Urban sewage system health evaluation method
By building a multi-level sewage system health evaluation index system and calculating index scores at all levels, the problem of single evaluation methods of existing sewage system is solved, and a comprehensive health evaluation of urban sewage systems is achieved, and scientific efficiency improvement measures are provided.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411139336.6
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-08-20
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-12
AI Technical Summary
The existing sewage system evaluation methods only target the operating efficiency of sewage treatment plants, and the evaluation indicators are single, resulting in biased evaluation of sewage system health and lack comprehensiveness and scientificity.
Build a health evaluation index system for urban sewage systems, including multiple first-level indicators and second-level indicators. By collecting full-process data, calculate the score of each second-level indicator, and obtain urban and towns based on the first-level indicator weight and second-level indicator weight. Comprehensive evaluation score of the sewage system health and evaluation of the health status of the system.
It has achieved a comprehensive and scientific health evaluation of the sewage system, can promptly detect and locate problems, provide targeted correction measures, improve the accuracy and scientificity of the evaluation, and is suitable for the management of sewage systems in various urban areas.
Smart Images

Figure CN118941161A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention belongs to the technical field of sewage systems, and in particular relates to a health assessment method for urban sewage systems. Background Art
[0002] Urban sewage systems are important infrastructure for protecting the water quality of rivers and lakes and ensuring the safe operation of cities. However, various factors in the operation of sewage systems can easily lead to a decline in the health of the drainage system, including damage to the drainage pipe structure, performance degradation, blockage, sewage overflow, etc., which may also have serious impacts on society and the environment. Therefore, it is necessary to conduct a health assessment of the drainage system in order to formulate more reasonable and scientific measures to improve the efficiency of the sewage system.
[0003] The invention patent application with application number CN201910191577.8 discloses a method for diagnosing problems in urban sewage systems. Taking sewage lift stations as nodes, the sewage pipe network of the urban sewage system is divided into primary pipe network, secondary pipe network, tertiary pipe network and sewage treatment plant. The diagnosis includes collecting the number, design scale and operation scale of sewage lift stations at each node, the design scale and operation scale of the sewage treatment plant, the inlet concentration and outlet concentration of the sewage treatment plant, and the total urban water consumption; calculating and evaluating the urban sewage collection system with the sewage collection efficiency of the primary pipe network, calculating and evaluating the urban sewage transportation system with the sewage transportation efficiency, calculating and evaluating the urban sewage treatment system with the sewage water volume treatment efficiency, and calculating and evaluating the urban sewage reuse system with the sewage reuse efficiency; it comprehensively considers the urban sewage collection-transportation-treatment-reuse, and diagnoses in combination with water volume and water quality indicators to understand the problems of the urban sewage system.
[0004] However, the current sewage system evaluation only focuses on the operating efficiency of the sewage treatment plant, and the evaluation indicators are single, which leads to biased health evaluation of the sewage system. Therefore, a comprehensive and scientific sewage system health evaluation method is urgently needed. Summary of the invention
[0005] The purpose of the present invention is to provide a method for evaluating the health of a municipal sewage system, which can comprehensively and scientifically evaluate the health of the sewage system.
[0006] To achieve the above object, the present invention provides the following technical solutions:
[0007] A method for evaluating the health of a municipal sewage system is provided, comprising the following steps:
[0008] Constructing a health evaluation index system for urban sewage systems; the health evaluation index system includes a plurality of primary indicators, and each of the primary indicators includes a plurality of secondary indicators;
[0009] Based on the collected data of the entire sewage system process, the current status of each secondary indicator is obtained;
[0010] Based on the expected value of the set secondary indicator and the current value of each secondary indicator, the score of each secondary indicator is obtained;
[0011] Get the weights of all first-level indicators and second-level indicators;
[0012] Based on the score of each secondary indicator, the weight of the primary indicator and the weight of the secondary indicator, the comprehensive evaluation score of the health of the urban sewage system is obtained, and the health status of the urban sewage system is evaluated according to the comprehensive evaluation score.
[0013] Optionally, the plurality of primary indicators include a sewage collection indicator N1, a sewage transportation indicator N2, a sewage treatment indicator N3, a recycling indicator N4, an operation and maintenance indicator N5, an ecological environment indicator N6, and a social service indicator N7;
[0014] The secondary indicators of the sewage collection index N1 include: sewage facility coverage index N11, sewage system service population ratio index N12, pipe network density index N13 and sewage collection rate index N14;
[0015] The secondary indicators of the sewage transportation index N2 include: overflow sewage chemical oxygen demand into the river pollution load index N21, overflow sewage total nitrogen into the river pollution load index N22, overflow sewage total phosphorus into the river pollution load index N23, overflow sewage characteristic pollutants into the river pollution load index N24, pipe network defect rate index N25, rainwater mixing rate index N26 and groundwater mixing rate index N27;
[0016] The secondary indicators of the sewage treatment index N3 include: sewage water volume treatment rate index N31, sewage chemical oxygen demand treatment rate index N32, sewage total nitrogen treatment rate index N33, sewage total phosphorus treatment rate index N34, sewage characteristic pollutant treatment rate index N35 and sewage treatment compliance rate index N36;
[0017] The secondary indicators of the recycling index N4 include: tail water reuse rate index N41, tail water reuse volume to total urban water consumption ratio index N42 and reuse tail water quality compliance rate index N43;
[0018] The secondary indicators of the operation and maintenance indicator N5 include: routine maintenance frequency indicator N51, operation and maintenance cost indicator N52 and real-time supervision coverage indicator N53;
[0019] The secondary indicators of the ecological environment indicator N6 include: greenhouse gas emission reduction rate indicator N61;
[0020] The secondary indicators of the social service indicator N7 include: service population satisfaction index N71.
