Process design support device, process design support method, and program

The process design support device addresses defects in conventional technologies by calculating nonconformity probability and cost impact, facilitating efficient and timely design of high-quality manufacturing processes.

JP2024157411APending Publication Date: 2024-11-07HITACHI LTD

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2023071763
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-04-25
Publication Date
2024-11-07

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Conventional process design technologies fail to adequately consider manufacturing process and condition design for high-quality product production, leading to increased defects and prolonged manufacturing periods due to insufficient consideration of manufacturing order and conditions.

Method used

A process design support device and method that utilizes a tree structure to calculate nonconformity occurrence probability and cost impact, enabling the selection and design of optimal manufacturing processes and conditions through a user interface.

Benefits of technology

Enables rapid design of high-quality manufacturing processes, reducing defect occurrences and manufacturing time by considering process quality and conditions proactively.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 2024157411000001_ABST
    Figure 2024157411000001_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To design manufacturing processes for manufacturing high quality products in short time.SOLUTION: A process design support device 10 includes: a manufacturing information accumulation part 101 that accumulates past manufacturing information at a storage part 12; an incompatibility occurrence probability calculation part 103 that calculates the probability of occurrence of incompatibility based on a tree structure created based on the accumulated past manufacturing information; a cost impact calculation part 104 that calculates cost impact from the probability of occurrence of incompatibility and loss cost; and a manufacturing process design part 105 that selectively displays, at a display part 13, one or a plurality of next manufacturing process candidates with relatively small cost impact and accepts the selection to design the next manufacturing process.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 1
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to a process design support device, a process design support method, and a program. [Background technology]

[0002] Conventionally, a support device has been proposed that predicts product performance using machine learning from past results when designing a product using manufacturing information (see, for example, Patent Document 1). Patent Document 1 describes a device having a result collection unit that collects manufacturing result data for each process, a storage unit that stores manufacturing specification results and evaluation index results, a search processing unit that uses at least two or more confirmed manufacturing result data among the manufacturing result data collected by the result collection unit after a predetermined process during manufacturing as fixed values ​​of the manufacturing specifications, performs reverse analysis based on a prediction model that links the manufacturing specifications and evaluation indexes of the product, and searches for manufacturing specifications for the process after the predetermined process so that the estimated value of the evaluation index asymptotically approaches a desired value, and an output unit that at least one of displays and outputs the searched manufacturing specifications. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0003] [Patent Document 1] Patent Publication No. 2022-14878 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0004] However, the conventional technology disclosed in Patent Document 1 does not fully consider the fact that a high-quality product can be obtained by appropriately designing the manufacturing process and manufacturing conditions. Therefore, the conventional technology disclosed in Patent Document 1 has room for improvement in terms of obtaining a high-quality product by appropriately designing the manufacturing process and manufacturing conditions, and it is desired to design a manufacturing process for producing a high-quality product in a short period of time.

[0005] The present invention has been made to solve the above-mentioned problems, and has as its main object to provide a process design support device, a process design support method, and a program that are capable of designing a manufacturing process for producing high-quality products in a short period of time.

[0006] The present invention also provides a process design support device, a process design support method, and a program that can solve the following problems in the conventional technology disclosed in Patent Document 1.

[0007] (1) The conventional technology disclosed in Patent Document 1 predicts the performance of manufacturing specifications and the like by creating a machine learning model using a regression curve, a neural network, or the like using past performance values ​​of the product. This conventional technology predicts the performance of a product when its form, etc. is decided, and does not take into account the process of determining the form and shape of the product, i.e., the manufacturing process. Normally, even if the final shape of a product is the same, nonconformities (defects) such as scratches are likely to occur in the product depending on the order of the manufacturing process and the manufacturing conditions. In other words, the frequency of occurrence of nonconformities may differ depending on the manufacturing process and manufacturing conditions. Therefore, the conventional technology has a problem that it is difficult to manufacture high-quality products unless the manufacturing process and manufacturing conditions are appropriately designed (set).

[0008] (2) Furthermore, the conventional technology disclosed in Patent Document 1 classifies and organizes the types of nonconformities (defects) that may occur and the countermeasures therefor, and clearly indicates the countermeasures when a nonconformity occurs, thereby efficiently taking measures when a nonconformity occurs. Such conventional technology can efficiently take measures against nonconformities (defects) that occur when a product is manufactured after the manufacturing process has been designed. However, since the conventional technology does not take into account the quality of the manufacturing process or manufacturing conditions, it is not possible to take measures against nonconformities (defects) that may occur at the stage before the manufacturing process is designed. Therefore, the conventional technology has the problem that when a nonconformity occurs, a large amount of countermeasure work is required, which extends the manufacturing period. [Means for solving the problem]

[0009] In order to achieve the above-mentioned object, the present invention is a process design support device comprising: a manufacturing information accumulation unit that accumulates past manufacturing information in a memory unit; a nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit that calculates the occurrence probability of nonconformity based on a tree structure created based on the accumulated past manufacturing information; a cost impact calculation unit that calculates a cost impact from the occurrence probability of nonconformity and loss cost; and a manufacturing process design unit that displays one or more next manufacturing process candidates having a relatively small cost impact on a display unit for selection, accepts a selection, and designs the next manufacturing process. Other means will be described later. Effect of the Invention

