Intellectual property management work evaluation system
By building an intellectual property management work evaluation system, combining quantitative and qualitative data, and using a fuzzy-level comprehensive evaluation method, the problem that existing technology cannot effectively evaluate the intellectual property management work of enterprises is solved, and a comprehensive and objective evaluation of intellectual property management work is achieved. .
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410927391.5
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-11
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-06
AI Technical Summary
The existing technology cannot effectively evaluate the enterprise's intellectual property management work and cannot accurately evaluate its role in promoting enterprise development.
Build an evaluation system for intellectual property management, and use the data input module, data processing module and result display module, combined with quantitative indicators and qualitative scoring, and use the fuzzy hierarchical comprehensive evaluation method to generate comprehensive evaluation indicators and visual display results.
It has achieved a comprehensive, objective and accurate evaluation of enterprise intellectual property management work, able to evaluate qualitative and quantitative indicators, and improved the evaluation ability of intellectual property management work.
Smart Images

Figure CN119090324A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention belongs to the technical field of data management, and in particular relates to an intellectual property management work evaluation system. Background Art
[0002] As market competition becomes increasingly fierce, enterprises have an increasing demand for technological innovation; the importance of intellectual property rights to enterprises is also being recognized by more and more enterprises; issues such as protecting intellectual property rights, improving the quality of intellectual property applications, and strengthening intellectual property information management are all difficult problems that enterprises need to solve in intellectual property management; in order to meet the needs of enterprises, more and more enterprises are beginning to use intellectual property resource management systems to enhance their innovation capabilities and competitiveness.
[0003] Chinese patent CN114493122A discloses an enterprise intellectual property management system, which institutionalizes, proceduralizes and quantifies the intellectual property management of enterprises, unifies intellectual property management with the development strategy of enterprises, integrates multi-system data through information technology, and manages patents throughout the entire life cycle, including: patent application plan module, project patent mining module, proposal application module, proposal plan review module, patent application module, patent classification module and patent approval module. However, it cannot analyze and judge the management of intellectual property rights, and thus cannot effectively evaluate the intellectual property management work of enterprises, and thus cannot play the role of intellectual property rights in promoting the development of enterprises.
[0004] Chinese patent CN117473173A proposes a patent achievement transformation management system and method based on big data, which inputs the platform's entrusted patents into the patent information analysis model to obtain the first patent information, inputs the first patent information into the conversion rate evaluation model to obtain the first conversion rate, determines the patent with a first conversion rate greater than the first preset value as a patent to be recommended, compares the first patent information of the patent to be recommended with the information of the platform's cooperative subject in multi-dimensional similarity, arranges the platform's cooperative subjects in descending order according to the similarity, determines the platform's cooperative subjects with a similarity greater than a threshold as the target cooperative subject, generates patent conversion recommendation information, and sends it to the account of the target cooperative subject. However, the patent does not disclose the evaluation indicators and evaluation models of intellectual property management work, and cannot be used to evaluate the intellectual property management work of enterprises.
[0005] Chinese patent CN109933703A discloses a method for constructing an enterprise intellectual property value assessment model, which uses a data acquisition system as a data input port and an assessment network as a calculation center to form an assessment model. The patent uses a vector feature tree, which can quickly and accurately assess the value of an enterprise's intellectual property, but is not suitable for evaluating the enterprise's intellectual property management work with qualitative and quantitative indicators. Summary of the invention
[0006] The present invention can comprehensively evaluate the qualitative and quantitative indicators of intellectual property management by constructing comprehensive, objective and accurate evaluation indicators for intellectual property management work, thus solving the technical problem that the prior art cannot effectively evaluate the knowledge management work of an enterprise.
[0007] The technical solution adopted by the present invention is as follows:
[0008] The present invention also provides an intellectual property management work evaluation system, comprising:
[0009] Data input module: The data input module includes at least one primary indicator module for intellectual property management work, and each primary indicator module for intellectual property management work includes at least one secondary indicator input module for intellectual property management work; the secondary indicator input module for intellectual property management work inputs quantitative indicator data and qualitative scoring data and sends them to the data processing module;
[0010] Data processing module: The data processing module receives the input quantitative indicator data and qualitative scoring data, and after processing, obtains the scores of the first-level indicators of each intellectual property management work and the overall score of intellectual property management work;
[0011] Result display module: The result display module provides a visual display of the first-level indicator scores of intellectual property management work and the overall score of intellectual property management work. The visual display forms include graphs and tables.
[0012] Furthermore, the result display module can generate a QR code, and the evaluation results of the intellectual property management work can be obtained by scanning the QR code.
[0013] Furthermore, when data from two or more units are input into the intellectual property management work evaluation system, the data of all input units are statistically ranked and displayed through a result display module.