[0021] Optionally, in obtaining the score of each secondary indicator based on the expected value of the set secondary indicator and the current value of each secondary indicator,
[0022] The scores of each secondary indicator of the sewage collection index N1, each secondary indicator of the sewage treatment index N3, each secondary indicator of the recycling index N4, the secondary indicator of the ecological environment index N6 and the secondary indicator of the social service index N7 are calculated by the secondary indicator score formula:
[0023] The secondary indicator scoring formula is:
[0024]
[0025] Among them, SC j is the score of the jth secondary indicator, CU j is the current value of the jth secondary indicator, EU j is the expected value of the jth secondary index; F j Set the full score value for the jth secondary indicator;
[0026] For obtaining the score of the secondary indicator of the sewage transport indicator N2,
[0027] Among them, the pollution load index N21 of chemical oxygen demand of overflow sewage entering the river, the pollution load index N22 of total nitrogen of overflow sewage entering the river, the pollution load index N23 of total phosphorus of overflow sewage entering the river, and the pollution load index N24 of characteristic pollutants of overflow sewage entering the river all compare the current value with the expected value. If the current value is equal to the expected value, the score of the secondary indicator is full mark, otherwise, it is recorded as 0 points; the pipeline defect rate index N25, rainwater mixing rate index N26 and groundwater mixing rate index N27 all obtain the corresponding score according to the set interval of the current value;
[0028] For obtaining the score of the secondary indicator of the operation and maintenance indicator N5,
[0029] Among them, the routine maintenance frequency indicator N51 and the operation and maintenance cost indicator N52 both obtain corresponding scores according to the set interval of the current status value; the real-time supervision coverage indicator N53 is calculated and determined according to the secondary indicator scoring formula.
[0030] Optionally, the maximum score set for each of the secondary indicators is 100.
[0031] Optionally, in the acquisition of the current status value of each secondary indicator based on the collected full-process data of the sewage system,
[0032] The full-process data of the sewage system include: total area of urban built-up areas, total population of urban built-up areas, total annual urban water consumption, annual urban living water consumption, number of sunny days in the year, area of urban built-up areas covered by sewage facilities, population served by urban sewage systems, pollution reduction coefficient, length of urban drainage pipelines, number of defects in urban drainage pipelines, daily inlet and outlet water data of sewage treatment plants, daily inlet and outlet water pollutant concentration data of sewage treatment plants, annual tail water reuse volume, annual overflow sewage volume and overflow sewage pollutant concentration.
[0033] Optionally, the obtaining of weights of all primary indicators and secondary indicators includes:
[0034] The weight of each first-level indicator is determined by the assignment method, and the sum of the weights of all first-level indicators is 1;
[0035] For each first-level indicator, the weights of the second-level indicators it includes are the same, and the sum of the weights of all second-level indicators is 1.
[0036] Optionally, the comprehensive evaluation score of the health of the urban sewage system is obtained based on the score of each secondary indicator, the weight of the primary indicator and the weight of the secondary indicator, and the health status of the urban sewage system is evaluated according to the comprehensive evaluation score.
[0037] The comprehensive health evaluation score SC of the urban sewage system is:
[0038]
[0039] Among them, β i is the weight of the i-th first-level indicator, γ j is the weight of the j-th secondary indicator, SC j is the score of the jth secondary indicator, p is the number of primary indicators, and q is the number of secondary indicators;
[0040] When the obtained comprehensive health evaluation score SC of the urban sewage system is ≥80, the health status of the urban sewage system is healthy;
[0041] When the obtained comprehensive health evaluation score of the urban sewage system is 60≤SC<80, the health status of the urban sewage system is sub-healthy;
[0042] When the obtained comprehensive health evaluation score SC of the urban sewage system is less than 60, the health status of the urban sewage system is unhealthy.
[0043] Optionally, the current value CU of the rainwater mixing rate index N26 RMR for:
[0044]
[0045] The current value CU of the groundwater mixing rate index N27 GMR for:
[0046]
[0047] Among them, RAINQ is the amount of rainwater mixed, GWQ is the amount of groundwater mixed, and SUMQ is the annual water inflow of the sewage treatment plant;
[0048] The rainwater mixing amount RAINQ is:
[0049] RAINQ=SUMQ-RAWQ-GWQ
[0050] Among them, RAWQ is the amount of raw sewage from the sewage treatment plant;
[0051] The raw sewage volume RAWQ of the sewage treatment plant is:
[0052] RAWQ=Q1×m
[0053] The groundwater mixing amount GWQ is:
[0054]
[0055] Among them, RAWQ is the original sewage volume of the sewage treatment plant, Q1 is the minimum water inflow of the sewage treatment plant, m is the number of natural days in the year, s is the number of sunny days in the year, Q k is the kth water inflow data of the sewage treatment plant after the daily water inflow data are arranged in ascending order, Q s It is the sth water inflow data of the sewage treatment plant after the daily water inflow data are arranged in ascending order.
[0056] Optionally, in the overflow sewage characteristic pollutant pollution load index N24 entering the river and the sewage characteristic pollutant treatment rate index N35, the characteristic pollutants include one or more of persistent organic pollutants, endocrine disruptors, antibiotics and microplastics, and the characteristic pollutants are determined based on the characteristics of sewage discharged by urban drainage households.
[0057] Optionally, in the pipeline network defect rate index N25, pipeline network defects include functional defects and structural defects;
[0058] The functional defects include sedimentation, scaling, residual wall and dam roots, tree roots, obstacles or scum;
[0059] The structural defects include corrosion, deformation, rupture, misalignment, leakage, undulation, blockage, falling off of interface materials, penetration of foreign matter or concealed connection of branch pipes.
[0060] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following beneficial effects:
[0061] The selection of the primary indicators of the present invention is more in line with the work and operation process of urban sewage treatment. In the calculation of the scores of the secondary indicators of the primary indicators, if the scores are too low, the problems can be discovered and located in time, so as to facilitate the subsequent maintenance and the corresponding corrective measures. In addition, the selection of primary and secondary indicators is more comprehensive, easy to obtain and quantifiable, so as to ensure that the health evaluation of the sewage system is more accurate and scientific. The present invention can be directly applied to the management of various urban sewage systems, and provides technical support for the formulation of scientific sewage system efficiency improvement measures, and is practical and applicable. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0062] Figure 1 is a flow chart of the urban sewage system health assessment method of the present invention;
[0063] Figure 2 It is a health evaluation index system diagram of the urban sewage system of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0064] The present invention will be further described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings. The following embodiments are only used to more clearly illustrate the technical solution of the present invention, and cannot be used to limit the protection scope of the present invention.
