and shutdown when necessary. Its main disadvantage is that the amount of condensate flowing through the low-pressure economizer is less than the total condensate volume. When the water intake position, water intake parameters and heat exchange area are unchanged, the heat exchange capacity of the parallel system cannot reach the maximum.
[0181] Process design optimization constraints include the following:
[0182] The constraints of some parameters in process design optimization are as follows:
[0183] (1) Water separation rate: The water separation rate cannot be too large, otherwise the amount of condensate flowing through the corresponding low-pressure heater will be too small, affecting the safe operation of the low-pressure heater. The water separation rate is required to be no less than 0.5; the water separation rate cannot be too small, otherwise the amount of condensate flowing through the low-pressure economizer will be too small, which is easy to cause flow deviation and thermal deviation. The condensate flow rate in the heated tube bundle is required to be greater than 0.3m / s:
[0184] Note: The influence of water separation rate on coal saving rate and the law of optimal water separation rate can be found in one of the special reports.
[0185] (2) Condensate inlet temperature: To effectively avoid flue gas water dew point corrosion, the condensate inlet temperature is set at 20°C above the water dew point;
[0186] (3) Increased flue gas resistance: After installing a low-pressure economizer, the flue gas resistance will increase, but the subsequent flue gas volume flow rate will decrease, and the flue gas resistance of the downstream equipment will decrease. After comprehensive calculation, the total resistance increase is required to be less than the pressure head margin of the existing induced draft fan.
[0187] (4) Flue gas velocity outside the tube bundle: For the solution where the low-temperature economizer is located before the electrostatic precipitator, the flue gas has a high ash concentration and is more sensitive to wear. The wear rate is closely related to the flue gas velocity. The flue gas velocity can be controlled within 8 m / s by adjusting the reasonable extended flue size and the horizontal and vertical spacing of the tube bundle.
[0188] Calculation of auxiliary power consumption:
[0189] Calculation of auxiliary power consumption of flue gas waste heat recovery system, including:
[0190] The power consumption of auxiliary equipment matched with low-temperature economizer usually includes the following categories: 1) Power consumption of induced draft fan caused by heat exchanger resistance; 2) Power consumption of circulating pump caused by the use of water medium system on the condensate side or flue gas side; 3) When the low-temperature economizer is installed upstream of the induced draft fan, the power consumption of the induced draft fan is reduced due to the reduction of flue gas temperature; 4) When the low-temperature economizer is installed upstream of the electrostatic precipitator, the power consumption is increased due to the improvement of the efficiency of the electrostatic precipitator; 5) Because the exhaust steam is discharged to the condenser, the amount of condensate increases. According to the equivalent enthalpy drop method, the back pressure of the turbine remains unchanged. At this time, it is necessary to increase the cooling water flow, improve the operating output of the circulating water pump, and increase the power consumption of the circulating water pump.
[0191] Calculation of auxiliary power consumption changes:
[0192] (1) Change in power consumption on the flue gas side of the induced draft fan △N ID , the calculation formula is as follows:
[0193]
[0194] or
[0195] Among them, N ID is the original shaft power of the induced draft fan, kW; △H ECO is the flue gas side resistance of the low-temperature economizer (including the inlet and outlet flues), Pa; H ID is the original total pressure head of the induced draft fan, Pa; φ p is the gas compressibility coefficient; △T ECO is the temperature drop of flue gas side of low temperature economizer, ℃; T ID is the original inlet temperature of the induced draft fan, °C; Q S is the flue gas flow rate on the induced draft fan side, m 3 / s; η ID is the efficiency of the induced draft fan.
[0196] When the low-temperature economizer is on the downstream side of the induced draft fan, the temperature drop on the flue gas side of the low-temperature economizer is not calculated in the above formula.
[0197] (2) Power consumption of condensate system △N COND , the calculation formula is as follows:
[0198]
[0199] Among them, Q C is the condensate pump flow rate, m 3 / s; △H C Change of pressure head on the main condensate side, kPa; η C is the condensate pump efficiency.
[0200] When the working pressure head of the main condensate pump does not increase due to the commissioning of the flue gas waste heat recovery system and the throttling regulation method is adopted, this item can be ignored.
[0201] (3) Power consumption of water medium circulation pump △N MC , the calculation formula is as follows:
[0202]
[0203] Among them, Q MC is the flow rate of water medium circulation pump, m 3 / s; △H MC is the water medium circulation pump pressure head, kPa; η MC is the efficiency of the pump.
[0204] (4) Electricity consumption of electrostatic precipitator △N EP , the calculation formula is as follows:
[0205] △N EP =N EP -N EP.0 (twenty three)
[0206] Among them, N EP is the original power consumption of the electrostatic precipitator, kW; N EP.0 It is the power consumption of the electrostatic precipitator when it operates in low temperature mode, kW.
