A method for identifying collision parameters between complex structures
By establishing the relationship between the nonlinear spring damping theoretical model and the ADAMS internal collision model, identifying the contact stiffness and maximum damping coefficient of complex structures, the problem of inaccurate collision force calculation in complex structures is solved, and the accuracy and reliability of the identification results are improved .
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202210260191.X
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2022-03-16
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-12
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-03-16
AI Technical Summary
In complex structures, the contact stiffness and maximum damping coefficient cannot be calculated through theoretical models, resulting in inaccurate calculation of collision force, affecting mechanical life and reliability design.
Establish the relationship between the nonlinear spring damping theoretical collision model and the ADAMS internal collision model. Through the corresponding relationship between the regular shape contact stiffness Hertz calculation formula and the maximum damping coefficient, dynamic simulation analysis is carried out to identify the contact stiffness and maximum damping coefficient, and realize the complex structures. Accurate acquisition of collision parameters.
The accuracy of collision parameter recognition and the results of ADAMS dynamic simulation are improved, the complexity and calculation amount of traditional multi-factor parameter recognition are reduced, ensuring that the recognition results are in line with the actual situation and can be migrated to collision processes in different operating states.
Smart Images

Figure CN114707306B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention belongs to the field of mechanical dynamics, and in particular relates to a method for identifying collision parameters between complex structures. Background Art
[0002] There are often many non-standard complex structures in complex equipment such as on-load tap changers. These complex structures will cause large contact collisions due to the existence of transmission clearance and material wear. The occurrence of such contact collisions often affects the material properties and the stability of the overall mechanical structure and even the mechanical life of the complex equipment. Therefore, obtaining accurate contact collision forces through collision models provides a reference for the mechanical life and reliability design of complex equipment. The subsequent collision parameter identification has become a hot issue in the current mechanical dynamics research.
[0003] There are often a lot of uncertainties in the collision process of complex structures. Some complex structure collisions cannot be tested for collision force due to the limitation of their structural size. In addition, it is difficult to directly obtain accurate collision force through experimental testing due to the limitation of the accuracy and resolution of the test instrument. Therefore, theoretical collision models and dynamic analysis software are often used for calculation. At present, the commonly used ideal collision models are often aimed at standard regular structures, such as linear collision models, Hertz nonlinear elastic models, and Hertz damping nonlinear models. Key collision parameters such as contact stiffness corresponding to complex structures cannot be calculated directly, so they are often calculated with the help of ADAMS dynamic analysis software. However, there is also the problem of inaccurate setting of key parameters in the internal collision model, and the results of determining parameters with empirical formulas are often inaccurate. Summary of the invention
[0004] The technical problem solved by the present invention is to provide a method for identifying collision parameters between complex structures, so as to solve the problem that collision parameters such as contact stiffness and maximum damping coefficient of complex structures cannot be calculated through theoretical models to obtain accurate collision force, thereby realizing accurate acquisition of contact collision force of complex structures.
[0005] To achieve the above object, the technical solution adopted by the present invention is:
[0006] A method for identifying collision parameters between complex structures comprises the following steps:
[0007] 1) Establish the relationship between the nonlinear spring damping theory collision model and the ADAMS internal collision model:
[0008] 2) Establish the corresponding relationship between contact stiffness and maximum damping coefficient in the ADAMS internal collision model;
[0009] 3) According to the relationship between the nonlinear spring damping theory collision model and the ADAMS internal collision model, as well as the corresponding relationship between the contact stiffness and the maximum damping coefficient in the ADAMS internal collision model, the contact stiffness value obtained by the Hertz calculation formula of the regular shape contact stiffness is used as a reference benchmark to determine the contact stiffness range data point sequence, and then ADAMS dynamic simulation analysis is performed to determine the contact stiffness and the maximum damping coefficient, thereby completing the collision parameter identification between complex structures.
[0010] A further improvement of the present invention is that the relationship between the nonlinear spring damping theory collision model and the ADAMS internal collision model is as follows:
[0011]
[0012] In the formula, c max - Maximum damping coefficient, D - Damping coefficient, d max - Maximum cutting depth, δ - penetration depth between contacting objects.
[0013] A further improvement of the present invention is that the corresponding relationship between the contact stiffness and the maximum damping coefficient in the ADAMS internal collision model is as follows:
[0014]
[0015] Where K is contact stiffness, e is restitution coefficient, and Δv0 is velocity difference after collision.