[0010] According to the present invention, a manufacturing process for producing high-quality products can be designed in a short period of time. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0011] [Figure 1] 1 is a configuration diagram of a process design support device according to an embodiment; [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is an explanatory diagram showing a processing procedure of a first phase of the process design support device according to the embodiment. [Diagram 3] FIG. 4 is an explanatory diagram showing a processing procedure of a second phase of the process design support device according to the embodiment. [Figure 4A] FIG. 1 is an explanatory diagram (1) showing an example of manufacturing information. [Figure 4B] FIG. 2 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of manufacturing information. [Figure 4C] FIG. 3 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of manufacturing information. [Diagram 5] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram illustrating an example of non-conformity information. [Figure 6] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a first input screen for a manufacturing process. [Figure 7] FIG. 1 is an explanatory diagram (1) showing an example of creating a tree structure of a manufacturing process. [Figure 8] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram (2) showing an example of creating a tree structure of a manufacturing process. [Figure 9] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram (3) showing an example of creating a tree structure of a manufacturing process. [Figure 10A] FIG. 1 is an explanatory diagram (1) showing an example of nonconformity information including the probability of occurrence of nonconformity, loss cost, and cost impact. [Figure 10B] FIG. 2 is an explanatory diagram (2) showing an example of nonconformity information including the probability of occurrence of nonconformity, loss cost, and cost impact. [Figure 10C] FIG. 3 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of nonconformity information including the probability of occurrence of nonconformity, loss cost, and cost impact. [Figure 11] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a manufacturing process input screen when a next manufacturing process candidate is displayed; [Figure 12] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a manufacturing process input screen when a next manufacturing process candidate is selected; [Figure 13] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a tree structure of manufacturing processes created with the manufacturing processes of the second permutation as the axis. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0012] Hereinafter, an embodiment of the present invention (hereinafter referred to as "the present embodiment") will be described in detail with reference to the drawings. Note that each drawing is merely a schematic illustration to allow a sufficient understanding of the present invention. Therefore, the present invention is not limited to only the illustrated examples. In addition, in each drawing, common or similar components are given the same reference numerals, and duplicated explanations thereof will be omitted.

[0013] <Configuration of process design support device> Hereinafter, the configuration of the process design support device 10 according to this embodiment will be described with reference to Fig. 1. Fig. 1 is a configuration diagram of the process design support device 10 according to this embodiment. In this embodiment, the process design support device 10 will be described as being configured as a personal computer operated by a user (designer). However, the process design support device 10 can be configured as a server communicably connected to the personal computer operated by the user (designer) via a network (not shown).

[0014] As shown in FIG. 1, a process design support device 10 according to this embodiment includes a calculation unit 11 that executes various calculations, a memory unit 12 that stores various programs and data, a display unit 13 that displays data, and an input unit 14 for inputting data.

[0015] The process design support device 10 has a control program Pr stored in the storage unit 12. The control program Pr is a program for causing a computer to function as the process design support device 10. The control program Pr is, for example, stored in advance in a storage medium Md, and is installed in the process design support device 10 from the storage medium Md. Alternatively, the control program Pr is stored in a distribution server (not shown), and is downloaded from the distribution server (not shown) to the process design support device 10 via a communication line (not shown). The storage medium Md is, for example, a memory member such as a USB memory, an optical medium such as a DVD, a storage device such as a hard disk or SSD (Solid State Drive), or in other forms.

[0016] In the process design support device 10, a manufacturing information accumulation unit 101, a manufacturing process input unit 102, a tree structure generation unit 102A, a nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103, a cost impact calculation unit 104, and a manufacturing process design unit 105 are constructed in the calculation unit 11 by storing a control program Pr in the memory unit 12. Also, a manufacturing information database 106 and an operation database 110 are constructed in the memory unit 12.

[0017] The manufacturing information accumulation unit 101 is a functional means for accumulating various types of manufacturing information, including past manufacturing information, in the manufacturing information database 106 of the storage unit 12. The manufacturing information accumulation unit 101 accumulates, in the manufacturing information database 106 of the storage unit 12, manufacturing information of the product, such as the manufacturing process and manufacturing conditions of the product, inspection results such as non-conformity information of the manufactured product, and loss costs associated with the non-conformity of the product.

[0018] The manufacturing process input unit 102 is a functional unit that accepts input of an arbitrary manufacturing process. When a new manufacturing process is designed, the manufacturing process input unit 102 accepts input of an arbitrary manufacturing process by an operation of a user (designer).

[0019] The tree structure generating unit 102A creates a tree structure based on past manufacturing information stored in the manufacturing information database 106 of the storage unit 12. The tree structure generating unit 102A outputs the created tree structure to the nonconformity occurrence probability calculating unit 103 and / or stores it in the manufacturing information database 106 of the storage unit 12.

[0020] The nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 is a functional means for calculating the occurrence probability of nonconformity. The nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 calculates the occurrence probability of nonconformity (defect) for the manufacturing process inputted by the manufacturing process input unit 102, based on a tree structure created based on past manufacturing information accumulated in the manufacturing information database 106 of the storage unit 12. At that time, the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 calculates the occurrence probability of nonconformity (defect) based on the tree structure created by the tree structure generation unit 102A. In addition, the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 can also calculate the occurrence probability of nonconformity (defect) based on a tree structure created in advance by the tree structure generation unit 102A or a means not shown based on past manufacturing information and accumulated in the manufacturing information database 106 of the storage unit 12.

[0021] The cost impact calculation unit 104 is a functional means for calculating a cost impact (degree of influence on costs) from the probability of nonconformity and the loss cost. The cost impact calculation unit 104 acquires loss cost information of one or more manufacturing process plans by performing an inspection process on the tree structure created by the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103. Then, the cost impact calculation unit 104 acquires the probability of nonconformity and the loss cost of each manufacturing process plan from the acquired loss cost information, and calculates the cost impact of each manufacturing process plan by multiplying the probability of nonconformity and the loss cost for each manufacturing process plan.

