Operation project risk analysis method and device
By analyzing the accident scenarios and event chains of high-risk industry operation projects and calculating risk parameters, the problem of low risk identification accuracy in the existing technology is solved, and the accuracy of accident risk management and the effectiveness of prevention measures are improved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202310522012.X
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-10
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-12
AI Technical Summary
The accuracy of the existing technology in high-risk industries is low in operational risk identification and risk level determination, which leads to frequent accidents, especially when young employees find it difficult to fully identify risks, resulting in insufficient prevention measures.
By analyzing the accident scenarios and sensitive factors that may occur in the operation project, forming an event chain, finding out key control points, and calculating risk parameters based on the failure probability and initial event frequency of the independent protective layer, improving the calculation accuracy of accident risk parameters.
Through more accurate calculation of risk parameters, managers can determine whether it is within an acceptable range. If not, add protective layers to reduce risks and ensure effective reduction of operational risks.
Smart Images

Figure CN118941064A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the field of risk assessment, and in particular to a method and device for analyzing risk of an operation project. Background Art
[0002] In recent years, in high-risk industries, such as high-altitude welding operations and oil storage and transportation operations, accidents caused by insufficient risk identification have occurred from time to time. The working environment of high-risk industries is complex and dangerous, and the work content often involves multiple types of work and three-dimensional cross-operation. In order to comprehensively and specifically analyze the operational risks, sufficient business experience and knowledge accumulation are required, and the personnel capabilities are required to be very high. At present, the work of identifying operational risks in various companies mainly relies on personnel experience, and most young employees find it difficult to fully identify operational risks if their knowledge level and experience are not in place. The identification of operational risks, the determination of risk levels based on these risks, and the establishment of effective preventive measures based on the determined risk levels are crucial to ensuring the smooth progress of operations.
[0003] A Chinese patent with application number 202110827359.6 discloses a method, device and computer equipment for determining risk parameters. In this method, the risk parameters of the accident are determined only based on the severity parameters of the consequences of the accident and the frequency of occurrence of the initial event, and the calculation accuracy of the risk parameters is relatively low. Summary of the invention
[0004] The technical problem to be solved by the present invention is to provide a method and device for analyzing operation risks so as to improve the accuracy of calculating the risk parameters of accidents.
[0005] The technical solution adopted by the present invention to solve the technical problem is: a method for risk analysis of an operation project, comprising the following steps:
[0006] According to the operation project, one possible accident in the operation project is selected for cause analysis, and the accident scene and sensitive factors that can cause the selected accident in the operation project are identified and screened;
[0007] Selecting the accident scenario as an initial event, and sorting out the intermediate events, consequence events, secondary events and derivative events caused by the initial event according to the product of the initial event and its relationship with the sensitive factors, so as to form an event chain;
[0008] According to the event chain information, finding the key control point in the event chain that caused the selected accident;
[0009] The risk parameter of the accident is calculated based on the required failure probability of the independent protection layer set for the critical control point in the operation project and the frequency of occurrence of the initial event.
[0010] Furthermore, the accidents include casualties, health damage, property damage, production stoppage and traffic accidents.
[0011] Furthermore, the frequency of occurrence of the initial event is obtained by using a statistical method.
[0012] Furthermore, the risk parameter
[0013] is the frequency of occurrence of initial event i (times / year);
[0014] PFD ij is the probability of failure on demand of the jth independent protection layer to prevent accident C in initial event i.
[0015] Furthermore, the initial events include external events, equipment failure events and human error events.
[0016] Furthermore, it also includes a step of judging the severity of the consequences of the accident before performing a cause analysis step on the accident to determine whether a cause analysis step is required. When the severity of the consequences of the accident exceeds a set accident standard, a cause analysis is performed; when it is less than the set accident standard, no cause analysis is performed.
[0017] Furthermore, the severity of the consequences of the accidents that may occur in the obtained operation project is judged by using a fault tree analysis method, an event tree analysis method, a reliability risk value method, a quantitative risk assessment method or a safety integrity level assessment method.
[0018] Further, it is confirmed that the sensitive factors in the operation project that can cause the selected accident include:
[0019] Judging the accident and obtaining the accident type;
[0020] Analyze the components of the accident;
[0021] A corresponding sensitivity factor is obtained based on the construct.
[0022] Furthermore, the key control point is a node that affects the preceding event or the succeeding event in the event chain.