[0207] The power consumption is determined based on the cooling conditions according to experience or manufacturer's data. Generally, the power consumption of dust removal increases with the improvement of efficiency.
[0208] When the low-temperature economizer is on the downstream side of the electrostatic precipitator, this item is not calculated.
[0209] (5) Increase in power consumption of circulating water pump of main condenser of steam turbine △N CW The calculation formula is as follows:
[0210] △N CW =[(1+△a c / a c ) 3 -1]×N CW (twenty four)
[0211] Among them, △a c / a c is the rate of change of condensing steam mass flow rate; N CW Power consumption of main condenser circulating water pump, kW.
[0212] (6) Total change of auxiliary power consumption, calculated as follows:
[0213] △N P =△N ID +△N COND +△N CW +△N EP (25)
[0214] Change in coal consumption corresponding to change in auxiliary power consumption △b P The calculation formula is as follows:
[0215]
[0216] Calculation method of plant power consumption rate and power supply coal saving rate:
[0217] For the plant power consumption rate and power supply coal saving rate, it is necessary to distinguish the following two different calculation methods.
[0218] Compared with the flue gas waste heat recovery system when it is put into operation and not in operation: for the low-temperature economizer system installed in front of the induced draft fan, the actual plant power consumption rate under the operation condition is relatively low, and the power supply coal saving rate may be lower than the power generation coal saving rate.
[0219] Compared with the case where the flue gas waste heat recovery system is installed, the plant power consumption rate increases, and the power supply coal saving rate is always lower than the power generation coal saving rate.
[0220] Calculation method for flue gas waste heat recovery system of low temperature economizer + air heater type:
[0221] Basic calculation methods, including:
[0222] Computational analysis system selection:
[0223] A flue gas waste heat input-output heat balance analysis system is selected.
[0224] The flue gas waste heat input-output heat balance equation is as follows:
[0225] The process structure includes: (1) a low-temperature economizer is arranged downstream of the air preheater to recover the waste heat of the flue gas and transfer it to the turbine heat recovery system to heat the condensate; the heat absorbed by the flue gas is (Q g,2 -Q g,3 ); (2) Water-based air heater, which recovers the waste heat of flue gas and transfers it to cold air. The heat absorbed by flue gas is (Q g,3 -Q g,4 ).
[0226] The heat balance equations for the boiler and steam turbine are listed separately as follows:
[0227] A. Boiler side:
[0228] (1) “Air heater + low-temperature economizer” not in operation: Establish the flue gas waste heat input-output heat balance equation, the formula is as follows:
[0229] Input side, fuel calorific value + cold air enthalpy + economizer feed water enthalpy:
[0230]
[0231] On the output side, the total heat absorption enthalpy of the steam system + combustion and heat dissipation losses + exhaust enthalpy (air preheater outlet):
[0232]
[0233] Based on the above formula, we get:
[0234]
[0235] or
[0236] (2) Operational condition of the “air heater + low-temperature economizer” system: the exhaust gas temperature interface is the outlet of the water-based air heater.
[0237] Input side, fuel calorific value + cold air enthalpy + economizer feed water enthalpy:
[0238]
[0239] On the output side, the total heat absorption enthalpy of the steam system + combustion and heat dissipation losses + exhaust enthalpy (water-based heater outlet):
[0240]
[0241] Based on the above formula, we get:
[0242]
[0243] Among them, (Q g,3 -Q g,4 ) is the heat absorbed by the water-fuel air heater and is included in the heat input on the boiler side; The exhaust heat loss caused by the increase of exhaust temperature of air preheater after the heater heats the cold air; (Q g,2 -Q g,3 ) is the heat absorption of the low temperature economizer and is named Q LECO , included in the input heat on the steam turbine side.
[0244] Based on this, it is determined that the boiler efficiency changes as follows:
[0245]
[0246] like △η≥0, the boiler benefits. When the final exhaust gas temperature reaches about 90℃, especially when water-based air heaters are installed before and after the induced draft fan, the increase in boiler efficiency is more obvious.