[0022] The manufacturing process design unit 105 is a functional means for designing the next manufacturing process. The manufacturing process design unit 105 displays one or more manufacturing process plans with relatively small cost impacts on the display unit 13 as next manufacturing process candidates in a selectable manner, accepts the selection, and designs the next manufacturing process. Specifically, the manufacturing process design unit 105 sets each manufacturing process plan as a next manufacturing process candidate, and acquires the next manufacturing process candidates and their cost impacts corresponding to the manufacturing processes inputted in the manufacturing process input unit 102 in order of the smallest calculated cost impact. Then, the manufacturing process design unit 105 displays the acquired next manufacturing process candidates on a manufacturing process input screen in a selectable manner, accepts the selection by the user (designer) operation, and designs the next manufacturing process.

[0023] The manufacturing information database 106 is a storage means for storing various pieces of manufacturing information. The operation database 110 is a storage means for storing data obtained from each section.

[0024] In the example shown in FIG. 1, the manufacturing information database 106 includes a manufacturing process database 107, a manufacturing equipment database 108, and an inspection result database 109. The manufacturing process database 107 stores past manufacturing process information. The manufacturing equipment database 108 stores past manufacturing conditions for the manufacturing equipment. The inspection result database 109 accumulates past inspection results and loss costs.

[0025] <Operation of the process design support device> Hereinafter, the operation of the process design support device 10 will be described with reference to Fig. 2 and Fig. 3. Fig. 2 is a flowchart showing the processing procedure of the first phase of the process design support device 10. Fig. 3 is a flowchart showing the processing procedure of the second phase of the process design support device 10.

[0026] The processing of the process design support device 10 according to this embodiment is roughly divided into two parts. The first process is a process (first phase process) of accumulating product manufacturing information such as the product manufacturing process and manufacturing conditions, inspection results such as non-conformity information of the manufactured products, and loss costs associated with the non-conformity of the products. The second process is a process (second phase process) of designing a new manufacturing process (next manufacturing process) using accumulated past manufacturing information.

[0027] Here, we will assume that the manufacturing process for a mechanical structure is to be designed, and explain the process from accumulating manufacturing information (first phase of processing) to designing a new manufacturing process (next manufacturing process) using the accumulated past manufacturing information (second phase of processing).

[0028] First, the first phase of processing will be described. 2, the process design support device 10 performs a first phase process (step S100) by the manufacturing information accumulation unit 101. The first phase process (step S100) is mainly a process of accumulating, in the operation database 110, product manufacturing information such as the product manufacturing process and manufacturing conditions, inspection results such as non-conformity information of the manufactured product, and loss costs associated with the non-conformity of the product, by the manufacturing information accumulation unit 101.

[0029] In the first phase of processing (step S100), first, the manufacturing information accumulation unit 101 of the process design support device 10 acquires product manufacturing information (see Figures 4A to 4C), such as manufacturing process information and manufacturing conditions related to the product, from the manufacturing process database 107 and the manufacturing equipment database 108 (step S101).

[0030] 4A, 4B, and 4C are explanatory diagrams showing an example of manufacturing information. As an example, manufacturing information of three types of products is shown in FIG. 4A to FIG. 4C. In the example shown in FIG. 4A, the manufacturing information D11a includes information of "24031" as the manufacturing number, information of "case" as the product name, and information of "AA2024" as the material, and includes manufacturing process information in the order of annealing, rolling, rolling, cutting, cutting, grinding, and inspection as the manufacturing process. In the example shown in FIG. 4B, the manufacturing information D11b includes information of "26021" as the manufacturing number, information of "shaft" as the product name, and information of "SUS304" as the material, and includes manufacturing process information in the order of annealing, rolling, cutting, cutting, cutting, grinding, and inspection as the manufacturing process. In the example shown in FIG. 4C, the manufacturing information D11c includes information such as “28428” as the manufacturing number, information such as “Disk” as the product name, and information such as “Ti16” as the material, and also includes manufacturing process information in the order of annealing, rolling, cutting, and inspection.

[0031] As shown in Figures 4A to 4C, manufacturing conditions are associated with the manufacturing processes of each of the manufacturing information D11a, D11b, and D11c. For example, in the manufacturing information D11b shown in Figure 4B, "BBB°C, B time (h)" is associated as the manufacturing condition of "annealing", which is the first manufacturing process, and cutting time X time (h) is associated as the manufacturing condition of "cutting", which is the third manufacturing process.

[0032] Returning to FIG. 2, after step S101, the manufacturing information accumulation unit 101 acquires, from the inspection result database 109, the manufacturing process information of the product manufacturing information acquired in step S101, inspection results such as product nonconformity information related to the manufacturing conditions (see FIG. 5), and information on loss costs associated with product nonconformity (step S102).

[0033] FIG. 5 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of nonconformity information. The nonconformity information Nd11 shown in FIG. 5 shows the correspondence between the occurrence mode of an event determined to be nonconformant in the inspection process and the loss cost associated with the nonconformity. In the example shown in FIG. 5, the nonconformity information Nd11 includes a production number column indicating the production number, a nonconformity type column indicating the nonconformity type column No11, and a loss cost column indicating the loss cost column Lc11. In the nonconformity information Nd11, in the production number "23662" of the product in the first row, "crack" occurs as the occurrence mode of an event determined to be nonconformant in the inspection process, and "###¥" is incurred as the loss cost at that time. In addition, in the nonconformity information Nd11, in the production number "23662" of the product in the second row, "missing" further occurs as the occurrence mode, and the loss cost at that time is "###¥".

[0034] Returning to FIG. 2, after step S102, the manufacturing information accumulation unit 101 inputs the manufacturing information and nonconformity information acquired in steps S101 and S102 into the work database 110 in association with each other via the manufacturing number (step S103).

