Weld part inspection method
The copper sulfate solution method allows for easy and cost-effective confirmation of the buttering layer's presence in welded parts, addressing the issue of layer absence and ensuring structural integrity in dissimilar metal welding.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023082153
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-18
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-28
AI Technical Summary
In dissimilar metal welding, the buttering layer may not remain after main welding, leading to potential damage such as cracking in welded parts, necessitating a method to confirm its presence or absence.
A method involving the application of a copper sulfate aqueous solution to the welded part to visually distinguish the buttering layer by coloration, where the layer with lower iron content does not react to form a strong copper deposit, allowing easy identification of its presence or absence.
Enables quick and accurate confirmation of the buttering layer's presence, preventing damage and ensuring the integrity of welded parts, while being cost-effective due to the use of inexpensive reagents.
Smart Images

Figure 2024165726000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present disclosure relates to a method for inspecting a welded portion of a welded component made of dissimilar materials. [Background technology]
[0002] In the heat transfer tubes (boiler tubes) and piping that make up a boiler, components with different base materials are sometimes welded together. In dissimilar material welding, in order to prevent dilution of the base material and to prevent weld cracks and embrittlement, one component is buttered to form a buttered layer, and then the buttered layer is welded to the other component (see Patent Document 1). [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0003] [Patent Document 1] Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 11-192579 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0004] A buttered layer should normally remain in a weld obtained by performing main welding after buttering. However, according to the results of investigations by the present inventors, it has been confirmed that there are welds in which the buttered layer does not remain after main welding, for example, when the buttered layer is not sufficiently formed in advance.
[0005] Welded parts where the buttering layer does not remain may suffer from damage such as cracks. Therefore, it is necessary to check whether the buttering layer remains before using welded parts that have been buttered and then fully welded.
[0006] The present disclosure has been made in consideration of the above circumstances, and has an object to provide a weld inspection method that can check for the presence or absence of a buttering layer in a dissimilar material weld. [Means for solving the problem]
[0007] In order to solve the above problems, the weld inspection method of the present disclosure employs the following measures. One aspect of the present disclosure provides a weld inspection method for a welded component, in which a base material of a first component is carbon steel or low alloy steel, a base material of a second component is a corrosion-resistant alloy, and the first component is buttered with a welding material having a lower iron content than the base material of the first component and then actually welded to the second component, the method comprising the steps of: designating an inspection area as a surface of the welded component in a range from the first component side end of the actual weld to beyond an area where a buttering layer has been formed by the buttering; applying a copper sulfate aqueous solution to the inspection area; confirming coloring due to precipitated copper in the inspection area where the copper sulfate aqueous solution has been applied; and determining the presence or absence of the buttering layer based on whether or not there is an area where coloring due to the precipitated copper does not appear or an area where the precipitated copper color is lighter than the colored area between the colored area most strongly colored by the precipitated copper and the actual weld. Effect of the Invention
[0008] According to the above disclosure, the presence or absence of a buttering layer in a welded portion of dissimilar welded members can be confirmed by using a copper sulfate aqueous solution. According to the above disclosure, the presence of the buttering layer can be visually observed, so that the confirmation can be easily and quickly performed. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0009] [Figure 1] 3A to 3C are diagrams illustrating a manufacturing procedure of the welded member according to the first embodiment. [Diagram 2] 1 is a schematic cross-sectional view of a welded member according to a first embodiment. FIG. [Diagram 3] 3 is a schematic diagram of the outer peripheral surface of FIG. 2 after application of an aqueous copper sulfate solution. [Figure 4] FIG. 11 is a flow chart showing the procedure of a welded portion inspection method according to a second embodiment. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0010] (welding materials) A welded member to which the weld inspection method according to the present disclosure is applied will be described. The welded member may be, for example, a heat transfer tube (boiler tube) constituting a boiler, a part of a device such as piping, etc.
[0011] The weld inspection method according to the present disclosure inspects a weld of a welded component in which a first member and a second member having different base materials are welded together via a weld metal (main weld). The welded component has a buttered layer (or a region in which a buttered layer is formed) between the first member and the main weld.
[0012] The base material of the first member is carbon steel or low alloy steel. "Carbon steel" is an alloy of iron and carbon, and is a steel with a carbon content usually in the range of 0.02 to about 2 mass%. Carbon steel may contain small amounts of silicon, manganese, phosphorus, sulfur, etc. "Low alloy steel" is a steel containing alloying elements in a total amount of 5 mass% or less. The alloying elements are chromium, niobium, vanadium, copper, phosphorus, etc. The low alloy steel may be 1Cr steel, 2Cr steel, etc.
