Lead-free shot composition for firearms

A lead-free ammunition composition using tin, bismuth, and indium addresses the limitations of alternative materials by enhancing deformability and hardness, achieving effective kinetic energy transfer and environmental safety with lead-like properties.

GB2630165APending Publication Date: 2024-11-20W HORTON GUNMAKERS LTD
View PDF 3 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
GB2024000846
Authority / Receiving Office
GB · GB
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2023-05-18
Filing Date
2024-01-23
Publication Date
2024-11-20

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Lead-based ammunition is toxic and environmentally harmful, and alternative materials like steel and bismuth-based ammunition face issues with density, hardness, and deformability, limiting their effectiveness and usability.

Method used

A lead-free shot composition comprising 20%-80% tin, 15%-80% bismuth, and 0.4%-5.71% indium, where indium acts as a binding agent to enhance deformability and hardness, creating composite materials with higher density and lower melting points, allowing for the production of ammunition with lead-like properties.

Benefits of technology

The composition achieves lead-like ballistic properties without toxicity, ensuring effective kinetic energy transfer and environmental safety, while maintaining comparable cost to existing alternatives.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

A lead-free shot composition for use in the manufacture of ammunition rounds, the composition comprising: 20%-80% by weight of tin; 15%-80% by weight of bismuth; and up to 10% by weight of indium.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

