Method for evaluating corrosion resistance of coating material

By simulating impact damage on paint test pieces and conducting accelerated tests, the method accurately evaluates paint corrosion resistance, addressing the inaccuracies of conventional methods and reducing maintenance costs.

WO2024228236A1PCT designated stage expired Publication Date: 2024-11-07NT T INC
View PDF 3 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/JP2023/017046
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-05-01
Publication Date
2024-11-07

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Conventional methods for evaluating corrosion resistance of paints in outdoor steel structures are inaccurate as they do not simulate real-world damage, such as impacts from flying objects, leading to misclassification of paint performance and increased maintenance costs.

Method used

A method involving a paint test piece prepared on a steel plate, where a weight is dropped to simulate impact damage, followed by an accelerated test to evaluate corrosion resistance, including impact resistance, under controlled conditions.

Benefits of technology

This approach allows for accurate evaluation of paint corrosion resistance in real environments, reducing repainting and maintenance costs by identifying highly corrosion-resistant paints effectively.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure JP2023017046_07112024_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure JP2023017046_07112024_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This method includes: a first step (S1) for preparing a coated test piece obtained by applying a coating material to a corrosive base material and drying the corrosive base material; a second step (S2) for dropping a weight onto the coated test piece and applying an impact; a third step (S3) for performing an acceleration test for promoting the corrosion of the coated test piece; and a fourth step (S4) for evaluating the corrosion resistance of the coating material on the basis of the result of the accelerated test.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Method for evaluating the corrosion resistance of paint

[0001] The present disclosure relates to a method for evaluating the corrosion resistance of a paint.

[0002] When evaluating the corrosion resistance of anticorrosive paints for outdoor steel structures, an accelerated test is conducted in which a painted test piece made by applying the paint to be evaluated to a steel plate is scratched with a cutter knife to accelerate corrosion of the painted test piece (see "7.5 How to make cuts" in Non-Patent Document 1).

[0003] “JIS K 5600-7-9:2006 General Test Methods for Coatings - Part 7: Long-Term Durability of Coating Films - Section 9: Cyclic Corrosion Test Methods - Salt Spray / Dry / Wet”, [online], [Retrieved March 30, 2023], Internet <URL: https: / / kikakurui.com / k5 / K5600-7-9-2006-01.html>

[0004] However, in a real environment, it is rare for a cutter knife to scratch a coating film, making it difficult to accurately evaluate the corrosion resistance of the paint.

[0005] The present disclosure has been made in consideration of the above circumstances, and an object of the present disclosure is to provide a technology that can accurately evaluate the corrosion resistance of paint in a real environment.

[0006] A method for evaluating the corrosion resistance of a paint according to one embodiment of the present disclosure includes a first step of preparing a painted test piece by applying a paint to a corroding substrate and drying the paint; a second step of impacting the painted test piece by dropping a weight on the painted test piece; a third step of conducting an accelerated test to accelerate corrosion of the painted test piece; and a fourth step of evaluating the corrosion resistance of the paint based on the results of the accelerated test.

[0007] According to the present disclosure, a technology can be provided that can accurately evaluate the corrosion resistance of paint in a real environment.

[0008] Fig. 1 is a diagram showing a method for evaluating the corrosion resistance of a paint. Fig. 2 is a diagram showing an example of an impact application position. Fig. 3 is a schematic diagram showing the appearance of a coated test piece after an accelerated test. Fig. 4 is a diagram showing modified impact application positions and the appearance of a coated test piece after an accelerated test. Fig. 5 is a diagram showing modified impact application positions and the appearance of a coated test piece after an accelerated test.

[0009] Hereinafter, embodiments of the present disclosure will be described with reference to the drawings. In the description of the drawings, the same parts are designated by the same reference numerals and the description thereof will be omitted.

[0010] [Summary of the present disclosure] In real-world environments, paint films are often damaged by flying objects colliding with steel sheets during strong winds such as typhoons, and these scratches often lead to corrosion of the steel sheets. Therefore, conventional methods cannot accurately evaluate the corrosion resistance of paints in real-world environments.

[0011] For example, a paint that is resistant to scratches even when subjected to impacts will be evaluated without that advantage from the start, and will not be able to demonstrate its inherent corrosion resistance in real environments. As a result, a highly corrosion-resistant paint with the lowest life cycle cost may be found to be inferior to a less corrosion-resistant paint, and the highly corrosion-resistant paint may be rejected.

[0012] In addition, there is a large variation in how the cuts are made depending on the worker, and when workers with significantly different weights and strength make the cuts, the depth of the cuts may have a greater impact than the corrosion resistance of the paint.

[0013] Furthermore, even if the same worker is using the same coating, the amount of force used when making the cuts will differ depending on whether the coating is easy to cut into or difficult to cut into, so the depth of the cuts may have a greater impact than the corrosion resistance of the paint.