[0013] The base material of the second member is a corrosion-resistant alloy. The corrosion-resistant alloy has a higher chromium content than the first member. The "corrosion-resistant alloy" may be a low-alloy steel with a higher chromium content than the first member, an austenitic stainless steel, a nickel-based alloy, etc. Examples of the austenitic stainless steel include SUS304, SUS303, SUS316, etc. Examples of the nickel-based alloy include an Inconel alloy, an Incoloy alloy, a Hastelloy alloy, etc.
[0014] The base material of the weld metal (main welded portion) may be the same as or of the same type of metallic material as the base material of the second member.
[0015] Figure 1 shows an image of the manufacturing procedure for welded components. First, in an unconstrained state, a metal is welded (buttered) to the end portion of the first member 1 to form a buttered layer 2 (see FIG. 1(a)).
[0016] For buttering, a welding material with a higher chromium content than the first member 1 is used. For the welding material, it is advisable to use a material of the same type as the weld metal 4 used for main welding the first member 1 and the second member 3 or the base material of the second member 3. Buttering can be performed by build-up welding, thermal spraying, or the like. In buttering, a buttering layer 2 of a predetermined size (length, thickness) is formed. A groove for butt welding is machined in the formed buttering layer 2.
[0017] Next, the second member 3 and the buttered layer 2 formed on the first member 1 by buttering are butted together and are permanently welded under restraint conditions (see Fig. 1(b) and Fig. 1(c)). As a result, a welded member 5 is obtained in which the first member 1 and the second member 3 are joined together via the weld metal (main weld 4).
[0018] In the welded component 5 manufactured by the above procedure, the buttering layer 2 usually remains between the first component 1 and the main weld 4. However, it is possible that part or all of the base material of the buttering layer 2 may disappear due to the influence of heat input from build-up welding or thermal spraying during buttering or the influence of dilution that occurs during main welding. In such cases, the reference numeral 2 in FIG. 1 may be understood as the "area where a buttering layer is formed." The "area where a buttering layer is formed" does not necessarily refer to the presence or absence of a buttering layer, but may be an area where a buttering layer has previously existed.
[0019] [First embodiment] Hereinafter, one embodiment of a weld inspection method according to the present disclosure will be described with reference to the drawings.
[0020] (Weld inspection method) In this embodiment, an aqueous solution of copper sulfate is applied to the inspection area 15, and coloring due to precipitated copper is confirmed to determine whether or not a buttering layer is present.
[0021] Fig. 2 is a schematic cross-sectional view of a welded member to be inspected. In the welded member 10 of Fig. 2, a tubular first member 11 and a tubular second member 12 are butt-welded (uranami welded) via a main weld 13.
[0022] In Fig. 2, reference numeral 14 indicates the region where the buttered layer is formed. The region 14 where the buttered layer is formed extends from the end of the main weld 13 (the back bead) on the first member side to a position that is a distance of the length (L) of the buttered layer toward the first member side along the pipe axis direction. The end of the back bead (main weld 13) can be visually confirmed.
[0023] In a welded component in which a buttering layer of a predetermined length (L) has been formed in the axial direction of the tube by buttering, when all of the buttering layer remains, the "area in which the buttering layer has been formed" corresponds to the predetermined length of the buttering layer (L, the range indicated by the double arrow in Figure 2).
[0024] The inspection area 15 is the surface of the welded member, including the range from the end of the main weld 13 on the first member side to beyond the area 14 where the buttered layer is formed.
[0025] For example, if the length of the applied buttered layer in the axial direction (the distance of region 14 where the buttered layer is formed) is 10 to 20 mm, then it is advisable to set the inspection region 15 from the first member side end of main weld 13 to a position 50 to 100 mm away on the first member 11 side. The inspection region 15 is not limited to only the outer circumferential surface side of tubular welded member 10, and may be on the inner circumferential surface side.
[0026] When a copper sulfate solution is applied to the surface of a first component that contains a lot of iron, the following chemical reaction occurs: Fe+CuSO4 → FeSO4+Cu The iron is replaced by copper, which dissolves to form a green ferrous sulfate solution, and the copper precipitates on the surface of the first component as reddish metallic copper, causing the surface of the first component to be colored copper colored.