The present invention relates to a lead-free shot ammunition composition, particularly but not exclusively for shot, for firearms, that are more environmentally friendly and less damaging to wildlife than lead based ammunition. Lead ammunition has long been the de-facto choice for hunting and recreational shooting activities. The ballistic properties of lead are chosen due to its high density and malleability, which can be difficult to replicate with other materials. Lead is a highly toxic material, which has a damaging effect on the environment and can poison wildlife. Due to these issues and the resulting restriction proposals on lead ammunition, there is a strong need to develop alternative ammunition. Steel ammunition is available on the market, but the lower density of steel compared to lead means more propellent is needed than lead bullets to achieve the same effect, which limits its usage. Additionally, steel is harder than lead, which means it does not deform on impact, lowering transmission of kinetic energy. Ammunition made solely from bismuth is fragile and can break apart in the barrel when fired or on impact. Bio-ammo, made from an alloy of bismuth and tin, has similar issues to bismuth ammunition when under pressure to achieve high velocity. It is an object of the present invention is to provide an alternative to lead for the production of ammunition that does not suffer from the issues described with other alternative ammunition referenced above. In the first aspect of the invention, there is provided a lead-free shot composition for use in the manufacture of ammunition rounds, the composition comprising: 20%-80% by weight of tin; 15%-80% by weight of bismuth; and between 0.4% and 5.71% by weight of indium. The inclusion of indium into a base alloy comprising tin and one or more non lead metals results in an improved material for the purposes of ammunition, due to more suitable characteristics of deformability and hardness. The indium appears to act as a suitable binding agent which allows the bismuth to not break apart on firing a firearm. More preferably, the composition may comprise 20-60% by weight of bismuth. The inclusion of bismuth in the composition allows the creation of composite materials with higher density and lower melting points. Additionally, the quantity of bismuth can be varied to create a range of composite materials with varying hardness and deformability between that of bismuth and the composite material it was added to. The creation of low melting point materials may make the process of formation more efficient than for lead equivalents. Optionally, the composition may comprise both bismuth and nickel, a combined percentage by weight of nickel and bismuth exceeding 15% and wherein a combined percentage by weight of nickel and bismuth is not greater than 80%. The inclusion of multiple non-lead metal elements increases the range of composite materials that can be produced, thus providing a greater range of parameters for several relevant material properties, including density, melting point, hardness, plasticity and deformability. The composition may comprise 40-80% by weight of tin, and more preferably, may comprise 60-70% by weight of tin. Tin forms the base of the ammunition, being a cheap metal which can readily alloy with other metals. Optionally, the composition may comprise between 0.5% and 4.76%, and more preferably 0.5% and 3.0% by weight of indium. A lower indium percentage can achieve successful binding of the metal composition whilst reducing the total cost thereof, since indium is a rare and expensive metal. Preferably, the composition comprises a percentage by weight of indium equal to (V / A) / x, where V is the volume of the shot to be manufactured, A is the surface area of the shot to be manufactured, and x is a number in the range of 80 to 180, and more preferably in the range 95 to 150. The use of indium as a binder is related to the ratio of the volume to surface area of the shot or pellet. According to a second aspect of the invention, there is provided ammunition for a firearm, the ammunition comprising a lead-free shot composition in accordance with the first aspect of the invention. Ammunition formed from the composition herebefore described has lead-like properties in testing, particularly for shot, and therefore is a viable non-toxic replacement for leadbased ammunition. According to a third aspect of the invention, there is provided a method of making shot having lead-like shot properties, the method comprises the steps of: a] smelting a tin alloy, or tin and bismuth, in the presence of indium, wherein there is 20%-80% by weight of tin, 15%-80% by weight of the one or more non-lead metals, and up to 10% by weight of indium, to form a lead-free shot composition; and b] forming the lead-free shot composition into ammunition. According to a fourth aspect of the invention, there is provided a lead-free ammunition composition for use in the manufacture of ammunition rounds, the composition comprising: two or more non-lead metals; and between 0.5% and 4.76% by weight of indium. The use of indium as a binder is an expensive way of producing ammunition, but use in comparatively small percentages allows this to be mitigated with cheaper metals, and also allows for lead-like properties of other less toxic