Complete electronic machine acceleration factor evaluation method considering competition failure
By determining the weak link components of the electronic machine and using the Monte Carlo simulation method to perform Weibull distribution fitting, the acceleration factor of the electronic machine is calculated, and the time and cost waste in the evaluation of high-reliable and long-storage life in the existing technology is solved. The problem has achieved accurate evaluation and conservation of acceleration factors.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411248469.7
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-09-06
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-29
AI Technical Summary
When evaluating high-reliable and long-storage life electronic machine products, existing acceleration test technologies often waste time and cost due to zero product failure or no significant degradation in performance, and the accuracy of the acceleration factor solution method based on component failure efficiency cannot be guaranteed.
By determining the weak link components of the electronic machine, a random life sample is generated using the Arrhenius model and Monte Carlo numerical simulation method, Vieble distribution fitting is performed, and the acceleration factor of the electronic machine is calculated to achieve the evaluation of high-reliability and long-storage life products. .
This method can accurately evaluate the acceleration factor of the electronic machine, save time and test costs, reduce the types and quantity requirements of components, and ensure the accuracy of the evaluation results.
Smart Images

Figure CN119047198A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of electronic whole machine life assessment, and more specifically, to an electronic whole machine acceleration factor assessment method taking into account competitive failures. Background Art
[0002] The storage life assessment mainly adopts methods based on on-site storage and accelerated testing. The method based on on-site storage test detects the performance parameters or failure data of the equipment under the actual storage environment on site, and realizes the storage life assessment of the equipment by analyzing the test data. The method based on accelerated test appropriately increases the stress level of the test environment, obtains the performance degradation or failure data under the accelerated stress level, conducts modeling analysis, and extrapolates the life under the normal storage environment stress level. Compared with the former, the latter is less time-consuming and less expensive, and can better meet the storage life assessment needs under the conditions of short development cycle of modern equipment and limited testing costs.
[0003] At present, the theoretical and experimental research of accelerated testing technology is mostly aimed at components and material-level products, and some basic data (life model and activation energy value, etc.) have been obtained. How to achieve rapid and highly reliable evaluation of the storage life of electronic whole-machine equipment through accelerated testing is a difficult problem that needs to be further solved in the field of storage life evaluation engineering.
[0004] For the accelerated storage test of electronic complete products, temperature stress is generally used as the accelerated stress. Determining the acceleration factor of the complete product is the core content of the accelerated storage test research of electronic complete products, and it is also the prerequisite for evaluating the storage life of the complete product through accelerated testing. According to the composition characteristics and product quantity of the electronic complete product, the following two acceleration factor evaluation schemes are generally adopted:
[0005] a) Acceleration factor evaluation scheme based on the whole machine or panel assembly;
[0006] b) Electronic equipment acceleration factor evaluation scheme based on component information.
[0007] When there are sufficient test samples, plan a) is preferred; when there are insufficient test samples, plan b) is preferred.
[0008] The acceleration factor evaluation scheme based on the whole machine or board assembly is to select a certain number of whole machines or circuit boards that can represent the characteristics of the whole machine to carry out accelerated testing, determine the life model under different stresses based on the product failure or degradation data, and obtain the acceleration factor of the whole machine or circuit board based on the Arrhenius acceleration model, and use this acceleration factor as the acceleration factor of the whole machine.
[0009] The electronic whole machine acceleration factor evaluation scheme based on component information is designed for situations where there are few test samples or insufficient funds, and the acceleration factor evaluation scheme based on the whole machine or board assembly cannot be used. The electronic whole machine acceleration factor is obtained by comprehensive calculation based on the basic data of the accelerated storage test research results of the components (life model and activation energy value, etc.) and the storage failure rate.
[0010] However, the currently adopted solution a) can only be effectively adopted under the premise that the whole machine or board components fail or degrade in the accelerated test for a certain period of time. At present, with the continuous improvement of the reliability level of the equipment itself, high-reliability and long-storage-life equipment products are already common. In the existing accelerated storage test research, after undergoing accelerated tests at 120℃ high temperature stress conditions for 5000h-6000h, the product still often faces the research dilemma of zero failure and no obvious degradation of performance parameters, resulting in a large waste of time and cost in the evaluation stage.