[0247] B. Turbine side:
[0248] (1) “Air heater + low temperature economizer” not in operation:
[0249] On the input side, the total heat absorption enthalpy of the steam system is:
[0250] ∑(Dh) 0 (35)
[0251] Output side, electric power heat consumption + economizer feed water enthalpy:
[0252]
[0253] (2) “Air heater + low temperature economizer” operation conditions:
[0254] On the input side, the total heat absorption enthalpy of the steam system + the input heat of the low-temperature economizer:
[0255] ∑Dh+Q LECO (37)
[0256] Output side, electric power heat consumption + economizer feed water enthalpy:
[0257] qN+Q fw (38)
[0258] Based on the above formula, the new heat rate of the steam turbine is obtained, and the calculation formula is as follows:
[0259]
[0260] For the low-temperature economizer operation condition, the turbine output power increment is:
[0261] △N=Q LECO η j , (40)
[0262] Among them, η j is the steam extraction efficiency.
[0263] However, the heat input from the cycle endothermic heat in the numerator does not need to be included in the waste heat Q LECO , and the main steam flow is the same as before the low-temperature economizer is put into operation, the new heat consumption is reduced to:
[0264]
[0265] (4) From the above, we know that the heat consumption of the steam turbine will decrease at this time, although the heat absorption of the low-temperature economizer of the system Q LECO Usually lower than the traditional low-temperature economizer system, but because the exhaust gas temperature of this system is higher, it can squeeze out higher-level extraction steam, and its extraction efficiency η j The higher the value, the greater the reduction in heat rate on the turbine side may be.
[0266] Based on the above analysis results, it can be considered that for the "air heater + low-temperature economizer" system, both the boiler side and the steam turbine side may benefit, and the coal-saving benefits should be calculated separately; but the distribution of flue gas waste heat should be clarified, and not all waste heat can be attributed to the steam turbine side. At the same time, the boiler efficiency is calculated according to the final exhaust gas temperature to avoid repeated calculation of the boiler and turbine benefits.
[0267] Calculation method of heat consumption change on steam turbine side:
[0268] The calculation method of the heat consumption change △q1 on the turbine side corresponding to the low-temperature economizer + flue gas / water medium heater system and the partial heat recovery of the low-temperature economizer is the same as that of the traditional low-temperature economizer flue gas waste heat recovery system.
[0269] Low temperature economizer + steam / water heater system:
[0270] The change of heat consumption on the turbine side in this process consists of two parts:
[0271] 1) Change in heat consumption on the turbine side corresponding to the heat recovery of the low-temperature economizer △q ECO The calculation method is the same as that of the traditional low-temperature economizer flue gas waste heat recovery system.
[0272] 2) Heat consumption change of steam turbine side corresponding to the heat consumption of heater part △q SAH , the calculation method is the same as the traditional thermal system.
[0273] The total heat rate change is:
[0274] △q2=-△q ECO +△q SAH (42)
[0275] Calculation method of boiler side exhaust gas temperature and hot air temperature:
[0276] The calculation of the exhaust gas temperature of the air preheater after the inlet air temperature is increased includes:
[0277] Theoretical calculation method:
[0278] (1) Calculation of exhaust gas temperature:
[0279]
[0280] or θ py =Φ×t F +Ψ×θ y =Φ×t F +(1-Φ)×θ y (44)
[0281] Among them, θ py.0 ,θ py is the exhaust gas temperature of air preheater; ℃; θ y is the air preheater inlet flue gas temperature; ℃; t F.0 ,t F The cold air temperature at the air preheater inlet; ℃;
[0282] Φ,Ψ are thermal calculation parameters, and the formula is as follows:
[0283]
[0284]
[0285] And Ψ=1-Φ.
[0286] (2) Exhaust temperature increase △θ py =θ py -θ py0 Determined by the following formula:
[0287]
[0288] or △θ py =Φ×△t F +Ψ×△θ y (48)
[0289] Calculation of hot air temperature in air preheater after the inlet air temperature is increased:
[0290] Theoretical calculation formula:
[0291] Air preheater supply air temperature from t F0 Increase to t F The hot air temperature calculation equation is:
[0292]
[0293] t rF =U×t F +V×θ y (50)a
[0294] or
[0295] △t rF =U×△t F +V×△θ y (52)a
[0296] In the formula
[0297]
[0298] And V = 1-U;
[0299] Calculation method of boiler efficiency and coal consumption rate after the inlet air temperature is increased:
[0300] The derivation of the relationship between boiler coal consumption and air supply temperature is as follows:
[0301] (1) The general formula for calculating boiler coal consumption is as follows:
[0302]
[0303]
[0304] Among them, η, η o Boiler efficiency determined according to ASME PTC.4 and GB10184; Q net,ar , Q inp Low calorific value and input heat of coal.