metals to be imparted to any final composition. In the fifth aspect of the invention, there is provided a lead-free ammunition composition for use in the manufacture of ammunition rounds, the composition comprising: 20%-80% by weight of tin; 15%-80% by weight of one or more non-lead metals; and up to 10% by weight of indium. The inclusion of indium into a base alloy comprising tin and one or more non lead metals results in an improved material for the purposes of ammunition, due to more suitable characteristics of deformability and hardness. The indium appears to act as a suitable binding agent which allows the non-lead metals to not break apart on firing a firearm. Optionally, the said one or more non-lead metals may comprise 15-80% by weight bismuth. More preferably, the composition may comprise 20-60% by weight of bismuth. The inclusion of bismuth in the composition allows the creation of composite materials with higher density and lower melting points. Additionally, the quantity of bismuth can be varied to create a range of composite materials with varying hardness and deformability between that of bismuth and the composite material it was added to. The creation of low melting point materials may make the process of formation more efficient than for lead equivalents. Optionally, the said one or more non-lead metals may comprise 15-80% by weight nickel. More preferably, the composition may comprise 30-40% by weight of nickel. The inclusion of nickel in the composition allows the creation of lightweight composite materials of lower density. Additionally, the quantity of nickel can be varied to create a range of composite materials with varying hardness and deformability between that of bismuth and the composite material to which it was added. Optionally, the said one or more non-lead metals may comprise both bismuth and nickel, a combined percentage by weight of nickel and bismuth being 15-80%. The inclusion of multiple non-lead metal elements increases the range of composite materials that can be produced, thus providing a greater range of parameters for several relevant material properties, including density, melting point, hardness, plasticity and deformability. The composition may comprise 40-80% by weight of tin, and more preferably, may comprise 60-70% by weight of tin. Tin forms the base of the ammunition, being a cheap metal which can readily alloy with other metals. Optionally, the composition may comprise up to 5% by weight of indium. A lower indium percentage can achieve successful binding of the metal composition whilst reducing the total cost thereof, since indium is a rare and expensive metal. According to a sixth aspect of the invention, there is provided ammunition for a firearm, the ammunition comprising a lead-free ammunition composition in accordance with the first aspect of the invention. Ammunition formed from the composition herebefore described has lead-like properties in testing, particularly for shot, and therefore is a viable non-toxic replacement for leadbased ammunition. Optionally, the said ammunition may comprise shot formed from the lead-free ammunition composition; a bullet being formed from the lead-free ammunition composition; or, where said ammunition is cased ammunition, a casing of the cased ammunition being formed from the lead-free ammunition composition. According to a seventh aspect of the invention, there is provided a method of making ammunition having lead-like shot properties, the method comprises the steps of: a] 5 smelting a tin alloy, or tin and one or more non-lead metals, in the presence of indium, wherein there is 20%-80% by weight of tin, 15%-80% by weight of the one or more nonlead metals, and up to 10% by weight of indium, to form a lead-free ammunition composition; and b] forming the lead-free ammunition composition into ammunition. According to a eighth aspect of the invention, there is provided a lead-free ammunition 10 composition for use in the manufacture of ammunition rounds, the composition comprising: two or more non-lead metals; and up to 10% by weight of indium. The use of indium as a binder is an expensive way of producing ammunition, but use in comparatively small percentages allows this to be mitigated with cheaper metals, and also allows for lead-like properties of other less toxic metals to be imparted to any final 15 composition. The invention will now be more specifically described with reference to exemplary compositions. Example 1 Composition Parts Total Parts Percentage by weight Tin Indium Bismuth Tin Indium Bismuth A 80 5 20 105 76.2% 4.76% 19.05% B 70 5 30 105 66.7% 4.76% 28.57% C 60 5 40 105 57.1% 4.76% 38.10% D 50 5 50 105 47.6% 4.76% 47.62% E 40 5 60 105 38.1% 4.76% 57.14% F 30 5 70 105 28.6% 4.76% 66.67% G 80 4 20 104 76.9% 3.85% 19.23% H 70 4 30 104 67.3% 3.85% 28.85% I 60 4 40 104 57.7% 3.85% 38.46% J 50 4 50 104 48.1% 3.85% 48.08% K 40 4 60 104 38.5% 3.85% 57.69% L 30 4 70 104 28.8% 3.85% 67.31% M 80 3 20 103 77.7% 2.91% 19.42% N 70 3 30 103 68.0% 2.91% 29.13% 0 60 3 40 103 58.3% 2.91% 38.83% P 50 3 50 103 48.5% 2.91% 48.54% Q 40 3 60 103 38.8% 2.91% 58.25% R 30 3 70 103 29.1% 2.91% 67.96% S 80 2 20 102 78.4% 1.96% 19.61% T 70 2 30 102 68.6% 1.96% 29.41% U 60 2 40 102 58.8% 1.96% 39.22% V 50 2 50 102 49.0% 1.96% 49.02% w 40 2 60 102 39.2% 1.96% 58.82% X 30 2 70 102 29.4% 1.96% 68.63% Y 80 1 20 101 79.2% 0.99% 19.80% z 70 1 30 101 69.3% 0.99% 29.70% AA 60 1 40 101 59.4% 0.99% 39.60% BB 50 1 50 101 49.5% 0.99% 49.50% CC 40 1 60 101 39.6% 0.99% 59.41% DD 30 1 70 101 29.7% 0.99% 69.31% Various compositions of tin, bismuth and indium are proposed. The compositions have been created by smelting of tin, indium and bismuth together, and then casting the material into the desired shape. This could be the shape of shot, a bullet, or potentially 5 even casing for ammunition where appropriate. Compositions A, C, E, Y, AA, and CC have all been tested and shown to have lead-like shot properties. For small-shot ammunition, the formation was performed via a lead-shot dripper, modified to accommodate the lower melting temperature of the lead-free ammunition composition. 