[0016] A further improvement of the present invention is that the recovery coefficient is calculated by the following formula:
[0017]
[0018] Among them, v A 、v B are the speeds of the master and slave after collision, v A0 、v B0 are the speeds of the master and follower before collision, respectively.
[0019] A further improvement of the present invention is that the Hertz calculation formula for the contact stiffness of a regular shape is as follows:
[0020]
[0021] Among them, K is the contact stiffness, σ1 is the deformation of the active member, σ2 is the deformation of the driven member, R1 is the curvature radius of the contact point of the active member, and R2 is the curvature radius of the contact point of the driven member.
[0022] A further improvement of the present invention is that the deformation of the active member and the deformation of the driven member are calculated by the following formulae:
[0023]
[0024]
[0025] Where λ1 is the first contact depth, λ2 is the second contact depth, E1 is the elastic modulus of the active member, and E2 is the deformation of the driven member.
[0026] A further improvement of the present invention is that the specific process of step 3) is:
[0027] The speed, collision time and recovery coefficient of the follower after collision are obtained through collision test;
[0028] Based on the Hertz calculation formula of contact stiffness of regular shapes, the contact stiffness reference value is determined. With the contact stiffness reference value as the center and an interval of 50N / mm, 10 values are taken above and below the contact stiffness reference value to obtain the contact stiffness value data sequence.
[0029] Determine the maximum damping coefficient value sequence corresponding to the contact stiffness value data sequence;
[0030] The velocity-time curve of the real active part before collision in the experimental test is used as the boundary condition input of the active part in the ADAMS dynamic simulation analysis. The dynamic analysis is performed based on the contact stiffness value data sequence, the maximum damping coefficient value sequence, the penetration depth between the contact objects and the stiffness index. The simulation results of the velocity, collision time and recovery coefficient of the follower after collision corresponding to each set of data in the contact stiffness value data sequence and the maximum damping coefficient value sequence are obtained.
[0031] The simulation results of the follower's post-collision speed, collision time and recovery coefficient corresponding to each group of data in the contact stiffness value data sequence and the maximum damping coefficient value sequence are compared with the follower's post-collision speed, collision time and recovery coefficient obtained from the collision experiment test, and the error of the simulation results corresponding to each group of data in the contact stiffness value data sequence and the maximum damping coefficient value sequence is calculated. The contact stiffness value data sequence with an error within the set threshold and the contact stiffness and maximum damping coefficient in the maximum damping coefficient sequence are obtained to complete the collision parameter identification between complex structures.
[0032] A further improvement of the present invention is that the collision time t is calculated by the following formula:
[0033] t=t A -t A0 =t B -t B0 (9)
[0034] Among them, t A With t A0 are the time before and after the collision of the active parts, t B With tB0 are the time before and after the follower collision, respectively.
[0035] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following beneficial effects:
[0036] For complex structure contact collision, the present invention obtains accurate collision parameters by establishing the relationship between the theoretical collision model and the ADAMS dynamic internal collision model, thereby solving the problem that the theoretical collision model cannot be used directly. The present invention realizes the normalization of all intermediate errors by establishing the relationship between key collision parameters, and ensures that the collision parameter identification results are in line with the actual situation, thereby improving the accuracy of the ADAMS dynamic simulation results. Compared with the multi-factor parameter identification and single-factor parameter identification commonly used in the collision parameter identification process of traditional dynamics software, the present invention can reduce the complexity and amount of calculation in the traditional multi-factor parameter identification process, and solve the problem that the single-factor identification does not conform to the actual situation and the accuracy problem. The present invention establishes a bridge between the two key collision parameters of the maximum damping coefficient and the contact stiffness by analyzing and comparing the ADAMS internal collision model and the theoretical collision model, and determines the maximum damping coefficient and contact stiffness corresponding to the complex mechanism based on the experimental results, thereby realizing the complex structure collision parameter identification. By establishing the relationship between the maximum damping coefficient and the contact stiffness, the multi-parameter identification is converted into a single-parameter identification process of contact stiffness. Parameter identification can be achieved by simply adjusting the contact stiffness, that is, error normalization is achieved. This can solve the problem that the theoretical collision model cannot be calculated, and the problem that the identification results in the single-factor identification process of collision parameters in traditional dynamics software do not conform to the actual collision process. The identification results can also be transferred to the calculation of collision forces in the collision process of different operating states under the structure. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0037] Figure 1 It is the overall analysis flow chart of the present invention.