[0065] It should be noted that the term "comprises" and any variations thereof in the specification and claims of the present invention and the above-mentioned drawings are intended to cover non-exclusive inclusions. For example, a process or method comprising a series of steps or units is not necessarily limited to those steps or units clearly listed, but may include other steps or units that are not clearly listed or inherent to these processes or methods.
[0066] Embodiment 1
[0067] like Figure 1 and Figure 2 As shown, a method for evaluating the health of a municipal sewage system is provided, comprising the following steps:
[0068] S1: Constructing a health evaluation index system for urban sewage systems; the health evaluation index system includes multiple first-level indicators, and each of the first-level indicators includes several second-level indicators.
[0069] Multiple first-level indicators include sewage collection index N1, sewage transportation index N2, sewage treatment index N3, recycling index N4, operation and maintenance index N5, ecological environment index N6 and social service index N7.
[0070] The secondary indicators of the sewage collection index N1 include: sewage facility coverage index N11, sewage system service population ratio index N12, pipe network density index N13 and sewage collection rate index N14.
[0071] The secondary indicators of sewage transportation index N2 include: the pollution load index of chemical oxygen demand of overflow sewage entering the river N21, the pollution load index of total nitrogen of overflow sewage entering the river N22, the pollution load index of total phosphorus of overflow sewage entering the river N23, the pollution load index of characteristic pollutants of overflow sewage entering the river N24, the pipeline defect rate index N25, the rainwater mixing rate index N26 and the groundwater mixing rate index N27.
[0072] The secondary indicators of sewage treatment index N3 include: sewage water volume treatment rate index N31, sewage chemical oxygen demand treatment rate index N32, sewage total nitrogen treatment rate index N33, sewage total phosphorus treatment rate index N34, sewage characteristic pollutant treatment rate index N35 and sewage treatment compliance rate index N36.
[0073] The secondary indicators of the recycling index N4 include: tail water reuse rate index N41, tail water reuse ratio index N42 and recycled tail water quality compliance rate index N43.
[0074] The secondary indicators of operation and maintenance index N5 include: routine maintenance frequency index N51, operation and maintenance cost index N52 and real-time supervision coverage index N53.
[0075] The secondary indicators of ecological environment indicator N6 include: greenhouse gas emissions reduction rate indicator N61.
[0076] The secondary indicators of social service indicator N7 include: service population satisfaction index N71.
[0077] The present invention comprehensively considers factors such as sewage collection, sewage transportation, sewage treatment, recycling, operation and maintenance, ecological environment, and social services to carry out health evaluation of urban sewage systems. The evaluation indicators are easy to obtain and quantifiable, and can be applied to the management of urban sewage systems. It provides technical support for the formulation of scientific measures to improve the efficiency of sewage systems, and is practical and applicable.
[0078] S2: Based on the collected data of the entire sewage system process, obtain the current value of each secondary indicator.
[0079] The full-process data of the sewage system include the total area of urban built-up areas, the total population of urban built-up areas, the total annual urban water consumption, the annual urban living water consumption, the number of sunny days in the year, the area of urban built-up areas covered by sewage facilities, the population served by the urban sewage system, the pollution reduction coefficient, the length of urban drainage pipelines, the number of defects in urban drainage pipelines, the daily inlet and outlet water data of sewage treatment plants, the daily inlet and outlet water pollutant concentration data of sewage treatment plants, the annual tail water reuse volume, the annual overflow sewage volume and the overflow sewage pollutant concentration.
[0080] The current status value of the secondary indicator is the monitoring value of the secondary indicator in that year.
[0081] S21: Calculate the current status values of each secondary indicator of the sewage collection indicator N1.
[0082] The current status of sewage facility coverage indicator N11 is:
[0083]
[0084] Among them, CU SC A is the current value of sewage facility coverage index N11; cu A is the urban built-up area covered by sewage facilities; u is the total area of urban built-up areas;
[0085] The current value of the indicator N12, the proportion of the population served by the sewage system, is:
[0086]
[0087] Among them, CU PP Current value of the proportion of population served by sewage system indicator N12; P cu Population served by urban sewage systems; P u is the total population of urban built-up areas;
[0088] The current value of pipeline network density index N13 is:
[0089]
[0090] Among them, CU ND is the current value of the pipe network density index N13; L is the length of the urban drainage pipe network; A u is the total area of urban built-up areas;
[0091] The current value of sewage collection rate indicator N14 is:
[0092]
[0093] Among them, CU CR is the current value of sewage collection rate indicator N14; Q in is the amount of sewage collected, is the annual water inflow of the sewage treatment plant; Q w is the annual urban domestic water consumption; α is the pollution reduction coefficient, which ranges from 0.8 to 0.9.
[0094] S22: Calculate the current status values of each secondary index of the sewage transport index N2.
[0095] The pollution load index of overflow sewage chemical oxygen demand entering the river is N21, and the current value is:
[0096] CU :COD =Q OS ×CCOD (5)
[0097] Among them, CU LCOD Q is the current value of the pollution load index N21 of the overflow sewage into the river; OS is the annual overflow sewage volume; C COD is the chemical oxygen demand concentration of overflow sewage;
[0098] The current value of the total nitrogen pollution load index N22 of overflow sewage entering the river is:
[0099] CU LTN =Q OS ×C TN (6)
[0100] Among them, CU LTN The current value of N22, the pollution load index of total nitrogen entering the river from overflow sewage: Q OS is the annual overflow sewage volume; C TN is the total nitrogen concentration of overflow sewage;
[0101] The total phosphorus pollution load index of overflow sewage entering the river is N23, and the current value is:
[0102] CU LTP =Q OS ×C TP (7)
[0103] Among them, CU LTP Q is the current value of N23, the pollution load index of total phosphorus entering the river from overflow sewage; OS is the annual overflow sewage volume; C TP is the total phosphorus concentration of overflow sewage;
[0104] The pollution load index of overflow sewage characteristic pollutants entering the river is N24, and the current value is:
[0105] CU LSP =Q OS ×C SP (8)
[0106] Among them, CU LSP Q is the current value of N24, the pollution load index of characteristic pollutants of overflow sewage entering the river; OS is the annual overflow sewage volume; C SP is the characteristic pollutant concentration of overflow sewage;
[0107] The current status of pipeline network defect rate indicator N25 is:
[0108]
[0109] Among them, CU NDR is the current value of the pipeline network defect rate index N25; ND is the number of defects in the urban drainage network; L is the length of the urban drainage network;
[0110] Pipeline network defects include functional defects and structural defects; the functional defects include sedimentation, scaling, residual walls and dam roots, tree roots, obstacles or slag; the structural defects include corrosion, deformation, rupture, misalignment, leakage, undulation, blockage, falling off of interface materials, penetration of foreign objects or concealed connection of branch pipes.