10 The melting point is approximately 30% lower than that of lead, and existing lead-shot drippers do require modification to be usable. Crush and density testing was performed, and the composition found to be comparable to lead. 50 cartridges were loaded with wad and propellant, and chicken carcasses shot at 30m. 15 Upon dissection, the performance of the shot was shown to be exactly the same as lead. Shot pattern was also monitored at 20m with % choke and Vi choke, and also at 30m with full and % choke. Performance was the same as for lead shot. Advantageously, upon testing, there was no equivalent to the ‘leading’ effect found in the barrels of the firearms, which is attributed to the lower friction of the composition. For bullets, eight different batches were tested for lower power ammunition types .22LR, .223, .308, and 9mm pistol. Formation of the bullets was achieved using wire, CNC, or hot die mould casting. In the .22LR instance, which would normally use a solid lead bullet, the composition 5 demonstrated a 1 / 2in minute of angle at 50m. Penetration tests on 9mm pistol showed identical travel and mushrooming to a solid lead bullet. The composition does leave residue in the barrel, similar to lead or copper bullets; however, it seems as though there does not appear to be similar effects with continued 10 build up, as the composition for higher calibre ammunition appears to act as a lubricant. Higher and more uniform bullet velocities appear to be achievable. Whilst testing has been limited thus far to small calibre ammunition, it is expected that the same properties outlined above make the ammunition composition feasible for high calibre ammunition. 15 The cost per gram of the lead-free ammunition composition is increased due to the inclusion of indium; however, it is broadly comparable to that of bio-ammo or pure bismuth ammunition. Example 2 Composition Parts Total Parts Percentage by weight Tin Indium Nickel Tin Indium Nickel A 80 5 20 105 76.2% 4.76% 19.05% B 70 5 30 105 66.7% 4.76% 28.57% C 60 5 40 105 57.1% 4.76% 38.10% D 50 5 50 105 47.6% 4.76% 47.62% E 40 5 60 105 38.1% 4.76% 57.14% F 30 5 70 105 28.6% 4.76% 66.67% G 80 4 20 104 76.9% 3.85% 19.23% H 70 4 30 104 67.3% 3.85% 28.85% I 60 4 40 104 57.7% 3.85% 38.46% J 50 4 50 104 48.1% 3.85% 48.08% K 40 4 60 104 38.5% 3.85% 57.69% L 30 4 70 104 28.8% 3.85% 67.31% M 80 3 20 103 77.7% 2.91% 19.42% N 70 3 30 103 68.0% 2.91% 29.13% 0 60 3 40 103 58.3% 2.91% 38.83% p 50 3 50 103 48.5% 2.91% 48.54% Q 40 3 60 103 38.8% 2.91% 58.25% R 30 3 70 103 29.1% 2.91% 67.96% S 80 2 20 102 78.4% 1.96% 19.61% T 70 2 30 102 68.6% 1.96% 29.41% U 60 2 40 102 58.8% 1.96% 39.22% V 50 2 50 102 49.0% 1.96% 49.02% w 40 2 60 102 39.2% 1.96% 58.82% X 30 2 70 102 29.4% 1.96% 68.63% Y 80 1 20 101 79.2% 0.99% 19.80% z 70 1 30 101 69.3% 0.99% 29.70% AA 60 1 40 101 59.4% 0.99% 39.60% BB 50 1 50 101 49.5% 0.99% 49.50% CC 40 1 60 101 39.6% 0.99% 59.41% DD 30 1 70 101 29.7% 0.99% 69.31% Various compositions of tin, nickel and indium are proposed. The compositions have been created by smelting of tin, indium and nickel together, and then casting the material into the desired shape. This could be the shape of shot, a bullet, including jacketed bullets, or potentially even casing for ammunition where appropriate. Where jacketed bullets are provided, a first indium-including composition could be used which is comparably heavy, with a second indium-including composition being used as the jacket, and which is lighter due to the alloy composition. This would allow mushrooming of the tip of the jacket, with the jacket expanding and the travel of the inner bullet being given higher kinetic thrust on impact. Compositions N, O, T and II have all been tested and shown to have lead-like shot properties. The cost per gram of the lead-free ammunition composition is increased due to the inclusion of indium; however, it is broadly comparable to that of bio-ammo and other nonlead alternatives. Whilst this example highlights how tin and nickel can be used together, it is more likely that a combination of tin, nickel, and bismuth could be bound together using indium. It is expected that as the size of the shot or bullet increases, that the percentage of nickel increases. Preferred compositions are expected to have between 40-80%, and more preferably 60-70% of tin. The percentage of indium is expected to be less than 10%, and more preferably less than 5%. The indium percentage is likely to increase as the size of the ammunition increases, to improve the binding effect. The