[0035] It is assumed that past manufacturing information is stored in advance in the manufacturing process database 107, the manufacturing equipment database 108, the inspection result database 109, and the work database 110. This completes the first phase of processing.

[0036] Next, the second phase processing will be described. 3, the process design support device 10 performs the second phase processing (step S200) by the manufacturing process input unit 102, the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103, the cost impact calculation unit 104, and the manufacturing process design unit 105. The second phase processing (step S200) is mainly a processing in which the manufacturing process input unit 102 accepts input of an arbitrary manufacturing process for designing a new manufacturing process, the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 calculates the occurrence probability of nonconformity of the input manufacturing process, the cost impact calculation unit 104 calculates the cost impact of the input manufacturing process, the manufacturing process design unit 105 outputs candidates for the next process of the input manufacturing process and their cost impact, the manufacturing process design unit 105 displays candidates for the next process, designs the manufacturing process while selecting, and inputs the designed manufacturing process information into the operation database 110.

[0037] In the second phase processing (step S200), first, the manufacturing process input unit 102 of the process design support device 10 acquires all past manufacturing information acquired in the first phase processing (step S100 in FIG. 2) from the work database 110 (step S201).

[0038] After step S201, the manufacturing process input unit 102 displays an input screen (see FIG. 6) for designing a new manufacturing process by operation of the user (designer) on the display unit 13 (step S202), and accepts input of any manufacturing process.

[0039] FIG. 6 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the first input screen Im11 of the manufacturing process. In the example shown in FIG. 6, the input screen Im11 includes a manufacturing No. column showing the manufacturing No., a product name column showing the product name, a material column showing the material, a selected process display column Sp showing the manufacturing process selected by the operation of the user (designer), a process candidate display column Cp showing the next manufacturing process candidate, a process decision button, and a process cancellation button. In the example shown in FIG. 6, information "24813" as the product manufacturing No., information "flange" as the product name, and information "SUS304" as the material are input in the input screen Im11. Since the input screen Im11 is the first input screen for the manufacturing process design, the selected process display column Sp and the process candidate display column Cp are blank. In other words, the process candidate display column Cp is not yet displaying the next manufacturing process candidate, and the selected process display column Sp is not yet inputting the manufacturing process.

[0040] 3, after step S202, the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 calculates the occurrence probability of nonconformity in the next manufacturing process (step S203). Here, it is assumed that the product with the product name "Flange" and material "SUS304" input in step S202 is the target of the calculation of the occurrence probability of nonconformity.

[0041] The nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 acquires manufacturing information on a product with the product name "Flange" and material "SUS304" in order to calculate the occurrence probability of nonconformity. Here, it is assumed that the user (designer) has not input a manufacturing process in the process candidate display field Cp (see FIG. 6) when acquiring the initial manufacturing information.

[0042] In this case, first, the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 acquires, from the work database 110, manufacturing information (see FIG. 7) that is the main part of the product with the product name "flange" and the material "SUS304".

[0043] FIG. 7 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of creating a tree structure of a manufacturing process. In the example shown in FIG. 7, a tree structure Tr11 of a manufacturing process is shown, which is the main part of manufacturing information (basic manufacturing information) of a product having a product name "flange" and a material "SUS304" to be acquired. In the example shown in FIG. 7, the tree structure Tr11 includes a manufacturing process of the first permutation being "annealing", a manufacturing condition of the first permutation being "AAA°C, Ah", a manufacturing process of the second permutation being "rolling", a manufacturing condition of the second permutation being "rolling ratio X1%, and similarly includes manufacturing processes and manufacturing conditions from the third permutation to the eighth permutation.

[0044] In the tree structure Tr11 (see FIG. 7) of the manufacturing process of a product with the product name "Flange" and the material "SUS304", the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 first acquires manufacturing information of the manufacturing process of the first permutation, and then acquires manufacturing information of the manufacturing processes of the second permutation and onward. Here, the "manufacturing process of the first permutation" means the first (leading) manufacturing process. Also, the "manufacturing process of the second permutation and onward" means the second and subsequent manufacturing processes.

[0045] Next, when the production information of other systems to be added to the tree structure Tr11 (see FIG. 7), which is the main part of the production information, is stored in the work database 110, the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 acquires the production information of other systems from the work database 110. Here, a description will be given assuming a case where tree structures Tr12a and Tr13a (see FIGS. 8 and 9) that match the production process "annealing" of the first permutation in the tree structure Tr11 (see FIG. 7) and the production condition "AAA°C, Ah" of the first permutation are acquired as the production information of the other systems.

[0046] Figures 88 and 9 are explanatory diagrams showing an example of the creation of a tree structure of a manufacturing process. Figures 88 and 9 show tree structures Tr12 and Tr13 that are created when manufacturing information of another system is acquired.

[0047] In the example shown in Fig. 8, tree structure Tr12 is configured by adding tree structure Tr12a to tree structure Tr11 shown in Fig. 7. Tree structure Tr12a is manufacturing information related to a product with the product name "Flange" and material "SUS304", and matches the manufacturing process "Annealing" of the first permutation and the manufacturing condition "AAA°C, Ah" of the first permutation, and includes a manufacturing process different from tree structure Tr11.

[0048] In the tree structure Tr12a, which is manufacturing information of another system that matches the manufacturing process "annealing" of the first permutation in the tree structure Tr11 and the manufacturing conditions "AAA°C, Ah" of the first permutation, the non-conformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 first acquires manufacturing information of the manufacturing process of the first permutation from the work database 110, and then acquires manufacturing information of the manufacturing processes of the second permutation and thereafter.