[0111] When collecting the daily water inflow data of the sewage treatment plant, the data is arranged in ascending order to obtain the sewage treatment plant water inflow matrix:
[0112]
[0113] Among them, M is the sewage treatment plant inflow matrix.
[0114] Q1 is the minimum water inflow of the sewage treatment plant, and m is the number of natural days in the year;
[0115] The annual water inflow SUMQ of the sewage treatment plant is:
[0116]
[0117] The raw sewage volume RAWQ of the sewage treatment plant is:
[0118] RAWQ=Q1×m (12)
[0119] The groundwater mixing quantity GWQ is:
[0120]
[0121] Among them, RAWQ is the original sewage volume of the sewage treatment plant, Q1 is the minimum water inflow of the sewage treatment plant, m is the number of natural days in the year, s is the number of sunny days in the year, Q k is the kth water inflow data of the sewage treatment plant after the daily water inflow data are arranged in ascending order, Q s It is the sth water inflow data of the sewage treatment plant after the daily water inflow data are arranged in ascending order.
[0122] The amount of rainwater mixed RAINQ is:
[0123] RAINQ=SUMQ-RAWQ-GWQ (14)
[0124] The current value CU of the rainwater mixing rate index N26 RMR for:
[0125]
[0126] The current value CU of the groundwater mixing rate index N27 GMR for:
[0127]
[0128] Among them, RAINQ is the amount of rainwater mixed, GWQ is the amount of groundwater mixed, and SUMQ is the annual water inflow of the sewage treatment plant;
[0129] S23: Calculate the current status values of each secondary index of the sewage treatment index N3.
[0130] The current value of sewage treatment rate indicator N31 is:
[0131]
[0132] Among them, CU WTR is the current value of sewage water treatment rate indicator N31; Q in is the annual water inflow of the sewage treatment plant; Q out is the annual water output of the sewage treatment plant;
[0133] The current value of sewage chemical oxygen demand treatment rate indicator N32 is:
[0134]
[0135] Among them, CU RCOD is the current value of the sewage chemical oxygen demand treatment rate indicator N32; C incod is the chemical oxygen demand concentration of the sewage treatment plant influent; C outcod is the chemical oxygen demand concentration of the effluent from the sewage treatment plant;
[0136] The current status of sewage total nitrogen treatment rate indicator N33 is:
[0137]
[0138] Among them, CU RTN is the current value of total nitrogen treatment rate indicator N33 in sewage; C intn is the total nitrogen concentration of the sewage treatment plant influent; C outtn is the total nitrogen concentration in the effluent from the sewage treatment plant;
[0139] The current status of sewage total phosphorus treatment rate indicator N34 is:
[0140]
[0141] Among them, CU RTP is the current value of sewage total phosphorus treatment rate indicator N34; C intp is the total phosphorus concentration in the sewage treatment plant influent; C outtp is the total phosphorus concentration in the effluent from the sewage treatment plant;
[0142] The current status of sewage characteristic pollutant treatment rate indicator N35 is:
[0143]
[0144] Among them, CU RSP is the current value of sewage characteristic pollutant treatment rate indicator N35; C insp is the characteristic pollutant concentration of the sewage treatment plant influent; C outsp is the characteristic pollutant concentration in the effluent from the sewage treatment plant;
[0145] The current status of sewage treatment compliance rate indicator N36 is:
[0146]
[0147] Among them, CU sSR is the current value of sewage treatment compliance rate indicator N36; m d is the number of days when the effluent from the sewage treatment plant meets the standards in that year; m is the number of natural days in that year.
[0148] S24: Calculate the current status values of each secondary index of the recycling index N4.
[0149] The tail water reuse rate index N41, the current value is:
[0150]
[0151] Among them, CU WRR is the current value of tail water reuse rate index N41; Q wr is the annual tail water reuse amount; Q out is the annual water output of the sewage treatment plant;
[0152] The proportion of tail water reuse to total urban water consumption is N42, and the current value is:
[0153]
[0154] Among them, CU TWR The current value of the ratio of tail water reuse to total urban water consumption index N42; Q wr is the annual tail water reuse amount; Q utw is the total annual water consumption of the town;
[0155] The current status of the recycled tail water quality compliance rate index N43 is:
[0156]
[0157] Among them, CU ISR The current value of the water quality compliance rate indicator N43 for the reused tail water; m is The number of days for the reused tail water to meet the standards; m tThe number of days for monitoring the quality of the reused tail water.
[0158] S25: Calculate the current status value of each secondary indicator of the operation and maintenance indicator N5.
[0159] Routine maintenance frequency indicator N51 current value CU MF , determined according to the actual maintenance frequency.
[0160] The current value of the operation and maintenance cost indicator N52 is:
[0161]
[0162] Among them, CU OMC is the current value of the operation and maintenance cost indicator N52; COST is the annual operation and maintenance cost; L w The length of the annual operation and maintenance pipeline network;
[0163] The current value of real-time supervision coverage indicator N53 is:
[0164]
[0165] Among them, CU RTC is the current value of real-time supervision coverage indicator N53; N int To achieve real-time supervision of the number of sewage facilities; N s The number of sewage facilities.
[0166] S26: Calculate the current status values of each secondary indicator of the ecological environment indicator N6.
[0167] Greenhouse gas emissions reduction rate indicator N61, the current value is:
[0168]
[0169] Among them, CU GGE is the current value of greenhouse gas emission reduction rate indicator N61; G b is the greenhouse gas emissions in the base year; G c is the greenhouse gas emissions for the year.