[0011] In solution b), the method for solving the acceleration factor based on the comprehensive method of component failure rate uses an empirical value or recommended value based on exponential distribution rather than actual test results, which results in the inability to guarantee the accuracy of the acceleration factor. Summary of the invention
[0012] In view of the problem in the above-mentioned prior art that the product has not failed after a long period of testing, resulting in a large amount of time and cost wasted in the evaluation stage, the present invention provides an electronic machine acceleration factor evaluation method taking into account competitive failures, which can realize the evaluation of the acceleration factor of high-reliability and long storage life electronic machine products, saving time and testing costs.
[0013] In order to solve the above technical problems, the technical solution provided by the present invention is:
[0014] A method for evaluating an electronic device acceleration factor considering competitive failures comprises the following steps:
[0015] S1: Determine the weak links and components of the electronic equipment;
[0016] S2: setting the storage life of the weak link components to have equal distribution parameters at different stress levels, wherein when the distribution type is normal logarithmic distribution, the equal distribution parameter is the logarithmic variance; when the distribution type is Weibull distribution, the equal distribution parameter is the shape parameter;
[0017] According to the storage life distribution type, distribution parameters and activation energy of the weak link components at room temperature, the storage life distribution type and distribution parameters of the weak link components at high temperature are calculated using the Arrhenius model; wherein the room temperature is the on-site storage temperature of the electronic complete machine, and the high temperature is the high stress temperature selected for the accelerated test;
[0018] S3: Generate multiple random life samples of the weak link components at room temperature and high temperature respectively by using a simulation method; set the weak link components to be connected in series, and use a competitive failure model to calculate the random storage life sample value of the electronic device;
[0019] S4: performing Weibull distribution fitting on all the random life sample values to obtain Weibull scale parameters of the electronic device at room temperature and high temperature respectively;
[0020] S5: Calculate the ratio of the Weibull scale parameters of the electronic whole machine at room temperature and high temperature respectively, and obtain the acceleration factor of the electronic whole machine.
[0021] In the above technical scheme, only the weak link components of the electronic whole machine are analyzed, which can narrow the types and quantity range of components used for the analysis of the electronic whole machine, and reduce the guarantee requirements for the basic data results of the component-level accelerated storage test. At the same time, the above technical scheme takes into account the competitive failure of components, which can ensure the accuracy of the evaluation results. By generating multiple random life samples of weak link components, and using competitive failure to generate random life samples of the electronic whole machine, and then fitting the Weibull distribution of the random life samples of the electronic whole machine at room temperature and high temperature, and finally calculating the acceleration factor based on the obtained Weibull scale parameters, the acceleration factor of high-reliability and long storage life electronic whole machine products can be evaluated in this way, saving time and testing costs.
[0022] Preferably, in the step S1, weak link components are determined based on data of components of the electronic device after an accelerated storage test.
[0023] Preferably, in the step S1, it also includes performing a high temperature accelerated test on the electronic complete machine, and then performing a performance analysis on the components of the electronic complete machine to determine the weak link components.
[0024] Preferably, in step S2, when the storage life distribution type of the weak link component is a normal logarithmic distribution, the distribution scale parameter of the weak link component at high temperature is calculated according to the acceleration factor of the weak link component. The calculation formula of the acceleration factor of the weak link components is:
[0025]
[0026] In the formula, is the activation energy of the component at room temperature, k is the Boltzmann constant, T0 is the Kelvin temperature at room temperature, T i Kelvin temperature for high temperatures.
[0027] Logarithmic life mean parameters of weak link components at high temperature distribution The calculation formula is:
[0028]
[0029] In the formula, It is the mean parameter of the distributed logarithmic life of the components at room temperature.
