A method for controlling rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion based on flow control

Through the rock hydraulic fracturing method based on flow control, the PID control technology is used to reduce the uncertainty of crack expansion in deep rock mass experiments, improve the controllability of crack expansion, and solve the poor crack expansion controllability in the existing technology and the high cost problem, the automatic control of the fracturing process and the deepening of the research on the deep rock mass mechanism.

CN118655923BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-05INST OF ROCK & SOIL MECHANICS CHINESE ACAD OF SCI
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202411133531.8
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-08-19
Publication Date
2024-11-05
Estimated Expiration
2044-08-19

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

In the existing research on controlled fracturing of deep rock mass laboratories, the crack expansion is poor, the fracturing process is difficult to observe, and the manpower, material and time cost is high, making it difficult to achieve controllable crack expansion.

Method used

The rock hydraulic fracturing fracture expansion control method is adopted based on flow control, and the area of ​​the fracturing fracture is controlled through PID, which reduces the added value of each flow, so that the injection flow is close to the critical cracking flow, limits the initial expansion length after the cracking, and By using PID to control the fracture area by using characteristics that the filter loss flow rate of the fracture surface is equal to the injection flow rate.

Benefits of technology

Improve the controllability of crack expansion, reduce the redundant elastic potential energy release during cracking, realize automatic control of crack area during fracturing, reduce experimental costs, and observe acoustic emission, surface strain rate and resistivity Changes further study the fracturing mechanism of deep rock mass.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118655923B_ABST
    Figure CN118655923B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention relates to a rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion control method based on flow control, wherein a sample is pressurized, a PID control parameter target crack area S is set, and a flow rate is injected into the sample; the equivalent seepage thickness after the last flow increase before the fracture is initiated is taken as the rock equivalent seepage thickness D ; After the initial cracking of the sample, observe whether the pore pressure changes significantly. If not, calculate the crack area after the pore pressure stabilizes. If it does not reach S, increase the injection flow rate. After the pore pressure stabilizes, calculate the crack area. Use the crack area difference as a feedback signal to adjust the injection flow rate, so that as the adjusted crack area approaches S, the change in flow rate after each adjustment decreases accordingly, until the crack area after the last flow adjustment is equal to or exceeds the target value, the experiment ends. The present invention reduces the increase in each flow rate and tries to make the injection flow rate close to the critical cracking flow rate to limit the initial extension length of the crack after cracking, and establishes a method for controlling the crack area using PID.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention relates to the technical field of rock hydraulic fracturing, and in particular to a rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion control method based on flow control. Background Art

[0002] In recent years, controlled fracturing technology for deep rock has become the core research technology for deep resource exploitation. The main means of studying the fracturing mechanism of deep rock is currently laboratory controlled fracturing research, which simulates the in-situ environment of deep rock through large-tonnage loading devices.

[0003] At present, the controlled fracturing research in deep rock laboratory mostly uses constant flow or constant pressure control to apply pore pressure, and monitors the fracturing process through acoustic emission, pressure gauge, strain gauge, etc. The disadvantages are: 1. The controllability of crack extension is poor. Before the fracturing cracks are initiated, there is a release of redundant elastic potential energy, which may cause the new cracks to directly extend and penetrate the surface of the rock sample; 2. It is difficult to observe the fracturing process. Small-sized rock samples are mostly used. After the cracks are initiated, they quickly extend to the surface, and the observable time is short; 3. The manpower, material resources and time costs of deep rock fracturing laboratory research are high. Therefore, the controllable crack extension in the fracturing process is a future research trend. Summary of the invention

[0004] The technical problem to be solved by the present invention is to provide a rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion control method based on flow control in response to the problems existing in the above-mentioned prior art. By adopting a flow-controlled fracturing fluid injection method, the injection flow is made as close to the critical fracture initiation flow as possible by reducing the increase in flow each time, and the redundant elastic potential energy at the time of fracture initiation is reduced as much as possible, thereby limiting the initial expansion length of the fracture after fracture initiation, and the area of ​​the fracture surface is obtained through the characteristic that the filtration flow of the fracture surface is equal to the injection flow, thereby establishing a method for using PID to control the fracturing crack area.