[0170] S27: Calculate the current status value of each secondary indicator of the social service indicator N7.
[0171] Service population satisfaction index N71, the current value is:
[0172]
[0173] Among them, CU CPS The current value of the service population satisfaction index N71; sa is the number of satisfied people; N p is the number of people surveyed.
[0174] S3: Based on the expected value of the set secondary indicator and the current value of each secondary indicator, obtain the score of each secondary indicator.
[0175] S311: For the sewage collection index N1, the expected value of the secondary index is set as:
[0176] Sewage facility coverage index N11, expected value EV SC =95%; Sewage system service population ratio indicator N12, expected value EV pP =95%; Pipeline network density index N13, expected value EV ND =7.5 km / km2; sewage collection rate index N14, expected value EV CR =95%.
[0177] S312: For sewage collection indicator N1, the score of each secondary indicator is:
[0178] Sewage facility coverage indicator N11 score SC SC :
[0179]
[0180] Sewage system service population ratio indicator N12 score SC PP :
[0181]
[0182] Pipeline network density index N13 score SC ND :
[0183]
[0184] Sewage collection rate indicator N14 score SC CR :
[0185]
[0186] S321: For the sewage transport index N2, the expected value of the secondary index is set as:
[0187] Overflow sewage chemical oxygen demand into the river pollution load index N21, expected value EV LCOD = 0 kg / year; Total nitrogen pollution load index of overflow sewage into the river N22, expected value EV LTN = 0 kg / year; Total phosphorus pollution load index of overflow sewage into the river N23, expected value EV LTP = 0 kg / year; Pollution load index of characteristic pollutants of overflow sewage entering the river N24, expected value EV LSP=0; Pipeline network rate defect index N25, expected value EV NDR =2 places / km; Rainwater mixing rate index N26, expected value EV RMR =2%; groundwater mixing rate index N27, expected value EV GMR =2%.
[0188] S322: For the sewage transport indicator N2, the score of each secondary indicator is:
[0189] Overflow sewage chemical oxygen demand pollution load index N21 score SC LCOD ,
[0190] When CU LCOD =EV LCOD = 0 kg / year, then SC LCOD =100; otherwise SC LCOD =0;
[0191] Overflow sewage total nitrogen pollution load index N22 score SC LTN ,
[0192] When CU LTN =EV LTN = 0 kg / year, then SC LTN =100; otherwise SC LTN =0;
[0193] Overflow sewage total phosphorus into the river pollution load index N23 score SC LTP ,
[0194] When CU LTP =EV LTP = 0 kg / year, then SC LTP =100; otherwise SC LTP =0;
[0195] Overflow sewage characteristic pollutants into the river pollution load index N24 score SC LSP ,
[0196] When CU LSP =EV LSP =0, then SC LSP =100; otherwise SC LSP =0;
[0197] Pipeline network rate defect index N25 score SC NDR ,
[0198] When CU NDR ≤EV NDR =2 places / km, SC NDR =100;
[0199] When 2 <CU NDR <10 / km, SC NDR =80;
[0200] When 10≤CU NDR <20 / km, SC NDR =60;
[0201] When 20≤CU NDR <30 / km, SC NDR =40;
[0202] When 30≤CU NDR <40 / km, SC NDR =20;
[0203] When CU NDR ≥40 / km, SC NDR =0;
[0204] Rainwater mixing rate index N26 score SC RMR ,
[0205] When CU RMR ≤EV RMR =2%, SC RMR =100;
[0206] When 2% <CU RMR <4%, SC RMR =80;
[0207] When 4% ≤ CU RMR <6%, SC RMR =60;
[0208] When 6% ≤ CU RMR <8%, SC RMR =40;
[0209] When 8% ≤ CU RMR <10%, SC RMR =20;
[0210] When CU RMR ≥10%, SC RMR =0;
[0211] Groundwater mixing rate index N27 score SC GMR ,
[0212] When CU GMR ≤EV GMR =2%, SC GMR =100;
[0213] When 2% <CU GMR <4%, SCGMR =80;
[0214] When 4% ≤ CU GMR <6%, SC GMR =60;
[0215] When 6% ≤ CU GMR <8%, SC GMR =40;
[0216] When 8% ≤ CU GMR <10%, SC GMR =20;
[0217] When CU GMR ≥10%, SC GMR =0.
[0218] S331: For the sewage treatment index N3, the expected value of the secondary index is set as:
[0219] Sewage water treatment rate index N31, expected value EV WTR =100%; sewage chemical oxygen demand treatment rate index N32, expected value EV RCOD =90%; sewage total nitrogen treatment rate index N33, expected value EV RTN =75%; sewage total phosphorus treatment rate index N34, expected value EV RTP =95%; sewage characteristic pollutant treatment rate index N35, expected value EV RSP =60%; sewage treatment compliance rate index N36, expected value EV SSR =100%.
[0220] S332: For sewage treatment indicator N3, the score of each secondary indicator is:
[0221] Sewage treatment rate indicator N31 score SC WTR :
[0222]
[0223] Sewage chemical oxygen demand treatment rate indicator N32 score SC RCOD :
[0224]
[0225] Sewage total nitrogen treatment rate index N33 score SC RTN :
[0226]
[0227] Sewage total phosphorus treatment rate index N34 score SC RTP :
[0228]
[0229] Sewage characteristic pollutant treatment rate index N35 score SC RSP :
[0230]
[0231] Sewage treatment compliance rate indicator N36 score SC SSR :
[0232]
[0233] S341: For the recycling index N4, the expected value of the secondary index is set as:
[0234] Tail water reuse rate index N41, expected value EV WRR =100%; tail water reuse ratio to total urban water consumption index N42, expected value EV TWR =50%; Recycled tail water quality compliance rate index N43, expected value EV ISR =100%.