[0030] Preferably, when the storage life distribution type of the weak link component is Weibull distribution, the distribution scale parameter of the weak link component at high temperature is calculated according to the acceleration factor of the weak link component. The calculation formula of the acceleration factor of the weak link components is:
[0031]
[0032] In the formula, is the activation energy of the component at room temperature, k is the Boltzmann constant, T0 is the Kelvin temperature at room temperature, T i is the Kelvin temperature of high temperature;
[0033] Distribution scale parameters at high temperatures The calculation formula is:
[0034]
[0035] In the formula, It is the distribution scale parameter of components at room temperature.
[0036] Preferably, in step S3, a plurality of random life samples of the weak link components are generated by using a Monte Carlo numerical simulation method, and the random samples of the weak link components are combined according to the same design specifications and connection methods to obtain random life samples of the electronic whole machine. A large number of random samples of weak link components can be generated by using the Monte Carlo simulation method, and combined into a large number of random samples of electronic whole machines according to certain rules, which can cover various situations that components and electronic whole machines may encounter, making the calculation results more reliable.
[0037] Preferably, in step S3, the calculation formula of the random life of the electronic device is:
[0038] T=min(T (1) ,…,T (M) );
[0039] Where M is the total number of weak link components in the electronic device, T (d) is the random lifetime of component d (d=1,…M).
[0040] Preferably, in step S3, when the storage life distribution type of the weak link component is log-normal distribution, the life distribution function of the dth component is:
[0041] F i (d) (t) = Φ[(lnt-μ i (d) ) / σ i (d) ],t>0
[0042] In the formula, μ i (d) For components d in S i Mean logarithmic life under stress, σ i (d) is the corresponding logarithmic life standard deviation; Φ(·) is the standard normal distribution function.
[0043] Preferably, in step S3, when the storage life distribution type of the electronic components is Weibull distribution, the life distribution function of the dth component is:
[0044]
[0045] Where η i (d) >0 is the component d distribution function in S i The scale parameter under stress, also called characteristic life; m (d) >0 is the shape parameter of the distribution.
[0046] Beneficial effects of the present invention:
[0047] (1) Analyzing the weak links of electronic equipment at the component level can narrow the types and quantities of components used for electronic equipment analysis and reduce the demand for the basic data results of component-level accelerated storage tests.
[0048] (2) The Monte Carlo numerical simulation method is used to generate multiple random life samples of weak link components, and competitive failure is used to generate random life samples of electronic complete machines. Weibull distribution fitting is then performed on the random life samples of electronic complete machines at room temperature and high temperature. Finally, the acceleration factor can be calculated based on the obtained Weibull scale parameter. This method can be used to evaluate the acceleration factor of high-reliability and long storage life electronic complete machine products, saving time and test costs, and ensuring the accuracy of the acceleration factor evaluation. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0049] Figure 1 The present invention is a flow chart of a method for evaluating the acceleration factor of an electronic whole machine considering competitive failures. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0050] The drawings are only for illustrative purposes and cannot be construed as limiting the present invention. To better illustrate the present embodiment, some parts of the drawings may be omitted, enlarged, or reduced, and do not represent the size of the actual product. For those skilled in the art, it is understandable that some well-known structures and their descriptions may be omitted in the drawings. The positional relationships described in the drawings are only for illustrative purposes and cannot be construed as limiting the present invention.
[0051] The same or similar numbers in the drawings of the embodiments of the present invention correspond to the same or similar parts; in the description of the present invention, it should be understood that if the terms "upper", "lower", "left", "right", "long", "short" and the like indicate orientations or positional relationships based on the orientations or positional relationships shown in the drawings, they are only for the convenience of describing the present invention and simplifying the description, rather than indicating or implying that the device or element referred to must have a specific orientation, be constructed and operated in a specific orientation. Therefore, the terms describing the positional relationship in the drawings are only used for illustrative purposes and cannot be understood as limitations on this patent. For ordinary technicians in this field, the specific meanings of the above terms can be understood according to specific circumstances.