[0023] An operation project risk analysis device used in the above-mentioned operation project risk analysis method comprises:
[0024] An identification module, for identifying and screening out accident scenarios and sensitive factors that may cause the selected accident in the operation project according to the possible accidents in the selected operation project;
[0025] The first analysis module is used to sort out the intermediate events, consequence events, secondary events and derivative events caused by the initial event based on the accident scene selected as the initial event and the relationship between the product of the initial event and the sensitive factor to form an event chain;
[0026] A second analysis module is used to find out the key control point in the event chain that causes the selected accident according to the event chain information; and
[0027] A calculation module is used to calculate the risk parameters of the accident according to the failure probability of the independent protection layer set for the key control point in the operation project and the frequency of occurrence of the initial event.
[0028] The beneficial effects of the present invention are as follows: an operation project risk analysis method and device of the present invention analyzes the accident in the triggering project, finds out the event chain that caused the accident, and then determines the key control points therein, and then calculates the risk parameters of the accident by the failure probability of the independent protection layer set for the key control point and the frequency of occurrence of the initial event, so as to more accurately calculate the risk coefficient of the accident, thereby facilitating management personnel to judge whether it is within an acceptable range according to the size of the risk coefficient. If it is not within the acceptable range, it is necessary to add a protection layer to reduce the risk to the level required by the allowable risk standard, so as to provide a guarantee for the investigation of operation risk factors and the setting of key control measures to ensure the effective reduction of operation risk events. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0029] Figure 1 is a flow chart of the analysis method of the present invention;
[0030] Figure 2 It is a structural diagram of the event chain. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0031] The present invention is further described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and embodiments.
[0032] like Figure 1 As shown, a method for analyzing the risk of an operation project of the present invention comprises the following steps:
[0033] Step 1: According to the operation project, select one of the possible accidents in the operation project for cause analysis, and identify and screen the accident scenes (accident events) and sensitive factors that can cause the selected accident in the operation project;
[0034] Step 2: Each event consists of a preceding event and a succeeding event. The output of the preceding event is the initial event of the next event. If there is no sensitive factor matching the output, the output of the preceding event will not cause secondary and derivative events. The prerequisite for the development of the output into the next event is that there are sensitive factors corresponding to the initial event in the surrounding area. Therefore, select an accident scene as the initial event. According to the output of the initial event and its relationship with the sensitive factor, sort out the intermediate events, consequence events, secondary events and derivative events caused by the initial event to form an event chain (see Figure 2 );
[0035] Step 3: Find the key control points in the event chain, which are nodes that can affect the preceding or succeeding events in the event chain;
[0036] Step 4: Calculate the risk parameters of the accident according to the failure probability of the independent protection layer set for the critical control point in the operation project and the frequency of occurrence of the initial event.
[0037] Obtain the possible accidents that may occur in the operation project, which can be specifically obtained by statistically analyzing historical
[0038] A method for analyzing risk of an operation project of the present invention analyzes the accident in the triggering project to find out the event chain that caused the accident, and then determine the key control points therein. Then, the risk parameters of the accident are calculated by the failure probability of the independent protection layer set for the key control point and the frequency of occurrence of the initial event. The risk coefficient of the accident can be calculated more accurately, which makes it easier for management personnel to judge whether the risk coefficient is within an acceptable range based on the size of the risk coefficient. If it is not within the acceptable range, a protection layer needs to be added.
[0039] The accidents in the present invention include casualties, health damage, property loss, production stoppage, traffic accidents, etc. Of course, more classifications can also be made by referring to GB6441 and other accident event standards.
[0040] Specifically, initial events generally include external events, equipment failure events, and human error events. Except in special circumstances, external events are generally not used as initial events for analysis. Usually, operational violations or illegal events / accident scenarios are mainly selected as initial events.
[0041] When determining the initial event, the following principles should be followed:
[0042] a) Review all causes of the incident to determine that the initial event is a valid initial event;
[0043] b) Identify other possible potential initiating events based on the accident to ensure that nothing is missed;
[0044] c) Each cause should be subdivided into an independent initial event to facilitate identification of the corresponding independent protection layer; d) The following events should not be used as initial events:
[0045] - Insufficient operator training;
[0046] -Incomplete equipment inspection, testing and maintenance;
[0047] - Safety protection devices (such as PSV, safety instrument system, etc.) are not available;
[0048] For specific initial event classes, see Table 1:
[0049] Table 1
[0050]
[0051]
[0052] In the present invention, the specific algorithm of the risk parameter adopts the following formula:
[0053]
[0054] is the frequency of occurrence of initial event i (times / year);
[0055] PFD ij It is the probability of failure on demand (PFD) of the jth independent protection layer (LPL) in the initial event i to prevent the occurrence of accident C, which is mainly derived from industry statistical data using statistical methods.
[0056] The frequency of occurrence of initial event i is also mainly derived from industry statistical data and obtained using statistical methods.
[0057] The failure probability of common independent protective layers is shown in Table 2.
