Method for determining repetition dispersion

By changing the value of the measurement parameters to evaluate the ability of the measurement process, the problem of difficult evaluation of a small number of inspection objects in the prior art is solved, and resource savings and early improvement identification is achieved, suitable for small-scale mass production and early-stage projects.

CN118922687APending Publication Date: 2024-11-08ROBERT BOSCH GMBH
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202380029499.6
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2022-03-22
Filing Date
2023-02-02
Publication Date
2024-11-08

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The prior art has difficulty in effectively evaluating the capability of the measurement process with a small number of inspection objects, especially in mass production of components and early stages of development, resulting in waste of resources and increased costs.

Method used

By changing the value of the measurement parameter on at least one inspection object while keeping the selection of the measurement parameters constant, making multiple measurements to calculate the repetitive dispersion, the ability to evaluate the measurement process is used to a small number or unique inspection object.

Benefits of technology

The ability to evaluate the measurement process with a small number of inspection objects is realized, resource savings and costs, and early identification of improvement possibilities, suitable for small-scale production and early project phases.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118922687A_ABST
    Figure CN118922687A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention relates to a method (1000) for determining the repetition dispersion of a given measurement process carried out on an object to be inspected (1), comprising the following steps: providing (100) at least one object to be inspected (1); ascertaining (200) at least one measurement variable (2) of the measurement process, the result of the measurement process being additionally related to the at least one measurement variable in addition to the characteristic to be measured of the examination object (1), which is given by the measurement variable (3) to be considered; ascertaining a variation range (21) of the at least one measured variable (2); -performing (300) a plurality of measurements on the examination object (1) for different values (210, 211, 212) of the at least one measured variable (2) within the corresponding range of variation (21), such that at least one distribution (310, 311, 312) of the measured values of the measured variable (3), which has at least one discrete measure (310a, 311a, 312a), in particular a discrete width, is obtained; -analysing the sought repetition dispersion from at least one dispersion metric (310a, 311a, 312a) of the at least one distribution (310, 311, 312) of the obtained measurements.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention relates to a method for determining a repeatability dispersion, a computer program for implementing the method, a machine-readable data carrier having such a computer program, and one or more computers having such a computer program. Background Art

[0002] As a measurement process capability within the scope of functional testing of series-produced components In order to prove the validity of the method, a statistical method is used, which is mainly based on the determination of the repeated discreteness of the inspection features. In this regard, the %GRR method has proven to be very effective. Typically, the repeated discreteness is considered for the evaluation of the measurement process, which usually includes the measurement of a larger number of inspection objects. For example, 25 inspection objects can be measured at least twice each. For the measured values ​​obtained on each inspection object, the discrete width is determined. The discrete widths obtained for all inspection objects form a distribution, and its standard deviation is determined. Finally, the capability of the measurement process is derived or evaluated from the standard deviation. If, for example, the ratio of the repeated discreteness of the inspected feature to the tolerance is lower than a predetermined threshold value, the measurement process can be considered to be applicable. This type of measurement is often performed by multiple inspectors, and in addition, in order to be able to be used for statistical analysis, a sufficiently large number of inspection objects are required. Summary of the invention

[0003] It has been recognized that the inspection process evaluation according to conventional methods cannot be performed with very few inspection objects. Therefore, measurement processes involving small mass-produced inspection objects or measurement processes in the early stages of development cannot be considered in common methods for inspection process evaluation.

[0004] The invention relates to a method for determining the repetition discreteness of a given measurement process which is carried out on at least one examination object. The method comprises at least the steps described below.

[0005] The repeated discreteness represents the discreteness of the measured values ​​when the measurement is repeated by the same person in the same laboratory on the same object (repeated conditions). Here, under otherwise identical conditions, the measurement parameter can remain constant between the measurements in the first measurement process and be varied in the second measurement process. Here, "remaining constant" or "varying" can relate to the selection of the measurement parameter and / or the value of the measurement parameter. In the following, the selection of the measurement parameter remains constant, but the value of the measurement parameter is varied.