[0038] Figure 2 Detailed flow chart for contact stiffness identification.
[0039] Figure 3 Comparison between collision output simulation and experimental data based on collision parameter identification results. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0040] In order to illustrate the technical solution and technical purpose of the present invention, the present invention is further introduced and described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
[0041] See also Figure 1 The present invention is a method for identifying collision parameters between complex structures, comprising the following steps:
[0042] Step 1: ADAMS internal collision model and collision parameter sensitivity analysis, determine that contact stiffness and maximum damping coefficient are two key influencing factors: by analyzing the ADAMS internal collision force calculation theory, determine the relationship between contact collision force and contact collision parameters (contact stiffness, penetration depth, stiffness index and maximum damping coefficient), and through single factor sensitivity analysis, determine that contact stiffness and maximum damping coefficient are two key influencing parameters;
[0043] By analyzing the internal collision force calculation theory of ADAMS, the collision force F is obtained. n The calculation formula is as follows:
[0044]
[0045] Where, δ is the penetration depth between contacting objects, K is the contact stiffness, ε - Stiffness index, its value is usually 1.5, c max - Maximum damping coefficient, d max - Maximum cutting depth, usually 0.1 mm, -Indicates the amount of deformation.
[0046] After the investigation of theoretical collision model and single factor exploration of ADAMS collision parameters, it was found that the stiffness index ε and the maximum penetration depth d max As the collision force F n The two variables in the calculation formula have a smaller impact on it than the contact stiffness and the maximum damping coefficient, and often the empirical values can be used directly, which can be selected as c max =1.5,d max =0.1mm. Contact stiffness K and maximum damping coefficient c max They are two important factors that affect the calculation results of collision force. They are indispensable and there is often a certain relationship between the two.
[0047] Step 2: Select the nonlinear spring damping theory collision model and the ADAMS internal collision model for mapping and comparison, and establish the connection between the nonlinear spring damping theory collision model and the ADAMS internal collision model:
[0048] The nonlinear spring damping theory collision model has the following functional expression:
[0049]
[0050]
[0051] Among them, e-restitution coefficient, Δv0-speed difference after collision, D-damping coefficient.
[0052] By comparing the nonlinear spring damping theory collision model with the ADAMS internal collision model, we can obtain:
[0053]
[0054] Step 3: Based on the connection between the nonlinear spring damping theory collision model and the ADAMS internal collision model, the corresponding relationship between the contact stiffness and the maximum damping coefficient in the ADAMS internal collision model is established;
[0055] The maximum damping coefficient c max By performing integral calculation, we can obtain:
[0056]
[0057] Then, by extracting the average value of the integral value, we can get:
[0058]
[0059]
[0060] Therefore, the deterministic relationship between contact stiffness and maximum damping coefficient in the ADAMS internal collision model is determined. Among them, the restitution coefficient as the only variable in the deterministic relationship can be obtained through experimental testing.
[0061] Step 4, collision parameter identification based on experimental test results: The contact stiffness value obtained by the Hertz calculation formula of the regular shape contact stiffness is used as a reference benchmark to determine the contact stiffness range data point sequence. Based on this, ADAMS dynamic simulation analysis is carried out according to the connection between the nonlinear spring damping theory collision model and the ADAMS internal collision model and the corresponding relationship between the contact stiffness and the maximum damping coefficient in the ADAMS internal collision model. By comparing the collision time and collision speed simulation results with the experimental results, the contact stiffness parameters are slightly corrected to determine whether the contact stiffness meets the calculation accuracy requirements, and the maximum damping coefficient is determined to complete the collision parameter identification of the ADAMS internal collision model. Specifically, the following steps are included:
[0062] Step 4.1, determine the restitution coefficient e through collision test and record the collision output test results: determine the speed of the master and slave parts before and after the collision by using speed test methods such as laser velocimeter, speed sensor and encoder, and then determine the restitution coefficient, and record the speed of the slave parts after the collision, collision time and restitution coefficient value test results;
[0063] The calculation formula of the restitution coefficient e is as follows:
[0064]
[0065] Among them, v A 、v B are the speeds of the master and slave after collision, v A0、v B0 are the speeds of the master and follower before collision, respectively;
[0066] The collision time calculation formula is as follows:
[0067] t=t A -t A0 =t B -t B0 (9)
[0068] Among them, t A With t A0 are the time before and after the collision of the active parts, t B With t B0 are the time before and after the follower collision, respectively.