[0027] On the other hand, the base material (welding material) of the buttering layer has a lower iron content than the first member, so even if a copper sulfate aqueous solution is applied to the surface of the buttering layer, the color of precipitated copper does not appear on the surface of the buttering layer, or even if the surface of the buttering layer is colored, the color of precipitated copper is lighter than that of the surface of the first member.
[0028] FIG. 3 is a schematic diagram of the outer peripheral surface of FIG. 2 after the copper sulfate aqueous solution has been applied. In the inspection area after the copper sulfate aqueous solution has been applied, the surface corresponding to the first member 11 is most strongly colored by precipitated copper (colored area 16). By confirming the presence of an area (non-colored area 17) between the main weld 13 and the colored area 16 where no coloring by precipitated copper appears or where the color of precipitated copper is lighter than that of the colored area 16, it can be determined that a buttering layer remains on the welded member 10. The color difference between the colored area 16 and the non-colored area 17 can be visually identified.
[0029] In fact, when a 20% (w / v) copper sulfate (II) aqueous solution (CuSO4·5H2O) in deionized (pure water) was applied to the inspection area of a welded component made of a BW&6330 short pipe (first component) that had been buttered with Incoloy 925 and Incoloy 925 (second component), a colored area 16 and a non-colored area 17 were visually confirmed as shown in Figure 3. The non-colored area 17 was not colored by precipitated copper.
[0030] As shown in FIG. 3, the axial length of the non-colored region 17 is measured using a caliper 18 or the like, and the remaining rate of the buttering layer can be confirmed by comparing the axial length of the non-colored region 17 with the axial length of the buttering layer formed by buttering.
[0031] Second Embodiment The procedure for the weld inspection method according to this embodiment is shown in Fig. 4. The weld inspection method according to this embodiment includes the steps of (S1) cleaning, (S2) applying an aqueous copper sulfate solution, (S3) determining whether or not a buttering layer is present, and (S4) removing copper, in that order.
[0032] (S1) Purification The inspected area of the welded component surface is cleaned by removing foreign matter. "Foreign matter" refers to any material that prevents the copper sulfate solution from wetting the surface of the welded component. Examples of foreign matter include mill scale, oxides, grease, and contaminants (organic matter, etc.).
[0033] To remove the foreign matter, a cleaning agent or degreaser can be used. For example, Magnaflux's SKC-S can be sprayed onto the area to be inspected on the surface of the welded component, and then the area can be wiped off with a clean cloth to remove the foreign matter. For example, SKC-S can be soaked into a clean cloth and the area to be inspected on the surface of the welded component can be wiped off with a clean cloth to remove the foreign matter.
[0034] After removing the foreign matter, dry the area to be inspected on the surface of the welded component. For example, if SKC-S is used to remove the foreign matter, the surface of the welded component can be dried by leaving it for 5 minutes or more.
[0035] (S2) Copper sulfate aqueous solution coating As in the first embodiment, the copper sulfate aqueous solution is applied to the inspection area on the surface of the welded member. A cotton swab dipped in the copper sulfate aqueous solution can be used for application. Application may also be performed with a brush, spray, or the like. The copper sulfate aqueous solution has a concentration such that, when applied to the first member, the surface of the first member is colored with precipitated copper. For example, a 20% (w / v) copper sulfate (II) aqueous solution in deionized (pure water) can be used. Application may be performed once.
[0036] When inspecting a weld immediately after buttering, it is advisable to apply the copper sulfate solution to the area to be inspected on the surface of the welded member after confirming that the area has cooled to room temperature. When applying the copper sulfate solution, the temperature of the area to be inspected on the surface of the welded member should be such that the copper sulfate solution does not evaporate to become anhydrous, for example, 0°C or higher and lower than 100°C.
[0037] (S3) Determine the presence or absence of a buttering layer As in the first embodiment, the coloring due to precipitated copper in the inspection area is confirmed, and the presence or absence of a remaining buttering layer is determined based on whether or not there is a non-colored area between the actual weld and the colored area.
[0038] If a non-colored area of uniform width can be confirmed in the circumferential direction between the main weld and the colored area, it is determined that the buttering layer remains. If a non-colored area of uniform width cannot be confirmed in the circumferential direction between the main weld and the colored area (if the main weld and the colored area are adjacent), it is determined that the buttering layer does not remain. "Uniform" is not limited to the same width value, but allows for a degree of error that allows the width to be recognized as being approximately the same by visual inspection.