[0006] In one method step, at least one examination object is provided. Furthermore, in a next step, at least one measurement parameter of the measurement process is ascertained, to which the result of the measurement process is additionally dependent, in addition to the property of the examination object to be measured and which can be described by the measurement parameter to be considered. In a further step, a variation range of the at least one measurement parameter is ascertained in order to perform a plurality of measurements on the examination object, wherein different values ​​of the at least one measurement parameter within the respective ascertained variation range are selected in such a way that in one measurement process a measured value of the measured variable considered is obtained in each case.

[0007] Subsequently, by repeated measurements, a plurality of measured values ​​are determined with each selected measurement parameter, which form at least one own distribution with at least one dispersion measure, in particular a dispersion width. Finally, the sought repetition dispersion is evaluated from these dispersion measures.

[0008] This can be done, for example, by means of a statistical evaluation of the obtained distribution, in that a standard deviation is determined for all obtained dispersion measures and then the sought repetition dispersion of the measurement process is evaluated from this standard deviation. In this case, the repetition dispersion can correspond, for example, to the standard deviation for at least one dispersion measure, in particular for all obtained dispersion widths. However, the repetition dispersion can also be determined as the difference between the maximum value of the obtained dispersion widths and the minimum value of the obtained dispersion widths.

[0009] It should be noted that in conventional methods for assessing measurement process capability, the measurement parameters that are varied in the methods described above and below are not varied but remain constant.

[0010] It is also possible to determine a plurality of measurement parameters of the measurement process to which the result of the measurement process is additionally dependent in addition to the characteristic to be measured of the object to be examined which is given by the measurement variable to be considered. The variation range of each measurement parameter is then determined. It is then further possible to perform a plurality of measurements on the object to be examined for different values ​​of each measurement parameter within the corresponding variation range, so that a plurality of distributions of measured values ​​of the measured variable under consideration are obtained, each having a discrete measure, in particular a discrete width. The sought repetition discreteness can then in turn be evaluated from the discrete measure of the distribution of the measured values ​​obtained.

[0011] If there are only a small number of inspection objects, the method described above and below makes it possible to evaluate the measurement process, that is, to judge its measurement process capability. Therefore, with the help of this method, it is also possible to determine whether the measurement process is sufficiently qualified for a small number of inspection objects, even for a single inspection object. Therefore, this method is suitable for evaluating the measurement process when there is only one inspection object or a small number of inspection objects. The measurement uncertainty of the measurement method under consideration can be studied, wherein, for example, resources in the form of stable components that must be provided and, if necessary, also selected for capability research can be reduced or saved. This can lead to significant cost saving potential for mass production components and in terms of equipment time in corresponding research devices.

[0012] A further advantage of the method described above and below is that a capability study of a measuring process with one or a smaller number of test objects can already be performed in an early phase of a corresponding development process, in which only a few sample test objects are available. This enables the capability of the measuring process to be demonstrated already in an early project phase. In particular, any improvement possibilities can be identified and implemented at such an early point in time. This can in turn lead to significant savings potential compared to a later capability demonstration, in which the need for significant changes or improvements to the measuring process can only be identified after high costs have already been incurred.

[0013] According to one embodiment, the variation range of the measured parameter is determined according to the setpoint value. Additionally or alternatively, the variation range of the measured parameter can be determined according to a predefined fluctuation range of the measured variable in combination with a known correlation between the measured variable and the measured variable.

[0014] The known correlation between the measured variable and the measured parameter can be, for example, a characteristic curve, by which the correlation between the measured variable and the measured parameter is described. The functional correlation between the measured variable and the measured parameter can be known in the form of a formula, by which the characteristic curve can be obtained, for example, by substituting at least the corresponding value of the measured parameter and, in some cases, other parameters characterizing the measurement process and / or the inspection object. It can also be realized that the functional correlation is additionally or only experimentally determined and, for example, is stored in the form of a value table, from which, for example, representative corresponding values ​​of the measured parameter and the measured variable can be extracted. The value table of the correlation between the measured variable and the measured parameter or the corresponding graphical representation (Auftrag) - in some cases with suitable interpolation - can be stored in digital form and / or in the form of a data table. The rated value of the measured variable and the variation range of the measured parameter can also be stored in a digital or analog form in a data table.