[0014] Furthermore, the data processing module pre-sets a primary indicator weight matrix, a secondary indicator weight matrix, a scoring standard, a membership function and a grade evaluation matrix;
[0015] The data processing module processes the input quantitative indicator data and qualitative scoring data through the preset scoring criteria and membership function to obtain the first-level indicator fuzzy evaluation matrix;
[0016] The data processing module multiplies the secondary indicator weight matrix with the corresponding primary indicator fuzzy evaluation matrix to obtain the primary indicator fuzzy evaluation result matrix;
[0017] The data processing module multiplies the grade evaluation matrix with the transposed matrix of the first-level indicator fuzzy evaluation result matrix to obtain the first-level indicator score of intellectual property management work;
[0018] The data processing module combines the fuzzy evaluation result matrices of each first-level indicator into a joint fuzzy evaluation matrix, and multiplies the first-level indicator weight matrix with the joint fuzzy evaluation matrix to obtain an overall fuzzy evaluation result matrix;
[0019] The data processing module multiplies the grade evaluation matrix with the transposed matrix of the overall fuzzy evaluation result matrix to obtain the overall score of intellectual property management work.
[0020] Furthermore, the membership function is as follows:
[0021]
[0022]
[0023]
[0024]
[0025]
[0026] Among them, X is the calculated score of the secondary indicator;
[0027] R1 is the evaluation level threshold of “excellent”, R2 is the evaluation level threshold of “good”, R3 is the evaluation level threshold of “average”, R4 is the evaluation level threshold of “pass”, and R5 is the evaluation level threshold of “poor”;
[0028] r1 is the percentage of "excellent" scores, r2 is the percentage of "good" scores, r3 is the percentage of "average" scores, r4 is the percentage of "passing" scores, and r5 is the percentage of "poor" scores; r1+r2+r3+r4+r5=1;
[0029] Each secondary indicator under each primary indicator calculates r1, r2, r3, r4 and r5 respectively to form a fuzzy evaluation matrix row vector [r1 r2 r3 r4 r5]. The fuzzy evaluation matrix row vectors of each secondary indicator constitute the corresponding primary indicator fuzzy evaluation matrix.
[0030] Furthermore, the geometric mean method is used to calculate the weight matrix in the primary indicator weight matrix and the secondary indicator weight matrix, including the following steps:
[0031] Step S11, constructing a judgment matrix;
[0032] Step S12, multiply the elements in the judgment matrix row by row to obtain a row matrix, and the i-th column element c in the row matrix i for:
[0033]
[0034] Step S13, the element c in the row matrix i Taking n as the power, we get
[0035]
[0036] Step S14, normalize the obtained row matrix, that is, divide each column element by the sum of all column elements to obtain a weight matrix W, that is:
[0037]
[0038] Among them, n is the number of indicators, a ij is the element in the i-th row and j-th column in the judgment matrix.
[0039] Furthermore, the calculation formula of the first-level index fuzzy evaluation result matrix B' is as follows:
[0040] B'=W'×R'
[0041] Among them, W' is the secondary indicator weight matrix, and R' is the primary indicator fuzzy evaluation matrix;
[0042] The calculation formula of the overall fuzzy evaluation result matrix B is as follows:
[0043] B=W×R
[0044] Among them, W is the first-level index weight matrix, R is the joint fuzzy evaluation matrix, R = [R1'R'2…R' m ] T , R1' is the first level indicator fuzzy evaluation matrix, R'2 is the second level indicator fuzzy evaluation matrix, R' m is the mth first-level indicator fuzzy evaluation matrix, m is the number of first-level indicators;
[0045] The calculation formula for the first-level indicator score E' of intellectual property management work is as follows:
[0046] E'=D×B' T
[0047] The calculation formula for the overall score E of intellectual property management work is as follows:
[0048] E=D×B T
[0049] Wherein, D is the rating matrix, D = [90 80 70 60 50].
[0050] Furthermore, the result display module displays the first-level indicator score E' of intellectual property management work and the overall score E of intellectual property management work, and displays the evaluation level based on E' and E:
[0051] When E'≥90, the corresponding first-level indicator evaluation level of intellectual property management work is "excellent"; when E≥90, the overall evaluation level of intellectual property management work is "excellent";
[0052] When 80≤E'<90, the corresponding first-level indicator evaluation level of intellectual property management is "good"; when 80≤E<90, the overall evaluation level of intellectual property management is "good";
[0053] When 70≤E'<80, the corresponding first-level indicator evaluation level of intellectual property management is "general"; when 70≤E<80, the overall evaluation level of intellectual property management is "general";
[0054] When 60≤E'<70, the corresponding first-level indicator evaluation level of intellectual property management work is "passing"; when 60≤E<70, the overall evaluation level of intellectual property management work is "passing";
[0055] When E'<60, the corresponding first-level indicator evaluation grade of intellectual property management work is "poor"; when E<60, the overall evaluation grade of intellectual property management work is "poor".