[0235] S342: For recycling indicator N4, the score of each secondary indicator is:
[0236] Tail water reuse rate index N41 score SC WRR :
[0237]
[0238] Ratio of tail water reuse to total urban water consumption indicator N42 score SC TWR :
[0239]
[0240] Recycled tail water quality compliance rate index N43 score SC ISR :
[0241]
[0242] S351: For the operation and maintenance indicator N5, the expected value of the secondary indicator is set as:
[0243] Routine maintenance frequency indicator N51, expected value EV MF =4 times / year; Operation and maintenance cost index N52, expected value EV OMC = 12,000 yuan / km; real-time supervision coverage index N53, expected value EV RTC =100%.
[0244] S352: For the operation and maintenance indicator N5, the score of each secondary indicator is:
[0245] Routine maintenance frequency index N51 score SC MF ,
[0246] When CU MF ≥EV MF =4 times / year, SC MF =100;
[0247] When CU MF = 3 times / year, SC MF =80;
[0248] When CU MF = 2 times / year, SC MF =60;
[0249] When CU MF = 1 time / year, SC MF =40;
[0250] Otherwise, SC MF =0;
[0251] Operation and maintenance cost indicator N52 score SC OMC ,
[0252] When CU OMC ≤EV OMC = 12,000 yuan / km; SC OMC =100;
[0253] When 1.2 <CU OMC ≤14,000 yuan / km; SC OMC =80;
[0254] When 1.4 <CU OMC ≤16,000 yuan / km; SC OMC =60;
[0255] When 1.6 <CU OMC ≤18,000 yuan / km; SC OMC =40;
[0256] When 1.8 <CU OMC ≤20,000 yuan / km; SC OMC =20;
[0257] When CU OMC >20,000 yuan / km; SC OMC =0;
[0258] Real-time supervision coverage indicator N53 score SC RTC :
[0259]
[0260] S361: For the ecological environment indicator N6, the expected value of the secondary indicator is set as:
[0261] Greenhouse gas emissions reduction rate indicator N61, expected value EV GGE =50%.
[0262] S362: For the ecological environment indicator N6, the score SC of the greenhouse gas emission reduction rate indicator N61 GGE :
[0263]
[0264] S371: For social service indicator N7, the expected value of the secondary indicator is set as:
[0265] Service population satisfaction index N71, expected value EV CPS =98%.
[0266] S372: For social service indicator N7, the service population satisfaction indicator N71 score SC CPS :
[0267]
[0268] S4: Obtain the weights of all first-level indicators and second-level indicators.
[0269] S41: The weight of each first-level indicator is determined by the assignment method, and the sum of the weights of all first-level indicators is 1.
[0270] The weight of each first-level indicator can be obtained based on expert experience. As an option, the weights of sewage collection index N1, sewage transportation index N2, sewage treatment index N3, recycling index N4, operation and maintenance index N5, ecological environment index N6 and social service index N7 are 0.2, 0.2, 0.2, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1 and 0.1 respectively.
[0271] S42: For each first-level indicator, the weights of the second-level indicators it includes are the same, and the sum of the weights of all second-level indicators is 1.
[0272] The sewage collection index N1 includes 4 secondary indicators in total, and the weight of each secondary indicator of the sewage collection index N1 is 1 / 4.
[0273] The sewage transport index N2 includes 7 secondary indicators in total, and the weight of each secondary indicator of the sewage transport index N2 is 1 / 7.
[0274] The sewage treatment index N3 includes 6 secondary indicators in total, and the weight of each secondary indicator of the sewage treatment index N3 is 1 / 6.
[0275] The recycling index N4 includes three secondary indexes in total, and the weight of each secondary index of the recycling index N4 is 1 / 3.
[0276] The operation and maintenance index N5 includes three secondary indexes in total, and the weight of each secondary index of the operation and maintenance index N5 is 1 / 3.
[0277] The ecological environment indicator N6 includes 1 secondary indicator, and the weight of the greenhouse gas emission reduction rate indicator N61 is 1.
[0278] The social service index N7 includes 1 secondary indicator, and the weight of the service population satisfaction index N71 is 1.
[0279] S5: Based on the score of each secondary indicator, the weight of the primary indicator and the weight of the secondary indicator, obtain the comprehensive evaluation score of the health of the urban sewage system, and evaluate the health status of the urban sewage system according to the comprehensive evaluation score.
[0280] The comprehensive health evaluation score SC of the urban sewage system is:
[0281]
[0282] Among them, β i is the weight of the i-th first-level indicator, γ j is the weight of the jth secondary indicator, SC j is the score of the jth secondary indicator, p is the number of primary indicators, and q is the number of secondary indicators;
[0283] When the obtained comprehensive health evaluation score SC of the urban sewage system is ≥80, the health status of the urban sewage system is healthy;
[0284] When the obtained comprehensive health evaluation score of the urban sewage system is 60≤SC<80, the health status of the urban sewage system is sub-healthy;
[0285] When the obtained comprehensive health evaluation score SC of the urban sewage system is less than 60, the health status of the urban sewage system is unhealthy.
[0286] The selection of the primary indicators of the present invention is more in line with the work and operation process of urban sewage treatment. In calculating the scores of the secondary indicators of a certain primary indicator, if the score is too low, the problem can be discovered and located in time, thereby facilitating later maintenance and the targeted proposal of corresponding corrective measures. In addition, the selection of primary and secondary indicators is more comprehensive, easy to obtain and quantifiable, thereby ensuring that the health evaluation of the sewage system is more accurate and scientific. The present invention can be directly applied to the management of various urban sewage systems, providing technical support for the formulation of scientific sewage system efficiency improvement measures, and is practical and applicable.
[0287] The present invention uses a direct assignment method to assign values to each primary indicator, making it more concise when calculating the comprehensive score, thereby reducing the difficulty of evaluation and improving practicality and applicability.
[0288] When calculating the secondary index score of the present invention, it is based on the ratio of the current value to the expected value or based on the set interval in which the current value is located, without other complicated calculations, so that the calculation of the present invention is more concise and fast.