[0014] For example, paints with high hardness that are difficult to cut with a utility knife (such as paints containing glass flake pigments) tend to be harder to cut than regular paints, so they tend to require more force to make deeper scratches. As a result, they are tested under less favorable conditions than other paints in the subsequent accelerated corrosion test.

[0015] Therefore, in this disclosure, in order to evaluate corrosion resistance, including impact resistance against impacts from flying objects and the like, and to reduce variations in human cutting work, an accelerated test is conducted in which a weight is dropped onto a painted test piece to impact the paint film, and then the corrosion of the painted test piece is accelerated.

[0016] In this way, by using a weight that simulates a flying object and the natural phenomenon of a fall, it is possible to accurately evaluate the corrosion resistance, including the impact resistance, of paint in a real environment. As a result, by using a precisely selected highly corrosion-resistant paint, it is possible to reduce the cost of repainting steel structures and the maintenance costs of infrastructure steel structures.

[0017] [Method for Evaluating the Corrosion Resistance of Paint] Fig. 1 is a diagram showing a method for evaluating the corrosion resistance of paint according to this embodiment. In this embodiment, a steel plate is used as an example of a corroding substrate.

[0018] First, a painted test piece is prepared by applying a paint to be evaluated to the surface of a steel plate and allowing it to dry (Step S1). Next, an impact is applied to the painted test piece by dropping a weight onto the painted surface of the painted test piece (Step S2). Next, an accelerated test is performed to accelerate corrosion of the impacted painted test piece (Step S3). Finally, based on the results of the accelerated test, the corrosion resistance of the paint to the corrosion of the steel plate is evaluated (Step S4).

[0019] [Method for Preparing Coated Test Pieces] The method for preparing coated test pieces performed in step 1 of FIG. 1 will be described.

[0020] Two steel plates measuring 70 mm x 150 mm were prepared, and the surfaces of each steel plate were subjected to a blast treatment, after which paints A and B to be evaluated were painted on them, respectively, and allowed to dry. In this way, two types of painted test pieces, each painted with paint A and B, were prepared.

[0021] In this case, in the case of a paint that takes a long time to completely harden after application, it is desirable to use paint that has been left for a sufficient time after application. In the case of a paint that takes a very long time to completely harden after application at room temperature, the time required for complete hardening after application can be shortened by aging it at a relatively high temperature using a thermostatic bath or the like.

[0022] The temperature during aging should be lower than the upper limit of the temperature in the environment in which the paint will be used. For example, if the paint is to be used outdoors in direct sunlight at noon in midsummer, where the surface temperature will rise to 60 to 70°C, it should be aged at 60°C for two weeks.

[0023] The aging conditions can be arbitrarily determined, not just the above-mentioned conditions, as long as the paints A and B to be compared are all aged under the same conditions.

[0024] Aging may also be replaced by an accelerated test to evaluate some type of durability of the paint. For example, a test to evaluate resistance to ultraviolet light and rain (weather resistance) may be carried out based on JIS K 5600-7-7 "Accelerated Weather Resistance and Accelerated Light Resistance (Xenon Lamp Method)."

[0025] In this test, the sample temperature is 38°C to 63°C, and the test time is often 1000 or 2000 hours, so it is expected that the coating film will be sufficiently cured after the test. By combining this with the present disclosure, it is possible to evaluate the overall corrosion resistance of a paint, including not only impact resistance but also resistance to ultraviolet light and rain. In addition to JIS K 5600-7-7, any accelerated test that evaluates resistance to ultraviolet light and rain can be similarly used.

[0026] Furthermore, by carrying out a test to evaluate resistance to temperature and humidity changes in addition to resistance to ultraviolet rays and rainfall (for example, "Resistance to repeated hot and cold wetting" according to JIS K 5600-7-4), the present disclosure may be implemented to evaluate the overall corrosion resistance of the paint, including not only impact resistance but also resistance to temperature and humidity changes.

[0027] This test involves many periods of high temperature and humidity (e.g., 50°C and 95% RH), so it is expected that the coating film will be sufficiently cured after many cycles of this test. Typically, this test is performed for 10 cycles, but when combined with the present disclosure, it is desirable to perform the test for 100 cycles or more to ensure sufficient curing of the coating film.

[0028] [Impact Application Method] The impact application method performed in step 2 of FIG. 1 will be described.

[0029] For example, based on JIS K 5600-5-3 "weight drop resistance," an impact resistance test is conducted in which a weight of a specific shape, hardness, and weight is dropped onto a coated test piece from a predetermined height. Any other method in which a weight of a specific shape, hardness, and weight is dropped onto a coated test piece from a predetermined height and the results are not affected by the operator can be suitably used.