[0305] The practical calculation method for the boiler efficiency of the low-temperature economizer + heater system is as follows:
[0306] Efficiency calculation mode A;
[0307] The method is based on the measured heat absorption of the heater;
[0308] The key points are: 1) The boundary of boiler efficiency heat balance calculation is defined as the heater inlet and the air preheater flue gas outlet, the reference temperature is the average air temperature at the heater inlet, and the exhaust gas temperature is the flue gas temperature at the air preheater outlet; 2) The heat recovered by the waste heat recovery system into the boiler is based on the actual heat measured by the water medium system; 3) The boiler efficiency calculation formula is as follows:
[0309]
[0310] Among them, η b is the boiler efficiency, %; Q inp is the heat input of the boiler (mainly refers to the total heat input of the fuel), MW; Q yr Recover the heat entering the boiler for the waste heat recovery system, MW; Q L The various heat losses of the boiler are calculated according to the current specifications.
[0311] When only the fuel input heat is calculated, the boiler input heat Q in the above formula inp According to the measured coal consumption B g (kg / h) and coal calorific value Q net,ar (kJ / kg) calculation:
[0312] Q inp =B g ×Q net,ar / 3600,MW; (58)
[0313] Or it can be obtained according to the measured standard coal consumption b (kg / kWh) and power generation N (MW):
[0314] Q inp =7000R h ×b×N / 3600,MW. (59)
[0315] Since the amount of heat absorbed by the heater can be easily measured with the help of the temperature rise of the water medium system and the circulation pump flow rate, the test accuracy is relatively high, so method A is more suitable for performance testing.
[0316] Efficiency calculation mode B;
[0317] A method based on the theoretical analysis of "changes in boiler coal consumption after increasing inlet air temperature";
[0318] According to this formula, the calculation formula for the change in boiler efficiency caused by the increase in hot air enthalpy under different calorific values and operating conditions is as follows:
[0319]
[0320] Among them, △η b is the change in boiler efficiency when the heater is in operation and not in operation, %; q 3-6 is the other boiler heat loss except exhaust heat loss q2 in heat balance calculation, %; H hF is the specific enthalpy of hot air at the outlet of air preheater, kJ / kg; H go.i is the specific enthalpy of flue gas at the air preheater inlet, kJ / kg; the lower corner codes A and 0 of the symbol respectively mark the parameters when the heater is in operation and not in operation.
[0321]
[0322] Among them, dq2 is the heat loss of boiler exhaust gas (based on the air preheater inlet temperature); dq inp is the input heat brought into the boiler due to the increase in the air temperature of the air preheater; dq2 and dq inp Both have lower calorific value than coal.
[0323] △η=(1-K X )△h F / Q net,ar (62)
[0324] In the formula
[0325] Efficiency calculation mode C;
[0326] The calculation formula based on the equivalent exhaust temperature is as follows:
[0327] △η b =-△q2.eq (64)
[0328] Among them, △q 2.eq The equivalent exhaust gas temperature θ 2.eq The heat loss of exhaust gas calculated as the benchmark;
[0329] θ 2.eq =θ-(△θ+△θ ID-BUF ),℃. (65)
[0330]
[0331] Calculation mode C is suitable for macroscopic evaluation of boiler efficiency changes.
[0332] Calculation of auxiliary power consumption and plant power consumption rate:
[0333] Basic calculation method:
[0334] (1) Calculation principles: First, it is necessary to distinguish whether the calculation is a comparison between 1) operation and 2) shutdown of the flue gas waste heat utilization system, or a comparison between 1) setting and 2) not setting.
[0335] (2) Calculation method: Similar to the traditional low-temperature economizer system, but the following must be taken into account in the calculation of the power consumption of the three major fans: the resistance of the heater on the blower side; the resistance of the smoke and water cooler on the induced draft fan side and the heater.
[0336] Calculation method for air preheater bypass flue type waste heat recovery system:
[0337] Calculation method A, the main calculation data mode is provided by the main engine manufacturer: 1) The energy definitions of the boiler plant and the turbine plant on the main engine side must match, and should be connected on the heat balance diagram. Since the turbine heat consumption and boiler efficiency are provided by the turbine plant and the boiler plant respectively, if the heat definitions do not match, it will lead to wrong conclusions. 2) The design institute makes corresponding provisions for the calculation conditions of the main engine manufacturer, the matching conditions for the heat balance calculation between the boiler island and the turbine island, and the verification requirements for the main engine calculation data (in addition to the main steam parameters and exhaust back pressure, the reheat steam parameters and exhaust steam humidity (enthalpy value) are related to the efficiency inside the turbine. If the turbine flow performance is not obtained in advance, the calculation of the variable operating heat consumption of the turbine after the waste heat is applied is not accurate enough. If the profit is calculated based on the unchanged power generation, the theoretical efficiency change caused by the reduction of the steam inlet volume due to the sliding pressure of the unit must also be considered. Especially when the waste heat recovery volume is large, the error is more obvious). 3) Make necessary provisions for the calculation method of energy loss between the boiler island and the steam turbine island (outside the main engine calculation boundary), such as: the resistance and heat dissipation loss of hundreds of meters of pipelines between the boiler islands, the additional heat dissipation loss of the air preheater bypass flue system, the pressure drop calculation method of the water medium system, etc.