[0005] The technical solution adopted by the present invention to solve the above-mentioned technical problems is:

[0006] A rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion control method based on flow control, the controlled fracturing experiment includes the following steps:

[0007] S3.1. Apply triaxial pressure to the rock sample according to the experimental plan, and set the PID control parameters in the host computer. The control parameters include the target fracture area S. After the triaxial pressure is stable, start the fracturing pump and monitoring equipment. The fracturing pump injects fracturing fluid into the rock sample. The initial flow rate is ;

[0008] S3.2, when the rock sample is not cracked, the flow rate of each lift is less than 10%, the increase in flow rate each time decreases, and the injection flow rate after each increase in flow rate is , continue to inject for a set time, and calculate the equivalent seepage thickness after the pressure stabilizes Until the rock sample cracks, the equivalent seepage thickness calculated after the last increase in flow before cracking is taken as the equivalent seepage thickness of the rock D ;

[0009] S3.3. After the initial fracturing of the rock sample, observe whether the pore pressure changes significantly. If so, observe whether there is fracturing fluid seeping out of the rock sample or whether there is confining pressure fluid backflowing in the cracks. If so, stop the experiment, unload the load, replace the rock sample, reduce the injection flow rate, and continue the fracturing experiment; if not, proceed to the next step;

[0010] S3.4. After the initial expansion of the crack and the pore pressure stabilizes, calculate the fracturing crack area at this time; if the crack area does not reach the target value S, increase the injection flow rate, and continue to inject for the set time after increasing the flow rate. After the pore pressure stabilizes again, calculate the crack area at this time, and calculate the difference in crack area after the injection flow rate changes as a feedback signal for adjusting the injection flow rate, so that as the adjusted crack area approaches the target value S, the change in flow rate after each adjustment decreases accordingly, until the fracture area equals or exceeds the target value S after the last flow adjustment, the fracturing experiment ends.

[0011] In the above scheme, in step S3.1, the initial value of the injection flow is for:

[0012]

[0013] in: is half the side length of the rock sample, is the exposed section area of ​​the borehole, is the fracturing fluid viscosity, is the permeability of the rock sample, It is the sum of the minimum principal stress and the tensile strength of the specimen.

[0014] In the above scheme, in step S3.2, the equivalent seepage thickness is:

[0015]

[0016] in: Before cracking j The injection flow at the time, Before cracking j The equivalent seepage thickness at time , To inject flow The pressure after the borehole pressure stabilizes, is the permeability of the rock sample, is the exposed section area of ​​the borehole, is the fracturing fluid viscosity, is the pore pressure inside the rock.

[0017] In the above scheme, in step S3.3, if the pore pressure changes significantly, observe whether fracturing fluid seeps out of the rock sample or whether confining pressure fluid flows back into the cracks. If so, stop the experiment, remove the load, replace the rock sample, reduce the injection flow rate, and continue the fracturing experiment.

[0018] In the above scheme, in step S3.4, the fracturing crack area is:

[0019]

[0020] in: is the injection flow rate at time i after the crack initiation, is the fracture area of ​​the sample at time i after the cracking started, To inject flow The pressure after the borehole pressure stabilizes, is the fracturing fluid viscosity, is the equivalent seepage thickness of rock, is the permeability of the rock sample, is the pore pressure inside the rock, It is the exposed section area of ​​the borehole.

[0021] In the above scheme, the injection flow rate at time i=1 is , drilling hole pressure is The hydraulic fracture area is ; The injection flow rate at time i=2 is , drilling hole pressure is The hydraulic fracture area is ; The difference in crack area at two moments is:

[0022]

[0023] in: is the difference in fracture area after the injection flow rate changes.

[0024] In the above scheme, in step S3.4, each time the injection flow rate is increased, it is necessary to observe whether the cracks penetrate the rock sample. If so, the fracturing experiment is stopped.