[0049] Next, the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 creates a tree structure Tr12 (see Fig. 8) by superimposing the manufacturing information and manufacturing conditions of the manufacturing process of the tree structure Tr12a (see Fig. 8), which is the acquired manufacturing information of the other system, on the manufacturing information and manufacturing conditions of the manufacturing process of the tree structure Tr11 (see Fig. 7), which is the main part, with the manufacturing process of the first permutation as the axis. The tree structure Tr12a (see Fig. 8) is a tree that is an additional part to the tree structure Tr11 (see Fig. 7).

[0050] 8, tree structure Tr12a matches tree structure Tr11 in the manufacturing information and manufacturing conditions of the manufacturing processes of the first and second permutations, but differs from tree structure Tr11 in the manufacturing information and manufacturing conditions of the manufacturing processes of the third and subsequent permutations. Tree structure Tr12a is configured such that the manufacturing process of the first permutation is the axis, the manufacturing processes of the first and second permutations are integrated into tree structure Tr11, and the manufacturing processes of the third to sixth permutations are branched off from tree structure Tr11.

[0051] In the example shown in Fig. 9, tree structure Tr13 is configured by adding tree structure Tr13a to tree structure Tr12 shown in Fig. 8. Tree structure Tr13a is manufacturing information related to a product with the product name "Flange" and material "SUS304", and matches the manufacturing process "Annealing" of the first permutation and the manufacturing condition "AAA°C, Ah" of the first permutation, and includes a manufacturing process different from tree structures Tr11 and Tr12.

[0052] In the tree structure Tr13a, which is manufacturing information of another system that matches the manufacturing process "annealing" of the first permutation in the tree structure Tr11 and the manufacturing conditions "AAA°C, Ah" of the first permutation, the non-conformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 first acquires manufacturing information of the manufacturing process of the first permutation from the work database 110, and then acquires manufacturing information of the manufacturing processes of the second permutation and thereafter.

[0053] Next, the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 creates a tree structure Tr13 (see FIG. 9) by superimposing the manufacturing information and manufacturing conditions of the manufacturing process of the tree structure Tr13a (see FIG. 9), which is the acquired manufacturing information of the other system, on the manufacturing information and manufacturing conditions of the manufacturing process of the tree structure Tr11 (see FIG. 8), with the manufacturing process of the first permutation as the axis. The tree structure Tr13a (see FIG. 9) is a tree that is an additional part to the tree structure Tr11 (see FIG. 8).

[0054] 9, the manufacturing information and manufacturing conditions of the manufacturing process of the first permutation match those of tree structure Tr11, but the manufacturing information and manufacturing conditions of the manufacturing processes of the second permutation and thereafter differ from those of tree structure Tr11. Tree structure Tr13a is configured such that the manufacturing process of the first permutation is the axis, the manufacturing process of the first permutation is integrated into tree structure Tr11, and the manufacturing processes of the second to fifth permutations branch off from tree structure Tr11.

[0055] The nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 acquires all manufacturing information that matches the manufacturing process of the first permutation. Then, the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 creates a final tree structure (tree structure Tr13 in the example shown in FIG. 9) by superimposing the tree structure Tr11 as the main part and the tree structures as the additional parts (tree structures Tr12a and Tr13a in the example shown in FIG. 9) on the manufacturing process of the first permutation.

[0056] In the final permutation of the final tree structure (tree structure Tr13 in the example shown in FIG. 9), an inspection process for calculating the occurrence probability of nonconformity in the manufacturing process is set. When the tree structure Tr13 is created, the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 calculates the occurrence probability of nonconformity in the manufacturing process. At this time, since there are multiple products with different manufacturing numbers even if they have the same manufacturing process or manufacturing conditions, the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 calculates the occurrence probability of nonconformity in the inspection process of the final permutation of the tree structure Tr13. In the example shown in FIG. 9, the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 calculates the occurrence probability of nonconformity for each of the tree structures Tr11, Tr12a, and Tr13a included in the tree structure Tr13, creates nonconformity information Nd21, Nd22, and Nd23 (see FIGS. 10A to 10C), and stores the created nonconformity information Nd21, Nd22, and Nd23 in the work database 110.

[0057] 10A to 10C are explanatory diagrams showing examples of nonconformity information Nd21, Nd22, and Nd23 including the occurrence probability of nonconformity, loss cost, and cost impact. Here, the nonconformity information Nd21 shown in FIG. 10A will be described as information corresponding to the manufacturing information of the tree structure T11 in the tree structure Tr13 in FIG. 9. The nonconformity information Nd22 shown in FIG. 10B will be described as information corresponding to the manufacturing information of the tree structure T12a in the tree structure Tr13 in FIG. 9. The nonconformity information Nd23 shown in FIG. 10C will be described as information corresponding to the manufacturing information of the tree structure T13a in the tree structure Tr13 in FIG. 9.

[0058] In the examples shown in Fig. 10A to Fig. 10C, the nonconformity information Nd21, Nd22, and Nd23 are configured to include, in the column direction, a nonconformity type column No11 indicating the occurrence mode of the nonconformity (fault), and a loss cost column Lc11 indicating the loss cost. In addition, the nonconformity information Nd21, Nd22, and Nd23 are configured to include, in the row direction, an occurrence probability column Op11 indicating the occurrence probability, an average loss cost column Alc11 indicating the average loss cost, and a cost impact column Ci11 indicating the cost impact. The nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 calculates the occurrence probability from the number of occurrences and the number of production numbers. For example, in the nonconformity information Nd21 shown in Fig. 10A, taking the occurrence mode "galling" as an example, the number of occurrences is two, so the occurrence probability is "A%".