[0056] Furthermore, the first-level indicator module of intellectual property management work includes: intellectual property creation indicator module U1, intellectual property basic management indicator module U2, intellectual property information utilization indicator module U3, intellectual property application indicator module U4, intellectual property protection indicator module U5, intellectual property work reward indicator module U6;
[0057] Enter the following secondary indicator quantitative indicator data in the intellectual property creation indicator module U1:
[0058] The total effective intellectual property rights index data U11, the intellectual property rights application index data U12, the intellectual property rights authorization index data U13, the intellectual property rights application index completion rate index data U14, the invention patent application ratio index data U15, the invention patent authorization rate index data U16, the effective invention patent index completion rate index data U17, the authorized patent maintenance rate index data U18;
[0059] Enter the following secondary indicator qualitative scoring data in the intellectual property basic management indicator module U2:
[0060] Intellectual property management institution establishment index scoring data U21, intellectual property management system construction index scoring data U22, intellectual property management personnel allocation index scoring data U23, intellectual property information system construction index scoring data U24, intellectual property management work implementation index scoring data U25, intellectual property work information reporting index scoring data U26;
[0061] Enter the following secondary indicator quantitative indicator data in the intellectual property information utilization indicator module U3:
[0062] Project application index data U31, project establishment index data U32, project implementation index data U33;
[0063] Enter the following secondary indicator quantitative indicator data in the intellectual property application indicator module U4:
[0064] Transfer license quantity indicator data U41, pledge financing valuation share quantity indicator data U42, cooperation implementation quantity indicator data U43, income amount indicator data U44;
[0065] Enter the following secondary indicator qualitative scoring data in the intellectual property protection indicator module U5:
[0066] Intellectual property early warning mechanism index scoring data U51, intellectual property rights protection capability index scoring data U52, intellectual property rights protection awareness index scoring data U53;
[0067] Enter the following secondary indicator quantitative indicator data in the intellectual property protection indicator module U5:
[0068] Intellectual property protection case indicator data U54;
[0069] Enter the following secondary indicator quantitative indicator data in the Intellectual Property Work Reward Indicator Module U6:
[0070] China Patent Award index data U61, national award index data U62, provincial and ministerial award index data U63, group / company level award data U64, group association award data U65.
[0071] Furthermore, the qualitative scoring data is scored by at least two intellectual property management work assessors and obtained through weighted average or geometric average.
[0072] The present invention also provides a method for evaluating intellectual property management work, comprising the following steps:
[0073] Step 1: constructing evaluation indicators for intellectual property management work, wherein the evaluation indicators include at least one primary indicator, and each primary indicator includes at least one secondary indicator;
[0074] Step 2: Determine the scoring rules for each secondary indicator, calculate the scores of each secondary indicator, and establish the corresponding primary indicator fuzzy evaluation matrix;
[0075] Step 3, construct a judgment matrix, calculate the weights of the first-level indicators and the second-level indicators, and form the first-level indicator weight matrix and the second-level indicator weight matrix respectively;
[0076] Step 4, multiplying the secondary indicator weight matrix with the corresponding primary indicator fuzzy evaluation matrix to obtain the primary indicator fuzzy evaluation result matrix;
[0077] Step 5, construct a grade evaluation matrix, multiply the grade evaluation matrix by the transposed matrix of the first-level indicator fuzzy evaluation result matrix, and obtain the first-level indicator score of intellectual property management work;
[0078] Step 6, the fuzzy evaluation result matrices of each first-level indicator are combined into a joint fuzzy evaluation matrix, and the first-level indicator weight matrix is multiplied by the joint fuzzy evaluation matrix to obtain an overall fuzzy evaluation result matrix;
[0079] Step 7, multiplying the grade evaluation matrix by the transposed matrix of the overall fuzzy evaluation result matrix to obtain the overall score of intellectual property management work;
[0080] Step 8: Based on the overall score of intellectual property management work and the score of the first-level indicators of intellectual property management work, make an overall evaluation and a specific evaluation of the intellectual property management work respectively.
[0081] Furthermore, the first-level indicators include: intellectual property creation index U1, intellectual property basic management index U2, intellectual property information utilization index U3, intellectual property application index U4, intellectual property protection index U5, and intellectual property work reward index U6.
[0082] Furthermore, the intellectual property creation index U1 includes:
[0083] The total effective intellectual property rights index U11, the intellectual property rights application index U12, the intellectual property rights authorization index U13, the intellectual property rights application index completion rate index U14, the invention patent application ratio index U15, the invention patent authorization rate index U16, the effective invention patent index completion rate index U17, the authorized patent maintenance rate index U18;
[0084] The basic intellectual property management indicators U2 include:
[0085] Intellectual property management institution establishment index U21, intellectual property management system construction index U22, intellectual property management personnel allocation index U23, intellectual property information system construction index U24, intellectual property management work implementation index U25, intellectual property work information reporting index U26;
[0086] The intellectual property information utilization index U3 includes:
[0087] Project application index U31, project establishment index U32, project implementation index U33;
[0088] The intellectual property utilization indicators U4 include:
[0089] Transfer license quantity indicator U41, pledge financing valuation equity quantity indicator U42, cooperation implementation quantity indicator U43, income amount indicator U44;
[0090] The intellectual property protection index U5 includes:
[0091] Intellectual property early warning mechanism index U51, intellectual property rights protection capability index U52, intellectual property rights protection awareness index U53, intellectual property protection case index U54;
[0092] The intellectual property work reward indicators U6 include:
[0093] China Patent Award Index U61, National Award Index U62, Provincial and Ministerial Award Index U63, Group / Company Level Award U64, Group Association Award U65.
[0094] Furthermore, the secondary indicators in step 2 include qualitative secondary indicators and quantitative secondary indicators; the qualitative secondary indicators are scored by expert scoring, and the quantitative secondary indicators are scored according to set calculation rules.