[0015] Within the scope of the method, a measurement parameter can, for example, be changed stepwise, wherein the step size of the change is respectively adapted in a subsequent step, more precisely depending on the distance of the measured value distribution obtained in the previous step from a predetermined rated value of the measured variable and / or the distance of the median or mean of the distribution from a predetermined rated value of the measured variable.

[0016] This can be achieved, for example, by taking into account the size of the difference between the distribution or median or mean of the measured values ​​on the one hand and the setpoint value of the measured variable on the other hand. For example, for measured values ​​in the environment of the setpoint value, a smaller step size can be selected in the case of a change in the measured parameter in order to achieve a more accurate consideration of this range of the measured variable. This makes it possible to take into account the range around the setpoint value that is particularly relevant to the measurement process in an enhanced manner.

[0017] Furthermore, it can be provided that the step size for changing the measured variable is selected to be smaller in the range around the setpoint value of the measured variable and to be larger near the upper and lower limits of the fluctuation range of the measured variable. Thus, in the investigation of the capability verification of the measuring process, the range of the measured value which is located at a greater distance from the setpoint value of the measured variable can have a weaker weighting, and the range which is located in the vicinity of the setpoint value of the measured variable receives a stronger weighting in the capability verification.

[0018] According to another embodiment, the variation range of the measurement parameter is determined as a function of the technical specifications of the measurement process, of the device used for the measurement process and / or of the object to be examined. In this way, corresponding prior knowledge can be used to determine the repetition dispersion.

[0019] According to another embodiment, the nominal value of the measured variable, the fluctuation range of the measured variable, the known correlation between the measured variable and the measured parameter and / or the technical specifications can be obtained from at least one data table. Additionally or alternatively, the above-mentioned variables can be obtained from a digitally stored data set of the measurement process, a device for the measurement process and / or the inspection object. Then, these sources of prior knowledge can also be used in the method for determining the repeatability discreteness.

[0020] According to one embodiment, at least one sample of a component manufactured either individually or in mass production can be selected as the inspection object. It is thus advantageously possible to use a smaller number of manufactured inspection objects during the method, for example only one or two inspection objects. It is thus possible to reduce the costs associated with providing the inspection objects and performing the measurement process. In addition, the method can be used in situations where a measurement process for a small-scale production with a smaller number of mass-produced components is evaluated. It is thus possible within the scope of the method to use at least a portion of this small-scale production as the inspection object and to avoid providing a correspondingly larger number of inspection objects of the small-scale production.

[0021] According to one embodiment of the invention, a fuel injector of an internal combustion engine can be selected as the test object. In the method described above and below, it is no longer necessary to provide a larger number of fuel injectors in order to determine the repetition dispersion of the corresponding measurement process within the scope of the test process evaluation.

[0022] According to one embodiment, it can be determined whether the repetition dispersion determined within the scope of the method meets a predetermined criterion. If so, the measurement process can be declared suitable for quality control of mass production.

[0023] The predetermined criterion may be, for example, the condition that the ratio of the determined repetition dispersion to the predetermined tolerance does not exceed or, depending on the formulation of the condition, falls below a predetermined value. A version of the %GRR capability certificate adapted to the method described here may be used.

[0024] According to one embodiment, the measured variables may include a liquid injection rate, a gas delivery rate, an output power, a current and / or a torque.

[0025] According to another embodiment, the measured parameters may include pressure, injection time, voltage and / or temperature.