[0052] The technical solution of the present invention is further described in detail below through specific embodiments and in conjunction with the accompanying drawings:
[0053] Example 1
[0054] After a certain electronic device has undergone a 6000-hour 120°C high-temperature accelerated storage test, the product has zero failures and no obvious performance degradation trend. The following steps of an electronic device acceleration factor evaluation method considering competitive failures are used to evaluate its acceleration factor:
[0055] S1: Determine the weak links and components of the electronic equipment;
[0056] S2: Based on the storage life distribution type, distribution parameters and activation energy of the weak link components at room temperature, the storage life distribution type and distribution parameters of the weak link components at high temperature are calculated using the Arrhenius model; wherein the room temperature is 21°C and the high temperature is 120°C;
[0057] S3: Generate multiple random life samples of the weak link components at room temperature and high temperature respectively by using a simulation method; set the weak link components to be connected in series, and use a competitive failure model to calculate the random storage life sample value of the electronic device;
[0058] S4: Perform Weibull distribution fitting on all characteristic life sample values to obtain the Weibull scale parameters of the electronic whole machine at room temperature and high temperature;
[0059] S5: Calculate the ratio of the Weibull scaling parameters of the electronic machine at room temperature and high temperature to obtain the acceleration factor of the electronic machine.
[0060] Specifically, in step S3, the Monte Carlo numerical simulation method is used to generate random life samples of multiple weak link components, and competitive failure is used to generate random life samples of electronic complete machines. Weibull distribution fitting is then performed on the random life samples of electronic complete machines at room temperature and high temperature. Finally, the acceleration factor can be calculated based on the obtained Weibull scale parameter. In this way, the acceleration factor of high-reliability and long storage life electronic complete machine products can be evaluated, saving time and testing costs.
[0061] Furthermore, in step S3, 100,000 random life simulations are performed on the weak link components, that is, 100,000 random life samples of the electronic whole machine are generated, and there are 50,000 random life samples of the electronic whole machine at room temperature and high temperature. This number can make the calculation result sufficiently credible and avoid unnecessary time cost waste caused by too many simulation times.
[0062] Furthermore, in step S3, the calculation formula of the random life of the electronic device is:
[0063] T=min(T (1) ,…,T (M) );
[0064] Where M is the total number of weak link components in the electronic device, T (d) is the random lifetime of component d (d=1,…M).
[0065] Furthermore, in step S3, when the storage life distribution type of the weak link component is log-normal distribution, the life distribution function of the dth component is:
[0066] F i (d) (t) = Φ[(lnt-μ i (d) ) / σ i (d) ],t>0
[0067] In the formula, μ i (d) For components d in S i The logarithmic life mean under stress and, σ i (d) is the corresponding logarithmic life standard deviation; Φ(·) is the standard normal distribution function.
[0068] Furthermore, in step S3, when the storage life distribution type of the electronic components is Weibull distribution, the life distribution function of the dth component is:
[0069]
[0070] Where η i (d) >0 is the component d distribution function in S i The scale parameter under stress, also called characteristic life; m (d) >0 is the shape parameter of the distribution.
[0071] The effect verification of this embodiment:
[0072] 1) Determine the weak link components of the electronic whole machine, and determine that 5 types of 7 electronic components are the weak links of the whole machine. The basic data of the accelerated storage test of the components are shown in Table 1:
[0073] Table 1 Life distribution type and activation energy of components in weak links of electronic equipment at room temperature
[0074]
[0075] 2) According to the Arrhenius model and the storage life distribution model of weak link components at room temperature, the distribution model of weak link components at high temperature is calculated, as shown in Table 2:
[0076] Table 2 Life distribution types of components in the weak links of electronic equipment at 120°C
[0077] Serial number model Lifetime distribution μ(η)(120℃) σ(m) 1 Component 1 Lognormal 11.39 hours 0.26 2 Components 2 Weibull 10.40 years 1.79 3 Components 3 Weibull 3.56 years 8.371375 4 Components 4 Weibull 14.38 years 3.56485 5 Components 5 Lognormal 8.90 hours 0.23
[0078] 3) The Monte Carlo numerical simulation method was used to simulate the model 100,000 times, and random sampling was performed on 5 types of 7 weak link components of the whole machine at normal temperature and high temperature to obtain random samples at normal temperature and high temperature respectively.