non-lead metals other than tin, here bismuth and nickel, are preferred to have a total weight in the range of 40-60%. Small shot might use exclusively bismuth, and small bullets only a small percentage of nickel, with bismuth making up around 30-40% of the total composition weight. For large shot, there may be close to equal percentages of bismuth and nickel, whereas for large bullets, there may be predominantly nickel, around 30-40% of the total composition, with maybe perhaps 10% bismuth. Furthermore, it may be possible to alloy bismuth and nickel together using indium, without the use of tin, or indeed, generally using non-lead metals alloyed together using indium, in the context of making ammunition. Example 3 For shot in particular, an optimum indium percentage can be determined, according to the volume to surface area ratio. An optimum indium percentage is approximately equivalent, in percentage terms, to the ratio between the volume of an individual shot, and its surface area, since shot will be spherical or near spherical once manufactured. The volume of the shot will be equivalent to: 4 , V = — nr 3 The surface area will be equivalent to: A = Anr2 The table below outlines various preferred shot sizes, and the optimum indium percentage found after experimentation. Shot Size (UK) Diameter (mm) Pellets per oz Weight / pellet (g) V A V / A Optimum In % (V / A) / In % LG(i) 9.1 6 72.91 3156.55 1040.62 3.03 3.00 101.11 SG(2) 8.4 8 54.69 2482.71 886.68 2.8 2.25 124.44 SSSG(3) 6.8 15 29.16 1317.09 581.07 2.26 1.90 119.30 AAA 5.1 37 12.5 555.65 326.85 1.7 1.75 97.14 US BB(4) 4.5 50 8.75 381.70 254.47 1.5 1.25 120.00 BB(5) 4.01 70 6.25 270.10 202.07 1.34 1.25 106.93 1(6) 3.8 90 4.86 229.85 181.46 1.27 0.99 127.95 2 3.6 100 4.37 195.43 162.86 1.2 0.89 134.83 3(7) 3.3 140 3.12 150.53 136.85 1.1 0.87 126.44 4(8) 3.1 170 2.58 124.79 120.76 1.03 0.87 118.77 5 2.8 220 1.99 91.95 98.52 0.93 0.87 107.28 6 2.6 270 1.62 73.62 84.95 0.87 0.77 112.55 7 2.4 340 1.28 57.91 72.38 0.8 0.65 123.08 7 1 / 2 2.3 400 1.09 50.97 66.48 0.77 0.65 117.95 8 2.2 450 0.97 44.60 60.82 0.73 0.50 146.67 9 2 580 0.75 33.51 50.27 0.67 0.50 133.33 (1) US equivalent 000 BUCK (2) US equivalent 00 BUCK (3) Spanish equivalent 6,6; Italian equivalent 8 / 0; US equivalent 2 BUCK 5      (4) Spanish equivalent BB; US equivalent BB (5) Italian equivalent 2 / 0 (6) US equivalent 2 (7) Italian equivalent 3 (8) Italian equivalent 4 10 All tests in example 3 were caried out in 12 gauge with 70mm cartridges with a given volume and variety of gunpowder. Pellets for shot are typically formed by forming droplets of molten metal at a nozzle, dropping them through the air and into a liquid cooling bath. This creates spherical or substantially spherical ammunition. This method of formation allows for the relationship between volume and surface area, and the necessary percentage of indium, to be determined easily. The smaller the shot size, the greater the cross-sectional density, and the less indium is required. There is also some variability in the indium percentage required based on shot speed, typically measured in feet per second (fps). For example, clay / sport shooting is generally carried out at between 1050fps and 1300fps (365.4m / s to 396.2m / s) with the desired outcome being a short shot string, measured as the distance from the front-most pellet to the rear-most pellet. This assists with consistent shooting. For high pheasant shooting, this is carried out at greater distance, and penetration and pattern are required. Larger diameter pellets are required, with more charge, so as to reach speeds of around 1500fps (457.2m / s). The lower the velocity, the less constriction there is, the less pressure is placed on projectiles. This means that less indium is required to produce lead-like effects. The absence of indium, however, causes the bismuth and tin to fail to alloy, and break up under pressure. These ratios represent optimum ratios, and there is expected to be functional lead-like shot behaviour at ±20% variation around the values quoted. It is therefore possible to provide a lead-free ammunition composition for use in the manufacture of ammunition rounds which uses indium as a binding agent for non-lead metals. Whilst this is an expensive component, it can be used in small quantities to minimise cost whilst still retaining beneficial properties in the final composition. The words ‘comprises / comprising’ and the words ‘having / including’ when used herein with reference to the present invention are used to specify the presence of stated features, integers, steps, or components, but do not preclude the presence or addition of one or more other features, integers, steps, components, or groups thereof. It is appreciated that certain features of the invention, which are, for clarity, described in the context of separate embodiments, may also be provided in combination in a single embodiment. Conversely, various features of the invention which are, for brevity, described in the context of a single embodiment, may also be provided separately or in any suitable sub-combination. The embodiments described above are provided by way of examples only, and various other modifications will be apparent to persons skilled in the field without departing from 5 the scope of the invention as defined herein.