[0026] In addition, the present invention also relates to a computer program, which contains machine-readable instructions, which, when executed on one or more computers, cause the one or more computers to implement the method according to the present invention. Likewise, the present invention includes a machine-readable data carrier on which the above computer program is stored, and a computer equipped with the above computer program or the above machine-readable data carrier. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0027] Further measures that improve the invention are shown in more detail below together with a description of preferred exemplary embodiments of the invention with reference to the drawings.

[0028] Shows:

[0029] Figure 1 : An embodiment of a method 1000 for determining a repetition discreteness of a given measurement process performed on an examination object 1;

[0030] Figure 2 : Another embodiment of method 1000. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0031] according to Figure 1, the method comprises at least the steps described below. In step 100, at least one inspection object 1 is provided. Here, the inspection object 1 can be, for example, a fuel injector. In step 200, at least one measurement parameter 2 of the measurement process is determined: in addition to the characteristic to be measured of the inspection object 1, the result of the measurement process is additionally related to the at least one measurement parameter. The characteristic to be measured of the inspection object 1 here relates to a measurement variable 3 to be considered within the scope of the measurement process. It should be noted that in the common method for determining the repetition discreteness of the measurement process, the above-mentioned measurement parameters do not undergo any changes, but are selected constantly. In another step 300, a variation range 21 of the measurement parameter 2 is determined. Thereafter, in step 400, a plurality of measurements are performed on the inspection object 1, wherein the measurement parameter 2 is changed within the variation range 21 determined for this purpose, and a plurality of measurement values ​​(at least 2) of the considered measurement variable are obtained for the corresponding values ​​of the measurement parameter. In step 500, for each performed measurement parameter variation, the discrete widths 310a, 311a, 312a are calculated from the distributions 310, 311, 312 of the measured values ​​of the measured variable. Finally, in step 600, the sought repeatability discreteness of the measurement process is determined from at least the standard deviation 41 of the individual discrete widths 310a, 311a, 312a. Figure 2 The correlation between all the above parameters is elaborated in detail.

[0032] Figure 2 An exemplary implementation of the method 1000 in the mass production of a fuel injector is shown. A fuel injector is provided as the inspection object 1, on which a measurement process is carried out, and within the scope of which the repetition dispersion of the measurement process is to be determined. The purpose of the method 1000 is to determine whether the repetition dispersion meets a predetermined criterion, wherein if the criterion is met accordingly, the measurement process can be declared suitable for quality control of mass production.

[0033] A measurement parameter 2 of the measurement process is further determined. This is a parameter that does not change within the scope of the associated measurement in the conventional method for determining the repeat discreteness. The difference between the method described here and the conventional method with the purpose of evaluating the measurement process is in particular that in the former, the parameter change is carried out within the scope of generating the measured value, while in the latter, on the contrary, a large number of inspection objects are taken into account in the process of generating the corresponding measurement data, but the measurement parameter here adopts a predetermined fixed value. The result of the measurement process is obviously mainly related to the selection of the measurement parameter 2. Figure 2 In the example shown in , the actuation time t of the fuel injector is selected as the measured variable 2 .

[0034] Accordingly, in the method described here, a variation range 21 of the measurement parameter 2 is determined and a plurality of measurements are performed on the examination object 1 with different values ​​210, 211, 212 within the variation range 21 of the measurement parameter 2. In this case, the control time t is within the minimum time t as the lower limit 22 of the variation range 21. min The maximum time t is the upper limit 23 of the variation range 21. max Changes between.