[0095] Furthermore, the first-level index fuzzy evaluation matrix in step 2 is obtained by calculating the membership function, and the membership function is as follows:
[0096]
[0097]
[0098]
[0099]
[0100]
[0101] Among them, X is the calculated score of the secondary indicator;
[0102] R1 is the evaluation level threshold of “excellent”, R2 is the evaluation level threshold of “good”, R3 is the evaluation level threshold of “average”, R4 is the evaluation level threshold of “pass”, and R5 is the evaluation level threshold of “poor”;
[0103] r1 is the percentage of "excellent" scores, r2 is the percentage of "good" scores, r3 is the percentage of "average" scores, r4 is the percentage of "passing" scores, and r5 is the percentage of "poor" scores; r1+r2+r3+r4+r5=1;
[0104] Each secondary indicator under each primary indicator calculates r1, r2, r3, r4 and r5 respectively to form a fuzzy evaluation matrix row vector [r1 r2 r3 r4 r5]. The fuzzy evaluation matrix row vectors of each secondary indicator constitute the fuzzy evaluation matrix of the corresponding primary indicator.
[0105] Furthermore, the row vector [r1 r2 r3 r4 r5] of the fuzzy evaluation matrix of the qualitative secondary index is directly calculated according to the ratio of the number of experts scoring, as follows:
[0106] r1 = number of experts who scored “excellent” / total number of experts;
[0107] r2 = number of experts who scored “good” / total number of experts;
[0108] r3 = number of experts who scored “average” / total number of experts;
[0109] r4 = number of experts who scored “passing” / total number of experts;
[0110] r5 = number of experts who scored “poor” / total number of experts.
[0111] Furthermore, constructing the judgment matrix in step 3 specifically includes the following steps:
[0112] Step 31, evaluating the importance between any two indicators in the first-level indicators, and evaluating the importance between any two indicators in the second-level indicators under the first-level indicators;
[0113] Step 32, the importance evaluation results of the first-level indicators and the importance evaluation results of the second-level indicators are respectively composed into corresponding judgment matrices A, which are as follows:
[0114] <![CDATA[a1]]> <![CDATA[a2]]> ...... <![CDATA[a n ]]> <![CDATA[a1]]> <![CDATA[a 11 ]]> <![CDATA[a 12 ]]> ...... <![CDATA[a 1n ]]> <![CDATA[a2]]> <![CDATA[a 21 ]]> <![CDATA[a 22 ]]> ...... <![CDATA[a 2n ]]> ...... ...... ...... ...... <![CDATA[a ji ]]> <![CDATA[a n ]]> <![CDATA[a n 1]]> <![CDATA[a n 2]]> <![CDATA[a ij ]]> <![CDATA[a nn ]]>
[0115] Among them, a n is the nth indicator for importance evaluation, n is the number of evaluation indicators; a ij For indicator a i Relative indexa j Importance evaluation; ji For indicator a j Relative index a i Importance evaluation; 1≤i≤n, 1≤j≤n; a ij >0,a ji =1 / a ij , a nn =1.
[0116] Furthermore, the indicator a in step 32 i Relative indexa jThe importance of the ij The values are as follows:
[0117]
[0118]
[0119] Furthermore, in step 3, the weights of the first-level indicators and the second-level indicators are calculated using any one or more of the following methods: geometric mean method, arithmetic mean method, eigenvector method, and least squares method.
[0120] Furthermore, the step 3 also includes checking the consistency of the judgment matrix, and the consistency check uses the consistency ratio index CR for judgment, CR=CI / RI, where RI is the average random consistency index, and the value is as follows:
[0121] n 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 RI 0 0 0.58 0.90 1.12 1.24 1.32 1.41 1.45 1.49
[0122] The calculation formula of CI is as follows:
[0123]
[0124] Among them, λ max is the maximum eigenvalue of the judgment matrix, n is the number of evaluation indicators;
[0125] When CR≤0.1, the judgment matrix is considered to have satisfactory consistency;
[0126] When CR>0.1, the judgment matrix is considered inconsistent and needs to be adjusted and the CR value recalculated until CR≤0.1.
[0127] The beneficial effect of the present invention is that it adopts the fuzzy hierarchical comprehensive evaluation method to propose a suitable intellectual property management model, judges the enterprise's intellectual property management level by combining qualitative and quantitative methods, and combines the particularity of the aerospace industry and its high technology, high investment, high output, high risk, and long cycle. From the six aspects of intellectual property creation, basic intellectual property management, intellectual property information utilization, intellectual property application, intellectual property protection, and intellectual property work rewards, an aerospace industry intellectual property management index evaluation system is established to accurately evaluate the intellectual property management work of aerospace enterprises. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0128] Figure 1 It is a structural diagram of the intellectual property work management system of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0129] The specific embodiments of the present invention are further described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings. It should be noted that the drawings are in very simplified form and use inaccurate ratios, which are only used to conveniently and clearly assist in explaining the purpose of the embodiments of the present invention.