[0289] Embodiment 2
[0290] A specific embodiment of a method for evaluating the health of a town sewage system is provided. Taking a town as an example, the steps are as follows:
[0291] (1) Data collection
[0292] The total area of urban built-up areas is 15.56 square kilometers, the total population of urban built-up areas is 39,300, and the total annual water consumption in urban areas is 5.94×10 6 tons, urban annual domestic water consumption 2.58×10 6 tons, 205 sunny days that year, 10.21 square kilometers of urban built-up areas covered by sewage facilities, 32,100 people served by urban sewage systems, 0.9 sewage reduction coefficient, 89.6 kilometers of urban drainage pipe network, 2,050 defects in urban drainage pipe network, daily inflow and outflow data of sewage treatment plants, daily inflow and outflow chemical oxygen demand, total nitrogen, total phosphorus, and microplastic concentration data of sewage treatment plants, and annual tail water reuse volume of 1.25×10 6 tons, annual overflow sewage volume 1.28×10 4 Cubic meters, the average chemical oxygen demand concentration of overflow sewage is 79.8 mg / L, the average total nitrogen concentration of overflow sewage is 12.0 mg / L, the average total phosphorus concentration of overflow sewage is 1.34 mg / L, and the average microplastic concentration of overflow sewage is 63.1 pieces / L; characteristic pollutants are determined as microplastics based on the characteristics of sewage discharged by urban drainage households.
[0293] (2) Construction of urban sewage system health evaluation index system
[0294] The urban sewage system health assessment index system includes a primary index layer, and each primary index layer includes several secondary indicators.
[0295] The first-level indicator layer is composed of first-level indicators, including sewage collection index N1, sewage transportation index N2, sewage treatment index N3, recycling index N4, operation and maintenance index N5, ecological environment index N6, and social service index N7.
[0296] Secondary indicators are: sewage collection index N1 includes sewage facility coverage index N11, sewage system service population ratio index N12, pipe network density index N13, sewage collection rate index N14; sewage transportation index N2 includes overflow sewage chemical oxygen demand into the river pollution load index N21, overflow sewage total nitrogen into the river pollution load index N22, overflow sewage total phosphorus into the river pollution load index N23, overflow sewage characteristic pollutants into the river pollution load index N24, pipe network defect rate index N25, rainwater mixing rate index N26, groundwater mixing rate index N27; sewage treatment index N3 includes sewage water treatment rate index N31, sewage chemical oxygen demand into the river pollution load index N32, sewage total nitrogen into the river pollution load index N33, overflow sewage total phosphorus into the river pollution load index N34, overflow sewage characteristic pollutants into the river pollution load index N35, pipe network defect rate index N36, rainwater mixing rate index N37, groundwater mixing rate index N38 ... The indicators of sewage treatment rate N32, sewage total nitrogen treatment rate N33, sewage total phosphorus treatment rate N34, sewage characteristic pollutant treatment rate N35, sewage treatment compliance rate N36; recycling index N4 includes tail water reuse rate index N41, tail water reuse volume to total urban water consumption ratio index N42, reuse tail water quality compliance rate index N43; operation and maintenance index N5 includes routine maintenance frequency index N51, operation and maintenance cost index N52, real-time supervision coverage index N53; ecological environment index N6 includes greenhouse gas emission reduction rate index N61; social service index N7 includes service population satisfaction index N71;
[0297] (3) Determination of urban sewage system health evaluation index scores
[0298] The expected values, current values and scores of the secondary indicators of urban sewage system health assessment are shown in Table 1.
[0299] Table 1 Expected values, current values and scores of secondary indicators for urban sewage system health assessment
[0300]
[0301]
[0302] (4) Determination of weights of urban sewage system health assessment indicators
[0303] The weights of urban sewage system health assessment indicators are shown in Table 2.
[0304] Table 2 Weights of indicators for evaluating the health of urban sewage systems
[0305]
[0306]
[0307] (5) Comprehensive evaluation of urban sewage system health
[0308] Comprehensive evaluation score of urban sewage system health
[0309] 60≤SC<80, the health status of the urban sewage system is "sub-healthy".
[0310] The various embodiments in this specification are described in a progressive manner, and each embodiment focuses on the differences from other embodiments. The same or similar parts between the various embodiments can be referenced to each other.
[0311] The above are only preferred embodiments of the present invention, and the protection scope of the present invention is not limited to the above embodiments. All technical solutions under the concept of the present invention belong to the protection scope of the present invention. It should be pointed out that for ordinary technicians in this technical field, some improvements and modifications without departing from the principle of the present invention should be regarded as the protection scope of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for evaluating the health of a municipal sewage system, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: Constructing a health evaluation index system for urban sewage systems; the health evaluation index system includes a plurality of primary indicators, and each of the primary indicators includes a plurality of secondary indicators; Based on the collected data of the entire sewage system process, the current status of each secondary indicator is obtained; Based on the expected value of the set secondary indicator and the current value of each secondary indicator, the score of each secondary indicator is obtained; Get the weights of all first-level indicators and second-level indicators; Based on the score of each secondary indicator, the weight of the primary indicator and the weight of the secondary indicator, the comprehensive evaluation score of the health of the urban sewage system is obtained, and the health status of the urban sewage system is evaluated according to the comprehensive evaluation score.
2. The method for evaluating the health of a municipal sewage system according to claim 1, characterized in that: The multiple primary indicators include sewage collection index N1, sewage transportation index N2, sewage treatment index N3, recycling index N4, operation and maintenance index N5, ecological environment index N6 and social service index N7; The secondary indicators of the sewage collection index N1 include: sewage facility coverage index N11, sewage system service population ratio index N12, pipe network density index N13 and sewage collection rate index N14; The secondary indicators of the sewage transportation index N2 include: overflow sewage chemical oxygen demand into the river pollution load index N21, overflow sewage total nitrogen into the river pollution load index N22, overflow sewage total phosphorus into the river pollution load index N23, overflow sewage characteristic pollutants into the river pollution load index N24, pipe network defect rate index N25, rainwater mixing rate index N26 and groundwater mixing rate index N27; The secondary indicators of the sewage treatment index N3 include: sewage water volume treatment rate index N31, sewage chemical oxygen demand treatment rate index N32, sewage total nitrogen treatment rate index N33, sewage total phosphorus treatment rate index N34, sewage characteristic pollutant treatment rate index N35 and sewage treatment compliance rate index N36; The secondary indicators of the recycling index N4 include: tail water reuse rate index N41, tail water reuse volume to total urban water consumption ratio index N42 and reuse tail water quality compliance rate index N43; The secondary indicators of the operation and maintenance indicator N5 include: routine maintenance frequency indicator N51, operation and maintenance cost indicator N52 and real-time supervision coverage indicator N53; The secondary indicators of the ecological environment indicator N6 include: greenhouse gas emission reduction rate indicator N61; The secondary indicators of the social service indicator N7 include: service population satisfaction index N71.