[0025] In the above scheme, the rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion control method based on flow control also includes step S1, laboratory controlled fracturing experiment preparation: processing rock samples, pre-embedding fracturing pipes in rock samples, and pre-setting orientation mechanisms; and using the same batch of rock samples to measure basic physical parameters of rock samples, including permeability , measuring fracturing fluid viscosity ; Build a laboratory fracturing test system, including a confining pressure loading device, a fracturing pump, a host computer and monitoring equipment, the monitoring equipment includes an acoustic emission acquisition device, a strain rate acquisition device and a resistivity acquisition device.

[0026] In the above scheme, the rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion control method based on flow control also includes step S2, loading preparation: installing a rock sample, installing a monitoring device on the surface of the rock sample, connecting a fracturing pump to a fracturing pipe pre-buried in the rock sample, and using a vacuum pump to extract air from the pipeline and the fracturing hole.

[0027] In the above scheme, the rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion control method based on flow control also includes step S4, further studying the fracturing mechanism of deep rock mass by observing the acoustic emission, surface strain rate and resistivity changes during the fracturing process.

[0028] The beneficial effects of the present invention are:

[0029] 1. The present invention proposes a rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion control method based on flow control. Flow control can reduce the influence of flow on the initiation pressure, reduce the initiation pressure, reduce the redundant elastic potential energy released at the initiation moment, reduce the expansion distance of the crack at the moment of initiation, and improve the controllability of crack expansion. When the crack stops, the filtration loss generated by the fracturing crack surface and the pore wall is exactly equal to the injection flow rate of the fracturing fluid. When the injection flow rate increases, the crack surface will expand again. By establishing the relationship between the fracturing crack area and the injection flow rate during the control of the fracturing process, the crack area corresponding to a certain flow rate can be obtained, and then a method for using PID to control the fracturing crack area is established. The PID control method uses the crack area obtained according to the injection flow rate as the target parameter of the control closed loop. The next level of control closed loop of the crack control is flow control. When the target parameter is not reached, the flow rate is adjusted. After each flow adjustment, the crack area changes accordingly. After each flow change, the injection setting time must be continued until the pore pressure is stable, and then the adjusted crack area is calculated, and the crack area difference after the injection flow rate changes is calculated as a feedback signal for adjusting the injection flow rate, so that as the adjusted crack area approaches the target value, the change in the flow rate after each adjustment decreases accordingly, until the crack area equals or exceeds the target value after the last flow adjustment. The fracturing experiment ends. The present invention limits the expansion distance of the fracturing crack by reducing the increase value of each flow rate and making the injection flow rate as close to the critical fracturing flow rate as possible, thereby realizing the automatic control of the crack area during the fracturing process.

[0030] 2. The fracturing mechanism of deep rock can be further studied by observing the changes in acoustic emission, surface strain rate and resistivity during the fracturing process. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0031] The present invention will be further described below with reference to the accompanying drawings and embodiments, in which:

[0032] Figure 1 It is a schematic diagram of the structure of the laboratory rock fracturing test system constructed in the method of the present invention;

[0033] Figure 2 It is a flow chart of controlling the fracturing experiment in the method of the present invention.

[0034] In the figure: 1. True triaxial pressure chamber; 2. Rock sample; 3. Drilling hole; 4. Monitoring equipment; 5. Injection pipeline; 6. Triaxial pressure; 7. Fracturing pump; 8. Servo control system; 9. Valve instrument; 10. Host computer; 11. Acquisition and processing equipment; 12. Acquisition card. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0035] In order to have a clearer understanding of the technical features, purposes and effects of the present invention, specific embodiments of the present invention are now described in detail with reference to the accompanying drawings.

[0036] The present invention proposes a rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion control method based on flow control, which reduces the redundant elastic potential energy at the time of crack initiation and limits the initial expansion length of the crack after initiation by adopting a flow-controlled fracturing fluid injection method on an existing laboratory fracturing test system, and obtains the area of ​​the crack surface through the characteristic that the filtration flow rate of the crack surface is equal to the injection flow rate, and then controls the crack expansion process during the fracturing process through a PID algorithm. Specifically, the following steps are included:

[0037] S1. Preparation for laboratory controlled fracturing experiment.