[0079] 4) Based on the Monte Carlo simulation data, the competitive failure model is used to obtain the storage random life data of the whole machine at normal temperature and high temperature. The storage random life data of the whole machine at normal temperature and high temperature are respectively fitted by Weibull fitting to obtain the storage life distribution of the whole machine at normal temperature and high temperature. See Table 3 for details.
[0080] Table 3 Distribution of storage life of electronic equipment
[0081] Serial number Temperature stress Lifetime distribution Scale parameter (η) Shape parameter (m) 1 normal temperature Weibull 67.6730 4.0714 2 120℃ Weibull 0.9388 4.3597
[0082] *Note: The unit of scale parameter (η) is year.
[0083] 5) According to the storage life distribution of the whole machine at room temperature and 120°C, the acceleration factor of the electronic whole machine under 120°C stress is 67.6730 / 0.9388=72.08.
[0084] Beneficial effects of this embodiment:
[0085] (1) Analyzing the weak links of electronic equipment at the component level can narrow the types and quantities of components used for electronic equipment analysis and reduce the demand for the basic data results of component-level accelerated storage tests.
[0086] (2) The Monte Carlo numerical simulation method is used to generate multiple random life samples of weak link components, and competitive failure is used to generate random life samples of electronic complete machines. Weibull distribution fitting is then performed on the random life samples of electronic complete machines at room temperature and high temperature. Finally, the acceleration factor can be calculated based on the obtained Weibull scale parameter. This method can be used to evaluate the acceleration factor of high-reliability and long-storage-life electronic complete machine products, saving time and testing costs, and ensuring the accuracy of the acceleration factor evaluation.
[0087] Example 2
[0088] This embodiment further supplements step S1 based on embodiment 1.
[0089] Furthermore, in step S1, weak link components are determined based on data of components of the electronic device after the accelerated storage test.
[0090] Furthermore, in step S1, it also includes performing a high temperature accelerated test on the electronic device, and then performing a performance analysis on the components of the electronic device to determine the weak link components.
[0091] The other features, working principles and beneficial effects of this embodiment are consistent with those of Embodiment 1.
[0092] Example 3
[0093] This embodiment further illustrates step S2 based on embodiment 2.
[0094] Further, in step S2, when the storage life distribution type of the weak link component is Weibull distribution, the distribution scale parameter of the weak link component at high temperature is calculated according to the acceleration factor of the weak link component. The calculation formula for the acceleration factor of the weak link components is:
[0095]
[0096] In the formula, is the activation energy of the component at room temperature, k is the Boltzmann constant, T0 is the Kelvin temperature at room temperature, T i is the Kelvin temperature of high temperature;
[0097] Distribution scale parameters at high temperatures The calculation formula is:
[0098]
[0099] In the formula, It is the distribution scale parameter of components at room temperature.
[0100] Further, in step S2, when the storage life distribution type of the weak link component is a normal logarithmic distribution, the distribution scale parameter of the weak link component at high temperature is calculated according to the acceleration factor of the weak link component. The calculation formula for the acceleration factor of the weak link components is:
[0101]
[0102] In the formula, is the activation energy of the component at room temperature, k is the Boltzmann constant, T0 is the Kelvin temperature at room temperature, T i is the Kelvin temperature of high temperature;
[0103] Logarithmic life mean parameters of weak link components at high temperature distribution The calculation formula is:
[0104]
[0105] In the formula, It is the mean parameter of the distributed logarithmic life of the components at room temperature.
[0106] The other features, working principles and beneficial effects of this embodiment are consistent with those of Embodiment 2.