[0039] The non-colored area and the colored area are different in color type or color intensity. Therefore, the two can be distinguished by visual inspection. If a light color due to precipitated copper is confirmed in the non-colored area, it is recommended to determine the presence or absence of a buttering layer at the timing when the color difference between the non-colored area and the colored area is the largest. If the color difference between the non-colored area and the colored area is small, it is recommended to adjust the concentration of the copper sulfate aqueous solution or the time to check the coloring.
[0040] If no coloring due to precipitated copper (existence of colored areas) can be confirmed in the area being inspected, it is possible that the copper sulfate aqueous solution used for application is not functioning as a colorant. Therefore, a separate test is conducted to confirm whether the copper sulfate aqueous solution used is capable of precipitating copper by reacting with iron. In the separate test, the copper sulfate aqueous solution whose function is to be confirmed is applied to a test piece of carbon steel or low-alloy steel whose composition is known and which has been confirmed to have been properly cleaned, and coloring is confirmed.
[0041] If no coloring due to precipitated copper is confirmed on the surface of the test piece, it can be determined that there is a problem with the copper sulfate aqueous solution, so prepare a different copper sulfate aqueous solution (S2) and start over by applying the copper sulfate aqueous solution. If coloration due to precipitated copper is confirmed on the surface of the test piece, it can be determined that there is no problem with the copper sulfate aqueous solution.
[0042] (S4) Copper removal After checking for the presence or absence of a buttering layer, copper is removed from the inspected area on the surface of the welded component. The copper plating deposited in the colored area can be physically removed by polishing. For polishing, a polishing pad such as Scotch Bride (trademark) and a wire brush can be used. Areas other than the colored area where the copper sulfate solution was applied (non-colored areas, etc.) are also polished in the same manner as the colored area to remove the copper derived from the copper sulfate solution.
[0043] The welded portion inspection method according to this embodiment may include, after the copper removal step (S4), a step of confirming the presence or absence of remaining copper (S5).
[0044] (S5) Determination of residual copper After the copper removal in (S4), a copper detection reagent is applied to the area to be inspected on the surface of the welded component, and the presence or absence of remaining copper is confirmed by checking the coloration caused by the copper detection reagent. If remaining copper is confirmed, the above (S4) and (S5) can be repeated until no remaining copper is confirmed. If no remaining copper is confirmed, the area to be inspected on the surface of the welded component is wiped with a cloth, and the inspection is completed.
[0045] The copper detection reagent may be an ammonia-based solution. When the ammonia-based solution comes into contact with copper, a blue complex is formed. If copper remains in the area to be inspected, the surface of the welded part is colored blue or blueish. This coloring can be visually confirmed.
[0046] <Additional Notes> The welded portion inspection method according to the embodiment described above can be understood, for example, as follows.
[0047] A weld inspection method according to one embodiment of the present disclosure is a weld inspection method for a welded component (10) in which a base material of a first component (11) is carbon steel or low alloy steel, a base material of a second component (12) is a corrosion-resistant alloy, and the first component is buttered with a welding material having a lower iron content than the base material of the first component and then finally welded to the second component, the method comprising the steps of: (S2) applying a copper sulfate aqueous solution to the inspection region (15) including a range from the first component side end of the actual weld (13) to beyond a region (14) in which a buttering layer has been formed by the buttering; (S3) confirming coloring due to precipitated copper in the inspection region to which the copper sulfate aqueous solution has been applied; and judging the presence or absence of the buttering layer based on whether or not there is a region (17) in which coloring due to the precipitated copper does not appear or a region (17) in which the precipitated copper color is lighter than the colored region (16) between the colored region (16) most strongly colored by the precipitated copper and the actual weld.
[0048] When a buttering layer formed on a first member and a second member are dissimilarly welded via a welded portion, the buttering layer may disappear from the welded portion of the resulting welded member. According to the first aspect of the present disclosure, the presence or absence of a buttering layer in a welded portion can be determined by using a copper sulfate aqueous solution.
[0049] The copper sulfate aqueous solution is applied to the area where the buttered layer is formed and to the surface of the first component adjacent to said area.
[0050] If there is a large amount of iron in the inspection area to which the copper sulfate aqueous solution is applied, the iron is replaced by copper, and reddish brown copper is precipitated. Therefore, when the copper sulfate aqueous solution is applied to the first member, the surface of the first member is colored.