[0069] Step 4.2, determine the contact stiffness analysis data sequence: Based on the Hertz calculation formula of the contact stiffness of the regular shape, determine the contact stiffness reference value, then take the reference value as the center, take 10 values above and below the specified interval of 50N / mm, and set the contact stiffness value data sequence to about 21 groups, that is, determine the contact stiffness variation range, and use the data sequence containing 21 groups of data values as the contact stiffness value data sequence for ADAMS dynamic analysis;
[0070] The Hertz calculation formula for contact stiffness based on regular shapes is as follows:
[0071]
[0072] Among them, K is the contact stiffness, σ1 is the deformation of the active part, σ2 is the deformation of the driven part, R1 is the curvature radius of the contact point of the active part, R2 is the curvature radius of the contact point of the driven part, E i is the elastic modulus of the object, λ i is the contact depth, and i is the object number.
[0073] Step 4.3, determine the maximum damping coefficient value sequence corresponding to the contact stiffness value data sequence: The maximum damping coefficient is another key parameter affecting the collision result. The maximum damping coefficient value sequence corresponding to the contact stiffness value sequence is determined based on the above-mentioned relationship between contact stiffness and maximum damping coefficient, i.e., Equation 7, as well as the recovery coefficient and pre-collision velocity difference obtained in step 4.1.
[0074] Therefore, through steps 4.2 and 4.3, the determined value sequence of the four key variables required in ADAMS dynamic analysis, namely contact stiffness, maximum damping coefficient, penetration depth and stiffness index, can be determined. Each set of collision parameters contains these four key variable values, thus forming a collision parameter sequence.
[0075] Step 4.4, ADAMS dynamic analysis under a given collision parameter sequence: Based on the 21 groups of contact stiffness value data sequences determined in step 4.2 above and the maximum damping coefficient value sequence, penetration depth value, and stiffness index value determined in step 4.3, a dynamic analysis is performed. After setting the maximum damping coefficient value sequence, the velocity-time curve of the real active part before the collision in the experimental test is used as the boundary condition input for the ADAMS dynamic simulation analysis, and the simulation results such as the velocity after the collision, collision time, and recovery coefficient of the driven part corresponding to each group of data in the contact stiffness value data sequence and the maximum damping coefficient value sequence are obtained;
[0076] Step 4.5, determine the optimal collision parameters based on experimental reference values: by comparing the simulation results obtained in step 4.4 with the speed, collision time and recovery coefficient results of the follower after collision obtained from the collision test in step 4.1, calculate the error of the simulation results corresponding to each set of data in the collision parameter sequence, and choose to set the maximum allowable error to about 10% (set threshold), that is, when the simulation result errors of the speed, collision time and recovery coefficient values of the follower after collision are within 10%, it is considered that the identified collision parameters are accurate and reliable, and determine the optimal results in the contact stiffness value data sequence and the maximum damping coefficient sequence that meet the maximum allowable error, and slightly correct them based on the obtained optimal results to obtain more accurate contact stiffness and maximum damping coefficient.
[0077] This method has been used in the collision of key components of the tap changer, and the results are good. The results obtained by calculating the collision parameters determined by the traditional empirical formula are far from the experimental results, and the error rate is as high as 200%. By using the collision parameters determined by this collision parameter identification method for simulation calculation, the collision output error rate of the collision time, post-collision speed, and recovery coefficient is small. The specific corresponding results are as follows Figure 3 As shown, the moving contact is an important collision component in the tap changer used to verify the method. The structure of this component is irregular and complex. By comparing the simulation results corresponding to the optimal collision parameters with the experimental results, the following is obtained: Figure 3 The error values shown in .
[0078] According to the present invention, the collision force of the collision process can be more accurately calculated. According to the present invention, the collision parameters determined are brought into the ADAMS dynamics software, and the collision force of the collision process can be more accurately calculated.
[0079] The present invention realizes the normalization of multi-collision parameter identification errors, reduces the complexity of traditional multi-factor collision parameter identification and the unreliability and authenticity of single-factor identification, and the method can be used for complex structure collision parameter identification based on dynamic analysis.