[0130] The present invention provides an intellectual property management work evaluation system, such as Figure 1 As shown, including:
[0131] Data input module: The data input module includes at least one primary indicator module for intellectual property management work, and each primary indicator module for intellectual property management work includes at least one secondary indicator input module for intellectual property management work; the secondary indicator input module for intellectual property management work inputs quantitative indicator data and qualitative scoring data and sends them to the data processing module;
[0132] Data processing module: The data processing module receives the input quantitative indicator data and qualitative scoring data, and after processing, obtains the scores of the first-level indicators of each intellectual property management work and the overall score of intellectual property management work;
[0133] Result display module: The result display module provides a visual display of the first-level indicator scores of intellectual property management work and the overall score of intellectual property management work. The visual display forms include graphs and tables.
[0134] The following is further described in conjunction with a specific embodiment. In the specific embodiment, the evaluation index of intellectual property management work is constructed, including quantitative index (represented by C) and qualitative index (represented by N), see Table 1.
[0135] Table 1 Evaluation indicators of intellectual property management work
[0136]
[0137]
[0138] A first-level evaluation index judgment matrix is constructed, as shown in Table 2, where U1 is intellectual property creation, U2 is basic intellectual property management, U3 is intellectual property information utilization, U4 is intellectual property application, U5 is intellectual property protection, and U6 is intellectual property work rewards.
[0139] Table 2 First-level evaluation index judgment matrix
[0140] U1 U2 U3 U4 U5 U6 U1 1 5 3 1 4 4 U2 1 / 5 1 2 1 / 3 2 2 U3 1 / 3 1 / 2 1 1 / 3 1 2 U4 1 3 3 1 3 4 U5 1 / 4 1 / 2 1 1 / 3 1 2 U6 1 / 4 1 / 2 1 / 2 1 / 4 1 / 2 1
[0141] The geometric mean method is used to calculate the weights, and the formula is as follows:
[0142]
[0143]
[0144] Similarly, we obtain w2=0.112100, w3=0.094010, w4=0.295883, w5=0.089609, w6=0.060397.
[0145] Weight vector w = [w1,w2,w3,w4,w5,w6] T
[0146] Maximum eigenvalue λ max The calculation formula is as follows:
[0147]
[0148]
[0149] λ max ≈6.192824
[0150] CI = 0.0385648
[0151] CR=CI / RI=0.0385648 / 1.24≈0.031100<0.1
[0152] Through calculation, it can be seen that the judgment matrix CR of the first-level evaluation index is less than 0.1, which meets the consistency test requirements, indicating that the construction of the first-level evaluation index judgment matrix is reasonable.
[0153] The same method is used to construct the judgment matrix of each secondary indicator to obtain the corresponding weight vector w and the maximum eigenvalue λ max and consistency ratio index CR.
[0154] 1) Weight of evaluation indicators for intellectual property creation
[0155] A judgment matrix for the evaluation index of intellectual property creation is constructed, as shown in Table 3, where U11 is the total amount of effective intellectual property, U12 is the amount of intellectual property applications, U13 is the amount of intellectual property authorizations, U14 is the completion rate of intellectual property application indicators, U15 is the proportion of invention patent applications, U16 is the invention patent authorization rate, U17 is the completion rate of effective invention patent indicators, and U18 is the maintenance rate of authorized patents.
[0156] Table 3 Judgment matrix of evaluation indicators for intellectual property creation
[0157] U11 U12 U13 U14 U15 U16 U17 U18 U11 1 1 1 / 2 1 / 5 1 / 2 1 / 3 1 / 2 2 U12 1 1 1 1 / 3 2 1 / 2 1 / 3 3 U13 2 1 1 1 / 3 1 / 2 1 / 2 1 / 3 2 U14 5 3 3 1 3 3 1 3 U15 2 1 / 2 2 1 / 3 1 1 1 / 3 2 U16 3 2 2 1 / 3 1 1 1 / 2 3 U17 2 3 3 1 3 2 1 3 U18 1 / 2 1 / 3 1 / 2 1 / 3 1 / 2 1 / 3 1 1
[0158] Weight vector w1'=[0.064313, 0.093525, 0.081524, 0.260699, 0.096949, 0.134226, 0.220997, 0.047766].
[0159] Maximum eigenvalue λ max =8.421638; CI=0.060234.
[0160] The consistency ratio index CR=0.042719<0.1 meets the consistency test requirements.
[0161] 2) Weights of evaluation indicators for basic intellectual property management
[0162] A judgment matrix of basic intellectual property management evaluation indicators is constructed, as shown in Table 4, where U21 is the establishment of intellectual property management institutions, U22 is the construction of intellectual property management systems, U23 is the allocation of intellectual property management personnel, U24 is the construction of intellectual property information systems, U25 is the implementation of intellectual property management work, and U26 is the reporting of intellectual property work information.
[0163] Table 4 Judgment matrix of evaluation indicators for basic intellectual property management
[0164] U21 U22 U23 U24 U25 U26 U21 1 1 2 1 1 / 5 1 / 3 U22 1 1 2 1 1 / 4 1 / 3 U23 1 / 2 1 / 2 1 1 / 2 1 / 5 1 / 3 U24 1 1 2 1 1 / 4 1 / 3 U25 5 4 5 4 1 2 U26 3 3 3 3 1 / 2 1
[0165] Weight vector w'2 = [0.094686, 0.098274, 0.059648, 0.098274, 0.403625, 0.245493].
[0166] Maximum eigenvalue λ max =6.079805; CI=0.015961.
[0167] The consistency ratio index CR=0.012667<0.1, meeting the consistency test requirements.