[0038] Process rock samples 2, embed fracturing pipes in the rock samples, prefabricate slits, perforations and other directional mechanisms to control the orientation of crack initiation; and use the same batch of rock samples to measure the basic physical parameters of the rock samples, including uniaxial compressive strength, uniaxial tensile strength, permeability ;Measure fracturing fluid viscosity .

[0039] Build a laboratory fracturing test system, such as Figure 1As shown, the laboratory fracturing test system includes a true triaxial pressure chamber 1, a fracturing pump 7, a servo control system 8, a monitoring device 4, a valve instrument 9, a host computer 10, an acquisition and processing device 11, and an acquisition card 12. Among them, the true triaxial pressure chamber 1 is used to apply triaxial pressure 6 to the rock sample 2; the fracturing pump 7 is connected to the pre-buried fracturing pipe in the borehole 3 of the rock sample 2 through the injection pipeline 5, and the servo control system 8 is electrically connected to the fracturing pump 7 to achieve high-precision control of the injection flow of the fracturing fluid; the monitoring device 4 includes an acoustic emission acquisition device, a strain rate acquisition device, and a resistivity acquisition device, which are respectively used to monitor the acoustic emission, surface strain and resistivity changes during the fracturing process; the monitoring device 4 is connected to the acquisition card 12, and the acquisition card 12 is connected to the acquisition and processing device 11, respectively performing signal acquisition and processing; the host computer 10 is connected to the servo control system 8, and the host computer 10 controls the flow and pressure of the fracturing pump 7 through the servo control system 8.

[0040] Further optimization, penetration The test method complies with GB / T 28912-2012 standard. The number of test cores shall not be less than 5 and the permeability shall be the average value of the test results.

[0041] For further optimization, all rock samples were soaked in pure water for more than 48 hours before use, and the samples were saturated with water.

[0042] S2. Loading preparation.

[0043] Install the rock sample, install monitoring equipment 4 on the surface of the rock sample 2, including an acoustic emission probe, a strain gauge, and an electrode, connect the fracturing pump 7 to the fracturing pipe pre-buried in the borehole 3 of the rock sample 2, and use a vacuum pump to extract the air in the pipeline and the borehole 3.

[0044] S3. Controlled fracturing experiment. The experimental process is as follows: Figure 2 shown.

[0045] S3.1. Apply triaxial pressure according to the experimental plan and set PID control parameters in the host computer. The control parameters include the target fracture area S. After the triaxial pressure is stable, start the fracturing pump and monitoring equipment. The fracturing pump injects fracturing fluid into the rock sample. The initial flow rate is :

[0046]

[0047] in: is half the side length of the rock sample, is the exposed section area of ​​the borehole, is the fracturing fluid viscosity, is the permeability of the rock sample, It is the sum of the minimum principal stress and the tensile strength of the specimen.

[0048] S3.2. When the rock sample is not cracked, the injection flow rate after each flow increase is , continue to inject for a set time (such as 5 minutes), and calculate the equivalent seepage thickness of the rock after the pressure stabilizes :

[0049]

[0050] in: Before cracking j The injection flow at the time, Before cracking j The equivalent seepage thickness at time , To inject flow The pressure after the borehole pressure stabilizes, is the permeability of the rock sample, is the exposed section area of ​​the borehole, is the fracturing fluid viscosity, is the pore pressure inside the rock.

[0051] Until the rock sample cracks, the equivalent seepage thickness calculated after the last flow increase before cracking is taken as the final rock equivalent seepage thickness D .

[0052] It should be noted that each increase in flow is less than 10%, the increase in flow rate each time decreases. In this embodiment, the first increase in flow rate is The increase in flow rate each time is 10%, and the increase in subsequent flow rate is 0.8 times the previous increase. By reducing the increase in flow rate each time, the injection flow rate is made close to the critical fracture initiation flow rate as much as possible, and the redundant elastic potential energy at the time of fracture initiation is reduced as much as possible, thereby limiting the initial extension length of the fracture after initiation.

[0053] S3.3. After the initial fracturing of the rock sample, observe whether the pore pressure changes significantly. If so, observe whether there is fracturing fluid seeping out of the rock sample, or whether there is confining pressure fluid backflowing in the crack. If so, it indicates that the crack penetrates the rock sample after the initial expansion. Stop the experiment, unload the load, replace the rock sample, reduce the injection flow rate, and continue the fracturing experiment; if there is no significant change, proceed to the next step.