[0080] Although the embodiments of the present invention are described above in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, the present invention is not limited to the above specific embodiments and application fields, and the above specific embodiments are only illustrative and instructive, rather than restrictive. A person of ordinary skill in the art can also make many forms under the guidance of this specification and without departing from the scope of protection of the claims of the present invention, all of which belong to the protection of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for identifying collision parameters between complex structures, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: 1) Establish the relationship between the nonlinear spring damping theory collision model and the ADAMS internal collision model: 2) Establish the corresponding relationship between contact stiffness and maximum damping coefficient in the ADAMS internal collision model; 3) According to the relationship between the nonlinear spring damping theory collision model and the ADAMS internal collision model, as well as the corresponding relationship between the contact stiffness and the maximum damping coefficient in the ADAMS internal collision model, the contact stiffness value obtained by the Hertz calculation formula of the regular shape contact stiffness is used as a reference benchmark to determine the contact stiffness range data point sequence, and then ADAMS dynamic simulation analysis is performed to determine the contact stiffness and the maximum damping coefficient, and complete the collision parameter identification between complex structures; The relationship between the nonlinear spring damping theory collision model and the ADAMS internal collision model is shown in the following equation: In the formula, c max - Maximum damping coefficient, D - Damping coefficient, d max - Maximum cutting depth, δ – penetration depth between contacting objects; The corresponding relationship between contact stiffness and maximum damping coefficient in the ADAMS internal collision model is as follows: Where, K-contact stiffness, e-restitution coefficient, Δv0-speed difference after collision; The coefficient of restitution is calculated by the following formula: Among them, v A 、v B are the speeds of the master and slave after collision, v A0 、v B0 are the speeds of the master and follower before collision, respectively.
2. The method for identifying collision parameters between complex structures according to claim 1, characterized in that: The Hertz calculation formula for regular shape contact stiffness is as follows: Among them, K is the contact stiffness, σ1 is the deformation of the active member, σ2 is the deformation of the driven member, R1 is the curvature radius of the contact point of the active member, and R2 is the curvature radius of the contact point of the driven member.
3. The method for identifying collision parameters between complex structures according to claim 2, characterized in that: The deformation of the active component and the deformation of the driven component are calculated by the following formulas: Where λ1 is the first contact depth, λ2 is the second contact depth, E1 is the elastic modulus of the active member, and E2 is the deformation of the driven member.
4. The method for identifying collision parameters between complex structures according to claim 1, characterized in that: The specific process of step 3) is: The speed, collision time and recovery coefficient of the follower after collision are obtained through collision test; Based on the Hertz calculation formula of contact stiffness of regular shapes, the contact stiffness reference value is determined. With the contact stiffness reference value as the center and an interval of 50N / mm, 10 values are taken above and below the contact stiffness reference value to obtain the contact stiffness value data sequence. Determine the maximum damping coefficient value sequence corresponding to the contact stiffness value data sequence; The velocity-time curve of the real active part before collision in the experimental test is used as the boundary condition input of the active part in the ADAMS dynamic simulation analysis. The dynamic analysis is performed based on the contact stiffness value data sequence, the maximum damping coefficient value sequence, the penetration depth between the contact objects and the stiffness index. The simulation results of the velocity, collision time and recovery coefficient of the follower after collision corresponding to each set of data in the contact stiffness value data sequence and the maximum damping coefficient value sequence are obtained. The simulation results of the follower's post-collision speed, collision time and recovery coefficient corresponding to each group of data in the contact stiffness value data sequence and the maximum damping coefficient value sequence are compared with the follower's post-collision speed, collision time and recovery coefficient obtained from the collision experiment test, and the error of the simulation results corresponding to each group of data in the contact stiffness value data sequence and the maximum damping coefficient value sequence is calculated. The contact stiffness value data sequence with an error within the set threshold and the contact stiffness and maximum damping coefficient in the maximum damping coefficient sequence are obtained to complete the collision parameter identification between complex structures.
5. The method for identifying collision parameters between complex structures according to claim 4, characterized in that: The collision time t is calculated by the following formula: t=t A -t A0 =t B -t B0 (9) Among them, t A With t A0 are the time before and after the collision of the active parts, t B With t B0 are the time before and after the follower collision, respectively.