[0168] 3) Weights of evaluation indicators for the use of intellectual property information
[0169] A judgment matrix of evaluation indicators for the use of intellectual property information is constructed, as shown in Table 5, where U31 is project application, U32 is project establishment, and U33 is project implementation.
[0170] Table 5 Judgment matrix of evaluation indicators for the use of intellectual property information
[0171] U31 U32 U33 U31 1 1 / 5 1 / 3 U32 5 1 1 U33 3 1 1
[0172] Weight vector w'3 = [0.113972, 0.480640, 0.405388].
[0173] Maximum eigenvalue λ max =3.029064; CI=0.016209.
[0174] The consistency ratio index CR=0.027946<0.1 meets the consistency test requirements.
[0175] 4) Weight of evaluation indicators for intellectual property utilization
[0176] A judgment matrix of intellectual property utilization evaluation indicators is constructed, as shown in Table 6, where U41 is the number of transfer licenses, U42 is the number of pledge financing shares, U43 is the number of cooperative implementations, and U44 is the amount of income.
[0177] Table 6 Judgment matrix of evaluation indicators for the use of intellectual property rights
[0178] U41 U42 U43 U44 U41 1 2 2 1 / 5 U42 1 / 2 1 2 1 / 5 U43 1 / 2 1 / 2 1 1 / 5 U44 5 5 5 1
[0179] Weight vector w'4=[0.174136, 0.123133, 0.087068, 0.615663].
[0180] Maximum eigenvalue λ max =4.121320; CI=0.040894.
[0181] The consistency ratio index CR=0.045438<0.1 meets the consistency test requirements.
[0182] 5) Weight of evaluation indicators for intellectual property protection
[0183] A judgment matrix of intellectual property protection evaluation indicators is constructed, as shown in Table 7, where U51 is the intellectual property early warning mechanism, U52 is the intellectual property rights protection capability, U53 is the intellectual property rights protection awareness, and U54 is the intellectual property protection case.
[0184] Table 7 Judgment Matrix of Intellectual Property Utilization Evaluation Index
[0185] U51 U52 U53 U54 U51 1 1 / 3 1 1 / 4 U52 3 1 3 1 / 2 U53 1 1 / 3 1 1 / 5 U54 4 2 5 1
[0186] Weight vector w'5=[0.107098, 0.290322, 0.101287, 0.501293].
[0187] Maximum eigenvalue λ max =4.015490; CI=0.005163.
[0188] The consistency ratio index CR=0.005801<0.1, meeting the consistency test requirements.
[0189] 6) Weight of evaluation indicators for intellectual property work rewards
[0190] A judgment matrix of evaluation indicators for intellectual property work rewards is constructed, as shown in Table 8, where U61 is the China Patent Award, U62 is the national award, U63 is the provincial and ministerial award, U64 is the group award, and U65 is the group association award.
[0191] Table 8 Judgment Matrix of Evaluation Indexes for Intellectual Property Work Awards
[0192] U61 U62 U63 U64 U65 U61 1 3 4 4 5 U62 1 / 3 1 2 2 3 U63 1 / 4 1 / 2 1 1 3 U64 1 / 4 1 / 2 1 1 3 U65 1 / 5 1 / 3 1 / 3 1 / 3 1
[0193] Weight vector w'6=[0.472703, 0.208429, 0.129823, 0.129823, 0.059221].
[0194] Maximum eigenvalue λ max =5.128045; CI=0.032011.
[0195] The consistency ratio index CR = 0.028581 < 0.1, which meets the consistency test requirements. Therefore, the judgment matrix of the primary and secondary indicators has satisfactory consistency, and the weight setting is reasonable, which can be applied to the evaluation of intellectual property management work, as shown in Table 9.
[0196] Table 9 Weights of evaluation indicators for intellectual property management work
[0197]
[0198]
[0199] The above quantitative evaluation indicators are comprehensively evaluated to obtain the evaluation criteria of quantitative indicators, as shown in Table 10.
[0200] Table 10 Evaluation criteria for quantitative indicators
[0201]
[0202]
[0203] Qualitative indicators are scored on a 100-point scale, divided into five levels: excellent (R1), good (R2), average (R3), pass (R4), and poor (R5), as shown in Table 11.
[0204] Table 11 Correspondence between qualitative evaluation levels and scores
[0205] R R1 R2 R3 R4 R5 evaluate excellent good generally Pass Poor Fraction Rˊ [90,100] [80,90) [70,80) [60,70) <60
[0206] Taking Unit B as an example, the following detailed description of the specific implementation method of intellectual property management work scoring.
[0207] 1) Quantitative indicator scoring
[0208] Table 12B Unit quantitative index evaluation standards
[0209]
[0210]
[0211] 2) Qualitative indicator scoring
[0212] Table 13B Unit qualitative indicator evaluation criteria
[0213]
[0214] 3) Constructing fuzzy evaluation matrix
[0215] According to the score of each indicator, the membership of each indicator is calculated through the membership function to form the fuzzy judgment matrix R.
[0216] Taking the total effective intellectual property rights (U11), the number of intellectual property applications (U12), and the intellectual property early warning mechanism (U51) as examples, we can perform fuzzy processing on them and obtain the following:
[0217] Example 1: Total effective intellectual property rights (U11)
[0218] X=107, r1=0, r2=0, r3=0, r4=0.035, r5=0.965.