[0058] Table 2
[0059]
[0060]
[0061]
[0062] In order to reduce the amount of analysis, a judgment can be made on the severity of the consequences of the accident before the cause analysis step is performed on the accident to determine whether a cause analysis step is required. When the severity of the consequences of the accident exceeds the allowed or acceptable accident standard (the set accident standard) in the operation project, a cause analysis is performed to confirm the initial events and sensitive factors in the operation project that can trigger the selected accident. When the severity is less than the set accident standard, no cause analysis is performed.
[0063] The severity of an accident is determined based on the severity of the consequences of the accident and the frequency of the initial event. Specifically, statistical methods, risk matrix analysis (RMEA), indicator system evaluation method (IST), operating condition hazard evaluation method), reliability-based maintenance (RCM) and other methods, fault tree analysis (FTA), event tree analysis (ETA), reliability risk value method (ALARP), quantitative risk assessment method (QRA), safety integrity level evaluation method (SIL) and other methods can be used to evaluate the severity of risk accidents. The basis for determining the consequence level of typical overpressure scenarios and chemical leaks is shown in Table 3;
[0064] Table 3
[0065]
[0066]
[0067] illustrate:
[0068] In this embodiment, there are high risk areas (20-25), relatively high risk areas (10-16), general risk areas (5-9), and low risk areas (1-4).
[0069] The specific steps of sensitive factors are to judge the type of the accident, obtain the accident type, analyze the components of the risk accident type, and obtain the corresponding sensitive factors based on the components. Accident types include physical factor accidents, chemical factor accidents, biological factor accidents, behavioral factor accidents, environmental factor accidents, and management factor accidents.
[0070] Common accident sensitive factors are shown in Table 4
[0071] Table 4
[0072]
[0073]
[0074]
[0075]
[0076]
[0077] The present invention also provides an operation project risk analysis device for the above analysis method, comprising:
[0078] An identification module, for identifying and screening out accident scenarios and sensitive factors that may cause the selected accident in the operation project according to the possible accidents in the selected operation project;
[0079] The first analysis module is used to sort out the intermediate events, consequence events, secondary events and derivative events caused by the initial event based on the accident scene selected as the initial event and the relationship between the product of the initial event and the sensitive factor to form an event chain;
[0080] A second analysis module is used to find out the key control point in the event chain that causes the selected accident according to the event chain information; and
[0081] A calculation module is used to calculate the risk parameters of the accident according to the failure probability of the independent protection layer set for the key control point in the operation project and the frequency of occurrence of the initial event.
[0082] Example:
[0083] Taking high-altitude welding operations as an example, high-altitude welding operations are carried out at a process site where there is a possibility of natural gas leakage. The operation activities include climbing high and performing pipeline welding operations on the operating table. The equipment, facilities and materials for high-altitude pipeline welding operations are stacked in the operating channel.
[0084] Step 1: For the work site, identify and screen the accident scenes and sensitive factors of high-altitude fall fatal accidents in places with one or more of the four problems: content overflow, uncontrolled energy release, negligent dangerous behavior, and defective environmental conditions. The sensitive factors are shown in Table 4. The results of accident scene identification are as follows:
[0085] 1. Climbing places involve increased potential energy of personnel, and there is a risk of falling from heights;
[0086] 2. Welding operations may penetrate the pipeline and cause natural gas leakage;
[0087] 3. Welding operations on the operating platform may result in platform collapse;
[0088] 3. Electric spark burns caused by improper positioning of welding operators during welding operations;
[0089] 4. Welding construction equipment and materials piled up in the operation channel may prevent personnel from passing normally;
[0090] 5. When an emergency occurs, emergency personnel may collide, slip, fall, etc. during emergency response, rescue and escape.
[0091] Step 2: Select the initial event: Violation of regulations, accidentally welding the pipeline, according to the selected initial event, Figure 2 Given the sequence of the event chain, find the intermediate event, and with the help of similar events and Table 4, the event chain is composed of the initial event (unintentional welding of the pipeline), the intermediate event (natural gas spillage, sparks from welding rods, and enabling events (sparks igniting the spilled natural gas)) and the consequence event (fire accident caused by natural gas combustion). After the fire accident, the flame burned the welder who was not able to escape in time (secondary event), causing him to fall from a height and die (derivative event), forming an event chain.
[0092] Step 3. By combing through the chain of events, it can be seen that when welding the pipeline, the venting of combustible gas and nitrogen replacement in the pipeline is one of the key control activities of this operation; after the gas in the pipeline catches fire, the welder can use the spare fire extinguisher to put out the flame in time, causing a larger fire, and will not burn the welding operator next to the operating table, so as not to cause the welding operator to fall; if there is a fall protection net when the welding operator falls, the welder will not fall to the ground and die from the fall.