[0054] It should be noted that the sudden drop in pore pressure and the surge in acoustic emission signal intensity can be combined to determine whether the crack has started.

[0055] S3.4. After the initial expansion of the crack and the pore pressure stabilizes, calculate the fracturing crack area at this time; if the crack area does not reach the target value S, increase the injection flow rate, and continue to inject for a set time (such as 5 minutes) after increasing the flow rate. After the pore pressure stabilizes again, calculate the crack area at this time, and calculate the difference in crack area after the injection flow rate changes as a feedback signal for adjusting the injection flow rate, so that as the adjusted crack area approaches the target value S, the change in flow rate after each adjustment decreases accordingly, until the fracture area equals or exceeds the target value S after the last flow adjustment, the fracturing experiment ends.

[0056] Even if a flow-controlled fracturing method is used, the fracturing cracks may still penetrate the rock sample at the moment of initiation. Therefore, the present invention limits the expansion distance of the fracturing cracks by reducing the increase in flow rate each time and making the injection flow rate as close to the critical fracturing flow rate as possible.

[0057] Specifically, the calculation method of the fracturing crack area is as follows:

[0058] Assuming that the crack extension direction is perpendicular to the minimum principal stress direction, ignoring the pressure difference in the crack, the seepage of the fracturing fluid in the borehole and the crack surface conforms to Darcy's seepage law, and the following relationship between the crack area and the injection flow rate can be established:

[0059]

[0060] Transformed into:

[0061]

[0062] in: is the injection flow rate at time i after the crack initiation, is the fracture area of ​​the sample at time i after the cracking started, To inject flow The pressure after the borehole pressure stabilizes, is the fracturing fluid viscosity, is the equivalent seepage thickness of rock, is the permeability of the rock sample, is the pore pressure inside the rock, It is the exposed section area of ​​the borehole.

[0063] During the fracturing process, the calculation process of the fracture area difference after the injection flow rate changes is as follows:

[0064] 1) Assume that at time i=1, the fracturing pump injects at a constant flow rate , the pore pressure rises;

[0065] 2) When the pore pressure rises to the fracture initiation pressure, the cracks begin to crack;

[0066] 3) Maintain injection flow after fracture initiation Continue to inject until the pressure stabilizes. ;

[0067] 4) When i=2, the injection flow rate is increased to , the crack starts to expand again, and the pore pressure at the stable state is ;

[0068] 5) According to the above formula, the difference in fracture area after the injection flow rate changes can be obtained as:

[0069]

[0070] in: is the difference in fracture area after the injection flow rate changes.

[0071] It should be noted that each time the injection flow rate is increased, it is necessary to observe whether the cracks penetrate the rock sample. If so, the fracturing experiment is stopped.

[0072] S4. Further study the fracturing mechanism of deep rock mass by observing the changes in acoustic emission, surface strain rate and resistivity during fracturing. For example, based on the acoustic emission positioning signal monitored during fracturing, the approximate range of the fracturing cracks can be obtained, and the crack parameters can be corrected in time, such as the crack distribution range and crack extension direction.

[0073] The embodiments of the present invention are described above in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, but the present invention is not limited to the above-mentioned specific implementation modes, which are merely illustrative rather than restrictive. Under the guidance of the present invention, ordinary technicians in this field can also make many forms without departing from the scope of protection of the present invention and the claims, all of which are within the protection of the present invention.

Claims

1. A method for controlling rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion based on flow control, It is characterized in that The controlled fracturing experiment includes the following steps: S3.