[0107] Obviously, the above embodiments of the present invention are merely examples for clearly explaining the present invention, and are not intended to limit the implementation methods of the present invention. For those skilled in the art, other different forms of changes or modifications can be made based on the above description, and it is not necessary and impossible to list all the implementation methods here. Any modifications, equivalent substitutions and improvements made within the spirit and principles of the present invention should be included in the protection scope of the claims of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for evaluating the acceleration factor of an electronic device considering competitive failure, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: S1: Determine the weak link components of the electronic machine; S2: According to the storage life distribution type, distribution parameters and activation energy of the weak link components at room temperature, the storage life distribution type and distribution parameters of the weak link components at high temperature are calculated using the Arrhenius model; wherein the room temperature is the on-site storage temperature of the electronic complete machine, and the high temperature is the high stress temperature selected for the accelerated test; S3: Generate multiple random life samples of the weak link components at room temperature and high temperature respectively by using a simulation method; set the weak link components to be connected in series, and use a competitive failure model to calculate the random storage life sample value of the electronic device; S4: performing Weibull distribution fitting on all the random life sample values to obtain Weibull scale parameters of the electronic device at room temperature and high temperature respectively; S5: Calculate the ratio of the Weibull scale parameters of the electronic whole machine at room temperature and high temperature respectively, and obtain the acceleration factor of the electronic whole machine.
2. The electronic equipment acceleration factor evaluation method considering competitive failure according to claim 1, characterized in that: In the step S1, weak link components are determined based on data of components of the electronic device in an accelerated storage test.
3. The electronic equipment acceleration factor evaluation method considering competitive failure according to claim 2, characterized in that: In the step S1, it also includes performing a high temperature accelerated test on the electronic device, and then performing a performance analysis on the components of the electronic device to determine the weak link components.
4. The electronic equipment acceleration factor evaluation method considering competitive failure according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S2, when the storage life distribution type of the weak link component is a normal logarithmic distribution, the distribution scale parameter of the weak link component at high temperature is calculated according to the acceleration factor of the weak link component. The calculation formula of the acceleration factor of the weak link components is: In the formula, is the activation energy of the component at room temperature, k is the Boltzmann constant, T0 is the Kelvin temperature at room temperature, T i is the Kelvin temperature of high temperature; Logarithmic life mean parameters of weak link components at high temperature distribution The calculation formula is: In the formula, It is the mean parameter of the distributed logarithmic life of the components at room temperature.
5. The electronic equipment acceleration factor evaluation method considering competitive failure according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S2, when the storage life distribution type of the weak link component is Weibull distribution, the distribution scale parameter of the weak link component at high temperature is calculated according to the acceleration factor of the weak link component. The calculation formula of the acceleration factor of the weak link components is: In the formula, is the activation energy of the component at room temperature, k is the Boltzmann constant, T0 is the Kelvin temperature at room temperature, T i is the Kelvin temperature of high temperature; Distribution scale parameters at high temperatures The calculation formula is: In the formula, It is the distribution scale parameter of components at room temperature.
6. The electronic equipment acceleration factor evaluation method considering competitive failure according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S3, a Monte Carlo numerical simulation method is used to generate a plurality of random samples of the weak link components, the weak link components are set to be connected in series, and a competitive failure model is used to calculate the random storage life sample value of the electronic device.
7. A method for evaluating the acceleration factor of an electronic device considering competitive failures according to any one of claims 1 to 6, characterized in that: In step S3, the calculation formula of the random life of the electronic device is: T=min(T (1) ,…,T (M) ); Where M is the total number of weak link components in the electronic device, T (d) is the random lifetime of component d (d=1,…M).
8. The electronic equipment acceleration factor evaluation method considering competition failure according to claim 7, characterized in that: In step S3, when the storage life distribution type of the weak link component is log-normal distribution, the life distribution function of the dth component is: F i (d) (t)=Φ[(lnt-μ i (d) ) / s i (d) ],t>0 In the formula, μ i (d) For components d in S i Mean logarithmic life under stress, σ i (d) is the corresponding logarithmic life standard deviation; Φ(·) is the standard normal distribution function.
9. The electronic equipment acceleration factor evaluation method considering competition failure according to claim 7, characterized in that: In step S3, when the storage life distribution type of the electronic components is Weibull distribution, the life distribution function of the dth component is: Where η i (d) >0 is the component d distribution function in S i The scale parameter under stress, also called characteristic life; m (d) >0 is the shape parameter of the distribution.