[0093] The key control points on site are as follows:
[0094] The combustible gas in the pipeline is cut off and emptied and replaced with natural gas nitrogen;
[0095] The welding operation platform is equipped with fire extinguishers for welding operators to effectively extinguish initial fires in a timely manner;
[0096] Setting up a fall prevention net under the working operation platform can timely protect the falling operator from falling from a height.
[0097] Step 4: Calculate the risk parameter of the accident selected by the initial event according to the failure probability of the independent protection layer set for the key control point in the operation project;
[0098] The independent protection layers set up at the key control points are as follows:
[0099] Safety regulations for management of natural gas nitrogen replacement;
[0100] Fire protection management regulations for hot work;
[0101] Check the reliability of the operating platform and anti-fall net.
[0102] Step 4: Execute the "Safety Regulations for Natural Gas Nitrogen Replacement Management" according to Table 2, which belongs to "Intrinsically Safe Design"
[0103] PFD i1 =1×10 -2
[0104] Check Table 2, the implementation of "Fire Operation Fire Management Regulations" belongs to the implementation of "Operation Procedures"
[0105] PFD i2 =1×10 -2
[0106] Check Table 2, and the "check the reliability of the operating platform and anti-fall net" belongs to "fixed protective facilities"
[0107] PFD i3 =1×10 -2
[0108] The above three protection layers are all independent protection layers. After inspection, the operating platform and the anti-fall net have valid verification marks. The risk parameters of death from falling from height caused by the initial event described in this high-altitude welding operation are calculated according to the formula.
[0109]
[0110] The enterprise's allowable failure probability is 1×10-5, so it can be seen that the residual risk of setting up the protective layer for this operation is acceptable. No further control measures are needed.
Claims
1. A method for risk analysis of an operation project, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: According to the operation project, one possible accident in the operation project is selected for cause analysis, and the accident scene and sensitive factors that can cause the selected accident in the operation project are identified and screened; Selecting the accident scenario as an initial event, and sorting out the intermediate events, consequence events, secondary events and derivative events caused by the initial event according to the product of the initial event and its relationship with the sensitive factors, so as to form an event chain; According to the event chain information, finding the key control point in the event chain that caused the selected accident; The risk parameter of the accident is calculated based on the required failure probability of the independent protection layer set for the critical control point in the operation project and the frequency of occurrence of the initial event.
2. A method for analyzing project risks according to claim 1, characterized in that: The accidents mentioned include casualties, health damage, property loss, production stoppage and traffic accidents.
3. A method for analyzing project risks according to claim 1, characterized in that: The frequency of occurrence of the initial events is obtained by using a statistical method.
4. A method for analyzing project risks according to claim 1, characterized in that: The risk parameters f i I is the frequency of occurrence of initial event i (times / year); PFD ij is the probability of failure on demand of the jth independent protection layer to prevent accident C in initial event i.
5. The method for analyzing the risk of an operation project according to claim 1, characterized in that: The initial events include external events, equipment failure events and human error events.
6. A method for analyzing project risks according to claim 1, characterized in that: It also includes a step of judging the severity of the consequences of the accident before performing a cause analysis step on the accident to determine whether a cause analysis step is required. When the severity of the consequences of the accident exceeds a set accident standard, a cause analysis is performed; when it is less than the set accident standard, no cause analysis is performed.
7. A method for analyzing project risks according to claim 6, characterized in that: The severity of the consequences of the accidents that may occur in the obtained operation project is judged by using the fault tree analysis method, event tree analysis method, reliability risk value method, quantitative risk assessment method or safety integrity level assessment method.
8. A method for analyzing project risks according to claim 1, characterized in that: Confirm that the sensitive factors that can cause the selected accident in the operation project include: Judging the accident and obtaining the accident type; Analyze the components of the accident; A corresponding sensitivity factor is obtained based on the construct.
9. A method for analyzing project risks according to claim 1, characterized in that: The key control point is a node that affects the preceding event or the succeeding event in the event chain.
10. An operation project risk analysis device used in an operation project risk analysis method according to any one of claims 1 to 9, characterized in that: include: An identification module, for identifying and screening out accident scenarios and sensitive factors that may cause the selected accident in the operation project according to the possible accidents in the selected operation project; The first analysis module is used to sort out the intermediate events, consequence events, secondary events and derivative events caused by the initial event based on the accident scene selected as the initial event and the relationship between the product of the initial event and the sensitive factor to form an event chain; A second analysis module is used to find out the key control point in the event chain that causes the selected accident according to the event chain information; as well as, A calculation module is used to calculate the risk parameters of the accident according to the failure probability of the independent protection layer set for the key control point in the operation project and the frequency of occurrence of the initial event.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Risk parameter determination method and device and computer equipment
CN115689268A