[0030] In this case, it is desirable to apply two or more levels of impact strength to the coating test piece, because applying impacts of multiple levels of strength will provide more information about how much impact the coating can withstand than if only one level of impact strength is applied.

[0031] In this embodiment, an impact test conforming to JIS K 5600-5-3 was conducted, and five different impact intensities were applied to the coated test specimen. Specifically, the coated test specimen was placed on the floor with the paint side facing up, and lead of different weights was dropped from different heights. The five impact intensities, a to e, are shown in Table 1. Impact a is the weakest, and impact e is the strongest.

[0032]

[0033] The impact application positions for impacts a to e are shown in Figure 2. Impacts a to e are applied at impact application positions P11 to P15, respectively, on the paint surface of the coated test piece 1. At this time, the weaker the impact strength, the more the impact should be applied to a position that will be the upper part of the coated test piece 1 (the position that will be the upper side when the coated test piece 1 is held vertically or inclined in the subsequent accelerated corrosion test), and the stronger the impact strength, the more the impact should be applied to a position that will be the lower part of the coated test piece 1.

[0034] This is because in the subsequent accelerated corrosion test, corrosion progresses from the position where the coating film was damaged by the impact, causing rust fluid to flow downward. In other words, by applying a relatively weak impact to the upper part of the coated test piece 1 and a relatively strong impact to the lower part of the coated test piece 1, it becomes easy to determine how much impact the coating film can withstand if, for example, corrosion does not progress in the marks from the weak impact on the upper part but progresses in the marks from the strong impact on the lower part.

[0035] Conversely, if the impact is stronger at the top, corrosion at the impact mark at the top will be more likely to progress, and the rust that has formed at the top will flow to the bottom of the painted test piece 1, making it difficult to determine whether corrosion is progressing at the impact mark at the bottom.

[0036] When an impact is applied to the coating as in this embodiment, the impact is stronger at the bottom of the painted test piece 1, so the lower the impact mark, the more severe the damage to the coating, and with paint that has low impact resistance, there is a high possibility that the damage will reach the underlying steel material.

[0037] It is also advisable to apply impacts of the same strength at two or more locations. Three or more locations are preferable. In the example of FIG. 2, impacts of the same strength are applied at three locations each. For example, impact a is applied at impact application positions P11, P21, and P31, impact b is applied at impact application positions P12, P22, and P32, impact c is applied at impact application positions P13, P23, and P33, impact d is applied at impact application positions P14, P24, and P34, and impact e is applied at impact application positions P15, P25, and P35. This is because damage to the coating film caused by the impact of a dropped weight is not stable, and applying impacts of the same strength at two or more locations allows for accurate assessment of the progression of corrosion.

[0038] [Accelerated Test Method] The accelerated test method performed in step 3 of FIG. 1 will be described.

[0039] After impact application, the coated test specimen is turned vertically or tilted, and then subjected to an accelerated corrosion test. For example, as in JIS K 5600-7-9 "Cyclic Corrosion Test Method," corrosion of the coated test specimen is accelerated by repeating, in order, a spraying step in which salt water is sprayed onto the coated test specimen, a drying step in which the coated test specimen is dried, and a step in which the coated test specimen is kept in a high-temperature, high-humidity state.

[0040] The accelerated test can be performed for any predetermined time. For example, the cycle A test specified in JIS K 5600-7-9 can be performed for 1000 hours. However, other test methods can also be used for accelerated testing to promote corrosion.

[0041] [Corrosion Resistance Evaluation Method] The corrosion resistance evaluation method performed in step 4 of FIG. 1 will be described.

[0042] In this embodiment, coated test pieces coated with the paints A and B to be evaluated were subjected to five impact strength levels at three locations with the same impact strength, as shown in Figure 2 and Table 1, and then subjected to a 1000-hour test according to cycle A specified in JIS K 5600-7-9. Figure 3 shows a schematic diagram of the appearance of each coated test piece 1, 1' after the test.

[0043] The worker compares the corrosion conditions of Paint A and Paint B and evaluates the degree of corrosion progression. In the case of Figure 3, the paint film of both painted test pieces 1 and 1', which were painted with Paint A and B respectively, is damaged by impact marks at the bottom, from which corrosion of the steel plate underneath the paint progresses and rust flows out.

[0044] However, in the case of the painted test piece 1 coated with paint A, rust flows out from impact application positions P13, P14, P15, P23, P24, P25, P33, P34, and P35 where impacts c to e were applied, whereas in the case of the painted test piece 1' coated with paint B, rust only flows out from impact application positions P15, P25, and P35 where impact e was applied.

[0045] Therefore, in the case of Figure 3, the worker would evaluate Paint B as having less corrosion and as having better overall corrosion prevention properties, including impact resistance. The evaluation may be performed visually by the worker or by computer image analysis. In the case of computer image analysis, for example, the area of ​​each corroded region is calculated from images taken with a camera, and the progress of corrosion is evaluated based on the relative size of the corroded regions.