Claims

1. A lead-free shot composition for use in the manufacture of ammunition rounds, the composition comprising:20%-80% by weight of tin;15%-80% by weight of bismuth; andbetween 0.40% and 5.71% by weight of indium.

2. A lead-free shot composition as claimed in claim 1, wherein there is 20-60% by weight of bismuth.

3. A lead-free shot composition as claimed in any one of the preceding claims, wherein the composition further comprises nickel, and a combined percentage by weight of nickel and bismuth exceeds 15% and wherein a combined percentage by weight of nickel and bismuth is not greater than 80%.

4. A lead-free shot composition as claimed in any one of the preceding claims, wherein the composition comprises 40-80% by weight of tin.

5. A lead-free shot composition as claimed in claim 4, wherein the composition comprises 60-70% by weight of tin.

6. A lead-free shot composition as claimed in any one of the preceding claims, comprising between 0.5% and 4.76% by weight of indium.

7. A lead-free shot composition as claimed in any one of the preceding claims, comprising between 0.5% and 3.0% by weight of indium.

8. A lead-free shot composition as claimed in any one of the preceding claims, wherein the composition comprises a percentage by weight of indium equal to (V / A) / x, where V is the volume of the shot to be manufactured, A is the surface area of the shot to be manufactured, and x is a number in the range of 80 to 180.

9. A lead-free shot composition as claimed in claim 8, wherein x is a number in the range of 95 to 150.

10. Shot for a firearm, the ammunition comprising a lead-free shot composition as claimed in any one of the preceding claims.

11. A method of making shot having lead-like shot properties, the method comprises the steps of:5                  a] smelting a tin-bismuth alloy, or tin and bismuth, in the presence ofindium, wherein there is 20%-80% by weight of tin, 15%-80% by weight of bismuth, and between 0.5% and 4.76% by weight of indium, to form a lead-free shot composition; andb] forming the lead-free shot composition into shot.10

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Composition and method for making frangible bullet

    US20050188890A1

  • Frangible-type shell

    CZ26587U1

  • CZ000026587U