[0059] Returning to FIG. 3, after step S203, the cost impact calculation unit 104 calculates the cost impact of the next manufacturing process plan (step S204). The cost impact represents the ratio of the cost of the corresponding process to the cost of all processes. A small cost impact value indicates good performance, and a large cost impact value indicates poor performance.

[0060] In step S204, the cost impact calculation unit 104 first calculates the average loss cost of each occurrence mode based on the manufacturing information acquired in step S203. For example, in the nonconformity information Nd21 shown in Fig. 10A, taking the occurrence mode "galling" as an example, the average loss cost is calculated from the loss costs of production numbers "32456" and "21222" where galling has occurred. In the nonconformity information Nd21 shown in Fig. 10A, the average loss cost is "X1¥".

[0061] The cost impact is calculated using the following formula (1). Cost impact = (Occurrence probability x average loss cost) ……(1)

[0062] For example, in the nonconformity information Nd21 shown in Fig. 10A, taking the occurrence mode "galling" as an example, the cost impact (CP) of galling is calculated as "Y1¥" as the average loss cost from "occurrence probability A% × average loss cost X1¥". The cost impact calculation unit 104 calculates the cost impact in all trees, creates the nonconformity information Nd21, Nd22, and Nd23 shown in Fig. 10A to Fig. 10C, and stores them in the work database 110.

[0063] Returning to Fig. 3, after step S204, the manufacturing process design unit 105 acquires nonconformity information Nd21, Nd22, and Nd23 from the task database 110, and acquires one or more manufacturing process plans that are candidates for the next manufacturing process and their cost impacts (step S205). At this time, the manufacturing process design unit 105 acquires the cost impacts for all trees, and arranges the trees in ascending order of cost impact. The tree with the smallest cost impact is the candidate for the next manufacturing process.

[0064] After step S205, the manufacturing process design unit 105 displays one or more manufacturing process plans acquired in step S205 on the display unit 13 as candidates for the next manufacturing process (see FIG. 11), accepts a selection made by a user (designer) and designs the next manufacturing process (step S206).

[0065] Fig. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a manufacturing process input screen Im21 when the next manufacturing process candidate is displayed. The input screen Im21 shown in Fig. 11 has a configuration similar to that of the input screen Im11 shown in Fig. 6. In the example shown in Fig. 11, the input screen Im21 has a configuration in which a process candidate Cp21 is displayed in a process candidate display field Cp. The process candidate Cp21 is a next manufacturing process candidate. The process candidate Cp21 includes the manufacturing process, manufacturing conditions, and cost impact acquired in step S205.

[0066] The user (designer) operates the input unit 14 to select an arbitrary manufacturing process as a next manufacturing process candidate from among the process candidates Cp21 displayed in the process candidate display field Cp. After selecting the next manufacturing process candidate, the user (designer) inputs the selected next manufacturing process candidate (selected process Sp22 (see FIG. 12)) into the selected process display field Sp by dragging and dropping it, or the like. The process design support device 10 repeats the processing from step S203 to step S206 shown in FIG. 3 until the user (designer) presses the decision button (see FIG. 12) (i.e., until it is determined in step S206a whether or not OK is selected and it is determined to be OK ("Yes")).

[0067] FIG. 12 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of an input screen Im22 of a manufacturing process when a next manufacturing process candidate is selected. The input screen Im22 shown in FIG. 12 has the same configuration as the input screens Im11 and In21 shown in FIG. 6 and FIG. 11. In the example shown in FIG. 12, the input screen Im22 is in a state where a selected process Sp22 is input in the selected process display field Sp. In the example shown in FIG. 12, the user (designer) has designed the manufacturing process from "annealing" of the first permutation to "rolling" of the second permutation. "IC" included in the selected process Sp22 input in the selected process display field Sp is the total value of the cost impact of the selected process Sp22 (in the example shown in FIG. 12, "annealing" of the first permutation and "rolling" of the second permutation). In the example shown in FIG. 12, the manufacturing process candidates from the third permutation onwards are displayed in the process candidate display field Cp. The total cost impact value of the manufacturing process candidates from the third permutation onwards is calculated by the process design support device 10 performing the processing from step S203 to step S206 shown in FIG. 3 when the manufacturing process candidates from the third permutation onwards are entered into the selected process display field Sp.

[0068] The process design support device 10 performs the processes from step S203 to step S206 shown in Fig. 3 to create a tree structure Tr21 of manufacturing processes shown in Fig. 13 for the manufacturing process candidates of the third permutation and thereafter. Fig. 13 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a tree structure Tr21 of manufacturing processes created with the manufacturing process of the second permutation as the axis.

[0069] In the example shown in FIG. 13, the process design support device 10 acquires the manufacturing information and manufacturing conditions of the manufacturing process of the other system, in which the manufacturing process of the second permutation is "rolling" and the manufacturing condition of the second permutation is "rolling ratio X%" for a product with the product name "flange" and the material "SUS304". Then, the process design support device 10 creates a tree structure of the next manufacturing process candidate by superimposing the acquired manufacturing information and manufacturing conditions of the manufacturing process of the other system on the manufacturing information and manufacturing conditions of the manufacturing process that is the main part, with the manufacturing process of the second permutation as the axis. In the example shown in FIG. 13, there is only one manufacturing information in which the manufacturing process of the second permutation is "rolling" and the manufacturing condition of the second permutation is "rolling ratio X%". Therefore, there is only one manufacturing process of the second permutation that is the axis of the superposition process.

[0070] In step S204 shown in FIG. 3, the process design support device 10 calculates the probability of nonconformity for the superimposed tree of processes shown in FIG. 13 by the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 based on the nonconformity information that occurs from a specified first inspection process to an Nth inspection process.