[0338] Calculation method B, the calculation mode led by the design institute: 1) Selection of calculation system (steam turbine benefit or boiler benefit calculation system); 2) Selection of calculation method (such as the use of equivalent enthalpy drop method to calculate the steam extraction efficiency before and after the reheater when the turbine heat consumption is calculated, there are different calculation methods); 3) Coal saving rate calculation basis; 4) Some regulations are made on the selection of pipeline efficiency, etc.
[0339] Calculation method C, refer to the industry standard DL / T2169 "Calculation method for energy saving of cascade utilization of flue gas waste heat in thermal power plants" (draft for approval): the following issues need to be paid attention to: 1) Appendix A takes the premise that the recovered waste heat is equal to the heat taken out of the air preheater bypass as the premise for the boiler efficiency to remain unchanged, which is not representative. More projects will have the situation where the recovered waste heat is not equal to the heat taken out of the bypass, especially when it comes to the coupled calculation of the drying output of the powder making system, which makes it more difficult to achieve accurate balance to ensure that the boiler efficiency remains unchanged. 2) Therefore, it is necessary to calculate the air preheater expansion ratio and related thermal indicators simultaneously with the boiler plant. 3) The several formulas for calculating the heat consumption of the steam turbine and the efficiency of the boiler are all general calculation formulas, and there is a lack of specific connection between them and the heat of the air preheater bypass flue system. 4) The thermal calculation of the rotary air preheater should be based on a new generation of calculation procedures that take into account the effect of hot end leakage on heat exchange. 5) The characteristics of the two methods of equal flow or equal electric power for calculating the heat rate of the steam turbine after the cascade utilization of flue gas waste heat should be analyzed. The equal electric power method is more sensitive to the power consumption of the auxiliary machine. 6) This standard discusses fuel efficiency, and it should be calculated by the steam heat input and output / fuel combustion heat. Since the heat of the bypass economizer is regarded as a loss, it is not necessary to subtract this part of heat from the positive balance boiler efficiency calculation formula (6).
[0340] Calculation method D is the boiler efficiency / turbine heat consumption / pipeline efficiency / coal consumption calculation matching system model.
[0341] The present invention also provides a method for calculating the coal saving benefit of a flue gas waste heat recovery system, which is as follows:
[0342] Boiler heat balance solution based on the input-output heat balance principle:
[0343] Heat balance analysis method based on the energy balance of the steam generation process: a boiler is subjected to heat balance analysis according to two modules: 1) steam generation unit (steam-water system); 2) hot air generation unit (smoke, air and pulverized coal system). In the 1) steam generation unit module, the feed water is heated by the fuel calorific value to generate superheated steam and reheated steam, and the boundary of its final exhaust gas temperature is the economizer outlet; at this time, the coal consumption can be calculated according to the heat balance equation of the boiler process, and the boiler efficiency can be calculated. In the 2) hot air generation unit module, the high-level waste heat flue gas is used to heat the cold air into hot air, and the boundary of its final exhaust gas temperature is the air preheater outlet or the heater or even the low-temperature economizer outlet. In this unit, the smoke and air parameters (mainly the hot air temperature) are calculated according to the air side heat balance method to cooperate with the heat balance calculation of the steam generation unit. Compared with the traditional boiler heat balance analysis method, the input-output heat method based on the steam generation process avoids the entanglement of the boiler efficiency calculation link, making the calculation of boiler coal consumption more direct.
[0344] Embodiment 2:
[0345] The present invention also proposes a coal saving system 200 based on a flue gas recovery system, such as Figure 2 As shown, including:
[0346] A screening module 201 is used to determine a benefit calculation method applicable to a plurality of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers;
[0347] The first calculation module 202 is used to calculate the first coal quantity used when each target flue gas recovery system is used together with the large boiler under the condition of producing the same benefits, and calculate the second coal quantity used in the historical use of the large boiler under the condition of producing the same benefits;
[0348] A second calculation module 203 is used to determine, based on the first coal amount and the second coal amount, a coal saving rate when each target flue gas recovery system is used together with a large boiler relative to a historical use case of the large boiler;
[0349] The third calculation module 204 is used to determine the first cost reduced by the coal saving rate, and to determine the second cost increased when the target flue gas recovery system and the large boiler are used together after converting from the historical use of the large boiler, and to select the target flue gas recovery system and the large boiler corresponding to the first cost whose first cost is greater than the second cost and the difference is greater than the preset range, so as to save coal when the large boiler generates benefits.