[0035] like Figure 2 As shown in FIG. 1 , it is possible to determine the variation range 21 of the measured variable 2 based on the setpoint value 31 of the measured variable 3 and the associated fluctuation range 32 of the measured variable 3, which variation range can be described primarily by an upper limit 23 and a lower limit 22. Therefore, the upper limit 23 of the variation range 21 of the measured variable 2, the maximum control time t max For example, it can be related to the upper limit 34 of the fluctuation range 32 of the measured variable 3, in this case the maximum injection quantity Q max Similarly, the lower limit 2 of the variation range 21 of the measurement parameter 2, the minimum control time t min Therefore, it is possible to compare the lower limit 33 of the fluctuation range 32 of the measured variable 3, in this case the minimum injection quantity Q min Corresponding. Alternatively or additionally, it is also conceivable to use a known correlation 5 between the measured variable 3 and the measured parameter 2, which is valid within the variation range 21 of the measured parameter 2. The correlation 5 can be, for example, a known characteristic curve 5 between the measured variable 3 and the measured parameter 1, which can be recorded in a tabular form or in a graphical form. For example, a corresponding table, but also a graphical representation of the correlation between the measured variable 3 and the measured parameter 2 can be obtained by interpolation using previous measurements on one or more reference examination objects and can be considered for use within the scope of the method described here. The corresponding information related to the characteristic curve 5 can be stored in a database or data table 6 in a digital or analog form and used in the corresponding method steps.

[0036] Now, a plurality of measurements are performed on the examination object 1, wherein different values ​​210, 211, 212 of the measurement parameter 2 within the variation range 21 are considered. For each value 210, 211, 212 of the measurement parameter 2, a distribution 310, 311, 312 of the measurement values ​​with discrete widths 310a, 311a, 312a is acquired. Figure 2 The points marked in (symbol ·) represent the average values ​​of distributions 310 , 311 , 312 and other distributions of the same type, respectively. These average values ​​are dispersed around characteristic curve 5 .

[0037] In the scope of this measurement process, the measurement parameter 2 can be changed step by step. It can be achieved here that the step lengths 220, 221 between the consecutive measurements are matched according to the distribution 310 or, for example, the distance from the set value 31 of the measurement variable 3 to the median or mean value of the distribution 310. For example, if in the previous step, the distribution 310 or its mean value or median has a smaller distance 320 from the pre-given set value 31 of the measurement variable 3, the step length 221 in the next step can be selected smaller than the step length 220 in the previous step. The smaller distance can be understood, for example, as a deviation in size within the pre-given limit. Therefore, within the scope of the proposed method, a larger number of measured values ​​can be generated in the surroundings around the set value 31 of the measurement variable 3 than in the following range: in this range, the measured value has a larger distance 320 from the set value 31. Additionally, in a similar manner, if distribution 310 or its mean or median was to have a greater distance 320 from predefined setpoint value 31 of measured variable 3 in the preceding step, step length 220 of the following step may be selected to be greater than step length 221 of the preceding step.

[0038] Furthermore, it is possible to determine the variation range 21 of the measured variable 2 and possibly also the parameter value to be selected by the technical specifications of the measuring process, the device for the measuring process and / or the inspection object 3. The corresponding data and specifications can be extracted in particular from an analog or digital data set or data table 6. The same applies to the setpoint value 31 of the measured variable 3, the fluctuation range 32 and the known correlation 5.

[0039] Finally, the standard deviation 41, σ is obtained by using the discrete widths 310a, 311a, 312a of the distributions 310, 311, 312 of the obtained measured values ​​representing the injection amount Q, respectively. Q As the sought repetition discreteness. Alternatively, the sought repetition discreteness can be obtained from the difference between the maximum and minimum values ​​of all discrete widths. It can then be checked whether the measurement process can be considered suitable for quality control of mass production, taking into account the use of standardized standards.

Claims

1. A method (1000) for determining the repetition discreteness of a given measurement process performed on an examination object (1), the method comprising the steps of: Providing (100) at least one inspection object (1); Ascertaining (200) at least one measurement parameter (2) of the measuring process to which the result of the measuring process is additionally dependent in addition to the property of the examination object (1) to be measured which is given by the measured variable (3) to be taken into account; Determining a variation range (21) of the at least one measurement parameter (2); for different values ​​(210, 211, 212) of the at least one measurement parameter (2) within a corresponding variation range (21), a plurality of measurements are performed (300) on the examination object (1), so that at least one distribution (310, 311, 312) of the measured values ​​of the measurement variable (3) is obtained, which distribution has at least one dispersion measure (310a, 311a, 312a), in particular a dispersion width; The sought repetition dispersion is evaluated from at least one dispersion measure (310a, 311a, 312a) of at least one distribution (310, 311, 312) of the obtained measured values.