[0219] Example 2: Number of intellectual property applications (U12)
[0220] X=44, r1=0, r2=0, r3=0, r4=0.8, r5=0.2.
[0221] Example 3: Intellectual Property Early Warning Mechanism (U51)
[0222] X=82, r1=0.2, r2=0.8, r3=0, r4=0, r5=0.
[0223] The fuzzy evaluation matrix and indicator weights of the intellectual property management work of Unit B are as follows:
[0224] Table 14B Fuzzy evaluation matrix and indicator weights for unit intellectual property management
[0225]
[0226]
[0227] 4) Conduct comprehensive evaluation
[0228] A and R are combined to obtain the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation result B, where:
[0229] B1=(0.626411,0.059596,0.074630,0.14229,0.097072)
[0230] Similarly, we obtain:
[0231] B2=(0.798188,0.201813,0,0,0);
[0232] B3=(0.51936,0,0.288384,0.192256,0);
[0233] B4=(0.789799,0,0,0,0.210201);
[0234] B5=(0.021420,0.477287,0,0,0.501293);
[0235] B6=(0.129823,0,0.129823,0,0.740353);
[0236] According to the first-level fuzzy evaluation results, establish the second-level fuzzy evaluation matrix R, R = (B1, B2, B3, B4, B5, B6) T
[0237] B=A×R=(0.593478,0.085536,0.060177,0.066168,0.184641).
[0238] 5) Conduct rating
[0239]
[0240]
[0241]
[0242]
[0243]
[0244]
[0245]
[0246] E=R·B=(90,80,70,60,50)×(0.593478,0.085536,0.060177,0.066168,
[0247] 0.184641) T =77.67(General)
[0248] The contents not described in detail in this specification belong to the prior art known to those skilled in the art. It is obvious to those skilled in the art that the present invention is not limited to the details of the exemplary embodiments described above, and that the present invention can be implemented in other specific forms without departing from the spirit or essential features of the present invention. Therefore, no matter from which point of view, the embodiments should be regarded as exemplary and non-restrictive, and the scope of the present invention is defined by the appended claims rather than the above description, and it is intended that all changes falling within the meaning and scope of the equivalent elements of the claims are included in the present invention.
Claims
1. An intellectual property management work evaluation system, characterized in that: The intellectual property management work evaluation system includes: Data input module: The data input module includes at least one primary indicator module for intellectual property management work, and each primary indicator module for intellectual property management work includes at least one secondary indicator input module for intellectual property management work; the secondary indicator input module for intellectual property management work inputs quantitative indicator data and qualitative scoring data and sends them to the data processing module; Data processing module: The data processing module receives the input quantitative indicator data and qualitative scoring data, and after processing, obtains the scores of the first-level indicators of each intellectual property management work and the overall score of intellectual property management work; Result display module: The result display module visualizes the scores of the first-level indicators of intellectual property management work and the overall score of intellectual property management work in the form of graphs and tables.
2. The intellectual property management work evaluation system according to claim 1, characterized in that: The result display module can generate a QR code, and the evaluation results of the intellectual property management work can be obtained by scanning the QR code.
3. The intellectual property management work evaluation system as claimed in claim 2, characterized in that: When data from two or more units are input into the intellectual property management work evaluation system, the data of all input units are statistically ranked and displayed through the result display module.
4. The intellectual property management work evaluation system according to claim 1, characterized in that: The data processing module pre-sets a primary indicator weight matrix, a secondary indicator weight matrix, a scoring standard, a membership function and a grade evaluation matrix; The data processing module processes the input quantitative indicator data and qualitative scoring data through the preset scoring criteria and membership function to obtain the first-level indicator fuzzy evaluation matrix; The data processing module multiplies the secondary indicator weight matrix with the corresponding primary indicator fuzzy evaluation matrix to obtain the primary indicator fuzzy evaluation result matrix; The data processing module multiplies the grade evaluation matrix with the transposed matrix of the first-level indicator fuzzy evaluation result matrix to obtain the first-level indicator score of intellectual property management work; The data processing module combines the fuzzy evaluation result matrices of each first-level indicator into a joint fuzzy evaluation matrix, and multiplies the first-level indicator weight matrix with the joint fuzzy evaluation matrix to obtain an overall fuzzy evaluation result matrix; The data processing module multiplies the grade evaluation matrix with the transposed matrix of the overall fuzzy evaluation result matrix to obtain the overall score of intellectual property management work.
5. The intellectual property management work evaluation system as claimed in claim 4, characterized in that: The membership function is as follows: Among them, X is the calculated score of the secondary indicator; R1 is the "excellent" evaluation level threshold, R2 is the "good" evaluation level threshold, R3 is the "average" evaluation level threshold, R4 is the "pass" evaluation level threshold, and R5 is the "poor" evaluation level threshold; r1 is the percentage of "excellent" scores, r2 is the percentage of "good" scores, r3 is the percentage of "average" scores, r4 is the percentage of "passing" scores, and r5 is the percentage of "poor" scores; r1+r2+r3+r4+r5=1; Each secondary indicator under each primary indicator calculates r1, r2, r3, r4 and r5 respectively to form a fuzzy evaluation matrix row vector [r1 r2 r3 r4 r5]. The fuzzy evaluation matrix row vectors of each secondary indicator constitute the corresponding primary indicator fuzzy evaluation matrix.