[0350] Among them, by determining the types of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers, a benefit calculation method applicable to a variety of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers is determined.
[0351] The flue gas recovery system includes at least one of the following: a conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, a heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system, and an air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system;
[0352] Among them, the benefit calculation method used by each of the flue gas recovery systems corresponds to a plurality of benefit calculation systems. Before determining the benefit calculation method applicable to a plurality of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers, the benefit calculation system is determined. After determining the benefit calculation system, the benefit calculation method applicable to a plurality of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers is determined according to the benefit calculation system.
[0353] The benefit calculation system includes:
[0354] For each benefit calculation system, the benefit calculation system is verified using the same input data to determine the accuracy of each benefit calculation system, and the benefit calculation system that best meets the accuracy requirements is used as the benefit calculation system used by the flue gas recovery system;
[0355] The benefit calculation system used as a flue gas recovery system meets the preset selection criteria.
[0356] Among them, the benefit calculation methods corresponding to the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, the heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system and the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system all include multiple calculation modes, and all include calculation methods for multiple indicators and multiple constraints;
[0357] Among them, the benefit calculation method and the calculation mode used are selected according to the actual sampling data of the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, the heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system and the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system;
[0358] The benefit calculation method corresponding to the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system includes calculation methods for multiple indicators, including: heat consumption change calculation method, auxiliary power consumption calculation method, and plant power consumption rate and power supply coal saving rate calculation method;
[0359] The benefit calculation method corresponding to the cascade utilization system of the heater plus low-temperature economizer includes calculation methods of multiple indicators, including: basic indicator calculation method, boiler side exhaust gas temperature and hot air temperature calculation method, boiler efficiency and coal consumption rate calculation method after the inlet air temperature is increased, practical calculation method of boiler efficiency and auxiliary power consumption and plant power rate calculation method;
[0360] The benefit calculation method corresponding to the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system includes calculation methods for multiple indicators, including: boiler efficiency calculation method, hot air temperature calculation method, air preheater thermal calculation method, air preheater bypass flue high temperature economizer exhaust steam extraction efficiency calculation method and coal saving efficiency calculation method.
[0361] The coal saving rate is verified, and if the verification result does not meet the preset requirements, the benefit calculation method corresponding to the verification result that does not meet the preset requirements is adjusted until the verification result meets the preset requirements.
[0362] The present invention establishes a flue gas waste heat recovery benefit calculation system, which has practical value for accurately applying domestic and foreign boiler specifications to calculate coal consumption and avoid repeated calculation or omission of coal-saving benefits, and also helps to improve the level of coal-saving calculation of flue gas waste heat utilization systems.
[0363] It will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that embodiments of the present invention may be provided as methods, systems, or computer program products. Therefore, the present invention may take the form of a complete hardware embodiment, a complete software embodiment, or an embodiment combining software and hardware. Moreover, the present invention may take the form of a computer program product implemented on one or more computer-usable storage media (including but not limited to disk storage, CD-ROM, optical storage, etc.) containing computer-usable program codes. The schemes in the embodiments of the present invention may be implemented in various computer languages, for example, object-oriented programming language Java and literal scripting language JavaScript, etc.
[0364] The present invention is described with reference to flowcharts and / or block diagrams of methods, devices (systems), and computer program products according to embodiments of the present invention. It should be understood that each process and / or block in the flowchart and / or block diagram, as well as the combination of processes and / or blocks in the flowchart and / or block diagram, can be implemented by computer program instructions. These computer program instructions can be provided to a processor of a general-purpose computer, a special-purpose computer, an embedded processor, or other programmable data processing device to produce a machine, so that the instructions executed by the processor of the computer or other programmable data processing device generate instructions for implementing the processes in the flowchart and / or block diagram. Figure 1 A process or multiple processes and / or boxes Figure 1 A device that provides the functions specified in a block or multiple blocks.
[0365] These computer program instructions may also be stored in a computer-readable memory capable of directing a computer or other programmable data processing device to operate in a specific manner, so that the instructions stored in the computer-readable memory produce an article of manufacture comprising an instruction device, which implements the process Figure 1 A process or multiple processes and / or boxes Figure 1A function specified in one or more boxes.
[0366] These computer program instructions can also be loaded onto a computer or other programmable data processing device so that a series of operating steps are executed on the computer or other programmable device to produce a computer-implemented process, thereby providing instructions for implementing the process. Figure 1 A process or multiple processes and / or boxes Figure 1 The steps for the functions specified in one or more boxes.