2. The method (1000) according to claim 1, characterized in that: Perform the following steps: Providing (100) at least one inspection object (1); ascertaining (200) a plurality of measurement parameters (2) of the measuring process, to which the result of the measuring process is additionally dependent in addition to the property of the examination object (1) to be measured which is given by the measured variable (3) to be taken into account; Obtaining the variation range (21) of each measurement parameter (2); For different values ​​(210, 211, 212) of each measurement parameter (2) within a corresponding variation range (21), a plurality of measurements (300) are performed on the examination object (1), so that a plurality of distributions (310, 311, 312) of the measured values ​​of the measurement variable (3) are obtained, each having a dispersion measure (310a, 311a, 312a), in particular a dispersion width; The sought repetition dispersion is evaluated from a dispersion measure (310a, 311a, 312a) of the obtained distribution (310, 311, 312) of measured values.

3. The method (1000) according to any one of claims 1 to 2, wherein: A standard deviation (41) is determined for the at least one dispersion measure (310a, 311a, 312a) as the sought repetitive dispersion.

4. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 2, wherein: The sought repetition discreteness is determined as the difference between the maximum and the minimum of all discrete widths.

5. The method (1000) according to any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein: The variation range (21) of the measured variable (2) is determined based on a setpoint value (31) and / or a predetermined fluctuation range (32) of the measured variable (3) in combination with a known correlation (5) between the measured variable (3) and the measured variable (2).

6. The method (1000) according to claim 5, in, The measurement parameter (2) is changed stepwise and in a subsequent step the step length (220, 221) is respectively adapted according to the distance (320) between the distribution (310) of the measured values ​​obtained in the previous step and a predetermined setpoint value (31) of the measurement variable (3) and / or the distance (320) between the median or mean value of the distribution and a predetermined setpoint value (31) of the measurement variable (3).

7. The method (1000) according to claim 6, in, The step size (220, 221) for changing the measured variable (2) is selected to be smaller in the range around a setpoint value (31) of the measured variable (3) and to be larger near an upper limit (34) and a lower limit (33) of a fluctuation range (32) of the measured variable (3).

8. The method (1000) according to any one of claims 1 to 7, wherein: The variation range (21) of the measurement parameter (2) is determined according to the technical specifications of the measurement process, of a device used for the measurement process and / or of the object to be examined (3).

9. The method (1000) according to any one of claims 5 to 8, in, The setpoint value (31) of the measured variable (3), the fluctuation range (32) of the measured variable (3), the known correlation (5) between the measured variable (3) and the measured parameter (2) and / or the technical specification are obtained from at least one data table (6) and / or a digitally stored data set of the measuring process, a device used for the measuring process and / or the inspection object (1).

10. The method (1000) according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein: At least one sample of a component is selected as an inspection object (1).

11. The method (1000) according to claim 10, in, A fuel injector of an internal combustion engine is selected as an inspection object (1).

12. The method (1000) according to any one of claims 10 to 11, wherein: In response to “the determined repeatability dispersion meets a predetermined standard”, it is confirmed that the measuring process is suitable for quality control of mass production.

13. The method (1000) according to any one of the preceding claims, in, The measured variables (3) include liquid injection rate, gas delivery rate, output power, current and / or torque.

14. The method (1000) according to any one of the preceding claims, in, The measured parameters (2) include pressure, injection time, delivery time, voltage and / or temperature.

15. A computer program comprising machine-readable instructions which, when executed on one or more computers, cause the one or more computers to perform at least the computing steps of the method according to any one of claims 1 to 14.

16. A machine-readable data carrier having a computer program according to claim 15.

17. A computer equipped with a computer program according to claim 15 and / or a machine-readable data carrier according to claim 16.