1. Apply triaxial pressure to the rock sample according to the experimental plan, and set the PID control parameters in the host computer. The control parameters include the target fracture area S. After the triaxial pressure is stable, start the fracturing pump and monitoring equipment. The fracturing pump injects fracturing fluid into the rock sample. The initial flow rate is ; S3.2, when the rock sample is not cracked, the flow rate of each lift is less than 10%, the increase in flow rate each time decreases, and the injection flow rate after each increase in flow rate is , continue to inject for a set time, and calculate the equivalent seepage thickness after the pressure stabilizes Until the rock sample cracks, the equivalent seepage thickness calculated after the last increase in flow before cracking is taken as the equivalent seepage thickness of the rock D ; The equivalent seepage thickness is: in: Before cracking j The injection flow at the time, Before cracking j The equivalent seepage thickness at time , To inject flow The pressure after the borehole pressure stabilizes, is the permeability of the rock sample, is the exposed section area of ​​the borehole, is the fracturing fluid viscosity, is the pore pressure inside the rock; S3.

3. After the initial cracking of the rock sample, observe whether the pore pressure changes significantly. If not, proceed to the next step; S3.4, after the initial expansion of the crack, the pore pressure is stabilized, and the fracturing crack area is calculated at this time. If the crack area does not reach the target value S, the injection flow rate is increased. After the flow rate is increased, the injection is continued for the set time. After the pore pressure is stabilized again, the crack area is calculated at this time, and the difference in the crack area after the injection flow rate is changed is calculated as a feedback signal for adjusting the injection flow rate, so that as the adjusted crack area approaches the target value S, the change in the flow rate after each adjustment decreases accordingly, until the crack area after the last flow adjustment is equal to or exceeds the target value S, the fracturing experiment ends; the fracturing crack area is: in: is the injection flow rate at time i after the crack initiation, is the fracture area of ​​the sample at time i after the cracking started, To inject flow The pressure after the borehole pressure stabilizes, is the fracturing fluid viscosity, is the equivalent seepage thickness of rock, is the permeability of the rock sample, is the pore pressure inside the rock, It is the exposed section area of ​​the borehole.

2. The rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion control method based on flow control according to claim 1, It is characterized in that In step S3.1, the initial value of the injection flow for: in: is half the side length of the rock sample, is the exposed section area of ​​the borehole, is the fracturing fluid viscosity, is the permeability of the rock sample, It is the sum of the minimum principal stress and the tensile strength of the specimen.

3. The rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion control method based on flow control according to claim 1, It is characterized in that In step S3.3, if the pore pressure changes significantly, observe whether fracturing fluid seeps out of the rock sample or whether confining pressure fluid flows back into the cracks. If so, stop the experiment, remove the load, replace the rock sample, reduce the injection flow rate, and continue the fracturing experiment.

4. The rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion control method based on flow control according to claim 1, It is characterized in that Assume that the injection flow rate at time i=1 is , drilling hole pressure is The fracture area is ; The injection flow rate at time i=2 is , drilling hole pressure is The fracture area is ; The difference in crack area at two moments is: in: is the difference in fracture area after the injection flow rate changes.

5. The rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion control method based on flow control according to claim 1, It is characterized in that In step S3.4, each time the injection flow rate is increased, it is necessary to observe whether the cracks penetrate the rock sample. If so, the fracturing experiment is stopped.

6. The rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion control method based on flow control according to claim 1, It is characterized in that The method also includes step S1, laboratory controlled fracturing experiment preparation: processing rock samples, pre-embedding fracturing pipes in the rock samples, and pre-setting orientation mechanisms; and using the same batch of rock samples to measure basic physical parameters of the rock samples, including permeability. , measuring fracturing fluid viscosity ; Build a laboratory fracturing test system, including a confining pressure loading device, a fracturing pump, a host computer and monitoring equipment, the monitoring equipment includes an acoustic emission acquisition device, a strain rate acquisition device and a resistivity acquisition device.

7. The rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion control method based on flow control according to claim 6, It is characterized in that The method also includes step S2, loading preparation: installing a rock sample, installing a monitoring device on the surface of the rock sample, connecting a fracturing pump to a fracturing pipe pre-buried in the rock sample, and using a vacuum pump to extract air from the pipeline and the fracturing hole.

8. The rock hydraulic fracturing crack expansion control method based on flow control according to claim 1, It is characterized in that The method also includes step S4, further studying the fracturing mechanism of the deep rock mass by observing the acoustic emission, surface strain rate and resistivity changes during the fracturing process.