[0046] [Modification] The position where the weak impact is applied should not be below the position where the strong impact is applied in the subsequent corrosion acceleration test. Furthermore, if the impact positions are not on the same vertical axis, the position where the weak impact is applied may be above the position where the strong impact is applied. In other words, the positions where the weak impact and the strong impact are applied should be on different vertical axes.

[0047] For example, as shown in Figure 4, the weak impact a may be applied to the right side, and the strong impact e may be applied to the left side. The left and right may also be reversed. By applying the impacts in this way, it is possible to prevent rust from flowing from the strong impact position from making it difficult to observe the weak impact position.

[0048] Furthermore, the positions at which the impacts are applied may be arranged in a zigzag pattern (staggered) in the vertical direction, as shown in Figure 5. By applying the impacts in this manner, even if corrosion progresses at the upper impact mark, rust flowing from there is less likely to flow to the lower impact position, making it easier to observe the progress of corrosion at the lower impact mark.

[0049] [Effects] According to this embodiment, a weight is dropped onto a painted test specimen coated with a paint to be evaluated on a steel plate, impacting the coating film, and then an accelerated test is performed to accelerate corrosion of the painted test specimen. This allows for accurate evaluation of the corrosion resistance, including the impact resistance, of paint in a real environment. As a result, for paints designed to be resistant to scratches even when impacted, the corrosion resistance can be evaluated taking advantage of this advantage, and the problem of the prior art, which was the variation in the depth of cuts due to the worker's work or the hardness of the coating, can be reduced. Furthermore, the use of accurately selected highly corrosion-resistant paints can reduce the cost of repainting steel structures and the maintenance costs of infrastructure steel structures.

[0050] Furthermore, according to this embodiment, impacts of at least two different intensities are applied to the coated test piece, so that the corrosion resistance of the coating in an actual environment can be evaluated more accurately.

[0051] Furthermore, according to this embodiment, the position where a weak impact is applied is higher than the position where a strong impact is applied, so that the corrosion resistance of the paint in an actual environment can be evaluated more accurately.

[0052] Furthermore, according to this embodiment, the positions where a weak impact is applied and the positions where a strong impact is applied are on different vertical axes, so that the corrosion resistance of the paint in a real environment can be evaluated more accurately.

[0053] Furthermore, according to this embodiment, impacts of the same intensity are applied to two or more locations on the coated test piece, so that the corrosion resistance of the coating in an actual environment can be evaluated more accurately.

[0054] Furthermore, according to this embodiment, the paint applied to the steel plate is dried through an accelerated test that evaluates some durability of the paint (for example, durability other than impact resistance, such as resistance to ultraviolet rays or rain, or resistance to changes in temperature and humidity), so that the overall corrosion resistance of the paint, including resistance other than impact resistance, can be evaluated.

[0055] [Others] The present disclosure is not limited to the above-described embodiments, and it is apparent that many modifications and combinations can be made by a person having ordinary skill in the art within the technical spirit of the present disclosure.

[0056] 1, 1' Painted test piece

Claims

1. A method for evaluating the corrosion resistance of a paint, comprising: a first step of preparing a painted test specimen by applying a paint to a corroding substrate and drying the paint; a second step of applying an impact to the painted test specimen by dropping a weight; a third step of conducting an accelerated test to promote corrosion of the painted test specimen; and a fourth step of evaluating the corrosion resistance of the paint based on the results of the accelerated test.

2. The method for evaluating the corrosion resistance of a coating material according to claim 1, wherein in the second step, impacts of at least two different intensities are applied to the coating test piece.

3. A method for evaluating the corrosion resistance of paint as described in claim 1, wherein in the second step, the paint surface of the painted test piece is vertical or inclined, and the position where a weak impact is applied is higher than the position where a strong impact is applied.

4. A method for evaluating the corrosion resistance of paint as described in claim 1, wherein in the second step, the paint surface of the painted test piece is vertical or inclined, and the position where a weak impact is applied and the position where a strong impact is applied are on different vertical axes.

5. The method for evaluating the corrosion resistance of a paint according to claim 1, wherein in the second step, impacts of the same intensity are applied to two or more points of the painted test piece.

6. A method for evaluating the corrosion resistance of a paint as described in claim 1, wherein in the first step, the paint applied to the corroding substrate is dried by an accelerated test for evaluating durability other than the impact resistance of the paint.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Method for evaluating corrosion resistance of painted metal plate

    JP1995311192A

  • Corrosion resistance evaluation method of surface treated steel plate

    JP2009075061A

  • Apparatus for controlling scratch depth of painting layer

    KR1020110022311A