3. The method for evaluating the health of a municipal sewage system according to claim 2, characterized in that: In the process of obtaining the score of each secondary indicator based on the expected value of the set secondary indicator and the current value of each secondary indicator, The scores of each secondary indicator of the sewage collection index N1, each secondary indicator of the sewage treatment index N3, each secondary indicator of the recycling index N4, the secondary indicator of the ecological environment index N6 and the secondary indicator of the social service index N7 are calculated by the secondary indicator score formula: The secondary indicator scoring formula is: Among them, SC j is the score of the jth secondary indicator, CU j is the current value of the jth secondary indicator, EU j is the expected value of the jth secondary index; F j Set the full score value for the jth secondary indicator; For obtaining the score of the secondary indicator of the sewage transport indicator N2, Among them, the pollution load index N21 of chemical oxygen demand of overflow sewage entering the river, the pollution load index N22 of total nitrogen of overflow sewage entering the river, the pollution load index N23 of total phosphorus of overflow sewage entering the river, and the pollution load index N24 of characteristic pollutants of overflow sewage entering the river all compare the current value with the expected value. If the current value is equal to the expected value, the score of the secondary indicator is full mark, otherwise, it is recorded as 0 points; the pipeline defect rate index N25, rainwater mixing rate index N26 and groundwater mixing rate index N27 all obtain the corresponding score according to the set interval of the current value; For obtaining the score of the secondary indicator of the operation and maintenance indicator N5, Among them, the routine maintenance frequency indicator N51 and the operation and maintenance cost indicator N52 both obtain corresponding scores according to the set interval of the current status value; the real-time supervision coverage indicator N53 is calculated and determined according to the secondary indicator scoring formula.
4. The method for evaluating the health of a municipal sewage system according to claim 3, characterized in that: The maximum score set for each of the secondary indicators is 100.
5. The method for evaluating the health of a municipal sewage system according to claim 1, characterized in that: Based on the collected data of the whole process of sewage system, the current value of each secondary indicator is obtained. The full-process data of the sewage system include: total area of urban built-up areas, total population of urban built-up areas, total annual urban water consumption, annual urban living water consumption, number of sunny days in the year, area of urban built-up areas covered by sewage facilities, population served by urban sewage systems, pollution reduction coefficient, length of urban drainage pipelines, number of defects in urban drainage pipelines, daily inlet and outlet water data of sewage treatment plants, daily inlet and outlet water pollutant concentration data of sewage treatment plants, annual tail water reuse volume, annual overflow sewage volume and overflow sewage pollutant concentration.
6. The method for evaluating the health of a municipal sewage system according to claim 1, characterized in that: The method of obtaining the weights of all primary indicators and secondary indicators includes: The weight of each first-level indicator is determined by the assignment method, and the sum of the weights of all first-level indicators is 1; For each first-level indicator, the weights of the second-level indicators it includes are the same, and the sum of the weights of all second-level indicators is 1.
7. The method for evaluating the health of a municipal sewage system according to claim 1, characterized in that: The comprehensive evaluation score of the health of the urban sewage system is obtained based on the score of each secondary indicator, the weight of the primary indicator and the weight of the secondary indicator, and the health status of the urban sewage system is evaluated according to the comprehensive evaluation score. The comprehensive health evaluation score SC of the urban sewage system is: Among them, β i is the weight of the i-th first-level indicator, γ j is the weight of the j-th secondary indicator, SC j is the score of the jth secondary indicator, p is the number of primary indicators, and q is the number of secondary indicators; When the obtained comprehensive health evaluation score SC of the urban sewage system is ≥80, the health status of the urban sewage system is healthy; When the obtained comprehensive health evaluation score of the urban sewage system is 60≤SC<80, the health status of the urban sewage system is sub-healthy; When the obtained comprehensive health evaluation score SC of the urban sewage system is less than 60, the health status of the urban sewage system is unhealthy.
8. The method for evaluating the health of a municipal sewage system according to claim 2, characterized in that: The current value CU of the rainwater mixing rate index N26 RMR for: The current value CU of the groundwater mixing rate index N27 GMR for: Among them, RAINQ is the amount of rainwater mixed, GWQ is the amount of groundwater mixed, and SUMQ is the annual water inflow of the sewage treatment plant; The rainwater mixing amount RAINQ is: RAINQ=SUMQ-RAWQ-GWQ Among them, RAWQ is the amount of raw sewage from the sewage treatment plant; The amount of raw sewage RAWQ of the sewage treatment plant is: RAWQ=Q1×m The groundwater mixing amount GWQ is: Among them, Q1 is the minimum water inflow of the sewage treatment plant, m is the number of natural days in the year, s is the number of sunny days in the year, Q k is the kth water inflow data of the sewage treatment plant after the daily water inflow data are arranged in ascending order, Q s It is the sth water inflow data of the sewage treatment plant after the daily water inflow data are arranged in ascending order.
9. The method for evaluating the health of a municipal sewage system according to claim 2, characterized in that: In the overflow sewage characteristic pollutant pollution load index N24 entering the river and the sewage characteristic pollutant treatment rate index N35, the characteristic pollutants include one or more of persistent organic pollutants, endocrine disruptors, antibiotics and microplastics, and the characteristic pollutants are determined based on the characteristics of sewage discharged by urban drainage households.
10. The method for evaluating the health of a municipal sewage system according to claim 2, characterized in that: In the pipeline network defect rate index N25, pipeline network defects include functional defects and structural defects; The functional defects include sedimentation, scaling, residual wall and dam roots, tree roots, obstacles or scum; The structural defects include corrosion, deformation, rupture, misalignment, leakage, undulation, blockage, falling off of interface materials, penetration of foreign matter or concealed connection of branch pipes.