[0051] On the other hand, the buttering layer has a lower iron content than the first component. Therefore, even if a copper sulfate aqueous solution is applied to the buttering layer, it is not colored, or is difficult to color, so the color is lighter than the surface of the first component. Therefore, the first component and the buttering layer can be visually distinguished by the difference in color.
[0052] If the buttered layer remains, a non-colored area can be seen between the colored area and the actual weld. If the buttered layer does not remain, the colored area and the actual weld appear to be adjacent to each other, or the distance between the colored area and the actual weld appears to be shorter than the length of the buttered layer buttered to the first component.
[0053] According to one aspect of the present disclosure, since the presence or absence of a buttering layer can be visually determined, the inspection of the welded portion can be easily and quickly performed on-site. Since the copper sulfate aqueous solution is inexpensive, an increase in the inspection cost can be suppressed.
[0054] The size of the buttering layer applied during dissimilar material welding is often smaller for small diameter piping such as soot blower lance tubes than for large diameter piping such as main steam piping. The smaller the applied buttering layer, the more important it is to check whether the buttering layer remains.
[0055] A weld inspection method according to a second aspect of the present disclosure is the same as that of the first aspect, in which, before applying the copper sulfate aqueous solution, (S1) the area to be inspected is cleaned, and the presence or absence of the buttering layer is determined, and then (S4) copper is removed from the area to be inspected.
[0056] By cleaning the area to be inspected before applying the copper sulfate solution, the surface of the welded part can be wetted with the copper sulfate solution without being hindered by foreign matter. Also, by cleaning the area, coloring due to foreign matter can be avoided, so the presence or absence of a buttering layer can be determined more accurately.
[0057] Before applying the copper sulfate solution, it is advisable to confirm that the surface temperature of the area to be inspected is within a predetermined temperature range. The predetermined temperature range is a temperature range in which the copper sulfate solution does not freeze or evaporate. This prevents the applied copper sulfate solution from freezing or evaporating to become anhydrous, and therefore prevents the coloring caused by the precipitated copper from being inhibited.
[0058] After determining whether or not a buttering layer exists, the copper deposits can be removed from the area to be inspected to prevent solder embrittlement caused by residual copper. The copper deposits can be easily removed by thinly polishing them with a polishing pad or the like.
[0059] A weld inspection method according to a third aspect of the present disclosure is, in the second aspect, (S6) after removing the precipitated copper, a copper detection reagent is applied to the inspection area, and the presence or absence of remaining copper is determined by confirming coloration by the copper detection reagent.
[0060] After the copper removal process, the presence or absence of remaining copper can be checked using a copper detection reagent to more reliably prevent solder embrittlement. [Explanation of symbols]
[0061] 1,11 First member 2. Buttering layer 3,12 Second member 4,13 Welded section (weld metal) 5,10 Welding materials 14 Area where buttering layer formed 15 Inspected area 16 Colored area 17 Non-colored area (area where no coloring due to precipitated copper appears, area where the color of precipitated copper is lighter than the colored area) 18 Caliper
Claims
1. The base material of the first member is carbon steel or low alloy steel, the base material of the second member is a corrosion-resistant alloy; A weld inspection method for a welded member in which the first member is buttered with a welding material having a higher chromium content than a base metal of the first member and then welded to the second member, comprising the steps of: The surface of the welded member including the range from the end of the welded portion on the first member side to beyond the area where a buttered layer is formed by the buttering is set as the inspection area, Applying a copper sulfate aqueous solution to the inspection area; Confirming coloration due to precipitated copper in the inspection area to which the copper sulfate aqueous solution has been applied; A weld inspection method for determining the presence or absence of a buttering layer by determining whether or not there is an area between the colored area most strongly colored by the precipitated copper and the actual weld where no coloring by the precipitated copper appears or where the precipitated copper color is lighter than the colored area.
2. Before applying the copper sulfate aqueous solution, the inspection area is cleaned; 2. The weld inspection method according to claim 1, further comprising removing copper from the area to be inspected after determining whether or not the buttering layer exists.
3. 3. The weld inspection method according to claim 2, further comprising the steps of: applying a copper detection reagent to the inspection area after removing the precipitated copper; and determining whether or not copper remains by confirming coloration caused by the copper detection reagent.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Method and device of forming stress corrosion crack
JP1999192579A