[0367] Although the preferred embodiments of the present invention have been described, those skilled in the art may make other changes and modifications to these embodiments once they have learned the basic creative concept. Therefore, the appended claims are intended to be interpreted as including the preferred embodiments and all changes and modifications that fall within the scope of the present invention.
[0368] Obviously, those skilled in the art can make various changes and modifications to the present invention without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention. Thus, if these modifications and variations of the present invention fall within the scope of the claims of the present invention and their equivalents, the present invention is also intended to include these modifications and variations.
Claims
1. A coal saving method based on a flue gas recovery system, characterized in that: The method comprises: Determine the benefit calculation method applicable to various target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers; Using the benefit calculation method, calculate the first amount of coal used when each target flue gas recovery system is used together with a large boiler under the condition of producing the same benefits, and calculate the second amount of coal used in the historical use of the large boiler under the condition of producing the same benefits; Based on the first coal amount and the second coal amount, determining a coal saving rate when each target flue gas recovery system is used together with a large boiler relative to a historical use condition of the large boiler; Determine the first cost reduced by the coal saving rate, and determine the second cost increased when the target flue gas recovery system and the large boiler are used together when the historical use of the large boiler is converted, and select the target flue gas recovery system and the large boiler corresponding to the first cost whose first cost is greater than the second cost and the difference is greater than the preset range for use, so as to save coal when the large boiler generates benefits; By determining the types of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers, a benefit calculation method applicable to a variety of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers is determined; The flue gas recovery system includes at least one of the following: a conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, a heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system, and an air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system; Among them, the benefit calculation method used by each of the flue gas recovery systems corresponds to a plurality of benefit calculation systems. Before determining the benefit calculation method applicable to a plurality of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers, the benefit calculation system is determined. After determining the benefit calculation system, the benefit calculation method applicable to a plurality of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers is determined according to the benefit calculation system. The benefit calculation system includes: For each benefit calculation system, the benefit calculation system is verified using the same input data to determine the accuracy of each benefit calculation system, and the benefit calculation system that best meets the accuracy requirements is used as the benefit calculation system used by the flue gas recovery system; The benefit calculation system used as the flue gas recovery system meets the preset selection criteria; The selection criteria of the benefit calculation system are as follows: (1) Select by project nature: For power plants, it is advisable to select a steam turbine calculation system; Select boiler calculation system for heating projects; (2) Make specific selections based on the different characteristics of waste heat utilization schemes: For the scheme of using flue gas waste heat to heat the steam turbine reheat system, the heat absorbed by the low-temperature economizer is not directly returned to the boiler, and the steam turbine heat consumption reduction analysis system is selected; For the solution where flue gas waste heat is used to heat boiler combustion air, select the boiler efficiency improvement analysis system; For the solution where the flue gas waste heat is used to heat both the steam turbine reheat system and the boiler combustion air, select the boiler efficiency improvement analysis system + steam turbine heat consumption reduction analysis system; For the air preheater bypass flue solution, select the flue gas waste heat input-output heat balance calculation system; (3) For the flue gas waste heat utilization system coupled with the turbine and boiler, the flue gas waste heat cannot be completely analyzed according to the turbine heat consumption reduction analysis system or the boiler efficiency improvement analysis system; according to the flue gas waste heat input-output heat balance principle, the boiler side efficiency change and the turbine side heat consumption change are calculated separately, that is, the input-output heat balance calculation system is adopted; The benefit calculation methods corresponding to the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, the heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system and the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system all include multiple calculation modes, and all include calculation methods for multiple indicators and multiple constraints; Among them, the benefit calculation method and the calculation mode used are selected according to the actual sampling data of the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, the heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system and the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system; The benefit calculation method corresponding to the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system includes calculation methods for multiple indicators, including: heat consumption change calculation method, auxiliary power consumption calculation method, and plant power consumption rate and power supply coal saving rate calculation method; The benefit calculation method corresponding to the cascade utilization system of the heater plus low-temperature economizer includes calculation methods of multiple indicators, including: basic indicator calculation method, boiler side exhaust gas temperature and hot air temperature calculation method, boiler efficiency and coal consumption rate calculation method after the inlet air temperature is increased, practical calculation method of boiler efficiency and auxiliary power consumption and plant power rate calculation method; The benefit calculation method corresponding to the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system includes calculation methods for multiple indicators, including: boiler efficiency calculation method, hot air temperature calculation method, air preheater thermal calculation method, air preheater bypass flue high temperature economizer exhaust steam extraction efficiency calculation method and coal saving efficiency calculation method.
2. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The coal saving rate is verified, and if the verification result does not meet the preset requirements, the benefit calculation method corresponding to the verification result that does not meet the preset requirements is adjusted until the verification result meets the preset requirements.
3. A coal-saving system based on a flue gas recovery system, characterized in that: The system comprises: A screening module for determining the benefit calculation methods applicable to various target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers; A first calculation module is used to calculate the first amount of coal used when each target flue gas recovery system is used together with a large boiler under the condition of producing the same benefits, and calculate the second amount of coal used in the historical use of the large boiler under the condition of producing the same benefits; A second calculation module is used to determine, based on the first coal amount and the second coal amount, a coal saving rate when each target flue gas recovery system is used together with a large boiler relative to a historical use condition of the large boiler; The third calculation module is used to determine the first cost reduced by the coal saving rate, and determine the second cost increased when the target flue gas recovery system and the large boiler are used together when the historical use of the large boiler is converted, and select the target flue gas recovery system and the large boiler corresponding to the first cost whose first cost is greater than the second cost and the difference is greater than the preset range for use, so as to save coal when the large boiler generates benefits; By determining the types of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers, a benefit calculation method applicable to a variety of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers is determined; The flue gas recovery system includes at least one of the following: a conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, a heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system, and an air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system; Among them, the benefit calculation method used by each of the flue gas recovery systems corresponds to a plurality of benefit calculation systems. Before determining the benefit calculation method applicable to a plurality of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers, the benefit calculation system is determined. After determining the benefit calculation system, the benefit calculation method applicable to a plurality of target flue gas recovery systems and large boilers is determined according to the benefit calculation system. The benefit calculation system includes: For each benefit calculation system, the benefit calculation system is verified using the same input data to determine the accuracy of each benefit calculation system, and the benefit calculation system that best meets the accuracy requirements is used as the benefit calculation system used by the flue gas recovery system; The benefit calculation system used as the flue gas recovery system meets the preset selection criteria; The selection criteria of the benefit calculation system are as follows: (1) Select by project nature: For power plants, it is advisable to select a steam turbine calculation system; Select boiler calculation system for heating projects; (2) Make specific selections based on the different characteristics of waste heat utilization schemes: For the scheme of using flue gas waste heat to heat the steam turbine reheat system, the heat absorbed by the low-temperature economizer is not directly returned to the boiler, and the steam turbine heat consumption reduction analysis system is selected; For the solution where flue gas waste heat is used to heat boiler combustion air, select the boiler efficiency improvement analysis system; For the solution where the flue gas waste heat is used to heat both the steam turbine reheat system and the boiler combustion air, select the boiler efficiency improvement analysis system + steam turbine heat consumption reduction analysis system; For the air preheater bypass flue solution, select the flue gas waste heat input-output heat balance calculation system; (3) For the flue gas waste heat utilization system coupled with the turbine and boiler, the flue gas waste heat cannot be completely analyzed according to the turbine heat consumption reduction analysis system or the boiler efficiency improvement analysis system; according to the flue gas waste heat input-output heat balance principle, the boiler side efficiency change and the turbine side heat consumption change are calculated separately, that is, the input-output heat balance calculation system is adopted; The benefit calculation methods corresponding to the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, the heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system and the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system all include multiple calculation modes, and all include calculation methods for multiple indicators and multiple constraints; Among them, the benefit calculation method and the calculation mode used are selected according to the actual sampling data of the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system, the heater plus low-temperature economizer cascade utilization system and the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system; The benefit calculation method corresponding to the conventional low-temperature economizer waste heat utilization system includes calculation methods for multiple indicators, including: heat consumption change calculation method, auxiliary power consumption calculation method, and plant power consumption rate and power supply coal saving rate calculation method; The benefit calculation method corresponding to the cascade utilization system of the heater plus low-temperature economizer includes calculation methods of multiple indicators, including: basic indicator calculation method, boiler side exhaust gas temperature and hot air temperature calculation method, boiler efficiency and coal consumption rate calculation method after the inlet air temperature is increased, practical calculation method of boiler efficiency and auxiliary power consumption and plant power rate calculation method; The benefit calculation method corresponding to the air preheater bypass flue cascade utilization system includes calculation methods for multiple indicators, including: boiler efficiency calculation method, hot air temperature calculation method, air preheater thermal calculation method, air preheater bypass flue high temperature economizer exhaust steam extraction efficiency calculation method and coal saving efficiency calculation method.
4. The system according to claim 3, characterized in that The coal saving rate is verified, and if the verification result does not meet the preset requirements, the benefit calculation method corresponding to the verification result that does not meet the preset requirements is adjusted until the verification result meets the preset requirements.