[0071] After step S204, in step S205 shown in FIG. 3, the process design support device 10 sets the input manufacturing process plans of the second permutation as candidates for the next manufacturing process, and the manufacturing process design unit 105 acquires one or more manufacturing process plans that will be the next manufacturing process candidates and their cost impacts from the work database 110.

[0072] After step S205, in step S206 shown in FIG. 3, the process design support device 10 displays one or more third permutation manufacturing process plans (manufacturing process plans of the parts surrounded by dotted lines in FIG. 13) acquired in step S205 on the display unit 13 as candidates for the next manufacturing process (see FIG. 11), and accepts selection by operation of the user (designer).

[0073] 3, if it is determined as OK ("Yes") in step S206a (i.e., if the user (designer) presses the decision button (see FIG. 12)), the designed manufacturing process information is input to the job database 110 (step S207). This causes the process design support device 10 to end the series of routine processes.

[0074] <Main features of the process design support device> (1) As shown in FIG. 1, the process design support device 10 according to the present embodiment includes a manufacturing information accumulation unit 101, a nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103, a cost impact calculation unit 104, and a manufacturing process design unit 105. The manufacturing information accumulation unit 101 accumulates past manufacturing information in the storage unit 12. The nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 calculates the occurrence probability of nonconformity based on a tree structure created based on the accumulated past manufacturing information. The tree structure created based on the accumulated past manufacturing information means both the tree structure generated immediately before by the tree structure generation unit 102A and the tree structure created in advance by the tree structure generation unit 102A or a means not shown and accumulated in the manufacturing information database 106 of the storage unit 12. The cost impact calculation unit 104 calculates the cost impact from the occurrence probability of nonconformity and the loss cost. The manufacturing process design unit 105 displays one or more manufacturing process plans with a relatively small cost impact on the display unit as candidates for the next manufacturing process in a selectable manner, accepts the selection, and designs the next manufacturing process.

[0075] The process design support device 10 according to the present embodiment calculates the occurrence probability of nonconformity based on a tree structure created based on past manufacturing information. The process design support device 10 according to the present embodiment calculates the cost impact from the occurrence probability and the loss cost, and displays one or more manufacturing process plans with a relatively small cost impact selectably on the display unit as the next manufacturing process candidates, thereby accepting the selection of the next manufacturing process candidate and designing the manufacturing process. The process design support device 10 according to the present embodiment can appropriately design (set) the manufacturing process and manufacturing conditions for manufacturing high-quality products in a short time. Therefore, high-quality products can be easily manufactured in a short time. Furthermore, the process design support device 10 according to the present embodiment can present the user (designer) with a tree structure that takes into account the merits and demerits of the manufacturing process and manufacturing conditions even before the design of the manufacturing process. Therefore, the user (designer) can easily take measures against nonconformity (defects) that may occur.

[0076] (2) In the process design assistance device 10 according to the present embodiment, the manufacturing process design unit 105 may be configured to display next manufacturing process candidates in order of the least cost impact.

[0077] The process design support device 10 according to this embodiment displays the next manufacturing process candidates in order of least cost impact, and therefore can easily guide the user (designer) to select the candidate with the best performance first.

[0078] (3) The process design support device 10 according to this embodiment may further include a manufacturing process input unit 102 for inputting an arbitrary manufacturing process, and the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 may be configured to calculate the probability of nonconformity occurrence for the input manufacturing process input by the manufacturing process input unit 102.

[0079] The process design support device 10 according to this embodiment can associate the probability of occurrence of nonconformity with the input manufacturing process inputted in the manufacturing process input unit 102. The process design support device 10 according to this embodiment can present a tree structure that takes into consideration the pros and cons of the manufacturing process and manufacturing conditions to the user (designer) even at the stage before the manufacturing process is designed. Therefore, the user (designer) can easily take measures against nonconformity (defects) that may occur.

[0080] (4) In the process design support device 10 according to this embodiment, the manufacturing process design unit 105 may be configured to display next manufacturing process candidates in order of the least cost impact for the input manufacturing process inputted in the manufacturing process input unit 102.

[0081] The process design support device 10 according to this embodiment displays the next manufacturing process candidates in order of least cost impact, and therefore can easily guide the user (designer) to select the candidate with the best performance first.

[0082] (5) In the process design support device 10 according to this embodiment, the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 may be configured to create a tree structure of the manufacturing process by overlapping the input manufacturing process with the manufacturing process included in the past manufacturing information for the input manufacturing process input by the manufacturing process input unit 102, and to calculate the occurrence probability of nonconformity based on the nonconformity information obtained from the created tree structure. Also, the cost impact calculation unit 104 may be configured to calculate the cost impact by multiplying the occurrence probability of nonconformity by the average loss cost.

[0083] The process design support device 10 according to this embodiment can calculate the cost impact by multiplying the occurrence probability of nonconformity by the average loss cost.

[0084] (6) As shown in FIG. 3 , the process design support method according to this embodiment may include a nonconformity occurrence probability calculation process (step S203) for calculating the probability of nonconformity based on a tree structure created on the basis of accumulated past manufacturing information, a cost impact calculation process (step S204) for calculating a cost impact from the probability of nonconformity occurrence and a loss cost, and a manufacturing process design process (step S206) for displaying one or more manufacturing process plans having a relatively small cost impact on a display unit as candidates for a next manufacturing process so as to be selectable, accepting a selection, and designing the next manufacturing process.

[0085] The process design support method according to this embodiment can appropriately design (set) the manufacturing process and manufacturing conditions for manufacturing high-quality products in a short time. Therefore, high-quality products can be manufactured easily and in a short time. Furthermore, the process design support method according to this embodiment can present the user (designer) with a tree structure that takes into consideration the pros and cons of the manufacturing process and manufacturing conditions even at the stage before the manufacturing process is designed. Therefore, the user (designer) can easily take measures against non-conformities (defects) that may occur.