6. The intellectual property management work evaluation system as claimed in claim 4, characterized in that: The geometric mean method is used to calculate the weight matrix in the first-level indicator weight matrix and the second-level indicator weight matrix, including the following steps: Step S11, constructing a judgment matrix; Step S12, multiply the elements in the judgment matrix row by row to obtain a row matrix, and the i-th column element c in the row matrix i for: Step S13, the element c in the row matrix i Taking n as the power, we get Step S14, normalize the obtained row matrix, that is, divide each column element by the sum of all column elements to obtain a weight matrix W, that is: Among them, n is the number of indicators, a ij is the element in the i-th row and j-th column in the judgment matrix.
7. The intellectual property management work evaluation system as claimed in claim 4, characterized in that: The calculation formula of the first-level index fuzzy evaluation result matrix B' is as follows: B'=W'×R' Among them, W' is the secondary indicator weight matrix, and R' is the primary indicator fuzzy evaluation matrix; The calculation formula of the overall fuzzy evaluation result matrix B is as follows: B=W×R Among them, W is the first-level index weight matrix, R is the joint fuzzy evaluation matrix, R = [R1'R'2…R' m ] T , R1' is the first level indicator fuzzy evaluation matrix, R'2 is the second level indicator fuzzy evaluation matrix, R' m is the mth first-level indicator fuzzy evaluation matrix, m is the number of first-level indicators; The calculation formula for the first-level indicator score E' of intellectual property management work is as follows: E'=D×B' T The calculation formula for the overall score E of intellectual property management work is as follows: L=D×B T Wherein, D is the rating matrix, D = [90 80 70 60 50].
8. The intellectual property management work evaluation system according to claim 7, characterized in that: The result display module displays the first-level indicator score E' of intellectual property management work and the overall score E of intellectual property management work, and displays the evaluation level based on E' and E: When E'≥90, the corresponding first-level indicator evaluation level of intellectual property management is "excellent"; when E≥90, the overall evaluation level of intellectual property management is "excellent"; When 80≤E'<90, the corresponding first-level indicator evaluation level of intellectual property management is "good"; when 80≤E<90, the overall evaluation level of intellectual property management is "good"; When 70≤E'<80, the corresponding first-level indicator evaluation level of intellectual property management is "general"; when 70≤E<80, the overall evaluation level of intellectual property management is "general"; When 60≤E'<70, the corresponding first-level indicator evaluation level of intellectual property management work is "pass"; when 60≤E<70, the overall evaluation level of intellectual property management work is "pass"; When E'<60, the corresponding first-level indicator evaluation grade of intellectual property management work is "poor"; when E<60, the overall evaluation grade of intellectual property management work is "poor".
9. The intellectual property management work evaluation system according to claim 1, characterized in that: The first-level indicator modules of intellectual property management work include: intellectual property creation indicator module U1, intellectual property basic management indicator module U2, intellectual property information utilization indicator module U3, intellectual property application indicator module U4, intellectual property protection indicator module U5, intellectual property work reward indicator module U6; Enter the following secondary indicator quantitative indicator data in the intellectual property creation indicator module U1: The total effective intellectual property rights index data U11, the intellectual property rights application index data U12, the intellectual property rights authorization index data U13, the intellectual property rights application index completion rate index data U14, the invention patent application ratio index data U15, the invention patent authorization rate index data U16, the effective invention patent index completion rate index data U17, the authorized patent maintenance rate index data U18; Enter the following secondary indicator qualitative scoring data in the intellectual property basic management indicator module U2: Intellectual property management institution establishment index scoring data U21, intellectual property management system construction index scoring data U22, intellectual property management personnel allocation index scoring data U23, intellectual property information system construction index scoring data U24, intellectual property management work implementation index scoring data U25, intellectual property work information reporting index scoring data U26; Enter the following secondary indicator quantitative indicator data in the intellectual property information utilization indicator module U3: Project application index data U31, project establishment index data U32, project implementation index data U33; Enter the following secondary indicator quantitative indicator data in the intellectual property application indicator module U4: Transfer license quantity indicator data U41, pledge financing valuation share quantity indicator data U42, cooperation implementation quantity indicator data U43, income amount indicator data U44; Enter the following secondary indicator qualitative scoring data in the intellectual property protection indicator module U5: Intellectual property early warning mechanism index scoring data U51, intellectual property rights protection capability index scoring data U52, intellectual property rights protection awareness index scoring data U53; Enter the following secondary indicator quantitative indicator data in the intellectual property protection indicator module U5: Intellectual property protection case indicator data U54; Enter the following secondary indicator quantitative indicator data in the Intellectual Property Work Reward Indicator Module U6: China Patent Award index data U61, national award index data U62, provincial and ministerial award index data U63, group / company level award data U64, group association award data U65.
10. The intellectual property management work evaluation system according to claim 1, characterized in that: The qualitative scoring data is scored by at least two intellectual property management work assessors and obtained through weighted average or geometric average.