[0086] (7) As shown in FIG. 1, the control program Pr according to this embodiment may be a program that causes a computer including a manufacturing information accumulation unit 101 that accumulates past manufacturing information in a memory unit 12 to function as a nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit 103 that calculates the probability of nonconformity based on a tree structure created based on the accumulated past manufacturing information, a cost impact calculation unit 104 that calculates a cost impact from the probability of nonconformity occurrence and a loss cost, and a manufacturing process design unit 105 that displays one or more manufacturing process plans having a relatively small cost impact on a display unit as candidates for the next manufacturing process, accepts the selection, and designs the next manufacturing process.

[0087] The control program Pr according to this embodiment can realize the process design support device 10 according to this embodiment.

[0088] As described above, the process design support device 10 according to this embodiment makes it possible to design a manufacturing process for producing a high-quality product in a short period of time.

[0089] The present invention is not limited to the above-described embodiment, and includes various modified examples. For example, the above-described embodiment has been described in detail to easily explain the present invention, and is not necessarily limited to having all of the configurations described. In addition, it is possible to replace a part of the configuration of the embodiment with another configuration, and it is also possible to add another configuration to the configuration of the embodiment. In addition, it is possible to add, delete, or replace a part of each configuration with another configuration.

[0090] For example, each of the components shown in FIG. 1 may be realized in hardware by configuring it with a specially designed integrated circuit.

[0091] Also, for example, in the above-described embodiment, the process design support device 10 is configured as a personal computer operated by a user (designer). However, the process design support device 10 can be configured as a server communicably connected to the personal computer operated by the user (designer) via a network (not shown). [Explanation of symbols]

[0092] 10 Process design support device (computer) 11 Arithmetic section 12 Storage section 13 Display section 14 Input section 101 Manufacturing Information Storage Department 102 Manufacturing process input section 102A Tree structure generator 103 Non-conformity occurrence probability calculation unit 104 Cost Impact Calculation Department 105 Manufacturing Process Design Department 106 Manufacturing Information Database 107 Manufacturing Process Database 108 Manufacturing Equipment Database 109 Test Results Database 110 Working Database ALc11 Average loss cost column Ci11 Cost Impact Column Cp process candidate display field Cp21 process candidate D11a,D11b,D11c manufacturing information Im11, Im21, Im22 input screen Lc11 Loss Cost Column MD storage medium Nd11,Nd21,Nd22,Nd23 Nonconformity information No11 Nonconformity type column Op11 Occurrence probability column Pr Control program (program) Sp Selected process display field Sp22 selection process Tr11 Tree structure (main part of the tree structure) Tr12,Tr13,Tr21 Tree structure Tr12a,Tr13a tree structure (tree structure that is the additional part)

Claims

1. a manufacturing information storage unit that stores past manufacturing information in a storage unit; a nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit that calculates a nonconformity occurrence probability based on a tree structure created based on the accumulated past manufacturing information; a cost impact calculation unit that calculates a cost impact based on the occurrence probability of the nonconformity and the loss cost; a manufacturing process design unit that displays one or more next manufacturing process candidates having a relatively small cost impact on a display unit so as to be selectable, accepts the selection, and designs the next manufacturing process. A process design support device characterized by:

2. 2. The process design support device according to claim 1, The manufacturing process design unit displays the next manufacturing process candidates in order of decreasing cost impact. A process design support device characterized by:

3. 2. The process design support device according to claim 1, Further, a manufacturing process input unit is provided for inputting an arbitrary manufacturing process, The nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit calculates the occurrence probability of the nonconformity for the input manufacturing process inputted by the manufacturing process input unit. A process design support device characterized by:

4. 4. The process design support device according to claim 3, The manufacturing process design unit displays the next manufacturing process candidates in order of decreasing cost impact for the input manufacturing process inputted in the manufacturing process input unit. A process design support device characterized by:

5. 4. The process design support device according to claim 3, the nonconformity occurrence probability calculation unit creates a tree structure of the manufacturing process by superimposing the input manufacturing process inputted by the manufacturing process input unit on a manufacturing process included in the past manufacturing information, and calculates the occurrence probability of the nonconformity based on nonconformity information obtained from the created tree structure; The cost impact calculation unit calculates the cost impact by multiplying the occurrence probability of the nonconformity by an average loss cost. A process design support device characterized by:

6. a nonconformity occurrence probability calculation step of calculating a nonconformity occurrence probability based on a tree structure created based on the accumulated past manufacturing information; a cost impact calculation step of calculating a cost impact from the occurrence probability of the nonconformity and the loss cost; and a manufacturing process design process of displaying one or more next manufacturing process candidates having a relatively small cost impact on a display unit so as to be selectable, accepting a selection, and designing the next manufacturing process. A process design support method comprising:

7. A computer having a storage unit for storing past manufacturing information, a non-conformity occurrence probability calculation unit that calculates a non-conformity occurrence probability based on a tree structure created based on the accumulated past manufacturing information; a cost impact calculation unit that calculates a cost impact based on the occurrence probability of the nonconformity and the loss cost; a program that functions as a manufacturing process design unit that displays one or more next manufacturing process candidates having a relatively small cost impact on a display unit so as to be selectable, accepts a selection, and designs the next manufacturing process;

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Manufacturing specification determination support device, manufacturing specification determination support method, computer program, and computer readable recording medium

    JP2022014878A

Cited By

  • Control device, design support method, and design support program

    JP7856835B1